访谈·中文精读

马斯克谈Tesla、汽车业与自动驾驶愿景(2015年丹麦采访)

Elon Musk – Visions for Tesla, the auto industry and self-driving Teslas (Interview in Denmark 2015)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

丹麦有个挺拧巴的反差。

这个国家是全球风能的老大哥,维斯塔斯(Vestas)的总部就在日德兰半岛,风机卖到全世界。丹麦的风电占比常年排在世界最前面。可你站在哥本哈根的街头数车,一百辆里能找出电动车,得费点劲,占比不到1%。

2015年,马斯克飞到哥本哈根看Tesla的丹麦团队,把这个反差直接摆上了台面。他刚从卢森堡过来,接下来还要去德国、荷兰、比利时。这趟欧洲行的目的很直接:见团队,见政府官员,看看各地的进展。采访他的是丹麦《商报》(Dagbladet Børsen)。

记者问他,你给丹麦带什么话。

丹麦是可再生能源的领导者,尤其是风能。我觉得这里有机会在可持续交通上也成为领导者。但你看路上跑的车,电动车的数量非常少,远低于1%。(马斯克)

他把话往下说了一层:丹麦发了这么多风电,却没把它用进交通里,等于只做了半件事。可持续发电和可持续交通,是同一个问题的两半。

2015年的Tesla站在什么位置

要听懂这场访谈,得先知道当时的Tesla是什么体量。

Model S在2012年上市,到2015年全球累计交付刚过十万辆,当年全年销量大约五万辆。这个数字放进全球一亿辆的年产量里,连零头都算不上。Model X原定2013年交付,跳票到2015年9月底才发出第一批。内华达的超级工厂2014年动工,2015年还在盖。

所以马斯克在访谈里说Tesla“销量在起来,车在往外交”,语气是谨慎的。一家年销五万辆的公司,同时要挑战汽车业和能源业两个庞然大物,说难听点叫不自量力,说好听点叫押注未来。

也正因为体量小,他讲的话才更像宣言,不像财报。整场访谈里他几乎没提销量目标、股价、利润率,讲的全是能源结构、产业速度、监管节奏。这种讲法在当时的车企CEO里很少见。

风发出来的电没处存,电动车就是现成的缓冲池

风电有个天生的毛病,看天吃饭。风大的时候电多得用不完,风一停就抓瞎。丹麦的风电装机越大,这个矛盾越突出。记者替丹麦问了一句:我们存不住风电,你能帮忙吗?

马斯克的回答把两件事接到了一起。

电动车本身就可以当风电的缓冲。风电发得多的时候,电价可以压低,人们就在这个时候给车充电;发得少,电价高,充电就少。另外Tesla有一款固定式电池组,正在开发,今年晚些时候会进入规模量产。(马斯克)

逻辑很朴素。电网怕的是供需对不上。电动车停在那儿的时间远多于开的时间,一辆车就是一块几十度电的电池。几万辆电动车拧在一起,等于给电网装了一个可以随时吸电、随时放电的大水池。风大的夜里,池子蓄满;用电高峰的白天,池子往外吐。

更妙的地方在于价格信号。电网不需要派人挨家挨户通知,只要把电价按供需浮动,车主自己会挑便宜的时候插枪。车主的钱包和电网的平衡,被同一个价格曲线牵着走。

固定式电池组是另一个水池,只不过它不跑,就装在变电站或者工厂旁边。2015年4月底,Tesla在洛杉矶发布了Powerwall和Powerpack,家用版10千瓦时,商用版100千瓦时。马斯克在访谈里说的今年晚些时候规模量产,指的就是内华达那座还在建设中的超级工厂。

记者追问,那你会不会考虑在丹麦设厂。马斯克说,确实在考虑。

这句话在2015年不像客套。丹麦有风能,有政策意愿,市场虽小但示范性强,Tesla在欧洲的产能布局迟早要落子。至于最后落在哪儿,是后来的事。

三块拼图:发电、储能、电动交通

马斯克在访谈里把可持续能源拆成了三块。

电池技术无论对电动车还是固定储能,都是长期可持续能源未来的关键一环。你需要可持续的发电,我认为主要是风能和太阳能;然后你要配固定储能,因为可再生能源是间歇性的;第三块是电动交通。三块拼齐,未来才有一套完整的解法。(马斯克)

这个拆法可以多说两句。很多人谈能源转型,只盯发电端,觉得多装风机、多铺光伏就完事了。马斯克提醒的是,发电、储能、用电三端得一起动,缺一块,另外两块的价值就出不来。

风机发出来的电没法存,就得弃风,等于白白浪费。电存住了,但终端还是烧油的汽车,减排效果打折扣。三块拼在一起,才形成闭环。

后来几年Tesla的产品线,基本是照着这三块铺的:车对应电动交通,Powerwall和Powerpack对应储能,太阳能屋顶对应发电。2016年Tesla收购SolarCity,把发电这块补上,在很多人眼里是关联交易、是救急,放进这套拼图里看,倒是顺理成章的一步。

回头看,2015年这场访谈里,这套打法的骨架已经讲清楚了。

电池为什么是整条链子的扣

三块拼图里,电池被马斯克反复提到。这笔账用算术就能说清。

一辆电动车的成本,电池占三到四成。电池便宜一度电,整车价格就往下走一截。储能柜的成本结构更极端,电芯能占到一半以上。也就是说,发电、储能、交通三条线最后都卡在同一个零件上。

马斯克给了一个进步速率:电池每年提升5%到10%。这个数字看着温和,含义很重。能量密度每年涨一点,同样重量能装更多电;成本每年降一点,同样的钱能买更多容量。两条曲线交叉十年,整车的经济性就换了个量级。

他在访谈里没给成本数字。Tesla后来公布的电池包成本,从2010年的每千瓦时一千美元出头,降到2015年的不到三百美元,再到后来的更低。这个斜率大致对得上他说的每年5%到10%。

超级工厂的意义也在这里。它不是单纯扩产,是把电芯、模组、电池包、回收放在一个屋檐下,用规模把成本压下来。车的产能和储能的产能一起消化,工厂的利用率才拉得满。只做车的公司,电池成本降不下来;只做储能的公司,没有车的规模撑着。两头都做的,才有机会把成本压到别人够不着的地方。

小国为什么能当全球样板

丹麦人口不到六百万,汽车市场也小。记者问,这么小的市场对Tesla有意思吗。

马斯克的回答从市场跳到了样板。

丹麦的长处,是给世界做个榜样,告诉大家可持续交通能做到什么程度。大国要做出大改变很难,小国反而容易说:看,这就叫可能性。政策对了,路上可以有相当比例的电动车。丹麦能在这件事上当全球的重要领导者。(马斯克)

这个视角和一般商业逻辑反着来。一般逻辑是,市场越大越值得投入。马斯克看的是示范效应:一个几百万人的国家,政策调整快,数据看得清,做成了就是活广告。别的国家要说服议会、说服选民,最省事的办法就是指着丹麦说,人家做到了。

这也解释了Tesla为什么早年愿意在小市场投入。挪威、荷兰、丹麦这些地方,电动车渗透率上得快,成了Tesla在欧洲的桥头堡。挪威后来成了全球电动车渗透率最高的国家,特斯拉在那边长期是销量冠军。小国的政策杠杆撬动的,是整个欧洲的舆论。

从公司的角度算,这笔账也划得来。小市场的绝对销量不大,但单位获客成本低,口碑扩散快,政策沟通的层级也短。跟丹麦的部长开一次会,效果可能顶得上在美国游说半年。

把专利全部开源,Tesla算的是整个品类的账

访谈里有个问题挺尖锐。记者说,你比别的电动车厂起步早,但现在保时捷这类公司也推出了电动跑车,你怎么应对竞争。

马斯克的回答没按常理出牌。

我们做Tesla,是为了加速可持续交通的到来,让路上有更多电动车。为了这个目标,我们把所有专利都开源了。任何车企都可以用我们的技术,不用付钱。(马斯克)

2014年6月,Tesla在官网上发了一篇题为《All Our Patent Are Belong To You》的公告,宣布开放专利。标题借了一句网络梗,态度轻,分量重。马斯克在访谈里把这个决定讲成了一句大白话:我们是哲学驱动的,我们在乎的是电动车普及,因为如果没有可持续交通,未来会很糟。他还补了一句,希望这些公司跑得比公布的还快。

记者替投资者问了一句:投资者可能期待你去打败对手,拥抱对手听着不像CEO该说的话。

马斯克的回应更直接。

Tesla上市的时候我就说过,这家公司有强烈的意识形态动机,不同意的人就别投。这一点我从一开始就讲得很清楚。只要我们做出有说服力的产品,Tesla就能过得不错。我们不该因为对手失败才过得好,我们该因为造了好车才过得好。(马斯克)

这套逻辑在商业上看着别扭,但站得住。电动车当年最大的对手是燃油车,另一家电动车厂排不到前头。整个品类占的份额太小,谁家多卖几辆,改变不了大盘。把专利放开,让更多玩家进场,品类做大了,Tesla作为头部玩家自然受益。

开放专利还有个副作用:标准话语权。谁的技术被更多人用,谁就更容易成为事实标准。这一点马斯克在访谈里没展开,但后来的充电网络、电池规格,多少印证了这个方向。2014年开放专利,2023年Tesla把充电接口标准开放给其他车企,福特、通用、Rivian陆续宣布采用。前后是同一套思路。

大公司手肘很硬,但Tesla不想靠对手失败赢

记者问,同时挑战汽车业和能源业这两个庞然大物,什么感受。

有时候确实很难。大车企和大能源公司手肘很硬,他们一开始会想办法把小公司压下去,Tesla就是其中之一。不过我们总体上得到了公众的支持,Tesla内部也有一支能打的团队。很难,但进展不错,销量在起来,车在往外交。(马斯克)

手肘很硬这个说法挺形象。美国的汽车经销商协会、石油公司、传统车企,在州一级的立法上游说,阻止Tesla绕过经销商直接卖车。好几个州一度禁止Tesla开店。这类事在2015年前后闹得不少,Tesla的门店开一家,官司跟一家。

马斯克没在访谈里逐条抱怨,只说了他们一开始会想办法压。后面那句更关键:我们要靠造好车赢,不靠对手失败赢。这话说给投资者听,也说给自己团队听。一家公司的胜负心,最好放在产品上,别放在盼着对手出事故上。

这句话在两年后有了另一个注脚。2016年Autopilot出第一起致死事故,舆论汹涌,马斯克在回应里反复强调的一点也是:技术本身要经得起检验,靠遮掩撑不了多久。

800公里到1200公里:续航的时间表

续航这段聊得最实。

记者问,什么时候能突破一千公里。

一千公里要看在什么条件下。Model S目前的纪录是八百公里,是有人实际开出来的最远距离。我们离得不远。那次测试车速比较慢,大概每小时四十到五十公里。我猜一两年内能破一千公里。(马斯克)

记者追了一句,2016年还是2017年。马斯克说,2017年肯定行。

记者又往前推,2020年单次充电能跑多远。马斯克给了一个数:大概能造出跑一千二百公里的车。他补了一句节奏,电池每年进步5%到10%。

这几个数字放在一起看才有意思。2015年Model S的官方续航在四百多公里(欧洲NEDC工况),实测八百公里是低速跑出来的极限值。马斯克说的破一千,指的也是这种理想条件下的成绩,日常高速巡航打对折是常事。把测试条件和官方数据分开看,才不会被数字绕晕。

每年5%到10%的进步率,看着不快,复利起来很可观。十年下来是1.6到2.6倍。电池能量密度、成本、循环寿命,三条线同时在爬。马斯克没在访谈里给成本数字,但Tesla后来公布的电池成本曲线,大致对得上这个节奏。

2020年那款跑1200公里的车没造出来。可电池这条路一直在往前走,只是方向从堆续航转到了压成本。Model 3、Model Y卖得动,靠的是每度电更便宜,不是每辆车跑得更远。马斯克在访谈里的预测,错在把进步的方向想窄了。

自动驾驶:一个月后上高速,三年后全自动

记者问有没有自动驾驶的计划。马斯克的回答分了三层。

现在生产的Tesla已经具备在高速公路上自动转向、自动巡航的能力。这套功能正在beta测试,希望下个月就能大范围推送。也就是说,高速和相对简单的道路上实现自动驾驶,大概还有一个月。(马斯克)

这就是后来的Autopilot。2015年10月,Tesla通过空中升级给Model S推送了Autopilot 7.0,功能包括自动转向、自动变道、自动泊车。时间点和访谈里说的下个月对得上。

第二层是完全自动驾驶。

我猜完全自动驾驶大概要三年。不过监管可能不允许,至少要再等一到三年,看具体市场。有些市场的监管更激进。技术上三年可行。(马斯克)

三年是2018年。回头看,这个预测明显乐观了。完全自动驾驶的难度远超当年预期,长尾场景一个接一个,监管放开更是遥遥无期。马斯克在访谈里至少把技术和监管分开讲了,这一点比后来很多发布会上含糊其辞的说法要诚实。

第三层是二十年后的图景。

希望二十年后,路上跑的很大比例是电动车,所有出厂的新车都具备完全自动驾驶。不过要记住一件事,人们容易把车当成手机那样的消费品。手机平均两三年换一部,车的寿命通常是二十年才报废。(马斯克)

汽车不是手机:20亿辆存量的换血速度

这段信息量很大,很多人算电动车普及速度时会漏掉。

全球汽车和卡车的保有量大约20亿辆,这个数字还在涨,可能到25亿。新车年产量大约1亿辆。就算从明天起所有新车都是电动车,换掉整个车队也要二十多年。自动驾驶可能快一些,因为自动驾驶意味着需要的车和卡车更少,但即便如此,至少也要10到15年。(马斯克)

这套算术的意义在于,它把新车渗透率和存量渗透率分开了。新闻里常看到的某月电动车占新车销量百分之几,说的是增量。路上跑的车,是存量。存量的更新速度被车的寿命卡着,一年最多换掉二十分之一。

所以哪怕新车市场明天全部电动化,街上的燃油车还要再跑二十年。政策制定者如果只盯增量数据,容易高估转型速度;反过来,如果因为街上电动车还少就否定趋势,又容易低估拐点的力量。

自动驾驶那一段的推演也有意思。如果车能自己跑,私家车没必要那么多,出行可以变成按需调用。车少了,存量换血的速度反而快。马斯克给的10到15年,是把这个因素算进去之后的估计。

后来Robotaxi的争论,本质上还是这套算术。车队规模缩小,单位里程成本下降,公共交通和私家车的边界被打散。马斯克2015年就把逻辑讲完了,只是落地的时间一再往后推。

怎么衡量进步:数路上的车

访谈里马斯克给了一个特别朴素的衡量标准。

想知道电动车进展如何,就去路边数车,看一百辆车里有几辆是电动的。这比任何报告都直接。丹麦算是相对激进的地方了,还是不到百分之一。(马斯克)

这个指标的好处是没法修饰。销量数据可以挑口径,渗透率可以选分母,路边数车不会骗人。马斯克反复用这个说法,是在提醒听众,别被发布会的热闹带偏,看真实世界的存量。

这套方法论放到别的行业也成立。判断AI落地得怎么样,别看发布会上演示了几个案例,看多少业务流程真的改了。判断一个新平台是不是起来了,别看下载量,看日活里有多少人第二天还回来。口径越简单,越不容易被包装。

婴儿产业不能被抽走补贴

记者最后问,丹麦能做什么,帮可持续未来早点到来。

对所有做电动车的公司,Tesla只是其中一家,早期阶段最重要的是激励政策别撤。这些政策不需要永远存在,但如果撤得太快,等于把一个还在襁褓里的产业直接掐掉。现在撤,太早了。将来撤,没问题。(马斯克)

这段话有具体的背景。丹麦对电动车的税收优惠当时正在讨论退坡。丹麦的汽车注册税在世界上算高的,一辆普通燃油车的税可能超过车价的一倍,电动车免税,价格优势很明显。政策一变,车价立刻涨上去。马斯克2015年专门跑这一趟,跟政府官员见面,谈的就是这件事。

后来的事大家都知道,丹麦的电动车税收优惠还是逐步退坡了,销量应声下滑,几年后才随新车型和价格下降慢慢恢复。马斯克说的毯子抽太快,在丹麦应验了。

这段对话背后有个产业经济学的常识:新兴产业早期,规模小、成本高,靠补贴把量撑起来,量起来之后成本往下走,补贴再退。顺序反了,产业就死在半路上。马斯克把这个顺序讲得很清楚,没有替自己公司多要一分钱,说的是整个品类。

这句话还有个前提容易被忽略:他承认补贴不该永久存在。很多企业家谈补贴只谈要,不谈退。马斯克把退出条件也说了,反而更像在讲道理,不像在讨钱。

面对监管:技术跑得比规则快

自动驾驶那段话里,马斯克把技术和监管拆开讲,可以单独拎出来说。

技术上三年可行。监管可能不允许,至少要再等一到三年,看具体市场。有些市场的监管更激进。(马斯克)

这个拆分是理解自动驾驶行业的关键。技术到位不等于能上路。法规、责任认定、保险、道路基础设施,每一样都要跟上。马斯克给的三加一到三,是把这两条线叠在一起算的。

回头看,技术那条线的难度被低估了,监管那条线也没那么快松口。但把两条线分开看的框架是对的。很多讨论把技术能不能和允不允许混在一起,得不出有用的结论。

把这个框架往外推,今天的AI监管、基因编辑、商业航天,全是同一道题。技术曲线和规则曲线各自有斜率,谁跑得快,决定了产品能走多远。

丹麦这趟行程的分量

一场二十分钟的访谈,马斯克讲了能源、车、储能、自动驾驶、监管、产业政策。信息密度不低。

他讲这些事的方式,比讲了什么更值得琢磨。他没把Tesla讲成一家要打败谁的公司,讲的是要推动的一件事。专利开源、欢迎竞争、投资者先看意识形态,这些话放在一起,是一套完整的世界观。

丹麦这趟行程本身也有象征意义。一个几百万人的小国,风能做到了世界前列,电动车却几乎为零。马斯克跑这一趟,是想让丹麦把另一半也补上。他说的那句话,其实是对所有国家说的:发了绿电,还得把绿电用进交通里,这事才算做完。

十年过去,丹麦的电动车占比从不到1%涨到了新车销量口径的过半。马斯克当年说的一两年破一千公里,量产车上没实现,但电池每年5%到10%的进步,确实一直在发生。Autopilot推送了,完全自动驾驶还在路上。Powerwall进了千家万户,超级工厂从一座变成好几座。

预测会错,方向没跑偏。真正扛得住时间检验的,是那套拆问题的框架:发电、储能、用电三块一起算,技术和监管分开算,增量和存量分开算。这三条,今天做能源和出行的人还在用。

  • 评估电动车或任何新技术的进展,先看存量,别只看新车销量。路上跑的有多少,才是真实渗透率。
  • 做能源项目时,把发电、储能、用电三端放在一张表里算。任何一端缺位,另外两端的价值都会打折。
  • 做技术时间表预测,把技术可行和监管允许拆成两条独立的线,各自给区间,再叠加。混在一起算,结论一定失真。
  • 判断一个新兴产业的补贴政策,看退坡节奏,不看有无。行业在婴儿期撤补贴,等于提前结束比赛。
  • 读一家公司的战略,先看它把壁垒放前面还是把使命放前面。这个顺序决定了它面对竞争时的动作。
  • 做长期市场预测,先算存量换血的物理速度。车的寿命、设备的更换周期,是不会被情绪改变的硬约束。
  • 判断一个行业有没有真的起来,找一个没法修饰的指标,比如路边数车。指标越简单,越难被包装。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:04he is one of the most talked-about CEOs in the world right now the main behind companies such as SpaceX and Tesla mr. musk it's a great pleasure to have you in Copenhagen yeah thanks for having me I'm glad to be back what brings you to Denmark well I'm here to see the Tesla Danish team I'm

0:26actually visiting a number of countries on this visit I just came from Luxembourg and I'm headed to Germany and Netherlands and Belgium so here here to see the team so you could see how things are going talk to some of the people in government and so forth what message do you bring to show Denmark oh well I think the most important message is that is that Denmark is a great leader in renewable energy with wind and I think that there's an opportunity to be a leader in sustainable transport as well but although Denmark is doing incredibly well on on wind that if you look at how many cars going down the road or electric there's very few well under 1%

1:12so I think it's it's very important that government policy continue to support electric vehicles and and you know as more wind energy is generated it didn't make sense to put that into sustainable transport I think it's but there's sort of two very important halves of the same problem so I think it's it's a Denmark an interesting and market for for Tesla a small country like Denmark yeah I think the Forte for Denmark

1:44I think they're more conserve as an example to the rest of the world to say what can be done with the sustainable transport so with with larger countries it's difficult to make a big impact but with smaller countries you can say hey this this is what it can be like to to other countries to say you know with the right policies you can have a significant number of electric vehicles on the road so I think demo can be an important leader in the world as an example in this regard you mentioned when Denmark has the world's largest windmill maker Vesta large production of sustainable energy right but we do have trouble storing the wind energy yeah can you help us with

2:24that absolutely so the electric vehicles themselves can be obviously a great recipient to buffer a wind energy so depending upon where what level of wind energies is being generated you can actually have the pricing of electricity very so that people can charge their electric cars depending upon if there's a large amount or small amount of energy being generated from the wind then in addition Tesla has a battery pack a stationary battery pack that is under development or going to significant production later this year and so combining wind energy with a stationary storage is very powerful because that provides a complete solution would you consider setting up a facility in

3:06Denmark even yeah that that is that is certainly something under consideration yeah Tesla is improving battery technology really fast how do you expect your battery technology will change the auto sector as well as the energy sector in the coming years well for the battery technology both for for electric vehicles and for stationary storage is a critical piece of the equation for a long-term future of sustainable energy so you need to have sustainable energy generation which i think is going to be primarily as wind and solar and then you combine that with stationary storage which is needed because of the intermittent nature of renewable energy

3:46generation and then you can and then the third piece of the equation is electric transport so if you have all three of those pieces sustainable generation storage and electric vehicles then you have a complete solution for the future and then we have a good future but how do you feel about taking on such large industries as the audience industry and the energy industry well it's definitely it can be quite difficult at times the you know the big car companies and the big energy companies have quite sharp elbows so they try to you know first times they try to squash small companies like Tesla but I think we you know we have the support generally of of where

4:25the popular support and everywhere a team at Tesla so man it's hard but I think you know we're making good progress Tesla is really getting sales going really getting cars out there you've been able to get a head start on other electric car makers but they're really coming along now what I think is great yeah yeah what what is yours response to to the new competing electric sports car such as Porsches new electric car yeah well you know the reason that we're doing Tesla is to try to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport to have there be more electric cars in the road and and to that end we actually open sourced all of our patents so we said

5:06you know any car company can use our technology it's no problem that I didn't have to pay a fee to us so so for us you know we're very philosophically motivated you know we care about at the advancement of electric vehicles because we think you're and unless there's sustainable transport it's going to be the future is going to be terrible so so I'm glad to see these announcements of these other companies I hope they they move even faster than they announced but don't you expect you may be your investors to expect you to fight off these competition rather than embracing it well yeah I mean I did say

5:43that when we were in public even I said look your Tesla has a strong ideological motivation so they shouldn't invest if they disagree with that so they know from the beginning I've always been very clear about that but as long as we make compelling products I think Tesla will do ok so it's it's not you we shouldn't

6:06do ok just because the competition failed I mean we should do okay because we make good cars that's the only reason I want to get into your vision for missions for electric cars musk am when will we break the thousand kilometer range you mark for an electric car a thousand kilometers hmm well it depends under what circumstances for a thousand kilometers as it is the record right now for Model S is 800 kilometers that's the furthest that anyone has driven a Model S so we could be close yeah we're pretty close now in order to do that they did drive at a relatively slow speed so you know we're talking I think they drove maybe at 40 or 50 kilometers an hour or something like

6:50that but I I think my guess is probably we could break a thousand kilometers within a year or two okay yeah so within 2016 maybe even I say if you say 2017 I'd say 2017 for sure how fast there sorry how far can attest like hard drive on a single charge in 2020 Oh in 2020 is we could probably make a car go 1,200 kilometres okay it's that kind of the pace going forward moving battery so yeah if you think maybe you know five to ten percent a year something like that okay yeah do you have any current plans for a self-driving Tesla we do I mean the they can tell me about that yeah sure so the the Tesla that is

7:44currently in production has the the ability to do automatic steering or order pilot on highways and that's currently being but beta tested and we'll go into wide release hopefully next month so we're probably only a month away from having autonomous driving at least for highways and for relatively simple roads I mean my guess

8:11for when we will have full autonomy is about three years three years approximately three years however regulators will probably not allow full autonomy for maybe at least one to two years may 1 to 3 years after that so it depends on this on the particular market some markets will be the regulators will be more forward-leaning than others but in terms of technic winner will be technologically possible I think three years what kind of costs are we driving twenty years from now I hope

8:45civilization is still around in 20 years if it is yeah exactly I think in 20 years I think you will see hopefully a very long percentage of cars being electric probably all cars being built will have full autonomy in 20 years but it but it is important to bear in mind like sometimes people think I think of cars like consumer products like a phone or something like that but in the case of a phone the the average ownership time for a phone is is 2 or 3 years but for a car a car typically lasts 20 years before it is finally scrapped so the the total fleet of cars

9:29and trucks in the world is about 2 billion and that fleet is increasing probably to two and a half billion and the new car production is is about a hundred new cars and trucks about a hundred million per year so in order to change the fleet if if all cars become electric say immediately then it would take more probably more than 20 years to change the fleet for autonomous driving that may be less because if a town was driving means that fewer cars and trucks are needed then it's a probably a smaller period of time but it's probably still at least 10 to 15 years okay so

10:08that's an important consideration we think when thinking about how fast can things changing in cars and as I mentioned earlier the if you want to say how how we're doing in terms of electric cars in terms of sustainable transport you know I'd say just look at the cost going down the road count how many electric cars out of a hundred and that's that tells you how many how much progress has been made been made and even in a place like Denmark which is relatively forward-leaning less than one percent what can we do here in Denmark - - well help you reach the goal of the sustainable future sure well I think it's it's it's it's formerly for for all electric all

10:48companies making electric cars Tesla being one of them it's really important particularly in the early days of electric cars to have the incentives remain in place they don't have to be there forever but but if the if the rug is pulled too quickly for electric cars then you have a industry which is just a baby it's just a little tiny tiny thing and it's it's I think too early to sort of pull pull incentives for a industry that isn't in its infancy and in the future no problem but now would be difficult

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份