发布会·中文精读

马斯克 Neuralink 更新:2022年9月

Elon Musk's Neuralink Update – September 2022

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2022 年 10 月 31 日,万圣节。马斯克把 Neuralink 当年最重要的一场公开活动定在了这天,名字叫 show and tell,展示与讲述。

日子选得有点自嘲:一家往人脑里塞芯片的公司,在鬼节开发布会。只盯着这场发布会,会漏掉同期另外两件事。一件是路透社放出的消息,说马斯克接触了脑机接口公司 Synchron,谈的内容可能涉及收购。另一件更不起眼,藏在得州奥斯汀的市政规划文件里:Neuralink 要在 37 英亩的地皮上盖 8 栋楼。

一个日期,一条传闻,一片工地。三件事拼起来,才是这家公司 2022 年秋天的真实状态。Neura Pod 是一个长期跟踪 Neuralink 的频道,主播把这期节目做成了情报汇总,把散落在推特、播客、路透社和市政材料里的碎片摆到了一起。

为什么一场发布会值得等一年

距离上一次对外更新,已经过去相当长一段时间。马斯克在推特上公布日期的时候,只说了会有进展汇报,没说会演示什么。

能猜的线索都藏在团队过去两年的公开表述里。他们反复讲一个目标:让瘫痪病人用键盘和鼠标的速度,超过健全人。这句话听起来像营销,但它是一个可以量化的工程指标,打字速度、光标定位精度、点击延迟,全都能测。

2021 年 4 月那只叫 Pager 的猴子是个起点。它靠脑子里的植入体玩 Mind Pong,没有摇杆,没有摄像头追踪手势,只有神经元放电。主播提了一个挺有意思的设想:让 Pager 和一个握着真实摇杆的健全人打一局,同样的游戏,同样的规则,谁赢?

这个对比之所以有价值,在于它把脑机接口从"能做什么"变成了"比什么快"。前者是科学演示,后者是产品指标。演示只需要成功一次,指标要求每次都成立。

团队还多次提过另外几个方向:增加电极数量、提升机器人单次植入的效率、把芯片设计做得更省电更紧凑。这几件事都不上镜。观众看到的是猴子玩游戏,看不到的是通道数从一千涨到几千之后,信号处理链路要重写多少遍,散热和功耗预算要重新排多少次。

工程上的进步往往是静音的,而发布会只放大能拍出来的部分。所以懂行的人看这类活动,盯的是数字,跟舞台没关系。

那枚硬币大小的东西,究竟装了什么

Neuralink 官方放出的宣传片里,马斯克自己当过讲解员。他把要解决的问题说得非常朴素:

随着时间的推移,几乎每个人都会出现大脑或脊柱方面的问题,而这些问题都可以用一枚可植入的 Neuralink 解决。神经元就像布线,电子的问题需要电子的方案来解决。(马斯克)

硬件参数他讲得很直白:直径大约一英寸,内置电池、蓝牙和感应充电线圈,植入头骨。手术由一台专门开发的机器人完成,机械臂要非常小心地避开血管,插完线缝合,外人根本看不出这个人身上有接口。

基本上,只要在脑子的任何位置建立接口,就能解决范围极广的脑损伤。如果你想让未来变好,就必须亲手把它造出来。(马斯克)

一英寸这个尺寸值得多说两句。它意味着整套系统无线、可充电、完全埋进体内。用户不需要顶着一根线缆出门,不需要每天擦洗创口,也不需要一个人在旁边帮他开机。这一点直接决定了设备能不能被普通人接受,而不只是实验室里的志愿者愿意忍。

机器人同样是产品的一部分。人脑表面的血管分布因人而异,靠人手把几十根比头发丝还细的线插进皮层,既不精准也不可复制。把这件事交给机器,本质上在解决产能和一致性两个问题,精度只是入场券。

电极通道数为什么重要,可以这么理解。单个电极能听到的是一小群神经元的放电,声音嘈杂,信息量有限。通道越多,相当于在同一个区域架起越多麦克风,后端才能把混在一起的声音分离出来,还原出运动意图、语言意图这类复杂信号。通道数上去之后,麻烦会转移:数据量暴涨,功耗上升,芯片和无线链路都得重做,植入的手术时间也会变长。

所以每次发布会上那个看起来平平无奇的通道数,背后牵着的是一整条工程链。

路透社那条合并传闻,值得打个问号

9 月,路透社发了一篇报道,标题大意是:在 Neuralink 进度落后的背景下,马斯克接触脑芯片创业公司 Synchron,商讨交易。

报道说,马斯克和 Synchron 的创始人兼 CEO Tom Oxley 讨论过潜在的合作,甚至包括两家公司完全合并。消息源要求匿名,理由是内容保密。

两家公司的技术路线差别很大,这点必须先讲清楚。Synchron 走的是低侵入路线,通过血管把一枚支架送进脑血管,不需要打开头骨。Neuralink 走的是高侵入路线,开颅、植线、用机器人操作,当时还没有开始人体试验。

这两条路的取舍很明确。血管内路线手术风险低,监管路径短,但电极只能待在血管里,隔着血管壁记录信号,位置由血管走向决定,挑不了。开颅路线能贴着皮层甚至插进皮层,信号质量高出一个量级,但要过的手术和伦理门槛也高出一个量级。

所以"合并"这件事在工程上很难成立。两套技术栈、两种临床路径、两拨工程师,凑在一起并不会自动变成一家更强的公司。它能带来的好处大概是资金和监管经验上的互补,代价则是把两条本来清晰的产品线搅在一起。

主播还去查了写这篇报道的记者的过往文章,发现她引用过一份 62 页的 Neuralink 员工手册,语气里带着审慎。他顺手对比了一下:特斯拉那份著名的手册叫"反手册",只有四页。这个对比没能证明什么,但能说明写作者对这家公司并不偏爱。

结论很简单:把这条消息留在传闻区,别急着等合并公告。

37 英亩、8 栋楼,藏在市政文件里的野心

比起传闻,奥斯汀的规划文件可靠得多。

Neuralink 在得州 Del Valle 地区拿到了一块 37 英亩的地,计划盖 8 栋建筑。最大的一栋 78,000 平方英尺,包含两处办公空间和仓库。另一栋 5,850 平方英尺,文件里被描述为"动物兽医办公室",能容纳 12 名员工。

这栋小楼的内部配置列得很细:两间手术室、术前准备室、储藏室、短期动物存放区、机房、会议室、更衣室、淋浴间、候诊区,还有一个标注为"组织学"的房间。

组织学研究的是组织的微观结构。翻译成人话:把脑组织切片、染色、放到显微镜下,看植入的线周围有没有炎症、有没有神经元死亡、胶质细胞有没有增生。这是所有侵入式脑机接口公司都绕不开的一步,也是长期安全性数据的来源。

两间手术室加上短期动物存放,说明这个场地是按规模化临床前试验的标准设计的,跟样板间没关系。要提高植入通道数、要验证新一代线材、要跑长期随访,都得靠这样的场地一批一批地做,每一批都产生可提交给监管机构的数据。

看一家硬科技公司要去哪,别听它说什么,看它盖什么楼。78,000 平方英尺的办公加仓储,配上专用的动物手术设施,这个组合对应的组织规模是几百人,十个人的研究组用不上这些。

如果总部最终也搬到得州,Neuralink 就会和特斯拉、SpaceX 一样,把根扎进得州。

马斯克在播客里聊的其实是脑震荡

在 Full Send 播客上,话题从 UFC 选手一路滑到 NFL 球员,落点在反复撞击头部会怎样。

他的说法很物理:任何快速加速,都会让脑组织在颅骨内壁上撞一下。

反复的脑震荡,或者反复的头部损伤,结果是你会损失一部分神经元,神经元会死掉。你把自己的脑子在颅内撞上颅骨,仅仅因为一次快速加速,就会死掉一批神经元。如果一直这么干,损失的量足够大,就会产生实质差别。(马斯克)

主持人追问:一次脑震荡有多严重?他的回答挺克制,一次大概还行。接着主持人抛出了一个更狠的问题:你愿意用 30% 的脑处理能力和记忆力,换一百万美元吗?

这段对话看起来跟产品无关,其实指向了一条清晰的需求曲线。脑机接口最早的用户,未必是先天瘫痪的人,很可能是自己把自己撞坏的人。职业运动员、退役拳手、退伍军人,这些群体受损明确、诉求迫切、付费方往往是联盟或保险。

再往下才是帕金森、癫痫、抑郁这类适应症。而"让瘫痪病人打字比健全人快"这个指标,属于最难的终点,也最有传播力。

现在就能报名的临床试验:BrainGate2

很多人问怎么参加 Neuralink 的试验。答案是,当时还参加不了,因为它的首次人体试验尚未启动。

不过有另一组试验正在招人,技术上最接近:BrainGate2。加州大学戴维斯分校健康中心正在招募受试者,目标是造一个神经假体,帮失去说话能力或正在失去说话能力的人恢复语言。

招募对象是有神经损伤或进行性神经疾病的人,包括脊髓损伤、脑卒中、肌萎缩侧索硬化(ALS)。相关入口在 braingate.org,也可以直接联系 braingate.ucdavis.edu。

语言重建是侵入式脑机接口里最接近临床价值的方向之一。控制发声的皮层区域相对集中,信号可解码,患者的收益又极其直接。一个人能不能重新说出自己孩子的名字,比在屏幕上移动光标重要得多。

扎克伯格的选择

同一时间,马克·扎克伯格上了 Joe Rogan 的播客,聊了将近三个小时。

节目里他谈到 Meta 的长期方向:把大量技术堆起来,最终交付一种真实的临场感,让你觉得另一个人就物理上坐在你旁边。

你得把所有这些不同的技术都建起来,才能交付一种真实的临场感:就像另一个人物理上就在你身边。我觉得这是世界上最神奇的事情。(扎克伯格)

看完这三个小时,主播的判断是:扎克伯格的核心动机是连接人,不管这个连接发生在物理世界、今天的数字世界,还是更未来的虚拟世界。

但在侵入式植入这条路上,他和他的公司当时既不愿意,也没有打算迈出那一步。

这个分野值得说清楚。Meta 走的是穿戴式路线,头显、眼镜、腕带,能大规模出货,迭代以月计,用户随时可以摘下来。Neuralink 走的是植入路线,一次手术,一个监管审批周期,迭代以年计。

两条路的时间尺度差了整整一个数量级。短期看,戴在身上的东西会先普及;长期看,只有贴到神经元上,带宽才可能有数量级的跃迁。它们各自跑在不同的赛道上,用不同的计时单位衡量。

招人:把产线放大十倍

Neuralink 官网挂出了一个岗位:机器人团队的制造工程师。不需要脑科学背景,要的是把设备造出来的能力。

这个团队负责设计生产针头弹匣的设备和产线。针头弹匣是机器人末端执行的部分,也就是真正插进脑组织的那一节。它属于一次性耗材,精度要求极高,用量随手术台数线性增长。

团队成员 Sam 在招募视频里说得很直接:

我们打算明年把产线规模扩大十倍,最终要做到一百倍甚至更多。工作量很大,但会很有意思。我们在找造过装配线、设计过机器、做过数据追踪的人,或者任何你觉得用得上的技能。(Sam,Neuralink 团队)

申请方式不复杂:简历,加上最重要的三到四条技术成果,用要点写清楚你做过什么、达到了什么指标。

这条招聘信息的信息量比发布会上任何一页 PPT 都大。从"能不能做出来"到"一年做十倍",是一家公司从实验室变成工厂的分界线。十倍产能对应的是临床试点的扩张,一百倍对应的是商业化。

一件印着动作电位的 T 恤

顺带一提,Neuralink 的周边商店上线了,入口在 shop.nuralink.com,可以留下邮箱等开售通知。

工程师 Kevin 在几周前分享了消息。已知的图案有三种:植入体本身、一张叫 spike train 的神经元放电序列图、以及动作电位的波形曲线。

一家做脑机接口的公司,把神经科学的教科书插图印在 T 恤上卖,这件事挺说明团队气质。他们是真心觉得这些东西好看。

把碎片拼起来看

2022 年秋天这家公司的状态,可以压缩成几个动作:定了一场万圣节的发布会,被路透社传了一次合并,在得州买了 37 英亩地,把动物手术室和产线扩招同时推进,CEO 上播客聊了聊脑震荡。

发布会负责吸引注意力,工地和招聘负责交付。两者之间的时间差,就是外界总觉得它"进展缓慢"的原因。

至于万圣节那天到底会展示什么,主播抛了个玩笑:会不会搞点跟弗兰肯斯坦有关的东西。玩笑背后有个真问题。公众想看猴子打游戏,工程师想听通道数,这两件事很少在同一天被满足。

  • 看发布会只盯三个数字:单次植入的电极通道数、机器人完成一例植入的耗时、芯片的通道密度与功耗。舞台效果和视频剪辑都不算进展。
  • 把 Synchron 的合并传闻当噪音处理:真正该追的是 Synchron 自己的血管内路线人体数据,那才是对开颅路线的实质参照。
  • 想参加脑机接口试验:先看清楚入选条件,BrainGate2 招的是脊髓损伤、脑卒中、ALS 等导致语言功能受损的患者,入口在 braingate.org 和 braingate.ucdavis.edu。Neuralink 当时尚未开放人体试验招募。
  • 想投简历:别写"热爱脑科学",写三到四条可量化的工程成果,产线节拍、良率提升、数据采集系统的覆盖范围。招人方明确说了,最重要的是这几条。
  • 判断这家公司走到哪一步:看它的招聘岗位类型和厂房规划,比看发布会准得多。招制造工程师、盖动物手术室,说明它正在从演示阶段往量产和临床推进。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00hey there welcome to neuropod a Channel about all things related to the Elon Musk founding company neurolic in this update episode I'll discuss neuralink's progress update and demo coming up on Halloween then we'll talk about nerlink's merch store and we'll show you where you can sign up to be notified first when the store goes live next we'll talk about rumors about emerge with synchron another BCI company and then Elon went on the full sun podcast so we'll talk a little bit about that then there was an article that talks about neuralink's new Austin expansion plants we'll dive into some of the highlights from that article then there's another company called brain

0:38gate 2 that's enrolling patients in a clinical trial that'll be pretty similar to neuralink we'll show you where you can sign up if you're interested in that then Mark Zuckerberg went on Joe Rogan's podcast to talk about a wide variety of topics we'll discuss where he thinks neuralink and meta are heading in the future and then we'll finish up the episode with how you can help make a neuralink robot Elon announced on Twitter that there's going to be a knurling progress update show and tell on October 31st Halloween I'm pretty excited for this event it's been a little while since we've gotten an update from the company so it'll be nice to see what they've been working on

1:17since Elon and the team often discuss how nerling can help paralyze patients use a computer keyboard and mouse more efficiently than an able-bodied human I think it'd be cool to expand on the monkey man pong demo from back in April 2021 and have pager play a video game like pong and compete against an able-bodied human where they're using an actual joystick Additionally the team is often stated that they're wanting to increase the number of electrodes so maybe we'll hear of some improved Channel counts increase utility of the robot and or more efficient chip design all of which could be easily overlooked by the public but should probably be more appreciated

2:00as these engineering Feats are not simple to achieve let me know in the comments what you think the team could showcase might they show something related to Frankenstein or Halloween a few weeks ago Kevin a neurlink engineer shared the neurolink merch store is coming soon you can sign up for it at shop.nuralink.com this reminds me of one of our original update episodes from almost two years ago when I said this Viv and Max both shared some cool shirt designs maybe these are some of the designs we'll see when the shop goes live it looks like there's a link implant a brain activity plot called a spike train and an action potential almost everyone over time will

2:44develop Brain and Spine problems these can all be sold with an implantable neural link the neurons are like wiring and you can need an electronic thing to solve an electronic problem neural like device it's about an inch in diameter and has a battery and a Bluetooth and a inductive charger it would be implanted in your skull [Music] the Victor is very carefully inserted with a robot that we developed very carefully avoiding any veins or arteries and then you Stitch it up and you wouldn't even know that somebody has interface basically anywhere on your brain you can solve a very wide range of brain injuries if you want the future to be good you must make it so

3:30[Music] there's a Reuters article that started to gain quite a bit of traction it's titled musk approaches brain chips startup synchron about deal amid neuralink delays the article talks about how Elon and Tom Oxley the founder and chief executive of synchron discussed a potential collaboration or a complete merging of the two companies I think it's worth noting that synchron and neuralink have very different BCI approaches synchron is working on a less invasive approach that requires inserting a stent into the vasculature or blood vessels of the brain and neuralink is working on a more invasive approach that has not yet started human trials

4:20there's quite a bit about this article that doesn't line up in my view so although I suppose it could be right I think it's best to keep the story in the rumor category and not expect a merger anytime soon of course later in the article the author states that the sources requested anonymity because the matter is confidential and I looked into the author a little bit further based on the Articles she's written it seems like she's not elon's number one fan there's one article in particular where she references a 62-page neuralink handbook that seems nothing like what I'd expect given that Tesla's handbook was literally called an anti-handbook that's only four pages

5:02anyway moving on Elon talked about the impact of repeated hits to the head and how it impacts UFC fighters and NFL players in any kind of heart like real fast joke acceleration is get your your brain is going to get damaged up against your skull how bad how bad is a concussion just one concussion oh I can crush is probably okay would you trade 30 of your mental processing and memory for a million dollars or any amount for that matter he then went untad these comments about neuralink repeated repeated concussions or repeated injuries like what's going to happen is you're going to lose you're going to lose a certain number of neurons are going to die you know so you

5:48smash you smash your brain against your skull internally just due to a fast acceleration you can lose some number of neurons now if you keep doing that you're going to lose enough neurons to make a difference a lot of this isn't very new to the Avid neuropod listeners so I'll link to the interesting sections of the interview in the description as you've probably inferred from me mentioning the Austin job openings for so long neuralink is expanding their operations in the US and Texas area if or when nerlink's headquarters also moves to Texas they'll join the other musk companies who have planted roots in the Lone Star State they're working on constructing eight

6:25buildings on a 37-acre property in the Del Valley area Link's largest addition to the property would be a 78 000 square foot building with two office spaces and warehouse space according to a filing another building would be a 5850 square foot office that is described as an animal vet office capable of fitting 12 employees the office will also have two operating rooms surgery preparation and storage rooms short-term animal storage and it room a conference room a locker room showers and a waiting room it also has a room labeled histology which is the study of microscopic structure of tissues [Music] asked about how one might go about enrolling in neuralink's clinical trials

7:14so in addition to synchron's trials I thought I'd raise awareness of another set of Trials taking place at brain gate 2. this is probably the most comparable to neuralink's devices the release States UC Davis health is recruiting people for a clinical trial with the goal of building a neurological prosthesis for restoring speech to people who have lost or are losing the ability to speak the research is aimed at people who have neurological injuries or Progressive neurological diseases such as spinal cord injury stroke and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis or ALS the link to this article will be in the description to learn more about the study visit bringate.org or contact

7:59bringate UC davis.edu Joe Rogan and Mark Zuckerberg discuss the early days of Facebook how Mark feels about Twitter and where meta is going meta has been interested in augmented reality virtual reality and brain interfaces for several years now this is a short clip of what Mark said regarding the future of meta and neural interfaces and we haven't even gotten to neural interfaces yet but we should definitely spend some time on that but it's like you kind of go across all these different things and it's just this incredibly wide amount of technology that that needs to get built in order to basically build and deliver a realistic sense of presence like you're physically

8:38there with another person which I just think is the most magical thing in the world after watching the full three-ish hour-long episode it's clear to me that Mark Zuckerberg is primarily motivated by Connecting People whether that connection happens in the physical world today's digital world or a more futuristic virtual digital world at least right now he and his company are not willing nor wanting to take the leap forward and embrace the invasive implant neural interface route which I suppose might be good news doesn't it seem fun to work on building neuralink robots experience with brains would not be necessary to do this one example role is manufacturing engineer

9:21on the robot team the team designs the equipment and the production line that makes the needle cartridges or the end part of the robot here's a message from Sam on the nerlink team we are trying to scale our line by 10 times in the next year and eventually 100 times or more so there's a lot of work to do but it'll be a lot of fun we're looking for anyone that has built up assembly lines design machines implemented Data Tracking or as any skill they think would be useful for this the application is really simple just upload your resume and most importantly three to four bullet points of technical accomplishments highlighting your exceptional ability

10:01the link to the job posting will be in the description and here's neurlink's employee count according to LinkedIn if you're passionate about the mission of the company and think you have any applicable skills it's worth applying this company is still in the super early stages and has plenty of room to grow thank you to our generous patreon supporters and channel members who enable us to continue producing neuropod if you found this video useful please do us a favor and like And subscribe for future updates if you missed our videos about kernel or deepminded check them out here thanks for watching hope to catch you at the next episode [Music]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份