大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克在卡塔尔经济论坛接受采访(2022.06.21)

Elon Musk is interviewed at Qatar Economic Forum on the 21.06.2022

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

纽约凌晨三点,马斯克出现在卡塔尔经济论坛的大屏幕上。主持人开场先给他分了身:现在媒体要应付至少三个马斯克,推特的潜在买家、特斯拉和 SpaceX 的掌门人、一个正在成形的政治力量。这还没算上那些推文和争议。

整场对话里最容易被划过去的一个数字,出现在裁员那一段。他说特斯拉要砍掉 10% 的领薪岗位。听起来是场大裁员,换算成总人数只有 3% 到 3.5%。特斯拉的员工结构是三分之二小时工、三分之一领薪,这个换算他主动做了,而且做了两遍。

一场凌晨三点的连线,信息量最大的往往不是那些上头条的句子,是受访者顺手给出的分母。

440 亿美元的收购卡在三个具体的地方

主持人先摆了一个事实:看现在的交易价差(deal spread),投资者似乎在押注这笔 440 亿美元的收购不会完成。所谓价差,就是收购价和推特当前股价之间的距离,距离越大,市场越不相信它能成。

马斯克没有正面回应这个赌注。他说这是一件敏感的事,公开场合能说的话有限,他会“谨慎措辞”,避免引发新的诉讼。主持人接过话头说,减少证词(deposition minimization)确实重要。马斯克同意。

然后他把这笔交易拆成了三件待办。

第一件,推特声称虚假账号和垃圾账号占系统用户的比例低于 5%。马斯克说,这个数字大概和大多数人使用推特的体验对不上,他们还在等推特给出解释,他称这是“一个非常重要的议题”。

第二件,债务融资的那一部分能不能凑齐。

第三件,股东会不会投票赞成。

三件事解决之前,交易无法完成。他没有说哪一件最难,但他花在虚假账号上的时间明显更多。

5% 这个数字和他的使用体验对不上

虚假账号比例是这场收购里最技术、也最致命的一项尽调。

推特的商业模式建立在广告上,广告主买的是真实人类的注意力。如果可货币化日活用户(mDAU)里有相当比例是机器注册的空壳,整个估值模型的地基就要重算。5% 是推特在历年年报和 SEC 文件里反复申明的口径,也是它向广告主交付的承诺。

马斯克的怀疑很朴素:他自己用推特,看到的东西不像只有 5%。这个质疑不需要复杂的统计训练就能提出,但要用数据证伪或证实,就要推特开放原始样本、账号抽样方法和判定标准。

他反复强调“仍在等待解决”。这句外交辞令背后是一道很硬的题,推特如果拿不出让买方满意的证据,买方就有理由主张卖方陈述不实;推特如果拿得出,那这笔交易就只剩下钱和票数的问题。

衰退:某个时点必然发生,近期大概率发生

主持人提到,拜登刚刚公开表示美国衰退“并非不可避免”,问马斯克怎么看。他之前对经济的判断被媒体广泛引用,用的词是“超级糟糕的感觉”(super bad feeling)。

衰退在某个时点上是不可避免的。至于近期是否会发生,我认为可能性大于不可能。它当然不是确定性事件,但看起来更可能发生。(马斯克)

主持人当场表态说自己同意这个判断。

这段话的价值在于它的精度。他没有预测哪个月开始、持续几个季度、失业率会到多少。他给出的是一个概率方向:某个时点必然,近期更可能而非更不可能。这种表述在宏观预测里已经算克制,但被剪成标题就成了“马斯克预言衰退”。

更实际的信号藏在别处。整场对话里他谈论经济的时间不到两分钟,谈论产能、原材料和供应链瓶颈的时间长得多。对企业经营者来说,判断衰退的方式往往就是看自己手上订单的取消率和交货周期,而不是看经济学家的模型。

能说什么,和能被多少人看到,是两件事

主持人问他,推特到底要让谁进来,有没有边界。

马斯克给了一个规模目标:理想状态下,他希望北美 80% 的人、全世界大约一半的人,以某种形式用上推特。这个数字听上去夸张,但它决定了后续所有的产品逻辑。要覆盖那么多人,平台就不能让人感到不适或者被骚扰,否则这些人根本不会留下。

接着他提出了一个区分,这个区分构成了他整套推特改造思路的骨架。

言论自由和触达自由之间有巨大的差别。在美国,你可以走到时代广场中央,几乎想喊什么就喊什么,你会惹恼周围的人,但在一个拥挤的公共场所,你或多或少被允许喊出你想喊的东西。当然,如果你喊“这是抢劫”,那可能会给你惹上麻烦。但你喊出的东西,无论多有争议,并不需要被广播给整个国家。(马斯克)

他的方案是把这两件事拆开。让人在法律允许的范围内说他们想说的,然后用推荐系统限制“谁看得到”。用户自己在设置里选:想看到一切,那就给你一切;不想看到某类冒犯性内容,那就把它过滤掉。

这个思路绕开了一个长期困扰平台的死结。过去十年,内容治理的默认动作是“删”或者“封”,因为只有这两种手段能阻止内容扩散。马斯克提出的第三条路是“降权到看不见”,把裁决权从平台转移到用户偏好。

它当然有代价。过滤气泡会变得更厚,公共讨论的共同事实基础会进一步碎裂。而且“什么算冒犯”这件事,最终还是得有人写进代码。整场对话里,他只在这一点上把话说完整了,其余部分大多是口号、数字或者澄清。

头衔不重要,产品才重要

主持人直接问:你打算当推特的 CEO 吗?如果当了,还继续当特斯拉和 SpaceX 的 CEO 吗?

马斯克的回答滑开了职位那一层。

我会去驱动产品,这是我在 SpaceX 和特斯拉做的事。我驱动产品和技术。我被称为 CEO 还是别的什么头衔,远不如我能不能把产品推向正确方向重要。(马斯克)

这句话可以当成推脱,也可以当成他给自己写的岗位说明书。他在特斯拉和 SpaceX 的实际角色从来不是财务或运营管理者,是总工程师。Model 3 的产能地狱期间他睡在工厂地板上,星舰的每一次设计变更都有他的痕迹。他把推特也归入同一类工作:一个需要有人从技术侧推动的产品,而不是一个需要职业经理人优化的现金流资产。

中国车企让他印象很深

话题转到特斯拉。主持人提到一个预测,说几年之后大众在电动车领域可能超过特斯拉。马斯克回了一句:这个预测应该是你们彭博做的。主持人承认是自己做的。马斯克说,他不同意这个预测。

然后他主动把话题引到了中国。

我必须说,我对中国的公司、中国的汽车公司总体印象非常深刻。我认为他们极其有竞争力、勤奋、聪明。会有一波中国产品出海的大浪潮。现在已经有了,比如几乎所有的 iPhone 都是中国的代工厂为苹果制造的。我认为我们会看到许多行业的中国产品大规模出口。(马斯克)

这段话在 2022 年年中说出来,分量不轻。当时中国新能源汽车的出口才刚刚起量,欧洲街头还很少见到中国品牌的乘用车。两年之后,中国成为全球第一大汽车出口国,比亚迪的单季销量一度超过特斯拉。他说的那波浪潮,来的比他描述的还要快。

特斯拉真正的瓶颈在锂矿,不在大众

主持人追问:你把大众、通用当成对手,还是把中国的新公司当成对手?

马斯克的回答揭示了一个很少被外界理解的经营现实。

从特斯拉的角度,我们其实不太考虑竞争对手。我们的约束更多在原材料和产能爬坡上。约束不是竞争对手施加给我们的,是供应链的现实和制造能力的建设施加给我们的。任何试着下过特斯拉订单的人都知道,需求极高,等车名单很长。这不是我们故意的,我们在以人类可能的最高速度提升产能。(马斯克)

这段话解释了一个一直让分析师困惑的现象:特斯拉为什么敢在需求旺盛的时候连续涨价,为什么交付周期能长达几个月,为什么它不推低价车型去打份额。

因为瓶颈落在供给端。需求从来不缺,竞争他也不太看。真正卡住他的是锂、镍、石墨,是精炼产能,是正极材料前驱体,是电芯成型产线。他从采矿、精炼一路数到正极材料和电芯成型,把整条锂离子电池供应链的卡点念了一遍。

市场份额的争夺发生在下游,决定胜负的却是上游的矿和产线。这种竞争观很像工程师的思维:先找到系统的物理上限,再谈其他。

他说“我们只需要把工厂建得更快”。这句话听起来像玩笑,实际是特斯拉过去三年最核心的组织目标。

裁员 10% 的账,他自己算了一遍

主持人拿出了那条已经被媒体炒了好几轮的新闻,先说要裁 10% 的员工,后来说只裁 10% 的领薪员工,再后来又说总人数会增加,到底哪个是真的。

马斯克给了一个精确到小数点的答案。

特斯拉会在未来三个月左右把领薪员工削减大约 10%。我们预期小时工队伍会扩大,这一点很清楚。我们在领薪这一侧增长得非常快,某些领域增长得有点过快,所以需要缩减。我们的结构大约是三份之二小时工、三分之一领薪,所以严格来说,领薪岗位减少 10%,只相当于总人数减少大约 3% 到 3.5%。(马斯克)

这个换算值得所有看裁员新闻的人记住。一家制造业公司的名义裁员比例和实际人数变化之间,隔着一个员工结构。同样一句“裁员 10%”,放在一家全员领薪的软件公司,和放在一家三分之二是产线工人的汽车公司,含义完全不同。

他还提到已经有一桩相关诉讼,并把这件事归到“无关紧要”那一档。

别对一桩没有立场的先发制人式诉讼做过度解读。那是一桩后果轻微的小官司。任何和特斯拉相关的事情都会上头条,无论是一场自行车事故还是严重得多的事件,都能带来大量点击。我会把那桩诉讼归入无关紧要这一类。一年之后,我们的总人数会更高。(马斯克)

他对媒体报道逻辑的这段吐槽,比裁员数字本身更值得琢磨。“和特斯拉有关”已经成了一个流量标签,标签之下的事件严重程度被抹平了。这是注意力经济的必然结果,也是所有高关注度公司必须承担的噪音成本。

德桑蒂斯、特朗普,和一笔两千万美元的政治捐款

主持人把话题切到政治。马斯克此前表示过,如果佛罗里达州州长罗恩·德桑蒂斯(Ron DeSantis)竞选总统,他可能会支持。主持人问这个立场有没有变,以及会不会考虑支持特朗普。

马斯克的澄清是:当时只是被问到下一届总统选举会支持谁,他说还没决定;被追问倾向于谁,他说“可能是德桑蒂斯”。至于特朗普,他现在的态度是“未决定”。

然后他确认了另一件事:他打算给一个支持“超级温和派”候选人的超级政治行动委员会(Super PAC)出钱。

具体金额还没定,但会是一笔不小的数目,大概在 2000 万到 2500 万美元这个量级。(马斯克)

主持人追问,德桑蒂斯和特朗普这类政客都在对中国的议题上高声表态,这会不会影响他在中国的生意。

马斯克的回答很干脆:不认为会。

这个回答和他前面关于推特的表态是一致的。他没有把地缘政治风险和商业利益放在一个天平上称,他的判断是这些噪音不会转化为实际的经营障碍。这个判断在 2022 年看起来合理,后面几年发生的事情,给出的答案要复杂得多。

狗狗币:他在回应工厂里的人

主持人提到加密货币市场的血洗,问他周末公开支持某种加密货币是怎么回事,人们还应不应该投资。

马斯克先做了一个重要的切割:他从来没有说过人们应该投资加密货币。

然后他交代了仓位。特斯拉、SpaceX 和他本人买了比特币,但只占现金和近现金资产的一小部分,不算显著。他还买了狗狗币,特斯拉接受狗狗币支付部分周边商品,SpaceX 也会跟进。

我打算个人支持狗狗币,因为我看到很多不那么富裕的人鼓励我买它、支持它。我是在回应这些人。就是在 SpaceX 或特斯拉工厂里走动的那些人,他们要求我支持狗狗币,所以我就这么做了。(马斯克)

狗狗币当时从高点跌了 80% 到 90%。他的解释是,正因为跌了这么多,他才站出来说他认为那里还有价值。

这段话可以被读成一种奇怪的民粹主义,一个世界首富因为工厂工人请求就去公开支持一个 meme 币。也可以读成另一种东西:他清楚地知道自己的每条推文能让散户账户跳多少个百分点,而他选择在自己主动加杠杆之后,用“我从来没让人投资”来划清责任边界。

两种解读同时成立。事实层面他说的没错,影响层面他不作任何承诺。

9 月 30 日,一个希望拿得出手的原型

主持人问到了人形机器人。特斯拉计划在 9 月 30 日的 AI Day 上展示 Optimus 原型。

我希望我们能给人们展示一个有趣的原型。特斯拉有一支非常有才华的团队,我和他们紧密合作,争取在九月底准备好一个人形机器人原型,我认为我们在按这个节点推进。AI Day 上还会聊几件其他令人兴奋的事。我们办这些活动,是想强调特斯拉远不止是一家汽车公司,在我看来,我们是现有最强的现实世界人工智能公司。(马斯克)

“现实世界人工智能”这个提法值得停一下。它指的是在物理环境中处理感知、决策和执行的 AI,自动驾驶是其中一类,人形机器人是另一类。这与在文本和图像数据集上训练的大模型属于不同的技术路线,前者要处理的是传感器噪声、实时性约束和长尾场景。

他办 AI Day 的真实目的,是让资本市场重新给特斯拉定价。一家汽车公司的市盈率和一家人工智能公司的市盈率,差距可以是数量级的。

他想要一个 AI 的 FDA

主持人提到谷歌的那场风波:一名工程师认为公司的对话模型表现出的东西比以往任何时候都更接近人类思维,甚至认为它有了人格。

马斯克的回答没有纠缠那个工程师的判断对不对,他跳到了制度层面。

我认为我们应该对人工智能感到担忧。我长期以来一直主张,应该有一个监管机构来监管人工智能,为公共利益服务。任何对公众存在风险的领域,无论是食品药品管理局、联邦航空管理局还是联邦通信委员会,只要涉及公共风险或公共利益,有一个政府裁判、一个监管机构是好事。我认为人工智能也应该有,而我们现在没有。这是我的建议。(马斯克)

这套类比很工整。FDA 管药品,一种新分子要经过三期临床才能上市;FAA 管航空,一架新机型要拿到适航证才能载客;FCC 管频谱,一家运营商要用某段频率得先拿牌照。它们的共同点是:技术在造成伤害之前,必须先通过一个独立的第三方审查。

AI 现在没有这道关。模型发布的速度由公司自己决定,风险评估由公司自己做,出问题之后的处置也由公司自己宣布。他说的“政府裁判”,本质上是要求引入一个不拿公司薪水的第三方。

有意思的是,提这个建议的人自己正在造一个现实世界的 AI 系统,正在部署大规模自动驾驶,正在筹备人形机器人。他的立场并不是反对技术进步,他要求的是给进步装一个刹车踏板,并且这个踏板由公共机构来踩。

整场对话到此结束。主持人感谢他在凌晨三点出现,说这是一场英勇的表现。

这场凌晨三点的对话,能带走什么

把三十分钟压缩成一句话:马斯克在这段时间里给出的所有判断,都建立在同一个方法上,把宏大问题拆成可以计算的分母。

收购卡在哪里,三件事。裁员到底裁多少,3% 到 3.5%。产能受限于什么,从锂矿到电芯成型的六个环节。AI 该怎么管,参照 FDA 的审批流程。政治捐款多少,2000 万到 2500 万。

他几乎不说“大概”“可能很多”这类词。哪怕是在预测衰退这种本质上无法精确的事情上,他也要加上“可能性大于不可能”这样的概率限定。

这种表达方式会让人觉得他什么都知道。真正的启示在另一面:他对每件事都先问一遍“这件事的约束条件到底是什么”,然后只谈约束条件。他谈竞争时落点在供应链,谈舆论时落点在产能,谈头衔时落点在能不能推动产品。

下面几条是可以直接拿去用的。

  • 看到“裁员 10%”这类新闻,先找员工结构。名义比例乘以领薪员工占比,才是对总人数的真实影响。制造业和服务业的同一个百分比,含义差三倍。
  • 判断一笔并购会不会完成,看交易价差,不看新闻标题。价差扩大意味着市场在给失败概率定价,这比任何“知情人士称”都更接近真相。
  • 评估一家制造业公司的真实处境,去上游找答案。锂、镍、正极材料、电芯产能,这些环节的瓶颈决定了下游能交付多少台车,比新车发布会的参数表有用得多。
  • 讨论平台治理时,把“能不能说”和“能被多少人看到”分开处理。前者是法律问题,后者是产品问题。混在一起谈,永远谈不出方案。
  • 判断一项新技术该不该管,看有没有独立的第三方审查。如果一个领域的风险评估、发布节奏和事故处置全由开发者自己决定,这个领域早晚要出事。
  • 听到任何人对某个资产表态,先分清他是在陈述仓位,还是在给出投资建议。这两件事的法律含义和责任边界完全不同。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Music] thank you very much we have been discussing capitalism and we now have a man who by many measures at least as the world's greatest capitalist at the moment elon musk thank you very much for coming and talking to us you could argue at the moment that us in the media we have at least three elon musks to deal with we have the proposed buyer of twitter we have the ceo of tesla spacex and much else and we have musk the emerging political force and that's before we discover or discuss all the different provocations and tweets and so on but maybe we can run through those three and let's begin with twitter and i suppose my question for you is

0:58what is the status of the 44 billion deal 44 billion deal to buy the company if you look at the deal spreads at the moment the investors seem to be betting that it won't happen i suppose and right here you have the qataris who are amongst your backers what are you going to say to them and to us first of all i'd like to say

1:25your highness your excellencies and distinguished guests thank you very much for hosting me virtually it's an honor to be here or be there virtually and i actually wish i could be there in person so with respect to the twitter transaction there's a limit to what i can say publicly given that is somewhat of a sensitive matter so i i will actually be measured in my responses here such as not to generate incremental lawsuits unfortunately that seems to be a risk you sometimes manage to overcome yes a deposition minimization is i think important have you have twitter given you enough information well there are still a few unresolved matters you've you've probably read about the

2:18question as to whether the number of fake and spam users on the system is less than five percent as twitter claims which i think is probably not most people's experience on when using twitter so we're still awaiting resolution on that matter and that that is a very significant matter so we're awaiting resolution on that and then of course there is the question of will the the debt portion of the round come together and then will the shareholders vote in favor so i think those are the three things that stand in the you know that need to be resolved before the transaction came to complete what about the general state of the economy does that weigh on you when you

3:08think about this i mean you described it you have a super bad feeling about the economy are you still in that position i just said to you earlier joe biden has just come out and said that a recession in america is not inevitable how do you feel about the economy well i think a recession is inevitable at some point as to whether there is a recession in the near term i think that is more likely than not it certainly isn't it's not a certainty but it appears more likely than not and what do you think i'm i'm i'm i'm with you i agree with you i think it's more likely can i ask you one particular thing to do with the twitter bid which is you know you are one of the

3:56biggest and fastest growing investors in china tesla you've talked about it being a third of your sales going forward you're now buying twitter the kind of public forum for free speech the chinese historically don't tend to be very enthusiastic about free speech are you worried about whether you can keep those two particular horses running is is buying twitter going to get you in trouble with the chinese well twitter does not operate in china so

4:32and i think china does not attempt to if you interfere with the free speech of the of the press in the u.s as far as i know i because i assume you're not under pressure to at bloomberg to from china so i think there's i i don't think this is gonna be an issue and in terms generally of that issue of freedom of speech and twitter you've talked about twitter being making it even freer and letting more people onto it is there a limit at all to who you think should be allowed onto twitter well i my aspiration for twitter or in general for the digital town square would be that it is as inclusive in the broader sense of the word as possible about it is it is an appealing

5:28system to use so i mean ideally i'd like to get like 80 of that's in north america and perhaps i don't know half the world or something ultimately on on twitter in one form or another and that needs that means it must be something that is appealing to people it obviously cannot be a place where they feel uncomfortable or harassed or they'll simply not use it so it and i think there's this big difference between freedom of speech and freedom of reach in that one can obviously let's say in united states go in the middle of times square and pretty much yell anything you you want and you you know you'll you'll annoy the people around you but but

6:16you're you're kind of allowed to just sort of yell whatever you want in in in you know a crowded public place more or less apart from this is this is a robbery probably that would get you in trouble so but but then that that whatever you say however controversial does not need to then be broadcast to the whole country so i think generally the approach of twitter should be to let people say what they want to do within the balance the law but then limit the you know who sees that based on the any given twitter users preferences so if your preferences are to see anything or read anything then well you'll get that and if but if your preferences are well you prefer not to

7:08see you know comments that you find offensive in one form or another then you you can have that as a setting and not see it and but i think one way or another it one needs to take the steps that that entice most people to to want to be on twitter and enjoy it and find it informative and entertaining and funny you know and just something and useful as useful as possible it sounds like you want to be involved is your plan to be ceo of twitter and if you do that would you still keep being ceo of tesla and spacex well i i would drive the product

7:59which is what i do at spacex and and tesla so i drive the product with technology whether i'm that when i'm called the ceo or something else is much less important than my ability to drive the product in the right direction can i jump towards tesla though you know most people it's very obvious you have changed the car industry in a in a dramatic way i'm quite intrigued by one thing which is your competitors where do you see competition coming from do you see it coming from the old car makers coming back at you i just saw a forecast that maybe in a couple of years time volkswagen would be bigger than you in electric cars or do you see it coming from new place do you

8:42believe that why not i believe that forecast was was from you yes it was yeah and do you agree with that i would not agree with that forecast no do you see people like volkswagen and general motors and people like that as the opponents or do you see people like china the new chinese companies where do you see the most vibrant competition in electric cars i have to say that i am very impressed with the the companies and the car companies in china just in general with companies in china i think they're extremely competitive hard and smart and and i think there's going to be

9:27just a massive wave of chinese products going out into the world there already are but you know for example i think almost all the iphones are made in china by contract manufacturers for apple but i think we'll see just a large wave of products being exported from china in many industries you know in electric cars do they have an advantage at all yeah yeah no i i do think well i should say from a tesla perspective we don't really think about other competitors our constraints are much more in raw materials and and being able to scale up production so our constraints are not imposed upon us by competitors but rather the just imposed upon us by the

10:23realities of of the supply chain and building up a manufacturing capacity so i mean as anyone knows who has tried to order that order at tesla the demand for our cars is extremely high and the wait list is long so our and and this is not intentional if we are increasing production capacity as fast as humanly possible so that's so relaxing we really don't think about competition at all we just think about how how do we address the limiting factors in the supply chain and in our own industrial capacity basically we need to build the factories faster and then we need to look ahead to whatever the chokepoints are in the whole lithium-ion battery supply chain

11:10from mining and refining to catheter nanoproduction and cell formation so can can you can you set the record straight on one thing which is this issue about the layoffs i think you've said initially that tesla 10 of the workforce would be cut then 10 of salary would be cut then salaried would stay fly flat and overall head count would go up what is the number i know there's already i think been a lawsuit about the 10 is is 10 the goal to reduce the workforce or what is the number that we should think about or that you're planning yes so tesla is reducing the salaried workforce by roughly 10 over the next probably three months or so the we expect to grow out our hourly

12:06workforce it's quite clear that we expect to grow our hourly workforce but we we grew very fast with on on the salary side and we grew a little too fast in some areas and so it requires a reduction in salaried workforce and we're about two-thirds hourly and one-third salary so i guess technically a 10 reduction in the salary workforce is only roughly a three three and a half percent reduction in total head count now i think that number is important legally isn't it because i think people are trying to say if you if you're going to lay off 10 of your workforce you have even in america to make an announcement about that we did make an announcement

12:57yes let's not read too much into a a preemptive lawsuit that has no standing that that is a small lawsuit of minor consequence that just anything that related to tesla gets big headlines but it is whether it is you know a bicycle accident or something much more serious it's still it and it seems like anything illustrated tesla gets a lot of clicks whether whether it is trivial or significant i would put that lawsuit referring to in the trivial category so a year from now i think our head count will be higher in both salaried and obviously in hourly but in the short term of the next few months we expect to see like i said roughly a 10 reduction in saudi salaried workforce

13:50which is actually just really only a three three and a half percent reduction in total head count and not a super material should we jump to that la that third elon musk the the uncontroversial one in politics you you've indicated that the florida governor ron desantis is someone you could get behind if he ran for president i wonder if you're still in that position and whether you would for instance think about supporting donald trump if he were to run well i was simply asked if there was if i decided on who i would be supporting in the next presidential race and i said i had not decided

14:33who i would support then i was asked well who might you be leaning towards i said possibly to sanchez and now now i'm asking you about trump whether you would consider him i think i'm undecided at this point on that election i wonder you talked about putting money behind a super moderate super pac in the us and i wondered how much money do you think you're going to put into that what kind of support would you push i have not decided on an amount but it would be some some non-trivial figure i think i mean at least sort of on the order of non-trivial would you mean a lot sorry non-trivial could mean a lot of money with you i i was guessing well

15:22i don't know i have not decided on the exact amount but perhaps would be 20 or 25 million dollars just on that issue i mean again you look at the samsung what desantis says you look at what trump says and those sort of politicians they again are people who make a large noise about china and i wondered whether you thought that was also an issue for you in terms of business in china

15:56well no i don't think so you're a brave man is it can i can i ask you over the weekend you you tweeted your support of one cryptocurrency you've seen the kind of carnage that has been happening in cryptocurrencies at the moment what is happening and do you still think people should should invest or is it a more selective approach well i i have never said that people should invest in crypto in the case of tesla spacex myself

16:33you know spacex and tesla and myself all did buy some bitcoin but it's a small percentage of our total cash and near cash assets so you know not all that significant i also bought some dogecoin and tesla accepts dogecoin for some merchandise and spacex will do the same and and i intend to personally support a dogecoin because i just saw a lot of people who are not that wealthy who you know have encourage me to buy and support dogecoin so i'm responding to [Music] those people just people that would have walked around the factory at spacex or tesla they've asked me to support dogecoin so i'm doing so because dogecoin i think has come down a lot it's down about

17:3380 90 percent or it's down a lot and that's the reason why you you came out and said that you still thought there was value there i said i support altcoin and i'm doing that can i ask you one last question is i noticed that you you're going to unleash a humanoid robot to be unveiled on september 30th i wonder if there's anything more you could tell us about that well i hope that we will have an interesting prototype to show people but we're a very talented team at tesla that i'm working with closely to have a a prototype humanoid robot ready by the end of september and i think we're we are tracking to that point so that and there'll be a few other

18:23exciting things that we talk about at the tesla ai day but i i really want to you know we have these sort of ai day events to just emphasize that tesla is a lot more than a car company and that we are in my view the the leading real world ai company that exists well you were you did you see at all the the drama about the the the at google

18:52where tweet where people at least one engineer thought that what was happening in terms of their ai machinery was closer to human thought than had been seen before and quite worry had a personality is that something that you think about at all and or you worry about i think i think we should be concerned about ai and and i've said for a long time that i think there should be ought to be an ai regulatory agency that oversees artificial intelligence for the public good and i think just as there's anything that for anything that where there is a risk to the public whether that's a the food drug administration or federal aviation administration federal

19:35communications commission whether it's a public risk or public good at stake there it's good to have sort of a government referee and a regulatory body and i think we should have that for ai and we don't currently and that would be my recommendation elon musk you've been incredibly kind with your time not least because i think it's three a.m and then in the in the morning in new york it's been a heroic performance thank you very much for talking to the qatar economic forum and talking to bloomberg thank you you're most welcome thanks for having me [Music] you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份