卡塔尔经济论坛的台上,主持人拿着一个具体数字问马斯克:选前你说 DOGE 能省下 2 万亿美元,现在 doge.gov 上写着 1700 亿,中间那一万八千多亿去哪了?
马斯克的回答是:“你这个问题的基本前提就是荒谬的。”
他反问主持人,是不是以为两万亿能在几个月里凭空变出来。主持人说我没这么以为,我只是问你目标还是不是两万亿。这段对话来回拉扯了四五个回合,最后马斯克给出的定性是,对面这位记者“被困在传统记者的 NPC 对话树里”,跟这样的人说话“像在跟一台电脑讲话”。
这场访谈值得读的地方,不在于马斯克给了什么漂亮答案,而在于他被追问时怎么处理压力,哪些地方松口,哪些地方硬顶,哪些地方直接把问题扔回去。下面按议题拆开讲。
从 2 万亿到 1700 亿,DOGE 的账本怎么算
先把数字摆清楚。马斯克选举前公开说,DOGE(政府效率部,Department of Government Efficiency)至少能砍掉 2 万亿美元联邦支出。论坛当天 doge.gov 上显示的累计节省是 1700 亿美元,他在同一场对话里另一次说法是 1600 亿。他还提到过每天省 40 亿美元这个量级。
主持人的算术很直接:40 亿一天,DOGE 撑到明年 7 月,加起来也到不了 2 万亿。
马斯克没否认这个算法。他换了个角度回答:DOGE 是顾问小组,不是政府。它不立法,不管司法,也不控制行政分支。能省多少,取决于国会和行政部门愿不愿意采纳建议。
“我们不是政府的独裁者,我们是顾问。到目前为止,作为一个顾问团队,我们干得非常出色。我不认为政府历史上任何一个顾问委员会做得比我们更好。”
这句话已经把 2 万亿这个承诺悄悄降级了。原来的表述是目标,现在的表述是上限,实际能到多少要看别人给不给面子。他说的三个分支“某种程度上反对这种规模的削减”,等于承认阻力来自体制内部。
他反复强调的一点是透明度:所有 DOGE 的动作都发在 doge.gov 和 X 上的 doge 账号。这个说法可以查证,也确实是他整套叙事的支点,把“我砍了什么”变成公开记录,让反对者自己去挑刺。
至于 2 万亿还是不是目标,整场对话他一次都没有正面说“是”。他只说在顾问这个定位下做得很好,随后把话题推向“砍浪费和欺诈本身是好事,这一点大家总能同意”。一个可验证的数字承诺,被换成了一个没人会反对的价值判断。
“把那些孩子指给我们看”
争议最大的一段是 USAID(美国国际开发署)。主持人转述比尔·盖茨的说法:削减对外援助可能让数百万人丧命。马斯克的回应分两层。
第一层是程序性的:USAID 的项目没有全部被砍,被认为哪怕有一点点用处的部分,都转到了国务院。并非删除,只是换了个主管部门。这个说法值得记下来,因为它和“全面关停”的流行叙事不一样。
第二层是实质性的,也是他真正想说的:
“他们说这笔钱要帮助儿童,要根除某种疾病。我们就说,好,请把这群孩子的情况告诉我们,想跟他们聊聊,了解他们到底面临什么问题。结果什么都拿不到。我们甚至说,能不能至少见几个孩子,他们在哪,如果他们有困难,我们想和他们以及他们的照护者谈谈。回应是零。因为我们发现的是大量的欺诈和贪腐。”
他这段话的落点很硬:你声称在救人,那就让我见到被救的人。见不到,我就认为钱没到人手上。这个举证要求很难反驳,尤其对在战乱地区或威权国家运作的援助项目,保护受助者隐私本来就是行业规范。
主持人随后拿出了最硬的一个案例。PEPFAR(总统防治艾滋病紧急救援计划)在过去二十年被公认拯救了 2600 万人。它被卷入了对外援助冻结,后来拿到有限豁免,但服务仍然中断。联合国艾滋病规划署的估算数字是,如果永久停止,到 2029 年将多出 400 万艾滋病相关死亡。2023 年已经有 63 万人死于艾滋病相关疾病。
马斯克的第一反应是:“艾滋病药物项目还在继续,所以你根本前提就是错的。”
主持人说不完全是,豁免是有限的,联合国艾滋病规划署明确说不是所有原来由 USAID 资助的服务都还在。马斯克追问:那具体哪些没在资助?
主持人提到了一个药:来那卡帕韦(lenacapavir),去年获批,被认为是对抗艾滋病多年来最大的突破之一,它的推广受到波及。
马斯克的回应是整场最有力的一句:“如果这是真的,虽然我怀疑,那我们会修好它。”
这句话有两面。一面是给了一个可执行的承诺:给我清单,我来改。另一面是把举证责任完全推给对方,“虽然我怀疑”等于先把对方的信息标成可疑,再答应处理。对于被指出的具体漏洞,他既没有承认,也没有否认,只把它变成一张待核实工单。
这场交锋里,双方其实都在做同一件事:要对方拿数据。主持人拿的是联合国机构的估算,马斯克要的是能见到的具体受助者。两套证据标准不一样,所以谁也说服不了谁。
“我未来会少花很多钱”
政治捐款的问题,马斯克的回答干脆得反常。上一轮美国大选他花的钱远超三年前在同一场合的预期,主持人问中期选举还打不打算这个量级。
“在政治支出上,我未来会大幅减少。我觉得我已经做得够多了。”
主持人追问是不是因为反噬。他没接这个词,只说:如果将来看到理由,我会花;目前看不到理由。
“我已经做得够多了”这句话,从一个刚刚被问及品牌受损、销量下滑、展厅被开枪的人嘴里说出来,含义不太一样。它可以是“任务完成”,也可以是“代价我付过了”。他没解释是哪一种。
后面聊到普京。主持人问多久通话一次。马斯克说:“我不跟普京通话。” 主持人追问从来没通过?他说大概五年前有过一次视频通话,仅此而已。
主持人提到他在西点军校演讲里说过“我向普京发起挑战”,还提到《华尔街日报》报道过他的通话。马斯克的反应是反问:“这世上有比《华尔街日报》更烂的出版物吗?” 他说这份报纸是全世界最烂的报纸,一份名字里带“华尔街”的报纸本该支持资本主义,但它不是,所以他对它的评价低到不能再低。
这里有个细节需要还原清楚。他确实公开挑战过普京单挑,但那是在 X 上发的一条帖子,不是私下通话。他自己把两件事分开了:帖子是帖子,通话是通话。主持人也接受了这个澄清。
处理方式值得琢磨:他把“你是否与外国领导人私下沟通”这个具体问题,迅速转成“这家媒体可不可信”的元问题。防守动作很有效,代价是原问题失去了追问的基础。
那张贴纸,和他承认的“左侧流失”
特斯拉的部分是整场访谈里马斯克最不设防的一段。
他自己先定了调:欧洲是我们最弱的市场,其他所有地方都很强。 不谈销量预期,他直接指向市值:重回一万亿美元以上,市场已经给出了判断。主持人提醒他,我问的是销量不是股价,他也没退。
主持人抛出了那个著名的车主贴纸:“我在知道马斯克疯了之前买的这辆车。” 特斯拉曾经有极强的向往感,人们把自己和它绑在一起,因为它站在气候危机的最前线。现在这个位置变了。
马斯克的回答没有辩护,直接承认:
“是的,我们可能在左侧失去了一些销量,但在右侧赢了回来。目前的销量数字是强劲的,我们在需求上没有问题。”
这句话是对整个品牌争议最诚实的总结。他没说那些贴纸车主误解了我,也没说这件事不影响。他描述的是客户结构发生了位移:走了一批,来了一批。对消费品公司而言,这种置换真实发生着,代价是品牌含义被重写了。
他顺手给了个看数据的建议:如果你想要最好的内幕信息,去看股价,市场分析师有那个。 这话从一个做实业的人嘴里说出来相当反常识,也符合他一贯的做法:用资本市场当背书,绕开经营层面的追问。
五年之后还在不在,和那位“扮演法官的维权人士”
主持人问,五年后你还是不是特斯拉 CEO。
马斯克说:“是,毫无疑问。除非我死了。”
这个回答让全场笑了,也让后面的话有了着力点。主持人顺势问:那薪酬对你这个决定有没有影响?
他没有直接说没有。他说这个话题不适合在这个场合讨论,然后给了个原则:如果做出了惊人的事,报酬应该匹配那件惊人的事。接着他把矛头对准特拉华州那位两次否决他 560 亿美元薪酬包的法官:
“不是法官。是一个在万圣节服装里扮演法官的维权人士。”
主持人问他知不知道按当前期权价值算,这个包已经接近 1000 亿美元。他说他知道,并且相信那位“扮演法官的人”做什么都不会影响未来的薪酬安排。
真正重要的信息在后面。主持人逼问:你未来五年对特斯拉的承诺,是不是完全和钱无关?
马斯克说:“不是无关的。” 然后立刻澄清他要的不是钱:
“我要的是足够的投票控制权,让我不会被维权投资者赶走。这一点我公开说过很多次。它不是钱的事,是对公司未来有合理控制权的事,尤其当我们正在造几百万、甚至可能几十亿个人形机器人的时候。我不能坐在那儿,因为政治原因被一群维权人士踢出去。那不可接受。”
这段话把薪酬争议的真正争点说清楚了。560 亿或 1000 亿只是表象,底层是股权结构里的表决权比例。人形机器人这条产品线是他给出这个诉求的理由:如果 Optimus 真的量产到千万级,特斯拉就从一个汽车公司变成一个劳动力供应公司,那个体量的公司由谁控制,已经超出财务范畴。
子弹、纵火,和一个他自己造的词
主持人问了一个很直接的问题:过去几个月发生在特斯拉身上的事,你往心里去了吗?
马斯克说:“去了。”
然后主持人问,这有没有让你对参与政治这件事产生过一丝后悔,或者重新考虑。
他的回答里有一个自创的说法:
“我做了该做的事。然后是那场暴力的抗体反应。我从来没对任何人施暴,但我的公司遭到了大规模暴力,我本人遭到了大规模暴力威胁。这些人是谁?他们为什么要这么做?他们能错到什么程度?他们站在历史的错误一边。去损坏一个无辜者的车,去威胁要杀我,这些人到底怎么了?我没有伤害过任何人。”
“抗体反应”这个词用得很讲究。他把攻击描述成一种自动的、非理性的生理排斥,而非有理由的政治反对。这套框架一旦成立,讨论就跳到“他们为什么这么不理性”,而不是“他们反对的是什么”。
他明确说了后续:往展厅里打子弹、烧车,这些人会进监狱;资助和组织他们的人也会进监狱。
主持人做了一个必要的区分:欧洲有很多人是因为政治立场转向反对特斯拉的,其中绝大多数人不会诉诸暴力,他们只是不认同你说的或做的事。
马斯克的回应回到了边界问题:反对政治观点当然没问题,但诉诸暴力、吊假人、发死亡威胁不行。 他说这在任何意义、任何形式上都无法辩护,而一些传统媒体还在试图为它辩护,这不可接受,“他们应该感到羞耻”。
这段对话的价值在于划出了一条线。线的一边是消费者用钱包投票,另一边是刑事犯罪,马斯克把两者都归到了“反噬”这个词下,但只对后者要求追责。他没说的是,前者的规模远大于后者,而它对公司的影响也更持久。
90% 的入轨质量,和一门不做的生意
主持人问 SpaceX 会不会做武器化的无人机,马斯克先笑了,说“你确实问了很有意思的问题,而且是没法回答的那种”。然后他给了个定义式的澄清:SpaceX 不造无人机,SpaceX 造火箭、卫星和互联网终端。
接着是一组硬数据,这场访谈里信息密度最高的部分:
- 今年全球入轨质量中,SpaceX 大约占 90%
- 中国占剩下的约一半,也就是 5%
- 世界其他地区,包括美国其余部分,加起来约 5%
- 也就是说,SpaceX 一家的发射量相当于世界其他所有国家总和的十倍,或中国的二十倍
- 在轨活跃卫星中,大约 80% 属于 SpaceX
- 星链(Starlink)已在约 130 个国家获得批准
他还特意补了一句,中国做得“非常令人印象深刻”。这句话在这种场合说,不是客套,是把对手的位置标定清楚:我赢不是靠别人不行。
关于星链的意义,他给了个很朴素的论证:把人从贫困里拉出来,最有效的一件事是给他一个互联网连接。 有了连接,可以免费学到任何东西,也可以把商品和服务卖到全球市场。知识和交易能力一旦具备,生活水平就会大幅改善。他还当场点了一句,这次访谈的网络连接走的就是星链。
至于武器生意,他的表述很清楚:“我不认为 SpaceX 会进入武器业务,那不在我们的志向里。经常有人来找我们做武器项目,我们拒绝了。”
这里要区分两件事。星链在乌克兰前线发挥了关键作用,这是事实,也是争议的来源:一套民用通信系统在战争中的角色,边界在哪里。马斯克没有展开这个矛盾,他谈的是公司业务范围,不涉及产品在地缘政治中的实际用途。
星链上市卡在了一类诉讼上
星链会不会独立上市?马斯克的答案是“未来某个时候有可能”,然后立刻补上:“我不着急。”
不着急的原因他讲得很细,也很有信息量。上市能融更多钱,代价是上市公司的管理开销,以及“不可避免的一堆非常烦人的诉讼”。他把矛头指向美国的股东派生诉讼制度:
“原告律师事务所并不代表股东,却能假装代表股东,找一个只持有几股股票的傀儡原告,对公司发起一场巨额诉讼。最讽刺的是,即使他们声称代表的那个群体投票说不要这场诉讼,诉讼还是会继续。如果一个群体反对,它怎么还能叫代表这个群体的集体诉讼?这是美国一个荒谬的状况,急需改革。”
他还给了一个立法层面的判断:这需要国会立法,而立法需要 60 票,民主党会投反对票,因为在他看来,原告律师团体是民主党的第二大金主。联邦层面走不通,州层面可以。德州最近通过了一项法律,要求至少 1/33 的股东,也就是 3%,同意才能组成这样的股东集体。
这段话透露的信息比“要不要 IPO”更重要。一家公司要不要上市,在这个案例里取决于一个程序法问题:小股东发起滥诉的成本有多低。这类制度性摩擦不出现在产品发布会上,但它实实在在影响资本决策。
砍掉雨林去做木材生意
OpenAI 的诉讼,马斯克确认会继续打。
他给出的理由里有一段很形象的比喻:
“我起的名字叫 OpenAI,开源,非营利,头大约 5000 万美元是我出的。它的定位就是非营利的开源公司。现在他们为了自己的财务利益,要把它改成一个闭源的营利公司。这就好比你出资办了一个保护亚马逊雨林的非营利组织,结果它变成了一家木材公司,把森林砍了,把木头卖了。你会说,等一下,我当初出的钱不是干这个的。”
主持人提到 OpenAI 后来对公司结构做了一些调整,部分撤回了重组计划。马斯克的回应只有一句:“那只是他们对媒体说的。”
这段对话没有太多新信息,但它确认了一件事:诉讼不会因为对方的结构性让步而撤。争点已经从“你怎么改结构”变成“你当初的承诺算不算数”。
裁判的比喻:老行业裁判比球员多,AI 场上一个裁判都没有
三年前在同一场合,马斯克说过美国缺一个联邦层面的 AI 监管机构,类似 FDA 或 FAA。现在他自己在政府里推削减监管,主持人问他立场变了没有。
他说没变,然后用了一个贯穿整段访谈的比喻:
“监管机构就像球场上的裁判。场上应该有几个裁判,但不能多到你一踢球就撞上裁判。美国很多领域的监管负担已经长到裁判比球员还多。新领域像人工智能是监管不足,事实上根本一个裁判都没有;而汽车、航空、食品药物这些老行业是监管过度。”
他给这套累积机制做了解释,这段值得单独看,因为它是一条关于制度如何膨胀的一般性观察:长期繁荣、没有生存性战争的年代,缺少一个清理无用法律和法规的机制。 立法者总要立法,监管者总要监管,于是每年往上堆,堆到最后什么都是非法的。
他举了一个自己撞上的例子。拜登时期,司法部起诉 SpaceX 不雇用难民身份申请者。问题是,按 ITAR(国际武器贸易条例),SpaceX 雇用任何非美国永久居民本身就违法,理由是这些人可能把先进的火箭技术带回母国。
“所以我们同时处在这样一种处境:雇用他们违法,不雇用他们也违法。做也完蛋,不做也完蛋。”
这个例子的说服力很强,因为它不需要立场就能理解:两条规则互斥,企业无论怎么选都违规,而执法机关选择了其中一条来起诉。这类案例比任何抽象的“放松监管”口号都有效。
利益冲突那一问,他没有正面接
主持人问了一个结构性的问题:你通过 SpaceX 手握数十亿美元联邦合同,现在又通过 DOGE 获得了整个联邦政府内部的视野,这算不算利益冲突?
马斯克的回答分三点。第一,历史上有很多顾问有经济利益,他只是顾问,没有正式权力,总统可以选择听或不听。第二,如果他的公司拿到任何一笔被外界认为不正当的合同,那会是头条新闻,就算他不提,竞争对手也会提。第三,DOGE 的所有动作都公开在网站上,完全透明,他没见过哪怕一个关于利益冲突的指控。
主持人换了个角度:DOGE 进入每一个联邦部门,意味着你和你的团队能看到波音、蓝色起源(Blue Origin)、火箭实验室(Rocket Lab)这些竞争对手与政府的关系。
马斯克的回答是流程性的:他们只审查这个机构有没有已经失去相关性的部门,以及正在授予的合同是不是物有所值,“说实话这个门槛并不高”。如果没有价值,就向部长提建议,部长可以选择执行或不执行,执行的动作发在网站上。
这里有个逻辑需要读者自己补上。“公开”和“没有利益冲突”是两件事。 公开能防止暗箱操作,却消除不了结构性的位置优势:知道对手的合同细节,和不知道,是不一样的。马斯克没有回应这一层,他把问题重新定义成了“有没有违规操作”。
随后是南非的问题。彭博当天报道,南非政府正在绕开黑人持股的规定,以便让星链落地,时间点就在拉马福萨(Cyril Ramaphosa)访问白宫前夕。主持人问这算不算利益冲突。
马斯克的回应是把问题整个翻过来:
“当然不算。首先你该问的是,南非为什么会有种族主义的法律?这才是第一个问题,这才是你该攻击的。南非有种族主义法律是不正当的。曼德拉是个伟大的人,他主张的是所有种族在南非享有平等地位。正确的事不是用一套种族主义法律替换另一套种族主义法律。现在南非有 140 条法律,如果你是黑人南非人就有强烈的优待,否则没有。所以我处在一个荒谬的处境:我出生在南非,却因为不是黑人拿不到星链的运营牌照。”
主持人追问这看起来是否合理,马斯克拒绝回答,说“这不是该我回答的问题”,反过来要求主持人回答。双方在这里僵住了,主持人说自己只是在提问,马斯克说“不,你回答我的”。来回几轮之后,主持人放弃,转回 DOGE 的节省数字。
这段是整场访谈控制得最差的部分。张力真实存在:南非的平权法案(BBBEE)是为了纠正种族隔离留下的经济结构,执行二十多年后,确实出现了以种族划线分配经营权的具体摩擦。马斯克把这个摩擦描述成“种族主义法律”,这个框架有争议,但他给出的那个具体处境,出生地与实际限制对不上,确实是他个人的真实经验。
从访谈技巧角度看,这次防守成功了:一个关于“你是不是受益于特殊安排”的问题,被转成“你是不是该先谴责那些法律”。主持人没能把话题拉回来。
最后被 Grok 总结的一年
主持人用了一个设计过的收尾:他问 Grok,马斯克最大的挑战是什么,Grok 的回答是“在财务、监管和公关危机中同时管理多家高风险企业的压力”。然后他问马斯克认不认这个描述,以及这是不是他人生中的关键一年。
马斯克说,每一年都挺关键,今年也一样。然后他列了清单,这份清单是整场访谈里信息最实在的部分:
- 星舰(Starship)实现完全复用。 助推器和飞船都要被筷子夹住回收,这将是人类历史上第一枚完全可复用的轨道火箭。他把这件事定性为“让生命成为多行星物种的必要突破”,也是成为太空文明的前提。
- Neuralink 已帮助五名患者恢复能力。 用的是 Telepathy 植入体,患者可以只靠想就能控制电脑。
- 首例恢复视力的患者。 Blindsight 植入体,时间点在年底或明年初。他还提了一句,第一例患者可能在阿联酋,因为当地有合作方和克利夫兰诊所。
- AI 那边接近 AGI。 他的原话是“接近你可能会称作 AGI 或数字超级智能的东西”,并且正在看到数字超级智能的爆发。
- 特斯拉在奥斯汀下个月启动无监督自动驾驶。 车里没有人。
他给自己最后的定位是:“首先,我是个技术专家。”
这句话可以看作整场访谈的自我总结。前面一个多小时谈的都是援助预算、政治捐款、薪酬包、诉讼、监管、种族法案,那些是他被迫应战的部分。星舰、脑机接口、AGI、无人驾驶,才是他愿意主动展开的部分。两套话题的比例,某种程度上说明了这一年他的时间是怎么分配的。
对话里真正有价值的三件事
第一,2 万亿这个数字基本已经作废。 他没有撤回,但把它变成了一个取决于国会配合度的条件式目标。判断 DOGE 的实际成效,看 doge.gov 上的累计数字比听表态可靠。
第二,对外援助的争论卡在证据标准上。 一方要的是统计层面的死亡估算,一方要的是能见到面的具体受助者。马斯克给了个可执行的开口:“没被资助的清单给我,我马上修。” 这句话可以被当真,也可以被检验。
第三,特斯拉的品牌争议,他自己承认了客户结构在换手。 左侧流失,右侧补回。他没打算掩饰这件事。判断长期影响,看的是置换之后的人群是否复购,而不是某一季的销量。
至于更远的东西,星舰复用、Blindsight 首例、奥斯汀无人驾驶、AGI 的临界点,这几个时间点都落在未来十二个月内,都属于可以被验证或被证伪的承诺。
- 想跟踪 DOGE 的真实进展,别记 2 万亿这个数,直接看 doge.gov 的累计节省曲线,以及国会是否真的采纳了具体建议。建议和采纳之间那道缝,才是关键。
- 想判断对外援助争议,去找联合国艾滋病规划署列出的“未恢复资助服务清单”,对照马斯克说的“给我清单我马上修”,看三个月内有没有实际动作。有动作,说明这套机制有效;没动作,说明“我怀疑”才是真实态度。
- 想验证特斯拉的品牌置换,别看月度交付量,看两个指标:欧洲市场的订单等待周期,以及二手车保值率。左侧客户走了、右侧客户进来,如果新客户不复购,等待周期会持续缩短。
- 想跟技术节点,把四个日期记在日历上:星舰首次助推器加飞船双回收、Blindsight 首例患者植入、奥斯汀无监督自动驾驶上线、以及你自己对 AGI 的判断标准。前三个是硬事件,第四个需要你提前想清楚判断依据,否则等它来了你只会跟着舆论走。
- 读这类访谈时,把“他回答了什么”和“他避开了什么”分开记。这场里被避开的有三个:2 万亿还算不算目标、DOGE 的知情权是否构成结构性优势、以及削减援助的具体受影响清单。避开的地方,往往比回答的地方信息量大。
0:00millions of lives. yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what we found with USAD cuts and by the way they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that we found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the State Department. So not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the State Department.
0:24but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we've when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing.
0:49We we don't they don't even try to prevent show come up with a with a with a show often meaning like it's sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they if they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and then we get nothing as a response because it's what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft let me put this example very little of it actually gets to the kids if anything at Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data. The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS
1:32treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPAR which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze. Then there was a limited waiver. Its services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost.
2:09I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example? Elon not in its entirety not in its entirety. the the program there's a limited waiver and UN aids have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing so that's that's why that's why I put that example to you okay well which ones aren't being funded I'll fix it right now for okay well actually they're all on the UN UN a's website so you'll be able to see them but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the
2:58roll out of a drug called Glenn Capavir which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure UNA you and Aids would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes. Well well if if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is then we'll fix it. Okay fine.
3:19so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections?
3:47I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future. And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. What about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
4:22I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. That's the only thing I speak to President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. Believe the legacy. I speak Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red.
4:55Is is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal? I wouldn't use that to to line up my cage for choreographics. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and if you know if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. U, but it isn't. So I I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them which you are and and
5:34for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned me challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single combat over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you. That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you've said you have rather than a video. Okay.
6:05Legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said the strain of managing multiple highstake ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis. And I wondered whether you recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life.
6:35Well, every year has been somewhat pivotal and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interesting things that hopefully are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we catch both the booster and the ship which will be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetary and ultimately become a space fairing civilization.
7:10we've got Neurolink which is now helped five patients res restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight with our blind sight implant which is either end of the year or early next. in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the I I think on the AI front we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence.
7:58I think we'll see we we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got at Tesla the we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy, basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So, it's it's a big year for sure. many other things on the in the in the works, too. Okay. I'm I'm technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Qatar Economic Forum. Thank you.
8:31Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point. we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap. So clearly the market is aware of the situation. So it's it's already turned around, but sales still down compared to this time last year.
9:03In Europe. In Europe. Okay. And yes, but but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions. Does that mean that you're not going to be able Yes. Does that mean European is quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing, okay, let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. It saw it, they saw it being at the forefront of the climate crisis. And now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, "I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy." And there are also people who are buying
9:42it because Elon's crazy or however they may view it. so yes, we've lost some sales perhaps on the left, but we've gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what and I mean you can just look at the stock price the the if you want the best inside information the stock market analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra rather than sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh
10:21sh sh sh sh sh sh share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in 5 years time? Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no, I might die. Okay, short of that. I'm dead. So there's a slight amount of Does does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision?
10:58well that's not really a subject subject discussion in this forum. the I think obviously there should be compensation for if there's something incredible is done that compensation should match the that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
11:28This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. The activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay. That that's your characterization.
11:50I think the val on the current value of stock options. I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay.
12:17No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. a sufficient voting control such that I cannot be oustered by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of my alleged pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company.
12:44Especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there u and wanting to get tossed out by for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable. That's all that matters. Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Move on.
13:03Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political endeavors [Applause] because it is I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet, massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
14:02To go and damage some po innocent person's car. to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So, something needs to be done about them and a number of them are going to prison and they deserve it. More will. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think Yeah. bullets into showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah.
14:37Those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry. But wouldn't you come and you wouldn't wouldn't [Applause] you but wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way.
15:02They just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically. Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay. you know that's absurd. that is
15:25in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. and and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them. Let's talk about your other companies then in other business areas. SpaceX, I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point military academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
16:05[Laughter] You certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is is the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position in space launch. So of of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%.
16:43China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world including the rest of the US will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
17:09maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth global connectivity throughout the world. In fact, this connection is on the SpaceX connection. So, I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or where it's very expensive. And I think the single biggest thing you can do to look to people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection. because once you have the internet connection, you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and
17:46services to the global market. and once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good in the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with it. I I I don't currently antic SpaceX getting into the weapons business. that's certainly that's not an aspiration.
18:26We're we're frequent we're frequently asked to do to do weapons programs, but we have just declined. Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all? it's possible that Starlink may go public at some point in the future and what would be the what would be the time frame?
18:55What kind of time frame you consider? I mean, no rush. No, I'm in no rush to your public. the the you know public is I guess a way to you know potentially make more money but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably a whole bunch of lawsuits which are very annoying.
19:16so really something needs to be done about the shareholder shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a public plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. And the irony being that extreme irony that even if the class they purport to represent were to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit would still continue. So how can it be a a class action representing a class if the class went against it? And that's the bizarre situation we've got in the US. It needs a dire need of reform and and as as
19:59anyone who's run a public company experienced this, it's an absurd situation that needs to change. Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it? You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starlink IPO?
20:16Well, it would need a law to be passed. the the trouble being that you would need 60 Senator Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it. the the the the the plaintiff's bar is I believe the second largest contributor to the Democratic party. That's the that's the issue. At the state level, this can be solved. And and I should say Texas recently passed a law which at this at least the state level made made the election lawsuits much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class of shareholders 3%.
21:00This is a this will be will be really help with privilege lawsuits. Okay. let's talk about AI which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes the development of generative AI since you last spoke to this forum 3 years ago. You're in this space of course with Grock which almost everyone will know. You co-founded Open AI and then left and you've obviously got a legal battle with Open AI and Sam Orman. I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the president last week with Samman in the same place at the same time was in the in the neighborhood. Okay. So
21:48does does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against open AI? Yes. But so look, I came I came up with the name OpenAI as an open-source and as a nonprofit and I funded a AI OpenAI for the first roughly $50 million. and it was intended to be a nonprofit open-source company and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. So, this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I
22:37funded. That's opening eye." They've made some changes to their corporate structure, though, haven't they, since in recognition of what of what you've said. And no, that's just what they told the media. Okay. part they have part they have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court, of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Mikkelweight, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you
23:23really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
23:45Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so in many in most perhaps
24:04fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary
24:34laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you'll get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a of a truly absurd situation. under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for
25:04not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers. And the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question was specifically about a regulator for
25:46AI, which you said 3 years ago was needed. And you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What what No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a few a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive so aerospace you know
26:22the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no regulator at all. So, so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying, which I think is just basic common sense, that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees in the field. You don't want to have an army of referees. you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or any given arena, industrial arena to ensure help that public safety is taken care of. but you don't have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like I said,
27:06it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd. but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good. Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insidider's knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a
27:43conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in throughout history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests. and I'm simply an adviser. I don't have formal power. and that's it. the president can choose to accept my advice or not. And that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded
28:21improperly it would immediately be front page news to say the least. and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then clearly it's not conflict to interest. the yeah there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who would like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA Blue Origin Rocket Lab and because Doge is in every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies affairs. and those companies relationships with the federal
29:06government. No do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant. and and then are the contracts that that that are being awarded good value for money? In fact, frankly, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract? and if there's if there isn't then we make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions and that's it. And then any action that that that is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at doge handle on the Xplatform. So it's it's complete transparency.
29:56and I have not seen any case where to the best of my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's a and what about the international dimension now? let's think about Starlink. Starink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules
30:37on black ownership in order to allow Starink and that is being done on the eve of the visit that President Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest? No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa?
30:55That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela who was a great man proposed was that all all races should be on equal footing in South Africa. That's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws which is utterly wrong and improv. so the that's that's the deal that all races should be treated equally. and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are now 140 laws in South Africa that give u that basically give give strong preference to to if if you're a black South African and
31:37not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but cannot get a license to operate in Starink because I'm not black. Well, it looks like that's about its looks like you looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question. Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa and it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you.
32:09Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. your question yes or no laws yet. Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work zone and the amount of savings. I do like racist laws. This is not for me to answer. Come on now. You wouldn't be trying to dodge a question. You have to ask question. No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to.
32:42I want to ask you about the total I can't believe it. That's not good. I want to ask you about the total amount. I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least 2 trillion. The number currently on doge.gov is $170 billion. That's a big
33:04change. What happened to the 2 trillion? Would you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? because those are supposed to run till next July. I mean, your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day, you know, within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved? No, I'm not at all.
33:24I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is it still your given the amount of time? Have we not made good progress given the amount of time? That's exactly what I'm asking. So, is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to 2 trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is a function of whether the government and this includes Congress is willing to take our advice. we are not the dictators of the government, we are the advisers and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. Doge team has done incredible work. but the the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from Congress and from the executive
34:15branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the advisers. but thus far for advisers we've the George team to their credit has made incredible progress. You've talked about4 billion dollar a day being saved, but that that that won't get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to 2 trillion over the lifetime of Doge.
34:52I'm sorry. The 4 billion the 4 billion a day if Doge is going to run till next July is not going to get you to$2 trillion. But you still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There's there's there's there there's what doge I mean I feel you're somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional ver journalist. So it's difficult to when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the dialogue tree of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer.
35:27so Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups of the government. now we we we don't we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot we cannot take action beyond that because we are not u some sort of imperial dictator of the government.
36:07There are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. but nonetheless let's let's let's not criticize whether those 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.
36:38So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him my I know you you said that already. I wondered also and I'm just where does who does Bill Gates think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he is he for a quote of Jeffrey Epste?
37:06Okay. Well, he's he's he said he regrets those and he's spent he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is have you looked at the data to check if he might be of lives? yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what we found with USA ID cuts and by the way they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that we found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the state department. So they've not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the state department.
37:49but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we've when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing.
38:13We we don't we don't even try to prevent show come up with a with a with a show often meaning like there sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they if they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and then we get something as a response because it's what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft let me put this example very little of it actually gets to the kids if anything at Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data. The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS
38:56treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPAR which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze then there was a limited waiver. Its services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So
39:20if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost. I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example? Noted it Elon not in its entirety is false. Not in its entirety. the the pro there's a limited waiver and UN aids have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing. So that's that's why that's why I put that example to you. Okay.
40:09Well, which ones aren't being funded? I'll fix it right now. For Okay. Well, actually they're all on the UN UN AIDS website, so you'll be able to see them, but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the roll out of a drug called Glenna Capavir which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure you and AIDS would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes. Well, if if if in fact this is true, which I doubt it is, then we'll fix it. Okay, fine.
40:44so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections?
41:12I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future. And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. And what about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
41:47I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. Okay. That's the only President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. Believe the legacy. Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red. Is is is there a worst publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal?
42:24I wouldn't use that to to line up my cage for paragraphings. that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and you know, if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. but it isn't. So, I I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them which you are and and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned
43:05me challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single combat over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you. That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you've said you have rather than a video. Okay.
43:29All legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said, "The strain of managing multiple highstakes ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis." And I wondered whether you recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life.
44:00Well, every year has been somewhat pivotal and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interest that hopefully are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we we catch both the booster and the ship which will be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetarian ultimately become a space fairing civilization.
44:38we've got Neurolink which is now helped five patients res restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight with our blind sight implant which is either end of the year or early next. in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the
45:14I I think we're running on the AI front, we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence. I think we'll see we we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got at Tesla the we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy, basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So it's it's a big year for sure.
45:42many other things on the in the in the works too. Okay. I'm I'm a technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Qatar Economic Forum. Thank you. Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point. we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock
46:17market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap so clearly the market is aware of the situation so it's it's already turned around but sales still down compared to this time last year in Europe in Europe okay and yes but but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
46:40Does that mean that you're not going to be able Does that mean European is quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing, okay, let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. it saw it they saw it as being at the forefront of the climate crisis and now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy and that there also people who are buying it because Elon's crazy or
47:13however they may view it. so yes we've lost some sales perhaps on the left but we've gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what do And and I mean you you can just look at the stock price the the if you want to invest in information the stock market
47:35analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra rather than share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in 5 years time?
48:01Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no, I might die. Okay. Short of that. I can't see you if I'm dead. So, there's a slight amount of Does does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision? well that's not really a subject subject for discussion in this forum.
48:31the I think obviously there should be conversation for if there's something incredible is done that compensation should match that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
48:56This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. the activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay, that that's your characterization.
49:17I think the val on the current value of stock options I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion dollars. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay.
49:45No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. sufficient voting control such that I cannot be ousted by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of mileage pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there u and wanting to get tossed out by for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable.
50:24That's all that matters. Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Let's move on. Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political
50:54[Applause] endeavors? Because it. I mean, I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction. and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet, massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
51:29To go and damage some po innocent person's car, to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So, something needs to be done about them, and a number of them are going to prison, and they deserve it. More will. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think yeah, putting bullets into showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah, those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry. But wouldn't you come and read you wouldn't wouldn't you
52:13[Applause] but wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way. They just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically. Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay.
52:44you know that's absurd. that is in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. And and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them. Let's talk about your other companies then and other business areas. SpaceX, I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point Military Academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
53:29[Laughter] you certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is it's the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites, and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position in space launch.
53:59So of of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%. China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world, including the rest of the US, will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
54:33maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth level connectivity throughout the world. In fact this connection is on the SpaceX connection. So I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or where it's very expensive and I think the single biggest thing you can do to lift people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection because once you have the internet connection you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and services to the
55:10global market and once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good and the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with I I I don't currently anticate SpaceX getting into the weapons business.
55:48that's certainly that's not an aspiration. We're frequent we're frequently asked to do to do weapons programs, but we have just declined. Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all? it's possible that Starlink may go public at some point in the future and what would be the what would be the time frame?
56:19What kind of time frame you consider? No, I mean no rush. No, I'm in no rush to your public. the the you know public is I guess a way to you know potentially make more money but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably a whole bunch of lawsuits which are very annoying.
56:40so really something needs to be done about the shareholder shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a public plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. And the irony being that extreme irony that even if the class they purport to represent were to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit would still continue. So how can it be a a class action representing a class if the class went against it? And that's the bizarre situation we've got in the US. It needs it's a dire need of reform and and as as
57:23anyone who's run a public company experienced this, it's an absurd situation that needs to change. Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it? You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starlink IPO?
57:40Well, it would it would need a law to be passed. the the trouble being that you need 60 Senator Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it. the the the the the plaintiff's bar is I believe the second largest contributor to the Democratic party. That's the that's the issue. At the state level, this can be solved. And and I should say Texas recently passed a law which at this at least the state level made made the election lawsuits much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class of shareholders 3%.
58:24This is a this will be will be really help with privilege lawsuits. Okay. let's talk about AI which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes the development of generative AI since you last spoke to this forum 3 years ago. You're in this space of course with Grock which almost everyone will know. You co-founded Open AI and then left and you've obviously got a legal battle with Open AI and Sam Orman. I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the president last week with Sam in the same place at the same time was in the in the neighborhood.
59:13Okay. So does does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against open AI? Yes. so I came I came up with the name OpenAI as an open-source and as a nonprofit and I funded a AI open for the first roughly $50 million and it was intended to be a nonprofit open-source company and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. So, this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I
1:00:03funded. That's opening eye." They've made some changes to their corporate structure though, haven't they, since in recognition of what of what you've said. And no, that's just what they told the media. Okay. part they have part they have partly warped back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court, of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Likwway, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you
1:00:49really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
1:01:11Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you can think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so in many in most perhaps
1:01:31fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary
1:02:00laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you will get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a of a truly absurd situation. under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for
1:02:30not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers and the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question was specifically about a regulator for
1:03:12AI, which you said 3 years ago was needed. And you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What what No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive so aerospace you know
1:03:48the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no regulator at all. So so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying, which I think is just basic common sense, that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees on the field. You don't want to have an army of referees. you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or any given arena, industrial arena to ensure help that public safety is taken care of. but you don't have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like like I
1:04:32said, it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd. but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good. Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insider's knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a
1:05:09conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in throughout history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests. and I am simply an adviser. I don't have formal power.
1:05:31and that's it. the president can choose to accept my advice or not and that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that you know any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded improperly it would immediately be front page news to say the least and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then clearly is not conflict of interest. the yeah there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who would like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA Blue Origin Rocket Lab and because Doge is in
1:06:17every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies affairs. and those companies relationships with the federal government. No, all we do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant. and and are the contracts that that are being awarded good value for money? In fact, frankly, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract? and if there's if there isn't then we make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions
1:07:05and that's it. And then any action that that that is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at doge handle on the X platform. So it's it's complete transparency. and I've not seen any case where to the best of my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's it. And what about the international dimension now? let's think about Starlink.
1:07:36Starlink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules on black ownership in order to allow Starink and that is being done on the eve of the visit that President Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest?
1:08:13No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa? That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela who was a great man proposed was that all all races should be on an equal footing in South Africa. That's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws which is utterly wrong and improv. so the that's the that's the deal that all races should be treated equally and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are
1:08:49now 140 laws in South Africa that give u that basically give give strong preference to to if if you're a black South African and not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but cannot get a license to operate in Starink because I'm not black. Well, it looks like that's about its looks like right looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question. Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa and it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you.
1:09:32Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. is your question. Yes or no? Yes or no? Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work though. The amount of savings. I do like racist laws. This is not for me to answer. Come on.
1:09:53Now, you wouldn't be trying to dodge a question. You have to ask question. No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to. I want to ask you about the total I can't believe it. That's not good. I want to ask you about the total amount.
1:10:11I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least 2 trillion. The number currently on doge.gov is $170 billion. That's a big change. What happened to the 2 trillion? Would you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? because those are supposed to run till next July. I mean, your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day you know within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved? No, I'm not at all.
1:10:47I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is it still your aim to get the amount of time? Have we not made good progress given the amount of time? That's exactly what I'm asking. So, is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to 2 trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is a function of whether the government and this includes Congress is willing to take our advice. we are not the dictators of the government, we are the advisers and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. Doge team has done incredible work. but the the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from
1:11:33Congress and from the executive branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the advisers. but thus far for advisers we've the George team to their credit has made incredible progress. You've talked about $4 billion a day being saved, but that that that won't
1:12:02get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to 2 trillion over the lifetime of Doge. I'm sorry. The 4 billion the 4 billion a day if Doge is going to run till next July is not going to get you to$2 trillion.
1:12:27But you still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There's there's there's there there's what doge I mean I feel you're somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional ver journalist. So it's difficult to when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the dialogue tree of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer.
1:12:50so Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups for the government. now we we we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot
1:13:25we cannot take action beyond that because we are not u some sort of imperial dictator of the government. There are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. but nonetheless let's let's let's not criticize whether those 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.
1:14:01So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him. I know you you said that already. I wondered also and I'm just who does who does Bill Gates think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he is he for a quote of Jeffrey Epste? Okay.
1:14:33Well, he's he's he said he regrets those and he's spent he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is, have you looked at the data to check if he might be right that the cuts to USAD might cost millions of lives?
1:14:57yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what we found with USAD cuts, and by the way, they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that were found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the State Department. They've not they've not been deleted. They've been transferred to the State Department.
1:15:18but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing. We we don't we don't even try to prevent show come up with a with a with a show often meaning like it's sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they if they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and then we get
1:16:00something as a response because it's that what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft. Okay, let me let me put this example to you. Very little actually gets to the kids if anything at all. Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data. The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPA which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze then there was a limited waiver that services are disrupted and UN aid
1:16:42says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost.
1:17:04I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example? Not in Elon. Not in its entirety. Not in its entirety. the the program there's a limited waiver and UN aids have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing so that's that's why that's why I put that example to you okay well which ones aren't being funded I'll fix it right now for okay well actually they're all on the UN UN a's website so you'll be able to see them but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the
1:17:53roll out of a drug called glenna capa which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure UNA you would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes. Well if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is then we'll fix it. Okay fine.
1:18:14so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections?
1:18:42I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future. And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. And what about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
1:19:17I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video calling with him once about 5 years ago. That's the only President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. I believe the legacy. I speak Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red.
1:19:50If is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal? I wouldn't use that to to line up my cage for paragraphs. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and you know, if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. U, but it isn't. So, I I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them, which you are, and
1:20:28and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned me challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single combat over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you. That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you said you have rather than videos. Okay.
1:21:00Legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said the strain of managing multiple highstakes ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis. And I wondered whether you recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life.
1:21:30Well, every year has been somewhat pivotal and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interesting things that hopefully are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we we catch the both the booster and the ship which will be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetarian ultimately become a space fairing civilization.
1:22:05we've got Neurolink which is now helped by patients res restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight without blind sight implant which is the end of the year early next. in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the
1:22:41I I think what's running on the AI front, we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence. and I think we'll see we we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got at Tesla the we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So it's it's a big year for sure.
1:23:10many other things on the in the in the works too. Okay. I'm I'm a technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Kther Economic Forum. Thank you. Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point. we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock
1:23:44market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap so clearly the market is aware of the situation so it's it's already turned around but sales still down compared to this time last year in Europe in Europe okay and but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
1:24:08Does that mean that you're not going to be able Yes. Does that mean European quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing? Okay. Let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. It saw it, they saw it being at the forefront of the climate crisis. So now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, "I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy." And there also people who are buying it because Elon's crazy or however they may view it. so yes, we've left some sales perhaps on the left, but we've
1:24:45gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what and I mean you you can just look at the stock price the the if you want the best insight information the stock market analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures rather than share price. Well tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in 5 years time?
1:25:29Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no. I might die. [Applause] Okay. Short of that. I'm going to be see if I'm dead. So, there's a slight amount of Does does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision? well that's not really a subject subject for discussion in this forum.
1:25:59the I think obviously there should be compensation for if there if something incredible is done that compensation should match the that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
1:26:23This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. the activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay, that that's your characterization.
1:26:45I think the val on the current value of stock options I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay.
1:27:12No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. a sufficient voting control such that I cannot be oustered by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of mileage pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there and wanting to get tossed out by for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable.
1:27:51That's all that matters. Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Move on. Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political [Applause]
1:28:24endeavors? Because I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction. and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
1:28:57To go and damage some po innocent person's car, to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So, something needs to be done about them. And a number of them are going to prison, and they deserve it. More well. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think bullets into showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah. Those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry. But wouldn't you reach it? Wouldn't wouldn't you
1:29:43[Applause] But wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way. They just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically. Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay.
1:30:14you know that's absurd. that is in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. And and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them. Let's talk about your other companies then in other business area. SpaceX, I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point Military Academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
1:30:55[Applause] [Laughter] you certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is it's the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites, and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position in space launch.
1:31:29So of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%. China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world, including the rest of the US, will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
1:32:03maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth level connectivity throughout the world. In fact this connection is on a SpaceX connection. So I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or where it's very expensive and I think the single biggest thing you can do to look to people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection because once you have the internet connection you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and services to the
1:32:41global market and Once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good and the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with it. I I I don't currently anticipate SpaceX getting into the weapons business. that's certainly that's not an aspiration. We're frequent we're frequently asked to do to do weapons
1:33:24programs, but we have just declined. Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all? it's possible that Starink may go public at some point in the future. And what would be the what would be the time frame? What kind of time frame you consider?
1:33:51No, I'm in no rush. No, I'm in no rush to go public. the the you know public is I guess a way to you know potentially make more money but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably a whole bunch of lawsuits which are very annoying. so really something needs to be done about the shareholder shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a public plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. And the irony being that extreme irony that even if the class they purport to represent were
1:34:37to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit would still continue. So how can it be a a class action representing a class if the class were against it? And that's the bizarre situation we've got in the US. It needs in dire need of reform, you know, and as as anyone who's running a public company experienced this, it's an absurd situation that needs to change. Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it?
1:35:00You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starlink IPO? Well, it would it would need a law to be passed. the the trouble being that you need 60 Senator Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it.
1:35:23the the the the plaintiff's bar is I believe the second largest contributor to the Democratic [Applause] party. That's the that's the issue. At the state level, this can be solved. And and I should say Texas recently passed a law which at this at least the state level made made the election lawsuits much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class of shareholders 3%.
1:35:55This is doesn't will be really help with privilege lawsuits. Okay. let's talk about AI which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes the development of generative AI since you last spoke to this forum 3 years ago. You're in this space of course with Grock which almost everyone will know. You co-founded Open AI and then left and you've obviously got a legal battle with Open AI and Sam Orman. I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the president last week with Sam in the same place at the same time in the in the neighborhood. Okay.
1:36:42So does does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against open AI? Yes. that. So, look, I came I came up with the name OpenAI as an open-source and as a nonprofit and I funded AI OpenAI for the first roughly $50 million and it was intended to be a nonprofit open- source company and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. So, this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I funded."
1:37:33That's opening eye. They've made some changes to their corporate structure, though, haven't they, since in recognition of what of what you've said. And no, that's just what they told the media. Okay. [Applause] part they have part they have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court, of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Mikkel, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you
1:38:18really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
1:38:40Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so in many in most perhaps
1:38:59fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. when you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary
1:39:29laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you will get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a truly absurd situation.
1:39:53under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and returns to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers. And the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question
1:40:38was specifically about a regulator for AI, which you said 3 years ago was needed. And you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What what No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a few a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive so aerospace you know
1:41:16the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no regulator at all. So, so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying, which I think is just basic common sense, that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees in the field. You don't want to have an army of referees.
1:41:42you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or even any given arena, industrial arena to ensure that public safety is taken care of. but you don't have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like I said, it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd. but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good. Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars
1:42:25worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insidider's knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in Iran history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests. and I am simply an adviser. I don't have formal power.
1:42:59and that's it. the president can choose to accept my advice or not. And that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded improperly it would immediately be front page news. to say the least and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then clearly it's not conflict of interest. the yeah there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who'd like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab and
1:43:44because Doge is in every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies affairs. and those companies relationships with the federal government? No, all we do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant. and and then are the contracts that that that are being awarded good value for money? In
1:44:23fact, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract? and if there's if there isn't then we make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions and that's it. And then any action that that that is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at doge handle on the X platform. So it's it's complete trans transparency. and I have not seen any case where to the
1:44:56best of my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's it. And what about the international dimension now? let's think about Starling. Starink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules on black ownership in order to allow
1:45:34stink and that is being done on the eve of the visit the president Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest? No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa? That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there to be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela, who was a great man, proposed was that all all races should be on equal footing in South Africa. That's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws, which is utterly wrong and improv. so
1:46:12the that's that's the deal that all races should be treated equally and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are now 140 laws in South Africa that give u that basically give strong preference to to if if you're black South African and not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but can't get a license to operate in Starink because I'm not black. Does that seem right? It looks Looks like you looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question.
1:46:47Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa and it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you. Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. Ask your question. Yes or no?
1:47:12Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work zone and the amount of savings. I do like racist laws. This is not for me to answer. Come on. Now, you wouldn't be trying to dodge a question. You have to ask question. No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to.
1:47:36I want to ask you about the total I can't believe it. That's good. I want to ask you about the total amount. I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least $2 trillion. The number currently on Doge.gov is $170 billion. That's a big
1:47:59change. What happened to the 2 trillion? What do you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? Because those are supposed to run till next July. I mean your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day you know within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved? No I'm not at all.
1:48:18I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is it still your aim to get the amount of time? Have we not made good progress given the amount of time? That's exactly what I'm asking. So is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to two trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is
1:48:39a function of whether the government and this includes Congress is willing to take our advice. we are not the dictators of the government. We are the adviserss and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. Those team have done incredible work. but the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from Congress and from the executive
1:49:10branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the advisers. but thus far for advisers we've the George team to their credit has made incredible progress. You've talked about $4 billion a day being saved, but that that that won't get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to 2 trillion over the lifetime of Doge.
1:49:47I'm sorry. The 4 billion the 4 billion a day if Doge is going to run till next July is not going to get you to2 trillion dollars. But you still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There there's there's one I mean I feel you somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional journalist. So it's difficult to when when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the valid crew of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer. so
1:50:24Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups of the government. now we we we are we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot we cannot take action beyond that because we are not u some sort of imperial dictator of the government.
1:51:02there are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. nonetheless let's let's not criticize whether there's 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said, I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.
1:51:33So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him I know you you said that already. I wondered Also, I'm just Where does who does Boogies think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he would be frequent to Jeffrey Epste? Okay.
1:52:03Well, he's he's he said he regrets those and that guy he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is, have you looked at the data to check if he might be right that the cuts to USID might cost millions of lives?
1:52:27yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what we found with USAD cuts, and by the way, they haven't all been cut. the the parts of USA ID that we found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the state department. They've not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the state department.
1:52:48but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever, I say, "Well, please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue." We get nothing. We we don't we don't even try to prevent show we should come up with a with a with a show orphan, meaning like this sort of like, well, can we at least see a few kids like where where are they? If they're in trouble, we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers. And then we
1:53:29get thing as a response because it's what what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft. Okay. Let me put this example. Very little actually gets to the kids if anything at all. Okay. Let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa. So you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well.
1:53:49And this is why I asked about the data. US le on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPA which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze then there was a limited waiver that services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So
1:54:19if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost. I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now, do you have another example? Not, Elon. Not in its entirety. Not in its entirety. The the pro there's a limited waiver and UND have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing. So, that's that's why that's why I put that example to you. Okay. Well, which ones aren't being funded? I'll fix it right now. For
1:55:12Okay. Well, actually they're all on the UN UN AIDS website, so you'll be able to see them, but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the roll out of a drug called Glenna Capavir which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure you would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes, but what if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is then we'll fix it. Okay, fine.
1:55:43so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections?
1:56:12I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future. And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. What about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
1:56:46I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. That's the only President President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. You believe the legacy. Speak Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red. Is is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal? I wouldn't
1:57:24use that to to line up my cage for parcroppings. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and you know, if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. but it isn't. So I I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them which you are and and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned
1:58:04be challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single com over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you. That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you said you have other than video. Okay. They call legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said, "The strain of managing multiple highstakes ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis." And I wondered whether you
1:58:50recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life. Well, every year has been somewhat pertile and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interesting things that probably are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we
1:59:20catch both the booster and the ship which would be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetary and ultimately become a space fairing civilization. we've got Neurolink which is now helped by patients restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight with our blind sight implant which is either end of the year or early next. in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a
2:00:08relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the I I think what's running on the AI front, we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence. I think we'll see we we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got Tesla the what we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So it's it's a big year for sure.
2:00:42many other things on the in the in the works too. Okay. I'm I'm a technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Qatar Economic Forum. Thank you. Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point.
2:01:06we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap so clearly the market is aware of the situation so it's it's already turned around but sales still down compared to this time last year in Europe in Europe okay and yes but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
2:01:40Does that mean that you're not going to be able Yes. Does that mean European quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing? Okay. Let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. It saw it, they saw it being at the forefront of the climate crisis. So now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, "I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy." And that there also people who are buying it because Elon's crazy or
2:02:12however they may view it. so yes, we've lost some sales perhaps on the left, but we've gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what and I mean you you can just look at the stock price the the if you want the best inside information the stock market analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures rather than share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief
2:02:56executive of Tesla in 5 years time? Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no. I might die. [Applause] Okay. Short of that. I'm going to see if I'm dead. So, there's a slight amount. Does Does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision? well that's not really a subject subject discussion in this forum.
2:03:31the I think obviously there should be compensation for if there something incredible is done that compensation should match the that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
2:03:55This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. the activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay, that that's your characterization.
2:04:17I think the on the current value of stock options, I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options, I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years, as long as you are still with us on this planet, is completely independent of pay.
2:04:44No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. a sufficient voting control such that I cannot be ousted by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of mileage pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there and we're going to get tossed out by for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable. That's all that matters.
2:05:25Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Move on. Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political [Applause]
2:05:56endeavors? Because I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction. and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
2:06:29To go and damage some po innocent person's car, to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So, something needs to be done about them. And a number of them are going to prison, and they deserve it. More will. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think Yeah. bullets into showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah.
2:07:01Those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry. But wouldn't you come to you? Wouldn't wouldn't [Applause] you wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way. They just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically.
2:07:32Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay. you know that's absurd. that is in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. And and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them.
2:08:00Let's talk about your other companies then and other business areas. SpaceX. I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point Military Academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
2:08:24[Applause] [Laughter] you certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is is the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position in space launch.
2:08:58So of of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%. China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world including the rest of the US will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
2:09:32maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth level connectivity throughout the world. In fact this connection is on a SpaceX connection. So I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or where it's very expensive and I think the single biggest thing you can do to lift to people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection because once you have the internet connection you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and services to the
2:10:10global market and once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good and the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with I I I don't currently anticipate SpaceX getting into the weapons business. that's certainly that's not an aspiration. We're frequent we're frequently asked to do to do weapons
2:10:53programs, but we have just declined. Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all? it's possible that Starink may go public at some point in the future and what would be this what would be the time frame? What kind of time frame you consider?
2:11:20No, I'm in no rush. No, I'm in no rush to go public. the the you know public is I guess a way to you know potentially make more money but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably a whole bunch of lawsuits which are very annoying. so really something needs to be done about the shareholder shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a public plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. And the irony being that extreme irony that even if the class they purport to represent were
2:12:06to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit would still continue. So how can it be a a class action representing a class if the class went against it? And that's the bizarre situation we've got in the US that needs it's in dire need of reform and as as anyone who's running a public company experienced this. It's an absurd situation that needs to change. Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it?
2:12:29You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starlink IPO? Well, it would it would need a law to be passed. the the trouble being that you need 60 Senator Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it.
2:12:51the the the the the plaintiff's bar is I believe the second largest contributor to the Democratic party. That's the that's the issue. At the state level, this can be solved. And and I should say Texas recently passed a law which at this at least the state level made made the election lawsuits much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class of shareholders 3%.
2:13:24This is a this will be will be really help with privilege lawsuits. Okay. let's talk about AI which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes the development of generative AI since you last spoke to this forum 3 years ago. You're in this space of course with Grock which almost everyone will know. You co-founded Open AI and then left and you've obviously got a legal battle with Open AI and Sam Orman. I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the president last week with Sam Orman in the same place at the same time was in the in the neighborhood. Okay. So
2:14:11does does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against open AI? Yes. so look, I came I came up with the name OpenAI as an open-source and as a nonprofit AI open for the first roughly $50 million and it was intended to be a nonprofit open-source company and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed the source. So, this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I funded. That's opening eye." They've
2:15:06made some changes to their corporate structure, though, haven't they? Since in in recognition of what of what you've said and No, that's just what they told the media. Okay. part they have part they have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court, of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Miklthweight, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you
2:15:49really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
2:16:11Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you can think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so u in many in most perhaps
2:16:31fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary
2:17:00laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you'll get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a of a truly absurd situation. under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for
2:17:30not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers and the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question was specifically about a regulator for
2:18:12AI, which you said 3 years ago was needed. And you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What what No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a few a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive so aerospace you know
2:18:48the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no regulator at So, so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying which I think is just basic common sense that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees on the field. You don't want to have an army of referees.
2:19:13you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or any given arena industrial arena to ensure help that public safety is taken care of. but you don't have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like like I said, it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd.
2:19:40but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good. Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insider's knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a
2:20:09conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in throughout history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests. and I am simply an adviser. I don't have formal power.
2:20:31and that's it. the president can choose to accept my advice or not. And that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded improperly it would immediately be front page news to say the least and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then clearly is not a conflict of interest. the yeah there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who would like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA Blue Origin Rocket Lab and
2:21:15because Doge is in every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies affairs. and those companies relationships with the federal government. No, all we do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant. and and are the contracts that that are being awarded good value for money? In fact, frankly, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract? and if there's if there isn't then we make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions
2:22:05and that's it. And then any action that that that is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at doge handle on the Xplatform. So it's it's complete transparency. and I've not seen any case where to the best of my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's it. And what about the international dimension now? let's think about Starlink.
2:22:36Starlink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules on black ownership in order to allow Starink and that is being done on the eve of the visit that President Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest?
2:23:13No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa? That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela who was a great man proposed was that all all races should be on an equal footing in South Africa. That's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws which is utterly wrong and improv. so the that's the that's the deal that all races should be treated equally and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are
2:23:49now 140 laws in South Africa that give u that basically give give strong preference to to if if you're a black South African and not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but cannot get a license to operate in Starink because I'm not black. Well, it looks like that's about its looks like right looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question. Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa and it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you.
2:24:32Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. your question yes or no laws yet. Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work though and the amount of savings. I do like racist laws. This is not for me to answer. Come on now. You wouldn't be trying to dodge a question. You have to ask question. No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to.
2:25:05I want to ask you about the total I can't believe it. That's not good. I want to ask you about the total amount. I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least 2 trillion. The number currently on doge.gov is $170 billion. That's a big
2:25:27change. What happened to the 2 trillion? Would you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? because those are supposed to run till next July. I mean your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day you know within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved?
2:25:46No, not at all. I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is it still your progress amount of time? Have we not made good progress given the amount of time? That's exactly what I'm asking. So is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is a function of whether the government and this includes Congress is willing to take our advice. we are not the dictators of the government, we are the advisers and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. Doge team has done incredible work. but the the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from
2:26:33Congress and from the executive branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the advisers. but thus far for advisers we've the team to their credit has made incredible progress. You've talked about $4 billion a day being saved, but that that that won't
2:27:02get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to 2 trillion over the lifetime of Doge. I'm sorry. The 4 billion the 4 billion a day if Doge is going to run till next July is not going to get you to $2 trillion.
2:27:27But you still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There's there's there's there there's what doge I mean I feel you're somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional ver journalist. So it's difficult to when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the dialogue tree of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer.
2:27:50so Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups for the government. now we we we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot
2:28:25we cannot take action beyond that because we are not u some sort of imperial dictator of the government. There are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. but nonetheless let's let's let's not criticize whether those 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.
2:29:02So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him my I know you you've said that already. I wondered also and I'm just who does who does Bill Gates think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he is he for a quote of Jeffrey Epste? Okay.
2:29:30Well, he's he's he said he regrets those and he's kind of he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is have you looked at the data to check if he might be right that the cuts to USAD might cost millions of lives?
2:29:57yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what what we found with USAD cuts, and by the way, they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that were found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the State Department. They've not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the State Department.
2:30:19but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we've when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing.
2:30:44We we don't they don't even try to prevent show come up with a with a with a show often meaning like it's sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they if they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and then we get nothing as a response because it's what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft let me put this example very little of it actually gets to the kids if anything at Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data. The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS
2:31:26treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPAR which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze. Then there was a limited waiver. ID services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So
2:31:50if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost. I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example?
2:32:22Elon not in its entirety. Not in its entirety. the the program there's a limited waiver and UN have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing so that's that's why that's why I put that example to you okay well which ones aren't being funded I'll fix it right now for okay well actually they're all on the UN UN a's website so you'll be able to see them but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the roll out of a drug called Glenn Capavir which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure you and AI as
2:33:05would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes. Well well if if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is then we'll fix it. Okay fine. so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming
2:33:27midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections? I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future.
2:33:51And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. What about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
2:34:17I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. Okay. That's the only Can I speak to President Putin? Oh, you must I get it. I speak Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red. Is is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal?
2:34:55I wouldn't use that to to line up my cage for paragraphs. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and you know, if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. U, but it isn't. So, I I have the the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them, which you are, and and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of
2:35:33time. So you mentioned you mentioned be challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single combat over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. Great. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you.
2:35:51That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you've said you have rather than video. Okay. Legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said the strain of managing multiple highstake ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis. And I wondered whether you recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life.
2:36:30Well, every year has been somewhat pivotal and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interesting things that hopefully are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we catch both the booster and the ship which will be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetary and ultimately become a space fairing civilization.
2:37:05we've got Neurolink which is now helped five patients res restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight with our blind sight implant which is either end of the year or early next. in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the I I think we're running on the AI front, we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence.
2:37:53I think we'll see we we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got at Tesla the we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy, basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So it's it's a big year for sure. many other things on the in the in the works too. Okay. I'm I'm technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Qatar Economic Forum. Thank you.
2:38:26Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point. we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap so clearly the market is aware of the situation so it's it's already turned around but sales still down compared to this time last year in Europe in Europe okay and yes but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
2:39:08Does that mean that you're not going to be able Does that mean European is quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing, okay, let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. It saw it, they saw it as being at the forefront of the climate crisis.
2:39:28And now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, "I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy." And that there also people who are buying it because Elon's crazy or however they may view it. so yes, we've lost some sales perhaps on the left, but we've gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what do And and I mean you you can just look at the stock price the the if you want to invest in information the stock market analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry
2:40:13about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra rather than sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh sh share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in 5 years time?
2:40:29Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no, I might die. Okay. Short of that. I can't see you if I'm dead. So, there's a slight amount of Does does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision? well that's not really a subject subject of discussion in this forum.
2:40:59the I think obviously there should be conversation for if there's something incredible is done that compensation should match that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
2:41:23This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. the activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay, that that's your characterization.
2:41:45I think the val on the current value of stock options I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion dollars. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay.
2:42:12No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. a sufficient voting control such that I cannot be ousted by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of mileage pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there u and wanting to get tossed out by for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable.
2:42:51That's all that matters. Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Let's move on. Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally? Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political
2:43:23[Applause] endeavors? because it is I mean I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction. and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
2:43:57To go and damage some po innocent person's car, to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So something needs to be done about them. And a number of them are going to prison and they deserve it. More will. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think bullets into showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah. Those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will
2:44:36also don't worry. But wouldn't you wouldn't wouldn't [Applause] you but wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way. they just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically.
2:45:03Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay. you know that's absurd. that is in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. and and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them.
2:45:31Let's talk about your other companies then in other business areas. SpaceX. I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point military academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
2:45:59[Laughter] You certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is it's the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position in space launch.
2:46:29So of of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%. China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world including the rest of the US will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
2:47:03maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth global connectivity throughout the world. In fact, this connection is on a SpaceX connection. So, I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or it's very expensive. And I think the single biggest thing you can do to lift people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection.
2:47:34because once you have the internet connection, you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and services to the global market. and once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good in the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with it. I I I don't currently spa space getting into
2:48:17the weapons business. that's certainly that's not an aspiration. We're frequent we're frequently asked to do to do weapons programs, but we have thus far a client. Do you envisage SpaceX or indeed Starlink as a separate entity publicly listing in the near future or at all? it's possible that Starlink may go public at some point in the future and what would be the what would be the time frame?
2:48:49What kind of time frame you consider? No, I mean no rush. No, I'm in no rush to your public. the the you know public is I guess a way to you know potentially make more money but at the expense of a lot of public company overhead and inevitably a whole bunch of lawsuits which are very annoying.
2:49:10so really something needs to be done about the shareholder shareholder derivative lawsuits in the US because it allows plaintiffs law firms who don't represent the shareholders to pretend that they represent the shareholders by getting a puppet plaintiff with a few shares to initiate a massive lawsuit against the company. And the irony being that extreme irony that even if the class they purport to represent were to vote that they don't want the lawsuit, the lawsuit would still continue. So how can it be a a class action representing a class if the class went against it? And that's the bizarre situation we've got in the US that needs and it's a dire need of reform and as as
2:49:53anyone who's running a public company experienced this. It's an absurd situation that needs to change. Well, do you think Donald Trump might change it? You've certainly got his ear. I imagine that you've put this to him. Is this something you're trying to change before any Starink IPO?
2:50:10Well, it would it would need a law to be passed. the the trouble being that you need 60 Senator Senate votes and the Democrats will vote against it. the the the the the plaintiff's bar is I believe the second largest contributor to the Democratic party. That's the that's the issue. At the state level, this can be solved. And and I should say Texas recently passed a law which at this at least the state level made made the election lawsuits much more reasonable because you have to get at least one in 33 shareholders to agree that they are part of a class of shareholders 3%.
2:50:55This is a this will be will be really help with privilege lawsuits. Okay. let's talk about AI which is in so many of your businesses and in all our worlds in different ways. It's one of the big changes the development of generative AI since you last spoke to this forum 3 years ago. You're in this space of course with Grock which almost everyone will know. You co-founded Open AI and then left and you've obviously got a legal battle with Open AI and Sam Orman. I wonder if you could say something about the status of that because you were together in Saudi Arabia with the president last week with Sam Orman in the same place at the same time was in the in the neighborhood. Okay. So
2:51:42does does that mean you are pushing ahead with the lawsuit against open AI? Yes. so I came I came up with the name OpenAI as an open-source and as a nonprofit and I funded a AI open AI for the first roughly $50 million and it was intended to be a nonprofit open-source company and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. So, this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I
2:52:32funded. That's opening eye." They've made some changes to their corporate structure though, haven't they, since in recognition of what of what you've said. And no, that's just what they told the media. Okay. part they have part they have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court, of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Miklthweight, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you
2:53:17really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?
2:53:40Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you can think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so u in many in most perhaps
2:53:59fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary
2:54:28laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you will get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a of a truly absurd situation. under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for
2:54:59not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers and the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question was specifically about a regulator for
2:55:41AI which you said 3 years ago was needed and you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What what No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field a few referees but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive so aerospace you know the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no
2:56:27regulator at all. So, so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying which I think is just basic common sense that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees on the field. You don't want to have an army of referees you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or even any given arena industrial arena to ensure that public safety is taken care of.
2:56:55but you don't want to have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like like I said, it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd. but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good.
2:57:13Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insider's knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a
2:57:37conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in throughout history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests. and I am simply an adviser. I don't have formal power. and that's it.
2:58:01the president can choose to accept my advice or not. And that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded improperly it would immediately be front page news to say the least and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then the clear is not conflict to interest. the yeah
2:58:32there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who would like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA Blue Origin Rocket Lab and because Doge is in every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies affairs. and those companies relationships with the federal government.
2:59:03No, all we do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant and are and and are the contracts that that that are being awarded good value for money? In fact, frankly, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract? and if there's if there isn't then we make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions and that's it. And then any action that that that
2:59:39is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at doge handle on the Xplatform. So it's it's complete transparency. and I have not seen any case where to the best my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's it. And what about the international dimension now?
3:00:05let's think about Starink. Starink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules on black ownership in order to allow Stalink and that is being done on the eve of the visit that President Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest?
3:00:44No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa? That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela who was a great man proposed was that all all races should be on an equal footing in South Africa. That's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws which is utterly wrong and improv. so the that's the that's the deal that all races should be treated equally. and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are
3:01:20now 140 laws in South Africa that give u that basically give strong preference to to if if you're a black South African and not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but cannot get a license to operate in Starink because I'm not black. Well, it looks like that's about its looks like that looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question. Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa. And it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you.
3:02:03Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. Ask your question. Yes or no? Yes. Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work zone. The amount of savings. I do like racist laws. This is not for me to answer. Come on.
3:02:24Now, you wouldn't be trying to dodge the question. I question. No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to. I want to ask you about the total I can't believe it. That's not good. I want to ask you about the total amount.
3:02:43I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least $2 trillion. The number currently on Doge.gov is $170 billion. That's a big change. What happened to the 2 trillion? Would you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? Because supposed to run till next July.
3:03:08I mean your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day you know within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved? No, I'm not at all. I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is that still your aim to get the amount of time? Have we not made good progress given the amount of time?
3:03:27That's exactly what I'm asking. So is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to two trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is a function of whether the government and this includes the Congress is willing to take our advice. we're not the dictators of the government, we are the adviserss and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. The Doge team has done incredible work. but the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from Congress and from the executive branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the advisers. but thus far for advisers we've the George
3:04:20team to their credit has made incredible progress. You've talked about $4 billion a day being saved, but that that won't get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to 2 trillion over the lifetime of Doge.
3:04:47I'm sorry. The 4 billion the 4 billion a day if Doge is going to run till next July is not going to get you to $2 trillion. But you still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There's there's there there's one doge. I mean I feel you're somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional journalist. So it's difficult to when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the dialogue tree of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer.
3:05:21so Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups for the government. now we we we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot
3:05:56we cannot take action beyond that because we are not u some sort of imperial dictator of the government. There are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. but nonetheless let's let's let's not criticize whether there's 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.
3:06:33So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him I know you you said that already. I wondered and I'm just who does Boogies think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he frequented Jeffrey Epste. Okay.
3:07:02Well, he's he's he said he regrets those and he's spent he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is have you looked at the data to check if he might be right that the cuts to USA ID might cost millions of lives?
3:07:26yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true or it's false. the what we found with USAD cuts, and by the way, they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that we found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the State Department. So, not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the State Department.
3:07:47but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing.
3:08:12We we don't they don't even try to prevent show. We should come up with a with a with a show often meaning like this sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they? If they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and then we get as a response because it's what that what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft. Okay, let me let me put this example. Very little of it actually gets to the kids if anything at all. Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data.
3:08:50The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPAR which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze then there was a limited waiver that services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So
3:09:18if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong. Millions of lives could be lost. I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example?
3:09:50Noted Elon. Not in its entirety. Not in its entirety. the the pro there's a limited waiver and UN aids have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing. So that's that's why that's why I put that example to you. Okay. Well, which ones aren't being funded?
3:10:09I'll fix it right now. For Okay. Well, actually they're all on the UN UN AIDS website, so you'll be able to see them, but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the roll out of a drug called Glenn Capa which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year.
3:10:30So if you are perhaps I'm sure you unsaid would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes. But well if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is then we'll fix it. Okay fine. so finally political your political influence I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming
3:10:56midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here 3 years ago. Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections? I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future.
3:11:20And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. Okay. And what about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?
3:11:46I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. That's the only I speak to President President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. You believe the legacy. Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red. Is is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal? I wouldn't
3:12:24use that to to line up my cage for paragraph meetings. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and you know, if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. U, but it isn't. So, I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal. Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them, which you are, and and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned
3:13:04you challenging I I did so on on the X platform. I challenged Vladimir Putin to single com over the but I didn't talk to him. That was a post on the X platform. That's why that's why I asked you and you've and you've clarified and explained. Thank you. That's that's why I was asking whether you have had reported conversations and and you said you have rather than a video. Okay.
3:13:28Legacy media lies. Okay. Listen, I actually thought I might give Grock the last word. because when I asked Grock what your hardest challenge is, it said the strain of managing multiple highstake ventures amid financial, regulatory, and public relations crisis. And I wondered whether you recognize that characterization and whether you do think that this is a pivotal year in your life.
3:13:59Well, every year has been somewhat pivotal and this one's no different. so I mean in terms of interesting things that probably are accomplished this year the getting Starship to be fully reusable so that the we we catch the both the booster and the ship which will be the first fully reusable orbital rocket ever in history which is would be a profound breakthrough as the essential breakthrough necessarily to make life multilanetary and ultimately become a space fairing civilization.
3:14:34we've got Neurolink which is now helped five patients res restore capability using the telepathy implant where they're able to control a computer simply by thinking. we'll be doing our first patient to restore blind to restore to restore sight without blind sight implant which is the end of the year early next.
3:15:03in fact that might that first patient might be in UAE since we have a relationship with UAE and the Cleveland Clinic clinic there. the I I think what's running on the AI front, we are close to what you might call AGI or or or digital super intelligence. and I think we'll see we are we are seeing an explosion in digital super intelligence here. and then we've got at Tesla the we'll be launching unsupervised autonomy basically self-driving cars with no one in them in Austin next month. So it's it's a big year for sure.
3:15:41many other things on the in the in the works too. Okay. I'm I'm a technologist first and foremost. Elon Musk, thank you very much for joining us here at Qatar Economic Forum. Thank you. Europe is our weakest market. We're strong everywhere else. so our sales are are doing doing well at this point. we don't anticipate any any meaningful sales shortfall and the you know the obviously the stock
3:16:16market recognizes that since we're now back over a trillion dollars in market cap so clearly the market is aware of the situation so it's it's already turned around but sales still down compared to this time last year in Europe in Europe okay and but that's that's true of of all manufacturers. There's no exceptions.
3:16:40Does that mean that you're not going to be able Does that mean European quite weak? Okay. But you would acknowledge, wouldn't you, that what you are facing, okay, let's just take it as Europe. What you are facing is a significant problem. This Tesla was an incredibly aspirational brand. People identified with it. It saw it, they saw it as being at the forefront of the climate crisis.
3:17:00So now people are driving around with stickers in their cars saying, "I bought this before we knew Elon was crazy." And there also people are buying it because Elon's crazy or however they may view it. so yes, we've lost some sales perhaps on the left, but we've gained them on the right. the sales numbers at this point are strong and we we see no problem with demand. So what and I mean you can just look at the stock price the the if you want to insider information the stock market
3:17:34analysts have that and a stock wouldn't be trading near all-time highs if it was not if things weren't in good shape. They're fine. Don't worry about it. Okay. I I was citing sales figures ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra ra rather than share price. Well, tell me then how committed you are to Tesla. Do you see yourself and are you committed to still being the chief executive of Tesla in 5 years time?
3:18:00Yes. No doubt about that at all. Well, no, I might die. [Applause] Okay. Short of that, I'm dead. So, there's a slight amount of Does does that mean that the value of your pay doesn't have any bearing on your decision? well that's not really a subject subject for discussion in this forum.
3:18:31the I think obviously there should be compensation for if there something incredible is done that compensation should match the that something incredible was done. but I I'm I'm confident that whatever the u whatever some activist posing as a judge in Delaware happens to do will not affect the future compensation.
3:18:55This is the judge who twice struck down the $56 billion pay package that was that was awarded to you. I think the value on the basis on the current value of stock options. Yeah. Not a judge. Not a judge. the activist who is cosplaying a judge in a Halloween costume. Okay, that that's your characterization.
3:19:17I think the on the current value of stock options I think the actual justice according to the law on the current value of stock options I think the value of that pay package stands at about hundred billion. Are you saying you are relaxed about the value of your future pay package? Your decision to be committed to Tesla for the next 5 years as long as you are still with us on this planet is completely independent of pay.
3:19:44No, it's not independent. So pay is a relevant factor then to your commitment to Tesla. a sufficient voting control such that I cannot be ousted by activist investors is what matters to me. And I've said this publicly many times. but let's not have this whole thing be a discussion of mileage pay. It's not a money thing. It's a a reasonable control thing over the future of the company, especially if we're building millions, potentially billions of humanoid robots. I can't be sitting there u and want to get tossed out by
3:20:20for political reasons by activists. That would be unacceptable. That's all that matters. Now, let's move on. Okay. Well, just one question. Move on. Well, one question before we move on to other companies, which is that I wonder if some of what you've has happened to Tesla in the last few months, did you take it personally?
3:20:41Yes. And did it make you regret any of or think twice about your political [Applause] endeavors? Because I did I did what needed to be done. the the violent antibody reaction. and I'm I'm not someone who's ever committed violence. and yet massive violence was committed against my companies. Massive violence was threatened against me. Who are these people? Why would they do that? How wrong can they be? They're on the wrong They're on the wrong side of history. And that's an evil thing to do.
3:21:29To go and damage some po innocent person's car, to threaten to kill me. What's wrong with these people? I've not harmed anyone. So, something needs to be done about them, and a number of them are going to prison, and they deserve it. More will. You're you're referring to the attacks on Tesla showrooms, but I think yeah showrooms and burning down cars is unacceptable. Yeah, those people will go to prison and the people that funded them and organized them will also go to prison. Don't worry. But wouldn't you come and reach her? Wouldn't wouldn't you [Applause] But wouldn't wouldn't you acknowledge that some of the people who turned against Tesla in Europe were were upset
3:22:21at your politics and very few of them would have been violent in any way. They just objected to to what they saw you say or do politically. Well, it's certainly fine to object to political things, but it's not it's not fine to resort to violence and hanging someone in effigy and death threats. that's obviously not okay.
3:22:44you know that's absurd. that is in no way justifiable at all in any way, shape or form. And and some of the the legacy media nonetheless have sought to justify it which is unconscionable. Shame on them. Let's talk about your other companies then in other business area. SpaceX, I saw that you said in a speech at the West Point Military Academy recently that the future of warfare is AI and drones and obviously defense is an increasingly booming sector with the state of the world at the moment. Do you see SpaceX moving into weaponized drones?
3:23:24[Applause] [Laughter] you certainly ask interesting questions that are impossible to answer. so SpaceX is is is the space launch leader. So SpaceX doesn't do drones. SpaceX builds rockets, satellites, and internet terminals. so but SpaceX has has a a very dominant position is space launch.
3:23:58So of the mass launch to orbit this year, SpaceX will probably do 90%. China will do the rema half half of the remaining amount, so 5% and the rest of the world, including the rest of the US, will do about 5%. So SpaceX will do about 10 times as much as the rest of the world combined or 20 times as much as China, which is and China is doing actually a very impressive job. the reason for this is that we're putting into into orbit the largest satellite constellation the world has ever seen by far. so I think at this point about
3:24:32maybe approaching 80% of all active satellites in orbit are SpaceX. and they're providing global high high bandwidth global connectivity throughout the world. In fact this connection is on the SpaceX connection. So I think this is a very good thing because it means that we can provide lowcost high bandwidth internet to parts of the world that don't have it or where it's very expensive and I think the single biggest thing you can do to lift people out of poverty and help them is giving them an internet connection because once you have the internet connection you can learn anything for free on the internet and you can also sell your goods and services to the
3:25:10global market and once you have knowledge by the internet and the ability to engage in commerce that this is going to greatly improve quality of life for people throughout the world and it has and I just like to thank anyone in the audience who may have been helpful in you know with Starlink and and getting it to to approved in their country and I think it's doing a lot of good in the countries that have approved it which is I think at this point 130 countries are very happy with I I don't hardly anticipate a space I create
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版