2016年1月25日晚上,香港。马斯克站在台上,给出一组数字:全球每年生产的新车和卡车超过9000万辆,其中电动车占比不到0.2%。
紧接着他说,香港大概会成为全世界电动车的领先城市,人均电动车数量可能超过任何一座城市。
把这两句话放在一起,会让人觉得有点矛盾。一个占全球新车销量千分之二的品类,一座地少人多、大部分人住在公寓里连私人充电桩都装不了的城市。马斯克偏偏把后者看成前者的突破口。
这场活动由特斯拉全球销售总裁约翰·麦克尼尔(John McNeal)开场。他提到香港是特斯拉全球扩张最快的市场之一,台下坐着不少Roadster和Model S的老车主。马斯克上台先谢了这批人,说他们从Roadster时代就开始支持特斯拉,然后开始讲计划。
2016年初的特斯拉,正处在一个微妙的节点。Model S已经卖了三年多,Model X刚发布不久还在产能爬坡,Model 3要等到两年后才能交付。公司刚从那几年最艰难的阶段缓过来,手里有产品,但离规模还差得远。
三代产品,一条价格往下走的曲线
马斯克把特斯拉的产品路线讲得很直白:2008年推出Roadster,产量低、价格高;后来是Model S和Model X,中等价格、中等产量;大约两年后推出Model 3,价格更低、产量更高。
这条路线经常被解读成"从高端往下打"的商业策略。马斯克给出的理由更简单:特斯拉的目标是加速可持续交通的到来,能多做一点就多做一点,让那个未来早一点发生。
2014年,特斯拉开放了全部专利。这件事放在当时的汽车行业里不算常见。马斯克的逻辑是,如果目标是让整个行业转向电动,多一个玩家推进这件事,比守住自己的技术优势更有价值。
把这条路线看成三级火箭更好理解。第一级证明技术可行,第二级证明商业可行,第三级才谈规模。每一级的定价和产量,对应的其实是不同阶段要回答的问题。
Roadster回答的是"电动车能不能做得快、做得好看"。它基于莲花Elise的底盘改造,2008年金融危机期间上市,卖了两千多台。数字不大,但它第一次让一部分人相信,电动车不一定是慢吞吞的怪东西。
Model S和Model X回答的是"电动车能不能成为豪华车市场里的正经对手"。这个市场对性能、做工、服务的要求最高,能在这里站住脚,往下走才有说服力。
Model 3要回答的是"电动车能不能变成大众消费品"。这一关过了,整个行业的天花板才会被抬起来。
这个顺序反过来说也成立。如果特斯拉一上来就造便宜车,它要同时解决成本、产能、品牌三件事,任何一件出问题都可能拖垮公司。先用高价车换取利润和技术积累,再往下走,风险被拆开了。
开源专利这一步也有同样的考虑。特斯拉当时的技术优势主要在电池管理和整车电子架构,这部分靠专利壁垒其实守不住多久。主动放开,换来的是整个行业加速投入,供应链成本下降,特斯拉自己也是受益者。
电动车得先是好车,然后才是环保的车
演讲里有一段话,马斯克讲得比较慢。
过去人们对电动车的印象是高尔夫球车:慢、丑、跑不远。要让人接受电动车,光说它环保没有用,必须让人看到它可以是当下最好的车:快、操控好、好看、续航长。
把这个判断放回2016年的语境里看,很实际。那年特斯拉的潜在客户,大多开惯了宝马、奔驰、奥迪,环保在他们心里的权重,远不如"这车好不好开"。马斯克要先把这批人拉过来,让他们相信电动车在性能上不输,甚至更好。
他给出的证据是几个数字:98%的Model S车主表示愿意再买一台;Model S拿到多个年度车型奖项;《消费者报告》(Consumer Reports)说这是他们测试过的最好的车。
98%的复购意愿,在汽车行业里是很高的数字。多数品牌的复购率在50%上下。这个数字背后是产品体验,环保理念在这里帮不上忙。
这段讲话里藏着一个做产品的顺序问题:一个新技术品类要进主流,绕不开一道坎,它得先是好产品,然后才轮得到讲它的附加价值。顺序颠倒,就只能卖给你本来就认同这件事的一小撮人。
电动车行业后来十年的分化,基本印证了这一点。活下来的新势力,产品力都不差;只靠补贴和政策活着的,大多没撑住。
安全这件事,电动车有先天优势
马斯克讲安全时列了几条:Model S全项五星;至今仍是所有测试过的车里安全评级最高的;没有发动机,车头溃缩区比任何燃油车都长;座舱刚性很强;电池铺在底盘上,重心低。
溃缩区这个概念值得解释一下。燃油车的车头塞着发动机和变速箱,碰撞时这一段能吸收的能量有限。电动车前面是空的,可以设计更长的变形区,撞击能量被更多结构吸收,传到乘员舱的就少了。这是结构上的先天优势,堆材料堆不出来。
电池铺在底盘带来的低重心,顺带解决了另一个问题:操控。车越重越难开,但重心越低越稳。Model S整车重量接近2.2吨,开起来却不像这个重量,原因就在这里。
再加上全轮驱动,0到100公里加速3.3秒,续航接近500公里。马斯克说,这些特性放在一起,才能让电动车成为燃油车真正的替代品。
3.3秒这个数字放到2016年的量产轿车里是什么水平?当时能跑进4秒的基本都是百万级的性能车。一台五门轿车做到3.3秒,这件事本身就在替电动车做广告。
安全评级也是同样的道理。五星成绩单看不算稀奇,很多车都有。但"所有测试过的车里最高"这个说法,会直接进入购车者的比较清单。
把性能、安全、续航三件事同时做上去,成本是很高的。电池容量要够,车身结构要强,电机功率要大。这背后是电池成本在快速下降,也是特斯拉敢把价格往下压的底气。
车卖出去之后,还会变好
燃油车的软件在出厂那天就定型了。你买到什么就是什么,除非回4S店刷程序。特斯拉的做法不一样,通过OTA(空中升级)持续给车推送新功能。
马斯克说,这意味着你买的不只是一台静态的车,它会随着时间变好。
这句话在2016年听起来还有点新鲜。今天几乎所有新车都在讲OTA,但当时能把整车软件当服务来运营的车企屈指可数。硬件预埋、软件迭代这套打法,特斯拉是最早跑通的那一批。
它的前提是硬件要留出余量。传感器、芯片、屏幕,出厂时就得按未来几年的功能需求配齐,否则软件再更新也没有载体。这条经验后来被整个行业学会,也带来一个新问题:硬件预埋的成本,最终要摊到车价里。
对用户来说,OTA带来的另一个变化是保值率。软件持续更新,老车型不会因为功能落后而快速贬值。这一点在二手车市场里慢慢被验证,也成了特斯拉区别于传统车企的一个卖点。
Autopilot 这个名字,是从飞机上借来的
讲到自动驾驶辅助,马斯克说第二天要跟香港政府开会,希望能批准释放Autopilot功能。"谨慎乐观"是他用的词。
Autopilot会随着软件更新不断变好,能力上限取决于传感器套件:摄像头、雷达、声呐、GPS。这套硬件决定了它能走多远。马斯克说,能走的距离其实相当远。
为什么叫Autopilot?他解释得很清楚:想让人们像理解飞机自动驾驶那样理解它。
飞机上的autopilot不意味着飞行员可以放下责任去睡觉,那会很危险。它做的是减少工作量,让飞行更容易。(马斯克)
放到车上,逻辑一样:它减轻驾驶负担,不转移责任。
台下有位提问者说自己刚考完香港警察的一级驾驶考试,用Autopilot之后需要的注意力更少,对周围情况的感知更清楚,堵车时压力小很多。他说想把Autopilot要回来。
这个反馈和马斯克的命名逻辑是呼应的。用户感受到的是负担减轻,而不是被替代。
2015年10月,Autopilot通过OTA推送给部分Model S车主,当时的能力是高速路段的车道保持和自动变道。这套功能上线之后,关于它的讨论迅速分成两派:一派觉得它让长途驾驶轻松了很多,另一派担心司机会过度信任它。
马斯克在香港这场活动里反复强调的,正是后一种担心的反面。他不想让用户觉得可以把责任交出去。命名、说明书、交互提示,都要把这条边界说清楚。
坏消息传得快,好消息没人讲
一位来自Charged Hong Kong的提问者说了一段挺尖锐的话。他提到Blendtec搅拌机靠"能不能搅碎"的简单演示在网上走红,而他一直在等Autopilot的好消息,等来的全是灾难片式的报道。
他的问题很直接:每一条坏消息,需要五条好消息才能在心理上平衡,特斯拉能不能分享一些正面案例?
马斯克的回答很坦白:确实有很多干预案例,但公司没有征得车主同意去公开他们的信息。他承认这是个好主意,可以用很低压力的方式去问车主愿不愿意分享。
然后他提到一个统计学上的观察。他最近看到一张车道位置的直方图,对比Autopilot开启和手动驾驶两种情况。Autopilot状态下,车辆在车道内的位置分布明显更集中;手动驾驶时,人们其实会大幅度偏离车道。
这个数据点值得停一下。人们对自己驾驶水平的估计普遍偏高,觉得自己稳稳压在车道中间。直方图不讲情面,手动驾驶的车道位置分布比想象中散得多。
马斯克说,也许该把这类数据公开,让大家看到Autopilot的车道位置分布比手动更收敛。他还分享了自己的体感:用了几周Autopilot,到达目的地时精神好很多。
这段对话里有件事后来反复出现:涉及安全的新功能,舆论场对个例极其敏感,对统计却不敏感。一家公司如果只在事故发生时被动回应,长期会输掉叙事。主动设计数据披露的机制,是产品之外的另一项工作。
提问者提到的Blendtec案例,本质上是把复杂技术翻译成一个所有人都能看懂的演示。Autopilot缺的正是这种翻译。它的好处藏在几万次平淡无奇的正常行驶里,坏处却集中在几条视频里。传播规律天然对新技术不利。
从5个人到15000人,从600辆到5万辆
演讲里有一段数据回顾。2004年特斯拉只有5个人,现在接近15000人。五年前一年生产约600辆车,现在一年5万辆。
他还提到一个累计数字:特斯拉的车主们一共省下了超过1.5亿升汽油。
这两个数字放在一起看,能看出特斯拉当时所处的阶段。5万辆的年产量,放到全球9000万辆的年销量里,占比不到0.06%。1.5亿升汽油听起来很多,换算成全球石油消费量也只是很小一部分。
马斯克自己也很清楚。他说,每年9000万辆新车和卡车里电动车不到0.2%,要把世界转向可持续能源,还有很长的路要走。这件事才刚刚开始。
组织能力的变化也值得看一眼。从600辆到5万辆,五年增长超过80倍。这个速度对制造体系、供应链、售后网络都是极限压力测试。特斯拉那几年交付延迟、服务网点不足的抱怨,和这个增速是同一件事的两面。
15000人这个规模,放在传统车企里还只是零头。丰田、大众的员工数都是几十万。特斯拉当时还是一个用软件公司的方式组织起来的制造企业,效率高,但抗风险能力也弱。产能一旦出问题,现金流很快就会紧张。
香港的充电难题,先升级存量
提问环节第一个问题就很硬。提问者说,特斯拉在香港很成功,但大多数车主没法装自己的充电桩,公共充电设施不好,超级充电网络的扩张速度跟不上车辆增长,长此以往充电会变成障碍赛。他问马斯克怎么解决。
马斯克的回答分三层。
第一层,跟政府合作升级现有公共充电站。他了解到香港大概有800到1000个公共充电点,但功率偏低。正确的做法是把它们升级到更高功率,同时向其他品牌的电动车开放。特斯拉愿意提供技术支持。
第二层,改建筑法规。理想情况下,如果有人在大楼里提出充电需求,建筑方应该有义务提供。
最好的充电方式,是在你给手机充电的地方给车充电。(马斯克)
这条建议指向长期体验。每天回家插上,第二天满电出门。要去第三个地方专门充电,体验就差了一截。
第三层,长途场景另说,那靠超级充电网络解决。
这套解法里有个判断:面对基础设施不足,先升级存量,而不是只建增量。香港寸土寸金,新建充电站选址极难,把已有的800到1000个低功率桩升级,是更现实的路。
800到1000个充电点听起来不少,但摊到全香港的电动车保有量上,比例立刻变得紧张。公共桩功率低,充一台车要几个小时,周转率上不去,排队就会成为常态。这是所有高密度城市都会遇到的算术题。
马斯克还说了一句挺大的话:香港人均电动车数量可能会是世界第一,这意味着香港会率先趟出"大量电动车接入电网怎么办""充电怎么组织"这些问题的答案,给全世界做样本。
这个判断后来没完全兑现。2017年之后香港调整了电动车税收优惠,销量增速明显放缓。但"高密度城市是电动车最好的试验场"这个想法,在别的地方被验证了。新加坡、深圳、挪威的奥斯陆,走的都是类似的路。
顺带说一句,特斯拉当时在大中华区的布局是15家门店、7个主要城市、数百个超级充电桩,以及数量更多的目的地充电桩。澳门计划在当年年底开店。这个网络密度,放在2016年已经算靠前。
右舵Model X,和车载App的取舍
一位老车主问右舵版Model X什么时候能见到。马斯克说,Model X的量产大约在2016年年中启动,右舵版希望能在夏天交付。
还有人问Model S什么时候能下载App。马斯克的回答挺有意思:与其自己建一套App生态,更合理的做法是让iPhone和安卓手机上的App投射到中控屏上。
这个取舍放到今天看是对的。车企自建应用商店,最后大多变成几个视频和音乐App的集合,开发者没动力,用户也不买账。让手机生态直接映射到车机,省事得多。
这段问答里还能看出一件事:特斯拉当时对CarPlay和Android Auto的态度是暧昧的。它既不想把中控完全交给手机,也不愿自建生态,最后选了"投射"这条路。这条路后来走得很慢,车机生态到今天仍是车企的心病。
右舵市场是另一个长期问题。香港、英国、日本、澳大利亚、印度,这些市场加起来不小,但产线要为右舵单独排产,成本高,节奏慢。特斯拉当时的策略是先满足左舵大市场,右舵往后排。Model X的右舵版从宣布到真正大规模交付,中间还拖了一段时间。
回看这场演讲
这场演讲过去快十年了。回头看,马斯克当时讲的几件事,有的兑现了,有的还在路上。
他说香港会成为电动车之都,这句话在2016年到2017年确实接近现实,后来随着税收优惠调整,增速慢了下来。他说Autopilot会随着软件更新变好,这件事一直在发生。他说Model 3会把价格打下来,2017年交付,后来成为全球最畅销的电动车之一。
但这场演讲里最耐读的部分,是他怎么想问题。
一个新技术品类要起来,绕不开一道坎:它得先是好产品,然后才轮得到讲它的好处。电动车如果只是环保,永远只能卖给一小撮人;只有先变成最快的车、最安全的车、最省心的车,才可能进入主流。这个顺序不能颠倒。
基础设施的解法也是同样的思路。与其等着新建,不如先看存量能不能升级;与其抱怨规则不合理,不如直接去推动规则改。这两件事都不酷,但都比等着强。
至于Autopilot那段,最有价值的是他对命名的解释。一个功能叫什么是产品设计的一部分,它决定了用户的心理预期,也决定了出事之后的责任怎么划。
还有那个被忽略的细节:0.2%。马斯克在演讲里两次提到这个数字,一次是开头,一次是结尾。他知道自己站在一个极早的起点上,所以把"这只是开始"说了不止一遍。这种对阶段的清醒判断,比任何一句豪言都更有信息量。
这些判断放到今天,仍然成立。
- 评估一个新技术品类,先问它有没有做出同价位最好的产品;环保、效率这类附加价值,排在性能和体验之后。
- 做硬件产品,从第一天就预留OTA能力,把卖出当成服务的起点,软件迭代的节奏要比硬件换代快一个数量级。
- 涉及安全的功能,命名要用用户已经理解的类比,责任边界写进交互和说明书,别把辅助功能包装成自动驾驶。
- 进入基础设施薄弱的城市,先盘点存量设施能不能升级,再谈新建;同时去推动建筑法规这类隐性规则。
- 舆论场上坏消息的传播速度大约是好消息的五倍,产品团队要主动设计数据披露机制,用统计分布讲事实,别等个案发酵。
- 平台型硬件的应用生态,优先考虑把手机生态投射进来,自建生态的投入产出比通常不划算。
- 判断一家公司的长期走向,别只看它这一年的销量,看它敢不敢在品类占比不到1%的时候,把路线图讲到第三代产品。
0:09Mr owners in the crowd tonight is that right yes all right great thank you thanks for your long time support of Tesla and also some Model S owners thank you for your support Hong Kong one of the fastest expanding markets for Tesla worldwide so I'm John McNeal the president of worldwide sales and I know that you came here to see Elon Musk so let me without any further delay about this month
0:40hey welcome everybody so thanks for coming and I know this number of long-time pairs of supporters in the card so thanks for your face from the beginning you know from Roadster Model S and everything and so it's going to tell you about what our plans are in in Hong Kong and and yeah it's we got big plans so
1:07as as I think you may know the the goal of Tesla is to accelerate the Advent of sustainable transport so to do whatever we can to to have the have a sustainable future happen sooner rather than later so we started off with the Roadster back in 2008 it's a low volume obviously high price now with the model S and X which are mid price mid volume and then in about two years we expect to have the model 3 which is a lower price higher volume car so that the overarching goal though is just to accelerate the Advent of sustainable transport and you know
1:47and to help other companies do that as well which is why we open source our patents last year [Music] we tried very hard to make an electric car be the best car it was really important because the previously people had the idea of electric cars being like a golf cart like something that was slow and ugly and low range we had to show that electric car could actually be the best car that could be fast it could be a great have great handling look good have long range this was very important to break them all to get rid of the idea that an electric car is not a good car and the results were quite quite good 98 of owners would buy
2:37the model S again there were one car of the year and the consumer report said it was the best car that they've ever tested the [Applause] so we start off with with safety and achieving five stars across the board the model S this still has the highest safety rating of any car ever tested it's a very well in that front we have a longer crumple Zone than any car in any gasoline car because there's no engine in the front a very rigid cabin and a low center of gravity because of the battery pack being in the floor pattern
3:19and then it's also all-wheel drive it can make it to 100 kilometers in 103 seconds it has a range of almost 500 kilometers so these were really really important characteristics to achieve in an electric car to show that electric car could be a real substitute for a gasoline car and then with over there updates the car keeps improving over time so instead of buying a car and having the software be static and unchanging that this would actually improve over time then with autopilot which come on [Music] we haven't meeting with the government tomorrow hopefully [Applause]
4:13well we're gonna have some conversations and hopefully they will consider allowing us to release autopilities so anyway but i'm cautiously optimistic that it'll be a good good meetings tomorrow anyway this is going to keep getting better over time with the software updates and and we'll take it as far as the sensor Suite will allow so I think which is actually pretty far and that's combining the the camera the radar the sonar and GPS
4:54it's with maybe showing like some of the key statistics in in 2004 Tesla was just five people and now we're almost 15 000. and five years ago we're making about 600 cars a year and now it's 50 000 cars a year so it's it's good progress I think and and and as part of the fact that we were saved over 150 million liters of gasoline [Applause] [Music] so it is where we are in Greater China the we have 15 stores and in seven major cities several hundred superchargers and even more destination charges and we're opening up in Macau towards the end of this year I actually think Hong Kong will probably be the leading study in the world for electric cars wow
5:54[Applause] and and yeah so I think it's going to be really a Leading Light because I I think it'll actually have more EVS per capita than any any other City which means we'll Pioneer figuring out how to do charging how to handle the large number of electric cars on the grid one of these issues which will then be a good example for the rest of the world yeah I think Hong Kong's the perfect City for electric vehicles it's that sense of movement that sense of dynamism the Hong Kong people they want to go everywhere fast [Music] Tesla's really taken off me it just they make sense [Music] the number of Tesla is on the street I'm seeing are just you know that bowl
6:50triple now you see easily dozen Teslas on the roads every single day [Music] when I test drove it I just couldn't stop thinking about the car afterwards It's a combination of the practicality of it the performance all the cut connection technology inside the vehicle we've got a five-person family every day I feel comfortable abstract and safe is coming cars on today if not the safest [Music] the moment you put your thought on the paddle is off a very good sports car Tesla has installed superchargers in Union locations so people can charge while they're out shopping I love it when you have this you know Tesla only sign you don't have to worry about
7:40running out of battery [Music] convert 100 to electric transportation we do want to reduce the carbon footprint especially here in Hong Kong we need to preserve the air quality and really where electric car that roadside pollution driving a Tesla and it's entirely quiet and there's just no emissions it's so smooth they're so quiet you're almost in this your own little bubble when you're inside the car amidst all this noise around
8:13[Music] [Applause] thanks to the customers that were part of the video 2016 coming up the second half the year we've got model X so that'll be coming to Hong Kong I've got a huge new service center that we're building so it should help reduce some of the service time challenges and they're also expanding the the charge networks substantially but it's always important to remember that this is just the beginning as over 90 million new cars and trucks produced every year and less than 0.2 percent are electric vehicles so there's still a huge huge way to go to transition the world to sustainable energy so
9:14I think that's that's something with with bearing in mind it's really just the very beginning so but I we do expect that Hong Kong will be the leader of any city in the world for sustainable transport all right that's the introductory remarks I'm going to answer a few questions you know that like Tesla is a huge success in Hong Kong but however like most of our car owners cannot install their own charges and we don't have a very good public charging infrastructure the pace of the super trading Network expansion cannot keep up with the growth system will become the an obstacle course in Hong Kong so how do you think you can also become this challenge thank
10:01you sure what so that's a great point so in my meetings tomorrow with the government I'm actually going to be discussing this exact subject we want to try to upgrade some of the the public charging stations to higher power and and make them available to other part companies as well but we really want to work with the government and offer our technology for upgrading the public charging spots because my understanding is that there's maybe as many as 800 or even a thousand public charging spots but they're low power so we're better I think the right solution is to upgrade them to higher power and also to have the regulations the building regulations
10:46ideally require that if somebody requests charging and they're building you've got the this obligation to provide it because in the long run the best way to charge your car is to charge at the same place you charge your phone if you have to go to a third third location that's generally undesirable most convenient is where your phone is charged that's where your car should be charged except for long distance driving of course but that's that's the basic idea so regulatory changes and then and then providing whatever technology and support that we can have from a Tesla standpoint to the government to upgrade the public charging state
11:35firstly before my question I'd just like to say in the last five years we've had George okay we've had Jerome come and but today's really special thank you so much well thank you for supporting president so as well as the Roadster Model S I've got a model X on reservation so of course the question is what is the plan for right hand drive model X and when are we going to see it well the plan is to vote for X's is we
12:07should be selling production of those around the middle of this year so hopefully this summer is when we should be delivering the right hand drive axes hello I'm sorry it's always hard to stop by the sign all right I'm here with charged Hong Kong which is Hong Kong's charity represent EVS again thank you for coming specific question about autopilot one of the most successful campaigns online for in the last couple of years was for Blendtec I don't know if you saw that one can you blend it there's simple demonstrations of the technology I've been sort of waiting with basic breath to see Cascade of good news about autopilot and the situations that
13:01saved and all we've seen has been the disaster movies is there something to share or because for every bad news we need five times more good news to balance it psychologically is there anything that Tesla could be sharing well I mean there is there are a lot of sort of interventions that occur that we're aware of but we we haven't really asked customers if we could share their share their information I'm sure many of them would agree actually it's a good point you know we can we don't want to put any pressure like no pressure If you want to share it
13:41yeah maybe that if we can sort of ask people in kind of a really low pressure way each of us I think has had us all repeat playback for at least a week yeah and there are many I mean there are thousands more so that's a good idea maybe we should just ask that's the point I mean whether there were case studies or if you could do aggregated statistics and I'm sure I for one would volunteer if I was ever saved by my models actually the statistics bring something out that I think is brand in a statistical way maybe the right move and I've just actually recently saw a just a histogram of of for example the lane position for autopilot versus non-order pilot and the the probability
14:32of distribution is much tighter if you're if you're an autopilot then then for if it's manual driving it's actually remarkable how much people bury in their Lane if it's manual driving quite a lot actually so it's I think maybe releasing that would be a good idea just to show like look it's it's actually a tighter approach position Distribution on autopilot than not autopilot but what I can share on the record is in the few short weeks that we had autopilot I was arriving much more refreshed yeah it is it I mean like the reason we called water apart was to have people think of it in the same way that people think of an air an airplane autopilot which is not to
15:18say that the pilot can abdicate responsibility or go to sleep that would be concerning but but but rather that it's a workload reduction so just it it it eventually makes you makes it easier to fly the plane and and to drive the car with the orders to your function Plus on a personal note I did complete the police class one driving test back for safety and and I can absolutely say that it requires much less concentration and I'm much more aware of the situation around me I'm much less stressed by traffic jams and so on so I want it back we're doing our best all right I'll take one more question then hand it over to John
16:06okay we're right sure I really want to go okay sure just to repeat the comments the preface was you have an uncle in Australia a father-in-law sorry in Australia yeah and it likes that you said yeah okay so he he loves using autopilot in Australia yeah and so he it wasn't all the things the autopilot is a better driver than he is so that's that's a good compliment and the question was with respect to apps will we when we'll be able to download apps and whatnot into the Model S [Music] you know and as we've sort of thought about it more the logical thing to do from an app standpoint is to maybe allow
17:41apps on your iPhone or Android to project onto the center display as opposed to trying to create a new app ecosystem so that's that's probably going to be our Focus in the future is is enable you to project apps from your phone onto the center screen that's the it seems like logical move all right well once again thanks everyone for coming and I hope you have a great night [Applause]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版