发布会·中文精读

观看:马斯克出席 2020 火星学会活动直播

WATCH: Elon Musk at 2020 Mars Society Event - Livestream

B 站版本为网友搬运,时间点可能差几秒
中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

马斯克在那场直播里给了一个数字,我反复看了几遍。

全球所有一次性火箭加起来的入轨能力,大约是 500 到 600 吨。就算明天世界末日,所有人拼命造,撑死也就 1000 吨。

而要把 100 万吨物资送上火星表面,得先在低地球轨道攒出 500 万吨的运力。

1000 吨对 500 万吨。五千分之一。不到 0.1%。

他的原话是,一次性火箭「绝对愚蠢」,人们应该停止浪费时间。这话是 2020 年说的,火星学会(Mars Society)的年度活动,9000 人在线听,全程一个多小时。前半段马斯克主讲,后半段由火星学会创始人罗伯特·祖布林(Robert Zubrin)接手答疑。

把这两段拼起来看,SpaceX 那几年几乎所有决策的账本都能对上。

火星城市的验收标准:飞船停飞之后还能不能活

主持人开场就问了一个很基础的问题:你当初为什么要创办 SpaceX。

马斯克的回答没有绕弯。人类要成为多行星物种,要成为太空文明,才能弄清楚宇宙到底是怎么回事,才能确保意识延续下去。就目前所知,我们是唯一的生命。很多人相信有外星人,但他没见过任何迹象。

然后他给了一个判断标准,这段话是整场演讲里最硬的骨架:

如果从地球出发的飞船因为任何原因停止到来,火星上的城市会不会消亡?如果会,我们就还没到安全的位置。(马斯克)

停飞的原因可以是小行星撞击,可以是核战争,可以是任何事。标准只有一个:断了补给,那座城市还能不能自己活下去。

所以目标不能是「送几个人上去」,也不能是「建一个基地」。目标必须是自给自足的城市。他把这个叫做酸性测试(acid test)。

接下来他提到了大过滤器。人类能不能在第三次世界大战之前,把火星城市建成自给自足的状态?他的判断很直接,战后建成的概率很低。所以时间不是充裕的,是紧的。

「坦白说,文明现在看起来不太强,有点摇摇欲坠。」这是他的原话。

很多人把火星计划理解成一张逃生船票。马斯克专门否定了这个说法。如果火星还不能自给自足,那搬到另一个地方只是换个地方死掉,那不算救生艇。而且他预计,让火星完全自给自足这件事,大概率不会在他有生之年完成。

那这件事的意义在哪?他的回答有两层。一层是把整个文明的存在性风险降到最低。另一层听起来更朴素:人类需要一个让人早上愿意起床的未来。永远困在地球上,等着某次不可避免的灭绝事件,这件事既压抑又无趣。

成为太空文明,是他认为足够让所有人兴奋起来的那个未来。

倒推运力:五千分之一的差距

主持人接着追问,从猎鹰 9 到猎鹰重型,再到 Starship,这条设计路线是怎么来的。

马斯克先纠正了提问方式。你先得说清楚目标是什么,然后才能拿各种设计去对照目标打分。否则你根本没法解释为什么 A 方案比 B 方案好。

目标定下来之后,剩下的全是算术。

要让火星自给自足,需要多少吨物资?他给的范围是 10 万吨,也许 100 万吨,含人在内。按 5 比 1 的换算,每 5 吨送上低地球轨道,大约能有 1 吨送到火星。那么 100 万吨到火星,意味着 400 万到 500 万吨的有效载荷要先进地球轨道。

这个量级一摆出来,后面的结论就是自动的。

一次性火箭的全部产能是 500 到 600 吨。缺口是五千分之一。他说,「我们连所需能力的 0.1% 都不到」。

他举了三个类比,语气明显不耐烦。如果有人向你推销一次性飞机,你会笑到把他赶出房间。一次性汽车,一样。一次性马,你会怀疑他精神状态有问题。

「所有这些交通工具都是可重复使用的。可重复使用是必需的。」

可重复使用的轨道火箭难在哪?他给了一组很具体的数字。很多聪明人投入了大量精力,能做到入轨质量的 2% 到 3%。真正史诗级的火箭,可能到 4%。

所以设计上要反着推:先做出一个在一次性形态下能到 4% 的火箭,然后拿出一半的性能预算去换可重复使用,最后净得 2%。这个账算不过来,整个方案就不成立。

猎鹰 1 号当年试过给一级装降落伞,结果一级再入时像撞上一堵水泥墙,直接炸了。他一开始怪降落伞,后来才想明白,是自己的问题。高马赫数进入大气,温度和力量都极端,必须专门设计减速手段。

一次性火箭为什么荒唐,火箭为什么越大越划算

猎鹰 9 号比猎鹰 1 号大得多,这不是顺手放大,是被规模经济逼的。

火箭小到一定程度,基本上只能把航电系统送上天。假设你要把一枚 10 吨级的火箭送入轨道,有效载荷大概率是零,因为电子设备本身就吃掉了全部配额。

火箭变大之后,箭体在长,脑子不用跟着长。航电系统的重量占比会迅速趋近于零。

还有一个更少人知道的好处,他叫它规格优势(gauge advantages)。东西做得太小,材料厚度很难控制精准,铸件有最小壁厚,板材有误差下限。火箭大到一定尺寸,就不再受这个限制,壁厚的百分比精度可以做得非常好。

他顺手给了两个日常类比。运货要用半挂卡车,不是一堆小卡车。跨海运集装箱要用大船,不会有人给每个集装箱装个舷外机让它自己漂过去。

尺寸重要,完全可重复使用更重要。猎鹰 9 号花巨大代价搞定了助推器回收,整流罩现在也基本能重复使用。

但马斯克说,猎鹰 9 号在自己的架构里已经接近局部最优解了。燃气发生器循环、煤油加液氧、3.6 米直径。直径之所以卡在 3.6 米,是因为公路运输的宽度限制,再大物流成本就爆炸。而一枚又长又细的火箭质量效率很差,为了扛住弯矩,壳体会被迫加厚。

煤油也不是正确的燃料。到这里,话题自然转到了甲烷。

甲烷:喷得快,还能在火星上造

他用最朴素的语言解释了火箭方程。气体从尾部喷出去的速度越快,火箭飞得越远。推进剂占整枚火箭的质量比例越高,火箭飞得越远。

就这么两条。

甲烷的排气速度比煤油高,这是第一个理由。第二个理由更关键:甲烷能在火星上制造。

如果返程燃料和氧气都能就地生产,就不用从地球背过去。这一点直接决定了整个火星计划的成本结构。

还有第三个不那么显眼的好处:氧燃比。煤油的氧燃质量比大约是 2.5 比 1,甲烷可以到 3.5 比 1。火箭里大部分质量本来就是氧气,氧气密度大、价格低。他半开玩笑地说,地球上到处都是制氧厂,浮游植物天天在制氧,氧气的成本基本就等于电的成本。

顺便科普了一段化学。煤油就是 RP-1,本质上是喷气燃料的严格等级版。甲烷是 CH4,一个碳配四个氢。氧气写作 O2,因为氧原子成对结合。

Starship 的起飞推力大约是土星五号的两倍,载荷能力差不多。多出来的推力全部用来换可重复使用、更低的成本和原位推进剂生产。他总结说,这套设计是自洽的。

时间表和他的信心刻度

主持人问出了所有人都想问的那串问题:什么时候高空试飞,什么时候入轨,什么时候第一次送货去火星,什么时候送人。

马斯克先声明,这不是他藏着日期的意思,是真的在未知领域里探索,以下都只是猜测。

然后他给出了带百分比的判断。

Starship 在明年(2021 年)入轨,他有 80% 到 90% 的信心。

把飞船和助推器都收回来,信心降到 50% 到 60%。他把这件事形容为「更悬」。在真正搞定大气层返回和着陆之前,大概率会损失几艘飞船。助推器他希望一艘都别丢,因为发动机太贵。早期的助推器试飞只装 2 到 4 台发动机,不是 28 台。28 台是很多发动机。

高频次飞行,他估计要到 2022 年。

然后他说了一句听起来像管理口号、其实是硬约束的话:必须确保创新速度在加快,而不是在放缓。

如果创新速度不是接近指数级增长,我们到不了火星。纯线性根本到不了。(马斯克)

他补了一句自嘲:如果是纯线性,他早就死了。

按指数曲线走,无人火星任务大概在四年后。火星转移窗口每 26 个月开一次,今年一次,两年后一次,四年后一次。他认为赶得上第二个窗口是有胜算的。

目标本身就是方法论

主持人问,从 2012 年到现在,猎鹰 9 号复用、猎鹰重型、载人龙飞船、卫星星座,中间还夹着一个 Starship,这种创新速度的方法论是什么。

马斯克的回答是「我真不知道」。但紧接着,他把答案绕回了目标。

一个足够大的目标,会变成一个强制函数(forcing function)。如果目标只是把一些卫星送进轨道,那你没有理由去搞完全且快速的可重复使用。他特意强调「快速」和「完整」这两个限定词:可重复使用只有在又快又彻底的时候才有意义。

在这个目标之下,轨道加注是必需品,火星推进剂生产也是必需品。少一样,整条路走不通。

反过来,如果目标只是击败洛克希德和波音,那早就赢了。他甚至觉得奇怪:这两家公司造的是可重复使用的飞机,卖飞机的时候绝不会说「这架 737 只能用一次」,可卖火箭的时候,一次性他们卖得很安心。

如果目标只是保持常规卫星发射的领先,那成长曲线会是对数形的,今年 10 次,明年 12 次,对手 6 次,慢慢爬。

但目标是让生命多行星化,时间就是硬约束。所以他说,我们瞄准的是火星,不只是月球。

瞄准火星,不只是瞄准月球。除非别人也在瞄准火星,否则他们在发射几颗卫星这种平常事上,不可能有竞争力。(马斯克)

意愿和方法:等一百万人既想去又去得起

主持人问,火星学会能帮上什么忙。

马斯克给了一个集合论的答案。要有自给自足的火星城市,需要两个集合的交集:一个集合是想去火星的人,另一个集合是能负担得起的人。负担的方式可以是自己出钱,可以是找到赞助,可以是政府出资,也可以是贷款。

当这个交集达到大约 100 万人,火星城市就会出现。

他把这件事浓缩成一句话:我们需要意愿,也需要方法(the will and the way)。

主持人接得很快:你提供方法,我们提供意愿。

马斯克说,对,就是这样。

后来有观众问,年轻人喜欢火星但不知道怎么帮忙,能做什么。他把这个「意愿」讲得更具体了。

很多人在派对上、在朋友之间,根本不会把火星当成话题。所以任何人只要坚定地为火星发声,就已经在起作用。他的建议是把这件事变成日常对话的一部分,在网上说,在饭桌上说。

他给了一个比例:人类应该把至少 1% 的资源投在这件事上。

1% 不会从根本上改变生活质量。这个数字远低于医疗支出,他说,大概比化妆品还少。而 1% 就足够让生命变成多行星的。

但他要的不只是钱,是注意力。至少 1% 的谈话时间在谈这件事,形成一个临界规模。SpaceX 会努力提供方法,一旦方法被证明可行,其他公司也会跟进。

火星第一铲土:选址、机器人和推进剂工厂

问答环节有人问,火星最好的着陆点在哪。

马斯克说自己也不是特别确定,但可以讲清楚筛选标准。中纬度,大概率在北半球,靠近冰,不能离太阳太远否则太阳能不够用,海拔要低,这样大气制动效果最好。他点名了自己偏好的一片区域,在北半球中纬度,气压相对高,附近有冰,具体位置还得实地勘测。

第二个问题问的是第 2 到第 10 次任务的优先级,是探索、基建还是科学。

他的回答没有犹豫:第一要务是建推进剂工厂。

机器人可以先扔一批上去,这不是问题。他描述得挺具体:基本上就是一台太阳能遥控车,装腿也行,SpaceX 提供通信中继,你坐在家里用电脑连上去就能开自己的车。

有人担心地球微生物污染火星。他不太当回事。能在火星上活下来的东西都极其顽强,那里又冷,紫外线又强。他的判断是,火星环境比地球上任何地方都严酷,不用太担心地球带过去的东西。

真正的难点在化工厂。挖冰得到水,从大气里取二氧化碳,水和二氧化碳合成甲烷和氧气。原理不难,难的是能量需求巨大,而且要把这套装置做得足够可靠。

工厂跑通了,才有资格谈科学探索。

给想做工程师的孩子,以及尼古拉·特斯拉的假设

有一个 13、14 岁的女孩通过主持人提问。她叫 Dara,想当工程师,想造星舰和机器人,梦想是进 SpaceX,问应该重点学什么。

马斯克的回答很宽:什么工程都需要。不一定是航空航天,电子、机械、电气、软件都行。化工也需要,推进剂工厂和推进剂储罐就等着化工的人来做。

他单独推荐了物理。理由是物理提供了最好的批判性思维工具。

另一个问题问招聘标准,尤其是工程师。

他说只看一件事:卓越能力的证据。高中毕业还是大学毕业,不重要。

然后他讲了一个自己都觉得很讽刺的假设。如果尼古拉·特斯拉(Nikola Tesla)来特斯拉应聘,他们会不会给面试机会?他不太确定。这家伙来自东欧某个听都没听过的学校,举止有点怪。「我们大概会想,要不要给他一个面试?」

他说正确的反应应该是:这人超级聪明,他想要什么?要多少钱都给。

「但现实是,招聘过滤器有时候会出错。」

隧道、月球、金星,以及一艘通用飞船

有人问,无聊公司(The Boring Company)是不是就是为了造能在火星上挖洞的盾构机。

马斯克说不是,这家公司起初就是个玩笑。有五年多时间,他逢人就说,有没有人愿意开一家隧道公司。他认为隧道在缓解城市交通上有巨大空间,很多街道可以改成公园,车全部停到地下去。

所有人都以为他在开玩笑。

他顺手怼了一句所谓的交通专家:洛杉矶和华盛顿到现在还是交通噩梦,你们要是有好主意,怎么还是这样。

城市要立体化,只有两条路,上天或者入地。空中方案的问题很实在:任何能载人的飞行器都会产生巨大噪音和风力,还可能掉在你头上,隐私也没了。你在自家后院坐着,有人从头顶飞过,体验并不好。隧道全天候,不受天气影响,没有隐私问题,也安全。

拉斯维加斯的第一条实用隧道,他说一两个月后开放,希望赶上消费电子展。

火星上挖洞也有用,但系统必须做得极轻。地球上不太在乎质量,去火星,质量就是一切。

关于时间表,他又给了几个刻度。轨道加注演示,大约两年内有机会。月球版原型,大概两三年。一旦轨道加注跑通,一次就能往月球送 100 吨有效载荷。火星要再等几年,因为窗口每 26 个月才开一次。

有人问 Starship 能不能去金星和外行星。

他说这是一艘通用飞船。只要有固体表面能着陆,它就能去。金星大气密度极高,也很热,但正因为密度高,可以用某种飞艇浮在上层大气里,这种东西在地球大气里浮不起来。水星太热。谷神星和小行星可以去。木星的卫星可以去,但辐射很高。土星、柯伊伯带、奥尔特云,都属于更远的将来。

有了推进剂补给站,就能在太阳系里一站一站跳。它不是星际飞船,去不了别的恒星系统。但得先迈出成为多行星物种这一步,那一步会形成改进航天的强制函数,最终才会有跨恒星的技术。

祖布林补上的技术细节:加注、发动机和隔热瓦

马斯克下线后,祖布林接手答了十几分钟。这部分技术含量更高,补上了马斯克没展开的细节。

有人问轨道加注到底怎么做。祖布林的解释是:两艘 Starship 底部对接,朝加油船的方向轻微加速,让燃料在「上方」,然后靠重力把推进剂排进另一艘。

他补了一个甲烷氧气方案容易被忽略的优势。这两种推进剂储存温度相同,两个储罐可以紧密贴合,不存在隔热矛盾。换成煤油加液氧就没这么舒服,煤油在液氧的温度下会冻住。

关于 Starship 最难的技术点,他提到助推器底部的发动机数量,31 台,听说可能减到 28 台左右,但终归是 30 台这个量级。发动机多,容错能力强,几台熄火可以继续飞。但如果有一台爆炸,后果会很糟。推力是土星五号的两倍,还要可重复使用。

上面级要返回轨道,隔热是另一个坎。他拿航天飞机做对比。航天飞机的隔热瓦是 1970 年代的技术,每次落地后翻新要花很长时间,哥伦比亚号就是因为隔热瓦脱落而在再入时解体。NASA 几十年没有升级这套系统,马斯克是从当下最先进的技术起步的。

他给了一句评价:这是自冯·布劳恩(Wernher von Braun)以来最好的一支火箭团队。

有人问电推进火箭会不会在一百年内出现。祖布林说早就在用了,黎明号探测器就是靠电推进在小行星带里转悠。问题是推力太低。时间不紧、速度增量需求大的任务适合它。快速往返火星指望不上,那要靠降低发射成本、多带推进剂。除非出现功率重量比极高的太空核电源或者聚变电源,电推进会一直是辅助技术。

还有人问,是走月球中转再去火星,还是直接去火星。他的回答很干脆:想去火星,就得去火星。去月球有去月球的理由,但月球不是去火星的路。

关于火星第一批定居点的形态,他不看好高楼。他的设想是地下大规模生活空间,像一整套地铁系统,地表建穹顶。人大概 20% 的时间在地表穹顶晒太阳,80% 的时间在地下睡觉做事,完全屏蔽太空辐射。

他特别强调,火星殖民不可能只靠 SpaceX。SpaceX 承担的是最大的一块单一挑战,运输系统。剩下还有推进剂制造、自动化食物工厂、各种省力机械、机器人、人工智能、能源技术。火星长期人手短缺,氘的储量按氢的比例算又是地球的六倍,聚变如果有突破,火星是很好的落点。

博卡奇卡不是造一艘船,是造船坞

祖布林二月去过博卡奇卡(Boca Chica)。当时那里大约 250 人,他估计现在翻了三倍,半年内还会再翻三倍。

他说了一句很准的话:马斯克不只是在开发一艘飞船,他在开发一个船坞。

Starship 除了性能指标,从设计之初就是为了量产。这是一款量产的、完全可重复使用的重型运载火箭。他要的是数量。现在原型机的下线速度大约是每月一枚,他准备好承受损失。

这一点和 NASA 的模式完全不同。航天飞机失败一次就是灾难,两次失败让整个项目元气大伤,人的代价和财务的代价都极其沉重。所以 NASA 承受不起失败。而马斯克在直播里明说,前几艘大概率会炸。

祖布林判断,等真正启动载人火星计划的时候,不会只有四艘 Starship,可能有一百艘。

他也提到,马斯克早年是火星学会的董事会成员。后来他觉得,开一家发射公司去打开太空边疆,能做成的事更多。他给自己挑了最难的那道题。

祖布林最后说,现在需要的是招募更多的马斯克,去解决太空核动力、生命支持、自动化农业这些问题。这些难题背后是有钱可赚的,而且有很多钱在等着。

直播快结束时他说,2020 年这堆烂事里唯一的好消息是载人龙飞船,那是黑暗里的一点光。他希望 12 月之前能看到 Starship 冲到平流层。

把这场对谈从头到尾捋一遍,会发现马斯克讲的其实不是火箭,是目标怎么倒推设计,设计怎么倒推产能,产能怎么倒推时间表。中段那些工程细节,全都是从这个逻辑里长出来的。

对做技术的人来说,这场演讲真正能拿走的东西,是一套判断标准。你怎么知道自己手上的项目在正确的轨道上?看它有没有形成强制函数。目标足够大,方案会被逼到激进;目标太小,方案会停在舒适区,每年提升 10%,然后告诉自己这叫稳健。

下面几条是看完之后可以直接动手的事。

  • 把你手上项目的目标写下来,然后做一次酸性测试:如果关键资源断掉,这个东西还能不能自己运转。如果不能,说明目标定低了,或者方案还停在舒适区。
  • 做任何设计决策前,先把目标量化成数字。马斯克是先算出 100 万吨到火星、500 万吨到近地轨道,才得出结论说一次性火箭不可行。没有这个数字,争论会永远停在观点层面。
  • 对照检查你所在领域的「一次性火箭」。那些所有人都觉得理所当然、但换个行业看就荒唐到可笑的做法,往往就是最大的机会。
  • 如果你在做硬件或者重资产项目,算一遍规模账。小系统里固定成本占比极高,放大之后效率会非线性提升,这条规律在很多行业都成立。
  • 如果你是工程师或者想成为工程师,别只盯着一个方向。物理课值得认真上,它训练的是提问和拆解的能力,这个能力跨行业通用。
  • 如果你关心某件长期的事但觉得使不上劲,先把它变成日常话题。马斯克说的 1% 不是捐款额,是注意力份额。一个议题从没人讨论到有人讨论,本身就是进展。
  • 如果你在招聘,回头审一遍你的筛选器。学历、学校、履历这些信号,可能正在把尼古拉·特斯拉挡在门外。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00Elon, you need no introduction, but for those who don't know, you are the founder and chief engineer of SpaceX and a long time friend of the Mars Society, and we're delighted to have you back. We've got 9,000 people registered to hear you today. All right, cool. Sounds good. Okay, so we should like change this perspective. Let's see if I can change the perspective. Is that better or is that worse?

0:24I think you were better before. Okay. [laughter] Okay. So listen why don't we just start out with the basics. You started SpaceX to make humanity multilanetary. why do you see that as a critical goal? Yes. I think we we want to be on track to become a multipass species and and a space civilization in order to find out what the universe is all about like what you know and ensure the continuence of consciousness as we know it. As far as we know, we're the only life. I mean, people think there's aliens, but honestly, I haven't seen any sign of aliens.

1:05so as far as we know, we're the only the the only life u we could be the only life. So, let's put it that way. And we need to take the set of actions that are most likely to make the future good and result in the continuence of consciousness as we know it. Okay. So, okay. Well, obviously your your your means to that end is is to open the space frontier with reusable launch vehicles and you've gone through some partially reusable ones and now it's Starship. Can you explain the basically the line of thinking that led you to the Starship design?

1:43I forgot what I need to look at to look like I'm looking at the camera. [laughter] so let's see. Well, on the Starship front, we've gone through many iterations, starting from not really knowing how to build rockets at all, with with Falcon 1 and having four failures actually in reaching orbit. yeah, sorry, three failures and then the fourth one got to orbit. So, fourth one's a charm. so we only barely survived. I was at zero cash basically when we got that fourth one to orbit. and if that fourth one hadn't worked, we we would have been curtains.

2:20So, it's definitely not been smooth sailing. it's been a very difficult ride. with just a lot that has been discovered along the way. I mean, just just trying to figure out what questions to ask about the design was was quite difficult. I think it's helpful to have as the objective the creation of a

2:46self-sustaining city on Mars. I think this is this is has to be the objective, not simply a few people or a base, but a self-sustaining city. the acid test really is if the if the ships from Earth stop coming for any reason, does Mars die out for any reason? It could be from any Benol or it could be nuclear Armageddon. Doesn't matter. If the if the ship stop coming for any reason, does the city on Mars die out? If it does, we're not we're not in a secure place.

3:25so I mean I think this this really might come down to, you know, on the the great filter front, is this are we going to create a self-sustaining city on loss before or after World War II? And I think the probability of it being created after World War II hopefully that hopefully there's never World War II, but of after is low.

3:48So which try to create make the city self-sustaining before any possible World War II. This is just a risk. This is not you know I think sometimes people have difficulty dealing with with probabilities to see it this way or that way. But it's really we just face a series of probabilities. and there's some chance that we will have a giant war or a super volcano or you know a comet might hit the earth or we might just self-extinguish in some it might more of a more more of a whimper than a bang.

4:23and frankly right now civilization is not looking super strong. You know it's looking a little little rickety right now to be frank. Oh, would you say that it's it's more than a a lifeboat that it would make civilization more robust, clearly more able to divert asteroids from hitting the Earth and otherwise help.

4:51Yeah. it's not it's not an escape vehicle. It's it's a it's simply something that it's not like you can I mean unless mod is Mars is made self- sustaining which will probably not happen in my lifetime it is certainly not it's meaningless to have an escape you know lifeboat or or or escape hatch or something if you will you're simply moving to another place where you will soon die out that doesn't count.

5:23it's not much of a lifeboat really. so this is really about say minimizing existential risk for civilization as a whole and and then having an exciting future that you can look forward to and a future where we are a space fairing civilization and multilanet species is far more exciting than one where we are not.

5:50I mean that's an exciting future and being forever confined to Earth until some eventual extinction event is depressing and not fun. and we need things that make you want to get out of bed in the morning and be excited about the future. And I think being a space fairing civilization is one of those things that everyone get can get excited about.

6:11but but can you maybe just kind of lead people along the path that led you from the design of from Falcon 9 to Falcon Heavy, but now Starship is is is rather different than Falcon Heavy. yes, the engineering absolutely absolutely I didn't quite answer your original question. I the the you first have to say what what is the goal?

6:35and once you have what is the goal, you can then measure various designs against that goal. if otherwise you're saying how are you evaluating why is one design better than another? What's your goal? It's got to be a goal. So the goal is get enough tonnage to Mars to and enough people to make Mars self-sustaining as quickly as possible. So then you say, okay, let's back back out the math on this. We're going to need we're going to lot need a lot of tonnage. maybe I don't know 100,000 tons, maybe a million tons. So, you can't be fuffing around with these expandable rockets.

7:11They're a joke. They're they're absurd. Even Saturn 5 is tiny potatoes. we we need because if if you want to get like let's say first order approximation a million tons to the surface of Mars inclusive of people. you know that that means probably something around four or five million useful tons of payload in the into low earth orbit. You

7:39know, for every time you get to low with orbit, you're going to get four or five tons hopefully closer to five. It's it's you know, these this math is it's you really saw squeezing like tiny percentages. Let's say conf confidently if you got five tons to low Earth orbit, you can get one ton to Mars. That's that's confident. Maybe you can get maybe you only need four. Anyway, the point is you need 5 million tons into Earth orbit to get 1 million tons to Mars.

8:09Now, let's put this into perspective. total global capacity to orbit of all expandable rockets is around around five or 600 tons I think and and if you said okay the world's going to end if you do not increase your capacity perhaps they could do a thousand tons okay so that's five 5000th

8:36one 5,000th of what's needed ridiculous does you know it it's it's not even you know.1% would be you know 1,000 so way less than 0.1% we have way less than.1% of the capability needed to create a if if everyone went full tilt with expandable rockets expandable rockets are the are the absolute are just utterly stupid in my opinion utterly stupid they're complete waste of time. People should stop wasting their time. If you try to sell an expendable plane, people would laugh you out of the room. If you try to sell an expendable car, they would laugh you out of the room. If you try to sell an expendable horse, they would laugh you out of the room and think there's

9:25something wrong with you mentally. so all these things are reusable. It's essential to be reusable. Now creating a reusable rocket orbital rocket is very difficult. But doing a suborbital reusable rocket is easy. Doing a reusable orbital rocket is hard. even when a lot of smart people have put quite a bit of effort into it, they might get two or 3% of the lift of mass to low Earth orbit. and a really epic

9:53rocket would get four. I'm not sure I think anyone's ever gotten four. so but but you basically need to have something that in expendable form would probably get about 4% of its payload tool such that you can spend about half of that 4% on reusability and and still net out to around 2% of payload tool boot.

10:20so you have to make both the booster and the upper stage and the fairing everything reusable with Falcon 9. So, so with Falcon 1, we did actually attempt to do this. So, we had a parachute on the first stage, but really did not appreciate that that first stage was going to hit the atmosphere like a concrete wall. So, at first I got pretty mad at the parachutes fire until I realized, it's not their fault. We were just being ghouls.

10:42that that thing was exploding as soon as it it hit the atmosphere. and you know so you really got to do something to to ease the transition into the atmosphere at at at high mock number. It's very hot and there's a lot of force and a lot of heat. So then with Falcon 9 we made a bigger rocket. and that scale matters here because you do get basically economies of scale. You can't have a tiny rocket. there's a tiny rocket you basically just end up carrying your electronics to orbit. So your avionics, you know, so in a little rocket, you if if you're small enough, the the just your your avionics alone, ends up being a significant percentage of your, payload and and

11:32then you, you know, if you had a rocket that was, I don't know, trying to get a 10,000lb rocket, for example, or even a 10,000 kilogram rocket to orbit, I think you would basically get zero payload. now as you get bigger the the rocket gets bigger but the brain doesn't get bigger. The brain can stay the same size. So your avionics for example become a almost not almost 0% of the weight at a for a big rocket. then for big rockets you also get gauge advantages. So this is we're really in the nuances of rocket design and manufacturing here. If you things are very small it's difficult to get your gauge accurate. so the basically how thick is the material? like you want

12:16to do castings for example, there's a minimum gauge or thickness for a casting. there's a minimum kind of error bar on the you know on this material skins. even for a composite rocket, you've got you know you start hitting granularity issues as you get bigger. you no long you're no longer gauge limited. and you can get your your percentage accuracy on the thickness of walls and castings can be can be very good.

12:49these are nuances that I think almost no one appreciates, but suffice to say that there are advantages to size. and you can certainly see this in many walks of life where if you've got a truck that's carrying cargo, you it's more efficient to have a big semi-truck, not a bunch of little trucks. for ships, it would be pretty silly to see container ships, or containers going across the ocean one at a time with little outboard motors.

13:15That would be silly. You put them on a container ship. You have big ships, not little little tiny ships. so anyway, so size matters. It really does. and full reusability matters. So with with Falcon 9, after immense effort, we were able to achieve reusability of the booster. and we're mostly achieving reusability at this point with the fairing as well. but this is a this is a monumental effort.

13:49and I think within its architecture Falcon 9 is close to a local maximum. if you say you know gas generator cycle kerosene oxygen vehicle of this particular size with a a 12t or 3.6 m diameter which is which is that size for because of of road transport limitations. So you go bigger than that, you can transport it over the road and your logistics costs become extreme.

14:26so [sighs and gasps] but but having a long thin rocket is not very mass efficient. you you you end up having to have thicker skins to take out the bending moment. so and then and then having like kerosene is is not the right fuel. Methane is a much better fuel. You can get higher ISP.

14:48a specific impulse basically efficiency. I mean for for those who I think probably a lot of us who are listening know what the rocket equation is but in simple terms it's actually it's very simple it's like a rocket is going to go further if if the gas if it shoots the gas out of the end faster and if a bigger percentage of its mass is propellant obvious that's what the rocket equation says so shoot gas out faster in the right direction and increase the propellant

15:22the percentage of propellant that that's gonna get you go allow you to go further. with methane you can shoot out faster and and you can make it on Mars. You can make it on Mars for sure. exactly. So being able to to do institute propellant development is or production is very important. so you don't have to carry your return fuel with you or return fuel and oxygen. It's to me again like rockets are mostly oxygen or oxidizer. So, and there's there's some other subtle advantages with a oxygen methane system in that you can go to a higher percentage, a higher mass ratio of oxygen. So, with kerosene, you'd be at about roughly 2 and a half to one

16:11oxygen to to fuel mass ratio. With methane, you're more like three and a half to one. and you actually want that higher mass ratio because oxygen is very dense. and it's inexpensive. especially on Earth. So, you're going to, you know, you have all these plants just making oxygen all day long and plankton just making oxygen.

16:30never have to do anything. So, the cost of oxygen is basically the cost of electricity. anyway, so going from Falcon going from you know kerosene which is basically the same as jet fuel. It's like RP1 rocket propellant grade kerosene is just a tighter grade of jet fuel. you want to go from that to something which has where the gas shoots out faster and that's methane and where institute production of propellant is easier.

17:03so that's that's why the change from from kerosene to methane. Methane is just CH4. It's one carbon, four hydrogens's. and then the oxygen pairs pairs together. So you have it's it's called O2 because oxygen pair bonds. and obviously you knew all this stuff. I'm just yeah basically that kind of for the audience together large size twice the takeoff thrust of a Saturn 5 but yes about the same payload but that gives you reusability much cheaper insitu propellant it all is coherent and

17:39so let me ask you the thing that I think everybody wants to know which is when when are we going to see Starship do a highfly to stratosphere when to orbit bit when first payload to Mars when first humans to Mars. All right. Well, it's not like I I we're obviously in venturing into unknown territory. So, it's not as though I I I have all these secret dates and I and I I'm you know, just keeping them from people. But so, so my these are just guesses obviously. I'm I'm pretty I'd say I'm 80 to 90% confident that we will reach orbit with Starship next year. I I think probably 50 or 60

18:2550% confident that we'll be able to bring the ship and booster back. That's like that's more of a dicey situation. we'll probably lose a few ships before we we really get the atmospheric return and landing right. we might lose hopefully we don't you lose hopefully we don't lose any boosters because that's a lot of engines. our initial booster fights will just have maybe two to four engines not 28. 28

18:53is a lot of engines. So yeah and then I think we'll probably be in doing high volume flights I think probably in 2022. So a couple years from now well I'm trying to make sure that that our rate of innovation increases it does not decrease. this is really essential. In fact if we do not see something close to an exponential improvement in our rate of innovation we will not reach Mars like a pure linear doesn't get there. Not. Not. Well, I'll be dead anyway before it gets there if it's pure linear. If it's exponential, I think we could get to Mars. We could we could probably send an uncrrewed mission there in maybe four years. you know, there's

19:50a MOS conjunction every 26 months. There's one this year. So, that means in a couple years from now is another one. And then four years from now is another one. I I I think we've got a fighting chance of of making the that second Mars transfer window. So, one thing that is really amazing

20:14about SpaceX to those of us who have experience in the aerospace industry is is the rate of innovation. you know, okay, last time you spoke to the Mars Society Convention was 2012. Since then, you've made the Falcon 9 usable, introduced Falcon Heavy, Crew Dragon, a satellite constellation, and you're in the middle of developing Starship. so, what what is your you know, what would you say is your methodology that allows you to innovate so swiftly?

20:52I don't really know. [clears throat] when we're focused on like said it's it is important to have that have the objective view right that's why I was talking so much about the importance of making well Mars a self-sustaining building a self-sustaining city on Mars if if that's the objective then obviously you know just putting some satellites in orbit or there not that that's not important you have to achieve full and rapid reusability I emphasize full and rapid re reusability is only relevant to the degree is rapid and complete.

21:28and and then you also have to do orbital refilling. This is essential as well. and and then propellant production on Mars also essential. So you know and and with that as the goal then you know that that that means that that that creates I think a good forcing function for radical innovation because in the absence of radical innovation we have no chance of meeting that goal.

21:58whereas if our goal was simply you know defeat lock and Boeing or something like that that we would probably achieve already done it it that really wasn't even a thing you know I wish it was. yeah like they're they're not really trying to do not even trying to do reusability which is bizarre because they make planes that are reusable.

22:25so I mean if they if they talk to their, you know, if they talk to one of their customers buys a Lucky Fighter jet or a Boeing aircraft like, "Hey, we're going to sell you a 737. It can be used once and it's not a 737 Max." but that turns out that was a single use airplane at times. but really

22:49it would be an absurd thing for them to sell a singleuse aircraft, but they feel quite comfortable selling a single-use rocket. and anyway, but if if our goal was simply we're going to have be the leaders in launching the conventional satellites that exist, we would probably approach that in on a sort of a logarithmic basis where you know you'd get there and you'd sort of slowly make progress towards doing 10 launches a year, 12 launches a year while they do six or something like that. but since the goal is, hey, we

23:26need to make life multilanatory before it's too late. and time really matters. So, we're our say, it's like we're shooting for Mars, not just the moon. It's not shoot for the moon, shoot for Mars. and then and then the, you know, these these competitive things are are kind of small things along the way.

23:44Unless somebody else is shooting for Mars, they will not be competitive with something as pedestrian as launching a few satellites into Earth orbit. So, how how can the Mars Society help you? Well, I do think there's, you know, in order to for there to be a self-sustaining city on Mars, there's we're going to need an intersection of sets here. one set is the set of people that want to go and can either find sponsorship. they can either afford it themselves or find government sponsorship or take out a loan or whatever the case may be.

24:26but somehow you've got to have the the set of people who want to go to Mars and can and can come up with the funds somehow to do that. And then then you know it's it's I should say it's there's two sets desire to go to Mars and can afford to go to Mars. When the when desire to go to the people who want to go to Mars and and the people who could afford to go to Mars when that intersection of sets reaches a million roughly then I think we will have this city on Mars. so we need both the the motivation and the, you know, we need both the means and the way. I mean,

25:04it's like we we need people to want the will and the way. The will and the way. Yes, exactly. The will and the way there's a [clears throat] will and it way. But in this case, we need will and a way. So when the will and the way intersect then we will have be a multilanet species.

25:24The will and the way must intersect. So I think the Marc Society can really help with the will. Okay. You provide the way. We'll provide the will. Yes. Exactly. okay. Now your assistant Jen told me earlier that you have a hard cut off at the half hour. Is that true? Or do you want to stay and take some questions from from the audience?

25:46Yeah, we could do maybe five 10 minutes of questions. All right, great. So, I we've got hundreds of questions. So, would the Jim, do you want to read a question or two? Yeah, sure thing. hi Elon, my name is James Burke. I'm from Seattle, Washington. Where's the best place to land on Mars, do you think?

26:10Yeah, actually I'm not super sure. I can tell you what the criteria are that you'd want. you'd want to be but anyway, I think the short answer is mid latitudes. probably on the north. So, you want to be close to ice. you don't be too you you don't want to be too far away from the sun so you can get solar power. and you want to land at [clears throat] a low altitude so that you can take maximum effect of atmospheric braking.

26:42What do you think? I like Milis Kasma. It's a nice little area at the bottom of Alice Marinerys. The air pressure is high. Okay. Is there a lot of ice there? There's ice around there. We'd have to look for it, though. Okay. That kind of brings me to my next question, and I'm going to turn it over to Carrie to ask you one. how would you prioritize like missions like 2 through 10? Are you gonna focus on exploration or building up the infrastructure or science?

27:14We're gonna I think the first order of business is build a propellant plant. I I mean we can for sure lob out a bunch of droids, you know, that's no problem. I think why not, you know, we're going, you know, and probably if anyone wants to put their droid on, we we could just take it. and you know it's like hey it's basically a remote control car with solar powered remote control car.

27:39and we could provide the the the communication relay. So you know you could just basically connect to your car from your computer at home and you know cruise your electric. It could have legs too. It wouldn't matter your robo devicecar. That would be pretty cool. and yeah, there's a lot of people worried about like, you know, life contamination. It's like listen, anything that can survive on Mars is very so freaking tough. It's insane.

28:14that it is cold and there's like a lot of UV radiation and if it's not going to be too worried about anything we send from Earth, let me put it that way. it's just tougher [clears throat] than anything on Earth. so but but I think the first order of business is we've got to build a propellant plant to make propellant and this is so we got need a lot of energy.

28:39we got to mine some ice and we got you got CO2 from the atmosphere. So from the ice you got the H2O. Combine the H2O with the CO2 you got CH4 and O2. but that's a lot of energy and be quite hard I think to make that repellent plant reli reliable. so but that that's that's the primary order of business and then we could also look around and see if we can learn anything from a scientific standpoint.

29:12Carrie, do you want to go next? Sure. Thank you James. I'm Carrie Fade. I live in Denver, Colorado. thank you for joining us today Mr. Musk. that we do have a lot of questions from 13 14y old. So I'm just going to pick one and ask you. it's from a a teenager and her name is Dara and she wants to be an engineer and build starships and robots and her dream is working for SpaceX. What should she focus on to be an engineer?

29:46Well, I think there's all kinds of engineering that's needed. so you don't have to be an aerospace engineer. You could be in electronics, you mechanical engineer, electrical engineer, you could be software engineer. I mean there's a lot of engineering basically almost any kind of engineering. we'll need chemical engineering I think also for figuring out how to make a good propellant depot or propellant say propellant production plant.

30:17and yeah, I think physics in general is a good background for thinking and I just generally re recommend people take physics courses because physics has the best tools for critical thinking. Thank you Elon James. Yeah, thanks Carrie. another question. The Boring Company. Now, is that just kind of a an outfit to build tunneling machines that can work on Mars?

30:46no. The Boring Company actually started as kind of a joke. and I for a lot of times people would ask me what what do I think the opportunities are out there? And for I don't know five years or more, I kept saying can someone please start a tunneling company? because I think tiles have a lot of opportunity for alleviating traffic in cities and just improving quality of life overall. I mean there's a lot of streets you could turn into parks. you certainly wouldn't need parking. You could just park cars underground.

31:18So and I just everyone thought I was joking. I was and I was like, well, I guess we'll see what it takes to drill a tunn dig a tunnel and and all these like so-called traffic experts and like haven't really made much progress. you know, cities like LA and DC are still a traffic nightmare. I'm like, okay guys, well, if you got such great ideas, why why is this still a traffic nightmare? so, if you build tunnels, you got to go 3D somehow, either underground or above ground. Like either air or ground. And the problem with air is like, you know, anything that can carry a person is going to generate a lot of noise and a lot of wind force.

31:57So, and could fall on your head and also kind of not be good for privacy and like, you know, you're sitting in your backyard and someone's like flying over you. It's like not that cool. So, but tunnels are working all those things. They're also weatherproof. you know don't have any privacy issues and safe and anyway they will leave they would make a big difference to traffic and we have the first production tunnel or useful tunnel in Vegas that's going to open I think in a month or two so a few months I guess and hopefully we'll be ready for prime time around the consumer electronic show so

32:39and now for for Mars I tunnels and and digging in general is good, but you need to build a very light system compared to what would matters on Earth. You don't really care all that much about mass on Earth. You care a lot about mass going to Mars. Is it fair to say that you're learning some techniques that might apply to Mars with the Boring Company?

33:00Yeah. Yeah, probably. When do you think Starship will be able to be demonstrating refueling in low Earth orbit? I think we got a shot at doing that in about two years. And then when do you guys think you'll have a moonship prototype? probably two or three years. As soon as you've got orbital refilling, you can you can send significant payload to the moon.

33:35like significant meaning 100 tons of useful payload at a shot. So then from there I think you mentioned Mars is a couple years after that. It's only a couple years after that because the Mars transit window is every 26 months. like I think we maybe have a shot of sending or you know trying to send something to Mars in 3 years but the windows is four years away because of the being in the different parts of the solar system.

34:07Carrie asked a question from a young person. I'd like to also ask do you have any tips for young people who love Mars but don't know how to help with the settlement of Mars? Well, I think definitely I you know anyone who is a strong advocate for Mars I think this really makes a difference you know a lot of times it's not even people aren't even thinking about it and you know you talk to people at a party and they or talk to friends they're like it's just even not even a topic of conversation. So, I think it could really help if for everyone out there who who thinks this is important for the future of humanity and consciousness as a whole, to

34:45make it part of what people are thinking about, bring it up at at parties and talking to friends and online. It's like it should be a thing that we do. and I think it's worth you know, maybe 1% of our resources at least. and that's not going to fundamentally change change things, you know, quality of life. If we have one if we spend 1% of our resources, you know, much less than healthcare, obviously, maybe probably even less than we spend on cosmetics, frankly. then that that would be enough to make life multilanetary, but we really need to make this a thing people talk about at least 1% of the time. And that that would really matter. like as we

35:29were talking about earlier, we need we need the will, which is we need a critical mass of people wanting to make it happen and and then we need the way and st SpaceX is going to try hard to provide the way and and then once we show that there's a way probably there will be other companies that also try to do it as well. so we need the will

35:47and the way they can provide either the will is extremely important makes a huge difference. What's the coolest part of Starship development? Well, I guess the coolest part of Starship development is working with just a great team of engineers and coming up with interesting solutions.

36:09yeah, you know, I think it's just fundamentally enjoyable if you're working with a lot of good smart people creatively towards solutions that have never existed before. That's very rewarding. So, I guess probably like that the most. Can you talk a little bit about how Starship could be used for other destinations in the solar system like Venus and the outer planets?

36:36Starship is is definitely a general generalized ship. It basically can it it's it solves for transport anywhere in the solar system that where where there is a solid surface to land. So if you can land there, we're going to take there. We'll also actually go into the atmosphere of Venus, for example, just like go into orbit and and and

37:07perhaps to the upper atmosphere. Venus's atmosphere is extremely dense, also quite hot. so but because of that dense atmosphere, you could you could have something you could have a kind of like a some sort of derigible, [snorts] you know, kind some kind of like like things that could float on Venus that could not float on Earth in the atmosphere because of the dense atmosphere. So yeah, you could go to Venus. I mean, it's not a super friendly place. and then like Mercury is super hot.

37:42I think that we could go to Saras or any of the asteroids, the moons of Jupiter, although be quite high radiation around there. and then out to Saturn, you know, eventually getting out to you know, the sort of cable belt, Earth cloud, and that kind of thing, the outer solar system. So, so Starship once you have propellant depots, you can kind of like planet hop or moon hop around the the solar system. it's not it's not a vehicle that would enable us to go interstellar, but it's that that's that's a that's a tough one, but it we need to make this the leap of going to another planet first. Once we are multilanet species, we will create a forcing function for the rapid

38:28improvement of of space flight. and and we'll figure out new technologies that will ultimately allow us to go to other star systems. What do you look for in the people you hire, especially the engineers? really just look for evidence of exceptional ability. So it's not or at least aspirationally like sometimes these things get messed up in recruiting or the recruiting filter to beings ends up being wrong. Like I sometimes wonder with Tesla, if Nicola Tesla applied to Tesla, would we even give him an interview? It's not clear. You know, does this guy came from like some weird college in somewhere in Eastern Europe?

39:09He's got some odd mannerisms. No, we don't know if we should give him an interview. Like I I worry that that's actually what we do instead of like it should be like, man, Nicola Tesla, this this this kid is super smart. What does he want? We'll pay him anything. That should [laughter] that should be the reaction if Nicola Tesla applies, you know, to Tesla.

39:28ironically, but so, but I can tell you the intent is we're looking for evidence of exceptional ability. and it really doesn't matter if you went to graduated high school or college or anything. We're just looking for evidence of exceptional ability. such that it would be a good predictor for doing exceptional things at SpaceX.

39:51Right. You have some more questions from the audience there, Jim. I've got one. so have you thought about communication networks between Earth and Mars and kind of I mean, you're working on Starlink. What about like an internet around Mars? Have you thought about that? Yeah, I you could certainly do some variants of Starlink. I probably this will probably have to be the last question because I've got a bunch of things piled up, but yeah, you could just do it version Starlink around Mars. And then you just need a big laser coming from Earth.

40:22Probably want it to be in orbit so it doesn't get atmospheric defraction or attenuation. you you want to go from a big laser from Earth orbit to Mars orbit. And then you're gonna need some relay stations for when Mars is on the other side of the sun. So you can't just shoot a laser through the sun.

40:44All right. Thank you. Thank you so much, Elon. We're all pulling for you. Good luck. Much appreciated. And just like a thank you to all the people out there that that are that are fighting hard for the cause of Mars. There's there's not that many and we need more. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Okay. And so listen, Elon has to go, but I I'm willing to take questions for

41:07the next 15 minutes until the next session starts. So ask me anything. Got some questions there, Jim? I've got a lot of questions, Robert. let's see. What's the current let's see, A lot of these are for Elon, so I'm going to have to adapt one for you. do you see electric rockets happening in the next hundred years?

41:28Well, electric propulsion is already in use. the problem with electric propulsion, it's a low thrust system intrinsically. So, if if if time is not an issue, but delta V is, that is the total amount of of velocity changes you need to do, then electric propulsion is a good system for that. So, for instance, the Dawn spacecraft visited several different asteroids when puttering around the asteroid belt. That was done with electric propulsion. That was great. but electric propulsion is for instance not the way we're going to get quick trips to Mars. the we'll get quick trips to Mars. We cheapen the cost of the space launch. We can put more propellant on a rocket. it you

42:09know if that's what we want to do actually if we can get more stuff to orbit I'd prefer to deliver more payload but electric propulsion is a useful ancillary technology. but until we have very high energy high power to mass ratio space power systems very high power very high power to weight space nuclear power systems or fusion power systems electric propulsion will remain in in auxiliary technology. If we do get that kind of stuff well then the situation will change and especially for the outer solar system where you've got more time to pick up speed. but if it takes you six months to pick up speed this, you can get to Mars in six months with

42:54chemical propulsion, but right now it takes several years to reach Jupiter. So, an electric propulsion system might be useful for that. Here's a classic for you. do you like the current plan of going to the moon from the moon to Mars or do you think we should go straight to Mars?

43:11well, if you want to go to Mars, you need to go to Mars. Okay. There there's reasons to go to the moon for going to the moon, but the moon is not the way to go to Mars. The going to the moon is the way to go to the moon. Do you have any advice? I kind of asked him about advice for young people that are interested in Mars but don't know how to help directly. Do you have any advice for those?

43:33Well, you know, first of all, if you want to participate directly, learn all the science and math you can. and that way you can become a scientist or an engineer. although there's going to be other fields necessary for colonizing Mars, aronomy, we're going to want to have automated, highly productive green houses, genetic engineering of new crops. All the sciences come into play. This is a vast human endeavor. And if if you're not inclined towards the sciences, you know, I I I if you've got a way of spreading the vision, as Elon said, we need both the will and the way. And people who can recruit other people to the cause are a as valuable as people who

44:15can participate directly. Here's a really good one. Do you think the first civilization on Mars will be more of small living spaces like small bubbles and such or more normalized like tall buildings? Well, I I I don't think tall buildings are an appropriate architecture for Mars. I I think that what we'll

44:39have is we can have extensive living space underground like whole metro systems and then domes on the surface. So I I think you know people can spend you know about 20% of their time in the domes in the sunlight above the surface and 80% you know sleeping downstairs and doing other things downstairs where you're completely shielded from space radiation. That that's my personal view of of the most probable Mars architecture.

45:12Do you think Mars colonization can be done solely by SpaceX or will it be done collaboratively? no. This is a much bigger endeavor. SpaceX is taking on the biggest single challenge, which is the transportation system. There's all sorts of other systems that are going to be needed.

45:29We're going to need a propellant making systems. We're going to need automated food factories. We're going to because there's going to be tremendous labor shortage on Mars. Mars needs people and it it's going to be short-handed for a long time. So all kinds of laborsaving machinery, robotics, artificial intelligence, you know, energy technology, whether it's nuclear or solar or even perhaps geothermal for Mars or fusion power would be terrific for Mars because Mars has got six times the detium that Earth has as a percentage of its hydrogen. so you know there's a lot of things that one could think there's all sorts of engineering problems that need to be addressed and

46:16you know my personal hope is that you know we're going to see Starship reach the stratosphere before this year's out and if Elon's right reach orbit next year or the year after and this will change people's minds as to what is possible and then you know we'll have NASA seeking to fund the remaining pieces of the puzzle or entrepreneurs stepping forward to develop remaining pieces of the puzzle, space nuclear power reactors, you know, we had a great talk today from David Poston.

46:47but it would sure help us. Some private money gone into that game to to move the most advanced concepts along faster than the pace that DOE is willing to support. And and frankly, okay, you know, we could use people playing the political game who are on our side. so there's a lot of ways that people can help and there's a lot of other technologies that need to be developed. But by making the transportation system, by showing that we can deliver large payloads to Mars, then all of a sudden all sorts of other technologies can get a chance to play.

47:22Carrie, did you want to ask a question? Robert, I do. Hi, Robert. This is from one of the questions from our Q&A. have your thoughts outlined in the case for space changed with the progress and current direction of SpaceX since the most recent publication of that book? If so, how have they changed?

47:44Well, they haven't changed that much. In the case for space, I talk about how the entrepreneurial space launch revolution is basic is is changing the game relative to what it was when I wrote the case for Mars. now, Musk is moving pretty fast. and it's become more clear to me how he intends to accomplish orbital refilling because that's a hard thing to do. No one's ever done orbital refilling of a cryogenic repellent. But I think he's got a good plan which is to take two starships base to base accelerate them just slightly in the direction of the tanker that is in the direction of the one that is supplying the propellant. So it is in the up position as it were from

48:31the gravity and then point of view and then just drain its tanks down into the other one. And by the way, another advantage of methane oxygen that I'm sure Musk is quite aware of but he he didn't have a chance to mention is that the two propellants store at the same temperature. So the tanks can be an intimate contact. There's there's no issue of thermal contact between the methane tank and the oxygen tanks which there is say with kerosene and oxygen.

48:57Okay. Kerosene would freeze at liquid oxygen temperatures. Thank you Robert James. What do you think is the biggest or hardest challenge that SpaceX has to pull off what they're trying to do with Starship? Well, they have a a challenging system there. I mean, first of all, the booster it's got about last time I saw 31 engines. I heard one design where they might reduce it to maybe 28 or so, but still order of 30 engines on the base stage. and all firing they

49:37you know they of course with that many engines you can afford engines going out. They have a massive reliable engine out capability but if an engine should explode that would be very bad. the and there's so there's a lot more things that could go wrong. There's more resiliency against things going wrong.

49:56so this thing's got twice the thrust of the Saturn 5. and it's reusable. Now that's the other thing. The upper stage, the Starship proper, it's going to go to orbit. Now, we saw, you know, shuttle coming back from orbit, it had these tiles and it would take quite a while to refit them after each landing. and of course, in the case of Colombia, the tiles came off and it failed on re-entry. now there are more it shuttle tiles is 1970s technology and it's unfortunate that NASA never went beyond that, never refitted shuttles with more advanced thermal protection that became available over the following decades and and certainly Musk is starting from the point of view of

50:43the most advanced technologies available today. But he is basically attempting to repeat or solve in a new way all the development that went into the Saturn 5 and all the development that went into the space shuttle. and additional development being orbital refilling. now this guy, he's got the best rocket team since von Brawn. I that's why I asked him several questions about who does he hire or how does he approach this because you know as impressive as the actual spaceflight hardware of of SpaceX is the organization itself. It it it's just from the point of view, you know, I I run a company. I have 20 employees, so it doesn't compare to SpaceX, but still

51:35it is hard to hire the right people and to hire so many people and choose the right ones on such a scale and organize them to be effective. And this is incredible management skill here. That kind of reminds me of the story you told at one of our banquetss a couple years ago when Elon was just thinking about starting SpaceX. And wasn't he actually involved with the Mars Society before that?

52:02Well, yeah. Elon was actually a member of the board of the Mars Society for a while. but you know, he decided that he could accomplish much more by creating a launch company to open the space frontier. you know that he set himself the hardest task that needs to be done to make all this possible and what we need to do is go and recruit more Elon Musks to solve the problem of space nuclear power to solve the problem you know of h of good life support of solve the problem of automated agriculture there's a whole bunch of technical problems here that need to be solved and and there's money to be made doing it. By the way, there's a lot of money waiting to be

52:51doing it. And these are hard problems. there are people working on small modular nuclear reactors right now that are small relative to commercial reactors on Earth. but they're large relative to any power system that has ever been done in space. These are entrepreneurial efforts and you know the this is a hard thing to do to make money in that business. I mean, frankly, if all Musk had done was make money in the electric car business, he would have, you know, defied the odds. because no one ever did that before either. but there's a lot of other businesses here that need to be taken on. Okay? And, I see our

53:37job in the Mar society is inspire people to want to take them on. and hopefully some of them will succeed and all the pieces will come into play. What do you think of the operation he's got going on down in Bokh Chica? I've heard you describe it as a starship production line essentially that he's building, not just one vessel.

53:58Yeah, I I went and I visited him down in Bokhica in February and I saw this thing growing there. It was a sight to see. you know, he at that point had about 250 people there. My guess I we didn't ask him today, but my guess is he probably has tripled that by now and he'll triple it again in in the next six months. he's not just developing a ship, he's developing a shipyard.

54:24the Starship in addition to its performance characteristics in terms of how much payload it can do and and and and so forth is designed to be mass- prodduced. Okay, this is a mass production fully reusable heavy lift booster. He wants numbers and you know he's learned that you know the first launches of vehicles could very well fail. He he is is turning out these prototypes right now at a rate on the order of one a month.

55:00so he's prepared to take losses and you heard him today say we expect the first several to fail. Okay. NASA could never afford a space shuttle to fail. of course two did over the course of the program and that was a total those were total disasters, mega disasters. and and both from the human life point of view but also from the financial point of view and the program capability point of view. you know he he's not gonna launch a humans to Mars program with four starships.

55:36He'll he'll probably have a hundred by then and and and and more after. Looks like we're at four o'clock. Carrie, do you have one more question or are you good? I'm good. Thank you. Okay. I think we're gonna need to leave it there, Robert. We've got a bunch of track talks starting at our conference.

56:01All right. Well, thanks to everyone and let you know this year the one piece of good news was Crew Dragon in the midst of all this mess we've been living through. That was the one light in the darkness and I'm hoping for one more Starship reaching the stratosphere by December. maybe it'll happen. I hope it will.

56:24Okay, thanks everybody. This is the Mars Society signing off. See you on Mars. Thank you, Robert. Thank you, James. See you on Mars.

56:50Wonderful to be here. food on the on the ground, planet Earth as it were. We're going to be touching on some really interesting topics tonight. We've got an amazing panel and I'll give a brief over

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份