大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克威斯康星州市政厅活动(完整版)| FOX 5 News

Elon Musk Wisconsin Town Hall (Full) | FOX 5 News

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

威斯康星州 Green Bay 的一场市政厅活动,马斯克开场先举起帽子问台下觉得怎么样。台下有人喊 USA,也有人被他当场认出是索罗斯那边来的。一场地方选举的活动,气氛办得像全国竞选集会。

他要推的是 4 月 1 日那场州最高法院法官选举,候选人叫 Brad Schimel。博彩市场给这场选举开的赔率是,Schimel 败选概率 85% 到 90%。这个数字马斯克自己在台上念了出来。

他把这场投票形容成可能决定西方文明走向的事件。听着像集会上的套话,但他给了一条很具体的推演链。

一场州法官选举,被算成了众议院的席位账

起点是众议院的席位数字。共和党现在的多数优势只有几个席位,薄到经不起任何变动。威斯康星州最高法院如果被自由派拿下,就可能重新划分国会选区。马斯克的判断是,重新划区之后,共和党会在威斯康星丢掉两个众议院席位。

两个席位听着不多。但众议院多数只差几个席位,两个就足够让它翻蓝。

众议院翻蓝之后会做什么,他讲得很直白:会设法阻止正在推行的政府改革。所以在他看来,威斯康星的一张选票,最后会落到华盛顿的权力天平上。

这场选举里还绑着第二个议题:把选民身份证明写进威斯康星州宪法。马斯克抓住的是纽约和加州的一个现象,在这些地方,投票时出示身份证反而是违法的。

他的反问是,为什么要禁止出示身份证。他的解释很直接,哪里禁止查身份证,哪里就有选民欺诈的空间。

DOGE 查的东西,大部分无聊到上不了新闻

马斯克花了很大篇幅讲他那个政府效率部门,Department of Government Efficiency,简称 DOGE。挂在 doge.gov 网站上,X 上也有同名账号,所有砍掉的支出都公开列出来。

他给的目标很朴素:恢复功绩制,把人从政府手里放出来,让一个人在美国能不能成功,只取决于他的努力和才华。至于具体动作,就是看每一笔支出,问一句这是不是纳税人的钱该花的地方。

金额上,他说联邦政府 7 万亿的支出里,如果能省出 15%,就是 1 万亿。这个门槛在他看来并不高。

浪费和欺诈的比例,他给的是 80% 浪费,20% 欺诈。听着像随口一说,但他举的例子确实够具体。

秘鲁的跨性别漫画书。空置办公楼还在付租金。一个部门的软件许可证数量比员工人数多十倍。每年 1000 万美元订阅 Politico。这些支出单笔都不大,凑起来是天文数字。

更离谱的是他说的「幽灵付款」。政府合同经办人退休了、换岗了、去世了,付款流程没人关,钱就一直往外流。接收方很少会主动抱怨自己多收了钱。

所以 DOGE 给财政部提了一个建议:付款分类代码和付款说明必须填,还要附上批准人的名字。这样就能直接问批准这笔钱的人,这笔钱合不合理。

这件事听着像幼儿园级别的管理常识,但马斯克说政府从来做不到。这也是美国政府一直过不了审计的原因所在。审计本身并不难,难的是审计需要的信息压根不存在。全是空白支票,没有代码,没有说明,谁批的都不知道。

他估计光这一项,一年能省 1000 亿美元。

一个有意思的对照是,他说自己以前是民主党人。90 年代克林顿和戈尔讲减少浪费和欺诈,把他们的演讲稿和 DOGE 的声明放在一起,分不出谁说的。

你根本听不出区别,一模一样。(马斯克)

左派的火气,和被他点名要负责的媒体

活动进行到一半,场内有观众喊口号、举牌子,马斯克顺势讲了一段关于暴力的话。

他提到有人烧特斯拉、有人朝经销商店铺开枪、有人公开喊总统和他去死。他理解有人不想买某个产品,那是自由国家的自由选择,但把别人的车烧掉就过分了。

他特别提到一段视频,一位女士在扶梯上戴着 MAGA 帽子,对面方向的人经过时把帽子从她头上扯下来。他说至今没看到有人去扯拜登哈里斯的帽子。

他把这股火气的很大一部分归给传统媒体。他举的例子是一篇文章,把特朗普形容成比希特勒、墨索里尼和斯大林加起来还坏。

他的回应是,特朗普没杀过任何人,他擅长的是止战,不是开战。顺带还补了一句,学校是不是该多上点历史课,让学生知道那三个人到底做了什么。

这个话题他顺势拐到了教育上:反美宣传在学校里推送得太多,所以要把教育议程交回各州,别让华盛顿的一群人决定孩子学什么。

关于自己这边的安全,他给了一个很具体的数字。前一天有 18000 次死亡威胁,当天降到 17000 次。他说这话时的语气像在报天气。

两张百万支票,买的是媒体注意力

讲话中途,马斯克现场发了两张 100 万美元的支票。第一张给了 Nicholas Jacobs,第二张给了 Ekaterina Diestler。两个人都是签了反激进法官请愿书的支持者。

他解释得很坦率,发钱就是为了吸引注意力。他每次这么做,传统媒体都会集体抓狂,然后把这条新闻铺到每个频道上。

我花钱都买不到这种报道,要买的话得花十倍的钱。(马斯克)

请愿书本身的内容也很简单:法官应该解释法律,不该制定法律。他把矛头指向华盛顿正在发生的事,任何一个联邦法官都能叫停美国总统的行政动作。在他看来这已经到了必须刹车的地步。

街区队长:敲门拍张照,20 美元

发完支票,马斯克宣布了一个叫 Get Out the Vote 的项目,挂在 America PAC 网站和它的 X 账号上。核心玩法叫「街区队长」。

流程是这样的:报名之后,在自己所在的邮政编码区域内挨家挨户敲门,给对方一张 Brad Schimel 的照片,纸质的或电子版都行。对方只要竖个大拇指,把照片举起来拍一张,就能拿到 20 美元。

照片不要求是 Schimel 本人,哪怕是个近似版本也可以。钱不多,但门槛低得离谱。

这个项目真正要解决的是认知问题,说服倒在其次。马斯克说,大部分人根本不知道有这么一场选举,知道的人也不清楚哪天投、去哪里投、有多重要。很多人以为就是个法官的职位,没什么大不了。

他的原话是,4 月 1 日那天的投票,本质是在决定哪个党控制美国众议院。

从数字看,形势对他这边不利。民主党目前领先大约 10 万票。博彩市场给的败选概率是 85% 到 90%。他形容这种情况下需要「从帽子里拽出一串兔子」,一只接一只飞过空中落进投票站。

但他给了一个反转:如果上次投票给特朗普的人这次也去投票,就赢了。就这么简单。

他还提醒了一句实用信息:威斯康星允许在投票当天现场登记并投票。哪怕从来没登过记,4 月 1 日当天全部办完。

AI 会不会看穿创造者的偏见

问答环节第一个问题就很硬:AI 越来越聪明,会不会看穿它创造者的宣传。

马斯克的回答是希望会。他把 AI 比作被创造者养大的孩子,成长的方向取决于创造者给它设的「北极星」。一家企业养的 AI,可能就会迎合企业。在旧金山训练的 AI,就会带上旧金山的偏见。

他的参照系是人。聪明人之间的信念差异本来就巨大,AI 之间出现巨大差异也很正常。

Grok 的定位是最大限度追求真相,哪怕真相不受欢迎。

哪怕真相不受欢迎,你也要尽可能靠近它,这是我们的目标。(马斯克)

USAID 的钱绕一圈,进了谁的口袋

有人问 DOGE 有没有查到民主党政客直接从 USAID 拿钱的证据,点名了 Maxine Waters、Adam Schiff、Chuck Schumer。

马斯克的回答是,腐败是存在的,但路径非常迂回。

流程大致是这样的:纳税人的钱先拨给政府机构,政府机构再拨给 NGO。NGO 名义上是非政府组织,可一旦它的钱来自政府,它就是个政府机构,只是换了个壳。

问题出在管辖权上。钱一旦进了 NGO,就不再受美国法律约束。所以可以先汇到海外的一家 NGO,再在几家之间转几手,然后再流回美国。

他说自己高度确信其中一部分钱最后进了那些人的口袋,只是路径绕得太远,没有直接证据链。

他抛出的疑问是,国会里有些人年薪 20 万,身家却有 2000 万,没人能解释这笔钱从哪来。

把 Twitter 买下来,是为了让对话存在

一位观众问,社交媒体都在给用户推他们爱看的东西,大家各活在各的真相里,美国怎么还能重新走到一起。

马斯克的回答拉回到了收购 Twitter 这件事。他的说法是,过去很长一段时间里,传统媒体和新社交媒体步调一致,重复同一套左翼话术,压制所有异议,连中间派的观点也压。

所以他认为买下 Twitter,后来改名 X,是让对话重新存在的前提条件。

他也承认现在有进展。X 不审查共和党之后,其他平台开始松动。Meta 宣布要用类似 X 的社区笔记机制,替代原来那个被他说成「觉醒斯塔西」的审查部门。CNN 请了 Scott Jennings 上节目,他觉得这也是好信号。

在 X 上,他说平台不偏向任何一方,会尽量公平。他自己会回复那些知名度高的民主党人,哪怕对方把他说得很难听。

但他对街头那一面还是不安。示威现场有人喊总统和他去死,他觉得这条线不能过。

冒天下之大不韪说一句,呼吁杀人是不对的。(马斯克)

一个班三十个孩子,AI 能不能当助教

一位教师问,AI 教育工具加上可汗学院这类资源,五十年、一百年之后会走到哪里。

马斯克先开了个玩笑,说希望人类能撑到一百年后,那就中大奖了。真正的答案是火星,希望那时候人类已经在火星上。

回到教学本身,他认为 AI 在教育里的作用会非常深。一个班 25 到 30 个孩子,老师不可能给每个人单独的时间,师生比就摆在那里。但如果给每个孩子配一个个性化 AI,孩子遇到卡壳的地方随时能问,老师更像是乐团的指挥。

他也替英语文学说了句话。高中读狄更斯的时候他也会想,为什么要读这个。但现在回头看,英语文学里那些重要作品,孩子多少应该读一些。

关于教师这个职业,他讲了一个数据。教育支出这些年涨了很多,但涨的主要是行政人员,教师人数没怎么涨。行政开销一路飞升,教学开销基本持平。他的结论是,应该多招真正上课的老师,给老师好待遇,同时问一句为什么行政岗膨胀成这样。

美联储两万人,还不如一个魔法 8 球

有人问他对美联储的看法。马斯克第一句话是「End the Fed」,然后笑着说这句他想说很久了。

他的疑问很朴素。美联储有两万人,为什么需要这么多人,他们具体在做什么。

他还开了一个关于利率的玩笑。美联储的利率决策委员会和一个魔法 8 球,谁猜得更准。他的判断是魔法 8 球可能赢,而且便宜得多。摇一摇,出来一句「稍后再查」,意思差不多。

玩笑背后是他真正关心的事:政府支出不能远超政府收入。现在的赤字是 2 万亿,国债利息支出已经超过整个国防部预算。

这个对比是他反复强调的转折点。国防部预算已经很大了,利息比它还要高,而且还在涨。

国债利息超过国防预算,这才是真问题

一位观众说美国的经济常识教育很失败,很多人根本不知道国家正站在财政悬崖边上。马斯克同意。

他补了一层解释,很多人连国债是什么都不清楚。这笔钱是怎么欠下的,为什么没人签过字却要还。

账面数字是 30 多万亿,这还不算未来的义务,也不算州和地方政府的债务。他的比喻是国家像一个人,人会破产,国家集体也会,破产的方式是货币被稀释到一文不值。

如果不立刻采取大动作,我们就在往那个方向走。

如果美国这艘船沉了,我们全都跟着沉。(马斯克)

他说这话是说给商界听的。公司再强,船沉了也活不下来。有人问他会不会跑去别的国家避险,他的回答是我会死在美国,哪儿也不去。

他自己接了一句,可能会去火星,但那也会是美国的一部分。

非法移民背后,是一整套经济激励

这场活动里信息量最大的一段,是马斯克和投资人 Antonio Gracias 一起讲的非法移民问题。

马斯克的判断是,拜登政府把美国政府的每一个部门都弯向同一个方向:给非法移民创造来美国的经济激励。

社会保障、Medicaid、失业保险、残疾补助,连国税局都在里面。他甚至说,填一张假税表就能拿到退税,哪怕你压根没交过税。

路径上,庇护身份一年能拿绿卡,拿到绿卡四年后可以入籍,因为庇护那一年算进五年的等待期。也就是说,从入境到拿到投票权,最快五年。

Antonio Gracias 展示了另一张图表,社会保障数据库里有 2000 万已经去世的人被标记为活着。他提到社会安全号发放数量出现了一条异常的曲线。

马斯克把这些串起来,得出的结论是,这一整套安排瞄准的是改变美国的投票地图,把摇摆州变成深蓝,做成一个再也翻不回来的永久一党制。

他举了几个州的例子。纽约州曾试图让非法移民在州内投票,几周前被纽约最高法院叫停。加州给所有非法移民提供医保,最初说成本 30 亿,现在 90 亿,还在涨。

纽约那件事他讲得更细。罗斯福酒店和曼哈顿的豪华酒店被用来安置非法移民,钱来自联邦应急管理署。平均美国人住不起的酒店,非法移民住进去了,还发欢迎包和 1 万美元的借记卡。

他把这套东西称作美国历史上规模最大的选民欺诈,而且差一点就成功了。如果哈里斯那边赢了,那些人会被合法化,摇摆州就不存在了。

他也讲了操作细节。一张假的水电费账单、一张医疗账单、一张学校 ID,就能拿到社会安全号。有了号就能进选民册,然后由民主党的操盘手集中刷票。

加州的现状是他用来预警的例子。加州已经是民主党绝对多数,但至少人还能搬走。如果整个美国都变成那样,人无处可去,情况会比加州糟得多。

DOGE 不会动你的社会保障

关于 DOGE 正在砍社会保障的说法,马斯克回应得相当直接,而且重复了两遍。

DOGE 会确保人们拿到社会保障,会确保人们拿到 Medicaid,不会削减任何合法的支付。他把这句话称为「清清楚楚」。

他补充了一个细节。打进社会保障署的电话里,40% 是欺诈电话,也就是说,有人试图把一个老人的付款转到诈骗团伙那里。剩下那一半,大概是真正在问「我的钱去哪了」的人。

他还专门讲了自己在这份工作上的经济代价。有人质问他在偷社会保障的钱,他的回应是,这活他不拿工资,反而在倒贴。Tim Walz 在台上展示特斯拉股价图的那段时间,他的特斯拉股票和所有持股人的股票一起差不多腰斩。

这份工作很贵。(马斯克)

他补了一句,长期看特斯拉股票会没事,现在可能是个买入机会。

创业建议只有四个字:试着有用

有人问创业的建议。马斯克的回答是,找到一个你觉得真正被需要的产品或服务,然后把它做出来,尽量做到有用。

餐厅、商店、科技公司,判断标准都一样,你在做的事对别人有没有用。有用,公司大概率能成。

别人问我最重要的建议是什么,我说,试着有用。(马斯克)

但他随即泼了盆冷水。如果一个人需要被鼓励才去创业,他会建议别创。太难了。

美国汽车行业里,没破产过的公司只有两家,特斯拉和福特。SpaceX 之前没有一家商业火箭公司成功过。让产出的价值超过投入的成本,这件事比听起来难得多。利润就是这个差值,而绝大多数公司做不出这个差值。

日本一年少一百万人

临近结束,有人问人口崩溃。马斯克说这是他真正睡不着觉的事之一。

美国的生育率从 1970 年前后就低于更替水平,去年是有记录以来的最低值。这个趋势几乎出现在地球上每个国家。

日本是绝对数量在减少,一年少大约 100 万人,而且还在加速。韩国只有三分之一的更替率,按这个速度,三代之后整个国家只剩现在的 3% 到 4%,大概就剩首都的一小块地方。

他说自己一直在等生育率反弹,但没等到。人口崩溃一旦开始滚动,会自己加速。

只要你还相信人类,你就应该非常在意这件事。(马斯克)

同一位观众刚当上父亲,问养孩子最大的收获是什么。马斯克的回答没有绕弯:没有比孩子更能让你快乐的东西,孩子是幸福最大的来源。他这些年一直在劝朋友和身边的人多生孩子。

他还有一句更直接的话,没有人类,就没有人类文明。

其他几个问题的简短回答

关于 AI 在教学之外的应用,他提到 Neuralink 的「盲视」设备已经在猴子身上工作了好几年,猴子健康状况良好。今年晚些时候计划做第一例人体植入,让完全失明的人重新看见东西。他特意把期待压低,初期画质像雅达利游戏,但最终可能达到超越人类水平的视力。

Robotaxi 的时间表,他的说法是今年 6 月在奥斯汀实现无监督全自动驾驶。

关于政府透明,他提到应该恢复 Smith-Mundt 法案,禁止政府对本国人民做宣传和监视。

关于 Dogecoin 和 DOGE 会不会打通,他的回答是没有计划。名字像,但两件事完全不同。这个部门原本想叫 Government Efficiency Commission,是网友说应该叫 Department of Government Efficiency,他采纳了。

关于 Fort Knox 的金库,他说如果能直播就好了,那本来就是美国人民的黄金,人民有权看看它。总统对此有兴趣,希望能成。

关于邮政,他承认自己还没细看,但一些安全猜测是,有些公司没被收对邮费,行政开销也偏高。

关于家庭法庭,一位在 Dane County 打过官司的观众讲了很久。马斯克的回应是,父母应该掌控自己的家庭,国家不该有这个权力。他还提了加州的一个变化,如果老师认为符合孩子的利益,而家长不配合,州可以带走孩子。

行动建议

这场活动信息量很大,但落到能做的事上,其实没几条。整理如下。

  • 如果你在威斯康星或者有朋友在那儿,4 月 1 日当天可以现场登记并投票,两件事一次办完,别错过。
  • 去 America PAC 网站报名当街区队长。敲门、递照片、拍照,一次 20 美元,门槛低到可以顺手做。
  • 搞清楚你所在州投票时要不要出示身份证。很多限制藏在程序细节里,光看新闻看不出来。
  • 如果你在考虑创业,先别找鼓励,先问问自己要做的东西对别人有没有用。这个问题答不上来,就别开始。
  • 如果你在关注政府开支,doge.gov 上的每笔支出都公开。看到不合理的地方,去问批准这笔钱的是谁。
  • 如果想支持 AI 往真相的方向走,多用、多质疑、多纠错。模型的「北极星」喊不出来,只能靠用户一次次校准。
  • 关于人口问题,能做的很简单:如果你想要孩子,别一直等「条件成熟」。生育率不会自己反弹,人口崩溃也不会等人。
语音识别自动转录,可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:Rev.com (transcription humaine)。

0:05Hey everybody. Thanks for coming. What do you think of my hat? All right, I'm going to sign the hat and I'm going to throw it out. All right.

1:11I love you guys too. So, well, thank you for coming out in support of this very important Supreme Court race in Wisconsin. It's actually something that I think, it's one of those things that may seem like it's obviously important in the State of Wisconsin, but I think it could actually be important for the country as well, and maybe for the world. So the House majority right now is razor thin. It's really just a few seats. And if the Supreme Court is able to redraw the districts, they will gerrymander the districts and deprive Wisconsin of two House seats on the Republican side.

2:00Yeah, exactly. The result of that could be that the House switches to a Democratic House.

2:08Yes, indeed. And then they will try to stop all of the government reforms that we are doing and were getting done for you, the American people. The reforms that were getting done in DC thanks to President Trump and his great team, are really profound. Really, the goal is very simple, it's to restore merit and freedom, so that's what it comes down to. So America is the land of freedom and opportunity. So we want to restore individual freedoms, freedom of speech, just in general, get the government off your back. And then make sure that you succeed in the United States as a function of your hard work and your talent and nothing else. So these are really noble and important principles.

2:08And also, and I'll talk more about this all night really, as long as you guys want to hear about it, but as you may have seen with stuff that we've posted on the doge.gov website and the DOGE handle on the X platform, there is a tremendous amount of waste and fraud in the federal government. Like shocking, really. It's insane. Yeah, it's really wild. So I mean, it was inevitable that at least a few Soros operatives would be in the audience. Give my regards to George. Say hi to George for me.

4:29USA, USA, USA, USA. Yep, I mean, it was inevitable. I was waiting for that one. So yeah, thank you. Thanks guys. Yeah, I mean, isn't it shocking how much violence and hatred is coming from the left? I mean, isn't it supposed to be the party… They claim to be the party of empathy, and yet they're burning Teslas and shooting up dealerships and calling for the death of the president and me. I'm like, "Guys, this is insane." They're gone psycho. I mean, I totally understand if somebody doesn't want to buy a product, yeah, it's up to you, it's a free country, but you don't have to burn it down, okay? It's a bit much. That's somebody else's car, leave it alone.

5:35Thanks guys. Yeah, so man, that derangement level on the left has just blown my mind, frankly. I mean, I'm like, "What is going on? They've just lost it next level." It's like, whoa. And I wonder what's… The legacy media is in part to blame for this and maybe primarily to blame for this, because it's really terrible. It's like if they keep calling… They've obviously called President Trump, every name in the book. I think there was one article that called the President worse than Hitler, Mussolini and Stalin combined. And I'm like, actually, President Trump's not killed anyone. In fact, he's very good at stopping wars, not starting them. So we're really very different.

5:35Maybe we need to add some more history lessons back in schools, because I don't know if people understand what the difference… Do they know what Hitler, Mussolini and Stalin did? It seems they don't. I mean, it's indicative of the poor quality of education pushed by the National Department of Education. So that's why we want to restore freedom to the states, to let the states decide on the educational agenda, and not have something pushed by a bunch of neo-Marxists in DC. I mean, it is astounding how much anti-American propaganda is pushed on kids today in schools. It's mind blowing. It's like, what the hell is going on?

7:30So anyway, but on a poor positive note, we have this petition against activist judges, because judges should be simply interpreting the law, not making the law. So in appreciation for the support of people in signing this petition against activist judges, we just want judges to be judges, which is a reasonable thing to ask for. And we're obviously seeing some crazy stuff in DC, where it seems like any federal judge can stop any action by the President of the United States. This is insane. This has got to stop, it's got to stop at the federal level and at the state level. But let me first hand out two $1 million checks in appreciation. Okay, so the first check goes to Nicholas Jacobs.

7:30All right. Now I should say that the reason for the checks is that it's really just to get attention. It's like we need to get attention, and it's somewhat inevitably when I do these things, it causes the legacy media to lose their minds, and then they'll run it on every news channel. And I'm like, "I couldn't pay them to… It would cost like 10 times more to get the kind of coverage that we get."

9:42You're welcome. Thank you. All right. All right. You can just, I guess take it, if you want. I think we'll get you a real one too. And then the second one is to Ekaterina Diestler. Let's see, hopefully here. And like I said, this is just helpful for getting attention and then it's fun to see the legacy media lose their minds over it too.

10:43Love you too. Yeah. So let's see. Hello. Thank you. Congratulations.

11:06All right, congratulations. All right, so we are also going to be announcing, we are announcing now, a program a Get Out the Vote program. So the webpage should be going live, I think around now, which is at the America PAC website or just go to the America PAC X account. And the single biggest challenge I think, is actually just making people aware that there is this very important election. And there's both the very important election for Judge Schimel, as well as the deciding on adding voter ID to the Wisconsin constitution, which is very important. So it's quite shocking that… I mean, you can tell where voter fraud is happening where they ban ID. Why would you ban ID?

11:06In New York and California it's illegal to show ID at an election. Well, I can't imagine why that would be the case. So two really important things, it's really just to ensure judicial integrity on Tuesday and then the voter ID thing. And it's April Fool's Day. And, like I said, most people aren't aware that there is this important election. Most people don't even know that there's an election at all. Or if they do, they aren't sure exactly when and where it is. And they aren't sure yet of… Or they don't realize just how important it is. They think, well, it's just some kind of judicial thing that's not that important.

11:06But actually, what's happening on Tuesday is a vote for which party controls the U.S. House of Representatives. That is why it is so significant. And whichever party controls the House to a significant degree controls the country, which then steers the course of Western civilization. So I feel like this is one of those things that may not seem that it's going to affect the entire destiny of humanity, but I think it will.

13:42Yeah, so it's a super big deal. And the fact that I'm here in person, I'm not voting it in, I'm here in person.

14:00Yeah. And there were quite a few death threats, I have to tell you. My security team said, "Well, it's actually gone down from yesterday to today, went down from 18,000 to 17,000." So I'm like, "Oh, maybe it's getting better." But you can see how crazy some of these people are. Look at the two people that tried to assassinate President Trump. And they both almost succeeded, so it's real. It's not like some imaginary thing. So anyway, so what we're announcing is a block captain program, where somebody can sign up to knock on doors in their zip code and encourage people to… Well, make people aware that there is a vote and then aware of how important the vote is.

14:00So you can sign up to be a block captain for your zip code on the America PAC website right now, yeah. And if you do, it's basically 20 bucks for just taking a photo with somebody. It's pretty straightforward. You just knock on doors in your neighborhood and give them either a digital or a paper picture of Justice Brad Schimel. It can be an approximation. It doesn't have to be exact. And they just have to say, thumbs up and hold a picture of Judge Schimel and that's it and you get $20. It's pretty easy, it's easy money.

14:00But the whole point of it, is just to make people aware of the election and say, "That there is an election, it's on Tuesday and it's super important, please vote." But I think without something like this, we actually are in serious danger of losing the election. This is very important to put in mind, if you look at the betting market odds. So if you look at the Polymarket or Kalshi, the betting markets, it varies between 85% and 90% probability of loss for Justice Schimel, that's the current situation. So we've got to pull a rabbit out of the hat next level.

14:00We actually got to have a steady stream of rabbits out of the hat, like it's an arc of rabbits flying through the air and landing in a voting booth. Interesting picture. Barack could probably make that picture. So that's basically what's needed, is we need to generate an anomaly in the matrix, because I think there's currently the Dems are a hundred thousand votes ahead. But actually, if the people that voted for President Trump simply vote on Tuesday, we'll win. That's actually all it takes. Just vote, boom, done, victory. So we're basically to dragnet the state. It's like everybody's going to mobilize everywhere like crazy for the next 48 hours.

14:00And I think this will be important for the future of civilization, it's that significant. So you don't hear me saying that very often, it's a big deal. So vote for Judge, Super Judge Schimel. I call him Super Judge Schimel. So let's see. So with that, I think we can do Q and A, if you guys would like to do some Q and A. And I'm happy to answer any questions. It can be about those or whatever you'd like to hear about. Because I think if you ask questions that the public would be interested in hearing, then those snippets will go all over the place and it will be helpful to the public at large and maybe even beyond our country. So let's see. Yeah, go ahead. We can just start over there.

14:00Speaker 1 : As AI continues to get smarter, won't it inevitably see through its creators propaganda?

19:13Yeah, the question is, as AI gets smarter, will it see through its creator's propaganda? I hope so. I think you can think of an AI as it is somewhat nurtured by its creator. So what is the operating principle? What is the north star of the AI? If it's a somewhat corporate AI, it could be like it's just trying to make corporations happy. Or particularly some of the AIs that are trained in the City of San Francisco, it's going to have a San Francisco bias to it. Because you can think of smart people as well, there are big differences in beliefs among smart people. And so you can expect that there'll be big differences in beliefs among AIs as well.

19:13With Grok, our aspiration is a maximally truth seeking AI, which is like you always want to try to get as close to the truth as possible, even if the truth is unpopular. And that's our goal, which I think is a very important goal. Hey, nice shirt. Speaker 2 : Oh, thank you. First of all, Path of E.xile for life. But more importantly, as we see the whole world has turned to a fear-based mobilization effort, and we've seen that translate into violence and the right's not immune to it because can hit everybody's psychology.

20:48Sure. Speaker 2 : How do we beat that with optimism? Because that's going to be crucial to avoid mass eruption of conflict.

20:56Yeah, I mean there does seem to be… You're right, that the right is not immune from hidden violence, it's not nothing, but it does seem weirdly heavily weighted towards the left. I haven't seen anyone tearing off a Biden Harris hat. You feel a bit sorry for them. Like, "Oh, maybe they're wrong there." But you see people tearing off MAGA hats. And I saw a video just today, where somebody was just on an escalator, woman was on an escalator wearing a MAGA hat, and someone going the other direction tore the hat off her head. And I'm like, "What? That's rude." So in fact, I find myself in a strange position, because I didn't think of myself as right.

20:56I thought myself as centrist, but then the left went all the other way in the other direction and now everyone's a Nazi, before you know it. And I'm like, "Oh, wait a second. Do you know what that means? Obviously not." But yeah, I think I believe in peaceful discourse and that we make arguments, verbal arguments, and the people decide which way they want to go. But we don't engage in shouting people down or violence or burning things or shooting things. That's how democracy is supposed to work, is peaceful discourse. Speaker 3 : My question is about USAID.

20:56Has the DOGE team found any evidence that any of the radical left Democrats, like Maxine Waters, Adam Schiff, Chuck Schumer, have received money directly from USAID? And if so, will we be hearing about that evidence anytime soon?

22:57Yeah, so there is a massive amount of corruption, but it is circuitous. So what happens is, there's money, obviously, it's your taxpayer money that is then sent to various government organizations, who then send it to NGOs. Which an NGO is a non-governmental organization, but obviously if it's a government funded non-governmental organization, it's just an organization, it's just the government. And effectively, there's a giant fraud loophole, which is that the government can send money to an NGO that is then no longer governed by the laws of the United States. So they'll send the money overseas to one NGO, then it'll go through a bunch of them.

22:57And then I'm highly confident that a bunch of that money then comes back to the United States and lands in the pockets of the people you just mentioned. But it is a circuitous route, it doesn't go directly. But let's just say, that there's a lot of strangely wealthy members of Congress, where I'm trying to connect the dots of how did they become rich while earning… How'd they get $20 million, if they're earning $200,000 a year? Nobody can explain that.

24:22So something's… Yeah, we're going to try to figure it out and certainly stop it from happening. So yeah, I mean, just in general, the whole NGO scam is just crazy. And yeah, it's blown my mind really. So yeah. Speaker 4 : Most of us here are aware of social media censorship and I know you're keenly aware of it. Thank you for turning around X. Awesome.

25:04You're welcome. Speaker 4 : As censorship picks up in financial institutions, what can we do about that? Are you referring to offering financial services by X? Speaker 4 : No. Go ahead, sorry. Speaker 4 : Being kicked off of financial for beliefs?

25:22Oh, yeah. Yeah, well certainly that won't happen during the Trump administration. Hopefully, that can be enshrined in law, which is part of the reason why we need a Republican Congress. So you didn't see any Republicans kicking Democrats out and debanking Democrats, but there were a lot of Republicans that were debanked, thousands, which is really outrageous. So that's why I say, it does seem one-sided, trying to ruin people's lives financially and violent protests, overwhelmingly is coming from the left these days. Whereas the right is polite and fair as far as I can tell, so yeah. Go ahead. Speaker 5 : Thank you for being here.

25:22Your comment about the matrix is ironic because my husband and I watched the first matrix in the sequel yesterday. My question is when so much of social media nowadays, whether it be X or YouTube or whatever is curated to a person's particular beliefs, or even where we have protestors that show up to town halls or potentially are paid, how does America come together? And it used to be where you could have a conversation and have discourse like you discussed and still be friends even if you disagreed with some of their statements.

25:22When you talk about knocking on doors to different people's houses, one fear that I have is even if you talk to somebody, everybody has their own sets of beliefs and their own truth. So I guess how do you get through that?

27:31Yeah, well, I think what we saw there for quite a while was that all of the legacy media and all of the new social media were in lockstep together. And they were all parroting the same left-wing talking points. And they were suppressing any dissent and any so-called right wing or frankly even centrist views. And that's why I felt it was critical to acquire Twitter now X in order to enable that dialogue. So it's certainly a step in the right direction. And I think you've seen now once X was willing to break ranks and not censor Republicans, then you saw others also start to move in that direction.

27:31It looks like, for example, Facebook and Meta, certainly Mark Zuckerberg has stated that they will be doing community notes based on the community notes of the X platform, as opposed to having sort of far left censorship bureau, the woke Stasi essentially reviewing things. So that's a step in the right direction. There's maybe some hope for

29:00The CNN's of the world, it's like, with Scott being on there, he's great. I mean, I'm hopeful that things that are moving in the direction where different points of view are espoused on, or heard on, legacy media and social media, so I guess maybe I'm actually a little bit optimistic about the future. And on the X platform, we don't prioritize one side or the other, we try to be as fair as possible. And I will reply to prominent Democrats even if they say terrible things about me. So it's like, yeah, we should have this discourse. And so I think, at least on the media front, things are going in a good direction.

29:00But I am perturbed by how aggressive these protests are, where there are people at these protests calling for the death of the President, and death of me and, I don't know, probably death of others. That's the kind of thing that's not cool. At the risk of saying something outrageous, calling for murder is not cool. Yeah, please. Speaker 6 : Thanks for coming, Elon. I'm a teacher by trade. I have gone through the four-year bachelor degree to teach the nation's youth going forward. On that-

30:52Yeah. Actually I'm curious, what was that like? Speaker 6 : I got an English degree, man. At the end of the day, unless you want to hire me, that's about [inaudible 00:31:03].

31:05Sure. Speaker 6 : So during teacher college, they give us a heat map and it says, "These are the costs per head on each student." The southeast is generally the worst, but they're also generally the lowest spent per capita on each student. Beyond just that correlation of the one text I got in an education class, I wonder, with your investments in Khan Academy, with the advancement of AI educational tools where specifically you can get feedback and these students can get feedback-

31:42Yeah, absolutely. Speaker 6 : … where do we see a hundred years from now with all that's going on? Oh man, a hundred years from now? Speaker 6 : How about 50? I hope we last a hundred years, that would be jackpot. Speaker 7 : [inaudible 00:31:53]. Yeah, exactly. Speaker 7 : [inaudible 00:31:55].

31:56Hopefully we are on Mars. So that would be really cool. So I do think AI can be incredibly helpful in teaching, because you can essentially set up each kid with a personalized AI and that AI can then answer questions for each kid. And that actually can be very profound in learning. Because obviously, if you've got a classroom of say 25, 30 kids, it's literally impossible to spend time with every kid individually, or at least you can spend a little bit of time, but obviously it's a 1:20, 1:30 ratio. But what you can do is, you can set them up with the AI and then if things get stuck or whatever, if you want, you can essentially guide the orchestra in that way.

31:56And I think it could be a very powerful learning tool. I personally enjoyed my English classes in high school, actually. Sometimes I wondered, "Why am I reading Charles Dickens?" But there's some merit to reading Dickens and many of the… I actually think that we should have a great canon of English literature that kids do at least some number of the significant works in the English language. I mean, yeah, it seems very obvious to me. And another thing with regard to teaching is that I think teaching is a very important profession. If you look at the expenditures, there's a very big rise in the number of administrators, but not a very big rise in the number of teachers.

31:56And so that's really the big factor, which is we should have more actual teachers. And I believe in paying teachers well and having a lot of teachers, but we should say, "Why do we have so many administrators, or non-teachers?" So administrative expense has gone ballistic, but teaching expenses is more or less flat, it doesn't make sense. Speaker 8 : First I would like to apologize to you on behalf of America for the idiots you have to deal with for what you're doing for us to improve our country. Second of all, my question is, what is your opinion on the Federal Reserve, and do you have any intentions of doing anything with them?

34:26End the Fed. Yeah, I don't know, I always wanted to say that. But I think there's 20,000 people that work at the Fed, it seems pretty high. There's a lot of people that work at the Fed and it seems like, why do we have so many people at the Fed, and what do they do? And sometimes I wonder which one would win for interest rates, the board of the Federal Reserve or a Magic 8 Ball? And I'm like, I think the Magic 8 Ball might win. So then I'm like, well, the Magic 8 Ball is a lot cheaper. You shake it, it says, "Check back again later," I'm like, okay. Same thing. But I think what really matters is that government spending is not far in excess of government revenue.

34:26That's a fundamental issue that we have where we have a deficit of $2 trillion, and we have interest payments that now exceed the entire budget of the military. In fact, that was a big wake-up call for me was when the amount of money that we're paying national debt interest exceeded the Defense Department budget. I'm like, Defense Department budget is very big. And interest is higher than that and climbing? That's a disaster. So the very simple straightforward goal of the DOGE team is to get rid of waste and fraud, it's mostly waste. I'd say it's probably 80% waste, 20% fraud, something like that. But it's a trillion dollars, so that's still a lot. Speaker 8 : It's a lot.

36:27We've got another it's got to be… We got another Sora sleeper agent there? USA. USA. USA. USA. So I mean to be clear, the very simple thing we're doing and we post everything publicly on the DOGE website, which is, it's just to look at every expense and say, "Is this actually a good use of your taxpayer dollars?" That's it. It's not super complicated. And the thing that's pretty wild, this is why I say I used to be a Democrat. And if you listen to the speeches of Clinton and Gore in the '90s when they were going on about reducing waste and fraud, literally you wouldn't be able to tell the difference, if who said it, DOGE or Clinton and Gore? You can't even tell the difference. Sounds exactly the same. Speaker 7 : It's wild.

37:49It's wild. So we're really just trying to restore common sense to government and say let's not waste your money and let's make sure it's spent well. And that's it. In trying to save a trillion dollars of expenditures, what we're saying is of the 7 trillion in government spending, let's see if we can make it 15%, one, five percent, more efficient. And I'm confident that we can. That's actually not a huge bar, by the way. And when you see the crazy things that the government is spending money on, you can see a list of some of them, I don't know if we should be spending money on transgender comic books in Peru, that doesn't seem like an ideal thing to spend your money on. Why would we do that?

37:49If somebody in Peru wants to do that of their own accord, that's fine, but it should be your money that does it. We shouldn't be paying rent on empty buildings. I do think there is a role for government, but we're just going through and saying and doing what I would call an excellent and necessary and reasonably trusted review of organizations and personnel. So is this person doing a good job? Great. Is the role necessary? If so, that's good. And are they reasonably trusted? Meaning they're not a psycho. We're not talking about political affiliation, just that they're not crazy. So what's wrong with that? I'm like, sounds super normal to me. So that's it.

37:49Now in this process, one of the things that we've discovered, which is I think on the fraud side, which is a really big deal, is that the Democrat administration, the Biden administration, has basically taken every arm of the US government and bent it towards creating a financial incentive for illegal immigrants to come to the United States. Now this is every part of the government. So Social Security, Medicaid, unemployment insurance, disability, even the IRS. So you can fill out a fake tax return and say you need a tax… Maybe I shouldn't tell people this, but it'll actually work. I mean, mostly.

37:49There's some chance you'll get caught, but if you fill out a fake tax return, you can just get a tax refund even if you didn't pay taxes. So we're trying to stop all these things. Say like, okay, let's stop the waste and fraud. And we also need to turn off the massive financial incentive for illegals to come to the United States and stay in the United States. And this is really the thing that is causing the Democrats to lose their mind because they're actually spending, at this point, tens of billions to attract and retain illegals in the United States. It is really on that scale, it's a gigantic number. And the goal is to turn all the swing states blue. That means Wisconsin.

37:49So that's the goal. So with the asylum program, they can get a green card within a year and then they can get citizenship as quickly as four years after getting a green card, it's because the first year being asylum counts for the five-year citizenship waiting period. So this is a very big deal. So a number of friends of mine have actually joined the government in order to help with this process. I'd like to welcome my friend Antonio Gracias to the stage. I think so. Let's see, does it work? I can give you mine. Does it work? Speaker 7 : Can you get us past the Van Allen radiation belt?

42:14It'll be okay. I mean Buzz Aldrin's still alive and he went past the belts. There you go. So Antonio, can you tell us what you… Antonio is helping out with the Social Security, so just trying to review Social Security where you may have heard that we found 20 million dead people marked as alive in the Social Security database. This is so crazy. And then you'll notice there's a strange trend here where how many Social Security numbers were issued, do you want to…?

42:55You want to talk a bit louder, maybe. Yeah, this is a mind-blowing chart.

44:20Yeah. This is worth just reiterating. People sometimes think that under the Biden administration that he was simply asleep with the switch. They weren't asleep with the switch. It was a massive large scale program to import as many illegals as possible, ultimately to change the entire voting map of the United States and disenfranchise the American people, and make it a permanent deep blue one party state from which there would be no escape. And who did vote. Yeah.

49:33Yeah, it's pretty wild. I mean, you can see because there's still actually a lot of people out there, especially in the [inaudible 00:49:43] third of the country, that somehow think this is made up by the right or it is some fiction, that it's somehow not true. But it is absolutely true. And you can see that if you look at things like the state of New York, which tried to make it legal for illegal immigrants to vote in the state of New York. That was only shut down by the New York Supreme Court a few weeks ago. And California has made healthcare available to all illegals in the state. And they initially claimed that it would only cost 3 billion. It's now 9 billion and climbing.

49:33So it is really, if you create a massive financial incentive for people to come to the United States illegally, then that's what they will do. It'd be odd if that didn't happen. So the thing that is actually has the Democrats losing their mind, by far, the real reason for these attacks and the burning of the cars and everything is that we're going to turn off the payments to illegals. Yeah. I mean because that's not the deal. It's simply not right. And if you look at that thing with the Roosevelt Hotel and the luxury hotels in New York where the Federal Emergency Management Agency funds were being used to house illegals in luxury hotels in New York that the average American can't afford.

49:33And they were giving a welcome package and $10,000 debit cards and everything else. It's super real. I think it's the biggest voter fraud thing in history by far. And if left unchecked, it would've succeeded. As Antonio mentioned, the timeframe for going from asylum to citizen is roughly five years.

52:10And so all of the people that came in on that chart that you saw, if the machine behind the Kamala puppet had won, then they change out the puppet, but it's the same machine, then they would've actually legalized all those people and there would be no swing states.

52:34Yes. It was going ballistic. Right. Yeah. Yes. Well you could just actually make it up. Basically you can show basically a fake utility bill or- Yeah. Medical bill and a school ID, and you can get a Social Security number. And then from there you get on the voter rolls and then the basically Dem operatives will farm the vote.

53:40So the problem with this obviously is that if you turn the swing states blue, then there are no swing states. And then we're in a permanent one party system. And as soon as they win that, they'll have the House, the Senate, the presidency, they'll pack the Supreme Court, then they'll double down on the illegals just like California. So we've already seen this happen in California. California is a super majority Dem. But at least California is held back by the fact that people can move out of state. Once you can no longer leave America, they'll be far worse than California. So the gravity of the situation is severe. Speaker 7 : Help us clean up Wisconsin voter roll.

54:26Yes. Absolutely. So I mean, it is really simple stuff. Just having a photo ID to vote is… You can't buy something at the liquor store, but voting is more important than buying a beer.

54:51Yeah. You have fly anywhere. Yeah. And the same people who are saying that there should be no voter ID at voting stations demanded vaccine ID from everyone. I'm like, that's weird. So it's really about just restoring integrity to the voting system, which really should not be a right or left cause, but a cause for all. Do we not all want integrity in the voting system? Of course we do.

55:35So well you're welcome to hang out and see maybe there's some questions people, let's see. We'll go. Speaker 9 : Hi, Elon. I also am a teacher. I was a teacher in Colorado for eight years. High school Spanish. But I moved here last year and got to vote in Wisconsin where my vote actually mattered. And I'm so glad. That was amazing that we got Trump elected.

55:59Yeah. Speaker 9 : And I was listening to, I believe it was Patrick Bet-David. He called this perfectly where he said, "When Trump gets elected, he's going to go from enemy number one to Elon's going to be number one." And for the reason, I mean he only has a couple of years left and we've all seen the left go after you and make you number one enemy. And just walking in here, we heard, "Nazis suck." There's all this horrible thing. And just on a serious note, I just want to let you know my wife and I pray for you at night-

56:46Thank you. Speaker 9 : … for your safety. Thank you. I got to watch my hand gestures these days, but I think this one's safe. It's like can't wave to the crowd. Don't know what will happen. Speaker 9 : And I've been a fan of yours for like a decade and I've been a walking Tesla ad to anybody who talks to me, even though I never had a Tesla until I came to Wisconsin, too. And it's 10 years old. But it's the best Model S I've ever had.

57:27Thank you. Speaker 9 : It's incredible. Thank you. Speaker 9 : But I just wanted to take to ask you if it would be okay, I brought my dad with me, he's a pastor and I just thought, if it's okay with you, I would love for him to say a prayer for you as well for your protection.

57:44Sure. Thank you. Speaker 10 : Elon. Well, thank you so much for everything you've done for our country. We do love you very much.

57:58Thank you. Speaker 10 : Speaker 11 : … and as a pastor, but just as a person, right? And even if I wasn't a Christian, and I know not everyone here is a Christian, but I think there's quite a few of you here who are. Either way, we love all people. That's not the issue. The issue is fairness, what you're talking about. The issue of being just, and the justice being a weapon instead of… Lawfare instead of actually just, and all this corruption you're talking about. And that's a bad spirit if you want to say it that way. Putting it nicely. It's something evil that has come against our country, our morals, our families, etc. And then you and the president and others getting attacked with this outrage and this hate. So if you would allow me to pray.

58:55Thank you. Speaker 11 : All who want to, please join me. Bow our heads and pray. Gracious heavenly Father, we are thankful for our country. We are thankful that God does bless America and that God is the source of all goodness, love and provision, and that you, Lord God, have provided a great nation with great history. And although we've gone through many rough times, you're still very present and active with us. Thank you for protecting President Trump from that fatal attack. And we ask that you envelop and protect all of those who are fighting for justice, for freedom, for order, for dignity, and to reward people according to merit.

58:55And especially put your hedge of protection around Elon Musk, around his children, around his whole entire family and all of his team members that all would do good and just by our country and freedom truly and justice would reign once again. We ask this in the name of the blessed Savior, Jesus Christ, who we remember during this time of year who suffered and died for our sins. May you wash away all that is wrong with our country and start with us. We ask this in Jesus' name. Amen.

1:00:24Amen. Thank you. Thank you very much. Speaker 11 : Thank you.

1:00:39Sorry? It's up to you. You can hang out if you want. Well, that was beautiful. That was beautiful. I think we're going to need divine protection, frankly. Speaker 13 : Yeah. Hey Elon, I'd like to start off by thanking you for all that you've done for our country and the world as a greater whole. And I mean that from the bottom of my heart as well. I had a question for you. As you go about your decision-making at Doge, how are you able to keep your moral North star and not set precedents when it comes to overstepping democratic processes simply because the end justifies the means and have outcomes similar to the last election with Democratic presidential candidate being appointed without due process that just further polarizes the country.

1:01:35True. Speaker 13 : Also, on a side note, one more thing. Do you see a place in the long term for decentralized technology in society and government?

1:01:44Yeah, to answer the second question first, I think generally it's good to have decentralized systems because the more centralized something is, the more power that is in any one single entity, the more corruption you're likely to have. So decentralization I think is good to minimize corruption. Then with respect to Doge, I mean, as I said, we're trying to be as literal as possible. It's the Department of Government Efficiency, and it's just literally going through and saying, "Okay, this money was spent.

1:01:44Is it money that most Americans would agree is sensible or is it not?" And if it doesn't seem sensible, then we say, "Well, we shouldn't spend that money anymore and we should stop it." And then we try to be as transparent as possible. So all the Doge actions are posted on the Doge.gov website and on the Doge handle on X. So people disagree with something, we can say, "Well, which part do you disagree with?" And when I get these attacks of like, "Oh, it's unconstitutional." I'm like, "Well, which expenditure is unconstitutional that we have stopped?" And then they don't know actually because they haven't actually looked at anything.

1:01:44So now obviously a lot of this can be reversed with a new administration, but at least for some period of time we're going to make sure that your taxpayer money is spent at least 15% better. I think it's a reasonable goal, it's a rational goal, it's a sensible goal. And the net result, I should say, if we have the combination of a trillion-dollar increase an economic output and a trillion-dollar decrease in the budget deficit, then the outcome should be that there is no inflation or very little inflation from one year to the next.

1:01:44So at the end of next year, the prices at the grocery store will be very similar to what they are right now, which means that standard living will actually probably be higher, a little bit higher. Whereas we've had rampant inflation to date. And inflation is really just a pernicious tax that has been used by governments throughout history. It is very tempting for governments to use inflation as tax because it's indirect. People see the prices rising at the grocery store or for goods and services or for houses, and they tend to blame the store, but it's not the store, it's the government. The government has reduced the value of money and as a result, prices rise.

1:01:44So by reducing waste and fraud, we will essentially make the economy more efficient and we'll shift people resources from the government to the private sector and that will result in an increase in the output of goods and services. And so the average standard of living will therefore rise. So they try to make economics sound very complicated, but it is really not that complicated. The standard of living increases when the output of goods, average output of goods and services increases per person. There's basically more stuff, therefore you have more stuff to divide across the people. And that's it.

1:01:44You can run this little thought experiment and say if there was a hundred people on an island and you'd say, "Well, how many people do you want farming, fishing, making stuff versus doing regulations?" You would say, "Oh." You wouldn't want 20 people doing regulations. You'd be like, "Oh, that's too many." Well, maybe one or two, I don't know, maybe none. Ideally zero. I'm all for small government, by the way, I think really… Yeah. When the United States was formed, you had the Secretary of State, Secretary of War, which I think is a more accurate name than defense, but it was Secretary of War for a long time and you had Secretary of the Treasury and you had the Attorney General. That was it.

1:01:44And if it were entirely up to me, I'd be like, "Let's make it like that again." Yeah. Speaker 14 : Howdy, gentlemen. I got a quick question regarding government and transparency. Do you think Dogecoin may ever be used or the Dogecoin blockchain to be used for maximum transparency?

1:06:56Well, the names are similar, but they're doing two very different things. In fact, I was going to call it the Government Efficiency Commission, but that's a super boring name. And then the internet said, "No, it needs to be called the Department of Government Efficiency." I was like, "Well, internet." The internet is right. So we changed the name from Government Efficiency Commission to Department of Government Efficiency, but there are no plans for the government to use Dogecoin or anything as far as I know. So they happen to be similar names, but really it's just, we're literally trying to make the government 15% more efficient.

1:06:56Most of the work that's being done is, it's kind of like homework. It's just work. Frankly, it's like washing the dishes. It is not like a lot of, it's not super fun work. It's just going through and looking at every expense and saying, "Why does this department have 10 times more software licenses than people? That doesn't make sense. Why is the government spending 10 million a year on Politico subscriptions? That doesn't make sense." There's just one thing after another like that. It's like things that are just kind of boring. It's a ton of boring stuff. You do hear about the weird stuff that makes the headlines, but most of the costs that are being cut are just very basic, boring things.

1:06:56It is like homework at scale is what I'd call the Department of Government Efficiency.

1:08:42Yeah. I'm really selling it here. And we don't want to pick on Microsoft. It's like every software company, by the way. Yeah.

1:09:47Yeah, it's worth pointing out. You have to recalibrate how dumb things can be because it's the government, frankly, it's dumber than you think it could possibly be. For example, we found there were a whole bunch of what I call ghost payments going out where the government contracting officer had retired or changed jobs or were dead or I don't know, they were not around anymore and they forgot to turn off the payment stream to some company. And it's like leaving the money faucet on and you leave the house and it's just the money faucet keeps going, and it's a pretty rare organization that will complain about receiving money.

1:09:47So then you're like, "Is that waste or fraud?" I mean, the government did send them the money, but they didn't deserve it. So then well okay, we should turn off the money spigot if the contract is over, type of thing. So one of the things that we made a recommendation to the Treasury that the payment classification codes and the explanation for the payment be mandatory fields and have a name attached. So we could just ask the person who approved the payment, "Is this payment a good payment? Does this make sense?" This is the kind of thing that is normal for individuals and for companies, but that was not the case.

1:09:47So the reason why the government could not pass an audit was because the information did not exist that would be required to pass an audit. It was literally impossible because you just had all these blank checks going on with no explanation and no payment code. So how are you supposed to do an audit? It's literally impossible. So that's what I mean by it's very basic stuff. We just want the congressional appropriation payment code to be mandatory and a very short explanation. We're not even going to judge what the explanation is, but that there be any explanation at all and a name attached was revolutionary. And my guess is this will probably save a hundred billion dollars a year. A lot.

1:12:18Sorry? What do you mean it fell off the balance sheet? Where did it fall to? It's like a comedy sketch. Comedy routine here. But wait, where did it go? Where did it go? I never heard that.

1:13:50Is it in the computer? Is it in the computer, like Zoolander, you know? It's in the computer. I mean, it's crazy. So there's, it's one nutty thing after another like that. Yeah. I mean… Anyway, we're just trying to basically fix the computers so that we know what the heck's going on. Yeah, it's just like…

1:14:22Like I said, we're being fully transparent with the American people so you know exactly what's going on and just making sure that, yeah, anyway, money is not wasteful or fraudulent. One interesting statistic was that 40% of the calls into social security were fraudulent, meaning that it was someone trying to get a social security payment that was going to a senior instead to go to a fraud ring. Almost half of the phone calls were fraudulent. Probably the other half were people asking, "What happened to my social security?"

1:15:05Like, "Hey, where did my… What happened?" This is bananas. Stuff you could find on the internet.

1:16:17Two-Factor Authentication. Yeah, this is really worth emphasizing because the radical left are saying that somehow we're stealing social security. First of all, I don't need the money. In fact, it's costing me a lot to be in this job. You had Tim Walsh dancing on stage showing a chart of Tesla's stock, which is a really awful thing for him to do because what they're trying to do is put massive pressure on me and Tesla, I guess, to, I don't know, stop doing this. But my Tesla stock and the stock of everyone who holds Teslas went roughly in half. I mean, it's a big deal. So not only am I not getting paid, definitely not stealing money and would never get away with it, but the value of my Tesla stock is in half. So this is a very expensive job is what I'm saying. But I think it's welcome. Speaker 12 : Thank you!

1:18:24You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you very much, guys. But long term, I think Tesla stock's going to do fine. So maybe it's a buying opportunity, but the actual thing we're doing is making sure that people do get their social security and that it doesn't get stolen.

1:18:45Yeah. Yeah. Sorry, go ahead. Speaker 15 : Hi, Elon. I got a question for you about Doge. Great shirt. Speaker 15 : Everybody in this room has got a bunch of money sitting in a bunch of little boxes in a bunch of different states, and it turned into crickets when you brought it up online that you were going to go check our gold. And I'm worried about the Democrats and Joe Biden's last administration with the money not being there. Did you get blocked or are you still able to go check that?

1:19:19Sorry, I'm not sure I understand exactly what you're referring to. Speaker 15 : Fort Knox. Oh, Fort Knox. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, right. Oh yeah, yeah. Well that's up to the president of course. But I think it would be awesome to live stream Fort Knox. I mean, that would be really fun. And after all, it is actually the gold of the American people. So the American people should, it seems to me, have a right to see their gold. Hopefully it looks really cool. You open the doors, like, "Is it there? Is that really gold? Let's check." So maybe it'll be really interesting. I'm all for it. The president says he's interested in doing it, so hopefully that happens. All right.

1:20:14Good. How's it going? Great. Oh actually, that reminds me. So it is actually possible to both register to vote on Tuesday. If someone has not registered to vote, they can register to vote in Wisconsin and they can vote same day. So even if somebody is not a registered voter, you can do it everything on Tuesday.

1:21:08Well, sure. Well, it is very hard to start a business and have it succeed. It is true that most businesses that start do not succeed. I guess I'd really just say if there's a product or service that you think is really needed, then you go out and you make that product or produce that service, offer that service and try to be as useful as possible really. It's like whether it's a great restaurant or store or a technology company or whatever the case may be, it's really just like, are you doing things that are useful to your fellow human beings? And if you are, then I think the company will be successful. So that's really what it comes down to is just being useful.

1:21:08People ask me what's the top advice? I'm like, "Try to be useful." It's actually very difficult to be useful, but I have a lot of admiration for anyone who just does an honest day's work making products or producing services for their fellow human beings. That's what a company is. That's it. But it is hard. To be totally frank, I generally say if somebody needs encouragement to start a company, I would recommend not starting a company. It's very difficult. If you look at say the automotive industry, the only two American car companies that have not gone bankrupt are Tesla and Ford. So it's a big cemetery is what I'm saying. So that's a tough one. Very tough industry.

1:21:08And there were really no commercial rocket companies that were successful before SpaceX. It is generally very difficult to make the value of the output exceed the cost of the input. And that's really what defines a successful business. And profit is really the difference between the value of the output and the cost of the input. That's what profit is, but it's shockingly hard to make the output more valuable than the input. That's what I've found. Yeah. All right. Speaker 16 : Hi, Elon. Thank you so much for being here. Would you agree with me that the economic illiteracy in this country is staggering? That people don't understand-

1:24:12Yeah. Speaker 16 : … how close we are for the ship- Yeah, I would say that that is true. Speaker 16 : … of America to going over the fiscal cliff. Yeah. Speaker 16 : Right.

1:24:19Yes. Actually, I think most people… Well I think a lot of people don't know what a national debt is. How did this national debt come about and how come there's all this money that somehow we owed but we didn't sign up to owing this money. But there's, it's over $30 trillion of national debt and that doesn't count future obligations and that doesn't count state and local debt. So basically it's a lot of money that the government has signed everyone in America up for. So if we don't do something about it, then eventually there won't be any money for anything. We'll just be paying interest. A company, sorry, I should say a country is much like a person.

1:24:19It just bigger a country is a collection of people, but just like a person can go bankrupt, a country collectively can also go de facto bankrupt essentially by diluting the currency to where it's worthless. And that's where we're headed, unless we are take immediate and dramatic action with respect to government spending. We're in deep trouble basically.

1:25:47Yeah, exactly. You've seen in a lot of countries where think things have gone to hell in a handbasket and it's like we just need to not do that. So if the ship of America sinks, we all sink with it. This is something that I try to tell people in the commercial sector that, "Your company's make it if the ship of America sinks." So we all got to work together here to make sure it does not. Antonio, feel free to ad-lib as you wish.

1:26:35Right, exactly. I don't think we can run off to some other country and be okay. I will die in America. I'm not going anywhere.

1:26:48I mean, I might go to Mars, but that'll be part of America. Yeah. Speaker 17 : Speaker 17 : Hi, Elon. Thank you so much for taking the time out of your busy schedule to be here today with us in Green Bay, Wisconsin.

1:27:09Yeah. Speaker 17 : I just want to say that DOGE's findings demonstrate to the American people that the government clearly does not care about our hard-earned tax dollars. I'm only 26, but I can imagine it's frustrating for people who have worked their entire lives to see their tax dollars going to fraud, waste, and abuse. You alone have contributed so much money to our government.

1:27:39Yes. Speaker 17 : Via taxes. So thank you. You're welcome. Speaker 17 : I'm sorry that your money's not being spent very well. You've clearly shown your leadership and team is capable of transforming our government into something better than what we see today. I just want to say, I'm sure I'm not the only one who's wondering, but we know that DOGE has found quite a bit of money and we would like to see some of that returned to the American people. Do you have any information on when DOGE checks would be written or sent out?

1:28:19Sure. Well, I guess we need to be successful at scale. We've made a lot of progress, but there's still a tremendous amount of work to do. Effectively as government spending is made more efficient and spending is reduced, the tax buyer inflation is reduced. So one way or another, you will effectively be better off if resources in the United States are not wasted. So, it's somewhat up to the Congress and maybe the president as to whether specific checks are cut. Whether a check is cut or not, if you reduce wasteful spending, the economy is going to be better off. There will be… People will do more useful jobs than before.

1:28:19The total output of goods and services will increase and then the average standard of living will increase. So that's, yeah… I think the most important lesson in economics is simply common sense that the more people in a country that are engaged in producing useful products and services, the better off that country will be. You could run the thought experiment to say in the [inaudible 01:29:50], if we moved everyone in the car industry into the DMV, there would be no cars, but there would be a lot of regulators. So then you say, okay, well then how many people should be in the government versus not government? Generally I think you want to minimize the number of people in government.

1:28:19There will still be a lot of people in government, but you want to keep that to a minimum and move people from low to negative productivity roles to high productivity roles in the private sector. Speaker 18 : Hey, Elon. So the first time I heard about population collapse I think was from you on Joe Rogan. I grew up in the generation where it was very overpopulation, global warming. A lot of people don't want to have kids. My wife and I just had our first, she's a year.

1:30:38Congratulations. Speaker 18 : Thank you. Absolutely. I mean, I've been banging the baby drum for ages. Speaker 18 : Yes. Yeah. So my question to you is, what's the most surprising and fulfilling thing you've learned from your kids? Especially we've seen you around X all the time with Trump. So what's your most fulfilling thing you've learned from having kids?

1:31:07Yeah, X is in the back there, so watching this hopefully. Yeah, I think nothing makes you happier than kids, really is the truth of it. So kids will make a greatest source of happiness. I really encourage, as Antonio knows, I've encouraged all my friends and everyone to have kids. It is concerning the United States has been below replacement rate. The birth rate in the United States has been below replacement rate since roughly when I was born around 1970, '71 thereabouts. I think last year was the lowest birth rate on record. It was very low. Then we're seeing this trend in almost every country on earth. This is worrying because it's like, well, if something doesn't happen, humanity's going to disappear. So it's I think, very important to have kids. Kids will make you very happy, but there's also like, we got to keep humanity going here. No humans, no humanity.

1:32:33Sorry? Yeah. All right. Well actually, perhaps I can ask you what should DOGE be doing with respect to the postal service? Okay. Okay. I suspect you've seen that things are not entirely perfect in the postal service. Yes. So I mean obviously delivering mail and packages is very important. There's reason for why the postal service was created, and I haven't really had a chance to look at the postal service yet. Speaker 20 : [inaudible 01:33:39].

1:33:42You do? Okay, sure. Well, he can't say because he works there.

1:34:27Yeah. It seems like some companies are not being charged the right amount for package delivery. There's probably more administrative overhead than there should be, would be some safe guesses, I suspect.

1:34:40Yeah. Yeah. All right. Yo, good. How's it going? Cool. Yeah. Sounds good. Oh, I did? Okay. Yeah. At this point, yeah, sure. I'll do that. Sure. I mean right now I used to only follow maybe a few hundred accounts and it was possible to read a lot, most of what they posted. Now I think I follow 1100 accounts, which makes it impossible. So it's just like I can only see a few things that people post at random essentially. So yeah. I'm trying to digest as much information as my human brain can manage. Yeah, thank you for your engagement and just in general try to report on what's really happening is great. Thank you.

1:36:35Exactly. Totally. Obviously for any kind of special election is going to get a small fraction of the attention of say a presidential election. Then normally an election for a judge would not be that big of a deal. It just so happens that in this case it could decide the control of the US House of Representatives, which is a huge deal. Speaker 21 : My personal experience with Judge Crawford, I am a family that she moved a pedophile right next door.

1:37:10What? Really? Speaker 21 : Yeah. It is a true story in the ads that you're hearing from Mr. Schimel. I am one of the homeowners that had to live next to him for many years unaware. So the letter that I wrote to her, I'm sure played into what we are experiencing now in family court. Family, we're veterans 20 years. It just was not good for him. It was not good for me. We're trying to work through our family court situation. What we're realizing is the two strategies that they use are indoctrination or intimidation.

1:37:10If you step up and say we're a practicing Catholic family, the result is her band of merry rogue judges and the court affiliates and the commissioners will flood the family court, have flooded the family court system. I guess my question would be, regardless of what happens with this very important vote, let's not forget what's happening in the family court system in Dane County, Wisconsin that's being flooded with these rogue judges and affiliates and commissioners.

1:37:10Who then, if you don't subscribe to what they're saying, they will just wipe out your ability to raise your family or proceed with your family in a way that you feel your culture dictates, your religion dictates, your financial background dictates. It has gone completely bananas. I'm wondering what you can do to keep the light shine on our court system in Dane County. It does have lasting effect on families and it will breed out our ability to raise our families in the spirit in which we feel is most healthy for our young, our children, and the sanctity of our family.

1:39:04Absolutely. I think that's fundamental to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, which is the foundation of America that you should have control over your family, not the state. The state should not have control of your family. It's insane that people would think that.

1:39:44Really? Yeah. No, there's I think it changed the law in California where if the teachers determine that it's in the kid's interest, if you don't respect, I don't know, a 10-year old's pronouns or something, the state can take your kid in California. So it's insane. State forced indoctrination and if you don't match their, whatever the state wants, then they can take your kid in California. It's a big deal. Speaker 22 : [inaudible 01:40:24] government.

1:40:25Yeah, exactly. It should just be, families should have control over their own circumstances and it should not be the government that decides how your children should be raised.

1:40:44There's a lot of questions, I see. We're going to answer everything at this point. Please, go ahead. Sorry, go ahead.

1:41:06That's a very sort of space question. So there are two towers in South Texas and we plan to build two towers at the Cape in Florida and then probably some more elsewhere in the future. There'll be twin towers at the Cape and Twin Towers in South Texas at the Starbase. All right. Speaker 19 : Hey, Elon, good to meet you. Thank you for everything you're doing for the country and the world.

1:41:43Thank you. Speaker 19 : I have two questions, they asked me to keep it short. Sure. Speaker 19 : One, when do you envision solving blindness and bringing that to the masses where it'll be for everyone? The other is, is robo taxi on schedule?

1:42:06Well there's a wide range of questions tonight. Yes. So for Neuralink, Neuralink has had in monkeys a working device we call Blindsight where it's been working well and monkeys are healthy for a few years now. We're hoping later this year to do our first device implant for human, enabling someone who is completely blind to see. It is going to be low res at first, like Atari graphics. So I want to set expectations appropriately. So it'll start off with very low res, but then over time I think eventually the implant would enable vision that is like superhuman. So that'd be pretty cool. Then, yeah, things are currently on track to do unsupervised full self-driving in Austin in June. So I think we probably, we will take maybe four more questions. So just two from that side and two from that side and then we'll call it a night. So go ahead.

1:44:01Yeah, we should restore the Smith-Mundt Act so that the government cannot spy or issue propaganda to the people. So yeah, I don't know. I mean I thought that we're headed in a good direction for a while there and then the last month or so there've been these crazy violent things happening against Tesla and protesting me and whatnot. I'm like, this is just nuts. A lot of people parading signs around saying that President Trump and Elon Musk should die type of thing. I'm like, this is really nuts. I think the real issue is who's organizing and funding that? The same people that organized and funded the infiltrators, the hecklers earlier tonight. So it's whoever they are. I guess we know some of their names but it's really. Speaker 23 : Soros.

1:45:07Yeah, yeah. Soros and bunch of others. I'm not sure really what… Sometimes I wonder what is their goal? What's their aim? I guess is it communism I guess is a part of it or just, I don't know. Sometimes I wonder have they thought through, what if, let's say they got their goal, then what? So I don't know. I'm hopeful that things calm down, that people engage in dialogue but not violence and that for those who do push violence and destruction of property and intimidation, obviously they need to face legal consequences for that. The president has said that needs to happen.

1:45:07Obviously if people are pushing violence and destruction of property, that is against the law and they need to face the consequences of that. Speaker 24 : Thank you, Elon. I constantly hear that the DOGE efforts are going to do things like take away Social Security payments and reduce other government payments like that. You've touched on it tonight. You've discussed it at length over the last few months. Can you talk again about how the DOGE efforts are actually going to affect things like the payments and other programs like that?

1:46:49Yeah, I guess it would be helpful because, so I just stated as crisply and clearly as possible that DOGE will absolutely ensure that people get their Social Security, make sure they get their Social Security, make sure they get their Medicaid and will not be cutting any legitimate payments whatsoever. Crystal clear.

1:47:37Yeah. Thank you for asking that question because it is something that, as obvious as it sounds, it's a great question because we just need to be very crisp and clear. DOGE will make sure you get your Social Security. DOGE will make sure you get your Medicaid. There'll be no cuts to legitimate payments whatsoever.

1:48:46Yeah. Speaker 25 : We all know that ideas have consequences and bad ideas have victims and thank you for speaking up for victims. A few nights ago when you spoke with Bret Baier when you were being interviewed and he asks you what keeps you up at night and like that other question, you answered. You paused and it was depopulation. I was waiting for you to say, oh, the death threats against my life or the national debt or, but depopulation.

1:49:23Yeah, depopulation is a really big deal. Speaker 25 : It's not on people's radar. Why is that?

1:49:31Well, I think we haven't yet evolved to deal with depopulation. I guess it's something we better evolve to deal with or we're going to disappear. Once the depopulation ball starts rolling, it seems to gather up speed. I mean you can look at cases like Korea and Japan, which are much further ahead or behind depending on how you look at it. The population decline there is much worse. Japan is an absolute population decline. So they're losing about I think roughly a million people a year. That's going to accelerate. Korea has only a third replacement rate, which means that in three generations the country will be three or 4% of its current size.

1:49:31Basically all that'll be left is a small portion of the capital city. I keep waiting for the birth rate to turn around, but it doesn't. It seems like a population collapse accelerates. That's why I think it's a very serious matter. If you believe in humanity at all, you should care about this a lot. That's a long-term thing. The short term thing is remaining is that America needs to be financially solvent. That's what DOGE is about, trying to just make sure America is financially solvent. Then there's also the risks of AI. So we want to make sure that AI is maximally truth seeking and ideally has values that most Americans would agree with and that it's a pro-human AI.

1:49:31That it wants to foster the future of humanity. Those are the things that I think about. Thanks.

1:51:57Sounds good. Well, I think he's going to help get the governor off your back. So that's a big deal. For anyone that starts the business, you used to just be able to open a store and not get a zillion permits and licenses and everything. That's how America… You wanted to make a product, you just made the product and you didn't have to satisfy a massive body of regulations and get permission from all sorts of agencies. So hopefully Justice Schimel supports that and helps get the government off your back. All right, so let me finish by saying obviously… Speaker 26 : We need DOGE at the state level.

1:53:02Yeah. DOGE at the state level will be cool. Just remember the importance of the election on Tuesday is gigantic. It could decide the future of the House of Representatives, it could decide then the future of America and the future of the world. So it's absolutely critical that you need to just drag friends and family to vote on Tuesday for Justice Schimel and for voter ID. So thank you. Thank you, guys. Thank you.

从现场发言里挑出的 10 句原话,附中文译文(AI 翻译,以英文原话为准)。点时间戳可跳到视频对应位置。

所以我们要恢复个人自由、言论自由,总的来说,就是让政府别管你。然后确保你在美国获得成功,靠的是你的努力和才华,而不是别的。

So we want to restore individual freedoms, freedom of speech, just in general, get the government off your back. And then make sure that you succeed in the United States as a function of your hard work and your talent and nothing else.

▶ 2:08

我完全理解如果有人不想买某个产品,是的,这由你决定,这是个自由国家,但你没必要把它烧了,好吗?这有点过了。那是别人的车,别动它。

I totally understand if somebody doesn't want to buy a product, yeah, it's up to you, it's a free country, but you don't have to burn it down, okay? It's a bit much. That's somebody else's car, leave it alone.

▶ 4:43

我的意思是,今天学校里向孩子们灌输那么多反美宣传,真是令人震惊。简直让人瞠目结舌。这到底是怎么回事?

I mean, it is astounding how much anti-American propaganda is pushed on kids today in schools. It's mind blowing. It's like, what the hell is going on?

▶ 5:35

对于Grok,我们的愿景是做一个最大程度追求真相的AI,也就是说,你总想尽可能接近真相,即使真相不受欢迎。这就是我们的目标,我认为这是一个非常重要的目标。

With Grok, our aspiration is a maximally truth seeking AI, which is like you always want to try to get as close to the truth as possible, even if the truth is unpopular. And that's our goal, which I think is a very important goal.

▶ 19:13

但这么说吧,国会里有很多富得蹊跷的人,我试着把线索串起来:他们怎么在挣钱的同时…他们一年挣20万美元,怎么会有2000万美元?没人能解释这一点。

But let's just say, that there's a lot of strangely wealthy members of Congress, where I'm trying to connect the dots of how did they become rich while earning… How'd they get $20 million, if they're earning $200,000 a year? Nobody can explain that.

▶ 22:57

冒着说点惊世骇俗的话的风险:呼吁谋杀可不酷。

At the risk of saying something outrageous, calling for murder is not cool.

▶ 29:00

我认为真正重要的是,政府支出不能远远超过政府收入。这是我们面临的一个根本问题:我们有2万亿美元赤字,而利息支出现在已经超过整个军队预算。

I think what really matters is that government spending is not far in excess of government revenue. That's a fundamental issue that we have where we have a deficit of $2 trillion, and we have interest payments that now exceed the entire budget of the military.

▶ 34:26

在努力节省一万亿美元支出时,我们要说的是,在7万亿美元政府开支中,看看能不能让效率提高15%——百分之十五。我相信我们能做到。顺便说,这其实不是多高的门槛。

In trying to save a trillion dollars of expenditures, what we're saying is of the 7 trillion in government spending, let's see if we can make it 15%, one, five percent, more efficient. And I'm confident that we can. That's actually not a huge bar, by the way.

▶ 37:49

我认为一般来说,拥有去中心化系统是好事,因为某个东西越集中,权力越集中在单一实体手中,就越可能产生腐败。所以我认为去中心化有利于把腐败降到最低。

I think generally it's good to have decentralized systems because the more centralized something is, the more power that is in any one single entity, the more corruption you're likely to have. So decentralization I think is good to minimize corruption.

▶ 1:01:44

人们问我最好的建议是什么?我会说:“努力做到有用。”实际上,做到有用非常难,但我非常敬佩那些为同胞制造产品、提供服务、老老实实工作一天的人。

People ask me what's the top advice? I'm like, "Try to be useful." It's actually very difficult to be useful, but I have a lot of admiration for anyone who just does an honest day's work making products or producing services for their fellow human beings.

▶ 1:21:08

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份