播客·中文精读

马斯克未删减完整专访 | Verdict 第216期

ELON UNCUT - THE COMPLETE INTERVIEW | Verdict Ep. 216

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

53 岁的马斯克坐在白宫,对面是参议员泰德·克鲁兹(Ted Cruz)。访谈开场,克鲁兹抛出第一个问题:你在推特(Twitter)看到的烂摊子,和你在联邦政府看到的烂摊子,哪个更糟?

马斯克的回答没有犹豫:联邦政府。而且比他预想的还要糟。

紧接着他补了一句让克鲁兹笑出来的话:往好处想,这意味着改进空间巨大。如果这是一艘管理良好的船,想改进反而很难。现在的情况是,你走进一个房间,四面墙、天花板、地板全是靶子,朝哪个方向开枪都能命中。

克鲁兹顺着这个比喻说,那就随便打,怎么打都不会落空。

一万五千人,三万份软件许可证

DOGE(政府效率部)查出来的第一类问题,简单到不需要福尔摩斯。马斯克说,在每一个政府部门,注意是每一个,至今没找到例外,软件许可证和媒体订阅的数量都远远超过该部门的人类员工数。

一个 1.5 万人的机构,可能有 3 万份软件许可证。更离谱的是,这 1.5 万人里相当一部分从来没登录过对应的应用。DOGE 甚至发现有些软件订阅的登录次数是零,政府一直在为一个没人碰过的东西付钱。

信用卡是另一个重灾区。政府信用卡的数量是人类员工的两倍。马斯克说,他到今天也没找到一个合理的解释。这些卡的额度是一万美元,加起来是笔大钱。

克鲁兹追问:你看到的这些,是无能,还是人类历史上最大规模的洗钱?

马斯克给了一个比例:大约 80% 是浪费,20% 是欺诈。中间还夹着大片灰色地带。

他举了个例子。财政部有很多笔付款没有付款代码,也没有任何说明。DOGE 去追查,发现某份合同本该被关闭,但有人忘了关,于是公司继续收钱。这算浪费还是欺诈?马斯克的回答是:都算。你拿了不该拿的钱,政府把钱打给了你,但没有任何一个政府的人要求你还回来。

19 亿美元给了一个假 NGO

访谈里克鲁兹专门问了一个案子:Stacey Abrams 那个假 NGO 拿了 19 亿美元。

马斯克的评价很直接:这就是腐败,是在给政治盟友发钱。他说,你收到 20 亿美元的时候不可能没注意到,这显然不会是意外。这笔钱名义上是用于环保家电之类的项目,到目前为止大概交付了 100 台家电。用 20 亿美元买 100 台家电,就算每台是 Sub-Zero 那种高端冰箱,这个单价也离谱到没法解释。

真正让马斯克觉得荒谬的是制度设计本身:政府可以把钱给一个所谓的非营利组织,附带的监管极少,事后也不审计。于是这个组织可以给自己发极高的薪水,报销一切,买私人飞机、买房子,像国王和王后一样生活,账单由纳税人付。

克鲁兹强调,这类事情在成规模地发生,一两个案例根本解释不了。

“魔法印钞计算机”

这是马斯克在这次访谈里提出的最有画面感的概念。

普通人会以为,政府的计算机系统彼此连通、数据同步、资金流向能对得上账,参议员看到的数字就是真实数字。马斯克说,想得太美。这些数字不能说完全错,但可能偏差 5% 到 10%。

他把任何一台能凭空创造资金的计算机叫做“魔法印钞计算机”(Magic Money Computer)。这些机器直接发出付款指令。财政部有几台,卫生与公众服务部(HHS)有几台,国务院有一两台,国防部也有。最初他提到 11 台,访谈里他说现在找到了 14 台。

克鲁兹回忆起 2024 年大选前,他在奥斯汀的家里和马斯克聊天。马斯克说他不想在华盛顿要一份工作,他想要的只是每一台计算机的登录权限。克鲁兹当时觉得这话有点怪,没听懂。后来他明白了:要改革政府,传统的思路是要一张组织架构图,坐下来和各个机构的负责人谈。马斯克的做法是直接钻进支付系统。

计算机为什么这么要紧?马斯克的解释是:政府是由计算机运行的。

总统签署一道行政命令,命令会经过一层又一层的人,最后落到某台计算机上才真正被执行。如果你想弄清楚账目、想砍掉浪费和欺诈,就必须能直接分析数据库。否则你只能问一个人,这个人再问另一个人,一层层问下去,最后通常问到一个承包商,承包商再去问另一个承包商,让他们在系统里跑个查询。

这就是真实的运作方式,隔了很多层。

克鲁兹把这个动作形容为“重写矩阵”(reprogramming the Matrix)。他承认,国会里没有人理解“拿到计算机权限”意味着什么,大家习惯的做法是要一份开支报告,而不是钻进管道里。

马斯克补充:钱不是用卡车运的,是电汇,走 ACH 或者 SWIFT 系统。要追踪钱,就得看电子资金流。

克鲁兹提到马斯克说过的一句话:如果任何一家公司像联邦政府这样记账,高管会被逮捕入狱。马斯克确认:如果是一家上市公司,会立刻被摘牌,公司会倒闭,高管会坐牢。联邦政府的会计水平就是这么离谱。

一万亿美元和一条时间线

克鲁兹问进度:你们已经查了多少,还有多少没碰?是几个月还是几年?

马斯克说不是几年。他有相当信心能砍掉一万亿美元的浪费和欺诈,也就是在 2026 财年(从 10 月开始)实现一万亿美元的净节省,前提是 DOGE 被允许继续干下去,且进度不被阻挠。

他强调透明度:DOGE 的每一个动作,无论大小,都放在 doge.gov 网站上,同时在 X 上发布。有人说你们在削减成本,那就来看,哪一笔不对?所有事情都在阳光下进行,这种透明度前所未有。

从“酷先生”到“全民公敌”

克鲁兹把话题转向舆论。五年前,马斯克是左派心目中的英雄:电动车、太空探索,去好莱坞派对不会有人给他脸色。现在,他说自己还能收到邀请,但不确定该不该去。

克鲁兹说了一句很重的话:今天在左派眼里,除了特朗普,他们最恨的人就是你。马斯克接了一句:我看起来是第二名。

他管这叫“埃隆精神错乱综合征”(Elon Derangement Syndrome),和特朗普精神错乱综合征并列。街上有人举着牌子,牌子上写着希望他死。

恨到这个程度的原因,马斯克的判断是:因为 DOGE 真的有效。如果我们没在真的砍掉浪费和欺诈,不会有这种反应。

他接着说,DOGE 查出的欺诈绝大多数在左派那边。零星也有右派的,但几乎所有被资助的 NGO 都是左翼的。

而左派最怕的一件事,是 DOGE 关掉那些欺诈性的福利支付:社保、联邦医疗保险(Medicare)、失业救济、残疾补助、小企业管理局的贷款,以及发给非法移民的福利。马斯克说,这就是核心,这就是为什么他们恨到骨子里,希望他死。

规模有多大?他估计全国范围加起来超过一千亿美元,可能两千亿。

他把这套机制讲得很清楚:通过福利欺诈,民主党吸引并留住了大量非法移民。这些人依赖政府补助,投票时压倒性地投给民主党,加州已经演示过一遍。这是一套选举策略,是权力。

他算了一笔账:一个摇摆州常常只差一两万票就能翻盘。如果民主党能带进 20 万非法移民,随着时间推移让他们合法化,这个州就不再是摇摆州。这还没算作弊的部分。摇摆州会一个个变蓝,众议院、参议院、总统、最高法院全部落入一党之手,然后他们再引入更多非法移民来巩固这个结果。到那时,你没法靠投票走出来。

克鲁兹接过话:那就是一党制的社会主义国家,而且比加州更糟。因为在加州你至少还能搬走,搬到德州。他们要把每个地方都变成加州,而且更糟。

访谈里有一段私人回忆。疫情期间,克鲁兹遛着狗给马斯克打了 45 分钟电话,劝他离开加州搬来德州。他说,加州的共产党人受不了你,德州欢迎你。马斯克当时没马上搬,但不久之后就搬了。

加州对特斯拉做过什么?马斯克说,封锁几乎杀死了特斯拉。全国其他车厂都被允许复工,唯独位于加州的特斯拉工厂不被允许。他用了“几乎杀死”这个词。

充电站被点燃,谁在出钱

克鲁兹提到死亡威胁,说这不是他自己的想象,社交媒体上到处都是。有人举着牌子游行,说马斯克必须死。

他问:这些人是疯子,还是有外国势力、国内势力在背后?特斯拉充电站被纵火,这是有组织、有资金支持的吗?

马斯克的回答是:至少有一部分是有组织、有资金支持的,来自美国国内,基本上是左翼组织,由左翼亿万富翁资助。

克鲁兹点了名:ActBlue 是其中一个。马斯克提到了 Arabella,那个经典的左翼资金网络。

关于 ActBlue,马斯克讲了一个细节。这个平台上的个人捐款记录里,出现了一批死忠共和党人,一辈子没捐过钱的人,突然显示“我捐了 16.6 万美元”。这些人自己都不知道。他朋友的例子很典型:查到自己出现在 ActBlue 的名单上,说这绝对不是我。

克鲁兹把逻辑推到法律层面:如果能够证明这些钱在资助对特斯拉充电站的燃烧弹袭击,那就构成资助恐怖活动。法律条文写得很清楚,燃烧装置符合恐怖活动的定义。

十年后,AI 比最聪明的人更聪明

话题转向 AI。

克鲁兹问:十年后,AI 会让普通人的生活发生什么变化?

马斯克说,十年是很长的时间。按目前的改进速度,十年内 AI 会在认知上比最聪明的人类更聪明。同时会有大量人形机器人,最终达到数十亿台。

克鲁兹插了个玩笑:为什么你的机器人长得那么像那些吓人的机器人?马斯克说他本来期待对方会说“就是故意吓你的”。他解释说,Optimus 的设计不参照任何已有的机器人,会持续迭代。很多部件是外观件,可以像换壳一样换掉,你想让它长成别的样子也行。

关于自动驾驶,马斯克给了明确的时间表:十年内所有汽车都是自动驾驶,大约 90% 的里程由自动驾驶完成。五年内大约 50% 的里程是自动驾驶。

克鲁兹问了一个所有人都在担心的问题:如果 AI 比任何人都聪明,多少工作会消失?几百万人失业之后,人们干什么?

马斯克的回答是:商品和服务会趋近于免费。

为什么?因为有几十亿台机器人,它们能为你制造任何东西,提供任何服务,成本几乎为零。人们的生活水平不会下降,反而会大幅提高。真正的挑战落在另一件事上:意义感。你从哪里获得成就感,从哪里找到生活的意义。

20% 的概率,我们造出终结者

克鲁兹直接问:《终结者》里的天网是真的吗?杀人机器人灭绝人类的概率有多大?

马斯克的回答:大概 20%,也许 10%。

时间框架?他说就在十年之后。

但他马上给了另一面:你可以把这杯水看成八成满。八成概率是人类迎来极度的繁荣。

他补了一句这次访谈里被传播最广的话之一:我们正在和中国进行 AI 竞赛,如果要出现杀人机器人,我希望它们是美国的,而不是中国的。

克鲁兹问:美国现在领先吗?

马斯克说未来几年美国大概率会赢,但最终取决于谁控制 AI 芯片的制造工厂。如果更多工厂在中国手里,中国就会赢。

而现在的现实是:几乎所有先进 AI 芯片的工厂都在台湾。目前 100% 的先进 AI 芯片产自台湾。

如果中国在近期入侵台湾,全世界会立刻断供先进 AI 芯片。克鲁兹问把产能搬回美国有多重要,马斯克的回答是:对国家安全至关重要,而我们做得不够。

Zip2、PayPal,和一张 2.1 亿美元的支票

访谈中段,克鲁兹请马斯克讲创业史。两人同龄,生日只差 118 天,克鲁兹坐下来第一件事是感慨对方 53 岁已经做完这么多事。

1995 年,马斯克在斯坦福读博士,方向是超级电容,作为电动车储能的潜在方案。他判断互联网是那种罕见的机会:你可以选择当研究生旁观,也可以选择下场参与。他想,研究生院以后还能回去,读博的内容不会变,但互联网正在发生,他没法忍受只是看着。于是他退了学,创办了第一家公司 Zip2。

第一版软件是他一个人写的,包括互联网上最早的黄页、白页和地图导航。1995 年写的,四年后卖给康柏(Compaq),价格大约 3 亿美元现金。

他说了一个细节:毕业时他背着大约 10 万美元的学生贷款。刚到北美时,他带着 2500 美元、一包书、一包衣服。

3 亿美元里他个人拿到 2100 万。他本可以拿这笔钱去过舒服日子,但他想继续在互联网上做更多事,于是创办了 X.com,后来和彼得·蒂尔(Peter Thiel)、麦克斯·列夫琴(Max Levchin)的 Confinity 合并。合并后的公司最初还叫 X.com,后来改名 PayPal。今天人们知道的 PayPal,公司注册文件是他亲手递的。

克鲁兹提到那段著名的“宫廷政变”:马斯克在度蜜月兼融资的途中被董事会罢免了 CEO 职位。马斯克承认,他当时在做一些风险很高的动作,那些动作最终可能会成功,但他人在外面,没法安抚团队的担忧。他说,你不能在战斗最吓人的时候离开战场。

后来两人和解了。马斯克说,现在他还会住在蒂尔家里,蒂尔也投资了他几乎所有的公司。

去莫斯科买洲际导弹

2002 年,SpaceX 成立。但马斯克原本的计划完全不是自己造火箭。

他最初的设想是:拿 PayPal 那笔钱(税后大约 1.8 亿美元)中的一大部分,做一个公益项目,把公众对火星的热情重新点燃,然后 NASA 的预算就会增加,人类就能去火星。他甚至想好了画面:一个温室,里面有种子和脱水营养凝胶,着陆后水合,绿色植物在红色背景上生长。他说,那个镜头会很有冲击力。

他还讲了个插曲:他后来才知道 money shot 这个词在别的领域有完全不同的意思。

原计划就是花钱让 NASA 去火星,自己当那个出钱的人。

然后他发现,美国的火箭太贵了。波音、洛马的价格是天文数字,他买不起。

于是他去了两趟俄罗斯,想买洲际弹道导弹(ICBM)。

为什么俄罗斯会卖?因为和美俄之间的削减战略武器协议,俄罗斯有义务销毁一批洲际导弹。那些最大的导弹加一级,理论上能把一个小载荷送到火星。

克鲁兹听得入神,追问:你打给谁?俄罗斯战略火箭军?对方真的卖吗?

马斯克讲了价格谈判的过程:最初报价 400 万美元一枚,下一次谈变成 800 万,再下一次变成 1800 万,注意,这还都在签合同之前。他想,如果签合同之前价格就能翻这么多倍,签完之后会被宰成什么样。

莫斯科的谈判一度变成对吼。他在那边用蹩脚的俄语和对方互喊。他说,真该把那场面录下来。

这轮谈判前后持续了大约半年。最后一趟他带上了迈克·格里芬(Mike Griffin),后者后来成为 NASA 局长。

在回程的飞机上,马斯克想明白了一件事:他最初的假设错了。美国不是没有去火星的意愿,美国缺的是可负担的去火星的方式。

SpaceX 就这么诞生了。

克鲁兹补了一段背景:那些年美国连国际空间站都上不去,得靠俄罗斯送。一张联盟号(Soyuz)的座位,俄罗斯后来要价到 9000 万美元,而他们自己的成本大约 1000 万。马斯克说,这就是 SpaceX 出现之前的现实,很窝囊。

专利是给慢慢创新的人准备的

克鲁兹提到几个月前在博卡奇卡(Boca Chica)看星舰发射。五年前那里是德州南端一片空沙滩,现在是一个城市加一座工厂,每个月造一枚火箭。

在那次访问中,马斯克说了一段让克鲁兹印象极深的知识产权观点。

马斯克说,专利是给那些创新缓慢的人准备的(patents are for the weak)。

特斯拉把专利全部开源了,任何人可以免费使用。他们申请专利只有一个目的:防止专利流氓抢先申请、卡住特斯拉的路。所以特斯拉会预判哪些地方可能被专利流氓堵住,自己先申请,然后开源,让它免费。

他承认有例外。比如制药,一款药的三期临床试验可能要花 10 亿美元,但之后生产成本只有几美元。如果允许立刻仿制,就没人愿意付那 10 亿去做试验,这就是搭便车问题(free rider problem)。这类情况需要另做安排。

除此之外,他的观点是:大多数专利阻碍创新,抑制的作用大于促进。专利制度的初衷是最大化创新,执行下来常常反着走。点子本身是容易的部分,执行才是难的部分。老话讲 1% 的灵感加 99% 的汗水,实际上灵感可能还不到 1%。

克鲁兹接了一句:而流汗那部分,你干得特别好。

为什么几乎什么都自己造

克鲁兹问:你的公司都在造实体产品,车、火箭,做不好就是真出事。这种精密制造的能力和执行力是怎么建起来的?

马斯克说,他采用一种从物理学第一性原理出发、回到最基本约束的思路。他一开始并没打算垂直整合,实在没法有效外包。

特斯拉早期的设想是把几乎所有制造都外包出去。找遍全市场,没有能承接的公司。外包制造在美国是例外而非常态。于是一步步被迫内化,SpaceX 也一样。

他说了一句很重的话:因为不得不做,他变得非常擅长制造。到现在,他可能比历史上任何人都更懂制造,因为他在太多不同领域造过太多不同的东西。

克鲁兹说这听起来是个惊人的说法,但不疯狂。

接着他问作息:你每天睡几个小时?马斯克说平均 6 小时。克鲁兹说,你说 3 到 4 小时我也不会惊讶。那你每天工作几个小时?马斯克说,几乎所有醒着的时间都在工作。

克鲁兹讲了个细节佐证。他早年约马斯克吃饭,马斯克的回答是:我不吃晚饭,我基本上不参加社交晚餐。克鲁兹说,他没有在拒绝,他只是在陈述一个事实:为什么要专门去餐厅坐两小时?他的做法是把午饭和晚饭放在会议里吃,边吃边继续开会。

在办公室地板上睡了多少个晚上

马斯克回忆,这个习惯从第一家公司就开始了。那家公司叫 Zip2,他自己评价这名字很糟糕。他们租了个漏风的阁楼办公室,月租 500 美元,而附近最便宜的公寓要 800 美元。他和弟弟加起来只有 5.5 万美元。于是决定住在办公室。

他们买了几张能翻成床的沙发,晚上睡,早上来上班之前再翻回沙发。洗澡去街那头的 YMCA。这样过了好几个月。他说,那段时间身材很好,因为在 YMCA 锻炼。帕洛阿尔托 Page Mill 路那家 YMCA,他现在还记得。

克鲁兹问,你这一生大概有多少个晚上睡在办公室?马斯克说没数过,可能有几百天。

克鲁兹最后问:你现在是地球上最富有的人,还睡办公室吗?马斯克说,睡过。

火星:最早 2029 年,20 年建成自给城市

访谈后段回到火星。

克鲁兹问:人类第一次踏上火星是哪一年?

马斯克:最早是 2029 年,而且不会比这个时间晚超过两到四年。他强调这是人类本人踩上火星表面,无人任务另算。

克鲁兹问:你自己会去吗?马斯克说,他想在某个时点去火星。有人问他是否愿意死在火星上,他的回答是:愿意,只要不是摔死。

关于外星生命,马斯克说他不认为我们会找到活着的外星人。但可能找到两种东西:一个早已死亡的外星文明的遗迹,或者地下的微生物。

那火星城市什么时候能建成?马斯克先给了一个判断标准:真正的门槛是那座城市能不能在来自地球的补给船停止之后继续增长、继续繁荣。跨过那一刻,文明的预期寿命会大幅延长。

为什么这么在意这个门槛?因为文明可能死于一声巨响,也可能死于一声呜咽。可能是一场核战争,可能是一颗像干掉恐龙那样的陨石,也可能只是一个糟糕的病毒,让地球失去向火星发射飞船的能力。鸡蛋不能放在一个篮子里。

技术上来讲要多久?马斯克说,20 年可以做到,但确实需要 20 年。

需要什么?大概 100 万人,100 万吨货物。更重要的是,要在火星上重建地球的整个工业基础。从采矿开始,材料经过几百道精炼工序,种粮食,种树,用木头做东西。所有这些都要在火星上从零建起来,而火星是一个充满敌意的环境。火星赤道附近的夏天,有时气温能高于零度,整体非常冷。

初期人类只能住在生命支持舱里,不可能露天生活,也呼吸不了那里的空气。克鲁兹问会不会是玻璃穹顶,马斯克觉得这种形式有可能。

选址方面,他提到阿卡迪亚平原(Arcadia Planitia)是不错的选择之一。他有个女儿就叫 Arcadia。他大儿子的中间名是 ArM,基本就是 Mars(火星)的缩写。克鲁兹笑说,你在给自己的孩子取名字时都已经想到这一步了。

好奇心是底层驱动力

克鲁兹问:你碰过的每件事几乎都成功了,客观上就是如此。别的聪明人也有,但他们盯着自己的肚脐眼,什么也没做出来。你哪里不一样?

马斯克说,他有一套好奇心的哲学。他想弄清楚宇宙的本质,理解宇宙。要做到这一点,人类必须去其他行星,看其他恒星系,也许还有其他星系,也许能找到其他外星文明,或者至少是它们的遗迹。

他还想弄明白:宇宙要往哪里去?它从哪里来?以及还有哪些问题是我们尚不知道该问的?

这段话可以看作他所有公司的统一解释。特斯拉为了让能源转型发生,SpaceX 为了让文明多一个备份,Neuralink、xAI 也都挂在这套“理解宇宙”的框架上。

绕不开的几个小问题

访谈最后是快问快答。

最聪明的人?他提到拉里·埃里森(Larry Ellison),也提到拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)。他说聪明在某种程度上要看成果,你做出过什么困难和重要的事。他举了杰夫·贝索斯(Jeff Bezos),说贝索斯做了很多困难和重要的事。他最后补了一句:有很多人属于“对人类而言很聪明”的那一档。

《星球大战》还是《星际迷航》?他六岁在电影院看的第一部电影是《星球大战》,影响很深。最好的星战电影是《帝国反击战》,他当年和父亲排了三个小时队看首映。柯克还是皮卡德?两个都喜欢,但柯克。他说柯克是共和党人,皮卡德是民主党人,这话说出来左派会很生气。最好的《星际迷航》电影,他提了《可汗怒吼》,还提了第四部《抢救未来》,他们回到旧金山找鲸鱼,斯科蒂拿起鼠标说话,那部被低估了。

汉·索罗先开枪了吗?马斯克的回答很有意思:看起来像是他开了第二枪。但他补充,格利多的点射在近距离打空了,除非格利多先被打中,否则没法解释。所以他站在“汉先开枪”这一派。他说他不喜欢被清洗过的故事。

国际空间站上的宇航员是政治囚犯吗?马斯克说是的,有一部分是。SpaceX 本可以把他们接回来,但拜登的白宫说不。这不是 NASA 的决定,是白宫高层的决定:不想让一个支持特朗普的人在选举前把宇航员救回来。克鲁兹问,如果你是那两个宇航员,会不会气疯?马斯克说,如果他是民主党人就不会,一个是共和党,一个是民主党,取决于你问谁。

如果今天是你的最后一天,一百年后人们会记住你什么?马斯克的回答是:如果 SpaceX 把人类送上火星,那件事会盖过其他一切。

克鲁兹在节目最后说,他在 X 上征集问题,最常见的留言是:请转告马斯克,谢谢你。你不必承受这些,但你在做。马斯克回应:这对文明的未来是必要的,否则我不会做这件事。没人想要死亡威胁。

把这期访谈用起来

两个多小时的信息量很大,真正能拿走的,是几套可以迁移的思考方式。

  • 要找系统性问题,去看钱的电子流,别只看汇报材料。马斯克没从组织架构图入手,他要的是每一台支付系统的登录权限。任何组织里,真实的资源分配都写在流水里,不在 PPT 里。想搞清楚一家公司、一个部门、一个项目到底在干什么,先去看它的付款记录和账号数量,那两个数字比任何汇报都诚实。
  • 许可证数和人头数的比值,是一个低成本的组织健康指标。1.5 万人配 3 万份许可证,信用卡数量是员工的两倍。这类比值不需要审计就能看出来,任何团队都能自查三件事:我们为多少东西付钱,实际用的人有多少,登录次数为零的有多少。
  • 浪费和欺诈要分开算,灰色地带交给流程解决。80% 浪费、20% 欺诈,中间大片是“合同该关没关,钱继续打”。处理这类问题的落点应该放在流程上:让关闭成为默认动作,追责排到后面。靠人记得去关,永远关不完。
  • 把“第一性原理”翻译成一句可执行的话:我没法有效地外包。判断该自制还是外包,不必先问“核心不核心”,去市场上真找一遍。找不到能接的就自己做,找得到就交给别人。
  • 对 AI 的两种未来同时下注。八成是极度繁荣,两成是灾难。这个概率分布意味着两件事都要做:全力推进,同时把安全问题当真。只谈其中一面的叙事都不可信。
  • 记住 100% 这个数字。先进 AI 芯片目前全部产自台湾。讨论 AI 竞争时,把注意力从模型参数拉到晶圆厂,谁掌握产能,谁掌握节奏。这个视角比榜单更能说明谁在领先。
  • 效率的代价是社交成本。不参加社交晚餐,把饭放进会议里吃,睡办公室沙发。这套做法不适合所有人,它揭示的事实是:极致产出的背后一定有被明确放弃的东西。想清楚你愿意放弃什么,比想要得到什么更重要。

整期访谈里,最有分量的一句话与火星无关,也与 AI 无关。是克鲁兹转述的那个提问:如果你和马斯克喝啤酒,你会问什么?最多人说的是“谢谢你”。

一个做电动车、发火箭、买下推特、现在去查政府账本的人,收到的最高评价是这两个字。这大概也说明了,为什么他会在访谈里说那句话:这是文明未来需要的事,否则我不会做;没人想要死亡威胁。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00[Music] welcome in his verdict with Senator Ted Cruz Ben Ferguson with you and today is our exclusive conversation with Elon Musk the entrepreneur and innovator who is transforming Industries and is dismantling government waste Fraud and Abuse with Doge must Relentless pursuit of technology and space exploration continues to capture the world's imagination in this episode we unravel the thoughts and aspirations of a man who defies conventional boundaries pushing Humanity towards New Horizons so join us in the white house as we continue to explore the riveting journey of Elon Musk a modern day Pioneer whose revolutionary ideas are set to redefine

0:48tomorrow today is a really fun day CER because we have a special guest and we're in a special place I'm going to let you do the rest of the intro well we're in the white house right now and we're here with my friend Elon Musk who really has not been doing much of anything has not made any news is and nobody has noticed yeah the impact welcome Elon thank you holy crap yes wow let me just say never at dull moment never a dull moment the first 50 days the president has spent in office over the top and the first 50 days you've spent I I don't think there's ever been anyone to have an impact the way you have the beginning let me let me start with a question you know a lot about

1:31which was worse the mess you found at Twitter or the mess you found in the federal government well it's hard to compete with the federal government what surprised you about the federal government I I assume you came in and assumed it was bad is it worse than you expected it it is worse than I expected but on the plus side that means there's more opportunity for improvement so look if you look on the bright side there's there's actually a lot of opportunity for improvement in federal government expenditure because it's so bad if it if it was a well-run ship it would be very difficult to improve so like but but you so so now it's like people say well how how will

2:09you figure out how to save money in the federal government well it's like being in a room where the the walls the roof and the floor are all Targets so you shoot in any direction yeah and you're wi you can miss wow I'm sure you would agree so a lot of folks have talked about like like you can't you can't miss can't miss just go any direction a lot of the crazy expenditures things like like two million bucks for sex change surgeries in Guatemala an essential you know transgendered mice and and Sesame Street in Iraq a lot of that has gotten attention but some of the stuff you've told me about but like tell us about computer licenses and government agencies yeah so most of what

2:51do is finding you don't need to be Sherlock Homes okay it's very obvious B basic stuff so in in every govern Department I say every because we've not yet found a single exception there are far too many software licenses and and media subscriptions meaning many more software licenses and medum subscriptions than there are humans in the department like you were saying like an agency with 15,000 people might have 30,000 licenses yes and even of the 15,000 employees a good chunk of them hadn't used the license had never logged on or used the used the application yes we're found entire situations of of software licenses or media sub subscriptions with

3:33there were zero logins so it had and yet we were paying for it yes the government was paying for thousands of licenses of software or media subscriptions and no one had ever logged in even once or like credit cards you found the same thing with government credit cards we found that there are twice as many credit cards as there are humans could just and I still don't have a good explanation for why this is the case and these are $10,000 limit cards so a lot of money is it incompetence that you're finding or is this like the biggest money laundering scheme in the history of the world that you're finding look I think it's mostly if you say look what's

4:11the waste to fraud ratio yeah in my my opinion it's it's like 80% waste 20% FR but but but but you do have these sort of gray areas y example example would be so we saw a lot of payments going out of Treasury that had no payment code and no explanation for the payment and then we we we're tra we're trying to figure out what that payment is and we'd see that okay that contract was supposed to be shut off but but someone forgot to shut off that that contract and so the company kept getting money wow now is that waste or fraud

4:50yeah both both yeah yeah I mean you know you're getting something you're not supposed to get you're not supposed to get it but you but the the government sent it to you and nobody from the government asked for it back or take for example the one the $1.9 billion given to Stacy abon's a fake NGO utter Insanity explain that story that's that's just corrupt I think that's paying off cronies at that point 1,000% yeah yeah and by the way she knew like when you get $2 billion you don't miss that that's not that's not an accident that's allegedly it was for like you know environmentally friendly appliances or something and they've given like like like 100

5:30appliances so far for $2 billion it's very expensive toaster an appliance that's Subzero fridge boy it's nice right now since this just obviously one of the biggest scam Port holes we've uncovered which is really crazy is is that is that the government can give money to a so-called nonprofit with with very few controls and then that and there's there's no auditing subsequently of that nonprofit so there's no so this is way with the you know 1.9 billion Stacy ABS who's they then give themselves extremely lavish like insane salaries expense everything to the to the nonprofit you know buy Jets and homes and all sorts of things live like kings and queens yes on the taxpayer down

6:16correct you you mentioned this is happening at scale it's not just one or two we're seeing this everywhere now one of the things you told me about is is what you called Magic Money computers at the well so tell us about because I never heard of that until you you brought that up okay so you may think that these that that the government computers like all talk to each other they synchronize they they add up what funds are going somewhere and it's you know it's coherent that that that the you know there's and that and that the numbers for example that you're presented as a senator yeah are actually the real numbers in one would think one would think they're not yeah

6:57okay I mean they're not totally wrong but they're probably off by 5% or 10% in some cases so I call a magic money computer any computer which can just make money out of th a best magic money so how does that work it just issues payments and you said there something like 11 of these computers at treasury that are that are sending out trillions in in payments they're mostly a treasury some are with the sum at HHS some at

7:25there's one one or to at State there's some at DOD I think we found now 14 Magic Money computers okay they just send money out of nothing you have an ability to see where leverage points are and and how things actually happen so I remember back I think it was September or October of this year before the election we didn't know who was going to win and I I was at your h house in Austin we were talking about it and and and you said you you you said look I I I don't want a job in in Washington you said all I want is the login for every computer and and I remember thinking at the time that sounded kind of weird like I just didn't get it and I have to say what

8:05what's interesting on this if I would have thought like okay how do you reform government like sort of the traditional way to think about it is okay give me an orc chart let me sit down with the people who are running agencies and and what you saw immediately is to understand what's really going on get to the payment systems get to the computers yeah like like why are are why is getting to the computer so critical to understanding what's actually happening well the government is run by computers so you've got essentially several hundred computers that effectively run the government and if you want to know did you know that Ben no like yeah so

8:47when somebody like even when the president issues an executive order that's going to go through a whole bunch of people until ultimately it is implemented at a computer somewhere and if you want to know what what the situation is with the accounting you're trying to reconcile County and get rid of waste and fraud you must be able to analyze the computer databases otherwise you can't figure it out because all you're doing is asking a human who will then ask another human ask another human and finally usually ask some contractor who will ask another contractor to do a query on the computer wow that's how it actually works so it's many layers deep so the

9:22only way to reconcile the databases and get rid of waste and fraud is to to actually look at the computers and see what's going on so you that's what I call that's like that's what I when I sort of cryptically referred to reprogramming The Matrix you have to understand what's going at the computers you have to reconcile the computer databases in order to identify the waste and fraud I don't know that there was anyone in Congress who understood certainly myself included who understood the leverage that comes from the computer and the data in particular that that Congress would think about give me a report on what your expenditures are rather than

10:02actually getting into the pipes and I think that has been fascinating that it's let you uncover a bunch of crap that just nobody knew yes I mean in order for money to go to a bank account it it's it's not like we're sending truckloads of cash all over the place we're it's a we're wiring money right we're sending money through the a system or through the Swift system so in order for money to flow it's going to flow electronically so that's that's what you need to look at you need to look at the the the the actual electronic money flows and Tesla and all your companies you have accounting and you have every expenditure you have it coded for what

10:35it's going for federal government doesn't work that way they don't code with the money's going for they do not but they didn't they didn't and and like one of the things that that that you told me you said if any company kept its books the way the federal government does they'd arrest the officers and put them in jail yes if it was a public company it would be delisted immediately it would fail it's ordered and the the officers of the company would be imprisoned that's level of heiness in the federal government unfortunately it's deliberately or do you think this is in confidence again it's 80% it's 80% incompetence or and 20% malice so if if you look at if you look at Doge now

11:16and you look at the government and what you're finding what percentage have you guys even gotten to and how much of it is Mars where you haven't even gotten there yet because there's so much you're finding out here I mean how many you seem like a timeline guy when you say all right I want to get in there and get all these you know numbers and things how far are we from the ingame where you've seen it all been able to process it all and fix it I mean are we years away months away not years I I I I mean I'm reasonably

11:50confident that we'll be able to get a trillion dollars of waste and fraud out and that that meaning that it will have we'll have a net Savings in FY 26 which starts in October obviously of of a trillion dollars W provided we allowed to we're allowed to continue and and we're and our progress is not impeded and and and we're very public about what we do yeah you put it on the website on the website how we could be more transparent literally every action we do small or large we put on the Doge dot.gov website and we post on on the X handle and when people complain about it I I I and they say oh you're doing something on cost well which of these con doing it in the

12:31daylight everyone knows exactly what you're doing extreme transparency yeah I don't think it's anything's been this transparent ever so five years ago you were a hero to the left you were cool you had electric cars you had space and in five years you've g go I could could go to a party in Hollywood and not get dirty looks yeah in fact yeah a and now you might not even get invited still get invited but I don't know if I should go I don't think it's an exaggeration to say today after Donald Trump the left hates you more than any person on Earth yes I appear to be number two I mean if you're judged by the various signs they it's derangements it's Trump derangement syndrome and Elon

13:15derangement syndrome how is it that for you that's a little bit of whiplash of going from being like Mr Cool to the devil incarnate in just a couple of years is that is that kind of weird to experience that transformation yes why do they hate you so much well because we're we're clearly over the target if Doge was ineffective if we were not actually getting rid of a bunch of Wast and fraud and a bunch of that fraud I mean the fraud we're seeing is over overwhelmingly on the on the left m i mean there's it's not zero on the right but these NOS are almost all leftwing NGS that are being funded for example y so they they because

13:59doge is being effective and doge is getting rid of a lot of waste and for that they were that people in left were taking advantage of that that's that's that's what it comes out to and and the the the single biggest thing that they're that they're worried about is that doge is is going to turn off fraudulent payments of entitlements I mean everything from Social Security Medicare you know unemployment disability small business administ registration loans turn them off to illegals this is the Crux of the matter y okay this is this is the this is the thing that why why they really hit my guts and want me to die and do you think that's billions hundreds of

14:43billions what do you think the scale is of that I think across the country it's it's in it's wellth of 100 billion maybe 200 billion so by by using entitlements fraud the Democrats have been able to attra ract and retain vast numbers of illegal immigrants and and buy voters and and buy voters exactly the it basically bring in I don't know 10 20 million people who are beholden to the Democrats for government handouts and will vote overwhelmingly Democrat as has been demonstrated in California this is over it's an election strategy yes it's power yes and and it doesn't take much to turn the swing States blue I mean often a swing state might be won by

15:3110 20,000 votes sure so if the Dems can bring in 200,000 illegals and over time get them leg legalized not not counting any cheating that takes place because there is some cheating but even without cheating if you if you if you if you have if you bring in illegals that are 10x the voter differential in in a swing state it will no longer be a swing state right and the the dams will win all the swing States just a matter of time and America will be permanent

15:59deep blue socialist state where at the the house the Senate yep the presidency and the Supreme Court will all go hardcore Den they will then further cement that by by ex bringing in even more aliens so you you can't vote your way out of it their ob one party socialist State and it'll be much worse than California because at least California is mitigated by the fact that someone can leave California you can go to Texas yeah exactly you did they going to make everywhere California but wor by the way the middle of the pandemic I spent 45 minutes on the phone with Elon he was still in California I was walking my dog Snowflake and trying to convince you

16:38come to Texas the commies in California can't stand you we love you we want you here and you didn't quite go then but you went not that long afterwards I mean the the the co actions U almost killed Tesla because they they let every other Auto Plant in the country was allowed to open but ours which was in California was not allowed to open wow wow so they almost killed Tesla so as a

17:03as a personal matter did do you ever regret it like five years ago you go to the Oscars and Mr Cool and now you're you've got death threats every day like do you well these days the Oscars are boring I wouldn't want to go God bless the movies they nominate no one on earth has ever seen like like could they actually nominate a movie that human beings go watch I mean the how many great movies have come out in the last several years very few depressingly few yeah very few the last Oscar came and went I don't even watch it there's nothing to see I I was sad that Jee Hackman just passed away because Unforgiven was spectacular but that was a long time ago that un forgiven came

17:39out you You' mentioned today here and before about the possibility of someone wanting to take you out dealing with the death threats we see it's not in my imagination you could just look on social media yeah but like is is it because very clear yeah and look I'm I'm very familiar with that and they've got signs people with signs and demonstrations saying that I need to die do do you think are these just whack

18:06jobs or do you think there are foreign sane people do you think there are foreign entities behind this do you think there are domestic entities behind the the threats and also the attacks to Twitter like or not Twitter Tesla I mean you know you're getting Tesla's charging stations lit on fire do do you think that's organized and paid for yes at least some of it is organiz has paid for I think by domestic you know what basically

18:36leftwing organizations in America funded by leftwing billionair essentially is it like act blue or what act blue is one of them you know Arabella you know the classic it's funded by the you know the the the blue basically the the left wing and cabal how big of a thread is this to like what you build at Tesla I mean I remember when Teslas came out it was people that they didn't want to have gas cars a lot of it was environmental reasons I jokingly said I was like I'm a Texas guy I'm always going to have something that burns gas my kids now all three of my boys think that the that Teslas are awesome the Cyber truck is the car they want their dad to buy which I laugh

19:24because I never could have imagined that five years ago and now I'm looking at well we're at the White House in the president's Tesla parked right outside the West Wing which is the fullest damn thing you've changed a generation when you look at my kids are six and eight and they're going dad buy a cyber truck and I'm considering it that's a that's a Full Circle in a weird way yeah well I do have this theory that the most entertaining outcome is the most likely so yeah it seems often to be

19:52true you see like what what twist or turn of Fate well I the highest ratings if this was if we were a TV show what twistter fate would generate the highest ratings that there's a good chance that happens well I will say if if act blue and Arabella networks act blue is a huge scam next level do you think it's foreign money Chinese money where where do you think the money in act blue is coming from how do you figure that out well it's not coming from the in from a whole bunch of from a a ground swell of public support because when individual donors looked at in act blue they a bun turn to be like die hard Republicans right people have never given money in their life so

20:33you're going to track down a bunch of these people where it says oh I gave $166,000 and they're like I don't give $116,000 what are you talking about this this Republican friends of mine found themselves on the ACT blue list and they're like it defin wasn't me so that's if it can act actually be shown that they are funding firebombing of Tesla charging stations that's objectively a criminal act that that is funding terrorist activity and and the statutes make clear that an incendiary device qualifies so down is a terrorist activity yeah let me ask AI in 10 years how is life going to be different because of AI for for just a normal person well 10 years is a long

21:18time in 10 years probably AI could do anything better than a human can cognitively probably almost I think in 10 years based on the current rate of improvement AI will be smarter than the smartest human yeah yeah there will also be a massive number of robots so humanoid robots by the way I got to ask how come your robots look so much like the creepy robots for my robot was was that intentional or just I was hoping he was gon to say yeah just to mess with you it's not meant to look like any any prior robot and we'll iterate the design you and you you'll be able to have a lot of the robot parts are cosmetic you'll be able to switch out the kind of Snap-on cosmetic parts of

22:09the robot make it look like something else if you'd like so there will be ultimately billions of humanoid robots all cars will be self-driving in 10 years in 10 years probably 90% of miles driven will be autonomous huh wow that fast yeah in 5 years probably 50% of all miles driven will be autonomous now if AI will be smarter than any person how many jobs go away because of that and what do people do if you've got millions of people that are losing their jobs like that a lot of people are understandably freaked out about that well I Goods goods and services will become as close to free so it's not as

23:02though people will be wanting in terms of goods and services so why is that what why are goods and services free in an AI world or close to free well you have I don't know pull it tens of billions of robots that that they will they will make you anything or provide any service you want for basically next to nothing it's it's not that people will be will have a lower standard of living they'll have actually a much higher standard of living the the challenge will be fulfillment how do you derive fulfillment and meaning in life is Skynet real like like like you get the apocalyptic visions of AI how real is the prospect of of Killer Robots annihilating

23:54Humanity 20% likely maybe 10% on what time frame after to 10 years so soon like you you you see a world where that's possible yeah but I mean you could look at it like the glasses 80 90% full meaning like 80% likely will have extreme prosperity for all now I guess my view we're in a race to to win AI we're in a race with China and my view is if they're going to be killing robots I'd rather they be American Killer Robots than Chinese How likely are we winning right now is America winning right now and How likely is America to win the race for AI Vis China or anyone else for the next few years I think America is likely to win then it will be a function of who

24:48controls the AI chip fabrication the factories that make the AI chips who controls them if they're control if more of them are controlled by China then China will win more of the factories that are making the AI chips you you think that will determine it yes and how are we doing versus China on that front well right now almost all

25:15the advanced AI chip factories they call them Fabs are in Taiwan and what if China invades Taiwan miles away from yeah if what what happens if China if China invades Taiwan what happens to the world well if they were to invade in the near term the worlder would be cut off from Advanced AI chips and currently 100% of advanced AI chips are made in Taiwan how fast could we put that online in America and how important is that for National Security I think it's essential for National Security and we're not doing enough you're 53 years old I'm 118 days

25:58older than you by what the hell have I done in my life I know right 53 years old she did pretty well well so 71 was a great year and I was December 70 so I was just just right before you were the summer of 71 I born 69 days after 420 wow I I I I did ask Ben this is true all right you just you just open up 10 words I I did ask Ben should I show up and pull up a joint and say c can we beat Rogan's views but but I was pretty sure it might cause a scandal if if we SP house it just turned out to be like a chocolate cigar yeah let me ask you if If Today Was Your Last Day on Earth yeah what what I'm not suggesting it's going to be but if it were what do you think your biggest

26:46Legacy would be if everything you've done a hundred years from now what do you think people would remember if if if if it were zero to today and will you ever go to space in the in the distant future 100 or thousand years ago if SpaceX got humans to Mars that's what they would remember me before all right final set of questions who's the smartest guy you've ever met you hang out with some brilliant people like like when you look what's a CEO you look at other than yourself what CEO do you say damn that guy's good Larry elon's very smart so say Larry Alison's one of the smartest people you know Larry

27:33pagee I mean there are a lot of people that are very smart it's hard to say like you know I think to some degree smart is as smart does so you know what if what have they done that is difficult and significant you know Jeff feos has done a lot of difficult and significant things things I mean there are a lot of smart humans I call them smart smart for a human a lot of people who are in the smart for a human category all right final lightning round Star Wars or Star

28:15Trek the first movie I saw in the theater was Star Wars so I think it had a profound effect on me I was six years old I think imagine if first movie you ever see in a theater it's Star Wars it's going to BL your mind best Star Wars movie Empire Strikes Back the the only objectively right answer I stood in line for three hours with my dad to see it on opening day Kirk or peard I

28:43like them both but Kirk again objectively right answer by the way James T Kirk is a Republican and peard is a Democrat and and the left gets very mad when I say that yeah best Star Trek movie I mean the original the first Star Trek M that's in okay R of KH actually both both both Wrath of KH were pretty good but yeah the original Wrath of KH Ricardo monoban revenge is a dish best served cold it is very cold in space although I will say rathon is objectively the right answer but but four is a sleeper when they go back to San Francisco and and and go find the whales and and you know Scotty picks up SPS picks up the mouth and talks to it then goes a keyboard how

29:33quaint that's a sleeper all right last question did Han shoot first H it seemed like he shot second I like it this is verdict and by the way I apologize Ben so Ben was a jock and played tennis at Old Miss and so so occasionally when when we geek out a little I love watching y'all geek out over there might have first over because the guy still on the question I he missed his the alien missed his Blaster shot so why did he missed his Blaster shot must have been because he got shot first no he's missing a point blank Bassel shot if unless they got knocked off kill but it's a question of real consequence which is is Han Solo simply a hero or an anti-hero and and so I'm in

30:16the Han shot first category I don't like sanitized stories he would have had to have shot first because otherwi why why would the alien miss a Point Blank Range are you ever going to go to outer space is that say in your life yeah I'd like to go to Mars at some point and and people have said do I want to die on Ms and I say yes just not on impact now that's a very good answer the astronauts on the space station are they political prisoners some of them are because because you could have given them a ride back and and and Joe Biden said no purely for politics yeah I mean you know there's been some debate about this online but the thing is that it was very

30:58a very high level decision so it wasn't really even a NASA decision it was just that the Biden White House did not want to have someone who was Pro Trump rescuing astronauts right before the election so they posted well if you're one of those astronauts you got to be pretty pissed off about that well if they're a Democrat yes

31:20Republican yes if a Democrat like everything's fine fair enough so I think one of them is a republican one is a Democrat so depends which one you asked what year does man first set set foot on Mars I think the soonest would be 29 29 yes and I don't think it's more than two to four years beyond that and that's not an unman that's that's a human being putting his foot on the surface yes best case would be 29 and what do you what do you put the odds of finding either alien life or evidence of alien life I don't think we're going to find aliens okay but do we find ruins do we find remnants we may we may find the ruins of a long dead alien civilization that's possible and

32:11we may find Subterranean microbial life that's possible all right if man lands on Mars in 29 how soon after that do you land on Mars it remains to be seen I'm not sure the important thing is that we build a self-sustaining City on MOS as quickly as possible the the key threshold is

32:38when that City can continue to grow continue to prosper even when the supply ships from Earth stop coming at that point even if something would happen on Earth it might might it might not be World War III but it might be that a bad virus yeah yeah it might not be say like like say civilization could die with a bang or whimper it may be that Civilization dies with a whimper rather than a bang or and simply loses the ability to send ships to Mars but so you OB need Mars to be become self- sustaining and be able to grow by itself before the resupply ships from Earth stop coming that that is the critical civilizational threshold Beyond which the probable lifespan of civil

33:27ation is much greater and how close are we technologically to be able to do that to have a self-sustaining settlement on the surface of Mars I think it can be done in 20 years but it would take 20 years so we're not in 29 we're not there what are we missing what are the big Technologies we we don't have a few people running around the surface in a hostile environment is not going to make it self-sustaining right so you're going to need on the order of a million people maybe a million tons of cargo so but you think we could have a million people on Mars in 20 years yes and and what are what's the technology we're missing right now when you think about a million

34:06people on Mars do we have the ability to get water to get food to to keep them safe what I mean what what do we need to make that happen well you need to recreate the entire base of Industry of Earth so you know we're here at the top of of a massive perative industry that starts with mining V array of

34:29materials those materials going through hundreds of steps of refinement we grow food obviously we grow trees we make things out of the trees there's you know you've got to you've got to build all that on M and M is a hostile environment it's you know it sometimes gets above zero on a warm summer day near the equator on M really it's quite cold and how do you prep for that well in the beginning on Mars you have to have a a life support habitation module right like you need you can't just live outdoors you can't breathe the air like a dome you think is likely yeah glass domes type of thing have you identified a location on Mars that is likely to be ideal for a

35:18habitat what it might be Arcadia planetara is one of the one of the good options that's one of my da is his named Arcadia after that and what makes that attractive my eldest son's middle name is AR M you've been thinking about this for a long time if you're naming your kids around it my eldest kid is middle name is essentially Mars when did you get the dream like I mean it's 20 now 2021 soon this is a decades old yeah dream so like when you were 10 did you look up and say I'm going to Mars no

35:59no I read a lot of science fiction books and programmed computers but the first fin off the first video game that I sold was a space video game called

36:21blastar and you've managed everything you've touched has been an extraordinary success yeah yeah look I mean that's just objectively right so what what has led to that because there are other smart people that that's not true and they gaze at their nebal and they don't do anything so what what do you do differently that makes you so effective well I suppose I have a philosophy of curiosity I want to find out the nature of the universe understand the Universe and in order to do that we have to travel to other planets see other star systems maybe other galaxies find perhaps other alien civilizations or at least the remnants of alien civilizations

37:09gain a better understanding of where is this universe going where did it come from and what questions do we not yet know to ask about the answer that is the universe so let's go back 25 years late '90s you're at PayPal how do you turn PayPal into the success it was which which then helped launch you to the next one and the next one yeah so I studied physics and economics in college is a good foundation for understanding how the economy works and how the how reality Works and then was going

37:43to do a PhD at Stanford in Advanced Ultra capacitors actually as a potential means of energy storage for electric transport put that on hold to start an Internet company essentially came to the conclusion that the internet was one of those rare things and I could either watch it happen while a grad student or participate and I figured I could always go back to grad school you know grad school is going to be kind of the same but I I I couldn't bear the thought of just watching the internet happen so I wanted to be a part of building it so I created a an internet internet company we did the first Maps directions Yellow Pages White Pages on the internet I

38:33actually wrote the first version of the software software just by myself in 95 and we ended up selling that to compact Texas company I guess yeah for about $300 million in cash about four years after I graduated wow so I should say just to preface that I I graduated with about $100,000 in student debt so it wasn't yeah you and me both yeah yeah where's my right I know and when I first arrived in North America I arrived with $2,500 a bag of books and a and a bag of clothes all right so you sell the company for 300 million how how much does that change your life well I got $21 million Blackjack and but I wanted to do more on the internet so started a company called X

39:28which mer with a company called confinity which is Peter teal and Max Leon yeah and the combined company was actually at First still called x.com but we later later changed the name of the company to PayPal because of all the name changes it's kind of confusing but the company that people know is know as as PayPal today was actually I filed those incorporation documents for that company interesting yeah well and and as you know Peter teal and I were buddies back in the mid90s he went and of this but you know I became friends with him when he was a corporate lawyer in New York and just sort of a young libertarian with with a lot of dreams so it's it's

40:08been a heck of a journey yeah yeah and now obviously Peter was involved in a coup you know we had a little sort of knifing in the Senate situation where you know that they did CW me at at at PayPal I kind of now did you all make peace after that yeah yeah yeah I mean I was doing a lot of sort of risky moves that I think ultimately would have been successful but I then went on a two we trip which was a a dual money

40:42raising trip and honeymoon since I'd not done my honeymoon earlier in the year so I was raising money while doing doing H honeymoon but I was kind of a was how did that go by the way it worked it worked there you go kind of it worked ra money yeah yeah and we had a honeymoon there you go so yeah but you don't want to be away from the battle when things are scary so I was not there to assuage the concerns of the troops and

41:14anyway we we patched things up and have been friends nonetheless and yeah know these days I like stay at his house and stuff so obviously we're friends and he's also invested in in most of my companies all right so 2002 you you start SpaceX like how do you start a rocket company like what's the first day where you're like I want to make rockets and I want to go to Mars like what what do you do on day one so I think you have to start with a some sort of philosophical premise in order to have in order for the in order to be in order to be highly motivated you have to have some philosophical Foundation

41:57in my case it was that that we want to expand the SC the scope and scale of Consciousness to better understand the nature of the universe and in order to to expand expand Consciousness we need to go beyond One Planet if we're if we're on one planet there's there's too much risk you know hopefully Earth civilization prospers very far into the future but it may not there's always some risk that we are we self annihilate through nuclear war or that there's a big meteor that takes us out like the dinosaurs y there's always some risk if all your eggs are in one basket so it's going to be better if we're multiplet species and then once we're multiplan species

42:42The Next Step would be to be multi- stellar and have civilization among on on many different star systems so in 2001 I didn't think that I could I didn't think I could sell a rocket company so I I thought take some of the money from PayPal and that that case I think it was about $180 million after tax something like that and I thought you know I don't need $180 million so I'll spend a bunch of it on a philanthropic MOS mission to get the public excited about going back to Mars or going to Mars I should say yeah Mars was always going to be the destination after the Moon right in fact if you told people in 19 in 1969 that it would be 2025 and we've not even

43:33gone back to the Moon let alone it's hard to believe let alone Mars they'd be like what happened did civilation did civilization collapsed stop yeah like like they would be incomprehensible that we've not been to Mars by now if you told people L after landing on the moon in 69 why do you think in 50 years America never went back to the Moon well we destroyed the Saturn 5 rocket that was that that could take people the moon and had the space shuttle which could only go to lowth orbit and then there really hasn't been anything to replace any no no vehicle has been made since then that can go to the moon or to Mars until the SpaceX Starship rocket yeah so can't go

44:15to Mars if you don't have the ride so I remember you and I first met in 2013 when when I was a brand new baby Senator and I was still down in the basement office they stick freshman senators in basement office kind of like hazing yeah yeah I about say it sounds like there are 100 Senate offices but for six months you stay in the basement put you in your place but it's like wearing beanie they just they want you to know where you're supposed to be you know I got to say now 13 years into it I think there's a lot of wisdom to doing that but you were down in the basement office and I remember you were coming and sitting down with SpaceX and at the

44:48time the Air Force was not letting youall bid to to launch satellites and see you're coming and saying look we got a company I think we can do a really good job of this and yet we're locked out of this it's a little amazing to think the journey SpaceX has gone from then to now yes it's hard to believe that this is all real because originally consistent with my belief that we need to become a multiplan species I thought the only way to do that would be through NASA so and I think I thought well if

45:20if I can just get the public excited about Mars then they'll do a mission to Mars and so my thought was to have to send a small Greenhouse with seeds in dehydrated nutrient gel then land the greenhouse hydrate the seeds and you see these this the sort of money shot the money shot would be green plants on a red background yeah I also recently learn that mon shot has a different meaning in some other Arenas but yeah I'm glad you very very different story but what I'm trying to say is the the the captivating shot would be the green plants on a red background and that hopefully that would if we did something like that that would get the public excited about Mars

46:03that would increase NASA's budget and then we could send people to Mars so your original dream was NASA to do this yes not you no the original original plan was literally to to take a bunch of the money from PayPal and I guess by some people's definition Wast it with no no profit on a nonprofit thing to I wanted to spend a whole bunch of my money money for free to get NASA's budget to be bigger so we could go to fraking Mars right wow that's what I wanted so that was the Holy Grill that's what I wanted I was like so when did you change go to Mars that's what I wanted to know when when did it strike you okay you're going to have to do this if you

46:42want I tell you it gets crazier all right it gets crazier so so then I couldn't afford any of the US Rockets because as you know the US Rockets are way too expensive the bo locky rock lucky Rockets are crazy money I didn't have I didn't even even with 180 million there no way I could have afford how much were they back then well the the with with the additional stage

47:02to get to Mars it would have been about like 80 million so technically I could have afforded one of them but I wanted to do two in case one of them didn't work yeah so and then I didn't have enough money for that and I was sort of prepared to you know I don't know waste half the money and I figured if I had 90 million left that' be fine you know but ideally not all of it so I went to Russia twice to to try to buy icbms oh interesting how'd that go and who do you call the Russian rocket forces do they sell icbms does that work yeah you got to tell us the story then I want to know who you can buy anything in Russia yeah I I like please walk me down

47:47that I want to know how you made that phone call and when you get there how did that work and what do you tell your friends you know listen I'm I'm going to Russia device of ICBM I I might not you know depends on the situation literally so I guess slightly less insane when you when you understand that the Russians had to demolish a bunch of their icbms because of you know salt talks like the peace because of basically an agreement between the United States and and Russia to reduce the total number of icbms sure Russia was actually obligated to scrap a bunch of their icbms so took the very biggest icbms you could convert those into a rocket at an additional stage and

48:32and send something to Mars so so those are big enough with one more stage to get to Mars to send a small payload to Mars yeah so the ss8 so you try to buy cbms do you succeed or no or do you figure out you got to build your own instead they kept raising the price on me so because I figured like look they're going to throw these things in scrapyard anyway you should get a really good deal yeah right so the price started out

49:00at at 4 million then the next conversation there were at 8 million then the next conversation they were at like1 million and I'm like this is before we signed a contract by the way was there another bidder was there another bidder or were you the only one trying to buy them I think I don't know if there were other bids but they didn't mention any other bids yeah but I was like man if if the price is increasing this much before the contract signed yeah I'm really going to get fleeced after the contract signed so so I got pretty frustrated there

49:32actually in some cases we got into like shouting matches in Moscow some guy shouting at me in Russia and I'm shouting back at him in really badly you know I'm like so you are all I mean you're all ining me off in Moscow yeah so man I should have recorded that that would have been one for them how many days were you there negotiating that first time I mean was this like ongoing yeah yeah this this took place these conversations took place over probably six months or so wow so

50:11and then the final trip trip there was with the with was with Mike Griffin who later became Assa administrator I actually realized in the in the course of this that my original premise was wrong that that America actually has plenty of will to go to Mars but needs that it just needs a way to go to Mars that is Affordable and that doesn't break the budget you know well as you know we couldn't even get to the space station we needed the Russians to to to get us to our own space station that was embarrassing it really was pitiful I'm not sure most Americans know just how much we were being fleeced like I think they got up to like $90 million a seat yeah wow yeah for a seat that

50:51cost them like 10 that was pre Doge obviously but it was the only before SpaceX but but $90 million a seat for a seat that cost them 10 million is high yeah that's a lot of money yeah so a few months ago you and I were down in Bach chica with the president for a Starship launch and it is incredible what you built in Bach chica you know five years ago it was an empty beach at the southern tip of Texas sandar yeah and it's now a city and and a factory where you're building a rocket ship a month with with Incredible precision yeah but one of the things you you said to me when we were down there that really stood out to me is is is you said your philosophy on intellectual property

51:34talked to lots of CEOs they're like yeah we fight to guard our IP and and you had a very different approach what what's what's your view of Ip patent of the week Pat for those who innovate slowly I I literally do not know anyone else in business who would say something like that like like it was a startling and and and and what Elon said down there is he said look this stuff I assume everyone will steal everything but by the time they steal it will be five generations Beyond and it won't matter yes at at at Tesla we actually open source to live patents so we said our patents are anyone can use them for free really yeah the only we only do patents at Tesla to to avoid patent

52:15trolls causing causing trouble so we'll try to look ahead say Okay patent trolls going to Tri P file patents to block certain things will file patents and then open source patent make it free I mean it when I say patents for the week now there are a few cases in in say with Pharmaceuticals where it might cost you a billion dollars to do a P3 human trial but then subsequently the the drug is very cheap to manufacture so cases there are some in my opinion which should massively reduce what can be patented and and and say because the whole point of patenting is is to maximize Innovation not inhibit it m and in my opinion it's maybe a controversial opinion most patents

52:57inhibit Innovation they do not help it but there are case I want to do want to single out cases like where such as a face3 clinical trial that might cost a billion dollars but the then the drugs thereafter cost a few dollars to manufacturer and and if you can then immediately copy those drugs for a few dollars no one will pay for the billion dollar a free riter Problem free riter problem exactly so you have to address the free riter problem but other than that there should be no patents the ideas are easy you want ideas to flow maximum to people to get there faster and do things bigger the idea is the easy part the hard execution is the hard part as the old saying goes It's 1%

53:35inspiration if not less than 1% and 99% perspiration but I'll say the perspiration part you're really damn good at also because you're making you know the companies You're Building are actually building stuff they're building cars they're building spaceships they're building things that if they don't work it's a real problem and and the Precision you man facture things with how do you get that level of precision how do you get how do you build a culture you're not you're amazing at thinking outside the box but but what's interesting is you you may even be better at execution which is how do you execute so effectively well I take a post physics

54:14post principal approach to everything it's not as though I I I wanted to insource manufacturing it's just that I was unable to Outsource it effectively so you know the idea in the beginning of Tesla was that we would Outsource almost all the manufacturing but then it turned out there was no there were no good companies to Outsource manufacturing too which there wasn't really really wasn't Peaceable outour manufacturing actually is the exception of the rule and and just over time we had to ensource almost everything for Tesla and same for SpaceX I became very good at my facturing because I had to there's no choice at this point I might know more

55:00about manufacturing than any any human ever has because I've done so many I've manufactured so many different things in so many different Arenas I think probably more than anyone ever has look that's that sounds like an astonishing statement but it's not a crazy statement and and you're somehow running Tesla and running SpaceX and running X and running the boring company and running norlink and doing Doge how much do you sleep in a given night about 6 hours on average so about six so so that's it wouldn't have shocked me if you said three or four so the next question is how many hours do you work a day I work almost every waking hour and and Ben he he's not

55:42kidding at that like when Elon and I were first getting to know each other I suggested I said hey let's grab dinner sometime and I don't know if you remember what you said you said I I don't eat dinner I don't have social dinners really right I mean that yeah you obviously eat food but the idea you're not going to restaurant for two hours but the idea of like I I don't but it was it was just kind of matter of fact why would I go to dinner like I you you work yeah I I literally just thought I'll have lunch and dinner BR during meetings and continue the meeting how many nights have you slept at your offices you think your career percentage wise where you say I just got to take

56:23this nap basically because my body forces me to and I got to get back to work fast and efficiently without going somewhere else well I guess it started out even with with the first company sub2 which is a terrible name but the first internet company the we were able to rent an office which was like in a leaky attic essentially for $500 a month and the the cheapest apartment we could find was $800 a month so like and we only had about $55,000 between brother and I MH so we're like we're not we'll we'll we'll just stay in the office yeah so we got some couches that converted into beds and we'd kind of sleep at night and then we just have to like turn the

57:12the beds back into couches before anyone came and then we we sh the YMCA down the road and so that went that that that that literally was the for several months what we did was in great shape you know work out out the why I still remember that that YMCA at Page Mill alino in paloalto so that was a long time ago so it's been I don't know I've never thought to count it but several hundred days maybe I don't know so you're now the richest man on earth do you still sleep at the office well that's true maybe Mars we we'll we'll find someone else but I think if if someone is a sovereign head of a country that in facto richer by a lot do you still sleep at the office now I have

58:00slept at the office yeah well thank you Elon this this was this was awesome and and let me say and by the way I I put out on X the day before yesterday if you were having a beer with Elon and could ask him anything what would you ask and got lots of responses yeah the most common response people said is is is say thank you look Texans and the American people appreciate what you're doing you don't have to put up with this BS and you're doing it I'm grateful you're making a hell of a difference for this country I appreciate you and the Americans appreciate you thank you it's essential for the future of civilization otherwise I wouldn't be doing it yes

58:34it's not like I want to get death threats you know no don't forget we do this show Monday Wednesday and Friday hit that subscribe or Auto download button from the White House it's been a pleasure thanks for being with us on verdict we'll see you guys back here in a couple days [Music]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份