大会演讲·中文精读

2025 卡塔尔经济论坛:马斯克暗示对 OpenAI 与政治立场转变

Qatar Economic Forum 2025: Elon Musk Signals Shift on OpenAI and Politics

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2025 年卡塔尔经济论坛,马斯克坐在台上接受访谈。主持人问星链进入南非是不是存在利益冲突,马斯克的回答是反问:为什么南非会有种族主义法律?主持人说这不是我该回答的问题。马斯克说,这是你的采访,所有人都想听你说,你回答。

场面僵在那儿。主持人坚持要马斯克回答是或不是,马斯克坚持要主持人先回答他。双方来回拉锯了好几轮,最后主持人放弃,转去问 DOGE 的省钱数字。

这一段几乎是整场访谈的缩影。马斯克这次不打算做一个配合提问的受访者,他对每一个他认为前提有问题的提问都当场掀桌,把问题原样扔回去。他形容那位主持人的提问方式像"困在传统记者的 NPC 对话树里",说跟这种人说话像在跟电脑对话。

抛开现场的剑拔弩张,这场对话里塞满了实打实的信息:OpenAI 的官司打到哪一步、他为什么一边喊着要管 AI 一边反对监管、DOGE 到底省了多少钱、USAID 的账怎么算、他还会不会再掏钱搞政治。下面按主题拆开看。

你出钱保护雨林,对方转头开了伐木场

主持人先提 OpenAI。马斯克用一个类比说明他为什么起诉这家公司:

假设你资助了一个非营利组织去保护亚马逊雨林。结果他们不干这个,而是变成了一家伐木公司,把森林砍了,把木头卖了。你会说,等一下,这不是我出钱要干的事。这就是 OpenAI。

OpenAI 最初是非营利机构,靠捐赠运转,使命是让通用人工智能造福全人类。后来它长出了一个营利实体,现在正计划彻底转成营利公司,而且不再开源。在马斯克看来,捐赠人出的钱和最初的承诺被一起打包卖掉。

主持人追了一句:OpenAI 不是调整过公司结构吗,多少回应了你说的那些问题?马斯克的回答很短:那只是他们告诉媒体的说法。

主持人问,所以你确定要在法庭上见?马斯克说,当然。

这里有个信号值得留意。OpenAI 的重组方案在法律和资本层面牵扯极多,微软的股份、员工期权、非营利母体的存续,每一样都要重新谈。马斯克把话说死到"法庭见",意味着这场官司不会因为对方在结构上做点让步就收场。他要的已经超出修补的范畴,他要让这件事按他理解的原样退回原点。

裁判多到踢球都会撞上人,这球没法踢

接下来是 AI 监管。主持人翻旧账:三年前你在这个台上说,美国缺一个联邦层级的 AI 监管机构,类似 FDA 或者 FAA,还说要主动监管而不是被动应对。现在你自己站在削减监管那一边,是不是改主意了?

马斯克说没改。他用的还是那个裁判员比喻:

你可以把监管者想成球场上的裁判。场上应该有几个裁判,但不能多到你一踢球就撞上裁判。

他的判断是,美国大部分行业的监管负担已经重到"场上裁判比球员还多"。他把这归因于一个历史规律:长时间繁荣且没有生存性战争,社会就失去了清理冗余法规的机制。 战争会强制淘汰没用的制度和机构,和平年代没有这个东西,于是议员每年立新法,监管者每年出新规,一层层往上堆,堆到最后什么都是违法的。

他举的例子很能说明问题。拜登时期,司法部起诉 SpaceX 不雇佣政治庇护申请者。但 SpaceX 受 ITAR(国际武器贸易条例)约束,雇佣任何非美国永久居民都是违法的,理由是这些人可能把先进火箭技术带回本国。两条路都通向违法。

做也犯法,不做也犯法。司法部偏偏选了一条来起诉我们。

这个案例之所以好用,是因为它不需要讨论监管的尺度是否合适,它直接展示了规则之间互相打架的状态。当两套规则同时要求你做相反的事,你唯一的出路是祈祷没人来执法。

马斯克区分了两类行业:汽车、航空航天、食品药物这些存在了几十年的老行业,监管过度;人工智能这种新行业,监管不足,压根没有监管者。所以他说自己三年前的立场没变,现在依然认为 AI 需要一个监管机构。监管本身他从来没反对过,他反对的只有密度。

这个区分很重要,因为外界容易把他归到"反监管"阵营里去,尤其是在他主导 DOGE 大规模砍预算之后。他自己的表述是:新领域该有人管,老领域该松绑。至于这两个方向怎么在同一个政府里同时推进,他没展开。

我只是顾问,没有正式权力

主持人抛出的下一个问题很直接:你名下公司拿着联邦政府几十亿美元的合同,同时你又通过 DOGE 掌握了政府内部的运作信息,这算不算利益冲突?

马斯克的答法是把身份降到最低:

我只是一个顾问,没有正式权力。总统可以选择接受我的建议,也可以不接受。

他还给了一个可证伪的标准:如果我的任何一家公司拿到了被认定为不正当的合同,那会是头版新闻,就算我不提,竞争对手也会提。你没看到这类新闻,就说明不存在利益冲突。

这个论证有它的道理,也有它的漏洞。道理在于,SpaceX 和特斯拉的竞争对手确实盯得很紧,任何一点可疑的合同授予都会被放大。漏洞在于,很多利益输送不需要走到合同授予那一步,规则怎么定、预算怎么排、审查从哪个部门开始,这些环节本身就能产生影响,而这些环节不会上头条。

主持人换了个角度继续问:DOGE 进驻了每一个联邦部门,你对波音、蓝色起源、火箭实验室这些竞争对手和联邦政府之间的关系有了内部视角,这怎么说?

马斯克的回答把 DOGE 的工作范围缩得很小:只审查机构里有没有已经不再相关的部门,以及正在授予的合同是不是物有所值。他说这个门槛其实不高,只是问一句这份合同有没有价值。有建议就提交给部长,部长决定采不采纳。所有动作都发在 DOGE 官网和 X 上的 DOGE 账号,完全透明。

他还补了一句:到目前为止,他没看到哪怕一项关于利益冲突的指控。这句话成立的前提是,他说的"指控"指的是公开报道层面的指控。

南非有一百四十条法律,按肤色分配机会

访谈最激烈的部分在星链和南非。

背景是这样:彭博社当天报道,南非政府正在想办法绕过黑人持股比例的规定,好让星链能在南非运营。时间点很微妙,正好赶在南非总统拉马福萨访问白宫前夕。主持人把这个新闻摆出来,问马斯克认不认为这是利益冲突。

马斯克的反应是掉转枪口:

你应该先问,为什么南非会有种族主义的法律。这才是问题所在。南非有种族主义法律是不对的。

他提到曼德拉,说曼德拉的主张是所有种族一律平等,正确的做法是用一套种族主义法律替换另一套种族主义法律,这件事本身就错了。他说南非现在有一百四十条法律,给黑人南非人以强烈倾斜,其他族群没有。然后他讲了自己的处境:

我出生在南非,但拿不到星链的运营许可,因为我不是黑人。

主持人没有接这个话头,坚持要他回答是或不是。马斯克说,这不是我该回答的。主持人说,这是你的采访,大家都想听你说,你回答。马斯克说,你回答我的问题。来回几轮之后,主持人转向下一个话题。

这段对话的僵局本身比任何一方的论点都更有信息量。主持人的提问框架是"你个人是否从政策松动中获益",马斯克的框架是"这项政策本身是否正当"。两个框架并不互斥,但谁都不肯先进入对方的框架。

就事实层面说,南非的 B-BBEE(broad-based black economic empowerment,广泛黑人经济振兴)法案体系确实是全球范围内最激进的种族矫正政策之一,它的设计初衷是纠正种族隔离时期造成的资产和机会分配失衡。这项政策的正当性、有效性和执行方式,在南非国内一直有激烈争论。 马斯克把它直接定性为"种族主义法律",这属于立场鲜明的判断,事实层面另说,读者得自己分辨。

从两万亿到一千七百亿,中间隔着一个国会

主持人问 DOGE 的省钱成绩:选前你说至少能省两万亿,现在 DOGE 官网上的数字是一千七百亿,中间差了一个数量级,两万亿还是目标吗?

马斯克的回应有两层。第一层是时间:你难道以为几个月内就能立刻省出两万亿?第二层是权限:

DOGE 能做成什么,取决于政府和国会是否愿意接受我们的建议。我们不是政府的独裁者,我们是顾问。

他反复强调这个定位:DOGE 不立法,不控制司法,也不控制行政分支,三个分支在某种程度上都抵触这种规模的削减。在这个前提下,他认为团队干得非常好,没有哪个政府顾问团队比他们做得更多。他还说已经省了一千六百亿,后面还会继续省。

这里有个数字对不上。主持人引的是官网的一千七百亿,马斯克说的是省了一千六百亿。可能一个是总额一个是净额,也可能是口误,文字稿里没有澄清。

主持人继续追:你说每天省四十亿,算到明年七月也到不了两万亿。马斯克的回应是这场访谈里最出圈的一句:

我觉得你有点被困在传统记者的 NPC 对话树里了。跟一个卡在常规记者对话树里的人说话,就像在跟一台电脑说话。

撇开这个形容带来的火药味,他说的机制问题是真的。DOGE 是行政分支下的顾问机构,它的建议要变成实际支出削减,需要国会配合立法,需要各部委执行。削减多少不取决于 DOGE 多想省,取决于有多少建议被采纳。把"目标两万亿"和"实际省一千七百亿"当成承诺与违约来对比,混淆了建议权和决定权。

但反过来看,马斯克当初在竞选集会上喊出两万亿的时候,用的口吻很硬。政治动员语言和技术性澄清之间的落差,是他自己要面对的。

如果这些孩子真的存在,请让我见见他们

USAID 的部分,主持人先引了比尔·盖茨前几天的评论,说削减对外援助可能让数百万人丧命。马斯克的第一反应是针对盖茨本人:

考虑到他经常和杰弗里·爱泼斯坦来往,他凭什么对儿童福利发表评论?

主持人说,盖茨表示过后悔,而且他这些年花了很多自己的钱做全球慈善,我的问题是,你看过数据吗,有没有可能盖茨是对的?

马斯克说,我希望他拿出任何证据,这是假的。他解释了 USAID 的实际处置方式:被认定还有一点用处的部分转到了国务院,属于转移,不属于删除。

他接着讲了一个反复出现的模式。当他们去问某个项目到底做了什么,对方会说这个项目帮助儿童、帮助根除某种疾病。他们要证据,说请把你们帮助的这群孩子介绍过来,我们想聊聊,了解具体情况。然后什么都拿不到。

我们甚至说,能不能至少安排见几个孩子,他们在哪里,如果他们有困难,我们想跟他们和他们的照护者谈谈。结果没有回应。我们发现的是大量的欺诈和贪腐,真正到孩子手里的少之又少。

主持人不放弃,举了 PEPFAR 的例子。这个项目在二十年里被认为挽救了二千六百万人的生命,它被纳入对外援助冻结,后来有有限豁免,服务仍然中断。联合国艾滋病规划署说,如果永久停止,到 2029 年还会有四百万例艾滋病相关死亡。2023 年已经有六十三万人死于艾滋病相关疾病。

马斯克的回应是:艾滋病药物项目还在继续,你的前提就错了。主持人纠正:全部继续的说法不成立,是有限豁免,联合国艾滋病规划署说 USAID 之前资助的服务并非都在继续。

好,哪些没在资助?我现在就修。

主持人说,名单都在联合国艾滋病规划署网站上,主要是预防相关的部分,比如一种叫来那卡帕韦(lenacapavir)的药物推广,去年被认为是抗击艾滋病多年来最大的突破之一。马斯克说,如果这是真的,我怀疑不是,那我们会修。

这段对话值得单独拎出来看。马斯克给出的处理机制是"指出来,我立刻修",行政效率上确实加分,但它把一个需要系统论证的公共卫生问题压缩成了逐条报错、逐条修复的工程流程。 药物推广中断造成的伤害不会等到修复完成才发生,预防项目断档的代价往往在几年后才显现出来,到那时再补已经晚了。

另一方面,他对援助资金去向的质疑也不是空穴来风。国际援助的资金链条长、监管弱、审计难,是发展经济学里长期存在的问题。他的问题在于用个案中的欺诈推断整体,而证明整体有效所需的数据,恰恰是他要求对方提供、对方拿不出来的那种。

政治捐款:以后会少很多,我已经做得够多了

主持人问中期选举准备投多少钱。三年前在同一个台上,马斯克对政治支出的设想比后来实际花的少得多。

政治捐款这块,我以后会少很多。我觉得我已经做得够多了。

主持人追问,是因为反弹吗?马斯克没有正面承认,给了一个条件式的回答:如果将来看到需要花钱的理由,我会花,目前没看到理由。

这句话的信息量在于"目前"两个字。他没说退出政治,他说的是这一轮不打算再投入。从"我已经做得够多了"这个措辞看,更接近精力分配的判断,立场转变的成分不大。 他 2024 年在特朗普竞选上投入的金额和卷入程度,显然超出了他自己最初的预期。

关于普京,只有五年前的一次视频通话

主持人问,你多久和普京通话一次?马斯克说,我不和普京通话。主持人问,从来没通过话?马斯克说,大约五年前有过一次视频通话,那是唯一一次。

主持人提到马斯克在西点军校的演讲里说过挑战普京掰手腕,还说《华尔街日报》报道过相关对话。马斯克把火力对准了这家报纸:

地球上还有比《华尔街日报》更糟糕的出版物吗?那份报纸是全世界最差的报纸。如果有一份报纸应该支持资本主义,那就是名字里带华尔街的那份,但它不是。我对《华尔街日报》的评价低到不能再低。

主持人说自己读得很广,把这些提问摆出来是为了给马斯克回应的机会。马斯克回应说,你显然相信你在那些报纸上读到的东西。访谈在时间提醒中结束,马斯克最后提到,他是在 X 平台上公开挑战普京的。

这场访谈真正暴露的东西

把整场对话看完,会发现马斯克在这次访谈里做的动作高度一致:凡是提问里含着他不接受的前提,他先攻击前提,再拒绝在前提之上作答。

星链那个问题,前提是"政策松动让你获益所以存在利益冲突",他的反击是"这项政策本身不正当"。USAID 那个问题,前提是"削减导致了服务中断",他的反击是"项目本身在继续,你的前提错了"。DOGE 那个问题,前提是"两万亿是承诺",他的反击是"我们是顾问不是决策者"。

这套应对方式有效,是因为它确实指出了几个提问里被简化掉的环节:监管密度和政策方向是两件事,建议权和决定权是两种权力,资金转移和资金删除是两种情况。它也失效得很明显:把所有需要长期论证的问题都变成了当场对质,而对质赢不了公共卫生的账,也赢不了制度设计的账。

看这场访谈的技术从业者,能带走的东西不多,但有几条足够具体:

  • 看监管争论时先分清两层:这个领域该不该有人管,现在管的人是不是太多。马斯克对 AI 的判断是前者需要、后者没有,对汽车航天的判断是前者已有、后者过量。很多人把这两层混在一起吵,吵不出结果。
  • 评估任何"省钱成绩"时,问清楚这个数字是建议削减额、已批准削减额,还是实际支出减少额。这三个数在政府预算流程里能差出一个数量级,DOGE 的两万亿和一千七百亿之争就卡在这里。
  • 遇到"某项援助或者补贴被砍会导致灾难性后果"的论断,索要两样东西:受影响的具体人群名单,和中断前后的对照数据。要不到名单,说明执行链条本身有问题;要不到对照数据,说明因果推断还没做完。两样都拿不出来的时候,双方其实都在凭立场说话。
  • 看企业领袖的公共表态,把事实陈述和立场判断分开记录。南非那一百四十条法律是事实,把它定性为"种族主义法律"是判断。访谈里这两者被反复混着用,读者如果不拆开,很容易把判断当成事实接收。
  • 如果你在做和政府、大企业打交道的项目,把合规冲突当成真实存在的风险来管理。SpaceX 那个 ITAR 与雇佣平等的双违法困境不是孤例,两套规则互相打架的情况在跨境数据、出口管制、行业准入里都很常见,提前做规则冲突排查,比事后找律师便宜得多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00and now is they're trying to change that for their own financial benefit into a for-profit company that is closed source. So this would be like let's say you you funded a a nonprofit to help preserve the Amazon rainforest, but instead of doing that, they became a lumber company, chopped down the forest, and sold the wood. You'd be like, "Wait a second, that's not what I funded.

0:24That's open AI." They've made some changes to their corporate structure, though, haven't they? sense in in recognition of what of what you've said. No, that's just what they told the media. Okay. part they have part they have partly walked back their plan to restructure the business. I guess that's made no difference to how you feel about it. So you determined to see them in court?

0:54Of course. Okay. Well, that that's certainly going to be one to watch. I also wanted to ask you about AI and regulation because when you were here last talking to John Mikkelweight, you had some pretty strong words about the risk that AI poses and you said that you really felt what the US was missing was a federal AI regulator that you know something along the lines of the Food and Drug Administration or the Federal Aviation Administration. Now, you're clearly now in a zone where you're more you're more on the cutting regulation side than wanting new regulators. So, has your view changed on the need for an AI regulator?

1:32Well, it's not that I don't think there should be regulators. you can think of regulators like referees on the on the field in sports. there should be some number of referees, but that you shouldn't have so many referees that you can't kick the ball without hitting one. so u in many in most apps

1:52fields in the US the the regulatory burden has grown over time to the point where it's like having more referees than than players on the field. so and this is a natural consequence of an extended period of prosperity. It's very important to appreciate this. This has happened throughout history. When you have an extended period of prosperity with no existential war, there's no there's no cleansing function for the for for unnecessary

2:22laws and regulations. So what happens is that every year more laws and more regulations are passed because you know legislators are going to legislate, regulators are going to regulate and you will get the steady pile of more and more laws and regulations over time until everything is illegal. And let me give you an example of of a of a truly absurd situation. under the Biden administration, SpaceX was sued for

2:54not hiring asylum seekers in the US. Now, the problem is it's actually illegal for SpaceX under ITAR, international traffic and arms regulations to hire anyone who is not a permanent resident of the United States because the the premise being that they will take advanced rocket technology and return to their home country if they're not a permanent resident. So, we're simultaneously in a situation where it is illegal to hire asylum seekers and is also illegal to hire asylum seekers and that the Biden's Department of Justice chose to prosecute us despite both paths being illegal. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. But my question was specifically about a regulator for

3:36AI, which you said 3 years ago was needed. And you said we need to be proactive on the regulation of AI. rather than reactive. Have you changed your mind on that? No, of course not. What What No, of course not. What I'm saying is that there should be some referees on the field, a few a few referees, but you shouldn't have a field jam-packed with referees such that you cannot kick a ball in any direction without hitting one. So the the the the fields that have been around for a long time such as automotive aerospace

4:14you know the sort of food and drug industries are overregulated but the new fields like artificial intelligence are underregulated. In fact there is no regulator at all. So so there should be you still think that. Yes. I'm simply saying, which I think is just basic common sense, that you that you want to have at least you you want to have a few referees in the field. You don't want to have an army of referees.

4:40you but you want to have a few referees on on any given field in any given sport or any given arena, industrial arena. to ensure help that public safety is taken care of. but you don't want to have so so there's a there's a there's a a proper number of referees. Like I said, it's actually very easy to visualize this when compared to sports. If the if the whole field is packed with with referees, that would look absurd. but if there were no referees at all, your game's not going to be as good. Okay. So, let's then talk about your new world, your your role advising government. You are in this unique and unprecedented position of having billions of dollars

5:25worth of contracts with the federal government yourself mostly through SpaceX and also now an insidider knowledge of it because of Doge. Can you see that there is a conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest in broad terms just through that very fact? I I don't think so actually there have been many advisers in throughout history and in the US government and others who have had economic interests.

5:54and I am simply an adviser. I don't have formal power. and that's it. the president can choose to accept my advice or not. And that's that's how it goes. if there's a single contract that any of my companies have received that people think is somehow not was was awarded improperly it would immediately be front page news to say the least.

6:22and and if if if I hadn't mentioned it certainly my competitors would. So if you're not seeing that then clearly it's not a conflict of interest. the yeah there's another way though to look at it that for example you have many competitors whether it's companies like Boeing or companies who would like to do more of the kind of work you do for NASA Blue Origin Rocket Lab and because Doge is in every federal government department you or people who work for Doge and and you are the driving force behind it have an insight into those companies companies affairs and those companies relationships with the federal government.

7:05No, all we do is we review the organization to see if if the organization has departments that are no longer relevant. and and then are the contracts that that are being awarded good value for money? In fact, frankly, the bar is not particularly high. Is there any value for money in a contract?

7:26and if there's if there isn't then we may make recommendations to the secretary. The secretary can then choose to take those actions or not take those actions and that's it. And then any action that that that is as a function of Doge is posted to the Doge website and to the Doge.gov or at at Doge handle on the Xplatform. So it's it's complete transparency. and I have not seen any case where to the

7:57best of my knowledge there's even been an accusation of conflict. because it is it's completely and utterly transparent. that's it. And what about the international dimension now? let's think about Starlink. Starink is obviously a very very good internet service. It's sought after all over the world. It's critical to the front line in Ukraine. It has also had more contracts coming its way and there is some evidence that companies are allowing access to it because they want to be close to the Trump administration and send the right signal. So Bloomberg broke news today that the South African government is working around the rules on black ownership in order to allow

8:37Stalink and that is being done on the eve of the visit that President Ramaposa is going to make to the White House. Do you recognize that as a conflict of interest? No, of course not. First of all, you should be questioning why is there why are there racist laws in South Africa?

8:53That's the first problem. That's what you should be attacking. it's improper for there to be racist laws in South Africa. the whole whole idea with what Nelson Mandela who was a great man proposed was that all all races should be on an equal footing in South Africa. that's the right thing to do, not to replace one set of racist laws with another set of racist laws, which is utterly wrong and improv. so the

9:17that's that's the deal that all races should be treated equally. and there should be no preference given to one or the other. whereas there are now 140 laws in South Africa that give u a pre that basically give give strong preference to to if you're if if you're a black South African and not otherwise. And so now I'm in this absurd situation where I was born in South Africa but cannot get a license to operate in stalink because I'm not black. Well, it looks like it looks like you looks like that's about to change. I just asked you a question.

9:52Please answer. Does that seem right to you? Well, those rules were designed to bring. Those rules were designed to bring about an era of more economic equality in South Africa. And it looks like the government has found a way around those rules for you. Ask your question. This is this is your interview. Everyone wants to hear from you. Ask your question. Yes or no? Yes or no? Not not for me to answer. I have got a question for you about about your government work though and the amount of savings.

10:24Why do you like racist laws? This is not for me to answer sir. Come on now. You wouldn't be trying to dodge a question. You have to ask question. I answer No, no, you answer mine. I think I think if you I'm sure you can have that conversation directly with the South African government if you want to.

10:42I want to ask you about the total can't believe it. That's not good. I want to ask you about the total amount. I want to ask you about the total amount that you're planning to save through Doge's work. Before the election, you said it was going to be at least two trillion. The number currently on do.gov gov is $170 billion. That's a big

11:05change. What happened to the two trillion? Well, do you expect it to happen immediately? Well, is it going to happen? Because is supposed to run till next July. I mean, your question is absurd in in this fundamental premise. are you assuming that that on day, you know, within a few months there's an instant two trillion saved? No, I'm not at all. I'm just asking is that still your aim then? Is it still your aim to get out of time?

11:31Have we not made good progress given the amount of time? That's exactly what I'm asking. So, is it still your aim to go from 170 billion to two trillion? the the ability of Doge to operate is a function of whether the government and this includes Congress is willing to take our advice.

11:55we are not the dictators of the government, we are the advisers and so we can we can advise and the progress we've made thus far I think is incredible. Doge team has done incredible work but the magnitude of this the savings is proportionate to the support we get from Congress and from the executive branch of the government in general. so we're not the dictators, we are the adviserss.

12:24but thus far for advisers we've the George team to their credit u has made incredible progress. You've talked about4 billion dollars a day being saved, but that that that won't get which is and I think everyone can agree that combating waste and inefficiency in government is a very good thing, but if you add that up, it's not going to get to two trillion over the lifetime of Doge.

12:55I'm sorry. The four billion the four billion a day if DOA is going to run till next July is not going to get you to two trillion dollars. You still say it's your aim. So we'll take that as red. There's there's there's there's one I mean I feel you're somewhat trapped in the NPC dialogue tree of a traditional ver journalist. So it's difficult to when I'm conversing with someone who's trapped in the dialogue tree of a conventional journalist because it's like talking to a computer.

13:29so Doge is an advisory group. We are doing the best we can as an advisory group. the progress made thus far as an advisory group is excellent. I don't think any advisory group has done better in the history of advisory groups of the government. now we we we do not make the laws nor do we control the the judiciary nor do we control the executive branch. We are simply advisers. In that context we are doing very well. beyond that we cannot

14:05do we cannot take action beyond that because we are not some sort of imperial dictator of the government. there are three branches of government that u that are to some degree opposed to that level of cost savings. but nonetheless let's let's let's not criticize whether there's 4 trillion and instead look at the fact that 160 billion has been saved and more will be saved too. And as I said I think everyone can agree that cutting waste and indeed fraud in any government and being responsible with taxpayers money is a very good thing.

14:42So yes, I can see I can see that you're proud of that work. I do want to ask you about US aid and the comments that Bill Gates made the other day which and I know that you called him my I know you you said that already. I wondered also and I'm just who does who does Bill Gates think he is to make comments about the welfare of children given that he is he frequented Jeffrey Epste? Okay.

15:13Well, he's he's he's he said he regrets those and I would that guy he spent a lot he spent a lot of his own money on on philanthropy around the world over the years. My question to you is have you looked at the data to check if he might be right that the cuts to USAD might cost millions of lives.

15:37yes. I'd like him to show us any any evidence whatsoever that that is true. It's false. the what what we found with USA cuts and by the way they haven't all been cut. The the parts of USA ID that we found to be even slightly useful were transferred to the state department. So not they've not been deleted. They've simply been transferred to the state department.

16:00but many many times over with USAD and other organizations when we've when they said oh well this is going to help you know children or it's going to help some disease eradication or something like that. and then when we ask for any evidence whatsoever I say well please connect us with this group of children so we can talk to them and understand more about their issue. We get nothing. We don't they don't even try to prevent show We should come up with a with a with a show often meaning like it's sort of like well can we at least see a few kids like where where are they if they're in trouble we'd like to talk to them and talk to their caregivers and

16:42then we get something as a response because it's that what we find is an enormous amount of of fraud and graft. Okay let me put this example very little of it actually gets to the kids if anything at all. Okay, let let me put this example to you because you grew up in South Africa so you'll know the impact of HIV AIDS well and this is why I asked about the data. The US led on international efforts to combat HIV AIDS treatment prevention and there's an initiative called PEPAR which is credited with saving 26 million lives in the last 20 years. It was part of the foreign aid freeze. Then there was a limited waiver. its services are disrupted and UN aid says if permanently

17:26discontinued there will be another 4 million AIDS related deaths by 2029. So if you look at that example which is backed up by data in 2023 630,000 people died of AIDS related illnesses then perhaps Bill Gates's figures are not wrong millions of lives could be lost. I first of all the program the the the AIDS medication program

17:57is continuing. So your fundamental premise is wrong. It is continuing. Now do you have another example? Noted it Elon not in its entirety. That is false. Not in its entirety. the the pro there's a limited waiver and UN aids have said that not all of the services that were previously funded by USA ID are continuing. So that's that's why that's why I put that example to you.

18:22Okay. Well, which ones aren't being funded? I'll fix it right now. For Okay. Well, actually they're all on the UN UN AIDS website, so you'll be able to see them, but mostly they are to do with mostly they are to do with prevention and for example the roll out of a drug called Glenn Capavir which was hailed as one of the biggest breakthroughs against AIDS for many years which came out last year. So if you are perhaps I'm sure UNA you as would be delighted if you're able to look at that again. Yes.

18:52Well, if if if in fact this is true which I doubt it is, then we'll fix it. Okay, fine. so finally political your political influence. I wondered whether you have decided yet how much you're going to spend on the the upcoming midterms. Is it you you spent a lot more money on the last US election than you envisaged when you were speaking here three years ago? Are you going to continue to to spend at that kind of level on future elections?

19:27I think in terms of political spending I'm going to do a lot less in the future. And why is that? I think I've done enough. Is it is it because of blowback? Well, if I see a reason to do political spending in the future, I will do it. I do not currently see a reason. What about political influence beyond the US? How often do you speak to President Putin?

20:03I don't speak to President Putin. You've never spoken to President Putin? I I was on a video call with him once about 5 years ago. That's the only speak president President Putin. Oh, you must I get it. You believe the legacy. Speak. Actually, I've heard you I've heard you speak about it. For example, in your West Point speech, you said, "Oh, I challenged President Putin to to was it an arm wrestle?" And I know the Wall Street Journal has reported your reported conversations. If you're if you're saying they haven't happened other than once, I'll take that as red.

20:37Is is is there a worse publication on the face of the earth than the Wall Street Journal? I wouldn't use that to to line up my cage for paragraphs. that that that newspaper is the worst newspaper in the world. and there's and if you know if there's one newspaper that should be pro- capitalist, it's the one with Wall Street in the name. U but it isn't. So I I have the very lowest opinion of the Wall Street Journal.

21:06Absolutely nonsense. And you clearly believe the tribe that you've written that you've read in those papers. I read I read very widely and I'm putting these questions to you so that you have an opportunity to respond to them which you are and and for which we're all grateful to hear your responses. Okay, we are we are out of time. So you mentioned you mentioned be challenging I I did so on on the X platform I challenged Vlad

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份