美国国债总额突破36万亿美元。
2025年光是利息支出就预计达到9520亿美元,比整个国防预算还多。2026年会突破1万亿,到2035年是1.8万亿。未来十年,美国光付利息就要掏出13.8万亿美元。
这是众议院监督与问责委员会下属“政府效率小组委员会”的第一场听证会,主持人玛乔丽·泰勒·格林(Marjorie Taylor Greene)在开场白里抛出的数字。听证会的主题叫“对浪费开战”,核心议题是联邦政府的不当支付(improper payments)。
整场听下来,真正的主角不是这些数字,是一个人:埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk)。
民主党议员在发言里提到马斯克的次数,远多于提到“浪费”的次数。共和党议员反复论证另一件事:特朗普赢了选举,马斯克是他请来的,DOGE(政府效率部,Department of Government Efficiency)合法。
这场听证会值得细看的地方,不在于两党又吵了一架,而在于它把美国财政的真实病灶、两党对病灶的不同诊断、以及一个亿万富翁在政府里到底该扮演什么角色,全摊在了一张桌子上。
36万亿美元的债务,两党都不否认
先说一个罕见的共识时刻。
格林开场就说,这不是民主党的问题,也不是共和党的问题,这是美国的问题。她提到,即使把整个联邦政府全部砍掉,也逃不掉已经欠下的债和复利。利息支出不修桥、不修路、不救灾、不养活任何一个联邦机构,它只付给持有美国国债的人。
她用了一个很重的词:债务奴役(debt slavery)。
委员会主席詹姆斯·科默(James Comer)接着补了一组数据:自2003年以来,联邦政府因为不当支付损失了2.7万亿美元。欺诈者、有组织犯罪集团、敌对外国行为者,甚至政府内部员工,都在把钱从真正符合资格的人手里抽走。
民主党这边没有否认这个数字。少数党首席成员斯坦斯伯里(Stansbury)在开场白里明确说,每年有超过2360亿美元的不当支付流出,需要严格的监督和控制来防止欺诈和滥用。她还提到,自己曾在奥巴马时期的行政管理与预算办公室(OMB)工作过,是前公务员。
另一位民主党人康诺利(Connolly)讲得更直接:他刚进国会时,不当支付一年大概3到5亿美元,现在一年2800亿美元,涨了十倍。如果认真处理这个问题,十年能削减近3万亿美元债务。
换句话说,36万亿债务和每年数千亿的不当支付,是两党都承认的事实。分歧从下一步开始。
同一组数字,两套诊断
共和党的诊断很清晰:政府不会倒闭,所以它没有动力改。
格林在开场白里做了一个对比。私营企业每天要面对客户,服务不好就没人付钱,员工丢工作,老板破产,没有人兜底。联邦政府的收入是纳税人的钱,而且“按法律在枪口下征收”,不交税就进监狱。联邦政府不需要提供优质服务来赚收入,不管退伍军人有没有拿到福利、邮件有没有送到、税款是帮了本国人还是给了外国,钱照收,雇员工资照发,机构永远不会破产。
她对证人海伍德·塔尔博特(Haywood Talcove,LexisNexis Risk Solutions 政府业务 CEO)提了一个问题:私营企业的不当支付率是不是比联邦政府低?
塔尔博特的回答是:公共部门欺诈率大约20%,私营部门大约3%。原因不复杂,私营部门天天用的工具,政府不用。前端身份验证、取消自我认证、确认申请人真的是本人,这三件事做到,欺诈率会大幅下降。
格林追问:私营企业利润率也就20%左右,客户数据被偷一次可能就活不下去;联邦政府可以一直印支票,所以永远不修问题,因为它不会被强制关门,你同意吗?
塔尔博特说同意,还补了一句:疫情期间犯罪分子发现政府是“肥羊”(the mark),因为它永远不会没钱,而且被抓的概率几乎为零。
民主党的诊断完全不同。他们认为问题不在“政府不会倒闭”,而在“有人在拆房子”。
斯坦斯伯里开场就说,这不是一场正常的听证会。她列举了同时正在发生的事:特朗普和马斯克在“鲁莽且非法地”拆解联邦政府,关闭机构、解雇员工、扣留社区安全资金、侵入敏感数据系统。她说,就在前一天,马斯克站在椭圆形办公室的“坚毅桌”后面,政府正在紧急上诉,想解锁财政部支付系统的访问权限。
她提出了一个技术性但关键的问题:财政部的支付系统不是做支付决定的地方。支付决定发生在各个机构内部,而那些机构正在被拆。真正调查浪费、欺诈和滥用的人,是各机构的监察长(Inspector General),而特朗普上任第一周就解雇了其中19个。
康诺利把话说得更白:如果想认真对待不当支付,就不能解雇负责这件事的人。他提到,被解雇的监察长里,有人刚警告美国国际开发署(USAID)可能有5亿美元的食品援助因为资金冻结烂在仓库里;有人是美国阿富汗重建特别监察长(SIGAR),做了20多次阿富汗实地调查,追回了几十亿美元。
他的原话是这样:
如果要认真,就得有客观中立的监察长。你会发现在这类事业上,民主党人是非常愿意合作的伙伴。但拆迁队、拆迁吊车、拆迁球,不行。(康诺利,众议院监督委员会少数党首席成员)
那一万亿美元是怎么被偷走的
听证会请了四位证人,其中三位来自反欺诈一线,一位来自政府监督组织。他们提供的信息密度,比议员们的开场白高得多。
塔尔博特先说了一个数字:疫情期间被偷走1万亿美元,其中70%流向海外。
他的描述是,这不是零星的小偷小摸,是有组织犯罪集团把福利项目变成了“个人提款机”。他们从公共和私营部门偷个人身份信息,用真实身份去操纵老旧的政府系统,把钱抽走。政府还在给已故人员和在押人员发福利,给“不支付名单”(Do Not Pay list)上的人打钱,因为不按最佳实践核对,还会忽略重复的社会安全号码。
他举了一个具体到有点荒诞的例子:疫情期间,只要把PPP贷款领取者和国税局记录做一次简单交叉核对,就能暴露大规模欺诈。但没做。结果是跨国犯罪分子在暗网上卖他们的“秘方”。
AI 让这件事变得更糟。犯罪分子用它生成能通过生物识别的假身份证件,机器人每秒向门户网站灌入成千上万份欺诈申请,深度伪造能绕过2017年制定的 NIST 863 标准。他说,诚实且符合资格的人要面对几乎无法走通的无穷申请表,而来自俄罗斯、中国、罗马尼亚的犯罪分子轻松进入。
数据对比很刺眼:私营部门欺诈率低于3%,公共部门20%。
他给出的方案有三条:
- 前端做身份验证,犯罪分子一分钱都不该拿到
- 取消自我认证(self-certification),几十亿美元级别的项目不能再靠“荣誉系统”
- 持续审计,因为犯罪分子从不停下
他还专门点了“先付钱再追讨”(pay and chase)模式的荒谬:疫情期间失业欺诈被偷2500亿美元,追回来的不到50亿美元。政府里“要速度就不能要安全”的说法,是虚构的。
立法层面他提了四条:更新1974年的《隐私法》,允许数据共享和匹配;在每个拨款法案里给欺诈预防列预算,美国农业部只花0.08%在欺诈预防上;对被抓到偷福利金的人处以重罚并永久移出项目;取消宽泛的分类资格(broad-based categorical eligibility)。
他的结论是:如果做这些,每年能省1万亿美元。而且他强调,反欺诈不是反福利。这类犯罪有两个受害者,第一是纳税人,第二是真正需要福利的人。
停止欺诈不是拒绝福利,是保护福利。这个犯罪有两个受害者,第一是纳税人,第二是那些真正在申请福利的人。(塔尔博特,LexisNexis 政府业务 CEO)
唐·罗亚尔(Don Royal)是怀俄明州的认证福利欺诈调查员,做了16年。她讲了一个自己经办的案子:一位母亲在多次申请医疗补助、SNAP 和低收入能源援助时,隐瞒了孩子父亲的存在、他的工作和收入。这位父亲有一份稳定工作,六位数年薪,家里有度假、豪车、雪地摩托、房车,还有妻子送给丈夫的一瓶1200美元的波本威士忌。证据包括这位父亲竞选镇议员时提交的候选人登记表,上面写的住址和他妻子申请福利时填的地址一模一样。
这个案子的重点不在贪婪,在于在申请表上撒谎有多容易。她用四个字概括现行模式:信任,而非验证(trust, not verify)。
她点名了体制内的一种阻力:职业官僚长期声称 SNAP 的欺诈率低于1%,而 SNAP 预算里用于预防、发现和起诉欺诈的钱不到0.08%。在医疗补助“unwinding”期间,联邦官僚明确指示各州,即使行政听证或刑事程序已经认定某人犯有医疗补助受益人欺诈或滥用,各州也“不能从受益人那里追回或收回服务成本”。
她的建议和塔尔博特高度重合:取消申请流程中的自我认证;给身份验证技术拨款;立即实施全国准确性清算所(National Accuracy Clearinghouse,NACK),防止同一个人在多个福利项目里重复参与;把反欺诈资金定向分配,并规定只能用于预防、发现和起诉欺诈。
她说的另一句话,解释了为什么防欺诈的钱总是拨不出来:
各州不愿意花自己的州预算,去保护联邦的钱。(罗亚尔,怀俄明州认证福利欺诈调查员)
斯图尔特·惠特森(Stewart Whitson)来自政府问责基金会(Foundation for Government Accountability),前 FBI 特工、陆军退伍军人。他先把 DOGE 已经曝光的浪费项目列了一串:5900万美元在纽约豪华酒店安置非法移民,150万美元用于塞尔维亚工作场所的 DEI 项目,3.2万美元用于秘鲁的一本跨性别漫画书,还有1000万美元的食品流向基地组织。
然后他把矛头对准医疗补助(Medicaid):现在每5美元医疗补助支出里就有超过1美元是不当支付,未来十年仅医疗补助的欺诈和管理不善就要让纳税人损失超过1万亿美元。医疗补助占了所有联邦不当支付的近三分之一,其中超过80%是资格错误。
他给出的立法路径很具体:通过预算 Reconciliation 废除拜登时期的“医疗补助精简规则”(Medicaid streamlining rule),能省1640亿美元;加上工作要求,十年能省2410亿美元联邦支出。
他解释了这条规则为什么贵:它禁止各州对非残障人士每年核实资格超过一次;禁止面对面或电话核实身份;打开长达90天的“重新考虑期”,有些州实际拖到13年;它让非法移民有机会拿到福利。
委员会主席格林在提问时把这串限制复述了一遍,然后问:所以我们没法核实一个人是合法还是非法拿到福利?惠特森说,各州至少得等90天,实际看到有的州等了13年。
第四位证人迪伦·赫德勒-戈杰特(Dylan Hedtler-Gaudette)来自 Project On Government Oversight(POGO),是唯一一位花时间做概念澄清的。
他说,浪费、欺诈、滥用、不当支付,这四个词经常被混着用,但它们不是一回事。不当支付有时是记录保存差,有时是 IT 系统老旧,有时是人为失误,有时是疏忽。不当支付不全是坏人干坏事。
这句话在整场听证会里显得有点不合时宜,但它恰恰是理解后面所有争论的钥匙。
会议室里真正的战场:谁有资格查账
听证会开到一半,话题从“怎么防欺诈”滑到了“谁在拆政府”。这部分交锋比数据部分更激烈。
加州民主党议员卡萨尔(Casar)做了一组连环提问。他问证人是否知道,有多少正在调查马斯克公司的机构监察长被特朗普政府解雇了。答案是五个:劳工部监察长有17项针对特斯拉和 SpaceX 的公开调查;交通部监察长在查特斯拉;国防部监察长在查 SpaceX;农业部监察长在查 Neuralink;环保署监察长多次针对特斯拉采取行动。
他接着问:马斯克每天从联邦政府合同里拿多少钱?答案是800万美元。去年马斯克从近1100份联邦合同中获得了30亿美元的承诺。
然后他做了一个对照:一个靠社会安全金生活的老年人,每天大约65美元。
他的结论是这样一句:
我们不是在查马斯克每天800万美元,这个由玛乔丽·泰勒·格林主持的小组委员会,在查你祖母每天65美元。(卡萨尔,加州民主党众议员)
德州民主党议员克罗克特(Crockett)补了另一个角度。她说,这个小组委员会的前身就是监督委员会,过去几年一直在开不当支付的听证会,而格林一场都没参加过。她还提到,国防部占 discretionary spending 大约50%,连续六次审计失败,“大数字在那边”,而马斯克的钱大部分来自同一个方向。
共和党这边的反击也很集中。
南卡罗来纳州议员蒂蒙斯(Timmons)说,六年前他刚当选时国债是21万亿,现在36万亿,六年增加了15万亿,特朗普就是靠解决这个问题当选的,马斯克是那个把一家又一家公司扭亏为盈的人,所以总统请他来做这件事。
乔治亚州议员杰克(Jack)当场数了民主党发言里的词频:马斯克被提了27次,浪费被提了3次。他提交了一份 CBS 在2025年2月5日到7日做的民调,说70%的美国人认为特朗普正在做他当选时被要求做的事,62%的人希望民主党议员与特朗普合作。
德州议员吉尔(Gill)把话说得更狠:民主党不是真的关心“未经选举的官僚”,否则福奇、马约卡斯、卡多纳、根斯勒在任时他们去哪了。他的判断是,那些事有利于民主党那一边,所以没人吭声。
密苏里州议员伯利森(Burleson)抛出了一组更耸动的数字:每个美国纳税人背负超过32.3万美元的债务;经济政策创新中心说美国只剩18万亿美元的借款空间;每年新增2万亿美元赤字;社会安全金八年后破产,联邦医疗保险十年后破产,十五年后美元可能一文不值。他的结论是,这不是党派问题,是“你的养老金、你的银行存款、你的储蓄会变成废纸”的问题。
他还放了一段视频,剪辑了克林顿、奥巴马等人过去关于削减浪费、精简政府的讲话。视频里克林顿说,那份报告给了800条建议,包括削减12%的联邦雇员、合并联邦调查局、缉毒局和烟酒火器管理局;奥巴马说,不用等国会,我们可以自己动手砍浪费。用意是提醒民主党:这曾经也是你们的主张。
新墨西哥州民主党人斯坦斯伯里在质询环节回应了这段视频。她说自己确实在 OMB 工作过,参与过奥巴马签署的那项反浪费行政令,但有一个根本区别:他们守法。
她的原话是:“我们不为一个未经选举的亿万富翁工作,我们为美国人民工作。如果一个未经审查的私人公民在侵入我们的政府系统、违法、解雇联邦雇员、拆解依法设立的机构、扣留资金,我们会在法庭上跟你们打。”
财政部支付系统,一场关于谁能看账本的官司
整场听证会里,最具体、最有技术含量、也最容易被忽略的一段,是斯坦斯伯里关于财政部支付系统的质询。
她说,过去几周她一直在和财政部、OMB 的官员沟通,想搞清楚马斯克团队为什么急着要访问财政部的支付系统。这个系统本身不做支付决定,它只是执行付款:付军人工资、付海外行动开支、付社会安全金、付退税。
但它是全美支付流的中枢,每年流出的钱接近美国经济的五分之一,里面包含社会安全信息、数百万美国人的银行账户、以及涉及国家安全的数据。
她讲了几个细节:一位在财政部支付系统工作了30多年的高级公务员,在一个25岁的马斯克团队实习生试图获取系统代码访问权限后,被要求让位。一位硅谷背景的人被安插进财政部,同时仍然是一家私营 IT 公司(包括 Citrix)的 CEO,而这家公司和联邦政府有数百万美元的合同。她说,一名25岁的软件工程师违反法院命令,获得了修改代码的权限。
她的质问是:“这怎么可能合法?”
她的结论是,财政部内部把这件事称为“该机构历史上最大的内部威胁”。
格林在 closing remarks 里给出了完全相反的叙述。她说,DOGE 直接去了财政部的财政服务局(Bureau of the Fiscal Service),这个机构处理联邦每年数万亿支付中的大约90%。这次审计早就该做了。财政部长斯科特·贝森特(Scott Bessent)给了为政府工作的 DOGE 雇员只读权限,让他们做初步审计。审计已经出结果了:联邦机构本应用来防止向欺诈者、犯罪集团和死者付款的数据库,没有保持更新。
然后她讲了一个法官的裁定:纽约一位联邦法官上周五裁定,不仅禁止 DOGE,也禁止财政部长本人访问自己机构的支付系统。只有财政部的职业官僚能访问。
格林的评价是:“这把宪法倒过来了。”她引用《联邦党人文集》:司法部门既无剑也无钱袋,既无强制力也无意志,只有判断,而且最终要靠行政部门来让判断生效。
她的反问是:联邦法官不是选出来的,财政部的官僚不是选出来的,他们没能解决让纳税人被抢的问题。那为什么不请私营部门里真正成功过的外部专家来做日常该做的工作,比如审计?
这一段是整场听证会最有信息量的冲突点。它表面上在吵“马斯克有没有权限”,实际上在吵一个更根本的问题:当民选政府失灵了几十年,一个未经选举的亿万富翁带着自己的团队进来查账,这算纠错还是算越界?
两党给出的答案完全不重叠。共和党说,政府不会倒闭,所以必须从外面请人。民主党说,查账的人应该是监察长,而你们把监察长开了。
四个证人的方案,重合度比分歧高
把党派攻防剥掉,四位证人在技术层面的建议重合度很高。这部分是这场听证会真正有价值的地方,因为它指向的是可以立法的具体动作。
第一,前端身份验证。塔尔博特反复讲,私营部门每天都在做这件事,你打开银行 App 几毫秒就完成身份核验,政府没有理由落后。他点名了 NIST 863 标准是2017年定的,那个年代还没有深度伪造和生成式 AI。密苏里州用一套叫 Steady IQ 的系统验证工资和财富,试点节省了近20%的医疗补助支出。按每年9000亿美元医疗补助算,20%接近2000亿美元。
蒂蒙斯在质询里把这笔账算了一遍:我们一年在医疗补助上花近9000亿,省20%就是近2000亿,年度赤字1.8万亿,这一下就削掉2000亿。
第二,取消自我认证。罗亚尔和塔尔博特都提到,现行福利申请很大程度上是“荣誉系统”,申请人自己说自己符合条件,政府不核实身份、收入、居住地。罗亚尔的建议是,各州必须在注册之前核实身份,先查清楚再让人进来,不能先注册、以后再查。
第三,更新1974年《隐私法》。塔尔博特说,这部法律让数据共享和数据匹配几乎不可能。疫情期间如果允许数据匹配,可能拦住那一万亿中被偷走的一半。蒂蒙斯提到他已经提交了一个法案,让国税局与小型企业管理局、FBI、司法部共享数据,找出不符合 PPP 资格却拿到贷款的人,他估计能追回上千亿美元,而且可以追溯执行。
第四,实施全国准确性清算所(NACK)。罗亚尔说,这个系统能给各州提供数据,防止同一个人在多个社会福利项目里重复参与,应该立即上线。
第五,给反欺诈列专项预算并限定用途。美国农业部只花0.08%的预算在欺诈预防上,SNAP 不到0.08%。罗亚尔的建议是,拨款必须明确限制用于预防、发现和起诉欺诈。惠特森还提到,如果不加限制,钱到了州里会被挪去干别的。
第六,改革联邦支出追踪体系。赫德勒-戈杰特说,FFATA、DATA Act、USASpending.gov 当年都是重要创新,但现在需要大修。现状是联邦资金从端到端极难追踪,这个“信息黑洞”正是浪费、欺诈和滥用藏身的地方。更根本的是,美国现在一年近7万亿美元的预算,却说不清楚这些钱换来了什么。
他的表述是:“我们没法用一种清晰、一致的方式说清,花了这么多钱,我们得到了什么。”
第七,把总统的罢免权写进法律。惠特森的建议是,让所有行政部门雇员变成 at-will(可随时解雇),并授予总统永久裁撤空缺职位、合并非必要岗位的权力。他还提了《REINS Act》,让重大监管规则必须经国会批准,从而把 DOGE 的削减成果固化下来,不被下一任总统用一支笔推翻。他的判断很直接:人事即政策(personnel is policy),没有能干的人忠实执行总统的议程,DOGE 项目会失败。
第八,保护监察长和吹哨人。这是赫德勒-戈杰特唯一情绪化的部分。他说,2023财年监察长确认了超过930亿美元潜在节省;国税局吹哨人项目自2007年以来追回数十亿美元;司法部的 False Claims Act 案件里吹哨人起了关键作用。
他的原话是:
如果一届政府真的想清除浪费、欺诈和滥用,它会支持并给监察长和吹哨人资源,而不是妖魔化他们,更不会在非法的午夜清洗里解雇他们。(赫德勒-戈杰特,POGO 政府事务主任)
北卡罗来纳州议员诺顿(Norton)问了一个很直接的问题:政府正在制造联邦雇员的大规模流失,这会增加还是减少浪费、欺诈和滥用?
赫德勒-戈杰特的回答是:混乱不是效率的朋友。如果你破坏了政府的基本功能,你不会让它更高效,你只会让它更糟,而且之后修复这些出问题的地方要花更多钱。
几个不会上标题的细节
整场听证会有几个细节,新闻标题不会写,但它们能帮人理解这场争论的真实质地。
第一个细节,是格林在 closing remarks 里自己给出的数字:最近几年大多数不当支付集中在五个项目,联邦医疗保险(Medicare)、医疗补助(Medicaid)、劳动所得税抵免(EITC)、疫情失业补助(Pandemic Unemployment Insurance)、薪酬保护计划(PPP)。2023年一共有16个联邦项目的不当支付率达到10%以上,其中包括 SNAP,一年发出去100亿美元是不当的。
这个清单本身说明,问题不在某一个党执政时期,它是跨政府的结构性现象。
第二个细节,是惠特森说的那句话:医疗补助不当支付里超过80%是资格错误,不是欺诈。资格错误意味着什么?意味着系统允许不符合条件的人继续留在项目里,因为核实成本太高、规则不允许、或者没人有动力去查。这比“有坏人”更难解决,因为它不需要坏人。
第三个细节,是克罗克特问塔尔博特的那句:你说的这些系统升级,不是免费的吧?塔尔博特说,有些免费,有些要花钱。克罗克特说,好,我就说到这里。
这句对话很短,但它点出了一个所有“提高效率”方案都绕不开的问题:防欺诈本身要花钱,而花钱的预算和节省的预算往往不在同一个账户里。罗亚尔那句话说得更直接:各州不愿意花自己的钱去保护联邦的钱。这就是为什么她主张联邦拨款必须定向用于反欺诈。
第四个细节,是伯切特(Burchett)和塔尔博特关于 PayPal 的对话。伯切特问,PayPal 从来没被攻破过、没被偷过用户关键信息,是不是因为它用了你说的那些系统?塔尔博特说是。伯切特说,那政府为什么不用?
这个问题没有答案,但它比任何党派发言都更接近问题的核心。私营部门已经把身份验证做成日常基础设施,政府还在用2017年的标准和1974年的法律。
第五个细节,是罗亚尔描述的那瓶1200美元波本威士忌。这个细节之所以值得记住,是因为它说明福利欺诈不总是“穷人骗保”的刻板印象。有六位数年薪、有度假屋、有雪地摩托的家庭,也会在申请表上隐瞒收入,因为系统允许他们这么做,而且被发现的概率不高。
第六个细节,是杰克问惠特森的那个关于“把联邦机构搬出华盛顿”的问题。惠特森的回答是,在华盛顿市中心建总部和在阿拉巴马州亨茨维尔建,成本差很多;员工通勤和生活成本也会更好;总部落在哪个地区,招聘就会偏向那个地区的人,如果那个地区一党独大,机构的用人倾向就会偏。
这个回答不带党派色彩,但它解释了一件事:联邦机构设在哪里,本身就是一种政治资源分配。
这场听证会真正在争什么
听证会结束时,格林说这只是“对浪费开战”的第一场战斗,小组委员会之后会发布报告,提出立法方案,不会等到这届国会结束。
斯坦斯伯里在 closing 里说了一句值得琢磨的话:特朗普不是靠“让一个未经选举的亿万富翁负责拆解联邦政府”当选的,他是靠“降低美国人的生活成本”当选的。而就在听证会进行的同时,《纽约时报》头条说通胀意外上升,食品和能源价格又涨了。她还说,就在这两个小时里,共和党人公布了把债务上限提高4万亿美元的计划。
这两段话放在一起,其实点出了这场听证会最深的裂缝:两党对“问题是什么”有共识,对“谁来解决”没有共识,对“解决的成本由谁承担”更没有共识。
共和党的逻辑链是:债务要爆炸,政府自己不会改,所以请外部的人来查,查出来的钱用来减税和削减赤字。
民主党的逻辑链是:债务要爆炸,该由监察长和现有监督机制来查,而你们把监察长开了、让未经审查的私人团队进系统,查出来的钱用来给富人减税。
两条链的起点一样,终点完全相反。中间那个分岔口,是“谁有资格动这个系统”。
对读者来说,这场听证会最实用的信息不在党派攻防里,而在证人给出的那几个可操作方案里。它们不新,也不刺激,但每一条都指向一个具体数字:20%的公共部门欺诈率、0.08%的反欺诈预算、80%的医疗补助资格错误、每年1万亿美元的潜在节省。
这些数字如果能被推进一点点,比任何一场听证会上的口水仗都更有价值。
还有一件事值得记住。整场听证会里,共和党议员吉尔说了一句几乎是全场最尖锐的话,他说民主党不关心“未经选举的官僚”,否则福奇、马约卡斯、卡多纳、根斯勒在任时他们不会沉默。这句话反过来对共和党同样成立:如果真关心财政纪律,那么国防部连续六次审计失败、每年近7万亿美元预算说不清回报,这些数字也该用同样的力度去追。
两党都在用“浪费”这个词打对方,但真正的问题在中间:一个不会倒闭、不会失业、不需要向客户交代的组织,怎么可能自己长出效率。
以下是这场听证会里可以直接拿去用的行动清单:
- 如果你在做政府或大型机构的数字化项目,优先做前端身份验证,不要先上线再补。塔尔博特的数据是,公共部门20%的欺诈率里,大部分来自被盗身份,而不是真人骗保。
- 如果你在评估福利或补贴类项目的风控,把“自我认证”当成高危设计。任何靠申请人自己声明收入、住址、家庭状况的流程,本质上都是把核实成本推给了事后追讨,而事后追讨的回收率低得惊人:2500亿美元被偷,追回不到50亿。
- 如果你关心政策落地,盯住三个具体立法动作:更新1974年《隐私法》以允许数据匹配、在全国范围实施 NACK、给反欺诈列专项预算并限定用途。这三件事的技术门槛低,政治争议相对小。
- 如果你在做数据治理,注意赫德勒-戈杰特提的那个“信息黑洞”:联邦支出从拨款到最终受益人的端到端追踪是断的。任何组织如果说不清钱最后落在了哪里、产生了什么效果,浪费和舞弊一定藏在那个断点里。
- 如果你在观察美国政治,记住这场听证会的结构:两党都承认36万亿债务和每年数千亿不当支付,分歧在于“谁来查”和“省下的钱给谁”。这个分歧不会因为再多开几场听证会而消失,它会在法庭、在预算 Reconciliation 程序、在下一轮选举里继续。
- 最后一条,给所有做内容的人:这场听证会里被引用最多的名字是马斯克,被引用最少的词是“不当支付”。如果你要判断一个议题是否被认真讨论,数一下名字和名词的比例,通常就清楚了。
0:02this hearing of the subcommittee on delivering on government efficiency will come to order welcome everyone without objection the chair May declare a recess at any time also for today's hearing chairman comr and ranking member Connelly will each be recognized for one minute after me and the ranking member provide our opening statements I recognize myself for the purpose of making an opening statement good morning today we begin the first hearing on the oversight subcommittee on Doge this committee will be laser focused on bringing Full transparency to waste Fraud and Abuse within the federal government and presenting the plans to fix the tremendous problems we expose we as a
0:52country are $6 trillion in debt that is such a stunning amount of M money it's absolutely staggering to even comprehend how we as a people we as a country found ourselves here this is not a Democrat problem this is not a republican problem this is an American problem to make it clear for everyone not only are we $36 trillion in debt but the com the compounding interest on our debt is also growing out of control even if we decided to defund fund the entire federal government we cannot Escape our debt and the compounding interests owed on our debt which grows bigger and bigger every year in 2025 interest payments are projected to be 952 billion which is more than our
1:49entire military budget in 2026 it will be $1 trillion and by 2035 $1.8 trillion for the next decade total interest payments are projected to be $13.8 trillion these interest payments don't serve a single American they don't build a bridge a road provide disaster relief or fund a single part of the Behemoth that is the federal government these interest payments pay our masters who own our debt and the American people are in debt slavery to everyone who owns our debt our crippling national debt and massively growing interest on our debt will destroy us not destroy one political party or the other it will destroy all of us together it drives inflation making life unaffordable for
2:46Americans struggling to financially survive it is crippling small businesses struggling to be successful our massively growing debt and interest are the chains and shackles harnessed to every American American and their children and every generation to come but first let us be brutally honest about how this massive debt came to be in the first place it came from Congress and from elected presidential administrations and I believe enslaving our nation in debt is one of the biggest betrayals against the American people by its own elected government this American the American people's anger over this betrayal is what gave birth to the concept of Doge the department of
3:35government efficiency in fact Doge became a major part of President Trump's campaign and led to his overwhelming victory in November every day Americans go to work they run businesses they have to earn their paycheck no one guarantees it and if they don't do a good job they get fired they also have to pay their bills credit card debts balance their checkbooks and scrap and save every penny they can in order to plan for that rainy day and hopefully retirement one day private businesses only survive on hard-earned income by serving their customers so well that their customers pay them for the services and products they consume if that business fails its
4:24employees lose their jobs and paychecks and the owners lose their business and everything they risked along with it many go bankrupt in this process and lose everything no one bails them out they only Survive by excellent customer service and Smart Financial Management this is the real world that most Americans live work and survive in every day this is the pursuit of happiness and this is how you pursue the American dream however the federal government government employees and unelected bureaucrats do not live by the same rules as the Great American people and private businesses the federal government's income is the American people's hard-earned tax dollars their
5:13literal Blood Sweat and Tears and taxes are collected by law at gunpoint don't pay your taxes and you go to jail the federal government does not have to provide excellent customer service to earn its income it takes your money whether you like it or not and federal employees receive their paycheck no matter what whether veterans receive their benefits or not whether your mail shows up or not and whether your tax dollars are used to help Americans in need or sent to foreign countries for foreign people for foreign causes no matter how bad the federal government fails the American people it still takes your money money it still pays its own federal employees and it never ever goes
6:06out of business there are no consequences for bad customer service total failure and for enslaving the American people against their will and the ever growing and future all consuming national debt Congress has a dismal approval rating that ranges between 12 and 20% I don't blame the American people people one bit for their sentiment and disgust the American people will be watching this committee and how we tackle one of the biggest problems of our time while we are a committee made up of the opposite far-reaching corners of Congress we were each elected to serve and represent the American people and how their hard-earned tax dollars are spent we as Republicans and
6:55Democrats can still hold tightly to our beliefs but we are going to have to let go of funding them in order to save our sinking ship this is not a time for political theater and partisan attacks the American people are watching the legislative branch can't sit on the sidelines in this subcommittee we will fight the war on waste shoulder-to-shoulder with President Trump Elon Musk and the Doge team this week we turn our attention to impr proper payments by the federal government including in Medicaid and Medicare I'm looking forward to what we find out and how to solve this crisis I now y yield to the ranking member Miss stanbury for her opening
7:46statement all right well good morning everyone thank you madam chair and welcome to the very first subcommittee on government efficiency as was said this committee is tasked under the oversight committee with ensuring that the government and the vital services that it provides from Health Care to National Security actually work for the American people and this is certainly a topic that we have worked on for many many years here in the oversight Committee in which I personally have worked on as a former civil servant who worked at the Office of Management and budget and in fact for anyone who has ever worked on these issues you know that there is ample ground for
8:26bipartisan work to make the government work better for the American people and to ensure that it operates in a more efficient manner and in fact all of us here on the Democratic side are ready to roll up our sleeves and to get to work and just last week I had the opportunity to sit down with the chairwoman and to discuss these very issues and opportunities to work across the aisle and like the chairwoman who shared some of her background with me I grew up in a working family I grew up working for small mom and po top family businesses and understand the necessity of balancing the books making sure we can deliver and fiscal responsibility and that's why today's hearing is
9:10focused on making sure that the federal government is doing what it's supposed to and digging into the more than $236 billion dollar in improper payments that we see going out the door every single year and we need to get to the bottom of that and we need to make sure that we're putting into place rigorous oversight and controls to prevent Fraud and Abuse and of course to go after Bad actors and that is why myself and the oversight ranking member Connelly and other Democratic members of the committee sent a set of bipartisan ideas that we'd like to work on together that would root out waste Fraud and Abuse and modernize and streamline how our
9:51agencies deliver vital programs for the American people these are programs that are important for our seniors and our families and Healthcare and the education system and we need bipartisan solutions to get across the finish line and we've been trying over the last several years to get these ideas out of this committee but unfortunately the committee's priorities have been elsewhere under the current major majority so I hope we can fix that this Congress but we can't just sit here today and pretend like everything is normal and that this is just another hearing on government efficiency I mean all you have to do is look across this room and see that it is not a normal
10:33hearing because while we're sitting here Donald Trump and Elon Musk are recklessly and illegally dismantling the federal government shuttering federal agencies firing federal workers withholding funds vital to the safety and well-being of our communities and hacking our sensitive Data Systems in fact while we were here discussing government waste on the house floor yesterday Elon Musk was standing ing behind the Resolute desk in the Oval Office with the president and the ad Administration was making emergency court appeals to try to unlock his team's access to the treasury payment system which they claim they are using to study improper payments which is the
11:16topic of this hearing but here's the thing the treasury payment system which includes Social Security information and bank accounts for millions of Americans and data that's critical to National Security and the operation of the US government and payments that go out the door annually equal to almost a fifth of the US economy is not where the payment decisions are made because that happens inside the agencies that are currently being dismantled and the people who actually investigate waste Fraud and Abuse at these agencies are the inspector generals who Donald Trump fired his first week in office in a midnight Massacre so we have to ask ask ourselves what is really going on here
12:02why did Republicans block Elon Musk from appearing before this very committee last week why is the administration so eager to allow Elon Musk and his hackers to have access to proprietary and private information in the treasury Payment Systems why are our colleagues across the aisle shielding them as they are clearly breaking the law and why is the vice president trying to rewrite the US con institution by tweet and undermine the Judiciary so obviously we're in the oversight committee and we have a lot of questions and so do the American people especially while while our colleagues across the aisle are trying to scoop up the savings from the
12:46dismantling of these agencies to pay for the largest permanent tax break in American history for billionaires and the folks that they're helping on their side of the aisle so let me close by saying this directly to Mr Elon Musk we are well aware that you are eager to engage with members of Congress on social media but we're not here to play if you have serious desire to engage in democracy and transparency we welcome you to the oversight committee come and testify in front of the American people under oath because we want to know what you're up to so if you're interested in talking to us then please join us here in the people's house in the House of
13:35Representatives and with that I yield back the gentle lady yields president Trump signed an executive order on his first day in office called establishing and implementing the president's Department of government efficiency the EO simply renamed an office in the white house that was actually established by President Obama in 2014 called the US digital service president Trump can have Elon Musk into his Oval Office anytime he likes I now recognize the chairman of the oversight committee chairman James comr well thank you chairwoman green for holding today's hearing to launch a war on waste president Trump won an electoral Landslide with a clear mandate
14:23from the American people to eliminate Washington waste and stop the theft of of American tax dollars and he is delivering on his promise president Trump has empowered Elon Musk and Doge to conduct a government wide audit to identify solutions to curb waste and protect tax dollars that's exactly what the mission of this committee is supposed to be and I'm glad that my colleagues on the other side of the aisle have found a a new found interest in waste Fraud and Abuse with a staggering $37 trillion in national debt we have no time to lose a key place to start is improper payments since 2003 the government has lost $2.7 trillion because of improper payments
15:09fraudsters organized criminals hostile foreign actors and even government employees have siphoned money away from those who truly qualify for assistance for years Republicans and Democrats on the oversight committee have condemned this waste but now that doge is taking real action Democrats are choosing to defend the bureaucracy in status quo instead of standing up for the American people I want to thank chairwoman green for holding this very important hearing not only to expose the problems but to find Solutions we stand with President Trump and Doge in the fight to end waste Fraud and Abuse in Washington with that I yield back to subcommittee chairwoman
15:49green and congratulations again chairwoman on holding this first hearing of the Doge subcommittee thank you Mr chairman the gentleman yields back I now recognize the ranking member on oversight Mr Connelly excuse me thank you madam chair and thank you for having this first hearing on Doge you know improper payments is not a new subject I remember joining Steve Lynch and then Todd Platz Republican member from Pennsylvania in my freshman year talking about improper payments at that time improper payments were in the range of 3 5 billion a year they're now in the range of $280 billion do a year and times 10 we could cut almost 3 trillion dollars
16:37from the debt if we addressed improper payments in a deliberative way which GAO is called for in the high-risk category for years we can also secondly enforce the tax code it's estimated that at least a half a trillion dollars a year is left on the table uncollected but owed because of lack of resources in the IRS again times 10 is5 trillion over
17:05a decade and finally we can modernize Federal it systems which we've championed for years on this committee we know that Legacy Legacy systems alone could save hundreds of millions of dollars a year in operating and maintenance costs so if we want to be serious about it let's be serious about it but the way not to do it is to fire the people charged with the remit of waste Fraud and Abuse namely inspector's General president Trump has already now fired 19 including most recently the usaid Inspector General who dared to warn that we could lose a half a billion dollars of food Aid because it's in warehouses not being moved because of the funding freeze that was imposed in
17:51Aid that's a cost we need to avoid and for doing his job that IG was fired if we want to be serious we've got to have objective neutral inspectors General who are monitoring government waste Fraud and Abuse and expenditures and I think you would find Democrats more than willing Partners in that kind of Enterprise if we're going to be serious but a wrecking crew a wrecking crane a wrecking ball is not going to do it and we're not going to support that approach to waste Fraud and Abuse in the federal government I yield back thank you the gentleman yields the president of the United States has the prerogative to fire anyone that has overseen $ 36
18:33trillion doll in debt enslaving the American people and rightfully so I'm pleased to welcome today's expert panel of witnesses who each bring unique experience and expertise that will be valuable to today to today's discussion I'd first like to welcome Mr Haywood talve the chief executive officer for government at Lexus Nexus Risk Solutions Inc his commitment to customers needs allows Lexus Nexus to develop Market leading solutions that have enabled customers to stop fraud waste and abuse next we have Mr Stuart witson the senior director of federal Affairs at the foundation of government accountability Stewart was previously a special agent in the FBI a US Army
19:22veteran and now spends his time at fga advocating to improve welfare the workforce course and other policy next we have Miss Don Royal a certified welfare fraud investigator in the state of Wyoming and director for the United Council of Welfare fraud she advocates for investigating and preventing fraud of government benefits and has done so over the past 16 years finally we have Mr Dylan hler got
19:54it the director of government Affairs at the project on government oversight Dylan leads advocacy efforts and policy reforms to a wide range of good governance I thank each of our Witnesses for being here today and I look forward to your testimony pursuant to committee rule 9g the witnesses will please stand and raise their right
20:20hand do you Solly swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to give is the truth the whole truth truth and nothing but the truth so help you guide let the record show that the witness has answered in the affirmative thank you you may take a seat we appreciate you being here today and look forward to your testimony let me remind the witnesses that we have read your written statement and it will appear in full in the hearing record please limit your oral statement to five minutes as a reminder please press the button on the microphone in front of you so that it is on and the members can hear you when you begin to speak the light in front of you will turn green
21:06after four minutes the light will turn yellow when the red light comes on your five minutes have expired and we would ask that you please wrap up I now recognize Mr talve for his opening statement chairwoman green ranking member Stanberry and distinguished members of the committee for over a decade a silent War has been waged against American taxpayers not with bombs or guns but with data and Technology outdated government systems permit criminals to access unlimited sums of money during the pandemic they stole $1 trillion dollar 70% of those
21:45dollars went overseas shockingly it's just not criminals exploiting the system it's the flawed system itself acting as the accomplice if left unchecked the US government will continue to lead the world in funding cyber criminals this is a data and Technology problem and it Demands a datadriven response criminal syndicates have turned benefit programs into their personal ATM machines exploiting those in need who wait months for benefits that may never come these ruthless Crooks use our money to fund child trafficking disperse drugs in our communities and terrorism for years criminal networks have stolen personal information from the public and private private sector
22:30they exploit real identities to manipulate Antiquated government Systems siphoning off billions and taxpayers hard-earned money we continue to pay benefits to deceased and incarcerated individuals direct money to Bad actors flagged on the do not pay list and Overlook duplicate Social Security numbers by not following best practices during the pandemic a simple cross check of PPP loan recipients against IRS records would have exposed massive fraud and prevented payments to transnational criminals who sold their quote unquote sauce on the dark web to stop this we must reclaim control of our systems not just from the criminal syndicates but the flawed systems enabling them smarter
23:14technology data and identity verification are not optional they are Necessities to protect taxpayers and ensure Aid reaches those who truly need it now the use of AI is fundamentally changing Society but in the hands of criminals it has become a weapon law Breakers are now using it to supercharge their award on taxpayers they use AI to create fake identity documents that pass biometric verifications Bots flood portals with thousands of fraudulent claims per second in deep fakes that mimic real applicants bypass the outdated nist 863 standards from 2017 honest and deserving people seeking access to government benefits suffer through endless application forms that
24:01are nearly impossible to navigate but criminals from Russia China and Romania gain access with ease the private sector has fraud rates below 3% meanwhile the public sector operates at a 20% fraud rate the solution is clear it's already used every day to protect consumers you seiously interact with your bank through an app that verifies your identity in milliseconds there's no excuse for the government to lag if we do the following number one Implement identity verification on the front end criminals should never receive a dime eliminate self-certification no more honor System for billion doll programs and continuous auditing keep verifying because
24:47criminals never stop adapting pay and Chase does not work of the $250 billion stolen in pandemic unemployment fraud less than5 billion has been recovered the idea in government that you cannot have speed insecurity is fiction I urge Congress to consider making the following legislative changes number one update the 1974 Privacy Act to allow for data sharing and matching number two fund a budget for fraud prevention in each appropriation Bill the USDA spends 12 12th of 1% on fraud prevention mandate that individuals caught stealing from entitlement programs pay pay Hefty fines and are removed from the program permanently and finally eliminate
25:33broad-based categorical eligibility this committee has a choice continue losing this war against criminal cels in nation states or fight back and save $1 trillion doll annually fraud pre prevention is not benefit prevention it's the key to ensuring that every dollar reaches those who truly need it hardworking Americans rely on these programs not just to survive but to build Better Lives for their families when criminals exploit the system they just don't steal money they steal opportunities stopping fraud isn't about denying benefits it's about protecting them this crime has two victims the first are the taxpayers and the second are those seeking
26:16benefits the frosters cartels and criminal syndicates are watching this hearing I'm sure of it it's time to show them that America will not fund its own destruction thank you and I look forward to your questions thank you Mr Talco I now recognize Miss Royal for her opening statement good morning chairwoman green ranking member stanbury and committee members my name is Don Royal I'm a certified welfare fraud investigator two-term past president and a current director of the United Council on welfare Ware fraud the United Council on welfare fraud is a national professional organization dedicated to protecting Integrity in our nation's Public Assistance programs we are the only
27:08National Organization singularly focused on the detection prevention and prosecution of Welfare fraud for too long agency bureaucrats have pitted citizens access to welfare programs against the Integrity of those programs access versus Integrity should never be an either or dichotomy we can all agree that access to public assistance is crucial America's citizens should not be hungry or deprived of medical care because of their inability to pay however making sure vulnerable citizens have access to these welfare programs should not mean that we simply turn a blind eye to Integrity we do not pursue the prevention detection and prosecution of if we do not pursue the prevention
27:51detection and prosecution of fraud taxpayers become the victims as the welfare programs become slush funds for anyone wanting to supplement their income with SNAP benefits absolve themselves from the financial responsibility of medical bills and using Medicaid to further taxpayer exploitation by taking advantage of cash assistance energy assistance child care and other social welfare programs one example of a welfare fraud is a case that I investigated that was criminally prosecuted last year the applicant mother failed to disclose her children's father as well as his employment and income on multiple applications she submitted for Medicaid snap and lowincome energy assistance the
28:33codefendant father worked a steady job earning a sixf figure salary and provided an enviable lifestyle for his family including vacations luxury Vehicles snowmobiles motor homes lavish gifts including one from the wife to the husband which was a $1,200 bottle of bourbon evidence we presented at trial included a candidate registration forms filed by the defendant father when he ran for Town Council and later made of the town where he declared he lived at the same address provided by his wife on her Public Assistance programs this was a case of greed but it emphasizes how easy it was for these criminals to make false statements on applications in
29:12order to receive benefits from multiple programs that they were never eligible for I could spend the rest of my day providing countless examples of how taxpayer funded programs are exploited and the message would be the same investigators continue to be hamstrung by anti equated regulations conflicting directives from federal agencies and the lack of access to technology sadly investigators have also found themselves at odds with the career bureaucrats who recite watered down facts about fraud in order to Pro promote their political agendas specifically we can look to the career bureaucrats who have historically claimed that the fraud rate in snap is
29:50less than 1% the disregard for the value of Integrity is evidenced by the less than 12th of 1% of the snap budget spent on the prevention detection and prosecution of fraud as part of Medicaid unwinding debacle the bureaucrat specifically directed states that they and quote cannot recover or recoup the cost of services from a beneficiary even if they have been found after an administrative hearing or criminal proceeding to have committed Medicaid beneficiary fraud or abuse end quote sadly it is already apparent that career bureaucrats are not being totally transparent as they attempt to protect spending and broken programs we fail to understand how mitigating the rampant
30:33fraud in Medicaid snap and other welfare programs stands up or strengthens the welfare programs fact is the opposite is true ignoring fraud and gaslighting fraud statistics erodes the very foundations of the programs that are essential to their future viability there are this there are things this committee can do to help the investigators fighting the war on fraud number one eliminate self testation in the application process for all programs number two funding for technology that includes identity verification tools that will help prevent fraud the current pay and chase model is not sustainable number three immediately implement the national accuracy Clearing House The
31:16Knack that will provide data to states to prevent duplicate participation in all of the social welfare programs and four allocate direct funding with mandates restricting the use of the funding to the prevention detection and prosecution of fraud in closing we're at a Crossroads those of us who have firsthand knowledge of the degree in which Public Welfare programs are being attacked know that reform is absolutely necessary reform to the recipient application process the billing process in Medicaid and how SNAP benefits are processed and how providers and retailers are authorized we thank you for the opportunity for UK cof to participate in this hearing we feel that
31:57the investigators who are on the front lines fighting the daily battle against the war on fraud need to be at the table and participating in the development of action plans that will make a difference in protecting the programs and defending the taxpayers thank you Miss Royal I now recognize Mr witson for his opening
32:20statement chairwoman green ranking member stanbury members of the subcommittee thank you for the opportunity to testify today on the campaign Trail president Trump promised to take on the bloated bureaucracy in DC rebuild trust in the doj and the FBI crack down on waste Fraud and Abuse and restore common sense and on day one he started delivering on those promises with a wave of executive orders in the official launch of Doge which he of course tasked Elon mus to lead already Doge efforts have brought to the Public's attention countless examples of wasteful spending including 59 million dollar paid to luxury hotels
33:00in New York to house illegal immigrants 1.5 million to advance Dei in Serbia's workplaces $32,000 for a transgender comic book in Peru the list goes on but rather than applauding the work of Doge the left has launched a coordinated campaign to try to demonize Mr musk with the hope of Shifting Focus away from the disastrous waste Fraud and Abuse that occurred on Biden's watch but guess what it's not working because no matter what political party people hail from the vast majority of Americans agree that $10 million worth of food funnel to Al-Qaeda was probably not the best use of taxpayer money but there's another source a key source of wasteful spending that Doge
33:47and the subcommittee should set their SES on next and that's Medicaid waste and fraud while initially meant as a program for the truly needy Medicaid is bloated into a massive welfare program for millions of able-bodied adults lured into the Trap of government dependency and as Medicaid has grown so too has mismanagement today more than1 in5 spent on Medicaid is improper and Medicaid alone fraud and mismanagement is on track to cost us taxpayers get this more than $1 trillion dollar over the next 10 years when it comes to the problem of improper payments the Medicaid Program is the biggest culprit Encompass encompassing nearly onethird of all
34:26federal improper payments and more than 80% of Medicaid improper payments are due to one thing eligibility errors if Congress wants to help president Trump address wasteful spending then targeting eligibility errors in Medicaid should be one of your top priorities bottom line to address this challenge Congress can take three decisive actions so first Congress can strengthen the Medicaid Program through legislative action that would include repealing Biden's disastrous Medicaid streamlining rule which ties the hands of states trying to remove ineligible enroles you can and should do this through reconciliation and it will produce $164 billion do in
35:04savings if you do you can also strengthen verification requirements to ensure only eligible individuals receive benefits and ensure a nationwide Knack is implemented without delay second thing Congress can do is help to help president Trump's Doge effort by ensuring that entrenched partisan bureaucrats don't stand in the way of Reform so musk and his doge team have already found hundreds of billions of dollars funneled into wasteful fraud and flat out insane projects but they've only scratched the surface if this much fraud has been exposed in just a few weeks imagine what else is buried under layers of red tape and government excuses but guess what all of these
35:42insane projects have one thing in common they were all approved and funded by unelected bureaucrats and these and other entrenched bureaucrats are already pledging to fight against President Trump's efforts to improve government accountability and efficiency Personnel is policy and without competent staff to Faithfully execute the president's agenda the Doge project will fail and this is where Congress can help Congress can support the president in carrying out his doge effort by making all executive branch employees at will codifying the president's authority to fire unproductive or insubordinate agency employees as needed at the same time Congress can grant the president
36:22authority to permanently eliminate vacant positions and consolidate non-essential positions across agencies and departments to help promote efficiency and put the right people in the right seat the third thing Congress can make president Trump's Doge cost cutting and deregulatory reforms permanent by passing The reigns act and so there's only one big problem with the Doge effort most of its work can be undone by a future president with a stroke of a pen to make president Trump's Doge reforms permanent Congress must act and the best way to do this is to pass the reign act this would return article one budgetary power of the purse to Congress while promoting
37:04deregulation it would also help lock in the do's reforms and cement president Trump's Legacy as the most consequential deregulatory and cost cutting president in US history the American people are watching it's time for Congress to act thank you and I look forward to your questions thank you Mr witson I now recognize Mr hler got it for his opening
37:30statement thank you chairwoman green ranking member stanbury and members of the subcommittee my name is Dylan hler godet and I'm the director of government Affairs at the project on government oversight or Pogo I appreciate the opportunity to be with you here today to talk about the critical issue of bringing more accountability and transparency to federal spending including rooting out waste Fraud and Abuse since our founding in 1981 Pogo has been focused on promoting more accountability and rooting out wasteful spending and promoting efficiency especially at the Department of Defense we have a long and wellestablished track record on these issues and we take a
38:07back when it comes to promoting a better and more Effective Government which necessarily includes a federal government that is a good and responsible Steward of taxpayer dollars let's take a moment to pause here to talk a little bit about terms that we're going to hear a lot today and the difference between them waste is different from fraud fraud is different from abuse and abuse is different from both when we talk about improper payments they are a subset of those other three categories but that doesn't tell us the whole picture either sometimes improper payments are a function of bad recordkeeping sometimes they are a function of outdated
38:42Information Technology systems Sometimes they come about through human error and sometimes they come about through negligence there are a variety of reasons why improper payments happen it just simply is not the case that improper payments are only a function of bad people doing bad things with bad intent that doesn't mean we shouldn't focus on trying to mitigate improper payments and that certainly doesn't mean that the American people should not be concerned with how their tax dollars are used the good news is is that there are some time tested Solutions and tools to help mitigate these problems for example when we think about the independence of
39:20Inspector General we're talking about a resource that is extraordinarily valuable to the American people in fiscal year 2023 alone Inspector General identified over $93 billion worth of potential savings to taxpayers whistleblowers are also an incredible resource to the American taxpayer Through The irs's Whistleblower program alone billions of dollars have been recouped from tax cheeses since the Inception of that program in 2007 whistleblowers have also played an instrumental role in helping the Department of Justice pursue false claims act cases that have resulted in billions of dollars in reclaims settlement costs it seemed to me that if an
40:03administration were serious about wanting to root out waste Fraud and Abuse they would support and resource whistleblowers and Inspector General they would not demonize them and they would certainly not fire them on mos in a unlawful midnight purs there are other reforms we can think about too reforms that are more technical but just as important key statutes such as the federal funding accountability and transparency act the data act and critical platforms like usaspending.gov were really were really important improvements and Innovations when they came about but they are in need of overhaul and reform currently the status quo is that we have an extraordinarily hard time
40:45tracking federal dollars from end to end this is due in large part to a broken chain of data collection of reporting information and the ability to Monitor and track in real time what is happening with federal dollars this informational black hole is where a lot of impropriety happens it's where waste Fraud and Abuse live and yes this is where improper payments often happen but more importantly we also don't have a good clear and consistent way of understanding what is happening with tax dollars at the end point what is the impact that we're having what is the return on investment that we're having we now have an annual budget of close to7 trillion do a year we can't
41:28say with any degree degree of clarity and consistency what we're getting for all of that money we have some more good news though there are bipartisan efforts and there have been for years to try and clean up this situation we at Pogo have had the privilege and pleasure of working on some of those initiatives we were a part of of the federal taxpayers right to know act being passed into law just a couple of years ago which created for the very first time a program inventory of all the programs in the federal government and that would be available to the public we have worked with a member of this very committee the house oversight and accountability committee to
42:03introduce a piece of legislation that would bring more transparency to federal subaward reporting we have supported and endorsed multiple pieces of legislation that take direct aim at the improper payments issue we also have additional ideas that don't yet have Congressional Champions one proposal is to clean up and modernize and standardize the award descriptions that are available in USA spending to make them more useful and relevant we have another proposal to harmonize the amount of data and information we collect between contract spending and non-contract spending We Stand ready willing and able to work with anybody who wants to work with us on these Common Sense
42:41Solutions lastly I want to put in a quick word for congress yeah and specifically I want to the gentleman's time has expired apologies yes I can't see the flashing L that's okay thank you Mr hler got it we we appreciate your testimony I now recognize myself for five minutes of questions I'd like to thank our Witnesses today for your testimonies and the suggestions that you have brought before this committee I'd also like to thank chairman comr for this opportunity to chair the historic oversight subcommittee on Doge Americans are shocked to learn that
43:202.7 trillion dollars of their hard-earned tax dollars have been stolen or wasted in improper payments since 2003 you see in the private sector companies can't continue they can't continue to run if they keep employees that allow waste and abuse with their resources but that has continued for decades here in the federal government Mr talve do private sector companies have a lower rate of improper payments than the federal government yes the fraud rate the that the criminals are taking advantage of in the public sector is around 20% in the private sector it's around 3% and it's really because the tools that are used in the private sector aren't used in the public sector
44:12front-end identity verification self-certification and then finally making sure that individuals are who they say they are if we start using these tools you will see the fraud rate go down dramatically because for the most part this fraud isn't taking place by real individuals it's individuals whose identities have been stolen on the dark web they use that information pretending to be somebody else and because of the Antiquated systens processes and Technologies in place in government programs they're able to steal its scale right so Mr telkov we would say that private companies that pretty much have to exist on a 20% profit rate they're not allowed they can't continue
44:58to to be successful if they were to allow their customers data to be stolen like that and used by criminals however the federal government who can continue printing checks and continue an operation never fixes its problems because it can't be forced to go out of business would you agree with that yes or no yes one of the things I noticed during covid was the criminals learned that government was the mark because it never runs out of money and they focus on it at scale and then the likelihood of getting caught is virtually zero I think it's outrageous for Americans to know that their identity can be stolen and then used for child trafficking drug
45:38trafficking and terrorism like you stated in your opening statement Miss Royal your testimony states that many programs operate under essentially an honor system in which applicants need not verify their identity income residency or other key eligibility factors you call this a trust everyone instead of a trust by verify approach does this mean the federal government and some states are giving out billions of dollars to individuals without verifying who they are or whether they meet program eligibility requirements yes ma'am that's correct out that's outrageous do do states have enough incentive to prevent fraud and to recover improper payments
46:23no and in fact states are hesitant to spend their State dollars to protect federal dollars would greater investment in program Integrity efforts yield a positive return for taxpayers yes it could easily be self-funding amazing Mr witson your testimony states that both the Biden and Obama administrations issued rules and guidance that made it harder for states to verify eligibility for Medicaid you say that repealing Biden's Medicaid streamlining rule would save 164 billion over 10 years because the rule restricts elig eligibility verification that states can perform can you explain why this rule is so costly yeah so the rule does a number of things
47:08but for instance it prohibits States from verifying eligibility more than once a year so for non-disabled folks to just go in and look and say hey are you still eligible for the program it says you are forbidden from doing that any more often than once a year and so obviously people's lives change and so they may become ineligible and so it's designed to keep them on the program another thing it prohibits in-person or phone interviews to verify their identity so people apply for it and then the person on the other end says well I just want to call and make sure this is a real person not someone in another country or whatever the the rule prohibits that and so there's a number
47:43of other Provisions it it also opens a lengthy reconsideration periods and this is where illegal immigrants are able to obtain the benefits and so basically it says once you get you know these benefits you can't interfere with it for a 90day per period or longer and so there's a number of horrible things but thank thank so we can't verify if someone is illegal or legal receiving Ben just to correct that yes or no you have to wait at least a state has to wait at least 90 days and actually what we're seeing is it's LED some states to wait as long as 13 years and so that on the unbelievable my time has expired thank you very much I now recognize Mr
48:19Lynch from Massachusetts for five minutes thank thank you very much Madam chair first of all let me congrat congratulate you and and also miss stanbury on your new positions and I want to thank the witnesses for for your testimony we've already heard some some good ideas about how to work together and Mr hler godet I for one would be most open to to working with Pogo and and and trying to work on some of the legislative ideas that you have to actually get at some of this waste Fraud and Abuse since this is my first opportunity to speak in this new subcommittee as the representative for the eth congressional district in Massachusetts I want to first of all
49:04make clear that my my primary purpose in seeking appointment to this subcommittee is for the singular and sacred purpose to defend our democracy which I believe is under attack in this country and to uphold my oath to support and defend the Constitution against those who might secretly or openly seek its destruction make no mistake this is a moment for representative democracy this is a test of our resolve in the coming days in weeks we will all get to decide whether we stand with a couple of billionaires who despite their own Financial successes still Harbor such grievances in their hearts that after all that democracy has provided to them they
49:49remain they remain animated by the desire to dismantle this democratic government and to punch down at some of the weakest and most vulnerable in our society to Men Who clearly understand that the easiest way to incite large numbers of people is to use social media to exploit the dynamic forces of hatred and fear Madame chair if we're going after a waste Fraud and Abuse let's start with abuse abuse of power as of yesterday there were 55 lawsuits under consideration by the federal courts across our nation as a result of Elon musk's and president Trump's unlawful acts many of those lawsuits have already been sustained by the federal district courts and have
50:37been R and orders have been rendered to undo those unlawful acts but this is just the beginning and Congress has an important role to play and I for one look forward to that opportunity this is a moment of great consequence for our country and for our democracy and I remain grateful to to the good people of the E congressional district of Massachusetts who sent me here Mr hetler gardet again happy to join you on some of your efforts Pogo has worked very closely with our IG Community is that right the inspector generals yeah that's correct Congressman I know your work is is is very much similar to what we ask our inspectors generals to to undertake I want to
51:23ask you what what do you think so so in the most recent report from the inspector generals and this is the Council of the inspector generals a nonpartisan group on integrity and efficiency in government they identified more than 93 billion doll in potential savings so the first thing that President Trump did coming into office was to fire fire 17 agency Inspector General
51:55what What can you tell us from pogo's standpoint what what does that do to our ability to identify and and root out waste Fraud and Abuse thank you Congressman I would say to put it simply it completely undermines our ability to root out waste Fraud and Abuse Inspector General exists for essentially one purpose and they were originally created in the immediate aftermath of Watergate and I think you all probably do not need me to give you a history lesson at all on what happened in the Watergate era there's a reason they were created at that time because there was a lot of waste rod and abuse happening and there were not cops on the beat that were internal that were
52:32independent that were situated in agencies to be able to find these things and expose them and do something about them that's what Inspector General exists to do so it's completely anathema to I'd say an to any state mission to find CA savings and to root out waste Fraud and Abuse to fire Inspector General and to undermine them it it it makes no sense those two things do not add up thank you very much the the firings that occurred on the when President Trump came to office included the special in Inspector General for Afghan reconstruction Mr Soco I I actually did over 20 trips to Afghanistan working with him he actually uncovered $4 billion doar in in Savings in rooting
53:17out American taxpayer waste being conducted in Afghanistan the IG at the Department of Defense the agency the gentleman's time is EXP thank you madam chair I yeld back thank you apprciate thank you I now recognize the gentleman from Texas Mr Cloud thank you madam chair for far too long DC politicians have gotten away with measuring their personal value and worth by how much of other people's money they give away and for far too long they self-righteously have opined that the spending was for altruistic purposes given out of care and compassion for far too long they've been more concerned with looking like they cared than having enough care and concern to actually do
54:01the due diligence to ensure that the tax dollars were being used wisely and effectively and for far too long those of us who've worked to uncover waste Fraud and Abuse have had to deal with what amounts to an unconstitutional fourth branch of permanent bureaucracy that has too often worked to ignore offis scate delay and frustrate our efforts to bring transparency and oversight over the last few weeks the Doge effort has begun to uncover not only how massive the waste Fraud and Abuse is but also the extent at which DC politicians and too many obstinate bureaucrats have coordinated to create what is essentially the largest money laundering scheme in history and while
54:43Americans have been working to make ends meet they have been using taxpayer dollars to fund unnecessary egregious and even evil things here at home and around the world thankfully in Doge we have a president bringing the leadership needed and a focused effort along with the talent technology tools and transparency to this waste Fraud and Abuse and to those who would stand opposed to this effort I would just point out while it's understandable to find waste Fraud and Abuse that has grown and metastized in this government even over decades certainly accelerated over the last few years to continue to protect it is corrupt ion I want to thank the chair for beginning
55:29this war on waste on this side of Pennsylvania Avenue and bringing together this committee this effort is so important as we work to relieve the Americans people of this burden of waste Fraud and Abuse Mr toov you mentioned in your written statement and talked about it in your your statement at the beginning that this waste Fraud and Abuse is a national security threat and certainly one of the challenges facing us that is a national security security threat is our fiscal situation and so we have got to find ways to find savings to the American people in order to strengthen the bring confidence to the bond markets to to put our country on a fiscal footing and and to reverse the
56:08curse so to speak that we are placing on our our children and our grandchildren you mentioned a couple threats though you mentioned internal threats you said that these cases involve government employees individuals entrusted with administering benefits who instead of using their positions to approve fraudulent claims override security controls or even sell sensitive claim claiming information for profit now this is not every federal employee for sure but within the context of people who are trying to give their best effort we have an internal threat but you also mentioned transnational fraud Rings terrorist organizations Nations nation states North Korea nuclear
56:47weapons programs funded by our tax dollars China Nigeria Iran Romania Russia not our friends necessarily that are being funded by taxpayer dollars could you give us some examples of how this is happening God yeah so when you think about what happened during the pandemic 1 trillion was stolen 70% of that money
57:08went overseas and I can give you some examples in a western state they had more people applying for unemployment insurance benefits than they had individuals over 18 the people that were stealing the money from Romania were using it to facilitate other fraud schemes that include fentol that include doing things to impact our democracy on The Insider thread right the first thing you have to say and my dad was a public servant is 99% of people that work in the public sector are honest hardworking individuals but there are some and what you need is data and Technology to root that out there were examples during the pandemic there were some examples even
57:53of last week where people got into the Medicaid system in a Southern in a western state and stole $50 million in less than four months so you have to have these controls in place right these aren't individual stealing Mr Cloud these are organized criminal groups both domestic and transnational that as you mentioned taxpayers are being forced to fund the demise of our own country Mr Winson I wanted to ask you because there's a lot of talk about reconciliation right now you mentioned Medicaid and what could be done to to bring pretty substantial amount of savings and this is without affecting those who truly need Medicaid and and for what the the purpose of the
58:36program was extended for now the the gentleman's time has expired did does the witness want to answer the question no only to say that yes there's a a a tremendous amount of savings that can be found from the streamlining rule but also work requirements in the program is another big area that can be done in reconciliation and could save a significant amount as well 241 billion in federal spending over 10 years thank you thank you thank you madam chair you're welcome I now recognize the gentleman from California Mr Garcia well thank you thank you to all of our Witnesses for being here and I want to just start off by making something clear I think we're all
59:17here to fight against the lies the Corruptions and the attacks on our social safety net now we should in no way be cooperating with House Republicans who want to shut down the Department of Education and Destroy Medicare and Medicaid and we should not stand by as the richest man on the planet gives himself and his companies huge tax cuts while the American people get absolutely nothing now I find it ironic of course that our chairwoman congresswoman green is in charge of running this committee now in the last Congress chairwoman green literally showed a dickpick in our oversight Congressional hearing so I thought I'd bring one as well now this of course we know is
1:00:03President Elon Musk he's also the world's richest man he was the biggest political donor in the last election he has billions of dollars in conflicts of interest and we know that he is leading a power grab also abided by and encouraged by Donald Trump and of course the chairwoman congresswoman green but I also want to run through what Doge actually is going to do it's a demolition plan that's going to run through our government Jo is trying to abolish the Department of Education that means opportunities denied to kids it means you're ripping away opportunities for children with disabilities who are dependent on this money you're also halting medical research which is also
1:00:43critical which we have to also stop the idea that we are going to eliminate or destroy the Department of National Institutes of Health and NIH is crazy let's talk about the Department of Labor we're talking protections for working people across this country where people can actually complain about abuses their companies are making against them and their co-workers workers are now going to be in Danger let's also talk about the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau another huge issue for us think about the scammers and fraudsters that will be empowered across this country because Elon mus wants essentially these companies have more power over consumers and over
1:01:24people across this country look at the Centers for Disease and centers for Medicare and Medicaid services that is actually what's being discussed partly today healthc care we're talking about being denied to millions of poor people workingclass people across this country and now of course they're on to their largest Target the US Social Security Administration we're talking about this the destruction of the actual social safety net in this country we know that one in five Americans collect Social Security seniors disabled people this
1:01:58entire plan is about hurting the American social safety net and destroying our institutions and it's important that we actually call out what is happening at this subcommittee this is not about working with the richest man on the planet this is actually about empowering this committee wants to empower the richest person in the world to hurt people so they can take all of this money that they So-Cal want to save and then give it to themselves their compan and their billionaire friends that is the attack that is happening in this committee and across this country and it's important that we call it out we also know of course that Elon Musk is sending his unqualified Doge staff to
1:02:40carry out this agenda across all these agencies and in some cases actually teenage staffers no accountability no experience and problematic records they're trying to rob you and they're probably a minor thank you and I yield back the gentleman yields and I now recognize the gentleman from South Carolina Mr Timmons for five minutes thank you madam chair I I find it sad that my colleagues across the aisle can't take this seriously we have $36 trillion in debt we run an annual almost $2 trillion deficit when I got elected six years ago we had $21 trillion in debt so in six years we've added over over5 trillion dollar to the debt and guess what president Trump ran on fixing
1:03:32this problem president Trump told the American people he would write the ship financially and he said during the campaign that Elon Musk was going to be the person to lead this charge the man that has turned business after business around he's the richest man on the planet because he succeeds at his Endeavors and that's why president Trump has appointed him the head of this effort this is a very serious problem and it's incredibly hypocritical that my colleagues across the aisle are complaining about this because Joe Biden Joe Biden signed his name and wanted the American people to believe that he had the ability to forgive 250 billion with a
1:04:14signature guess what Supreme Court ruled he did not that's our system of checks and balances the president Biden he clearly was experiencing cognitive decline he didn't even have the ability to be charged with the crime as determined by his own department of justice but he signs his name and he thinks it gives a quarter of a trillion dollars away redistributes taxpayer dollars it's just crazy that we can't come together to address the greatest national security threat facing this country our debt now to the task at hand Medicaid fraud Mr talv if we Implement
1:04:58enhanced identity verification and enhanced income verification what will happen how much money will we save you'll save hundreds of billions of dollars identity verification elimination of self-certification and monitoring beneficiaries will prevent these transnational criminal grps from accessing those systems at scale so legitimate people who need the benefits can get them in a Time fashion so we're going to get actual benefits to people to American citizens that are in need faster because if you do it electronically through web base like they did in Missouri where the pilot program saved almost 20% of Medicaid dollars so all we have to do is adopt
1:05:44what has already been proven in Missouri and we'll save 20% to the people out there listening we spend almost $900 billion every year on Medicaid and and if 20% of that is saved that's almost $200 billion we got a $1.8 trillion annual deficit we just knocked off 200 billion let's keep this train going the
1:06:09fact that the Democrats are filing lawsuit after lawsuit to impede the efforts of President Trump to write our fiscal ship is unforgivable it's unforgivable Mr talo you talked about pandemic fraud I have a bill that would cause the IRS to share data with the small business administration and the FBI and the Department of Justice that would show that you were ineligible for PPP loans and you got them so
1:06:41I think that would save probably a hundred billion do do you think that we should go back and take money away from people that fraudulently got covid money yeah during the pandemic the PPP program was a virtual buffet for fraudsters and it was because of that 1974 Privacy Act where data sharing and matching is virtually impossible Congress needs to change that but we can do it retroactively we can do it retroactively we can find the people that stole this money hold them accountable probably get some of the money back so I already have that bill filed that bill I think would probably get a hundred billion dollars so now we got enhanced identity ver verification enhanced
1:07:23income verification that has been proven in Missouri it does work so I'm working on that bill we're going to drop it soon that's $200 billion there's a competition in Congress I think we should have a competition on this committee I got $300 billion doll in savings proposed we got to all pull our weight because we have such a massive problem right now but I would just ask my colleagues across the AIS to get out of the way if you don't want to help if you don't want to help write the fiscal ship in this country get out of the way stop filing lawsuit after lawsuit we do not have the Financial ability to continue down this path and we're going to save this
1:08:01country with or without you you can kick and scream all the way or you can get out of the way I prefer the former thank you madam chair the gentleman yields I now recognize the gentleman from Texas Mr casar this subcommittee is supposedly about looking into waste Fraud and Abuse so I'd like to start talking about independent inspector generals who are supposed to be looking into waste Fraud and Abuse Mr talve do you know how many inspector generals at agencies that were investigating Elon musk's companies have been fired by the Trump musk Administration no it is five Miss Royal
1:08:42the Inspector General at the Department of Labor had 17 open investigations into Tesla and SpaceX do you know what the Trump musk Administration did to that Inspector General no they they fired him and I think youall know Mr witson the Inspector General at the Department of Transportation was investigating Tesla do you know what the Trump musk Administration did to that Inspector General no they were fired the department of defense's Inspector General was looking into SpaceX Mr hedler do you know what the Trump musk Administration did to that Inspector General I believe he was fired thank you I think everybody on the panel knows what the answer to these questions were
1:09:21the US Department of Agriculture Inspector General was investigating musk's neuralink Mr talve now I'll ask you again under oath do you know what Mr Trump did to that Inspector General that was looking into one of musk's companies no he was fired the Inspector General at the EPA was repeatedly taking on Tesla
1:09:41Mr hedler since it seems that you're answering the questions that everyone knows the answer to do you know what the Trump musk Administration did to that Inspector General I believe he was also fired also fired at least five inspector generals that were looking into Elon musk's companies were fired by the Trump musk Administration these inspector generals who are independent protected by law they are the people that find the waste Fraud and Abuse and found many of the cases of waste Fraud and Abuse that have been brought up today fired because they were looking into Elon Musk at the nlrb the National Labor Relations Board which is supposed to protect workers
1:10:21from getting their unions busted by folks like Elon Musk made functionally broken by the so-called Department of government efficiency that really is the Department of government efficiency for Elon Musk not for you they are trying to shut down the Department of Education the Department of Labor you know what Elon Musk doesn't seem to be looking into his own contracts again I'll ask
1:10:46you Mr Talco do you know how much money a day Mr musk will receive from the federal government for his contracts no the answer is $8 million a day just last year Elon Musk was promised $3 billion from close to1 100 contracts with the federal government Miss Royal do you know how much the average person in this country who survives on Social Security one of our seniors who's worked their entire life about how much they have to survive on a day I do not $65 a day we're not looking into Elon musk's $8 million a day this subcommittee chaired by margerie Taylor Green in the house of Republicans is looking into your grandmother's $65 a day let me be clear I think we
1:11:35would all support taxpayer savings look into money we might needlessly send to billionaires and big corporations find taxpayer savings and send it back to your hardworking family but instead what House Republicans and the Trump musk Administration want to do is they want to look into your kids lunch money your kids teachers salary into your grandparents Social Security they want to take that money and give it out in billionaire tax cuts and they are talking about that in committee tomorrow in budget committee tomorrow they just released their plan so let me be clear when Republicans talk about government efficiency in this Congress they're not
1:12:14looking into billionaires who don't pay their taxes they're not looking into billionaires who get rich off of Government contracts they're not looking into Elon Musk firing Watchdogs who are supposed to keep him accountable they're looking at cutting your Public Schools they're going straight for your Social Security they're coming straight for cancer research they're coming straight for the Department of Education they're not looking at Big Tech they're not looking at Big Pharma because those people fund their campaigns if this committee were serious about rooting out waste from our federal government then today's whole hearing would be about how
1:12:44musk and Donald Trump are firing the independent Watchdogs who've done this work for decades instead my Republican colleague's actual goal on this committee is to distract from Trump and from musk's corrupt war on accountability this will not be a subcommittee dedicated to making government efficient for everyday people it's about helping Elon Musk and Donald Trump be as efficient as possible in robbing our government and handing out our government service services to a to the rich so this seems that this subcommittee is just going to agency it's after the gentleman time has expired a total sham the American people are $36 trillion in debt it certainly
1:13:27seems reasonable that someone has been fired I now recognize the gentleman from Tennessee you're going to put us further INB with your billionaire you're not recognized Mr burett you're recognized for five minutes thank you chair lady the gravy train for a lot of these folks it's been on biscuit wheels and it's about to run off the dead gum tracks and it's about time could you imagine standing up here and defending waste Fraud and Abuse but I think that's what we're seeing when people squeal and don't ask questions I think it shows the American public what the heck's going on and that little gravy train is getting ready to run out the SP it is getting
1:14:05ready to be turned off Mr talve that's correct how you say your name brother yes sir all right how can the federal government improve identity verification for these entitlement programs yeah it's doing what the private sector does every single day whether you use your bank you go to Amazon using those tools and moving away from some of the dated compliance standards that the federal government uses nist IAL 863 2017 before there was anything called Deep fakes and generative AI tools also I was informed that
1:14:45PayPal has never been they've never been able to crack into that and steal people's Vital Information are they using those systems that you would be favorable towards that government seems to be shying away from yes sir and describe that how that works the there there systems that are based on encryption they use technology and they use data to validate you are who you say you are the people that are stealing right now I believe a lot of them are actually ghosts from China Russia Nigeria and Romania I read a report today that North Korea was involved in this in some of that as as well they are and those people are enemies again they'll hate us for
1:15:29free we don't have to give them taxpayer money and are there loopholes that can be closed to avoid these improper payments and I wish you'd describe those to me the the biggest most important thing particularly in the benefit program space is the use of self-certification as Mr Timmons noted the state of Missouri is using a solution called steady IQ to validate wages and wealth you have cannot allow individuals to provide the information based upon what they think it has to be based on what you know and that will stop the ghosts from using people's identities to steal money from us taxpayers how much money do you calculate is wasted due to waste
1:16:14Fraud and Abuse in the entitlement programs each year yeah my number right now between federal state and local government is you can save $1 trillion a year by simply putting in front-end identity verification eliminating self-certification and monitoring the back end of the programs that are providing the benefits those three things you said you could eliminate that but there are others you feel like some more low hanging fruit I would start with those three things because they're simple that'll take that 20% fraud rate that you're seeing in the public sector down below 5% chair lady I would suggest that we adopt Mr Tim's legislation and get
1:16:59that out of the committee as fast as possible what actions also could Congress take to fix these problems quickly yeah I think the the first thing is updating and redoing the 1974 Privacy Act that is virtually impossible to do data matching it's very difficult to have data shared and when you look back at the Pand mic data sharing and data matching would have stopped probably 50% of the trillion dollars that was stolen from taxpayers any yall like to add anything to that Congressman I would just add that rather than accepting self attestation that State should have to be required to actually verify people's identities and here's the key part
1:17:50before they get enrolled they shouldn't get enrolled and then eventually come down the later on down the road it's amazing to me have a doctor's appointment back in Knoxville and the verification process is very extensive it's more so than the federal government requires for any of this what type of computer systems are these agencies using and do they need updating they're using very dated technology but they're also burdened I look at the USDA 6.2 million words in a 10,000 page document that shows how to implement the rules of the program nobody can figure that out so one of the things that I think has to happen is the simplification of these
1:18:37processes and systems and then just use the technology that we use every day in the private sector okay thank youall so much for being here gentleman's time has expired thank you chair lady I now recognize the gentle woman from Texas Miss Crockett for five minutes thank you madam chair and Mr talve I'm just going to go ahead and pick up where you left off really quickly just to be clear the upgrades that you're talking about as it relates to our data processes these aren't things that would be free are they they would cost some kind of money not looking for a number but they will cost correct some are free and some would cost money okay all right
1:19:17so I just want to leave it there because we've had a number of these hearings so I do want to be clear before the Trump administr ation came in this committee did exist in the form of the oversight committee and our task is to root out waste Fraud and Abuse in that vein we had a number of hearings at least last term I can't speak for any other term as I'm only in my sophomore term and we dealt with improper payments and interestingly enough our chairwoman who was so passionate about this today she missed every single one of those improper payment hearings but just to be clear I was there so I don't want anyone to believe that Democrats just come to
1:20:00work and don't plan to do work in fact I'm trying to figure out exactly what it is that the Republicans believe our job is because right now they have relinquished their constitutional duties over to an unelected bureaucrat someone who no one went out to vote for and absolutely he is occupying the Oval Office as we saw yesterday and that is a first for me to see someone occupying the Oval Office who's never actually been elected to the Oval Office and and actually answering more questions than the person that allegedly got elected but for whatever reason this is the first time we're having a doge subcommittee hearing and that guy is not here instead we have y'all so I do want
1:20:44to thank you for coming but I will say this it's also interesting to me that in the first few days of Doge existing we know that they are trying to get rid of the Department of Education usaid Consumer Financial Protection Bureau they're laying off FAA workers they are going after the FDA the CDC the HHS the FBI agents and they're talking about getting rid of FEMA and they brought y'all in and I am going to say that I actually was shocked that there was only one person that seemed like he was an overt Trumper as you laid out your opening remarks because I anticipated that at least one of y'all would say yes what Elon is doing is exactly what we
1:21:25would prescribe but instead I will applaud you because you actually were focused you talked about what the American people are looking for us to do we've actually consistently on this side of the aisle promoted this idea of making investments into technology so that we can do things such as say look at the Department of Defense the Department of Defense that takes up approximately oh 50% of our discretionary income or our discretionary spending approximately 50% goes to Department of Defense Department of Defense has not been able to pass an audit in the last six Audits and we're not talking about pennies I understand that we want everything to be perfect
1:22:09and if we could get all ways Fraud and Abuse out that would be fantastic but let me talk about the big numbers the big numbers are on that side when we look at say our entire Workforce our federal Workforce as we're trying to somehow fire all of them they don't even make up a total of 5% it's even less than that when we look at our budget but let's talk about defense that just happens to be the same side of the Ledger that Mr musk gets the vast majority of his money from in fact at the same time that they were unlawfully and we will stay in court because on this side we believe in Law and Order we believe in I mean a number of us are actually lawyers but nevertheless we
1:22:51understand the Constitution we believe in that as well and so there things such as you know impoundment right because as Mr witson said he said we need to return the power of the pur of Congress it never left according to the Constitution that's where it's at now I know that people are confused right now because for whatever reason we had a guy that went in and you talk about people invading our data listen people said that they were upset about Tik Tock but I'm upset about the guy that runs Twitter who for sure is doing nefarious things because I don't understand if you were trying to conduct Audits and figure out where the waste Fraud and Abuse is I
1:23:29don't know why you would go to some tech guy in fact it was only techies that were sitting there at inauguration we didn't have Auditors I I would welcome Auditors to come in and do forensic audits in fact he sat there in the Oval Office yesterday and he admitted that he was lying and he was using his propaganda machine to do it when he said that we sent millions of dollars to Gaza for Condoms that was a lie so let me tell you something time for us and re in this Rogue actor know the gentle ladies time has expired I now recognize the gentleman from Missouri Mr
1:24:09burles thank you madam chair I just want to speak frankly at first to the American people we are nearing $37 trillion in national debt what does that mean that means that each and every US taxpayer owes over were $323,000 okay what does that mean that means when when the Epic which is the economic policy Innovation Center says we have 18 trillion left that's it 18 trillion left to take out and we're spending $2 trillion do in debt every year folks we are at the precipice of a
1:24:48debt like a like a debt cycle we are literally at a at a point in which the dollar will be worth nothing what does that mean and I mean it I mean we know social security goes bankrupt in eight years right Medicare goes bankrupt in 10 years and then 15 years from now the the dollar is completely devalued and worth nothing so what does that mean that means your pension the money in your bank you know your savings me is mean is
1:25:21nothing it's worthless so what are we doing we're trying to save this country we're trying to save your pensions we're trying to save your bank accounts we're trying to save this country for the next generation and it would be nice if we had help but instead we have people that are fighting us on this and you know they don't I think that it's I would hate to be in the Democratic party right now because you're in a really bad bind you're having to defend all of this crazy spending all of this crazy waste so how do you do it you do ad hominin attacks you attack the messenger oh Elon Musk right he's Rich he must be evil right that's the that's the attacks
1:26:00really you can't do any better than that right let's talk on the policy on the policy help us we're trying to save this country this is what and Elon Musk who's making no money doing this is trying to save this country why because he has invested in the United States of America more than anybody right so I think that we should embrace it in fact not a single comp governor of any state would
1:26:27ever turn down Elon Musk and his team of Doge from coming in and providing free services to write the course and financially in any state or organization it's ridiculous that we would demonize someone that loves this country so much Mr Whitman the formation of agencies via the executive action is not new
1:26:50right the the formation of Doge is not new can you you know are you familiar with any other previous presidencies where they've formed organizations like Doge via executive action yes so I so actually the agency that doge is occupying is one that was created in a previous administration so it is something that happens routinely but but I don't know if that answers your question yeah there's been the office of budget management was created Environmental Protection Agency was created the US digital service which is now Doge was created all by executive order right and actually one other I'd add is US Aid was originally created through an executive order by President
1:27:31Kennedy and then later formalized and then Madam chair I have a video I would like to end with that just let's review if if we could cue that it remind and I want to remind my Democratic friends at a point in which you once had the majority of the American people on your side this is this is what your party believed in
1:27:56this report tells us how to cut waste cut red tape streamline the bureaucracy change procurement rules change the Personnel rules and create a government that works better and cost less I've read it and where it says the President should the president will among the 800 recommendations eliminating 12% of the federal Workforce merging some government agencies like the FBI the DEA in the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms closing hundreds of government offices outside Washington from the day I took office one of the commitments that I made the American people was that we would do a better job here in Washington in rooting out wasteful spending we thought that it was
1:28:42entirely appropriate for our governments and our agencies to try to root out waste large and small in a systematic way it means cutting some programs that I think are worthy but we may not be able to afford right now a lot of the action is in Congress and legislative but in the meantime we don't need to wait for congress in order to do something about wasteful spending that's out there we haven't seen as much action out of Congress as we'd like and that's why we launched on our own initiative the campaign cut waste and we're going to keep on finding every possible way that we can do that even if Congress is not acting there you go
1:29:27I think it speaks for itself my time is expired the the gentleman's time is expired thank you I now yield to the gentlewoman from the District of Colombia Miss Norton for five minutes thank you our Republican colleagues and the Trump Administration continue to demonize our friends and neighbors who work for the federal government and swear and oath to protect the Constitution and serve the public thousands of civili ion federal employees have given their lives in the line of duty for their country the administration seems intent on dismantling much of the federal government in violation of the Constitution statutes and regulations and our Republican colleagues are
1:30:11letting them do it they want to gut the nonpartisan civil service and to convert a significant portion of the remaining Civil Service into Political appointees depriving the federal government of employees expertise and experience will harm the services that the government provides to all Americans Mr hetler
1:30:38garlett the administration is attempting to cause a mass Exodus from our federal Workforce will this increase or decrease waste Fraud and Abuse thank you delegate Norton I think it's pretty clear that chaos is not the friend of efficiency if you undermine the very functionality of the government you're not going to make it more efficient you're going to make it worse and it's going to cost even more money to recoup or to fix things that go wrong in the interim so I you know again I mentioned earlier that if you care about waste F and abuse firing Inspector General doesn't add up I think if you care about government being more efficient think intentionally creating
1:31:23chaos is the the opposite of that well Mr hetler gotlet do federal employees operate without oversight or rules and regulations no absolutely not they are governed by plenty of rules and regulations and when there are independent Inspector General at the agency they're supposed to be at they also have a cop on the beat making sure that they do so I want to highlight some stories demonstrating exactly the kinds of fedal world ERS the administration is trying to force out how about Chris Mark at the Department of Labor whose pioneering work on M safety has reduced M safety
1:32:10minor safety deaths from roof collapses to almost zero today or Jared kopman at the Internal Revenue Service who p pioneered new methods for tracking criminal cyber security currency transactions that led to the rescue of 23 children from rape and assault as well as the seizure of hundreds of millions of child abuse videos and 370 pedopile arrests this work also
1:32:48prevented funding from going to terrorist groups or Ronald E W Alters who manages the 155 National cemeteries around the country and tends to the resting places of almost 4 million veterans these are just a few of the federal workers who serve Americans every day the workers are the workers
1:33:14are Wildland firefighters border guards doctors nurses food inspectors air traffic controllers and law enforcement that do their civic duty often despite the fact that they could make such more in the private sector thank you and I yield back the general lady yields I nail yield to the gentleman from Georgia Mr Jack well thank you very much M thank you very much Madam chair and I want to also thank you for convening this hearing I think it's incredibly important and I want to thank our Witnesses for appearing before us today like another member of this committee I too was once an employee of the Executive Office of the President I worked in president Trump's White House
1:34:01from the very first to very last day of his first term and I saw firsthand how entrenched and resistant the federal bureaucracy was to his agenda so it's no surprise that today a few of my Democrat colleagues have continued that Trend by using their time to bash Elon Musk instead of discussing ways to work together to advance a bipartisan Cornerstone of President Trump's agenda the mission to eliminate finally eliminate waste Fraud and Abuse and I just took a a rudimentary count of the the dims testimony or rather comments today and I've got 27 mentions of Elon Musk and three mentions of waste and I don't know if that's in fact the right count encourage anybody to
1:34:43fact check me but I think it illuminates and illustrates one of the problems that we're facing which is a lack of bipartisan effort to address these these critical things that you know waste water and abuse is something that should be bipartisan the chair noted that in her opening remarks now Madam chair you know how much I enjoy studying public opinion so with your approval I'd like to enter into the record the CBS News poll from this past weekend conducted February 5th to 7th 2025 and I'd also like to illuminate two findings first 70% of Americans Democrats and Republicans included believe President Trump is already doing the job that he was elected to which is
1:35:23interesting because I have an article here from CNN from September 2024 that notes Trump says Elon Musk has agreed to lead proposed government efficiency commission as ex-president unveils New Economic plans so he is doing exactly what he said he would do by empowering his administration to root out waste Fraud and Abuse and that's exactly what we're trying to do here today I'd also like to note one interesting statistic from that 62% of Americans want Democrats and Congress to work with us to advance the priorities that President Trump was elected to to govern on so I I think those are two stats that I hope everyone pays attention to but to ask questions of our Witnesses I'd
1:36:03first like to start with Mr talve you know one of the things that I found very interesting from your opening testimony is you you talked and and I think you engaged with Mr burett on the 1974 Privacy Act and I had some interesting folks visit my office yesterday who noted that onethird of all prior authorizations are still done manually by phone facts or direct postmail first off would love your comments on that and I'd also like for you to expound upon some of the solutions that we can deliver this Congress and modernizing that 1974 Privacy Act yeah these aren't people problems these are technology problems you can't process the number of individuals that are accessing our
1:36:43systems person by person it just takes too much time so by updating the 1974 Privacy Act and allowing for digital Max ing you would have very quickly realized that a large portion of the PPP loan funds were going to the wrong person you would have been quickly able to match and I think the number was 20% were on the do not pay list you can't expect people to do what a machine and especially AI can do today fair enough thank you very much for that and if I can also ask Mr witson we I think we share a common interest which is to to move departments and agencies outside of Washington DC it's something that I campaigned on something that I helped president Trump
1:37:29effectuate in his first Administration and I have to imagine that if we have departments and agencies outside of DC if we've got you know a Workforce that's more reflective of the balance that America is we at the same time too could potentially root out some of this waste Fraud and Abuse by enabling other Americans other citizens of our country to help Advance some of these issues so we love your your commentary on that before my time expires no I think you're exact right Congressman Jack and so I think a you you'd save a lot of taxpayer money so building a headquarters in downtown DC versus Huntsville Alabama you're going to be able to save a lot of money number two
1:38:04you're actually going to make life better for the employees as well so that's a point that's also missed a lot but commuting into DC versus being to go somewhere else where it's a better cost of living and things like that might be better for the folks and then lastly these areas where you set up a headquarters are going to be populated by people that live in the area to fill the rank and file of Staff positions and so if you plant these Federal agency headquarters in the heart of any area that's overwhelmingly one party or the other then you're going to naturally get that sway versus something that's more representative of the people as a whole
1:38:36well thank you very much our Witnesses mindful of my time I want to finish before my time expires I yield back to our chairwoman marger Taylor green thank you chairwoman I I would like to enters ask for unanimous consent to enter something into the record so what is it it is a report from the the Congressional research service nonpartisan CRS that lays out the rules and the law for firing inspectors general which of course look into waste Fraud and Abuse and without objection thank you and that rule requires for the law to be followed for Congress to be notified with 30 days and a reason for firing inspectors General to give Congress a chance to overrule that and
1:39:14that's the the law so thank you for entering that into the record Madam chair wi without objection the materials Mr Jack cited are also submitted for the record I now recog yes apologies and while we're on it I'd also like to ask for unanimous consent to submit for the record two items one is a statement from the AFL CIO Department of people who work for a living with views on working people to make the government work and the second is a statement for this from the center for responsibility and ethics in Washington on ways to combat waste Fraud and Abuse in the federal government without objection so ordered I now recognize the gentle lady from New
1:39:51Mexico and ranking member Miss Stansbury for five minutes all right well thank you madam chairwoman and thank you once again to all of our Witnesses for being here to testify thank you to my colleagues we are going to have so much fun in this committee this Congress I actually appreciate the video that was shown just a few moments ago because when I worked at the Office of Management and budget I actually worked on the waste EO that was referenced that President Obama signed but there is one fundamental difference between the presidents and vice presidents that were shown on that video and what's happening today and that is that they followed the
1:40:31law so my colleagues across the aisle who are asking us to get out of the way and stop trying to block things in the courts let me tell you we do not work for an unelected billionaire like apparently this guy does we work for the American people and so if an unelected unvetted individual private citizen is hacking our government systems breaking the law firing federal employees dismantling statutorily created agencies withholding funds we are going to fight you in the courts and I'm actually really sad that my dear friend Mr burette left because I want to talk about that gravy train on biscuit wheels that he just talked about because that gravy train is not the federal Workforce
1:41:18it's the billionaires that are trying to hack that system right now and which unfortunately my colleagues right now are working on a Reconciliation deal to cut Medicaid to cut Medicare and use that money to give to tax breaks to their billionaire buddies that is the gravy train that is actually going on here but because this is the oversight committee let's do a little bit of oversight for the last several weeks I've been talking to Treasury and OMB officials to try to get to the bottom of why Elon Musk and his team are trying to hack the treasury payment system system because this is a completely nonpartisan system that literally just pays the
1:41:58bills of the federal government so why are they so eager to hack this system and I have to say that over the last several weeks we have literally received thousands of calls in every single Congressional office in fact we know that our friends across the aisle are also receiving these calls because this system pays the bills of the US government it pays our soldiers it pays for the work that we do overseas it pays your Social Security benefits it pays your tax refunds so why is Elon Musk and
1:42:35his hackers trying to access that system and why did a senior civil servant who had overseen the system for over 30 years get asked to stand down after a 25-year-old intern working for Elon Musk tried to get access ACC to the code for that system now thankfully they were shut down in the court system but musk has installed with the president's blessing one of his silicone buddies Silicone Valley buddies who I want to point out in which the media has not paid a lot of attention to is the CEO of a private IT company including Citrix that has millions of dollars in it contracts with the federal government and not only is he still operating at as
1:43:23the installed Doge person at treasury he's actively still the CEO of this private company how is that even legal is it legal I don't think it's legal because the federal court is trying to shut this down we also know that that 25-year-old software engineer in violation of the court order was actually given access to modify the code
1:43:49so what is going on here and why is this such a threat to the American people why are thousands of people calling us it's because of the size and the significance of these payments because it is an invasion of the privacy and security of the American people because it could threaten our ability as a country in if there was a default in the debt ceiling and because it contains highly classified information that our foreign adversaries are trying to Cyber attack us regularly for so why is a private citizen being given access to this system we know they're trying to shut down payments they're trying to shut down agencies what's next are they going
1:44:29to shut down your Social Security payments we don't know because they have no oversight and Elon Musk will not come in front of this committee and in fact the treasury folks are saying this is the biggest Insider threat they've ever seen in the history of the agency so we are sounding the alarm and no matter how many executive orders that Donald Trump signs or how many tweets the VP sends you cannot rewrite the Constitution and we are going to hold you to account I yield back the general lady yields and I now recognize oh yes I have three documents I want to submit for the record the first the first document is the Constitution Article two I would
1:45:11like to submit that for the record that clearly spells out the president's Authority I would also like to submit for the record us 5 us code 3161 the employment compensation of employees which clearly spells out his authority to create Doge and then I want to submit for the record the executive order that Trump issued on January 20th of 2025 establishing Doge officially
1:45:35without objection so ordered I now recognize the gentleman from Texas Mr Gil for five minutes thank you madam chair and thank you for hosting this committee if we've learned anything so far it's that Republicans want to cut waste Fraud and Abuse from our federal government and save taxpayer dollars and Democrats want to grandstand and play politics we can see right now even of the six Democrats on this committee only one can even be bothered to stay for the duration of this hearing all we've heard about for most of this hearing from the other side of the aisle is Elon Musk Elon Musk Elon Musk unelected bureaucrat and I'd like to ask if if Democrats really care about
1:46:22unelected bureaucrats making decisions over our lives where were they whenever their God Anthony fouchy was forcing vaccine and mask mandates on the American people for four years during the excuse me for during the covid crisis where were they whenever unelected alandro mayorcas was facilitating the invasion of our country by illegal aliens who were murdering and raping and pillaging our people where were they when the Secretary of Education unelected Cardona targeted States and schools and people who were disagreed with his view of the radical left's transgender ideology where were they whenever Gary gendler former chairman of the SEC also
1:47:11unelected was lawlessly thwarting the development of financial markets particularly in the crypto Space by lawlessly pursuing regulation via enforcement they were no nowhere to be seen because they don't care because all of those things benefited their side of the aisle at the expense of hours and perhaps that's also why they don't seem to be very interested in rooting out improper payments from our federal government if you wonder why so many people are cynical about American politics this is it this is exactly why the reality is that Elon Musk serves as an employee of the the president and we were given a massive mandate to carry out what he's been
1:48:01doing his job is to carry out the will of the American people as expressed through the executive that's exactly how the Constitution is supposed to work the Constitution did not create an unelected unaccountable fourth branch of government in the administrative State the American people know this my colleague Brian Jack discussed some of the opinion polls recently we are doing and president Trump is doing exactly what he is elect he was elected to do and that's why he's polling at a 53% approval rating higher than he was at any point during his first Administration even Elon Musk and his doge efforts now are polling at a 49% approval rating which just to point out
1:48:49is 16 points higher than President Biden was polling at whenever he finished his his term in office the Democrat Party has for decades systematically grown and weaponized the administrative State against the American people and the American people have had enough of it right now we're talking about $2.7 trillion dollar in improper payments since 2003 we are uncovering what could be the biggest money l wering scandal in American history and the other side of the aisle could care less they have no concern about where this money went to what entities it went to what governments to what people or groups nothing all they're all they want to talk about is Elon Musk
1:49:41incessantly so it does make me wonder if they don't care about where it's going do they have an idea because what we've uncovered so far is that so much of the waste Fraud and Abuse of our federal government is actually funding their side of the aisle it's funding media Outlets that are running cover for Democrats routinely the NPR PBS the BBC Politico
1:50:06it's going to fund left-wing NOS that are facilitating the invasion of our country it's going to fund left-wing transgender activism and sex changes all over the globe this is money that's being used taken from the American people and used against their interests if you care about rooting out waste Fraud and Abuse we should be serious about this I'm very excited to be on this committee I'm excited to expose what's been going on thank you madam chair and with that I yield the gentleman yields in closing I want to thank our Witnesses again for their testimonies today I now yield to the ranking member for closing remarks thank you Madame chairwoman well I never
1:50:56thought so many conspiracy theories and wild accusations could be wound into one five minute speech but I appreciate my friends across the aisle first of all let's talk about this massive mandate that supposedly brought Donald Trump into office Donald Trump did not run on putting an unelected billionaire in charge of dismantling the federal government he ran on lowering prices for
1:51:23Americans and I think it's interesting that while we're sitting here this morning the top of the New York Times is reporting that inflation has risen unexpectedly as food and energy prices have sared what's going on guys I thought you were going to tackle inflation in food and energy prices isn't that what the executive orders were supposed to do oh wait or is dismantling diversity equity and inclusion and our federal agencies and putting an ideological agenda and trying to fire the federal Workforce your actual agenda have you been too busy trying to actually address the fiscal health of this country because the numbers are telling us that you have
1:52:09so let's be real about what's going on here I also want to point out that literally while we've been sitting here for the last almost two hours getting lectured on fiscal responsibility literally the Republicans just released their plan to raise the debt limit while we were sitting here and they want to raise it by four trillion dollars okay guys like literally I I'm just like without words inflation is going up you want to raise the debt ceiling by $4 trillion dollar you want to gut Medicare you want to gut Medicaid you're talking about going after Social Security after promising that you wouldn't I mean really what the heck is going on here we're not trying
1:52:58to take down Elon Musk as a businessman this dude is literally breaking the law inside of the federal government and for a party that is supposed to be the party of Law and Order in quotes I really do not see you holding him accountable and doing your most basic constitutional responsibility in the separation of powers so so I want to end where I started we are the oversight committee we are the people's house for the United States of America we represent the American people and so Mr Elon Musk if
1:53:36you would like to appear in front of the oversight committee you have been duly invited please come tell us what you're doing come testify in front of the American people and please come hold yourself to account with that I yield back the general lady yields I now recognize myself for closing remarks president Trump was elected with a mandate to reign in unaccountable bureaucracy in Washington and to wage war on waste I know that because I campaigned alongside him and so did my colleagues this hearing was the first battle of that war and in the coming days the subcommittee will release a report with legislative solutions to the problems we have
1:54:20identified here today we aren't going to wait all the way until the end of this Congress we're going to get to work immediately the bureaucrats who have run Washington for decades are beyond the point of forgiveness their sheer incompetence and pure spite for the hardworking American people have resulted in total failure the federal government has made over $2.7 trillion dollar in improper payments since 2003 including 236
1:54:51billion in 2023 alone those are trillions of dollars that honest Americans have paid in taxes at gunpoint over the years as we approach April 15th Americans are once again preparing to do their taxes and Fork over their unfair share of money it takes to run this country and I have to tell you the American people have not been getting their money's worth for a long time most improper payments in recent years were issued through five programs Medicare Medicaid the Earned Income Tax Credit pandemic unemployment insurance and the paycheck Protection Program but a total of 16 Federal programs had improper payment rates of 10% or more in 2023
1:55:42that includes snap the federal food stamp program which paid out 10 billion taxpayer dollars improperly to get their arms around this problem Elon Musk and the Doge team went straight to the source they went to the treasury Department's fiscal service which makes about 90% of the trillions in federal payments issued annually the audit of these Payment Systems was long overdue treasury secretary Scott bassent gave Doge employees working for the government readon access to these systems so they could conduct that initial audit that audit is already paying dividends must learn that the databases federal agencies are supposed to check to prevent payments to frauders
1:56:31Crime rings and dead people are not being kept up to date going forward we are going to get more mileage out of these do not pay databases that means fewer improper payments and less fraud and waste of taxpayer dollars despite this fraud that's already been revealed a federal judge in New York issued a ruling last Friday that ran totally contrary to the will of the people the judge blocked not only Doge but the treasury secretary himself from accessing his own agency's Payment Systems that's absurd only career Treasury Department unelected bureaucrats can access the system the judge ruled this turns the constitution on its head we will hold this judge and
1:57:20others who try to stop the will of the people and their elected leaders accountable as is written in the Federalist Papers the Judiciary has no influence over either the sword or the purse no Direction either of the strength or the wealth of the society it may truly be said to have neither Force nor will but merely judgment and must ultimately depend upon the aid of the executive arm for the efficacy of its judgments but the whole DC swamp is freaking out that the unelected officials from Doge were allowed access to these systems that makes no sense federal judges were not elected the treasury bureaucrats were not elected and they have failed to fix the problem
1:58:09that is enabling American taxpayers to be robbed so why not bring in skilled out outside experts like private companies and private citizens who are exess who are successful in the real world world to do everyday work that we need to get done here like audits of course Federal payment systems are only one Link in the improper payment chain we need to look at other links in the chain we need better front-end identify verification to screen out frauders and we need to close eligibility loopholes that means not letting applicants self attest to their own eligibility and it means ending categorical eligibility which lets someone who fraudulently
1:58:53qualifies for One Federal benefit automatically get other Federal benefits finally we need to do better coord we need to better coordinate fraud prevention efforts between Federal governments and the states these are all issues that we will be taking a hard look at in this committee and coming up with solutions to including legislation and referrals to Committees of jurisdiction that will deliver for the American people with that and without objection all members have five legislative days within which to submit materials and additional written questions for the witnesses which will be forwarded to the witnesses if there is no further Business Without objection the
1:59:38subcommittee stands adjourned
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版