美国联邦政府雇员办退休,最后一步是把纸质档案送进一个石灰岩矿。
不是隐喻。那座矿 1955 年开始挖,现在存放着所有联邦雇员的退休文书。每份材料手工填写、手工计算,装进马尼拉纸信封,由人搬进矿井。整个流程的瓶颈是矿井电梯的运力:电梯一个月能跑多少趟,决定这个月有多少联邦雇员能退休。电梯坏了,全美国就没人能办退休。
矿里养着大约一千人。
这个故事是马斯克在椭圆形办公室讲的。那天他和特朗普并排坐着,本来要宣布跟"政府效率部"(Department of Government Efficiency,简称 DOGE)有关的一项安排,结果成了一场美国财政漏洞的现场汇报。记者挤在门口提问,特朗普时不时插话,马斯克偶尔被孩子的动静打断。
先定义一下 DOGE 到底想干什么
特朗普开场就把调子定在"欺诈、浪费和滥用"上。他说已经找到了数十亿美元,说自己竞选时承诺过要查这个,"没人知道情况有这么糟、这么病态、这么腐败"。
马斯克给的框架更大。他说 DOGE 的目标是恢复民主。
如果没有人民到政府的反馈回路,如果是官僚在统治,如果人民无法投票、民选代表的意志无法决定事情,那我们就不生活在民主里,我们生活在官僚制里。(马斯克)
他把联邦官僚体系称为"未经选举的、违宪的第四分支",说它手里的权力比任何民选代表都大。他补了一句,联邦官僚里当然有好人,问题不在人,在于这套体系可以自主运转,不对人民负责。
这个说法可以争。但它解释了 DOGE 的行为逻辑:他们不是在做政策,是在试图把一条断掉的线接回去。
开国元勋会怎么看
马斯克还引了一次制宪者。他说如果问开国元勋怎么看今天的结果,答案会是:出现了一个未经选举、也不合宪的第四分支,它掌握的权力超过任何一位民选代表。
这个类比有点浪漫化。制宪者设计的制衡里,行政机构本来就有相当大的裁量空间;1883 年《彭德尔顿法》之后,文官体系还刻意与选举政治保持距离,理由正是防止政权更替把行政能力一起换掉。马斯克把这种距离感称为"自主",把自主称为"违宪",中间跳过了不少制度史。
但他的问题本身站得住:当行政机构大到能决定政策细节,而它对选民的唯一反馈渠道是四年一次的投票,这条线确实松了。
比腐败更紧迫的是利息
马斯克提到的第二个数字更硬:美国每年的财政赤字是 2 万亿美元。
他说如果不处理,国家会破产。让他自己都意外的细节是,国债的利息支出已经超过国防部预算。
我们花了很多钱在国防上,但光是利息就超过了整个国防部预算。如果这样下去,我们实际上会让国家破产。(马斯克)
所以他给这件事的定性是:削减联邦开支算不上一个选项,它关系到美国还能不能作为一个有偿付能力的国家存在下去。这话听起来像夸张,但"利息超过国防预算"这个事实本身不需要夸张。
工资几十万,净资产几千万
特朗普问马斯克,团队到底发现了什么疯数字,还特意提到"那个拿走大约 3000 万美元的女人"。
马斯克的回答带着一种刻意的困惑。他说官僚体系里有不少人,名义工资只有几十万美元,却在任上积累了数千万美元的净资产。USAID 就是个例子。
也许他们很擅长投资,那我们应该听听他们的投资建议。但这看起来像是神秘地变富了。我们不富,他们富,钱从哪来?现实是他们在纳税人的钱上变富,这是实话。(马斯克)
他没有点名,也没有给出具体案卷。这类指控通常需要审计报告支撑,而 DOGE 目前给出的是方向,不是证据链。这一点后面还会回来。
财政部在签发空白支票
真正让马斯克兴奋的是财政部的支付系统。他说那里缺的东西,是任何一家公司都有的基本控制。
具体三条。第一,每笔付款应该有付款分类代码,说明这是什么类型的钱。第二,应该有备注字段,说明这笔钱是干什么的。第三,如果收款方在"禁止付款名单"上,就不该付。
目前这三条一条都不成立。所以各部门通不过审计,因为付款没有分类代码,就像大量空白支票从大楼里飞出去。你没法对空白支票做账。备注字段也是空的,你不知道这笔钱为什么付。(马斯克)
关于"禁止付款名单",他讲得更狠。一个组织要花上一年才能进这个名单,进了名单也不一定用。名单上是什么?恐怖组织、已知诈骗犯、已知的浪费项目、跟国会拨款对不上的支出。
花一年才能上名单,上了名单也不用。这让人无法理解。(马斯克)
他提到五角大楼上一次通过审计大概是十年前。要通过审计,前提是财务信息能追溯每一笔付款。现在追溯不了,因为源头就没记。
为什么烂成这样:投诉最小化
记者没问,但马斯克自己解释了系统为什么会变成这样。这段是整个讲话里最有解释力的一段。
当你明白一切都围绕着"投诉最小化"运转,动机就清楚了。人们收到钱不会投诉,没收到钱会投诉,而骗子投诉得最大声、最快。所以财政部批准所有付款,因为批准所有付款就不会有投诉。(马斯克)
他还原了一个官僚的处境:拒付一笔可疑的钱,可能惹来投诉、律师函、议员电话;照付,什么麻烦都没有。日复一日,系统就长成了现在这样。
DOGE 现在的做法是把这个默认值反过来:如果纳税人的钱花得不合理,我们也会投诉。
马斯克强调这不是激进改革,只是常识。逐笔看支出,问一句这笔钱是否符合人民的最大利益,符合就批,不符合就重新考虑。
150 岁的社保领取人
他举了社保的例子。系统里有 150 岁的人还在领钱。
你认识 150 岁的人吗?我不认识。他们应该进吉尼斯世界纪录,他们错过了。我猜他们大概率已经去世了,要么就是非常出名,两者必居其一。(马斯克)
还有大量社保付款没有身份识别信息。他的表述很克制:应该确保有资格领社保的人能领到,而且要快、要准。问题是没有身份信息的付款,连"有没有资格"都无从判断。
那座矿
然后是开头那个故事。
DOGE 想把联邦官僚体系瘦身。思路很温和:如果人们能带着全额福利退休,那就让他们退休。结果被告知,一个月最多一万人能退休。
原因是一整套纸质流程。退休材料手工计算,写在纸上,然后送进那座石灰岩矿。矿里像 1955 年的时间胶囊,因为它就是 1955 年开始用的。限制产能的不是预算,不是人力,是矿井电梯的速度。
电梯有时候会坏,坏了就没人能退休。这听起来不疯狂吗?大约有一千人在干这个。(马斯克)
他的建议是:这一千人可以去做几乎任何别的事,都比在矿井里搬马尼拉信封更能增加美国的商品和服务产出。
繁荣的底层公式
讲完矿,马斯克给了一个很朴素的经济学框架,也是他给 DOGE 找的最终理由。
怎么提高繁荣?让人们从低生产力甚至负生产力的岗位,转移到高生产力的岗位。这样商品和服务的总产出增加,所有人能享受的生活水平就提高。这才是真正的目标。(马斯克)
这句话把前面所有零碎的案例串起来了。矿井、空白支票、150 岁的社保记录,在他眼里都是同一件事:劳动力被锁在低产出甚至负产出的位置上。
"敌意接管"的指控
记者问得直接:很多批评者,包括不少民主党人,说你是在对政府进行敌意接管,而且过程不透明。
马斯克的回答回到选票。
你找不到比这更强的授权。多数选民投票给特朗普总统,我们赢了众议院,赢了参议院。人们投票支持重大政府改革,这一点毫无疑问。总统在每一场集会上都讲了。人们会得到他们投票支持的东西,这就是民主的全部意义。(马斯克)
这个论证有它的边界。赢了大选,不等于每一项具体操作都获得了授权,也不等于程序问题可以跳过。但马斯克显然认为,改革的方向已经被选票确认过。
利益冲突:把一切摊在阳光下
接下来的问题更尖。白宫说马斯克会识别并回避自己的利益冲突,记者追问:那是不是等于你自己监督自己?有什么制衡?
马斯克的答案是透明度。
我们的所有行动都发在 X 的 DOGE 账号和 DOGE 网站上。我想不出有哪个组织比 DOGE 更透明。透明度建立信任,不是某个人声称自己可信。(马斯克)
记者不放过:你本人从联邦政府拿了数十亿美元合同,比如五角大楼的,总统还让你去查国防部,这算不算冲突?
马斯克说,那得看单份合同。他不是提交合同的人,提交的是 SpaceX 的人。然后他加了一句:
如果你看到任何一份给 SpaceX 的合同,不是对纳税人最划算的,告诉我。因为每一份都是。(马斯克)
这句话很马斯克。它同时也暴露了透明度论证的弱点:公众要判断一份国防合同是不是"最划算",需要的专业能力不比承包商少。
特朗普在旁边补了一句,解释为什么是马斯克:
他是个大商人,很成功,这就是为什么我们想让他做这件事。我们不想要一个不成功的人来做。(特朗普)
这句话的潜台词是,商业成功可以迁移到政府审计。部分成立。查账、砍冗余、逼流程标准化,这些确实是企业里练出来的本事。但政府没有利润这个单一指标,也没有股东会,砍掉一项支出的代价往往在几年后才显现,商业训练未必覆盖这种时间尺度。
三个月的合同,付了二十年
特朗普在这场讲话里贡献的最具体案例,是合同的永动机。
一个人拿到三个月的合同,合同到期了,他们继续付他二十年。因为没人去终止合同。你在正常商业里,三个月合同三个月就结束了。(特朗普)
他把这类现象归成两类原因:无能和腐败。然后倾向于后者。
这里面有大量回扣。因为没人能蠢到给出某些这样的合同,所以一定有回扣。(特朗普)
关于总额,特朗普给了一个跨度很大的估计:已经找到数十亿,最终可能接近一万亿美元。这个数字目前没有公开的明细支撑,属于他的口头预期。
他举了纽约的例子:一家酒店因为安置非法移民拿到 5900 万美元,付的是正常房价的两倍,而且按 100% 入住率算。
他对发现规模的说法是:
我们完全没想到会发现这么多。它不复杂,就是工作量很大,很多非常聪明的人在做。通常你翻一百样东西,能找到一样是好的;这里几乎反过来了,你得去找哪一样是好的。你看标题就会问,我们为什么要做这个?(特朗普)
"反过来了"这个说法很传神。审计的常态是从大量正常支出里挑异常,而他们描述的是从大量异常里挑正常。
把赤字砍半只需要两样东西
有记者问马斯克,把 2 万亿赤字砍到 1 万亿,最关键的两个要素是什么。
他的回答只有两个词:能力和关心。
把能力和关心加在一起,赤字就能砍半。我预计自己会被每天彻底检查一遍,基本上相当于每天做一次直肠镜。所以我不觉得自己能蒙混过关。(马斯克)
第二个杠杆是放松管制。他的说法是,大量法规最终并不服务于公共利益,需要把美国的建设者释放出来。如果做到,经济增长可能到 3%、4%,甚至 5%。
然后是那套算术:如果能带来 1 万亿美元的经济增长,同时把赤字砍掉 1 万亿,2026 年就不会有通胀。政府借得少,利率成本下降,房贷、车贷、信用卡、学生贷款的月供跟着降。
你推着购物车走在超市货架间,今年的价格和去年一样,你的房贷和所有债务月供都在下降。这对普通美国人有多好。(马斯克)
这套推演成立的前提不少:增长真能到那个水平,砍支真能落地,利率真能顺着传导。任何一个环节打折,结论就打折。但它至少给出了一个可以被检验的因果链。
国会那一票
有记者提到参议员兰德·保罗(Rand Paul)的说法:DOGE 的削减最终需要国会投票。特朗普的回答是不知道,但不怕投票。
如果发现欺诈和滥用需要国会投票,我没问题。我觉得我们能拿到票,虽然有些人不会投。为什么法官想拦住我们?为什么连国会也想?如果我们真的需要投票,会很容易通过,因为现在有记录了,我们已经找到数十亿的滥用、无能和腐败。(特朗普)
这里有个宪法层面的实际问题。削减已由国会拨款的支出,行政分支能不能单方面做,是美国法律界正在激烈争论的事。特朗普把它简化成"查账的权利",而批评者说的是"花钱的权力属于国会"。两个说法都对了一半。
他还反复强调公众站在他这边:
公众懂。你看民调,公众在问,我们为什么要付这些钱?这些事持续了很多年。(特朗普)
法官
特朗普对司法阻挠的不满贯穿全场。他说有"活动派法官"想阻止他们查账。
怎么阻止查?我们已经找到了。我真不理解这怎么能行得通。(特朗普)
记者问,如果法官挡住了你的某项政策,你会遵守裁决吗。
我总是遵守法院。然后我会上诉。但他做的是拖慢势头,给不诚实的人更多时间掩盖账目。一个不诚实的人被抓了,其他人看见了,事情就会变得更烫手。(特朗普)
他还给法官出了道题:如果一笔钱明显是腐败的,你是希望我们把它寄出去,还是退给纳税人。
马斯克补了一个角度:很多欺诈的钱根本不是给美国人的。
很多在美国运作、占联邦政府便宜的欺诈团伙,尤其是在福利项目里,实际上是外国团伙,在别的国家运作,把钱出口到别的国家。这必须停止。(马斯克)
他给这类外流的规模估了个数:每年 1000 亿到 2000 亿美元。
那 5000 万美元的避孕套
有记者翻出了马斯克在 X 上的一条帖子:他说有 5000 万美元的避孕套被送往加沙。事实核查后发现,接收方是莫桑比克,项目是防 HIV。
马斯克的回应值得完整引一遍。
首先,我说的有些话会是不准确的,应该被纠正。没有人能百发百中。我们会犯错,但会很快纠正。(马斯克)
然后他补了半句实话:
我不确定我们应该往任何地方送 5000 万美元的避孕套。坦率说,我不确定美国人对这个会很兴奋。那是数量惊人的避孕套。如果去的是莫桑比克而不是加沙,好吧,没那么糟,但还是,我们为什么要做这个?(马斯克)
这段对话是整场讲话里最有信息量的地方之一。它同时展示了两件事:DOGE 的公开数据会出错;出错之后,纠错和"这钱该不该花"是两个不同的问题。前者是事实问题,后者是判断问题,而判断问题不会因为事实纠正就消失。
USAID:性价比和别的账
记者问,USAID 是主要目标之一,关闭它会不会导致其他国家的疾病扩散,最后传回美国。
马斯克说他们跟国务院和国务卿卢比奥紧密合作,已经恢复了对埃博拉预防和 HIV 预防的拨款。然后他承认了节奏问题。
我们行动很快,所以会犯错,但我们也会很快修正错误。(马斯克)
对 USAID 的整体评价,他给了两个词:性价比不高,以及
USAID 做的太多事情,是以可疑的方式影响选举,这些事经不起阳光。(马斯克)
特朗普的版本更直接:USAID 腐败、无能、真的很腐败。他还说接下来要看军队和教育,那是更大的领域。
五角大楼和"你在查你自己"
记者第三次追问利益冲突,这次锁定五角大楼:你拿了数十亿合同,总统让你查国防部,这不是冲突吗。
马斯克的回答前面引过:看单份合同,我不是提交人,SpaceX 的每一份合同都是最优性价比。
他还补了一个流程细节,说明 DOGE 不是自己拍板:
我们跟各机构负责人密切合作,有制衡,不是我们冲进去乱来。我不断跟总统确认,几乎每天都谈,反复确认这是不是总统想要我们做的。(马斯克)
这套说法把决策权归还给了总统和机构负责人,DOGE 更像审计和参谋。至于这个分工在法律上站不站得住,是另一个战场。
财政部到底在查什么
特朗普之前提过要查"treasuries",记者请马斯克解释。他先澄清:指的是财政部,不是国债。
然后他把答案压缩成一句话:第一件事是确保我们真的在收钱,以及钱真的按规矩付出去。分类代码、备注字段、禁止付款名单,三条基本控制。听起来琐碎,但审计通不过、账对不上、死人还在领钱,全都从这三条缺口里长出来。
几十万笔这样的交易。我们有一个很大的团队。(马斯克)
买断和那 48000 人
最后一个问题是关于联邦雇员的买断计划:选择辞职的人能不能保证拿到钱。
特朗普说能,还说这是笔好交易。他给的理由是政府人太多,办公楼只有 4% 的使用率,很多人不来上班是因为被告知不用来。他把这归到拜登头上,说给了 48000 人五年的免上班通行证。
这个数字需要核实,但他说这话时的重点不在数字,在归因:
很多事是拜登的错。他在边境做的,几乎不如他在这些合同上做的糟。(特朗普)
他最后回到那个反复出现的论点:不能想象任何法院会裁定,总统或者他的代表,比如财政部长、国务卿,没有权利去查账、确认一切诚实。
你不能这样经营一家企业,也不能这样经营一个国家。(特朗普)
这场讲话真正说了什么
把它拆开,其实只有三层。
第一层是事实主张:支付系统缺基本控制,禁止付款名单形同虚设,退休流程卡在矿井电梯上,社保系统里有 150 岁的记录。这些是可验证的,也应该被验证。
第二层是规模主张:已经找到数十亿,最终可能接近一万亿,外流欺诈每年 1000 到 2000 亿。这些目前是口头数字,没有对应明细。马斯克自己也承认会说错,会纠正。
第三层是逻辑主张:赤字 2 万亿,利息超过国防预算,不砍开支国家会破产;砍开支加放松管制,能把增长推到 3% 到 5%,2026 年无通胀,利率下行,普通人的月供下降。
三层里,第一层最扎实,第三层最值得讨论,第二层最需要证据。而整场讲话最容易被忽略的一句,是马斯克解释系统成因的那句"投诉最小化"。腐败很少以阴谋的形式出现,它更像一个默认设置:不惹麻烦的人得到奖励,久而久之,空白支票就成了流程。
如果你想自己判断这件事
- 去 X 上的 DOGE 账号和 DOGE 官网看原始条目,别只看二手转述。马斯克说所有行动都公开,那就用公开性去检验公开性。
- 看到"节省了多少亿"这类数字,先问三件事:省的是今年还是未来十年,是取消还是延迟,有没有对应的合同终止文件。
- 看到具体案例(避孕套、150 岁社保、5900 万酒店),先做一次事实核查再下结论。马斯克自己说了会错,也说了会改,这个标准同样适用于他的批评者。
- 关注法院的裁定文本,而不是新闻标题。法官挡的是程序还是实体,是管辖还是授权,差别很大。
- 把"效率"和"合法性"分开打分。一件事可能既真的浪费,又确实需要国会授权才能停。两件事同时成立,不矛盾。
- 对中国读者最有用的一条:这套争论的核心不是马斯克这个人,是任何大型组织都会遇到的同一个问题,当"不投诉"成为考核标准,账目就一定会烂。看看你自己所在的组织,付款有没有分类,支出有没有备注,异常有没有人敢提。
0:00and we're going to be signing a very important deal today it's Doge and I'm going to ask Elon to tell you a little bit about it and some of the things that we found which is shocking billions and billions of dollars in waste Fraud and Abuse and I think it's very important and that's one of the reasons I got elected I said we're going to do that nobody had any idea was that bad that sick and that corrupt and it seems hard to believe that judges to try and stop us from looking for corruption especially when we found hundreds of millions of dollars worth much more than that in just a short period of time we want to weed out the corruption and it seems hard to believe
0:43that a judge could say we don't want you to do that well so maybe we have to look at the judges because that's a very serious I think it's a very serious violation I'll ask Elon Musk to say a few words and we'll take some questions El go ahead sure so the at at a high level if you say what is the goal of do or or and and I think a significant part of this presidency is to restore democracy this may seem seem like well aren't we in a democracy well if you don't have a feedback okay we would have to if you if you sorry tell you gravitas can be difficult sometimes so if if if there's not
1:32a good feedback loop from the people to to the government and if if you have rule of the the bureaucrat if the bureaucracy is in charge and then then what meaning does democracy actually have if the people cannot vote and have their will be decided by their elected representatives in the in the form of the president and and the Senate and the house then we don't live in a democracy we live in a bureaucracy so it's incredibly important that we close that feedback loop we fix that feedback loop and that the public the Public's elected representatives the president the house and the Senate decide what happens as opposed to a large unelected bureaucracy this is not
2:14to say that there aren't some good there are good people who who are in the federal bureaucracy but but you can't have an autonomous Federal bureaucracy you have to have one that is responsive to the people that's the whole point of a democracy and so and if if you looked at the if you asked looked at the founders today and said what do you think of the way things have turned out well what we have this unelected fourth unconstitutional branch of of government which which is the bureaucracy which has in a lot of ways currently more power than any elected representative and this is this is not something that people want and it's it's not it does not match the will
2:56of the people so it's just something we've got to we've got to fix and then we also got to address the the deficit so we've got a $2 trillion deficit and if this if we don't do something about this deficit country is going bankrupt I mean it's it's really astounding that the the interest payments alone on the national debt exceed the defense department budget which is shocking because we got a lot we spend a lot of money on defense but and and if that just keeps going we're essentially going to bankrupt the country so what what I really want to say is like it's not option for us to sit to reduce the federal expenses it's essential it's essential for America to remain solvent
3:37as a country and it's essential for America to have the resources necessary to provide things to its citizens and not simply be servicing vast amounts of debt and also could you mention some of the things that your team has found some of the crazy numbers including the woman that walked away with about 30 million right Etc well we we we are we do find it sort of rather odd that you know there there are quite a few people in in in the bureaucracy who who have a ostensibly a salary of a few hundred, but somehow managed to acrw tens of millions of dollars in net worth while they are in that position which is you know what what happened at usaid
4:20we're just curious as to where it came from maybe they're very good at investing they which case we should take their investment advice perhaps but just this it seems to be mysteriously they they get wealthy we don't why where does it come from and I think the reality is that they're getting wealthy at tax bear expense that's that's the that's the honest truth of it so you know we're looking at say well we
4:47just if you look at say say treasury for example basic controls that should be in place that are in place in in any company such as making sure that any given payment has a payment cap categorization code that there is a comment field that describes the payment and that if it if a payment is on the do not pay list that you don't actually pay it none of those things are true currently so the reason that departments can't pass ords is because the payments don't have a categorization code it's like just a massive number of blank checks just flying out the building so you can't reconcile blank checks you've got comment fields that are also blanks you don't know why the payment
5:26was made and then we've got this a truly abs a do not pay list which can take up to a year for an organization to get on a do not pay list and and this we're talking about terrorist organizations we're talking about known fraudsters known aspects of waste known things that do not match any Congressional appropriation can take up to a year to get on the list and even once on the list the list is not used it's mindblowing so so what we're talking here we're really just talking about adding common sense controls that should be present that that haven't been present so you say like well how could such a thing arise that's that seems that seems crazy that when you
6:10understand that that really everything is geared towards complaint minimization so that that then you understand the motivations so if people receive money they don't complain obviously but if people don't receive money they do complain and and the frauds does complain the loudest and the fastest so then when you understand that then then it makes sense oh that's why everything just they approve all the payments at treasury because if you approve all the payments you don't you don't get complaints but now now we're saying no actually we we all going to complain if if money is spent badly if the if your taxpayer dollars are not spent in a sensible and pral manner then that's not
6:53okay your your tax dollars need to be spent wisely on things that matter to the people I mean these things like it's just common sense it's not it's it's not Draconian or radical I think it's it's really just saying let's look at each each of these expeditures and say is this actually in the best interest of the people and if it is it's proved if if it's not we should think about it so you know there's crazy things
7:21like just Cur re examination of Social Security and we've got people in there that are 150 years old now do you know anyone 150 I don't okay they should be on the Guinness bookal World Records they're missing out so you know that's a case where like I think they're probably dead it's my guess or or they should be very famous one of the two and then that a whole bunch of Social Security payments where there's no identifi identifying information well like why is there no identifying information obviously you want to make we want to make sure that people who deserve to receive Social Security do receive it and that they receive it quickly and accurately I
8:03tell another crazy thing so you know one of the things is like we are trying to sort of rightsize the the federal bureaucracy just make sure that this obviously need there need to be a lot of people working for the federal government but not as many as currently so we're saying well okay well let's if if people can retire you know with full benef benefits and everything that that would be good they can retire get their retirement payments everything and then we were told this is actually I think a great anecdote because we're told no the the most number of people that could retire possibly in a month is 10,000 we're like well why why why is that well
8:35because all the all the retirement paperwork is manual on paper it's manually calculated then written down on a piece of paper then it goes down a mine I'm like what do you mean a mine like yeah there's a limestone mine where we store all the retirement paperwork that look and you look a picture at a picture of this mine we'll post some pictures afterwards and this this mine looks like something out of the 50s because it was started in 1955 so it looks like it's like a Time Warp and then the speed then the limiting factor is the speed at which the mine shaft elevator can move determines how many people can retire from the federal federal government and the elevator breaks down
9:17and then sometimes and then you can't nobody can retire doesn't that sound crazy there's like a thousand people that work on this so I think if we can take those people and say like you know what instead of working in a m shaft and carrying manilla envelopes to you know boxes in a m shaft you could do practically anything else and you you would add to the the goods and services of the United States in a more useful way so anyway so I think you know that's an example at like at a high level if you say like how do we increase Prosperity is we get people to do to to to shift from roles that are low to negative productivity to high productivity roles
10:00and so you increase the total output of goods and services which means that there's a higher standard of living available for everyone that's that's the actual goal everyone's very quiet by the way quiet your detractors Mr musk I what including a lot of Democrats I have detractors you do sir I don't believe it say that you're orchestrating a hostile takeover of government and doing it in a non-transparent way what's your respons to that criticism well first of all
10:33you couldn't ask for a stronger mandate from from the public the public voted you we to have a majority of the public vote voting for president Trump we won the house who won the Senate the people voted for major government reform there should be no doubt about that that was on the campaign the president spoke about that at every rally the people voted for for major government reform and that's what people are going to get they're going to get what they voted for and and a lot of times that you know people that don't get what they voted for but in this presidency they are going to get what they voted for and that's what democracy is all about Mr musk the White House says that
11:17you will identify and excuse yourself from any conflicts of interests that you may have does that mean that you are in effect policing yourself what are the checks and balances that are in place to ensure that there's accountability and transparency no well we actually are trying to be as transparent as possible in fact our actions WE Post our actions to the the Doge handle on X and to the Doge website so all of our actions we are are maximally transparent in fact I don't think there's been I I don't know of a case where where an organization has been more transparent than the Doge organization and and so
11:54you know and the kind of things we're doing are I think very very simple and basic they're not we're you know what I mentioned for for example about treasury just making sure that that payments that go out taxpayer money that goes out is C categorized correctly that the that the the payment is explained that organizations on the do not pay list which are takes a lot to get there that actually are not paid which currently they are paid these These are these are not individual judgment decisions these are about Simply Having sensible checks and balances in the system itself to ensure that taxpayer money is spent well so it's got nothing to do with like say
12:29a contract for some company of fine at all but if there is a conflict of interest when it comes to you yourself for instance you've received billions of dollars and federal contracts when it comes to the Pentagon for instance which the president I know has directed you to look into are you policing yourself in that is there any sort of accountability check and balance in place that would provide any transparency for the American people well all of our actions are are fully public so if you see anything you say like wait a second hey you that doesn't seems like maybe that's you know there's a conflict there I it's s like people are going to be shy about saying that
13:05they'll say it immediately you know incling you yourself yes but it's it transparency is what builds trust not simply somebody asserting trust so not somebody saying they're trustworthy but transparency so you can see everything that's going on and then you can see am I doing something that benefits one of my companies or not it's totally obvious 2 1 on the latest edition of theber business podcast conversation with Max
13:31musk offer to that we watch that also he a big businessman he's a successful guy that's why we want him doing this we don't want a an unsuccessful guy doing this now one thing also that Elon hasn't really mentioned are the groups of people that are getting some of these payments they're ridiculous and we're talking about billions of dollars that we've already found we found fraud and abuse
14:00I would say those two words as opposed to the third word that I usually use but in this case Fraud and Abuse it's abusive because most of these things are virtually made up or certainly money shouldn't be sent to them and you know what I'm talking about it's crazy so but we're talking about
14:20tens of billions of dollars that we've already found and now a judge who's an activist judge wants to try and stop us from doing this why why would they want to do that I campaigned on this I campaigned on the fact that I said government is corrupt and it is very corrupt it's very very it's also foolish as an example a man has a contract for three months and the contract ends but they keep paying them for the next 20 years you know because nobody ends a contract you got a lot of that you have a contract that's three a three-month contract now normally if you're in a small it's in in all fairness it's the size of this thing is so big yeah but if you have have a
15:02contract and you're in a regular business you end the contract in three months you know it's a consultant here's a contract for three months but it goes on for 20 years and the guy doesn't say that he got money for 20 years you know they don't say it they just keep getting checks month after month and you have various things like that and even much worse than that actually much worse and I guess you call that incompetence maybe it could be corruption it could be a deals made on both sides know where you got to get some money he kicks I think he has a lot of Kickback here I see a lot of Kickback here there's a lot of Kickbacks a tremendous Kickback because
15:37nobody could be so stupid to give out some of these contracts so he has to get a kickback so that's what I got elected for that and borders and Military and a lot of things but this is a big part of it and I hope that the court system is going to allow us to do what we have to do we got elected to to among other things f all of this fraud abuse all of this this horrible stuff going on and we've already found billions of dollars not like a little bit billions many billions of dollars and when you get down to it it's going to be probably close to a trillion dollars it could be close to a trillion dollars that we're going to find that will have quite an impact on the budget
16:22and and you'll go to a judge where they handpick a judge and he has certain leanings I'm not knocking anybody for that but he has certain leanings and he wants us to stop looking how do you stop looking I mean we've already found it we have a case in New York where a hotel has paid $59 million 59 million because of because it's housing migrants illegal migrants
16:48all illegal I believe and and they were being paid twice the normal room rate at 100% occupany unbelievable so it's AET I ask a question you if I may sort of just going for the president's comments U at at a at a high level say well what how exact how do what what are the two ingredients that are really necessary in order to cut the budget deficit in half from 2 trillion to 1 trillion and it's really two things competence and caring and if
17:19you add competence and caring you'll cut the budget deficit in half and and and I fully expect to be scrutinized and get you know a daily proctology exam basically my so just camp out there so it's not like I think I can get away with something I'll be scrutinized non-stop and but with support of the president we can we can cut the budget deficit in half from 2 trillion to one and then with deregulation because there's a lot of sort of regulations that don't ultimately serve the public good we need to free free the buers of America to build and if we do that that means I think we can get the economic growth to be maybe 3 4% maybe 5% and that means if you can
18:03get a trillion dollars of economic growth and you cut the the budget deficit by a trillion between now and next year there is no inflation there's no inflation in 26 and if the government is not borrowing as much it means that interest costs decline so everyone's the mortgage their car payment their credit card bills any their student debt the the monthly payments drop that's a fantastic scenario for the average American I mean imagine they're going down the grocery AIS and the prices from one year to the next are the same and they're and they're they you their mortgage all their debt payments dropped how great is that for the average American we had no idea we had no idea
18:51we were going to find this much and it's open it's it's not like complicated it's simple compated a lot of work we can't believe it a lot of work a lot of smart people involved very very smart people but it's you're talking about anywhere maybe 500 billion it's crazy the kind of numbers you're talking about you know normally when you're looking at something you'll find you're looking for one out of a 100 here you're almost reversing it you look for one that's good yeah and you can look at the title and you say why are we doing this why are we doing that and the public gets it you know the public gets it you've seen the polls the public is saying why are we paying all this money
19:30this for years this has gone on yeah go ahead wait go ahead Senator Rand Paul today said that Doge Cuts will ultimately need a vote in Congress do you agree with that is that the plan I really don't know I I know this we're finding tremendous fraud and tremendous abuse if I need a vote of Congress to find Fraud and Abuse it be it's find with me I think we'll get the vote although there'll be some people that wouldn't vote and how could a judge want to hold us back from finding all of this fraud and finding all of this incompetence why would that happen why would even Congress want to do that now Congress if if we do need a vote I think we'd get a very easy vote because we
20:11have a track record now we've already found billions of dollars of abuse incompetence and Corruption a lot of corruption if a judge does block one of your policies part of your agenda will you abide by that ruling will you comp I always abide by the courts and then I'll have to feel it but then what he's done is he slowed down the momentum and it gives crooked people more time to cover up the books you know if a person's crooked and they get caught other people see that and all of a sudden it becomes hotter later on so yeah the answer is I always abide by the courts always abide by him and will appeal but appeals take a long time and I would hope that a
20:53judge if you go into a judge and you show him here's a corrupt situation we have a check to be sent but we found it to be corrupt do you want us to send this corrupt check to a person or do you want us not to give it and give it back to the taxpayer I would hope a judge would say don't send it give it back to the taxpayer yeah if I can add to that what we're finding is that a bunch of the fraud is not even going to Americans so I think we can all agree that if there's going to be fraud it should at least go to Americans but a bunch of the fraud rings that are operating in the United States and taking advantage of the federal government especially in
21:27the entitlements programs are actually foreign for rinks they're operating in other countries and actually exporting money to other countries we should stop that Mr and this is big big numbers talk about1 to $200 billion a year sure serious money U Mr musk you said on X that an example of the fraud that you have cited was $50 million of condoms was sent to Gaza but after fact check this it apparently Gaza in mosm Beek and the program was to protect them against HIV so can you correct this statement it wasn't sent to Hamas actually it was sent to mozambik which makes sense why condoms was send there and how can make we make sure that all the statements that you said were
22:12correct so we can trust what you say well first of all some of the things that I say will be incorrect and and should be corrected so nobody's going to bat a thousand I mean any you know we will make mistakes but we'll act quickly to correct any mistakes so you know if if the I'm not sure we should be sending $50 million with the condoms to anywhere frankly I'm not sure that's something Americans would be really excited about and that that is really an enormous number of condoms you think about it but you know if it if it went to MOS Beque instead of Gaza I'm like okay that's not as bad but still you know why are we doing that thanks much can you talk a little bit about how
22:50closely you're working with agency heads as you're directing these Cuts do they have the how much input do agency have have when you're making these decisions yeah we work closely with the agency heads and yeah so so there there is there are sort of checks in place so it's not us just going in and doing things willy-nilly it's it's in partnership with the agency heads and and I checked prevently with the president to make sure that you know the this this is what the president wants to have happen so you know we talk almost every day and I I you know I I double check things to make sure is this something Mr President you want us to do this we'll we'll then we'll do it USA
23:31USA ID has been one of your main targets are you concerned at all that some of the cuts or that shutting that agency alt together may lead to diseases or other bigger problems starting in other countries that then come to to the United States yeah so that's that's an interesting example so that's something where we work closely with the state department and secretary ruio and we have for example turned on funding for Ebola prevention and for HIV PR prevention left that you said yes correct and and and we are we are moving fast so we will make mistakes but we'll also fix the mistakes very quickly so you see as a worthy cause usaid I I think that there's some worthy
24:13things but but overall if you say what was the bank for the buck I would say it's it was not very good and there was far too much of what US idea was doing was influencing influencing elections in ways that I think were dubious and do not stand at the light of day I just have to follow up to the the Pentagon contracts if you had received billions of dollars in contracts from the Pentagon and the president's directing you to look into the Department of Defense is that are going to do at the president's request does that present a conflict of interest for you no because you'd have to look at the individual contract and say first of all I'm not the one you know filing the
24:51contract it's people at SpaceX or something will be putting for the contract and I'd like to say if if you see any contract where the the where it was awarded to SpaceX and it wasn't by far the best value for money for the taxpayer let me know because every one of them was the president said the other day that you might look at treasuries could you explain that a little bit what kind of fraud or and that question goes to both of you what kind of fraud are you expecting to see or do you see right now in US treasuries yeah I I think you mean the treasury Department as opposed to treasury bills or you also referenced treasuries on Air Force One
25:26the other night well the as I mentioned earlier really the the first order of business is to make sure we're actually collecting sorry for this I thought my son might might enjoy this but it's he's sticking his fingers in my ears and stuff it's bit hot to hear sometimes hey sop that so no
25:47the stuff we're doing with with treasure department is so basic that you can't believe it doesn't exist already so so so for example like I mentioned just making sure that that when a payment goes out it has to have the payment categorization code it's like what type of payment is this you can't just leave the field blank currently many payments the field is left blank and you have to describe what's the payment for some basic rationalization that also is left blank so this is why you know the Pentagon when's the last time the Pentagon passed an udit I mean a decade ago maybe I ever really and we want
26:24to just in order to actually pass audits you have to have Financial information that allows you to trace the payments so you know and and once in a while the the treasury has to has to pause payments if it thinks the payment is going to a fraudulent organization like if if if a if a company or organization is on a do not pay list we should not pay it I'm sure you would agree like if it's quite hard to get on that payment doal pay list it means that this is someone that is is like dead people terrorists known fraudsters that kind of thing we should not pay them but currently we do which is crazy we should stop that many many transactions and by the way
27:14hundreds thousands of transactions like that you know we have a big team and for the sake of the country I hope that the person that's in charge and the other people that report to me that are in charge are allowed to do the right thing namely make sure everything's honest legitimate and competent but we're looking at just when you look at usaid that was that's one we're going to look at the military we're going to look at education they're much bigger areas but the US Aid is really corrupt I'll tell you it's corrupt it's incompetent and it's really corrupt and I can't imagine a judge saying well it may be corrupt but you don't have the right you got elected to
27:57look over the country and to as we say make America great again but you don't have the right to go and look and see whether or not things are right that they're paying or that things are honest that they're paying and nobody can even believe this other people law professors they've been saying can't how can you take that person's right away You're supposed to be running the country but we're not allowed to look at who they're paying it to and what they're paying we have massive amounts of fraud that we caught I think we probably caught way over a lot of billions of dollars already in what two weeks yes and it's going to go to numbers that you're not going to
28:35believe and much as I said much is incompetence and much is dishonesty we have to catch it and the only way going to catch it is to look for it and if a judge is going to say you're not allowed to look for it that's pretty sad for our country I don't understand how it could even work program can you personally guarantee that the buyout program the operative federal workers can you personally guarantee that the workers who opt in to resign now will be paid through SE they'll get their money but they're getting a good deal they're getting a big buyout and what we're trying to do is reduce government we have too many people we have office space it's
29:10occupied by 4% nobody's showing up to work because they were told not to and then Biden gave them a five-year pass some of them 48,000 of them gave them a fiveyear pass that for five years you don't have to show up to work and and let me tell you this is largely much of the stuff is because of Biden it's his fault he allowed this country what he did on our border what he did on our border is almost not as bad as what he did with all of these contracts that have come out it it's it's a very sad day when we look at it I can't even believe it but many contracts just extend and they just keep extending and there was nobody there to correct it and
29:51that cannot be I can't imagine that could be held up by the court any court that would say that the president or for his Representatives like Secretary of the Treasury Secretary of State whatever doesn't have the right to go over their books and make sure everything's honest I mean how can you have a country you can't have anything that way you can't have a business that way you can't have a country that way thank you very much everybody thank [Applause] you back tonight will be at the White House tonight at about 10:00 if you want to come over you can say hello to him anything in return
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版