查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚(Chamath Palihapitiya)家里没有屏幕时间这回事。
三个孩子,那年八岁、七岁、五岁。没有 iPad,没有电脑,电影偶尔看一点。孩子天天问,因为同学都有。
这个人是谁?Social Capital 创始人,管着 25 亿美元以上的资产,9 月在纽交所上了一只 SPAC。更早的时候,他在 Facebook 内部,是把用户规模做起来的那批人里排得很靠前的一个。
一个靠社交网络把用户从零做到几亿的人,回家把屏幕全关了。这中间的逻辑,比任何一条关于「科技公司该不该被监管」的新闻都值得掰开看。
他在斯坦福说的那番话,被压成了一条针对 Facebook 的标题
事情的起因是斯坦福的一场演讲。院长请他去给 MBA 学生讲,题目是社交媒体的长期影响。
他当时的原话大意是:今天被造出来的这些工具,正在侵蚀社会运转所依赖的那层结构。
然后这条讲话在几个月里炸了。他后来说,麻烦在于大家很自然地把这段话读成「一个前 Facebook 高管在骂 Facebook」,因为他确实在那儿干过,而且干的是增长。
他真正想说的是另一件事。
「我们活在一个很容易把真相和流行搞混的世界里。你可以用钱去放大你相信的任何东西,然后让人们相信流行的那个就是真实的,不流行的那个就可能不是真实的。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他举了自己和主持人乔的例子。两个人在气候议题上立场长期相反。现在他有钱,他可以通过这一整套社交媒体系统触达几亿人,用非常细微的方式,让乔的所有朋友、所有和乔相似的人,慢慢接受他的看法。乔也可以对他做同样的事。
疫苗可以这么打,同性恋权利可以这么打,洗手间法案可以这么打,伊斯兰恐惧症也可以这么打。任何一个还没有形成社会共识的议题,都可以被这套机制提前定价。
他抛出的问题落在操作层面,跟道德判断无关:我们怎么在一个「这件事已经变得可能」的世界里生活。
多巴胺那部分,他用了一个很具体的场景
主持人把他的话拆成两条线,一条是花钱操纵别人的想法,另一条是点赞驱动的社会里那个像毒品一样的反馈回路。第二条他接得很干脆。
所有这些系统,没有一个例外,都在利用人类想要反馈的天性。化学层面就是多巴胺释放。Call of Duty 是这样,别的电子游戏是这样,社交网站也是这样。它们让你反应,让你再来一次。
问题出在耐受度上。你要是被过度脱敏,需要一次又一次、越来越频繁地获得那个反馈,最后会发生的事是你和你生活的世界脱开了。人坐在屏幕前面,表情变得麻木,说话变得粗糙,但那个说话的人其实已经不在场了。
为了说明这一点,他讲了个自己的故事。
他和亚当·贝恩(Adam Bain,前 Twitter 首席运营官)去看尼克斯的球,场边座位,位置好得不能再好。两个人拍了照,然后花了十五分钟挑滤镜。
「如果亚当·贝恩和我都卡在那儿,就为了决定用哪个滤镜,因为我们太渴望那个反应了,那其他人得是什么状态?是不是别人也在那一刻感到我感受到的那种空洞?」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
那十五分钟里,球赛在场上进行,他们两个没在看。
他自己也在改行为。进办公室第一件事是把手机扣着放,因为不扣着,邮件通知、股价提醒会一直往脑子里钻。他说他甚至记得有一次忘带手机,站在某个队伍里,每隔两分钟就有一次信号从潜意识里冒出来,提醒他缺了什么。那种「幻痛」,手机明明不在身上,还是会觉得刚才好像有消息进来。
他说这大概是化学机制在起作用。电子游戏是这样,电视是这样,音乐也是这样。手机只是最新的一种载体。
他对 Facebook 的评价,比批评更难听
主持人的追问很尖锐:Facebook 刚宣布要给 7 到 13 岁的孩子做一个 App。你自己说这东西是多巴胺,现在要把它接给七岁的小孩,这说得过去吗?
他的回答分两层。
第一层是给 Facebook 说话的。在他近距离看过的所有公司里,Facebook 是最会运营的,技术上也是最成熟的,在修这个问题上,做得比任何一家都多。他还补了一句更重的:我欠那些人一切,我今天坐在这把椅子上,是因为我参与了一家做了很了不起的事情的公司。他说那些人看到他这段话,可能觉得他没做对得起他们的事,他为此感到抱歉。
但他不收回。
「我不会把我说过的话收回来,因为在最基本的层面上,我们必须开始谈这些东西。为什么我们青少年的焦虑和抑郁比以往任何时候都高?这个世界明明更安全、更有建设性、你本该能接触到一切。到底发生了什么?」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
第二层是往回推的。他说我们从来没有退后一步问过,七年了,我们到底该怎么和这些东西相处,我们对整个互联网该有什么期待。
他给了一个更狠的判断:整个互联网的商业模式,可能从根本上就是有问题的。因为我们允许自己被以自己控制不了媒介、也控制不了信使的方式去互动,而且我们没给自己设任何屏障,没给自己留任何停机时间。
所以他给出的方向也落在集体层面:个人要想,公司要想,政府也要想,得有一些不一样的商业模式被发明出来,让人能从里面脱身。
孩子什么时候能有手机:等他找到工作
主持人问他,那你九岁的孩子什么时候能有屏幕?
答案很干脆:等他找到工作。我十四岁在汉堡王打工,等他自己挣够钱买那部手机,他想怎么用就怎么用。在那之前,我负责给他吃饭、给他衣服、给他住处、送他上学,就这些。
他解释这套逻辑的时候,说的是「共生依赖」这个词。
「我不喜欢这种依赖,他们离不开我,我一旦腾不出手就塞给他们一个设备,那设备就成了保姆。你出去想办法,去外面跑,摔破膝盖,摔在地上,去打场球,输一场,然后回来找我聊。我们像理性的人一样聊,我尽量告诉你刚才那件事为什么对你是好事。而不是我手头有别的事,所以给你一个屏幕。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他也承认这套做法不一定适合所有人。他说的是「这是我做的清醒选择」,他真正想传递的是那个词:清醒。选择本身可以不一样,但你得是在清醒状态下做的。
聊到这部分时,主持人提到肖恩·帕克(Sean Parker)几周前也说过类似的话,说社交网络在利用人性的漏洞。查马斯说他看到那条新闻的时候,自己那段话已经讲出去一个月了,本来只是当时在想什么就说什么,没想到后来整个事情完全失控。
比特币:一百多美元的成本,曾经持有全网近 5%
话题转到比特币,他先让演播室的人难受了一下。
2012 年有人介绍他认识这个东西,他花了十八个月才搞懂。他自己说「我算有点技术背景」,言下之意是这件事的门槛比外面看起来高得多。2013 年开始买。
成本是多少?他犹豫了一下,说了:平均下来一百多美元一枚。
他和另外两个人(其中一个不愿意透露姓名)在那段时间里,一度持有全网接近 5% 的比特币。后来卖了。「我希望我们全留着,但没有,没关系。」
2013 年他写了篇文章,核心逻辑是不对称上行。当时一枚大概一百美元,他估的上行空间是黄金的总市值。下跌空间很小,上行很大。他的建议是拿净资产的 1% 去买这个「傻瓜保险」(schmuck insurance,意思是万一整个体系出问题,这份保险能救命)。
然后他自己给这个说法打了个补丁。
「现在这是一场信心游戏(confidence game),它没有真正的实用价值。但它是对专制政权、对我们知道正在腐蚀世界正常运转的那套银行基础设施的绝佳的根本性对冲。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他接着把话说完:你不能让央行无限印钞,你不能让一群人带着跑偏的货币政策和财政政策去做决定。所以有能力把风险对冲出去,而且是用一种和「做那些决定的人、以及那套基础设施」根本不相关的方式对冲出去,这件事本身很聪明。
主持人当场抓住了「信心游戏」这个词。他的回应是把时间轴拉长:这本书我们才看了前几章,接下来要经历一次大的流动性回收,我们看看会发生什么。
三到四年十万美元,二十年一百万美元
主持人问,如果这班车已经开走了呢?
他说,和 2013 年一样,拿净资产的 1% 投进去。然后加了一句预测。
「我今天把话放在这儿,这个东西三到四年内大概是十万美元一枚,二十年内是一百万美元一枚。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
这段访谈发生在 2018 年初,当时比特币在一万美元上下。三年多之后的 2021 年,它最高摸到接近七万美元,离十万还有距离。这算不上对他判断的否定,只是提醒一件事:这类预测真正值钱的部分在配置逻辑,那个数字本身没那么重要。
主持人追问得更实际:一个普通散户,手里有点钱,该放进 401k 还是买比特币?
他的回答没有做二选一。99% 买标普 500 指数基金,1% 买比特币。一百美元里投一美元。
「那一美元之所以值钱,是因为它和另外那 99 美元从根本上不相关。万一管着那 99 美元的那些人并不完全知道自己在干什么,那一美元可能真的能救所有人。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他补充说自己的 IRA 里就持有相当数量的比特币,税优账户是可以买的。
主持人抛出 2008 年的教训:那时候大家也以为不同资产之间的相关性有差异,危机一来,所有相关性都变成了 1。你怎么知道比特币的相关性是什么?
他的回答很干脆,也很诚实:这是一串在电脑上生成的字母和数字,存在一个安全钱包里。它和现实世界的功能效用真的不相关,它是一个想法,一套信念系统,这可能让一些人害怕。相关性由谁持有它、相对他另外那些资产来决定。
泡沫的问题他也回答了。市场总共才几百亿美元,把一个还在几十亿美元量级的市场叫「市场」就已经不太公平,说它是投机泡沫更勉强。更可能的情况是,绝大多数人根本不知道比特币是什么,一小撮人在边上围观、发表意见,但从没费心读过定义,没打开过钱包,没读过维基百科条目,却想把它塞进一个自己熟悉的框架里,因为那样安全。
他说他自己 2012 年也是这么过来的,花了十八个月才把成见放下。他的建议是,别人如果愿意花同样的时间,可能会得出一个和「显而易见的悲观结论」完全不同的答案。
亚马逊不是市场垄断,是「自然产品垄断」
他之前在一个场合说过亚马逊是垄断,被主持人逮住了。他澄清了自己的定义。
他想说的是「自然产品垄断」(natural product monopoly)。你造了一个东西,它开始管用,使用方式会告诉你一条面包屑的轨迹,你顺着这条轨迹走,下一步会比上一步稍微容易一点,再下一步再容易一点。
证据是那年的 re:Invent,亚马逊的开发者大会。五六万人涌进拉斯维加斯,爆满了好几个赌场、好几个大宴会厅,很多人飞过去只是为了在场。
一年之内发布的关键功能,数量多到单独看每一个都不算什么,全部加起来的时候,你会愣一下:这些是一年做的?以这个速度、这个规模、这个影响力做的?
而且这些功能大概抹掉了 20 亿美元的股权价值。那是 VC 投在一些「本来就没什么道理」的想法上的钱,因为那些人想抢在亚马逊前面,却没想清楚亚马逊一旦进场意味着什么。
「我脑子里的自然产品垄断就是这个意思。它每天都比昨天稍微快一点。它完全不是市场垄断,因为有别的选择,有 Google,有微软,在中国有阿里巴巴。但在我看来它就是会一直跑下去,每年便宜一点、完整一点、你能拿到的东西多一点。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
主持人把特朗普的民粹角度摆上来:大就是太大,不能让这么多权力集中在少数人手里,而且被点名的不会只是亚马逊,是整个硅谷。
他的回应是替亚马逊摆事实:现在雇了五十多万人,雇的退伍军人比一些公司的总员工还多,第二总部大概率会落在红州或紫州,德州、密歇根都在名单上。从企业责任这个维度看,他们做得不错。
然后他自己把话题扩大了。
科技公司当年拿到的那张空白支票,到期了
他讲了一段行业史。1999 年他报道互联网的时候,共识是不能对互联网征税,因为大家想让这些公司先跑起来。这些公司当时提出的主张是:我们不一样,所以我们能自我监管。
这张支票兑现了很久。现在人们醒过来了:凭什么有特殊豁免?所有生意都该被同样对待,不管你是怎么做的。所以未来这些行业的政府介入,大概率是更多而不是更少。
他的建议是主动接受,然后往更聪明的方向走。
「当你的商业模式能产生 60%、70%、80% 的利润,只赚 55% 是可以的,多雇两万五千人也是可以的。尤其当你是在试图避开那些能把你掐死的监管,或者你真心想解决那个你本能感到不对的不平等问题。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他说这也是 Social Capital 给自己定的标准之一:到 2045 年,旗下企业要雇佣一千万人。他把这个数字当成一个信号,用来表明「充分就业的另一种版本是必要的」这件事。
主持人替贝索斯说了句话:如果杰夫坐在这儿,他会说进步就是把包裹更快更便宜送到你手上,如果能让人不用去搬箱子、走街,那些工作我们很乐意升级成别的事情,那才是进步。
他说他同意前两条,第三条不确定。然后他搬出了巴菲特讲得最清楚的那个类比。
巴菲特那个 1917 对 2017 的类比,说的是拖拉机救不了人
1917 年的美国是农业经济,然后拖拉机来了。
拖拉机本身没有说「我来当你的救世主」。把人从土地上替换掉的是技术,接住那些人的是另外一些东西:政府、社会基础设施、通往教育的路、退伍军人法案(GI Bill),是这一整套东西让人在一个不一样的事情上重新找回自我和身份。
他相信贝索斯这类深思熟虑、体面的 CEO,会愿意为了带更多人一起走,主动牺牲一点效率,哪怕这意味着利润率少几个点。
这话说起来容易。主持人提醒他,跟股东讲这套很难,沃尔玛宣布提高最低工资的时候,市场反应也是这样。他的态度是:难,但并不是做不到,而且越早做越主动。
英伟达的好日子,和英特尔正在变成富士康
Social Capital 的公开市场业务做 alpha short,不收管理费,只从后端利润里分成,所以他们一直在找那些方向错了、资本错配了、或者刚滑过雪尖的公司。
他觉得机器学习、AI 这块能挖到有意思的标的,但要放长眼光。
原因在于买家结构变了。超级规模玩家(hyper scalars)都在自己滚芯片:Facebook、Google、微软、亚马逊,中国是百度、阿里巴巴、腾讯。Google 有自己的 TPU,在搞 FPGA,亚马逊刚把裸金属层面的算力访问开放出来。
英伟达当时 200 美元一股,市值 1200 亿美元,是家好公司。但三四年后 AI 真正上规模的时候,任务在哪里跑?可以确定的是,那不会是一个单一供应商的环境。这些巨头需要尽可能完整地把 AI 握在自己手里,他们不会走过去说「你就按你喜欢的利润率卖给我吧」。
英特尔会经历什么,他打了个比方。这些巨头把英特尔拉进房间:我是亚马逊,我有这么多需求;我是 Google,我有这么多需求;我是 Facebook,我是百度。这是我愿意付的价格,你选。不选我就去上 ARM 架构,或者自己滚一个。
结果是大量产能和大量能力,英特尔消化不了。长期看,英特尔会变成别人的代工厂,像富士康。从一个 15 到 20 年的趋势看,这算不上好生意。
主持人不服:他们就不能多招些研发的人,搞出新东西吗?
他的回答是:等这些新东西做出来,已经有一批像我们这样的投资人能一路投到底。他手上有几十亿美元可以部署到 Groq 上,让它变成一个长期存活的上市公司。Groq 的芯片设计是革命性的,性能好一个数量级。
主持人追问得更狠:如果亚马逊这类公司能决定英特尔这样的供应商能不能活,那它们怎么不是垄断?
他纠正了问题本身:我们争的是市值,存活与否不在讨论范围内。英特尔会继续盈利,会继续很大,只是回不到原来的位置。英伟达也会被重新估值。这是必然的。
特斯拉:买可转债,别碰裸股
他们大幅做多特斯拉的可转债。
理由是他对这一代创业者的判断:
「押注埃隆·马斯克,最安全、最确定的方式就是这个,我根本上认为他是我们这一代最重要的创业者。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
为什么不买股票?因为股权代表巨大的波动。他得对自己和合伙人的本金负责,想要的是一个能拿到 95% 上行、零下行的机制。可转债正好给了这个机制,不用他去当风险牛仔,去证明一件本来不必证明的事。
他们买入时的价格大约 87,到期收益率 5%,现在收益率已经接近零。主持人问接近零你还买吗,他说买,因为你拿到了下行保护。
主持人问,如果马斯克愿意卖一点 Boring Company 的股份呢?他立刻说买,这家公司非常有意思。
「这个人我认识很久了,他真的把每一块钱都押在自己嘴上说的话上。他在试着把人类变成星际物种,把出行从石油里解出来,减少交通拥堵。所以我不理解为什么有人跑出来说这家公司是骗局。这个人身上没有欺诈,这项技术上没有欺诈。这就是有人想要在失败上跳舞,我不理解。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
主持人把吉姆·查诺斯(Jim Chanos)那类质疑摆上来:他每次给出销量预期,很少甚至从来没有达到过,看起来是习惯性让人失望,而且常常是拿着这些宏大预测去融资,然后不达标。
他的回应没有绕:
「造革命性的东西很难。你不是走进去就发明了 iPhone,那里有复杂性。你不是走进去就发明了 Facebook,有巨大的复杂性。你得用年份来想这件事。虽然我们逼着这样的公司按季度来汇报,但那不管用。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
这段话既是替马斯克说的,也是替所有造硬东西的人说的。按季度考核一家正在造新品类公司的进度,衡量出来的东西和行为本身基本无关。
国歌跪地:他先作为一个有色人种回答
他是金州勇士队的共同所有人。主持人问 NFL 的跪地抗议,他先提了个请求:在作为老板回答之前,能不能先作为一个有色人种回答。
他自己开车被警察拦过,就因为在开车。他不觉得那是哪个警察的错,那就是我们生活的环境的一部分。他上飞机时知道有人不舒服,因为对方的第一反应是「飞机上有个棕色皮肤、留胡子的家伙」。他感受过那个。
所以各种人都会在日常生活里感受到不同版本的这类东西。当其中一些人想把它反映出来,然后展开对话,第一件该做的事是退一步,问他们从哪儿来,然后再问这里是不是合适的地方、该怎么做。
他认为亚当·萧华(Adam Silver)做得非常好,NBA 的球员很了不起,因为他们有观点、他们相信,他也同意他们,他们赢得了开启一场对话的权利。他看着勒布朗、克里斯·保罗、库里做的事。
「你把 52 个裹着金属的人放在场上互相撞,然后把它货币化成一家几百亿美元的企业。这些人是整个体系的核心。如果他们想反映世界上真实存在的某些挫败感,这些是真实存在的事情,你必须让讨论发生。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
主持人给了个台阶:能不能不政治化,不要在全国国歌时做,免得疏远一部分球迷?
他说,大概可以。如果一开始就把所有人聚到一起谈,这件事就不会变得这么撕裂、这么两极化。麻烦在于我们生活的这个世界,一旦吵起来,每个人都被逼到自己的角落,谁也退不回来。老板退不回来,球员也退不回来,然后就会出现那种奇怪的折中方案,比如只在国歌时不出场,或者干脆待在更衣室里。
他把这和他早上讲的那套接上了:我们处在一个不同的时代,本来可以用不同的方式把事情解决掉,但现在的机制不是为此设置的。
卡佩尼克:结果是一样的,那就够了
主持人问,你觉得他被老板们联合封杀了吗?
「这事还不明显吗?这个人从一个非常、非常合格的球员,变成一个大概还算合格的替补,然后他就再也拿不到工作了。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
主持人替联盟说话:也可能不是有组织的封杀,就是每个老板都在想,等等,我不想把这个争议带进我家。
他接受了这个修正:可能没有那么有组织,可能没有一个 WhatsApp 群在协调怎么干这件事。但他把落点放回结果上:一个正当的人,有可信的运动能力,在某个时点是联盟前三前四的四分卫,大概还有能发挥的作用,但他再也拿不到那份工作了。很清楚。
会不会有老板下赛季赌一把?他说不知道。
然后他补了一句题外话:说实话,橄榄球他四年没看了。看不下去这些人互相撞,这项运动让他烦,太慢。他爱篮球,球队很棒,人很棒,管得很好,NBA 万岁。
苹果正在变成一家奢侈品公司
他之前说过苹果不再是科技公司,后来把这个说法修了一点:他认为苹果正在迁移成一家很有意思的软件公司,加一家奢侈品公司。它在琢磨怎么驾驭这个转变,怎么管品牌,怎么卖一千美元一台、有某些特定能力的设备。
「当你退一步,真的去看那台手机,和 Pixel 或者三星下一代比,坦白说产品是一样的。它有的是品牌,是一种区隔感,这和路易威登或者任何别的奢侈品没有区别:你愿意为它付溢价,而如果去看实际用到的原材料,那个溢价大概撑不住成本。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
所以苹果要做一次很有意思的转型:怎么让更多 iPhone X 落地,让像我们这样的人愿意付一千美元。那剩下的是什么?剩下的市场会被小米、三星这类公司在低端进一步整合。
主持人说它大概会是万亿美元公司。他说会,但那也就是在现在基础上再涨 12% 到 15%。真正的问题是:这么多钱、这么大的规模,你拿它干什么。
如果海外现金回流,该买什么?他的答案很具体:特斯拉、Netflix。这两家是有巨大运营杠杆的生意,苹果应该拥有它们。
他对苹果的一个观察是:那座新园区花的钱,比任何一次重大产品发布、任何重大功能都多。他把这理解成一个信号,说明公司正处在一个需要代际交接的时刻,需要让和乔布斯遗产距离更远一点的人接手这些生意。然后你要么看到它沉下去,要么看到它像火箭一样完全爆发。
主持人最后问,怎么评价蒂姆·库克的领导力?
「我认为他是个很好的管家。但他像一个旁观者那样在经营,不想因为不小心贬损 Steve 的遗产而把边界推得太远。」(查马斯·帕里哈皮蒂亚)
他拿微软类比:鲍尔默尽力了,情况不同,然后需要交接给另一个人。他特意说,别去看股价、市值、过去这些年的营收,那些他都不否认。他要问的是另一件事:有没有出现过有远见的产品领导力。他的判断是,苹果做的是把一份交到手上的生意,管得很好。
把这场访谈浓缩成能用的东西
- 给自己的手机设一道物理屏障。进办公室扣着放,关掉所有非人类发来的通知。你自己都扛不住的东西,别指望孩子扛得住。他忘带手机时每两分钟一次的「幻痛」,就是这套系统在你身上起作用的证据。
- 孩子的第一部手机,让他自己挣钱买。在那之前你负责吃住和学费,不负责多巴胺。抄他的做法未必合适,但把「要不要给」这件事当成一个要主动做的决定,这一层可以照搬。给设备之前先问自己一句:这么做图的是教育,还是给自己腾时间?
- 做比特币这类配置,用 1% 的框架去想,剩下 99% 放在宽基指数里。他把「401k 还是比特币」这个问题拆掉了,那是个假问题。他真正在卖的是一句提醒:管着那 99% 的人,不一定完全知道自己在干什么。
- 判断一家公司是不是「自然产品垄断」,别只看市场份额,看它下一步是不是比上一步容易。re:Invent 那五六万人和一年内堆出来的功能清单,比任何一份研报都直观。
- 面对一个连续多年不达预期的创始人,先分清是执行烂,还是事情本身就难。可转债这类工具的价值在于,让你在判断对的时候吃到大部分上行,判断错的时候不死。这个思路可以平移到任何高波动标的。
- 公共议题上,先问「他从哪来」,再问「这是不是合适的地方」。顺序反了,就只剩站队,谁也退不回来。他在国歌争议里给的正是这个顺序。
- 别把「产品差不多、卖得更贵」当成贬义。品牌是真实资产,路易威登卖了上百年。但你要清楚自己买的是品牌,然后按品牌的逻辑去判断它还能撑多久。
0:00want to bring in our guest hosts this morning to mouth Polly hoppity is the founder of social capital which manages more than 2.5 billion dollars in assets he also launched a blank cheque public company it's been trading on the New York Stock Exchange in September maybe can give us some hints about what that SPAC wants to buy mouth I was also the part owner of the Golden State Warriors and we're thrilled to have him here travels with an entourage and we have a whole team of people here this morning hi over there it takes a village takes a village if you got a wardrobe consultant from the Sorkin collection this is from these photo to the Month Club as you
0:34correctly there we go what about what's backing from Jamaa for a sort of but what do you think sweater line got like a trunk club situation it's it I think it's a great accessory under use no but look we have the whole we're affix ready to go so we're thinking of selling a sweater every month I love it we'll just send it out in a box I would buy it what would you pay anywhere between 50 and $500
1:03so we have a lot to talk about and unpack as people like to say in the news business talking about this I want to talk Bitcoin and then we should probably first start with this so because you made a lot of headlines or lose I know you you you made this comment just a couple a couple of weeks ago but it was viral now yeah your thoughts I've heard it it's viral no no they just appeared in some of the blog's another thing might have nipple days you made some critical truly critical comments about Facebook really up ending children and our society and it would let me let me set the context so the context was I was I was at Stanford and the Dean asked me to speak to the MBA
1:43students and in it what I was talking about was the question was you know what do you think the long-term effects of social media in general are and unfortunately what happened was I think it's easy to characterize what I said just as a space book Facebook specific thing because I worked there and I was a key part of growing it the the the reality of what I would explain what you said at the time all I said was I think the tools that have been created today are starting to erode the social fabric of how society works and what I meant by that is the following thing today we live in a world now where it is easy to confuse truth and popularity and you can
2:19use money to amplify whatever you believe and get people to believe that what is popular is now truthful and what is not popular may not be truthful you know Joe and I for example we've been on the wrong other side of climate for a long time right and the reality is now I can take money and I can use that through all of these social media systems that exist to hundreds of millions of people and I can convince all of Joe's friends and everybody like him of my opinion in very subtle in small ways and he can do the same to me we can do that about vaccines we can do that about gay rights we can do that about bathroom laws we can do that about ROI more and so I think the question we
2:59have to ask ourselves is how do we live in a world where this is now possible and so is about that but just so I understand it was it because cuz I read and watched parts of what you were talking about part of it seemed to me about the ability to pay to manipulate people's thoughts the other seemed to me to be this sort of a DD society with which the sort of liking most everything else has created the sort of feedback loop that you that you compared to drugs we know for a fact that what all of these systems do every single one is it exploits our own natural tendencies in human beings to get and want feedback and that feedback chemically speaking is
3:39the release of dopamine in your brain and so what these feedback loops do and they exist everywhere in call of duty in other video games in social networking sites they get you to react and I think that if you get too desensitized and you need it over and over and over again then you become actually detached from the world in which you live I'm callous you become crude live in front of your screen but it's not your mouth let me ask you this because the the thing that I've been so concerned about is Facebook just announcing that you're gonna be having some app that you can use when you're seven to thirteen I mean it's one thing for us to be doing this but to be
4:16hooking your kids on something that you're describing as a dopamine fix so age that's crazy so look I think in the case of Facebook specifically I think they have probably done more than any other company quite honestly to try to fix it because of all of the companies and I've seen them all up close they are the most frankly to be very blunt and honest the best run and the most technically sophisticated but they're also they're also emailing me if I haven't logged on to Facebook for a while saying hey did you see the post from so-and-so did you see the post from so-and-so trying to lure you back in and again we can make those decisions as adults yes as children that is a
4:45different well I think the product I don't know it quite honestly in as much detail they should but I think the way that that product works because of privacy laws in the United States you how actually have to get parental permission the point though is and what you're bringing up is I think is the most important thing we all have never taken a step back and actually asked ourselves how should we be interacting with these things now seven years into it and what should we be expecting of the Internet at large look the reality may be the entire business model of the Internet may be fundamentally somewhat broken right because we allow ourselves
5:18to get interacted with in ways where we don't necessarily control the medium or the messenger and we are not putting up any barriers to ever give yourself any downtime for that exactly and so it may mean that we all collectively need to figure out not just individuals but also the companies we're also government's quite honestly how different business models need to exist so that we can actually divorce ourselves from how well what goes on in the poly Hypatia household there's no screen time whatsoever none none so forget about let's I'm your Facebook is not just off-limits you're talking no iPads none how old no that's it I have three eight nine seven and
5:56five and do they ask all the time because their kids their friends have it all the time movies a little bit if we have to but no computers at all you know here's here's here's here's the life that I live with my children which may not be for everyone I said I I don't I don't like this codependency of they need to rely on me and when they can't I feed them a device because that becomes a babysitter you go figure it out go outside skin your knee fall on the ground play a sport lose at something and then come back to me and we can talk about it and we'll talk about it as rational human beings and I'll try to tell you why that's a good thing that
6:33just happened to you versus here you are I'm in a baby's because I have something else to do and so I've we've made these conscious choices I've made conscious choices but their conscious and what I was trying to get across and I could have done it more articulately is it needs to be more of a conscious choice I'll give you a different example Adam Bain who you know and love you know he and I go to the knick game and you would think that it's amazing we're sitting courtside it's fantastic I took a picture he took a picture we sweated the filter for 15 minutes trying to figure out which photo and I thought if Adam Dean and I are stuck trying to figure
7:07out what photo filter we're gonna use because we're so craving the reaction what must everybody else be going through and aren't other people feeling this void that I'm feeling in this moment so I'm just right a sensation time you're not watching the game you're not paying attention to what's going it's it's just a really weird place I was just trying to articulate what kind of reaction does Mark Zuckerberg call you who calls you in the valley after you make a comment like this let's just say a lot of people called and texted here's what I would say I owe those guys everything they made me I mean I'm sitting in this seat because frankly I was able to be a part of a
7:45company that did something really wonderful and they're gonna they're gonna do more to fix this stuff than anybody else so I feel bad that guys there may feel like I didn't do right by them in what I said but it was not directed at Facebook I was really just trying to talk about something societally and I agree with you Joe I'm not gonna backtrack on what I said because that's some core basic level we have to start talking about this stuff how should our kids why is anxiety and depression amongst our teenagers higher than they've ever been yes it's in a world that is safer in a world that's more constructive in a world where you should have access to
8:21everything what is going on and we just have to figure this out and talk about it when when will you let your nine-year-old actually have a screen he can get a job I worked at Burger King when I was 14 when he gets a job and earns enough money to buy his phone he can do whatever he wants with it up until then I'm going to feed him clothe him and house him and send him to school and that's all I'm gonna do I mean I feel you yourself don't feel the urge to always check your screen or you do I checked my screen a lot at the this he's got the phone right there no and even now I've actually morphed my behavior what I do now is like whenever I even come into the
9:02office typically I actually put it facedown because otherwise I feel all these notifications I'm constantly my email notifications stock alerts etc well you can be things off I don't have those on this is a pervasive trend that's what I feel it and I was I remember the other day where I forgot my phone and I was in a line somewhere and it was a signal from my unconscious just about every two minutes that I felt I was like by the way do you ever feel the the panic phantom pain of wherever you keep your phone yep or where you hear you feel like maybe a text just yeah so this is this is clearly something that's new have you talked to Sean Sean Parker
9:41about this because he made some comments that were similar just two or three weeks ago well this is why I thought you know what I said a month ago really it was just it was me kind of just saying what at the time I was thinking through and and then it was a month later now this whole thing has kind of gone crazy it so I didn't you know what it probably is chemically mediated I mean in in my brain I mean whatever gets me to all of a sudden feel that need to do something to do for video games it's true for television it's true for other forms of it's true for music so it's probably true for your phone right we're gonna be spending a lot more time with you but I
10:17do want to just get to one other top because we talk about everyday Bitcoin it is out of control like look what's Bitcoin let's talk Bitcoin mm mm 12 I was introduced to it I started to accumulate accumulate 2013 I wrote an article and York Joe hold on just a wee just so we know we can feel bad about ourselves you're accumulating it at what price well my dollar cost average is around a hundred and something and and you've held it everything you've bought well at one point myself and you know two so I was introduced to it by a person I asked him if I could disclose his name he said no but he myself and another person all three of us relatively well-known in the
10:54valley we went we started at one point we owned almost 5% of the entire firm in 2013 we've sold they've sold etc etc I wish we had kept it all we didn't it's fine then I wrote an article and I said you know what there is so much asymmetric upside here this is a thing that either goes to you know at the time I said roughly the value of gold and at the time it was about a hundred dollars a coin and so there's very little downside there's all this asymmetric upside I said take one percent of your net worth and buy this schmuck insurance and it's a schmuck insurance in this kind of very elegant beautiful way this did I miss this Hawkins yarn that was that $100
11:33though what would I mean I I actually started hearing from people that I know very well who don't often invest who are now asking me if this is the time to buy this much insurance now here's the thing this is now a confidence game right there is no real utility in this this is a fantastic fundamental hedge and store value against autocratic regimes and banking infrastructure that we know is corrosive to how the world needs to work properly you cannot have central banks infinitely printing currency you cannot have folks with you know misguided and misdirected monetary and fiscal you just called it a confidence game right and we've done okay and the
12:14economy is built on central bank's and built on on fiat currencies where you you said yourself how much better life is and in every respect and it's ever been and that's with that as a so we've seen the first few chapters of this and now we have to go through this great unwind right when all this liquidity now what what has to do what happened we'll see what happens and so all I'm saying is to have the ability to hedge that out but in a way that isn't fundamentally correlated to the people in the infrastructure that made those decisions that we were not a part of fundamentally I think is a smart at that point is if you haven't jumped on this bus or train
12:48or whatever so vehicle you want to describe it as as it left the station no so here's what I would say the same way that I said in 2013 put one percent of your net worth into Bitcoin I will put myself out there today I think this thing is a hundred thousand dollars a coin probably in the next three to four years and I think it is in the next 20 years a million dollars ago so there you have it you're you're telling people to put one of 1% of your net worth at the test that's firmed it's a lot pardon but that's for people who have money to play with I mean if you're talking to an average retail investor who's looking at this somebody who's trying to figure out
13:26should I put it in my 401k or should I put it in Bitcoin you would tell them what well I don't think that's the real trade-off in your 401k so for example in your IRA I'm saying that there are people who have to make decisions about these things who are fully invested in for one so what I'm saying is I own a lot of Bitcoin in my IRA it is possible so I did take a small percentage and I put it in there all I'm saying is there's a Scott tax-advantaged way absolutely but you have money to play with but what I'm saying is you could buy the S&P 500 index by 99 percent of that so if you have a hundred dollars to invest what I'm saying is what one dollar one dollar
14:01and and the reason that one dollar is so valuable is that it is fundamentally not correlated to the other 99 and just on the off-chance but all the people that manage the 99 may not totally know what they're doing the one dollar may actually save us all okay we are going to be spending a lot more time with you and talking you on so many other topics as well and I'm sure we'll come back to Bitcoin too so thank you thank you Bob all of your Fed worship we found out today has been misplaced because sure math our guest host says you should sell based on the feds and other central bankers unbelievable missteps you should sell everything and buy Bitcoin because
14:43it's been so bad so far that's why I said that the world the dollar crashed like all the Fed critics thought it was gonna happen and it's why I might have started off now if the past was an absolute perfect judge of the future we'd be all set you didn't Tomas I totally I'd set up a straw man you didn't say sell everything and put it in baby I actually didn't say he didn't say that but what Tomas did say what still wouldn't argue with always right but if there's if there's just slightest chance that these guys are somewhat conflicted or clueless or not you know have different irons in the fire for the way they manage currency you should have something that isn't
15:23affected by all that that's not correlated with what central bankers is if I got that I think that's basically right I think you have to basically have a what if the sky falls strategy and and in any time the unwind let's go no more Bitcoin correlator doesn't correlate with right let's go back to 2008 when we thought there were differences in correlations and asset values and what we found out in 2008 was as Jackson Browne sang in the in the fury of the final hour that all there was a it's a great line it's a great line that really describes the financial crisis in any event when that happened all correlations went to one right so we don't know what bitcoins
16:05correlations really are what I mean correlation what I what I really is what I'm talking about is at the end of the day this is a string of letters and numbers that was generated on a computer that sits in a secure wallet it Bru truly is in the functional utility of the world uncorrelated to anything it is an idea and it is a belief system and that may scare people here's a correlation is determined by those who hold it though relative to their other assets do you have any anxiety that its core that its current rise is is correlated to a market bubble meaning exactly that reflects that there's just too much money sloshing around and people have so much money that they're
16:47looking for these sort of any opportunity to weigh that they might not of two and three and four years ago I think bubbles happen when there's a scale of importance and I think it's very unfair to look at a market that's still measured in the you know few tens of billions of dollars and call it a a market to begin with and then be that there's a speculative bubble maybe that can happen from time to time at such small scale I think what's more likely is that there's just an overwhelming number of people who literally don't even know what bitcoin is right and then there's a very very small number of people who are at the periphery lookie looing having opinions but have never
17:23even bothered to read the definition it's a good phrase you know have never bothered to open in a wallet have never bothered to even read the Wikipedia article but they want to correlate it to a framework they understand because it's safe and what I would say is I would suspend disbelief which is what I did in 2012 it took me 18 months to understand yeah I'm reasonably technical and so what I would say is other people if they took the time may come to a very different conclusion than what is the obvious negative Nelly conclusion I think it would be really elegant if the the bubble itself helped create the answer to what caused the bubble in other words the the central bank
18:03I completely agree with you that would be a real in the way the universe works that would be interesting because then you'd really see whether the emperor had closer to done see the there is a bubble from all the money sloshing around that what the real Bitcoin is the answer to the profit I thought the market was up on the Trump economy I'm not necessarily talking about just hold on you can't have it both ways I can't be a bubble
18:31just give me a hard time but also I mean this is an unusual time where all assets seem to be inflated to a higher degree and the question is whether or not the Fed has inflated this when when when you look at what's happened to the money supply a lot of this extra liquidity in bank or excess reserves has not been converted or created into either loans or money Joe and so the idea that somehow there is this froth or bubble in the system from the Fed is a little bit negated by the idea that it's not been turned into money it's it's the bond bubble the stock market right say on a on a price-to-earnings basis is not in bubble territory can I can I did you think the
19:13stock market and but I don't I don't know I don't think about the stock market but let me do some I don't think it's it's it's the underlying earnings that are this is based on the Fed is reducing its balance sheet and it has plans to reduce its balance sheet you would think that in that case the market would price in the forward plans of the Federal Reserve in that time period long paper has declined in yield that's because that's because of it's a global bond market now so it's their central bankers head of the or maybe there's tremendous underlying demand for long dated risk assets and it's not a bubble I mean at the yields in which they offer
19:49I just don't think that really is true but people are going out every day and buying in this market not at gunpoint from the government right you could almost make an argument that we have a deficit of long dated paper at the market design that's because in Japan you get 50 cents a year on $1000 ever the reason private hands are going in all right and they're behind this stuff and they're welcome back everybody let's get back to our guest Oh Stu mas poly Hypatia he is social capital founder also Golden State Warriors co-owner and tomate the last time you were with us you said something that got us thinking that Amazon was a monopoly now I know
20:30you didn't mean it the same way but we just heard last week that Lee Cooperman said he was having dinner with President Trump and he asked him twice yeah twice if Amazon was a monopoly yeah let me talk to you about what I was trying to say there which is it is what I think about as a natural product monopoly what does that mean you build something and when it starts to work what happens is the usage tells you what the trail of breadcrumbs is you should follow so what Amazon is done elegantly is they've built a product that has such fantastic product market fit they watch how people use it and then they actually use that to distill what to do next and what to
21:07do next becomes slightly easier and easier every turn and every you know time they do it and so what you have for example this year if anybody went to Amazon reinvent which is your annual developer conference 50 60 odd thousand people flooded into Las Vegas they overflowed multiple casinos multiple grand ballrooms in order to even just use so you flew there just to watch it remote and what you saw were tens upon tens upon tens of critical features that they had done in a year and when you take a step back and say wait a minute the totality of what they did is unbelievable and then you think they did that in a year and then they did that at a velocity that you
21:49could imagine at a scale and an impact and then you think to yourself well what is next you're gonna look like and by the way the things that they did probably wiped out about two billion dollars of equity value of VCS putting money into ideas that frankly made no sense in the first because they jumped ahead of all they tried to jump ahead and not really think through the implications of an Amazon and so that to me is what I think about is a natural product monopoly it is a thing that now pounds every day slightly a little bit faster than the day before it's by no means a market monopoly because there are other alternatives there's Google there's Microsoft you know in China you
22:24have Alibaba and $0.10 etc but it is a thing now that in my opinion just continues to run and every year gets a little bit cheaper gets a little bit more complete and more things are available to you it's it's an incredible president the president comes from a place of populism and his idea on the campaign trail and now even in office has been that sometimes big is just too big and we can't allow that much power in the hands of a select group of people and that's not just Amazon but that's all of Silicon Valley that could be targeted as yeah I mean when you think about Amazon they employ now I think more than half a million people they employ frankly you know more vets than
23:03some of these companies have employees they are doing all the right things I think very are about to open a second headquarters I suspect you'll see it in a you know red or purple state Texas maybe Michigan and so on every dimension they are from a corporate responsibility perspective acting well but again I'm shifting from just Amazon to saying Facebook Google all of the tech darlings that for so long were kind of giving carte blanche and said we said we need to help them build up because I mean I remember covering the internet back in 1999 and there was not going to be the Internet tax on any of these things because we wanted these companies
23:39to play we made a claim and I think that it worked for a very long time that we are different and as a result we can self-regulate and I think people are waking up to a world that is slightly different from that which is hey wait a minute we shouldn't have special exceptions we should probably treat all kinds of businesses the same independent of how you do it and in that there is probably more governmental involvement than less overtime in all of these industries and in all of these businesses and I think we should just rationalize it be prepared for it and also we should take a step back and say what is the other responsible thing you know Joe talked about the inequity
24:18should we not maybe do things in a slightly different way it may mean two three four or five percent impact to earnings is that okay and what I would tell you is when you have business models that generates 60 70 80 % profits yeah it is okay it is okay to actually only make 55 percent versus 60 percent and have 25,000 more employees it's okay well particularly if you're trying to stave off regulation that can strangle some of that anyway or frankly you actually if you want to displace the actual inequity that you viscerally feel as a problem in the first place so tech companies have this mechanism and a capability to do a broad set of things to employ people fully to pay
24:57them well to give them benefits to do that all over the world it doesn't always have to be cheaper faster better it's it's easy to say that though can you imagine trying to deliver that message to shareholders we've seen it with Walmart you know what they actually come out and said they were going to pay higher the minimum wage you know and I when I set up social capital I took a step back and I said how do I want to define what success looks like there's progress there's impact and one of the things that we said is we want our businesses by 2045 to be employing 10 million people and the reason we said that was that as the tip of the spear that says hey some different kind of
25:33full employment is gonna be necessary it's not all about making money it's not about about doing it in the in the simplest way and impacting the most people it's also by pulling through people so people come back to Amazon for just yeah just a second if Jeff Bezos were sitting at this table with us right now yeah he would say progress is getting the package to you quicker for
25:55cheaper and frankly if we could avoid human beings actually having to lift the boxes go through the street that those are the kinds of jobs that we actually would we'd love to upgrade them to do something else that that is progress do you agree with that and I I hope I'm not putting words in his mouth but he's talked about this idea of what progress looks like and that you don't necessarily want people doing certain types of jobs that I frankly would want to get away from so I think I think the warren buffett has actually had the most clarifying thoughts on this which is when he contrasts you know america in 1917 versus america in 2017 and you
26:36think about the agrarian economy we lived in and then the advent of the tractor and what that did it wasn't that the enter of the tractor all of a sudden said hey wait a minute I'm gonna basically be your salvation it was the government it was the social infrastructure it was a path to education it was a path to GI Bill it was all of these other things that allowed people to reclaim a sense of self and a sense of identity in doing a different thing and so I think I agree with the first two things that probably Jeff would say I'm not sure that he would say the third thing but I do think that he and CEOs like him who are thoughtful and honorable will go out of
27:13their way to be slightly less efficient for the sake of bringing more people along and I think that is the right thing to do he employs more people than any other company right but what part of what he would say is by doing it cheaper by doing it faster it's and that's that that's that's the spear if you do it that way then then you're gonna be more successful so you can employ more people in one hand and on the other hand you are finding different ways of creating different kinds of jobs that do all of the things that you need to do samatha is our guest Oh she'll be with us for the rest of the program our guest dose this morning Timothy Polly hoppity is
27:48the founder of social capital never one to hold back so let's sit let's not you mentioned at the the top of this hour that you had some short ideas some some things that maybe you're not going long on you're betting against you know so I mean in our in our public equities business we've what we do is we alpha short so we don't short the hedge because we don't really charge fees we just make profits on the back end and so we always look at companies and say are there companies that are just fundamentally are they're misguided or misallocating capital or have they just gotten over their ski tips or they just fundamentally misunderstood and one of the best spaces
28:24where I think you can find some really interesting companies is in sort of this machine learning AI now you have to take a longer-term view but there is just so much activity happening at Facebook Google Microsoft Amazon amongst what what are called technically these companies are called hyper scalars mhm in China by do you intend sent where everybody is rolling their own chips right then you have companies like rock which we can talk about in a second which is just an absolute revolutionary approach to chip design an order of magnitude improvement to all of that stuff and so what you're seeing is an expansion of a market you're going into a multi vendor environment right but
29:03today there's only one vendor and that vendor is an nvidia and then that stock is now a you know $200 stock it's a you know a hundred and twenty billion dollar market cap a fantastic company and you have to ask oneself what has happened to Intel when all of these big monolithic companies get into the game is you crush margin you crush vendor diversity and things get very difficult what happens in the world the machine learning and artificial intelligence and I suspect that that will happen and so it's one of these areas that while we as an organization are baking some really interesting private companies we're looking at the public markets and kind
29:40of scratching our heads and asking ourselves this entire ecosystem obviously put up in the video on the screen I mean this has been one of the great darlings oh absolutely of the stock market over how passionately say 24 months it's just been on a rocket ship of arrive you're looking at right there what do you think it's worth in reality then I think you have to ask yourself in three to four years when AI really hits its scale how are the tasks done and where is the task running in terms of the hardware and what we know is that it will never be a single vendor environment in three to four years we know that conclusively and we also know that these big companies need to own AI
30:22as fully as possible we've seen it play out at Google they own their own chips called TPU they're building these FPGAs you know Amazon just released the ability to access that at the raw bare metal level what do you think these companies are gonna do they're not gonna go over and say hey just sell it to me at whatever margin you like you're the same how do you think of the other chip makers and I'm thinking by the way Broadcom calm yeah great news right now great question so given the merger this is a proposal this is all trending to commodity so in the absence of some fundamental technical innovation in leap I think what we're going to see is a
30:55flattened market it's going to be thin margins it's going to be high velocity high volume and so you have to sort of plan that into what your business model looks like and the problem is the existing incumbents are you sure the whole space what I would do quite honestly and this is I will do is once we land the next major technical release of our chip once I know what the performance characteristics looked like which we know is in order of magnitude better than anything else then I know that that product is gonna work what do you think about Intel and Brian krzanich because they bought mobile AI they're trying to pursue sort of a big data strategy of collecting all this stuff
31:32from the cloud you're smiling laughing I think we're gonna get a comment like like a like the way you did about Watson at IBM at about a moment you know I have a lot of friends at IBM and I have a lot of friends at Intel so I will not say what I said there but here's what I will say Intel is going through what I think everybody else will go through which is you have a processor it kind of works it's kind of semi useful and then all of a sudden these big guys get you into a room and say I'm Amazon I have this much demand I have Google I have this much demand I have facebook on Facebook I'm $0.10 imbaba here's the price I'm willing to pay choose or don't use and
32:10if you don't choose I'm gonna go and spin up arm or I'm gonna go roll my own and you've seen how that plays out massive amounts of capacity massive amounts of capability that Intel can't actually deploy they over time will become a contract manufacturer for others they will look like Foxconn for others that is not a great business from where they are and so this is a 15 to 20 year trend that is gonna play out for them but they are the canary in the coal mine for how other folks in the absence of something truly revolutionary technically that's the path that everyone else will go down why can't they just hire the R&D guys to come up with with new things with new
32:47innovations are you saying there is I think that is it what is it Moore's law that there is no more innovation to come no it's that when the when these innovations get baked now there are folks like us a vibrant ecosystem of investors who can get behind them and fund them to completion you know I have billions of dollars that I can deploy behind grok to make sure that they are a vibrant long living public business explain to me how Amazon and all these guys aren't monopolies if they can then determine whether an Intel a doubt component can actually compete and survive if you know if you say I'm so big that you're going to either work with me or I'm going to take my business
33:20elsewhere and crush you because it's it's one of many businesses that Intel is in my point is you're taking the most high value business and you're gonna erode margin sir which means that will they be profitable sure will they be large sure but it's not going to be where they are and so this company will get re rated Nvidia will get rear ated it it is just the thing that'll happen so we're debating market cap I don't think we're debating viability ok different company Tesla where do you land right now we are massively long the convertible bonds why the convertible bonds again it's the safest and the surest way to basically bet on Elon Musk who I just fundamentally think is the
33:58most important entrepreneur of our generation but you don't like the equity you don't like the stock the equity represents tremendous volatility I mean if you put it on the screen you can see it right there and for our risk management for the way that I want my capital in my partners capital run what I want is a mechanism to get 95% of the upside zero of the downside and literally the bonds give you that and so you know there's no need for me to sort of step out there try to be a risk cowboy to prove something that we don't have to prove because Elon is said to the entire world hey listen you can buy the naked equity or take this other thing which gives you 95% of it and no
34:37downside it's a coupon when we bought it it was gen yielding 5% now it's close to zero well what's the premium over conversion no we bought it at like 87 would you still buy it close to zero yeah because you don't you get the downside protection separate question if he was willing to sell you a piece of the boring company this is the tunneling companies which may be boring to some people but I think it's pretty exciting I think it's really exciting you buy here's what you buy this is what absolutely here look here's the thing with this guy I've known him for a long time he is truly putting every single dollar where his mouth is the guy is trying to make us an
35:14interplanetary species get us off of oil reduced traffic and this is where I don't understand when like people like chinos come out and say you know what this company is a fraud or that I don't understand what he's talking about there's nothing fraudulent about this guy there's nothing fraudulent about the technology this is just like people wanting to dance on failure and I just don't get him they call that their call provision further converts it that we own the ability to convert at a certain can he call it at poor it you can't because they'd be a force they'd have to yeah we could force it really you sure instrument it's an amazing answer mask
35:52you this we happen to both being agreement about Elon Musk however yeah overtime every time he's put out some type of expectation about sales of those vehicles they rarely if ever hit them in fact they seem to disappoint routinely so I think when part of the the chain OHS story is he puts out these grand projections oftentimes raises money on the back of them and then doesn't hit the numbers but here's what my Jim Chanos and everybody else needs to appreciate building revolutionary things is hard okay you don't just walk in and invent the iPhone there's complexity there you don't just come in and invent Facebook there's tremendous complexity
36:31and so you got to think about this in years and even though we force companies like that to boil them down to porters it doesn't work sh'mon we haven't gotten a chance to talk to you about your role as an NB a-- owner yesterday roger goodell was here on the set talking about the kneeling controversy what that is meant for football and as an NBA owner what's your take how should teams approach this how should the league approach it can i can it before i answer that as an owner can i answer it as a colored man sure i've gotten pulled over by the police just driving I don't think it's their fault I think it's sort of just the part of the milieu we live in
37:12I've gotten on planes where I know that people feel uncomfortable because their initial reaction is oh there's a kind of brown bearded guy on the plane I felt that and so what I think that is worth realizing is that all different kinds of people can feel different versions of those things in the natural course of life and when some of those people want to reflect that and then have a dialogue about it I think the first thing you have to do is quite honestly take a step back and say where are they coming from and then is this the right place and how should it happen what I can tell you is that I think as a owner I think Adam silver has done an
37:54unbelievable job I think the players in the NBA are incredible because they have a point of view they believe and I agree with them they've earned the right to be able to start a conversation see what LeBron does Chris Paul does Steph and I just wish that the NFL kind of embraced it in a little bit of a different way the reality is you know you're putting 52 men on the field wrapped in metal to bang each other up and then to monetize that in a 50 odd 100 odd whatever billion dollar enterprise those are key part of the system and if they want to reflect some frustrations that exist these are true things that exist in the world you have to enable the discussion and
38:40that frustrates me just as a man and as an owner I would just say that I'm just really glad that I'm part of an organization that has enabled a very different kind of conversation to be fair the NBA has the benefit of going second they got to see what the NFL kind of stumbled through along the way I also think Adam is a person that was just a really empathetic smart guy the the way of doing it where you say the players have earned a right to express their feelings and and let their voice be heard is there a way to do that and not politicize it to have it in a position where you're going to potentially alienate some of your fan base too to say maybe not during the national anthem
39:15yeah there probably is and and I think like if they had kind of like gotten everybody together much sooner then it wouldn't have become such a divisive polarizing issue because then everybody then again in the modern world we live in is forced to go to their corner and now there is just absolutely no backtracking nobody can backtrack the owners can't backtrack in the NFL the players can't backtrack in the NFL then you have these weird mixture of like oh well let's compromise by only doing it in the you know in Bernal showing up staying in the locker room so this is all part and parcel of even how we started talking in the morning it's just this kind this is the kind of stuff
39:51we're in a different era we would have just figured it out in a different way and we don't it's not set up well for that right now we asked Roger Goodell yesterday about Colin Kaepernick as someone who used to plan a team we're in San Francisco exactly and we asked him straight up do you think he's being blackballed by the owners what do you think yeah I mean it's isn't it obvious I mean the guy went from a very very legitimate player to probably a pretty legitimate backup to there is he cannot get a job although is that is that necessarily blackballing or does it every owner saying wait a second I don't want to bring the controversy into my
40:26house yeah you're right maybe may not be as organized there may not be a you know a whatsapp group were ther organizing how to do this I get that but the outcome is the same which is a legitimate human being who has credible athletic ability who at one point was probably a top three or four QB at some point in the league who probably has a functional role to play can never get that job again it's pretty clear and so it's it's an you think there's an owner potentially even next season who would take a chance on him work right now I'm not sure I don't know you know don't you be quite honest with you like you know football quite honestly I haven't
41:03watched it in four years I just Minh so passed the I just can't look at these guys beating themselves up it just it really the sport frustrates me it's it's slow quite honestly I love basketball it's incredible the teams are amazing the people are amazing they're well run long live the NBA all right Samantha's our guest Oh guest host he's gonna be with us for the rest of the hour this isn't San Francisco but tough year to watch the 49ers too I mean oh my gosh yeah he's trying his best but Oh Bob from Cincinnati so I mean oh my gosh Wow a lot of oh my gosh Aang Apple what did you say about Apple I said Apple is no longer a tech company but then you
41:45change that a little bit well I mean I think what it is is sort of like it's it's in this migration to being a really interesting software business and a luxury good business and it's trying to figure out how to navigate that and how to manage the brand and how to manage you know how to sell thousand dollar devices that have certain capabilities but when you take a step back and actually like look at that phone and compare it to a pixel or the next generation Samsung what you see is frankly the same product and so what it has is brand it has a sense of differentiation and that's no different than Louis Vuitton or any other luxury good that you're willing to pay a
42:26premium for that may not really bear the cost of it if you look at the actual raw materials that go into it and so they are gonna have to make a really interesting transition because they're gonna have to figure out how to land more of these iPhone tens where you know people like us are willing to pay a thousand dollars but what does that leave behind and I think what it leaves behind is a market that's gonna get consolidated even more by folks like Xiaomi or Samsung on the low-end mmm so it's a trillion dollar company probably it definitely bleeds into that category because now you're just talking about you know another 12 or 15 percent accretion from where they are but you
42:58know the question has always been like what do you do with all this money what do you do with this scale and especially unfortunately so far that's all they've done and if you repatriate it what should they be buying if anything I mean you know I still think Tesla Netflix these are the businesses that Apple should be in the business of owning just because it has so much operational leverage do you think they will meaning I don't want the tax policy you know yes I think that they are they have fun you know look I mean they've spent more on their building quite honestly than they have in any sort of major feature or product launch so this is something
43:31between a billion and five billion dollar I think it was a ten billion dollar campus or something I mean look the point they probably spent more to figure out how to curve the glass then you know so they're third a point in time where I think they're being stewards they need a generational transition where now people that are a little bit further divorced from the Steve Jobs legacy can take over those businesses and then you'll either see it flounder or just completely go nuclear in a rocket ship and we need that moment to come exciting a judge how do you judge Tim Cook's leadership oh I think I think he's been a great steward but I think he's
44:02operated like I said again as an outsider just looking at it as not wanting to push the envelope too much by accidentally denigrating Steve's legacy what do you love the right thing to do in that situation yeah and frankly I can you look at Microsoft it's roughly the same thing where Ballmer tried the best he could now slightly different circumstances obviously and then you needed a transition to someone I would say look at the look both look at the stock price look at the market chair look look look at the revenue produced over the last none of those things I take away what I'm saying is has there been visionary product leadership and I think what instead they've done is
44:37they've managed a business well that has been given to them Tomas love having you here thank you thanks guys ready to see hey there thanks for checking out CNBC on YouTube be sure to subscribe to stay up-to-date on all of the day's biggest stories you can also click on any of the videos around me to watch the latest from CNBC thanks for watching
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版