克里斯·安德森(Chris Anderson)在 Web Summit 2022 的舞台上被问到,TED 是怎么在新的媒介环境里保持存在感的。他的回答里藏了一个数字:TED 从来没有在营销上花过一分钱。从 1984 年创办到现在,几十亿的播放量、两万多名志愿译者、遍布全球的 TEDx 组织者,全部靠口口相传长出来。
这个细节放在 2022 年听有点刺耳。那一年所有人都在讨论推荐算法、讨论怎么被平台选中、讨论内容要不要为分发做适配。一个内容品牌淡淡地说,它四十年没投过广告,也活成了全球辨识度最高的思想平台。
TED 的历史并不线性。1984 年创办,真正的起飞点是 2006 年。那一年他们开始把演讲视频放到网上,然后事情超出了所有人的预期:视频病毒式传播,一个全球观众群体就这么形成了。安德森说这话时用的是"to our surprise",意外。
但他也承认,互联网一直在演化,想保持新鲜就得持续观察外面在发生什么。不能让演讲风格变成陈词滥调。观众想听到的是新东西,一旦台上的人在重复一种已经被用烂的腔调,注意力立刻就散了。所以 TED 的核心工作,说到底是让每个讲者找到自己的声音,找到属于自己的表达方式。
没有公式,只有找到自己的声音
很多人相信 TED 演讲有一套模板:开场抛一个惊人数据,中间讲三段个人故事,结尾升华到人类命运。安德森直接否掉了这个说法。一旦你认为存在公式,那场演讲就注定无聊、注定俗套。
公式的反面是具体的人。有人靠数据说服人,有人靠一个故事,有人靠现场演示,有人靠把自己搞得很狼狈。这些风格没法被抽象成方法论文档,也没法被批量复制。这也解释了为什么 TED 的演讲质量参差得厉害:它押注的是个体,个体不保证成功。
换个角度看,这套做法其实放弃了工业化的稳定产出。你没法保证每一场都精彩,你只能保证每一场都是某个具体的人在讲他自己真正在乎的事。安德森把这个代价看得很清楚,也愿意付。因为一旦开始追求稳定产出,就得靠模板,模板一起,观众立刻能闻出来。
政客会下台,思想不会
安德森把 TED 的内核讲得非常干脆:这个世界上真正重要的是思想,思想塑造了历史。
我们习惯用领导人和政治事件来讲述当下,新闻里全是人名、选举、博弈。他的提醒是时间尺度的问题:
「政客来来去去,思想是永恒的。」(克里斯·安德森)
这个说法听起来像漂亮话,但他给了一个更具体的解释。当你听到一个人提供了一种看世界的新方式,那种兴奋感来自可能性被打开。你会觉得"对,这样说得通",然后你的脑子里多出了一块空间,原本不存在的东西现在可以被设想。
思想的奇妙之处在于,人可以重新构想未来,把这个构想讲给别人听,然后通过共同的意图,把它真的造出来。地球上没有第二个物种能做这件事。放在历史的长度上看,这近乎奇迹。
这段话里有一个容易被忽略的前提:构想必须被讲出去。留在一个人脑子里的未来,改变不了任何东西。传播这件事本身,就是思想得以生效的环节。
这个能力在商业和社会里的投影就是协作。公司围绕产品协作,科学家围绕问题协作。不同想法的人需要一个能交换、能碰撞的场所,这个场所本身就有巨大的价值。维基百科在文字形态上做过一次类似的尝试,TED 做的事情是在它之上增加了深度和现场感。
维基百科用零头的钱打败了微软
安德森对世界的判断里有一条很清楚的分界线:零和视角和创造视角。
很多人看世界的方式是零和的。资源就那么多,你多拿一块我就少一块,所以一切都是一场推与拉的角力。他说,争夺权力的仗有时候确实要打,但更好的做法是去创造新的可能性,让所有人都有得赢。这就是思想世界的奇妙之处。
他举的例子是维基百科。当年没有人相信,一部体量巨大的百科全书可以由所有人共同编辑。微软在 Encarta(Encarta 电子百科全书)上砸了一大笔钱,维基百科花的只是其中很小的一部分,结果在量级上把它彻底甩开。安德森用的词是"blow away",差了一个数量级。
这件事值得多停一会儿。微软当年有的是钱、有的是专家、有的是版权资源,它输在哪里?输在它假设知识必须由一小撮被授权的人来编写。维基百科假设每个普通人都掌握着某个条目里的一小块真相,把这些小块拼起来就够了。两种假设对应两种成本结构,后者便宜了几个数量级。
互联网就是这样,它让各种形式的协作成为可能,前提是人们愿意把自己的想法免费分享给全世界。TED 自己就是受益者:从没花钱做推广,全靠口碑扩散,结果有两万多名志愿者主动把演讲翻译成一百多种语言。安德森说,这种事在互联网出现之前根本没法设想。TEDx 的组织者更极端,他们在世界各地自费、自担风险、自己出时间办活动。
他喜欢这种被创造出来的可能性世界。同时他也清楚,同样的连接能力也会放大糟糕的东西。这是所有人正在打的仗。
人类的声音,终于能传到全球
安德森有一个被低估的判断:人类的声音第一次获得了全球规模的分发能力。
从古登堡印刷术发明之后的几百年里,人类唯一能够规模化传播的媒介是文字。退后一步看这件事,会发现它漏掉了沟通里极大的一块。人说话时的语气、停顿、音量、犹豫,本身携带大量信号,文字把这些全部剥掉了。
所以他把在线视频、播客这些东西看得很重。它们让人声重新回到了传播的中心,而这件事的重要性远没有被充分认识。
「如果社交媒体一开始就是语音,而不是一小段一小段的文字碎片,它大概不会制造出那么多仇恨。」(克里斯·安德森)
这个假设没法验证,但它指向一个真实的差异:文字碎片剥离了语境和语气,剩下的东西最容易被误读,也最容易被激怒。同样一句讽刺,用嘴说出来对方能听出是玩笑,打成字就变成了一句攻击。
关于新平台,TED 的态度是参与但不迎合。TikTok 上有一个 TED Talks 账号,数据还不错。安德森说得很坦白,要在这类平台上保持相关性,但不能在这条路上走得太远。因为 TED 真正调用的是最古老的通道:一个人说话,另一个人在听。这件事可以追溯到无数代人围着篝火聊天,写在人的本能里,没法被替代。形式会一直更新,篝火不会。
每个孩子口袋里都该有世界上最好的老师
TED 越来越把教育当成自己的责任。TED-Ed 这个项目把教师最好的课做成短动画,年播放量现在接近十亿,安德森提到这个数字时明显很兴奋。
他更在意的是另一件正在发生的事:今天出生的每一个孩子,人类历史上第一次真正有机会接触到世界上最好的老师,就在他们的智能手机里。他用了"奇迹"这个词。
现在还有一部分人没有智能手机。他给的判断是,十年之内几乎人人都会有。这属于有历史分量的转变,需要有人去服务这批人。
他也把话说得很清楚,TED 只能提供其中一小块内容,应该和教育领域的很多其他提供者合作,帮人获得一生的学习。他把终身学习当成一件理所当然的事,而不是一句口号。这个态度在台上说出来分量不一样:一个靠演讲成名的人,把知识的供给看成公共基础设施,而不是自家产品。
信任是文明最贵的东西,我们正在把它扔掉
被问到信息太多、该信谁的问题,安德森没有绕。他认为这是个大问题,而且被社交媒体的机制弄得越来越糟。
他描述的那个动态很准确:人们在社交媒体上最擅长的,是在对方身上找出所有错误,找出足够多的理由去恨另一群人。这个循环会自己给自己供能,越转越快,最后把社会撕成两半。
解法在他看来是反向的:去做事,去和别人一起做成点什么。
「跟另一个人一起做成一件很酷的事,信任就在这个过程里长出来了。」(克里斯·安德森)
这句话的重量在后半段:信任是文明手里最珍贵的资源,而我们现在正处在把它丢掉的危险里。
马斯克在推特上真正的难题
2022 年秋天,马斯克收购推特是全场最想听的话题。安德森没有回避,也没有顺着骂。
他先给了个平衡的评价。马斯克是个了不起的人,有争议,确实会做一些古怪的事,有些推文明显不妥。但坐下来聊过几次之后,会发现他是个思考很深的人,内心深处真的相信自己是在为人类做事。安德森说得很直白,他不认为马斯克是个右翼疯子。他认为马斯克至少会尝试让推特没那么疯。
然后他把机制拆开讲了一遍,这是整场对话里最锋利的一段。想在推特上被放大,需要三个条件同时满足:政治立场极端、对事实不在乎、语言上足够冒犯。换句话说,你越能挑衅对面那一方,你能拿到的注意力就越多。被算法推上去的,正是这类推文。
他说自己唯一想问马斯克的问题就是这个:你打算怎么阻止这件事。
他猜马斯克是有方案的,而且他不打算赌马斯克输。理由落在行为模式上:这个人习惯先动手试,边做边改,很少等到方案完美才出发。
执行力上,安德森的评价是"令人印象深刻"。马斯克进去之后是闪电战速度,非常果断。是不是太快了,他承认还得看。他也点出了难度:这是马斯克遇到过最大的挑战之一,而且这场仗不太能用上他的强项。造火箭、造车都是物理问题,可以被计算;改造一个由人类情绪驱动的公共言论场,不行。
算法只放大黑暗的东西,这非常危险
话题后来滑向了更大的框架。安德森把这称为人类的生存性问题:社交媒体有概率把我们带向反乌托邦。
路径并不复杂。如果我们持续激怒彼此身上最坏的那部分,最后会走到一个除了争吵和互相攻击之外什么都做不了的境地,很多已经建成的东西会被撕开。他在当天上午的演讲里讲过这个,语气里没有戏剧性,像在陈述一个工程风险。
他保留了一份乐观:已经有人在意识到这件事有多荒谬,也已经有很多力量在努力限制最坏的情况。
但他给出了两个硬条件。一个是新的商业模式,因为靠注意力变现的模型天然偏向激怒。另一个是决心,大公司和每一个在网上的人都要试着记起互联网真正擅长什么。
「互联网非常擅长把人聚到一起。网上有很多美好的东西可以病毒式传播。」(克里斯·安德森)
他的结论是要在这上面加倍投入,走出"只有黑暗的东西才有传播力"的处境。而当前的算法,正在把我们往那个方向推。他用了一个很重的词:unbelievably dangerous。
这里有个值得留意的逻辑:他没有把责任全部推给平台。算法是产品决策的结果,产品决策是人做的,人是被指标考核的。要改,就得从指标和商业模式这一层改起,光靠喊口号和内容审核解决不了。
他自己最满意的几场对谈
被问到做过的最好的一次访谈,安德森先提了德克萨斯州超级工厂(Gigafactory)那两个小时。他坐在马斯克对面,聊的是要造出一个让人兴奋的未来需要什么条件。话题铺得很开。他聊完的感受是,那个未来有机会被建出来,而且会很有意思。他手上有两场和马斯克的对话,一场谈推特,一场谈未来,他觉得后者更好。
另一场是比尔·盖茨和梅琳达·盖茨还在一起的时候,他把两人请到一起谈慈善。他的理由很实在:世界上有这么多财富,重要的是看到这些钱被用在好的地方,他认为他们做得不错。
还有尤瓦尔·诺亚·赫拉利(Yuval Noah Harari)。安德森对他的评价集中在思维方式:这个人能在大尺度上看人类,而且在播客上聊过好几次,每次都很兴奋。
把这三个选择放在一起看,能看出安德森的偏好:他喜欢和那些在时间尺度上思考的人对话,无论是造火箭的、做慈善的,还是写人类史的。他们关心的东西都比一场发布会更长久。
- 如果你要做内容,先把"找到自己的声音"这件事当成任务,自己去套一套流行模板只会更快被识破。一旦你的表达能被别人一眼看出套路,观众就走了。
- 评估任何合作时先问一句:这是零和博弈,还是能创造出新的可能性让所有人都有得赢。维基百科和 Encarta 的差距就是这两种思路的差距。
- 如果你经营社群或平台,优先级应该放在"让人一起做成一件具体的事"上。信任靠共同完成的事情生长,靠发声明长不出来。
- 检查你自己产品的推荐逻辑:被放大的内容是不是极端、不在乎事实、语言冒犯的那一类。如果是,你就正在参与那个"难以置信地危险"的循环。
- 做个人表达时,多用能承载语气和语境的形式。语音、长视频、播客传递的信息量,远高于切成碎片的短文字。
- 把最好的学习资源当成随身基础设施来用。十年内几乎人人都有智能手机,能从世界上最好的老师那里学习,谁先用满这个条件,谁就领先一整个身位。
0:01[Music] Chris Anderson. TED. I guess I'm the head of TED. And you're based on New York City. TED is a series of conferences. we capture the talks and share them freely with the world. So TED has become ideas we're spreading. That's our Monica. What is the evolution of the past few years? How do you use the mediums, the new social media platforms and all that to communicate those ideas?
0:38Yeah, I mean TED started in 1984, but it took off in 2006 when we could put the talks online and you know to our surprise they went viral and created this global audience. I mean the internet continues to evolve and it's to stay fresh. You have to keep looking at what's happening out there.
1:04You can't let present presentation styles become cliched. people people want to feel like they're hearing something fresh. So, you know, that's that's the main thing we do. We tell there is no some people think there's a formula to giving a TED talk. Not true. we if as soon as you think there is that talk is going to be boring and cliched. So so we're constantly trying to have speakers find their voice their way of communicating what matters. But I mean at the heart of it is the thought that what matters what really matters in the world is ideas. Like that is what ideas are what have shaped history. We often tell the story of current events in terms of leaders and politics and so
1:52forth. Politicians come and go. Ideas are forever. And and so I think that's fundamentally the appeal of of TED is that you feel when you when you're hearing someone giving you a new way of looking at the world, it just makes you excited. You know, you feel like, okay, that that makes sense. And it it creates a new sense of possibility. This is the miracle of ideas is that we can literally reimagine the future and share that with someone so that you can see this new possibility space which through shared intention you can actually create. I mean no other species on the planet can do that. And it's it's kind of a miracle in in terms of history. I think it's fascinating
2:34just thinking of we build companies to do products to do make something better. We build even societies around that idea of being collaborative. We have scientists that collaborate to build the stuff and having a space where different people with different set of ideas can share and collaborate is really a powerful idea in terms of the larger scope. Wikipedia was a bit of that in the written form, right? But you add more depth to that, right?
3:06Yeah. So many people have a view of the world that is kind of zero sum. It's they see the world as just a battle of who has resources and it's it's a pushpull situation. once you enter the world of ideas that there are other possibilities there. Yeah. It's important to fight certain battles for power I guess. but but even better is to create to build to create new possibilities so that actually everyone can win. And that's the miracle of the world of ideas. So yeah, Wikipedia, no one thought you could have a massive encyclopedia on the internet that was edited by everyone. Like it it cost a tiny fraction of what Microsoft invested in in Carter on the internet
3:50and completely blew it away. Completely blew it away by an orders of magnitude. and the internet's like that. It makes possible all kinds of collaborations for us. the fact that people were willing to share ideas freely across the world. I mean, TED has never spent money on marketing. This was all word of mouth is how it spread.
4:12the and it resulted in people offering to translate our talks into 100 languages. We have like 20,000 plus volunteer translators. again, you couldn't you couldn't imagine this in a pre- internet age. and and and then the fact that TEDex organizers are willing to host TED events everywhere in the world on their own expense and risk and time. That's amazing as as well. So I I I love the notion of this world of possibility that we've created where by by connecting everyone amazing things can happen. Unfortunately, also some terrible things can happen, but that's that's the battle we're all fighting in in terms of storytelling. Things haven't changed completely, but there's new
4:58mediums. There's Tik Tok, YouTube has a big role also, but social media in general. Podcasts are a thing for the past few years more. How do you use the different channels to do stuff? Because there's TED talks, but now you also have longer format interviews on podcast. How do you use those? Yeah, I mean look the big picture is that the the human voice has finally allowed been allowed to go to global scale. Like for centuries since the goodenberg press was invented the only way that we communicated at scale was through the written word. And when you step back and think about that for a minute that's missing out a huge element of what it is to communicate where you know as humans
5:40we send so many other signals through how we speak through voice. and so I think it's it's underappreciated how big a deal it is that online video and then you know like things like podcasting and all these other ways of allowing voices to speak because they definitely connect with people differently. I think if social media had been voice only instead of little text fragments, we
6:05wouldn't have they wouldn't have created all the hatred they they've created. so yes that medium keeps innovating. I think we're definitely we want to be relevant on media like like Tik Tok. So for example there's a TED talks channel on Tik Tok which is doing fine. but we don't want to go too far down that route. Ultimately what we're tapping into is the power of the most ancient communication channel that's wired deeply into us which is just people talking to each other and listening to each other. It goes back to countless generations of people gathering around campfires. It's really it's a deep part of who we are. We can't ever forget that. So that's that's
6:50always going to be at the heart of ch. I mean we we're taking ever more seriously our role as as educators. we have this wonderful TED Ed project that creates turns teachers best lessons into short animations that get pretty much a billion views annually now and are really that's been really exciting to see.
7:17I think there's so much more we could do. Like every child who's born today should it's it's kind of a miracle that for the first time in history, every child really has access to the world's best teachers right there on their smartphone. Some people don't have smartphones now. Within 10 years, pretty much everyone will. And it's that is a shift of historical importance. So, let's serve them. Let's let's do everything we can.
7:44It's not, you know, TED talks and TED can provide a little part of the mix, but we should be collaborating with many other education providers to help help allow people to have a lifetime of education. we should all be lifelong learners and I I find that exciting and so we're reaching out to others to see how we can collaborate in terms there's a lot of talk and trust online these days news organizations where to to trust in terms of information young kids also learning how what to trust do you think there it's a there's a challenge there too many information but what to trust yeah I do I mean it's it's a it's a it's a big problem and it's made worse by the
8:28fact that, you know, we we've we've got this dynamic on social media of of people finding everything wrong with each other, finding many reasons to hate other people, and that is creating a self- fueling cycle of division. So, we need to reverse that and find ways to build things together. It's basically by by doing something cool with someone else, you you you build trust that way, but it's in many ways it's the most precious resource that civilization has and we're in danger of throwing it away.
9:06So, it's a big issue. about that, Ellen Mus now is on the news for because of Twitter. Is there any question that you would like to ask him now, right now at this time? you you've interviewed him a bunch of times, but what you think is the main thing he or everyone should be focused on?
9:28Yeah, he's he's a remarkable man. he's controversial. He definitely does some odd things. I think some of his tweets are ill advised. but when you talk with him, I've talked to him on several occasions, you you discover someone who is deeply thoughtful. And I I think at heart at heart is genuine in his belief that he's acting on behalf of humanity. I don't think he's a right-wing lunatic. I don't think, you know, I I think what I think he's going to try at least to make Twitter less crazy right now. The key to getting amplified on Twitter is to be a combination of politically extreme kind of reckless with the truth and being willing to be quite obnoxious
10:20in the language you use. In other words, the more you can taunt the other side, the more attention you'll get and and those are the tweets that are getting amplified. I'm I guess my one question for him is be what are you going to do to stop that? And I think he has a plan. I wouldn't bet against him. And usually he tries things, right? He has a plan, but he adapts a lot. He tries things, right? Yeah. Exactly. he's been
10:48impressively decisive and fast in like he's gone in there and he's operating at absolute blitz creek speed. It's it's kind of amazing to watch. whether he's going too fast, we'll we'll see. but he's probably our generation's most impressive tech entrepreneur. If if you objectively stand back and look at what he's built, it is it is breathtaking. And I think I think Twitter's as big a challenge as he's had. It doesn't all play to his strengths. But like I said, I wouldn't but against him.
11:26Well, this is the existential question for humanity. there's a chance that it takes us into dystopia. I spoke about this here this morning, but there's a there's a chance that if we continue to provoke the worst in each other, we'll make it impossible to do anything else except fight and bicker and you know that the we could we could tear apart a lot of what we've built. I'm hopeful that people realize how crazy this is and that there are huge efforts underway to moderate the worst of this. you know I think I think it needs new business models. I think it needs absolute determination by the big companies and by everyone else online to try to remember what the internet's
12:12actually good at. The internet is amazing at pulling people together. there are lots of beautiful things that can go viral online. We need to double down on doing that on on making getting past the situation where the only stuff that is viral and compelling is the dark stuff which is what our algorithms are currently doing to us. That's unbelievably dangerous.
12:41Well, definitely Elon. the you know there was an interview I did with him about Twitter, but the I think the the interview I think is better still. I think they both good, but I think the better still one was I got to sit down with him for a couple hours at the Gigafactory in Texas and really hear his thoughts about what it will take to make a future that's exciting. we went through a lot lot of stuff there and I I think there is a chance that that future can be built and that it will be exciting. So that was that was definitely you know pretty good.
13:17let's see. I I enjoyed I was going to say Bill and Melinda Gates. I sat them down together when they were still together and asked them about their philanthropy you know that that when there's so much wealth in the world it's really important that we see it being turned to good purpose and I think they did a pretty good talk pretty good job of doing that. and then I loved interviewing Ivano Harrari. He's he's got such an amazing mind. you know, he's he he sees humanity in big picture terms. That that is exciting.
14:06So, I've interviewed him a couple times on the podcast and at
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版