股东会·中文精读

直播:Tesla 2022 股东大会,马斯克出席

WATCH: Tesla's 2022 Shareholder Meeting with Elon Musk - LIVE

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

马斯克在大屏幕上放了一条曲线。蓝线从2012年的接近零起步,前几年贴着地面爬,最近两年突然竖起来,陡得不像话。

他说,这条线看起来像风险投资商业计划书里画的那种、从来不会成真的曲线,问题是它是真的。

这大概是我见过最干净的指数曲线。它长得像商业计划书里那种永远不会实现的东西,但它确实发生了,这才是最惊人的部分。(马斯克)

曲线背后是数字。2012年8月,特斯拉累计造了不到3000辆车,2500辆Roadster,加上几百辆Model S。2022年,第300万辆刚下线。十年,一千倍。

这是2022年特斯拉股东大会,地点在得州奥斯汀的超级工厂。会议分两段,前半段是13项提案的正式表决,后半段是马斯克的年度汇报和问答。前半段的提案环节信息量不小,后半段马斯克讲的东西比很多人预期的更远。

那条像假的一样的指数曲线

先看产能。马斯克给出的目标很直接:年底达到200万辆的年化产能。

截至目前,特斯拉已经跑到150万辆的年化产能。他的判断是,今年全年大概落在150万辆附近,年底出年时摸到200万辆的产能水位。

这个数字需要放回历史里才看得清。十年前特斯拉累计产量不到3000辆,现在累计300万辆。马斯克说,这十年里最让他觉得不真实的一点,是累计产量真的呈现出一条干净的指数曲线,中间没有掉队,没有断档。

他用这张图解释了另一件事。特斯拉的累计盈利能力曲线,在2017年有一个明显的坑。他管那段叫“精神创伤”,说那条绿色的累计利润曲线大约等于心理痛苦的轨迹。2017年是Model 3产能地狱,公司差点断气。

然后曲线拐了过来。现在特斯拉的自由现金流在持续上升,而且马斯克强调,这还是在自动驾驶真正开始贡献收入之前。

我们实际上做到了产出的现金比花掉的现金多,留存收益转正,算是配得上自己的分量了。这非常难。(马斯克)

他还顺手报了一个数:特斯拉现在的营业利润率是全行业最高的。这句话他讲得很轻,台下反应很大。

关于竞争,马斯克给了一个视角。很多人把电动车市场看成特斯拉和其他车企抢份额,他的看法是,电动车整体在从燃油车那里抢份额。五年前那些大车厂还在公开说电动车的坏话,现在几乎每一家都表态全面电动化。

他还补了一刀:每次竞争对手给电动车打广告,特斯拉的销量就会涨。特斯拉开源了大量专利,别人可以免费用,他把这称为“共同繁荣”。

Model Y的预测他给了两个时间点。今年按收入算,Model Y会成为全球最畅销车型;明年按销量算,也会是第一。他加了一句限定条件,说这些工厂不是变魔术变出来的,柏林和奥斯汀两座超级工厂还在爬坡,问题清单有一万个,单个都不难,难的是同时解决一万个。

171个零件变成2个

制造这一段是马斯克今年讲得最技术、也最容易被忽略的部分。

特斯拉做出了一体化压铸,尺寸是行业里没有过的。原来一个后车身需要171个金属件拼起来,现在压成2个。

结果不只是省工序。马斯克说,零件更少之后,车身更轻、更刚,操控更好,噪声振动控制更好,防水密封也更好。他把这称为“从根本上重新思考一辆车怎么造”。

数据上还有一个更直观的对比:现在生产一台Model Y所使用的机器人数量,大约是当年生产Model 3时的30%。

工厂布局也在改。奥斯汀这座工厂接近单体结构,物料流向是一条几乎笔直的线。弗里蒙特工厂什么都干,但流程复杂,绕来绕去,效率天然吃亏。新工厂从设计阶段就避开了这个问题。

马斯克把制造抬到了战略高度。

所有人都会造电动车,所有厂商最终都会有电动车。所有车最终也都会变成自动驾驶,只是比他们以为的要慢。真正最难被复制的东西,是特斯拉的制造技术。(马斯克)

他给了投资者一个判断科技公司的土办法:看最聪明的工程师想去哪里工作。哪个队能签下最好的球员,哪个队就会赢。特斯拉去年收到300万份求职申请,他还提到,SpaceX和特斯拉之间允许员工互相流动,想造火箭的可以去造火箭,想造车的可以去造车。

工厂安全他也提了。特斯拉现在的工厂安全指标在行业里领先,改进的主要来源是鼓励一线员工提安全建议,今年已经超过每位员工三条建议的目标。

10.69版本,和Chuck那个左转

FSD(Full Self-Driving,完全自动驾驶)是全场呼声最高的部分。马斯克问台下有多少人在FSD beta项目里,举手的人不少。

他先讲了版本号。本来大家等的是10.13,但他表示这次架构改动很大,可能够格直接跳到10.69。这个数字在特斯拉社区里是个梗,他也没有回避,说版本号得自己挣来,不能白给。

技术细节里最关键的是一个著名的左转路口,社区里叫Chuck's turn。这个无保护左转路口一直是FSD的噩梦,马斯克说目前的成功率大约90%,接近100%了。台下欢呼。他接着说可能下周就能搞定,然后自己补了一句“所以是两周”,全场笑。这是马斯克的老梗,他说的“两周”通常不是两周。

更值得琢磨的是他对技术路线的解释。为什么坚持只用摄像头和硅基神经网络,不用激光雷达?

道路系统是为生物神经网络和眼睛设计的。所以自然的结论是,能匹配这个系统的硅基版本,就是摄像头加硅基神经网络。我们其实是在解决人工智能里一个非常重要的部分,真实世界的AI。(马斯克)

他把这件事的意义放得很大:自动驾驶如果比人类驾驶安全一个数量级,可以拯救数百万人的生命,避免数千万起严重伤害。

他用电梯做了类比。早年每部电梯都要配一个操作员,拉一个继电器,偶尔出事故把人切成两半。后来电梯自动化了,按个按钮就到楼层,没有人觉得奇怪。汽车也会走到这一步。

安全数据这一段信息密度很高。特斯拉称自己的车是美国政府测试过的所有车型里受伤概率最低的。真正的差别出在联网上,特斯拉的车全部联网,发生碰撞后能回传数据,工程师能看到碰撞结构哪里可以改进,然后通过OTA更新去优化安全带预紧逻辑和气囊展开策略。

今年新增的一件事是,Autopilot的AI开始预判碰撞。如果系统以99%以上的概率判断碰撞即将发生,会提前收紧安全带、展开气囊。绝大多数车只能在碰撞已经发生的瞬间展开气囊,那种展开方式更暴力,伤害更大。能预判,就能把气囊做得更温和。

FSD beta的累计里程已经超过4000万英里,马斯克预计今年会超过1亿英里。他重申了年底的目标:北美地区,任何申请FSD beta的人都能用上。

太阳能发的电,比造车和充电用掉的还多

这一部分马斯克讲得很动情,因为数据确实有点反直觉。

把过去十年特斯拉太阳能板发出的电全部加起来,比制造特斯拉所有车辆、以及在超充和家里给这些车充电所消耗的电,还要多。

这真的很惊人。特斯拉的使命是加速可持续能源,我们发的电比造车和充电用掉的还多,车跑了几十亿英里。(马斯克)

他给出了可持续能源未来的三个支柱:可持续能源生产,主要是太阳能和风能;固定式储能电池,解决风光发电的间歇性;电动交通。三个都有,就是一个完整的可持续未来。

电池回收这块,他纠正了一个常见误解。很多人以为电动车电池没法处理,实际上电池包是高度可回收的,可以把它当成高品位矿石,粉碎岩石和粉碎电池包,后者划算得多。内华达工厂现在每周回收50多个电池包,量不大,原因是电池寿命太长,通常要等12年,有时15年,绝大多数电池还在车上服役。回收业务现在是起步,长期会变得很重要。

Master Plan 3(宏图第三篇章)的定位他讲得比较克制,说还没完全准备好,可能这个月能完成。核心是从全球宏观经济角度算总账:要实现一个完全可持续的经济,需要多少吨锂、多少正极、负极、隔膜、电解液,需要做哪些事。

他特别提到为什么要讲这件事。他遇到太多人已经失去希望,觉得来不及了,地球没救了。

地球不会完蛋。地球能够被拯救,也一定会被拯救。(马斯克)

董事会主席Robyn Denholm在开场时给了一组数据做注脚。去年特斯拉全球车队、储能和太阳能产品帮客户避免了840万公吨温室气体排放,相当于减少200亿英里的燃油车行驶。去年储能产品卖了4吉瓦时,够300万户家庭用电,四年增长近四倍,占全球吉瓦时部署的15%以上。2030年的目标是每年卖2000万辆电动车。

通胀见顶了吗

问答环节里最有宏观价值的一段,是马斯克谈通胀。

他判断的依据来自采购端,跟宏观模型关系不大。造几百万辆车,必须提前几个月锁定大宗商品,供应链惯性极大,所以特斯拉对价格走向有一点前瞻视野。

他现在看到的是:超过一半的原材料,六个月后的价格趋势是向下的。

大多数大宗商品、大多数进入特斯拉的东西,不是全部,但超过一半,六个月后的价格在往下走。这说明我们已经过了通胀峰值。做宏观预测是灾难的配方,但我的猜测是,通胀峰值已经过去。(马斯克)

衰退他也给了判断:会有,但比较温和,大概18个月。

他给了一个和2008年对比的理由。2008年之前美国存在根本性的资本错配,建房速度是家庭形成速度的两倍,明显不合理,企业杠杆也很高。现在企业负债水平相对低,没有那种系统性的错配。所以他的结论是温和到中等程度的衰退,通胀会快速回落。

Optimus会掀翻“经济”这个词

这一段最能代表马斯克本人的思维方式。

他说自己有点意外,分析师们没有真正理解Optimus(人形机器人)的重要性。

我的猜测是,长期看Optimus会比车更有价值。它会颠覆我们对“经济”这个概念的整个理解。经济就是人均GDP,一旦劳动力不再稀缺,一旦没有资本约束,经济规模可以任意大。(马斯克)

逻辑链条是这样的。现在的乘用车,一周大概只用12个小时,其余时间都停在停车场里,因为车需要司机。如果车能自动驾驶,使用时长可能拉到50到60个小时,效用提升四五倍,但车的成本没变。这意味着自动驾驶车的毛利率会高到难以想象。

运营模式上,他预期是Airbnb和Uber的结合体。你可以完全拥有,可以偶尔租出去,可以大部分时间租出去,也可以完全不拥有、只在需要时叫一辆。车主自己决定把车放进车队还是拿出来。

Optimus把同样的逻辑推到劳动力市场。如果劳动力不稀缺,经济增长的约束条件就变了。他甚至开玩笑说,也许Optimus可以按小时出租。

关于Robotaxi的第一个试点城市,他没有给具体地名,理由是特斯拉做的是通用方案,不针对某个城市调参。各地监管审批速度不同,所以上线时间会有先后,但技术本身是通用的。

如果你生成一个随机的平行地球,只要它大致遵守现在地球的规则,我们的系统照样能开。(马斯克)

对未来十年的产量,他给了一个数:超过1亿辆。他的原话是,如果十年后不到1亿辆,他会感到意外。

八份股东提案,和一场没有悬念的投票

会议前半段的正式议程值得单独说,因为它暴露了特斯拉治理结构里一个长期存在的张力。

13项提案里,8项是股东提案,董事会对每一份都建议投反对票。最终结果,除了第2、3、6项,其余全部按董事会建议通过。

第2项是把董事任期从三年缩短到两年,第3项是取消绝对多数投票门槛。这两项董事会自己是支持的,出席股份里98%和97%都投了赞成,但没达到全体流通股三分之二的门槛,卡住了。

第6项是股东提出的代理权准入(proxy access),董事会反对,没通过。

代理权准入的提案人James McRitchie在线上发言,指出标普500里79%的公司已经允许符合条件的长期股东提名董事,特斯拉没有。提案要求很低:连续三年持有3%以上股份的股东,可以提名董事,提案正文限500字,不具约束力,具体防护条款由董事会自己加。

他还点出一个更尖锐的问题。2020年取消绝对多数要求的提案拿到56%的支持,2021年董事会去分级(declassify)的提案赢了,但董事会都没有真正执行,今年又拿出来投,还改成了“每两年选一次”的折中版。他的原话是:多大比例的多数,才能让董事会行动?

其余七份提案,每份都指向一个具体的治理或合规问题。

纽约州共同退休基金要求披露反骚扰和反歧视工作的有效性。发言引用了2021年10月加州一起歧视案的判决,陪审员听到的证据显示弗里蒙特工厂“充满种族主义”,管理层没有介入,有的主管还参与其中。平等就业机会委员会(EEOC)已经立案调查,加州公平就业和住房部也提起了诉讼。

Arjuna Capital要求披露董事会多元化的目标和进展。数据是:董事会25%是有色人种,25%是女性;员工里60%是有色人种。全美至少12个州已经出台或在考虑董事会多元化要求,纳斯达克要求至少两名多元化董事。

Nia Impact Capital要求披露强制仲裁的使用情况。核心论点是,强制仲裁让歧视案件的事实和结果都保密,其他员工学不到,集体诉讼也被堵死,系统性问题可以一直藏着。

Nathan Cummings基金会要求披露游说活动和气候目标的匹配度。特斯拉在CPA-Zicklin企业政治披露指数上拿了0分,满分70分。发言还引用了马斯克2021年接受《华尔街日报》采访时的原话,说“特斯拉没人提过这个法案,我们根本不想这事”,指的是拜登政府的《重建更好法案》。

支持工会权利的提案由Christine Pawley录制视频发言。她指出,全国劳资关系委员会(NLRB)已经裁定特斯拉恐吓、威胁、报复员工以阻止工会化;特斯拉的人权政策里没有结社自由和集体谈判的表述,供应商行为准则里有,但只约束供应商,不约束自己,这是双重标准。

Good Shepherd修女会要求披露2025年前消除供应链童工的计划,焦点是刚果民主共和国的钴矿。特斯拉面对一起集体诉讼,被指在供应链中协助和教唆童工死亡与重伤。

JCD Investments要求按地点披露用水数据。理由很实在:特斯拉很多工厂建在水资源紧张的地区,公司层面汇总的用水效率数据没有意义,每个地点的水风险完全不同,投资者没法评估实质风险。

这八份提案全部被否,但提案人讲的内容构成了这次会议的另一条叙事线。特斯拉在高速扩张的同时,治理、合规、劳工、供应链这几块的透明度,和它的市值体量并不匹配。

问答环节的真问题

现场和线上提的问题里,有几个信息量很大。

关于现金怎么用。马斯克说特斯拉的收购极少,SolarCity是唯一的大收购,其次是Tesla Grohmann,90%的增长是有机的。他对收购标的的偏好很明确:擅长制造自动化、软件、AI、制造技术的公司。资本开支和研发投入已经在尽可能快地花,快到再快就是浪费的程度。股票回购“有可能”,但他不想承诺,前提是确认没有不可抗力事件、未来现金流稳固、世界相对稳定。

关于要多少个工厂才能做到2000万辆。大约十几个。目标是每个工厂150万到200万辆年产能。弗里蒙特受空间限制,大概只能做到70到80万辆。

关于Cybertruck的定价。2019年发布时预订金是99美元,现在规格和价格都会变。他直接说了坏消息:通胀幅度超出预期,没法维持原价。但他补了一句,Cybertruck会是一台“了不起的机器”,明年年中在奥斯汀工厂量产,未来几个月开始安装产线设备。

关于4680电池。每周产量已经不错,年底会进入高量产阶段。但他明确说,今年这不构成产能约束,供应商的电芯足够造150万辆车。4680的重要性在明年。

关于继任。这是Future Fund的Gary Black提的,他说基金最担心的不是公关风险,是关键人风险。马斯克的回答是,他会在还能有用的时候留在特斯拉,最有用的地方是产品设计、工厂设计和制造优化。他说即使自己被外星人绑架或者回了母星,特斯拉也会继续做得很好,但承认这个问题没有简单答案。

我没打算离开,这一点要说清楚。(马斯克)

关于Twitter。他先澄清自己只持有两家上市公司的证券:特斯拉和Twitter,不是对冲基金,也不是私募基金。他说自己用Twitter很多,也经常搬起石头砸自己的脚,但他理解这个产品,知道该把工程团队往哪个方向带。他提到一个更早的构想,X.com的宏大愿景,Twitter能把这个构想加速三到五年。

关于Dojo。现阶段目标很聚焦:把视频训练做到极致。他说特斯拉现在的AI训练算力大概排在全球第四,正在逼近第三,用的是海量GPU。Dojo的第一目标是让神经网络训练比一堆GPU更高效。他强调Dojo是从底层为神经网络训练专门设计的计算机,这在业界此前没有过。

有人问车与车之间能不能通信,像飞机那样互相广播位置。马斯克的回答是,这对FSD完全不需要,路上绝大多数车还是人开的,车际通信的价值主要在传递路况信息:前方有事故、有坑、有封路,后面的车实时收到,不至于堵死。这套东西特斯拉在做。

关于Boring Company。他把这家公司的定位讲清楚了:让道路三维化,地下可以有任意多层隧道,理论上能解决任何城市的交通问题。地面上大量街道和停车场可以改造成公园。拉斯维加斯已经有一条在运营的隧道,从Resorts World到会展中心。

关于超充。超充的正常运行时间极高,因为桩始终联网,故障反馈闭环很快。V3已经在用,V4可能明年开始铺。超充数量每年翻倍。选址靠每天分析使用数据,但在部分地区拿许可极难,马里布一个点花了好几年。他现场答应做一次线上投票,让用户决定优先建在哪里。洛杉矶还计划做一个带餐厅的超充站,风格被他形容为“银翼杀手遇上希腊遇上杰森一家”,配大屏幕放影史百大电影片段,不买特斯拉的人也能来吃饭。

关于热回收。有人问工厂压铸机的余热能不能用于涂装线的烘干炉。马斯克说这个思路对,属于未来的优化项。他举了车上的例子:冬天续航靠的是同时给电池包充电和加热,让电池包同时充当电储库和热储库,热量在电机、电控、电池包和座舱之间来回搬运。同样的逻辑应该用到工厂。

关于普通人能做什么。最后一个问题问的是,除了买股票、买特斯拉、去特斯拉上班,普通人还能怎么推动这件事。马斯克的回答是支持可持续能源,并且传播乐观。

我不是在提倡躺平。我的意思是,如果我们真的努力朝可持续的未来走,我们就一定能实现它,未来是光明的。(马斯克)

把这场会当成一份检查清单

这场股东大会的信息可以分成两类。一类是当期的经营数据,一类是马斯克对未来下的判断。前者可以核对,后者要打折扣,但都值得记下来当检查项。

  • 盯住年底的产能数字。马斯克承诺的是年底200万辆年化产能,实际全年交付大约150万辆。这两个数字的差距,是判断2023年增长斜率的第一个锚点。
  • 把FSD beta里程当成领先指标。会上给的是4000万英里,年底目标1亿英里。里程爬升速度比版本号更能说明问题,因为它直接反映车队规模和用户实际使用频率。
  • 关注AI Day 2的Optimus和Dojo细节。马斯克把Optimus的价值排在车之上,但没给时间表。下一次AI Day是验证这属于愿景还是工程进度的场合。
  • 用大宗商品价格验证通胀判断。马斯克说超过一半原材料六个月后的价格在往下走。这个判断可以直接对照铜、铝、锂、镍的远期合约,比看CPI更早。
  • 把4680的量产节点记在2023年。今年它不构成约束,明年才关键。如果明年4680仍然爬不上量,得重新评估特斯拉的成本曲线。
  • 看Cybertruck的实际定价。马斯克已经提前打了通胀的预防针,明年年中量产的定价会告诉我们特斯拉在皮卡市场打算用什么价位切入。
  • 读一遍那八份被否的股东提案。它们写的是特斯拉治理结构的短板,包括仲裁透明度、董事会多元化、游说披露、供应链劳工。这些议题不会因为投票被否就消失,往后几年大概会反复出现。
  • 判断一家公司,先用它的产品,再看它的财报。这是马斯克在会上说的,也是他给散户打的那个高分。这句话有自我美化的成分,但作为筛选公司的第一步,它确实比大多数卖方研报好用。

至于马斯克本人,这场会里他讲得最实在的一句话,是关于短期波动的。他说人们太在意某个季度、某个供应商短缺、某个地区的停产,这些放在十年尺度上都是路上的小坑。公司是未来现金流的净现值,一个季度说明不了什么。他还说,如果看到大家恐慌,那不是“我的股票跌了”,那是买入机会。

这句话对不对,取决于你买的是什么公司。但至少在这次会上,特斯拉给出的产能曲线、利润率、制造工艺和FSD里程,是能被验证的东西。愿景可以打折,这些数字不能。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:40[Music] so [Music] do [Music] do [Music] so [Music] [Applause]

5:57so [Music] so [Music] good afternoon everyone and welcome to tesla's 2022 annual shareholder meeting my name is martin dieka i'm the vice president of investor relations and i'll be the chair of today's meeting we're super excited that finally after two years we get to get a proper attended meeting this year with so many people in the audience

13:59we have more people in the audience this year than we've ever had before but first and foremost i just really wanted to thank all of our investors and particularly our retail shareholders that have been so that i think just so supportive so supporting even just so engaged over the years and especially to those who have cast their ballot in the last few weeks each vote really matters so you know thank you so much for taking time to cast your ballot and do your part in the annual vote and we're hopeful that from now on every year you will be casting your ballot there will be two parts of today's meeting first we're going to do the formal part of the meeting

14:44which will cover 13 items that investors are going to be asked to vote on and after the voting i will introduce tesla's co-founder and ceo elon musk who will give a presentation [Applause] who will give a presentation about tesla and the year in review at this time i would like to thank members of the tesla team and the board who are here with us today a representative from pricewaterhousecoopers tesla's independent auditor is present on the phone as well but before we begin i would like to introduce you to our chair robin denholm chair of tesla's board who would like to say a few words [Applause]

15:37okay this is the short part of the agenda so so thank you martin and good afternoon everyone it's my great pleasure to welcome you all to tesla's 2022 annual shareholder meeting and i am delighted that we are here in person again this year and i'm also really thrilled to see so many of you with us today here in giga texas in austin and so because we know that not everyone can join us in person we would need a very large stadium to actually have everyone and because we have a lot of investors as well around the country and around the planet we actually have also got a lot of shareholders online today and i'd like to welcome them to this meeting as well so a big welcome to all

16:30of our virtual attenders i would also like to thank our amazing investors and acknowledge you because without you we would not be here today it is because of your support that we have become the company that we are and that we have been able to make so much progress against our mission of accelerating the world's transition to sustainable energy last year alone our global fleet of vehicles energy storage and solar panels enabled our customers to avoid emitting 8.4 million metric tons of greenhouse gas emissions and to put that in context that means that we avoided emissions by using tesla products last year it was the equivalent of driving gas-powered cars for 20

17:30billion miles and that is 20 billion with a b [Applause] and as as you all know that we are still in the very early phases of this transition and as i mentioned last year by 2030 we aim to sell 20 million electric vehicles per annum and we're making great progress towards achieving this goal in june of this year we achieved the highest vehicle production month in our history despite supply headwinds and despite the shutdowns in shanghai and we continue to ramp our factories both here in austin as well as in germany and most people know tesla for our cars but we are also making a great big impact with our solar and energy storage business as well

18:33last year alone tesla sold 4 gigawatt hours of energy storage products that represents enough energy to power three million homes tesla's energy storage deployments have nearly quadrupled in the last four years and last year represented over 15 percent of the gigawatt hours globally over the past decade tesla's solar panels have generated more electricity than has been consumed by our factories and by all of the tesla cars fleet on the road combined so in theory today all u.s domestic electricity needs as well as the vehicle and transportation needs could be met by solar power alone we're also continuously working on reducing the cost of our solar and storage products

19:30in order to foster mass adoption using renewable energy sources like solar and wind with battery storage it's fast becoming the cheapest energy option available and as we continue to bring our costs down more consumers will be able to not only have a positive impact on the environment but it will also make economic sense from to use renewable energy

20:06as we discussed in our impact report we're constantly working to improve not only the positive impact of our products but also to reduce the energy and water consumption that we are using in our manufacturing process in fact our goal is to be is for all of our factories to be carbon neutral and to that end we are continuously innovating for energy efficiency by building increasingly sustainable factories covering our rooftops with solar panels leveraging ai to reduce the energy consumption and utilizing renewable energy as much as possible throughout all of our operations in our newest factories we already use less water per vehicle than most almost

20:58any other traditional car maker and we are continuously exploring ways to reduce water further throughout our operations including optimizing and eliminating processes that are water intensive harvesting rain water and also reusing reclaimed and recycled water sustainability is our main driver and motivator it drives everything that we do it drives our values and our mission as a company it drives at all of our employees our shareholders our customers and it underscores everything that we do as directors this month marks my eighth anniversary as a director at tesla and i along with my fellow board members many of whom are here today and online

21:51who are here with us today and we could not be more proud to serve as your board to help ensure that the framework of governance needed to succeed in our mission our governance model has enabled us to remain focused on making decisions that matter often bold decisions that unlock growth potential decisions like engineering and manufacturing evs from the ground up rather than being just a supplier of components by building the world's largest lithium-ion battery factory today and so that we can scale our operations efficiently making investments in an international network of stores service centres and supercharging stations to expand customer convenience and access

22:51and we remain dedicated to advancing your interests your shareholder interests and firmly believe that good governance is a hallmark of sustainability driving long-term value protecting shareholder interests and ensuring our actions are aligned with our values [Applause] and as directors we listen to and value your voice and and input and whether it be by submitting comments and questions during our earnings calls or communicating with us through our board portal or attending and interacting with us at events like this and this shareholder meeting today i'm excited also to announce that we have recently launched a new shareholder platform to facilitate your interaction

23:48with management participating in company events and receiving information directly relevant to you as a shareholder you'll be hearing more updates on this platform in the near future once thank you once again i want to thank you for your support and for continuing to be our partner along this incredible and important journey i would also like to take this opportunity to thank all of tesla's amazing employees around the world you are the lifeblood of all of our achievements as a company you're phenomenal [Applause]

24:47and lastly i would also like to thank larry ellison who has diligently served as a director over the last three years your contributions have helped have helped us as a board and also as a company greatly and with that i want to hand it over to martin again thank you [Applause] thank you very much robin i will now call the meeting to order the time is now 4 42 central time pm

25:26and i declare that the polls are now open we have already received over the past few weeks voting proxies from our stockholders meaning that almost all the votes have been counted were already submitted before this meeting however if you wish to vote your shares or if you would wish to change your vote you may do so through the virtual meeting site for those here in person ballots and ballot boxes were made available for you prior to the meeting tesla's board of directors has appointed computer share trust company to serve as an inspector of election for this meeting computer share has taken and signed an oath as inspector of election and has certified that starting on june

26:1023rd 2022 the proxy materials or the notice of internet availability of the proxy materials well-mailed all provided to all tesla stockholders as of record day of june 6 2022. we have majority of outstanding shares represented at the meeting so i declare that there's a quorum present and that we may proceed with a meeting the items on the agenda are as follows

26:38number one the election of two class three directors ira enterprise and kathleen wilson thompson to serve for a term of three years or until their respective successors are duly elected and qualified if proposal 2 of the agenda is approved then mr enterprise and miss wilson thompson would serve for a term of two years or until their respective successors are duly elected and qualified number two to adopt amendments to our certificate of incorporation there is two to reduce director terms to two years number three to adopt amendments to a certificate of incorporation and bylaws to eliminate applicable super majority voting requirements number four

27:29to adopt to adopt a madman or certificate certificate of incorporation to increase the number of authorized shares of common stock by four billion common shares number five to ratify the appointment of pricewaterhousecoopers llp tesla's independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year 2022

27:53tesla's board has recommended that our stockholders vote for each of the director nominees and four each of those proposals we have also received eight stockholder proposals as described in our proxy statement i would like to remind our stockholders that tesla's board has prepared a statement in opposition to each of those proposals which appear in our proxy statement the first stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding proxy access our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal this doctor stockholder proposal is proposed by james mcritchie who is on the line to present the proposal mr mcritchie i would like to invite you

28:38to speak you have three minutes thank you tesla's opposition statement says the board recognizes proxy access is a topic of growing interest in the investor community unlike 79 percent of the s p 500 our board has failed to adopt any provision to provide shareholders with a real voice in directly nominating board members our representatives and on taxes corporate governance instead the board promises to continue to monitor the topic tesla further argues our proposal provides no safeguards against corporate raiders to affect the change in control nonsense our proposal is limited by law to 500 words it simply asks the board to allow long-term shareholders who've owned at

29:36least three percent of tesla continuously for three years or more to be able to nominate directors nothing in the proposal is binding past it is up to the board to add necessary safeguards as boards have done at hundreds of other companies getting more than 50 percent of the shareholder vote may mean little at tesla our proposal to eliminate super majority requirements that tesla won 56 of the vote at our 2020 meeting yet we are still voting on it this year

30:13our insiders at tesla voting to block adoption our proposal to declassify the board won at the 2021 meeting yet the board now wants a halfway measure instead of voting on directors every year the board wants it to be every other year how large of a majority is required to move our board to action because of the board's inaction proxy advisors iss and glass lewis recommended against the directors of for election at this meeting and against the halfway measure toward declassifying the board as stated in the practice proposal two of our largest shareholder proposals blackrock our shareholders blackrock and vanguard voted in favor of 87 and 91 of sheryl's proposal to establish proxy

31:11access during the last three and a half years additionally proxy advisors iss last lewis and egan jones all recommend a vote for proposal number six at this meeting let's cut the ball give shareholders a direct voice in nominating directors vote for proposal number six proxy access at tesla is long overdue thank you thank you mr richie the second stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding annual reporting on anti-harassment and discrimination efforts our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal this stockholder proposal is proposed by the new york state common retirement fund whose representative emily bogan is

32:02on the line to present the proposal miss bogan i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes afternoon on behalf of new york state comptroller thomas napoli trustee of the new york state common retirement fund owner of over a million shares of tesla valued at approximately 1.2 billion dollars i'm presented for level 7 on the proxy the proposal requests a report describing and quantifying the effectiveness and outcomes of company efforts to prevent harassment and discrimination and protected classes employees including but not limited to sexual harassment and racial discrimination testless 2020 diversity equity and impact support states quote

32:46insists on equitable practices not just because it's the right thing to do but because fair processes allow our team members to bring their whole selves to work we value and include underrepresented under-represented communities at all levels of our company meanwhile there have been multiple news reports allegations and lawsuits in recent years considering gender and race determination aircraft these include a federal district court recently concluding that there was ample disturbing evidence toward the outcome of a california discrimination trial in october of 2021 at which jurors heard that the tesla factory in fremont was saturated with racism and that

33:22supervisors at tesla's broader management failed to help the judge added our supervisors even joined in on the accused additionally the u.s equal opportunity commission has initiated an open investigation into tesla for alleged workplace discrimination at its facilities finally after receiving hundreds of tesla's workers complaints the california department of fair employment and housing is suing the company over allegations discrimination and harassment of black employees at a san francisco bay area factory shareholders need the information requested for the following reasons first it has been reported that most tesla workers are subject to mandatory

33:59arbitration agreements consequently transparency at the extent of workforce management is limited secondly civil rights violations within the workplace can result in substantial cost to companies including fines and penalties legal costs cost related absenteeism and productivity thirdly a company's failure to properly manage its workforce can damage corporate goodwill making it more difficult to retain and recruit employees and jeopardize its relationship with its customers at parker lastly a deloitte global executive survey on strategic risks found that the number one risk concern for business executives surveyed from around the world is reputation damage

34:37all these reasons shareholders want increased transparency transparency into the requested data policy and practices so we can better evaluate whether the board is effectively oversight obligations its efforts to translate efforts translate into improved performance in managing its workforce notification and whether there's alignment between tesla stating policies and actions thank you for your consideration thank you misspoken the third stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding annual annual report on board diversity our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal the stockholder proposal is proposed by

35:17alex lamp whose representative julia cederholm from arjuna capital is on the line to present the proposal ms cedarholm i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes good afternoon my name is julia peterholm from investment management firm arjuna capital and i move proposal eight asking the company to report on policies and practices to improve board diversity that is to attain racial and gender representation better aligned to the demographics of its employees and customers board diversity efforts are in the best interest of tesla and its investors numerous studies show greater diversity leads to better company performance and

35:58increased shareholder value regulation has increased as the value of war diversity becomes more evident at least 12 states have enacted or are considering board diversity requirements and the nasdaq requires companies attain at least two diverse directors but more is needed in a country comprised of 51 women and 42 minorities current board diversity aspirations fall short a board of directors whose diversity is reflective of its employee and customer base is better positioned to outperform when a board includes diverse members it can better recognize the unique needs and interests of its stakeholders that is why 61 of investors believe boards should aim to reflect companies

36:37customer base and broader societies in which they operate according to the survey by institutional shareholder services unfortunately tesla's board diversity is disproportionate with its employee base in u.s demographics the board remains majority white and majority male despite a majority minority employee base the board is made up of 25 percent racially or ethnically diverse directors far below its employee base which is 60 minorities the board is also made up of only 25 percent women additionally tesla currently faces litigation with california state for failing to deal with allegations of systemic racism and sexism at the automaker it's crucial tesla addresses these

37:17issues head on at the highest level of governance its board of directors while the company has said it's committed to board diversity there are no quantitative board diversity goals such goals and transparent reporting are needed to create progress over time and hold the company accountable to its investors employees and customers i urge you to support proposal 8 requesting tesla further diversify its board to reflect its employee and customer base such action can better position our company to respond to stakeholders needs and concerns and ultimately improve performance thank you for your support and proposal eight thank you mr cedelholm the fourth stockholder proposal is an

37:54advisory vote report regarding reporting on employee arbitration our board has recommended to vote against this stockholder proposal the stockholder proposal is proposed by nia impact capital whose representative christine hall is here he is here to present the proposal dr hall i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes

38:24hello i'm dr kristen hull founder and ceo at nia impact capital on behalf of nia and our co-filers i formally move proposal number nine as an investor i'm here today like many of you because we believe in the strength of this company to lead in the transition to the next sustainable economy this resolution requests that tesla's board of directors oversee the preparation of a report on the use of mandatory arbitration for dis dissolving disputes between workers and the company your yes vote today will impact tesla for the better and here's why significant concerns have been raised about the persistence of racism and racist actions at tesla there have been many recent

39:11discrimination claims including california's department of fair employment which alleges that hundreds of black tesla employees have been discriminated against in job assignments with disciplinary actions with regard to pay and being passed up for promotions allegations also include the use of racial slurs and racist graffiti also troubling may be a culture of retaliation where employees who have raised these issues with management at hr have claimed being retaliated against

39:46given the grave allegations it's time that investors get a look under the hood or the frunk as it would be with tesla when disputes are handled via arbitration the underlying facts and outcomes of the cases often remain secret preventing other employees from learning about and taking action on shared concerns arbitration precludes employees from suing in court and it blocks class actions allowing pervasive discrimination to continue stated simply arbitration of employee claims may allow bad corporate behavior to continue hidden from other employees and from investors bias discrimination and harassment in the workplace create uncompensated risks

40:34both for investors and as it seems to be invite legal brand and financial risks for our company tesla in this day and age we know strong human capital management is essential recruiting hiring and training an employee and then treating them in a way that inhibits their top performance even preventing them from doing their job well it doesn't make moral or financial sense tesla is known as we all know for its innovation and its leadership in technology and now tesla needs to rev up to solve this grave human capital issue tesla will need a smart well-run loyal and devoted workforce and of course loyal customer base to stay ahead and frankly racism has no place in a

41:26business seeking to lead our future we at nia ask again that the board evaluate the effects and the impact of arbitration on tesla's brand on its employees and on its workplace culture thank you thank you dr hall the fifth stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding reporting on lobbying our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal this stockholder proposal is proposed by the nathan cummings foundation whose representative lara campus is on the line to present the proposal miss campus i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes

42:12good evening i'm laura campos i am the director of the corporate and political accountability program at the nathan cummings foundation i'm participating in tesla's annual meeting to move proposal number 10 on behalf of the foundation and its co-filer green century proposal 10 requests that tesla's board of directors evaluate and report on tesla's direct and indirect lobbying and policy influence activities and how those activities align with the goal of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees celsius the proposal also seeks information on plans to mitigate risks presented by any misalignment that might be found here are just a few of the reasons we

42:53categorically disagree with the board's assertion that tesla does not need to evaluate and report on its lobbying and policy influence activities unlike most other companies of its size and influence tesla does not appear to have strong governance mechanisms in place to ensure its political activities including lobbying expenditures support its business model and its mission to accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy in fact the company earned an abysmal zero points out of a possible 70 on the most recent cpa ziklin index of corporate political disclosure and accountability tesla contends but a simple online search provides the information thought

43:34in this proposal that is incorrect to our knowledge the only information tesla discloses is found in its quarterly lobbying activity report which all active registrants are required to file these reports do not enable investors or the public to determine whether a company is taking a stance for or against a particular bill furthermore this reporting does not reveal whether tesla's advocacy is aligned with the paris agreement and it fails to shed any light at all on indirect lobbying tesla's message to investors when it comes to its political activities appears to be just trust us we're the good guys but that's simply not sufficient for a public company peers like gm and ford

44:17have substantially more disclosure in this area with more a public statement by tesla's ceo raised real questions about tesla's actual stance on legislation intended to support the world's transition to sustainable energy for instance in a 2021 wall street journal interview tesla's ceo expressed a lack of support for the buildback better act a centerpiece of the biden administration's efforts to address climate change in a statement indicative of the need for stronger governance mechanisms when it comes to political activities and lobbying tesla's ceo noted that quote no one at tesla has actually brought up whether they they care about this bill

44:58or not we don't think about it at all really end quote completing the requested evaluation would ensure that someone at tesla is thinking about the company's stance on critical pieces of major legislation that impacts not just the transition to sustainability this campus the three minutes have passed [Applause]

45:28thank you very much the sixth stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding the adoption of freedom of association and collecting bargaining policy our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal the stockholder proposal is proposed by christian paulie who has prepared a pre-recorded message

45:53hello shareholders members of the board my name is christine pawley with support of the shareholder association for research and education and co-founders at domini impact investments and soc investment group i wish to advance number 11 on tesla's proxy statement urging adoption of a policy to respect rights to freedom of association and collective bargaining in the company's operation [Music] these rights can enhance shareholder value through improving health and safety encouraging training and skills development increasing productivity promoting diversity equity and inclusion and strengthening human rights due diligence yet in the face of public allegations of

46:36tesla interfering in unionization efforts a national labor relations board ruling concluding that tesla intimidated threatened and retaliated against employees to prevent their organizing and the ceo's history of public comments on this topic to aid informed investment decisions investors require clarity on tesla's approach to these fundamental labor rights and management of related risks the board's response is caused for shareholder concern although the board states its commitment to human rights tesla's human rights policy omits mention of freedom of association or collective bargaining the board points to tesla's supplier code of conduct which does include

47:21respecting the rights of workers to form and join trade unions but in fact this policy does not apply to operations creating a double standard the nlrb findings already mentioned challenge the board's claim that the company complies with all applicable laws and often local laws fail to adequately protect these rights tesla's peers including ford general motors and goodyear explicitly reference freedom of association in their human rights policies which do apply to operations even non-unionized peers including toyota volkswagen and bmw have statements that respect right to freedom of association or collective bargaining that apparently apply to operations

48:08but tesla's governance gap on freedom of association and collective bargaining represents material reputational regulatory legal and operational risk and creates workforce uncertainty in the post-pandemic context of workforce organizing efforts at other major companies and growing interest in unionization an explicit commitment to freedom of association and collective bargaining is essential we urge the board to clarify the company's policies and practices to respect rights to freedom of association and collective bargaining in its operations fellow shareholders i urge you to vote for this proposal thank you thank you miss paulie the seventh stockholder proposal is an

48:54advisory vote regarding additional reporting on child labor our board has recommended that our stockholders vote against this stockholder proposal the stockholder proposal is proposed by the sisters of the good shepherd whose representative sister winifred dorothy is on the line to present the proposal sister dorothy i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes

49:22the quest for clean energy while honorable overtly perpetuates violations of children's human rights especially with regard to child labour good evening and thank you for this opportunity my name is winifred joherty and i am representing the sisters of the good shepherd new york province which is a tesla shareholder and the lead filer of this proposal requesting tesla issue a public report

49:58on how it will eradicate translator in this factory supply chain by 2025 i hereby move proposal 12 and encourage your support for this proposal i ask this ask is supported by the new york days common retirement fund and international rights advocates the sisters of the good shepherd support the education and sustainable development of children and their families in cobalt mining communities in the democratic republic of congo good shepherd mission partners have witnessed firsthand the harms on the health development and education of children who are exploited by child labour and chief labor and often enticed to work by a few coins the harsh working conditions

50:58lack of safety standards and reports of abuse place every child at risk poverty injury and in some cases even death is a daily reality article 32 of the rights of the child states that the child has the right to be protected from economic exploitation and from performing any work that is likely to be hazardous to or interfere with the child's education are to be helpful to the child's health our physical mental spiritual moral or social development despite tesla's claim that no child labour has been detected in this ev battery supply chains the company faces a class action lawsuit for allegedly aiding and abetting in the death and serious injury of children who

51:58claim they were working in cobalt mines in their supply chains as stated in the resolution child labor in the cobalt supply chain exposes tesla and you its investors to financial legal and reputational risks we demand supplier criteria that are binding enforceable and regularly monitored by independent auditors for compliance with international laws prohibiting child labour and with the company's own written policy sister dorothy i would like to remind you that three minutes have passed [Applause]

52:45thank you thank you sister dorothy and the final and the eighth stockholder proposal is an advisory vote regarding reporting on water risk our border our board has recommended to vote against this stockholder proposal this stockholder proposal is proposed by jcd investments whose representative elizabeth levi from su saw is on the line to present the proposal miss levi i would like to invite you to speak you will have three minutes

53:20good afternoon chairman members of the board my name is elizabeth levy thank you for the opportunity to present proposal number 13. climate change is causing more intense droughts globally and those droughts are predicted to worsen this climate change related water scarcity poses material risks to our company large water-reliant manufacturing plants including our companies are facing increasing competition from high-value uses such as drinking water and agriculture among others this competition for water resources will only become stronger tesla's automotive manufacturing uses significant amounts of water many of tesla's plants operate in water-stressed areas where our company's

54:05water use has generated public and ongoing controversy tesla supply chains are also increasingly subject to water risk while tesla has provided information on global water efficiency and is exploring ways to reduce water consumption shareholders have no meaningful way to put these actions into context generalized company-wide water use data does not address the issue of location-based risk each location in which tesla operates is unique in its water risk every region has different levels of water strain and scarcity use and competition with outside specific use information investors cannot accurately assess material risk such risks include the potential for

54:52operations destructions due to climate-related water depletion over-consumption or competition the company also fails to address how it can reduce the contentiousness of its interactions with communities in constrained areas which increasingly poses reputational risk to the company disclosing water use information will increase public good will and will provide investors with the data necessary to assess water related risk this is not a choice between making good vehicles and providing the requested data as one of the top 10 valued companies globally tesla has the resources and the know-how to do both thank you thank you miss levi please note that now is the final

55:36opportunity to submit any proxies in order for them to be counted i declare that the polls are now closed [Applause] based on the proxies that we have previously received i'd like to announce on preliminary basis there are stockholders approved have approved the recommendation of tesla board on all agenda items except item number two regarding the reduction of director terms to two years item three regarding elimination of applicable super majority voting requirements and item six for an advisory vote regarding proxy access well over 98 percent and 97 respectively of the shares present and entitled to vote on items two and three did so as recommended by the board

56:35unfortunately less than two-thirds of total outstanding shares which were required to approve these items submitted votes for these items after the final tabulation is completed we will formally announce the results of the voting by forming a form 8k within four business days of today's meeting that concludes the official business of today's shareholder meeting which is now adjourned [Applause]

57:13we will now move into the company update presentation by elon if you're currently joining through the virtual meeting site please go to tesla.com 2022 shareholder meeting to continue to watch the presentation during the course of the following session we may discuss our business outlook and make other forward-looking statements such statements are predictions based on our current expectations actual events or results could differ materially due to a number of reasons uncertainties including those disclosed in our most recent filing thank you with the sec such for-looking statements represents our views as of today should not be relied on thereafter

57:54and we disclaim any obligation to update them after today and with that please welcome elon musk

58:20welcome well i feel welcome so well it's great to see everyone here welcome [Applause] so yeah welcome to gigatexas [Applause] all right so let's see i'll go over kind of recount the year it's been an amazing year the tesla team has done amazing work and i have to say like one of the things that i was like what do you enjoy most in life i really being able to work with a super talented group of people and and manufacture those products and deliver them to people and make people happy from those products is is that that's one of the best things in life so [Applause]

59:49so yeah i'd just like to say what an honor it is to work with such a talented team at tesla and that's the reason we've been able to do all these things so yeah we're aiming to achieve a two million vehicle run rate by the end of the year [Applause] [Laughter] this is the best crowd i mean [Applause]

1:00:33i mean [Applause] [Laughter] i love you guys too so anyway thanks to the the hard work of the tesla team we've already been able to achieve a one and a half million unit annualized run rate and depending on how the rest this year goes we i think we might get close to or we'll get approximately at the one and a half million mark and and be exiting the year at a two million unit run rate and and then also worth noting just recently in the last a few weeks we made our three millionth car so

1:01:30you know the it's pretty wild to think like 10 years ago where things were you know 10 years august 2012 we'd we'd made 2500 roadsters and i think maybe a couple hundred model s's ish but less than 3 000 cars so 10 years ago it made less than 3 000 cars and here we stand 10 years later having made over 3 million [Applause]

1:02:16and actually actually this is one of the cleanest exponentials i've you know it it looks like one of those sort of you know business plan presentation things that that doesn't actually come true but you know you see it in the venture capital business plan situation but it's actually true that's the amazing part and yeah

1:02:51[Laughter] yeah we're doing okay on demand so thank you so yeah it's great here i love california too to be frank i'm gonna be clear you know oh come on we got great teams in california and and and we've got a great team in and china and shanghai and a great great team in berlin and germany and europe it's

1:03:36and i thought it's interesting to look at the the cumulative profitability since inception and this approximately track attracts to sort of mental pain actually this is psychic damage with that green curve is approximately correct but it it's it's i'm just very proud of the fact that we've actually been able to to to produce more cash than we have spent and have positive retained earnings and be worth our salt essentially and that that's a really big deal it's very hard so i mean this is this is a big deal and i think it's going to go up from here [Applause]

1:04:42so you can see we obviously had some challenges there in 2017 and then a bit but since then our free cash flow generation has been been very good and trending training upwards and and this is really before autonomy really kicks in we've we have autonomy to some degree but solving autonomy is

1:05:11will will really be an amplification of a free cash flow to degree that is you know you run the numbers and it's like wow can it really be that crazy but it could be that crazy and you know this this year i swear [Applause] [Music] anyone here in the fsd beta program [Applause] [Music] sweet yeah no totally totally totally okay well i i thought i thought [Applause] all right i thought i thought you might ask that so because it's 10.13 we've been working on for a while and and actually what's sort of happened is we've we've made some pretty significant architectural improvements so it's really going to be more than a 10.12 to 10.13 release it

1:06:20might not speak too soon it might qualify for 10.69 so [Applause] this is it's got to earn that obviously you can't just throw that out you know but it's it's it's there's a lot of a lot of improvements and especially in a complex left turns and yeah we were we're gonna solve chuck's turn yes yes i'm sad

1:06:58absolutely you know we have a lot of respect for valid criticism so and yeah so i i i i think we're at roughly 90 success rate with with your turn so yeah we're almost at 100. so so it's looking good and [Music] yeah so i mean i'm hopeful it might it might be a wheat next week so yeah two weeks so

1:07:33yeah it's working well for me so yeah it's anyway team's like working literally seven days a week and and making major improvements and it's really interesting because we're effectively solving an important aspect of artificial intelligence real world ai for self-driving which when you think about it kind of is what's needed to solve the to solve self-driving because how is the road system designed it's designed for a biological neural net and eyes and so naturally the thing that would therefore work the silicon analog is cameras and silicon neural nets and and so sort of sort of by accident we're actually solving an important i think very useful

1:08:33element of artificial intelligence and i definitely want people out there you know talented people are working on ai to consider working at tesla because i think we're solving just a very important part of ai and one that can ultimately save millions of lives and prevent tens of millions of serious injuries by by driving just an order of magnitude safer than than than people you know there used to be a time back in the day where we'd have yeah this is super important so

1:09:13i mean there used to be a time when we'd have elevator operators it was normal to have elevator operators and have like a big relay and stuff but you know every count every now and again you make a mistake and cheer somebody in half so i'd be like okay then we went to automated elevators and you press a button you go to your floor and it just works and and that's kind of how it's going to be in the future with cars and yeah so [Applause]

1:09:41and then we'll have lots of interesting things to say on ai day at the end of next month so i'll leave that next month yeah so you know when we started out here obviously we were talk to we were told electric cars were impossible and even if really if you could make a you know electric car with a couple hundred miles range then nobody would buy it anyway because people just love gasoline cars so you know when we started out it was it was dumb to start a car company and then dumb square to do an electric car company and we're told you're never going to make money etc and we didn't for a while but now we have the highest operating margin in the whole industry

1:10:26[Applause] exactly exactly it says there's not just a car company tesla's many companies in one and we're as much as a software company as we are a hardware company so and that's that's really going to be obviously essential for the future and software both in the car and obviously with neural net training but also software in the factory as well so you can think of the factory as a you know giant cybernetic collective so factory is just an enormous cybernetic collective of humans and machines and software and the better the software is the better that cybernetic collective works i don't think other oems think like that but that's what it is

1:11:25so you know there's a lot of talk of competition among elect electric vehicles but really it's the the evs are electrificals taking a market share from gasoline cars so yeah so the and from tesla's standpoint we obviously welcome this and we're very excited to see that other the big car companies are embracing electric vehicles if you were to re rewind their press releases to five years ago that was not the case they were you know say not saying nice things about electric vehicles five five years ago but now i believe almost every major car company in the world has embraced electric electrification and agrees that it is the right path and this is really what we set out to do

1:12:19with tesla you know it was not to like to cr you know get maximum market share or anything it was really try to get the to show the order industry that it was possible to go electric and that if you made compelling electric cars people would buy them and and and that's that's what's happened and i think that's really profound so yeah

1:12:49also when when our competitors advertise for electric vehicles every time they do that our sales go up so it's it's pretty funny so yeah but but we do we have open source a lot of patents so they can use our patents for free and so we're you know helping out and i think it's sort of a mutual prosperity thing and it's it's good so

1:13:17yeah so model y you don't you know definitely don't want to count chickens until they're hatched but i think we're tracking to have model y be the highest selling vehicle by revenue this year and the highest by unit volume next year [Applause] still a lot of work to do like these these factories don't just magically work so still a lot of work to do in berlin and and here in austin to spool up these two gigafactories and we've got different supply chains and so it's always there's a host of problems none of the problems are individually all that difficult but there's like 10 000 of them so it's the rate of production is like how fast can you solve the 10 000 problems

1:14:17essentially and we're solving pretty fast but a lot of work to do and yeah we might be able to announce another factory location later this year [Applause] [Music] [Applause] wait wait wait wait where should we okay where should we build it [Laughter] [Music] okay we got a lot of candidates [Laughter] [Applause] no i i'm half ca i'm half canadian so maybe i should you know but yeah well i think you know ultimately we'll we'll end up building i don't know probably at least 10 or 12 10 or 12 giga factories and they will there will be really gigafactories like output you know aiming for output average output of like one and a half to two million units per

1:15:31factory which is enormous so and the our fremont factory in california is already the highest output factory in north america so well i think we'll have a friendly competition between texas california berlin shanghai is hard to beat i have to say shanghai is a pretty our shanghai team is is just awesome so that they're yeah anyway great great team there so with respect to you know sometimes you get this sort of you know these bogus attacks of like evs are somehow worse than gasoline cars which is not true the average life cycle emissions of of an ev are dramatically lower than that of a gasoline car i'm kind of telling you things you already know

1:16:36but yeah every now and again you think surely this nonsense has been put to bed but it it it pops up again but it's obviously an electric car is just dramatically lower co2 or lifetime than than any than a gasoline car so anyway that's kind of obvious now this this is a thing that i think is super cool if you add up all the energy produced over the last 10 years buy a tesla solar panels it is more energy than was used to manufacture all of our cars and charge all of our cars at superchargers and at home this is

1:17:19i mean this is like and i mean the the mission of tesla is to accelerate sustainability and the i think this this is really amazing you know more energy produced than was used in making the car or and charging them all over billions of miles so and we're going to keep obviously increasing our solar activity and and vehicles and and try to keep these on par because the three elements of a sustainable energy future are sustainable energy production primarily with solar and wind and then a stationary battery packs to store the the the sustainable energy because of its wind and solar intermittent intermittent and then electric transport and if you have those

1:18:11three pillars you have a fully sustainable future and yeah so that's it's yeah and obviously battery packs are very recyclable they are there you can think of it like high grade ore do you want to you know crunch up a bunch of rocks or crunch up a battery pack which is like super high grade ore so it's a no-brainer to recycle battery packs and we are already recycling i should point this out so most people wonder what's happening we're already recycling at over 50 a week in nevada so tesla battery recycling is already underway has been underway and is scaling up now cars are lasting quite a long time so there's not that many batteries to actually recycle because you kind of

1:19:05have to typically wait like 12 years or something like quite a long time before the battery actually is no longer useful sometimes 15 years so recycling starts off small but then it becomes very significant long term so it's about some factory footage obviously just 50 packs a week yeah so yeah that's what i'm saying like this actually just not that many packs to recycle because there's not the vast majority of them are still in use

1:19:57all right oh yes exactly that's what i'm sorry where is that thing so so mass plan three is going to be fundamentally about scaling just looking at the overall problem from a global macro economic standpoint and saying what what are all the things that are needed to achieve a fully sustainable economy because i think a lot of people don't don't know and really like what tonnage of lithium of cathode anode separator electrolytes like electronics what are all the things that are needed that what all things that need to be done in order to transition to a fully sustainable global economy which i think you know the sooner we do that the better for the planet

1:20:59and i think just articulating that and and just making it clear that this is absolutely doable and it it is being done and we just want it to be done as fast as possible because i think a lot of times i mean i meet a lot of people out there who who have lost hope you know they think they think it's too late and they think there's there's no chance and the earth is doomed it's like it's not doomed okay it's yeah [Applause]

1:21:41yeah earth can and will be saved [Music] [Applause] so in addition to battery advancements and electronics advancements in ai we've also done a lot to simplify the structure of cars to make it easier to manufacture and one of the things we've done is create the the largest castings that have ever been done and they're very complex castings and so we're able to take a 171 pieces of metal and go from 171 pieces to two and in the process make it lighter stiffer with better ride handling better noise vibration harshness better sealing against water so it's really better in every way and yeah so [Applause]

1:22:46so and we're going to keep enhancing the the casting so this is a testament to our materials team and to our a lot of casting technology so really rethinking the whole way in which a car is made and it's a yeah it's a gigantic improvement we have at this point from going from say model s or even even model three we're at about thirty percent of the robots used for model three from for a current model y so yeah [Applause]

1:23:28we've also improved the layout of the factory so the factory is sort of a sort of a single mod well close to a single monolithic factory with a very straightforward flow freemont we we do a lot in fremont but the flow is complex and and and it's not not an easy flow so we're really rethinking the factory and i think if the the like the really long term sustainable advantage of tesla will be manufacturing i mentioned this before but obviously everyone will have electric cars all manufacturers will have electric cars and eventually it'll probably take longer than they think but eventually all cars will be self-driving and the thing that will be hardest to

1:24:17replicate is tesla's manufacturing technology so this is actually very important for from a long-term standpoint [Applause] you know when thinking about the competitiveness of companies especially if the companies are technology companies i recommend looking at where the smartest engineers want to work this is where wherever the the smartest engineers want to work that's going to be that that that technology company is going to be the one that is likely to succeed just like if it's a pro sports team where are the ace players going okay probably that team will win so we put a lot of effort into ensuring that the best engineers in the world want to work at at tesla and

1:25:14frankly sometimes tesla tesla's number one sometimes space section one but this is just like like last year but and we do actually for those curious and maybe want to work at either spacex or tesla we do allow people to move from one company to the other if they would like so if you want to spend a better time working on electric vehicles but at a time spending working on rockets you can that that's cool we support that so yeah

1:25:47and we've also made a lot of improvement with factory safety so we i think we believe we now have the the best factory safety in the industry and so we're yeah we're pretty excited to have you know very good safety and getting better so and a bunch of this is driven by just encouraging people within the factory to submit ideas for safety improvement and we've passed a goal of of three suggestions per employee in this year and this this is really is the game changer for improving safety so

1:26:34and [Applause] don't you don't have to clap after every slide unless you really want to but so we we there's a lot of interest in working at tesla with three million job applications last year so sorry yeah it's true so a lot of interest in working at tesla now some people may occasionally have encountered a supercharger that didn't work but in general the uptime of our superchargers is extremely good and we just try to make it super smooth and the because our superchargers are always connected like the car is always connected our feedback loop for fixing a supercharger is very quick and obviously we keep upgrading the supercharger capability we're now at

1:27:30version three we'll start rolling out version four i don't know maybe next year so they're just the superchargers get better and better and you know who knows that yeah actually i want to give away the [Laughter] let's just say that there's some there's some cool stuff happening on the supercharging front so

1:27:57alaska yes all right we we're we're basically doubling our supercharged account every year so if there isn't a supercharger in some place that you think is important it probably will be there soon so we've also made a lot of progress on safety so our cars are already the the safest in the industry so we have the lowest probability of injury of any cars ever tested by the us government and we update this in real time so we because our cars are connected this is a big difference all the other cars with rare exception are not connected so that so the manufacturers don't really know what happened in a crash but in the case of tesla we are able to look at crashes and

1:28:49see how can we improve the safety and you know look at the crashes and prove that the crash structure also we improve how the seat belts tension and how the airbags deploy so in these updates if we figure out oh there's a slightly better way to deploy the airbags to improve the safety in a crash we'll actually do an over there update to improve the way that the airbags deploy or the way that the seat belt pre-tensions and we're now starting to include our tesla autopilot ai to be able to see if a crash is about to occur and if it if it sees that the crash is about to occur with 99 plus percent probability then it will activate this the seat belt

1:29:39pre-tensioners and deploy the airbags as opposed to what the vast majority of cars do is the the only the vascular cars are only able to deploy airbags when the crash is happening and so that's that makes the airbag deployment a lot more violent but if you can anticipate the crash the airbag deployment can be much better than than just impact so [Applause]

1:30:14we're also seeing fsd beta grow very rapidly and this this is definitely going to go very exponential in miles driven so we're now at over 40 million miles and i suspect by this year we'll be i know well over 100 million miles so and we're still tracking very much to have a wide widespread deployment of fsd beta this year in north america so i'm yeah

1:30:48so i i should say if if basically fsd beta will be available to anyone who requests it by the end of this year so [Applause] so ai day part two i think people were blown away but that's at the end of next month so we'll leave that it should accept it's there's going to be a lot of cool stuff so

1:31:23the i'm sort of surprised that you know people or these like analysts out there are not really understanding the importance of the optimus robot my guess is optimus will be more valuable than the car than long term and in fact it will i think turn the whole notion of what's an economy on its head you know the point at which you have no shortage of labor you know economy is gdp per capita if you do not have a capital constraint then what the economy just is can be arbitrarily huge so yeah it's sort of crazy

1:32:14anyway and thank you for voting so your vote matters and and it's great to have direct contact with individual shareholders and thank you for for voting to support our proposals [Applause] so the next the next decade huh i wonder how many cars we'll have in 10 years 10 years ago we had less than three thousand cars now we've made three million three hundred million

1:33:08i say 100 million is pretty doable so i'd be surprised if i'd be surprised if it's not over 100 million in 10 years and then many other products some of which you've heard about some of which you have not so [Applause] all right so we've got some questions from the internet that were voted to the top so i'll answer these questions and then we'll take just quite questions from the audience and so one of the questions is how does tesla intend to utilize cash in the in the coming years will we increase cap edge capex well i guess you can read the question share of ibex dividends or acquisitions well it's interesting like tesla has actually done very few acquisitions

1:34:07apart from the solar city acquisition was the only really big acquisition we did and the next largest would be tesla groman but it's tesla's actually used a remarkably small amount of its equity to do acquisitions compared to other companies the vast majority of our growth basically 90 of our growth has been organic which i think is actually a really good thing but if we do see interesting companies we you know we will acquire them but it's quite rare for us to acquire a company but we are interested in companies that are very good at manufacturing automation software ai manufacturing technology in general that kind of thing we certainly will increase capex

1:35:00we are actually spending cap we're spending capex money and r d money as fast as we can do so without wasting it so this is not a constraint if we try to spend it any faster we'll just be wasting money so we're we're cranking hard on on capex and r d depending on what our future cash flow looks like i think a sort of sheriff buyback is is possible i wouldn't want to commit to that but well you know let's just make sure you know that there's not some force majira event somewhere you know we think we want to make sure we we have plenty of capital that and that future cash flow is looking very solid the and the world is relatively stable and then i think sure about buyback is

1:35:56is on the table yeah [Applause] so how many factories are necessary to achieve 20 million vehicles i think probably roughly a dozen so we're aiming for one and a half to two million units per factory now our factory in california we're just running out of room so it's it's hard to get more than maybe [Music] seven hundred or eight or seven or eight hundred thousand vehicles a year out of there but most most places will be aiming for one and a half to two so

1:36:45a dozen sites although we are aiming for giant monolithic buildings cyber truck pricing it was unveiled in 2019 and the and and the reservation was 99 so you know things have a lot has changed since then so the specs and the pricing will be different i you know hate to sort of give a little bit of bad news but i think there's there's no way to sort of haven't anticipated quite the inflation that we've seen and the various issues but what i can say is that the cyber truck will be one hell of a product and it's gonna be like a damn fine machine so yeah [Applause]

1:37:43and we're tracking to be in production middle of next year from this factory so that we're installing we're going to be installing the production equipment tooling and all starting the next couple months we'll begin the the installation so aiming to be in volume production middle next year so [Applause]

1:38:08now what could possibly go wrong in answering this question [Laughter] oh man all right so i should just pass well let me just say that you know i hope for peace and respect [Applause]

1:39:00fair enough [Applause] yeah yeah good advice so we're trying to we're deploying supercharges wherever we see the greatest need now sometimes the greatest need is in some place that is extremely difficult to get permits like the getting a permit in malibu was nuts like the next level that took years and so some places are hard to get permits and some places are easier but we are aiming to just generally we analyze the supercharger usage every day and and we prioritize supercharged locations according to where we see the greatest need with respect sorry where well you know maybe we should do an online poll for where is it where should we put superchargers

1:40:17yeah let's go okay we'll do that so i mean with respect to amenities for with supercharges i think we'll do a couple of just fun fun things like we're gonna do a really fun supercharger location in la and the general vision is to have something that's like a futuristic kind of like diner sort of like i don't know blade runner meets greece meets jetsons yeah you know something cool different and but with some style and and where you can you know get you know so some great food and the one in l.a we're planning to have like these big screens at the supercharged location and the screens will be aiming to show like the 100 greatest movie clips of all time and so you can

1:41:10like you know have a cheeseburger and charge your car and watch some cool stuff on the screen and it'll be open to others who are not you know you can come to the restaurant if even if you don't own a tesla but it'll be like a like a little gem i think there in in la and and then depending on how that goes we'll you know we might roll that out to a few other places we'll try to interesting fun things that are not necessarily economically sensible but they're cool

1:41:48so 4680 the this is a this is not an easy one to answer we are making a decent number every week and i think we will be in high volume production by the end of this year it's always difficult to predict this is because a lot of new technology what's the slope of the s-curve on ramp and except that i'm confident we will get to the you know the the high production rate but it's probably end of this year before we get confidently to a high production rate but but this does not affect our vehicle output we actually have enough supply from enough battery cell supply from suppliers to make one and a half million cars this year so it's not a constraint

1:42:45on output it but it is it will be important for next year and a new mass plan is not not yet ready i don't know maybe aim to get it done this month but like i said it's going to be just looking at the big picture what does it take to make earth fully self-sustaining from an energy standpoint and

1:43:12yeah just map it out and say this is this is what needs to be done tesla will try to be as useful as possible in this regard and hopefully lots of other companies can join in and and help accelerate the sustainable energy revolution [Applause] with peak inflation behind us so the inflation question is is interesting because we we do get a fair bit of insight into where prices of things are going over time because when you're making millions of cars you have to purchase commodities many months in advance of when they're needed like so you need to tell because it's a very long supply chain with a tremendous amount of inertia so we we sort of have some insight into

1:44:09where prices are headed over time and the interesting thing that we're seeing now is that most of our commodities most of the things that go into a tesla not all but i don't know more than half the prices are trending down in six months six months from now this could change obviously but but the trend is down which suggests that we are past peak inflation now making macroeconomic prognostications is a recipe for disaster but my guess is that we are past peak inflation and that we will see we will have a recession i think it will be a relatively mild recession sort of but i'm just guessing here this is total speculation but i would guess it's a it's a

1:45:10you know mild recession for i don't know 18 months or something like that it would be my best guess right now we don't have fundamental capital misallocations in the in the us as we have had in the past like in leading up to 2008 where we were building primary housing units at twice the rate of of household formation which obviously doesn't make sense and there were a lot of companies were over levered the the leverage or debt that companies have right now is relatively low so yeah i would say probably you know mild moderate recession maybe 18 months ish and and i think we i think inflation is going to drop rapidly that's my guess i don't know what do you guys think

1:46:06it's like sound about right okay great all right cool yeah the tesla robot essentially changing the economy like how can we base an economy on automation ai with the full self-driving that's being implemented you're gonna have a full fleet of vehicles that can drive themselves you'll have these robots that can go and get into your vehicle and place things will you be moving to a rental model or how will you base a tesla model on selling cars whenever these cars are fully automated can drive wherever they would like and hopefully would be applicable to having multiple people use the vehicle instead of just one person

1:46:48yeah so it's interesting to think about an autonomous car because you know when you drive around look at you look at how many cars are parked like they're just parking lots full of cars everywhere because cars need a driver and so most of the time they're doing nothing you know typically a passenger car is going to be like 12 hours a week or something like that of usage if it's autonomous maybe it can get to 50 or 60 hours of usage and that's sort of you know four or five time four four or fivefold improvement in the utility of a car but the interesting thing is that the car still costs the same so in that scenario at least for some period of time

1:47:40the effect of gross margin on an autonomous car is kind of boggles the mind so and in terms of how the calls will be operated i mean i think it would be you know just you'd have the option of of owning a car using a car just occasionally when you need it like an auto uber or something like that and there would be people and then an owner of a car could decide that they want to use their car or they want to add or subtract it to the fleet so i think it would end up being some kind of combination of like airbnb and uber or something like that you know so sometimes you you know you can go all the way from owning it to renting it sometimes to renting it a lot

1:48:32to completely renting it but the but the the utility of the car will just be mind-blowingly great and then like i said optimus will really bring the future to now so yeah maybe maybe maybe you could rent optimus hourly i mean assuming we get all these things we do all these things i think probably tesla will be the most valuable company in the world

1:49:23elon hi we all know how the media treats you so well yeah so i don't have a question for you today i just want to say on behalf of my six-year-old at home kyler scott that's watching right now who thinks you're awesome as well thank you for making the world a better place thank you

1:50:09[Applause] well i love you guys too i i i just like to say thank thank you for helping make it happen yeah because with it without without the without you without the early adopters of electric vehicles and sort of full self-driving tesla would not be where it is today so thank you for your support [Applause] sir what a presentation thank you tesla team it's an honor to be a stockholder elon i brought you the final checkpoint for spacex a mini moon maybe little lex can play with it my name is david guajardo i'm a former bronzeville resident my first suggestion is to add a new string mode option where the driver can select lazy mode and have the software accommodate between comfort

1:50:58standard and sword modes depending on the speed the car is going this will increase handling and safety second when the when disengaging autopilot with the wheel the accelerator stays on please fix it last one weeks ago talking to mr san patel at starbase i told him that the team should add a tab in the spacex website and disclose what type of skills and preparation are going to be needed from us to accomplish the greatest adventure ever ever in human history going to mars all right well thanks for the suggestions those those are good suggestions thank you all right sure hi so i do actually have a question but one thing that i want to okay like people ask you all the questions

1:51:50what do you think people miss and should be excited way more about and what do you think people are threatened way too much about and shouldn't be worried at all yeah that's actually that's a good point you know i think actually the the questions and ideas posed by a retail investors like small retail investors like i think many of you in the audience are actually the most insightful and it's i find it remarkable that you know essentially amateur like normal everyday people actually understand tesla better than the analysts i mean unless you must see this as like that's like [Applause] and i mean i think like you know to really say like well like what's what's

1:52:44the what's the point of a a company is the point of a company is to create useful products and services you know company is not it should not exist in and of itself it exists it's it's a group of people gathered together to make products and services and if those products and services are great it's a valuable and useful company and if they're not it's not and so really to understand a company you must use its products and if you think the products are great then it's well the company is great that's it that that's how it is and so i i think ironically a lot of the people people that just sort of professional analysts don't drive teslas so like well okay you know

1:53:23maybe you should yeah cool i mean i mean we aim to make tesla the most amount of fun you can have in a car you know so yeah so let's see so i think that there are a lot of really good and insightful ideas that that i see on the internet on twitter and whatnot and oh yeah twitter

1:53:52[Applause] so yeah so let's see i think sometimes people fret a bit too much about short-term things that which are clearly just you know just bumps in the road type of thing where there might be a supplier shortage or a you know some shutdown in some part of the world but but really those things are you know are clearly just kind of one-off items that don't really matter for the long-term

1:54:38the the sort of the you know the the trend if you like looking at the sort of cumulative output and cumulative miles driven and you can see that that cumulative output is a very clean exponential and it's so you know so i guess sometimes people fret a little bit too much about this quarter or that quarter but you know if you're a shareholder a company is really like the net present value of future cash flows and so what is a you know one quarter is not really a big deal i think if you see people panicking then instead of saying oh man my stock's gone down it's a buying opportunity

1:55:29hi elon thanks for the meeting i became a marine because i want to help protect your future base on mars my friends and i are trained and we're we support the mission would you be open to this idea yeah space marines absolutely [Applause] hi elon a lot of tesla's products today focus on electrical energy for sustainable future do you foresee tesla perhaps exploring thermal energy sustainable products other than hvac like say for example in this gigafactory taking the residual heat from the gigapresses and applying them to say the drying ovens in your paint line yeah i think get getting dual use of like if you use electricity to do something and then it generates

1:56:26heat and then you're transporting that heat elsewhere within the factory it's it's probably a good idea to to do that actually it it is a a sort of i would say a future optimization but but it is probably something worth doing in the factory and it is something we do in the car so in the car we carefully manage the the electrical and the thermal energy and so like one of the ways that we achieve a long range in cold weather is by both charging the pack and heating the pack and then the pack acts as a both an electrical and a thermal reservoir to achieve long range even in very cold climates and so we're constantly within the car shuttling heat back and forth between motor drive

1:57:09motor power electronics pack and the cabin volume so that same concept should be applied to a factory i agree elon what's up and my name is justin some know me as smd capital on twitter i've i had the number one voted question last earnings about scaling to extreme size i have another big question i think a lot of people would want to know in regards to when would tesla launch their first pilot city for the tesla network the robo-taxi business

1:57:53well you see i think it's actually going to be probably much more widespread than that because tesla is is developing a general solution for self-driving and it's not really specific to one city or location now there's different regulatory requirements in in various cities and states so some locations will offer regulatory approval sooner than others but but we are aiming for a general solution and in fact if if you if you created a sort of a a randomly generated alternate earth our system would still work like literally you know like you had some sort of computer generated earth that you know obeyed roughly the same rules as current earth our system is sufficiently generalized

1:58:48that it would work in a a computer generated alternate earth so yeah so anyway [Applause] so i'm gary black managing partner of the future fund tesla's our largest position probably the thing we worry about most it's not not pr but it's it's succession so you know key man how does the board think about your succession and especially when you have you know a judge who's going to decide in a couple months whether or not you have to take over twitter how would you split your time

1:59:45well i think tesla's definitely gathering a lot of momentum and we have a very exciting product roadmap that will last a long time so now obviously execution against that roadmap is is difficult because these are not simple products they're not copies of what anyone else is doing they're new things so [Music] but i intend to stay with tesla as long as i can be useful and you know i can be most useful i think on the product design and manufacturing so basically factory design product design and sort of manufacturing optimization so and we do have a very talented team here so i think i think tesla you know would continue to do very well even if i was kidnapped

2:00:43by aliens or went back to my home planet maybe [Laughter] but so yeah but no i think it's a good question and i to be frank i don't have us an easy answer open to ideas that you know i'm definitely working as hard as i can and and i'm very excited about the future of the company and you know i think it's it's got it's got a very very bright future even without me so i'm not leaving so to be clear

2:01:27so [Applause] you know i also have to be a little careful about what i say with about twitter because you know this was like lawsuit and stuff so sometimes people get bent out of shape but i i do use twitter a lot so it's not like i would i'm like randomly going around wanting to acquire companies or something i'm not like a hedge fund i'm not a hedge fund or a private equity firm or something so in fact the only two publicly traded securities i own on tesla and twitter that's it so and i think in the case of twitter since i use it a lot shoot myself in the foot a lot you know dig my grave etc but you know i think it's i do understand the product quite well

2:02:25so i think i've got a good sense of of where where to point the engineering team with twitter to make it radically better and i i do i i do sort of have a well as like a grander vision for what i thought x.com or fx corporation could have been back in the day it's a pretty pretty grand vision and obviously that could be started from scratch or but i think twitter would help accelerate that by three to five years so it's kind of like something i thought would be quite useful

2:03:13for a long time i know what to do don't don't have to have twitter for that but it would it's like i said it's probably at least a three-year accelerant and i think it's something that will be very useful to the world how's it going elon my name is ronnie and with the projected release of the robot taxi coming in the years ahead would it be looked at as a the boring company would it be used to get regulation for full self-driving and would it be a good venue for the robo taxi also my little brother zane says hi owns all tests of hot wheels okay cool i say hi to him back so yeah boring company is making good progress actually and you know for the longest time

2:04:10people like i'd give a talk somewhere and people say what what are opportunities you know about us like tunnels and they'd be like for five years i said if if somebody could just do a tunneling company we can solve traffic and we can have also very high speed transport between cities because while i'm a fan of trains and i like high-speed trains they do they do intersect the you know go through towns and neighborhoods and chop people's property in half and they're very loud so but i want to be clear i'm pro-trained some of those are trained people you know i take every opportunity to drive to go on interesting trains so but if you have a sort of

2:04:54a much simplified version of the hyperloop it's really just tesla's in a tunnel that's depressurized you can go between cities super fast and without disrupting the stuff above ground so that's kind of the vision for the boring company is to make make roads 3d and have sort of an arbitrary an arbitrary number of layers of roads and i think you can solve essentially any traffic problem in any city if you go 3d with with with tunnels of multiple areas of tunnels going from you know connecting the the city and you can also turn a lot of the streets into parks because you won't need them any you won't need to have cars indoors you won't need parking

2:05:46so i think one company i think is capable of much more transformation than it may seem and we actually have an operational tunnel in vegas right now so yeah if you go to vegas go to resorts world and you can hop in the tunnel and and go to the convention center and like yeah and you can paint doge exactly i'm doing what i can to support those so

2:06:17so but yeah i think i think porn company is going to do some pretty interesting things in the years to come so let's see good afternoon elon i think many people share my experience i gave you and or at least tesla my complete family's legacy because i believed in it and thank you for you and your company outperforming i think you saved a lot of us thank you yeah okay

2:06:44my question is this commercial aircraft have something called a cast where aircraft relay telemetry of their position between one another to a permanent collision yeah sometimes too much telemetry thank you so taking this to a higher level do you see tesla's communicating with one another with one another and dojo turning into some kind of ultimate air traffic control for tesla supply chains and robo taxi thank you actually that's an interesting idea i haven't thought about that i mean right now our goal with dojo is just to be really good at video training so we actually already have i think the maybe the fourth and maybe approaching the third

2:07:23most powerful computing center in the world for ai training yeah i think it might be through it at this point which obviously uses just an enormous number of gpus and stuff so so our first goal with with dojo is to make it competitive and and be be more effective at neural net training than a whole bunch of gpus and we might you know might get there soonish and then of course it can be used for many other neural net training tasks it's it's a fundamental it's a computer designed from the ground up to be optimized for neural net training which which really no computer has no that's never been done before and yeah so and then maybe it'll do some traffic

2:08:13control i haven't really thought of that the the tesla's probably there will be some merits to communicating fort fort tells us to communicate to each other but but that won't be needed for full self-driving at all and for long for a long time the the vast majority of cars on the road will be manually driven so the the value of tesla to tesla communication is is not that high except for perhaps communicating traffic issues or you know accidents potholes things that may be helpful to the road closures and that kind of thing so it's like you're getting real time a tesla ahead of you has got seen a road closure and you get that real time updated to your car so you don't get

2:09:02stuck in the road closure situation that's that's the kind of stuff that i think we we definitely what we are we are working on right now so all right all right we have one last question and it's yours thank you very much hello elon simply i would just like to say thank you for everything you've done for earth and the community and everything you've done i have one question and aside from working for tesla being a shareholder or purchasing a tesla how can the masses help push your vision all right well i think just generally you know encouraging sustainable energy and being supportive of that i think is is really helpful so but i i say you're doing great so far

2:09:52so you know like i said without your support we tells it wouldn't be where it is so it's people like yourself and everyone in this room and out there and the three million people who have bought our cars and the the millions who have gotten solar and you know that's all that all really helps you know make the world a better better place for the future and and i'd say like it definitely i'd like to sort of convey a message of of optimism about the future and like if we if we work you know really hard to accelerate sustainable energy sustainable transport the future will be good you know it's and and i think just just make sure people know that

2:10:32like and i i'm not suggesting complacency at all i'm literally saying if we work hard towards a sustainable future we will achieve it and and the future was bright so thank you right thanks guys thank you thank you [Music]

2:11:21so [Music] so [Music] do [Music] do [Music] do [Music] you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份