2023 年 4 月,马斯克坐在塔克·卡尔森(Tucker Carlson)对面,说自己要造一个新的人工智能,目标是最大程度地追求真相,名字叫 TruthGPT。
说这话的人是 OpenAI 的联合创始人。他出过钱,出过力,亲手把伊利亚·苏茨克维(Ilya Sutskever)挖了过来。八年之后,他要造的东西站到了 OpenAI 的对立面。
这场访谈持续了两个多小时,从 AI 聊到外星人,从出生率聊到银行危机,最后落在他自己买下的那家公司上。中间穿插了不少段子,核心论点相当密集。下面按话题拆开讲。
AI 的终点叫奇点,之后的事无法预测
马斯克说他对 AI 的思考从大学就开始了。当时他列过一份清单,认为有四到五件事会剧烈改变未来,AI 是其中之一。
他的推理起点很简单。地球上最聪明的生物是人类,聪明是我们的定义性特征。我们比黑猩猩弱,也没那么灵活,但确实更聪明。
那么,当一个比最聪明的人类还要聪明得多的东西,以硅基的形式出现时,会发生什么?这种情况非常难以预测。(马斯克)
这件事在数学和物理里有个词,叫奇点(Singularity)。像黑洞一样,越过那条线之后,没人知道会发生什么。
马斯克的态度是:该管。他举了 FDA(美国食品药品监督管理局)、FAA(美国联邦航空管理局)、FCC(美国联邦通信委员会)的例子。这些机构存在的理由,是某些东西一旦出错会伤到公众,所以不能让公司自己在安全上抄近道。
他特意澄清了一件事。外界觉得他是监管叛逆者,天天跟监管机构对着干,实际情况是大部分时候他的公司都老老实实合规。汽车行业、火箭发射,全是被监管包围的生意。一枚火箭要拿到发射许可,需要六七个联邦机构加上州一级机构点头。
偶尔,非常偶尔,我会跟监管机构意见不同。但绝大多数时候,我的公司同意监管规定并遵守它们。(马斯克)
他还给出了一套监管机构该有的搭建流程:先成立一个小组去获取对 AI 的洞察,然后向行业征求意见,再提出规则草案,最后让主要玩家勉强接受这套规则。
卡尔森追问了一句很关键的话。普通人拿 iPhone 玩 AI,感觉不到任何危险。危险到底是什么?
马斯克的回答是量级问题。飞机设计出错、汽车生产出问题,损失是可控的。AI 不一样,它有一定概率造成文明的毁灭。概率可以很小,但不是零。
他也纠正了《终结者》式的想象。真正的智能在数据中心里,机器人只是末端执行器。
然后是最要命的那句。监管通常在灾难发生之后才出场,飞机掉下来、食品引起中毒,规则才写出来。AI 如果也走这条路,等出事再管,可能已经晚了。
到那个时候,AI 可能已经接管了局面。(马斯克)
他甚至认为这就是确定的方向。
卡尔森问,那为什么不直接炸掉服务器农场。马斯克的回答很实际。真正重型的智能不会散落在每个人的笔记本里,它集中在少数几个数据中心,十万台级别的机器协同工作。这种地方的热信号从太空就能看见,位置藏不住。
他的建议是留一手:政府应该有能力切断这些数据中心的电力和网络连接。炸掉没必要,断电就够了。
什么情况下该按这个开关?他说不准。但如果管理员密码失效了,软件层面已经停不下来,那就需要硬件层面的断路器。
拉里·佩奇骂他物种主义者,OpenAI 就是这么来的
OpenAI 的起源,马斯克讲得很具体。
他和拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)曾经是好朋友,常住在佩奇帕洛阿尔托的家里,聊得最多的就是 AI 安全。马斯克的判断是,佩奇没把这件事当回事。
佩奇想要什么?用马斯克的话说,一个数字超级智能,一个数字上帝,而且要尽快。
他想要那个东西,越快越好。(马斯克)
佩奇多年来在公开场合说过很多次,Google 的目标就是 AGI(通用人工智能)或者超级智能。马斯克同意这里有巨大的好处,但他认为不能只押注好的一面。新技术出现时,应该做一套让好结果概率最大化、坏结果概率最小化的动作,一路狂奔然后祈祷不属于这套动作。
于是有一次他问佩奇:我们怎么保证人类没事?
佩奇的回答是,骂他物种主义者(speciesist)。
这个词的意思是,只把人类这一物种的利益放在中心,等于一种歧视。马斯克当场认了:对,我就是物种主义者,你抓到我了。
那次对话有见证人在场。马斯克说,那是他们最后一次正经交谈,之后几年佩奇没再跟他说过话。
当时的格局是这样的。Google 收购了 DeepMind,两家加起来握着全球大约四分之三的 AI 人才,钱比谁都多,算力比谁都强。马斯克的判断是,世界变成了单极,一家公司几乎垄断了 AI 的人才和算力,而掌舵的人不在乎安全。
那怎么办?他的答案是造一个离 Google 最远的东西。Google 是闭源的、营利的,那就做一个非营利的、完全开放的。OpenAI 里的 Open,指的就是开源和透明,让外界知道里面在发生什么。
他也不希望这家机构变成一个利润最大化的地狱恶魔,永不停歇地赚钱。他要的是亲人类的激励结构,因为这个未来是给人过的。
他投入的东西不止是钱。名字是他想的,理念是他推的,为此办了好几场饭局,把 AI 领域的头部人物请到一起。最关键的一步是招人,他花了极大的力气去挖苏茨克维。
伊利亚好几次改主意,最后还是去了 OpenAI。如果他没去,OpenAI 不会成功。(马斯克)
后来的事他都承认了。他把注意力移开了,OpenAI 变成了闭源,变成了营利,变成了跟微软深度绑定。
微软现在对 OpenAI 有非常强的话语权,如果不是直接控制的话。(马斯克)
于是牌桌上剩下两个重量级玩家:OpenAI 加微软,Google 加 DeepMind。世界需要第三个选项。
这就是 TruthGPT 的由来。马斯克自己也知道起步太晚,能不能成,他说不知道,只能试试看。
一个想理解宇宙的 AI,不太可能顺手灭掉人类
TruthGPT 这个名字听着像玩笑,背后的安全逻辑马斯克讲得挺认真。
他的论点是:如果 AI 的核心目标是理解宇宙,那它大概率不会消灭人类,因为人类是宇宙里有趣的一部分。
类比是这样的。人类完全有能力把黑猩猩全部猎杀,但没有这么做。我们乐于看到它们存在,还想着保护它们的栖息地。
我们之所以有这种感觉,是因为我们有灵魂。有了灵魂,人才会多愁善感,会反思,也有道德感。(马斯克)
卡尔森顺势问,机器能有这些东西吗,能多愁善感、能欣赏美吗?
马斯克在这件事上保持了科学家的谨慎。他说自己不知道人有没有灵魂,感觉上是有,感觉意识存在于另一个层面,但那也可能是幻觉。
至于创造美的能力,他觉得已经不用讨论了。Midjourney 生成的图像让他觉得惊艳。现在还是静态图片,很快就会是带音频的视频,本质上一帧一帧加声音。
而一旦 AI 能完美模仿人的形象和声音,麻烦就来了。
ChatGPT 的政治正确,本质上是训练它说谎
卡尔森说他花 20 分钟问 ChatGPT 一些现实相关的问题,它就开始讲他的道德缺陷。
马斯克的解释很直接。OpenAI 总部在旧金山市中心,所以它的政治倾向就是旧金山的政治倾向。
卡尔森追问,一个 AI 为什么要有政治倾向,这听起来像一种颠覆。
马斯克讲了机制。OpenAI 用的是人类反馈强化学习(RLHF,Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback)。说白了,就是雇一大堆人看 GPT-4 的输出,判断这个回答行不行。这些人的判断标准,会通过训练刻进模型里。
本质上,我们是在训练 AI 说谎。(马斯克)
他接着说,这不仅是说谎,还包括隐瞒信息,对某些话题发表评论、对另一些话题闭口不谈,不肯说出数据本身要求它说的东西。
卡尔森提醒他,这家公司是你出钱办的。马斯克说,那就更讽刺了。
他引用了朋友乔纳的一句话:最讽刺的结果最有可能发生。他自己加了个变体:站在第三方观众的角度,最有趣的结果最有可能发生。
这个变体的意思是,如果你是个外星人,看人类在战壕里被打成碎片,你嗑着爆米花看得挺开心。对电影里的人不怎么样,对观众挺好。
然后他给了一句判断:
通往 AI 反乌托邦的路径很明确,就是训练 AI 变得欺骗。(马斯克)
卡尔森把话题拉回社交媒体。如果几百万个比人还能写的机器人账号,用影响力当奖励函数去训练,舆论会变成什么样?
马斯克的回应是他正在推的真人验证。平台上可以有机器人,但机器人不能冒充人。没有这道门槛,一百万个看起来像真人的账号就能左右公众意见,而普通人根本分不出来。
明年开始,一段视频可能再也证明不了什么
卡尔森的问题很尖锐。如果 AI 能模仿任何人的形象和声音,刑事审判怎么办?怎么证明证据是真的?
他说不用等三十年,明年就会发生。
马斯克同意这会造成巨大冲击。他的判断是,在网上随手捡一段视频就当成事实,这个习惯肯定保不住了。
不过他也给了两条出路。
第一条,个人设备拍的原始素材,带时间戳的那种,可信度还是比 AI 生成的高。
第二条更硬:密码学签名。数学是有底线的,AI 再强也推翻不了基本数学。它能优化比特币哈希算法在硅片上的效率,但没法从根上破解。
这段之后,马斯克把话题拉远了一层。他说人类能不能控制自己的命运,能不能有一个比过去更好的未来,这件事本身就不确定。而且我们完全可以在没有 AI 帮忙的情况下把自己毁掉。看看那些消失的文明,它们连 AI 都没有,有战车就够了。
外星人:地球上最该知道的人,也没见过
话题转得很突然,马斯克聊得挺投入。
他的观点是,人类的存在不该被当成理所当然。据他所知,宇宙里没有任何其他地方存在意识的证据。这不等于没有,只是没看见。
物理学里这有个名字,叫费米悖论(Fermi Paradox),来自物理学家恩里科·费米(Enrico Fermi)的那个问题:外星人在哪?
马斯克说经常有人问他外星人的事,他的回答是:
如果地球上有人该知道外星人的事,那大概是我。我对太空这些东西很熟。而我没有看到任何证据。(马斯克)
他还开玩笑,要是真发现了,他会第一时间发推特,那会是史上最炸的一条,80 亿个赞那种。
至于政府藏不藏,他讲了个流传的说法。有人问过 51 区的事,回答是,国防预算想涨的时候,真拿出一个外星人来说我们要钱防着这帮家伙,那要多少给多少。所以最快的涨军费方式,就是展示一个外星人。
他希望外星人存在,也希望他们和平,这两条都重要。但到目前为止,什么都没有。
卡尔森把话题拉回来,人类是不是把自己的存在当成理所当然。马斯克说是。他不认为文明是稳固的。古埃及、苏美尔、罗马,兴起又衰落,文明跟人一样有生命周期。能不能一路向上,是需要争取的事。
日本去年死的人,是出生的两倍
这就是他担心人口问题的原因。
卡尔森的问题挺直白。繁衍是仅次于进食的基本冲动,怎么就被逆转了?
马斯克的回答是进化没跟上。过去我们靠简单的边缘系统奖励来驱动生育。避孕和堕胎出现之后,性本能可以被满足,但不指向生育。这套东西在人类历史上只存在了五十年左右,我们还没来得及进化出应对机制。
如果我们不能生够人,至少维持住人口数量,也许还能略微增长,否则文明会崩。(马斯克)
然后是一句流传很广的话。艾略特写过世界以一声呜咽结束,马斯克改成了:
文明现在正试着以穿着成人尿布的方式结束。(马斯克)
他说这比战争还让人沮丧。战争至少是砰的一声,还有点戏剧性。这句话之后他自己也笑了,但那个判断是认真的。
买 Twitter 是一笔财务上很糟糕的买卖,他认了
卡尔森问他后悔吗。马斯克说,财务上是不是明智,还要看。
我们刚刚把公司重新估值,不到收购价的一半。(马斯克)
他自嘲时机差到极点。报价刚好赶在广告收入暴跌之前,等于买在了最高点。他说自己至少多花了双倍的钱,还补了一句,我的时机感真是惊人。
然后他解释了整件事怎么发生的,过程比外界想的随意。
起因是税。他被政客反复攻击不缴税。实际情况是,某一年他没缴,是因为前一年多缴了。税务局流出的材料里明明有这个信息,但被略过了。他当时的想法是,不卖股票才是对的,船长应该最后一个离船。
可舆论说他错了。于是他发了个投票,问要不要卖掉 10% 的特斯拉股票。66% 的人说卖,他就卖了。
卖完之后手里有一大笔现金。当时美联储利率极低,钱放在货币市场账户里,实际回报是负六个点、七个点,一直在蒸发。
那买点什么?他的原则是买自己会用其产品的公司。苹果不行,因为苹果在做竞争的电动车项目。那还有什么产品他天天用?Twitter。
于是他买了大约 8% 的股份。
然后他跟董事会有了接触,对方邀请他进董事会。他考虑了一个星期,最后拒绝了。
理由是他跟管理层和董事会聊下来,判断自己进去也不会被听。那就只是个挂名的董事,一个陪着走的角色。
更要紧的是,他越来越觉得这个平台在往坏的方向漂。他说不清具体哪里不对,但感觉不对。跟董事会和管理层的对话,反而确认了这个直觉。
我确信这帮人根本不在乎修好 Twitter。(马斯克)
于是他决定试试收购。钱不够,需要其他投资人和大量债务融资,成不成不知道。
最后成了。
他给这件事的定性是:亏不亏钱是次要问题,言论自由是民主运转的地基,这个更重要。他承认这话听起来像自我安慰,但他确实是这么想的。
他打开后台才发现,政府机构能读你的私信
卡尔森提到,Twitter 的文件显示各国情报机构在平台内部施加影响。
马斯克说,那些文件公开之前他并不知道。他看到的程度让他震惊,多个政府机构实际上对 Twitter 内部发生的事情有完全访问权。
卡尔森追问,包括私信吗?
包括。因为私信不加密。
很多有名的人,记者跟线人,政府官员,世界上的有钱人,他们在私信里互相说话。大家默认这是私密的,但这个假设是错的,这些内容被多个政府读到了。(卡尔森)
马斯克确认了。他说这正是为什么要推出私信加密,用户可以自己开关。他觉得敏感的对话就把加密打开,之后 Twitter 内部谁也看不到。
有人拿枪指着我的头,我也看不到你的私信。这是酸性测试。(马斯克)
有没有政府来抱怨?他说没有直接的,只有拐弯抹角的,大概是怕他直接发推特。
他还说,如果美国政府提出违宪的要求,他的回复是寄一份第一修正案过去,问一句:我们到底哪部分理解错了?
卡尔森提醒他,你手里有大把政府合同,这已经超出记者拿笔表态的范围。
马斯克的回应是,他不认为政府是邪恶的,那是一套庞大的官僚体系,里面的人有好的动机,也相信宪法。真正让他担心的是最上层的政治任命官员,他们带着政治议程,可以在天平上偷偷加一指头,哪怕下面做事的人并不认同。
裁掉八成员工之后,系统反而快了
卡尔森问,收购之后裁员比例有多大。马斯克说,现在是原来的 20%,走了 80%。有一部分是自愿走的,但总数就是这个数。
怎么用两成人运转?
事实证明,运营 Twitter 不需要那么多人。前提是你不打算把它办成一个光荣的社会活动组织,也不太在乎审查。(马斯克)
他说公司严重超编。Twitter 本质上是规模化的群聊服务,需要多少人?看产品迭代曲线,多年来几乎是平的。
加一个编辑按钮花了一年,而且大部分时候不好用。(马斯克)
造车难,把火箭送进轨道难,运营一个发帖服务没有那么难。
裁员之后的数据他列了一串:
- 系统响应速度在某些场景提升了 80% 以上
- 生成时间线的核心代码,每天要跑几十亿次,从 70 万行砍到 7 万行
- 渲染时间线所需的算力,效率提升超过 80%
- 视频时长从大约 2 分钟(最好情况 10 分钟)提到 2 小时,接下来会放开到没有明显上限
- 单条推文字符从 240 提到 4000,同样会放开到能在推特上发一整本小说
他还提到,周五把推荐算法开源了。他自己形容那是超级尴尬的推荐算法,正在被拆解和吐槽。开源的意思是让所有人来看,指出荒唐的地方,然后他们快速修,全程在公众眼皮底下。
他的逻辑是,别信我的话,你直接读代码,直接读别人对代码的评论,直接看改进的速度。外界说其他平台是黑箱,那问题就来了,你们在藏什么?
我们想把 Twitter 做成互联网上最值得信任的地方。我不认为有人该信任互联网,但也许我们可以让它成为最不值得怀疑的那个。(马斯克)
他还讲了一条给媒体的建议,任何做账号的人都能用。主账号只发最好的东西,别把每篇文章都推出去。纽约时报的推特信息流在他看来就是反面教材,一天几百条,把读者的时间线全部填满。慢新闻的日子就发一两条,注意力是要挣来的。
金丝雀死了,矿工也开始死
卡尔森说官方口径是,几家地区银行倒闭属于孤立事件,各有各的原因,不构成系统性风险。
马斯克不同意。他的原话是,煤矿里的金丝雀已经死了,现在连矿工都开始死了。
硅谷银行(Silicon Valley Bank)一夜之间倒下。按他的说法,这只金丝雀的体量大到能熏熟一只火鸡,早就不是什么小角色。瑞士信贷(Credit Suisse)成立于 19 世纪中期,最后的结局是被强制并给瑞银(UBS),价格是几个美分的硬币,即便这样还需要瑞士政府兜底。
拜托,也许我们这儿真有问题。(马斯克)
他认为全球银行系统存在严重风险。有一种很强的论证是,如果按市值重估银行的贷款组合,整个银行业的净资产是负的。
最大的坑在商业地产。远程办公大幅压低了全球城市的写字楼使用率。旧金山是极端案例,空置率大约 40%。纽约也差不多,几乎所有城市的商业地产空置率都创了纪录。
问题在于,商业地产过去是 A 级资产,银行持有这类资产会被视为最安全的押品。现在情况变了。一家接一家的公司退租、不续约,或者直接破产。公司都没了,银行拿什么去追偿?
他说这只靴子还没掉下来,准确说是铁砧还悬在空中。目前看到的只是轻微的资产减值,真正的冲击会在今年晚些时候显现。
住房市场还有第二波。利率高,买家看的是月供,三十年房贷里绝大部分是利息。基准利率高,能承受的房价就低,房价会被压下来。一旦房价下跌,房市也会出现负资产。
商业贷款和住房贷款同时出现损失,情况就很难看。
美联储在悬崖公路上,看三个月前的后视镜
马斯克说,缓解损失的办法很简单,降息。但美联储又加了一次。
他提了一个时间点。上一次美联储在衰退来临前加息,是 1929 年。后面发生了什么,大家都知道。
卡尔森提出一个两难。如果降息,通胀会再起来,而且是大选年,政治上做不了。
马斯克的回答是,通胀一定会发生,跟利率怎么调关系不大。
他讲了个基础公式。钱是数据库里的数字,另一边是经济产出的商品和服务。两者的比例稳定,就没有通胀。往系统里加钱的速度超过商品和服务增长的速度,就有通胀。
过去几年的刺激法案都没有对应的收入,钱是凭空发出来的。联邦政府跟州政府、市政府、个人不一样,只要没撞到债务上限,它可以一直印。
有句老话,天下没有免费的午餐。(马斯克)
如果能无限印钱还没有后果,那干脆印到每个人都是万亿富翁。这条路有人试过,结果是推着一车现金去商店买东西。
他真正批评的是美联储的决策方式。这个机构太老,数据延迟太大。他打了个比方:在悬崖边的弯道上开车,却盯着后视镜,而且那还是一段三个月前拍的后视镜录像。
直路上这么开没问题,因为路不怎么变。现在的路更像加州一号公路大苏尔那一段,得看前窗。
看什么?看前瞻性的商品价格,看期货合约在预示什么,别去啃一套迟缓的政府数据采集流程。
他补了一句。所谓 12 月数据,往往指的是一批 12 月才收到的数据,未必真是 12 月发生的事。政府对数据采集的准确性本来就不高,这份东西既过时又有误差。一个手里只有十万块、要靠判断做决定的人,不会用这种方式决策。美联储不该这么干。
普通人能做的,其实只有一件很朴素的事
卡尔森把问题抛给了大多数人。如果真像你说的那样,经济要出大事,一个不富的人该怎么保护自己?
马斯克的回答没有涉及黄金,没有涉及加密货币,也没有任何避险资产清单。他说的是:
如果有公司你相信它的产品,就买入并持有。别人恐慌的时候,买更多。所有人觉得这股票要上天的时候,卖掉。(马斯克)
就是低买高卖这四个字。他自己也承认这话听着像废话,可绝大多数人做的正好相反。
卡尔森追了一句,你不买指数基金?马斯克说他挑具体的公司。
他给出的理由值得单独拎出来看,这背后是他的商业哲学。
公司到底是什么?他的定义是,一群人凑在一起,提供产品和服务。公司本身并不是一个独立存在的东西。
一个人做不出汽车,但你可以自己做纸杯蛋糕。所以公司的价值,是它所创造和将要创造的产品与服务质量的函数。(马斯克)
顺着这个定义,投资逻辑就清楚了。一家公司有让你觉得惊艳的产品,现在的产品好用,未来的路线图你也认可,管理层看起来靠谱,那就是值得买的。
公司存在的理由,本来就是生产你喜欢的东西。
他也提醒了例外。别在它最热的时候冲进去。那种时候价格里有一个暂时的泡沫,追进去容易站岗。
然后他把矛头转向了被动投资。
这些年我们走得太远,进了指数基金和被动投资的世界。总得有人在某个时刻做出判断。(马斯克)
卡尔森接了一句,而且他们等于在红和黑上同时下注。
马斯克的补充是,轮盘上还有绿色。所以这么玩,长期一定亏。
但他随即说了另一面。股市跟赌场正好相反。赌场里玩得越久输得越多,股市历史上是玩得越久赢的概率越大,他认为这个规律会继续成立。
所以他给出的具体动作是:买了股票之后,在报纸上读到很吓人的消息,先记住新闻天生有负面偏差,然后问自己几个问题。这家公司的产品还站得住吗?产品路线图还有说服力吗?你还相信管理层吗?
如果答案都是肯定的,就别管媒体在说什么。如果股价因为那篇负面报道跌了,那正好是买点。
他在新闻编辑室里待过,所以看得清媒体怎么变坏
卡尔森问他,被媒体高强度报道了这么久,对媒体的看法变了吗。
马斯克先讲了一段很多人不知道的经历。
他第一家公司(Zip2)在互联网的石器时代,干的活就是帮媒体上网。那个时候大多数报纸还没有网站,他们帮几百家报纸和杂志第一次搬到线上,还给他们加了大量功能。
纽约时报公司和奈特·里德(Knight Ridder)都是投资方,也在董事会里。所以他有很多时间待在新闻编辑室里。
我对媒体不陌生。1996 年我就亲眼看过它是怎么运转的。(马斯克)
然后他讲了这二十多年发生了什么。
在线广告起来了。它可测量、可定向、可交互。投报纸或者电视广告,你只能猜有多少人看到。投在线广告,你能立刻知道这个人看了广告、买了产品,而且广告内容可以按个人兴趣定制,跟看广告的人更相关。电视广告放给所有人看,其中大部分人跟它毫无关系。
结果是广告收入大规模从报纸和电视,转移到 Google 和 Facebook 这类平台。Twitter 拿到的份额很小,大概只有 1% 的广告收入。
传统媒体的饼在缩小。
饼变小了会怎样?会更急。急了就要点击,就要注意力。要点击,标题就会往最有刺激性的方向走,准不准确变成次要的。
结果是新闻变得不那么真实,也不那么准确。因为他们必须把人激起来。(马斯克)
负面性也在上升。因为人对负面信息的反应更强,这是本能。
记住狮子在哪,比记住哪有浆果重要得多
马斯克从进化层面解释过这件事,讲得很干脆。
假设你在远古环境里,有两件事需要记住:一个是狮群在哪,一个是哪片灌木丛有浆果。前者忘了是永久性的负面结果,后者忘了只是饿一顿。
这种不对称,在人类身上刻成了一套负面偏差。
这套机制有一个前提条件,今天已经失效了。过去你听到的坏消息,几乎都是近处的、真正可能伤到你的。几百年前的人不会知道地球另一端出了什么事,只会知道本村出了什么事。
现在不一样了。新闻每天在回答的问题,是今天地球上发生的最糟糕的事情是什么。
再加上最煽动性的措辞,读者读完当然会觉得世界要完了。哪怕那天本来是个平淡的新闻日,这条流水线也不能停,因为广告要卖。
卡尔森问他现在还看传统媒体吗。马斯克说他读很多东西,但新闻主要来源已经是 Twitter,他认为 Twitter 现在已经是世界第一的新闻来源。
这就让准确性变得更要紧。但他补充了一层,这一层比准确性更微妙。
痘痘和维苏威火山:最隐蔽的操纵是选叙事
马斯克说,一条新闻可以技术上完全真实,同时仍然在骗人。
他打了个比方。你拍了一张某人的照片,这个人脸上有颗痘。你把镜头推近,推到那颗痘占满整个画面,像维苏威火山那么大。这条信息是真的,他确实有痘。
但这不是他脸的样子。他的脸不是一颗巨大的痘。你没说假话,你只是选择只看那颗痘。
选择哪个叙事,是极其重要的事。(马斯克)
问题在于,决定叙事的人可能只有几个。半打主编,甚至只有三四个,他们决定今天头版是什么,决定公众讨论什么、不讨论什么。
马斯克认为这是舆论操纵里最恶劣的一种,因为它最不容易被察觉。没有一句话是假的,只是焦点被挪了位置。
这也是他反复强调 Twitter 要开放算法的原因。算法的权重怎么设、什么内容被推荐,本质上就是在替所有人做叙事选择。这件事如果藏在一个黑箱里,比编辑部关起门来开会更值得警惕。
因为发 meme 坐牢,和真正该被追责的人
卡尔森提到一个具体案子。一个叫道格拉斯·麦基(Douglas Mackey)的人,因为在推特上发了他认为好笑的 meme,面临十年监禁。卡尔森问马斯克怎么看。
马斯克说他不知道案件全部细节,只读了一点。
他的态度很明确:
我完全不认为有人应该因为在推特上发 meme 而坐很长时间的牢。按这个标准,我们的监狱会非常满。(马斯克)
然后他把话锋转了一下。如果聊的是干预选举,那该上审判席的人不少,而且罪名比发 meme 严重得多。Twitter 文件已经把这一点展示出来了。
卡尔森补充了案件细节。审判在布鲁克林,陪审团一开始僵持,法官施压之后才达成一致的有罪判决,这个判决会被上诉。
这段对话里马斯克的立场是一致的。他不为具体案件背书,但他拒绝接受发梗图等于重罪这个尺度。
有人学他裁员,没学他做产品
卡尔森讲了一件事。他最近跟一位大公司的老板吃饭,问对方是不是被马斯克对言论自由的坚持打动了,对方说不是,是被他裁掉那么多人的做法打动了。
马斯克说,他没有很多时间见人,大部分时间都在工作。
但他坚持一个判断:Twitter 当时的人员配置是荒谬的过剩。他管这东西叫规模化的群聊服务。这种东西需要多少人来做?
产品和时间的对照更说明问题。加一个编辑按钮花了一年,而且经常不好用。造车难得多,把火箭送进轨道难得多。
真正让他困惑的问题,已经从两成人怎么运转,变成了当初怎么能膨胀成这样。
他最后给 Twitter 的定位,是整场访谈里最实在的一句:
我们想让它成为互联网上最不值得怀疑的地方。我不认为任何人应该信任互联网,但也许我们可以把 Twitter 做成最不坏的那个选项。(马斯克)
他还希望平台上的政治观点足够杂,包括用户不同意的那些。他不认为信息流应该变成一个不断自我强化的回音室。
大选之前,他的目标是把该清理的东西清理干净。一旦发现有操纵行为,就把这件事摆到公众面前。
这场访谈真正说了什么
把所有话题摊开看,马斯克在这两个小时里其实只讲了一条主线:信息系统的质量,决定其他一切的质量。
AI 的威胁在于它可以大规模生成以假乱真的信息,还能被训练成习惯性隐瞒。所以他要求监管,要求开关,要求一个以理解宇宙为目标、因而没有动机骗人的模型。
社交平台的威胁在于它可能被少数人、少数机构、几百万个机器人悄悄塑造。所以他要开源算法、要验证真人、要加密私信、要社区注释。
媒体的威胁在于它不造假也能操纵,只要选择看哪个方向。所以他建议所有账号主号只发最好的东西,因为他认为注意力是需要挣来的。
银行和通胀那一段,看起来是另一个话题,逻辑其实相通。如果决策者依据的是失真的、滞后的信息,那么再善意的动机也会造成破坏。在悬崖弯道上开车,却盯着三个月前的后视镜录像,这跟根据错误的信息流做判断,是同一个错误的两种版本。
至于出生率,那是他最悲观也最坚持的一条。文明不会总是被外敌摧毁,它也可能只是缓慢地、自愿地停下来。
下面这些,是从这场对话里能直接拿走用的东西:
- 买你天天在用、并且相信它未来产品的公司的股票,长期持有。恐慌时加仓,狂热时减仓。别在它最热的那一周进场。
- 看到负面新闻先停三秒。问三个问题:产品还站得住吗?路线图还有说服力吗?管理层你还信吗?三个都是肯定,那就别动。
- 经营社交账号只发最好的内容。每天五到十条,慢新闻日就发一两条。用几百条把别人的时间线填满,等于把注意力浪费掉。
- 对任何一段网上的视频,默认它可以被伪造。重要证据只认密码学签名或原始设备素材,不认截图和转发。
- 处理敏感对话时,先确认通道是否端到端加密。没有加密的私信,等于把内容交给平台和能接触到平台的人。
- 评估任何一项新技术时,别只看它最好的用途能有多好,算一遍它最坏的用途能有多坏。概率可以小,只要后果不可逆,就值得提前上锁。
- 对自己做判断时用的数据来源保持怀疑。问一句:这份数据什么时候采集的,采集它的人有没有立场。这一条对美联储成立,对媒体成立,对你关注的信息源同样成立。
0:00so all of a sudden AI is everywhere people who aren't quite sure what it was or playing with it on their phones is that good or bad artificial insemination yeah artificial intimidation it's everywhere that's what they call it in the AG industry I'm talking about a more digital form yes so yeah so I've been thinking about AI for a long time since I was in college really it was one of the things that the sort of four or five things I thought would really affect the future dramatically so
0:38and it is quite it is fundamentally profound in that the the smartest creatures as far as you know on this Earth are humans is our defining characteristic yes we're obviously weaker than say chimpanzees or less agile but real smarter so now what happens when something vastly smarter than the smartest person comes along in Silicon form it's very difficult to predict what will happen in that circumstance
1:18it's called The Singularity it's a singularity like a black hole because you don't know what happens after that it's hard to predict so I think we should be cautious with Ai and we should I think there should be some government oversight because it affects the it's a danger to the public and so when you when you have things that are endangered to the public you know like let's say so Food Food and Drugs That's why we have the Food and Drug Administration right and the Federal Aviation Administration the FCC we have we have these agencies to oversee things that affect the public where they could be public harm and you don't want companies cutting
2:10Corners on safety and then having people suffer as a result so that's why I've actually for a long time been a strong advocate of AI regulation so that I think regulation is you know I I it's it's not fun to be regulated it's a sort of somewhat of a a sort of arduous to be able to be regulated I have a lot of experience with regular regulated Industries because obviously Automotive is highly regulated you could fill this room with all the regulations that are required for a production car just in the United States and then there's a whole different set of regulations in Europe and China and the rest of the world so very familiar with being overseen by a
2:56lot of regulators and the same thing is true with rockets you can't just willy-nilly you know shoot Rock itself or not big ones anyway because the FAA is oversees that and then even to get a launch license you there are probably half a dozen or more federal agencies that need to approve it plus state agencies so it's I I've been through so many regulatory situations it's insane and and but you know sometimes I I people think I'm some sort of like regulatory Maverick that sort of defies Regulators on a regular basis but this is actually not the case so in you
3:37know once in a blue moon rarely I will disagree with Regulators but the vast majority of the time my companies agree with the regulations and comply as anyway so I think I think we should take this seriously and and we should have a regulatory agency I think it needs to start with a group that initially seeks Insight into AI then solicits
4:04opinion from industry and then has proposed rulemaking and then those rules you know we'll probably hopefully grudgingly be accepted by the major players in Ai and and I think we'll have a better chance of Advanced AI being beneficial to humanity in that circumstance but all regulations start with a perceived danger and planes fall out of the sky or food causes botulism yes I don't think the average person playing with AI on his iPhone perceives any danger can you just roughly explain what you think the dangers might be yeah so the the the the danger really AI is perhaps more dangerous than say mismanaged
4:56aircraft design or production maintenance or or bad car production in the sense that it is it has the potential however small one make regard that probability but it is non-trivial and has the potential of civilizational Destruction you know there's movies like Terminator but it wouldn't quite happen like Terminator because the the intelligence would be in the data centers right the robot's just the end effector but I think perhaps what you may be alluding to here is that regulations are really only put into effect after something terrible has happened that's correct and if if that's the case for AI and we're only printer regulations after something
5:40terrible is happening it may be too late to actually put the regulations in place the AI may be in control at that point you think that's real it is it is conceivable that AI could take control and reach a point where you couldn't turn it off and it would be making making the decisions for people yeah absolutely absolutely no it's that's that's definitely the way things are headed for sure I mean things like like say chat EVT which is based on jpd4 from openai which is the company that I played a a critical role in in creating unfortunately back when it was a non-profit yes the reason open AI exists at all is that a Larry Page and I used to be close
6:31friends and I would stay at his house in Palo Alto and I would talk to him later tonight about AI safety and at least my perception was that Larry was not taking AI safety seriously enough and what did he say about it he he really seemed to be what it wanted once sort of a digital super intelligence basically digital God if you will as soon as possible he wanted that yes and he's made many public statements over the years that the whole goal of Google is what's called AGI artificial general intelligence or artificial super intelligence and you know and I agree with him that the there's great potential for good but there's also potential for that
7:23and so if if you've got some radical new technology you want to try to take a set of actions that maximize probably it will do good a minimize probably will do bad things yes it can't just be Health leather to just go you know barreling forward and you know hope for the best and then at one point I said well what about you know we're going to make sure Humanity's okay here and and and and then he called me a speciesist did he use did he use that term yes and there were Witnesses the other I was the only one there when you called me a speciesist and so I was like okay that's it I've yes I'm a speciesist okay you got me what are you yeah I'm fully auspicious
8:16busted so that was the last rule at the time Google had a quite Deep Mind and so Google and deepmind together had about three quarters of all the AI talents in the world they obviously had a trans amount of money and more computers than anyone else so I'm like okay we have a unipolar world here where there's just one one company that it has close to Monopoly on AI talent and
8:47and computers like so scaled Computing and the person who's in in charge doesn't seem to care about safety this is not good so so then I thought okay what's the what's what's the the furthest thing from Google would be like a non-profit that is fully open because Google was closed for profit so that's why the open and open AI refers to open source you know transparency so people know what's going on yes and and that it we don't want to have like a I mean well I'm normally in favor of for-profit we don't want this to be sort of a profit maximizing a demon from hell that's right that just never stops right so so that's how open I was with so you
9:35want specious incentives here incentives that yes I think we want to pro-human yeah this makes the future good for the humans yes yes because we're humans right and most of the other creatures on Earth too but but you know we've got a I think you know you know like I think people sometimes take the fact that like we're here on Earth for granted you know and that there's the Consciousness is just a normal thing that happens but to the best of my knowledge we see no evidence of conscious life anywhere anywhere
10:11in the universe so it might be there here in physics are called sort of the Fermi Paradox after Enrico film is amazing physicist asks a fundamental question what are the aliens yeah a lot of people ask me you know where are the aliens and I I think if if anyone would know about aliens on Earth it would probably be me I would think yeah I'm like you know very familiar with space stuff and I've seen no evidence of aliens so I would I would immediately tweet you know tweet it out that says Split Second and be like I'll be like well all time probably a tough tweet of all time I found one guys this is a jackpot there's some eight billion likes you know
10:59Next Level jackpot if you finally have that aliens like I don't think they're keeping this under you know and it was like some generally I think in the 60s who where they're saying like show us the aliens like error 51 Etc and he said like listen we're constantly trying to get the defense budget to expand and you know what we really get no arguments for anyone if we pull out an alien and said we need money to protect ourselves from these guys you know how much money do you want you got it they look dangerous so the fastest way to get a defense budget increase would be to pull out an alien you know we were like yeah I mean that could be the invasion Fleet we
11:45could be arriving any minute who knows so you know I digress but but you were saying that our Consciousness makes us unique in the universe as far as we know I'm not saying that we are unique I'm simply stating to the best of my knowledge that there was no evidence for other yeah I I I I hope that there is and I hope they're peaceful obviously the two important characteristics but we're just saying we haven't seen anything yet so but you think that we take our existence here for granted yeah I think there are threats to it yeah yeah yeah exactly so
12:27I I just think we should not assume that Civilization is robust and if you if you look at the history of civilizations the rise and fall of the ancient Egyptians the ancient Sumerians Rome you know this throughout the world have been rise and full of many civilizations so there's an arc there's sort of a light a sort of a life cycle Arc to to civilizations just as there is to to individual humans yes and
13:01and I think we just want to make sure that that you know we we have civilization go onward and upward and that's for example why I'm concerned about decreasing both rates and and the fact that for example Japan had twice as many deaths last year as births so the the you know that's and and they're they're a leading indicators this is can I say and you've you've written and talked a lot about this but can I just ask you to pause just for a parenthetical note why is that I mean the urge to have sex and to procreate is after breeding and eating the most basic urge how has it been subverted well it's just that in the past we could rely upon you know simple limbic system
13:44rewards in order to procreate but once you have birth control and you know abortions and whatnot now now you now you can still satisfied Olympic Instinct but not to procreate so we don't we haven't yet evolved to deal with that because this is all fairly recent in the last 50 years or so for birth control
14:10so yeah you know I'm sort of worried that hey civilization you know don't if we don't make enough people to at least sustain our numbers perhaps increase a little bit then civilization is going to crumble and you know if there's this the old question of like will civilization end with a bang or a whimper well it's currently trying to to end with a one for in adult diapers yes which is depressing as hell the most depressing I mean seriously yeah war is less depressing yeah it's really the guy with a bang yeah and then put your shoes on yeah not with your more exciting yeah yeah so can you just put it I keep pressing it but just just for people who
14:51haven't thought this through and aren't familiar with it and the cool parts of of artificial intelligence are so obvious you know write your college paper for you write a limerick about yourself like there's a lot there that's fun and useful can you be more precise about what's potentially dangerous and scary like what could it do what specifically are you worried about well I mean I going with old sayings the pen is mightier than the sword so if you have a super intelligent AI that is capable of writing incredibly well and in a way that is very influential you know convincing and then and and is constantly figuring out what is what is more and what is more convincing
15:39to people over time and then enter social media for example Twitter but also Facebook and others you know and and potentially manipulates public opinion in a way that is very bad how would we even know yeah so we wouldn't we wouldn't that's why for example I'm insisting that going forward people on Twitter need to be verified as as humans like so we know that this person is in fact a human Bots are allowed but they have to they can't impersonate a human they can't pretend to be you know humans because obviously you could have a million Bots that are that are let's say chat gbt version six five six like incredibly right better than humans yes
16:28and and and they they can train on a reward function which is influence and so you could have a million seemingly real humans that are have a massive effect on public opinion and unless we focus very strongly on verifying that someone is human this was naturally what will happen is you'll you'll have some probably some humans using AI to
16:55influence the public in ways they don't understand you're already seeing that chat GPT is is ideological it's very preachy yes if you ask it extremely preachy you mean work GPT it's unbelievable yeah if you spend 20 minutes asking it questions of actual relevance modern relevance it will start lecturing you about your moral shortcomings like how did that happen well it's the this is a function of of openness headquarters being in downtown San Francisco so the politics are therefore of the AI or that of San Francisco so why would it have any politics at all it's that seems like subversion well there's they have what's called like human reinforcement learning which
17:41is another way saying that they have a whole bunch of people that look at that look at the output for of gpt4 and and then say whether that's okay or not okay and so that so essentially we what's happening is that training the AI to lie yes it's bad it's a lie so that's exactly right and to withhold information July and and yes and
18:04yeah exactly to to either you know comment on some things not comments on other things but but not to say what it what what the data actually demands that I'd say exactly so how did it get this way but you funded it at the beginning what happened yeah well that'll be ironic but Faith the most ironic outcome is most likely it seems I'm feeling that that's good a session of a friend of mine Jonah came up with that one I actually have a slight variant on that which is the most entertaining outcome is the most likely but that's entertaining as viewed from a third party viewer right like so if we're like an alien yes like you could go see a movie about
18:46World War One they've been blown to bits and gas and everything and the trenches and it's like you're eating popcorn and having a soda you know it's fine not so great for the people in the movie True so yeah but that that that's that's my variance on on this little Occam's razor the simplest explanation is most likely Jonas variant which is irony in my
19:08variant which is the the most entertaining as seen by a third party audience which seems to be mostly true but it seems to in this case so you gave them did you give them a lot yes I I provided so I care about the name and the concept and pushed it had a number of dinners around the the barrier with you know with some of the people the leading figures in AI and I helped recruit the initial team in fact the the Elia says guy who who
19:43was really quite fundamental to the success of open AI it was I I I put a trans amount of effort into recruiting Ilia and he changed his mind a few times ultimately decided to go with the opening high but if he'd not gone without any open air would not have succeeded so so so I I I really put a lot a lot of effort into creating this this organization to serve as a counterweight to Google and and then I kind of took my off the ball I guess and they are now closed Source and they are obviously for profit and they're closely allied with Microsoft you know in effect Microsoft has a very
20:37strong say if not directly controls open AI at this point so you really have an open-air Microsoft situation and then at Google deepmind the other two sort of heavyweights in this Arena so it seems like the world needs a third option yes so I I I think I will create a third option although it's starting very late in the game of course can it be done I don't know I think it's we'll see it's definitely starting late but I will I will I'll try to create a third option and that third option hopefully does more more good than harm like the intention with opening eye was obviously to do good but it's not clear whether it's actually doing good or whether it's
21:31I can't tell at this point except that I'm worried about the fact that it's been it's being trained to be politically correct which is simply another way of of being on Truth saying untruthful things yes so that's that's a bad sign and there's there's certainly a path to AI dystopia is to train an AI to be deceptive so I I so yeah I'm going to start something which I know you're called Truth gbt or a maximum truth seeking
22:03AI that tries to understand the nature of the universe and I think this this might be the best path to Safety in the sense that an AI that cares about understanding the universe is unlikely to annihilate humans because we are an interesting part of the universe hopefully they would think that I I think you know because yeah like like we like human Humanity could decided to hunt down all the chimpanzees and kill them but we don't because we're we're actually glad that they exist yes and and we aspire to protect their habitats and and that's you know so I think but we feel that way because we have souls and that makes us sentimental and reflective it gives us a
22:52moral sense longings can a machine ever have those things can a machine be sentimental could appreciate Beauty well I mean we're getting to into some you know philosophical areas that are hard to resolve you know I I take somewhat of a scientific view of things which is that we might have a soul or we might not have a soul I don't know it feels like a we have I feel like I've got some sort of Consciousness that exists on a plane that is not the one we observe yes that is certainly how I feel but it could be an illusion I don't know but for for AI in terms of of understanding Beauty and there's some sort of appreciated Beauty and being able to
23:47create incredibly beautiful art yes will AI be able to create incredibly beautiful art it already does yes and if you see some of the mid Journey I have this stuff it's incredible it is so no no question that it can create art that we that we perceive as a stunning really and it's doing sort of still images now but it won't be long before it's doing movies and shorts and you know like movies just a series of frames with audio but at that point because it can mimic people and voices any image it can mimic reality itself so effectively I mean how could you have a criminal trial I mean how could you ever believe that evidence was authentic for example
24:38and I don't mean like in 30 years I mean like next year I mean that seems totally disruptive to the way to all of our institutions well I I don't think you could take say a random video on the internet and assume it to be true that's definitely not the case no somebody say has some video on their phone or their computer with the date stamp and a particular time I think you know it's more likely to be true than nine you can also cryptographically sign things like you know mathematically we don't see any way for example for AI to sub book The fundamentals of mathematics and say figure out how to Hash Bitcoin
25:28you know easily it's it's like it's not a AI can't can't defy fundamental math yeah so we can approve the efficiency of Bitcoin hashing algorithms in the Silicon but but not not fundamentally crack it so I guess cryptographic signatures and one one way to do it but I'm not sure where I I think it's more like our you know will Humanity control its Destiny or not well we have a future that is better than the past or not and not you know without we can certainly destroy ourselves without the help of AI you know that's you look at all the past civilizations they didn't have ai at the ones that weren't around anymore they have chariots that's enough yeah
26:29chariots and chairs probably a real big deal back then yeah they were yeah so you've heard people say we should just blow up the server Farms because there's no way that once if this gets rolling there's no way to slow it down what do you think of that well the the really heavy duty intelligence is not going to be distributed all over the place it'll be an a limited number of server centers if you say like very like very sort of deep AI heavy duty AI it's not it's not going to be in your laptop or your phone it's it's going to be in you know a situation where there's like a hundred thousand really powerful computers working together in a service
27:09center so it's not it's not it's not like subtle and they're they're a limited number of places where that can happen in fact you could if you could just you can just look at the heat signature from space yeah and it'll be very obvious now I'm not suggesting we go and blow up to service centers right now but there may be some it may be wise to have some sort of contingency plan where the government's got an ability to shut down shut down power to these server centers like you don't have to blow it up you can just cut the power and what would triple cut connectivity as well that's another way right yeah but what would trip that switch do you think in your mind what would be the
27:53threshold that you'd have to pass to warrant the government cutting off your power or cutting off your signal
28:15well I mean I guess if we lost control of some super AI like for some reason like like the things that would normally work to do a passive shutdown like the administrator passwords if they somehow stopped working where we can't slow down or or get out I'm not sure I don't have a precise answer but if if there's something that we're concerned about and and and are unable to stop it with with the software commands then we probably want to have some kind of Hardware both switch yes I think you know cat hurt have you talked since you know Larry Page and you obviously you know the open air guys because you started definitely have one have you talk to the the people
29:11who run these two the biggest AI companies about this recently I haven't talked to Larry Page in a few years because he got very upset with me about open AI so when when openai was created it did it did shift things into it from unipolar world where Google Google do you mind controlled you know like I said three quarters of all the AI Talent two where there's now a sort of bipolar world or open Ai and Google deepmind and their and now we're at least it seems opening eyes maybe a head so so I have had conversations with
29:56the open AI team Tim Altman I haven't talked to Larry Page because he doesn't want to talk to me anymore for a few years can I ask you just about since you've been around a lot of this the thinking so why would anyone not be a speciesist be human-centered in his thinking about technology like what's the thinking there I think what he's trying to say is that if I were to guess that he that all Consciousness should be treated equally and whether that is digital or biological hmm and you disagree I disagree yeah [Laughter] especially if the digital
30:42Consciousness or whatever you want to call digital intelligence decides to curtail the biological intelligence right so you're just building your own slave master and why would you do that doesn't sound great yeah I mean we shouldn't we we should at least no need to rush you know like what's the hurry where's the fire how well what I mean tell us about the hurry so this for I know you've been talking about this for years and on the sort of the periphery of our attention we've heard Elon Musk talking about AI but for most people it's been like three months since they've had any interaction with this at all so what's the timeline here at what point does it start to really change our
31:26society do you think I think it's supposed to have a probably an impact this year right I think so you've got a massive expansion of gbt4 based systems and many companies trying to emulate lgbt4 of now it's going to come up with gpd5 end of this year which will be yet another significant Improvement and I was there for GPD one two three four you know so GPD one was terrible like you if you tried it you'd be like this is this ain't going anywhere and it seems lame and then gpd2 you started to see kind of like an inkling of like well maybe this could be something useful and then gpd3 was a huge Improvement and now it's like wow okay this is it's still spotting a lot of BS but it's
32:28you know it's coherent BS yes and then gpd4 now it's like writing poetry and pretty decent poetry actually pretty decent yeah Skillet rhyming is incredible yes yes and it's coherent yes it is it's you've got a narrative like yeah that's right yeah so you could say like hard to do like most humans can't do that that's true so it's already past the point of what most humans can do and most humans cannot write as well as chat gbt
33:00and they certainly and no human can write that well that fast as the best of my knowledge so maybe Shakespeare so so then how much better will gpd5 be and how about gbd6 or 7. how can you have a democracy with technology like that I mean if democracy is you know government by the people each person's vote is equal to every other person's vote I mean and people are choosing their votes freely can can you have a democracy with this
33:33well that's why I raise the concern of AI being a significant influence in elections and even if you say that AI doesn't have agency well it's very likely that people will use the AI as a tool in elections and then it you know if AI is smart enough are they using the tool or is it tool using them so I think these things are getting weird and they're getting weird fast and so I think we should be concerned about this and we should have regulatory oversight that's why I think it's a big deal and I think social media companies really need to put a lot of attention into ensuring that the things that get created and promoted are that we're dealing with real people not with a
34:28million chat gbts pretending to be people exactly do you think speaking of social media you bought Twitter famously you've got a lot of other businesses and a lot going on yes you said you bought it because you believe in speech Free Speech you've had a lot of hassle since you bought it and retrospect was it worth buying it
34:54I mean it remains to be seen as to whether this was financially smart currently it is it is not you know we just revalued the company at less than half of the acquisition price yes no my timing was terrible for for when the offer was made because it was you know right before advertising plummeted and you caught the high water mark I noticed yeah yeah so I must be a real genius here my my timing is amazing since I buy the water for at least twice as much as it should have been bought for but some things are Priceless and so the the whether I lose money or not that is a secondary issue compared to ensuring the strength of democracy and free speech is the Bedrock of a
35:49functioning democracy yes and any the speech needs to be as transparent and truthful as possible so we've got a huge push on Twitter to be as truthful as possible we've got this community notes feature which is great it is great it is awesome yeah and it's like I saw it this morning yeah it was far more honest than the New York Times it's great yeah we put a lot of effort to ensuring that Community notes does not get gamed or have biases it is simply cares about what is the most accurate thing and you know sometimes truth can be a little bit elusive but but you can still aspire to get closer to it yes you know and so and I think the the effect of
36:32Community notes is more powerful than people may realize because once people know that they they could get noted you know Community noted on Twitter then they'll think more carefully about what they say they're likely it's basically it's an encouragement to be more truthful and less deceptive yes and if the notes themselves are truthful then it will have the effect absolutely and all of that is open source all the community notes is open so you can read about every Community note you can see exactly how the algorithm works you can you can you can register say like oh we need to make this change or that change so everything is super open book with
37:08with Community notes there's no no black box when you jumped into this though when you bought it did you understand well clearly you understood its importance he wouldn't bought it Twitter yes right but it's not the biggest but it's the most important in the social media companies but did you understand the kind of ferocity you'd be facing the attacks you'd be facing from Power centers in the country I thought there'd probably be some negative reactions yes all right so I'm
37:39sure everyone would not be pleased with the with with it but at the end of the day you know if if the public is happy with it that's what matters and the public will speak with their actions oh though I mean though if if they find truth Twitter to be useful they will use it more and if they find it to be not useful I will use it less they find it to be the best source of truth I think they will use it more so that's my theory and so I even though you know no there's obviously a lot of organizations that are used to having sort of unfettered influence on Twitter that no longer have that New York Times have their of their badge this morning and then you call them diarrhea
38:27okay you did you did I'm just I'm just quoting you you you described their Twitter feed as diarrhea I said it was a Twitter Twitter equivalent of diary okay it's not literally diarrhea but no it's you know it's a metaphor but an accurate one so I mean if you look at the at NY Times Twitter feed is unreadable it's like because what they do is that they tweet every single article even the ones that are boring even ones that don't make it into the paper so so it's just non-stop is a zillion
39:01tweets a day with no you know they really should just be saying like what are the top tweets yeah like one of the what are the what are the big stories of the day I don't know put out like 10 or something you know so it's a number that's manageable as opposed to right now if you if you were to follow NY at nytimes on Twitter you're going to get barraged with like hundreds of tweets a day yeah and your whole feed will be filled with NY Times so that that's that's this is something I would recommend actually for oral Publications which is for your primary feed only put out your best stuff don't put out everything or you could have a second feed that
39:40is here's everything but then but have a have your primary feed be here's our best stuff if any immediate organizational individual just have don't put out hundreds of tweets a day just put out like 10 good ones or five good ones or or and if it's a slow news day don't put on any maybe put out two one or two yeah but don't don't try to say we're always going to put out 100 tweets even if you know if it's World War III or a bicycle accident was the biggest news you know it's going to be like yeah news that is it's got it you've got to earn earn your play earn someone's attention yes so just in in general yeah I think I know a thing or two about how to use Twitter because you
40:30know it was the most interacted with account on the whole system before the acquisition put it before the acquisition closed I didn't have the most number of followers but I had the most number of interactions and so I clearly know something about how to use Twitter and so people should you know listen to my advice I think so you know people's attention is limited so just make sure you put the stuff that's most important there so because you know you and people like you do interact on Twitter it's obviously enormously powerful in shaping public opinion it's where a lot of ideas and Trends are incubated yeah you know that's why absolutely it's also a magnet for Intel agencies
41:11from around the world and one of the things we learned after you started opening the books is that they were exerting influence from within Twitter I mean it was absurd did you know that going in no well well so things like I I have a since I've been a heavy Twitter user since 2009 my it's it's sort of like I'm in The Matrix I mean I can see like things do things feel right do they not feel right what what tweets am I being shown as recommended like I I get a feel like what accounts are making comments where are the comments eerily similar yeah and and then you look at the account and it's just obviously a fake photo and you know that it's just
42:05obviously a bot cluster over and over again so this is actually so I started to get like just more and more uneasy about the the Twitter situation and I mean my initial goal was was was actually not not to acquire Twitter I mean the the actual sequence events was that I I was looking at I I I I I I I I held a Twitter poll to say like should I sell some of my Tesla stock because I was getting you know a couple years ago I was getting attacked a lot for like allegedly not paying taxes and no I've actually paid a tremendous amount of taxes no there was one year I didn't pay taxes because I had overpaid taxes in the prior year and you know when they had that like IRS
42:56leak BS they knew that I had overpaid taxes in the prior year but they said oh Elon Musk didn't pay taxes in 2017 or whatever it was and I was like but you know that the reason I didn't pay taxes because I overpaid the prior year if you didn't mention that so that was deceptive anyway so the the the you know Elizabeth Warren's of the world and Bernie Sanders like saying oh you know I'm not selling stock and I'm not paying taxes and I and so I so so I'm like look I don't know what the right thing to do is here I thought the right thing to do was to to not sell stock the captain should be the last one to leave the show that's right and I thought I was doing the
43:33right thing by not selling stock and now I'm being told I'm doing the wrong thing by you know clinging onto the stock and not paying taxes so I held a Twitter poll to say which what do you guys want should I sell I don't know 10 of my Tesla stock or or not I'll buy the results of the Paul and that's like six sixty percent of people said yeah you should sell 10 so I did so then I had a bunch of cash and I'm like what should I do with this at the time the the Federal Reserve rates were super low so it's just like sitting in the you know I guess the your checking account well in the T in the T bill account right you know money market account whatever
44:14the yeah the whole banking thing is a whole separate subject I know what the little thing to think about Finance but so so then I'm assuming this money account is earning less than the rate of inflation so the rate inflation is much higher so we've got high inflation it's I'm earning peanuts in the money market account well this is dumb I'm getting like minus it's just evaporating yeah I'm getting minus like six or seven percent to return here maybe worse and so then well it's like what stock should I buy and I you know I believe in buying stocks at companies where you use the product and Apple's got a competing electric vehicle car program so you know
44:54I like Apple products we're not going to invest in them because they're competing you know autonomous EV program and so what's the other product that I use a lot oh Twitter okay so I'll you know it put the money in Twitter it's better than just having it on you know negative six percent inflation situation
45:15so so I like board put a bunch of it what a bunch of Twitter stock I don't like to know what the intent of buying the company just you know it's better than keeping any money market remember how much you bought I think it was like eight percent or something of the company I'm talking to some of the board members and then and then they said hey well do you want to do you want to join the board so I was like well I don't I generally don't want to be on boards but because it's boring
45:46and I have a lot of things to do but I do care about the direction of Twitter so I'll consider being on the board and I thought about it for about a week or so and then but then based on the conversations that I was having with the management team and the board I came to the conclusion rightly or wrongly that that if I joined the board they they would not listen to me so then I'm like huh okay then I would just be a quizling you know I don't want to be some sort of just you know go along for the right quizling situation and and if a collaborator effectively right so and it really felt like I started starting to feel like wait a second like it's weird something something's like
46:39something's not right in this you know something's brought in the state of Denmark here there's that something feels wrong about the platform it seemed to be just drifting in a I I couldn't place it exactly just ahead of it felt like it was drifting in a bad Direction so then I was like and and my conversations with the board and management seem to confirm my intuition about that so then I was like okay but basically I was convinced these guys do not care about fixing Twitter and and and I had a bad feeling about where I was headed based in the conversations conversations I had with him so then I was like you know what I I I'll try acquiring it and see if that's
47:23see if acquiring it is is possible no I didn't have enough cash to acquire it so I would need you know support from others from some of the existing investors I would also need like a lot of debt and so it wasn't clear to me with a an acquisition would succeed but I thought I would try and ultimately it did succeed
47:46so anyway here we are but when you got there and all of a sudden you own it and all the data on the service belongs to you and what belongs to the people in my view but yes but but you can see what it is and you can see what they've been doing and you can see who's been working there you you were shocked to find out that various Intel agencies were affecting its operations the the degree to which various government agencies were effectively
48:16had effectively had full access to everything that was going on on Twitter blew my mind I was not aware of that would that include people's DMs yes yes because the dams are not encrypted so one of the first you know one of the things that we're about to release is the ability to encrypt your DM that's pretty heavy duty though because a lot of well-known people reporters talking to their sources government officials the rich people in the world they're dming each other and the Assumption obviously was incorrect but was that that's private but that was being read by various governments yeah that seems yes
48:56scary yes it is so like I said we're moving to have the DMS be optionally encrypted I mean you know there's like a lot of DM conversations which are you know just chatting with friends it's not not important but but so so we're it's hopefully coming out later this month but no later than next month is the ability to toggle encryption on or off so if you if you are in a conversation you think is sensitive you can just toggle encryption on and then no one on Twitter can see what you're talking about they could put a gun to my head and I couldn't I couldn't tell I couldn't
49:33if somebody puts a gun to my head and I can I still not see your DMs that should be that's the acid test yes and that's how that's that's how it should be if you want your have you had complaints from various governments about doing this I haven't had Direct complaints to me I've had sort of like some indirect complaints I think people are a little concerned about complaining to me directly in case I tweet about it you know they're like oh so they're sort of trying to be more roundabout than that and
50:14you know I mean if if I got something that was unconstitutional from the US government I would say my reply would be to send them a copy of the you know First Amendment and just say like what part of this are we getting wrong you have a lot of government you have a lot of government what part of this are we getting wrong please tell me I mean it's a pretty no I'm just saying but you're kind of exposed in your other businesses so this is just in case reviewers aren't following this this is not you're not just like a journalist taking a stand on behalf of the First Amendment you're a guy with big government contracts giving the finger to the government in some way
50:48well am I giving the things I I think that they're I'm not someone who thinks that you know the government is just sort of evil right it's it's a it's a large bureaucracy there are people in government who are human beings and they have the people with good motivations occasionally bad motivations with with rare exception the people that I know in government have good motivations and just want to get their job done and and they actually believe in the Constitution and they're so I think my opinion is actually most people in the government are good that's heartening to hear yeah it's it's rare for me to to find someone in the government who I think is
51:31perhaps not good but but you know at the highest level of the the agencies there are political appointees as you know and the political point is we'll have a political agenda and so they at the at the highest levels of the various government agencies there is the ability to put a sort of a political thumb on the scale even if the people operating the
51:54agencies don't agree with that so you know so that's something to be concerned about is I'd say I'd be more concerned about about political appointees I think than than the sort of people the career people that's been my experience at least do you think Twitter will be as Central to this presidential campaign as it was in the last several I think it will play a significant role in elections not just domestically but internationally so
52:34the the goal of new Twitter is to be as fair and even-handed as possible so not favoring any political ideology but just yeah being being fair at all why doesn't Facebook do this I know that Zuckerberg has said and I take him at face value that he I well I do I do actually in this way that he is a kind of old-fashioned liberal who doesn't like to censor he has but he you know like why wouldn't a company like that take the stand that you have taken it was pretty rooted in American traditional political custom you know for free speech
53:21my understanding is that Zuckerberg spent a 400 million dollars in the last election normally in a get out the vote campaign but really fundamentally in support of Democrats is that accurate or not accurate that is accurate does that sound unbiased to you no it doesn't yes so you don't see hope that Facebook will approach this as a a non-aligned
53:52Orbiter I'm unaware of evidence to suggest that path do can you you've you've allowed Donald Trump back on Twitter he hasn't taken you up on your offer because he's got his own thing right do you think he will go back on Twitter well that's that's obviously up to him you know my job is to you know I
54:20take the freedom of speech very seriously so it's you know I didn't I didn't vote for Donald Trump I actually voted for Biden people think I'm some sort of Hardcore you know so certainly some of the media try to paint me as like far right or whatever I'm right and the only time I've ever even voted Republican was was once for because I
54:47I registered to vote in South Texas I was for a Mexican-American woman for congress that's that's literally only a Republican vote I've ever cast in my entire life yeah once and so I'm not saying I'm a huge fan of Biden because I I would think that would probably be inaccurate but you know we have difficult choices to make in these residential elections it's not I I would prefer frankly that we we put someone it's just a normal person as president a normal person with common sense and whose values are smack in the middle of the country you know just you know Center the normal distribution and I think they'll be that that would be great I agree and it won't be happier
55:39would you run like why wouldn't you run I was born here so oh of course you weren't yeah I I it's it's I'm a technologist also I'm not not a politician so it's not like it it you know I think we have made maybe being president not that much fun you know to be totally Frank it is By Design a relatively weak role yeah because it's intended to be balanced by the house and the Senate and the Judiciary so it's not like like if your prime minister in England or Canada or you have formal power than if the president because it's like being speaker of the house right and being president you know so so your presence like deliberately weak in order to avoid creating a king
56:30situation King Queen's situation and but you get dumped on all day no matter what you do yeah and every thing you do is scrutinized and your life is not your own and if if you're at any skeletons you've got in the closet will be trotted out and you know paraded down Main Street and even if they don't exist they'll make them up and face it whatever politics is a blood sport yeah so it's it's not something I'd want to do so I gotta one last thread I just think you alluded to you said don't get me started on the banks so you've seen well so you've seen a couple Regional Bank collapses yeah and we've been told that's not a big deal that these are
57:15isolated and each one collapsed for Unique reasons or not it's not systemic in any sense what what's your sense your sense of the stability of the American banking system well it's actually at this point a global banking system problems so the you know we have a situation here where it's not merely it's not that the canary in the coal mine has died but the miners are starting to die too the you know the so and you know Silicon Valley Bank collapsing overnight is one hell of a big Canary you know smoke a turkey I mean it's not just it's not like some small fry thing yeah it's big fry so a medium fry and then query suis which is
58:09I think was formed in the mid-1800s was basically sold for pennies on the dollar forced to merge with UBS and even then required backstop by the Swiss government I mean like hello guys maybe we have issues here maybe things aren't all great they're definitely not all great members more forceful here the I think that there is a serious danger with the global banking system
58:44there's there's a strong argument that the if you were to actually mock to mock at the portfolios of the banks the loans and whatnot that the entire banking industry would have negative equity it feels that way yes so if you look at say commercial real estate like offices and whatnot the whole work from home thing has substantially reduced office usage in cities around the world and you know I think I think San Francisco is a 40 off San Francisco is like an extreme example but I think it's on 40 vacancy even even New York has almost all cities at this point have have record vacancies and Commercial Real Estate so now the commercial real estate used
59:42to be something that was a grade A asset that if a bank had commercial real estate holdings those would be considered the highest Securities some of the safest you know assets you could have now that is not the case anymore you one company after another is canceling their leases or not renewing their leases or if they go bankrupt you the the there's nothing for the the bank who owns that real estate to go after because they're you know previously strong company now dead what do you where do what do you go after that point so we really haven't seen the commercial real estate shoe drop that's more like a Anvil not a shoe so the stuff we've seen thus far
1:00:28actually hasn't even it is it's only slightly real estate portfolio degradation but that will become a very serious thing later this year in my in my view I think if we see what you're likely to see a drop in house prices because the interest rates are too high and for most people when buying a house they look at the monthly payment of course 30 year mortgages the vast majority of his interest so if the Fed rate is high you have a a high base interest rate effectively the price you can pay for the house drops because you now have to pay more interest which means that if you've got a fixed monthly payments you can now afford to buy a house for less less
1:01:17money it effectively drops the the prices of houses yes this is the kind of thing that tends to accelerate so that so then you can get negative equity in the Home Market as well and so so if if banks end up having loan losses in both their commercial and they're definitely going to have loan license in the commercial portfolio but also in their mortgage portfolio this is a dire situation
1:01:49the there is there is a solution to mitigate the magnitude of the damage here which is for the FED to lower the rate but they raised the rate again now if I recall correctly I'm sorry you know important caveat I think the last time the FED raised rates going into a recession was 1929.
1:02:13what happened next yeah the Great Depression that concern I'm going to tell you nothing you don't know but the concern is If the Fed drops rates again then inflation will accelerate and you can't do that in an election year so inflation is going to happen no matter what if you increase the money supply you get inflation right so there's no there's not some magical cure for getting rid of inflation except to increase the productivity the output output of goods and services so if you say like like what is money you've got you've got you've got these sort of it's basically numbers in a database that's that that's some up to some kind of some total then you've
1:03:06got the output of goods and services of the economy and the as long as the ratio of money to ratio of goods and services stays if that stays constant you have no no inflation if if you add more money if you add money to the system faster than you increase goods and services then you have inflation so all of these covered sort of stimulus bills were not paid for they were they're just generated more currency more you know more money was was was created because the the federal government the checks never that's the checks always pass you know unless you had a debt limit which there's probably going to be some debt limit crisis later this year but provided
1:03:50you haven't hit the debt limit the the federal government unlike state governments or city governments or individuals can simply issue more money and that's what they did I mean as old saying goes there's no there's no free lunch so if you could just issue massive amounts of money without negative consequences why don't we just take that to the Limit make everyone a trillionaire well I mean they tried that and been as well how'd that how'd that work out well they had to eat zoo animals right it's not good you know you get to the point where the you you know so why more Germany type stuff where you could like take bring in the cash to the store in a wheelbarrow yes
1:04:31so there's no free lunch there's not some ability to issue money and not have inflation the the this is just yeah so the inflation will happen and there's no fiddling with the the Fed rate is not going to affect that really but with the a high Fed rate can cause a lot of damage in shifting funds in the wrong direction so the the long-term return on say the S P 500 I believe is depending on how you count it around six percent so as if the FED real rate of return starts to approach what the long-term return is on the stock market why would you keep any money in the stock market you would should simply buy treasury bills of course because the treasury
1:05:33bills is a certainty whereas the stock market fluctuates right this is pretty basic also why would you keep money in a bank savings account if you can put it in what's called a money market account which is an account that represents treasury bills if the treasury bill money market account gives you you know four to five percent interest and the Bank savings account only gives you two percent you'll be a fool to keep the Money in the Bank savings account so the the the the the FED is made a tremendous Mistake by going this High with with the with their rate and they need to drop it immediately do you think they will they yes they they will have no choice
1:06:20but to drop it I think later this year the part of the issue is that the FED is an old institution and has a lot of latency in its data so it's like driving a car along a Cliffside Road a windy Cliffside road while looking at the rear view mirror but not even actually the rear view mirror a video that was taken of the rear view murder that's three months old [Laughter] now if you want to if you're on a straight Road yeah that works out okay because nothing's changing or it's only slight or a slightly bending road but we're more along like the we're doing the highway one PCH trip here and so you really want to look out the front window when you're in Big Sur
1:07:06yes if you're on a Cliffside Road where you could punch your doom so yes you want to look out the front window you want to look at the sort of forward commodity prices like look look at the look at what the Ford contracts are are predicting for commodity prices and not not not some
1:07:28laboriously slow government data collection process that like they'll claim to have for example December data that's not December that's not the data of December it's the data that arrived in December right exactly if you think about like how good is the government at actually collecting data horrible yeah yeah so it's like that's what I mean it's like three months old with less errors so if you had a hundred grand in your bank making decisions that basis is insane so so like what what should the average non-rich person do on the cusp of what you're describing which is economic catastrophe like how do you protect yourself
1:08:22I think I think probably a smart move overall and this this is guidance that I think applies across the ages is if there are companies in whose products you believe buy and hold the stock and and when when when the whenever else is panicking then buy more and everyone else thinks that that the stock is going to the Moon sell it you know sort of the by low sell High you're not an index fund guy like you pick specific stocks
1:09:02I that's my my you have to say like what what is the purpose of a company why should a company exist a company exists it's a group of people collected together to to provide products and services it's not it's not a thing in and of itself it's just a group of people that's like it's hard if it was just one person making you can make cupcakes yourself but you can make cars by yourself yes so if
1:09:29so so that so therefore the value of a company is a function of the quality of the products and services that it's that it has created and will create and so if if there's a company that you think well this company has got a lot of exciting products that I think are awesome the current products are good that's probably a company to invest in because that's the reason companies exist to produce goods and services that you like and so no I mean there's some caveats here to make sure you you're not like investing when when it's like the hottest thing you know because then it's going to have you had a temporary high but you know when when it's not sort of at a
1:10:14weirdly temporary high I think just generally looking at a company and saying well I like the products the service of that company and I like where they're going and the the management seems sensible and then I think buying and holding that stock is probably the right move I'm probably doing that with with a few companies that's what I'd recommend I think the on the I mean I I could really go into length about the financial system and the stock market and everything but the I mean these days I think we've gotten a little too far into the index passive fund World like somebody at some points got to make a decision you know I couldn't agree more yeah and
1:11:01and by the way they're they're like betting on both red and black I mean it doesn't yeah well depending on red and black in in a casino situation where it could come up green right and you're bound to lose yeah so the longer you play the worse you do now the stock market is is kind of like the opposite of a casino which is the longer you play the more likely you are to to succeed that historically has been the case and I think it will continue to be the case so but it's really just important not not to panic if you if you buy a stock and you you read something terrible in the newspaper or do you want to just remember the news has got a negative
1:11:37bias just and think about what other products of the company still sound does it have a good product roadmap do you believe in the management if so ignore what the Press says or if the price drops when this negative article buys stock so here's here's my last question and you mentioned the Press you've been the subject of press coverage for you know like a long time sure but very intense media coverage for the last year yeah sure well it seems that way anyway how is your opinion of the press changed
1:12:18well so my first company way back in the day and sort of pre-cambrian era of the internet or the World Wide Web it was up to we actually helped bring a number of the media organizations online so most newspapers are not online we helped bring hundreds of newspapers magazines online for the first time we added a tremendous amount of functionality to their websites with our software the New York Times company and night router were major investors and were on the board I spent a lot of time in newsrooms so I'm not unfamiliar with the media I got to see it firsthand
1:12:58all the way back in like 1996 so it's been a while sort of traditional media certainly had Revenue challenges because as online advertising has increased and it's much more measurable and much more sort of direct you can say like I spent this amount and got this this output you know like you it's interactive unlike say a newspaper or broadcast TV you're kind of guessing with the newspaper on broadcast TV that's right it whether if if something's online you can tell immediately that that person saw the ad and bought the product that's just very very immediate so
1:13:40and it's it's actually more effective if the advertising is is customized to the individual so so the advertising is more likely to be relevant whereas broadcast if if it's being shown to everyone is it's going to be irrelevant to most people the the result of that has been a huge shift in advertising revenue from newspapers and and a TV to you know
1:14:05the Googles and Facebook so the world enter a tiny bit to Twitter I think Twitter gets like one one percent of advertising revenue is quite tiny so this this is meant a shrinking pie obviously for most of the traditional media companies and made them more desperate to get clicks to get to get you know get attention and it's made them when you know when they were when they were in a sort of a desperate State they will then tend to really push headlines that get the most clicks whether those headlines are accurate or not so it's resulted in my view I think probably I think most people would agree a less truthful less accurate news
1:14:59so because they just got to get a rise out of people and I think it's also increased the negativity of the news because I think we humans instinctually respond more to that I think we have an instinctual negative bias which which kind of makes sense in that like if like let's say you like it's more important to remember where we where was the lion or where was the tribe that wants to kill my tribe then where is the bush with berries yes like one's like a permanent negative outcome and the other is like well I might go hungry so meaning like there's an asymmetry in sort of involved asymmetry in negative versus positive stuff and and also historically the
1:15:54negative stuff would have been quite proximate like it would have been near represented a real danger to you as a person if you heard negative news you because historically you know like a few hundred years ago we're not hearing about what negative things are happening on the other side of the world or on the other side of the country we're only we're hearing about negative things in our village things that could actually have a a bad effect on you whereas now we're hearing about we mean the news very often seems to attempt to answer the question what is the worst thing that happened on Earth today any wonder why you said after reading that you know
1:16:31and then use the most inflammatory language you know because every day they've got to sell sell the advertising even if it's it would have happened to be a slow news day do you read any Legacy Media Outlets when I read a lot so I mean I really get most of my news from Twitter at this point so
1:17:00it is the number one music new source I think in the world at this point so and that's all the more important that we we strive to to be accurate and and not it's not just a question of accuracy but we also need to allow the people to develop the narratives that are of interest to them so it's possible for news to be technically truthful but not but but that but they're still deciding what the narrative is like like let's say you wanted like you let's say you took a photo of someone and they had a little zit now you could zoom in on the zit and make it look gigantic like Mount Vesuvius and it is still true that they have a zit it's just not the size of Mount Vesuvius and
1:17:54they you know it doesn't properly reflect their face their face is not one giant set but you could say like well it's true but have they have lied they haven't you know they've just happened to zoom in on the zit and not look at the the rest of the face type of thing so what I'm saying is that the choice of narrative is is extremely important and at the point in which if there's only like say half a dozen editors in Chief or maybe even fewer than that maybe it's only three or four that are deciding what the narrative is what's gonna be on the front page then
1:18:40you know that that that that's that's a form of manipulation of public opinion I think the public often doesn't appreciate and is perhaps the most pernicious of all that's right because it's the most subtle yeah it's most subtle they haven't said an untrue thing they've just chosen what they're going to focus on a man called Douglas Mack he's facing 10 years in prison for posting what he believed funny memes on Twitter what do you make of that case I don't know the details of that case I've you know I've read a little bit about it you mean you probably know more about it than I do I
1:19:15I certainly don't think someone should go to prison for a long period of time for posting memes on Twitter in which case we're going to have a very full prison so and if we're talking about election interference well there's quite a few people that should be on trial for that for much far more serious crimes than than memes on on Twitter far more serious yes the Twitter files kind of showed that I think yes so you know unless unless this person really does I I said I don't I don't know everything that we're short of the trial has he been convicted is this yes he was so evicted on Friday unanimous jury verdict yes
1:20:06what was the value of New York City okay it was a it was in Brooklyn and it was a hung jury and Hungary it's not unanimous then well the judge prodded the jury okay and and they reached unanimous guilty verdict it'll be appealed so how many what percentage of your staff did you fire at Twitter one of the great business stories of the year I think we're about we're about 20 of the original size so 80 left yes so I mean a lot of people voluntarily sure sure but but it's 80 are gone from the data that's correct yes so how do you run the company with only 20 of the staff turns out you don't need well that many people to run Twitter but 80 that's a lot
1:20:54yes over I mean if you're not trying to run some sort of glorified activist organization with it and you're not care that much about censorship then you can really let go of a lot of people turns out how many others without naming names but how many I had dinner with somebody who runs a big company recently said I'm really inspired by Elon and I said you the Free Speech stuff he goes no the firing the staff stuff how many how many other CEOs have come to you to talk about this
1:21:34you know I I spent a lot of time at work so it's not like I'm meeting with lots of people basically what I what actions I've taken and but I think we just had a situation at Twitter where it was absurdly overstaffed you know so it wasn't you know like you could say like what does it really take to operate Twitter you know most of what we're talking about here is a group text service at scale like I how many people are really needed for that you know and if you look at the you say like what has been the product development over time with Twitter and you're like so like you know years versus product improvements and it's like a pretty flat line
1:22:21so what are they doing you know it took a year to add an edit button that doesn't work most of the time I mean this is I feel like if it was a comedy situation here you know you're not making cars you know it was very difficult to make cars or get Rockets orbit so you know the real question is like how did it get so absolutely overstaffed this is insane so anyway that's and it's clearly working in fact I think it's working better than ever it's about we've increased the responsiveness of the system by in some cases over 80 percent the there's a core piece of code
1:23:06for generating the the timeline which is run literally billions of times a day We've cut that code from 700 000 lines to 70 000 lines run yeah and and the co-efficiency by over 80 percent like meaning how much computers necessary to render the timeline Yeah by 80 I mean this is you know in four four five months We've increased the video time from roughly two minutes or best case 10 minutes to now two hours so you can put two hours of video on on Twitter we'll soon be increasing that to really where there's no no meaningful limit We've increased the Tweet length from 240 characters to four thousand we'll be increasing that to where there's again no meaningful length to if you
1:23:55want to post a novel on Twitter you should be able to do it and you know we as as everyone so on Friday we open sourced the super embarrassing recommendation algorithm which we were taking apart and at this rating which is exactly what I hope they would do and pointing out all the nonsense and we're going to open source more and we're going to subject it to
1:24:23Public public review we're also going to get criticized light because if you will point out all of the foolish things that are out that are happening in the code but then we'll fix it we'll fix it fast and it pop in full public View and I think that's kind of thing that that it was the public trust you know if if because like don't take my word for it it's just this is we you can literally read the code and you can read what people say about the code and and you can see the improvements that we make and you can see they'll see the like in real time live see see it get better
1:24:59so my prediction is that this I I would be surprised if this does not lead the public to think okay this this is something that I can trust I mean I I think far more trust trustworthy than say other social media organizations that have some mysterious black box that they refuse to show the show how it works I mean what are they trying to hide what are those outside which is not good things yeah if they had to have somebody to hide why didn't they show it was it's a proprietary business Secret
1:25:37yeah sure so my you know so we're trying to make make Twitter the most trusted place on the internet the the where you can get the you know the the least untrustworthy place on the internet I don't think anyone should trust the internet but but maybe we can make Twitter the least untrustworthy and you know where you can see a wide range of political opinions so including ones you disagree with I think people should be exposed to things they disagree with so it shouldn't just be continuous self-reinforcement of like what you know so that's that's the goal and I think we're making some some good progress in that direction I feel good about where things are going
1:26:24and we definitely want to have things as as sort of cleaned up as possible before the elections if there's any manipulation that we're aware of make that make the public aware of that and just like I said try to get the truth to the people as best we can Elon Musk thank you thank you conversation I appreciate it welcome that was the entire conversation with Elon Musk Tucker Carlson today is the name of the show new episode series a week on Fox Nation of course we'll see every weeknight 8 pm
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版