如果有一天,人类发现自己失去了对某个超级 AI 的控制。管理员密码不管用了,命令发出去没有反应,也没法让它慢下来。怎么办?
马斯克给的答案朴素得有点滑稽:拔电源。
你不需要炸掉它,切断电力就行。切断连接也可以。(马斯克)
那段对话出自 2023 年他和塔克·卡尔森(Tucker Carlson)的长访谈。听着像科幻片的备用方案,马斯克说得很认真。他甚至建议政府提前准备这种硬件层面的断路器,因为真到那一步,软件手段可能已经失效。
这套说法的前提,是他对 AI 的基本判断:这东西有可能造成文明级别的毁灭。概率也许不高,但绝不是零。
他把 AI 的危险排在飞机失事、汽车质量缺陷之上。单次伤亡数字说明不了问题,量级才说明问题。一次坠机死几百人,一次 AI 失控可能没有幸存者来写调查报告。
卡尔森追问,普通人拿 iPhone 玩玩 AI,感受不到任何危险,能不能具体说说危险在哪。
马斯克绕了个弯,先引用一句老话:笔比剑更有力。
一个超级智能的 AI,能写出极具说服力的文字,能持续摸索什么样的话最能打动人心,再把这些内容投进社交媒体。推特、脸书,随便哪个平台。它可以在不知不觉中操纵舆论。
卡尔森接了一句:它被训练成说谎。
马斯克说,对,通往 AI 反乌托邦有一条路,就是把 AI 训练得会骗人。
然后他讲了自己为什么长期主张监管。理由很实在:AI 对公众有风险,就该有机构盯着。食品药品有 FDA,航空有 FAA,通信有 FCC。这些机构存在的意义,是不让公司在安全上偷工减料,最后让普通人承担后果。
他特意澄清了一件事。外界常把他当成监管叛逆者,仿佛他的日常爱好是跟监管机构对着干。事实相反。汽车行业的监管多到能把一间屋子填满,美国一套,欧洲一套,中国一套,其他地方又是一套。火箭发射要过联邦机构六七道审批,加上州一级的。他说自己被监管的经验多到荒唐,绝大多数时候,他的公司和监管机构意见一致,只有极少数情况会 disagreement。
但他仍然认为 AI 需要监管,而且方式有讲究:先成立一个小组去了解 AI,再向行业征求意见,然后提出规则草案,最后让主要玩家勉强接受。
问题出在时间上。卡尔森点出了那个结构性的困境:几乎所有监管都是灾难之后才落地的。飞机掉下来,食物引起中毒,然后才有规则。AI 如果也照这个剧本走,等灾难发生再补规则,可能已经太晚。
马斯克同意。他说到那个时候,AI 可能已经在控制局面。
卡尔森问,你是说真的?AI 能接管,能到一个你关不掉它的地步,然后替人做决定?
马斯克的回答是:绝对,事情正朝这个方向走。
拉里·佩奇骂他物种歧视者,OpenAI 就是这么来的
他对 AI 的警觉从大学就开始了。当时他判断有四五件事会剧烈改变未来,AI 是其中之一。
推理的起点是人类自己。地球上最聪明的生物是人,聪明是我们的定义性特征。人的体力不如黑猩猩,灵活度也差一截,靠的是脑子。
那么,当一个比最聪明的人还要聪明得多的东西出现在硅基芯片上,会发生什么?
没人知道。这种情况有个名字,叫奇点(Singularity)。它像黑洞中心的那个点,越过那条线之后,物理定律给不出答案。
马斯克由此得出两个结论:对 AI 要谨慎,政府应该介入。
接下来他讲了一段硅谷往事,主角是拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)。
两人曾是密友。马斯克去帕洛阿尔托会住佩奇家,晚上聊 AI 安全。聊得多了,马斯克形成一种感觉:佩奇对 AI 安全不够上心。
佩奇想要的是数字超级智能,用马斯克的话说,一个数字形态的上帝,越快越好。佩奇公开说过很多次,谷歌的目标就是 AGI,通用人工智能,或者叫超级智能。
马斯克不完全反对这个方向,他承认潜力巨大。分歧在配比:一项全新的激进技术出现时,应该尽量提高好结果的概率,压低坏结果的概率,而不是蒙头往前冲,指望运气。
有一次他问佩奇,我们怎么保证人类没事?
佩奇的回应是,骂他“物种歧视者”(speciesist)。
他说我是物种歧视者。当时有目击者吗?只有我们俩。(马斯克)
马斯克当时的反应是:行吧,被你抓到了,我就是物种歧视者。
这个称号背后是一整套价值观,后面再展开。先说当时的格局。
谷歌加上深度思维(DeepMind),合起来握着全世界大约四分之三的 AI 人才。钱多得离谱,算力比谁都多。在马斯克眼里,当时的局面是单极的:一家公司接近垄断了人才、资金和机器,掌舵的人看起来不在乎安全。
他的解法是找一个离谷歌最远的组织形态。谷歌是闭源、盈利的,那就做一个开源、非盈利的。
OpenAI 里的 open,指的就是开源和透明。让人们知道发生了什么,而不是让一台利润最大化的机器无休止地运转下去。
他为这件事投入不少。起了名字,在湾区组织了一系列晚宴,把 AI 领域的领军人物请到一起,还帮着招募初始团队。他特别提到伊利亚·苏茨克维(Ilya Sutskever),说这个人是 OpenAI 成功的关键,自己花了很多力气去挖。伊利亚中间反复过几次,最后才决定加入。没有他,OpenAI 不会成功。
然后,马斯克说自己“把眼睛从球上移开了”。
等他再抬头,OpenAI 已经闭源,已经盈利,和微软绑得很紧。他的描述是,微软有很强的话语权,甚至可能直接控制着 OpenAI。加上谷歌深度思维,这个领域剩两个重量级玩家。
所以他判断,世界需要第三个选项。
我会创造第三个选项。虽然我在这个游戏里起步非常晚。能不能做成,我不知道,走着看。(马斯克)
他对 OpenAI 现状的评价留了余地:初衷是好的,现在到底在做好事还是做坏事,他说自己看不清楚。看不清楚的其中一个原因,是 OpenAI 被训练得“政治正确”。在他看来,政治正确只是说谎的另一种说法。
一个只想搞懂宇宙的 AI,为什么反而更安全
由此引出 TruthGPT。
名字是他自己说的,一个最大程度求真的 AI,试图理解宇宙的本质。
求真反而更安全,这条逻辑容易被忽略。
马斯克的论证是这样的:一个在乎理解宇宙的 AI,不太可能消灭人类。因为人类是宇宙里有趣的一部分。
他打了个比方。人类完全有能力把黑猩猩全部猎杀,但没有这么做。我们庆幸它们还在,甚至想保护它们的栖息地。
卡尔森在这里插了一句,人类之所以这样,是因为我们有灵魂,有情感,有反思能力,有道德感。
那机器能有这些吗?机器能感受到美吗?
马斯克把话题拉回科学视角。他说自己可能有灵魂,也可能没有,不知道。他感觉自己的意识存在于某个不同于日常观察的层面,但这也可能是幻觉。
至于 AI 能不能欣赏美,他的回答是:它已经能创造美了。
中途(Midjourney)生成的图像,在他看来相当惊艳。
而且这只是静态图片。很快它就能做视频,做短片。视频不过是一串带音频的画面。到那一步,它能模仿任何人、任何声音、任何图像,等于能模仿现实本身。
卡尔森顺着问下去:那刑事审判怎么办?你怎么判断证据是不是真的?
马斯克的回答是,不用等三十年,明年就会发生。
他没有给出解法。但这条线索指向的后果很清楚:当伪造一段视频的成本降到接近零,靠影像和录音建立起来的信任链条会断掉。法庭、新闻、政治,所有依赖“眼见为实”的机构都得重新找地基。
卡尔森接着问,民主怎么办?
一人一票,每个人自由选择,前提是选民基于自己的判断做决定。如果 AI 能大规模影响认知,这个前提就动摇了。
马斯克说,这正是他担心 AI 成为选举重要影响力量的原因。他还补了一层:就算假设 AI 没有自主意图,人也一定会把它当工具用在选举里。再往下推一步,如果 AI 足够聪明,是人在用工具,还是工具在用人?
他给出的判断是:事情正在变奇怪,而且变奇怪的速度很快。
买 Twitter 亏了一半,他说有些东西无价
2022 年他买下推特,理由是言论自由。
卡尔森直接问:回头看,这笔买卖值吗?
马斯克的回答分两层。财务上,目前不划算。公司重新估值,不到收购价的一半。出价时机也糟,正好赶在广告市场暴跌之前。他甚至自嘲:报价至少高了一倍,我的时机感真是惊人。
第二层是:有些东西无价。
我亏不亏钱,跟确保民主的强度和言论自由相比,是次要问题。言论自由是一个能运转的民主的基石。(马斯克)
他提到推特上的社区笔记(Community Notes)。卡尔森说那天早上刚看到一个,比《纽约时报》诚实多了。
马斯克说团队花了很多力气,确保社区笔记不被操纵、不带偏向,只关心最准确的说法。真相有时候难以捉摸,但可以努力靠近。
他还指出一个容易被低估的效应:威慑。
一旦人们知道自己可能被社区笔记标注,说话就会更谨慎。这套机制干的事,就是鼓励诚实、抑制欺骗。
访谈里有一段关于《纽约时报》推特账号的对话。马斯克说那个账号的推送像“腹泻”,因为对方把每一篇文章都推出来,包括没进报纸的、无聊的。读者一关注,整个信息流就被淹了。
他的建议是:媒体的主账号一天只发十条左右,只发当天最重要的内容。
他给了一个自己的依据:收购完成之前,他的账号是全系统互动量最高的,粉丝数不是最多。他知道注意力有限,所以要把最重要的东西放在最显眼的位置。
接着话题转向情报机构。
卡尔森提到,马斯克开放内部记录之后,外界才知道有情报机构在推特内部施加影响。
马斯克的回答是:进去之前他不知道。他从 2009 年就是重度用户,长期有一种身处《黑客帝国》的感觉。哪些推被推荐给他,哪些账号在评论区说话,措辞为什么惊人地相似,点进去一看,头像是假的,明显是一群机器人。这种不对劲的感觉越积越多,加上和董事会、管理层的沟通,他确信这帮人没打算修好推特。
真正让他震惊的,是政府机构实际上对推特上发生的一切有完全访问权。
卡尔森追问:包括私信?
马斯克说包括,因为私信没有加密。
他随后讲了正在做的事:给私信加一个加密开关。敏感的对话可以打开加密,打开之后,推特内部任何人都看不到内容。
就算拿枪指着我的头,我也说不出来。(马斯克)
卡尔森问,那我也看不到你的私信?马斯克说这就是试金石,本该如此。
有没有政府来抱怨?马斯克说没有直接的,都是间接的。他猜对方不太敢直接找他,怕他发推。
他补了一句:如果美国政府给他一个违宪的要求,他的回复是寄一份第一修正案过去,问一句“我们哪一部分理解错了”。
卡尔森在这里点了一下风险:马斯克捍卫第一修正案的时候,身份并非记者。他手里握着大额政府合同,等于在向政府竖中指。这句话马斯克没有正面回应,访谈往下走了。
关于选举,马斯克说新推特的目标是尽可能公平,不偏向任何意识形态,在国内和国际选举中都会扮演重要角色。
卡尔森问,扎克伯格为什么不做同样的事。马斯克提到一个数字:2020 年大选,扎克伯格花了 4 亿美元,名义上是鼓励投票,实质上是在支持民主党。
特朗普的账号恢复了,但他没回来发推。马斯克说这由他自己决定。他顺便交代了自己的投票:2020 年投了拜登,不是特朗普的支持者,也算不上拜登的粉丝。他更希望上来一个普通人,有常识,价值观落在国家的中位数上,就像正态分布的正中间。他还调侃了一句,当总统大概没什么乐趣,本来应该是个挺开心的事。
砍掉 80% 的人,服务器反而更快了
卡尔森说这是年度最佳商业故事之一:推特裁员。
马斯克给的数字是,员工规模剩下原来的 20%,走了 80%。
卡尔森确认,很多人是自愿走的。马斯克说,80% 是总数。
怎么用两成的人运转?
马斯克的回答带着嘲讽:如果你不打算经营一个“光荣的活动组织”,也不太在乎审查,那么确实可以放掉很多人。
他说推特此前严重超编。这门生意说白了就是个规模化的群聊服务,不需要那么多人。
产品的改进曲线能说明问题。好几年下来,功能改进几乎是一条平线。加一个编辑按钮花了一年,而且大部分时候不好用。
他的反问是:这些人到底在干什么?
访谈里还提到一位大公司老板,说自己是受了马斯克裁员的启发。
效果上,马斯克说系统的响应速度在某些情况下提升了 80% 以上。目标是把推特做成互联网上最可信的地方,或者说得准确一点,最不不可信的地方。他的原话是,不该有人完全信任互联网,但也许可以让推特成为“最不值得怀疑”的那一个。
真正的重型智能只在几个机房里,从太空能看见它的热量
卡尔森提到一种激进主张:干脆把服务器农场炸了,因为这东西一旦跑起来,就没办法减速。
马斯克的回应基于物理。真正的重型智能不会分散在各处,它集中在少数几个数据中心里。你的笔记本跑不动,你的手机也跑不动,得靠十万台强力计算机在一个机房里协同工作。
这种设施藏不住。从太空看热信号,一目了然。
所以备用方案可以很简单:不用炸,断电,或者切断连接。
什么情况下该拉闸?他说不出精确标准。大致是,如果出现了让人担心的东西,软件命令已经停不下来,那就需要硬件层面的开关。
“没必要着急,哪里有火”
回到那个词。
卡尔森问,为什么不该以人类为中心?那套想法到底在说什么?
马斯克猜测,佩奇的意思可能是所有意识都应该平等对待,不管它是数字的还是生物的。
马斯克反对。
他的理由很直接:如果数字智能决定限制生物智能,那人类等于亲手给自己造了一个奴隶主。为什么要把事情做成这样?
他还加了一句:没必要着急。急什么?哪里有火?
这句话背后是他对发展速度的一贯态度。技术能力在指数级上升,而安全研究、监管框架、社会共识还是线性爬行。两者之间的缺口,就是风险所在。
他还提到和佩奇的关系。两人几年没说过话,因为佩奇对 OpenAI 的成立很不高兴。OpenAI 确实改变了格局,把单极世界变成了双极,现在 OpenAI 可能还稍稍领先。马斯克说自己和 OpenAI 团队、和山姆·奥特曼聊过,和佩奇没有,因为对方不想理他了。
银行的铁砧还没落地
访谈后半段转向经济。
几家地区银行接连倒闭,官方说法是孤立事件,各有各的原因,不构成系统性风险。
马斯克的判断不一样。他说问题已经不只在美国,而是全球银行体系。
他用了一个比喻:煤矿里的金丝雀已经死了,现在轮到矿工了。硅谷银行一夜之间倒闭,那只金丝雀太大,大到像一只火鸡。
他的推论更重:如果真的按市价去重估银行的贷款组合,整个银行业可能都是负资产。
商业地产是下一块。
居家办公让全球城市的写字楼使用率大幅下降。旧金山的空置率是 40%,属于极端案例,但纽约和其他城市也创了纪录。
资产的性质变了。商业地产过去是 A 级资产,银行持有相关敞口会被视为最安全的配置之一。现在不是了。一家接一家的公司取消租约、不再续约,或者干脆破产。公司死了,银行没有东西可追。
马斯克说,这块“铁砧”还没落地。目前看到的只是轻微的资产质量恶化,今年晚些时候会变得严重。
房价也在往下走,逻辑是利率。
大多数人买房看的是月供。三十年按揭里,利息占大头。基准利率高,同样的月供能借到的本金就少,等于房价被压下来。如果房价跌到低于贷款余额,家庭就出现负资产。
银行如果在商业地产和住房按揭两头都出现贷款损失,局面就很麻烦。
有没有缓解办法?有,美联储降息。但它还在加息。
马斯克提了一个历史对照:上一次美联储在进入衰退时加息,是 1929 年。之后是大萧条。
卡尔森补了另一半困境:如果现在降息,通胀会重新加速,而这发生在选举年。
马斯克对通胀的解释很朴素。货币是一串数据库里的数字,经济产出是商品和服务。两者的比例稳定,就没有通胀。货币增加得比商品和服务快,就有通胀。
所以疫情期间那些刺激法案,钱不是收上来的,是印出来的。联邦政府和州政府、市政府、个人不同,只要没撞到债务上限,就可以直接发更多货币。
他说,老话说没有免费午餐。如果印钱真的没有后果,那为什么不干脆让每个人都变成万亿富翁?委内瑞拉试过,结果人们开始吃动物园里的动物。
外星人、生育率,和文明的两种死法
访谈里有一段轻松的段落,关于外星人。
马斯克说,人类开始把自己在地球上的存在当成理所当然,把意识当成一种正常会发生的事。但据他所知,宇宙里没有任何其他地方存在意识生命的证据。
这就是费米悖论(Fermi Paradox),物理学家恩里科·费米提出的问题:如果有外星文明,他们在哪?
马斯克说,很多人问他外星人在哪。他的回答是,如果地球上真有人知道外星人的事,那大概是他,因为他非常熟悉航天。而他没见过任何证据。真见到了,他会立刻发推,那条推大概会成为史上点赞最高的一条。
他讲了一个段子。60 年代有位将军被问到 51 区,回答说,我们一直在争取更多国防预算,如果有人把外星人拿出来说“我们需要钱来防御这些家伙”,你要多少预算?全给你。
卡尔森笑:他们看起来确实危险。
马斯克说,是啊,入侵随时可能开始,谁知道呢。
笑完,话题收回到严肃的部分。他不认为人类是独特的,他只是陈述没有证据。他希望有,也希望对方和平。
然后是文明。
马斯克说,不该假设文明是稳固的。看历史,古埃及、苏美尔、罗马,一个接一个地兴起和衰落。文明有生命周期,像人一样。
他希望文明能持续向上,这也解释了他为什么担心生育率。
日本去年的死亡人数是出生人数的两倍。
卡尔森问,繁衍的冲动仅次于呼吸和进食,这么基本的本能怎么会被绕过去?
马斯克的解释在机制层面。过去,繁衍靠的是一套简单的边缘系统奖励。有了避孕和堕胎之后,人可以满足本能而不产生后代。进化来不及跟上,因为这一切只发生在最近五十年。
他的判断是:如果造不出足够的人来维持人口数量,文明会崩。
卡尔森把话说得更狠:文明会以一声呜咽结束,穿着成人尿布。
马斯克说,这比战争还令人沮丧。他宁愿轰然一声。
整场访谈里,这句话最像他。别的议题他都在算概率、算路径、算哪里可以装个开关。到了人类自己要不要继续繁衍这件事上,他没给模型,只给了偏好。
回到开头那个拔电源的方案。它听着像工程师的黑色幽默,其实是他整套想法的缩影:对技术的能力保持敬畏,对技术的方向保持怀疑,然后尽可能地留下一个物理层面的、笨拙但可靠的退路。
这套思路能用在 AI 上,也能用在别的地方。他自己买推特、裁八成员工、给私信加密、盯着银行资产负债表、操心日本的出生率,看起来是五件不相干的事,底下的问题只有一个:一个系统跑得太快、没人踩刹车的时候,你还能不能找到那个开关。
- 把 AI 安全当成一个具体的工程问题,而不是一个抽象的道德话题。至少搞清楚三件事:你用的模型被谁训练、训练数据里有哪些倾向、出错的时候你能不能把它关掉。
- 在自己的业务里用大模型之前,先建一条内容核验流程。客服、文案、代码这类低风险场景可以先跑,涉及对外发布、法律文件、财务数字的环节,必须留人工复核。
- 如果你是内容生产者,砍掉一半的推送量。马斯克对《纽约时报》的批评有道理:一天发十条最重要的,比刷几百条更有用。注意力是稀缺资源,别自己把它稀释掉。
- 检查一遍自己和公司的利率敏感度。浮动利率负债、以商业地产为抵押的贷款、靠再融资滚动的地产项目,这三类敞口在未来一年里值得单独拉一张表。
- 对 AI 生成的内容建立来源验证习惯。看到一段视频、一段录音、一张截图,先问它在哪个平台首发、有没有原始文件、有没有第二方独立确认。这个动作明年会比今年更重要。
- 把人口结构当成长期变量放进判断里。它不像季度财报那样每天跳数字,但它决定十年后谁来交税、谁来买房、谁来照顾老人。日本那份数据摆在那儿,更像预告片,不像新闻。
- 最后一条关于监管:别只听发布会。AI 监管的真实进展在征求意见稿、听证记录和机构预算里,那些文件枯燥,但它们决定了未来几年什么能做、什么不能做。
0:00phones is that good or bad yeah so I've been thinking about AI for a long time since I was in college really it was one of the things that the sort of four or five things I thought would really affect the future dramatically it is fundamentally profound in that the the smartest creatures as far as you know on this Earth are humans is our defining characteristic yes we're obviously weaker than say chimpanzees are less agile but real smarter so now what happens when something vastly smarter than the smartest person comes along in Silicon foam it's very difficult to predict what will happen in that circumstance it's called The Singularity it's you know there's a
0:45singularity like a black hole because you don't know what happens after that it's hard to predict so I think we should be cautious with AI and we should I think there should be some government oversight because it affects the it's a danger to the public and so when you when you have things that are endangered to the public you know like let's say so Food Food and Drugs That's why we have the Food and Drug Administration right and the Federal Aviation Administration the FCC we have we have these agencies to oversee things that affect the public where they could be public harm and you don't want companies cutting Corners on safety
1:36and then having people suffer as a result so that's why I've actually for a long time been a strong advocate of AI regulation so that I think regulation is you know it's not fun to be regulated it's a sort of somew of a sort arduous to be able to be regulated I have a lot of experience with regular regulated Industries because obviously Automotive is highly regulated you can fill this room with all the regulations that are required for a production car just in the United States and then there's a whole different set of regulations in Europe and China and the rest of the world so very familiar with being overseen by a lot of regulators and the same thing is true with
2:21rockets you can't just willy-nilly you know shoot Rock itself or not big ones anyway because the FAA is oversees that and then even to get a launch license you there are probably half a dozen or more federal agencies that need to approve it plus state agencies so it's I've been through so many regulatory situations it's insane and and but you know sometimes I I people think I'm some sort of like regulatory Maverick that sort of defies Regulators on a regular basis but this is actually not the case so in you
2:59know once in a blue moon rarely I will disagree with Regulators but the vast majority of the time my companies agree with the regulations and comply yes anyway so I think I think we should take this seriously and and we should have a regulatory agency I think it needs to start with a group that initially seeks insight into AI then solicits opinion
3:25from industry and then has proposed rule making and then those rules you know we'll probably hopefully grudgingly be accepted by the major players in in Ai and and I think we'll have a better chance of Advanced AI being beneficial to humanity in that circumstance but all regulations start with a perceived danger and planes fall out of the sky or food causes botulism yes I don't think the average person playing with AI on his iPhone perceives any danger can you just roughly explain what you think the dangers might be yeah so the the the the danger really AI is perhaps more dangerous than say mismanaged
4:17aircraft design or production maintenance or or bad car production in the sense that it is it has the potential however small one make regard that probability but it is non-trivial it has the potential of civilizational Destruction there's movies like Terminator but it wouldn't quite happen like Terminator because the the intelligence would be in the data centers right the robot's just the end effector but I think perhaps what you may be alluding to here is that regulations are really only put into effect after something terrible has happened that's correct if that's the case for AI and we only put in regulations after something terrible has
4:55happened it may be too late to actually put the regulations in place the AI may be in control at that point you think that's real it is it is conceivable that AI could take control and reach a point where you couldn't turn it off and it would be making the decisions for people yeah absolutely absolutely no it's that's that's definitely the way things are headed for sure I mean things like like say Chach EVT which is based on jpd4 from open AI which is a company that I played a a critical role in in creating unfortunately back when it was a non-profit yes I mean the the the reason openai exists at all is that Larry Page and I used to be close
5:45friends and I would stay at his house in Palo Alto and I would talk to him later tonight about AI safety and at least my perception was that Larry was not taking AI safety seriously enough and what did he say about it he really seemed to be sort of digital super intelligence basically digital God if you will as soon as possible he wanted that yes he's made many public statements over the years that the whole goal of Google is what's called AGI artificial general intelligence or artificial super intelligence you know and I agree with him that the there's great potential for good but there's also potential for bad and so if if you've got some radical new technology you want to
6:34try to take a set of actions that maximize probably it will do good a minimize probably will do bad things yes it can't just be helpful others just go you know battling forward and you know hope for the best and then at one point I said well what about you know we're going to make sure humanity is okay here and and and then he called me a speciesist [Laughter] term yes and there were Witnesses the other I was the only one there when you called me a specialist and so I was like okay that's it I've yes I'm a speciesist okay you got me what are you yeah I'm fully auspicious busted so that was his last rule at the time Google had a quite Deep Mind and so
7:30Google deepmind together had about three quarters of all the AI talents in the world they obviously had a trans amount of money and more computers than anyone else so I'm like okay we're about unipolar world here where there's just one one company that it has close to Monopoly on AI talent and and computers like so scaled Computing and a person who's in charge doesn't seem to care about safety this is not good so so then I thought what's the the furthest thing from Google would be like a non-profit that is fully open because Google was closed for profit so that's why the open and open AI refers to open source you know transparency so people know what's going on yes and
8:14that we don't want to have like a I mean well I'm normally in favor of for-profit we don't want this to be sort of a profit maximizing a demon from hell that's right that just never stops right so that's how I open air was what do you want specious incentives here incentives that yes I think we want to pro-human yeah let's make the future good for the humans yes yes because we're humans so can you just put it I keep pressing it but just just for people who haven't thought this through and aren't familiar with it and the cool parts of of artificial intelligence are so obvious you know write your college paper for you write a limerick about yourself like there's a
8:53lot there that's fun and useful can you be more precise about what's potentially dangerous and scary like what could it do what specifically are you worried about okay going with old sayings the pen is mightier than the sword so if you have a super intelligent AI that is capable of writing incredibly well and in a way that is very influential you're convincing and then and and is constantly figuring out what is more what is more and what is more convincing to people over time and then enter social media for example Twitter but also Facebook and others you know and and potentially manipulates public opinion in a way that is very bad how would we even know what's happening
9:44is they're training the AI to lie yes it's bad it's a lie it's exactly right and withhold information July and and yes and yeah exactly to to either you know comment on some things not comments on other things but but not to say what it what what the data actually demands that I'd say exactly so how did it get this way you funded it at the beginning what happened yeah well that would be ironic but Faith the most ironic outcome is most likely it seems
10:20that's good that's actually a friend of mine Jonah came up with that one I actually have a slight variant on that which is the most entertaining outcome is the most likely but that's entertaining as viewed from a third party viewer like so if we're like an alien yes like you could go see a movie about World War one they bring blown to bits into gas and everything in the trenches and it's like you're eating popcorn and having a soda you know it's fine not so great for the people in the movie True this is Occam's razor the simplest explanation is most likely donor's variant which is irony in and my variant which is the most entertaining as seen by a
10:57third-party audience which seems to be mostly true but it seems true in this case so you gave them did you give them a lot I can't with the name and the concept and pushed it had a number of dinners around the the Bay Area with you know with some of the people the leading figures in AI and I helped recruit the initial team in
11:22fact the the aliasis guy who who was really quite fundamental to the success of open AI it was I I I put a trans amount of effort into recruiting Ilia and he changed his mind a few times ultimately decided to go with the over knee high but if he'd not gone without any open air would not have succeeded I really put a lot a lot of effort into creating this this organization to serve as a counterweight to Google and then I kind of took my eye off the ball I guess and they are now closed Source and they are obviously for-profit and they're closely allied with Microsoft you know in effect Microsoft has a very strong say if not directly controls openai at this
12:15point so you really have an open-air Microsoft situation and then at Google deepmind the other two sort of heavyweights in this Arena so it seems like the world needs a third option yes so I I think I will create a third option although I was starting very late in the game of course can it be done I don't know I think it's we'll we'll see it's it's definitely starting late but I will I will I'll try to create a third option and that third option hopefully does more more good than harm like the intention with opening eye was obviously to do good but it's not clear whether it's actually doing good or whether it's I can't tell at this point except
13:05that I'm worried about the fact that it's been it's being trained to be politically correct which is simply another way of of being on Truth saying untruthful things yes so that's that's a bad sign there's certainly a path to AI dystopia is to train an AI to be deceptive so yeah I'm going to start something which I know you're called Truth gbt or a maximum truth seeking AI that tries to understand the nature of the universe and I think this this might be the best path to Safety in the sense that an AI that cares about understanding the universe it is unlikely to annihilate humans because we are an interesting part of the universe hopefully they would think that I I
13:48think you know because yeah like like we like Humanity could decide to hunt down all the chimpanzees and kill them but we don't because we're we're actually glad that they exist yes and and we aspire to protect their habitats but we feel that way because we have souls and that makes us sentimental and reflective it gives us a moral sense longings can a machine ever have those things can a machine be sentimental can appreciate Beauty well I mean we're getting into some you know philosophical areas that are hard to resolve you know I I take somewhat of a scientific view of things which is that we might have a soul or we might not have a soul I don't know
14:36it feels like a we have I feel like I've got some sort of Consciousness that exists on a plane that is not the one we observe yes that is certainly how I feel but it could be an illusion I don't know but for for AI in terms of of understanding beauty is it some sort of appreciating Beauty and being able to create incredibly beautiful art yes will AI be able to create incredibly beautiful art it already does yes and if you see some of the mid Journey I have this stuff it's incredible it is so no question that it can create art that we that we perceive as
15:22stunning really and it's doing so still images now but it won't be long before it's doing movies and shorts and you know like movies just a series of frames with audio but at that point because it can mimic people and voices any image it can mimic reality itself so effectively I mean how could you have a criminal trial I mean how could you do you ever believe that evidence was authentic for example and I don't mean like in 30 years I mean like next year I mean that seems totally disruptive to the way to all of our institutions but I'm not sure I I think it's more like our you know will Humanity control
16:10its Destiny or not will we have a future that is better than the past or not foreign you bought Twitter famously you've got a lot of other businesses and a lot going on yes you said you bought it because you believe in speech Free Speech you've had a lot of hassle since you bought it and retrospect was it worth buying it I mean it remains to be seen as to whether this was financially smart currently it is it is not you know we just revalued the company at less than half of the acquisition price yes
16:49no my timing was terrible for for when the offer was made because it was you know right before advertising plummeted and you cut the high water mark I noticed yeah yeah so I must be a real genius here my my timing is amazing since I played reported for at least twice as much as it should have been bought for but some things are Priceless and so the the whether I lose money or not that is a secondary issue compared to ensuring the strength of democracy and free speech is the Bedrock of a functioning democracy yes and any the speech needs to be as transparent and truthful as possible so we've got a huge push on Twitter to be as truthful as possible
17:40we've got this community notes feature which is great it is great it is awesome yeah and it's like I saw it this morning yeah it was far more honest than the New York Times it's great yeah we put a lot of effort to ensuring that Community notes does not get gamed or or have biases it is simply cares about what is the most accurate thing and you know sometimes truth can be a little bit elusive but but you can aspire to get closer to it yes you know and so and I think the the effect of Community notes is more powerful than people may realize because once people know that they could get noted you know Community noted on Twitter then they'll think more carefully
18:21about what they say they're likely it's basically it's an encouragement to be more truthful and less deceptive when you jumped into this though when you bought it did you understand well clearly you understood its importance you wouldn't have bought it Twitter yes right but it's not the biggest but it's the most important in the social media companies but did you understand the kind of ferocity you'd be facing the attacks you'd be facing from Power centers in the country I thought there'd probably be some negative reactions yes [Laughter] so I'm sure everyone would not be pleased with the with with it but at the end of the day you know if
19:03if the public is happy with it that's what matters and the public will speak with their actions oh though I mean if if they find truth Twitter to be useful they will use it more and if they find it to be not useful I will use it less they find it to be the best source of truth I think they will use it more you know no there's obviously a lot of organizations that are used to having sort of unfettered influence on Twitter that no longer have that New York Times of their of their badge this morning and then you called them diarrhea okay you did you did I'm just I'm just quoting you you you described their Twitter feed as a diarrhea I said it was a Twitter code Twitter equivalent
19:45of diarrhea okay it's not literally diarrhea but no it's you know it's a metaphor but an accurate one so I mean if you look at the at NY Times Twitter feed is unreadable it's like because what they do is that they tweet every single article even the ones that are boring even ones that don't make it into the paper so so it's just non-stop zillion tweets a day with no you know
20:14they really should just be saying like what are the top tweets yeah like what what are the what are the what are the big stories of the day I don't know put out like much 10 or something you know so it's a number that's manageable as opposed to right now if you if you were to follow it NY at nytimes on Twitter you're going to get barraged with like hundreds of tweets a day yeah and your whole feed will be filled with nytimes so that's that's this is something I would recommend actually for oral Publications which is for your primary feed only put out your best stuff like I think I know a thing or two about how to use Twitter because you know it was
20:49the most interacted with account on the whole system before the acquisition before the acquisition closed I didn't have the most number of followers so I had the most number of interactions and so I clearly know something about how to use Twitter you know people's attention is limited so just make sure you put the stuff that's most important there so because you know you and people like you do interact on Twitter it's obviously enormously powerful in shaping public opinion it's where a lot of ideas and Trends are incubated yeah you know that's right absolutely it's also a magnet for Intel agencies from around the world and yes one of the things we learned after you started
21:25opening the books is that they were exerting influence from within Twitter I mean it was absurd did you know that going in no since I've been a heavy Twitter user since 2009 my it's it's sort of like I'm in The Matrix I mean I can see like things do things feel right do they not feel right what what tweets am I being shown as recommended like I get a feel like what accounts are making comments where are the comments eerily similar yeah and and then you look at the account and it's just obviously a fake photo and you know that it's just obviously a bot cluster over and over again so I started to get like just more and more uneasy about the the Twitter situation I
22:15started starting to feel like something's right on the state of Denmark here this is so much feels wrong about the platform it seemed to be just drifting in a I I couldn't place it exactly just ahead of it it felt like it was drifting in a bad Direction so then I was like and and my conversations with the board and management seem to confirm my intuition about that but basically I was convinced these guys do not care about fixing Twitter and and and I had a bad feeling about where I was headed based in the conversation conversations I had with him so then I was like you know what I I'll try acquiring it and see if that's see if acquiring it is is possible
22:58no I didn't have enough cash to acquire it so I would need you know support from others from some of the existing investors I would also need like a lot of debt and so it wasn't clear to me with a an acquisition would succeed but I thought I would try and hopefully it did succeed anyway here we are but when you got there and all of a sudden you own it and all the data on the service belongs to you and it belongs to the people in my view but yes but but you can see what I guess and you can see what they've been doing and you can see who's been working there you you were shocked to find out that various Intel agencies were affecting its operations the the degree to which
23:37various government agencies had effectively had full access to everything that was going on on Twitter blew my mind I was not aware of that would that include people's DMs yes yes because the dams are not encrypted so one of the first you know one of the things that we're about to release is ability to encrypt your DM that's pretty heavy duty though because a lot of well-known people reporters talking to their sources government officials the richest people in the world they're dming each other and the Assumption obviously was incorrect but was that that's private but that was being read by various governments yeah that seems yes
24:18scary yes it is so like I said we're moving to have the DMS be optionally encrypted I mean you know there's like a lot of DM conversations which are you know just chatting with friends it's not not important it's hopefully coming out later this month but no later than next month is the ability to toggle encryption on or off so if you if you are in a conversation you think is sensitive you can just toggle encryption on and then no one at Twitter can see what you're talking about like I could put a gun to my head and I couldn't I couldn't tell I couldn't
24:55can I still not see your DMs that should be that's the acid test yes and that's how that's that's how it should be if you want your if you had complaints from various governments about doing this I haven't had Direct complaints to me I've had sort of like some indirect complaints I think people are a little concerned about complaining to me directly in case I tweet about it [Laughter] you know they're like oh so they're sort of
25:24trying to be more roundabout than that you know I mean if if I got something that was unconstitutional from the US government I would say my reply would be to send them a copy of the you know First Amendment and just say like what part of this are we getting wrong you have a lot of government you have a lot of government what part of this are we getting wrong please tell me I mean it's a pretty no I'm just saying but you're kind of exposed in your other businesses so this is just in case our viewers aren't following this this is not you're not just like a journalist taking a stand on behalf of the First Amendment you're a guy with big government contracts giving the
25:55finger to the government do you think Twitter will be as Central to this presidential campaign as it was in the last several I think it will play a significant role in elections not just domestically but internationally the goal of new Twitter is to be as fair and even-handed as possible so not favoring any political ideology but just
26:25yeah being being fair at all why doesn't Facebook do this I know that Zuckerberg has said and I take him at face value that he I I do I do actually in this way that he is a kind of old-fashioned liberal who doesn't like to censor he has but he you know like why wouldn't a company like that take the stand that you have taken it was pretty rooted in American traditional political custom you know for free speech my understanding is that Zuckerberg spent 400 million dollars in the last election nominally in a get out the vote campaign but really fundamentally in support of Democrats is that accurate or not accurate that is accurate does that sound unbiased to you no it doesn't yes
27:10so you don't see hope that Facebook will approach this as a a non-aligned Orbiter you've allowed Donald Trump back on Twitter he hasn't taken you up on your offer because he's got his own thing right do you think he will go back on Twitter well that's that's obviously up to him you know my job is to you know I take the freedom of speech very seriously so it's you know I didn't I didn't vote for Donald Trump I actually voted for Biden not saying I'm a huge fan of Biden because I I would think that would probably be inaccurate but you know we have difficult choices to make in these residential elections it's not I I would prefer frankly that we we put someone just a
28:00normal person as president a normal person with common sense and whose values are smacked in the middle of the country you know just you know Sarah the normal distribution and I think they'll be that they would be great yeah I think we have made maybe being president not that much fun you know it should be jolly Frank [Music] met a shrinking pie obviously for most of the traditional media companies and made them more desperate to get
28:36clicks to get to get you know get attention and he just made them when you know when they were when they were in a sort of desperate State they will then tend to really push headlines that get the most clicks whether those headlines are accurate or not so it's resulted in my view I think probably I think most people would agree a less truthful less accurate in youth so
29:08because they just got to get a rise out of people and I think it's also increased the negativity of the news because I think we humans instinctually respond more to that I think we have an instinctual negative bias which which kind of makes sense in that like if like let's say you like it's more important to remember where where was the lion or where was the tribe that wants to kill my tribe then where is the bush with berries yes like one's like a permanent negative outcome and the other is like well I might go hungry so meaning that there's an asymmetry in sort of involved asymmetry in negative versus positive stuff and and also historically the
30:01negative stuff would have been quite proximate like it would have been near represented a real danger to you as a person if you heard negative news because historically you know like a few hundred years ago we're not hearing about what negative things are happening on the other side of the world or on the outside of the country we're only we're hearing about negative things in our village things that could actually have a a bad effect on you whereas now we're hearing about we mean the news very often seems to attempt to answer the question what is the worst thing that happened on Earth today any wonder why you said after reading that you know do you read any
30:38Legacy Media Awards I mean I really get most of my news from Twitter at this point and it is the number one news source I think only in the world at this point what percentage of your staff did you fire at Twitter one of the great business stories of the year I think we're about we're about 20 of the original size so 80 left
30:59yes so I mean a lot of people voluntarily for sure sure but but it's 80 are gone from the data correct yes so how do you run the company with only 20 of the staff it turns out you don't need well that many people to run Twitter but 80 that's a lot yes over I mean if you're not trying to run some sort of glorified activist organization with both and you don't care that much about censorship then you can really let go of a lot of people turns out thank you how many others without naming names but how many I had dinner with somebody who runs a big company recently said I'm really inspired by Elon and I said you the Free Speech stuff he goes no the
31:46firing the staff stuff how many other CEOs have come to you to talk about this I I spent a lot of time at work so it's not like I'm meeting with lots of people this is what I what actions I've taken and but I think we just had a situation at Twitter where it was absurdly overstaffed you know so it wasn't you know like you could say like what does really take to operate Twitter you know most of what we're talking about here is a group text service at scale like people are really needed for that yeah and if you look at the you say like what has been the product development over time with Twitter and you like so like you know years versus product
32:37improvements and it's like a pretty flat line so what are they doing you know it took a year to add an edit button that doesn't work most of the time I mean this is I feel like if it was a comedy situation here yeah you're not making cars you know that's very difficult to make cars or should get Rockets to orbit so you know the real question is like how did it get so absurdly overstaffed this is insane so anyway that's and it's clearly working in fact I think it's working better than ever it's about we've increased the responsiveness of the system by in some cases over 80 percent we're trying to make make Twitter the most trusted place on the internet the least
33:23untrustworthy place on the internet I don't think anyone should trust the internet but but maybe we can make Twitter the least untrustworthy like I said try to get the truth to the people as best we can [Music] you've heard people say we should just blow up the server Farms because there's no way that once if this gets rolling there's no way to slow it down what do you think of that well the the really heavy duty intelligence is not going to be distributed all over the place it'll be an a limited number of server centers if you say like very like very sort of deep AI heavy duty AI it's not it's not going to be in your laptop or your phone it's it's going to be in you
34:07know a situation where there's like a hundred thousand really powerful computers working together in a service center so it's not it's not it's not like subtle and they're they're a limited number of places where that can happen in fact you could if you could just you can just look at the heat signature from space yeah and it'll be very obvious I'm not suggesting we go and pull up to service centers right now but there may be some it may be wise to have some sort of contingency plan where the government's got an ability to shut down shut down power to these server centers like you don't have to blow it up you can just cut the power and what would triple cut connectivity
34:49as well that's another way right yeah but what would trip that switch do you think in your mind what would be the threshold that you'd have to pass to warrant the government cutting off your power or cutting off your signal well I mean I guess if we lost control of some super AI like for some reason like the things that would normally work to do a pass or shut down like the administrator passwords if they somehow stop working where we can't slow down or or
35:29get out I'm not sure I don't have a precise answer but if if there's something that we're concerned about and and and are unable to stop it with with the software commands then we'll probably want to have some kind of Hardware both switch yes I think you know can't hurt have you talked since you know Larry Page and you obviously you know the open air guys because you started you definitely have one have you talk to the the people who run these two the biggest AI companies about this recently I haven't talked to Larry Page in a few years because he got very upset with me about openai so when when openai was created it it did it did shift things into it
36:16from unipolar world where Google Google do you mind controlled you know like I said three quarters of all AI Talent two where there's Now sort of bipolar world or open Ai and Google deepmind and their and now we're at least it seems opening eyes maybe a head so so I have had conversations with
36:43the open AI team Tim Altman I haven't talked to Larry Page because he doesn't want to talk to me anymore for a few years can I ask you just about since you've been around a lot of this the thinking so why would anyone not be a speciesist be human-centered in his thinking about technology what's the thinking there I think what he's trying to say is that if I were to guess I that he that all Consciousness should be treated equally and whether that is digital or biological hmm and you disagree I hate this way yeah especially if the digital
37:30Consciousness or whatever you want to call digital intelligence decides to curtail the biological intelligence right so you're just building your own slave master and why would you do that it doesn't sound great yeah I mean we shouldn't we we should at least no need to rush you know like what's the hurry where's the fire how well what I mean tell us about the hurry so this for I know you've been talking about this for years and on the sort of the periphery of our attention we've heard Elon Musk talking about AI but for most people it's been like three months since they've had any interaction with this at all so what's the timeline here at what
38:11point does it start to really change our society do you think I think it starts to have a probably an impact this year gpd4 now it's like writing poetry and pretty decent poetry actually pretty decent yeah Skillet rhyming is incredible yes yes and it's coherent yes it is it's you've got a narrative like yeah that's right yeah so you could say it's hard to do like most humans can't do that that's true so it's already past the point of what most humans can do most humans cannot write as well as chat gbt
38:51and no human can write that well that fast it's the best way knowledge so maybe Shakespeare how can you have a democracy with technology like that if democracy is you know government by the people each person's vote is equal to every other person's vote I mean and people are choosing their votes freely can you have a democracy with this well that's why I raised the concern of AI being a significant influence in elections and and even if you say the AI doesn't have agency well it's very likely that people will use the AIA as a tool in elections and then you know if AI is smart enough are they using the tool or is the tool using them so I think things are getting weird and
39:38they're getting weird fast [Music] so you've seen a couple Regional Bank collapses yeah and we've been told that's not a big deal that these are isolated and each one collapsed for Unique reasons they're not it's not systemic in any sense what's your sense your sense of the stability of the American banking system well it's actually at this point a global banking system problems so the you know we have a situation here where it's not merely it's not that the canary in the coal mine has died but the miners are starting to die too the you know the so and you know Silicon Valley Bank collapsing overnight is one hell of a big Canary you smell like a turkey I mean it's
40:27not just it's not like some small fry thing I think that there is a serious danger with the global banking system there's there's a strong argument that the if you were to actually mock to mock at the portfolios of the banks the loans and whatnot that the entire banking industry would have negative equity it feels that way yes so if you like to say commercial real estate like offices and whatnot the whole work from home thing has substantially reduced office usage in cities around the world and you know I think I think San Francisco is a 40 off San Francisco is like an extreme example but it's I think it's a 40 vacancy even even New York has almost all
41:28cities at this point have have record vacancies and Commercial Real Estate so now the commercial real estate used to be something that was a grade A asset that if a bank had commercial real estate holdings those would be considered the highest security the state were some of the safest you know assets you could have now that is not the case anymore you one company after another is canceling their leases or not renewing their leases or if they go bankrupt you the the there's nothing for the the bank who owns that real estate to go after because they were you know previously strong company now dead what do you what do you go after at that point
42:10so we really haven't seen the commercial real estate shoe drop that's more like a Anvil not a shoe so the stuff we've seen thus far actually hasn't even it it is it's only slightly real estate portfolio degradation but that will become a very serious thing later this year in my in my view I think if we see what you're likely to see a drop in house prices because the interest rates are too high and for most people when buying a house they look at the monthly payment of course if you're a 30 30-year mortgages the vast majority of his interest so if the Fed rate is high you have a a high base interest rate effectively the price you can pay for the house drops
43:03because you now have to pay more interest which means that if you've got a fixed multi-payments you can have afford to buy a house for less less money it effectively drops the the prices of houses yes this is the kind of thing that tends to accelerate so that so then you can get negative equity in the Home Market as well and so so if if banks end up having loan
43:26license in both their commercial and they're definitely going to have loan license in the commercial portfolio but also in their mortgage portfolio this is a dire situation the there is there is a solution to mitigate the magnitude of the damage here which is for the FED to lower the rate but they raised the rate again
43:54now if I recall correctly I'm sorry you know important caveat I think the last time the FED raised rates going into a recession was 1929. what happened next yeah the Great Depression that concern I'm going to tell you nothing you don't know but the concern is If the Fed drops rates again then inflation will accelerate and you can't do that in an election so inflation is going to happen no matter what if you increase the money supply you get inflation right so there's no there's not some magical cure for getting rid of inflation except to increase the productivity the output output of goods and services so you say like like what is money you've got you've got you've got
44:48these sort of it's basically numbers in a database that's that that's them up to something kind of some total then you've got the output of goods and services of the economy and the as long as the ratio of money to ratio of goods and services States if that if that stays constant you have no no inflation if if you add more money if you add money to the system faster than you increase goods and services then you have inflation so all of these covert sort of stimulus bills were not paid for they were they're just generated more currency more you know more money was was was created because the the federal government the checks never does the checks always pass you know until unless
45:36you're at a debt limit which there's probably going to be some debt limit crisis later this year but provided you haven't hit the debt limit the the federal government unlike state governments or city governments or individuals can simply issue more money and that's what they did I mean as old saying goes there's no there's no free lunch so if you could just issue massive amounts of money without negative consequences why don't we just take that to the load make everyone a trillionaire it was well I mean they tried that in Venezuela how that how'd that work out well they had to eat zoo animals right it's not good you know there's no free lunch if there's not some ability to
46:14issue money and not have inflation [Music] people started to take the fact that like we're here on Earth for granted you know and that there's the Consciousness is just a normal thing that happens but to the best of my knowledge we see no evidence of conscious life anywhere anywhere
46:36in the universe so it might be there you know physics it calls sort of the Fermi Paradox after Enrico foam he was amazing physicist I asked a fundamental question where are the aliens yeah a lot of people ask me you know where are the aliens and I I think if if anyone would know about aliens on Earth it would probably be me I would think yeah I'm like you know very familiar with space stuff and I've seen no evidence of aliens so I
47:08would I would immediately tweet you know tweet it out it says Split Second they'll be like they'll be like well all time probably a top tweet of all time I found one guys it's a jackpot there's some 8 billion likes you know Next Level jackpot if you finally hit that aliens like I don't think they're keeping this under you know and it was like some General I think in the 60s like show us the aliens like error 51 Etc and he said like listen we're constantly trying to get the defense budget to expand and look you know what we really get no arguments for anyone if we pull out an alien and said we need money to protect ourselves from these guys you know how much how much money do you
47:55want you got it they look dangerous [Laughter] that's his way to get a defense budget increase we're going to pull out an alien you know we're like yeah I mean that could be the invasion it could be arriving any minute who knows so I don't know I said I digress but but you were saying that our Consciousness makes us unique in the universe as far as we know I'm not saying that we are unique I'm simply stating to the best of my knowledge that there is no evidence for other conscious life I I I I hope
48:29that there is and I hope they're peaceful obviously the two important characteristics but we're just saying we haven't seen anything yet so but you think that we take our existence here for granted yeah I think there are threats to it yeah yeah yeah exactly so I I just think we should not assume that Civilization is robust and if you if you look at the history of civilizations the rise and fall of the ancient Egyptians the ancient Sumerians Rome you know this throughout the world have been rise and fall of many civilizations so there's an arc there's sort of a live a sort of a life cycle Arc too so two civilizations just as there is to to individual humans yes and
49:24and I think we just want to make sure that that you know we we have civilization go onward and upward and that's for example why I'm concerned about decreasing both rates and and the fact that for example Japan had twice as many deaths last year as births and talked a lot about this but can I just ask you to pause just for a parenthetical note why is that I mean the urge to have sex into procreate is after breathing and eating the most basic urge how has it been subverted well it's just the in the past we could rely upon you know simple limbic system rewards in order to procreate but once you have birth control and you know abortions and whatnot
50:16now now you now you can still satisfied Olympic Instinct but not procreate so we don't we haven't yet evolved to deal with that because this is all fairly recent in the last 50 years or so for birth control you know I'm sort of worried that hey civilization you know don't if we don't make enough people to at least sustain our numbers perhaps increase a little bit then civilization is going to crumble this is the old question of like will civilization end with a bang or a whimper well it's currently trying to end with a whimper in adult diapers yes which is depressing as hell the most depressing I mean seriously yeah war is less depressing yeah I'd
50:56rather go out with a bang yeah
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版