2023年4月11日,BBC记者詹姆斯·克莱顿(James Clayton)给马斯克发了一封邮件,他自己都觉得不会有人回。几个小时后,他坐在了推特旧金山总部,对面是马斯克本人,三台摄像机、一堆补光灯,同时在线收听这场对话的有二十多万人,后来涨到三百多万。
采访是临时拼起来的,没有预热,没有提纲交换。克莱顿后来说,这场对话原本只给了他二十分钟。
两个人聊了很多:推特到底会不会死、裁员为什么那么狠、仇恨言论有没有变多、蓝标凭什么收八美元、媒体还值不值得信任、AI 会不会把互联网彻底搞乱。中途马斯克反客为主,开始念推特上的实时评论,还让几个听众直接开麦发言,其中一位当面要求克莱顿“做个负责任的记者”。
把整场对话读完,会发现一个挺有意思的落差:外界给马斯克贴的标签是狂人、是冲动、是口无遮拦,但在这场对谈里,他讲得最细、最较真的部分,全是账本、服务器和代码。
一笔他自己都想反悔的收购
采访从最尴尬的地方切进去。
2022年4月,马斯克提出收购推特,推特董事会的反应是启动“毒丸计划”。他用了个很损的比喻:董事会的态度相当于“宁肯吞氰化物去死,也不让你买”。
然后他自己退缩了,说不想买了。再然后,推特董事会反过来告他,要求必须完成交易。
“我当时的反应是:你们是同一批人吗?前脚说宁死也不卖,后脚拿枪指着我的头说必须买,这不奇怪吗?”(马斯克)
克莱顿追问得很直接:你当时说不要了,是不是因为觉得买贵了?
马斯克没有绕。他给了一个仓库的类比:你被告知仓库里只有不到百分之五的货物是坏的,等你走进去一看,坏掉的有百分之二十五。这时候你还想按原价买吗?正常人都会想压价。
他说的“坏货”,指的是虚假账号。推特对外披露的用户数据,远高于真实用户数。
克莱顿继续逼:所以你最后还是买了,是因为法院会强制你买,对吧?
马斯克答:是,这是原因。
他之所以买下推特,是因为律师告诉他跑不掉了。这个细节很关键,它解释了后面所有事情的节奏:一个被迫接手的买家,兜里揣着一张自己都觉得贵的账单,走进了一栋他形容为“装修很贵、很漂亮”的办公楼。
四个月就会死的公司
这是整场访谈里信息最密集的一段,也最容易被情绪化讨论盖过去。
马斯克给出的数字是这样的:交易完成那一刻,推特的年度亏损正在朝着三十多亿美元走,账上只有十亿美元现金。
“十亿在账上,一年亏三十亿,那就是四个月后死亡。”(马斯克)
他进一步拆了收支结构。正常情况下,推特一年营收大约四十五亿美元,成本大约四十五亿,基本打平。打平不算破产,问题出在收购带来的大约十五亿美元债务利息,加上营收大幅下滑。
下滑的原因他归为两部分:周期性的广告需求收缩,加上政治因素。同期 Meta 和 Google 的广告收入也在跌,只是推特跌得更狠一些。
然后数字变成这样:营收从四十五亿掉到三十亿,支出从四十五亿涨到六十亿,负现金流三十亿美元。账上那十亿,撑四个月。
这套账摆在任何一个 CEO 面前,第一动作只能是砍成本,而且要立刻砍、大规模地砍。
这也是理解后面裁员争议的前提。克莱顿提到,很多被裁的员工说过程很混乱、很冷漠,有人是刷门禁卡的时候才发现自己已经被裁了。他问马斯克怎么看。
马斯克的回答没有道歉,用的是沉船的比喻:如果整条船要沉了,没人能活下来。他还补了一句,被裁的人大多拿到了三个月薪水,有些情况更多。
克莱顿提了一个更尖锐的角度:你身家两千亿美元,为什么不能自己掏钱补上,非要卖特斯拉股票?
马斯克说,他确实卖了很多特斯拉股票来完成这笔交易,而他并不想卖。他还提到一个外界常年误解的点:他只能在特定窗口期卖股票,而每次卖股票都会被解读成“对特斯拉失去信心”,实际上是为了给推特输血。
人数上,推特从大约八千人砍到一千五百人左右。他承认,裁掉这么多人一点都不好玩,也没办法一个个去谈。
最难的那件事,排在裁员前面
克莱顿问,过去六个月最难的事是什么。
他给出的答案是关掉其中一个数据中心,裁员反倒排不上。
推特原来有三个数据中心,他关掉了一个,等于只剩三分之二的算力。关之前他以为这个中心是冗余的,关完才发现,有大量功能是硬编码在这个中心里的。
“那真的挺灾难的,我们丢了很多功能,然后紧急抢救把它恢复回来。”(马斯克)
时间是2022年12月底到2023年1月初。
这段值得琢磨。外界容易把推特当成一家“发帖子的网站”,它实际上是一套跑在物理机房上的复杂系统,关错一个开关,功能就成片消失。马斯克反复强调的另一组数字是:算力只剩三分之二,但核心算法优化后,CPU 占用大幅下降,所以在使用量创历史新高的同时,页面响应反而比以前快。
他给出的成绩单是:每日用户总时长突破八十亿分钟,创历史新高;平台上线了长推文、两小时视频、创作者付费订阅;推荐算法开源。
关于开源,他说得很直白:你愿意相信一个别人家的黑箱算法,还是愿意相信一个你能亲眼看到、能读懂的算法?
克莱顿不买账,说很多工程师认为推特的“水管”已经破了,随时可能出问题。马斯克的回应是:这些人早就预言推特会挂,但预言没有实现,马克·吐温说过,关于我死掉的报道被夸大了。
那场关于“仇恨言论”的对峙
整场访谈里最僵的一段,发生在这个话题上。
克莱顿的逻辑是:你恢复了大量被封账号,包括一些因仇恨言论被封的人,是不是把言论自由排在了虚假信息和仇恨言论前面?
马斯克反问他:谁来定义什么是虚假信息?是 BBC 吗?
他接着说了一句我觉得整场最锋利的话:BBC 自己也发布过后来被证明不实的内容。一家有一百年历史的机构,即便主观上追求准确,也必然有出错的时候。
克莱顿没有退让,换了个角度:那你自己刷推特的时候,有没有感觉仇恨内容变多了?
马斯克说,他自己的推荐信息流确实感觉多了一些。
克莱顿立刻追:能举一个例子吗?一条就行。
马斯克说,他现在基本不看推荐流,只看自己关注的人,所以举不出来。
克莱顿抓住这点:你刚才说你看到了更多仇恨内容,现在一条例子都举不出来,这说明你根本不知道自己在说什么。
马斯克回:我确实没看那个信息流,所以没法给你具体例子。他还把话题拐回去,说很多组织声称仇恨言论在上升,但那些组织什么话都说得出来。
这段对话后来在社交媒体上被剪成很多版本,双方支持者各取所需。把完整文字稿读一遍,会看到更朴素的东西:克莱顿的提问方式是把“感受”逼成“证据”,马斯克接不住,因为他确实没做准备,也没打算准备。两个人都没赢,但这段暴露了这场对话的性质:它算不上标准的企业公关访谈,更像两个人在直播里互相较劲。
关于内容审核,马斯克给出的完整逻辑是这样的:
- 平台删掉了海量的机器人账号,这些账号以前在推送诈骗和垃圾信息。旧管理层对机器人睁一只眼闭一只眼,因为他们的奖金和用户增长挂钩。
- 社区笔记(Community Notes)机制让用户自己给有问题的推文补充上下文,实际纠错效率很高。
- 平台的审核尺度应该由各国的法律来定,某个国家的人不想要某类言论,就去找自己选出来的议员立法。比如在美国,鼓吹杀人本来就是违法的。
他的总结是:我个人的判断是,现在的虚假信息比以前少,不是更多。
克莱顿反问:你的意思是,大幅减少内容审核,反而能减少虚假信息?
马斯克说,推特照样在审核,只是不再把手指按在政治天平的一侧。
这里有个绕不开的自相矛盾,克莱顿抓得很准。马斯克说社区笔记是解决虚假信息的好工具,但社区笔记就在马斯克自己的一条推文上标注过“翡翠矿”的事。他说那是假的,他父亲从来没拥有过什么矿,连百分之五十的股份都没有,没有产权记录,没有照片,这件事根本不存在。
克莱顿的意思很清楚:你把它当万灵药,它在你身上就出错了。
马斯克的回应是:社区笔记不可能完美,但命中率非常高。
蓝标八美元,是一道防 AI 的堤坝
很多人把蓝标收费理解成“推特想赚钱”,或者理解成马斯克报复《纽约时报》。他确实说了,取消《纽约时报》的认证标记让他很爽。
但他给出的正经理由是另一个,而且这个理由在2023年4月听起来还很超前。
“任何不要求付费认证的社交媒体公司,最终都会被 AI 机器人淹没。”(马斯克)
他的推演是这样的:现在的 AI 已经能通过任何人类验证测试,生成一个 Instagram 账号的成本接近于零,生成一百万个看起来完全像真人的机器人,算力成本低到可以忽略。
唯一的防线是抬高造假成本。八美元一个月,一年一百美元,还得绑一张信用卡和一个正规运营商的手机号。这样造一百万个机器人的成本就高到不划算。
他顺带说了一句预言:ChatGPT 本质上就是一堆机器人,以后你在社交平台上分不清谁是人谁是机器,付费认证是少数还管用的分界线。
有人问,能不能给 AI 生成的内容加个标记,方便创作者声明“这是假的、是恶搞”。马斯克说,发帖时主动说明这不是真的,是应该做的,但平台层面的强制标记他没承诺。
他提到那张教皇穿羽绒服的照片,还有各种名人假视频,说伪造音频已经到了以假乱真的地步,他收到过一段模仿乔·罗根(Joe Rogan)的假音频,转发给乔本人,乔的反应是“这也太疯了”。
“什么才是真的,这会是一个极其根本的问题。”(马斯克)
和媒体的关系,一半是 hate
克莱顿问了一个不太像标准采访的问题:你一边猛烈批评媒体,一边又会被媒体的报道伤到,这种关系你怎么形容?
马斯克的回答是“爱恨交织”,但他自己补了一句:可能恨的部分更多一些。
然后他说了一段挺坦白的话。他说自己一直处在被攻击的状态,他并非心如铁石,这些批评会通过推特不停地喂到他眼前。他取消了自己的屏蔽列表,一个人都不屏蔽,所以大量的负面反馈会直接砸过来。
但他又说,负面反馈是重要的,你得知道别人在骂你什么。
“如果媒体不停地写你是个多么糟糕的人,那确实会伤人。”(马斯克)
他承认这是一种矛盾的状态:他享受媒体可以自由骂他的环境,因为在很多地方媒体不敢骂有权势的人;同时他自己也会被骂得难受。
关于“冲动”这件事,克莱顿问得毫不客气:你觉得自己是个冲动的人吗?
马斯克说,他确实多次用推文把自己坑了。
然后他给出了三条自己的规则,这段我觉得是整场访谈里最像“人”的部分:
- 凌晨三点以后不发推。
- 喝醉了不发,情绪极度激动的时候不发。
- 如果一条推文可能有争议,先存成草稿,第二天再看还想不想发。
他说第三条是一个朋友建议的,很管用。
他嘴里的痛苦,不是修辞
2023年2月,马斯克发过一条推文,说过去几个月极其艰难,这种痛苦他不想让任何人经历。
克莱顿追问:你说的是情绪上的痛苦吗?
马斯克没有回避。他说推特这件事的痛苦程度非常高,这从来谈不上派对,是连续几个月的压力。
被问到是否后悔收购推特,他的答案是:这件事需要有人做。
“推特带来的痛苦程度非常高,这从来不是什么派对。”(马斯克)
他也承认过程中犯了很多错误,但话锋一转,说“结局好就一切都好”,现在公司大致打平,广告主在回归,推荐质量在提升,趋势是好的。
关于钱,克莱顿问得很刁:如果有人现在出四百四十亿美元买推特,你卖吗?
马斯克说不卖。又问,会考虑吗?他说要看买家是谁,如果确信对方会认真做这件事,他乐意交出去。
“我不是真的在乎钱,我想要一个我能依赖的真相来源。”(马斯克)
至于接班人,他说还没找到,也坦承“说实话我不知道谁能管推特,这活儿很难”。
顺便说一句,访谈里他反复强调自己已经不是 CEO 了,现在的 CEO 是他的狗 Loki。
X 是什么,他只说了一半
有人问起 X 公司(X Corp)。马斯克说,X 公司背后有实际内容,远不止一个法律主体。
“我的目标是做出 X,那个万能应用(everything app),推特是这个目标的第一步和加速器。”(马斯克)
具体是什么,他的回答是“你等着看就知道了”。
关于 AI,他确认推特和特斯拉都在采购 GPU,同时也在做 Dojo。他说 Dojo 的潜力被外界低估了。GPU 的抢购潮被他调侃成“再这样下去,你得去小巷子里才能买到 GPU”。
关于 TikTok,他的态度很清楚:他不用,但他一般不赞成封禁任何东西,哪怕封了 TikTok 对推特有利。
关于中国,他说特斯拉在中国有业务,SpaceX 也有全球业务,利益偶尔会冲突,但推特不在中国运营,他也从未收到过来自中国政府的任何关于推特的要求。
旧金山,他用了“僵尸末日”这个词
采访在推特总部进行,话题自然绕到这座城市。
马斯克说,十年前的旧金山还挺好,现在他认不出这个地方了。推特总部周边的情况,他的形容是“僵尸末日”。他强调自己没有夸张,不用等到深夜,早上十点、下午两点,开车过来看看就知道了。
他还提到一件挺荒诞的事:推特有好几栋楼,只用了其中一栋,他想把另一栋改成流浪者收容所,被楼栋所有者拦住了,对方连屋顶上那个 W 标志都不让拆。
关于是否搬离旧金山,他说暂时不搬,这地方挺好的。
尾声:记者被围观
访谈的后半段,马斯克开始念推特上的实时评论,然后直接点名让几个听众开麦提问。
第一个提问的是个长期订阅用户,问为什么改个头像就会掉蓝标。马斯克解释,过渡期要对冒充行为保持高度警惕,等信任记录建立起来就会放开,同时鼓励大家做组织认证。
第二个提问的听众明天要飞美国,问入境时该怎么说来由,马斯克建议她把推特的 W 标志也算上。这位听众最后补了一句,直接对着克莱顿说:你声称看到大量仇恨言论,却举不出一个例子,请做个负责任的记者。
克莱顿当场回应:我说的是我的推荐流里仇恨内容多了一点,我没说平台遍地仇恨言论。马斯克接了一句:反正录音都在。
最后克莱顿说他要走了,马斯克说这可能是历史上第一次采访者中途离场。现场没散,又聊了半个多小时,聊 AI 生成内容、聊 X、聊旧金山的治安、聊一个因为发梗图被起诉的人。
把整场对话从头到尾看完,那些金句很快会被忘掉,真正值得记住的是几个硬邦邦的事实:一家公司账上十亿、一年亏三十亿;服务器关错一台,功能成片消失;八千人的团队砍到一千五;算法开源,任何人都能去读。
这些东西不性感,但它们决定了推特能不能活下来。
至于那场关于仇恨言论的对峙,它给所有做内容和做产品的人提了一个问题:当你指责一个平台“变坏了”,你能说清楚坏在哪里吗?说不清楚,讨论就变成了立场表态。
给读者的几条行动建议
- 判断一家公司会不会死,先看现金和现金流,别看声量。推特当时的数字是账上十亿、年亏三十亿,四个月的时间窗口决定了一切决策的优先级。
- 接手复杂系统,先搞清楚哪些东西是硬编码的。马斯克关数据中心之前以为那是冗余,关完才发现大量功能绑在上面,这个教训对任何做技术迁移的人都适用。
- AI 时代判断账号真伪,看成本结构。能免费批量生成的账号不值得信任,绑了信用卡、手机号、付了年费的账号,造假成本高一个数量级。
- 发重要内容前设一道延迟。马斯克自己给的规则值得抄:情绪激动时存草稿,第二天再看。这条规则对做公开发言的人比对他更管用。
- 批评一个平台或一家媒体之前,先逼自己举一个具体例子。举不出来,说明你手里的是情绪,不是判断。
0:00but clearly well-oiled machine here you're an okay it's not listening start speaking Yeah here we go I think I'm in okay how does he listed as a speaker okay can everyone hear me I can hear you that's the main thing but you're right next to me all right okay just everyone knows Elon Musk gave me about 20 minutes noted so it's also going to go on top yeah it's true like this whole thing came only came together in like a matter of hours so
0:44came together by a very speculative email yes which I didn't think would even be responded to and you were like no let's do it tonight sure anyway all right are we we're actually filming just so everyone knows we're filming this for the BBC so we have like three cameras and loads of Lights but this is also being listened to around the world yeah it's unique open and transparent there we go exactly wait can you is my audio coming through just checking okay and and it is James invited to well it doesn't really matter because I should be on right
1:31speaker yeah man I don't see you listed as a speaker both mics are around the same time though oh we'll get feedback I'm just gonna I'm just gonna mute that there we go okay are we good guys wow okay we've got 200 000 people listening that is great all right okay great should we do this yes so I'll keep us here I guess so you can kind of keep it yeah right this is yeah about around that around yeah is that in shot [Laughter] okay it doesn't actually matter if the phone's in shot I think we all know that that you do it it's not a top secret all right okay fine I'm going to start I'm going to start asking questions great fire away all right first of all why did you agree to do
2:35this this interview with the BBC I don't know I like a spontaneity and I don't know there's a lot going on Tim's like I I actually do you have a lot of respect for the BBC although sometimes forget what the PVC stands for you know but what does it say just kidding yes I do so yeah yeah so there's there's a lot going on so I thought this might be a good opportunity to answer some questions and
3:10you know I guess maybe get some feedback too what should we be doing different I know the BBC for example is not thrilled about being labeled State Affiliated media I mean I was going to get to that later but let's go for it now it's officially objected to that time do you want to respond to it yeah yeah so I mean our goal is simply to have you know to be as truthful and accurate as possible so I think there's I think we're we're adjusting that labeled to be publicly funded which I think is perhaps a not too objectionable it would try to be accurate I'm not the BBC but publicly funded is how the BBC describes okay okay so that would be accurate
3:57that's if we use the same words that the BBC uses to describe itself that presumably would be okay I'm not asking you for a yes or no since you're not running if you see per se or but it's probably it seems to pass a reasonable reasonably so you're going to change those labels on the team
4:22basically that's rhetorically accurate as possible okay yeah all right fine first of all I just want to clear something up are you sleeping in the office here I sometimes sleep in the office like in the library five days a week no no three days a week I'm not here five days a week but there's a library that nobody goes to on the seventh
4:48floor and there's a couch there and I some I sleep there sometimes okay okay in terms of the general Library the reason why I think we've agreed to do this is because he wants to talk about the first six months as chief executive owner of Twitter yeah it's kind of like whatever you want to talk about yeah right so how do you think it's gone well it's not been boring it's doing quite a roller coaster so
5:23I mean Thanksgiving I think you know reasonably well I mean we've seen some all-time highs in terms of total user time so we passed 8 billion user minutes per day which is a lot of user minutes so yeah that's what usage is out growth is good the site works a few glitches here and there but I decided is working really well and we're doing it with a small fraction of the original you know accounts so I mean you mentioned houses that that have been several and we've actually spoken to an engineer who works at Twitter and they said that the plumbing is broken here and it's on fire and there could be problems at any minute do you do you accept that
6:20I mean there have been a few outages but not from very long and it's currently working fine so you don't you don't it doesn't keep you up at night that Twitter might go offline again at this point I think we've got a pretty good handline on what makes gonna work and we're also doing it with
6:40two data centers instead of three so we used to run have three data centers we shut down one of them so we're actually two-thirds of the roughly two-thirds of Prior compute capability but we've made so many improvements to the core algorithm in some cases we improved the about 80 so the actual CPU usage or computer usage is dramatically less so I bet there's also people themselves the system despite being at all time highs of usage is fast it's responsible it's more responsive than it was before the Takeover and we've also added long full tweets we've added you can now post videos up to two hours and two videos of any length we're we're rolling out our
7:30subscriber programs so so people can content creators can actually make a living on Twitter by having some of their content behind a payroll and we're open source the algorithm so there's transparency about what tweets get shown what what content gets shown versus not I think you say like what are you really going to trust are you going to trust some sort of Black Box algorithm from some other site or are you going to trust something that you can actually see and understand but do you accept that there are lots of Engineers that are looking at at the way that Twitter is built and the lack of Engineers because so many have left and are worried about the health of Twitter
8:18well I mean they've been many of these people have predicted that Twitter will cease to function their predictions have not turned out to be true you know insert Mark Twain saying you know Rosemont exaggerated let's go back six months later I mean we're literally on Twitter right now right
8:47let's go back six months and even further further back than that when you put that initial bid in you then had a wobble you kind of said I actually don't want to buy Twitter anymore oh no I mean I mean it really is quite entertaining I mean it's like soap opera because when I first made the offer the response was the the Board of doctor poison pill so they were like hell no you can't buy Twitter we'd rather die we're like chew on cyanide before it could be being bored that was their initial response and then and then you said and then you said actually I don't want to buy it yes and and then they said no you must buy us gun to the head you have to buy us
9:30I'm like are you the same people who said you'd rather die then be bored doesn't that seem odd so I guess I guess my question to you is in terms of you said that you said that the reason was because of thoughts because Twitter was filled with Bots well looking back at it now was there a little bit of you that thought actually maybe I've overpaid actually maybe I don't want to do this I want to get out of this the problem was that the publicly stated user numbers were in excess of the real user numbers so
10:09but I've heard you talk about that yeah you can talk about that but yeah basically looking back at it now was that the only reason that you wanted to put out yes that was literally the issue it's like it's like let's say you buy a warehouse full of goods and you're told that less than five percent of the goods in the warehouse are have have are broken you know
10:36but then you actually get to work out you look into the warehouse and turns out actually 25 of the things broken you'll be like huh that's so what you said so then you change your mind again and decided to buy it did you do that did you do that because right did you do that because you thought that a court would make you do that yes right yes that is the reason right so you were still trying to get out of there and then you just were advised by lawyers look you're gonna we're gonna have to buy this yes
11:10so you so you didn't you didn't actually want to purchase it even when you said you were going to you really no I mean like like let's say I think analogy is pretty pretty close like let's say you know it's like you there's a warehouse all good they say the warehouse less than five percent of what's in the warehouse so it's broken and then you walk into warehouse and say actually it's 25 so you you guys still want to buy what's the in that warehouse but probably at a lower price we're not buying the stuff that's broken so you didn't have an epiphany you just thought I'm gonna I'm gonna have to buy this I might as well buy the bullet yeah so then you walk it's super complicated
11:51right right I'm not sure you've said that before fair enough so then you you came into QQ Harvard court case with a sec what were your first impressions well wow this is a really nice office building and expensive yes very expensive office building great decor it's lovely place and I mean and it definitely is spending money like it's doing on a fashion which is it doesn't quite going out of fashion yet so I mean at the gradually situation perhaps it's not well understood of
12:51you know at the point of which the company looked transaction closed Twitter was tracking to lose over three billion dollars a year so and had one billion in the bank so that's four months to death so this is your starting position how would you feel pretty pretty intense you know you just had to borrow quite a lot of money and pay interest on that too well that's why by the way it was a three billion dollar run rate so in rough numbers the normal year of Twitter would do your say let's say four and a half billion in Revenue one half billion dollars in cost I mean it was really kind of like a non-profit they'd run it at roughly about roughly Break Even but that's not
13:39a bank that's not bankruptcy no it's breaking even but then then the issue is that if you then add a billion and a half dollars in debt Servicing and have a massive drop in Revenue if we did which was partly cyclic and partly you know political concerns whatever so Revenue you know quote dropped by
14:03over a third it's not and this is not just Twitter you know Facebook and Google processing some significant advertisement over your clients it was a little it's been a little higher on Twitter but mostly advertisers are coming back so I think we'll just pull back me back where there's a cyclic demand a drop which is still pretty significant
14:24a revenue dropped from four and a half billion to three and expenses went from four and a half to six creating a three billion dollar negative cash flow situation and Twitter having a billion dollars in the bank that's four months to live so unless drastic action was taken immediately it's going to die to be honest let's talk about that drastic action because almost immediately you sacked a lot of Twitter workers yeah and I I spoke to them it's very easy to speak to them when it happened and and the way they set pretty much everyone said is that it felt quite haphazard it was it felt a little bit uncaring do you I wouldn't say uncare the the
15:07you know the issue is like the companies are going to go bankrupt or if we do not cut costs immediately this is not a carry uncarried situation it's like if whole ship sinks so nobody's gonna drive right yeah but a lot of people just lost their jobs like that and and they went well why didn't even know they would they lost their jobs often they just because they were just crossing out of their accounts what would you well you might want to give someone some notice I mean you might it's by the way I'm not running Twitter but I know but this is the criticism this is what actual this is what I'm talking about to say a little bit of notice you know I
15:46understand you're four months to live 120 days and 120 days you're dead so how so what do you want to do how much are you worth I don't know but yeah I mean we're talking about around the 200 billion dollar Mark I mean it's not quite you're framing it in in a way that that you know that it had had a few months to live you're quite a rich man I sold a lot of Tesla stock to close this deal listen I did not want to sell the Tesla stock okay do you have any regrets on the way that some of the staff will let go
16:26I mean who were given you know three months of seven in some cases more so but you know we really like I said the companies need to run on their own cognizance and it's not it's not so easy for me to sell stock as between my dick after sales stock during certain periods I can't sell stock during other periods so there's only there are only brief Windows where I can sell Tesla stock and then this is often taken as some lack of faith in Tesla the Tesla stock sales of course the Tesla stock deposit which is not good do you think those two were connected well the the people can couldn't pass the difference between I'm selling Tesla stock because I've lost weight in 1000
17:14which I haven't or that it's desperately needed for Twitter okay and then after that after you let go of a lot of Staff obviously from Twitter came slim down a lot and then he started making some more policy decisions one of those policy decisions was to bring Donald Trump back he hasn't actually tweeted yet right do you expect him to come back at any point like have you spoken
17:43but the point is that Twitter should be a Town Square that that is gives equal voice to you know the whole country and ideally the whole world it should not be a partisan politics you know and and the moral partisan politics that are the very far left of the spectrum San Francisco publicly politics normally it's quite Niche but if Twitter effectively active as a megaphone for a very Niche Regional politics and megaphone that to the world so if in order for something to serve as a digital Town Square it must you know instead of all people from all political Persuasions provided it's legal so close to half the country voter for Trump I wasn't one of them I voted for
18:38white but nonetheless you know free speech is meaningless unless you're allow people you don't like to say things you don't like otherwise it's relevant and if at the point of which you lose a free speech it doesn't come back I think I think the issue some people have is that a lot of people were brought back I mean some people were brought back who were previously bad for spreading things like Cuban on conspiracies you have people like Andrew take you were brought back you were previously banned for things like hate speech do you think you prioritize freedom of speech over
19:15misinformation and hate speech well you know who's to say that's something of misinformation who is the officer of that is it the BBC are you literally asking me yeah well no you are the Arbiter on Twitter because you own Twitter yes I'm saying who is to say that one person's best information is another person's information the point of which you said that there is this is missing like who is this information can be dangerous that it can cause real world harms that it can potentially cause them yeah so the point of trying to make is the BBC itself has at times published things that are false do you agree that that has occurred I I I I'm quite sure the BBC have a said
20:07things before that turn out to not be true right and it's whatever it is 100 Year history and questions even if you aspire to be accurate there are times where you you will not be yeah but you accept it has to be a line in terms of hate speech I mean not you're not looking at total 100 unrestricted speed speech there's well I mean I generally I've got 15 in that too if if you if if the people of a given country are against a certain type of speech they should talk to their elected representatives and pass a law to prevent it so for example you cannot Advocate murdering someone that's illegal in the United States and everyone really suspect so
20:57so they're on limits to speech I mean I guess taking your argument to a logical conclusion that do you accept that there's more misinformation on the platform if it's not being policed in the same way I I actually think there's there's less these days because we've eliminated so many of the Bots which we're pushing scams to spam and previously previous management turned a blind eye to to the bonds because their bonuses were tied to user growth and if you go if you if your competition is tied to use a growth well you're not going to look too closely at some of the users that's part of the problem so I think we've got less less information because we've we don't
21:37have the what problem that we used to do and we also have given a lot of attention to community notes which corrects where the community itself corrects misinformation has been very effective I I mean I would only just add that you know we have spoken to people who who have been stacked that used to be in content moderation and and we've spoken to people very recently you were involved in moderation and they just say they just there's not enough people to police this stuff particularly around particularly around hate speech in the company is that something about I mean you use Twitter right do you see a rise in hate speech I mean just your personal anecdote like what do
22:18you do I don't personally my for you I would see I get I get more of that kind of content yeah personally but I'm not going to talk to talk to the rest of for the rest of Twitter hate speech personally I would say I would see more hateful content in that than that whatever you don't like or or hateful what do you mean to describe a hateful thing yeah I mean you know just content that will solicit a reaction something that may include something that is slightly racist or slightly sexist those kinds of those kinds of things so you think of something is slightly sexist it should be bad
22:59I'm asking for specific examples and if and you just said that if something is slightly sexist that's hateful content does that mean that it should be bad well you've asked me you've asked me whether my feed whether it's got less or more I'd say it's got slightly more that's why I'm asking for examples right can you name one example I I honestly don't you I I honestly I don't name a single example I'll tell you why because I don't actually use that for you feed anymore because I just don't particularly like it there's actually a lot of people a lot of people are quite similar I I only I only look at mine as my followers you can't name it a single example not
23:36even one I'm not sure I've used that fee for the last because I've been I've been using it I've been using twister since you've taken it over for the last six months okay so then you must have at some point seen that you're poor you hateful content I'm asking for one example right right and I'm saying I I say so that you
23:55don't know what you're talking about really yes because you can't be a single example of hateful content not even one tweet and yet you're claimed that the hippo content was high well that's a false no what I could applied what no no what I claim was there are many organizations that say that that kind of information is on the rise now whether whether it has on my feed or not I mean right unless we can get something like this should the Strategic dialogue okay they will say that so people will say all sorts of nonsense I'm literally asking for a single example UK name one right and as I already said I don't use that feed but let's help it I don't
24:34think this is getting any literally said you experience more hateful content and then couldn't name a single example right and as I said that's absurd I haven't I haven't actually looked at that feeder because I'm saying that's what I saw a few weeks ago I can't give you an exact example let's move on we have we only have a certain amount of time covered misinformation
24:59BBC changes covered misinformation the BBC does not set the rules on Twitter so I'm asking you no I'm talking about what the BBC's most information about Kobe I'm I'm literally asking you about you change the labels the covered misinformation labels there used to be a policy and then it then disappears why do that
25:25covert is no longer an issue does the BBC hold itself at all responsible for misinformation regarding masking and side effects of vaccinations and not reporting on that at all and what about the fact that BBC was put under pressure by the British government to change the editorial policy are you aware of that this is a this is not an interview about the baby's age oh you thought it wasn't I see now why you've done Twitter spaces I am not a representative of the BBC's editorial policy I want to make that clear let's talk about something else all right let's let's talk about let's talk about something else you weren't expecting that let's talk about
26:09something else Narendra Modi the BBC did a documentary about Narendra Modi and his leadership during the rising Goods you're out we then believe that some of those some of that content was taken off Twitter was that at the behest of the Indian government I'm not aware of that particular situation so you're just you're not sure I I don't know if I don't know about that that you know what exactly happened with some content situation in India that the rules in India for for what can appear on social media are quite strict and we can't go beyond the laws of the country but do but do you get the if you do that you incentivize countries around the
26:54world to Simply pass more Draconian laws no look what if we have a choice of either our people go to prison or we comply with the laws we'll comply with the laws same goes for the BBC okay okay since you became CEO there's been another story in town I'm not CEO anymore okay you're a chief twit or what are you no my dog Loki is let's see okay I I saw that yeah okay so so Tick Tock has also been in the news there's talk of perhaps by demonstration wanting to potentially ban it or or force a sale what what's your view of the situation
27:43I don't really use tick tock I mean one of the reasons that I emphasize that the I thought our goal here at Twitter is to maximize unregretted user minutes or unrequited user time is that I hear many people tell me they spent a lot of time on Tick Tock but they regret the time spent and that seems like okay well we don't want to have a regretted time we want the time to be undergraded where you learned things you were entertained and used I get to more lapse out of Twitter than anything else and many people tell me the same thing so that's a good sign for tick tock itself like I said I just don't know enough about what's going on there
28:34I can't say I have a strong opinion on tick tock so you'd have an opinion on whether it should be banned or not you know I'm generally against Banning things so I I probably not be in favor I mean it would it would help Twitter I suppose if Tick Tock was banned because then people would spend more time on Twitter unless I'm in Tick Tock but even though that would be that even if it would help Twitter I would be generally against a Banning of of things okay
29:13do you feel sometimes that your many business interests might get in the way of you having an opinion I mean for example Tesla has major Connections in China do you you you wouldn't you wouldn't have a you wouldn't have a certain opinion on something or feel uncomfortable about saying something because of your other business interests elsewhere do they look uncomfortable
29:35yeah I mean Tesla has got activities around the world and sort of SpaceX you know once in a while those things do common to conflict but it's not like Twitter's like you know operates in China doesn't do Choice brand new China so and assuming I perceived no no communication whatsoever from the Chinese governments regard to Twitter okay
30:11in terms of advertising obviously the Twitter's not a private company anymore so we don't really know how it's how it's all going have all the advertisers come back not all but most
30:41how is it going is twittering profit now no Twitter is rough I'd say we're roughly break even at this point and I think you've said before you you see a you see a world where you could be in profit is there a timeline on that do you think I mean depending on how things go if current trends continue I think we could be profitable or I mean
31:07to be more precise we could be cash flow positive this quarter if things keep going well this quarter as soon as that I possibly yeah wow and do you have a message for the advertising can you say which advertisers haven't come back I think I think almost all of them have either come back or say they're going to come back there are very few exceptions can you say it's any of the exceptions fun I actually don't know of anyone who said definitively they're not coming back they're all sort of training towards coming back but there are some that just jump in the water as well it's great that's your message to the to the advertisers they haven't come back yeah
31:47I mean look you know for me feels comfortable advertising their children's movies and apple feels comfortable advertising iPhones those are good indicators that Twitter is a good place to advertise I want to talk about if you have any regret regrets and and you know I think you you were Buddha Dave Chappelle concert I think your own lawyer a little a little well some say a little some say a bit more I think your own lawyer said you couldn't get a fair trial in San Francisco because there are lots of people that don't necessarily like you here yeah but you know he was wrong against the because I
32:34was murdered by the San Francisco jury unanimously so but I guess do you have any regrets by buying Twitter I think it was something that needed to be done like the the pain level of Twitter has been extremely high this hasn't been some sort of party so it's been really quite a stressful situation for the last several months not not an easy one but apart from the pain I mean so it's been quite painful but I think a day that it should have been done I think that were there many mistakes made along the way of course you know and but you know all swell that ends well and so I I feel like we're headed to
33:33a good place you know where roughly break even I think we're trending towards being half flow positive very soon literally in a matter of of months the advertisers are returning the I think the quality of recommended tweets has improved significantly we've taken a lot of feedback from people that have looked at the open source recommendation algorithm and we've we've made a lot of improvements even since even since that was made open source and we're going to keep doing that so overall I think the trend is very good so you know I mean it was actually something I was going to ask you you mentioned the pain but you actually tweeted I think in February you said
34:14the last three months have been extremely tough I wouldn't wish that pain on anyone could are you talking emotionally there I mean can you can you explain oh there was a stat right right some people around Europe is dangerous technology it is it can be but just can you just talk me through the emotional strain of this yeah I mean look I'm under I've been under attack I mean it's not like I you know have a stone called heart or something like that you know you know I if you're under constant criticism attack it's and then that gets fed to you non-stop including through Twitter that it's rough you know not not the other day I kind of think that like if you do lose your feedback
35:01loop that's that's actually not good so you know if so I think it's it is actually important to get negative feedback I don't turn reply is all and I actually got rid of I removed my entire block list so I don't block anyone either so so somebody can you know so so I get like a lot of negative feedback
35:29good to get negative feedback right when you talk about the emotions rate you've gone back to feedback is that the thing that's been most difficult to take the sort of negative feedback yeah I mean if if if the media is writing non-stop stories about why you're a horrible person I mean you know
35:49it's it's hurtful obviously I mean I I I've written down a lot of these questions about but I haven't written this one down but it's interesting it feels like you have quite a kind of interesting relationship with the media because in one in some ways you're quite skeptical by critical certainly of established media but also you kind of get hurt by what the media writes and did you get your news still from the BBC as you've already said everybody right right so do you feel you have a kind of kind of odd relationship with the media yes explain no it's it it it it is somewhat of a love-hate relationship although I mean it might be filtered towards the hate
36:36that but you know it's a you know I I think that's what this is so sort of part and parcel of having a a free media situation which is that you know I do I do take part in the media is actually able to trash me on a regular basis in you know in the United States in the UK and whatnot whereas you know in a lot of other places media cannot say mean things to proper people okay so I think it's better that we have a situation where the media can say mean things to problem people if we're talking about the media let's talk about verification labels you obviously want to create another Revenue stream that's subscription based it's verification the
37:36way to do that because we have a kind of a situation at the moment where the New York Times doesn't have a verified badge whereas anyone else who can pay whatever few bucks a month yeah can is that can that be right is that what you've envisaged when you bought Twitter I I must confess this I'm Delight in removing the verified batch from The New York Times that was that was great anyway they're still alive and well so they're doing fine but on a serious note it could flame disinformation again if you have verified accounts that are from anyone who can pay money they simply they go up to potentially the top of feeds they get more action on Twitter and traditional media that
38:20may not pay for verification doesn't do you see how that could potentially be a driver of misinformation well I mean I I think the media is Survivor of misinformation much more than the media would like to admit that they are I mean that's a different question yeah but you are sort of saying like like who who knows best the average citizen or you know someone who is a journalist and I think a lot of cases is the average citizen that knows more than than the journalist in fact I mean very often when I see an article about some something that I know a lot about and I read the article it's like that if they get a lot wrong and you know some of the best
39:06interpretation is there is someone who doesn't really understand what's going on in the industry has only a few facts to play with has to come up with an article and that it's going to be you know something it's not good at the bullseye so so then like generally this is what how equates to the start of your if you read an article that's something you know about how much of that how accurate is that article now imagine that that is the that is how essentially all articles are they they're an approximation of what's going on but not any not an exact situation so if somebody is actually let's say in The Fray or like an expert in the field and was actually there and then
39:46and writes about their experience of being actually there I I think that actually that that could that's in a lot of cases going to be better than a journalist because the journalist wasn't there I think you said the Legacy verified blue ticks are going to go next week there have been a few few deadlines yeah I see the joke
40:09clearly yeah it costs you a lot of money well unfortunately it didn't in the trial well yeah right but he put it as you say right yes we're going to ask for a refund yeah okay yeah good luck [Laughter] let's move on from that but blue text in theory all Legacy blueticks gone gone next week and this is and at that point you'll kind of work out whether this is going to sink or swim yes what's your what's your hash I mean you've obviously I think it's good as well yeah yeah I'll swim just fine okay what are you looking for in terms of in terms of a revenue stream on that whatever cost well I I think it's like that's really a giant Revenue stream
40:55you know even if you have sort of a million people that are subscribed for let's say 100 a year in the ish that's a hundred million dollars and that's that's a that's a fairly small Revenue stream relative to advertising but what we're really trying to do here with verification is to massively raise the cost of this information and and bonds in general so my prediction is that in any social media company that does not insist on paid verification will simply be overwhelmed of my events AI Bots I mean check gbt is essentially a resilient instances of chat gbt how would you even know what you want on the platform do you want big news organizations being overwhelmed
41:45by Bots you won't be if you pay but a lot of organizations have already said they're not going to pay like the New York Times well then you know that's up to them if they you know can't make them pay it's a small amount of money so I don't know what their problem is so but if we're going to feed everyone equally so what we're not going to do is say that there's some anointed class of journalists who are the special ones who get to tell everyone what they're which what they what they should think that it should be up to the people what they think and even if an article is completely accurate and comprehensive and everything is they're still in in writing that article
42:30the media is choosing the narrative they're deciding what to write an article about so I'm hopeful that this can be more a case of the public choosing the narrative as opposed to the media choosing narrative but the media choosing at least at least a combination of the media and the public choosing narrative and the the public getting to to weigh in on stories if they if they think that they should add something to it or we've got something wrong and over time I think if Twitter is the best source of Truth it will succeed and if we are not the best source of Truth we will fail someone comes in and offers you 44 billion dollars for Twitter right now
43:09would you take it no would you consider it yeah why well I I think about it depends on who I suppose if I was confident that they would pursue that would they would rigorously pursue Then I then I I guess I guess I would be glad to hand it off to someone else I don't care about the money really but I I I do want to have some sort of truth that I can count on and and I I hope that's our aspiration with much better is to have a source of proof that you can count on that's that's also real time it's an immediate source of truth that you can count on and that gets more accurate with time as people comment on a particular thing but if you don't care
44:00about the money you could just give it to someone that you that you think is a good person to run to myself who do you think that might be I I'm not aggressive Twitter nobody choose well that's you might still have an idea who could run Twitter yeah honestly I had no idea who could run Twitter yeah it's a hard drive okay let's I mean let's move on to that you've said that you were going to Stand Down chief executive right okay
44:37I'm telling you I'm not the CEO of Twitter my dog is the CEO okay have you got any it's a great dog other than the dog very alert and it's hard to put get anything by him okay that's good to know other than the dog have you got any success you've got a black a turtle turtleneck or what do you need foreign
45:11what were we talking about there yeah who would who who would you want have you got a successor in mind not yet hopefully at some point right so because you just say you were going to stand out I did send out okay all right let's move on from that then all right what about this office I'm intrigued about this office you said it was basically expensive yeah yeah but why can't we be an anarchicalist commune I think Jack Dorsey kind of recommended oh yeah doing that and we kind of ignored it yeah it was kind of bad actually this office are you thinking about moving out of San Francisco not yet not yet oh yeah I mean this place is nice and we you know I kind of like this obstacle
46:05thing actually yeah okay so you're not because I know you've talked about there's been high levels of crime here you actually said at one point you should do something about the crime right because people are dying right we should take action you've also talks about how potentially I would think you might have been joking but you could turn this into a homeless shelter so then I guess the reason I'm asking is you know you if we're trying to turn into a commercial Group Well the owner rejected it you tried it yeah they won't let us but we're only using one of the buildings and so the other building could be a homeless shelter and you've tried to yeah we would like to do it
46:40right now really yeah and no you're being stopped by who by the Bollywood they weren't naive No in fact they wouldn't even let us take the W off the site so how are you going to do that quite quite you know what was your what was your plan for the shelter I don't know we could just let people stay there it's nice right okay whatever
47:06right and it's a roof over their head yeah it's the building owner of that sauce will do it yeah so if the building only that owner lets you you would you would happily do that yes okay all right there we go what's the most difficult thing you've had to do what's the hardest thing you've had to do in my whole life in the last six months we're talking about the last six months is Switzerland Twitter owners well shutting down our one of our service centers was was quite difficult because it turns out there were I thought the service centers were redundant but they were in fact a lot of things that were hard-coded to the swan server Center and so we shut it down and
47:50we actually it was quite catastrophic we lost a lot of functionality so really rushed to put it back when was that I was around late December during early January so that was the biggest sort of I'm I'm worried the biggest crisis yeah yeah and what about Han in terms of emotional I mean how it means is len Go I mean what what were the current the levels of stuff and what are they now I think we're around 1500 people at this point and there was I think 7 800.
48:28I think it was around just under eight thousand eight thousand fifteen hundred right now okay and has it been hard letting out that many people go yeah it's not fun at all people I mean I guess in in what way do you do you feel like you need to speak to people when they when when they leave or I mean it's not physically possible to speak to that many people has that I mean you've talked about that being the most technical bit is that has has that been sort of the hardest thing emotionally or is it it's one of the hardest things certainly yeah
49:09the Nazi Pelosi tweet but there have been nice an example of a theme there have been others do you feel like you're an impulsive person I mean have I shot myself with a quote with tweets multiple times yes do you feel like I need bulletproof shoes at this point I mean you've definitely done that the issue is that you're now Twitter owner do you feel like you should be look at your tweets more you have more a higher responsibility when you tweet something out for it to be accurate I think I should not tweet after 3am
49:46that's the new rule something like that okay so there's a blanket ban I should I shouldn't I shouldn't what are your Twitter what are your Twitter rules I mean I've heard some people say never tweet when you've been drinking or never tweet when angry what are your Twitter rules well I think those are two grid rules yeah don't tweet if you're wasted and or you know really upset about something yeah probably I mean a good friend of mine I actually have a good suggestion it has helped which is that if you're gonna tweet something that maybe is controversial save it as a draft look at it the next day and see what store and that has been a good rule of thumb
50:37okay we've got a bunch of things I'm glad I didn't say I can't remember whether I've asked you this this was my sort of sort of wrapping up at this point but yeah do you do you have any regrets I mean what was like hindsight's 2020 so you know a bunch of decisions that can be made better for sure but as I said all's well it ends well I think it's going pretty well so the grand scheme of things I can't complain okay I'm gonna just check my my list of things to make sure I've actually I mean it's maybe there's probably the people on the on the Twitter what you say ask you know we could ask them that's on you that's on you wow it's with 680 000
51:24people listening there you go that's a lot that is a lot let's see how do we see okay let me see who I'll just look at my my tweet and see what people last night or what questions they have [Laughter] do you like the BBC do you like BBC okay yeah we're not gonna oh I can't even we always have work for the BBC you like do you like BBC
52:09[Laughter] I'm not going to okay well I just want to see if there's like any you know good there's a lot of comments here I can imagine so many anyway so it's it's nice to be interviewed by the BBC I have a lot of respect for the British Broadcasting Corporation when did you say when the when the actual label is going to go public oh this is is it do we still say State Media or whatever or it's just government-funded media currently as opposed to publicly funded media well I guess probably we can make that change tomorrow if you'd like
53:07we'll expect that tomorrow I mean do you have any requests on a personal level or you can't speak on a personal level no I don't okay okay I think we've established that what what questions are people asking you go on I mean there's like a lot of comments let's see I was literally reading on looking at replies to but you know the fact that just the species are there any good questions that I've missed out in the last in the last six months I'm sure there are many I mean people generally seem to like this interview before you can tell refer a few negative comments so generally positive is that is that that's probably bad for me [Laughter] I'm scrolling as fast as I can to sort
54:03of see I guess there's some complaints about Twitter spaces being needing some improvement let's fix what our spaces is one of the comments people like the fact that my dog Loki is the CEO and I'm not really just rolling as fast as I can here I I think like she known this one I like BBC okay
54:40I do find it funny I I think I mean honestly if looking listening to the interview the answer about misinformation and saying oh we don't police misinformation in the same way but because we try and get books because we try and take down Bots when we effective at Bots we're actually there's actually less misinformation on the platform okay I think that's a big factor because I'll ask you one more question on that because it doesn't mean that is quite a lot of people I think will be listening to this is true really you're arguing you can police content moderation far less and end up with less misinformation how how much we do have we do have you know
55:20moderation it's not like we don't so I've spoken to lots of people who've been who've been fired so a lot lots of people have been let go I mean you've gone from eight yeah the censorship Bureau was like oh I don't think the the sort of putting a thumb on the political skills in the far left has been let go because that's not right that's not what you want for a public a Public Square you know you've got to have equal treatment for people from across the political Spectrum so
55:49you know of something we're going to be upset about that but like I said my my experience is that there's less less misinformation these days not more and that the community notes feature is extremely powerful for addressing so-called misinformation I mean you've been you've had Community notes placed on your own tweets yes one of them involving I had an alleged diamond mine diamond mine I mine the I think it was a mind that your father part owned yeah my father never owned a should you think of an emerald Emerald Emerald mine yeah I'd like to see a picture of the alleged Emerald line because you've been you've been Community noted on that tweet yeah did you know that no but it's
56:36he never owned a a emerald mine it's a total [ __ ] not even a 50 stake no because in community no first of all okay okay do you think Emerald do you think something like Emerald mine would have like you know some sort of property register there'd be like a picture of it it's not like you can say oh that's my mind you know these things are hotly debated if you've got something valuable you you have to have some property record like a house but but much more important than a house and yet there is no property record whatsoever there is no picture of this mine whatsoever it doesn't exist it's fake so that's so it's a really good example then because
57:15there is a community note on that tweet that says you said this thing on the X day blah blah blah so in that instance the Q next didn't work so you're saying that that's a way of solving misinformation but you're literally saying one of those Community notes is wrong the community community may be referring to a thing where I I went on a trip with my father to Zambia but I never saw any mind or anything so there's no such there's no mic I'm not right but at this point I'm just saying the community note says it is so you're saying it's this big great Panacea but yeah it's literally on your own tweet the community notes according to you are wrong
57:56if they're referencing an article then the article may not be wrong which there is Caminos is not going to be perfect but it's the batting average of community notes I found to be extremely high right so Community next Plus getting rid of millions and millions of bots every day I guess that's that's what we're talking about yeah that that that's what you think is tackling misinformation over over content moderation and I think I think because I think that's the bit that a lot of people will go really really yes really but look the asset test is people use the system and find it to find it to be a good source of Truth or they don't and no no system is
58:44going to be perfect in its pursuit of the truth but I think I think we can be the best of the least inaccurate that's our goal the least inaccurate and I think we I I think we might be there already if we're not there we'll be there soon do you have I've I've spoken to people who you think nice do you have a a kind of message for people who who think that Twitter has been ruined well we have all-time high usage so I don't think it has been I'll tell you that yes well they're probably the same people who predicted that Twitter would cease to exist and their predictions have turned out to be false okay I know I'm not gonna ask you whether you think it's been ruined
59:30because obviously you look no I think it's right that's way better better by a lot I'm done with this interview it sounds like you don't want to take any questions from your Legions or fans I mean I was looking for you know questions okay Let's designer okay so what I do the top of the guy yeah he's submitted we're just getting some technical help for anyone who's listening okay so should I how do you unmute he just needs to okay those designer if you if you unmute you can talk hey Lauren can you hear me but let's unmute Jason and David as well and and us and definitely definitely Walter Isaacson if he does want to speak I actually
1:00:49can bring a balance too yeah sure well we'll get a few people going here I thought we had half an hour for this interview I know we're so good at switch supposed to keep going I always told you a very impressed for time yeah it's true Alex you can speak hey what's going on yeah all right that's better so my question actually had to do with more privileges or features for long-term Twitter blue subscribers
1:01:34one of the complaints I hear a lot is people who change their just their profile picture and not their display name how they lose their verification badge I know there's an ID verification coming up as well what are your thoughts for expanding privileges for long time subscribers so they kind of gain trust with the platform where they might not have to lose their blue check if they just change their profile picture as opposed to their name and profile picture yeah just you know during this kind of transition period we're
1:02:13extra vigilant about impersonation so I agree that over time if somebody is has a trusted track record they should be able to change their their name and profile picture without losing the blue track you know during this transition period we want to be just like I said extra vigilance against impersonation so that's that's why we're being so rigorous in this regard now if somebody has organizational affiliation they can't change their name or picture without losing the verification check because they're cross-verified with their organization so I really would encourage people to get organizational verification as much as possible and I mean we're going to add you know so you can
1:03:01be have multiple organization affiliations I think this can be really powerful for avoiding in post Nation I've heard from a lot of people that impersonation is a serious issue actually more on other platforms than Twitter and I think that you know if you can say that you you really do belong to if the organization if some organization can say that that you really do belong to them that's a great way to address impersonation risk yeah for sure thank you cool hey Lauren can you hear me I can yes how's it doing good how's it going all good I'm flying to us tomorrow I just have couple of questions for you one is like I will be asked why you are here in
1:03:42like U.S so what should I tell them I am here to visit Twitter headquarters or just Twitter headquarters yeah well I mean I've yeah I would recommend adding adding the W for the srts yeah and second question is like so will I be able to meet that Twitter CEO there or no sure perfect can't wait and I just have one message for James like you know the number of people like you know in this Twitter space so you should be responsible like you should be a responsible reporter you are claiming that you are seeing a lot of hate speech but you could not even give a single example so I just request you to be a responsible speaker that's it all right thank you
1:04:26thank you so let's see let's see David or Jason I don't know if you guys can speak you're welcome to if you'd like I I just want to clear up what what I said there you said you said has you I believe I said something like has you will feed or something and I said my for you feed has got a bit more hateful I didn't say I was seeing tons of hate speech on it that's not what I said no but you can I mean you can frame it like that well look it's recorded so you know it's not like you know we don't have to like engage in guess what characters recorded in terms of your for you feed are you just trying you're trying to get as many videos that are viral to to
1:05:09people as possible to get people to stay on the platform is that is that the is that well I think if we keep people entertained then they're gonna keep they're gonna yeah I mean if if we're entertaining and informing people then they're gonna stay on powerful right obviously I mean it's if we bore people or it's like you know somehow uninteresting then they they will beep yeah there has been this talk that that people like you and other senior celebrities some journalists get favorable treatment on the algorithms well you're gonna pay for treatment right now do you give yourself a favorable treatment on the algorithm No in fact the algorithm is is open sourced so
1:05:57you can see exactly what's going on I believe defeat the for you one is open source is that right well following is just who you follow it's pretty it's not algorithm it's just personal algorithm yeah that's still an algorithm you don't see every single in following you should see all the tweets of people that you follow if not there's a bugging system right just just sequentially when they tweet yeah yeah following is literally the thing they say when they say it there's no but there shouldn't be any algorithmic interaction there so
1:06:36all right so it's hard to actually see I think well I I definitely see some room for improvement from a functionality standpoint because when you have a really big spaces it's hard to see who it's actually hard to even see who's requesting to speak because there's so many times right here okay it's a long ways
1:07:06oh okay at a time I've got a I've got a question here someone's texted me okay what about Elon chat what about him that was obviously quite controversial moment when I think you but I think he does he ban his account for a while yeah real-time boxing of locations is that okay is that flexing your muscle overly I mean now it's just a real-time boxing is not not allowed because if I take a picture of someone in the street and then tweets it it's not toxic actually it's against their will and you're you're sort of following them around then yeah that would be exactly
1:07:59but Elon jet wasn't wasn't following you around he was just using publicly available information wasn't there no it wasn't here it actually I think it's actually not true I know there's a debate about that yeah he was using non-public information to combined with public information do you think that you you sort of gave yourself favorable treatment there I mean that that's the criticism on that that no it's just real-time doxing is it's not allowed that wasn't right but that wasn't you literally created that rule after that actually no it just was unevenly enforced right so there's no doxing rule it was unevenly enforced in fact in general part of the issue with the prior
1:08:43management Twitter is there they'll have all these rules but they would only enforce them against some people not against others you know what doxing generally means which is revealing someone's address yes where they are right as I say taking a picture is revealing somewhere someone is yeah that's being a concert yeah and take a picture of loads of people if you can't recognize them then it's not a thing I think I think it was clarified where they would say that if it was a public event like a concert or say a political Rally or whatever that's a public space rather than somebody is traveling you know that I think there's the distinction there yeah it's not
1:09:20someone's house right if you're going to somebody's house and you're taking a photo of it saying JK Rowling right so several people have harassed at her house that would be dachshund right and they have been gotten rid of so I don't know where the question is here James it was actually a question it got texted to me it wasn't on my list let's move on to be honest I'm I'm done so okay do you want to leave I'm happy to if you want to carry on doing questions yeah maybe you're welcome to this will be the first time the interview interviewer has ever walked out how to turn tables how long are you gonna sit here for who's gonna pack up around you yeah that
1:09:57sounds good Elon thank you very much for talking to me oh you're welcome so it was fun I enjoyed it thoroughly sounds good well this has really given me a long list of feature improvements that we need for spaces oh yeah I I yeah I have a bunch of suggestions not right now but I do being on Twitter spaces every single day there are a host of problems first of all where's the desktop app right I want to connect with my nice microphone yeah it's pretty good but it's like you know it's yeah a lot a lot of things need to be improved that's for sure oh yeah there's a laundry list of things
1:10:50all right how often do you use stock Twitter spaces I'm like you know I'm sure you have like an ALT account or something do you do stock Twitter spaces no not really and I actually didn't even have a burner account I I do have a second account at this point because I need to test the app before it goes out so it's kind of like a beta test account but no I don't I don't have a boner or anything like that okay and never yeah never have had
1:11:30yeah none of those okay nope so well let's see I mean any any key points anyone wants to make otherwise we'll I'll sign off in a few minutes I just I don't know if the other guys do I think whole whole Mars blog is here maybe he has some questions yeah I had one question about Twitter Elon some media had been reporting today that Twitter bought 10 000 gpus for some type of generative AI project and I also noticed that on Twitter there were a couple of people who mentioned working at AI infrastructure the super Computing team at both Tesla and Twitter I was wondering if you could share anything with us about what Twitter's working on there and if there's maybe any synergies
1:12:18maybe you know Twitter using Dojo or something like that or what exactly is going on with this project well it seems like everyone you know and their dog is buying deep use at this point you know it's kind of getting to the point where like you're gonna have to buy gpus in a back alley so certainly a lot of people find gpus Twitter and
1:12:49Tesla certainly buying gpus and we're also working on dojo so I think there's a lot of potential there with Dojo that people don't realize so yeah well actually I do have a question and well I guess people keep dming me they're wondering what's the future of the Twitter files do you still have any journalists working on these things or no yeah I mean I mean at some point we need to move on from the Twitter files but I think there's a few things left but you know generally I think there's not there's not a lot that I'm aware of that's left so it's mostly just like you know let's let's move on to the Future that's true yeah yeah I think yeah I
1:13:33think that's more that's true what what are your thoughts on you know companies like Facebook Instagram Tick Tock kind of following Twitter's footsteps you know I think Facebook recently did a verification thing for 15 which is like double the price what's your what's your thoughts on that yeah like I said my opinion is that any social media organization that does not insist on paid verification will be worthless because at this point you take Instagram for example if you you can generate an infinite number of those picks using my journey and you know for free we're not for free for very little and you can get at this point modern AI can pass you know any human
1:14:19verification test so the the only solution that I can think of is to increase the cost of a fake accounts so if somebody's paying on the order of eight bucks a month that's a hundred dollars a year and they also need to get a credit card and a phone number from reputable referral carrier so so then like the it's much harder to create like a million Bots whereas if you don't require those things it's trivial frankly to create a million Bots and they'll all seem very human and and will take very little Computing effort to do so so that's why I think basically any social media that does not require paid verification will basically cease to be relevant makes sense speaking of
1:15:10generative content is it possible for you guys to add a flag that says that hey this video or this image is you know for like like I make a lot of AI generated content and a lot of it looks real right I put a one of Donald Trump making out with Gavin Newsom yeah you have anything it looks pretty real right and yeah including the voice like you can get the voice match and the video matched I mean it's really gonna get it's really getting to the point where it'll be quite easy to generate for extremely realistic fake videos images and so forth and voice I mean I saw like a fake like Joe Rogan interview and it really sounded like Joe Rogan's voice
1:15:59I sent it to Joe and he was like well this is crazy so so yeah I think verification is going to be extremely fundamental in the future that's why we're so focused on it so I mean the reason I brought that up is you know as a content creator I'd like to keep making those and I don't want to necessarily fool people right so would it be possible to I don't know add a flag to it so that you know content creators can say hey this is EI generated content don't take it seriously it's a parody well I think in in the in the Tweet you know in the post I think that it would be advisable to say that this is not real right if it is something that can be potentially
1:16:35misinterpreted it was crazy how viral that you know picture of of the Pope with the you know awesome yeah yeah yeah oh there was a lot of Joe Biden falling off the airplane I mean you could also like the best advertisement Balenciaga has ever gotten in in their attorney like the Harry Potter Balenciaga demon flying fox one was it was a genius he did a D1 today yeah a lot of the Rings I think yeah yeah it's amazing
1:17:14and actually even even the AI fashion is great right I mean if if I was a fashion designer I'd be taking ideas from this because the stuff that makes actually original right yeah the AI fashion is incredible yeah yeah so I mean just can we just like print that somehow or make it because yeah it's amazing maybe you should patent the idea you know just have like an EI profession generator thing that prints them out and you know it's like a like I think there's craft or something right like the clothing manufacturer thing that you can do it at home yeah yeah you can make so much money well I I don't really believe in patents actually yeah so but yeah I mean there's really some
1:17:57amazing AI generated clothing it's really cool and that I really love that one with the Pope and that went viral a lot of people thought that the pope actually had that outfit which is not like totally out of the question because there's a lot of amazing fashion in Italy so it's possible that some you know Fashion House made a really epic code for the pope you know and
1:18:21but that that was that was obviously AI generated I mean we're headed into a weird world here we are we're video games like trying to figure out what's real is super hard yeah I mean I mean I fooled millions of people of the you know the one of Joe Biden fall off the airplane so I mean anything's possible Right well that I mean he has slept a few times on the stairwell so you know the stairways so that's that's you know yeah quite quite believable in that situation so yeah a bunch of things like very close to the truth are it's quite reasonable to expect that people would interpret that as possibly true so yeah I think just just verification that an account is real
1:19:01that material is real the what is real anymore is a extremely fundamental question world right I mean that's what Bill Clinton used to say yeah so walk here so here at Twitter we're going to be very focused on you know figuring out what's real and it's not real then you know trying to address it I mean I think Nick Carter has been doing a great job of you know covering the news right like four hours ahead of the AP so I mean that's a big plus for Twitter that it you know you have citizen journalists now who are able to cover this stuff hours before anybody else yeah I mean if you want the real-time news is this is the best place is Twitter yeah and and you know like I said
1:19:47in any given a source of information is going to have some degree of inaccuracy and we can just aspire to make that as small as possible and and iterate towards you know being closer to the truth over time that is our goal yeah it's it's a good goal and but we're not we're definitely not going to assert that everything we say is everything you see on Twitter is true because because it isn't yeah I think
1:20:20any organization that claims to be completely truthful yeah you know so because they're not and so that that very claim is false so you know I think it's important to reflect on what mistakes we're making and try to make few of them in the future yeah unlike you know media could you tell us about x-corp is this just something that's like a legal thing that you had to do or is there maybe something more to it there is something more to it oh yeah
1:21:01my goal is to create X the everything app you know that's the goal so we're working towards nice on Twitter First Step yeah Twitter is an accelerant to X the average does that what does that mean what does it mean well I guess you'll have to stay tuned to find out I love it for another episode I've canceled my Netflix Twitter Twitter's taking my time yeah thank you for that like it's very entertaining very interesting I was I was thinking like like Twitter does make me miserable at times but it actually makes me laugh as well and right you know and I think if it's sort of entertaining and informative and that then we're doing a good job like there's the difference between
1:21:49Twitter and Tick Tock because Tick Tock is mostly passive entertainment you're just watching videos right but right on Twitter you're interacting you're saying things to people and when you tweet as a celebrity there's a pretty good chance they read your tweets and they get irritated by it let's say you're trolling them which is what I do so I mean it's good it's fun having that reaction it's like it's like playing a video game but better yeah yeah totally exactly I mean I honestly this is Twitter is trial Heaven hey a lot of the media is going to hate it because you know they want to stay safe on Twitter and and other things like even I I even get trolled and I'm like
1:22:30God like why did I control the game that was really right yeah every day and it's like ah well you know part and parcel of being on Twitter yeah totally it's worth it on that note did you see the guy who got charged for a meme on Twitter what were your thoughts on that I know you commented on it I didn't know if you got to look more into it his name's Douglas Mackey oh that's the guy who I guess was accused of election interference or something you'll Vote or something yeah like people shouldn't believe everything that they see online and you know I don't think that should be criminal no I I think criminal is a that's over the top there I would agree
1:23:13with that that they went too far you know if that's the standard for throwing someone in prison then there's really a lot of a lot of people in prison yeah what are you in prison for oh meme crimes exactly meanwhile it's like motor is running free you know so yeah exactly precisely I mean look at San Francisco right pretty damn good example crime there I I I was in San Francisco I don't know a decade ago it was it was fine and now I look at it and it's like I don't recognize this place anymore yeah we really needs something needs to be done about the client situation in San Francisco it's really the area around Twitter's headquarters especially is
1:23:54like zombie apocalypse is the perfect way to describe it yeah literally it's like if people think oh maybe you're exaggerating I'm like no you can just literally come here any day of the week including like you know 10 in the morning or two in the afternoon like we're not talking like you know midnight stuff literally mid-morning you know driving into Twitter it looks like it looks insane so it just you feel it can just come here and see further or not with their own eyes it's you know it's next level or you know watch your videos on Twitter because it's safer yeah as sad as it is right oh man like every single intense so I mean it's like you're like whoa
1:24:38I mean it can be overplayed too I mean we I spend my time often being outside Twitter with a camera doing lives really yeah outside Twitter yeah like are you brief what are you doing like pointing camera at the sign or something are you serious yeah okay why is it because it's more sort of gives up Ambiance or something yeah you must have seen the news right I know well I I suppose I have seen a few things where there's sort of people doing interviews with the Twitter science background and I I guess that's more interesting than just being in a studio or something well I mean next time I do it you can just invite me in okay sure just shoot me a note great
1:25:20but it's it's the W is now background color so look I hold up I held a poll and there was a strong yes on Twitter removing it Down Right you've got a bite better people it vox populi Vox day exactly
1:25:51only dog haters would be opposed to making the dog CEO yeah I see people saying oh you promised to quit and step down I'm like well no the dog's a CEO you know yeah like what are you complaining about yeah it's a great dog I mean there are towns where Demir is the dog right they elect a dog because all the people suck yeah here's the same thing yeah dog's always cool yeah he's got great instincts [Laughter]
1:26:23anyway I hope people have a good time on Twitter and learn things and you know like I said acid test is undergraded user time and if it's undergraded user time is growing then we're doing the right thing it's good I'd like to hear that I mean I love Twitter and it's good to see things go onward and upward all right sounds good well good talking guys I'll I'll head back to work and thanks for all your feedback yeah my question three million people joined this space wow three million yeah yeah dang people really like that part of the interview where you started interviewing them this is Elon Musk interviewing the BBC you can still hear me oh no
1:27:12okay well all right well thanks for coming time you enjoyed that yeah entertainment hey welcome you're most welcome welcome all right thanks for signing off guys bye
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版