2024 年,马斯克和本·夏皮罗(Ben Shapiro)在奥斯维辛集中营旧址边走边聊。这场对话由欧洲犹太协会组织,话题从参观集中营的感受开始,一路延伸到言论自由、反犹主义、DEI 意识形态、大学危机、加沙战争,最后落在人类文明该往哪走。这场对话里马斯克说的很多话,比他在 X 上那 1.69 亿粉丝每天刷到的一百条推文都更完整、更有逻辑。以下是这场对话的核心内容。
走完奥斯维辛,他说需要几天才能消化
访谈一开始,夏皮罗问马斯克,当天走过奥斯维辛和比克瑙两个集中营,是什么感受。
马斯克的回答没有任何修饰。他说这极其触动人心,也极其悲伤,人类竟然能对同类做出这种事。纪念地必须存在,就像铭牌上写的那样,为了让它永远不再发生。
他补了一句很实在的话:自己是个历史爱好者,看过照片、看过视频,但真正站在现场,那种冲击完全不一样,是直接砸在心上的。他说到现在还在消化亲眼所见的这场悲剧的规模,可能要过几天才能真正沉下去。
接下来他说的一段话,是整场访谈的第一个关键论点。他说,如果当年有社交媒体,纳粹的罪行不可能被完全掩盖。如果当时有言论自由,情况也会不同。纳粹上台后做的第一批事情之一,就是关掉所有媒体,切断一切信息传递渠道。
美国宪法第一修正案之所以是言论自由,是因为当年来到美国的人在自己的国家没有言论自由。他们如果说了什么不该说的话,可能被关进监狱,甚至被杀害。所以对宪法的第一条修正,就是让人可以想说什么就说什么,不会被投入监狱或被杀。(马斯克)
这段话把言论自由和 Holocaust 直接连起来了。马斯克的意思很清楚:信息封锁是暴行的前置条件。它从来都处在暴行的上游,绝非可有可无的附属现象。
X 平台的定位:做世界上最好的真相来源
夏皮罗接着把话题转到 X 上。他承认自己也是通过 X 获取新闻的人之一,但他也提到围绕 X 的一个持续批评:平台上反犹内容在上升。
马斯克的回应分两层。
第一层是机制。他说平台的总体偏向是支持言论自由,而最终言论自由会赢。如果有人说假话,尤其是在 X 上,你可以直接回复纠正。他特别强调自己对社区笔记(Community Notes)的投入,说公司把最大的资源和注意力都压在这上面。像否认大屠杀这种谎言,一旦出现,会立刻被纠正,而且那个标注删不掉,会一直挂在你身上。
第二层是目标。他说 X 平台的总体目标是成为世界上最好的真相来源。他承认完美真相很难达到,人们对真相的解读也常常不同,但可以始终朝着更准确的方向努力,把说出口的话和事实之间的误差压到最小。
他用的词是"对真相的不懈追求"(relentless pursuit of the truth)。只要不违法,让人们说他们想说的话,哪怕有争议,也是对的。
以色列之行:最让他震惊的是杀戮中的欢愉
夏皮罗提到,10 月 7 日之后马斯克去了以色列,亲眼看到了那些基布兹(kibbutz)和莫沙夫(moshav)里的惨状。
马斯克说他看了大量视频。最让他震惊的,是杀害无辜者时那种欢愉,杀孩子、杀手无寸铁的妇女和男人时的欢愉,完全没有悔意,恰恰相反。
那需要一种极度强烈的洗脑。所以要解决这个问题,必须处理洗脑的源头。没有人应该为杀死一个孩子感到高兴。(马斯克)
这里他第一次提出了贯穿整场访谈的核心判断:暴行来自后天的灌输,来自一整套被搭建起来的仇恨教育,所以要解决问题就得从教育源头下手。
夏皮罗感谢马斯克一直戴着那串纪念人质的项链。马斯克说,他出发前查过,还有那么多人质,希望他们还活着,希望他们能回来。
"我三分之二的朋友是犹太人"
谈到 10 月 7 日之后全球反犹情绪的暴涨,马斯克说了一句很坦率的话:他承认自己在这件事上有点天真。
他解释说,在他所处的圈子里,几乎看不到反犹主义。他开玩笑说自己有个"我只有一个犹太朋友"的老梗,实际情况是他三分之二的朋友是犹太人,犹太朋友的数量是非犹太朋友的两倍。他说自己是"通过关联成为犹太人",是"有志向的犹太人"(aspirationally Jewish)。
所以在晚餐桌上他从来没听过反犹言论,觉得这事很荒谬。但当他看到西方几乎所有主要城市都爆发了大规模亲哈马斯游行,他震惊了。更让他震惊的是,这些游行发生在那些本应"开明"的精英大学校园里,耶鲁、宾大、哈佛。
他提到哈佛 Harris 民调的一个数据:18 到 24 岁的年轻人里,约 67% 认为犹太人属于"压迫者阶级"。
他接着把这个数据和反犹主义的本质连起来。美国有大约 700 万犹太人,总人口 3.3 亿,占比极小。但"犹太人等于压迫者阶级"这套意识形态,和反犹主义的根源高度吻合。反犹主义本质上是一种阴谋论,一种关于权力的阴谋论。纳粹宣传的核心就是:犹太人是一个小小的种姓,却掌控着所有主要产业,站在一切世界权力的背后。希特勒的说法是"国际犹太人"要为德国一战战败负责,也要为盟国在二战前不愿和德国达成协议负责。
DEI 和反犹主义,几乎是同一张维恩图
这是整场访谈里马斯克逻辑最锋利的一段。
他说,那种关于权力和群体身份的理论非常丑陋,而今天我们能在"多元、平等、包容"(Diversity, Equity, Inclusion,DEI)意识形态里看到它的回声。DEI 的基本假设是:整个社会是一座巨大的群体身份金字塔,站在最顶端的是那些成功的人,而这些人正在剥削其他所有人。判断谁成功,不看他的实际成就,而看他的群体身份。
这跟反犹主义几乎完全重合,在维恩图上几乎就是一个圆。(马斯克)
他接着说了一句很狠的话:任何名字听起来像是从乔治·奥威尔小说里走出来的东西,你都该警惕,这从来不是好兆头。多元、平等、包容,听起来都是好词,但它真正意味着的是基于种族、性别和性取向的歧视,它反对唯才是举(merit),所以从根本上就是反犹的。
夏皮罗补充说,那些校园里支持哈马斯的集会,组成了人类历史上最奇怪的联盟之一。你会看到 LGBTQ 的旗帜和支持哈马斯的人站在一起,而如果一个 LGBTQ 人士真的身处加沙地带,他根本活不下来。
马斯克同意这个观察,但他给出了更深一层的解释。这种联盟之所以存在,是因为背后有一种"联盟式"的理念:权力结构必须被不惜一切代价推倒,如果这意味着和恨我的人结盟,那我就和恨我的人结盟。
弱者不等于正义,这是当代最大的思维错误
夏皮罗问,如果西方继续拥抱这套理念,未来会怎样。
马斯克的回答回到了道德哲学层面。他说,必须停止一个原则:更弱的一方总是对的。这根本不成立。如果你是被压迫者、是弱势方,这不代表你就是对的。如果这些弱势群体想灭绝你,那也不能让他们变成好人。
我是道德绝对主义的坚定信徒,不是道德相对主义。善与恶是绝对存在的。你评判任何群体或个人,要拿绝对道德标准去衡量,而不是看他所谓是被压迫者还是压迫者。他们是在做好事吗?他们想谋杀无辜的人吗?那就是坏的,不管他们是谁。(马斯克)
他承认,通常情况下"别去欺负比你弱小的人"是对的。但如果那个更小的群体想杀你,那他们就是坏的。
夏皮罗顺着这个逻辑,把它推到以色列身上。他说现在有一种完全颠倒的逻辑:因为以色列军事强大、技术先进,在世界上人口最稠密的地区之一尽力限制平民伤亡,而恐怖分子像蜂巢一样嵌在社会的每个角落,在加沙地下修了数百英里的隧道,长度相当于整个伦敦地铁系统。以色列打击这些系统时杀死了很多平民,每一个平民的死亡,责任都在把平民当人盾的恐怖组织身上。但外界却把这套"弱小即道德优越"的逻辑套在这场冲突上。
马斯克说,这确实是 180 度的大翻转。历史上大部分时间运行的规则是"强权即公理"(might makes right),谁强谁有理。现在翻到了另一头:谁弱谁有理。但两头都不对。对错独立于强弱。一个人强不代表他对,一个人弱也不代表他对。必须看绝对的道德标准。
人性本善,除非被洗脑
夏皮罗问了一个更根本的问题:去了奥斯维辛、走过 10 月 7 日之后的基布兹,这改变了马斯克对人性的看法吗?是让人更悲观,还是更确认人性中光明和黑暗的两面?
马斯克的回答出人意料地温和。他说,爱人类其实是人的天性,除非被洗脑成别的样子。大多数人的默认状态就是爱人类、喜欢和人待在一起。
他举了一个例子。监狱里最严厉的惩罚之一就是单独监禁,而单独监禁的意思不过是不能和其他囚犯待在一起。那些囚犯可能都不是什么好人,但即便如此,不能和其他囚犯待在一起也被视为可怕的惩罚。
所以从本质上说,我们天生都爱人类,除非被洗脑成别的样子。所以我们必须阻止那种洗脑。(马斯克)
加沙的三条建议,第三条最难
夏皮罗追问:那该怎么阻止洗脑?西方学校里的软性洗脑,加沙那种硬性洗脑,孩子们从很小就在毕业典礼上重演绑架和杀害以色列士兵的场景。不解决这个,就不可能有和平。
马斯克说,他在以色列时给出的最高优先级建议就是这个:必须确保加沙对孩子仇恨式的洗脑停下来。他理解进军加沙的必要性,也承认难免有无辜者死亡,但最重要的事情是确保之后不再有那种从孩子刚能听懂语言时就教他们"你的目标是杀死以色列人"的教育。从幼儿时期就被这样告知,人就会相信它。这必须停止。
然后他给出了完整的三条建议,这是他整场访谈里最具体、最可操作的部分。
第一条,清除哈马斯武装分子。改革是不可能的,他们唯一的目标就是杀死以色列人,所以要么被击毙,要么被监禁。否则他们只会杀更多以色列人。
第二条,改变学校里的洗脑。不能再让孩子从两岁起就被教导去仇恨。
第三条,也是最难的:对加沙人民做出显眼的善举(conspicuous acts of kindness)。
如果你对一个人做了好事,你就更难恨他。哪怕他们咬你,试图咬你的手,也要继续做。(马斯克)
他用历史上的马歇尔计划(Marshall Plan)来支撑这个论点。一战后德国承担了不公平的罪责,产生了巨大的怨恨,正是这种怨恨让希特勒得以上台。而二战后完全相反,美国通过马歇尔计划出资重建德国和日本。历史上这种事很少发生,但看看结果:和德国没有战争,和日本和平相处,德国到今天快一百年了。
为什么他对西方仍然乐观
夏皮罗说他很难乐观。过去两年太丑陋了,从乌克兰到以色列和哈马斯的冲突,到美国国内政治,到处都是极化和撕裂。他问马斯克,西方的未来在哪,人们还能围绕共同价值团结起来吗,尤其当每个人都在被信息消防水管灌的时候。
马斯克承认信息过载是真的。你可以实时获取全世界的所有信息,但一个人不可能消化所有这些。信息可得性的好处背后,是选择瘫痪和过载。
但他认为有些东西是大多数人都会认同的,是酷的、激励人的。比如人类登上月球。如果你问世界上几乎任何地方的孩子,人类做过最酷的事是什么,很多孩子会说我们上了月球。
我们想延续这种探索精神。我们想拥有一个梦想:成为一个跨星球文明,一个多行星物种,走向群星之间,去发现宇宙的本质,共同追求更大的启蒙,更好地理解我们身处的这个不可思议的宇宙。我觉得这非常吸引人,我想大多数人也会觉得这非常吸引人。(马斯克)
夏皮罗补了一层:这里还嵌着唯才是举的价值观。说"人类能登月"是一回事,说"我能成为登月的一部分"是另一回事。唯才是举意味着你可以是那件事的一部分。人类有这个能力只是前提,更关键的是,如果你足够努力、足够创新、足够坚持,你可以参与其中。那些放弃了这个信念的社会,也放弃了登月。
他说美国现在有个问题:不愿简单地说一句"自由是了不起的,唯才是举是有史以来最伟大的发明,我们应该守住它"。正是这个东西把人类送上了月球。丢掉它,我们就到不了月球,也到不了火星,哪儿都去不了。
被忽视的平等:信息获取的平等
马斯克接着讲了一个他认为被严重低估的事实。
人们总在谈不平等,但有没有人谈信息获取的平等?现在你只要有一台很便宜的电子设备,在一个网吧,就能免费看到 MIT 的所有课程,能看到几乎任何一本书,能学任何东西。这种信息获取的平等,在二三十年前是不可想象的。你可以免费自学任何技能。
也许我们太关注那些不平等的东西,却忘了那些已经变得平等、已经大幅改善的东西,比如信息获取。这正是星链(Starlink)想帮忙的地方:给那些没有网络、或者网络太贵用不起的人提供互联网接入。因为一旦有了网络,你就能学任何东西,你就能卖你的产品和服务。(马斯克)
他说了一句很朴素的话:如果我们数自己的苦难,也该数自己的福气。
一天发一百条推文,没有团队
夏皮罗问他,作为公众人物,一条推文影响巨大,怎么决定什么时候发、发什么,怎么确保自己了解所谈论的话题。
马斯克说他确实发得很多,有时候一天一百条。偶尔会发些蠢东西,这是肯定的。但他尽量说一些自己觉得有趣或好笑的东西。他半开玩笑地说,1.69 亿人关注他总得有点原因,大概是他在某种程度上娱乐了他们。
关于准确性,他说社区笔记对他和对任何人都一视同仁。如果他说错了,或者上下文不全,社区笔记会很快纠正他。
他特别强调了一点:所有帖子都是他本人发的,没有团队。
我一般会建议世界各国的领导人,就自己发自己的东西。偶尔犯个错,别担心。(马斯克)
"大屠杀在西方重演的概率极小"
访谈接近尾声,夏皮罗问了一个沉重的问题。10 月 7 日之后,全世界很多犹太人都在问,"永不重演"(Never again)到底只是指 1939 到 1945 年那一段,还是指"现在就永不重演"?如果有一个种族灭绝组织想杀很多犹太人,你愿意现在就站出来反对吗?
马斯克对"会不会重演"这个问题给出了一个明确的判断。
我认为大屠杀在西方重演的概率极小。我可能是天真的,但我真这么认为。(马斯克)
他的论据是历史细节。希特勒第一次半选举上台时大概只拿到三分之一的选票,然后搞了政变式的夺权。但想想有多少人为了摧毁纳粹而战斗、牺牲。数以百万计的人战斗并死去,西方绝大多数人即使在那时也反对纳粹,战斗并牺牲。
他讲了自己祖父的故事。祖父在二战中打了将近六年,所有朋友都死了,他是唯一活下来的。战后他受到严重创伤,几乎说不出话来。他大部分时间在东非、北非、意大利。他活下来纯属侥幸:战争快结束时,军队给他做了个能力倾向测试,因为他只是个下士,高中没毕业,没资格进军官学校,结果他被挑出来,大概就在他快死之前,被派去伦敦为英国情报部门工作,在那里遇见了他祖母。
他就是为阻止纳粹而战的人之一,还有数百万其他人。所以我们不要忘记,西方绝大多数人为阻止纳粹而战、而死。(马斯克)
这段话是对"西方注定重演悲剧"这种悲观论调的一个直接反驳,而且用的是家族史,不是抽象论证。
孩子、历史和一所纽约精英高中
夏皮罗提到当天见到了马斯克三岁的孩子,问他怎么跟孩子讲大屠杀和反犹主义这些话题。
马斯克说他的孩子读书很多,读了很多历史,在这个话题上不无知。三岁的那个当然还不会读。
但他讲了一件让他震惊的事。他和几个亲戚家的孩子有过一次令人不安的对话,那些孩子不是他亲生的。有孩子说,因为美国糟糕的外交政策,世贸双子塔被摧毁是"活该"的。
我当时就想,这就是纽约精英高中教给你们的东西?这太有问题了。(马斯克)
这个细节值得单独拎出来。它说明马斯克对"洗脑"的担忧来自他在自己家族里亲眼见到的东西,跟抽象的政治表态无关。一个在精英教育体系里长大的孩子,能说出"911 是活该",这套逻辑和校园里"犹太人等于压迫者阶级"的逻辑,是同一套东西。
这场对话真正在说什么
把整场访谈串起来看,马斯克其实在讲一条完整的因果链。
信息封锁是暴行的前提。纳粹先关掉所有媒体,再干别的。所以言论自由是防止暴行的基础设施,它从来都处在暴行的上游。
反犹主义的内核是一套关于权力的阴谋论:一小撮人暗中掌控一切。这套阴谋论今天换了衣服,叫 DEI,叫"压迫者与受害者"的群体身份金字塔。它不再说"犹太人",但它说的是同一件事:成功者的成功来自他们所属的掠夺性群体,跟他们做得好不好无关。
这套逻辑最危险的推论是"弱者即正义"。一旦你接受了这个公理,任何弱势群体对强势群体的暴力都被自动合理化。马斯克的反驳很干脆:对错独立于强弱,只能拿绝对道德标准去衡量。
而洗脑是可以被拆掉的,但只能从两头拆:一头是清除那些改革无望、唯一目标就是杀人的武装分子;另一头是改变教育,让孩子不再从两岁起被教去仇恨;中间那一头最难的,是对敌人做出显眼的善举。因为你对一个人做了好事,你就更难恨他。
最后他给出了一个乐观的判断,而且这个判断有历史支撑:大屠杀在西方重演的概率极小,因为当年有数以百万计的人为阻止它而战、而死,这个记忆还在。
给读者的行动清单
这场访谈信息量很大,但真正能用的部分不多。如果非要从中提炼出几条对普通从业者有用的东西,大概是这些。
- 警惕任何以群体身份替代个人能力的评价体系。不管它叫 DEI、叫"多元化",还是叫别的什么好听的词。判断一个人,只看他做出来的东西。这是马斯克整场访谈里最硬的一条主张,也是最容易在日常工作中验证的一条。
- 遇到"弱者即正义"的论证,先停一下。问一句:这个结论是因为他弱才成立,还是因为他做的具体事情才成立?把这两件事分开,很多争论会立刻清楚。
- 把"信息获取的平等"当成一个真实的机会。MIT 的课免费,几乎任何书都能找到,你可以自学任何技能。这件事在二三十年前不可想象,今天免费。别只盯着自己缺什么,也看看自己已经免费拥有什么。
- 如果你要公开发声,自己写,别外包。马斯克 1.69 亿粉丝,一天一百条,没有团队。他的判断是:偶尔犯错,别担心,社区会纠正你。这个建议对任何需要建立公众信任的人都成立。
- 想化解仇恨,先做一件具体的好事。别只发声明,也别只表态。对那个人、那个群体做一件看得见的好事。哪怕对方不领情,继续做。这是马斯克给加沙的第三条建议,也是普通人今天就能用的一条。
- 读历史,但别只读结论。马斯克反复说自己是历史的学生,但他引用历史的方式是具体的:希特勒第一次上台拿了多少票,马歇尔计划之后德国和日本发生了什么,他祖父在哪一年被调去伦敦。具体的历史比抽象的判断更能救人。
0:00we walked ashz I I hadn't been there before either I first of all just wanted to get your thoughts on what it was like to walk ashz and birken out today well it was Inc incredibly moving and deeply sad and tragic that humans could do this to other humans it's good to have the memorials as as the plaque says so that it never happens again no i' I mean I'm a student of History so I'd seen the pictures I'd seen the videos but it's not quite it's it hits you much more in the heart when you see it in person I'm still absorbing frankly the magnitude of the tragedy that I witnessed place where the tragedy occurred I think it'll take a few days just to sink in
0:37frankly as was mentioned if if there had been social media I think it wouldn't have been impossible to hide if if there had been freedom of speech as well you know you know one of the one of the first things the Nazis did when they came in is they shut down all the press and any means of conveying information so it's worth noting in in United States the first amendment in the United States was freedom of speech because the people that came to the United States from other countries did not have freedom of speech that if they had said something they could be imprisoned or killed and that's why the first correction to the Constitution was the ability to say what
1:16you want to say and not be thrown in prison or killed yeah Elon is obviously the the CEO of X which is the largest news service on the internet the place where a huge number of people including me get the news you you've been committ since you took over to a much broader perception of free speech on the outlet and that's led to a lot of criticisms about suggestions of rising anti-Semitism on on the outlet as well I can say for my own part that the broadening of speech on Twitter I think and on X has been a a an excellent thing one of the things that that I was able to do for example in the aftermath of October 7th was actually put out full footage and pictures of what exactly was
1:56happening so see what's really happening the true horror is is something think people need to be able to see if they want to see it and the community notes feature has allowed for people to even when when things that are false are put up that used to maybe pass in real time now you can correct all of that how do you balance the necessity for free speech with with all these critiques about you know what is hate speech what is anti-Semitism and how do you balance that well the the general bias of the platform is in favor of free speech and I think at the end of the day free speech wins if somebody says something that's false especially on our platform
2:27you can then reply to it with the correction and then I'm a huge fan of community notes I've put we've put maximum resources and attention behind Community notes so if somebody tries to push a falsehood like Holocaust denial or something like that they can immediately be corrected and and they and you can't get rid of the tag it's like stuck on you you I think it's and and the overarching goal for the xplatform is to be the best source of Truth in the world now now you know one can it's it's difficult to get to perfect truth and sometimes people have different interpretations of truth but one can can always aspire to be as accurate as possible and to minimize the
3:05error between what is being said Relentless pursuit of the truth the goal with with X and allowing people to say what they want to say even if it's controversial provided it provided that it does not break the law I think that's the right thing to do and setting the new standard for the Town Square as I say has allowed for more speech and more availability of information than ever before certainly on on the platform you recently didn't just go here obviously after October 7th you went to Israel and you saw the wages of horrific anti-Semitism in the various kibuts and mo I saw all the videos I saw a lot of video yeah yeah it was shocking to see I
3:45think maybe the most shocking thing was to see the Delight in killing innocent people like the Delight in killing kids and defenseless woman and man and there there was no remorse quite the opposite I mean that requires a level of indoctrination that is extremely intense so so I think that to solve that you have to address the source of the indoctrination because no one should ever be glad about killing some child I know a number of enormous number of Jews myself included a very move that you continue to wear the necklace in remembrance of the hostages so so I want to thank you for that obviously because raising the profile of the fact there's
4:25still dozens of men women and children so many I I checked before I came so many hostages I hope they're alive I hope they come back so let's talk about you know the the uptick in anti-Semitism more broadly one of the things that's been hard to watch as a Jew but also just as an American and a Westerner has been the radical upsurge in anti-semitic activity just generally anti-semitic sentiment appallingly after October 7th it's been astonishing actually yes and I I I must admit to being somewhat frankly naive about this in the circles that I move I see almost no anti- anti-Semitism and you know there's a this all oh joke I've got like this one Jewish friend no
5:02I have like 2third of my friends are Jewish I have twice as many Jewish friends as non-jewish friends I'm like Jewish by association I'm aspirationally Jewish so I don't you know I was like what are people talking about with this anti-Semitism CU I never hear it in at dinner conversations it's like an absurdity you know at least in my friend Circle but when you know looking at the pro Hamas rallies in vast numbers that took place in almost every major city in the west blew my mind and on including on the elite college campuses that are supposed to be you know if you're an elite college campus you're supposed to be enlightened it's supposed to be
5:37fostering hate and yet you had these Pro demonstrations that har you know Yale including at p i I went to upen at pen and I was like this is unbelievable I mean there's a poll recently from Harvard Harris showing that some 67% people aged 18 to 24 said that the Jews were an oppressor class which you know in in America Jews represent approximately 7 million Jews in the United States out of 330 million Americans tiny percentage of the population but that ideology that the Jews are an oppressor class matches up very nicely and very closely with what is a conspiracy theory at root anti-Semitism is a conspiracy theory and it's a conspiracy theory about power and
6:17if you read Nazi literature the Nazis literally promoted the idea that Jews were of course this small caste of people who were running all the major industries who were standing behind all world power as Hitler's suggestion is it was world jeury that stood behind Germany's loss in World War I and then the Allies unwillingness to make a deal with Germany prior to World War II and you know that theory of power and group identity is really ugly and we see Echoes of it today diversity equity and inclusion ideology that basically suggest that all of society is a vast pyramid of group identity and that at the very top are the people who are successful and that those people are
6:51exploiting everybody else and we can tell who's Successful by their group identity not by their level of success by their group identity it matches up incredibly it syns up almost a vend diagram with antisemitism absolutely the diversity actually inclusion you should always be wary of any name that sounds like it could come out of a George Orwell book that's never a good sign and because it sounds like sure diversity Equity inclusion these all sound like nice words but there what what it really means is discrimination on the basis of race sex and sexual orientation and and it's against Merit and thus I think is fundamentally anti-semitic yeah you know
7:24the I think the the whole all of the sort of the all of the ri that were in the major cities and college campuses I think was a shocking wakeup call to I think any sort of civilization a civil minded person really it was quite a shock the crossover between some of these rallies on college campuses in favor of Hamas I mean they they unite the the weirdest coalitions maybe in human history you'll see lgbtq Flags in favor of Kamas where of course if an lgbtq person were to be actually in the Gaza Strip they would no longer be in the Gaza Strip they would be dead that that coalition that's like seriously out of touch yeah but it it isn't but it only isn't out of touch in
8:04the sense that there is a coalitional idea here that basically power structures must be torn down at all costs and if that means allying with people who hate me then I'll Ally with people who hate me and and the fact that's grown in fervor since October 7th really is you know as I said to me on on a personal level quite shocking what do you make of the future of a West if if the West continues to embrace that idea well I think we really need to stop this principle that the weaker nor normally weaker party is always right this is simply not true if you are in qutes oppressed or the weaker party it doesn't mean you're right because if some of those you know we weaker groups want to
8:42annihilate you that does not make them good we just we have to get rid of the rule that if you're weaker you're automatically good that's obviously makes no sense you know you know it often makes sense where it's like okay you don't want to beat up on someone smaller and weaker than you but if that smaller group wants to kill you that they're bad okay I mean I'm a big believer in moral absolutism not moral relativism there is there's good and bad in the absolute and you judge any group or individual against absolute moral standards not whether they they're the so-called oppressed or oppressor just on absolute moral TBS are they doing good things do they want to motor inent
9:20people that's bad doesn't matter who they are you would think but the the pseudos sophisticates on college campus seem to think differently so I want to get your take on why you think this is so prevalent on college campus what do you think the future of the universities in the United States looks like given the fact that entire universities appear to have been corrupted by moral relativism and this sort of perverse ideology do you think that a wave of change is coming to the universities do you think that there's going to be direct hiring out of high school what is the solution for universities in the United States as well as abroad I think
9:51we need to return to what it where things were or mostly were which is a focus on and it doesn't matter whether you're a man woman you know what race you are what beliefs you have what matters is you know how good are you at your job or what are your skills you know you know you could be a three-legged green Martian you know wears a kimono and drinks Yak milk who cares doesn't matter you know it what matters is like how good is your work that's it that that's the that's the least sort of racist sexist you can be is just care about the work that somebody does and not anything else that's what the focus needs to be to return to yeah yeah it seems as though
10:28you metion mentioned earlier the the sort of problems tax on the meritocracy and you know one one of the claims is that there's no real meritocracy there's there's a pseudo meritocracy that basically all these institutions are Run for the benefit of those who run the institutions and it feels like there is some truth to the idea that institutions have lost credibility with the people particularly in the west and in the backlash to that I think that there's now you know sort of an idea that if we do away with all institutions and all limits on moral Behavior then that somehow is better but there needs to be a recapturing of the institutions or at
11:00least a rebuilding in place of those institutions new things and that's something obviously that you're very focused on not only with X but your other companies is building new things Innovation try and create our way out of the problems that we've created for ourselves yeah I think generally people should always be wored that they may have either consciously or press mostly subconsciously internalized the notion of a a zero sum game or a fixed pie and if you're internalize that that there's that everything's Zero Sum meaning like in order for me to get ahead someone else has to not get ahead or for me to have stuff someone else must not have
11:31stuff if you have that axiomatic flaw then that's what what it needs to be done is to to fix that act flow because it is false there it's not a zero sum game we can absolutely grow and have grown and the evidence is overwhelming that we have grown the output of goods and services we have many things today that we did not have in the past we are far more prosperous all of humanity is far more prosperous today than it was at times in the past I mean it wasn't that long ago where you know we would count a good year as one where well the bonic plague wasn't that bad only killed 10% you know we not that many people sted through the winter we only lost you know
12:095% of our population due to raids from other tribes you know basically life used to be very rough in the old days and it's if if they could see us now they'd be like what are you guys complaining about this is amazing you know not having to worry about F food for I mean we were constrained for you know probably the last 100,000 years until recently you know really the the present day future is is amazing compared to the past and anyone who doesn't think it's amazing is not a good student of History I think we live in the most interesting of times and probably the best of times one of the things that I would hope that and I think you're part of this is a coalition
12:45of meritocrats standing up for the meritocracy is going to be deeply necessary in a future where trust has been fragmented with so many institutions we're going to have to stand up and loudly say that Merit still exists and that Merit is individually based not based on innate characteris istics of some sort you mentioned earlier you know that you're aspirationally Jewish that you surround yourself with that you're surrounded by so many Jews are you part of the Jewish conspiracy what exactly is the maybe that'll please the haters on online yeah I'm sure no I mean I just yeah I grew up around a lot of Jewish people I went to Hebrew preschool Rachel sparo in South
13:18Africa I my name is very Jewish oh for I will tell you that for the past 10 years people have assumed in my community that you Jewish until I informed them otherwise yeah is PR Jewish name it's super Jewish yeah and then I went to Israel when I was 13 you know I mean you know visited Mada I'm certainly checking the boxes on a lot of things and like I said most of my friends are Jewish just worked out that way sometimes I yeah I guess maybe I forget am I Jewish I'm Jewish aspirationally Jewish yeah when you hear critiques about X right about the amount of anti-Semitism on X what are the metrics that you're seeing from the inside about the amounts of
13:54anti-Semitism or quote unquote hate speech because it's always a vaguely defined term hate speech page on your platform yeah I mean the outside audits that we've had done at least the ones that we've had done show that there was the least amount of anti-Semitism on X if you look at all the other social it's never going to be zero if you've got 600 million people on a platform expecting it to be anything to be zero is extremely unlikely because you got 600 million people on a platform but when they compare us to you Instagram Tik tok's actually got a lot of7 Tik Tok is pretty terrifying people have not checked out Tik Tok I mean the algorithm
14:27is absolutely pushing you to material yes it is I believe it's we have Tik Tok has like five times the amount of anti-Semitism per post than we do so it's not like it's not going to be zero but to the best of our knowledge it is has the least amount of antisemitism of any platform Legacy Media has spent an awful lot of Ink on you there's been a lot of attempts to paint you as anti-semitic or paint X as anti-semitic where do you think that's coming from why does the Legacy Media seem to have you particularly in the last year and a half half in the crosshairs so much well I mean the re reality is that X is competition for the Legacy Media you know X is a is where people go to get
15:07the most current news and learn about the world so leg you know the Legacy Media is are direct competitors so they're really going to find trying to every angle to try to cancel that's I mean if you want to know why things are happening look at the incentives you know and Legacy Media has had a tough time with respect to usage the numbers I saw was that the sort of traditional print cable television viewership went down something like 20 30% last year on the other hand X went up roughly the same roughly 203% so it's a direct competition for people's attention if there's some attack they can Levy against me they will it seems as though one one of the other matters is not just
15:44direct competition between the media and X but also that the the Legacy Media for most of my life up until the past you know 15 years performed what they saw as a gatekeeping function they were the ones who got to define the narrative they were the ones who got to determine what was appropriate new and what was inappropriate news and then even after social media arose in the early days there was this sort of the sort of things that you articulate were actually articulated by virtually all the social media heads Mark Zuckerberg used to say the kinds of things that you say Jack dorsy used to say the kinds of things that you said and then there seemed to
16:12be an Institutional takeover by a lot of Legacy Media types in terms of the kinds of rules and restrictions that were placed on what you could and could not say on these platforms who would get banned but not get banned advertisers weaponized against you know particular you know particular Outlets if those Outlets didn't follow the dictat that were put forward by by these types and it seems like since you took over one of the biggest objection of all is that they're not performing the AE keeping function anymore someone else is well yes I mean I don't think that there should be a gatekeeping function by a small number of of individuals I mean if
16:43really if you say like for newspapers in America there are about five editors that decide what what gets put on the front page what to focus on or what not to focus on and most of the other most of the other papers just copy them essentially but is that really what we want do we want just a handful of of people deciding what they think is important should it be that the people decide what's important and I think it should be sort of organic thing where the people decide what's important and what to focus on not just a handful of editors and yeah they don't like the fact that this power has been taken away from them but I think it should be I
17:16want to go back to something that you said a little bit earlier talking about the idea that on a moral level you know the there's nothing that suggests that that simple weakness is itself virtue that a weak person can be virtuous but doesn't necessarily mean that they are a powerful person can be you know the victimizer but doesn't necessarily mean that they are that logic carried forward particularly to what's going on in Israel right now has been in my opinion entirely pernous and wrong there's this idea that because Israel is a powerful militarily sophisticated country that is doing its best to limit civilian casualties in one of the most population-dense areas of
17:49the world in which we have terrorists who are honeycombed throughout every aspect of society building literally hundreds of miles of tunnels the entire London subway system worth of tunnels underneath the ground that somehow you know Israel targeting those systems and killing a lot of people because when you kill terrorists unfortunately they're embedded among civilians it's terrible and it's horrifying that every one of those deaths is on the terrorist group that embeds itself with civilians there's been this logic has been mapped onto that conflict that smaller and weaker means morally virtuous because victimized yeah it really has come completely full circle from or or 180°
18:26from what has historically been the case through most of History the operating principle has been might makes right yeah for really up until modern times might makes right was the if you were stronger you were right now now we've sort of flipped it to know if you're weaker you're right but neither is true there is rightness independent of strength or weakness just because somebody's strong doesn't mean they're right and doesn't because somebody's weak doesn't mean they're right you have to look at morals in the absolute on a broader level you you talk a lot about you know your Hope For Humanity i' say that you're somebody who really loves Humanity which is why you talk about
19:01expanding Humanity's reach out to the Stars when you go to a place like like aitz or when you walk the villages like kibuts Berry after October 7th does that change your opinion of humanity or does it reinforce what you think Humanity can be on both the positive side and on on the negative side I think it is actually human nature to love Humanity unless you are indoctrinated otherwise I think the actual default for most people is to love humanity and to love being around you can take for example like what's one of the worst punishments in prison is solitary confinement and all solitary confinement means is that you're you're you don't get to hang out with the other
19:37prisoners which might not be the best group of people to hang out with but even that is considered a terrible punishment to not be able to hang out with other prisoners so in truth I I think in our nature we all love Humanity unless we are indoctrinated otherwise and so we have to stop that indoctrination how do you think that people ought to pursue that because obviously we have seen indoctrination at a wide variety of levels ranging from sort of soft indoctrination in various schools in the west very hard indoctrination that you see in for example the Gaza Strip where kids are literally unfortunately at very young ages they have graduation ceremonies
20:09that we've seen tapes of where they're reenacting kidnapping of Israeli soldiers or killing of Israeli soldiers for example that fundamentally has to be addressed or there will not be peace the education of kids in Gaza the the indoctrination of hate into kids and Gaza has to stop so I you know when I was in Israel I was like that was my top recommendation is like you got to make sure I understand the need for this to invade Gaza and unfortunately some innocent people will die there's no way around it but the the the most important thing is to ensure that afterwards that the indoctrination where kids are taught from as soon as they can understand
20:45language that their goal is to kill Israelis and if you're told that from when you're a toddler well you're going to believe it and that needs to stop on a technological side what do you think can be done there because actually this is one of the areas where you know the guys strip isn't famous for its internet access you know there there there there a lot of places around the world where the government puts an extraordinarily heavy hand on the flow of information you're mentioning that the Nazis first thing they did was take over the entire press mechanism inside Germany and then inside the occupied areas of Europe but that obviously happens all over the
21:15world right now and one of the things you use startling for is to try and open up some of those Avenues of information but what can you do what should we be at it's worth also the the Nazis engag in in extreme censorship within Germany for anything that was pr- Semitic I'm not sure how many people are aware of that but you were that they they censored any prosmetic anyone who tried to defend the Jews in Germany any pro Semitic was was censored yeah I think freedom of speech and R rigorous pursuit of the truth is the way is is one way to get her to defeat hatred you know when when I look at the United States well when I look at the United States one of
21:49the things that that seems to be breaking down and and when any the first element historically maybe the last element of a society in a state of mental decline is a a vast outbreak of anti-Semitism this is what was happening in Nazi German but historically countries that are in a state of decline tend to have wild outbreaks of anti-Semitism and it seems to me that one of the key things that can reverse that process is the rebuilding of local institutions and as local institutions break down you see sort of this fragmentation of the population how do you merge the the need for technological development with the building of those local institutions families churches
22:25schools and the kinds of things that societies are built upon yeah actually I I should say there were really three things that were my strong recommendation visiting Israel one is obviously one has to get rid of Hamas fighters who where reform is impossible their only goal is to kill Israelis they ought to be either killed or imprisoned because otherwise they will simply kill more Israelis then the second thing is you you've got to change the indoctrination in the schools so that kids are not taught to to hate from the moment they are 2 years old and then the third thing is and which is a very hard thing to do in this situation is conspicuous acts of kindness to the
23:02people in Gaza conspicuous acts of kindness to the people in Gaza it's just that much harder to hate someone if you do nice things for them even if they bite they try to bite your hand when you do it keep doing it and you look at the Marshall Plan after you know look at world look at the difference between World War I and World War II where after World War I Germany got an unfair share of the blame it led to immense bitterness it's what allowed Hitler to rise to power was the German Schult soldiers from World War and but then you look in contrast to what happened after World War you had the Marshal plan you had you know had United States coming in
23:37and actually funding the rebuilding of Germany and re and the rebuilding of Japan how often does that happen in history but look at the results no war with Germany peace with Japan and Germany for now soon it'll be almost a century so when you look at the state of the West right now you somebody maybe it's all the Doom scrolling but when you you look at the state of the West right now you're very optimistic it sounds like you know I find it hard to be optimistic in In This Moment it's been a very ugly couple of years you know from Ukraine to the current conflict in Israel and Hamas to domestic politics in the United States and else seems like
24:11there's a lot of polarization a lot of fragmentation what do you think is the future of of the West can we come together around any sense of shared common values especially given the fact that everybody is kind of drinking from the fire hose of information one of the downsides about the upside of information is the availability the downside is you know choice paralysis is an overload I mean you can definitely get information overload there so much information coming at you these days CU you can get all the world's information real time it's impossible for one human to digest all that you know I think there are some things that we can agree on or most people would agree on are
24:44cool and inspiring like Humanity going to the Moon you know if you ask probably kids almost anywhere in the world what's the coolest thing humans have ever done I think a lot of kids would say we went to the moon you know and so I think we want to continue that Spirit of exploration you know speaking of kind of growing the pie and is that we we want to I think have a dream that we can be a space bearing civilization a multiplet species a multi-cell species and go out there among the stars and discover the nature of the universe that we can collectively seek greater Enlightenment to better understand this Incredible Universe we live in I find
25:24that very compelling I think most people would find that very compelling I think embedded that it's also as you say that core value of meritocracy because it's one thing to say man can go to the moon it's another thing to say I can be part of man going to the moon and a meritocracy suggests that you can be part of that it's not just that human beings are capable of doing the thing it's that you can be a part of that thing if you work hard enough if you innovate enough if you try hard enough and so societies that seem to have given up on that also seem to have given up on on going to the Moon societies that are so reflective about their own supposed
25:53laws the United States has this problem right now that they are unwilling to to Simply say freedom is pretty phenomenal and meritocracy is the greatest thing that's ever been invented and we should hold on to that and that's what's going to allow us to get to the Moon that that stops us from going to the moon or to Mars or to anywhere else yeah I mean there's and there's many wonderful interesting things that are happening beside space exploration obviously as time goes by we improve our ability to cure cancer to cure many diseases there's increased access to information and people talk a lot about inequality but what about the equality of access to
26:26information that's incredible you know right now if you've got you know a very cheap electronic device at an internet internet cafe you can access all of the lectures of MIT for free you can access almost any book you can learn anything this is Ane equality of access to information that was Unthinkable even 20 30 years ago you can teach yourself how to do anything for free that's amazing maybe there's like too much focus on the things that are unequal but we should we forget about the things that are equal and that have have improved inequality so much like access to information you know that's one of the things that we're trying to help out
27:02with stall link is provide access internet internet access to people who don't have internet access or where it's too expensive for them to afford because once you have internet access you can learn anything and you can sell your your your products and services I think that's that's pretty amazing I mean you know that if we're going to count our flows we should also count our blessings one of the things that I think is amazing about what you've been doing Elon is that it's not just you know the business side of you that's important obviously you become this unbelievably you know large figure looming in the public imagination and that means that
27:36when you tweet it has you know impact that is very large how do you decide when to tweet sometimes it's memories sometimes it's joking sometimes it's these long thought out post how do you decide when to tweet how do you inform yourself on the topics that you're tweeting about well I do put post a lot on the xplatform you know sometimes 100 times a day and once in a while I'll do something dumb for sure but really you know I try to say things that I think are interesting or funny I mean there must be some reason why 169 million people follow me I guess I don't know I must be keeping them amused in some way so amuse Entertain You know have opinions on something sometimes they're
28:13wrong sometimes they're right and you know for things like Community notes it applies to me as well as it applies to anyone else if I say something that's incorrect or you know not full context then Community notes will correct me very quickly but it's only me doing these posts ever I don't have a team or anything in fact I generally would recommend for leaders of the world to just literally post your own stuff and once in a while you make a mistake don't worry about it yeah can't win them all can't nobody bets a thousand obviously where we visited today you know the big takeaway always is never again the I think that the question that a lot of
28:47Jews worldwide asked after October 7th and after that wild up surge of anti-Semitism which we've seen the Jew hatred that that continues now is whether never again really for a lot of people me never again between the years 1939 and 1945 or whether it actually means never again like right now as in if there's a genocidal group that wishes to kill lots of Jews is that something that you wish to stand up against right now and when you look out at the world and the state of the world you know the the video that EJ put up a moment ago suggesting that the Holocaust would have been somewhat mitigated or people may have had more information been able to
29:20certainly been able to escape earlier I mean one of the one of the things that's astonishing obviously about the history of the Holocaust is how many because they were only getting partial information it was slow and it was gradual and by the time they wanted to get out it was just too late for them to get out you know what are your hopes that never again is a real thing I mean I certainly hope there not the Holocaust that's how realistically is it I think it's unlikely frankly at least if you say like I mean I could be naive but I think the probability of a Holocaust in the west is extremely tiny you know I think if you look at say the you know
29:51the Nazis I think hler got like a third of the vote or something like that when he was first semi he was sort of sort of semi- elected and then did did basically a crew and but but think of all the people that fought to destroy the millions and millions of people that fought and and were died to destroy Nazism the that's the vast majority of the West opposed even in those days opposed not and fought and died and my grandfather was in World War II for almost 6 years all his friends got killed he was the only one of his friends to survive and he was severely traumatized like he really just couldn't even talk afterwards most of that time was in East Africa North Africa Italy
30:28the only reason he's even alive frankly is because towards the end of the war they gave like a an aptitude test cuz he was just a Corporal he he didn't graduate high school so he wasn't eligible for Officer school and they plucked him out probably right before he died and sent him to work for British intelligence in London which is where he met my grandmother you know so he was one of the people fighting to stop the Nazis and many along with millions of others you know so let's not forget that the vast majority the of the West fought and died to stop Nazism I had the chance to briefly meet your three-year-old today oh yeah he's a he's a fun guy
31:02adorable I have three-year-old of my own so I can they're all very similar but you know as you're you have some kids who are much older you have you know kids who who are younger obviously when it comes to teaching them about things like the hola and anti-Semitism how do you address those topics well my kids are pretty well read so they read a lot of history they're not ignorant on the subject I mean maybe the three-year-old is sure I would hope can't read no my my kids are very well read but I you know they I've had some sort of just disturbing conversations with sort of some say nephews or some family members not my kids but kids of family members
31:36were I was actually shocked to see anti-em or or at least yeah one disturbing conversation was you know saying that the you know that we deserve to have the Trade towers destroyed because of our terrible foreign policy I was like this is what they're teaching you in Elite New York high schools this is messed up well Elon I think I personally choose all over the world a lot of people in this room want to thank you for not only visiting aitz but also visiting Israel after October 7th and for the strong moral voice you've been on behalf of the fight against anti-Semitism it's great to spend time with you thank you so much thank you for having me thank you very much you know
32:11thank you Ben for very interesting interviews interview thank you for the questions and thank you for the answers I would like now please to call the 10th president of the state of Israel hen rivlin and drel M the president of the conar of Paris for a for a brief picture please T president of Israel Dr J M the president of the cons of France we take please a picture before we move on with the program thank you president presid if he please can call you for the okay house you hold it again it's quite heavy okay yeah please do okay
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版