马斯克在 X 上骂他是白痴,还追了一句“不可忍受的黑猩猩”(insufferable chimp)。两天后,这位被骂的人站在都柏林一间会议室里,宣布推出“大白痴机票促销”(big idiot seat sale):10 万张票,16.99 欧元一张。促销上线一天,三四百万次点击,瑞安航空预订量涨了两到三个百分点。
被骂的人叫迈克尔·奥利里(Michael O‘Leary),瑞安航空(Ryanair)CEO。他对着满屋子记者说,感谢马斯克带来的免费宣传,上午已经派人把一张免费机票送到 X 的都柏林办公室,连 16.99 欧元都不用付。
这场记者会本来跟马斯克一点关系都没有。
奥利里开场就把主题亮出来了:他要骂爱尔兰总理迈克尔·马丁(Micheál Martin),绰号“什么都不做的马丁”(Michael Do Nothing Martin)。都柏林机场有一条 3200 万人次的客流上限,马丁的政府在执政纲领里白纸黑字写着“尽快取消”,13 个月过去,什么都没发生。
会议室里准备了印着标语的 T 恤。奥利里的原话是,他们和美国的航空公司一起,要求“什么都不做的马丁”把这个上限废掉。
至于马斯克,“算是被社交媒体争议盖过去了,我们在最后统一回应”。
那条 3200 万的上限,超了 440 万,还是没人动
先把这条上限讲清楚,因为整场记者会一半的怒气都从这里来。
都柏林机场的客流上限法定为每年 3200 万人次。这个数字由规划审批环节绑定,机场自己定不了。2025 年,瑞安、爱尔兰航空(Aer Lingus)和“美国航空公司协会”(Airlines for America,A4A)一起打官司,拿到了一份法院禁令,把上限暂时冻结了。
结果去年都柏林机场客流涨了 140 万,达到 3640 万人次。比法定上限高出 440 万。
奥利里用这件事嘲讽政府的执法能力:一条超了 440 万人次还没人执行的上限,说明它从头到尾就没起过作用。
这场官司现在打到了欧洲法院。瑞安方面的主张是,这条上限违反了保障人员自由流动的欧盟基本权利宪章,因此不合法。时间表已经排出来了:2 月总检察长出具意见,6 月终审判决。
政府那边说要等法院。奥利里不接受这个说法。他举了一个对比:当年设立“国家资产管理机构”(NAMA)清理银行坏账,相关立法 24 小时就通过了。同一个议会,同一套程序,处理银行家的事一天搞定,处理机场的事 13 个月没动静。
他给了一条明确的截止线:1 月底之前立法废除,做不到就 2 月底。再做不到,瑞安和美国的航空公司会一起呼吁特朗普政府,取消马丁 3 月的白宫访问。
真正让爱尔兰政府紧张的是美国人递上去的那份投诉
记者会里最有分量的一段,跟机场上限本身关系不大,跟华盛顿有关。
去年 12 月,A4A 向美国政府提交了一份投诉,理由是都柏林机场的客流上限在歧视美国航司。投诉要求爱尔兰在 1 月底之前给出答复。奥利里的判断很直接:如果答复不是“我们立刻废除这条上限”,特朗普政府有相当大的可能禁止爱尔兰航空的航班降落纽约。
他接着往下推了一步:马丁 3 月的白宫访问也可能被取消。
然后他给出了这场记者会里最锋利的一句预测:
到那时候,这条上限 24 小时内就会被废掉。因为马丁的海外行程一旦受限,那会变成一场国家紧急状态。(奥利里)
这句话背后的逻辑值得停一下。奥利里花了整整十分钟,逐条列举马丁过去四个月的行程:9 月在加拿大发橄榄球,11 月在巴西参加气候大会(环境部长本来可以去),11 月在南非参加 G20(财政部长本来可以去),11 月顺路去安哥拉开了个就业峰会(他访问之后,爱尔兰没多出一个就业岗位),1 月在中国待了 4 天,本周在达沃斯跳舞,当晚还要给 80 位高管办晚宴,主题是“聚焦就业”。
奥利里的评价是,马丁在国外待的时间比埃尔顿·约翰还多。
他真正想说的是:一个把海外露脸看得比国内事务重的政府首脑,只有在自己的海外行程被卡住的时候才会真正动手。这就是他敢说“24 小时”的依据。
顺便说一句,马丁政府在下议院握有 20 席的多数优势。奥利里反复提这个数字,意思很清楚:这活儿技术上毫无难度,缺的只是意愿。
每座 35 欧元:瑞安所有争论的起点
记者会开场的十分钟,奥利里报了一串数字,这些数字决定了后面所有争论的走向。
瑞安去年的每座成本是 35 欧元。维兹航空(Wizz)和易捷航空(EasyJet)平均在 75 欧元左右。英航、法航、汉莎是 180 欧元。
去年瑞安运送旅客 2.07 亿人次,同比增长 3%。今年夏天从 96 个基地、224 个机场起降。平均票价 45 欧元,平均航程 1 小时 15 分钟。去年燃油支出约 55 亿欧元。
对比放在大西洋两岸更明显。奥利里说,美国现在最便宜的机票也在 100 美元以上。瑞安当年是照着西南航空的模板起家的,那时候西南的票价是 10 美元。去年西南的平均票价约 130 美元,瑞安是 45 欧元。
他给出的结论挺有意思:美国在 AI 和 IT 上领先,欧洲在航空票价上把美国按在地上摩擦。
这套成本结构靠的是一连串取舍:没有免费餐食,没有免费行李,没有指定座位,机队高度统一,飞机日利用率拉到极限。所以在讨论星链、讨论机场费用、讨论环境税的时候,奥利里的判断标准永远只有一条:这东西会不会推高每座成本。
他也没打算掩盖爱尔兰市场的尴尬。瑞安在爱尔兰有 42 架飞机、214 条航线,今年预计运送 2550 万人次。看起来不错,但对比一下:意大利今年增长 9%,摩洛哥 11%,西班牙 3%,阿尔巴尼亚接近 60%,爱尔兰因为上限卡着,基本原地不动。
他讲了个地拉那的例子。去年 9 月他去阿尔巴尼亚宣布开基地,当地机场只有一个航站楼,只服务 8 架飞机,而维兹航空在那边就有 8 架。阿尔巴尼亚政府说,9 月开工,明年 3 月完工。奥利里当场说不可能,得两年。结果他今年再去,楼已经盖好了,正在做内部装修,前后五个月。
对比句他没说出口,但满屋子人都听懂了。
和 Starlink 谈了一年,卡在两个天线和 2% 的阻力
现在说马斯克那条线。
奥利里强调,瑞安和 Starlink 已经谈了一年多,他对这套系统的评价相当高:“非常好的系统,我们喜欢它,它运转得很好。”
问题出在装机方案上。要在机身顶部装两个天线,数量翻不了倍。这两个天线会带来 1% 到 2% 的燃油阻力。
把数字摊开算:瑞安一年烧 55 亿欧元燃油,1% 到 2% 的阻力意味着多花 1 亿到 2 亿欧元。加上设备安装和改装费用,一年总成本在 1.5 亿到 2.5 亿欧元之间。
然后是收入端。Starlink 那边的判断是,90% 的乘客愿意为机上 Wi-Fi 付费。奥利里的判断是不到 10%,他还补了一句“这可能都算乐观,也许不到 5%”。分歧就在这里:一边认为九成,一边认为不到一成,中间差了近十倍。
他给了唯一可行的方案:如果 Starlink 愿意自己出钱装设备、自己承担燃油阻力,瑞安非常乐意装。或者在短途航线上干脆免费送,让乘客用起来。让乘客为 1 小时 15 分钟的航班付 1 欧元、2 欧元、3 美元,他认为没人会买单。
为了证明这个判断有来历,他翻出了一段旧账。大约 10 年前,瑞安在机上装娱乐系统,租平板电脑给乘客用。他当时的预期是这东西会供不应求。同一时间,瑞安开始卖机上彩票,他当时的判断是“人类历史上最愚蠢的生意,没人会买”。
结果是:机上娱乐系统撑了两个月就撤了,彩票卖了十年还在卖。
改装成本也解释了一遍。装天线得把飞机从航班表里撤出来,在机身上钻孔,装完再飞回去。钻机身的活贵、难,还涉及适航。如果试点失败,还得再来一遍同样的流程把东西拆掉。奥利里说,只要结果是燃油阻力上升,瑞安碰都不会碰。
马斯克说他不懂空气动力学,奥利里的回应是:
他的说法是,在机身上装天线不产生气动阻力。这对波音和空客来说是个大新闻,他们花了一百年时间优化飞机的气动外形。我们在机翼上加一对小翼,花几十万欧元,能省两三个百分点的油。这么小的改进都能带来显著的燃油节省,而像天线这种东西挂在机身上,只会增加成本。(奥利里)
谈判没有关门。奥利里说,瑞安同时还在跟亚马逊、沃达丰谈,这三家的系统都不错。他相信技术最终会解决:将来天线可能装进客舱、装进前后厨房或者货舱,不用挂在机身外面,到那时候短途航班的免费 Wi-Fi 会变成标配。
所以现在的策略是等:等到有人愿意出钱,或者等到技术不再有成本惩罚。
把“白痴”做成促销,10 万张 16.99 欧元的机票
记者会上最好玩的部分,是奥利里怎么处理马斯克的辱骂。
他的原话大意是,自己完全没觉得被冒犯:
任何有十几岁孩子的人都懂,你在家里天天被叫白痴、被叫各种难听的词。我不需要出门去找人骂我。(奥利里)
他还补了一句,说马斯克要排队,因为觉得他是白痴的人已经排了很长很长的队,包括他四个十几岁的孩子。
Sky News 的记者问得更狠:马斯克骂他“不可忍受的黑猩猩”,这算不算对黑猩猩群体的侮辱?两个成功又渴望曝光的商人互喷幼稚的垃圾话,是不是纯粹为了免费的曝光?
奥利里的回答分两层。第一层是玩笑:这个定性对黑猩猩不公平。第二层是生意:这种互喷对瑞安的预订量有好处,他就喜欢这种能带来订单的公关战。
他也没有回避对方的成就。记者问,马斯克在送人类去火星,你却说他不了解空气动力学?奥利里说,这件事本身就挺明显的。语气轻,但没松口。
关于收购传闻,他讲得很清楚。马斯克在 X 上发起投票,问要不要收购瑞安。奥利里的回应是:瑞安是上市公司,任何人都可以买股票,欢迎。但欧盟规定非欧洲公民不能控股欧洲航空公司,所以真要收购,法律上不可能。
然后他顺手捅了一刀:如果马斯克想投资瑞安,他会认为这是一笔非常好的投资,比他在 X 上赚到的财务回报好得多。
记者追问:既然你们骂成这样,为什么不干脆请他来做个试点?奥利里说不用,欢迎所有股东,但试点不试点的前提不变,得有人出钱。
匿名才是他真正想禁的东西
记者问奥利里怎么看 X,他的回答绕了一圈,落到了一个比马斯克大得多的题目上。
他先承认自己不用 X,从没注册过。然后说了一句挺重的话:所有社交媒体都是粪坑,不只是 X,比 X 更糟的多得是。
但他真正反对的东西很具体:匿名。
他讲了个二十多年前的旧案。早年有人在匿名网站上发帖,说瑞安航空不安全,发帖人自称是有 23 年飞行经验的飞行员。瑞安一路打到加州法院,最后查明是一个住在纳文(Navan)的 17 岁少年,穿着睡衣在家编的。
他的主张是:
你想发什么就发什么,但用你自己的名字发。言论自由在美国和欧洲都受保护,我完全同意。但你得为自己的话负责。现在这种匿名,让键盘侠可以给政客发死亡威胁,让女明星被人一键脱衣,没人该受这个。(奥利里)
他提到最近 Grok 的“脱衣”争议,说给女性、给孩子做裸体化处理,跟言论自由毫无关系,政府应该直接立法禁止。他的原话是,这世上黄色的东西已经够多了,不需要再多一种。
关于澳大利亚禁止 16 岁以下使用社交媒体的做法,他的判断是白费力气。他拿克努特大帝挡潮水打比方,说 14 岁、16 岁的孩子绕过一道禁令的速度,比瑞安今天的促销卖得还快。四十、五十岁的政客给十几岁的孩子定规矩,注定无效。
那该怎么做?还是那句:禁匿名。让平台知道谁在发帖,让每个人用自己的名字或者实名账户发言。
这里有个细节值得注意。记者问他,既然说社交媒体是粪坑,瑞安为什么还开着账号发内容?奥利里说,瑞安在 Facebook、Instagram、TikTok 上都有账号,TikTok 还是最大的企业号之一。他个人觉得 TikTok 是他见过最没营养的东西,但如果年轻人都在那儿,那就得去那儿。区别在于,瑞安发帖从来用自己的名字,说错了自己负责。
这个立场和他骂马斯克的方式意外地一致:可以互喷,可以蹭流量,但你要署名。
票价还要涨,产能紧张撑到 2030 年
后半场转向生意本身,给出的信息密度更高。
今年夏天票价预计上涨 3% 到 4%,个位数的小幅上调。如果油价继续跌,涨幅可能被吃掉一部分,甚至回落。
为什么涨?奥利里的答案很简单:运力不够。
瑞安今年从波音接 29 架飞机,座位供给只增长约 3%。整个欧洲的情况更紧:大部分空客机队还在等普惠(Pratt & Whitney)发动机的维修,很多飞机停在地上。除瑞安之外,欧洲没有哪家航司在 2030 年之前有像样的飞机订单。维兹航空原本有,大部分推迟或取消了。
需求那边在排队。利雅得航空想买一两百架短途飞机,2030 年前拿不到。土耳其想再买 500 架。印度要更多。中国已经大约七年没订波音了。
奥利里的判断是:2030 年之前,运力增长不会超过 GDP 增速。这意味着票价的下行压力很小。
也有人问油价。奥利里猜特朗普会在 11 月中期选举之前压油价、压利率,包括处理委内瑞拉问题以增加石油供给。如果今年出现供给过剩,油价下跌的部分会传导到票价上。他把这段明确标成了猜测。
他顺手给了一条更现实的建议:早点买票。6 月、7 月的欧洲短途假期现在就该订。理由是瑞安不飞美国,而爱尔兰也进不了世界杯,所以那段时间的欧洲航线不会有需求暴增压垮价格的问题。
飞机订单、康马克,以及“总会有灾难”
瑞安手上有一笔疫情时期下的订单:300 架波音 737 MAX 10,2027 年 1 月接首架,交付排到 2034 年。现有波音机队 630 架。奥利里说,瑞安是全球范围内运力增长最有控制权的航空公司,这句评价他自己说得很坦然。
2 月接完最后 4 架,下一批要到 2027 年春天。MAX 10 的取证还得等,波音那边说今年晚些能拿到。
关于中国商飞(Comac),有记者问地缘政治会不会促使瑞安分散供应商。奥利里给了一组硬数据:商飞去年全年造了大约 60 架飞机。而且所谓国产大飞机,本质是把 A320 做了一遍子装配:发动机是 GE 或赛峰,航电是霍尼韦尔,还有柯林斯。商飞产能越大,对欧美本就紧张的供应链抽血越狠。目前机型 180 座,对瑞安来说太小。
结论是:2030 年代中前期之前,商飞不可能救任何人的急。但奥利里希望到 2030 年代初,市场上能有三家供应商可选:波音、空客、商飞。
空客那边他也问过了。瑞安旗下休闲品牌有 30 架 A320,租约 2028 到 2029 年到期,他想再订 100 架。空客的答复是,2032 或 2033 年之前交不出窄体机。
所以他给了一句挺冷静的判断:从现在到 2030 年代初,航空业不出现一次意外下行的概率是零。这个行业每隔三到五年就会遇到一次灾难。上一次是新冠,刚缓过来,普京入侵了乌克兰。
顺便,他在这里插了一段政治表态:特朗普在 NATO 增加军费上是对的,在回撤环境税上是对的,很多经济政策也是对的。但在乌克兰问题上错了,在不批评俄罗斯这件事上错了,在关税上错了。
他的原话是:关税从来没有成功过,将来也不会,因为它推高通胀,推高普通人的生活成本。
特朗普、格陵兰、关税,还有“爱尔兰中立是个笑话”
记者问特朗普要格陵兰对不对。奥利里的回答是:错的。
他承认美国有真实的防务关切,也指出美国二战后已经和丹麦、格陵兰达成过协议,在那边有十几个军事基地。想重开基地、想投资,丹麦和北约都不会反对。但你不能走进来说“我要格陵兰,给我”。
他补了一句:
那你让中国怎么看台湾?你不能一边说我要格陵兰,一边要求别人不许动。(奥利里)
谈到贸易战,他的立场是欧洲该硬一点。如果特朗普对欧洲加关税,欧洲应该对等回击。他的判断是特朗普会退缩,因为美国企业在欧洲的盘子很大,双向贸易额太大,而且 11 月中期选举在即,八个月之内打一场跨大西洋贸易战,代价太高。
从瑞安自己的角度,他希望飞机和发动机能被豁免。理由很实在:航空器和发动机是美国最大的制造业出口品类之一,波音、GE 背后是大量美国就业岗位;欧洲这边同样,美国航司是空客的大买家。
奥利里多次强调瑞安是北美以外波音最大的客户:630 架现役加 300 架订单。他说自己“是美国的大力支持者”,美国在自由贸易和民主推广上做过很多好事。但他也希望欧洲别再一味迎合,该顶回去就顶回去。
聊到爱尔兰的军事中立,他的用词是全场最不客气的:
爱尔兰的中立是个笑话,是这个国家疯子左派的心头好。我们是一个没有防御能力的岛,位于欧洲边缘,既保护不了自己的天空,也保护不了自己的海域。(奥利里)
他的主张是爱尔兰应该加入北约。他甚至往前推到了 1945 年,说当年就该加入,那样北约会在爱尔兰西海岸建深水潜艇港,会在全爱尔兰建大约 25 个机场,基础设施会比现在好得多。他把责任归到德瓦莱拉(Éamon de Valera)的孤立主义路线,说孤立主义在爱尔兰行不通,在朝鲜行不通,在中国也试过,同样不行。
他还专门提了一条:香农机场(Shannon)作为美军中转站,收益很大,应该继续鼓励。任何让这个国家左派不爽的事,都应该积极鼓励。
那个被撤掉的人,和一整套做不动的系统
有记者问都柏林机场 CEO 肯尼·雅各布斯(Kenny Jacobs)的离职传闻。奥利里的回答分两半。
前半是讽刺:看起来他的错误是得罪了芬戈尔郡议会(Fingal County Council)的某些人,以及交通部的某些官僚。他说每个人每天早上都该说一句,今天第一件事就是得罪郡议会的官僚和交通部里没用的官员。
后半是批评,而且批评得不留情面。奥利里说雅各布斯在都柏林机场干得并不好,他力推了一条 2.2 亿欧元的隧道,从滑行道底下穿到货运区。奥利里的评价是,包裹不需要隧道,绕着飞机开过去就行了。这属于为了抬高监管资产基数、好继续涨费用而做的过度建设。
这套逻辑串起来很完整:机场花费越高,监管批准的收费基数越大,航空公司付的钱越多。所以奥利里对都柏林机场扩建方案的态度是:DAA(都柏林机场管理局)想在客流和利润都创纪录的时候涨 10% 的费用,同时砸 90 亿建一堆航空公司根本不需要的东西。
他给出的替代方案很具体:都柏林机场目前的收费是每位出发旅客 16.50 欧元,就冻结在这个水平,靠这笔钱照样能建出需要的航站楼设施。两条跑道能撑 6000 万人次,先把上限废掉再说。
还有一条欧盟层面的规则,他提了两次。欧洲的航空碳税体系 ETS 只对在欧盟境内飞行的欧洲公民征收,美国、中国、海湾国家的航司往返欧洲全部豁免。他的原话是,只对自己的公民征税、把其他所有人都豁免,这种做法没法辩护。解决办法是把 ETS 和国际民航组织的 CORSIA 机制对齐,结果是所有欧盟公民的票价下降。
这套主张可以连起来看:取消上限,冻结机场费用,对齐碳税规则,然后拿 7 年计划换 50% 的客流增长。计划的具体数字是:2025 年 40 架飞机、2300 万人次,7 年后 60 架飞机、3500 万人次,都柏林大幅扩张,科克从 4 架到 7 架,香农从 3 架到 7 架,在诺克(Knock)新开一个 2 架飞机的基地。
奥利里说,这套计划唯一的前提就是政府动一下。而现在的政府,按他的说法,因为总理忙着周游世界,处于停摆状态。
整场记者会的底色
把这些内容拼起来,会看到一个挺有意思的图景。
奥利里骂马丁,用的词是“什么都不做”。他骂马斯克,用的词是“在空气动力学上很自信地搞错了”。这两种批评指向的东西其实一样:占据资源、占据注意力、占据话语权,却不承担把事情做成的责任。
他对社交媒体的态度也是同一套逻辑。匿名的键盘侠和拖着不立法的政府,在他看来都属于同一种失灵:有发声的渠道,没有对应的责任。
但他并不天真。他知道这场和马斯克的互喷是免费的广告,知道“白痴促销”能把骂声变成订单,知道记者会需要一个好标题。他甚至主动把这个机制说破:只要不涉及安全,所有公关战对瑞安都是好事。
唯一没被打折对待的是成本。35 欧元的每座成本是瑞安存在的理由,任何一项新增开支,不管是两个天线带来的 1% 到 2% 燃油阻力,还是机场涨的 10% 费用,还是欧盟只对自己人收的碳税,都要放回这个分母上算一遍。算不过,就不做,哪怕对方是马斯克,哪怕舆论上难看。
这场记者会里,那些狠话传得最快,但更值得记住的是一组对比:一个只有 8 架飞机容量的航站楼,在阿尔巴尼亚 5 个月就能扩出一倍;一条写在执政纲领里、握有 20 席多数优势、只需要一次投票的上限,13 个月动不了。
奥利里的结论很简单:制度变慢,往往是没人打算让它快。
读者可以直接用上的判断有这么几条:
- 看一家低成本航司的战略,先看它的每座成本,再看它拒绝什么。瑞安拒绝机上 Wi-Fi、拒绝机场扩建、拒绝碳税不对等,三件事的否决理由完全一致。
- 判断机上 Wi-Fi 什么时候会普及,别盯技术发布会,盯两件事:天线能不能装进客舱,以及有没有第三方愿意买单。这两条同时满足,短途航班的免费 Wi-Fi 就会变成标配。
- 近期要飞欧洲的,现在订 6 月、7 月的票。运力紧张要持续到 2030 年,票价今年预计涨 3% 到 4%,旺季不会有便宜可捡。
- 关注欧洲航空业的人,把两个日期记下来:2 月欧洲法院总检察长就都柏林上限出具意见,6 月终审判决;1 月底是爱尔兰政府回应美国投诉的最后期限。这两件事决定都柏林机场未来十年的容量。
- 看企业公关战的时候,别只看谁骂得狠,看谁的订单涨了。瑞安这次预订量涨 2% 到 3%,10 万张 16.99 欧元的票在卖。骂战既是成本,也是渠道。
0:00Just this way. Okay, thank you. Just one in here Michael and you're ready. That's great. Lovely. Thank you very much. Great, thanks. Great. Hold back and see if we can get the TV cameras on. Sure. No worries. Okay. I'm over that sitting position. Just one in here. Lovely, just point the finger just in here. That's great. Lovely, thank you. [laughter]
0:40Who are we going to be closer to today? Yeah. Thank you. All right. Yes, sorry. You go first, sorry. I'll go in here, is it? Center of the screen is better. Yeah, if you move where you were.
1:09Center is better. Center is okay. Thank you. How are you doing? Get me a coffee. Will you get us coffee, will you? [clears throat]
1:27Okay, can I just go into the office? Can I just go into the office? All right. Yeah, yeah, I fixed it. You're wonderful. Great, thanks. Thank you very much. You go ahead, sir. Where do you want us? Where do you want to go, sir? Just a minute there. So, just flick right back to it.
1:48No, I sorry, I I meant all to you at the end.
1:50And there's the clicker there back and forth. Yeah, we'll do it I think you can do that. Have we got the press release you have? We did it a bit earlier. Everybody happy to start? Since we TV's here for some of them going live. Okay. ladies and gentlemen, you're all very welcome. we had originally called this press conference to call out our T-shirt Micheal Do Nothing Martin for 15 year of 13 months of inaction on the Dublin Airport cap. We are really concerned that given the complaint made by Airlines for America to the US administration that the White House will or there's a real risk that the White House will block Aer Lingus flights landing in New York
2:33or worse still, you know, a national catastrophe could befall. They might block Micheal Martin going to the White House in March. so, it's time for action and we want to call we and the American Airlines are calling on our T-shirt Micheal Do Nothing Martin to scrap the cap. It is not good enough to say it'll happen at the end of this year or 2 years time.
2:52They had a government program published in January 2025 that said they would scrap this cap as soon as possible. As soon as possible doesn't mean 15 months later. The Nama legislation was passed within 24 hours. We don't think this is as urgent, but 13 months is not as soon as possible and we want the cap abolished by legislation by the end of January, failing that by the end of February. And if it doesn't, then we are calling on the Trump administration to block or cancel Micheal Martin's visit to the White House until the US Airlines have a fair shot or we lift this cap at Dublin Airport.
3:27I understand we've been slightly overtaken by some social media controversy with Elon Musk which I'm we will be happy to address at the end of this meeting at the end of the briefing. We'll run through this pretty quickly and then get you on to the recent stuff. So, Ryanair is wonderful. we're growing very strongly in Ireland and all over Europe at rate of 207 million passengers last year. This summer we're operating from 96 bases, 224 airports and we are growing strongly.
3:55The only problem is we can't grow as strong as we'd like here in Ireland because we have a do nothing T-shirt and a do nothing government have failed to lift the cap. The reason we grow so strongly is we have such a cost advantage over every other airline in Europe. So, our cost per seat is just 35 euros compared to Wizz, EasyJet who average around 75 euros and BA, Air France, Lufthansa are 180 euros.
4:17current developments this year, our traffic is up 3% to 207 million passengers. we're growing our market share across the EU, particularly in those countries such as Sweden, Slovakia, Italy, Albania and Malta who are abolishing travel taxes and lowering airport charges. They're following the recommendations of the Draghi report which 15 months ago called for a much more competitive European Union and we need a much more competitive European Union if Europe is going to increase defense spending. There are some countries like Belgium, Austria, France and Germany who are still raising taxes, but they are losing capacity and losing traffic. And the critical thing for
4:55Ryanair is we have 300 aircraft on order. We start taking the first of these new Max 10 air craft in January of next year, 2027. We want to deploy these aircraft in countries all over Europe, particularly in Ireland, but the cap prevents us from doing so. last year in Ireland we've grown traffic at Dublin, Cork and Shannon, Belfast Airport. The most remarkable thing about the cap is how completely ineffective it is. So, the traffic cap at Dublin Airport is set at 32 million passengers, but thanks to the efforts of the airlines Ryanair, Aer Lingus and Airlines for America last year we got a court injunction which sus pended the cap. As a result of that
5:31last year mainly thanks to Ryanair's growth, we grew by an extra million passengers at Dublin Airport. Dublin grew by 1.4 million passengers to 36.4 million passengers. It's now 4. 4 million passengers over the cap. And yet our government still won't abolish or won't pass the legislation they promised to abolish this cap. The airlines have taken this to the European courts. We expect a decision from the Advocate General sometime in February and a final court ruling in June. We believe the cap is illegal because it's contrary to the European Charter which which protects freedom of movement.
6:06But we're calling on our government, why 13 months later have you done nothing to remove the cap which you promised you would as soon as possible. And the reason we believe is that Micheal Do Nothing Martin is wasting his time on a round the world tour getting his photograph taken, eating Ferrero Rochers and doing bugger all at home on the cap, on housing or on infrastructure. And there is a real danger now. The A4A complaint which was submitted to the US administration in December demands Ireland has to respond to that by the end of January and if the response doesn't consist of we will immediately abolish this cap, then we think there is a real likelihood under the Trump
6:41administration that Aer Lingus flights would be blocked landing in New York. Micheal Martin will be blocked from visiting the White House in March and then you will see the cap abolished within 24 hours because it'll be a national emergency when Micheal Martin's overseas travels are constrained. Good news in Ireland, we're still growing strongly this year in 2026 again thanks to the injunction we have against the cap. We're still growing our traffic. We have 42 aircraft in Ireland, two new aircraft, 214 routes. We expect to grow traffic in Ireland by about to 25.5 million passengers this year including a fourth aircraft and four new routes in Shannon.
7:16In Dublin, we're growing strongly traffic up last year by 4% at 18.7 million, but Dublin is a real challenge for us and for the other airlines. This illegal cap is blocking growth. The US Airlines are not willing to commit to long haul routes or to putting more routes in there until the uncertainty of the cap is removed. We as a short haul airline can continue to grow because we can, you know, if the cap is reimposed, we can flip those aircraft out of Dublin reasonably quickly and it's time for this do nothing government to act. As I said, we have a do nothing government, Micheal a do nothing T-shirt whose world tour continues while fails to get
7:52anything done at home. We don't object to our T-shirt parading the world eating the Ferrero Rochers, but we would prefer if he actually stayed at home and implemented his government program and let some of his ministers do the overseas travel. And this is a brief snapshot of the last four months in our glorious leader's life. So, in September he was handing over rugby balls in Canada. In November he was at the COP conference in Brazil. We have an environmental minister who could have done that. In November he was at the G20 in South Africa. The finance minister could have gone there. In November he remarkably stopped off for a jobs summit in Angola where not one job has been
8:27created in Ireland as a result of his visit to Angola. And very defensive, "Oh, I'm here representing the country. Nobody objects to me." Yeah, sorry, we do. we don't mind you on your overseas travel as long as you're implementing your government program at home, but the government program at home is do is has not been implemented. 15 I said 13 months later, we still have the cap and with a 20 seat majority he still hasn't abolished it. And it continues. In January he was off in China for 4 days with the Ferrero Rochers and this week where is he? He's dancing in Davos.
8:59Tonight hosting a dinner for 80 people, top executives to focus on jobs. The most important thing Micheal Martin could do for jobs would be to abolish a cap at Dublin Airport and let Ryanair and the other airlines get on with the job of growing traffic, growing tourism and growing jobs in Ireland. But of course that wouldn't involve him getting his photograph taken or nibbling on the Ferrero Rochers. We have a very exciting 7 year growth plan for Ireland, but it's only implementable if this government takes some action or uses its 20 seat majority. We believe we can grow traffic from 40 aircraft over in 2025 and 23 million passengers to 60 aircraft and 35
9:37million passengers over the next 7 years. That would see dramatic growth at Dublin. Cork would grow from four to seven aircraft, Shannon from three to seven aircraft. We would open a new base in Knock which is currently not a base, a two aircraft base in Knock. All we require is one, scrap the cap and allow Dublin to handle the 60 million passengers that it can ha it can handle with two runways. Freeze the Dublin Airport already high Dublin Airport fees at its existing 1650 per departing passenger. That would still allow them to build the additional terminal facilities we need, but they would have to stop their current proposal is to waste 9 billion building stupid stupid
10:13things that airlines don't need at Dublin Airport and much more importantly in EU focusing on the Draghi report, we need to bring ETS, which is the environmental taxation system in Europe into line or a level playing field. We only tax European citizens traveling on intra-EU flights. We don't we exempt Americans, Chinese, the Gulf carriers all coming to Europe to a coming to and from Europe. It is indefensible that we only tax our own citizens and and exempt everybody else. The only way to fix that distortion is to bring ETS environmental taxation into line with Corsia, which would result in lower fares for all EU citizens. And so in summary, as you
10:50know, we are Europe's number one airline. We have grown in Dublin, we're still growing in 2026 125 routes and 18.7 million passengers in Dublin. The DAA are proposing to put charges up 10% despite record traffic and record profits. Micheál Martin has 13 months later still failed to scrap the Dublin Airport cap, which he promised to do as soon as possible. We believe it's cuz he's too busy on his worldwide tour. He spends more time abroad than Elton John does.
11:17We want and can deliver 50% traffic growth by 2032 and it is imperative that this government acts quickly before Aer Lingus flights get blocked in New York or God forbid Micheál Martin's March visit to the White House gets scrapped. We have in recent days as you'll seen have run into some controversy with the owner of X, Elon Musk. I don't quite know why he took such umbrage over it. I had a discussion about we have been in discussion with Starlink, his satellite system for about over 12 months now. It is a very good system.
11:51We like the Starlink system. It is a terrific system. It works very well. The problem is if you put it on board aircraft, there is a cost of that that of about two 250 million a year including the cost of installation and then the fuel drag. You have to put not one but two aerials on top of the aircraft fuselage. That will have a between 1 to 2% fuel drag. We spend about 5.5 billion a year on fuel and therefore it would increase our fuel bill by about 100 to 200 million.
12:19The Starlink people believe that 90% of our passengers would happily pay for Wi-Fi access. Our experience sadly tells us we think less than 10% of our passengers would pay for this [snorts] access and therefore we can't afford to shoulder costs of between 150 or 250 million a year. If Starlink wants to fit the flights that fit fit our aircraft and pay for the fuel drag, we'd happily put them on board, but the only way we see Starlink working on board our aircraft on short haul flights is if you give it away for free. And like most things in life, if you give it away for free, passengers will use it. If you want passengers to pay something modest
12:56like a euro, two euros or three dollars on our average 1 hour 15 minute flights, we think less than 10%. I think that's even optimistic, probably less than 5% of passengers will take this up. I thought that was a reasonably measured response to why we're not using Starlink. Elon Musk apparently took great umbrage and resorted to insulting me on X the weekend calling me an idiot. I think yesterday he also rounded on me and called me a I think a
13:27All I would say to Elon Musk is he would have to join the back of a very very very very long queue of people who already think I'm a including my four teenage children. We do want to thank him. We've had I think over I think three or four million hits on this seat sale our IT team launched yesterday, which is the big idiot seat sale. There's 100,000 seats available for sale at just 16.99, which just goes to show that Europe leads the world in low low airfares.
13:58There's no airfares like this in North America. And we're later on this morning going round to the X offices in Cumberland House to present or to give Elon Musk a free ticket. He doesn't even have to pay the 16.99 a free Ryanair ticket to thank him for the wonderful boost in publicity, which has seen our bookings rise significantly. They're up about two or three percent in the last five days, which given our volumes is a very significant boost. So, thank you to Mr.
14:26Musk. I take no insult at all at being called an idiot or a a as anybody with teenage children would know. You're frequently called an idiot and a at home. I don't need to go outside to be insulted. But he's wrong on the fuel drag. We noticed he was holding a poll about should he launch a bid for Ryanair.
14:48We're a publicly owned company. He's free to do so at any time, but non-European citizens cannot own a majority of European airlines. But if he wants to invest in Ryanair, we would think it's a very good investment, certainly a significantly better investment than he's the financial returns he's earning on X.
15:08And we want to thank him sincerely for the additional publicity. Eddie, anything else you want to add in terms of the growth strategy for Ireland? No, I mean we are very reflections on [clears throat]
15:17your view also called me an idiot and a on a regular basis. But no, you're quite right. I mean on the on the on the whole connectivity and there are lots of companies doing this and you got the three parties. You got the customers, you got the providers, you got the airline. And I think it'll be actually much less than 5% of people would actually pay for it.
15:37I'd say Wi-Fi would be a good thing to have on board, but it it would make our fuel more expensive because there is some drag on that. And when we come up with a solution, then we'll have Wi-Fi on board, but we're not paying for it. Sure. Okay, any questions? John.
15:51The issue of Wi-Fi has been something that's come up for many many years for airlines and as mentioned that kind of fuel drag. But why are you why have you been talking to Starlink for 12 months if you know that obviously you don't really want it, but it's going to incur that kind of cost in terms of the fuel and the drag etc.
16:07Would you even think of trialing it on some of the aircraft to see what happens and see what the take up is like? Look, there would clearly be a demand for Wi-Fi on board our aircraft if it was free. You know, other airlines, mainly long haul carriers like Aer Lingus, like Lufthansa and others are talking about installing Wi-Fi on board as a facility and giving it out for free, but their average fares, particularly on long haul, are over 1,000 euros. Our average fares are 45 euros. And we cannot afford that kind of to pay that 150 250 million cost to install Wi-Fi unless it can be paid for. We have had discussions with Starlink and other providers, Amazon
16:46Amazon and others. A lot of it has focused on, you know, how can we is there a way we can jointly put this on board? We'll trial it for you. We give you a platform with 200 300 million passengers across Europe, but you pay for it. You sponsor it or can we get joint sponsorship? There's always ways of which you're looking at creative solutions that might overcome what is our fundamental issue with putting Wi-Fi on board and that's cost. We don't believe passengers will pay for it.
17:17But it would certainly be a welcome addition if we can in some way finance it and put it on board our aircraft for free. Why? And we have had many years of experience. You get on board our aircraft. Lots of people are there on 1 hour flights, but they're on they're on their laptop. They have Netflix and all this kind of stuff. I don't we don't believe there's any there is significant demand on the base of people would pay for it on 1 hour flight. Sorry. Michael, Stephen Murphy, Sky News. Elon Musk on X has now called you an insufferable chimp. Is that kind of is that kind of rhetoric really insulting to the chimpanzee community and should anyone take this that
17:51seriously at all? I mean, the share price hasn't moved much. EU regulations prevent him from trying to buy Ryanair in any case. Is this not just a case of two highly successful publicity hungry businessmen trading immature barbs at each other to get tons of free publicity? I think that's very unfair characterization. I do think it's unfair on chimps.
18:12But you know, it is very good for our bookings and you know, if we can prolong these kind of we love these PR spats that drive bookings on Ryanair. I'm sure it does wonders for Elon Musk and his X or whatever subscribers he has on X as well to be fighting with somebody. But you know, if it's as long as it doesn't involve safety and we've never compromised on safety. Any of these spats are great for bookings and great for awareness all over Europe. But he's putting humanity on Mars and you're saying he doesn't know anything about aerodynamics. Well, I mean that's pretty self-evident. You know, his claim is that there is no aerodynamic drag by putting aerials on
18:48top of, you know, which comes as a great surprise to both Boeing and Airbus who have spent literally 100 years refining the aerodynamics of aircraft. I mean, we're fitting little winglets on the side of our, you know, similar winglets on the side of the wings of our aircraft at a cost of, you know, couple hundred thousand, but they save about two or three percent to improve so tiny little amounts of improvements in fuel drag result in very significant fuel savings, but tiny impediments like aerials hanging off aircraft would add to costs. But we're very happy to continue the controversy. I welcome I think I I welcome the accusation that I'm a chimp.
19:32I think [snorts] it's somewhat unfair on the chimp community, but chimp chump, as long as it increases Ryanair bookings through January, February and March, it's all good fun and entertainment. Yes, sir. You described X as successful Yes. in style of Elon Musk. Do you think X would be a massive success if it was like a somebody called and who would have access to Ryan's feed?
19:55look, I mean I have very little time. I do believe social media X in particular is a cesspit. I'm not a member, don't never have subscribed, don't participate in it. but I find my personal objection to social media is anonymity. I mean we have numerous examples of, you know, people being Simon Harris's family being threatened anonymously on these things. And you know, they go through enormous I failed to understand why if you want to put something up on social media, put it up on your own name. And you know, I hear this nonsense defense, "Oh, in Iran, you know, the government will not in America, not in Europe." Your your freedom of speech is protected in the US
20:35and in Europe. And I fundamentally disagree. I believe governments should now legislate both in Europe and in the US to remove anonymity. Post away to your heart's content, but put it out under your own name. And if you want to slag off politicians or if you want to, you know, make false claims about safety. I mean we had we had this originally earlier on back in the in the website days, you know, people were posting stuff on anonymous websites claiming that Ryanair was unsafe and, you know, he was a pilot of 23. We went through the Californian courts and found out eventually it was some 17-year-old in Navan sitting in his PJs, you know, making up this stuff. so, I would
21:14just remove anonymity and, you know, people have freedom of speech, but you have to be responsible for what you say. And I failed to understand why you have things like X and not it's not the only social media which protects anonymity, which gives all these keyboard warriors the right. And I think the most recent controversy with Grok, you know, undressing children or undressing women is frankly offensive. I don't understand why governments don't make it illegal.
21:38That's nothing to do with freedom of speech. Women and children and the occasional man, I presume as well, should be protected from not happy having your images nudified. there's enough porn out there for those who want to watch porn. But, you know, I I think it is a social media and you know, things that enable nudification or pedophilia or, you know, child abuse and there's lots of cases of that.
22:05Should be outlawed. But the easiest way to do it is remove anonymity. Yes. Michael, I just previously I was in this in another room like this with you before and you were referring to Catherine Martin and Eamon Ryan about 2 years ago as donkeys. And you were leading a big campaign with them having donkey hats on. Do you think people are thinking you're getting a bit of a taste of your own medicine now with Elon coming for you?
22:28I don't think so. I mean firstly, we were entirely vindicated. Both of them lost their seats at the subsequent election. I think the you know, we are now living with the consequences of 5 years of green failure. Road transport Dublin is the most congested city in Europe. We've had a 5 years with an aviation policy in Ireland that allowed that, you know, allegedly promotes growth in traffic, tourism, and jobs. We had a capital of an airport.
22:52but I think the Irish electors have had their say and clearly agree with me. I'm not always right, but if somebody wants to have a pop at me, I'm all up for it. Shoot away. As I said, I have four teenage children, so there is nothing that Elon Musk can say to me that my teenage kids haven't already said to me. but if it results in a bit more PR for Ryanair or helps us to promote a world-leading seat sale during the dark months, weeks two, three, and four of January, it's great. We I more than welcome it.
23:23But I'm well able to take my own medicine, so, you know, Michael, can I just ask you, would you welcome somebody like Elon Musk as a shareholder in the company? And are you calling today on Starlink and Elon Musk to sponsor basically a trial run of the technology on board? If it was successful, would you consider using it or is it going to be hard to gauge if people are using it for free?
23:42No, firstly, we welcome all shareholders on our share register. Now, obviously, we we have an obligation to have a majority to remain EU owned and controlled. So, it would not be possible for Elon Musk, even if he wanted to, to acquire Ryanair. But I would certainly encourage him to invest in Ryanair. I think it's one of the best airline investments. In fact, I think it's one of the best investments out there.
24:05what's the second part of the question, Fergus? Sorry. Just in relation to are you asking for a trial run basically today to No, no, no. Look, we have had discussions with all of the Wi-Fi inter Wi-Fi providers, you know, and the bigger ones, Amazon, Starlink, and Vodafone. They're all excellent systems.
24:22You know, I don't have any issue and I would be say publicly I think Starlink is a terrific system. But the the economics of putting it on board short-haul aircraft where we and our customer base don't believe they will pay for it are prohibitive. I mean we tried this There was a good example about 10 years ago when we put these in-flight entertainment systems on board, you you these kind of you we had the glorified PCs and we were renting them out. And I thought this would be the greatest thing since sliced bread. They would, you know, we couldn't we we wouldn't be able to keep them stocked.
24:54At the same time we put on lottery tickets which I thought was the greatest stupidity known to humankind. Nobody would ever buy that rubbish. 10 year I think the on-board in-flight entertainment systems lasted about 2 months and the lottery [clears throat] tickets are still going strong 10 years later.
25:09So, you know, we would always be happy to trial these things, but you know, when you start and it's not something that you it's not like, you know, we can roll these out on board and put them on the trolleys on board the aircraft. For us to refit these aircraft, we take the aircraft out of service to refit aerials on them.
25:26This is a huge you take the aircraft out of service. It's a huge capital expenditure to fit this technology onto the aircraft and then you have a fuel drag going forward. And if the trial doesn't work, you then take the aircraft out of service. You have to deal This is not simple, you know, if you start playing around and drilling holes in aircraft fuselages that are there, it is very expensive. It is technically difficult.
25:50And if it results in a fuel drag, it is a something we would never go near. But we are very happy and we are continuing to have discussions with Starlink, with Amazon, with Vodafone about the possibility of doing it, but only in a way where it will lower our costs. And those discussions will continue.
26:09So, we would not rule it out at any stage. Yes, sir. for your results next week, is there anything we can expect to see? And also our what what both sides profits are around 5 billion. Is that is that a realistic target? No, as you know, because we have put third quarter results on Monday, we're in a closed period. Can't say anything about results or guidance or anything else. It'll all be dealt with on Monday. when hopefully the our seat sale with Elon Musk will have have successfully concluded and this country will have blown over. Yes, sir.
26:36you said that X is a cesspit. Are you comfortable with Ryanair maintaining an account and posting there? No, sorry. No, I said all social media in my view is a cesspit. I I wouldn't confine it just to X. There's worse than X out there. Am I happy for Ryanair to be on these? Yes, I am.
26:53You know, we have to be out there we whether it's on Facebook or Instagram or Snap Oh God help us. We're on TikTok. We have one of the biggest corporate accounts on TikTok, which I think personally is the greatest load of rubbish I've ever seen. I don't see much of it. talking airplanes. Jesus. Is this what the world is coming to?
27:13but if that's what where you can reach the younger generation, that's fine. But on all of these sites, we post on Ryanair. We post under our own name. If we say something wrong, we're responsible for it. What I think should be stopped and what governments should tackle both in European and US level is remove the anonymity. So, I have no difficulty with social media as long as everybody's posting under their own names, but I think it's fundamentally wrong that people are out there with all the various scandals, whether it's nudification or child pornography or suicidality suicide ideation, whatever that is. Do it under your own name and fine. Then at least you're
27:53maintaining and protecting freedom of speech, but stop this thing where keyboard warriors can use anonymity to you know, mail cut cut into death threats at politicians. Like nobody deserves that kind of stuff. female celebrities who are nudified on these things, they don't deserve that. And we need a bit more common sense to see when governments seem to be frozen.
28:16Now, I'm not surprised our government is frozen cuz Micheál Martin is useless anyway. You know, with a 20-seat majority, 15 months later he still hasn't scrapped a stupid cap that he's completely ignored already. And but you know, we need to be much tougher. And he's out there in Davos today passing around the Ferrero Rochers with representatives from X and all the other American social media companies. I mean he said, "Carry a big stick and do something." Europe should be doing something about removing anonymity from social media and trying to tidy that crap up. Michael, have you had Have you had any direct contact with Elon Musk since the start? And what do you think
28:52his motivation is? I have no direct contact with Elon Musk. I am not, as you will know, on X. I don't think I have any way of reaching him. I have no reason to be in contact with Elon Musk. What's his motivation? I presume like he rants and raves on X. I think it's good for him promoting X and his own views on X. And we're very happy to respond in kind on the Ryanair X platform. And if he wants to call me an idiot, you know, he wouldn't be the first and he certainly won't be the last to call me an idiot or a
29:26but if it helps to boost Ryanair sales, you can insult me all day, every day. And Eddie Wilson as well, who's, you know, readily insultable, too. Although somewhat younger and more attractive than me. Do you despair for humanity, Michael? No, I am optimistic for humanity, John. We are bringing low-fare air travel to many more millions of European citizens in the next eight years. If they had only carried 200 million passengers a year, we'd be carrying 300 million passengers a year. Which is one of the great successes of the single market and European Union. You know, Europe spends far too much time pulling wool out of its own navel instead of, you know,
30:02crowing about its successes. And with the single market in Europe and the deregulation of airline has been one of the stellar success stories of European of the of the European Union. In America today, you know, the cheapest air fares are north of $100. We originally started by copying the formula Southwest Airlines who had $10 air fares. Last year their average air fare was about $130. Last year Ryanair's average air fare was €45. We wiped the floor with American in terms of competitiveness with American air travel. Now, America has a lead in AI, America has a lead in IT, but when it comes to air travel, Europe wipes the floor. All but we get
30:41that doesn't mean that Ursula von der Leyen, you know, shouldn't be doing something on reforming ATC, you know, a level playing field and environmental taxation. As the Draghi report highlighted, there is much to be done. But she's not much use either. So, we will continue to campaign for further reform. But no, I I look forward with nothing but enthusiasm for humanity and the human race if we could just move the kids a little bit more off social media. But they they will adapt to that. I remember when I was young here in the late '60s or early '70s and we used to watch I think about 3 hours of television the evening. RT would come on about 6:00, one station black and white,
31:22and we'd watch Wanderly Wagon and a few other programs that the kids my parents grandparents thought, "Your fried heads will be fried. Oh, you're watching too much television." You know. Now you're 24-hour television and the kids are on wall-to-wall social media. Do you think we should follow Australia's recent trying ban on social media? I think anybody trying to ban social media to under 16s is wasting your time. You may as well be I can't remember what it was King Canute trying to stop the tide coming in. You know, 16-year-old kids, 14-year-old kids will will wind their way around a ban faster than Ryanair seats are selling out today on today's seat sale.
31:57You know, the politicians in their 40s and 50s imposing bans on under 16-year-olds will be in relation to phone access and social media will be hopelessly ineffective. I do believe however that one of the ways rather than trying to ban something if you really want to ban something, ban anonymity on social media. Force people and all of the internet companies know who's posting, but they should be posting under whatever it is their their own name or their own account names and it would clean up a lot of the crap on social media.
32:30It's Yes, Conor. Sorry, I'll come back to you. Conor. Is the is Dragon Starlink worse than the others or better or do you have any sense of that? And and then just what's your general thought on Wi-Fi on low-cost carriers? Is it Is it being Has anybody cracked it? Do you think somebody will eventually or probably not? I look, technology will ultimately crack this thing. I'm sure we'll get to a 6G and an 8G and a 10G eventually and I, you know, I have no doubt that instead of putting aerials on the ex- on the external of the fuselage, we'll be able to fit an an aerial in the internal of the I don't know the in the front or the rear galley or something or the baggage hold. Like
33:09it will technology will have ultimately get there. We live in a hyper-connected world and people will ultimately have free access to Wi-Fi on board short-haul aircraft. So, I've no doubt the technology will get there, which is why we continue to be in dialogue with Amazon, with Starlink, with Vodafone on this.
33:28It will come. But we cannot see a way at the moment where the model anybody will pay for in fact I mean even if you look at the long-haul airlines, you have the Lufthansas and the Linguses, big song and dance, but you know, it's free Wi-Fi access now. I've traveled on Aer Lingus across the Atlantic and the Wi-Fi access isn't great at the moment anyway. So, even if it was free, I'm not sure it would be dramatically improved. But it's coming and the technology will keep improving. So, so you're waiting until it doesn't need an external aerial?
33:57We're waiting until one we can get it sponsored or guaranteed that it doesn't have a that it becomes some sort of, you know, that it doesn't have a cost penalty for us and two we can that we can we and together our partners can give it away for free and then I think people will genuinely use it. I mean, you know, you use lots of places where you go to hotels or you're going through places where you know, you can have free Wi-Fi access, but they want your email address. You do Maybe you do something like that and that gets more people on board with their internet address and there's lots of ways, but I I think ultimately the technology and the
34:30commercial agreements will will result in free Wi-Fi on board short-haul aircraft as well. Simon, you're very welcome to Dublin. [clears throat] Good morning.
34:40you flew Ryanair. I I did fly with Excellent. That's why I I did call past the No, that was a [laughter]
34:50Cancel his return FLIGHT, WILL YOU? DO YOU THINK inadvertently that Ryanair might be fueling smartphone addiction because it's now 3 months since you [clears throat] said you've got to check in with your smartphone? And how's that going? No, I mean already before we started that in November, we had about 80% of passengers checking on smartphones. That number is now up to about 98, 99%.
35:15And I hasten to add the other 1.5% are getting their paper We're printing the paper boarding pass for them free of charge at the airport as long as they've checked in online. But no, are we fueling smartphone addictions? I don't think so. Ours are transactional. If people are traveling with us, it's all done online
35:36and we we think that is the way of the future. But thank you for flying all the way to Dublin to ask that entirely that stupidly really intelligent question. And make it bigger than the morning. I sent a compliment any chance to win any prizes in the raffle? To what? Purchase a Tesla?
35:52For you to purchase a Tesla?
35:53No, absolutely not. I live in Mullingar, you know, 50 miles from Dublin and my favorite mode of transport is a Landini tractor. So, they don't have We're not at the electrification stage yet. Eddie I think is the proud owner of a Tesla. No, not a Tesla.
36:12Oh, yeah. What is it? No, not an Audi. Oh, yeah. [laughter]
36:16There's no support for Elon Musk and his social media website or his electric electric cars here. Michael, what was your next meeting with X? What? Your next meeting with X. I've never had a meeting with I don't think we've ever had a meeting with X. We we have meetings with Starlink on the on fitting the aircraft on fitting the aircraft with Wi-Fi. But we've no reason to meet with X. I mean we Someone said Ryanair does have an X account. But no, I think we are sending now around to the X Dublin offices this morning a free ticket for Elon Musk as part of our big idiot seat sale. And I would hope that we've I've included myself and him in this big idiot seat
36:55sale. I suspect he's a bigger idiot than me, but nevertheless, he probably thinks I'm a bigger idiot than him. So, were you going to the X offices today? No, I've got an airline to run. We'll We're hand hand delivering the free ticket around there. It'll be I'm sure there'll be something posted on our social media accounts later on today.
37:13And Michael, Yes, sir. What do you make of the handling of the Kenny Jacobs situation? Of the who? Kenny Jacobs. I don't know the detail of it and I'm not in a position to comment really. All I would say is, you know, it seems clear that Kenny's error appears to be that he's upset some people in Fingal County Council and some bureaucrats in the Department of Transport.
37:37And I think every one of us on a daily basis should get up and say that the first thing we will do today is to upset county people working for county councils and certainly useless bureaucrats in the Department of Transport. I imagine that the, you know, if he is replaced, the job description for the next leader of Dublin Airport will be please don't upset Fingal County Council or they might write to the Department of Transport and complain about you.
38:00I mean we have much bigger issues to fry. I don't think he's done a particularly good job at Dublin Airport. You know, he championed this ludicrous tunnel 220 million, a tunnel under the the taxiway out to nowhere. It's a tunnel to take people out to where the cargo aircraft are. Now, the parcels don't need tunnels. You know, they can drive around the outside of the aircraft.
38:22But it is more of the kind of gold-plating they want to waste this kind of money so that the regulation will give them more further increases in fees. And we live on an island at the periphery of Europe. It is vital that Ireland continues to be provide efficient facilities and low low fare access on and off this island. Now that we finally got rid of the green lunatics.
38:44You know, the idea that we're all going to be cycling to Brussels or, you know, like some of the famous green MEPs getting trains to the UK and boats to the We don't have time to have green MEPs may have 3 days to waste getting to Brussels, but the rest of the world doesn't. So, I think the situation is not is I I I regret the situation he personally finds himself in. I think it's a bit of a mess, but it seems to be a mess that is caused by criticizing those in Fingal County Council who are presiding over this stupid and illegal cap. And I think the much greater danger for Ireland is that, you know, if Aer Lingus Aer Lingus flights could well be blocked from
39:25landing in New York. I mean Micheál Martin might well be blocked from going to the White House in March and then you'll see this legislation passed within 24 hours. But for 13 months Micheál Martin and it's in the program for government, we will "We will scrap this cap {quote} as soon as possible." 13 months ago.
39:42You know, with a 20-seat majority. And it's not like they've done been busy passing other legislation last year. This government does very little. But it's led by somebody who spends far too much time being wheeled around abroad meeting global leaders instead of which would be fine as long as you were having a cabinet meeting here at 8:30 on a Monday morning and getting stuff done.
40:04He wanders in at about 11:00 on a Tuesday and then disappears to Davos for a couple of days. Michael, if Ireland qualify for the World Cup next year, will Ryanair consider putting on long-haul flights around the States and Mexico? There are very few things on which I could be truly certain about, but one, we won't be putting on flights to the US and two, I'm fairly sure Ireland won't qualify for the World Cup anyway.
40:28Which is why I urge everybody keep booking every should booking your short-haul holidays to Europe in June and July because don't worry, Ireland won't be in the World Cup. Hey Michael, do you think there'll be a trade war between the US and the EU and the world and if so, how do you think that will affect prices and consumers and so on? I mean, honestly, none of us know.
40:47But I think it is time for Europe to stand up to the US. I think, you know, if Trump threatens Europe with tariffs, Europe should respond to in like measure. And Trump will chicken out. Tackle. He generally does. You know, Europe is a big, wealthy economy with the second largest trading block in the world after the US economy and we need Europe needs to get its act together.
41:08How do I think it would affect our business? Who knows? And I certainly don't know. But I don't think a trade war would last very long given the amount of American business that are based here in Europe. Given the amount that Europe imports from America and vice versa. But you know, we have to have a more belligerent foreign policy towards certainly the Trump administration.
41:32And we would hope that eventually common sense will prevail. I mean, I think if you look at Trump, he is at the end of the day is interested in doing business. He certainly has midterm elections coming in November. He certainly wants the US economy to be doing well and I don't think Trump eight months out from midterm elections can afford to have a a trade war with Europe.
41:55But you know, it is absolutely imperative. I mean, you know, we have all grown up in the 80 years post the Second World War where thanks to NATO and certainly thanks to free trade, the world is a much wealthier place. And you know, we should continue that. But and you know, as a big importer of American aircraft, we are the largest investor in American aircraft outside of North America. We have owned a fleet of 630 Boeing aircraft. We've ordered another 300.
42:25They make great aircraft. I am a huge supporter of America. It has done wonders for free trade. It has done wonders for the promotion of democracy. And these things will pass. But you know, Europe does need to get its act together and if Trump wants to have a a row with Europe, well, let's have a row right back. So you're confident Boeing would eat the tariffs? Pardon me?
42:51confident that Boeing would eat any tariffs? I am not. But again, none of us know. But certainly during the last I mean, generally speaking, aviation, aircraft and engines have been excluded from most previous tariff instruments. The Europeans are big importers of Boeing aircraft. The American Airlines particularly on the long-haul side are big importers of Airbus aircraft. So, you know, if you look at the number of jobs in America, Boeing, GE, the engine side, huge amount numbers of American jobs depend on aviation exports.
43:29Aircraft and engine exports are one of the biggest export manufacturing exports in the US and similarly here in Europe into the US as well. So, I would hope from a selfish point of view that if there is A, that there won't be a tariff trade war. But if there is a trade war, that A aircraft and engines will be exempt. But we take delivery of our last four aircraft from Boeing in February.
43:51Then we don't have another aircraft delivery until the spring of 2027 when hopefully we get the first of the great new Max 10 aircraft. Is there anything in that contract for the Max 10s that allows you to alter the contract in any way if something like tariffs have been imposed? We would never comment comment on the contents of those contracts.
44:12They're entirely confidential. Next question? Barry? Michael, where do you see fares going this summer? We At the moment, we believe fares are likely to rise three or four percentage, you know, some small single digit. But that's our, you know, normal thing. They may level out or fall if fuel prices keep falling. Again, I think one of the things that I think Trump is focused on in advance of the midterm in November will be driving down oil prices and driving down interest rates in North America.
44:46Though she had the row with the the Federal Reserve and certainly every attempt there with the removal of the Venezuelan president to boost oil supply and maybe drive down gas prices. But you know, that's me merely speculating. If oil prices fall or continue to fall and there is generally an expectation that of a supply glut this year, then I think a lot of those oil price savings will be passed on in the form of lower fares. But it's hard to tell. The overriding kind of dynamic in Europe at the moment is constrained supply of aircraft, constrained seat supply. Even we this year can only grow and we're taking 29 aircraft from Boeing this year. We're
45:29only going to grow our seat supply by about 3%. So, it is very tight. You have most of Europe's Airbus are still going through the Pratt Whitney engine repairs. So, there's very little capacity out there, which is why again we urge the Irish government, you know, when drag Michael Martin back from Davos today kicking and screaming and telling them to pass the legislation so that with that spare capacity, we can actually put some growth into continue to grow here in Ireland [clears throat]
45:56and continue to grow in Europe. You've been talking about these capacity limits and they're the fact that we're pushing fares for about a half a decade. When do I don't know. Two about two years. Jesus, Barry. We've had COVID and a war in Ukraine and a buy the tickets. Yeah. Book earlier. There's available at 16.99 as we speak today. But clearly, you're not an idiot.
46:19No. You wouldn't qualify for this seat sale. Okay. When do you see the the capacity constraints easing? I mean, there is all of the indicators at the moment is there will be no easing in capacity or kind of upturn in capacity above kind of GDP growth before 2030. Both Boeing and Airbus are hugely backlogged on deliveries.
46:40The you know, and Boeing still has to get the Max 7 and the Max 10 certified. They're pretty confident they'll get it certified later this year. But and even if they do start those deliveries with the exception of Ryanair, no other European airline has any significant aircraft orders between now and 2030. Wizz Air had, but they've delayed most of delayed and deferred most of them.
47:02Probably because they can't afford to buy them or they don't know where to fly them. but there's very little capacity and if there's a backlog of orders at the moment coming through the Middle East, Riyadh Air wants to buy 100, 200 short-haul aircraft, but can't get any before 2030. The Turks want to buy another 500 aircraft. The Indians want more aircraft. So, all of the demand and the Chinese haven't ordered a Boeing aircraft for about seven years.
47:23So, there's a huge backlog of demand. Now, there could be some geopolitical disruption over Greenland, Ukraine, Taiwan, God knows what's going on in the world and the world feels a very uncertain place. So, that might you know, historically when the airlines are doing well, usually something comes out of left field whether it's 9/11 or a Gulf War that sets back
47:51we expect to grow our traffic from 207 million this last year to about 215 million in the next 12 months and we think there might be a modest two, three, four percent increase in airfares. But we haven't a clue yet. I think it's important, Barry, like you see where that capacity is going. Like yesterday we're in Italy, they're growing by 9%.
48:12We're in Michael got to got to go down to Albania yesterday, they're growing by almost 60% this year with Ryanair aircraft and 9% in Italy, 11% in Morocco and 3% in Spain and we're going nowhere in Ireland because there's no decision on that cap, you know? And and when you have no capacity growth, you're going to have fares rising, you know? I mean, I was down in Tirana in September announcing the the the new We're opening a base, three aircraft base in Tirana in March. In September, the problem in Tirana was they have an eight They have a one terminal building which serves only eight aircraft. Said it's too small. And Wizz Air have eight aircraft base in Tirana. Says, you need
48:48to double the size of the terminal building. He said, don't worry, we'll do We're going to start in September and we'll finish in March. No, you won't. It could take two years, sir. If you Michael Martin could take three or four years. They started in September. They've already finished the building. I was down there yesterday again announcing a fourth base aircraft. The building is built. They're just doing the internal fit out. And that could be done in five months in Albania.
49:12Which contrasts with Michael Martin doing nothing, just a scrap of bloody cap in in 13 months. Like some governments get it and get on with it. And some governments, sadly led by Michael Martin, do nothing Martin, don't get it and do nothing. Simon? yes. Now, just going back to Elon Musk, you've given him a free Ryanair ticket.
49:32Yes. So, he'll be very grateful. You going to give him any advice on which airline he should buy? I know it's would be inappropriate for us to give him any investment advice. I think he's running polls on X though where he's getting lots of advice from lots of idiots on X. As I said publicly, we welcome everybody investing anybody who wants to buy shares in Ryanair is free to do so.
49:55We're a publicly traded company listed on the European and the US stock exchanges but a non-European that we would politely and respectfully point out that a non-European cannot acquire or control a European airline. Any as I understand John you've spoken to Comac before. And given the geopolitical environment and whether that persists for however long that persists, does it get you to thinking at all strategically about, you know, where you need to position yourself in terms of future aircraft orders and possibly reducing your reliance on Boeing if the environment we're in continues we end up having, you know, longer-term tariffs or whatever. Would
50:38you align yourself more closely maybe with Comac and see what they're doing? Would you be interested in placing an order with them? I mean, look, we we have previously talked to Comac. We we signed a design agreement with Comac back around 2014-2015. The problem and the challenge for Comac is they're producing very few aircraft.
50:55Like Boeing is now talk Boeing are rumored yesterday to be in launching a production line for 737s up in Everett. They've only ever made them in Renton. And that would increase Boeing's monthly production from about 43 aircraft to about 65 aircraft. So, Comac last year I think built about 60 aircraft in the whole year.
51:13And the problem is the bigger the more Comac grows and Comac is doing the Chinese version. They're basically sub-assembling an A320. All of the avionics, all of the engines, all of the real complicated parts are all European. So, it's GE engines or Safran engines. It is Honeywell avionics. It's Collins. It's So, the the faster or the more Comac grows its production capacity, the more they draw from the already constrained supply chains for Airbus aircraft here in the US and in America in US and Europe.
51:47So, Comac is not going to come to anybody's rescue before certainly the early or mid-2030s. And the aircraft they're making at the moment is only 180 seats, so it's too small for us. I have no You know, we're placing aircraft orders here. We ordered 300 Boeing Max 10 aircraft back during COVID.
52:05Those deliveries are due to come to us from 2027 to 2034. So, we are the best-positioned airline in the world for controlled capacity growth and growth of low-fare air traffic for the next decade. Now, there is still an issue with Boeing still needs to get the those aircraft certified and delivered, but they're pretty confident and I think under the new management certainly led by Stephanie Pope and Kelly Ortberg, I think Boeing are doing very impressive things in turning the business [snorts] around. But even if I didn't want to order Boeing.
52:36If I went to Airbus today and said, I you know, I I your aircraft are more expensive but I want to order 100 which I would like to do for the air for the louder motion fleet. We have 30 A320s in louder motion but they're coming up to the end of their lease in '28-'29. Airbus cannot deliver me a narrow-body aircraft or an A320 or 321 until about 2032 or 2033.
52:57So, there's no aircraft available. So, thinking strategically, we're in a very fortunate position to be able to have controlled growth out to 2034. We would certainly need to another aircraft order in the early 2030s. But the chances of there not being some unforeseen downturn in aviation or some unforeseen downturn in the world between now and 2030 the early 2030s are I think zero. Because there's always some catastrophe visited on the air airline industry every three, four, or five years. the last one was COVID. We emerged out of COVID and then Putin illegally invaded Ukraine. Something that, you know, I disagree fundamentally with Trump on. you know,
53:41I think Trump is right on NATO needing to increase spending. Trump is right on rowing back against environmental taxation. Trump is right on an awful lot of his economic policies. But he is historically wrong on Ukraine and not criticizing Russia. And he is historically wrong on tariffs. Tariffs have never succeeded. They have never worked. And they will never succeed or work because they increase inflation and the cost of living for ordinary people.
54:10But so, thinking strategically, we're about as well-placed as any airline can be. And I would certainly hope that we will have be able to pick from maybe three suppliers in the early 2030s, Boeing, Airbus, or Comac. But we have to wait and see what happens between 2026 and 2030 first.
54:30Anybody else? Michael, is Trump right or wrong on Greenland? I think Trump is wrong on Greenland. I mean, I think you know, the US has persuasive and real kind of defense concerns on Greenland. But if you have I think do and they already reached agreement with Denmark and with with Greenland after the Second World War. I think they had 12 or 15 military bases up in our air bases in Greenland. If you want to reopen those bases, I think they would get nothing but support from NATO and from Denmark.
55:00But you can't in this world just go in and say, I want Greenland. Give it to me. I mean, what would you then say to the Chinese if the Chinese want to go and invade Taiwan? What do you say? I mean, well, I think he's already historically wrong on Putin just pushes into invades Ukraine in what is clearly an illegal invasion. I think he is, you know, historically wrong on that as well.
55:22but look, people also need to stand back. You know, history has shown us you have American administrations. This administration will last for another three years. There will be a midterm elections in the states at the end of this year. I have no idea what the outcome of those midterm elections. But if he loses the house or loses the Senate, there will be a dramatic change in US politics. And there will be another presidential election in three years time. So, there will be another US president. And I think Trump has gets lots of things right and he gets a number of things wrong.
55:56But that's democracy and he was elected. And we certainly in Europe have to manage that relationship for the next two or three years. But where he's wrong, Europe should stand up as a strong trading block and tell him he's wrong. And stop trying to pander to him and invite him to dinner when, you know, he wants to I don't understand why he needs to own Greenland. It's certainly not a a for some defense or military reasons because as a member of NATO and Denmark is a member of NATO, I don't think Denmark or Greenland would have any issue if Trump wanted to invest, reopen those bases in Greenland, and invest in Greenland. But you don't need to own it for that.
56:34There's been a long-term investment in Ireland from the military. Do you think there should be significantly more spent on Ireland's military? Should Ireland consider rethinking its neutrality given what's going on in the I think Ireland has no option but to go, you know, I mean, Irish neutrality is a joke.
56:50much beloved of the left-wing lunatics in this country. You know, we are a defenseless island on the periphery of Europe. we don't have are not able to protect either our skies or the seas off our coast. and I think Europe will be running out of patience with Ireland on this. I believe Ireland should be a member of NATO. I think Dev was historically wrong in the 1950s, you know, when the we should have joined NATO in 1945 and the late 1940s. We
57:23would have developed deep-sea submarine ports off the west coast of Ireland. NATO would have built about 25 airports across Ireland. And we would have far better infrastructure than we've managed on our own. But Dev made the chronic mistake to be I want to be isolationist. Isolationism has never worked. It hadn't didn't work in Ireland in the '50s and '60s. Didn't work in North Korea.
57:48it didn't work in China during in the '70s, '80s, and '90s either. We live in a world where free trade works. Free trade reduces costs for consumers and increases the wealth of nations and has done so since Adam Smith wrote his treaties in the 1850s. and Ireland needs to wise up. We need to generate much more revenue and we do need to increase significantly increase our defense spending. And I would personally, you know, think Ireland should be a member of NATO. I don't know how you can be a member of the European Union and not be a member of NATO because either we're going to support Europe when it's under threat as it is currently in Ukraine. If Putin decides he's going
58:38to invade the Baltic states or Finland or Poland, what are we going to do? Oh, sorry, we're we're neutral. We have to come to the aid and support of our European allies as we should come to the aid and support of our American allies. I have no difficulty with you know, the left-wing loonies winging about, you know, the us using Shannon Airport. Shannon Airport benefits significantly from US military the US military using Shannon as a stopover point for it's troops, etc. And we should encourage that.
59:14And anything that annoys the loony left in this country should be actively encouraged. Any other questions? Are your negotiations for your contract with Boeing moving along? Are they nearly finalized? They are moving along at a glacial pace. We have far more impressive things to deal with. I'm already contracted up to 2028 and there's really not much pressure on me or the board to finalize any new arrangements. Like, we are dealing with things like the price of oil, Boeing delivery delays, why can't we get Micheál Martin and it with a 20-seat majority to scrap a capital Dublin Airport when the Ambelians can be can build can double the size of their terminal in 5 months.
59:56Really, my contract falls way down the list of issues that need to be addressed. Okay. Folks, thank you very much. Appreciate your time and We are ready and myself are available for one-on-ones and or anything else. Eamon's going to line up one-on-ones. Thanks very much. Yes. I know we've done all of the photo ops.
1:00:20Do you want to do it here? How you doing? Great to see you. Good to see you and Come out a little bit from the screen. It's all right. We're good. That's it. Yes. Okay. All right. Thank you. I know. Come over like that here in here. Just take one step back here. No, I'm good. I'm good.
1:00:42All right. Sorry, thanks. Or two. Thank you. Perfect. Thank you. Come over here. Thank you. Thank you.
1:01:30How many have you got? I'm ready. No, we're not. All right. Sorry, guys. Thank you. Thank you. My very first honor. I have something to Where are you going to do it? With my dear here. You're going to do it here, Mike. You just bring that Yeah, bring that in front. Where's the light best here?
1:01:48Light light light here, Mike. It's okay. Yeah. Just bring it out in front of the table here. Hang on. Do you want to do it here in the front? Yeah, forget it. It's good. See if that helps. How's that? Yeah. Just like that. Hold me. I'll see you later. Have her right here at an angle or do you want to Return it?
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版