2018 年,特斯拉股东以约 73% 的赞成票,通过了一份给马斯克的薪酬方案。2024 年 1 月,特拉华州衡平法院首席法官麦考密克(Kathaleen McCormick)用一份判决书把它撤销了。
提起诉讼的原告是一位持股极少的个人投资者。几百万股东投了赞成票,一个人把它推翻了。
彭博科技这场访谈里,主持人把很多特斯拉股东的情绪直接摆到桌面上:股价涨了,产能铺开了,公司从濒临破产变成全球市值最高的车企之一。这份合同兑现了当年的承诺,凭什么说它无效?
坐在对面的律师格雷格(Greg)代表原告一方。他没有绕弯子。
这份方案确实交给了股东投票。但法院认定,随投票一起发出的代理声明有几处重大误导。(格雷格)
这句话决定了整个案子的走向。股东投票有效的前提,是公司交给他们的信息是真的。
被推翻的是程序,高薪本身并不在推翻之列
很多人把这件事理解成“法官嫌马斯克拿得太多”。这个理解错位很大。
特拉华州这套公司法逻辑里,董事会有权决定 CEO 拿多少,哪怕数字大得吓人。法院一般不替董事会判断薪酬是否“合理”,那是商业判断,法官不擅长也不该插手。
但董事会做这个决定时,必须满足两个前提。第一,做决定的人得真正独立于被奖励的那个人。第二,向股东征求意见时,必须把重大事实说清楚。
格雷格在访谈里反复回到第二点。有效资本市场理论有个基本假设:股东会根据公司披露的信息做判断。如果披露的信息有重大遗漏或误导,投票这个动作就失去了意义,哪怕 100% 赞成也一样。
用买房的场景来理解比较直接。你看了一份房屋检查报告,签字买了房。后来发现报告里漏写了地基开裂,那份报告是卖方找人写的,写报告的人还和卖方是牌友。你签的字仍然算数吗?法院的答案是不算。
格雷格的说法更朴素:
如果你在请股东采取行动的时候不告诉他们重大事实,资本市场就没法运转。这件事发生的正是这种情况。(格雷格)
560 亿美元这个数字,把整个行业的数据集都带偏了
格雷格团队是专门盯高管薪酬的。他讲了一个细节:他经常口误,把 560 亿说成 5600 万。这个量级的数字,人脑处理起来会打滑。
他说得更狠的一句是,这份薪酬包大到把整个薪酬咨询行业的数据集都向上拉歪了。做行业基准对比的时候,这个样本一进去,均值和中位数全变样。
他们之所以盯上这个案子,原因很单纯:从来没有人试过这么接近这个数字。而当你去找“最接近的可比对象”时,找到的是马斯克上一份薪酬包。这个案子里根本没有正常参照物,只有马斯克自己跟自己比。
主持人立刻抛出反方最强的论据:2018 年投票时,73% 的股东投了赞成;此后特斯拉的股价表现、市场地位、全球扩张都摆在那里。有一大批股东现在很生格雷格和他客户的气,认为这场诉讼是在跟公司价值过不去。
格雷格没有否认股价。他也没有否认马斯克干成了事。他把问题拉回到投票那一刻:股东当时看到的那份材料,是否如实描述了薪酬是怎么定出来的、定的人是谁、他们和 CEO 是什么关系。
董事会是橡皮图章,这件事股东其实早就知道
访谈里主持人麦克斯(Max)说了一句很实在的话:很多特斯拉股东心里清楚,这个董事会基本就是个橡皮图章。一堆人和马斯克是密友,有人跟他一起度假。名义上独立,实际上很难说独立。
这恰恰是马斯克输掉案子的重要原因之一。
特拉华州检验“独立董事”的办法不看名片上印什么头衔,看实际关系。一起度假、长期生意往来、家族交情,都会被当成独立性不足的证据。董事会里坐着几个和 CEO 私交深厚的人,谈出来的薪酬方案,法官很难相信那是一场真正的谈判。
麦克斯补了一句观察:这就是马斯克做生意的方式。你要是问他,凭什么能做成这么多事,他的回答大致是,因为我想做什么就能做什么。这套打法用来造火箭、建工厂极其有效,放进公司治理的框架里就会撞墙。
更麻烦的地方在于,判决出来之后,马斯克公开要的是更大的持股比例和投票权。他此前已经表达过,如果不能拿到,他宁愿在特斯拉之外推进 AI 业务。这句威胁在访谈里被提到两次。
法官最有力的那一问:一个期权都不给,他能赚多少
整场访谈里,法官关于动机的那段推理最值得细看。
法院认定,没有任何证据表明,必须给出这 560 亿美元,马斯克才会继续拼命干。法官算了一笔账:马斯克本来就持有大量特斯拉股票。这份薪酬方案里每设置一档业绩目标,对应的市值增量,都会让他已持有股份的净值增加约 10 亿美元。
即使一个期权都不发给他,只要他把公司做到那些目标,他的身家照样会涨将近 1000 亿美元。
格雷格把这层意思讲得很清楚:
法官的观点是,你看看其他成功的创始人,贝索斯、扎克伯格,他们不拿薪酬包,或者不拿任何实质性的薪酬包。他们靠的是推动股东价值、靠自己手里的基础股票。而马斯克先生本来就有机会让净资产增加接近一千亿美元,一个期权都不用拿。(格雷格)
这个论证的杀伤力在于它绕开了“值不值”的争论。它说的是:你不需要额外激励,你的利益和股东已经完全绑定。再叠一份巨额期权,属于重复计价。
主持人追问了一句“我确认一下单位,是千亿不是十亿”,格雷格确认了。
访谈里还有一句常被忽略但很要紧的定性:
说到底,这是一家汽车公司,不是太空探索公司。它是一家上市公司,上市公司按另一套规则运行。(格雷格)
这句话解释了马斯克和特拉华州之间长期的摩擦。私人公司里,创始人可以按自己的意志分配股权和资源。上市公司里,每一份股权激励都要经过董事会谈判、薪酬顾问评估、股东投票、信息披露这一整套流程。流程看着慢,看着烦,但它是外部股东愿意出钱的前提。
上诉几乎是确定动作,另一条路是重新做一份方案
访谈开头,主持人问会不会上诉。格雷格的回答是,如果看不到上诉他才会觉得奇怪。
特拉华州的程序有个特点:衡平法院的判决可以直接上诉到特拉华州最高法院,最高法院的裁决是终局。这件事的最终答案,可能要等上一段时间。
另一条并行路径更值得关注。现在坐在特斯拉董事会里的人,和 2018 年那批已经不是同一批。这个新董事会完全可以重新设计一份薪酬方案,再交给股东批准。
主持人问格雷格,这个过程里他和他的客户会参与到什么程度。格雷格的回答很克制:
简单说,这首先是董事会要决定的事。假设董事会履行了信义义务,用普通、合理的方式得出了一个结果,我的猜测是我完全不会参与,法官也完全不会参与。但如果董事会拿出来的方案,表面上就离谱、就夸张,或者从信义义务的角度让人产生疑虑,那我估计我和我的律所还会出现。(格雷格)
这段话给所有上市公司划了一条很实用的线。法院审查的重点落在定这个数字的过程上,薪酬总额的高低不在其列。过程干净,数字大一点也没关系;过程有瑕疵,数字本身多合理都救不回来。
主持人还追问了一个有意思的假设:董事会能不能拿出另一份 560 亿美元的方案,换个包装,数字照旧?格雷格的回答指向同一套标准。法院关心方案怎么来的。方案长什么样是次要的。
搬到内华达?马斯克一个人说了不算
判决出来之后,马斯克在 X 上表态,要把公司注册地迁出特拉华。此前 X 本身已经从特拉华迁到了内华达。
很多人以为这是 CEO 一句话的事。格雷格把流程讲得很直白:
简单说,马斯克自己什么都做不了。这是董事会首先要决定的事,然后提交股东投票。如果股东根据董事会的建议决定搬到内华达,他们有权这么做。但这不是马斯克能决定的。(格雷格)
他补了一句提醒:他不敢说精通全部 50 个州的州法,但他猜内华达同样禁止发布误导性的代理声明。如果马斯克搬过去,还想做同样的操作,大概率会撞上同一堵墙。
他说这话的时候带了一点调侃:这里有个小小的概念叫说实话,真的很基础。
这段话背后的信息对创业者有用。公司注册地确实可以换,特拉华也不是唯一选择,内华达、得州这几年都在主动争取企业。换州能改变适用的法律框架和判例体系。“向股东如实披露”这条底线换不掉。迁址本身还要走董事会决议加股东投票,如果有人主张迁址是为了削弱股东权利,那又会是一场新的诉讼。
特拉华法的底层设计:每个决策测两次
访谈最后,有观众提问:把特拉华州公司法从“不干预”的传统上挪开,你担心吗?
格雷格的回答是完全不担心,并且给出了这套体系的核心设计:
特拉华法里深深嵌入了一点,每一个决策都要被检验两次,一次从法律的角度,一次从衡平的角度。当受托人行事不公平,或者违反了他们的义务,你去追究他们,这恰恰落在特拉华法长期传统的正中间。(格雷格)
“法律”和“衡平”这两条线,是理解这个案子的最后一把钥匙。
法律线看程序是否合规:有没有开会,有没有披露,有没有按章程走。衡平线看实质是否公平:交易条件是否公道,决策者是否独立,有没有人从中不当得利。
很多公司能过第一条线,栽在第二条线上。特斯拉这份方案的代理声明在形式上齐全,投票也开了,股东也批了。但法院从衡平的角度看,发现定方案的人不够独立,披露的文件有重大误导,两条都不过关。
这也解释了为什么这个判决在美国公司法圈子里震动这么大。它没有创造新规则,它把一条存在了几十年的老规则,用在一个所有人都以为可以例外的人身上。
这件事真正的看点
很多人从这场判决里读出的结论是“马斯克被针对了”。读完整场访谈,会得到另一个结论:这场判决的检验对象是流程。个人不在检验对象之列。
同样的逻辑,过去几年在不少案子里出现过。创始人光环越强,董事会越容易变成应声虫,披露文件越容易写得含糊。等到出问题,法院翻的内容是当年的会议记录和披露文件,业绩数字派不上用场。
普通投资者可以从这个案子里拿到一个很具体的观察角度。看一家公司的创始人薪酬方案,先别看总额,去看薪酬委员会的成员是谁、薪酬顾问是谁请的、代理声明里的“薪酬讨论与分析”写了什么、业绩目标是怎么设的、可比公司组里放了哪些公司。这些细节决定了那份方案是否真的经过了谈判。
创业者该拿到的提醒更直接。董事会里坐几个好朋友,短期很舒服,长期是风险。真到了需要法院认可你决策独立性的时候,那些假期合影会变成呈堂证供。
接下来的看点是两个。上诉到特拉华州最高法院的结果,以及新董事会会不会拿出一份结构不同、逻辑更干净的新方案。后者比前者更能说明特斯拉打算怎么处理创始人和公众股东之间的关系。
- 如果你持有特斯拉股票,把上诉进展和新薪酬方案的披露文件列进观察清单,重点关注新方案的董事会谈判过程和薪酬委员会构成,期权的总金额可以往后放。
- 如果你投资任何一家创始人主导的上市公司,去读最近一份代理声明里的“薪酬讨论与分析”部分,检查薪酬顾问由谁聘请、是否同时为公司提供其他服务。
- 如果你是创业者或准备做股权激励,把董事会独立性当成融资前要解决的结构问题,别拖到上市前才补手续。关联董事的比例、私交关系的披露,都会在关键时刻被重新翻出来审视。
- 如果你在准备股东投票,记住投赞成票并不等于放弃追责权。信息如果存在重大误导,投票结果本身可以被推翻。
- 如果你关注公司迁注册地的动议,先看董事会给出的理由和独立财务顾问意见,再看有没有条款在实质上削弱小股东权利。迁址本身合法,动机和配套条款才是重点。
0:00will you expect an appeals now do you think that the board will go back and just try to restructure some sort of payment for Alon wouldn't surprise me at all if we saw an appeal under Delaware practice there is a direct appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court which is the final word on matters like this so it's likely there'll be an appeal and Max from Elon Inc your expertise of all things I mean he has been avidly against Delaware more broadly clearly there has been concerns about from Elon himself a lack of control of his own company now what do you think happens after this payack I mean this is a huge development not just because of the amount of money that is
0:36at stake in these options of value the options I've seen you know figures as high as 50 billion reported of course he hasn't exercised them yet but also because this kind of throws not just Tesla into chaos they have to figure out a way to try to retain Elon Musk he's already been sort of making these kind of veiled threats that he might be doing AI research outside of the company if he doesn't get a bigger pay package and then at the same time you have all his other companies which of course depend on his financing and we remember one of the kind of one of the reasons he wanted all this money supposedly was to pay for his you know Mars exploration so
1:10you have to ask where every where all of this goes last thing I'll say is this is another big loss on Del remember Delaware forced him to buy Twitter for $44 billion so now even for the world's richest man 44 billion 50 billion that's starting to add up Greg good morning it's Ed in in San Francisco as far as I can tell you and your clients are the only ones to actually ever take a look at the compensation package so as a starting point Greg what was it in the first place that that worried you or or that you thought was unusual about the package that caused you and your clients to look you know I I I have to say that I have a hard time articulating 55
1:54billion dollar I often misspeak and say $ 55 million $55 billion is such a large pay package that it basically skewed dramatically upward the entire data set for the compensation Consulting industry I think we put out a press release yesterday referring to it as a gargantuan package let me start by saying it was so large that we looked at it specifically because no one had ever tried to come this close and oh by the way when you look at the nearest comparable it's elon's prior pay package
2:32okay but Greg here's the thing it may be the biggest compensation package in history but there are a really large body of of Tesla investors out there that say so what 73% of those investors voted in favor of the package in 2018 when it was awarded and there is a big body of people out there Greg I hope you don't mind me saying that are pretty mad at you and your client who are Tesla shareholders because they say look at the share performance of Tesla since that package was awarded look at Tesla's position as the market incumbent in EVs and their growth globally in other products why does it matter well you know there's this idea in efficient Capital markets that
3:17shareholders ought to have a say in things like this and this package was in fact put to shareholders but it was put to shareholders on appr proxy that the court found to be materially misleading in several respects and look the bottom line is capital markets don't work if you don't tell stockholders material facts when asking them to take action and that's exactly what happened here Max this puts into question the board in particular the accusations from many an investor is there is no push back the judge articulated there was at no point any sort of questioning that this pay package was ever perhaps excessive what does it mean for the board of Tesla well
3:58it's not clear to me you know it's it's as Ed is kind of hinting at many Tesla shareholders were aware that the Tesla board of directors was essentially a a rubber stamp right you have a lot of people who are very close friends with Elon and and I think one of the reasons he lost this case is because you had nominally independent directors who were going on vacation with him we had clear clearly had a close relationship with now that's kind of like how Elon Musk has done business and and by Elon what's what's so I think Difficult about this going forward is that that's kind of been if you asked Elon Musk like what is your playbook how have you been able
4:33to achieve so much he would say well it's because I have a you know I've been able to do essentially whatever I want to do and and again as I said earlier he's been asking for even more control from where he got so so I don't know where that goes I do think there is some piece of risk that probably didn't exist yesterday that Elon Musk could either threaten to or even and again I think this is a far off possibility decide to walk away from Tesla I mean this is why the share price is somewhat what Under Pressure not massive moves Greg but the articulation from the judge was at no point did it seem that this 55 billion or these options awarded was necessary
5:09to keep Elon motivated but then to that end why not recompense the leader a Founder with such a significant upside if he's going to deliver for shareholders well the judge made the point I think very cogently and that is I believe his net worth increased in increments of1 billion dollar based on the stock he already held without this pay package for each increment that was identified in this pay package and so I think the judge's point of view was if you look at other successful Founders Bezos Zuckerberg others they don't take pay packages or they don't take any material pay package they rely on driving value for their shareholders in their own
5:54underlying stock Mr musk had the opportunity to to increase his is net worth by almost a hundred billion I have to stop and make sure I get the B right a hundred billion if he accomplished what he set out to accomplish under this pay package without getting a single option and you know at the end of the day this is a car company it's not a space exp exploration company and it's a public company and public companies live by different rules than private companies right if you're a if you're watching us live now on Bloomberg television and you're a terminal subscriber you can send questions to us via IB Greg I I told our audience on social media you
6:37were coming on and that there were lots of questions I think the most common is is just a want for deeper understanding of what the pathway forward is so you talk with Caroline about a likely appeal I think my understanding from sources is that's likely as well but the other thing is that this current board which is different to what it was in 2018 could put together a new compensation plan and then take it to to shareholders to to be ratified how involved do you think you will be with your client how involved do you think Kathleen J McCormack will be in that process if at all well the simple answer to that is that's a question for the board to
7:18determine in the first instance and assuming it fulfills its fiduciary duties and uses ordinary and reasonable means to arrive at a result my guess is I won't be involved at all and my guess as well as the judge won't be involved at all if the board comes out with a package which either facially is ridiculous gargantuan or
7:41otherwise raises concerns from a fiduciary perspective I suspect you'll see my firm and I involved as well right Max there's so much to discuss here I guess the board could also say well here's another $55 billion package looks different same number I mean one thing I'm curious about you know Musk overnight was sort of threatening to leave Delaware and to reincorporate in Texas I believe or you know I think x he moved from Delaware to Nevada is that a re is that can he do that and and is that like like will there be another sort of you know trch of lawsuits if it happens because shareholders were say oh he's he's just doing this to to reduce our rights or
8:21something so look the simple answer to that is musk can't do anything himself that's a matter that the board has to decide in the first instance and then it's presented to shareholders for a vote if shareholders upon the board's recommendation decide to move to Nevada they have a right to do that but it's not a musk decision let me also say that I'm not an expert in all 50 states laws but I suspect I get I would guess that even Nevada prohibits you from putting out misleading proxy statements and that if musk wants to go to Nevada and do the same thing he's probably going to run into some some problems there as well it's this little idea of telling the
8:57truth you know it's it's real basic right hey Greg real quick an audience question I'm just going to read do you worry about changing the Norms around Delaware corporate law away from non-intervention that was a follow on from what Max asked we have about 30 seconds no not at all I think it's very important to recognize and and this is something that's deeply embedded in Delaware law that every decision is twice tested both from a legal perspective and an equitable perspective and when fiduciaries act in a way that's not equ or in violation of their duties you're squarely within the long tradition of the Delaware law to call them on that
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版