访谈·中文精读

L5之声:马斯克的IAC演讲

Voices From L5 - Elon Musk's IAC Talk

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2017年9月,澳大利亚阿德莱德,国际宇航大会(IAC)。马斯克站在台上,抛出一个听上去像段子的数字:把去火星的成本降低500万倍。

换成工程师的语言,是4.5个数量级。人类上一次把某类成本砍掉4个数量级,是从手工织布到珍妮纺纱机,再到大工厂流水线,中间隔了一百多年。

他要在十几年里干完。

这场演讲叫《让生命成为多行星物种》(Making Life Multiplanetary)。台上的马斯克语速偏快,用词相当谨慎,反复出现“也许”“希望”“我认为”。跟他几年后在发布会上跳舞的状态不太一样,这次更像个正在答辩的工程师,一边说一边给自己留后路。

一个叫 Voices From L5 的太空播客把整场演讲逐句拆了一遍。主播开场就交代了立场:他时不时会批评“不加掩饰的太空资本主义”,知道这话不讨喜,但他觉得不提问才是问题。他提的疑问很具体:这些数字从哪来,一千艘飞船到底是什么概念,票价二十万美元和任务成本是一回事吗。

把两边的说法摆在一起看,比单看任何一边都有信息量。

他给人类只留了两个选项,其中一个其实被跳过了

演讲开场,马斯克把人类的未来压缩成两条路。

从根本上说,历史会沿着两个方向分叉。一条是我们永远待在地球上,然后终将迎来某种灭绝事件。我没有具体的末日预言,但历史表明总会有那么一天。另一条路是成为太空文明,成为多行星物种。我希望你们同意,这才是正确的方向。(马斯克)

台下有人喊了一声“yes”。他笑了笑,接着往下讲。

这条路为什么通向火星,他讲得很干脆。金星是高压加高温的酸浴,跟那位同名的女神毫无关系;水星离太阳太近;木星和土星的卫星虽然可以落脚,但离得太远,去一趟的成本高得离谱。排完一圈,只剩火星。

月球也被他排除了。理由有三条:比行星小得多,没有大气层,资源不如火星。

播客主在这里第一次停下来提问。他说,这个领域里相当多人认为,轨道上的空间城市(比如奥尼尔提出的自由空间栖息地)比火星殖民地更容易、更便宜,对整个人类也更好。为什么演讲里连提都没提?是疏忽,是研究过之后选了别的方案,还是马斯克在理念上就不认同“住在太空里”这件事?他说自己很想当面问,但好像从来没人直接问过。

月球的排除理由,他也不太买账。按马斯克后来的说法,最终要送一百万人上火星,可一百万人放在月球上其实也放得下。他承认自己不清楚月球资源的具体情况,只是觉得“太小、不够住”这个理由更像哲学分歧,不是事实分歧。

500万倍的成本削减,被拆成了四块

这是全场信息密度最高的部分,也是播客主最不满的部分。

马斯克的推导是这样的:按阿波罗式的传统打法,把一个人送上火星的乐观估计是100亿美元。要让这件事成立,成本得降5个数量级(他后来说“差不多500万倍”,也就是4.5个数量级)。

这4.5个数量级来自哪里,他分了三块:

  • 完全可复用,贡献2到2.5个数量级
  • 轨道加注、火星就地生产推进剂、选对推进剂,合起来再贡献2个数量级

听起来很有条理。播客主的反应是:这些数字是怎么来的?

他的原话大意是,任何人站在那个台上都能说出这些话,二十万一个人、这个数量级那个数量级,但推导过程一句都没有。他不认为马斯克背后没有逻辑,他只是说,现场没有把逻辑给你看。

他还专门挑了一个他觉得“不诚实”的地方:演讲里把任务成本和人均票价混着用。100亿美元一个人,说的是把整套研发、火箭、飞船、地面系统的钱摊到每个人头上;二十万美元一张票,说的是边际票价。这两个数不在一个层面上。

“SpaceX 每次送人上火星,如果算上所有研发投入,成本肯定远不止二十万美元。NASA 每次发射也不便宜,但没人会说 NASA 是靠卖票赚钱。”

他承认私营公司确实能把成本压得比政府低,这在很多案例里成立。他不理解的是,为什么要用这种容易混淆的表述来强调差距。

二十万美元的票价,和一次任务的实际成本

演讲进行到后半段,票价的问题被翻了出来。马斯克提到二十万美元是目标价,而按上下文推算,这只是初始价格的一半。也就是说,早期票价大概在四十万美元上下。

播客主认为这个数字比二十万“更像话”:能找到一百个愿意掏四十万美元的人,事情就有了一点现实基础。他紧接着抛出另一道题:要凑够一百万人,这些人既要有这笔钱,又要愿意单程搬家去一个没有空气、没有医院、没有外卖的地方,得花多久?

这个问题在演讲里没有答案。马斯克用的是“长期目标”这个词,没有定义长期是多长。

为什么是甲烷,这段技术账讲得最扎实

整场演讲里,推进剂选择这一段是播客主明确点赞的。他说“我非常喜欢这段推进剂讨论,讲得很好”。

马斯克比较了三种方案。

煤油。火箭用的是高度精炼的航空煤油,价格贵,但能把飞行器尺寸压小。麻烦在于火星上没有石油,就地生产几乎不可能。

液氢。比冲高,性能好,但液氢接近绝对零度,保温层的要求极其苛刻,蒸发损失很难控制。在火星上制氢、储氢,能源开销高得离谱。

甲烷。做整体系统优化的时候,甲烷是明确的赢家。

他还给了一个具体数字:在火星上生产推进剂,大概要消耗掉当地50%到60%的能量。

这段之所以扎实,是因为它给出了取舍标准:不只看发动机性能,要看全链条,包括在火星上能不能造出来。这是典型的工程思维,比后面那些数量级的说法实在得多。

运力条第一次超过火箭体积

演讲里放了一张对比图。白色条代表火箭的运力,背景是火箭本身的体积。现役火箭包括猎鹰系列,运力条只占体积的一小块,这是常识,因为火箭大部分体积装的都是推进剂。

马斯克说,行星际运输系统的设计让运力条第一次超过了火箭的物理尺寸。“这是第一次,飞行器的效率会超过飞行器自身的体积。”

播客主对这段话的评论只有一句:这不需要评论,这就是疯了。

他的意思是,物理规律在那里摆着,齐奥尔科夫斯基公式不会因为愿景宏大就网开一面。当然,如果把“体积”理解成结构干重占比,这话在某种口径下能自圆其说,但演讲现场没有给这个口径。

“零翻新”和20分钟周转,是全场最大胆的一句话

可复用是4.5个数量级里的主力,所以马斯克在这一点上说得最细,也说得最狠。

他提到,猎鹰9号的一级助推器从高速度再入、飞回卡纳维拉尔角、安全着陆,整个过程几乎不需要翻新就能再次飞行。他说这是自己人生中最好的时刻之一。2016年海上驳船的着陆也演示过了,那对高速度再入更关键。

然后他往前推了一步:这套系统要做到像飞机一样,加注燃料就飞,周转时间20分钟,连续复用4到5次。

播客主在这里的措辞很克制,但态度明确:SpaceX 这些年进步很大,着陆越来越稳,翻新周期也确实在缩短,这些他都认。但“用完完全全不需要翻新的发动机”是另一回事。他说得挺老实:他不认为这件事超出了 SpaceX 的能力边界,几乎所有工程问题最终都能解决,他质疑的是时间。五到十年内拿出这样一台发动机,非常非常了不起,也非常非常难。

他补了一句在场的名言:非凡的主张需要非凡的证据。

演讲里还有一个时间点:大约四年后完成第一艘开发版飞船。播客主说,他非常想知道四年后那台发动机到底是什么状态,如果真做到了零翻新,欢迎有人在评论区告诉他怎么做,他很乐意承认自己判断错了。

一千艘飞船,和一道除法题

演讲里出现了一个让人当场愣住的说法:最终会有超过一千艘飞船在轨道上等待出发。

播客主替观众做了翻译。马斯克的意思是,这套系统在理论上可以扩展到那个规模,不是说 SpaceX 明天就要造一千艘船、排成一列停在轨道上、把人一个个塞进去。他提醒,这类表述很容易被媒体截出来当标题。

真正值得算的是另一组数字。

每艘飞船设计载客一百人,这是长期目标,没有定义“长期”。地球和火星的发射窗口每26个月开一次。假如真有一百万人要过去,按每艘一百人算,是一万艘次的运力,得分摊到多少个窗口里?每个窗口要发射多少艘?地球上的发射场、燃料产能、人员训练、医疗保障,能不能跟上?

票价那道题也可以反过来算:一百万人乘二十万美元,是两千亿美元,还不含任何基础设施投入。

播客主的结论比较温和:这些问题的答案也许存在,也许四年后他会自己打脸,但在演讲现场,一个都没听到。

钱从哪来:卫星、空间站,还有“偷内裤”

这是播客主最关心的部分,因为在他眼里,把一堆人塞进飞船送去火星,从来就不是一个商业模式。

马斯克的回答分几层。

第一层是现有的现金流:发射卫星、给 NASA 运送空间站补给和人员、往返运送货物。这些业务能产生“相当不错的净现金流”。

第二层是外部资金:私营部门里已经有不少人对资助火星基地感兴趣,政府层面以后大概也会有兴趣。

他把整件事定性为一场大型的公私合作,还打了个比方,说美国本身和世界上很多国家的建立方式,就是公私合作。

中间他还开了个玩笑。有人问资金来源,他套用了《南方公园》里那个著名的“第一阶段:收集内裤;第二阶段:?;第三阶段:利润”的梗,把中间那步换成了“发射卫星、服务空间站、众筹”。

最重的一句话是关于他自己的:

我个人积累资产的主要目的,就是为了给这件事提供资金。除了尽可能做出最大的贡献,我没有别的动机去积累财富。(马斯克)

播客主对这句話的反应很有意思。他说自己相信马斯克是真诚的,也欣赏这个表态,但特斯拉的股东听到大概不会太开心。现实是,他不可能把特斯拉的钱全抽出来倒进 SpaceX,公司不是这么运作的。

他接着给出自己的判断:SpaceX 真正的商业模式,是把火星任务的设备和发射服务卖给各国政府,可能还包括私营部门。他拿南极做类比:真正赚钱的不是旅游公司,是那些卖船票、建基地、运补给的公司。他说自己问过很多次“SpaceX 的商业模式到底是什么”,一直没人正面回答,而这场演讲基本把答案说出来了,只是没用商业计划的格式写。

技术不会自动变好,这句话值得单独拎出来

演讲里有一段被很多人引用:

很多人没有意识到的是,技术并不会自动进步。1969年我们能登上月球,航天飞机能把人送到近地轨道,然后航天飞机退役了,那条趋势线一路掉到零。如果当时没有一家带着强烈意识形态动机的新公司进入航天领域,我们看起来根本不像在走向太空文明。(马斯克)

这段话的逻辑是:技术能力会退化,需要有人主动维护和推进。

播客主在这里跟马斯克有部分分歧,分歧还挺具体。

他同意“技术不会自动变好”,也同意阿波罗火箭的退役是一种损失。但他觉得把航天飞机当成退步的证据不公平。他的论据是:国际空间站用阿波罗火箭是建不起来的,航天飞机在这件事上是不可替代的工具。空间站本身产出了大量科研成果,加上俄罗斯的联盟号任务,人类在太空中已经维持了很长时间的连续存在,这件事值得骄傲。

他给了一个更朴素的技术观:技术是围绕具体任务开发的,你要做什么,就造什么工具。阿波罗时代的人如果看到今天能把火星车放上去、能落到移动的小行星上,大概会非常吃惊。

他甚至怀疑马斯克自己也未必完全相信“趋势线掉到零”这个说法,那句话更多是为了把观点推到听众面前。

纽约到东京25分钟

演讲中间插入了一个跟火星没什么关系、但传播效果最好的设想:用同一套火箭做地球上的点对点运输。

最远45分钟能到地球任何地方,多数地方20到25分钟。跨大西洋10分钟。如果在离岸二三十英里的海面上放一个浮动平台,从纽约到东京大概25分钟。

播客主在这里松了口,说他会买 SpaceX 航空的票。这是全片少有的、他完全站在马斯克那边的时刻。

他也顺带夸了一句命名品味:Falcon、Raptor,这些名字起得不错。他提到,在大会开幕前,团队完成了猛禽发动机的全系统点火,这是实打实的硬件进展。

把去火星的系统当成太阳系的高速公路

演讲接近尾声,马斯克把格局又拉大了一圈。

他强调这套东西叫“系统”而不是“火箭”,理由是他不喜欢什么都被叫成系统,连狗都是系统。但这里确实不止一个飞行器:助推器、飞船、加注船、推进剂生产装置,四个要素缺一不可。凑齐这四个,理论上可以在太阳系里跳岛。

在小行星带或者木星的某颗卫星上建一座推进剂补给站,从火星飞木星就不成问题。甚至在火星没有补给站的情况下,也能无代价地飞掠木星。再往外,土卫六、冥王星,一站接一站铺下去,整个太阳系就通了。

他自己也划了边界:不建议用这套东西做星际旅行。

播客主的回应是,这是“魔法乐园”时间。他说如果这套为火星设计的系统真能一路往外扩,直接跳到木卫二,那确实很酷,而这段话之所以出现在演讲里,大概是因为马斯克本人也想这么干。但他提醒,一旦飞出火星轨道,问题清单立刻变长:太阳能随距离迅速衰减,辐射屏蔽要重新设计,长期飞行的人工重力问题没有解,而且飞过去本身要好几年。

这到底是一场演讲,还是一份营销材料

播客主在结尾给了自己的定性,说得挺直白:他有点失望,因为这场演讲跟马斯克以往的风格差别不大,还是那个“我爱你们”的调子。他不否认演讲里的任何一条主张,他只是希望有人把这些问题提出来。

他的判断是,这场演讲在很大程度上是为了让人们对投资产生兴趣,让愿意出钱的人愿意出钱。在这个层面上,它做得非常成功,画面漂亮,信息有节奏,情绪给得到位。正因如此,他觉得不该因为演讲好看就默认里面每个数字都成立。

他也留了余地:也许四年后他会当众认错,也许那时他正坐在某艘飞往火星的船上。

这场对话最有价值的地方,恰好是两个视角的叠加。马斯克给出的是一张路线图,哪怕是草图;播客主问的是图纸背面的东西:数字怎么算的,钱谁来付,时间表凭什么。前者让人想出发,后者让人别在半路掉下来。

对做技术、做产品、做投资的人来说,这套阅读方法比演讲本身更耐用。

下次再看这类发布会,可以按这几条过一遍

  • 把“最终目标价”和“当下的实际成本”分开记账。听到二十万美元一张票,先问研发费用摊到哪里去了。目标价是规模效应跑满之后的结果,不是今天能买到的价格。
  • 听到“几个数量级”,追问基准和路径。4.5个数量级听起来很爽,但每一块贡献多少、靠什么实现、验证到哪一步,才是可核查的部分。
  • 区分已经点火试飞的硬件,和 PPT 上的方块。猛禽发动机全系统点火是事实,零翻新发动机是目标,一千艘飞船在轨是修辞。三者放进同一页幻灯片里,很容易被读成同一件事。
  • 给时间表乘一个系数。四年造出第一艘开发版飞船,按航天工业的历史规律,先按六年到八年做心理准备,再看进展调整。这不叫唱衰,叫留出余量。
  • 算除法,别只记住大数字。一千艘、一百万人、每26个月一个窗口,把这三个数放一起除一下,就能看出瓶颈在发射能力、燃料产能还是人本身。
  • 搞清楚谁付钱。任何宏大计划都要回答这个问题。马斯克给的答案是卫星发射、NASA 合同、公私合作,以及他个人资产。这已经比大多数愿景演讲诚实,但它同时也说明,火星计划短期内离不开政府订单。
  • 保留怀疑,但别让怀疑变成什么都不做的理由。质疑票价推导和质疑“人类该不该去火星”是两件事。前者的答案会随时间揭晓,后者你现在就该有自己的判断。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00hey guys welcome to voices from l5 today's going to be a little bit different as evidenced by the fact that you're watching a video right now and not listening to me through your podcast app but video episodes is something that I wants to do and on the patron and a couple of emails have told me that this is something people would like so and it's also the best medium for what I'd like to do today which is to go the ISE talk the alon Musk's is each at that

0:27happened pretty recently Elon's is subject that comes up pretty often on the show I think and listeners to my show probably wouldn't be surprised to hear that I am sometimes shall we say a critical of unabashed space capitalism which I know is a slightly unpopular view but I think that asking these questions is important and I think that oftentimes we all get bogged down in our desires to see space happen at all costs and we sort of inherently trust and hope

1:02for the best from what people say and that I think generally leads to a bad space we don't question what people say we don't critically examine their claims or question the things that they say and that's really where a lot of the things that I said come from and it's not necessarily that I think that Elon Musk is a bad person far from it he seems like a fairly nice nice guy and every time I've seen him more Jeff Bezos or whoever else talkative come offers earnest and genuinely excited to go into space I actually believe he'll on musk when he says that he wants to go into space to go into space now that aside I want to look into this talk that he

1:45gave because a lot of people are saying that's really really impressive and really really interesting and some people have told me that it's what I am looking for in an Elon Musk speech which is to say a little bit more grounded than his usual rock star entrepreneur stick so I'm excited to look into it and for everyone who's looking forward to another episode of voices from l5 a real one test for the guests and everything don't worry we'll be back to that next week all in two weeks totally too unless your opinion let's just stop there really to

2:28fundamental paths history is going to bifurcate along two directions 11 path is we say on earth forever and then there will be some eventual extinction event I don't have intermediate doomsday prophecy but there's it's eventually history suggests there will be some some doomsday event well the alternative is to become a spacefaring civilization and a multi-planet species which I hope you would agree that is the right way to go yes

3:04that's what we want yeah so right off the bat here we've got some interesting language are two options died on earth or leave and he's saying that what we want is to leave Earth and go and live on Mars that's kind of debatable I think going to Mars is really interesting from a scientific point of view but pretty much anyone in this field would agree that living in space and in space best cities would probably be easier cheaper and better overall for Humanity than a Mars colony but I guess that's just a point of debate I I can't really fault in too much for saying that I really like this graphic that he has a PIAA of ma's as if it's colonized kind of a nice one we have in

4:03terms of nearby options we've got Venus but Venus is a high pressure and super-high pressure a hot acid bath so that that would be a tricky one venus is not at all like the goddess this is not in no way similar to to to the actual goddess so it really difficult to make things work on Venus a mercury is also way too close to the Sun we could go potentially on the Mart one of them on the one of the moons of Jupiter or Saturn but those are quite far out much further from the Sun a lot harder to get to it really leaves us with one option if we want to become a multi-planet civilization and that's that's Mars okay so here we are again the Venus mercury

4:51moons all planetary options I don't know if this is just an oversight in that he has an examined space settlement like space bear settlements or if it's been examined and his research has shown something that other people other people's hasn't or maybe he just philosophically degrees with disagrees with the idea of living in space I don't know i I'd like to pick his brains about it at some point but I don't think anyone's ever directly asked him about it there's recently an am here with elan and i want to go through an examine that because maybe he picked up on it at that point we could

5:32consume if we go to our moon and I have nothing against going to the moon but i think it's it's challenging to create a become multi-planet or in the moon because it's it's much smaller than been thin a planet it doesn't have any atmosphere so the moon he rules out because it's too small and there's known as many resources I honestly don't know enough about the resources available in miles to argue with that one I know the moon has a great deal of some things that we need like helium 3 and what have you although the evidence for that is always changing I do get his point about scaling up that does make a lot of sense but seems like kind of a long term

6:12concern later in the video he talks about wanting to send a million people to Mars which we'll get to when we get to it but even a million people I think could probably fit on the moon relatively comfortably again more of a point of philosophical disagreement rather than anything factual using

6:46traditional methods you know if taking sort of Apollo style approach the an optimistic class number would be about 10 billion dollars a person does anyone have the numbers for this 10 billion per person thing that he's coming up with that almost seems kind of random for what the numbers that I've seen her on a NASA mission to Mars and a private

7:11sector mission to Mars it also kind of he kind of mixes it in with the price for a ticket in a minute he's going to talk about how it's going to cost 200,000 per person but the cost for the mission isn't the same as the cost per person and I think that equate them like this is dishonest you know it definitely cost SpaceX a lot more than 200,000 per person if you account for all the research and development of the rockets and so on it doesn't cost NASA however many millions per person every time they launched the rocket that's a dish involve the factors for building constructing research and etc the Rockets so I this is this is

7:53something that I think has brought up a lot that the private sector can do things for a lot cheaper and in a lot of cases that's true and I don't really see what the need for this sort of dishonest depiction of the cost differential so if

8:17it is a bit tricky because we have forgot how to improve the cost of trips to Mars by five million percent so this is just not easy and I mean it's and it sounds like virtually impossible but I think I think their ways to do it this this translates to an improvement of approximately four and a half orders of magnitude there these are the key

8:43elements that are needed in order to achieve the four and a half at order of magnitude improvement most of the improvement would come from full reusability somewhere between two and two and a half orders of magnitude and then the other two orders of magnitude would come from refilling in orbit propellant production on Mars and choosing the right propellant okay so

9:08this is one of the parts where I start to get a little frustrated and one of my main issues with Ilan completely is that all the numbers that he's saying here kinda I mean anyone could be on stage saying these and there's not really any details to back any of them up he's just saying things you know this many per person this much that much it's maybe this is what does a lot of logical thinking behind this i don't i'm not saying there isn't but i am saying that he's not presenting it to me and i kind of want to know what that is so we're all these numbers come from I understand this isn't a scientific thesis I get that he's not presenting a pod completely solid plan it's just that

9:52this is being depicted as that from the space community and I guess a lot of my criticism then doesn't necessarily go directly to Elon this is already feeling like one of his big dream speeches again where he sort of saying if you know maybe and and credit where credit's due elands being very reserved during the speech he almost seems a little nervous he's he's speaking in sometimes very very solid terms but often he's metering his speech with maybes and hopefully is which i think is a good idea I don't get where this order of magnitude business comes from I think it might just be the comparison to airlines but I don't think that anyone would seriously compare space travel to

10:35airlines even the sort of very very very mature level of space travel that he's talking about operates on very different principles than planes I don't think it's very fair to compare a flight from LA to las vegas to a mission to mars

11:11this is maybe this there's three main choices and I'm going to have that they have their merits but kerosene or rocket-propelled grade the kerosene which is also at jets use rockets use a very expensive form a highly refined form of jet fuel essentially which is a form of kerosene that it helps keep the vehicle size small but because it's a

11:35very specialized form of jet fuel it's it's quite expensive the you reasonably casual is lower very difficult to make this on Mars because there's no oil so really quite difficult to make the council Mars and and then propellant transfers because is pretty good but not not great hydrogen although it has a high specific impulse is it's very expensive incredibly difficult to to keep from boiling off because liquid hydrogen it is very close to absolute zero as liquid so the installation

12:14required is is tremendous and the the cost of the energy costs on Mars of producing and storing hydrogen is very high so when we looked at the overall system optimization who's best at that methane actually was the clear winner so we it require may be anywhere from you know fifty to sixty percent of the energy on Mars to reap to refold propellants using the propellant diva okay I have to say that I am a big fan of the propellant chat here it's very good

12:58this is part of the video that I think everyone got very excited about but I think that we should maybe be asking a couple questions about I it's a very very interesting system that he's talking about a wonderfully you know hopeful vision but are they talking about four hundred percent 20-minute turnaround reusability like you can launch immediately with zero filled landings and everything else I get that SpaceX is doing things in leaps and bounds but and and I don't even want to say that developing such a rocket such an engine is beyond their capabilities I think that almost anything is achievable it's just that he's talking about in the next five to ten years they're going to

13:42have an engine that app needs absolutely no refurbishment after use that would be very very very impressive and extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence they're doing a lot of great work and they've definitely got that refurb calm down and they've gotten much better at landing the Rockets but the sort of precision they're talking about here in the turnaround time is kind of insane not only that but he says this process will happen four or five times in a row it just seems unreasonably hopeful for repeatable consistent process

15:53they look almost identical this this also helps lower the development costs which obviously will not be small and and then the propellant tanker goes up and we'll go actually it'll go up multiple times anywhere from three to five times to fill the tanks of the of the spaceship in orbit and then once the spaceship is the tanks are full the cargo has been transferred and we reached the Mars rendezvous timing which as messages roughly every 26 months that's when the ship would depart no overtime there would be many spaceships you to ultimately have I think upwards of a thousand or more space ships waiting in orbit this is a really good example of what I mean by dream speech

16:41here elin says that he wants to have a thousand ships in orbit and I think that anyone's natural reaction probably should be like what but in reality he means that at one point they want to scale up to being able to send a thousand ships to Mars which I i already have questions about but my point here is that he clearly doesn't mean that SpaceX will literally build a thousand ships and put a fleet in orbit and then load people into those ships and then send them off to Mars he's saying that the system itself could scale up that high and that that's what it would take to you know get people in there another detail here is that he is looking to

17:21fill he says that there they can all have room for a hundred people but then Lettie he says that's a long term goal without actually qualifying what that means i also have questions regarding how long it's going to find i was kind of long it's going to take to find enough people to make this system function a lot of what he's talking about requires are constantly moving a lot of people shifting their and while two hundred thousand dollars is attainable I won't argue that how long's it gonna take to find a million people who have that much money and also all totally happy going two miles maybe I'm rheumatic maybe that'll happen in five minutes I believe that it's just there's

18:00a lot of questions here you that compares to you satisfied max capability of 135 tons but i think this atlas really gives a better sense for things the white bars show the performance of the vehicle but there was the payload to orbit of the vehicle so you can see essentially what it represents is what's the size efficiency of the of the vehicle and most drugs

18:46including ours that are currently flying the repeat performance far is only a small percentage of the actual size of the rocket but with the inter planetary system with traditionally views from ours we've been able to we believe massively improve the design performance so it's the first time I Rockets sort of performance bar will actually exceed the physical size of the rocket the first time a vehicle efficiency will exceed the size of the vehicle itself I don't think that really requires a comment that's just crazy

19:42Venn diagram where people actually want to go it's got to be really fun and exciting and it can't feel cramped or a boring so but the crew the crew compartment or the occupant compartment is setups that you can do zero-g games you can float around they'll be like movies lecture poles your cabins a

20:07restaurant it'll be like really fun to go you have a great time yeah I'll have fun neon server the propellant have left okay so 200,000 is revealed here to be half of what it will be in the beginning so there are rid the actual price for a ticket to mars is if you can you know find your way through this is going to be about four hundred thousand dollars that makes a little bit more sense financially speaking if you can find one hundred people with four hundred thousand dollars and certainly gets you a long way there so finding these

21:01are what about funding sources and so we could steal underpants launch satellites same cognitive space station Kickstarter of course followed by profit funding yes this is exactly what I want to know about hopefully we'll have some actually grounded information here you generate pretty decent net net cash flow

21:30from launching lots of satellites and servicing the space station for NASA of transferring hugger to and from space station and and then I know that there's a lot of people in the private sector who are interested in helping fund a base on Mars and then perhaps there will be interest on the government sector side to also do that ultimately this is going to be a huge public private partnership and I think that's that's

22:04how the United States was established and many other countries around the world is a public-private partnership let me that's probably what what occurs and right now we're just trying to make as much progress as we can with the resources that we have available and just sort of keep keep moving both forward and hopefully I think I think as

22:28we as we show that this is possible that this dream is real not just a dream it can pick something that we made real I think the support will snowball over time and as you say also the but the main reason i'm personally accumulating assets is in order to fund us so i really don't have any other motivation for personally accumulating assets except to be able to make the biggest contribution i can so you're making life multiplanetary okay that was

23:03shorter than I expected lots of hopeful ease maybes perhapses which i think is totally logical and reasonable I don't want anyone to come out thinking that I that Elon shooters come out and told me this is exactly what will happen the upon part here is the public-private partnership I appreciate the statement he makes about dumping all his assets into space X but I've mentioned this before that I don't think the investors in Tesla are going to be super happy with him saying things like that I mean maybe they will be people get buy into and love Elon's sort of personality but realistically he can't just take all the money out of Tesla and dumping into

23:38space that's not how it works at all I think the implication here is what I've been talking about for a while and what other people have speculated fall for a very long time that SpaceX is in reality hoping to sell Mars mission equipment and Mars mission launches to the governments of the world and maybe private sectors he mentions it a couple times but I think that that's basically what all this talks about when you really get down to it being I've said for a lot of times that just loading people into ships and sending them out isn't really a business model and I've been asking a lot about what the business model is behind SpaceX no one's really come out and said it but

24:17I'm pretty sure this is what we're looking at here he's talking about developing the technology to have up to a thousand ships worth of cargo for relatively cheap to send equipment science missions and other things to Mars I think SpaceX here should probably be compared to one of the companies that sell passage to places like Antarctica and base building facilities on and talk to you rather than the sort of tourist company that they're being crowded as I don't really think it's going to be that easy to get to Mars even with SpaceX doing what they're going to do if I came occasion that if they were if it wasn't some new entrant into into the space

25:11arena with a strong ideological motivation then it didn't seem like we were on a trajectory to ever be a spacefaring civilization and be out there among the stars because you know in 69 we were able to go to the moon and the Space Shuttle could get to low-earth orbit and then observational got retired but that trend line is down down to zero so I think what a lot of people don't appreciate is that technology does not automatically improve it this is

25:44frustrating I disagree in degree in equal parts to what he's saying he I do think it's important for Humanity have a machine that can go to the moon and travel as far as we can and I think that that technology should have been developed as far as it possibly could and it I do lament the loss of the Apollo rockets on the other hand I know that we like to poopoo on the shuttle a lot in the space world and this isn't going to make me any friends least of all so my Twitter people but the shuttle was very good for what it did okay like you couldn't have built a ISS with the

26:22Apollo rockets and I know I know that the ISS was sort of you can look at it as being invented for the special that have something to do but the special the special and the ISS did massive amounts of good for Humanity there's so much science so much good information being done and thanks to the efforts of the ISS and the shuttle and the Russian our

26:45missions of the we have had a semi permanent human presence in space for a very very long time now and I think that that's something to be proud of I don't understand why does this methyls of backsliding space technology when technology isn't at an extra balázs forward you develop the technology and the tools for what it is that you want to do and I you know you can sort

27:09of see this in NASA preparing to go to Mars and designing developing new tech for that now it all depends on what the mission is you know the people in the Apollo era might have been massively surprised and impressed at our ability to Land Rovers on Mars and land things on moving asteroids for example I don't know if Ilan really thinks this I think you might just be saying it like to impress people at the tall called the makeup overall point that he's trying to get to I want to know what he means by that there's a lot of examples of cultures reaching certain tech levels and they're not recovering for millennia but it's not really a big deal i think

27:51that again it's just sort of here in december i was definitely when the best moments of my life when the rocket booster came back and landed at Cape Canaveral that was really yeah

28:27so that really sure that we could bring an orbit class booster back from a very high velocity all way to the launch site and landed safely and and with with almost no refurbishment required for a flight and if things go well we're hoping to reef lie one of land at brusters in a few months so yeah and

28:54then 2016 Rosa demonstrated landing on ownership the landing on the ship is important for the very high velocity this is actually really inspiring stuff and I very much appreciate the part where he calls out to NASA in many ways SpaceX is only around because NASA exists and give them the money and only really right now continues to function because of that I don't know what SpaceX's finances are one hundred percent and I'll be the first person to admit that but I I mean you only really

29:22need to look at what they're currently doing and what their missions are to know they're being kept afloat by NASA and other governmental space agencies the same thing with almost every private space industry on board to boost back through the launch site so looking into the future next steps we

29:46were kind of intentionally a bit fuzzy about the sign line but the we're going to try to make as much progress as we can obviously it's with a very constrained budget but we're going to try to make as much progress as we can on the elements of the interplanetary transport rooster and spaceship and

30:09hopefully we'll be able to do to complete the first development spaceship in maybe about four years again with that zero refurb I'm really really really really really curious as to that and I would like a lot more information about how they plan to achieve zero refurb on engines maybe it's possible and if it is and you want to tell me how much of an idiom in the comments please go right ahead because I'm very willing to admit that I could be wrong on this but that seems very very difficult and also hinges a great deal on that just working out all that well maybe I'm wrong maybe I'm wrong he says it'll take four years to get to that point and

30:50maybe that's plausible but it doesn't seem like a very major part of the plan to sort of not really talk about that much we can transport cargo to anywhere on earth in 45 minutes at the longest so most places on earth three maybe 20 25 minutes so maybe if we had a floating platform out off the coast of you know

31:18say of Costa New York said 20 30 miles out you could go from you know New York to Tokyo in out of 25 minutes for cross the Atlantic in 10 minutes as I just wanted to say that I would fly SpaceX airlines that the team

32:01managed to do the all up rapture engine firing in advance of this conference that I suppose say thanks to to the Raptor team and I just want to say that i love SpaceX rocket names Mullen and Raptor they're pretty cool you as we thought about the system and the reason we call it a system because generally i don't like pulling things systems because everything's a system including your dog the is that is that

32:52it's actually more than a vehicle there's this absolute the rocket booster the spaceship the tanker and the propellant plant the problem the institute a propellant production if you have all of those four elements you can actually go anywhere in the solar system by but by planet hopping or moon hopping so by establishing a propellant depot on in the asteroid belt or on one of the moons of jupiter you can go to you can make flights from Mars to Jupiter no problem in fact even from even without a propellant e4 at Mars you can do a flyby of Jupiter without a penalty boat so but

33:39but by establishing propellant deeper let's say you know Enceladus or grow up for work or any of these few options and then doing another one on Titan Jupiter Saturn's moon and it perhaps another one further out on Pluto or elsewhere in the solar system that this system really gives gives you freedom to go anywhere you want in the greater solar system so you can actually travel out to the Cape abell to the earth cloud I wouldn't recommend this for interstellar journeys but this just this basic system provided

34:27we have filling stations along the way is means full access to the entire greater solar system

34:49okay so this is pretty fun Lee in magic dreamland right like this is just him talking and trying to get people excited I think at this point I am very I would be very exciting if this system that he's developing to go to Mars would be usable as far out as you want but I think that anyone would agree that there's a lot of other issues that you get to once you start flying past miles in a machine designed to go to Mars you know you've got solar power is going to start diminishing very quickly once you get out of the fuel radiation shielding on board gravity for long term flights it takes a fairly long time to get past miles to anything interesting it'd be

35:35cool if this was if this system turns out to be scalable that we can leapfrog right all our way to Europa that would be very cool and I I think that the reason this is here is because Elon would like that too well that's pretty much it I gotta say a little bit disappointed this really just felt like more of the same stuff that we hear from you on all the time which is to say I love talk I know that he likes to let the actual business do the talking and he's been very successful in that and I want to reiterate here that I don't disbelieve any of the things that he said here but I do want some of these concerns addressed at some point I I don't really get this idea of why we

36:16don't challenge some of these questions but anyway I'm not gonna get on that too much I really like some the imagery used here I really like some of the talk that he said and overall it's a fantastic message it's beautiful but I do think that a great deal of it's just trying to get people excited to invest and people interested in giving money to SpaceX and to that degree I don't think that it's really reasonable for us just to trust implicitly everything and anything being said in this video right now in a lot of places it's being touted as Elon Musk promising to revolutionize and he I think it's intentionally presented as such from his point of view

36:54but I have a lot of concerns and a lot of questions about some of the claims that he's making maybe he'll answer all them maybe in four years I'll be the one eating my own hat when he's starting all of these launches and a thousand people going to Mars and I'm on one of those rockets I mean who wouldn't I'm not saying that I am against the idea of villain must taken as alden's best I think there's some concerns about private actors doing that but I think all of my full criticisms of musk can be seen pretty much in a video that where we talk about them in particular the last one that I posted that examined some of the SpaceX claims of the missions finances this video doesn't

37:34answer a lot of the questions that I had that I was hoping that it did the financials aren't still on super clear it almost sounds like if you took his him at his word he's just hoping to coast on NASA money until well who knows he mentions that this system will be cheaper by orders of magnitude but doesn't really explain where those orders magnitude come from or where the numbers of the courts comes from and again I get it this isn't supposed to be taken I represent seriously this isn't a thesis this is marketing at its best it's fantastic I'm excited for it I the first time I watch this through I was I was caught up in it I felt the same with

38:14all of you guys but upon examination I have a lot of questions that I don't think of being answered well that's it hopefully you guys enjoyed that all you hated it and you'll let me know I'm sure either way we'll be back to our regular regularly scheduled episodes in the next week or two I really enjoy doing this

38:35sort of video deconstruction and I just want to say thank you guys for tuning in as always our videos videos our podcast everything comes to you courtesy if everyone's importance on peut ronak our condolence for disney co chrome and all of our supporters on there constantly helping out and telling us what they want from the show recently we're starting to push for more user requested contact so you can get yourself over there and voting some the holes we're gonna have up about what subjects will guest you want to see I really want to start giving you guys a little more control on to show voice has been running for a long time now and I'm really proud of it and it's mainly you

39:14guys it's one hundred percent you guys don't know about mainly it's a hundred percent thanks to all the support that I get from all of you even if you're not a patronage to get fantastic thank you for watching the show thank you for listening to us as always you can contact me at voices from l5 at gmail com or now you can go to voices from l5 dot space and check out our new website that's all for me for now thank you very much and goodbye

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份