访谈·中文精读

沃尔特·艾萨克森对话迈克尔·刘易斯:马斯克

Walter Isaacson in Conversation with Michael Lewis: Elon Musk

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

两个新奥尔良人在台上互相拆台。沃尔特·艾萨克森(Walter Isaacson)说,五年级的时候他是学生会主席,当年的老师和校长看见他俩现在的合影,会指着他说"嗯,这很合理",然后指着迈克尔·刘易斯说"他没戏"。刘易斯接过话头:确实,他们会这么说,而且他们错了。

两人都出自新奥尔良的伊西多尔·纽曼学校(Isidore Newman School)。这所 1903 年创办、最初是犹太孤儿手工培训中心的学校,后来成了 NFL 四分卫生产线,中间还顺带培养出几个作家。这一晚在 92NY 的台上,刘易斯是采访者,艾萨克森带着他的新书《埃隆·马斯克传》来的。

刘易斯一开口就把两人的处境摆平了:三周后他也要出一本书,写的是萨姆·班克曼-弗里德(Sam Bankman-Fried)。

我们俩都跟一个失控的角色经历了一场狂野的旅程,我们俩都有很多要解释的。(Michael Lewis)

一本书的难度系数,和那张后脑勺照片

刘易斯拿到书的时间很晚,三天半前才送到门口,那天早上刚读完。他说这是艾萨克森最好的一本,理由是难度系数。

他打了个比方:评判写作像评判奥运跳水,不只看完成得漂亮不漂亮,还要看动作的难度。翻三周半然后干净入水,比直挺挺跳下去溅一身水要强。这本书的难度系数极高,而且他一眼就看出高在哪里。书里有一张照片,马斯克第一天走进推特总部,画面边缘就是艾萨克森,只有一个后脑勺,标准的"墙上苍蝇"。

刘易斯把这个观察推进了一层。我们活在一个即时审判的年代,人们炫耀自己的快速判断,群体情绪几分钟就能聚起来。要在六百页里维持一种不审判的姿态,极难。而马斯克偏偏是全世界每个人都有意见的人。

结果艾萨克森写完了,读者合上书,仍然说不清作者本人怎么看他。刘易斯说,写乔布斯那本也是这样,有人读完说"我恨史蒂夫·乔布斯",有人说"我爱史蒂夫·乔布斯",而作者做的事情只是把故事讲好。

艾萨克森认下这个方法论,还搬出了两人共同的文学源头:T. 哈里·威廉姆斯写的休伊·朗传记。开头一段讲休伊·朗跑到天主教徒聚居的南路易斯安那演讲,说自己怎么套马、怎么带天主教祖母去教堂。事后竞选经理问他,你怎么从没提过你有个天主教祖母。他回答:见鬼,我们连马都没有。

读者看到这个段子会笑,然后自己判断,这个人是流氓、是骗子,还是天才。艾萨克森说他就想用这种方式写马斯克。

"你不能看书稿",他答应了

书是怎么来的,起点特别普通。特斯拉董事安东尼奥·格拉西亚斯(Antonio Gracias)跟艾萨克森说,你得写马斯克。艾萨克森说那我跟他聊聊。

某天下午在萨格港,两人通了九十分钟电话。艾萨克森把条件摆上桌:不做五次十次二十次的采访,他要跟在旁边,看这个人从早到晚在干什么。午餐、晚餐、深夜、产线,他都想在场。另一个条件是,你完全没有控制权,不能删,不能改,书稿不给你看。

马斯克全部接受。

接下来一年半的时间里,艾萨克森每个月去一个星期左右,拎着一个过夜包,因为永远不知道下一站去哪。马斯克说"我在星舰发射场",他就飞博卡奇卡(Boca Chica),德州最南端的那个尖角。那里的住所是马斯克唯一的一套房,两居室,他原本的五套豪宅都卖了,因为女儿嫌他是亿万富翁。艾萨克森就住在旁边一辆清风房车(Airstream)里。

深夜马斯克说一句"得去加州弗里蒙特",他就跟着上飞机。待够一周十天,他拖着身子回新奥尔良,洗澡换衣服,去杜兰大学上课,然后再飞出去。

马斯克几乎不跟他互动。他自己说过,他在自闭症谱系上,用他的词叫阿斯伯格。他对周围人的存在没有感知,也不会做那种"来,我给你看看这个"的社交动作。他就干自己的活,艾萨克森站在旁边记笔记。

艾萨克森原本担心海森堡原理:观察会改变被观察者。他说他问过身边人,所有人都希望这是真的,可惜不是。你在场的时候,他照样残酷。

刘易斯追问,他有没有问过你在干什么、能不能别写这段。答案是从来没有。艾萨克森倒是主动给特斯拉的人打过电话,问书里写到那个两万五千美元的全球车型和自动驾驶方案,会不会有麻烦。对方耸耸肩:他让你进的会。

书出版后特斯拉股价涨了一大截。刘易斯说,那一天《纽约邮报》登了两版,他自己都不知道自己写了那么多。

那个被父亲训了九十分钟的孩子

书从童年开始,刘易斯用的词是"一记耳光"。

马斯克在南非长大,瘦小、社交笨拙,被送去荒野营(Wilderness Camp)就挨揍。几年后他再去,人长开了,他说他学会了一件事:往对方鼻子上狠狠地揍回去,哪怕自己正在挨打。艾萨克森说,这是他后来所有行为的隐喻,包括在 X 上。

更狠的一次在学校。他被人推下混凝土台阶,脸被砸烂,住院一周左右。回到家,他站在父亲面前被训了九十分钟。那位父亲是杰基尔博士与海德先生的合体,转入黑暗模式以后,骂儿子愚蠢、软弱,还站到打人者那一边。

父母那时已经分开,他跟着父亲生活。艾萨克森说,那些前妻和前女友有一个共识:马斯克把爱和痛苦绑在了一起,因为保护我、爱我的人,恰恰是让我痛的人。

这个诊断几乎是所有人共同给出的。格莱姆斯(Grimes)说他的童年创伤太深,所以他只要一进入爱情,就进入戏剧。安柏·赫德(Amber Heard)也是这个模式。唯一一个艾萨克森觉得真正适合他的人,是塔卢拉·莱莉(Talulah Riley),他娶了两次。问题在于,她身上没有那种风暴。

刘易斯问,那他是不是热烈地爱上几个月,然后腻了。艾萨克森说不是腻,他会一遍遍把最初那几个月重演,但每次分手都伴随着剧烈的动荡。他说自己之所以知道,是因为那些吵架他就在旁边,声音很大,他躲不开。

四分钟沉默,换来的是什么

刘易斯问了一个技术性问题:你怎么进到一个人的生活里?

艾萨克森的回答是,他不填沉默。他是安静的观察者。这一招是在新奥尔良当记者时学的,那时他发现,普通人沉默三十秒就忍不住要说话。马斯克可以沉默,他就熬着,能熬四分钟。四分钟很长。然后马斯克会用一种毫无起伏的语调,像旁边根本没有人一样,一路讲下去。

只有聊到父亲的时候不一样。他会绷紧,会安静,有时候会眼泪上来。

贾斯汀(Justine,第一任妻子)和塔卢拉都讲过同一个场景:压力最大的那几年,火箭要炸、公司要破产,他在深夜呕吐,塔卢拉扶着他的头。而他在那种时候会开始复述父亲当年对他说过的话。

刘易斯顺势问出那个更大的问题:把这段童年拿掉,换成一个像我们俩一样幸福的童年,会怎么样。

艾萨克森没有直接下结论,他举了一串例子。爱因斯坦在德国做犹太人长大,不快乐。达芬奇是私生子,父亲不肯给他合法身份,左撇子、同性恋、注意力涣散,从芬奇村走到佛罗伦萨,到死还在画洪水。乔布斯被领养,第一对领养家庭没接受他,他觉得自己被抛弃又被选中。

他引了奥巴马回忆录里的那句话:每一个成功的人,要么在努力达到父亲的期望,要么在努力摆脱父亲的罪。而马斯克两样都占。

他和刘易斯都承认,自己属于另一类人:从小的环境聪明、友善、有点魔幻,长大以后变成世界的观察者,不去修什么,也不去炸什么。艾萨克森说他从没试过把火箭送上火星。问题悬在那里:想改变世界,是不是必须被心魔驱动。

十七岁逃跑,和一条二十二年后才走完的路

马斯克逃走了。十七岁,和本·富兰克林、爱因斯坦一样。

他离开暴力的南非,先去加拿大,身上大约四千美元,然后去宾夕法尼亚大学,再去硅谷。第一家公司 Zip2,做的是谷歌地图之前的地图服务。第二家叫 X.com,一个支付应用,还带社交网络功能。它后来变成 PayPal,把他踢了出去。

他想让公司继续叫 X.com,他想把它做成一个什么都装得下的应用(everything app)。这个执念跟了他二十二年,最后把他推到推特门口。

两次创业成功,他手里有过亿美元。刘易斯的问法是:什么时候人们开始发现这个人和别人不一样。

艾萨克森的答案在 PayPal 黑帮身上。那批人回忆,一旦他手里有了几亿美元,他没有买岛、没有买游艇,而是把所有筹码推去造火箭。彼得·蒂尔(Peter Thiel)的说法是,大多数伟大的创业者懂得计算风险,马斯克不一样,他对风险上瘾。他愿意把下一个东西看得和已有的东西一样值钱。

这就是他和普通富豪的分水岭,也是他后来会去买推特的底层性格。

买推特,五个理由里最私人的那个

刘易斯问,一个已经在做电动车、火箭、脑机接口、隧道,忙着把人类送上多行星的人,为什么非要买一个社交平台。

艾萨克森给了五个理由,他全都跟马斯克本人对过,书里也都写了。

第一条来自他妻子凯西的洞察。马斯克小时候在操场上一直被打,世界最大的操场就是推特,他可以把它买下来,自己当那个霸凌者。

第二条是 x.com 那个没做完的梦。他说过,推特可以当加速器。

第三条有点荒诞:钱在口袋里烧。伊丽莎白·沃伦说他税交得太少,他一气之下行使了一百亿美元的期权,交了人类历史上最大的一笔税,手上还剩一百亿。他的原话大意是,我拿这些钱干什么,我对推特上瘾,那就买吧。

第四条最复杂,也最难写。他最年长的孩子叫泽维尔(Xavier),名字取自他最喜欢的《X 战警》。这个字母从 SpaceX 一路用到 X。三年前孩子十六岁,完成性别转换,他能接受。但孩子同时变成了自认的马克思主义者,痛恨亿万富翁。他因此卖掉了全部五套房子。孩子还是彻底拒绝了他,改名,不跟他说话。

他崩了。他和孩子的关系对他极其重要,这一点本身有点奇怪,因为他对外人根本没有这种情感,原因还是他父亲没给过他。他认定是"进步派觉醒思想病毒"(progressive woke mind virus)感染了他的孩子。别人问这个词什么意思,他的回答是:别担心,埃隆知道它什么意思。

第五条和第四条连着。他认为推特也变成了进步派的大本营,把言论的口子收窄了。你不能质疑病毒是不是实验室泄漏,不能质疑封控和口罩令,批评防疫政策的杰伊·巴塔查里亚(Jay Bhattacharya)那批人被踢出了平台。

这些黑色的东西在他脑子里嗡嗡响。他刚过完人生最好的一年,口袋里有上千亿美元,然后开始偷偷买推特股票。

红牛加安必恩,凌晨五点半按下发送

2022 年 4 月,他手上的股份到了 9.9%,推特给了他一个董事席位,附带一份停滞协议(standstill agreement)。

他翻了。他觉得帕拉格·阿格拉瓦尔(Parag Agrawal)和杰克·多西什么都没干,视频没做,支付没做。他飞去夏威夷拉里·埃里森(Larry Ellison)的住处,同行的是一位澳大利亚女演员娜塔莎·巴塞特(Natasha Basset),连着三个晚上喝红牛、吃安必恩,在短信里跟阿格拉瓦尔对骂,这些短信全在书里。

刘易斯听到这里打断了:为什么要把红牛和安必恩一起吃。

艾萨克森说他问过。他搞不懂这人是想睡还是想醒。马斯克的回答是:它给我翅膀。

第三晚他决定不要那个董事席位,直接转恶意收购。阿格拉瓦尔在那边说等等、我们谈谈,他把人切断,飞去温哥华,因为格莱姆斯在那儿,要带小 X 去见外祖父母。

温哥华之后是 TED 大会,克里斯·安德森就在现场。晚宴结束,他和格莱姆斯打《艾尔登法环》打到凌晨五点半。通关最后一层地狱,他按下发送,内容是"我提出了要约"。

这里还有个插曲。班克曼-弗里德在书里客串了一下,他想投资,或者把自己的股份换成推特股份,两个人互相觉得对方疯了。刘易斯说,SBF 跟他讲过一句最不可思议的话:他管马斯克叫"怪人"。一个被全世界叫怪人的人,管别人叫怪人。

刘易斯问得直接:他适合拥有推特吗。

艾萨克森说,他适合当工程师,懂材料学,看产线一眼就知道问题在哪。但他对人跟人之间的情绪没有手感。马斯克的逻辑是,推特是一家科技公司,把技术修好就行。艾萨克森在书里写了自己的判断:推特不是科技公司,它是一个广告媒介,聚拢眼球,营造一个让人愿意投放品牌的温和环境。

当时马斯克不懂这个。现在他懂了,因为广告收入掉了六成。

他不懂推特,但他懂产线

刘易斯把话题转向马斯克真正擅长的部分,顺手做了一个对照:读乔布斯那本书,你会很清楚乔布斯强在哪。他会走进乔尼·艾维(Jony Ive)的设计工作室,用手感受手机边框的倒角,想象手指从下面划过去是什么感觉。

马斯克也做类似的事,场景换成了产线。他在博卡奇卡、奥斯汀、弗里蒙特、洛杉矶走线,一步一道工序地看。他让设计师把桌子搬到产线边上,弗朗茨·冯·霍尔茨豪森(Franz von Holzhausen)那批人就在那儿办公。如果某个漂亮的倒角或者雨刮液的设计卡住了产线,当场就要改。

他的说法是:美国人不再那么会创新,原因之一是制造外包了,每天那个"怎么造得更好、怎么设计得更好"的迭代过程没了。

刘易斯问他会不会用艺术史的办法做比较,把两张画挂在一起看差异,乔布斯和马斯克各占一边。

先讲共同点:两个人都带着现实扭曲力场。有人说做不到,他们就面无表情地看着你,说你能做到,然后逼着你做。他们的直觉判断在九成情况下是对的,而被他们逼的人,通常比他们更懂技术。

乔布斯让 Macintosh 团队把开机时间砍掉二十秒,工程师说不可能,你不懂写代码。一周以后做完了。马斯克一天要这么干七次八次:这个工位要九十秒,下周降不到四十五秒,就接受你的辞呈。这是他表达"请你离开"的客气说法。

而他手里的直觉是有根据的。第一性原理那套东西:第一次做火箭,别人报价,他说我知道原材料多少钱、燃料多少钱,我知道可以做到多少。他给工程团队的方法论是三步:质疑每一条需求,删掉每一个能删的零件,然后才开始自动化。这套东西在特斯拉和 SpaceX 都跑通了。

乔布斯有魅力,他没有,也不在乎

差异在哪。刘易斯问得更刁:谁更可爱。

艾萨克森说,两个人都有本事让人穿墙。扛下来的人会变得忠诚,格温·肖特韦尔(Gwen Shotwell)在 SpaceX 干了二十年,苹果那边埃迪·库伊、菲尔·席勒也一样。扛不住的当场走人。

但乔布斯身上有种精神性的东西,他愿意的时候,能和人建立极强的情感连接。艾萨克森讲了个例子:有一回他要带妻子凯西一起去,提前给乔布斯发消息说凯西同行。乔布斯回:带她来吃饭,我很想见。

艾萨克森赶紧给妻子打预防针:你要是说一句"今天 101 公路风景真好",他会回你"今天天气一点都不好"。

结果那顿饭吃完,凯西说,你完全错了,这是我见过最有魅力、最温柔的男人。

马斯克不会这个。他不会,也不在乎,压根不会去做。

再往下一层,是富兰克林那个对比。有人问艾萨克森,富兰克林会怎么看马斯克。他的回答是,富兰克林是反面。富兰克林太在意把人拉到一起,太在意别人喜不喜欢自己。约翰·亚当斯骂他"讨好献媚",那是贬义。杰斐逊和亚当斯闹翻,富兰克林去缝合。他的超能力是深共情。

马斯克的超能力,恰恰是不在乎这些,只在乎使命。

恶魔模式,格莱姆斯比他早二十秒察觉

刘易斯问了一个所有人都想知道的问题:你觉得他是好人吗。

艾萨克森说"好"这个字不在马斯克词汇表的前一千名里,这个词对他太温和了。他更愿意说,马斯克有好几个版本。

搞笑版、迷人版,在一起特别有意思。激励版,讲人类未来,你会被彻底迷住。工程版,你看着他拆解问题,会忘记时间。然后是恶魔版。

恶魔版来的时候,有一次吃饭,格莱姆斯、几个朋友在场,马斯克因为一堆事正在上头,气氛还算愉快。格莱姆斯凑到艾萨克森耳边说了句"恶魔模式"。他说那感觉像在新奥尔良上城,气压突然降下来,你知道暴雨要来了。格莱姆斯比他早二十秒感觉到。马斯克的眼神发直,进入一种恍惚状态,然后整整一个小时,极其残酷。

刘易斯问他有没有对你开过火。没有。艾萨克森说所有人都警告他"他早晚会对你开火",但一次都没有。他自己的解释是,他始终站在六步之外,从不介入,从不给建议,从不填沉默。他管那玩意儿叫火焰喷射器,喷了所有人,就是没喷他。

所以回到"好人"这个问题,他的答案拆成两半。

对身边那六七个人,他大部分时候都不好。他走进推特,所有人都在讲心理安全、讲关怀,他说不行,我们硬核,心理安全是激烈进步的敌人。他不会坐下来想"我得让这些人开心"。

但他对人类有很深的在意。让文明转向可持续能源,让人类成为多行星物种,挡住可能失控的人工智能。这些使命来自那个坐在角落里看超级英雄漫画的小孩。他做事的动力不是钱,也不是权力,更不是踩人。

所以答案是:使命是善的,执行的时候会碾过桌上的人。

那一夜,乌克兰的无人艇冲上了岸

刘易斯把问题推到最尖锐的地方:他是世界首富,控制一家社交平台,拥有最大的卫星网络,他对世界稳定构成什么风险。

艾萨克森先说了一句自己的判断:他现在权力确实太大了。

然后是星链那段。俄罗斯入侵乌克兰的第一晚,所有卫星通信被打掉,包括军方用的 ViaSat。能用的只有星链。为什么?因为他把星链做成了抗干扰、抗攻击的,而美国国防情报局没做到,波音也没做到。

再往上一个层次:美国的情报和军事卫星,尤其是要进高轨的那些,NASA 自己发不上去,波音发不上去,全靠 SpaceX。这件事落到一家私企手里,本身就很惊人。

星链救了乌克兰,这是真的。但后来出了一件事。乌方用星链操控无人潜航器,没跟他说,目标是克里米亚的俄罗斯舰队。

那天艾萨克森正在看纽曼高中的橄榄球赛,看阿奇·曼宁打球,手机一直响。他走到看台后面接。马斯克在电话里说,这会引发第三次世界大战,这是世界末日。

那一晚乌克兰的部长们一直在要求开启覆盖,短信都在书里。艾萨克森没有给建议,只问了一句:你跟杰克·沙利文谈过吗,跟参谋长联席会议主席马克·米利谈过吗,他们知道吗。答案是知道。

后来马斯克公开说过,如果美国政府要求他开启,他会开。艾萨克森说他无法证实这句话,只知道自己当时看到的情况。

这件事的结果是,他把星链的终端和服务直接卖给美国军方,由军方决定服务条款。起初是他和格温·肖特韦尔主动去问军方:你们是不是该有一点这个。

他跟艾萨克森说过一句话,书里也有:我为什么卷进这场战争。我们做星链,是为了让人躺着看 Netflix、打游戏。

一个人手里握着太多东西

刘易斯问,美国怎么把自己从马斯克手里拿回来。

艾萨克森的回答有点出人意料:让波音、诺斯罗普·格鲁曼这些公司重新能干活。他举了充电网络的例子。特斯拉建了一整套充电网,美国政府出钱让通用建自己的,最后通用放弃了,因为特斯拉那套好用。

他说这话不是替马斯克唱赞歌。他的立场很明确:不该让任何人,尤其是一个他委婉称为"反复无常"的人,握着这么大的筹码。应该有竞争者。

而竞争为什么消失了,马斯克自己的解释是:美国曾经是个冒险者的国家。不管是从五月花号来的,还是从格兰德河蹚过来的,来的人都是敢冒险的。现在裁判比冒险者多,监管者比创新者多,说"你不行"的人比动手的人多。结果是大军工企业什么都干不成,高铁也修不出来。

没有结局的传记

刘易斯问了一个写作者才懂的问题:这个人物还在往前走,你怎么收尾。

艾萨克森说他最后问自己:故事讲够了吗。他已经写了 xAI 的创办,写了星舰发射,写了推特改名 X。三年后如果他又搞出一个全球车型,或者又买了什么公司,读者应该已经能理解他会怎么想、会怎么做。他不需要再加一章,也不需要把书一直开着。

写这本书的过程中,他还被叫去奥斯汀一次。马斯克说有事要当面讲,电话里不说,是又要创办一家 AI 公司。艾萨克森的反应是:你已经在管六家了,现在要开第七家。

马斯克的回答,基本上就是他这个人的说明书:我总是把筹码推回桌子中央。

写给读完这场对谈的人

两个传记作者在台上聊了九十分钟,最后落在一个很朴素的方法论上:把判断留給读者。这件事对写作者有用,对读传记的人同样有用。

  • 读这本书之前,先承认自己已经对马斯克有立场。艾萨克森的办法是站在六步之外,读者也可以试试先站远一点,看完再回到自己的立场。
  • 关注"恶魔模式"出现的条件,而不是它出现的次数。压力、被质疑、被否定、涉及父亲、涉及孩子,这几个触发器反复出现,你可以用它们预测他下一次会在哪儿失控。
  • 把"他是不是好人"换成"他的使命是什么,执行代价由谁承担"。这个问题有答案,前一个没有。代价通常由离他最近的六七个人支付。
  • 看他的方法论,而不是他的结论。质疑每一条需求、删掉每一个能删的零件、然后才自动化,这套三步法可以直接搬到自己团队的项目上试一遍。
  • 如果要判断一家公司该不该由一个强人掌控,把"他多能干"和"他多不可预测"分开算。艾萨克森对星链的担心,落在后一项上。
  • 看到一个制度性问题时,先问竞争者去哪儿了。充电网络、火箭发射、卫星通信,问题都不在某个人太强,在没人能顶上来。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:12thank you so when I was in the fifth grade I don't want to hear this story again at the Isidor Newman School Walter isacon was the president of the student body MH and if you'd ask if you'd shown any of the teachers or administrators then the picture of us on stage now they had looked at Walter and said yeah that's about right and they had looked at me and said there's no chance he's up yeah right right right that's exactly what they would have said and they were wrong they were and the isor Numa school which started out in 1903 as a manual Training Center for Jewish orphans MH and it has gone on to be a factory for All Pro quarterbacks in the NFL but in between has

1:02generated a couple of writers well it was good that Eli and pton went there because Michael and I didn't have to worry about who were the famous Newman grad we were like agot type also from Newman but but there's there'll be a New Orleans theme a bit to this I think this conversation and very you know oddly and coincidentally you're publishing this book about Elon Musk three weeks before I publish a book with Sam bankman freed in the in the we both had Wild rides with a rogue character we both have a lot of explaining to do yeah exactly when did you figure out your character was going [Laughter] rogue let's talk about that but you know so let's this is this is mainly this is

1:47your debutant party not mine and and I wanted to so the the book I this thing landed on my doorstep three and a half days ago and I have now I read it but I had to read it fast I had thought very much about how to frame a conversation I finished it this morning I was blown away thank you I was blown away and let me see if I can articulate why I was blown away it's it's I it is I think my favorite of your books I think if you I one way I judge my writing is like Olympic Dives it's like not just quality of the execution but degree of difficulty like but yeah if it's a triple flip with a splash it's better than if it's a you know just jumping in

2:28and it doesn't Splash and and the degree of difficulty was extremely high and it was it was obvious to me over the last few years when we've spoken that the degree of difficulty for you was high and you know and I thought let me just find when I got I got to a page when I thought yeah that's why the degree of difficulty is high but there's a page in here here it is right here there's a pictures and in

2:54this picture of el el musk going into Twitter is Walter Isaacson you're there you're Fly the back of my head you're Fly you're fly on the wall and you you've had living subjects before people have been say oh this is hard for you because you don't your first biography was about Kissinger yeah I know so tell me about it yeah but but but you you the fly the your participation really in his life for the last few years change the tenor of the book and I'm going to let you speak eventually okay give me just a sec I'm perfectly happy okay you just but I'm giving you a little break here and then it's going to be your show but the thing that was so interesting to me

3:34because it's a problem that I've had to Grapple with is that we live in a we live now right now in a world of instant judgment yeah we live in a world where people celebrate their own quick judgments snap judgments mob mob sentiment forms very quickly it's very hard to preserve an absence of judgment a feeling of an absence of judgment and you have a character about whom the world is judgmental there isn't anybody in this room on the planet who doesn't have an opinion about Elon Musk and you who may know him better than anybody in the world now managed to write 600 pages and I actually don't know exactly what you think of him I learned all kinds of

4:15things about him but you've written a roar shot test that people going to come to it and they're going to have your readers are going to have such a range of response to it because youve just laid him out beautifully well you know it was that way with Steve Jobs too I mean some people they'd finish the book I remember being here and they'd come up afterwards and they' sayi finished your book and and I could look at it and they could sayi hate Steve Jobs or I I love Steve Jobs and what you do and what some of us do from Louisiana is say just let me tell you a story and you make it a narrative story and you make it really colorful and the people can form their

4:54own judgments from it now in the end I think you're going to anybody will have pretty strong reactions in a lot of judgments but I do try to get out of the way of what is an amazing story there's a wonderful T Harry Williams you and I grew up with the first great biography either of us read of Huey Long it just begins with a paragraph of Huey Long going down to South Louisana where it's Catholic and saying on the stump because he's from North Louisiana oh and then I had to hook up our horse and take my Catholic grandmother to church and one of his campaign managers afterward says he you never told us you had a Catholic grandmother he said hell we

5:31didn't even have a horse and you just get that anecdote and you laugh but T Harry Williams lets you build your own is this a rogue is this a liar is this and I really tried to do that with musk yeah you and you did do it with him the hey we're g I want to follow the Louisiana thread but I want to come back to it later okay I want to know I want to know the story sort of behind the book like how this happens and how your relationship with him develops so just tell us a little bit how you come to Elon Musk as a subject yeah I I was kicking around for some ideas and a mutual friend of musk and mine said

6:13you really got to do who is that Antonio graus he's on the board of Tesla and he was on the board of The aspiran Institute so nice guy and he said you got to do mosque I said well I'll talk to him and one day one afternoon we were actually out in Sag Harbor and had a 90minut conversation with them we got on the phone and I said if I do this book I don't want to do it based on five or 10 interviews or 20 interviews I just want to be by your side as you saw in that picture just watching you day and night at breakfast L well he doesn't eat breakfast but lunch dinner late night walk in the factory lines and the other

6:55criteria is you have no control over the book nothing's off you have no control you don't get to read it and he's probably still has he read it yet I don't know he says jokingly Walter told me I couldn't read it so not that I trust everything but at least he pretends he hasn't read right so so so when the subject is first suggested to you Elon Musk what is your instant so I'm thinking man that's a great idea here's a person cuz I love technology creativity people who break rules and innovate right you know the think different type thing and here's a guy who brought us into the a of electric vehicles had just had Tesla go almost bankrupt at the beginning of 2019 but

7:39then become more valuable than all the other car companies in the world combined a million cars brings us into the era of solar Roes with batteries the only person who can shoot off rockets and get things to orbit and have the boosters land is that true he's the only one who's done that nobody China hasn't done it the US hasn't done it Boeing hasn't done it he's the only person who's been able to do reusable Rockets he's put up 5,000 satellites recreated the internet in low earth orbit and I said man this is everything and then about a year into riding along with him everything's going well I say man you know this has been a pretty good year

8:20you've the richest person Earth you're times person of the year you've done all these things you're going to relax and he said that he was secretly buying shares of Twitter I went oh this is not going to end well this movie and so that's the Pivot Point yeah so but I want you to back up because because you don't know this person you you're introduced to him you tell him your terms he accepts the terms yeah where does the relationship go then how do you start to enter into his life I don't fill his silences I'm a quiet Observer physically where are phally you're teaching a class at at tulan un no but one week or two I got a lot of my students here so a round of applause for

9:00all my two lane students and your son is going to go to two lane which we like too so you probably haven't told tabith of that right I reveal we have a son who's a junior he hasn't decided so what I do is I'm always by a side taking notes and I try very carefully just to be the Observer I definitely don't F his silences he almost doesn't notice me by the end because he gets into demon mode sometimes where he is just a total jerk it actually there's a technical term that begins with a but he is like we and it's like I'm sitting there how can you and I was worried about the Heisenberg Principle that my observation would change the subject but you know people

9:49said I wish that was the case but he's just as brutal when you're watching as any other time and so about a week or so per month I would just go and i' say where are you wherever he and he would say I'm at the gig I'm at Bach chica in the tip of Texas at the star ship launch pad I'd go there I'd have a little overnight bag because you never knew where you're going and for about a week you know he'd say late at night he'd said okay we we we got to get to Fremont in California and he had a plane obviously and I would just tag along and after about a week or 10 days I'd straggle back to New Orleans shower change clothes teach the classes and then go back out again and what was his

10:34attitude toward you from in the beginning like how did he handle you he's not he is very he he talks about being on the autism disort of spectrum Asbergers he calls it and he is very unaware of other people around him and makes no mo emotional connection so I could just be sitting there or walking the fact reine with him and he wouldn't do things like oh here let me show you this whatever he would just be doing his work and I'd be standing there and you should so you you could just you could move into his life and it didn't totally at the time I mean he had I knew more about him than he knew about him yeah know including he was then having children with both Grimes and

11:21sioban right and I was in the midst of that let's pause it you know this is it this I don't want to just skip over this because I'm trying to get rapidly get back to the factory we get we can get to the Rockets and the cars and the boring company and all that but it's his love life is spectacular I mean it's an amazing thing and and it's even more amazing to me that all of his past loves

11:48seem to be or almost all of them seem to be wide open in talking to you about him oh especially yeah his wives in particular he's did he say to everybody just talk to this guy I guess because they all nobody said no nobody there's not what there isn't that surprised me in the story there's no sense of other people's fear of him in talking to you no they say including his mother his brother they all just his father father his father yeah we'll get there at some point yeah but all of his relationships with women or drama driven turmoil because he as grind says as

12:30Clare bue the artist known as gri says he had such a traumatic childhood that he Associates love with trauma and drama and so he's always stirring up drama so the minute he's in love he's in drama Amber herd type thing I mean Amber being one of them and who i' talk to and but the only one who I I just really like who was perfect for him was to Riley clearly married her twice and the problem is she just wasn't storm and Dr right is the pattern that he would

13:07fall dramatically in love and then after a couple of months get bored that's what that's what it kind of read like no cuz he keeps recycling back to he creates the first couple of months over and over yeah but there's always a turmoil to mous breakup you know huge look I know he wasn't noticing me because I was there for huge loud fights right yeah so

13:33so so you're moving in you're moving you get to his like you get to a point where you're in his life invisible well you know even when we're down in Bach chica which is the most interesting place compar you know which is this Tip of Texas place where they have the Launchpad for so he has the only home he has because his daughter rejected him because he's a billionaire and so he sold all of his houses has a two-bedroom home there and I had an air stream trailer right there and I don't know if you've stayed in an Airstream for four or five days but it's kind of fun and you just sort of watch do at any point did he ask you what you were doing or why you were doing it or could you do

14:14it this way or could you leave this out no he never did and I had to talk to Kathy and others my wife about some self things amongst them children under the age of 17 without their permission if it was something bad other than he was letting you you had to you had to be the filter cuz he wasn't and some ways they were calling me sometimes too right the other one was I was careful and maybe went a little too far but he doesn't seem to be mad about it about insid or information in other words I knew because I was in the meeting when he secretly decided that they're going to build a $25,000 cheap Global car that's going to transform Tesla and they're also going to do it on the same

15:02platform as a robo taxi I was worried and likewise about four months ago he decided to use artificial intelligence to totally revise how they're doing self-driving so it's done by imitating humans through video learning as as opposed to swallowing the lines of yeah swapping the lines of code yeah you're right and I'm thinking all right that's maybe proprietary information I did quietly check with a couple people at Tesla about you know how much trouble that could be and they Shrugged they said he let you in the meeting was there stuff in the book that would move stock prices it did oh it did yeah I didn't realize that yeah I mean I won't go too

15:46deep in that but Tesla went way up oh no when the book came out oh oh because of the global the global car which they think is huge as like a be a you know there's so much news in fire hose of news in the book that's the most amazing thing did you see the New York Post today I haven't finished it yet like two pages I said I didn't know I'd written all that all right I'm not going to worry this to death about you and him but it it's an interesting subject to me that it's there's there's an un a little bit of an undercurrent criticism of both you and me in with our subjects this time round that the price of having

16:29access the price of being so correct and it's a really interesting topic is it I mean I wanted to I mean I it's an interesting topic to to I I find it a problematic topic but I'm curious what you think of this kind of line of criticism well you it comes only from journalists by the way who don't have access they don't have access but that's but who who actually journalists who no one would want to hang around with which doesn't include you it may but one of the things that I had to keep in mind is

17:01it isn't about him or what he thinks right the reader is your only client that's right this paragraph goes in because it's going to help the reader or you never say how is this person going to react but for me it was kind of easy because this guy just didn't seem to care he wouldn't care he wouldn't care I don't think he cares now right and so I knew actually I don't want to lie I want to see this there was a part of me that said okay he may go ballistic what's what's it going to be like when he's like sicking his Fanboys on Twitter on me but I I thought okay I don't need to be his friend or whatever the rest so I kept trying to say it's only about the

17:40reader it's only about the reader and I never felt that he was going to kick me out because of what I was doing so it was not like writing about even Steve Jobs who really you had emotional connection he really cared Etc this guy didn't seem to care like all right now we're going to go you know to whatever him you can't wound him I think

18:10that he actually love he said I love pain I thought well that I can inflict some of that yeah yeah he said you know in my childhood it was all psychological pain my father yeah talk about this he was sent to Wilderness Camp you know when he was a young kid in South Africa and he gets beaten up because he's scrawny and socially awkward put it mildly and but the second time he goes a few years later he's grown up a bit he know he said I just learned to punch people really hard in the nose even if they were beating me up and that helped which is a metaphor for everything it does including on X and things but he gets beaten up once on the playground so badly at school pushed

18:57down the concrete St STS with his brother there and they smash his face and he says he was in the hospital for a week I think it was probably four or five days he gets home and he has a stand in front of his father for 90 minutes who is a Jackel and Hyde character who's gone into dark mode and berates Elon for being stupid for being a weakling and takes the side of the person who beat him up so the demons from that and the feeling and his parents were split and he was you know being raised by this father the feelings of love and the

19:34person protecting me causes me pain is what every single one of his Ex-Wives and girlfriends says is the key to him and how does he respond to that analysis he starts to get very te out the only times it's hard to get him to talk is when you say let's talk about your father again and boy he goes really silent and sometimes he tears up the interesting thing that I learned and I first learned it on the times pikun when I was a journalist down in New Orleans is if somebody goes silent most

20:09of us want to fill the silences we want to say something it's like you wait 30 seconds you got to say something he would go silent and I would Outlast him for four minutes or so that's a really long time and then suddenly in a monotone as if I were not there he would just drone on and his both Justine his first wife and Tula said late at night when he had so much pressure on him everything was going bankrupt the Rockets going he's energized by the pain but he's also vomiting in the bathroom and Lula's holding his head and said when that happened he would Channel things his father said to him so that's the key to the demons in his head I'm not say

20:55anything we sit here silently do you stop talking well so so how do you think of this I mean you open the book with his childhood and it's shocking the the the childhood is shocking it's a slap in the face to the reader almost you do this for a reason do you think like you remove that childhood or you make it a more more like our childhoods a happy child you know what's interesting about our childhoods because we grew up in a very magical place with parents that were really smart and nice and everything else is I sometimes wonder whether

21:36having a lot of demons from childhood gives you a lot of drives you and I with all due respect to both of us are basically observers in this world of people doing really weird and wild things we're not trying to fix anything we're not trying to blow things up I've never tried to get a rocket to Mars and the question is do you have to be demon driven to want to change I look at every one of my characters Einstein growing up Jewish in Germany not not happy Leonardo he's growing

22:08up illegitimate his father won't legitimate him gay left-handed distracted and he goes from the village of venci to Florence and has even to his deathbed he's still doing the delug drawings he's still tormented and I go down now Steve Jobs adopted and actually rejected by the or are not accepted by the first adopted family you know feels abandoned but chosen so as Obama says

22:37in his Memoirs I think every successful person is either trying to live up to the expectations of his father or live down the sins of his father and in his case he said is both well that's true of Elon but this so this is the ingredient the necessary unhappiness well I don't no you and I had these happy CH and we didn't amount to much it's true but it it's what it is it's true that you and I don't have the impulse to change the world we we are more comfortable like Hawthorne writes about being the detached Observer that's right that's completely true it so so with this

23:15this talk about a little bit of how Elon Musk escapes this like well he runs away at 17 like everybody Ben Franklin runs away at 17 Einstein runs away at 17 right you and I went down to you know some part gr party or something and Einstein's running away his palms are sweating and he escapes by leaving South Africa which has been very violent and comes to Canada at first with about $4,000 and eventually goes to Silicon Valley after going to Penn and starts a couple of companies one is a zip 2 which is like Google Maps but before that and the other is a really really interesting one x.com and it was a financial payments app that also has a social network

24:06attach it becomes PayPal they OU him he wants to keep it called x.com and he wants it to be an everything app right this is what drives him 22 years later to buy Twitter turn it into x.com and make it a payments app at what point in his career or life do people start saying this is a really unusual person who's going to do really unusual things

24:30I think I couldn't figure that out from the story yeah I think his first two companies which are zip 2 and then what we'll call PayPal both are successful and they both make them you can probably remember the numbers like a 100 million or so which is a lot of money yeah and instead of doing buying an island or buying a yacht he wants to keep putting his chips on the table right so with all the pay Mafia that he's having a fight with he decides he wants to send a rocket to Mars and they keep saying what what are you talking about he say well if we don't become a space fairing civilization human consciousness may die out and they say hey bro you you this this is where he

25:15becomes different from everybody correct and this is where everybody Peter teal I talk to him and Reed Hoffman that whole PayPal mafia they say suddenly once he had a couple hundred million he decides to put it all in to trying to get a rocket to Mars so this is a different risk profile than most people Peter teal said that most great entrepreneurs know how to calculate risk yeah and he said musk is different he's addicted to risk yeah that's the difference that he's willing that that the the the next thing is as valuable as what he exactly and he wants to always up the game yeah and now he's still doing it I mean he didn't have to buy Twitter and now after buying

26:00let's talk about that a little bit just since it's it's it's the it's the shocking turn the book The Story the life story takes the business story takes up to then he's had everything he's doing is actually kind of it's It's about moving people through space it's Tesla it's his Rockets it's his yeah Grand epic missions a guy who had read superhero comics too often and they I'm going to bring us into the era of sustainable energy and space travel help me understand why anybody would want to buy Twitter well I you know cuz I watched this from side yeah there are about four or five reasons that I think he wanted to by Twitter and I've talked to him

26:41about all of them and he even discusses them in the book one was an Insight Kathy had which is he was beaten up all the time in the playground always being bullied right and the world's great playground is Twitter and he can own it and be the bully and be the bully and he is yeah secondly he's driven by the unfulfilled vision of x.com and he says I can use this as an accelerant to do it right thirdly he had a lot of money burning a hole in his pocket because he was so resentful at Elizabeth Warren for saying he didn't pay enough taxes that he ends up exercising these options in 10 billion doar and paying more tax than anybody in history has ever paid any

27:22country but still has 10 billion left over he says what do I use all the time I'm addicted to Twitter let me start buying it up and then there's the very complex thing which I have in the book but it was difficult which is his oldest surviving child was named Xavier after his favorite in the X-Men Comics this ex letter is from SpaceX to X is there and at age 16 about three years ago she transitions he gets his head around that but she becomes an absolute Marxist she calls her self and hates billionaires and this

28:02causes him to sell all five of his houses and then but she still totally rejects him takes let you know changes her name and refuses to speak to him and he goes into a tail spin his relationship with his children are really important really important and which it's a little odd that it's important to him because he doesn't have that feeling about other right and it wasn't well because his father didn't have it with him so it's very fraught and he becomes comes convinced both from the attacks from Elizabeth Warren but also the Crossroads School in La which you know pretty well feeling that the progressive woke mind virus as he calls it and people say what do you mean by

28:41that said trust me Elon knows what he means by this Progressive woke mind virus infected my child and now she won't speak to me and he felt that Twitter had also become sort of progressive left and was well it had yeah and it had closed the aperture to some extent on Free Speech now that's a difficult balance you don't want hate speech you don't want disinformation but they were saying you can't question whether it was a lab leak Co and you can't question lockdowns or mask mandates that you know you were Jay bachara the people who ran well the critics of the covid policy all got kicked off of Twitter so these all these dark things are jangling in his head

29:31after he has $1 billion in his pocket and having the greatest year of his life and he starts secretly buying Twitter stock and in April of last year he's gotten about 99.9% and he has you've watched you've been watching this and I'm been sitting there in the mezzanine while his brother is trying to talk him out of it is he asking your advice no he never asked my advice every now and then I say a question question that then he vaguely thinks his advice which is like why are you buying Twitter and he'll say yeah maybe I'm wrong to do it I said no no that was a real question so in

30:10April he's offered a board seat for a stand still agreement right and he gets worked up because he thinks parag agrawal who's running Twitter and Jack dorsy they haven't done anything on they haven't put video on it they haven't made it a payment system and he flies off in a frenzy to Hawaii to Larry Ellison's place on Leni to secretly meet

30:35somebody was dating Natasha Basset a Australian actress and he stays up three nights in a road drinking Red Bull and taking ambian and at about why would you do both together I asked him once I said I couldn't figure out if he was trying to sleep why he's doing Red Bull after doing ambient he said well it gives me wings and I I didn't quite know the followup question like a Wing's a good thing to have at 3 in the morning when you're what color are the wings yeah exactly so on the third night he's having this pissing match really on by text messages all of which in the book against parag your friend Sam bankman freed makes a small Cameo because he

31:24wants to invest or roll over his stock and they both think each other is nuts oh it's in my book I'm sure it's in yours no one of the most amazing sentences Sam bman freed ever uttered to me was when he came off a call with or elon's people he said elon's a weird dude no no it was with Elon personally Sam bankman freed calling someone weird right this you're in rare air so

31:51on the third night he decides he's not going to take the board seat and that he's going to go hostile right and parag going wait wait we got to talk we got to talk and musk shuts him off and then flies to Vancouver because he's having a very complicated relationships because Grimes is in Vancouver and wants to introduce Little X their son to her parents she's from a sentence as no one has ever spoken before in fact I I think Chris Anderson's here had him at the Ted conference there and so he wants to go to the Ted conference but after the dinner with the Ted conference people he plays Elden ring till 5:30 in the morning with Grimes this is a new game

32:33right and at 5:30 when he finishes going through the last layer of Hell in that game he just sends out a message I made an offer and that's when he bought Twitter is he oh that's when he offered is he well suited to owning Twitter no no no no he is a well suited to being an engineer to understand Material Science he's amazing at looking at an assembly lines and how it works but I said you know how does that translate to Twitter cuz he has no emotional feel for human interactions or not a great emotional feel and he said well Twitter's a technology company we just have to fix the technology I don't think I said it to him because I'm not supposed I'm just an observer but I say

33:18it in the book Twitter's not a technology company it's an advertising medium trying to gather eyeballs in a sweet little environment so people can put their brands advertised and he doesn't have that feel does he know he doesn't have that feel now he does because he's lost 60% of his advertising yeah yeah let's let's go to the Cheery part of the story like what he's thought what he what he's good at what what is you know it's funny you read the you read job the jobs book and you get a very clear sense about of what Steve Jobs is is good at Steve would walk around Johnny IES or their Design Studio

33:58and he would feel what he called the chamfer of the phone how is this car and he would compare it to what your fingers would feel if it went under it right dos didn't care that much about design but he would do something similar he would walk the assembly line sometimes they'll two musk would walk the factory lines in

34:17Bach chica in Austin in Fremont in LA and he would watch each step of the assembly and he made his designers his Johnny I people FR France van Holz Housen the other designers have their desks right on the assembl line so if they designed some beautiful chamfer or some way of doing the windshield wiper fluid or something and it was causing a glitch in the assembly line he said this is why Americans no longer innovate that much because they Outsource their manufacturing so they don't have a daily iterative process of how to manufacture better and how to design better do a put you do this in art history sometimes where you put two pictures by rembrand up and you compare and contrast

35:04yeah put Steve Jobs up on one screen and Elon Musk up on you know it's why you write separate biographies deserve a biography you know Jennifer D is totally different no but what are they when when you put these two up next to each other what strikes you as different about them yeah well start with the the similarity which is reality Distortion field they both have this passion that if somebody says can't be done right they stare blankly and say you can do it right and they force people I think and they have a a pretty good intuition of what's possible both of them end up being right

35:4390% of the time and they're telling Engineers who you would think would know more than they do about what right and jobs would say about say the Macintosh you got to shave 20 seconds seconds off the boot up time and then Kenyan would say you can't do it you don't know coding that well here he'd say you can do it and after about a week it would be done likewise mus does that seven times a day 10 times a day just says you got that paint station there and it's taking 90 seconds if it's not down to 45 seconds next week your resignation is accepted which is the polite way he says it yeah there's some and and he has a really great fingertip feel right for the physics of

36:34Material Science and Manufacturing and he has what he calls first principles like when he first did the rocket they were saying it cost this he said no I know exactly how much the materials cost how much the fuel cost and I know that you could do it for this and the algorithm that he uses is question every requirement delete every possible part then you start automating and it's worked it's worked on Tesla and it's worked on SpaceX continueing continue with the contrast thing with the differences between these two which who is which is more lovable Steve Jobs or Elon Musk who who is more likely if you go around and talk to the people who worked for them to well they both would

37:20have people walk through walls with them except for those that you know stormed off in a huff if you survive either you become loyal Gwen shotwell's been at SpaceX 20 years you know likewise Eddie Q Phil Schiller a lot of them just totally totally loyal if they can make it through the grind there's a spiritual quality to Steve Jobs that really makes him emotionally connect to people in an awesome way when he wants to yeah Kathy I tell a story about well she's I can't see her so I'm going to go Barrel ahead here at one point I was going to visit them and Kathy was flying out with me we were both going to California and I texted him and said okay this jobs or

38:09musk this jobs and I said I'm coming by and by the way Kathy's with me but I'll drop you know drop said no no bring her to dinner I'd love to meet her ETA and I said to Kathy okay be prepared because if you say something like we drove down 101 because it was a beautiful day he'll say it wasn't a beautiful day you he's rough we get there I've never seen anybody be so charming and Kathy is like oh you're a lawyer what do you think Kathy said you're totally wrong that's the most Charming sweetest man I've ever met well he knows how to do it the difference is musk would never do that he would he didn't know how to do it he didn't give it he didn't care he just

38:50and he just wouldn't do it all right we've got some questions from the audience can we do this sure all right did you end up did you end up liking him more or less after writing the book why to either you know I always get did you like him question and it's a really difficult one is sort of a word that wouldn't be in the top 1,000 that pops to your mind because it's such a anod word in a way the interesting thing about him as I said earlier there really are multiple musks if you're around the funny guy the Charming guy it's a total blast if you're around the guy who is aspirational and inspiring and we have to get human you know it's really interesting if he's in engineering mode

39:37you you're totally mesmerized by him when he gets in the demon mode it's a pain it's like especially people like me and you I mean we don't like it when people are not being nice could you see him did he ever do it to you he never turned demon mode on me and everybody kept saying he's going to turn demon mode on you but it's yeah well fine but I don't yeah book's finished yeah but

40:01I think it was because I really did try to I mean you showed that picture if people get the book you can see it it's with a group of people at Twitter the first day he's come in and you can see I'm the detached Observer I'm about six steps away just watching and so I never I never had it's called flamethrower cuz he and and he never hit the flamethrower on me could you see it when he was could you tell when he was about to do it to someone else oh yeah I remember once being in dinner with Grimes and a few other people after some meetings and he was worked up about a lot of things but kind of in a fun spirited mode and she leaned

40:45over to me and said demon mode and it was like being in uptown New Orleans when you feel the air pressure lowering and you know a storm is about to come and she sensed it before I did that 20 seconds before I did but you could see his eyes glazed he became a bit trans-like and very dark and boom for about an hour he was brutal huh and as gri said you know I love I

41:15like being around Elon but I have to be careful which Elon I'm around so this is this leads to this question do you think Elon Musk is a good person you know once again good nice like I think there are Elon that are good here's the actual complex answer to that he is not good most of the

41:38time to people like right around him he doesn't sit there saying I really want to please all these people I want to make sure they don't get unhappy and when he went into Twitter and everybody's talking about psychological safety and we are nurturing he's like no we're hardcore we're all in no more py psychological safety is like yeah Wilderness Camp now psychological safety is the enemy right of intense progress so he is not I can't remember the word was nice or good but he has like Einstein I mean I

42:15don't want to compare him too much but he has a deep care about Humanity about getting us to the transition to a sustainable energy about human civilization and so he is motivated not by making money not by being powerful in you know kicking around people but by these missions that came when he was a little kid sitting in the corner reading the comic you superhero comics of I've got to help Humanity be space fairing I've got to help it get over this sustainable energy issue I've got to help it fight off artificial intelligence that might be evil so there is a goodness to his missions and their

43:01epic missions but in pursuing them he sometimes runs rough shod over the six or seven people happen to be at the table right what would Benjamin Franklin have thought of Elon Musk Benjamin fragin was the that was my question okay you pretended to read it Benjamin fragin was the opposite Benjamin Franklin cared too much often about bringing people together and having people like him John Adams said of him he was ingratiating and insinuating which is meant to be an insult because Franklin would always be there and know exactly how to flatter or how to get a person to like him and when there was a conflict between you know Jefferson and Adams Franklin would bring

43:45them together so Franklin's superpower was a deep empathy and a desire to please and bring people together mosque would say his superpower is not caring about that but caring about the mission given he's the world's wealthiest person controls a social media company and has the biggest satellite Network what risk is he to World stability you know I think that he has too much and he would feel okay is now a little bit too much power the whole starlink thing he finally at the end of the episode he talks to General Mark Millie he talks to Jake all explain that just a little bit yeah it was starlink when Russia invades

44:34Ukraine every satellite is knocked out their military our military ViaSat the only satellites that work for communications are Starling and why is that because he made them hack proof and somehow our defense intelligence agency didn't and Boeing didn't that's Riv that's where you get to the higher level of why does he have so much power why can't anybody else build satellites and can get into orbit right so that are hack proof that yeah they're hack proof but also get 5,000 into orbit do you know that us intelligence military satellites especially the ones that have to go into high Earth orbit NASA can't launch them Boeing can't launch them SpaceX launches all of

45:16them it's shocking that this is this has ended up in the hands of the private right so this is why he has the power and what happened that he sends all these Starling satellites it saves Ukraine because they weren't being able to communicate with the troops he gets all this credit but at a certain point they're using starlink without telling anybody to do a

45:38secret sub you know drone Subs using starlink that's going to hit the Russian Fleet in Crimea and I got I'm sitting there at the Newman High School football game watching Arch Manning play and the phone keeps so I go behind the bleachers he says this is going to start World War III this is the end of the world made a mistake actually because he said and we're not allowing it we're saying no we're not allowing them to use starlink which happens and the subs I mean through the evening I'm hearing this the subs wash ashore helplessly Dr yeah the the Drone subs and I mean I thought he meant he had disabled it turned it off that day he had actually disabled it

46:19before but all that night the Ukrainian you know ministers are saying you got to turn it on I have the text messages in the book and finally he says okay maybe I do have I I don't offer him advice but sometimes the questions he so I said have you talked to Jake Sullivan have you talked to Mark Millie the chairman of the Joint Chiefs are they aware the yes yes at least the American Military I'm going to say something that I don't know personally but he said today or yesterday in response to it which is they knew what was happening and if they had asked me to enable starlink I would have done it had they requested it right now I don't know if that's true I just

47:01read that today cuz he's been talking about but I know he was talking to in fact it's yeah he so afterwards he finally decides I'm going to take some starlinks the dishes and the services and sell them outright to the US Military and the US Military and intelligence agency will get to determine the terms of service come to him first he went to them and said you ought to have some of this no they were they were Gwen Shotwell and him they were all negotiating this but I think it it finally not finally it occurred to musk maybe you know he says

47:42to me it's in the book why am I in this War I invented this we did Starling so people could chill and watch Netflix movies and play video game why am I in this so I don't know exactly it took about a week or two to negotiate do at what point does he become aware that he has the One unhackable S communic oh about 40 minutes into the Russian invasion that first night but before that he didn't that so that that's what alerts him that that before that he didn't realize I think he I don't know I think he probably would have been surprised no other you know that via sat and all these others it was just a simple denial of service attack know that it wasn't

48:22like they hacked but you know his his are still working huh and he's got 5,000 of them I mean he cuz he shoots them off twice a week 40 or 50 and and he reuses the boosters whereas as I said NASA can't with its own Rockets get into high Earth orbit right you have a great subject so how does how does how does

48:47the United States regain its independence from Elon Musk well first of all I could learn how to manufacture yeah yeah yeah how could we stop him from interfering in foreign policy so but how but how this is the first the first part question I I think that foreign policy sort of inter intervene with him that it sort of found him rather than he wasn't really looking I would think it would be useful I mean this is a large question which is why is he successful at some of these things like getting 5,000 satellites up and he said we used to be a nation of really great Risk Takers even the people who ran Boeing probably were Risk Takers at one point not not

49:27safety risk but like they were going to try rocking stuff said everybody who came here whether it was on the Mayflower or across the Rio Grand they were adventurous they took risks he says nowadays we have more referees than we have Risk Takers we have more Regulators than we have innovators we have more people saying you can't do it the lawyers the whatever and he said it's made it so that our big military contractors can't get anything done we can't get highspeed rail I would think that the best way to make sure he doesn't have so much clout on things is for somebody to be able to build more electric vehicles I mean he built a charging Network and then the US

50:10government for GM decided to build their own and they've surrendered because the Tesla charging network works I'm not trying to you know just sing his Praises but it would be useful if you don't want him to control the charging Network and America if you don't want him to control the internet in outer space if you don't want him to control rocket launches to have Boeing and northr grummond and others be able to get stuff done we only got a minute or two left I'm I'm curious this is but wait let me make it clear I do think that should happen that there should be competitors I don't think it's really great to have anybody especially a guy who I will

50:56euphemistically say is Mercurial having this much Palace yeah yeah it this is this is your first book well maybe not your first book as Jennifer dowon has got a career ahead of her but you've got a character who but you got a you got this character who's going to be moving through space doing lots of things after your book is done you didn't have a natural ending to the book how did you how did you deal with that well I first I I I finally sort of said have I explained given enough story so that you get Elon Musk and he's now started the AI company he's now launched Starship he's now turned Twitter into X you know what he's like and what he's

51:40going to do if three years from now he does another Global car if he buys something I think you will fully understand him you know it's not like you need more chapters and for me to keep the book open where do you think think he goes from here I was stunned after he was running six companies and I thought man he kept saying maybe I'm biting off more than I can Che because I've got Twitter I'm turning into X I'm doing and then when he asked me to summoned me so to speak like you got to come to Austin I've got something to tell you I don't want to tell you on the phone it was about starting the new AI company I'm like wait you're now starting a seventh company and I

52:21actually say I said what you he said yeah I'm always pushing my chips back on the table I always want to push the edge of the envelope Walter Isaacson thank you very much Michael [Applause] Lewis was that good yeah sure [Applause]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份