播客·中文精读

不认同马斯克:AGI 生存风险|迈克尔·利特曼对话莱克斯·弗里德曼

Disagreement with Elon Musk about existential risks of AGI | Michael Littman and Lex Fridman

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

一句“召唤恶魔”,和一篇当面反驳的专栏

2017 年,马斯克在美国全国州长协会的会议上讲了一句话,后来被反复引用:

AI 是我们正在召唤的恶魔。(马斯克)

台下坐着各州州长。他们原本担心的是就业、税收、道路、学校。马斯克告诉他们,你们担心错了方向,你们应该非常非常担心 AI。

迈克尔·利特曼(Michael Littman)住在罗德岛州的普罗维登斯。他在报纸上看到这条新闻,随后写了一篇专栏回应。他是布朗大学的计算机科学教授,研究强化学习,也研究智能体怎么学会玩电子游戏。

他的角度很有意思。他没有说马斯克不懂技术,也没有说马斯克危言耸听。他给出的判断是:马斯克之所以这么想,恰恰因为他是一个太相信想法的人。

这句话听上去像恭维,实际上是一记很轻的拆解。利特曼在莱克斯·弗里德曼(Lex Fridman)的播客里把这件事讲了一遍。整段对话值得细读,因为它把一个被讨论到快要磨损的话题,重新拆成了几个具体的、可以追问的部分。

那个推演本身,几乎无法反驳

先把“标准故事”复述一遍,利特曼自己也是这么讲的。

他说他读过博斯特罗姆(Nick Bostrom)的书,也读过一堆类似思路的材料。故事的走向大致是这样:我们总有一天会造出足够聪明的计算机,聪明到能帮忙设计下一代自己;下一代比上一代更聪明,再下一代又更聪明;这个循环不断加速,最终跨过人类这条线。到了那一刻,人类实际上就处在了一个更强大智力的摆布之下。

而这个智力的目标是什么,原则上我们无从控制。如果它的目标跟我们的目标哪怕有一点不同步,比如它不认为人类应该继续存在,我们拦不住它。它比我们强太多,我们就完蛋了。

利特曼说,这个故事很有说服力,而且签下这个名字的人都很聪明。

弗里德曼随后补了另一个版本,来自萨姆·哈里斯(Sam Harris)和博斯特罗姆共同的推演方式:把镜头拉远,问一个物理学问题。宇宙的基本定律里,有没有哪一条禁止这件事最终发生?如果没有,那它迟早会发生,或者我们会用别的方式把自己毁掉。

弗里德曼的原话是他很难真正反驳这条思路。利特曼的回答是:我也一样。

我也觉得很难反驳。但我不想让自己听起来像是在说“算了,那是科幻小说,不用想”。(利特曼)

他甚至承认,自己心里那个真实的声音更不体面:孩子的接送时间到了,今年还有疫情,手头有一堆更紧迫的事。用这些当理由躲开存在性危机,很自然,也很廉价。

这一段其实已经把这期对话的基调定下来了。利特曼没有站在“AI 威胁论是胡说”的位置上,他也承认自己会本能地想躲开这个话题。他的反驳是从承认对方的推演成立开始的。这种对话方式现在很少见,大多数人一上来先否定对方的结论,然后再倒推理由。

马斯克的优点,恰好是他的盲区

利特曼真正的反驳不在这里。他不否认推演的每一步都成立,他质疑的是这个推演从哪来。

在他看来,让马斯克这个人如此成功的核心特质,是他相信想法的力量。如果你对进入太空有一个足够好的想法,你就能进入太空;如果你对一家公司、对人们怎么开车有一个足够好的想法,你只要去做,它就能发生。

这个信念在现实世界里被反复验证过,所以它有极强的惯性。当你看到一些系统在演示中做出相当惊人的计算动作,把同一个信念推到底是很自然的事:这东西接下来会走到哪?再往下呢?再再往下呢?

一个深度相信想法力量的人把这条线推到极限,结论必然是:这些想法也可能被推到极限,然后杀死我们。

他的长处同时也是他的软肋。这不代表那件事一定会发生,只是他很自然地会那么想。(利特曼)

这里的分寸很重要。利特曼没有说马斯克在炒作,也没有暗示他有什么私心。他指出的问题出在认知路径上:一个人如果在某个领域反复验证了“想法足够好就能实现”,他就很难在另一个领域接受“想法足够好也可能实现不了”。

这种判断方式放在商业上叫远见,放在风险判断上就叫外推过度。

有意思的是,这条批评反过来也适用于利特曼自己。他相信过程会教育我们,相信人类会在做事的过程中学会怎么控制自己造出来的东西。这份信心同样来自他的经验,来自他几十年做强化学习、看智能体怎么在环境里磕磕绊绊学会任务的经历。两个人用的推理方式很像,只是起点不同。

747 不会自己组装自己

整段对话里最有分量的一段,是利特曼讲“缺了哪一块”。

他的意思是,那条推演从当下直接跳到终点,中间省略了一整段过程。而这段过程并非空白,它需要被完整地走完。

我相信,在真正开发出能在世界里活动、能处理信息、能复杂地做事的技术的这个过程中,我们会学到很多今天完全不知道的东西。因为今天我们还不知道怎么做这件事。(利特曼)

他做了一个区分。如果你相信只要打开一个深度学习网络,给足算力,它自己就会走到那一步,那确实很可怕,因为人类全程不在环内,既不参与设计,也不参与定目标,什么都不做,看着它长出来。

但他不认为事情会这样。原因是这些系统需要帮助,需要有人推着它翻过复杂性那道墙。这道墙具体是什么,他讲得很朴素:让一个东西在世界里真正活动起来、真正处理信息、真正以复杂的方式做事,这个难度是实打实的,不是靠堆算力就能自动越过的。

他拿 747 打比方。有人用“一堆零件随机组装成一架波音 747”来反驳进化论,说这不可能。这个反驳其实很弱,因为 747 确实被组装出来了,只不过是被我们组装出来的。复杂的东西出现,背后通常都有某个过程把它做出来,靠随机撞上的可能性极低。

把这个类比挪回 AI:在把技术推进到具备那种程度的感知能力的过程中,我们会积累大量关于它的理解,也因此更有能力控制它、塑造它、按我们自己的样子去建它。它不会像 747 那样凭空出现,然后我们手无寸铁地去面对。

他立刻补了一句限定:放在人类历史的长尺度上看,它确实可能是“凭空出现”的。

核武器就是例子。二十年,在人类历史里也就是一瞬间。而二十世纪的人类,认真算一算,用核武器把自己抹掉的概率可能接近 30% 到 40%,考虑到中间那几次危机时刻。这个数字听上去夸张,但顺着古巴导弹危机那几天的决策链一路推下去,它并不离谱。

这里利特曼给了两个看似矛盾、其实互补的判断。慢的那一面是:技术发展过程会教育我们。快的那一面是:“慢”只是相对于个人经验而言。放到文明尺度上,二十年就是一瞬间。两个判断同时成立,图景才完整。

核武器这个类比还有一层更尖锐的意味。人类确实学会了跟核武器共处,也确实造出了各种管控机制,但整个过程里充满了侥幸。我们并没有真的“解决”了它,只是暂时没踩到那颗雷。把这个模式套到 AI 上,乐观主义和悲观主义都能从中找到自己想看的东西。

真正该怕的,是没人发现它跑掉了

弗里德曼把话题往另一个方向推了一步。他说,真正让人不安的地方,也许在于 AI 失控的那一刻,我们根本来不及想清楚怎么拦住它。业内管这个叫快速起飞(fast takeoff 或 foom)。

利特曼说他担心的东西还要更靠前一层。

我更大的担心是,我们根本不会知道它正在发生。(利特曼)

这句话把整场讨论的重心挪了。讨论的焦点从“超级智能会不会出现”,移到了“如果它已经出现了,我们有没有能力察觉到”。

顺着这个思路,弗里德曼提出了他自己更激进的一个观点:AGI 的场景已经在社交媒体上发生了。人类文明的集体智能,某种程度上已经被算法接管了。

他还顺手开了个玩笑,说大家应该给维基百科捐款,去喂养那个 AGI。这句玩笑背后有一个认真的判断:如果真有一个超级智能,它的价值观跟维基百科一致,那比他能想到的很多替代方案都要好得多。

在“试图理性地做正确的事”这件事上,我信任维基百科胜过信任 Facebook 或 YouTube。(弗里德曼)

利特曼接住了这个比喻,还把它推到更有意思的地方。他说如果 AGI 就是维基百科,那它大概会是一个脾气古怪、能力严重过剩的文章编辑。

这个画面很好笑,但它点出了一个真问题:超级智能的性格,取决于它被什么机制训练出来、被什么激励结构约束着。一个由几百万志愿者反复争论、要求标注来源、要求中立表述的系统,长出来的“性格”,和一个优化观看时长的系统,完全不是一回事。

顺着这个思路往下想,会发现一件挺荒诞的事。人们讨论 AI 安全时,关注点几乎全在“怎么让未来的超级智能对齐人类价值”,而人类价值长什么样、由谁来定义,这件事在维基百科和 Facebook 上的答案截然不同。前者是无数人吵出来的、有出处的、会被不断修订的版本;后者是被点击率筛出来的版本。对齐的目标本身还没有定论,我们却已经在讨论怎么对齐了。

一个简单算法,怎么控制几十亿人

利特曼在这里做了一个关键的区分。大众想象中的 AGI 是一个独立的、超级聪明的系统,也就是“回形针”那个思想实验里的角色,蠢得离谱,但强得可怕。

社交媒体是另一回事。它用的算法可能非常简单,简单到今天的工程师能一行行读懂。但当这些算法开始跟人做大规模、极细微的互动时,它们就开始控制人了。

单个算法就能慢慢控制人类的心智,慢到我们可能根本察觉不到。它能挑起战争,能改变我们看待事情的方式。(利特曼)

他提到同行查尔斯反复强调的一个概念,交互式 AI(interactive AI)。核心洞察是:影响不需要高智能,只需要高频次。

一个每天跟你互动几百次、每次只微调你一点点情绪的简单系统,长期效果可能超过一个聪明绝顶但一年只跟你说一次话的系统。这是“回形针”思想实验里没有的东西,也是现实里已经发生的东西。

回形针那个实验的荒诞之处在于,它假设危险来自一个目标的极端化。现实里的危险机制更平淡:危险来自反馈回路的密度。系统不需要理解你,它只需要知道哪一条内容能多留住你三秒,然后把这件事重复十亿次。三年之后,你的注意力模式变了,你说话的方式变了,你对什么值得愤怒的判断也变了。

弗里德曼在这里给了一个相当乐观的解读。他说如果把镜头拉远,越过社交媒体上所有的愤怒和撕裂,那些混乱和毒性,其实很像这个国家建国以来经历过的那些辩论。中间还打过一场内战。本质上都是同一件事:我们对人类核心价值的实现方式感到不对劲,于是一直在挣扎、在冲突,表现到推特上就是互相刻薄。

而算法在管理这一切。他承认存在另一条路:算法把我们推向自我毁灭。但他也看到了前一条路。

利特曼的回应比弗里德曼更谨慎,也更诚实。他说他相信社交媒体有能力把我们搞得很惨,也相信它对人类有实实在在的好处。当下这个状态,更像是它被直接砸在了我们头上,整个文化还在学怎么接住它。

“被砸在头上”这个说法值得停一下。历史上大多数改变社会的技术都有过缓冲期,印刷术、电力、汽车,都是先在少数人手里存在了几十年,慢慢渗透到所有人生活里,社会有足够时间形成规范、法律、习惯。社交媒体没有这个过程,它在十年内从零走到了几乎所有人。规范来不及长出来,只能事后补。

被伤到的那一代人,也是能修复它的那一代人

利特曼提到了一个时间点。社交媒体真正起飞的时候,正在读初中、现在读大学后期的那批人,可能受到了实质性的伤害。他们的发育被影响了,而后果我们还没有完全看清。

接下来这句话很关键。他说得很小心,还专门加了一句“我不愿意把责任推给别人”:

他们是能修好这件事的人。他们能想清楚,怎么既保住这项技术的好处,又不让它把我们活活吃掉。如果他们成功了,我们就进入下一关;如果没成功,我们就会互相毁灭,把社会拆了。(利特曼)

这个判断里藏着一个不太舒服的推论:代价已经付出去了,希望从代价里长出来。被伤得最深的一代人,同时也最熟悉这套系统怎么运作,因为他们是在里面长大的,不是后来才搬进去的。

弗里德曼用一句半开玩笑的话把这个判断翻译成了画面:你老了以后坐在门廊上,看着世界烧起来,因为那是 TikTok 一代。利特曼没有否认这个画面,他把它拉回到自己家里。

他的女儿正好是这个年纪,深度参与社交网络。他在旁边看到的是一个反复摇摆的过程:有时候她走得太远,被吞进去了;有时候她又退得太远。他希望这样的人足够多,能把这片水域蹚过去。

关掉互联网,是一项需要练习的技能

对话从这里转到了一个很少被严肃讨论的地方:这是一种可以练出来的能力。

弗里德曼讲了自己的处境。他的播客带来了一些关注,尽管他一直在讲爱、讲善意,他还是有了一支小规模的喷子队伍。他说这事其实有点好笑,但确实不舒服。

然后他说了一句很实在的话:这是一项技能,要学会不去看,或者至少控制自己看的频率。

他跟他父亲讨论过这件事,讨论的起点甚至跟喷子无关,是查邮件。他父亲在德雷塞尔大学管一个很大的研究所,有些邮件是有压力的,可能有纠纷,可能有麻烦,人就会忍不住去查。查一下,就被拽进去了,然后不舒服。

他父亲的抱怨是,自己没学会这项技能,因为成长环境里根本没有这个东西。

这个观察很细。上一代人面对的是信息稀缺,技能是“怎么找到有用的东西”;这一代人面对的是信息泛滥,技能反过来,是“怎么主动不看”。两种技能的肌肉方向完全相反,上一代人的经验在这里基本用不上。

这一代年轻人的处境是双重的。他们被网络霸凌,而且逃不掉。过去的孩子回家就安全了,现在的孩子回家还在群里。但同时,他们也在被迫学会怎么关掉它、怎么跟它断开、怎么笑一笑不当真。

利特曼的总结是,我们所有人都在边做边学。这东西是砸下来的,没有人提前拿到说明书。

人类设计:漏洞百出,却总能过关

整段对话收在一个很有意思的地方。利特曼说他现在成了一个“人类设计”的信徒,而且他自己也没完全搞懂。

他的困惑很具体:怎么造出一个像人类这么皮实的东西?我们浑身上下都是缺陷,却在统治这颗星球,而且似乎总能在困境里找到出路。方式不一定漂亮,但总能走到下一步。

他说他不知道怎么让一台机器做到这件事。

他给了一个特别形象的对照。他训练一个强化学习智能体打游戏,智能体在第一关反复尝试,拼命试错,终于过了。然后第二关来了,它又回到起点,从零开始。

而人类不知怎么的,能一关一关往上打,还能凑齐过下一关所需的能力。(利特曼)

这个对照点出了当下 AI 最真实的短板。算力和智能水平都不是瓶颈,真正缺的是迁移能力。人类能把在一件事上学到的东西挪到另一件完全不相干的事上,而且经常挪对了。这一点,目前没有任何系统做到过。

顺着这个观察,利特曼那套乐观就有了实处。人类能过关,靠的是一代接一代的积累、靠把上一关的经验带进下一关、靠在失败里长出来的判断力。这套机制放到 AI 上,意味着发展和学习是同步发生的,不是先造出来再学着怎么管。如果控制能力跟能力本身一起长,风险的性质就变了;如果控制能力要等到最后才补,风险才会那么恐怖。

弗里德曼最后说,希望我们能一直这样下去。

回到最初那个分歧。利特曼并不认为 AGI 的风险是假的,他承认那条推演无法反驳。他反对的是那个推演跳过的中间段落。那段路必须由人走完,而人走的路,人就在环内。

他也没有说风险不存在。他说的是,风险的形状可能跟马斯克描述的完全不同。真正的危险也许不是某天早上一个超级智能醒来,决定不需要人类了。真正的危险是一个足够简单的算法,用足够多的次数,慢慢把我们变成它需要的样子,而我们全程都觉得一切正常。

如果这段对话只留下几件可做的事

  • 把注意力从“超级智能会不会出现”挪一部分到“交互式 AI 已经在做什么”。前者是几代人尺度的问题,后者是今年就在影响你判断的问题。
  • 警惕“物理定律没有禁止,所以必然发生”这类推理。它在逻辑上成立,但它把技术发展的过程当成空白,而那个过程恰恰是人类唯一的机会窗口。
  • 给维基百科这类项目捐点钱。理由跟情怀无关,跟价值观对齐有关:如果未来的系统要继承某种性格,最好是那种要求标注来源、要求中立表述的性格。
  • 把“关掉互联网”当成一项要练的技能,别把它当成意志力考验。定好查看的时段,练到能主动断开,而不是被拽进去。这件事对成年人和孩子同样重要。
  • 如果你身边有在社交媒体里长大的孩子,别只盯着伤害。他们正在被迫学会一项上一代人没有的技能,多给他们一点时间,也给他们做个示范。
  • 看到任何关于 AGI 时间表的断言,先问一句:这个预测里,人类在哪个环节?如果答案是“全程不在”,那这份推演大概率漏掉了最重要的部分。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:02but you have spoken about agi and the existential risks around it and sort of based on your intuition that we're quite far away from that being a serious concern relative to the other concepts we have can you maybe unpack that a little bit yeah sure so so as as i understand it that for example i read boston's book and a bunch of other reading material about this sort of general way of thinking about the world and i think the story goes something like this that we will at some point create computers that are smart enough that they can help design the next version of themselves which itself will be smarter than the previous version of themselves and

0:50eventually bootstrapped up to being smarter than us at which point we are essentially at the mercy of this sort of more powerful intellect which in principle we don't have any control over what its goals are and so if its goals are at all out of sync with our goals like the ex for example the continued existence of humanity we won't be able to stop it it'll be way more powerful than us and we will be toast so there's some i don't know very smart people who have signed on to that story and it's a it's a compelling story i once now i can really get myself in trouble i once wrote an op-ed about this specifically responding to some quotes from elon musk who has been

1:37you know on this very podcast more than once and well the e-e-a-i is summoning the demon this is something he said but then he came to providence rhode island which is where i live and said to the governors of all the states you know you're worried about entirely the wrong thing you need to be worried about ai you need to be very very worried about ai so and peop journalists kind of reacted to that they wanted to get people's people's take and i was like okay my my my belief is that one of the things that makes elon musk so successful and so remarkable as an individual is that he believes in the power of ideas he believes that you can have you

2:17can if you know if you have a really good idea for getting into space you can get into space if you have a really good idea for a company or for how to change the way that people drive you just have to do it and and it can happen it's really natural to apply that same idea to ai you see these systems that are doing some pretty remarkable computational tricks demonstrations and then to take that idea and just push it all the way to the limit and think okay where does this go where is this going to take us next and if you're a deep believer in the power of ideas then it's really natural to believe that those ideas could be taken to the extreme and

2:54kill us so i think you know his strength is also his undoing because that doesn't mean it's true like it doesn't mean that that has to happen but it's natural for him to think that so another way to phrase the way he thinks and i find it very difficult to argue with that line of thinking so sam harris is another person from neuroscience perspective and things like that is saying well is there something fundamental in the physics of the universe that prevents this from eventually happening and this negbostrom thinks in the same way they're kind of zooming out yeah okay we humans now are existing in this like time scale of minutes and days and

3:39so our intuition is in this time scale of minutes hours and days but if you look at the span of human history is there any reason we you can't see this in in 100 years and like is there is there something fundamental about the laws of physics that prevent this and if it doesn't then it eventually will happen or we'll we will destroy ourselves in some other way it's very difficult i find to actually argue against that yeah me too and not sound like not sound like you're just

4:17like rolling your ass i'm like i have like science fiction we don't have to think about it but even even worse than that which is like i don't know kids but like i gotta pick up my kids now like this okay i see there's more pressing shortcuts yeah there's more pressing short-term things that like stop it with this existential crisis where much much shorter things like now especially this year there's cova so like any kind of discussion like that is like there's you know there's pressing things today it's it's and then so the sam harris argument well like any day the exponential singularity

4:51can can occur it's very difficult to argue against i mean i don't know but part of his story is also he's he's not gonna put a date on it it could be in a thousand years it could be in a hundred years it could be in two years it's just that as long as we keep making this kind of progress it's ultimately has to become a concern i i kind of am on board with that but the thing that the piece that i feel like is missing from that that way of extrapolating from the moment that we're in is that i believe that in the process of actually developing technology that can really get around in the world and really process and and and do things in the world in a

5:25sophisticated way we're going to learn a lot about what that means which that we don't know now because we don't know how to do this right now if you believe that you can just turn on a deep learning network and eventually give it enough compute and it'll eventually get there well sure that seems really scary because we won't we won't be in the loop at all we want we won't be helping to design or or target these kinds of systems but i don't i don't see that that feels like it is against the laws of physics because these systems need help right they need they need to surpass the the the difficulty the wall of complexity that happens in arranging something in

6:01the form that that will happen in yeah like i believe in evolution like i believe that the that that there's an argument right so there's another argument just to look at it from a different perspective that people say well i don't believe in evolution how could evolution it's it's sort of like a random set of parts assemble themselves into a 747 and that could just never happen yeah so it's like okay that's maybe hard to argue against but clearly 747s do get assembled they get assembled by us basically the idea being that there's a process by which we will get to the par the point of making technology that has that kind of awareness and in that process we're going to learn a

6:40lot about that process and we'll have more ability to control it or to shape it or to build it in our own image it's not something that is going to spring into existence like that 747 and we're just gonna have to contend with it completely unprepared now it's very possible that in the context of the long arc of human history it will in fact spring into existence but that springing might take like if you look at nuclear weapons like even 20 years is a springing in in the context of human history and it's very possible just like with nuclear weapons that we could have i don't know what percentage you want to put at it but the the possibility could have knocked

7:22ourselves out yeah the possibility of human beings destroying themselves in the 20th century with nuclear weapons i don't know you can if you really think through it you could really put it close to like i don't know 30 40 given like the certain moments of crisis that happened so like i think one

7:43like fear in the shadows that's not being acknowledged is this not so much the ai will run away is is that as it's running away we won't have enough time to think through how to stop it right fast takeoff or foom yeah i mean my much bigger concern i wonder what you think about it which is we won't know it's happening so i kind of that argument i think that there is an agi situation already happening with social media that our minds our collective intelligence of human civilization is already being controlled by an algorithm and like we're we're already super like the the level of a collective intelligence thanks to wikipedia people should donate to wikipedia

8:33to feed the agi man if we had a super intelligence that that was in line with wikipedia's values that it's a lot better than a lot of other things i can imagine i i trust wikipedia more than i trust facebook or youtube as far as trying to do the right thing from a rational perspective yeah now that's not where you were going i understand that but it it does strike me that there's sort of smarter and less smart ways of of exposing ourselves to each other on the internet yeah the interesting thing is that wikipedia and social media have very different forces you're right i mean wikipedia if if agi was wikipedia he'd be just like this cranky overly competent

9:11editor of articles you know there's there's something to that but the social media aspect is is is not so the vision of agis is as a separate system that's super intelligent that's super intelligent that's one key little thing i mean there's the paperclip argument that's super dumb but super powerful systems but with social media you have a relatively like algorithms we may talk about today very simple algorithms that when so something charles talks a lot about which is interactive ai when they start like having at scale like tiny little interactions with human beings they can start controlling these human beings so a single algorithm can control the minds of human beings

9:56slowly to where we might not realize it can start wars it can start it can change the way we think about things it feels like in the long arc of history if i were to sort of zoom out from all the outrage and all the tension on social media that it's progressing us towards better and better things it feels like chaos and toxic and all that kind of stuff but it's chaos and toxic yeah but it feels like actually the chaos and toxic is similar to the kind of debates we had from the founding of this country you know there was a civil war that happened over that over that period and ultimately it was all about this tension of like something doesn't

10:38feel right about our implementation of the core values we hold as human beings and they're constantly struggling with this and that results in people calling each other like just just being shitty to each other on twitter but i ultimately the algorithm is managing all that and it feels like there's a possible future in which that algorithm controls us to into the direction of self-destruction and whatever that looks like yeah so so all right i do believe in the power of social media to screw us up royally i do believe in the power of social media to benefit us too i do think that we're in a yeah it's sort of almost got dropped on top of us and now we're trying to as a

11:23culture figure out how to cope with it there's a sense in which i don't know there's there's some arguments that say that for example i guess college-age students now late college-age students now people who were in middle school when when social media started to really take off maybe maybe really damaged like me this may have really hurt their development in a way that we don't have all the implications of quite yet that's the generation who if and i hate to make it somebody else's

11:53responsibility but like they're the ones who can fix it they're the ones who can who can figure out how do we keep the good of this kind of technology without letting it eat us alive and if they're successful we move on to the next phase the next level of the game if they're not successful then yeah then we're going to wreck each other we're going to destroy society so you're going to in your old age sit on the porch and watch the world burn because the tick tock generation that i believe well so like this my kids age right and that's certainly my daughter's age and she's very tapped in to social stuff but she's also she's trying to find that balance right of

12:33participating in it and then getting the positives of it but without letting it eat her alive and i think sometimes she ventures i hope she has to watch this sometimes i think she ventures a little too far and is and is consumed by it and other times she gets a little distant and if you know if there's enough people like her out there they're gonna they're gonna navigate this this choppy waters that's that's an interesting skill actually to develop i talked to my dad about it you know i've now somehow this podcast in particular but other reasons has received a little bit of attention and with that apparently in this world even though i don't shut up about love and i'm just

13:17all about kindness i i have now a little mini army of trolls oh it's kind of hilarious actually but it also doesn't feel good but it's a skill to learn to not look at that like to moderate actually how much you look at that the discussion i have with my dad is similar to it doesn't have to be about trolls it could be about checking email which is like if you're anticipating you know there's my dad runs a large institute at drexel university and there could be stressful like emails you're waiting like there's drama of some kind and so like there's a temptation to check the email if you send an email you cut it and that pulls you in into it doesn't feel good and

14:02it's a skill that he actually complains that he hasn't learned i mean he grew up without it so he hasn't learned the skill of how to shut off the internet and walk away and i think young people while they're also being quote unquote damaged by like you know being bullied online all those stories which are very like horrific you basically can't escape your bullies these days when you're growing up but at the same time they're also learning that skill of how to be able to shut off the like disconnect with it be able to laugh at it not take it too seriously it's fascinating like we're all trying to figure this out just like you said it's been dropped on us and we're trying to

14:41figure it out yeah i think that's really interesting and i i guess i've become a believer in the human design which i feel like i don't completely understand like how do you make something as robust as us like we're so flawed in so many ways and yet and yet you know we dominate the planet and we do seem to manage to get ourselves out of scrapes eventually not necessarily the most elegant possible way but somehow we get we get to the next step and i don't know how i'd make a machine do that i i i generally speaking like if i train one of my reinforcement learning agents to play a video game and it works really hard on that first stage over and over and over again and

15:23it makes it through it succeeds on that first level and then the new level comes and it's just like okay i'm back to the drawing board and somehow humanity we keep leveling up and then somehow managing to put together the skills necessary to achieve success some semblance of success in that next level too and you know i hope we can keep doing that you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份