自给自足的火星城市,和第三次世界大战,哪个会先来?
这是马斯克在2021年一场Clubhouse访谈里自己抛出来的问题。没人问他这个,是他讲火星计划讲到一半,顺口说的。听着像黑色幽默,背后却是整套逻辑:火星殖民在这里更像一份保险,保的是人类意识这盏灯。
这份保险怎么买,买不买得到,以及一个造火箭的人为什么会同时操心脑机接口、狗狗币和mRNA,这场访谈里都有答案。信息密度很高,值得慢慢拆。
去火星,缺一块拼图都不行
马斯克把去火星拆成几个必须完成的动作,每一步都跳不过去。
第一步,星舰要能稳定入轨。第二步,轨道加注:再发射一艘"油轮"星舰上去,和主船对接,把推进剂转移过去,让主船接近满载。第三步,飞向火星。第四步,在火星本地生产推进剂。
他原话是,这几块凑齐,生命才有可能成为多行星的。
前三步是运力问题,第四步是生存问题。飞船到了火星,如果没法就地生产返程或后续任务所需的燃料,那这趟就是单程票,后面的人也别想形成循环。所以火星上必须有一套能利用当地资源造推进剂的设备。这一步不过关,前面三步全是白忙。
这里没有讨价还价的空间。少一环,整个计划就停在图纸上。
一个少年的存在主义危机
为什么要费这么大劲去一个红色荒原?马斯克的答案要从他小时候说起。
他十几岁时有过一段相当严重的存在主义危机。他反复问自己:生命的意义是什么?我们为什么在这里?这一切是不是根本没有意义?想不出答案,他一度很抑郁,也很悲伤。
把他拉出来的是道格拉斯·亚当斯的《银河系漫游指南》。书里有个著名的设定:超级计算机算了几百万年,最后给出宇宙终极答案是42。问题是,没人知道该问什么问题。
宇宙是答案,真正难的是找出该问什么问题。(马斯克,谈《银河系漫游指南》)
这个梗点醒了马斯克。答案容易,问题难。人类要想问出更好的问题,唯一的办法是扩大意识的范围和规模。人越多、认知工具越强、文明存续越久,能提出的问题就越多,越有可能逼近真相。
去火星,在他看来就是扩大意识规模的具体手段。插旗和旅游都不在考虑范围内,真正要保住的是"提问"这件事能持续得更久。
文明的弧线:建金字塔的人,后来忘了怎么建
马斯克提到一个概念:大过滤器。银河系里可能到处是死掉的单行星文明。它们繁荣过,也许繁荣了几百万年,然后因为外部灾难或内部原因慢慢崩溃,再也没有起来。
他举了几个地球上的例子。
五千年前,吉萨金字塔建起来了。几千年后,住在那里的人忘了怎么建金字塔,也忘了怎么读象形文字。罗马人修了发达的道路、渡槽和下水道,中世纪的人把这些技术丢了。苏美尔人、巴比伦人,走的都是同一条弧线:兴起、复杂化、停滞、遗忘。
这些例子指向一个不太舒服的推论:人类大概也会走同样的弧线。
更麻烦的是,全球化让恢复变得更难。过去一个文明崩了,还有别的文明接着。现在全人类绑在一起,一次全球性危机就没有备份。
地球45亿年历史里,生命第一次有可能延伸到地球之外。这个窗口开了多久,没人知道。马斯克的态度是:应该假设它开得很短。
我是个乐观主义者,不是悲观主义者。但你必须承认,这个窗口有可能只开很短一段时间。(马斯克)
所以他的结论是,趁窗口还开着,赶紧把生命送出去。人类在这个过程中扮演的是"生命的代理人"。他甚至说,我们几乎有一种义务,确保地球上的生灵能延续下去。
火星城市长什么样:他不打算替火星人定规矩
访谈里有人问,火星上的社会怎么组织?互联网怎么连?法律、衣服、规则怎么定?
马斯克的回答很干脆:这些事在美国发生,在每个国家发生,他不会去规定火星上应该怎样。他唯一在意的是,把人送过去,把建立自给自足文明所需的设备送过去,至少建成一座自给自足的城市。
至于城市叫什么、怎么治理、用什么货币、穿什么衣服,那是去的人自己的事。
他还泼了盆冷水。很多人以为火星是富人的逃生舱,他直接否掉了这个想象。
那里会非常危险。死亡的方式比地球上多得多,还要干大量体力活。但它会是一场伟大的冒险。(马斯克)
第一批到达的人住的是前沿哨所,跟度假村没有半点关系。艰苦、危险、充满未知,这是入场费。
自给自足和世界大战,哪个先来
马斯克给"成功"下了一个很硬的定义:如果地球的飞船因为任何原因停止到来,火星能不能活下去。
注意,是"任何原因"。可能是小行星,可能是核战争,也可能只是地球文明缓慢衰退,再也造不出飞船。
火星城市的生死线,就在这个假设上。哪怕只缺一样小东西,比如维生素C的等价物,它也能撑一阵,但最终会死。缺的那一样东西,就是压垮整个文明的最后一根稻草。
说得直白点:自给自足的火星城市和第三次世界大战,哪个先来?(马斯克)
这就是整件事的核心阈值。在灾难或衰退到来之前,能不能跨过去。跨过去,意识就有了两个家;跨不过去,前面所有投入都只是给历史添了一段注脚。
时间尺度上,前十年大概只是个很小的前哨站。二三十年之后能建成什么样,取决于前面每一次发射是否顺利、每一次迭代是否到位。
还有一个物理限制绕不过去:火星和地球每26个月才有一次合适的发射窗口。单程旅行现在要六个月,马斯克认为未来有可能压到一个月,但窗口的限制改不了。这意味着每隔两年左右会有一批新人到达,他们天然构成一代人。
火星社会会带着这种"批次感"生长。你属于哪一批,会成为一种身份标签。文化、口音、价值观,大概都会按批次分化。
长期看,火星可以被改造。马斯克说主要是给它加温,让它慢慢变得像地球。这要花很久,但方向上可行。在那之前,火星人过的是封闭舱室里的日子。
外星人:先把照片拍到便利店监控的水平
过去一年有不少UFO目击报告,还有那个穿过太阳系的神秘天体。马斯克的态度是先讲科学。
他说自己没见过任何一条确凿证据。这不代表没有外星人,只是说他看到的所有东西,都能用别的方式解释,而且别的方式概率高得多。
对那些声称拍到外星飞船的人,他有个很具体的吐槽:照片分辨率至少得像便利店监控摄像头的水平吧,你那是五亿像素的相机吗,这玩意儿哪儿找的。
这句话是玩笑,也是标准。证据的门槛不能因为话题刺激就降低。马斯克说,如果真有外星文明,他会是第一个跳出来确认的人,但他确实什么都没看到。
控制meme的人控制宇宙
话题转到meme。马斯克说过一句话:"谁控制了meme,谁就控制了宇宙。"
这是从《沙丘》来的梗。原句是"谁控制了香料,谁就控制了宇宙"。他把香料换成了meme。
他自己的解释是,这句话有点道理。meme是影响时代精神的东西,它决定什么话题会变得有趣、会被传播、会进入人们的注意力。
一张图胜过千言万语,一个meme可能胜过一万句。它是复杂的传播形式,把大量含义压缩进一张图里,还带着幽默。马斯克说自己就是喜欢meme,觉得它们常常很有洞察力。人类历史上,符号和象征一直在强烈地影响人。
从这个角度看,他把推特当成战场,一点不奇怪。
Neuralink:先解决带宽,再谈意识上传
Neuralink的长期动机,马斯克说得很清楚:就算AI是良性的,人类怎么跟上?
他举了GPT-1到GPT-2到GPT-3的进步速度,还有DeepMind。他的判断是,这些系统已经赢遍了所有能赢的游戏。
特斯拉也有很强的AI团队,但方向是现实世界的可用性,解决视觉感知和控制。他说特斯拉的AI团队可能是全世界最强的之一,只是不做通用智能。
问题在于,即便AI只想对人类好、让人类开心,人类怎么保持相关性、保持意义、至少"搭上车"?这个场景不坏,却也谈不上好。
更重要的,是怎么避免坏场景。马斯克的思路是把人类的集体意志和AI的结果耦合起来。能做到这一点,结局大概率比做不到要好。
耦合的前提是带宽。人类现在的交流方式效率极低:脑子里有复杂的想法,压缩成语言,对方接收后再解压,然后再压缩成语言传回来。大量脑力花在压缩和解压上,真正用于思考的部分很少。
Neuralink要做的是在大脑皮层和数字第三层之间建一条直连通道,把带宽提高几个数量级。马斯克给的数字是至少1000倍,可能10000倍以上。
带宽上去之后,两套Neuralink之间可以做"概念心灵感应":一串复杂的想法,不经压缩,直接传给对方。沟通的速度和质量会完全不一样。读心术的说法不准确,本质是把低效的语言层跳过去。
再往后是更科幻的东西:给大脑保存状态。人死了,状态可以恢复到另一个身体里,或者一个机器人身体里。马斯克承认这听起来很怪,但他补了一句,你每天早上醒来,其实也不是昨天的你了。一些脑细胞死了,一些记忆淡了,一些记忆变强了,新记忆又覆盖进来。
所以这有点像游戏里的存档:读档之后,你大体还是你,可能丢几段记忆。你可以选择回到人体,也可以选择回到机器人身体。
一只玩电子游戏的猴子
长期愿景很宏大,短期目标很具体:脑损伤和脊髓损伤。
第一款产品是无线植入芯片,让四肢瘫痪的人用意念控制电脑、鼠标、手机,或者任何设备。这对他们的生活是质的改变。
以前的版本要往脑袋上接电线,不能带回家,还经常不好使。马斯克的说法是,这一版相当于头骨里的一个Fitbit,带细线连到大脑。
他提到已经有只猴子,头骨里植入了无线芯片和细线,能靠意念玩电子游戏。猴子看起来不痛苦,也看不出植入物在哪,只是头顶有一小块深色的莫霍克发型。
还有个小插曲。美国农业部的人来检查猴子设施,检查员说这是她整个职业生涯见过的最好的猴子设施。马斯克特意补了一句:我们对猴子是额外用心的。
团队还在琢磨,能不能让两只猴子互相对打mind pong。现场有人开玩笑,说别让猴子玩《赛博朋克2077》,猴子玩这个太刺激了。
他也讲了早期应用的现实:第一批植入会带不可忽视的风险,所以优先给那些收益远大于风险的人,比如严重脑损伤患者。全程充分披露风险。团队还很在意植入物能不能取出来,测试过植入、取出、再植入,结果不错。不满意可以取,坏了可以换。
他甚至给了一个招聘角度:如果你擅长设计Fitbit、Apple Watch、手机、电脑这类东西,你很可能适合来Neuralink。
教育:别一上来就教扳手
谈到教育,马斯克先说了自家孩子的情况:大部分知识来自YouTube和Reddit,加上同学和课程。他判断,按孩子们花在网上的时间算,真正的教育大头来自线上。
他的观察是,教育应该尽量有趣、尽量让人兴奋。电子游戏能把孩子牢牢吸住,教育为什么做不到?如果孩子能在游戏里高度投入,课堂上却提不起劲,那说明教育的设计出了问题。
他很看重一件事:解释"为什么"。
我们要教你这个东西,同时要告诉你为什么教、它和什么相关。(马斯克)
这背后有进化逻辑。人类天生会忘掉和当下无关的东西。相关性没被讲清楚,大脑就默认它没用,记不住。哪怕它其实很有用,只要没人解释,就等于没关系。进化决定了人脑会优先保留对生存和未来有用的信息,其他的一律淡出。
他举了个具体例子。要教发动机原理,更好的做法是把发动机拆开再装回去。拆装过程中自然会冒出问题:需要什么工具?螺丝刀、扳手、内六角、绞盘。工具在需求里自然出现。
先有问题,再有工具,相关性就建立起来了,学习也有了叙事线。按科目切块、先把工具学一遍再去碰真实场景,效率低得多。
比特币蛋糕和狗狗币的讽刺
加密货币是绕不开的话题。马斯克先声明,他得小心说话,因为有些话会影响市场。
然后他讲了个故事。2013年,一个朋友给他带了一块比特币蛋糕,上面有比特币标志,他吃了一块。那位朋友多年来一直劝他入场。
我八年前就该买点比特币。人们还能做什么呢?真是来得太晚了。(马斯克)
他承认自己反应慢,道了歉。但现在的立场很明确:他认为比特币是好事,他是比特币的支持者。他觉得比特币正处在被传统金融界广泛接受的边缘。
对其他加密货币,他没有强烈观点。狗狗币他偶尔开玩笑,但那些真的只是玩笑。狗狗币本来就是用来讽刺加密货币的。
然后他说了一句很有意思的话:命运喜欢讽刺。用费米式的说法,最讽刺的结果往往最可能。或者说,最有娱乐性的结果往往最可能。
最讽刺的结果,是狗狗币未来成为地球的货币。(马斯克)
全场大笑。但他说的"最有趣的结果最可能发生",其实是他看世界的一个底层假设。很多看似玩笑的判断,背后都有这套逻辑在跑。
一天是怎么过的:上下文切换是精神杀手
有人问他典型的一天。马斯克说,醒来先看短信和邮件,有没有紧急情况。经常有。
他坦言,自己处理的很大一部分事情既不有趣也不好玩,就是杂务。他努力想甩掉这些杂务,但一旦不做,事情就会失控。
他不喜欢邮件。他说自己一看到邮件,边缘系统就有轻微的负面反应,邮件在折磨他。文本消息好处理得多,面对面会议更好,视频会议也行,反正什么都比邮件强。
日历基本是背靠背的会议。大部分是工程和设计,也有财务、销售这些公司运转必需的事。
真正的杀手是上下文切换。
恐惧不是精神杀手,上下文切换才是。(马斯克)
他说在SpaceX和特斯拉之间来回切换非常难,再加上Neuralink、Boring Company,还有个人事务和meme。Boring Company和Neuralink体量小,占用的CPU负载低一些,但切换本身照样消耗人。
他的应对办法是尽量少切换:一件事专注一小时,再换下一件。
他的日历排得很满,信息量像洪流。他说不建议别人来审计他的一天,太疯狂了。会议也不是"有空就来"的那种,每一个都是"必须开"。他偶尔会想,自己还能这样撑多久,是不是该休一周假清空一下脑子。
他还提到,关于特斯拉和SpaceX的书很多,但作者不在现场,很难写对。他考虑过自己写一本,把这些年犯的蠢错误和可能对别人有用的建议都记下来。
睡在会议室外面
有人问他现在还睡工厂地板吗。他说只在危机时。
逻辑很简单:当他要求团队拼命工作时,他必须在场,而且必须被看见。看见才相信。
他凌晨四点睡,四小时后起来。他特意睡在会议室外面,不进会议室,因为外面大家走过能看到。
我要求他们全力以赴,我自己就不能不全力以赴。(马斯克)
访谈者提到去过他的工厂,会议室就在厂房中间,十几英尺外就是巨型机器人,砸金属的声音不断。马斯克确认了,他大多数时候确实不在会议室里睡,而是在门外地板上。
全世界最富有的人,睡在轰鸣的厂房过道里。这画面比任何管理课都有说服力。
如果凭空多出五个小时:隧道和mRNA
有人问他,如果一天多出五个小时,会用来做什么新东西。
第一件事是隧道。他说过去五年一直跟人讲隧道有机会,没人动手,于是他干脆自己做了Boring Company。先是在洛杉矶挖了条测试隧道,没人信,然后在拉斯维加斯做了第一条运营隧道。
他的理由是,所有大城市都有交通问题,隧道能大幅改善生活质量,让城里人移动起来更容易。再往后是长途:把隧道抽成真空,速度可以超过飞机和高铁。
第二件事是mRNA,或者说合成病毒。他认为BioNTech和Moderna已经证明了效果,但人们还没完全意识到背后发生了什么:医学正在数字化。
你可以像写计算机程序一样,写一段RNA或DNA序列,然后把它扩增几百万倍、几十亿倍,再用脂质外壳包起来,让它看起来像细胞喜欢的零食。细胞是生物计算机,你给它一张打孔卡,它就照着执行。
理论上,你甚至可以想办法把人变成一只蝴蝶。(马斯克)
这话听着像狂想,但逻辑是自洽的:细胞执行指令,指令可以编程。过去医学靠试错,未来医学可能靠写代码。
更让人意外的是,特斯拉在做RNA微型工厂。四年前特斯拉收购了德国南部一家自动化公司Grohmann,对方说可以卖,但有两个和汽车无关的项目想继续做。
一个是芯片分析设备,另一个就是生物技术:DNA扩增、RNA扩增,再加脂质壳包裹。马斯克说,只要不超过10%的资源,就让他们继续。现在这套设备已经做到第三代,原本用于CureVac,也愿意给其他公司做。
一个造电动车的公司,顺手做了RNA生产设备。这种跨界在马斯克的公司里不算稀奇,但它说明一件事:底层能力的迁移,往往发生在你没想到的地方。
疫苗:我是支持疫苗的
聊到疫苗,马斯克特意澄清立场。
我不是反疫苗者,我是支持疫苗的。(马斯克)
他的判断是,疫苗供应会指数级增长,特斯拉那套设备也能帮上忙。再加上已经感染并康复的人群,社会正在接近某种程度的群体免疫。他还提到,自然感染产生的抗体反应比疫苗更强,但整体信息是乐观的:会有大量疫苗,他鼓励人们去打。
访谈到这里,Clubhouse已经被挤爆了,溢出房间开了十几个。对话在一种很随意的气氛里收尾。
所有事情都在跟时间赛跑
把整场对话串起来看,马斯克的思路有一条主线:所有事情都在跟时间赛跑。
火星要在窗口关闭前建成自给自足的城市。AI要在失控前和人类意志耦合。脑机接口要在AI远超人类之前把带宽提上去。文明要在下一次大过滤器之前变成多行星的。连比特币,他都在后悔八年前没上车。
这些判断不一定对,但它们彼此咬合,构成一套完整的世界观。你可以不同意,但很难说它自相矛盾。
普通读者从这场访谈里能带走的最有用的部分,可能不在那些宏大预测,而在他讲方法的地方:怎么学习,怎么工作,怎么看待新事物,怎么带团队。这些今天就能用上。
- 学任何新东西,先回答"为什么学"。相关性讲不清楚,大脑就会把它当噪音删掉。给孩子讲数学,先从一道真实的题开始,别从公式开始。
- 遇到复杂问题,先找场景再找工具。拆一台发动机,比背一本扳手手册有用。工作里也一样,先接一个真实项目,再补需要的技能。
- 把上下文切换当成真正的成本。一次专注一件事一小时,比五件事来回横跳效率高得多。开会前先想清楚这场会属于哪条线,别让大脑反复重装系统。
- 对新事物保持"比特币蛋糕"式的开放。2013年那块蛋糕,马斯克吃了,却没买,八年后他自己说来得太晚。看到新东西,先花半小时搞懂它,再决定要不要错过。
- 带团队时自己先在场。要求别人拼命,就别只发邮件。哪怕只是坐在旁边被看见,也比远程喊话有用。
- 关注合成生物学和mRNA。医学正在变成可编程的东西,这个变化会比大多数人的预期来得快。哪怕不创业,至少知道它在发生。
- 找时间读一遍《银河系漫游指南》。读它主要为提醒自己:问题比答案难。
0:00us so we had one about six months ago about a year and a half there'll be another one so figure you know i don't know five and a half years five and a half years so what does it take from here to that point like what are the milestones you think [Music]
0:32and then you need to have orbital refilling so where you can extend the ship up toward it then send another sugar dock with a transfer propellant so that you can load up to being almost full with propellant and then go to mars then you can go to mars and then and then one one last thing is on mars so you need a local propellant production if you have those elements life can become multi-planetary and we can have a self-sustaining city on mars which i think is one of the most important things we could possibly do for ensuring the long-term existence of consciousness you've spoken about this often which is you know expanding the scope of consciousness and how it is tied to
1:14multi-planetary life could you explain what that means for you and why that matters to you sure so the originally i i had sort of quite kind of an existential crisis when i was a kid i forgot what's the meaning of life why are we here what's the point of it all is it all meaningless i got quite depressed actually and sad about it and and then the thing that kind of broke me out of it was reading douglas adams's hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy where he essentially pointed out that the universe is the answer and really the hard part is figuring out what questions to ask about the answer that is the universe yeah exactly it's huge exactly try to
1:57make fun of the fact that the answer is the easy easy part but the questions are the hard part so in order for us to gain a a better understanding of what questions to ask or to understand what it's all about we have to increase the scope and scale of consciousness so that we're better able to figure out which questions to ask and answer them i think there's arguably a great filter that we face with you know will we become a multi-planet species or not you know we'll be surprised about their in our galaxy and others that there are a whole bunch of dead one planet civilizations that prospered prospered for a while they might have prospered for millions of
2:35years but then gradually the civilization collapsed for reasons external or internal and and that was that all civilizations go through to go through an arc where they they build they grow up in technology complexity but then they they don't keep going up they over time they they decline they fall this has happened obviously with your student history with many civilizations in the past you can look at ancient egypt you know five thousand years ago there was the great part of my giza but then the the people living there forgot how to build pyramids after a while and then they forgot how to read hieroglyphics you know givens famous book about the
3:17decline and fall of the roman empire and how they they had advanced technology in terms of roads aqueducts plumbing and so forth and and then they basically forgot about it the ancient sumerian stabilonians all these things that they've all gone through a similar arc which suggests that most likely we will go through an arc ourselves and we'll be probably less resilient to recovery because of globalization for the first time in the four and a half billion year history of earth has been possible to extend life beyond earth and make life falsely planetary and this window of opportunity may be open for alongside i hope it is or it may be open for a short and i
3:59think it time be wise for us to assume that it's open for a short time i'm an optimist not a pessimist but i you know you have to say like there's some chance of selling open for a short time and we should take advantage of this this brief window of opening where we can trans transfer life transport life to make life multi-planetary and and humanity is essentially the agent of life in this process and i think we almost have an obligation to ensure that the creatures of earth continue even if there was a calamity on earth which as i said could be man-made or it could be some national calamity as if you look at the fossil record there's there are many many mass extinctions
4:39yeah i think yeah i think you know all of that made sense and i think we've heard you've talked about this before i think one other question i have is you know when we get there you know we have to set up the whole society we have to set up civilization there how will the whole thing work in your mind like you know everything from what does it mean to have internet connection in mars all the way to like garments and rules and laws and everything yeah i think all those things need to happen in the us and happen in every country i would not presume to prescribe what should happen there i think the important part is just that we get people there
5:17and we get the equipment necessary to establish a self-sustaining civilization at least one self-sustaining city and i think the key threshold of when we would pass the great culture of this this particular great filter is is mars sufficiently self sustaining such that if the ships stop coming from earth for any reason it could be you know something massive or something i mean civilization on earth could end with a bang or a weapon but by the way if the ship stopped coming from mars does mars die out or not and it only has to be missing one little ingredient like the equivalent of vitamin c and it will survive for a while but it will not but it will eventually die out
5:59so it's kind of getting getting steroids to pass that that critical threshold where it is self-sustaining and are we able to do that before some calamity or or a gradual decline civilization occurs that prevents the strips from going there that's the key threshold in it i mean in a more pithy way is like the city on mars become self-sustaining which comes first a self-sustaining study on march or world war three if if you if you kind of let yourself dream out over the next few decades like what would you what would you consider success like let's say they get through the first you know five years in the first 10 years like what do you think is possible to build on mars
6:3910 years in 20 years then 30 years in after first arrival well i think i think most of it let's thought of being very tiny just like a tiny little outpost and by the way it's going to be very dangerous sometimes people think oh is this like some escape hatch forest people like no it won't be dangerous hard work it's gonna be you're out there on the frontier there's a way far more ways to die there than there are on earth and a transfer to hard work but it will be a fun and advent and a great adventure but over time like this would take a while but you could terraform the planet and make it earth-like mostly by just like warming it up do you think the sort of vector of
7:25civilization will unfold differently as a consequence of how difficult it's going to be to get it going yeah it probably will okay so so then maybe maybe we don't just have a backup right maybe we actually have an alternative like a and the ability to actually see two different two like fundamentally different civilizations flourish yeah absolutely the the the fact that it's you can only go to mars every two years and that is six months six months journey although i think we can over time get that potentially as low as one month but still you can't go to mars when earth is on the on the other side of the the sun from mars like the you know times where
8:01you know mars lifting the other side of the sun you can't get don't know what you do that time gap would mean that you know there'd be essentially a new group of people arriving roughly every two years i don't know i think interesting people probably trace their like yeah i came on you know this particular good you know earth synchronization event but like like the important thing is is like that we've established mars as a self-sustaining civilization and that we've done whatever we can to ensure long-term continuance of of consciousness as we know it because so as far as we can tell we're the only the live conscious which is a delicate little candle in the dark it's only here
8:44on earth i mean it might be else place other places there's arguments that it's likely to be other places honestly we have seen no sign of it and and i'm pretty sure that i wouldn't know about it and i am i've seen nothing to indicate that there's any alien civilization whatsoever i would i i'd be the first to jump on that in a second but i see i've seen there's such evidence you know that's actually something we wanted to ask you about because in the last year there has been multiple reported ufo sightings there was the mysterious object that flew past our solar system i think you just described that you haven't seen any evidence of aliens but
9:22we if we if we do have you heard of dark forest theory from the free body problem how do you think we should think about aliens yeah i i'm trying to be strict in the scientific sense the word of saying i've seen no no not a single piece of conclusive evidence that doesn't mean there aren't aliens i'm just literally saying i've seen nothing that could not be explained by other means and where the probable explanation by other means is much more likely than this alien technology so and for people to say like they're sightings of aliens i'm like listen man the the resolution of the picture needs to be at least like 7 11 atm good okay
10:11is that like a 500 megapixel camera what what are you talking about where do you find that thing so you you famously have a pile of you know really beautiful kids and you know i know you care about them a great deal as all parents too what would your response be if they start coming to you when they turn 18 or you know 22 and they say you know dad you know you know now you planted us on mars and there's calling for me like i really want to go yeah i think if we're talking about say those third or fourth set of landings on mars i think that'd probably be i'd be okay with that although i've called them so far and none of them say they want to go so
10:44they may change their minds but currently they're they're not chomping at flip to go to mars it's just safe to say and i want to move on from mars to memes it is safe to say that you might be the master of the memes and in fact you had a quote who controls the means controls the universe can you just explain what you meant by that and how you became a man well i mean it's a i mean it's a play on words from from dune who controls the spice controls universe
11:16and this if memes are spice then it's memes i mean there's a little bit of truth to it in that like like how do you you know what is it that influences the zeitgeist like how how do things become interesting to people it means like actually kind of a complex form of communication that's that like a picture says a thousand words and maybe a meme says ten thousand you know it's a complex picture with it with a bunch of meaning in it and it can be it's you know aspirationally funny you know it's i don't know i love memes that they i mean i think they can be very insightful you know throughout history i think the symbolism in general has powerfully
11:59affected people today you're posting about neuralink and why people should be working there for folks who don't know about it i thought it was really cool like you know just the possibility of it it's just really fantastic tell us more about it you know there are a lot of engineers listening on this this clubhouse you know what is neural link why should we care what is possible with it sure so the the long term okay so new link stands from a concern i had where i was trying to figure out even in a benign ai scenario how do we at least go along for the ride so i mean if for those who are falling ai closely it's it's obviously improving dramatically
12:39you know if you see like look let's say gt1 versus gpt 2 vs gp3 super t3 and just how radically that's improved and just as like you know deep minds and i mean i think they've run out of games to win at basically it's just and look i said like a tesla an important thing to note is like tesla actually has i think one of the the strongest ai teams in the world but it's ai team focused on real-world usability we're just really solving vision perception and control with the ai but even in a benign scenario for ai where let's say like the ai is like just really wants to be super nice to us and make us happy little how do we stay relevant and still
13:18and have meaning and at least go along for the ride that's not a good scenario and then in terms of avoiding the bad scenario we can couple collective human will to the outcome of artificial intelligence and what's developed in that way i think that would probably be a better scenario than if we're unable to effectively couple collective human world to that outcome so it's you know at some point peter gets smart enough it's like the kids like trying to talk to a tree you know trees do sort of talk but they've talked so slow that we don't notice so we need to improve the bandwidth and with a direct neural interface we can improve the bandwidth between
13:59your cortex and your digital tertiary layer by many orders of magnitude i'd say probably at least a thousand or maybe 10 000 or more we could also spend a lot more time thinking about interesting things as opposed to taking complex thought structures compressing them down into words which is which also gain a very low butt rate and then having someone else receive those words decompress them and then send words back at you so a huge amount about brain power spent in compression decompression and we could be instead sending it on deeper concepts and so if you had a neural link if two people had a neural link you could do conceptual telepathy where you
14:42have a conflict series a complex series of concepts and you can just transfer them directly uncompressed to the other person this would massively improve the quality of communication and the speed of it and then there are other sort of pretty wild things that could be done like you could probably save state in the brain and so if so if you were to die you could your state could be returned either in the form of another human body or a robot body okay this is getting like really you know it's weird sci-fi stuff here
15:17yeah exactly but i think you could decide you want to be a robot or a person or whatever and you wouldn't be exactly the same so you know there'd be a little lust in transfer but you could also say it's also arguably true that when you wake up in the morning you're not exactly the same as yesterday or the u of a month ago is not the same as you of today i mean a bunch of brain cells have died and memory some memories have faded some have strengthened their new memories anyway the point is like you wouldn't be you could there could be something analogous to a video game like a saved game situation where you are able to resume upload your last state yeah
15:53kind of like alter carbon maybe lose a few memories but but mostly be you so now that's the long-term stuff in the short term for neurolink the idea would really just be to address brain injuries or spinal injuries and you know make up for whatever lust capacity somebody has with with a ch with an implanted ship the first thing that we're going after is a wireless implanted chip that would enable someone who is a quadriplegic or quadriplegic or tetraplegic to control a computer or mouse or their phone or really any device just use just by thinking and this obviously would be a massive enabler you know make life way way easier for them there have been
16:39sort of primitive versions of this device one done with like wires sticking out of your head but it doesn't work all the time and and you can't take it home with you so just having basically you think like in it in simplistic terms i'd say it's sort of like a fitbit in your skull with tiny wires that go to your brain so fitbit in your skull with tiny wires so if somebody who's listening is is good at designing like fitbits apple watches phones computers various kinds then actually they would be a great fit for your link probably be releasing some some new videos showing progress maybe in a month or so and because we've already got like a monkey with
17:18with with a wireless implant in their skull and the tiny wires who can play video games using his mind and he's and amazing so it's not not looked like an unhappy monkey and you can't even see where the neural implant was put in except for that he's got like a slight like dark mohawk
17:43yeah he's not uncomfortable and he doesn't look weird so that so we're oh and i was like when when the usda person came through and inspected our facilities our monkey facilities she said it was like the the nicest monkey facilities she's ever seen in her entire career just fyi we went the extra mile for the monkeys as long as you didn't make them play cyberpunk that would be a well that would be a hell of a trip for monkey you know one of the things we're trying to figure out is like can we have the monkeys play mind pong with each other you know that would be pretty cool i have to say the pig demo was really fantastic that was that was really cool
18:28thanks yeah well it's it's a great team at neurolink and making good progress and like i said but i want to feel like the early applications will really just be for you know people who've had a serious brain injury like where it's like the the value of the implant is just would be enormous because obviously the early implants will come with some non-trivial risk and so it's going to be like okay does the good far outweigh the bad and then you know that that would be a candidate for some of the initial surgeries with full disclosure of like these little risks and everything and one of the things we're all we're really paying close attention to is the
19:05ability to remove the implant so it's like it's not like you know for if somebody doesn't want it or it's not working we can take it out and then we can re-implant another one so we've tested implantation removal and re-implantation say and it works great what you know with everything that we know now and kind of all the modern tools that we have like what's the best way to think about educating a five-year-old in today's world well my observation is my kids were mostly educated by youtube and reddit and and then you know and their i guess classmates and and they were i guess they were lessons as well but judging by the amount of time they spent
19:40online it seemed like most of their education is actually coming from online i mean i think generally with education you want to make it as interesting and exciting as possible you have to say like what are some of the like if you see like what old things like say a a good video game does to keep someone engaged and interested you know if they're if kids can be super engaged in video games like it's weird for them to be super engaged in education as well like one of the things that's i think very fundamental is to explain the why of of things like so we're teaching this but we need we're going to explain why we're teaching you this and why it is
20:12relevant i mean we've evolved to to forget things that are irrelevant or have low low relevance probability it makes sense like otherwise we'd remember all sorts of nonsense things that are weren't very important to our future so unless unless relevance is established clearly then people will have a hard time remembering remembering advice nature but it's because it appears to be irrelevant it might be relevant but if it's not explained to them they won't know there's if you want to have some sort of engage if you're trying to problem-solving some sort of engaging narrative for for the problem-solving like it's like far better to say okay if we're
20:49going to teach you how an engine works by taking apart an engine and and then putting it back together and then let's find out what tools are needed for you know in order to take this engine apart and put it back together it's like okay we need screwdrivers and wrenches and allen keys and we need a winch and you know a bunch of other things and then you understand the relevance and and it's much more interesting problem this is much better than having say a course on wrenches or a course on screwdrivers you just like start with a problem and say what tools i need to solve this problem that establishes relevance and gives a compelling narrative thread
21:24elon okay this is something you joked about but i'm kind of curious to get your you know maybe serious answer to this which is all things cryptocurrency and bitcoin you famously just change your twitter bio to just the bitcoin logo and the word bitcoin this week what do you think of cryptocurrency what do you think of bitcoin what do you think of other you know currencies would love to get your take on the entire thing well yeah i gotta watch what i say here because some of these things can really move them move the market first of all i should say like many friends of mine have tried to convince me to get involved in bitcoin for a long time like from where it first
22:02just popped you know you popped out there you know my friend my bully he he actually had bitcoin cake a cake that was like had a good sibling and he fed me a slice of bitcoin cake in 2013. i mean clearly i should have at least bite bought some bitcoin eight years ago like what what more do people even do you know like jesus talk about being late so i was a little slow on the uptake there my apologies but i i and i think about it for a bit but i i do at this point think bitcoin is a good thing i am a supporter of bitcoin well you know like i said i'm late to the party but i'm a supporter of bitcoin and i think bitcoin is really on the verge of getting
22:46broad acceptance by sort of the conventional finance people you know yeah i think so you know i i don't have a strong opinion on other cryptocurrencies i mean occasionally i make jokes about dogecoin but but they are they are really just meant to be jokes but you know dogecoin is made as a
23:05as a made as a joke to make fun of cryptocurrencies obviously but fate loves irony and and often as a fermi says that the most ironic outcome is the most likely or as like like i say the most entertaining outcome is is often most likely arguably the most entertaining outcome and the most ironic outcome would be that dogecoin becomes the currency of earth in the future [Laughter] it's safe to say a lot of people are very interested in how you work and you often for example describe yourself as an engineer so walk us through it's monday morning you wake up what is the day a typical work day in the life of elon look like i guess i wake up and and see if
23:47there are any emergencies by on text or email and often they are so i mean the a ton of what i deal with is not actually fun or interesting it's like chores i've tried really hard not to do my chores but then if i don't do my chores things go to hell yeah man you have to do your chores basically i'm a bit relieved that elon musk basically has the same schedule as the rest of us you know we all do i mean that's pretty much how it goes these days i do enjoy the in-person meetings more than email in fact i haven't i think i'm getting like a slight like negative like limbic reaction to email it's killing me texts are way better to deal with and and then in post meetings are are
24:34much better even zoom meetings or whatever you know they're still better than email anything's been on email frankly so anyway i'll have a bunch of meetings i'll write email write text especially if it's like an email to the group like saying hey we need to i think we need to change direction and do the following things and let me know if you think otherwise but otherwise we've got to do these follow these things and get get our act together in this area or that area and then yeah a bunch of meetings most of my meetings are engineering and design but of course you have to deal with finance and you know sales and other things and you know the things
25:13that are necessary for a company to function and and then then there's this quite a lot of context switching and so he sent me the meme of like fear is not the mind killer context switching is the mind killer which i totally agree with context switching is a real bear just try trying to basically try to do less context switching so maybe focus on one thing for an hour and then another thing for another hour it's really hard to context switch between spacex and tesla and all the things that are going on in space next to tesla and then and then neural link boring company which was fortunately pretty low low bandwidth they don't take a high level
25:53of cpu load because they were smaller and there's their personal stuff and and of course memes you know gotta get that's important what i mean i was like where's my meme and we are expecting a meme by now what does your calendar look like you have this yeah you allocated 30 minutes back to back you have a lot of open space how do you handle it i don't have a lot of open space it's generally back-to-back meetings and it's insane i mean my my days are like insane torrents tolerance of information i mean sometimes people if you want to like audit what i do for a day it's it's insane i don't recommend it i i i i mean yeah looks like i was thinking like man how long can i keep
26:36this up because i i don't want my brain to explode and it's like the meetings that are scheduled are not like nice to have meetings they're like this meeting is essential like okay it's pretty intense i was thinking like maybe i should like at some point like take a week off or something you know clear my mind i know there's like a bunch of people like writing books on tesla and spacex for example like it's very pretty hard for them to get it right because they just weren't there and maybe i should like write some like book of my experiences that has like you know all the foolish mistakes i've done and like you know some advice for others that might be helpful do you still sleep
27:12on the floor of your factory i remember used to at one point in time i did i haven't i only if there's like a crisis situation you know i actually it's like basically when when the team is being asked to do to to really work super hard i i i gotta be right there with them and they gotta they gotta see it you know seeing is believing and so if i'm just sleeping in the middle of the factory floor you know i sort of go to sleep at four in the morning and like you know waking up like four hours later and like they literally see me they walk past me it's not like hidden or anything and it's like okay see i was willing to take that level of pain then then they'll do it too i was
27:51going to say when you first said you slept in the factory i figured you know there must be like an executive floor or something and you must have like a couch and it must be like a nice setup and then you know when i when i came over when i came over to see you that one time you know it's like you have your conference room is literally literally in the middle of the factory and like the the giant sure i'm pardon my my my swearing but i have to the giant robots are like 15 feet away yeah and they're they're pounding metal and it's like you're splitting and your factory is like literally your your room is like literally right in the middle of them and then i at least i saw
28:24your your like sleeping bag in the conference room so i assume that's where you're sleeping and i didn't see any of the rooms like yeah so it's not just a factory it's like that's intense most of the time i did not sleep in the conference room because people could not see me in the conference room so i slept on the floor outside the conference room yeah but i was i was asking people to really go all out you know and i can't expect them to go out if i'm not doing the same thing when people think how does the richest person in the world live they don't think uncomfortably sleeping outside a conference room with like a lot of loud banging going on right next
28:53door they probably don't but people the people of the factory do they saw it themselves i love it that's what and that's what's important you know if you had to start if you somehow magically found an extra five hours in a day and you had to start another company or another effort what would you start i think there are still tremendous opportunities in tunneling you know for for five years like people ask me what would i see opportunities and i'd say tunneling and then nobody did anything so then actually initially as a joke created the boring company just and did it we did like a test tunnel in l.a and then still people don't believe us and then so we just did our first
29:30operational tunnel in vegas but the world really needs tunnels in it because all major cities have traffic and tunnels can massively improve people's quality of life by making it easier to travel from one place to another in a city and then that can be further expanded to long distance travel where if you just draw a vacuum on the tunnel then you can go extremely fast faster than a plane and faster than a plane or a high speed rail so i'd really still recommend can someone else say please start a styling company that'll be great then there's rna or mrna basically synthetic viruses which is we've seen puts a good effect with bioin tech and moderna but i think we'll then quite
30:14quite appreciate that that what's actually going on is the digitization of medicine it's where you can just literally create an rna or dna sequence like a computer program and then encapsulate that in a you have to multiply it many many millions of times billions of times and encapsulate that in a liquid shell so it looks like a tasty treat for yourselves and you can literally do anything this is absolutely the future of medicine when i say it i mean you could you could probably figure out how to turn someone into a literal butterfly okay that's it it's complete it's your cells are biological computers they're they execute just like at like a sort of
30:52old-school computer where you'd feed it like a you know if you you'd feel a tape you know or or a punch card that's that's just feed that that your cells which are tiny tiny biological computers this punch card and they will do whatever that punch card says that that was probably a big eye opener last for 2020 of like just the understanding the potential of rna and then just super randomly tesla actually is making a fairly advanced rna sort of micro fab or something where for currently for cure back but we're open to making it for other companies as well oh maybe i i don't think i i'm not sure i understand this why is tesla making an rna fad it's super random
31:39so like about four a little over four years ago we were quite a company in germany primarily for they were they're very good at automation it's called they were called groman and they're they're in southern germany near basically a city of rome at that time the acquisition they they said like look we're willing to be acquired but there's like just a couple of projects that we think even though they're not related to automotive we'd really like to continue if you don't mind that's like and the two projects were one is one is this like tiny chip analyzer or like i think with tiny wires for analyzing chips that intel needs from for making cpus and then another one was
32:19this biotech thing it's basically well there's this there's three parts to it there's a dna multiplier an rna multiplier and something which puts them the lipid shell on the rna sequence we're on like version three of it now and they said could they keep going so if you keep it under 10 percent of resources no problem you can keep going and then i know it turned out like it turns out it may actually be useful and i know because i know the tesla machine it can make a bazillion doses super fast so you know i think this there's definitely for those who are concerned about the vaccine it should you should expect an exponential increase in vaccine availability
32:59and then combined with that we we are i think starting to approach some degree of herd immunity with you know people who contract the virus and and and recovered so which is actually better than getting vaccine the antibody reaction is better than if you've got the vaccine i don't know about it but overall i think optimistic message that there will be lots of vaccines and i would really encourage people to take the vaccine i'm not an anti-vaxxer i want to be clear i'm pro-vaxxer okay elon you know i think you know i don't you don't take up too much of your time this has been amazing you're pretty much broken clubhouse there are probably about like over a
33:39dozen maybe more overflow rooms and i see so many twitter friends right now you've been so generous
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版