访谈·中文精读

马斯克 2020 火星学会访谈 | 剪辑版

Elon Musk interview at Mars Society 2020 |CUT|

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

全球所有一次性火箭的运力加在一起,大约500到600吨。这是马斯克在2020年火星学会(Mars Society)线上访谈里给出的数字。而他要建一座能自己活下去的火星城市,按他的倒推,需要往火星表面送100万吨物资,折算下来得先往近地轨道送500万吨。

差着四个数量级。

这场访谈有9000人报名旁听。主持人开门见山,问他当初为什么创办SpaceX,为什么把「让人类成为多行星物种」当成必须完成的目标。马斯克的回答没从浪漫开始,他从概率开始。

他不想造一艘逃生舱

理由可以拆成三层。第一层是好奇心:人类想知道宇宙到底是怎么回事。第二层是稀缺:就目前所知,宇宙里只有人类这一份意识,他没找到任何外星人存在的迹象。第三层是概率:既然只有这一份,那就该采取最有可能让未来变好的那组行动。

火星学会的人习惯把火星殖民比作救生艇。马斯克当场把这个比喻否掉了。

如果你只是搬到另一个地方,然后在那里很快死掉,那不算数,那算不上什么救生艇。除非火星实现自给自足,而这大概率不会在我有生之年发生。(马斯克)

他给自给自足下了一个很硬的测试标准:假设来自地球的飞船因为任何原因停飞了,火星会不会因此灭亡?如果会,人类就还站在悬崖边上。飞船停运的原因可以很平常,也可以很极端,核战争、超级火山、彗星撞击,甚至人类自己蔫蔫地把自己耗死,哪一种都算。

于是他把整场判断压成一句话:我们是要在第三次世界大战之前,还是之后,建成自给自足的火星城市?他的估计是「之后」的概率很低,那就必须在「之前」完成。

他也顺手给了当下一个评价:文明现在的状态看起来有点摇摇欲坠。

这段话在2020年说出来,语境很特殊。不过他随后补了一句更重要的:这算不上逃离地球的出口。真正的意义是给整个文明降低生存风险,顺带提供一个让人愿意从床上爬起来、对未来感到兴奋的方向。永远困在地球上,直到某一次灭绝事件把人类清空,在他看来是件压抑又无趣的事。

先钉死目标,再倒推火箭

主持人数次想把话题引到具体设计上,问从猎鹰9号、猎鹰重型到星舰,这条技术路线是怎么一步步走过来的。马斯克的回应有点不耐烦:工程师们没回答你的原问题。

他的方法论只有一句:必须先说清什么叫目标,然后才能拿各种设计去对照这个目标打分。没有目标,你连「哪个设计更好」这个问题都无法定义,更没法解释为什么A比B强。

目标定死了:尽快把足够的吨位和足够的人送上火星,让火星城市自给自足。接下来就是做数学。

火星表面要堆100万吨,包含人在内。按大约五分之一的比例折算,意味着要有400到500万吨有效载荷进近地轨道。这个比例听着乐观,他说这已经是「使劲抠那些小数点」之后的结果:每一吨送到近地轨道的东西,最后能有一吨落到火星表面就算不错,五比一是比较有信心的估计,运气好能到五吨换一吨,差一点四吨换一吨也认了。

然后他抛出那个对比数字。全球所有一次性火箭的入轨能力加起来,大概五六百吨。他假设全世界疯了一样把产能提高一千倍,那也才50万吨,只有需求量的十分之一。

顺着这个比例继续往下推,五六百吨对500万吨,差距在万分之一量级。结论没变:一次性火箭这条路,就算全世界拼了命干,也够不到目标的边。

卖一次性飞机,你会被笑出房间

顺着这个数字,马斯克说了一段全场最不留情面的话。

一次性火箭在我看来蠢透了,完全是浪费时间,人们应该停止浪费时间。你试着卖一次性飞机,人们会把你笑出房间。卖一次性汽车,会被笑出房间。卖一次性马,别人会以为你脑子有问题。(马斯克)

他觉得荒诞的地方在于,同一批造飞机的公司,卖一次性火箭却心安理得。波音造可重复使用的737,却可以坦然把火箭做成一次性的。他顺带开了个玩笑,说737 MAX某段时间确实成了「一次性飞机」,但那是事故,跟设计无关。

可复用到底难在哪,他给了一组很具体的数字。亚轨道可复用火箭容易,入轨可复用火箭很难。即便一堆聪明人投入大量精力,一般也就能把4%的起飞质量变成入轨载荷。3%算正常水平,4%算史诗级发挥,他不确定真有人做到过4%。

而要做复用,你得先设计一枚「一次性状态下能送4%载荷」的火箭,然后允许自己把其中一半的运力花在复用结构上。隔热、栅格舵、着陆腿、着陆用的剩余燃料,样样都要占重量。最后净剩2%左右,助推器、上级、整流罩,全都得复用。

猎鹰1号当年试过用降落伞回收一级,结果一级再入时像撞上一堵水泥墙,直接炸了。马斯克说他一开始还去怪降落伞供应商,后来才想明白,问题不在人家。这件事教会他:高马赫数再入时的热量和力量,必须专门设计结构去化解。

为什么火箭越大越划算

规模经济在火箭上体现得比大多数行业更极端。

小火箭的麻烦在于,电子设备不会跟着一起缩小。一枚很小的火箭,航电系统的重量能占到载荷相当大的一部分。马斯克说,如果硬要做一枚一万公斤级的入轨火箭,载荷大概率是零,全被自己的「大脑」吃掉了。火箭变大,大脑尺寸不变,航电占比就趋近于零。

加工精度上也有一份红利。东西小的时候,公差控制很难,铸件有最小壁厚,复合材料蒙皮有颗粒度问题,误差条相对尺寸就显得很大。做大之后这些限制松开了,壁厚的百分比精度反而能做得很漂亮,铸件也能浇得很准。他承认这些是几乎没人会注意的细节。

他还举了两个生活里的类比:运货用一辆大半挂,比用一堆小卡车高效;跨洋运集装箱,不会让每个箱子挂个舷外机自己漂过去,那样太蠢。所以尺寸真的重要,完全复用也真的重要。

猎鹰9已经到顶,所以必须换甲烷

猎鹰9在它自己的架构里,马斯克认为已经接近局部最优了。燃气发生器循环、煤油加液氧、3.6米直径。直径卡在3.6米,是被公路运输的上限锁住的,再大就没法用车拉,物流成本会失控。而一枚又细又长的火箭在质量效率上吃亏,薄壁得加厚才能扛住弯矩。

煤油也不是对的燃料。他用最朴素的方式解释齐奥尔科夫斯基火箭方程:燃气喷得越快,推进剂占总质量的比例越高,火箭就飞得越远。甲烷的比冲更高,喷得更快。

另一个更关键的理由在火星。返程燃料要么从地球带过去,要么在当地造。带过去太贵,等于白干,那就必须就地生产。火星大气里全是二氧化碳,地下有水冰,两者一合成就是甲烷和液氧。猎鹰9用的RP-1煤油做不到这一点,它得从石油里炼。

还有一个不显眼但很实在的优势:氧燃比。煤油的氧燃质量比大约2.5比1,甲烷能到3.5比1。氧气密度大、便宜,地球上制氧厂整天在产氧,植物的光合作用也在产氧,成本基本等于电价。所以更高的氧占比,等于更便宜、更紧凑的推进剂组合。

星舰的最终参数是:起飞推力约为土星五号的两倍,载荷量级大致相当。多出来的那些推力,全部拿去换复用能力。他还把甲烷的化学式念了一遍,CH4,一个碳四个氢,配上氧分子O2,这些基础内容他笑着说只是替听众复习一下。

时间表全是概率,没有确切日期

主持人问所有人最想问的那串问题:什么时候高空试飞,什么时候入轨,什么时候首次货运火星,什么时候载人。

马斯克先给了个免责声明:这些全是猜测。他自己并没有什么藏着掖着的秘密日期。然后给出的是一串带百分比的判断,这种口气在航天口径里相当罕见。

  • 2021年让星舰入轨,他有80%到90%的信心。
  • 把超级重型助推器完整回收,只有50%到60%的信心。他形容这部分「比较悬」,得看运气。
  • 在真正搞定大气层再入和着陆之前,大概率会损失几艘飞船。
  • 助推器希望别丢,因为那上面发动机太多,贵得很。早期助推器试飞只装2到4台发动机,不是满配的28台。
  • 高频次飞行,大概要等到2022年,也就是两年后。

他特别强调一件事:创新的速率必须加快,不能减慢。如果只是线性增长,他这辈子都看不到火星城市,人会先老死。必须接近指数级的改进,火星才在射程之内。

火星窗口每26个月一次。2020年是一个,两年后一个,四年后一个。他觉得四年后那次窗口,无人星舰去火星「有一战之力」。

如果目标只是打败波音和洛马,就永远到不了火星

主持人问了一个很实在的问题:SpaceX的创新速度为什么这么快?2012年你在这个大会上演讲,之后可复用猎鹰、猎鹰重型、载人龙飞船、星链、星舰,一样接一样冒出来。

马斯克的回答有点绕,但绕完是一句大实话:他也不太确定,是目标本身起了决定作用。

如果目标只是「在发射商业卫星这件事上领先」,那公司的行为模式会变成一条平缓的对数曲线。今年10次发射,明年12次,对手6次,慢慢磨,慢慢挪。但如果目标是「在来不及之前让生命成为多行星物种」,时间就成了硬约束,不搞激进创新就一丝机会都没有。

这个目标制造了一种强制函数。他甚至有点羡慕竞争:如果洛克希德和波音也在认真瞄准火星,他会觉得是好事。可惜对方连可复用都不碰。他调侃说,这些公司造民航飞机时明明懂复用,卖火箭时却完全不觉得一次性有什么问题。

所以他的判断是:只要对手不瞄准火星,在「往近地轨道扔几颗卫星」这种平淡的赛道上,他们永远追不上。那些竞争在他的坐标系里只是沿途的小事。

火星建城的真正瓶颈是意愿和钱的交集

主持人问火星学会能帮上什么忙。马斯克给了一个集合论的答案。

他说需要两个集合求交集:一个是「想去火星的人」,一个是「能凑到钱去火星的人」。凑钱的方式可以自费、可以找赞助、可以拿政府资助、可以贷款,怎么都行。当这两个集合的交集达到大约一百万人,火星城市就成立了。也就是说,意愿和手段得同时具备。

火星学会的定位因此很清楚:他们负责提供「意愿」(the will),SpaceX负责提供「路径」(the way)。马斯克借用了那句英文俗语「where there's a will, there's a way」,说这件事上二者必须相交,才会出现一个多行星物种。主持人接了一句,你提供路径,我们提供意愿。

第一批落地的设备是燃料工厂,不是房子

有人问火星任务第2到第10次的优先级,是先搞探索、先搭基建,还是先做科学。

马斯克的回答很干脆:第一件事是建推进剂工厂。

流程他讲了一遍。挖冰取水,从大气里取二氧化碳,水加二氧化碳合成甲烷和液氧。听着简单,做起来极耗能,而且要做得足够可靠非常难。这个工厂能不能稳定运行,直接决定返程火箭能不能起飞,也决定后续所有任务能不能接着干。

至于科学载荷,他的态度格外开放:可以带一堆机器人上去,谁想把自家机器人捎上去都行,基本就是一台太阳能遥控车,SpaceX提供通信中继,你在家用电脑连上去开着玩,带腿的也行。这个画面他描述得挺兴奋,说会相当酷。

他还顺手打消了一个常见担忧。有人怕地球微生物污染火星,他的回应很直接:能在火星活下来的东西,强悍到了离谱的程度。那里又冷,紫外线又猛,地球带过去的任何东西想活下来都难上加难,火星环境比地球上任何地方都苛刻。

着陆点他没给确定答案,只列了筛选标准:中纬度、偏北半球,靠近水冰,别离太阳太远以保证太阳能供电,海拔要低,好让大气制动发挥最大效果。他个人偏好水手号峡谷(Valles Marineris)底部的一小块区域,那里气压高,附近有冰,但还需要实地勘探。

隧道公司起于一个玩笑

有人问,无聊公司(The Boring Company)是不是在为火星挖隧道做技术储备。马斯克说,这家公司一开始真的是个玩笑。

来龙去脉是这样:有五年多时间,他反复在公开场合说,求求谁去开一家隧道公司吧。城市交通的出路在三维化,要么上天,要么入地。天上的问题太多,飞行器噪音大、风压强、可能掉下来砸到人、还有隐私问题,坐在自家后院头顶飞过一堆东西并不舒服。地下这些问题都没有,还防天气。

他等了几年,没人动。那些所谓的交通专家也没拿出什么方案,洛杉矶和华盛顿特区堵得一塌糊涂。他索性自己下场,试试挖一条隧道到底有多难。

拉斯维加斯的第一条实用隧道一两个月后就要开放,他说大概能赶上国际消费电子展(CES)的时间点。

火星上当然也用得上隧道,但逻辑不同。地球上挖隧道不太在乎重量,往火星运设备,每一公斤都要算进成本,必须做一套极轻的系统。他承认无聊公司在这过程中积累的一些技术,将来也许能用上。

加注、月球版星舰、以及26个月的等待

被问到在轨加注什么时候能验证,马斯克给的时间是2022年,也就是大约两年后。

月球版星舰的原型,估计要两到三年。他强调,只要在轨加注跑通,一次就能往月球送100吨有效载荷,这是「有效载荷」意义上的100吨,不是总重。从月球到火星,中间只隔一次26个月的火星窗口。

星舰的适用范围他也讲了。这是艘通用飞船,太阳系里任何有固体表面能着陆的地方都能去。金星可以进大气层,因为那里大气密度极高、高度也高,能做出在地球大气里浮不起来的东西,在金星反而能浮着。水星太热,木星卫星周围辐射太强,谷神星和小行星可以去,土星、柯伊伯带、奥尔特云是更远的远期目标。

有了推进剂储库,星舰可以像跳岛一样在太阳系里一站一站挪。

但星际旅行它做不到。马斯克的说法是,先把「去另一颗行星」这件事做出来。一旦成为多行星物种,就形成了一个强制函数,逼着航天技术快速迭代,最终会催生能飞出太阳系的新技术。那是另一个量级的难题,得先把第一步踩实。

招人只看一条:卓越能力的证据

主持人问他招工程师看什么。马斯克的回答是「卓越能力的证据」(evidence of exceptional ability),高中没毕业也行,大学没读完也行,学历一概不看。

然后他讲了一段自嘲式的反思:很多公司的招聘流程会走偏,招进来的人未必对。

我有时候会想,如果尼古拉·特斯拉(Nikola Tesla)来特斯拉应聘,我们会不会给他一个面试机会?这真不好说。这人从东欧某个奇怪的学院出来,举止有点怪,我们大概会犹豫要不要面他。可正确的反应应该是:这孩子太聪明了,他要什么我们都给。(马斯克)

他承认意图和现实之间有差距,招聘漏斗有时候会把对的人筛掉。但至少意图是明确的:找那些能预测出「会做出非凡事情」的证据。

给年轻人的建议只有一句:学物理

有个十三四岁的女孩叫Dara,想当工程师,想造星舰和机器人,梦想是进SpaceX。马斯克说,工程的方向多得是,不用非学航空航天。电子、机械、电气、软件、化学工程都要人。化学工程尤其重要,用来设计推进剂储库,琢磨怎么把燃料工厂做得可靠。

然后他补了一句更根本的:物理是很好的思维训练底子。他一般建议大家都去上物理课,因为物理提供了最好的批判性思维工具。学完不一定去造火箭,但那套拆解问题、估算量级、区分相关与因果的本事,到哪都用得上。

普通人能做什么:让火星成为饭桌上的话题

有人问,喜欢火星但不知道该怎么帮忙的年轻人能做什么。这段回答是全场最像行动号召的部分。

马斯克说,做一名坚定的倡导者,这件事本身就有意义。因为大多数人根本没在想这件事。你在聚会上跟朋友提起,它甚至算不上一个话题。如果每个认为这件事重要的人,都把它变成日常对话的一部分,在网上、在饭桌上、在朋友之间反复说,情况就会不一样。

他给了一个具体到可以量化的标准:人类大概应该拿出1%的资源投入这件事。

他的论证方式很有意思。这1%不会从根本上改变生活质量,比医疗开支少得多,甚至比化妆品上的花费还少。而这1%,足够让生命成为多行星物种。他甚至把门槛压得更低:让这件事被讨论的时间占到1%,就会产生巨大差别。

逻辑绕回那个集合论。先有足够多的人想要,才有意愿;SpaceX拼命提供路径;一旦路径被证明可行,其他公司也会跟进。他反复强调,意愿这一半极其重要,缺了它路径再好也没用。

最酷的部分不在硬件

主持人问星舰开发过程中最酷的是什么。马斯克没提发动机,没提不锈钢,也没提那场著名的发布会。

他说的是人。和一群很棒的工程师一起工作,一起想出有意思的解法。和聪明人创造性地做一件从未存在过的东西,这件事本身就让人享受。重复性的成功没什么意思,把不可能的事变成工程事实才有意思。

顺带他还答了一个通信问题。火星互联网可以用星链的变体来做,地球这边需要一台大功率激光,最好放在轨道上,避开大气衰减和衍射。火星绕到太阳背面时会断联,所以中间还得布中继站,激光没法直接穿透太阳。

这场访谈原定半小时,最后拖进了提问环节。收尾时马斯克说了一句很轻但很重的话:感谢所有为火星拼命的人,这样的人不多,需要更多。

把整场访谈的逻辑捋一遍,他其实只做了三件事。把目标定成一个可以被证伪的标准,飞船停运,火星能不能活。用这个标准倒推出运力、复用、燃料和时间表。再把目标当成强制函数,逼着自己和整个行业跑起来。剩下的细节,甲烷、不锈钢、3.6米直径、28台发动机,都是这几步算出来的结果,没多少浪漫成分。

读者能拿走的,是这套「先定目标再倒推,再用目标反过来逼创新」的做事方式,以及下面几个可以马上动手的动作。

  • 把火星变成日常话题。马斯克说的「1%的时间」不需要任何专业背景,只需要你在饭桌上、群聊里、社交平台上把它当成一件正经事提出来,而不是当成科幻。
  • 去上物理课。不管你以后做不做航天,物理提供的是一套拆解问题、估算量级、区分「听起来对」和「算得出来」的工具,这套工具在任何行业都值钱。
  • 别只盯着火箭本体。想进这个行业,电子、机械、电气、软件、化学工程都是入口。化工和材料尤其缺人,推进剂工厂和原位资源利用是火星上最硬的工程问题。
  • 盯住三个可验证的节点。2022年前后的在轨加注验证,2024年前后的火星转移窗口,以及高频次复用飞行的真实达成率。这三个指标比任何发布会幻灯片都更能说明进度。
  • 对「污染火星」的担忧保持比例感。火星环境比地球任何极端环境都苛刻,能在那活下去的地球微生物少之又少。该管的是行星保护协议和流程,恐慌解决不了问题。
  • 如果你是工程师,简历上少写学历,多写你造过什么。马斯克招人的标准就一条,卓越能力的证据。造过的硬件、跑过的代码、解决过的真实问题,比任何文凭都有说服力。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01well elon you need no introduction but for those who don't know you are the founder and chief engineer of spacex and a long time into the mars society and we're delighted to have you back we've got 9 000 people registered to hear you today all right cool sounds good okay so we should like change this perspective let's see if i can change perspective is that better or is that worse i think you were better before okay okay so listen why don't we just start out with the basics you started spacex to make humanity multi-planetary yeah why do you see that as a critical goal yes i think we want to be on track to become a multi-part species and a space

0:50breaking civilization in order to find out what the universe is all about like what you know and ensure the continuance of consciousness as we know it as far as we know we're the only life i mean people think there's aliens but i'll say i haven't seen any sign of aliens so as far as we know we're the only the the only life whether it could be the only life so let's put that away and we need to take the set of actions that are most likely to make the future good and result in the continuance of consciousness as we know it okay so okay well obviously your means to that end is if you open the space frontier with reusable launch vehicles and you've gone through some

1:33partially useful ones and now it's starship can you explain the basically the line of thinking that led you to the starship design i forgot what i need to look at just look like i'm looking at the camera so let's see well on the starship front we've gone through many iterations starting from not really knowing how to build rockets at all with with falcon one and having four failures actually in reaching orbit through yeah sorry three failures and then the fourth one got to open so fourth one is a charm so we only barely survived i was at zero cash basically when we got that fourth one to orbit and if that fourth one hadn't worked we would have been

2:21curtains so it's definitely not been smooth sailing it's been a very difficult ride with just a lot that has been discovered along the way i'm just just trying to figure out what questions to ask about the design was was quite difficult i think it's helpful to have as the objective the creation of a self-sustaining city on mars i think this is this has to be the objective not simply a few people or a base but a self-sustaining city the acid test really is if these if the ships from earth stop coming for any reason does mars die out for any reason it could be from but it could be banal or it could be nuclear armageddon doesn't matter if the if the ship stop coming for any reason

3:20does the city on mars die out if it does we have not we're not in a secure place so i mean i think this really might come down to you know on the the great filter front is this are we going to create a self-sustaining city on loss before or after world war three and i think the probability of it being created after world war iii hopefully the hopefully there's never a world war three but of after is low

3:50so we should try to create this make the city self-sustaining before any possible world war three this is just a risk this is not you know i mean sometimes people have difficulty dealing with with probability to see that this way or that way but it's really we just face a series of probabilities and there's some chance that we will have a giant war or through a volcano or you know a comet might hit the earth or we might just self-extinguish in some it might be more of a more of a whimper than a bang yeah and frankly right now civilization's not looking super strong you know this is looking a little rickety right now frank would you say that it's it's

4:37more than a lifeboat that it would actually make you civilization more robust clearly more able to divert asteroids from hitting the earth and otherwise help yeah it's not it's not an escape vehicle it's it's a it's simply something that it's not like you can i mean unless modest mars is made self-sustaining which will probably not happen in my lifetime it is certainly not it's me it's meaningless to have an escape you know life vote or or or escape hatch or something if you will you're simply moving to another place where you will soon die out that doesn't count it's not much of a lifeboat really

5:29so this is really about minimizing existential risk for civilization as a whole and and then having an exciting future that you can look forward to and a future where we are a space breaking civilization and multi-planet species is far more exciting than one where we are not i mean that's an exciting future and being forever confined to earth until some eventual extinction event is depressing and not fun and we need things that make you want to get out of bed in the morning and be excited about the future and i think being a spacefaring civilization is one of those things that everyone get can get excited about but can you maybe just kind of

6:17lead people on the path that led you from the design but from falcon 9 to falcon heavy but now starship is is rather different than falcon heavy yeah the engineers really absolutely didn't quite answer your original question the the you first have to say what what is the goal and once you have what is the goal you can then measure the various designs against that goal if otherwise you're saying how are you evaluating why is one design better than another what's your goal it's gotta be gold so the goal is get enough tonnage to mars to and enough people to make mars self-sustaining as quickly as possible so then you say okay let's back back out

6:59the math on this we're going to need we're going to need a lot of tonnage maybe i don't know 100 000 tons maybe a million tons so you can't be faffing around with these expandable rockets they're a joke they're absurd even saturn five is tiny potatoes we we need it because if you want to get like let's say first order approximation a million tons the surface of mars inclusive of people you know that that means probably something around four or five million useful tons of payload in the into a low earth orbit you know for every time you get to low with over you're going to get four or five tons hopefully closer to five it's it's you know these this math is

7:49is you really start squeezing like tiny percentages but let's say it comes to confidently if you've got five tons to low earth orbit you can get one time to mars that's that's confident maybe you can get i mean maybe you only need four anyway the point is you need five million tons into earth orbit to get one million tons to mars now let's put this into perspective total global capacity to orbit of all expandable rockets is around around five or 600 tons i think and if you said okay the world's gonna end if you do not increase your capacity perhaps they could do a thousand times okay so that's one five five thousand one five thousandth of what's needed

8:42this is ridiculous you know it's it's not even you know point one percent would be you know one thousandth so way less than point one percent we have way less than point point one percent of the capability needed to create a if everyone went full tilt with expandable rockets experimental rockets are the absolute are just utterly stupid in my opinion utterly stupid they're a complete waste of time people should stop wasting their time if you try to sell an expendable plane people would laugh you out of the room if you're trying to sell an expendable car they would laugh you out of the room if you're trying to access an expandable horse they would laugh you out of the room and

9:26think there's something wrong with you mentally so all these things are reusable it's essential to be reusable now creating a reusable rocket orbital rocket is very difficult doing a sub-orbital reusable rocket is easy doing a reusable oval rocket is hard even when a lot of smart people have put quite a bit of effort into it they might get two or three percent of the electric mass to lower the orbit and a really epic rocket would get four i'm not sure every i think anyone's ever gotten four so but you basically need to have something that in expendable form would probably get about four percent of its payload to orbit such that you can spend about half of

10:11that four percent on reusability and and still net out to around two percent of paler toolboot so you have to make both the booster and the upper stage and the fairing everything reusable with falcon 9 so so with falcon 1 we did actually attempt to do this so we had a parachute from the first stage but really did not appreciate that that first stage was going to hit the atmosphere like a concrete wall so at first i got pretty mad at the parachute supplier until i realized yeah it's not their fault yeah we were just being cool that that thing was exploding as soon as it hit the atmosphere and you know so you really got to do something to ease the transition into the

10:58atmosphere at high mach number it's very hot and there's a lot of force and a lot of heat so then with falcon 9 we made a bigger rocket and our scale matters here because you do get basically economies of scale you can't have a tiny rocket there's a tiny rocket you basically just end up carrying your electronics to orbit so your avionics you know so in a little rocket you if you're small enough the just your your avionics loan ends up being a significant percentage of your payload and then you end up you know if you had a rocket that was i don't know they're trying to get a 10 000 pound rocket for example or even a ten thousand kilogram rocket

11:43to orbit i think you would basically get zero payload now as you get bigger the the rocket gets bigger but the brain doesn't get bigger the brain can stay the same size so your avionics for example become almost not almost zero percent of the weight at a for a big rocket then for big rockets you also get gauge advantages so this is we're really in the nuances of rocket design and manufacturing here if things are very small it's difficult to get your gauge accurate so that basically how thick is the material like you wanna do castings for example there's a minimum gauge or thickness for a casting there's a minimum kind of error bar on the you know on this the material skins

12:31even for a composite rocket you've got you know you start getting granularity issues as you get bigger you know you're no longer gauge limited and you can get your percentage accuracy on the thickness of walls and castings can be can be very good these are nuances that i think almost no one appreciates but it's nice to say that there are advantages to size and you can certainly see this in many walks of life where if you've got a truck that's carrying cargo you it's more efficient to have a big semi truck not a bunch of little trucks for ships it would be pretty silly to see container ships or containers going across the ocean one at a time with

13:15little outboard motors that would be silly you put them on a container ship you have big ships not little little tiny ships so anyway so size matters it really does and full reusability matters so with with falcon 9 after immense effort we were able to achieve reusability of the booster and we're mostly achieving reusability at this point with the fairing as well but this is a this is a monumental effort and i think within its architecture falcon 9 is close to a local maximum

13:59if you say you know gas generator cycle kerosene oxygen vehicle of this particular size with a 12 foot or 3.6 meter diameter which is which is that size for because of of road transport limitations so you go bigger than that you can transport it over the road and your logistics class become extreme so but but having a long thin rocket is not very mass efficient you're you're not having to have thicker skins to take out the bending moment so we're and then having

14:44like kerosene is not the right fuel methane is a much better fuel you can get higher isp a specific impulse basically efficiency i mean but for those who i think probably a lot of us are listening know what the rocket equation is but in simple terms it's actually very simple it's like a rocket is going to go further if if the gas if it shoots the gas out of the end faster and if a bigger percentage of its mass is propellant was obvious so that's what that's what the rocket equation says so should gas out faster in the right direction and increase the propellant the percentage profile that that's gonna get you go allow you to go further with methane you can shoot it out faster

15:32and you can make it on mars you make it on mars for sure exactly so being able to do institute profound development is production is very important so you have to carry your return fuel with you or return fuel and oxygen it's to begin like rockets are mostly oxygen or oxidizer so

15:59and there's there's some other subtle advantages with a oxygen methane system in that you can go to a higher percentage a higher mass ratio of oxygen so with kerosene you'd be at about roughly two and a half to one oxygen to fuel mass ratio with methane you're more like three and a half to one and you actually want that higher mass ratio because oxygen is very dense and it's inexpensive especially on earth so you're gonna you know you have all these plants just making oxygen all day long and plankton just making oxygen never do anything so the cost of oxygen is basically the cost of electricity anyway so going from falcon going from you know kerosene which is basically

16:46the same as jet fuel it's like rp1 rock profound great kerosene is just a tighter grade of jet fuel you want to go from that to something which has where the gas shoots out faster and that's methane and where institute production of propellant is easier so that's that's why the change from from kerosene to methane methane is just ch4 it's one carbon four hydrogens and then the oxygen pairs pairs together so you have it's called o2 because oxygen pair bonds and obviously you know all this stuff i'm just basically hoping for the audience together large size twice to take off thrust of a saturn v but about the same payload but that gives you reusability

17:34much cheaper in situ propellant it all is coherent and so let me ask you the thing that i think everybody wants to know which is when when are we going to see starship do a high flight to the stratosphere when to orbit when first payload to mars the first humans to mars all right well it's not like i i we're obviously venturing into unknown territory so it's not as though i i i have all these secret dates and i i and i i'm you know just keeping them from people but so so that might these are just guesses obviously i'm pretty i'd say i'm 80 to 90 confident that we will reach orbit with starship next year i i think probably 50 or 60 50 confident that

18:28we'll be able to bring the shipment booster back that's like that's more of a dicey situation we'll probably lose a few ships before we really get the atmospheric return and landing right we might lose hopefully we don't you lose it hopefully we don't lose any boosters because that's a lot of engines our initial booster flights will just have maybe two to four engines not 28 28 slider engines

18:57so yeah and then i think we'll probably be in do it doing high volume flights i think probably in 2022 so a couple years from now i'm trying to make sure that that our rate of innovation increases it does not decrease this is really essential in fact if we do not see something close to an exponential improvement in our rate of innovation we will not reach mars like a pure linear doesn't get there no no well i'll be dead anyway before it gets there if it's pure linear it's exponential i think we could get to mars we could probably send an uncrewed mission there in maybe four years

19:52you know there's a moss conjunction every 26 months there's one this year so that means in a couple years from now is another one and then four years from now is another one i i think we've got a fighting chance of of making the that second mars transfer window so one thing that is really amazing about spacex to those of us who have experience in the aerospace industry is is the rate of innovation you know

20:26okay last time you spoke to the mars society convention was 2012 since then you've made the falcon unusable introduced falcon heavy crude dragon a satellite constellation and you're in the middle of developing starship so what what is your you know what would you say is your methodology that allows you to innovate so swiftly

20:54i don't really know we're focused on like i said it is important to have that that have the objective you're right as far as talking so much about the importance of making wealth mars a self-sustaining as building a self-sustaining city on mars if if that's the objective then obviously you know just putting some satellites in orbit or there's not that that's not important you have to achieve full and rapid reusability amp size full and rapid reusability is only relevant to the degree as rapid and complete and and then you also have to do orbital refilling this is essential as well and and then propellant production on mars also essential so you know and

21:46with that as the goal then you know that that that means that that creates i think a good forcing function for radical innovation because in the absence of radical innovation we have no chance of meeting that goal whereas if i go simply you know defeat lockheed and boeing or something like that that we would probably achieve

22:14that really wasn't even a thing you know i wish it was yeah like they're they're not really trying to do not even trying to do reusability which is bizarre because they make planes that are reusable so i mean if they if they talk to the like you know if they talk to one of their customers about bias or a lucky fighter jet or a boeing aircraft like hey we're going to sell you a 737 it can be used once and it's not 737 max but that was that turns out that was a single user plan at times but it really would it would be an absurd thing for them to sell a single-use aircraft but they feel quite comfortable selling a single-use rocket and anyway but if our goal is simply

23:02we're gonna have to be the leaders in launching the conventional satellites that exist we would probably approach that in on a sort of a logarithmic basis where you know you'd get there and you sort of slowly make progress towards doing 10 launches a year 12 launches a year and while they do six or something like that i don't know but since the goal is hey we need to make life multi-planetary before it's too late and time really matters so we're our states us it's like we're shooting for mars not just the moon it's not much suit for the moon shoot from ours and then and then the you know these these competitive things are are kind of small things along the way unless somebody

23:47else is shooting for mars they will not be competitive with something as pedestrian as launching a few satellites into earth orbit so how how can the mars society help you well i do think there's in order to for there to be a self-sustaining city on mars there's we're going to need an intersection of sets here one set is the set of people that want to go and can either find sponsorship either for themselves or find government sponsorship or take out a loan whatever the case may be but somehow you've got to have the set of people who want to go to mars and can se and can come up with the funds somehow to do that and then then you know it's i should say

24:39there's two sets desire to go to mars and can afford to go to mars when it's when desire to go to the people who want to go to mars and people who could afford to go to mars when that intersection of sets reaches a million roughly then i think we will have this city on mars so we need both the motivation and the the you know we need both the means and the way i mean it's like

25:12we need people to want the will in the way the will in the way yes exactly where there's a little way but in this case we will end away so when the will and the way intersect then we will have a well-dependent species the world on the way must intersect so i think the martial society can really help with the will okay you provide the way we'll provide the will yes exactly okay now your assistant jen told me earlier that you have a hard cut off at the half hour is that true or do you want to stay and take some questions from the audience yeah we could do maybe 5-10 minutes of questions all right great so i i've got a hundred

25:56question questions so would the jim do you want to read a question or two yeah sure thing hi elon my name is james burke i'm from seattle washington where's the best place to land on mars do you think yeah actually i'm not super sure i can tell you what the criteria are that you'd want you'd want to be right anyway i think the the short answer is middle latitudes probably on the north so you want to be close to ice you you don't be too you you don't be too far away from the sun so you can get solar power and you want to land at a low altitude so you can take maximum effect of atmospheric braking what do you think

26:46i like millis chasma that's a nice little area at the bottom of valles marineris the air pressure's high okay is there a lot of ice there there's ice around there we'd have to look for it though okay that kind of brings me to my next question and i'm going to turn it over to carrie to ask you one how would you prioritize like missions like 2 through 10 are you going to focus on exploration or building up the infrastructure or science we're going to i think the first order of business is build a propellant plant i mean we can for sure lop out a bunch of droids you know that's no problem i think why not you know we're going you know and probably if anyone wants to put

27:31their droid on we could just take it and you know it's like hey it's basically a remote control car a solar powered remote control car and we could provide the the communication relay so you know you could just basically connect your car from your computer at home and try you know cruise your electric you could have legs too no matter your robo device slash car that would be pretty cool and you know there's a lot of people worried about like you know life contamination it's like listen anything that can survive on mars is very so freaking tough it's insane that it is cold and there's like a lot of uv radiation and it if it's not going to be too worried

28:23about anything we stand from earth that way it's just tougher than anything on earth so but but i think the first order of business is we've got to build a propellant a plant to make propellant and that is we said we've gotta need a lot of energy we've got a mine some ice and we've got you got co2 from the atmosphere so from the ice you got the h2o combine that h2o with the co2 you get ch4 and o2 but there's a lot of energy and that would be quite hard i think to make that propellant plan to rely reliable

29:05so but that that's that's the primary order of business and then we can also look around and see if we can learn anything from a scientific standpoint carrie do you want to go next all right thank you james i'm carrie faye i live in denver colorado thank you for joining us today mr musk that we do have a lot of questions from 13 14 year olds so i'm just going to pick one and ask you it's from a teenager and her name is dara and she wants to be an engineer and build starships and robots and her dream is working for spacex what should she focus on to be an engineer

29:48well i think there's all kinds of engineering that's needed so you don't have to be an aerospace engineer you could be in electronics being a mechanical engineer electrical engineer you could be software engineer i mean there's a lot of engineering basically almost any kind of engineering we'll need chemical engineering i think also for figuring out how to make a good propellant depot or pressure sleep repellent production plant and yeah i think physics in general is a good background for thinking and i just generally recommend people take physics courses because physics has the best tools for critical thinking thank you milan james yeah thanks carrie

30:37another question the boring company now is that just kind of a an outfit to build tunneling machines that can work on mars no the boring company actually started as kind of a joke and i for a lot of times people would ask me what what do i think the opportunities are out there and for i don't know five years or more i kept saying can someone please start a tunneling company because i think tunnels have a lot of opportunity for alleviating traffic in cities and just improving quality of life overall i mean there's a lot of streets you could turn into parks you certainly wouldn't need parking you could just park cars on the ground so and i just everyone through i was

31:23joking and i was well and i was like well i guess we'll see what it takes to drill a town to dig a tunnel and and you know all these like so-called traffic experts and like haven't really made much progress you know cities like l.a and dc or split traffic nightmare i'm like okay guys well if you've got such great ideas when why is this little traffic nightmare so if you build tunnels you're going to go 3d somehow either underground or above ground like either air or ground and the problem with air is like you know anything that can carry persons can generate a lot of noise and a lot of wind force so and it could fall on your head and also kind of not be good for privacy

32:04and like you know just sit in your backyard and something like flying over you it's like not that cool so the tunnels are working all those things they're also weatherproof yeah don't have any privacy issues and safe and anyway they will leave they would make a big difference to traffic and we have the first production tunnel or useful tunnel in vegas that's going to open in a month or two so a few months i guess and hopefully we'll be ready for prime time around the consumer electronics show so

32:40and now for mars i think tunnels and digging in general is good but you need to build a very light system compared to what would matter on earth you don't really care all that much about mass on earth you care a lot about mass going to mars is it fair to say that you're learning some techniques that might apply to mars with the boring company yeah yeah probably when do you think starship will be able to be demonstrating refueling in low earth orbit i think we've got a shot at doing that in 22 about two years and then when do you guys think you'll have a moonship prototype

33:27probably two or three years as soon as you've got overall refilling you can you can send significant payload to the moon like significant meaning 100 tons of useful payload at a shot so then from there i think you mentioned mars is a couple years after that it's only a couple years after that because the mars transit window is every 26 months like i think we maybe have a shot of standing or you know trying to send something to mars in three years but the windows is four years away because of the being in different parts of the solar system kerry asked a question from a young person i'd like to also ask do you have any tips for young people who love mars but don't know how to help

34:16with the settlement of mars well i think definitely i you know anyone who is a strong advocate for mars i think this really makes a difference you know a lot of times it's not even people aren't even thinking about it and you know you can talk to people at a party and they or talk to friends they're like it's just even not even a topic of conversation so i think it could really help if for everyone out there who thinks this is important for the future of humanity and consciousness as a whole to make it part of what people are thinking about bringing up at parties and talking to friends and online it's like it should be a thing that we do and i think it's worth you know

34:57maybe one percent of our resources at least and that's not going to fundamentally change change things you know quality of life if we have one if we spend one percent of our resources you know much less than health care obviously maybe probably even less than we spend on cosmetics frankly then that that would be enough to make life multiplanetary but we really need to make this a thing people talk about at least one percent of the time and that really matter like that as we talked about earlier we need we need the will which is we need a critical mass of people wanting to make it happen and and then we need the way and state spacex is going to try hard to provide

35:40the way and then once we show that there's a way probably there will be other companies that also try to do it as well so we need the will in the way they can provide either the will is extremely important it makes a huge difference what's the coolest part of starship development well i guess the coolest part of software development is working with just a great team of engineers and coming up with interesting solutions yeah you know i think it's just fundamentally enjoyable if you're working with a lot of good smart people

36:20creatively towards solutions that have never existed before that's very rewarding so i guess probably like that the most can you talk a little bit about how starship can be used for other destinations in the solar system like venus and the outer planets starship is it's definitely a general generalized ship it basically can it it's it sells for transport anywhere in the solar system that where there is a solid surface to land so if you can land there we're going to take there we will also actually go into the atmosphere of venus for example just like going to orbit and and perhaps to the upper atmosphere venus's atmosphere is extremely dense

37:13it's also quite high so because that dense atmosphere you could you could have something you could have a kind of like a some sort of derivable you know some kind of like like things that could float on venus that could not float on earth in the atmosphere because of the dense atmosphere so it could go to venus i mean it's not a super friendly place and then like mercury is super hot

37:44but i think that we could go to cerris or any of the asteroids the moons of jupiter although quite high radiation around there and then out to saturn you know eventually getting out to you know these sort of cable belt earth cloud and that kind of thing the outer solar system so starship once you have propellant depots you can kind of like planet hop or moon hop around the solar system it's not it's not a vehicle that would enable us to go interstellar but it's that that's that's a that's a tough one but we need to make this the leap we're going to another planet first once we are multi-planet species will create a forcing function for the rapid improvement of of space

38:33flight and and we'll figure out new technologies that will ultimately allow us to go to other star systems what do you look for in the people you hire especially the engineers really just look for evidence of exceptional ability so it's not at least aspirationally like sometimes these things get messed up in recruiting or the recruiting photo beings it ends up being wrong like i sometimes wonder with tesla if nikola tesla applied to tesla would we even give him an interview it's not clear you know this guy came from like some weird college and somewhere in eastern europe i think he's got some odd mannerisms now we don't know if we should give an

39:14interview like i i worry that that's actually what we do instead of like right it should be like man this this this kid's super smart what does he want we'll pay him anything that should be that should be the reaction if nikola tesla applies you know to tesla ironically but so i can tell you the intent is we're looking for evidence of exceptional ability and it really doesn't matter if you want to graduate high school or college or anything we're just looking for evidence of exceptional ability such that it would be a good predictor for doing exceptional things spacex

39:53all right you have some more questions from the audience there jim i've got one so have you thought about communication networks between earth and mars and kind of i mean you're working on starlink what about like an internet around mars have you thought about that yeah you could certainly do some variants of starlink i'll probably probably have to be the last question because i've got a bunch of things piled up but yeah you could just do it version starlink around mars and then you just need a big laser coming from earth probably want it to be in orbit so it doesn't get atmospheric diffraction or attenuation you want to go from a big laser from earth orbit to mars

40:34orbit and then you're going to need some relay stations for when mars is on the other side of the sun so you can't just shoot a laser through the sun all right thank you thank you so much elon we're all pulling for you good luck very much appreciate it and just like thank you to all the people out there that that are that are fighting hard for the course of mars there's not that many and we need more thank you all right thank you

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份