2022 年 11 月,马斯克接手推特刚满一周。周五的裁员邮件发完,周末舆论炸锅,广告主在观望要不要撤预算。就在这个节骨眼上,推特的广告业务负责人 Robin Wheeler 发了条消息:下午有一场 Spaces 直播,马斯克会来回答问题。
通知提前量不到一小时。
Madeleine Sklar 是在开播前不久才看到的。她当时正在剪播客,戴着耳机,完全错过了这场直播,直到快结束时才发现时间线上所有人都在讨论同一件事。她后来在节目里说,那几天她一直盯着推特上那些大 V 的账号,如果提前很久就有风声,她不可能看不到。
就是这样一场临时起意的音频直播,峰值超过十万人同时在线。等到这期播客录制的时候,含回放的累计收听已经到九十万,在场的几个人都判断,当天结束前会破百万。
Madeleine 做了一个动作:直播一结束,她一分钟内切到回放页面截了图。因为在 Spaces 里,除了主播本人,普通参与者只能看到"实时加回放"的总数,而回放数字会随着时间一直往上涨。想拿到真实的实时在线人数,只能卡在那个窗口期截图。
她截图的时候,数字是十万零几千。名单比数字更说明问题:Netflix、LinkedIn、Pinterest 这些粉丝数以千万计的品牌账号,全在听众列表里。她往下滚动时发现,有些品牌账号居然关注了她,就排在离她很近的位置。
"我们做社交音频做了十八个月,一直在等这些大品牌出现。你们之前都去哪儿了?"她在节目里这么问。
推特的马斯克和说话的马斯克,是两个不同的人
这期播客里反复出现一个判断,几乎每个发言的人都提到了同一件事。
Madeleine 的原话大意是:过去几周看他的推文,她非常困惑,一度不确定自己该不该继续留在推特上,是不是明天这个平台就没了。听完这一个小时的对话,她的感觉完全变了,而且她不想再去别的平台找退路了。
Morgan 给了一个更精确的说法:一个人的推文和他本人在这个话题上开口说话,本来就是两回事。马斯克在别的视频采访里也表现过这种差别,但这次是在他自己的平台上、用他自己的产品、面对一群广告主说出来,效果不一样。
一位叫 Jason Bunsen 的听众说得更直白。他是老师,那天正好休息,全程听完了直播,顺手花八美元升级了蓝标。他说自己有个很不客气的比喻:发推的马斯克像个中学生,如果把一个初中生的手机交给他随便发,大概也就是那个水平。而说话的马斯克,条理清楚、有思想,把每一个问题都接住了。
他甚至说了一句带点遗憾的话:真希望他先说话,再发推。
这个差别解释了这场直播为什么重要。推文是异步的、碎片化的、没有语境的,一条一百四十字符的东西发出去,读者只能自己补全动机。一个小时的实时问答里,语速、停顿、被追问时的反应,这些信息量是推文给不了的。
Madeleine 提到她当时的处境:那一周所有人都在问她,你打算搬去哪儿?她说自己从没宣布要离开推特,但平台上确实人心浮动。听完这场对话,她的判断是,事情终于说得通了。
每天亏四百万美元,这是他开口的第一句实话
马斯克在这场问答里给出的第一条硬信息,是财务数字。
他说公司每天亏损大约四百万美元,一年下来是十亿美元量级。他还说了一句被在场听众反复引用的话:我上周才拿到钥匙。
这句话解释了他后面所有的动作逻辑。裁员、改验证、推订阅这些事,全发生在一个每天都在流血的账本上。这解释了它们为什么急促、为什么反复。
Adam 在节目里说,他听到这里反而理解了很多之前看不懂的操作:硅谷那套"快速失败"被搬到了一个成熟平台上,先做,看反应,错了立刻改。马斯克自己也承认,我可能完全错了。
关于广告主最关心的内容安全,他给了明确表态。他说自己支持言论自由,但这不意味着仇恨言论会出现在广告旁边。Adam 特别提到这一点,因为这是品牌方最在意的那条红线。
他还提到了用户投票。收购前后他发过好几个投票:是不是所有人都该被验证,私信该不该加密。这些投票动辄几百万回应。Adam 的判断是,他在看这些结果,他在听平台上的用户说话,不管是普通消费者还是付钱投广告的品牌。
关于平台要往哪儿走,马斯克给出的目标相当高:让推特成为互联网上最可信的信息来源。George 听到这句时的反应是,"哇"。他自己补了一句:现在离那个目标还很远,马斯克本人也承认这一点。
达成路径他说的是反馈机制:用户反馈、顾问委员会、他自己读回复。Adam 统计过,在那一个小时的对话里,马斯克有三四次提到用户反馈和用户参与。
Spaces 的团队被裁光了,产品却活了下来
这场直播的时间点相当讽刺。
就在几天前,Spaces 团队和社区团队的大部分人被裁。Madeleine 说,她周四晚上看到 Simon Bauman 的推文才知道消息。Simon 负责推特的社区业务,人在英国,那天对他来说是深夜。他是怎么知道自己被裁的?公司 Slack 登不进去,邮箱登不进去。
她用的词是"我为他感到非常难过"。她说 Simon 非常受大家喜欢,对工作极有热情,很多社区是他一手带起来的。
接着是 Danny Singh。他从 Spaces 还是 beta 测试阶段就在,一路陪着早期测试者走过来。Madeleine 说,她们这批人最开始就是 Spaces 的 beta tester,Danny 一直在听她们说话。
所以那一周,很多人的第一反应是:团队都裁了,Spaces 大概要没了。
Morgan 承认,他写这期节目的标题时,用的就是"这是 Twitter Spaces 的终局吗"。那个标题写在周五那场大裁员之后,当时他的判断是,这个功能没有前路了。
然后马斯克自己上了 Spaces,讲了一个小时。
Morgan 的说法是,这让 Spaces 有了一层光环效应:他本人在用这个产品,那它大概不会说没就没。他很谨慎地补了一句:马斯克本人从来没有明确承诺过 Spaces 会保留。他所有关于音频的表述,用的都是"长音频""播客""长视频"这些词,Spaces 这个词,一次都没出现过。
Morgan 提到 Matt Navarra 那周发过一条 TikTok 剪辑,马斯克在里面确实提到了长音频和播客,就是没说 Spaces。这个细节被重复提了好几次,因为它意味着:产品还在,它在马斯克的路线图里占什么位置,没人知道。
还有一个更现实的问题:谁来维护它。
Spaces 官方反馈社区有三个版主,现在都已经不在公司了。Morgan 说,严格意义上他们的劳动合同还有几个月才终止,但已经不允许做任何事了。这个社区现在处于无头状态。同样的情况也出现在不少官方社区里,Simon 走了之后,那些位置空着。
Morgan 的措辞很克制:问题有两层,这个产品会不会继续被维护和开发,以及短期内谁来干这件事,谁来听我们说话、回我们的问题。目前看不到有人急着补位。
一位叫 C 的设计师在推特上说,她也没有明确答案,事情每天都在变,但从她看到的情况判断,新管理层是认可 Spaces 和播客的价值的。这条推文被 Madeleine 放进了节目笔记里,因为它给了大家一点希望。
八美元买的是不被扔进垃圾邮件文件夹
这场问答的另一半内容,是那个八美元一个月的订阅。
价格本身变了好几轮。Madeleine 是早期 Twitter Blue 用户,她记得自己付的是 2.99 美元一个月,后来官方宣布涨到 4.99,最后定下来是 8 美元。她登录后台想改订阅,页面还显示 2.99,也没有给她切换到新套餐的入口。等到录制这期节目的当天,已有认证的用户开始陆续收到付费通知,价格写的是 7.99 美元一个月。
混乱不止在价格上。
节目里提到,那个灰色的 official 标签,从上线到撤下只隔了几个小时。几个主持人都确认了这件事:上午出现,下午就没了。Morgan 的评价是,这大概是推特历史上最短命的功能。
Jane Wong 做过对比,她是逆向工程圈子里专门拆解 App 的人。她升级之后发现,新蓝标和旧蓝标在界面上看不出任何区别。你看到一个认证账号,没法判断它是老认证还是花八美元买的。
Jason Bunsen 讲了让他下决心付钱的原因,这一段值得单独说。
马斯克在直播里提过一个算法逻辑:付费认证用户的推文会被优先对待,没有认证的账号,内容可能像 Gmail 垃圾邮件文件夹里的东西。Jason 的原话是,他从来不打开垃圾邮件文件夹,只有别人说"我给你发了个东西",他才会进去翻一下,然后看到一堆乱七八糟的东西躺在里面。
他说,他不想让自己的内容掉进那个文件夹。他做的是科学和共情的传播,他要让信息出去。八美元一个月,值。
他自己也承认,这个机制有点阶级味:付得起八美元的人,不会掉进垃圾箱。
从资格精英制换成金钱精英制,问题一点没少
在这套验证机制上,George 的评价相当尖锐。
他的观点是,过去那套蓝标是资格精英制:你有没有"值得关注"的身份,由平台审核决定,标准模糊、过程不透明,很多创作者申请多年拿不到。现在换成了金钱精英制:交钱就行。他不认为这是个聪明的办法。
他还指出一个逻辑上的死结:如果蓝标给订阅用户,official 标签给公众人物、明星、政府机构,两个标签并存,那验证本身的意义就没了。既然谁都能花钱买到一个标,这个标还能证明什么?
他的建议是,想从推特的功能里赚钱,路径很多,但"付费才能被当作可信的声音"这条路,解决不了平台上真正的问题:错误信息和虚假信息。
Jennifer 提出了另一个被忽略的角度:地域。
Twitter Blue 目前只在部分国家开放。一个 Spaces 主持人,或者一个社区运营者,如果人在一个还没开放这项服务的国家,那他直接被排除在游戏之外。他说这事必须尽快解决,第一阶段可以先这样,第二阶段必须覆盖到所有人,否则这个"公平的竞技场"根本立不住。
这个点比它听起来更重要。付费分层里更隐蔽的一条线,落在"有资格付钱"和"没资格付钱"之间。它的影响往往比有钱没钱更深,因为被这条线筛掉的人更多。
Ray Ray 补了一刀,说得非常干脆:就算你付了八美元,你还在给平台提供数据。所谓免费,我们就是产品;付了钱,我们还是产品。他不相信社交媒体上有真正免费这回事。
节目里有人接了这句话:东西免费的时候,你就是产品;等你付了钱,你仍然是产品,只是多了一层筛选标签。
收费这件事,别的平台早就干过
Madeleine 在这场讨论里提了个很实用的思路:把收费当成另一种解法,它和砍掉功能并不冲突。
她的逻辑是,那些大家喜欢的功能(Spaces、社区、新闻通讯),砍掉是浪费。想创建新闻通讯,付费;想主持 Spaces,付费;想组建社区,付费。收听免费,加入社区免费。
她举了两个现成的例子。Meetup.com 的组织者要交月费,现在是三十美元一个月,最早是二十美元,参加活动的人免费。LinkedIn 的会员分了十几档,从 29.99 美元到 140 美元一个月,不同档位对应不同的曝光和服务,基础功能一直免费。
她的判断是,很多人会忘掉一件事:其他平台上早就有大量用户心甘情愿为增值服务付钱。她自己就是 Twitter Blue 老用户,一直付费,因为她需要那些功能。
Morgan 把这件事放到了更大的背景里。广告市场疲软,加上苹果的 ATT 政策(应用追踪透明度),过去那种靠追踪用户行为做定向投放的广告模式被削弱了。很多科技公司结束了十三年的增长期,开始转向直接收入、订阅收入、经常性收入,来对冲广告收入的不稳定。
所以付费这件事本身不奇怪。奇怪的是它的形式。
Morgan 的说法是,他对这个具体形式有问号,"某种形式"是合理的。他自己也承认,那句著名的"我不敢相信这个网站是免费的"迟早要被当真。
他还有一个更悲观的推演:如果这套付费机制广泛铺开,那些付不起钱的人会真正失去声音。他们不会被优先推荐,回复不会出现在前面,Spaces 的听众列表里也排不上位置。付费的人被浮到顶端,其他人在底部。
他说,这套东西在一个意义上确实公平了:不再由某个审核员决定谁"值得关注",你自己花钱就行。换个方向看,它建立起了另一种等级。
他想让内容创作者把视频直接传上来
关于马斯克到底想把推特做成什么,节目里引用了 Simon 在另一次播客访谈里的判断。
他说马斯克眼下的优先级只有两条:第一,能直接给公司带来收入的产品;第二,用户向用户付钱、公司从中抽成的产品。
第二条对创作者的意义最大。Morgan 的解读是,你需要开始想一件事:在这个平台上,你能提供什么让别人愿意掏钱,甚至订阅?
马斯克在直播里还说了另一件事:他想让推特变成内容创作者真正上传内容的地方。创作者不用先发到 YouTube,再回来贴个链接。视频直接传上来,收入水平要对标 TikTok 和 YouTube。
Morgan 对这件事的评价很实在:对本来就是创作者的人是好事,但对所有在平台上的人来说,意味着竞争升级。如果这事成了,那些原本在别的平台的创作者会过来,同台竞争。
他把这称为"激动人心的前景",紧接着给了一个不那么激动的提醒:如果你打算在这个平台上做创作者,现在就该认真起来。
敏捷的代价是,你会看到很多蠢事
Esther Crawford 转推了马斯克的一条推文,这条被节目里当好几次引用。
请注意,推特在未来几个月会做很多蠢事。我们会保留有效的,改掉无效的。(马斯克,推文)
George 对这句话的态度是欣赏。他说自己经历过很多并购,一个团队被整体裁掉,不代表会出现真空。人被调走、业务被整合,这是常态,不必然意味着产品会被放弃或降级。他用的词是"我大大地被安抚了"。
他引用得最多的是那句"agility is the key",敏捷是关键。他补了一个很老派的说法:常犯错,少犹豫;犯了错立刻改,不做无法快速回滚的事。犯错本身没什么,拖着不改才是问题。
official 标签几小时上线又下架,在他看来,正好把这套方法论演了一遍。看到反应,撤掉,速度极快。
他还指出,马斯克在直播里三四次提到用户反馈,提到要建顾问委员会,提到自己会读回复、会回应。George 的判断是,他想要一个能自我纠正的系统,设一个很高的理想(互联网上最可信的信息来源),然后用高强度的反馈把方向调过去。
节目里也有人不吃这一套。Morgan 说自己听着得带点批判性。他很高兴马斯克用了 Spaces,但他不想看到马斯克只是说大家想听的话。他说自己还是不确定。
另一位发言者的措辞更重:不要过度浪漫化马斯克。这个人过去做过不少值得质疑的商业决策,这次接手的资产和他之前做的那些公司也不一样。Spaces 和推特的核心业务差别很大,他未必认为值得投入大量资源去扩展它的功能。最坏的情况是,什么都不会发生,或者支持和投入进一步缩减。
George 也补了一句实在话:你看到他在用 Spaces,很好;团队没了,产品要保持稳定运行和迭代,靠什么?
这类怀疑在节目里没有被反驳,只是被并列摆着。
一个 Clubhouse 老兵的提醒:功能欠账太多
节目里接入了一位叫 Peter 的听众,他的背景值得单独说。
他最早在 Clubhouse 上做房间。今年年初,他参与运营了社交音频历史上最长、最大的一个房间:乌克兰战争爆发后的头一百零五天,不间断直播,累计触达约一百五十万听众。Clubhouse 后来把他做成了 App 图标。
他说自己讲这些并无炫耀之意,只是想说明,他在这件事上干了很久。
他的判断是,推特和 Clubhouse 是两种东西。Clubhouse 从一开始就围绕社交音频搭建,界面、氛围、亲密度都不一样,他觉得用起来更舒服。推特的音频功能,是一个已有平台上的附加件。
他还是往推特迁移了,原因很简单:这里有增长空间。
他对 Clubhouse 的批评很直接:产品团队没在听创作者说话。他把自己说成"我不确定算不算内容创作者",但指的是一类人:把人聚起来做重要对话的人,做喜剧的人,做冥想和音乐房间的人。
他把推特给的机会说得很具体:赞助商。他已经在和品牌谈,想把赞助带进自己主持的 Spaces。他还把部分直播转成播客,做成常青内容。一份内容,多个平台,这是他认可的做法。
然后他列了一张功能欠账单,这张单子其实是给推特的建议:
- 能不能置顶一个链接,而不是让主播在音频里反复念网址
- 能不能把多个 Spaces 串起来,做成系列
- 能不能有"俱乐部"这样的组织形态,让人找到自己的社群,找到你这个人
- 共同主持功能他认可,但这只是起点
他还说了一句挺动人的话:他在推特上很少发文字,容易觉得无聊。他发现把话说出来的时候,表达得更好。
他做的是地缘政治方向的内容。这类内容不是所有人爱听,但伊朗、乌克兰这种正在发生的事情,音频是最快、最有效的传播方式。人权观察这类组织也在用。他不认同"社交音频不行了"这个说法:它不会取代视频和文字,但它是一种重要的传递方式。
那些说"我要走了"的人,最后都还在
节目后半段聊到一个有意思的历史现象。
几位主持人都是推特的早期用户。那个年代有一个固定仪式:告别。用户发一条"我要离开推特了",然后去 Plurk,去 Facebook。过一阵子又回来了。这个循环反复发生,以至于"告别"本身成了一个梗。
现在的情况像是一次重演。有人在推特上说要去 Mastodon,有社区在把成员往别的平台引。Morgan 的判断是,这大概率是短期的。不确定性是真的,人也会回来。他的原话是:长期看多,但现在确实有真实的不确定性,如果你正在这个平台上建设什么东西。
他还提了一个更实际的视角:在这套新规则下,什么样的人能活得好。答案是风险承受能力高的人。因为变化会很快。
Jennifer 的总结是,她还在观望,但她准备好了爆米花。Madeleine 说她也是。
这种态度听起来轻佻,其实是理性的。在一个产品路线图随时会变、团队随时会重组的平台上做长期投入,本来就是高风险动作;同样的环境里,如果马斯克说的那些东西真的兑现,早期占位的人拿到的是不对称的回报。
给内容创作者和产品人的六条具体建议
这场一个小时的问答,加上这期播客里几十个人的讨论,能提炼出的东西不多,但每一条都很具体。
- 如果你在推特上做内容,现在就考虑"用户愿意为你付钱"的形态。马斯克列的两条优先级里,第二条是用户向用户付费、平台抽成。这意味着单纯涨粉的价值会下降,能直接产生付费关系的账号价值会上升。想清楚你能卖什么:付费社群、付费直播、付费专栏,还是赞助。
- 把同一份内容做成多种形态。Peter 的做法可以直接抄:Spaces 直播,转成播客,同时谈赞助。一份内容,三条收入线,且不依赖单一平台的政策。
- 不要把身家性命押在单一平台上,但也不要一有风吹草动就搬家。推特历史上的每一次"大出走"都以用户回流告终。聪明的做法是保持主阵地的同时,把通讯录和核心受众沉淀到你能直接触达的地方,比如邮件列表。
- 如果你在做社交产品或社区产品,注意付费门槛的两层筛子。第一层是有没有钱,第二层是有没有资格付钱(比如某些国家没开放支付)。第二层筛子往往被忽略,它会把一整片市场的创作者直接排除在外,而这些人恰恰最需要平台支持。
- 把"免费用户是产品、付费用户也是产品"这句话记住。任何平台上的付费会员,买到的是更好的分发位置和更少的干扰。数据采集这一层,交了钱也不会消失。评估一个付费功能值不值,就看它在这两件事上给了你多少。
- 观察一个组织在动荡期的真实意图,看它把钱和人往哪里放,不看它说什么。马斯克在 Spaces 上讲了六十分钟,讲了可信度、讲了创作者收入、讲了用户反馈。这些承诺能不能兑现,要看接下来几个月 Spaces 团队是否重建、创作者分成是否上线。说出口的是愿景,编制和预算才是承诺。
0:00foreign hey this is Madeline sklar and sees Cooper and you're listening to all things audio well let's start with Elon space it says on our notion board so let's do that Madeleine Morgan I know that you were listening into some of that tell us about the space that has just finished I think right here on Twitter where Elon was involved in a q a right yeah he was on for for nearly an hour today with Robin wheeler I have the link to that in the nest I'm also going to put in a nest there was a really helpful live tweeting going on from Sarah Fisher and she basically took notes of the whole thing it's a great thread I'm going to put that in the nest as well
0:48because whether you were there or not just reading through this really she ties it all together and there were so many great points but the first thing I want to say is seeing Elon Musk tweets the last several weeks his daily tweets I was very confused about things and and granted a tweet is not the same as talking in spaces as we all know here after hearing his interview after hearing him talk about plans I feel like things make more sense now I don't feel like should I be on Twitter or should I might not be on Twitter is Twitter going away tomorrow is space is still going to be here I actually now feel better about things and it makes me not want to go run on
1:34some other platform because all week people have been like so Madeline where are you going to go next where are you going to ditch Twitter and go and I haven't made an announcement that I'm leaving Twitter but there's so much has been up in the air but I felt like he clarified and Morgan you were listening in right so do you feel better about things after hearing him talk I do but I also sort of expected this that's something when there's a difference between somebody's tweets and probably elon's tweet it's and hearing that person speak for themselves on the topic and we know that right but to put Elon up there he's you've seen this in video interviews elsewhere
2:14but just to do it here in front of that crowd I think makes a real difference and he absolutely should do that this is a strength of of one of the mediums on his platform that he can use and it was very good to see him do that I mean let's face it we you know the the question is in the title here is this the end for Twitter spaces the point at which I wrote that title which was you know before the weekend after Friday's kind of mass firing that The Exodus that a lot of people who we've built up relationships with Madeleine Morgan you know we've spoken to these people in spaces that have been building spaces and it really felt like there was no way
2:52forward for it so for Elon to now be using I mean what what's the latest figure on how many people joined that space it now does seem a little bit more probable that it's probably not going very far whereas previously I kind of thought well maybe this is a feature that isn't going to hang around you know they're cutting back the team isn't there they're cutting costs and all the rest of it but I guess maybe this shows that you know he really does value what spaces is about what do you think yeah absolutely so I was listening in live to the space and and it was a lot of listeners and I kept just watching the number go up and up and it got over a hundred thousand
3:34live tuning in at the same time now what I did as soon as it ended I went right to the replay like I was at the replay within a minute of an ending I took a screenshot it's in the nest and that's the best way to find out how many people tuned in live Because unless you're the host you're just going to see the total number of Live And replays and of course the longer after a room ends then the higher the replay count can start going up so I was able to catch it
4:04000 people were listening in live and there was every Big Brand in there I know a lot a lot of people were taking screenshots I saw Morgan was taking screenshots lots of people were doing that and and I was really like wowed by the fact that so many people especially these advertisers are interested to hear directly from Elon now when you go to Robin Wheeler's to
4:29a tweet with this q a is currently as of right now 838 000 tuned in so that's now adding in all the replays so that's a lot of people who tuned in and it shows you the power of Twitter spaces and I I feel very strongly in saying that space is not going anywhere I mean this really shows the power of it and and that he's using it to get his message across yeah absolutely and Morgan shared that screenshot didn't he of all the all the different I mean they're huge brand names in there like where have these Brands been we've all been doing this for like 18 months two years now where you all been we were waiting for these big branded spaces that we were talking
5:11about I mean this was a q a that was two advertisers as well wasn't it yes it was geared for advertisers but he did really explain a lot just in general and you know what's interesting just a little side note when when you're in spaces and you know how you can see like you know people you follow and follow you back are right next to you in the room and as you scroll around but it will always show you first the verified accounts of who follows you you follow them they follow you and I was surprised at a couple of big brands with millions and millions of followers that follow me and I was I was like whoa why are they so close to me next to you know that it
5:54was really interesting to see that just a little side thing but but yeah I was scrolling down and looking at all Netflix LinkedIn Pinterest so many big Brands we're tuning in to hear more about what he had to say but I felt like he put advertisers at ease I I felt and Jennifer I'd love to hear your thoughts on all this as well but I I really feel overall good about Twitter I feel like spaces is not going anywhere I feel like he was being sincere whereas when I was reading his tweets the last few weeks I did not always feel like things were sincere here just my personal opinion but after listening to him speak I I feel completely different about the
6:35whole thing in a much positive light I like hearing that from you Madeline a lot and Morgan so here's my question to you all I had headphones on I was editing podcasts I missed the whole thing so until at the very end I'm like What's Happening something big is happening and my question is was this announced in advance or was it like we're going live and you know let's see what happens and who shows up I mean was there advance notice or was it just hey elon's in a space talking no there was some notice but it wasn't a huge amount of time I I want to say maybe just under an hour ahead of time or maybe 30 minutes like it was not a big notice yeah I think Congress Swisher got a
7:15heads up perhaps yesterday so there's one of her tweets the ad Partners so this was a in quotes a call that it that may well have gone out to the various ad partners that they need to be there but it wasn't a it wasn't I think made public until the last time so so I asked because those numbers are pretty darn impressive for last minute exactly exactly that was like one of the first things I thought of because I I pay close attention to a lot of big names people who talk about Twitter a lot I I have a Twitter list and I'm always checking and I didn't see anything early on I mean it was it had to have been like just under an hour before it went live so I was like oh I got to be
8:01there I gotta check this out so I was able to catch the entire thing but I I really like that there was somebody you know taking notes in real time so again that's the tweet I put in the nest from Sarah Fisher and and it's a it's a nice long thread she really shows a lot of the key points a lot of things that he was quoted as saying so it's definitely an interesting read and and also put oh real quick also I put in the nest in response to that tweet there was one from Josh Olin and I thought he made a really good point here he said Twitter spaces is I believe the most significant single Innovation to be added to a mature social platform perhaps ever I'm glad to see it a
8:48priority on new Twitter's agenda now I don't recall seeing this as part of the agenda for the new direction of Twitter but because of this interview with Elon and how many people showed up and how we seem to embrace using social audio that is not going anywhere yeah and I think this is the thing isn't it up until now we've all been listening out for the buzzword we've been waiting for Elon to say spaces and we haven't heard it let's face it we haven't heard him categorically mention spaces or its future or anything really about it and then all of a sudden he shows up on it and uses it and is is there for you know a considerable amount of time with an
9:28awful lot of interest and so that kind of gives it that halo effect that you think well surely it can't go anywhere then because you know he's using it but no one said that and he hasn't said that all he's been talking about really is about you know expanding Twitter generally giving us longer form audio giving us longer video keep and you know it's all about keeping us right here on Twitter which as we've said before spaces is actually really good for for you know for what is essentially a micro blogging platform to take us back to the way back when the minimalism on Twitter has always been kind of its beauty certainly in terms of its tweets I didn't like it
10:06when the the character limit went up I was one of those kind of Star Wars it was like oh you know I kind of liked that limit of of having to squash my thoughts into 140 characters or whatever it was but I get that you know the longer we remain on a platform the better that platform becomes for advertisers and you know it becomes far more appealing for what the business and the you know the corporate side of it needs it to do so I guess the one thing that I was clinging on to with whether or not spaces might disappear was that very thing is that out of all the the micro things that Twitter offers spaces has people listening for a long time and
10:51quite often if you're anything like me unless you're hosting you're listening and you're scrolling you're on the platform you're seeing new things you're connecting with other people but you know you're also yeah scrolling so you're right here in Twitter doing what you want what they want you to do but Morgan I know you you picked up on there was a a tweet I think it might have been Matt Navara sent out during the week that was a kind of Tick-Tock clip of Elon talking and he'd literally just mentioned like I think he literally said like long form audio and podcasts but he didn't mention spaces I'm right I know yes yeah I've obviously been looking for
11:28this too and every time he's mentioned audio it's always either alongside podcasts and never with the word spaces or it's long long form video and and audio this is something that Twitter blue subscribers will be able to upload which for those of us who do recorded spaces is supposed to be a slight eyebrow race there it's like what well what kind of audio are you going to be uploading yeah and it'll be interesting you know what what happens with this audio tab yes quiet so this is still a this is really an open question but he he has inherited he bought he acquired the the spaces infrastructure structure and he's now using it but and
12:12some some in the audience today will will have this much more closer to home that many people on the spaces team were let go unceremoniously so and there's a kind of question about what happens in terms of development now and what does spaces become in the mix and I guess these were always questions for us it's just the slightly broader than they were so it's here to stay but how's this going to be added in and the other part of that is thinking about his priorities right now so this is something that Simon from Community said in a podcast interview recently that we should expect the priorities are very much about where Elon can make revenue and quickly
12:58so what form will that take when it's applied to audio is one of our questions I have something to add to that you know one of the tweets that I put out I don't know a few days ago was just kind of like a thread of like to the powers that be and it was some of these features that we know and love like spaces like communities you know some of these amazing the newsletter the review newsletter that we know and love I don't feel like they should get rid of them I feel like they should just make them premium if they had a choice between let's get rid of it or let's make it premium and if you want to create a newsletter premium if you want to host premium if you want to listen
13:32free if you want to run a community premium and if you want to join a community free because if we look at meetup.com that's you pay to host an organization on a Groupon meetup.com but if you join it's free and if you look at LinkedIn LinkedIn has many levels of premium service from like 29.99 or something all the way up to 140 a month depending on what level of service and premium service you want from them and yet there's also free so I feel like there's existing examples in the world in the online space that Twitter could look at and go well if you want to run a community that's like a Groupon Meetup and if you want to do premium stuff like
14:13you do on LinkedIn that's like Twitter blue and I feel like sometimes folks lose sight of the fact that there are premium services that people happily pay for in other platforms I mean I'm a Twitter blue subscriber but I've been one for a while now so it isn't like something new for me it's something I'm happy to pay for because of the features that I get so I feel like sometimes folks lose sight of that and it's just my own thought my own opinion which you know take it or leave it no I feel the same way and that's also where this whole idea of Elon wanting to create Apex you know which is just something for everyone that that's that's great but you know to break that
14:49out as your as you're talking about there is potentially you know we can see sense in that let's let's hope he can too I guess for him it's whatever way makes the most money but but yeah I mean let's roll back a little bit because you know prior to today kind of the I think the biggest shock for me was watching though those people those lovely people that we've spoken to in spaces who have built this amazing tool for us one by one say goodbye on Friday Madeleine I mean I don't know about you but I was really quite emotional about everything that happened at the end of last week oh absolutely Thursday evening I saw Simon Bauman's tweet that he found
15:32out and he's over in the UK it's always like because I remember it was evening time here in the US it was really late for him and the way he found out because it was I guess before the emails went out that he was locked out of the company slack in his email and I felt so bad for him and he was running Twitter communities he was doing the community for Twitter communities and overseeing communities and he was so well liked and so well known and so passionate about his work and I was shocked and then when we heard about Danny Singh being let go and he has done a tremendous job with spaces and he's just been there for us and listening to us all this time as we all started off
16:14as beta testers with spaces so it made a lot of us very nervous rightfully so that thinking okay spaces is probably going away why are they getting rid of the team but then there was a tweet I had this in the nest from C who does a lot of the design work over in spaces and while she's saying she doesn't really have a clear answer with everything going on she's saying things are changing day by day but she's she said from what she's seen that the new leadership does recognize a value in spaces and podcasts so you know that gave us some hope for sure but after listening to Elon in the interview today and seeing how many people came out and I guarantee you he's watching those
16:56numbers and we're really close to a million listens so it's that's got to count for something absolutely and I I mean the the next tweet that we've got here that we were going to share is actually about the spaces feedback Community Morgan this was one of yours you know obviously with with no team there you know it was a it was a space's team right that were that were really Fielding that community so do we know what's going to happen with that as yet Morgan have you got any insights no unfortunately not yet it's still very much in limbo so again this this is the sad a sad story but the three moderators for the the official spaces feedback community no
17:40longer worked for the company or at least I mean they I believe that the employment contract isn't actually terminated for a couple of months so technically they do they're just not allowed to do anything so that Community is is headless right now and it looks like much is true of the the high communities official Community as well not all of them there I think but but many of them certainly Simon has gone so there is this sort of limber at the moment where this this is it's not just will this product be maintained and developed it's and the question is who's going to do that in the short term and who's going to be talking and listening to us and replying to our
18:30questions right now because it doesn't seem like there's an immediate rush to fill those those no certainly not and I mean we've seen I've certainly seen at least one Community that's kind of trying to Usher people off of Twitter and and perhaps onto a different platform as well do you think we can expect a bit of an exodus from other communities as well I don't know I mean this is there's I I guess like one thing is there's uncertainty at the moment right now and you might wonder well look do I invest much of my time building a community where I don't have confidence in the road map and we have Elon tweeting today one thing which might I you know in in one
19:10sense I think this is great that he's willing to try things and drop them very quickly if they don't work but that's also instability too on the other hand we have everybody tweeting now about trying out other networks like going back to Macedon and I'm not I feel like my hunch is that this is a short-lived thing that there is uncertainty but people come back so I guess long-term bullish but there's there is real uncertainty now if you are building something yeah and you know I think as well while we're not sure what's going to happen potentially all of these strands as Jennifer was saying there could be packaged up into whatever Twitter blue is going to look
19:56like in future whatever it means to be verified blue checked whatever it's going to be called I mean that was the quickest thing in Twitter history surely didn't we have official as a tag earlier today and then literally hours later that was pulled did that happen or did I not did I miss that no that happened I mean they're they're trying things and changing it back at one point I think it was last week or over the weekend I when I went into my Twitter blue because like Jennifer I've had Twitter blue for a while I I am willing to pay to have these extra features but it only cost 2.99 a month now we know that's gone up to 4.99 but now the new thing with Elon
20:37is eight dollars a month so it'll be interesting to see with these features but what they did at one point is they when you logged into your Twitter blue it it mentioned you're now verified but there was no blue check mark and I went in to manage subscription that still showed 2.99 it did not give me an option for this new eight dollars but what I've noticed as of today okay is that people I know who are verified are now getting the notification to pay the eight dollars to 7.99 a month to get this new verification but then I saw there's so much to look at Sue's because then you got Jane Wong who is like she has it and she says if she stops it it'll go back to her old blue
21:24check mark but with this new Twitter blue she has the new check mark but she said also send her a tweet it doesn't look any different so you could not really tell the difference so that's a little confusing I think because we can look at a verified account and not know at the moment which it is but we've been hearing about this new grayed out way that's going to be the Like official account which makes sense but we're so used to the blue check mark being the way to know this this is a verified account this is who they say they are whereas that's going to go out the window and be more of your verified Twitter blue and you pay the money and with that you're supposed to get
22:09less ads you're supposed to get more relevant content which could be very worth paying for but plenty of people will say okay that's great and all but when you're used to a free platform and all of a sudden the platform charges you don't want to pay for it and I know that's how a lot of people are going to think they're gonna be like why would I pay for this it's been free all these years and I just wanted to have that democratizes stuff like Elon sort of saying you know this is supposed to be the the world's town hall or whatever how is that equal for people if actually you end up with people who have paid a certain amount getting a different service and you know their
22:54tweets being prioritized over other people's and how does that level the playing field and I'm sure I've seen him somewhere having said that or being quoted as saying that I'm not sure how that works I mean Jennifer Morgan what are your thoughts on the on the whole check mark and and the the payments you know I want to talk a little bit about what Madeleine said where when something is free and all of a sudden it switches to paid that people don't want to pay at one time meetup.com was free and then they started charging 20 a month if you were the organizer now it's up to 30 a month at one time LinkedIn was didn't have premium it was just free
23:28and then they started offering premium it didn't mean that the free stuff went away if I wanted to just be there so I feel like yes the democracyization part to address what you're talking about it becomes a challenge if you're running a group and you're in a country where they don't have Twitter blue then all of a sudden that becomes a problem I feel like they need to address that because if I'm running Community or I'm a spaces host and I'm in a country that's not part of the Twitter blue operational piece all of a sudden I'm left out in the cold and that's not right so I feel like phase one may be just this phase but they really very quickly need to address
24:03phase two for all the people in the countries that don't have Twitter blue access yet there's got to be something they can do to level that playing field that's such a great Point yeah yeah I mean it's kind of trend going on at the moment there's the weakness in the ad Market plus some major kind of systemic changes particularly around Apple's ads tracking transparency policies which mean that there are many tech companies at the moment that are struggling after a 13-year boom and introducing forms of direct revenue or subscription Revenue recurring Revenue to offset the variability of the weakness in the admire Okay so we're seeing this in many different
24:46places and I do think there's also another part of this the famous Twitter line I can't believe this this website is free well at some point you sort of take that literally that we all get a great deal of value from this and I think it doesn't become like a completely wild idea to think that this is a service that we might pay for in some form and it might be that I've got question marks about this being the form of it but but some form is possibly
25:19okay I mean I I don't know again at the same time I really feel that and I think I think you're absolutely right sis that this is like leveling the playing field for the middle classes but we still have the like the landlord at the top and the pros at the bottom everybody who can't afford this when this is much if this is much more broadly a thing will really lose voice here that you will not be prioritized in terms of Engagement or visibility and replies you won't show at the top of spaces if if many people have this those people will be floated to the top of spaces and everyone else at the bottom won't be so it does equalize in one sense that this
26:03is not tied to the whims of a verifier who decides who is notable and who isn't you can just pay for it but in other ways there is still a kind of a class or a cast system here of a different kind that's such a good point Morgan I mean I know in his interview he talked about this eight dollars a month to help reduce the Bots and the trolls but it's not going to completely stop it and it is going to cause people to that can't afford this to to get these extra services to do
26:38these things that elon's talking about so these are all really great points and I feel like we're still in this wait and see because we're still not 100 sure where this is all going yeah and and you know the the the tweet that we we picked up earlier from Esther Crawford she's actually retweeted elon's tweet which says please note that Twitter will do lots of dumb things in coming months like that some kind of Public Service Announcement that's the caveat for everything that might be a bit weird in the next few weeks and months we're just to ignore it because it's okay elon's aware of it he knows it's going to be a bit dumb there's going to be some strange stuff
27:13he says we will keep what works and change what doesn't but you know I'm not sure how how long our patients holds out with things and I think as you say the uncertainty there needs to be a bit of leadership a bit of understanding I mean yeah I totally don't see how they can keep things running and stable in that without the team like there's no team like this is all great and he's using spaces and all the rest of it but there's no team sorry but it is actually on fire behind you you know what I mean exactly right well so what about the farewell I mean would do we bring that back I mean I think that might be a hoot because for those of us who have been on Twitter from the very
27:56beginning the farewell was very very real we were so accustomed to it it just became part and parcel of oh it fell well and you oh it was common it was so common and you go to plurk you would go to plurk or you'd go to Facebook right right and so is this the new thing right where we're going to see that kind of farewell-esque type situations where we're like oh now we're going to Facebook now we're going to LinkedIn now we're going somewhere else and then we'll come back because we're still here Madeline and I who were here from those early days are still here even through all of that chaos I feel like there's yes chaos that's going to happen Elon is
28:29admitting it we all know it's going to happen because there's no team as soon as mentioned the majority of the team that helped all this happen is gone but I feel like I mean I don't know I feel like I'm still going to stick around to see what happens I've got my popcorn I'm ready to roll and see what happens yeah I'm the same I feel like the the risk profile changes here somewhat that the kind of character is going to do well in this new but you have to have a high level of risk tolerance because things are going to change quickly but that said there's also I think a lot of opportunity here so I mean the the two things that that Simon was mentioning in the podcast was
29:07look you should look for products that directly Drive Revenue to the company okay that's that's going to be one of elon's two main priorities but the other one is products where users pay other users and the company takes a card so you're going to have to start thinking about well look given what comes down the pipe here how can I do things that are really of value where other users on the platform are prepared to pay me for what I do or even subscribe to what I do the other part of this is which we got somewhat in elon's talk today is he wants this to be a place where content creators broadly on the internet will not just come and tweet about the
29:49thing they do on YouTube but we'll literally upload their video here and this will be a competitive place in terms of the kinds of Revenue they can make equivalent to places like Tick Tock or YouTube that's very good if you're that kind of Creator but it also means that everybody here has to up their game because if Elon stuff goes well those people will be over here too that's kind of an exciting prospect that it would mean that this place grows quite a lot but if you're thinking about being a Creator here it's probably time to get very serious about that very true I'm I'm going through now and I am actually we've got lots of of speakers we did
30:33have other news that we were going to cover today and if you pick up the Twitter moment there will be a few links in there for various things that are happening on Clubhouse this week but you know this is the topic of the moment it's the topic of the title and we've got a fair few people that have requested them like Peter I hope I might be saying your name wrong there please do correct me hello and welcome to the all things audio space what what are your thoughts hi very important tiny conversation just a premise about me I know Morgan personally from Clubhouse I first started on clubhouse and then earlier this year we ran I think it is the longest and largest
31:12room in Social audio history we basically ran a room for the first 105 days of the Ukraine war non-stop reached about one and a half million listeners and resulted in while they Connie made me the icon app I'm not trying to show off I'm just trying to give you an understanding that I I've been doing this for a while oh completely and we covered that space actually right here on all things audio we discussed it at the time oh wonderful about the the fact that it was so such long running and the the moment in time that it was capturing so it's really great to speak with you yeah so what what are your thoughts around everything that's going on yeah so backgrounder is the I like
31:52Clubhouse I've built up relationships there that you know Twitter's so much larger and I think that's the core component which is this is an add-on to an existing Outlaws Clubhouse was built around the social audio first and foremost so there's a degree of intimacy and sort of I don't know I like the app of Clubhouse in terms of its interface I think it's quite satisfying to use problem is Paul and the others haven't been listening to I don't know if I call myself a content creator but like people who are bringing people on to hold important conversations and or do things for comedy or build you know host meditation and music rooms and that's why I've shifted to Twitter more
32:34because there's this opportunity to grow here I am concerned by musk's acquisition you know I I don't think or maybe that's me hoping maybe more than realistically he's gonna remove Twitter spaces but if he if he doesn't you know I think there's a few areas he could improve it I mean I certainly could think of as couple easy ways to monetize this thing you know I've been talking to sponsors and people about coming onto spaces that I host with speakers to to bring in some monetization options I have a podcast which I convert some of the Twitter space into Evergreen content on on the podcast so this is a good multi-platform purpose right here but again I think that Twitter
33:18hasn't levied the the function as much as they could of there's a lot of features that I could include I like the co-host function but I think the opportunity to pin one specific link or connect spaces between one another give clubs or communities where people can you know enter a club function and find your community like club houses right and then they can find you as the finder and then that builds up your your your presence your reach I'm not a Twitter person in the sense of tweeting things text wise I get bored and frankly I find myself phrasing things much more well hopefully articulating them better audibly so that's where I've seen my main
34:03engagement and you know I I don't agree with people who say that social audio isn't a thing or it's not going to go anywhere clearly it has its place it's not going to S you know observe a video or YouTube and and text-based formats but I think it's a very important delivery method and and and you can see that from organizations like Human Rights Watch or activist groups I'm mainly in the field of of like geopolitics and stuff so I know not everyone's cup of tea but you know for that kind of area where you're bringing awareness to what's going on in Iran or or Ukraine it's so powerful and so easy to convey messages really quickly so you know I hope that we see some positive
34:48things coming out of this and and maybe for people who want to be able to monetize that there are some streamlined methods being created as well but yeah I'll land that because I I I could go on for ages but thanks for this for the space yeah thank you for being here and and sharing your thoughts we love hearing from our listeners and is such an interesting topic to be discussing today I do want to mention I went to look back to see how many listeners have now tuned in to the Elon q a it is at 900 000.
35:21it's in the nest he did a spaces q a earlier this afternoon I'll put the Tweet back in the nest to send the nest but it's more towards the beginning but I'll put it back in so it's easier to find there is a recording it was about an hour long very insightful and currently 900 000 total have tuned in which is so before the end of today we're going to be at a million listens which I think says a lot about spaces all right we've got a bunch more speakers next up is George hey George hey how are you I share you in Madeline's reassurance from Elon today I think we got schooled in the difference between voice and and tweets his tweets have been a little
36:06flaky a lot of his tweets are you know what the hell does he mean by this is this guy sincere I think his sincerity came through today at least for me I'm vastly reassured and I'm reassured by we've already mentioned this tweet about we'll we'll do a lot of dumb things I applaud that experimental attitude and I see I think there's going to be a lot more of it and what he said was the important thing is not not to make mistakes but he said agility is the key to the whole thing and that's what I'm hearing or reading between the lines I'm reading that for him this is a startup
36:48not for us and he's going to change a lot but he's going to do it under high feedback conditions he in many about three or four different places today mentioned customer feedback and customer or user user participation in this whole thing and so it's he he clearly wants something that's self-correcting and you set a high ideal which is to be the most credible Source on the internet Which is far it's far from that now and he acknowledges that but he wants to get high feedback with an advisory Council and a whole bunch of other things so I just want to point out one other thing just because he fired a team the spaces team or the community team
37:36doesn't mean there's a vacuum you know those of us have been through mergers and Acquisitions a lot you know you you remove whole teams you move other people in you consolidate things doesn't mean that it's going to break due to abandonment or be shut down due to lower lower priority so I'm vastly reassured and welcome this increased amount of of customer feedback and he mentioned several times you know answer my tweets I'm reading them I'll answer you etc etc so I'm I'm reassured I mean there's nothing more agile is there than bringing out this official tag and then totally seeing the reaction to it and removing it now that is quick work that's quick yeah that's the that's the
38:25entrepreneurial mindset it's like you know often and error rarely in doubt you know and when you make an error you correct it like immediately you know you don't do things that aren't correctable quickly and that's he he gets all that he knows all that and that's what we should expect well thank you for sharing your insights George and yeah you know you for everybody here you and I have been dming a lot these past few weeks you know hearing stuff from Elon I know you're definitely a bigger fan of Elon than I am but man hearing him actually speak
39:01versus those tweets I I felt he was so sincere whereas I felt like a lot of his tweets were not sincere a lot of his tweets pissed me off you've heard me talk about that the last several weeks and spaces but after list I mean I sat and listened I was out getting my car picking up my car my car's been in the shop at the dealership for a few days I was sitting in the dealership waiting for my car to get it and listening on my phone because I did not want to miss this conversation and listening on my whole drive back before I got back to the office and I I was just wowed by his sincerity and him answering these questions and he was getting some
39:40tough questions from the speakers this was not Saturday night his Saturday Night Live thing that was written and rehearsed and scripted you know all that stuff this was live and on the Fly and I really think he means what he says and says what he means and that he will you know now it could go down in flames but I think it will be not for want of trying yeah I felt like he just provided a lot of assurance that things you know that yes he admitted things could go wrong it could fail but but he but he is listening and he he invites critique he invites comment there was just so much sincerity so it's still a wait and see no doubt but I I feel better having listened to
40:28the entire conversation and if anybody missed it it was recorded it's in the nest I would definitely take a listen it was very interesting it's also I mean it was it was its purpose was to reassure advertisers let's not make any bones about that I mean that's just clear that was announced openly and transparently that being said I was also very impressed by y'all by the way Joel Roth and so I think they are they're
40:55trying and boy he said an awfully High ideal to make it the most credible place you know on on the internet wow all right let's get a move on to our other speakers but thank you George really great insights next up is Adam hey Adam how are you doing I'm doing well Madeline how are you doing and Susan everyone so many familiar faces it's great to see everyone so I was in a space two and it was
41:25you know first they I I almost felt like we were hearing the Down to Earth part of of Elon they were you know sitting in a meeting room having a Twitter space and broadcasting live answering questions and what I noticed that I remembered back when you know the bid initially went through he had put in or was tossed it might have been right before when he was tossing around and he started putting up those surveys like you know would you should everyone on this platform be verified would you should DMS be and then encrypted a lot but like so I think he was addressing a lot of those because those surveys that he posted had millions of responses and overwhelmingly
42:24he's listening to the users of the platform and whether that be the consumer or the Advertiser that's you know paying to have their ad and you know he's definitely for freedom of speech but he said you know that doesn't mean if something's said that that like essentially like you know it will it will be very quiet like he I was very
42:56glad when he said you know you're not going to see anything like next to an ad like he really he addressed it hates he dressed hate speech he addressed it he addressed just so many different things I mean we were all in there so in order not to go over but it I we really solve it down to earth version of him and and agreed with George on yo yo yo
43:28Roth his you know goal of keeping everything up and running and and then and and elon's candidness are saying like I just got the keys last week tomorrow like is the way he said it and the platform is losing you know is it four million dollars approximately per day a billion plus per year so something has to be done immediately so he is taking the Silicon Valley which in the entrepreneur we're out of you know fail fast if but but without without failing you don't have an invitation you know you have to try everything and he said I might be completely wrong I was just so like he was so honest about it so
44:16I I was very I I didn't expect I I expected a certain amount of honesty but he was completely honest with his feelings and really just ain't like it wasn't a scripted thing it was like you know he had the questions in advance he was thinking about it and then he said well let me go over to y'all Roth for that and do you have any thoughts on this I mean it was amazing to see that and and then again to reiterate the amount of brands that were in there that just shows the power of Twitter Twitter Spaces by itself I mean they're here and they're listening and they wanted to hear what he had to say so I thought it went very well and
45:05looking forward to see what happens and where everything goes and and hoping that we see the Innovation that he's talking about another major thing that I think is going to be coming will be you know the data and privacy of everything well you know we might have a bit more control of that he really I I went back over because I had you know screenshotted every one of those polls and that I noticed a lot of questions so that that's addressed so I just found it very valuable that's super interesting that you've managed to kind of tie up what you know he'd obviously said in previous weeks or whatever with what's come out today and I I really don't want to be too cynical about it
45:54but we did need some reassurance and we did need he needed some good PR over here maybe so maybe this was the moment I mean you know I'd be lying if I didn't say that I'm glad you used spaces because for me you know me Madeline and probably most of the people that are in here and certainly those that join our all things audio space each week we would hate to see spaces disappear and this does feel like a bit more reassurance for us that that feature on the platform isn't going to go anywhere soon and you know it might not be built as quickly as we've seen and it might not have new features and it might not expand and all those different things I'm really hoping it
46:32doesn't disappear behind some kind of paywall which is a possibility that we've discussed during this space today but yeah I mean it's good that he's taking the mic it's great that he's used spaces I've still got to go back and listen to it because it all happened so quickly before this space happened that I didn't have time to to listen to it but I will be listening with a bit of a pinch of salt critical here I've got to admit because you know I'm I'm still not sure I'm glad he's using spaces but I'm yeah I don't know I don't want him to just be saying what we want to hear you know what I mean thank you so much Adam for your thoughts that's that's just fantastic
47:04Ray Ray you're up next what are your thoughts around everything that's been going on over this last week yeah I think it's very fascinating I think I'm gonna listen I didn't hear I didn't I wasn't available at the time when he was doing a speech on Twitter but I think that you guys are wrong about saying that you know it's free we're giving information to them and and they're not you know even if you're paying eight dollars you still give me extra information maybe they don't say it but they are getting data from us they just are so I don't I don't believe anything is free when it comes to social media if they make you believe that but it's not true I don't know why
47:47they do that but it's not true they're using us and and they don't want to be he doesn't want to be you he wants to use us and us pay him for using us that's how I feel I'm Ray Ray thanks ooh good point Ray Ray because if something's free we are the product no doubt and even if we're paying we are we are the product good point yeah so well made I'm going to chat with Jason now Bunsen I see you there what are your thoughts on on all of this well I was I had the I have the day off so I'm super glad I was able to listen to the Elon Musk space live
48:25and then I noticed I had the ability to upgrade to the quote unquote blue check mark so that's what I did and that's all cool for eight bucks we got Bunsen and Beaker verified I I don't want to rehash what everybody said I totally agree with the sentiment that's the only thing I wanted to say is there's a vast difference between Elon that tweets and Elon that talks yes I kind of wish I
48:54kind of wish he talked before he tweeted because talking Elon is I almost want to say like kind like he had a he had a articulate thoughtful kind voice and it and he tackled all the questions but when he tweets occasionally he reminds me of like a middle school kit and I'm a teacher and if a middle school if I gave a middle school kid a Twitter account I kind of feel like they'd come up with kind of the same similar stuff that Elon was coming up with so it definitely caused people to get a little Leary and I that's probably why he that that space was so important he was it was damage control for all the brands that maybe wanted to abandon ship
49:39because they're super concerned with what was going on with Twitter so kudos to Elon I think he probably calm down the waters a bit one of the things that he mentioned that nobody else has brought up that I found very interesting is that he mentioned that for the people that are verified and they pay the eight bucks a month the algorithm is going to treat them differently and the analogy I think he made in the space is that if you aren't verified your tweets may become like the spam in your spam folder in your Gmail account and I mentioned this in another space I was in just a few seconds ago I never I never checked my spam folder I don't I go in there occasionally when somebody's
50:25like hey I sent you something and I was like whoops and then there's all this other crap in there so that was that was a huge impetus for me to quote unquote verify or pay for Twitter the upgraded Twitter blue is I don't want our stuff to wind up in spam filters I want our our message of Science and empathy to get out there so worthwhile for me good to listen to Elon and I don't want to rehash everything else that everybody said but maybe some of you who listened can give me your opinion on that that it is a little it is a little classist if you've got eight bucks a month you don't wind up in the spam folder that's the only thing I'm gonna say yeah I just want to jump
51:11in on that I I think we need to be careful about romanticizing musk too much this is a dude who's made questionable business decisions previously and this Venture if you want to call it that is a lot different to the other ones he's undertaken equally spaces is very different to the actual core Crux of Twitter and he may not see that it's worth putting in a bunch of time to expand the features or opportunities with it when he wants to improve Twitter as a whole so you may not see very much happen at all or he may reduce the support and the focus that is on it even as it stands so you know things get worse before they get better equally I think that the methodology
51:55when it comes to the blue verification Mark is absurd you've basically switched from one form of elitism I.E via whether or not you've got access to well specific qualifications to basically whether or not you have enough money to pay which I don't think is a very clever method and equally I was looking at one stream yesterday which was talking about how his his suggestion on other people's suggestion I think I retweeted it of adding an official like under name underneath your name or your your tagline would sort of be a supplement to the Blue Tick as well so Blue Tick is for those who are part of the subscription service and then if you're official
52:34public figure celebrity government agency whatever it is you know has an additional official underneath it which is all well and good but it kind of defeats the purpose of the verification about it in the first place then so what's the point and you might as well just offer other ways if you want to monetize the Twitter areas there's other ways to go about doing it then simply if you want to be seen as a verified voice paying your way through it it doesn't necessarily solve the misinformation disinformation element that we're seeing here I'm curious does anyone here pay for LinkedIn premium just does anyone because I know that the LinkedIn premium folks have like a badge
53:13if I'm correct like a goldish badge or something is that right I think they have like a yellow shield a yellow shield so isn't that and to some extent show that they are paying for additional features and additional services and probably get things that those of us who aren't me I'm going to raise my hand is not paying probably doesn't get I probably don't get as much reach as they do I'm thinking I don't know for a fact but I don't think I'm getting the kind of reach that someone who's paying 140 a month or 29.99 a month is getting and let's do that comparison the 29.99 a month at a minimum up to 140 a month compared to eight bucks yeah but the distinction I I'd make
53:53there is that LinkedIn is for networking and business explicitly whilst link Twitter is also social and just sort of chatting with people so I think targeted if that makes sense I think that the I think that the the check mark is going to provide an additional screening method for
54:16spaces I think it's very relevant to spaces so Elon went into some detail about how the eight dollars means that you have to have a bank account you have to have a credit card some spam bot's not going to go get a thousand credit cards so it's an additional screener and I think it will up the quality of of spaces because I certainly will let people up to these speakers more the people who have the check mark and their they've got that additional little layer of of verification and by the way as Adam was speaking before I got my check mark just appeared I'm sorry George but how how can someone who's got a better God it's a different kind of verification now it's not going to be
55:03the same type of verification it's going to be a different type that that's that's the point he made today it will just be that additional layer of legitimacy is it proof of legitimacy of course not but it's just that little extra Edge I will certainly give an extra Edge to people with check marks but somebody's got a a you know sensible bio and all that I'm not going to exclude them I think it's going to be relevant to the quality of spaces that's that's all I'm saying that's that's my hope thank you so much to everybody that has joined us in the space today everyone who's taken the mic special thanks to Jennifer and also to Morgan for joining us and helping to
55:45host bye [Music] thank you to all of our speakers who came on and shared so much great stuff and were available in all of your favorite podcast apps we're out there all things audio you can also go to all thingsaudiopodcast.com as well you certainly can and you can catch us here on Twitter and use the hashtag all things audio and we'll pick that up throughout the week so that's it for this week but thank you so much to everyone that's been here in the space with us and those of you listening and we'll catch up with you next week bye everybody foreign
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版