2019 年 11 月那场发布会上,不锈钢球砸向 Cybertruck 车窗之前,弗朗茨·冯·霍尔茨豪森(Franz von Holzhausen)已经在后台对着同一块玻璃扔了好几次。没碎。他还留了视频,准备证明这玻璃扛得住。
然后他走上台,球出手,玻璃裂了。
五年后他回忆那一刻,用的词是"心往下一沉"。台下有人问他,那是设计好的吧?他只能回一句:至少球没穿过去砸到人。
特斯拉首席设计师在这个位置上干了十五年。他见过 Model S 从一张草图变成街上最常见的电动车,见过 Cybertruck 从一块折不动的不锈钢变成一台量产车,也见过自己参与设计的东西被摆进博物馆。这篇访谈里,他讲了些平时不太说的细节:为什么 Cybertruck 长成那样,为什么门把手非要弹出来,以及跟马斯克意见不合时会怎么收场。
一通 2008 年的电话
他入行是因为他父亲。父亲做设计,他从小知道自己想干这行,后来听说洛杉矶有家学校叫艺术中心设计学院(Art Center),就去了。毕业后的路径很常规:大众、奥迪,然后换过几家公司,最后落在马自达,一待三年半。
马自达那边做的项目挺让他兴奋,但他心里有个疙瘩:这家公司对可持续这件事不上心。他平时爱翻杂志,在《大众科学》(Popular Science)一类的刊物上读到过一家小公司,把电池塞进汽车里。他觉得有意思。
后来朋友牵线,他跟马斯克通了一次电话,又跑去 SpaceX 见面。时间是 2008 年年中。那时候特斯拉和 SpaceX 都还在婴儿期,两家公司随时可能死掉。
我看到的是这样一家公司、这样一个人,极度专注在可持续上,想做别的车企没在做的事,做百分之百纯电。我们聊得挺投机,后面的事就成了现在这样。(弗朗茨·冯·霍尔茨豪森)
马斯克当老板:永远要求再多走一步
评价这位老板,他先说边界。马斯克一直在推边界,不让团队接受现状,永远要求"再往前一步,确保这个东西是完美的"。
更具体的一点是关注点落在哪里。马斯克极其在意顾客怎么感知这台车,顾客跟产品之间的关系是什么,坐进去会有什么体验。这种在意会传导下去,设计团队得跟着一起焦虑这件事。
那两个人吵不吵?吵。他的说法是"求同存异",但最后一句很干脆:他是老板。
这句话信息量不小。特斯拉设计流程里没有"设计师集体投票推翻 CEO"这种机制,争论的终点是马斯克拍板。Cybertruck 这种形状能活下来,某种程度上是因为拍板的人喜欢它。
Cybertruck 的起点是材料,不是造型
外界以为这台车的造型是先有想法再找理由,他的解释正好反过来:形态服从功能,而且这次是被材料和制造方式逼出来的。
汽车行业习惯把形态放在功能前面,两件事很难兼顾。Cybertruck 的出发点是另一套制造逻辑:把最硬的东西放在外面。他们想用不锈钢,让车最坚固的部分成为外表面,不用靠娇气的车漆去挡。皮卡在什么环境里都得扛,像一把瑞士军刀,得皮实。
问题在于不锈钢极难成形。要做到防弹级别的厚度、扛得住撞击不变形,常规的冲压办法直接失效。那个厚度下,钢材只能在一个方向上折弯,做不出复合曲面。
约束条件摆在那里,剩下的路只有一条:平面、直线、极简。所以那台车看起来像折纸,是因为它真的只能折。
他还提到另一层动机:皮卡这个品类六十到七十年没变过,一直是那个三段式的方盒子。他们想拆掉这个范式。顺便,把后斗盖起来、让车顶往后溜,空气动力学上更划算。
这句话值得单独拎出来:Cybertruck 看起来完全不像省油的车,但它的风阻表现非常好。违反直觉,但几何上说得通,斜面加溜背,气流走得比传统皮卡干净。
皮卡的三段式,七十年没动过
他反复回到"配方"这个词。皮卡有一套沿用了几十年的配方:车头一段、驾驶舱一段、后斗一段,比例固定,姿态固定,连用户对它的期待都固定。
这套配方不是不能改。他的态度是,只要安全、功能、作为皮卡该有的属性都达标,没有理由不改。
至于改完之后有人恨,他说得很平静:一半人爱一半人恨,本来不在设计意图里。意图是形态服从功能,是冒一次险,是大胆,同时还得满足一台皮卡的全部要求。
砸窗那一秒
回到开头那个球。他强调的是准备过程:上台前他在后台对着车窗扔过好几次,没碎,还有视频留存。所以玻璃裂开是真的意外。
后续的走向比事故本身更有意思。散场后观众过来问他,那是安排好的吧?没法解释,解释也没人信。这事迅速变成梗图,传遍全网。
他的判断是,这次翻车反而帮了忙。砸窗这件事让 Cybertruck 带上了某种邪典气质,一种自己的亚文化。发布会讲参数是要被忘掉的,玻璃碎了不会。
从发布到量产,中间那几年在干什么
外界一直在问为什么这么久。他的回答是,重新发明一个产品就得走完这些流程,把设想验证成现实。
"外骨骼"这个想法是核心难点:让车身外皮本身承担结构,而不是藏在里面的车架。这种结构能不能成立,得靠时间一点点试。
他还给了一个具体结论:量产车跟当年台上那台,用途上完全一致,尺寸可能略小几个百分点,总体上就是这个样子。
顺便说一句他早年的心愿。刚进特斯拉时他想,哪天能在城里开车兜一圈看见好几台特斯拉就好了。现在随便去哪都躲不开。
他更看重的是行业层面:特斯拉把"电动车可以比燃油车更好"这件事推进了,而不只是卖了多少台车。Cybertruck 要接着讲这个故事。
门把手为什么非要弹出来
隐藏式门把手被吐槽过无数次,逻辑其实很朴素。
门把手是人和车的第一个接触点。你走近,它伸出来,跟你握手。他把这个动作形容成给车加了一点拟人感,让人不至于觉得自己钻进一台冷冰冰的机器里。那是一个示好的动作。
第二层原因是空气动力学:把手不凸在车侧迎着风,阻力更小。
两件事合起来就是他理解的特斯拉:不受过去做法的束缚,愿意为了一个体验细节去改结构,最后交付的东西得让人愿意拥有、愿意跟朋友讲。
第一次造 Semi,反而更自由
重卡项目之前,他一次都没做过商用车。团队花了不少时间去理解司机这个角色:路线怎么跑,车怎么被使用,一天在车上待多久。
不熟悉并没有拖住他们,反而松了绑。没有历史包袱,可以从一张白纸开始,做出一套跟现有重卡完全不同的布局,最后得到完全不同的结果。
结果具体是什么:驾驶舱把电机和变速箱从车头挪走,司机被放在正中间,视野最好,位置尽可能往前推。驾驶舱围绕司机做成水滴形,一路顺到后面的货厢,风阻极低。
舱内空间更大,视野更好,塞进了包括自动辅助驾驶(Autopilot)在内的安全系统,没有尾气,没有震动。对每天要在车里待十几个小时的人来说,工作环境整体变好了。
电动平台把中间那块铁拿掉了
他讲了电动车和燃油车在布置上的根本差别。电池铺在底板,驱动单元放在轮间,整个底盘变成一块滑板,滑板以上全是给人用的空间。
燃油车上那些占地方的东西消失了:车头那坨沉重的金属、贯穿中央的传动通道、底盘下方一路铺到车尾的排气管。
空间被还给了用户。前面多出一个前备箱。Model S 之所以能塞下七个人,就是因为这些传统部件都不存在了。
自由不是无限的。他提醒了一句:车还是四个轮子,还是得装人,还是得安全。要在这些限制里把车做得好看,还不能看起来像被法规捆住的样子,这是设计团队长期面对的难题。
Cybertruck 是一张快速草图,Model S 不是
他区分了两种设计节奏。
有的车在脑子里很快就成形。Cybertruck 属于这一类,一张快速草图,想法就齐了。
Model S、Model 3 要慢得多。这两台车要反复打磨,从车身比例里榨出一种运动感、一种看起来就高效的感觉。"高效"这个词,他们内部用得极多,造型要围绕这个概念展开。
从想法到量产车,快的话也要走完整个链条。他提到团队正在尝试两年内完成一次。
他的墙上贴的是 Countach
问到他少年时代最喜欢的车,答案很直接:1962 年的法拉利 250 GTO。他的形容是"经典中的经典,一台疯车"。
他还偏爱楔形年代,早期的 Countach,那一批扁平、低矮的跑车。这些是他墙上的海报。
灵感来源他讲得有点散:飞机舷窗外的景象,以前骑车出门放空脑子,陪孩子乱跑。他承认说不清灵感从哪来,也没法预约某个时刻被启发。能做的只是保持眼耳打开,随时吸收。
他现在日常开的是 Model S Plaid。评价很实在:可能是他们造过最好的车,路上任何时刻都比别人快,同时安全,能装下全家,也能塞进自行车,一台什么都能干的车。而且这套设计从 2008 年立项到现在,造型依然不过时。
自动驾驶会改掉车的形状
他对未来的判断集中在一点:交通形态正在变,自动驾驶从稀罕事变成常态之后,人不再需要自己开到目的地。
飞机、火车早就这样了,人买票、坐着、被送到。汽车是最后一块没被改造的地方。
一旦驾驶位上不再需要人,车的形状就得重画。内部空间怎么排、坐着干什么、甚至"拥有"这件事还有没有意义,都会跟着变。自动驾驶改的不只是驾驶方式,是车这个物体的形态本身。
特斯拉没有备胎计划
他在全球好几家车厂干过,说特斯拉特殊的地方在态度。
可持续这件事上,特斯拉是全押,没有降落伞,没有 B 计划。产品做砸了,公司就完了。马斯克本人驱动力极强,团队跟在这个驱动后面,因为大家都信这个使命。
他提到的时间尺度很短:一个几十年没变过的行业,几年内被推着动了。这件事既让人有成就感,也让人继续往前跑,因为要做的还有很多。他的原话是,为了帮着救这个星球,得变快一点。
博物馆里的那台车,和十五年
被问到作品进博物馆是什么感觉,他先把功劳分出去:那不完全是他一个人的作品,他只是拼图里的一小块。展览呈现的是整个特斯拉团队,设计工作室的人、工程、制造,全凑在一个地方。
然后是另一种情绪。人一直盯着下一件事的时候,会忘记回头看已经走了多远。逛那个展对他来说像走了一趟记忆长廊,是过去十五年的一次集中展示。
给年轻设计师的话
他小时候知道"汽车设计师"这个职业存在时,感觉跟听说可以当宇航员差不多。
"追随你的梦想"这句话听着空,但在这一行它是有路径的:有可以学到手艺的学校,有几家能把人送进车厂的通道。他说得很直接,如果有这个念头,就去做,因为这行回报极高,也好玩。
回报具体是什么?看到别人花自己辛苦挣来的钱,买了你做的东西,然后从中得到快乐和满足。他说这种感觉最好。
把这场访谈拆成可用的东西
十五年的设计工作,浓缩成这套访谈,能拿走的其实不是 Cybertruck 好不好看这种结论。
他讲得最扎实的部分,是约束条件如何塑造结果。不锈钢只能单向折弯,所以车必须是平面;电池铺在底板,所以车头可以掏空前备箱;电机不占驾驶舱,所以司机能坐在正中间。每一个看起来奇怪的设计决定,背后都有一条硬邦邦的物理或工艺限制。
还有一层是决策机制。他和马斯克会吵,吵完求同存异,最后老板拍板。这套机制不优雅,但它让一个形状极端的车真的上了产线。反过来想,如果设计由委员会投票决定,Cybertruck 大概率不会存在。
用这些视角去看别的产品,比争论美丑有用得多。
- 看到一个反常识的设计,先找它的约束条件:材料、工艺、成本、法规,通常答案在那里,不在审美里。
- 评估一个创新时,问一句"它解决了谁的什么问题",Cybertruck 解决的是外表面强度,Semi 解决的是司机的视野和工时环境,答案都很具体。
- 团队里出现分歧,早点明确谁拍板。求同存异是过程,明确责任人是终点,两件事都得有。
- 做产品时把第一个接触点想清楚。门把手伸出来那一下,成本不高,但它决定了用户对整台车的第一印象。
- 给自己留出放空的时间。他自己说不清灵感从哪来,但骑车、跑步、看飞机窗外这些时刻起了作用,被动等灵感不如主动制造空档。
- 如果你是刚入行的人,去找那条通道:能教你手艺的学校、能让你进项目的公司。这行的门槛是技能,不是缘分。
- 隔一段时间回头看一眼自己做过的东西。他自己也承认,盯着下一件事的时候,会忘记已经走了多远。
0:00[Music] foreign [Music] I head up to sign for Tesla I've been doing this for about 15 years now I got into designing cars actually through my dad my dad's a designer I heard about this great school in Los Angeles called Art Center and started my career with Volkswagen and Audi and then have been through various companies through the years and until I got the phone call from Elon one day I was working at Mazda at the time and had been there for about three and a half years you know we were doing really exciting stuff and but I also felt like Mazda wasn't really focused on sustainability and I had been reading about this little car company that was
0:47using batteries and putting them in in cars and I think I read it in popular science or something in an article and I was really intrigued and then through a friend got connected to Elon and we had a really great conversation I went up to meet him at SpaceX and was just really impressed with what he was pulling together at that time this was mid-2008 and so both Tesla and SpaceX were in their infancy and just really getting started but I I just felt like here's a company and a guy incredibly focused on sustainability trying to do something that no other car company was doing and be 100 percent electric and yeah we connected and I don't know the rest is
1:31kind of the history that's around us foreign [Music] musk as a boss is a great boss I mean he's always pushing the boundaries oh he's pushing the limits and always keeps us trying to be as radical as possible never accepting the status quo always trying to take one extra step to make sure something is perfect he cares a ton about what the customer perception is how does a customer relate to the product what's the experience they're going to have and he cares deeply about that and so we are constantly worried about that as well and constantly focus on that so I mean he's just like I said he's just always pushing us and get exactly getting the the best out
2:27of everybody on the team moments when the two of you disagreed on a design element any stories that come to mind yeah I mean we we've agreed to disagree and but ultimately he's the boss so talk about the Cyber Truck design how did this design come to be the Cyber truck is a one of these rare moments where in a way form followed function a lot of times we put the form in front of the function especially in the automotive world and it's really tough to mix the two but cyber truck is really born out of the idea of a different way of manufacturing a material that put the toughness on the outside so we really wanted to use stainless steel as a material so that the hardest part of the
3:18vehicle was on the outside not the delicate paints and it felt right for a truck that's you know used in like a Swiss army knife in in any kind of environment has to be tough so stainless steel is really tough to form especially when you make it bulletproof or thicker to withstand impacts and not be damaged and so we really looked at new ways of manufacturing it you could only break form and form it in One Direction you can't do compound curves or things with the thickness of the stainless steel that we're using so it really led us to a design that was really planar really simplistic and it was also a chance to break the Paradigm of what pickup trucks
3:58have been for the past 60 or 70 years they're the same they're kind of this three box shape and we just thought from an aerodynamic perspective having a covered back a slipping roof would also be helpful and oddly enough it may not look it but the Cyber truck is incredibly aerodynamic vehicle I'm curious if you have a favorite design favorite feature something that you're most proud of favorite one is the one that's coming I think that it can talk about I'm really excited about cyber truck I think you know this vehicle has the chance to be something really radical in a pretty
4:39normal space so I'm looking forward to that shake up and seeing them out on the street and it's incredibly functional it's not just the way it looks as functional as any of its competitors if not more and so I think people use it in ways that we can't even expect and it'll be great to see how that how that plays out
5:02the window smashing was definitely not a thing that we expected to happen I had been in the back prior to getting on stage you know throwing this ball at the window multiple times it didn't break and we have you know we showed video proof of that but that moment was a little bit of a heart drop but at the end of the day it actually ended up being something really special and you know I think after the fact when I was talking with the people in the audience they're like that was supposed to happen right well at least the ball didn't go through the window and kill anybody or anything so it became a meme very quickly and I think it really helped cyber truck take on a whole
5:39cultish being of its own I guess it's been so long to get it off the production line there's a lot of new things in cyber truck when we're Reinventing a product sometimes we have to go through these processes just to prove it out we had this idea that using making an exoskeleton vehicle could work and so we've been using that time to make sure that that actually is working and the Cyber truck will look for all intents and purposes just like the one behind us it's maybe slightly smaller a few percentages but in general this is what the truck will look like there was a moment you know where I thought when I first joined Tesla that it would be great to see multiple Teslas in one
6:28drive experience around town and and now you know you it's hard to go anywhere without seeing a bunch of Teslas so it's great to see the impact that Tesla has had in people's lives but also how it's changed the industry and really pushed this idea that an EV can be better than a internal combustion vehicle and cyber truck will continue that that story some people hate the Cyber Truck design the other people love it how does that make that make you feel was that sort of the idea behind it it wasn't the idea behind it I think it was just about making again the the form follows the function and creating something that's different and taking a chance and being
7:13bold but still being safe and functional and hitting all the attributes for what a pickup truck should be and there's no reason why you can't change the recipe there are a lot of unique features on Teslas like the door handles for example why does Tesla decide to push the boundaries on small features like that some of these small features like the door handles are just really great first touch points but the handle is the thing that greets you when you approach the car and so to have the handle come out magically as you approach it and give you your first kind of handshake I really gave a slight anthropomorphic feel to the car just humanize it a
7:55little bit allows you to not just be stepping into a really cold machine it was a warming gesture and it's also very aerodynamic to not have door handles hanging out in the Wind on the side of the car so we combine those kinds of things Tesla isn't beholden to what's been done in the past and we're always trying to push the boundaries and and deliver on a promise of something fun something enjoyable and something that you would love to own and tell your friends about I was curious about the semi was that the first time you've worked on a semi truck before actually it was and you know we got really involved in what it means to be a driver a user how the
8:37routes work how trucks are used and but not knowing that didn't stop us and in fact it was quite liberating to approach it from a really clean sheet and by having a completely different package than what exists currently we were allowed to come up with a completely different end result and one that's way better for the driver the the user of the product there's much more interior cabin space there's a much better view we put our safety systems into it including autopilot there's no fumes there's no vibrations just a better overall working space for the driver where do you get your inspiration my inspiration comes from anywhere I mean like looking at the the window of a
9:21plane or I used to be a cyclist and just getting out on the road and clearing my head kind of allows for ideas to come like running around with my kids inspiration really comes from anywhere and I can't really pinpoint it or or expect to be able to be inspired at a specific time or moment to just have to be aware and open-eyed and open-eared and absorbed was there a car when you were a little boy that you've loved something that you know inspired you a favorite car I think my favorite car my all-time favorite car is a 62 250 GTO I mean it's
10:05quintessential it's an insane car but I'm also a big fan of this kind of wedge era so the early countaches and that whole that whole kind of flat low sports cars where I was always a those were always posters on my wall I'm driving a Model S plaid right now and it's it's an incredible car it's arguably the best car we've built is the fastest car on the road at any moment you know you're faster than anybody else but it's safe you can put my family fits in it I can put bicycles in it it's yeah it's a great all-around car it's still you know from the Inception of the design that we started in 2008 it still looks modern and it's fresh on the road
10:50today I'm curious how different it is to design for EVS compared to a gas-powered car designing an EV is especially the way that we architect our vehicles with a battery pack on the floor and the drive units Between the Wheels it really allows basically everything above that kind of skateboard or platform to be the the people space the space that we designed for the peoples there's no longer a big clunky massive metal in front of you or a transmission tunnel and a mission you know exhaust pipes Etc running down the middle of the car that's open space so we have a lot of opportunity to give back to the customer or give back to the to the owner of the
11:32the car space so you know there's a front trunk there's a Model S that like we put seven people in the car because we didn't have all these things that are traditionally found in internal combustion engine layout vehicle semis a pretty radical approach to an industry that hasn't seen change in the architecture of the vehicle since the Inception and so by removing the motor and the transmission in front of the vehicle we could put the driver in the middle for the best command view we could move him really far forward and create a really teardrop shape around the driver that goes back to the cab for an incredibly Aero efficient package so there's a lot of Liberties that come
12:14with it at the same time cars right now have four wheels and they need to hold people and they need to be safe and so there's a lot of challenges that we have to overcome to stylistically make the cars look pretty and not feel like they're over regulated and that's one of the challenges that we're always facing
12:36designing a car can happen in your mind pretty quickly cyber truck was actually you know a quick sketch and the idea was there Model S model 3 these cars were a lot longer to really evolve and try to really extract an athletic Poise out of a vehicle something that felt like it was efficient we used the word efficient a lot and so we were trying to design around this idea of efficiency the inspiration can come from anywhere you can formulate that into an idea quickly or you can it can take a while to really getting from the idea to the production car we're working on trying to do that in two years I think the future of transportation is going to change periodically I feel like
13:22we're on the precipice of that with the Advent of autonomy with autonomous vehicles becoming the norm and no longer do you have to drive yourself to a destination or be The Driver of the vehicle the the vehicle that's driving you if you think it changes our the way that we use the vehicles the way that we transport ourselves around we're pretty used to it already in planes and air travel and trains and process to some degree but I think the next step is really the the automobile and I think that autonomy is going to really radically change the form of the car how it's used the Interior Space potentially the ownership experience as well I've worked at a bunch of different
14:09manufacturers around the globe and I think Tesla is just unique and it's all in approach to sustainability there's no kind of parachute there's no backup plan we sink or swim on the products that we produce Elon is incredibly driven we're driven behind that we all believe in the mission and I think when you see the impact that we've been able to have in a few short years into an industry that has not changed in many many years it's rewarding in a way and it it's it it's motivating and it keeps us going because there's much more that we want to do and there's you know we need to we need to change faster in order to help save our planet how do you feel about having your work
14:52in a museum I mean it's not all my work I represent a little bit of the piece of the puzzle here this is an amazing focus on the Tesla team it's nice to see you know that there's artwork and the representation of people from our studio the engineering work manufacturing all of it coming together in one place so I've been involved in quite a few of the projects here and it's it's great to see it all come together in one piece and it's also a nice walk down memory lane you know when you're so focused on what's the next thing sometimes you forget to look back at what you've accomplished along the way and this is a really great Showcase of the accomplishments that Tesla has done in
15:32the past 15 years what advice do you have to Young designers in particular Auto designers yeah I think you know it's it's when I was a kid like when I learned that you could be a car designer it felt like being an astronaut you know you hear these ideas of like chase your dreams and go after it but in that instance you really have to there's opportunities for you to get involved and learn the craft and go to some there's a few amazing schools I can really teach you and put you in a position to get involved in some of these manufacturers in places like this and if you have any aspiration to do that do it because it's incredibly rewarding and it's a it's incredibly fun
16:16the reward is seeing how people spend their hard-earned money on something that you've created and get joy and satisfaction out of it that's the best feeling [Music] foreign [Music]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版