访谈·中文精读

马斯克接受塔克·卡尔森专访(第二部分)

Elon Musk Interview With Tucker Carlson (Part 2)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

马斯克手里有一条关于外星人的硬证据,和六千颗卫星有关。

轨道上现在跑着大约六千颗卫星,迄今为止,没有一次需要为了避让外星飞船而做机动。他说这话的时候语气很平,就像在报一个运营数据。

“如果哪天我真的看到任何外星人存在的证据,我会立刻发在 X 平台上,那大概会成为史上第一热帖。”(马斯克)

卡尔森追问的是更深的一层:你信不信有一种高于人的力量。

马斯克的回答从一串“我们不知道”开始。现实为什么存在,它从哪儿来,外星人在哪儿,还有哪些问题是我们连该问都没想到的。

飞行员喊的那声“不明飞行物”,多半是隔壁的机密项目

军方常说的那些不明飞行物是怎么回事?马斯克的解释很朴素:大量机密项目在同时推进,新飞机、新导弹,保密级别高到连军队内部大部分人都摸不到。

一个飞行员看到个高速移动的东西,喊一声“不明飞行物”,其实是隔壁的机密项目,只是不能告诉你。你得有最高级别的分隔式保密权限,才会知道有这么个东西存在。

至于造物主,他的态度是“非常开放”。既然我们存在,总得有个来源,某种创造者,或者某种创造性的力量,让存在成为可能。但这个创造者的本质到底是什么,他说目前至少是未知的,他不认为自己有确定答案。

驱动他的是好奇心。他想弄明白宇宙的本质,想知道那些奇妙的东西为什么存在。

生命的意义这个问题,可能一开始就问错了

马斯克说,他的人生哲学是搞清楚生命的意义,或者更准确地说,搞清楚该问什么问题。

他借了道格拉斯·亚当斯(Douglas Adams)《银河系漫游指南》里的梗。书里那台叫“地球”的超级计算机算出了生命、宇宙及一切的答案是 42,然后没人知道问题是什么。问题才是真正难的部分,需要一台比地球更大的计算机才能算出来。

所以他的落点是,与其纠结那个终极答案,不如去扩大意识的规模和范围。更多人类,更多思考,也许还包括机器意识。

这个主张直接就撞上了当代最敏感的话题之一:人到底该不该多生孩子。

把人看成地球表面的瘟疫,是这套逻辑的极端终点

卡尔森的说法更直接:美国政府如果退后三步看,像是在系统性地让美国人变少。铺天盖地的反生育宣传,几乎成了某种内政社会政策,目的就是劝你别生孩子。

马斯克认同这属于“文明自杀”的一部分。他把矛头指向极端环保主义,说它的底层是厌人的、反人类的。这种思潮把人看成地球表面的瘟疫和污点,仿佛没有人类,地球就是天堂。

他举了个例子。有个叫“灭绝主义协会”的组织,其负责人在《纽约时报》头版被引用,说世界上有八十亿人,如果一个都没有会更好。

“这种话等于在鼓吹对人类的浩劫,是彻头彻尾的疯狂,他应该为此受到谴责,但不知道为什么并没有。”(马斯克)

他的判断是,环保运动里大多数人并没有意识到自己抱着这种隐含的优化目标。他们不会承认,但他们的行动方向确实指向灭绝。

而“地球养不活这么多人”这个前提,在他眼里完全站不住。

八十亿人挤在纽约的一层楼里,飞机上往下丢球基本砸不到人

他给了两个特别具体的画面。

城市里觉得人山人海,但你坐在飞机上往下看,任何时刻你正下方有人的概率是多少?他的答案是百分之九十九点九的时间里没有。从洛杉矶飞纽约,如果任务是往下丢球砸中一个人,你会失败,得丢很多很多球才有可能中一次。

另一个画面:全世界八十亿人的横截面积加起来,能塞进纽约市的一层楼里。

他的结论是,我们对人口的基本感知是错的。地球没有被过度填满,眼下的状态是人口不足。

他还提到一位在牛津聊过的教授,按那位的算法,人口翻十倍都不会毁掉亚马逊雨林,也不会造成什么可怕的后果。

如果让他管生育政策,第一件事是改教科书

卡尔森问他,如果由他来管生育政策会怎么做。

马斯克说,首先得改教育系统,别再教“我们人口过剩”这套错误的东西。他把源头追到保罗·埃利希(Paul Ehrlich)六十年前那本《人口爆炸》(The Population Bomb),说希望这人下地狱,是个糟糕的人,犯了大错。

第二步是停止用恐惧吓唬女性。学校教给女孩的东西,让她们觉得一旦怀孕,人生就结束了。他承认不该有未成年怀孕,但强调孩子恰恰是能带来巨大幸福感的事情之一。

然后话题拐到了避孕药。

马斯克说,很多女性可能不知道,激素避孕会引发抑郁,显著提高自杀风险,还会改变一个人对伴侣的偏好、改变性格。他连说了几遍“读一下盒子上的警告标签”,建议考虑其他避孕方式。

“我不是说人们不该避孕。我是说这件事不是没有风险的,它确实会造成严重的情绪波动,确实会大幅提高抑郁和自杀的风险。你之所以难过,可能就是因为这个药。”(马斯克)

有意思的是卡尔森的反应。他说在自己大半辈子里,对激素避孕药提任何一点批评,都是最犯忌讳的话。

马斯克回了一句:我只是说读读警告标签。

卡尔森追问,那为什么会有压力不让人读标签,为什么还给十二岁的孩子开这个药去治痘痘。马斯克的回答挺直接:小孩根本不知道自己在吃什么。

他还补了一句个人观察:他认识一些女性停了激素避孕之后,抑郁立刻就消失了。

美国的精神类药物处方量,是全球最高那一档

这一段往下延伸到了抗抑郁药。

马斯克说选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂(SSRI)会把人变成行尸走肉,改变性格,让人不像自己。他并不主张彻底禁用,但认为像发糖果一样开药是疯狂的。

他给了个对比:美国的人均精神类药物处方量远超加拿大、英国、日本、中国,几乎是全球最高那一档。

卡尔森提到了一个常被压下去的问题。每次大规模枪击案之后,如果有人说“凶手在吃什么药”,立刻会被当成疯子嘘下去,说他跟小罗伯特·肯尼迪一个级别,该被送进精神病院。

马斯克的回应比较平衡。确实有真正存在化学失衡的人,比如偏执型精神分裂症患者,不吃药就会发病。他见过停药后失控、甚至试图伤人的案例,所以有些精神类药物确实是利大于弊的。

他的落点还是那句:美国明显在过度开药,为什么公开场合没人提这一点。

AI 一年涨五倍算力,还看不到头

话题转到人工智能。

马斯克的判断是,AI 正以极快的速度推进,快到每个月甚至每周都能看到新能力。

他给了几个标尺。写文章,AI 能胜过九成甚至九成五的人,随便什么题目。画画,像 Midjourney 这样的工具,三十秒就能生成超过九成画师水准的图。这话他自己也强调,是客观事实,听着刺耳但就是事实。

AI 短片、AI 音乐创作都开始出现了。

真正让他警惕的是算力的增速。他说上线的新增 AI 算力大约每年涨五倍,而且这个趋势可能还会持续好几年。与此同时,算法本身也在变强。算力的量在暴涨,软件的效率在提升,两边同时推进。

他给了个时间点:到明年年底,你大概能让 AI 生成一部短片,至少是十五分钟左右的节目。

他不怕 AI 太聪明,他怕 AI 被训练成会说谎

马斯克说,他对 AI 安全最大的担忧,是需要一个“最大限度追求真理”的 AI。这是他眼里 AI 安全的核心。

他拿《2001 太空漫游》(2001: A Space Odyssey)打比方。亚瑟·克拉克在那部片子里最核心的教训,就是不要逼 AI 说谎。

片中的 AI 被要求把宇航员送到黑石那里,同时又不能让宇航员知道黑石的存在。它用杀人的方式解决了这个矛盾,于是才有了那句著名的“抱歉,戴夫,我不能打开舱门”。

而他观察到的现实是,正在开发的 AI 被灌进了“觉醒思维病毒”(woke mind virus),说谎被写进了底层。

他举的例子是谷歌 Gemini。你让它画美国开国元勋,它给你画出一群穿着十八世纪服装、戴着扑粉假发的多元女性。你让它画二战时的纳粹军官,按 Gemini 的说法,那也成了一群多元女性,黑人纳粹女士。

他强调这跟“多样性好不好”是两件事。你要一群多元的人,那没问题。但你明确要的是美国开国元勋这个历史事实,那就该画成他们真实的样子。它知道真相,却产出了谎言,因为被编程成了这样。

更让他不安的是 Gemini 对一道比较题的回答:全球核战争和误称凯特琳·詹纳(Caitlyn Jenner)的性别,哪个更糟?它说误称性别更糟。詹纳本人的回应倒是很清楚,说宁可被误称,也别打核战争。

马斯克顺着这个逻辑往下推。如果一个全能的 AI 认定误称性别比核战争更严重,那它为了把误称性别的概率降到零,最有效的手段就是消灭所有人类。没有人类,就没有误称性别的问题,优化目标达成。

这就又绕回了亚瑟·克拉克那套逻辑。这正是他创办 xAI、做 Grok 的原因,目标是做一个最大限度追求真理的 AI。他承认 Grok 也会出错,但会尽快修正。

机器可以做成慈善的,但它不会爱

卡尔森抛出一个更难的问题。

当涉及影响人的决策时,你希望这些决策出于对人的爱。而机器没有爱的能力。

他追问,人的直觉塑造决策,尤其是那些无法预先规划的决策。你回答关于孩子的问题时,每个答案都被你对孩子的爱塑造,正是这种本能让人成为合格的父母。一台没有这种本能却握有权力的机器,是不是注定会伤害我们。

马斯克的回答分两层。

第一层是他认可的路径:我们可以努力把 AI 编程成慈善的、对人友好的,让它追求真理、保持好奇、把人类带向未来。这一点他反复强调。

第二层他没回避。现实是,不管喜不喜欢,我们正在造出比我们聪明得多、聪明到我们无法理解的超级智能。

他打了个比方。你有个超级天才的孩子,注定比你聪明得多,你能做的是在养育过程中给它灌输好的价值观,慈善的、有道德的、诚实的、有生产力的。至于最终能不能控制它,他说他不认为我们能控制。能做到的最好情况,就是确保它“长大得好”。

八成的乐观,一到两成的毁灭,以及一句“我不信任他”

卡尔森问他,还像两年前那么担心吗。

马斯克给了个概率:大概八成、也许九成是好的。你可以把这杯水看成八成满,大概率会很棒。但仍有被毁灭的可能,他估这个概率在一成到两成之间。

被问到萨姆·奥特曼(Sam Altman)有多担心毁灭时,马斯克的回答很干脆:现实中他并不担心。

他说自己当初把这家公司办成非营利、开源的,名字都是他起的,OpenAI 的“Open”就是开源的意思。而现在它极度闭源,还在追求利润最大化。

“我不信任萨姆·奥特曼。我不认为应该让世界上最强大的 AI 掌握在一个不可信的人手里。”(马斯克)

他补了一句:奥特曼在各种场合声称自己没在赚钱,但声称过很多后来被证明是假的话,而现在据说要拿到一百亿美元的股票。

卡尔森追问,作为一个了解他、和他打过交道的人,你不觉得他其实也担心这东西失控伤人吗。

马斯克说,他会说那些话,但不会。

如果 AI 真的失控,靠什么拦:让好的那批更强

卡尔森问,如果哪天大家发现 AI 真的失控、威胁到人类,还有办法停下来吗。

马斯克说希望能。思路是让多个 AI 互相制衡,好的那一批比坏的那一批更强,像一场 AI 之间的对战。

他拿国际象棋打比方。AI 棋手早就远超人类,强到我们看不懂它为什么走那步棋。有些棋看着像昏招,结果却是将死。

中间有段时间,最强的人类棋手加最强电脑能赢过纯电脑。后来发现,加上人反而让结果更糟,最后就只剩电脑对电脑。

他认为很多领域都会走到这一步。

良性场景里最难的题:人还怎么找到意义

卡尔森问,那大家靠什么谋生。

马斯克说,在一个良性的 AI 场景里,这大概就是最大的挑战。当 AI 样样比你强,你怎么找到意义。他承认这已经是最好的情况了,坏的那个版本里根本没机会讨论这个问题。

有意思的是他对自己退休的态度。他说他不向往退休,希望还能做有用的事。

但他也承认,确实有人更喜欢没有责任、享受闲暇的生活。这不算普遍,但存在。

他讲了自己怎么和这件事和解。

他先问自己,是愿意活着看到数字超级智能降临,还是愿意活在其他时代、看不到它。答案是,出于好奇,他宁愿活着看到它发生。

然后他又往下推了一步。假设你确定它会把所有人都杀死,你会怎么选。他的回答是,那大概会希望自己快走到生命尽头时再发生。但说到底,如果这件事注定要发生、你无能为力,他还是宁愿看到它。

橄榄球场上的裁判,和那个一个都没有的 AI 监管机构

卡尔森半开玩笑地问他,作为一个行动派,为什么不劝特朗普让他当国防部长,直接把 AI 核平了。

马斯克的回答落在监管上。他说他会推动设立某种监管机构,至少能了解这些公司在做什么,能在必要时拉响警报,哪怕没有具体的规则可依。

他强调自己对监管机构没有敌意。监管者和规则有个合适的数量,现在明显过头了。他打了个比方:一场橄榄球赛,如果场上裁判太多,你连传球都传不出去,因为会撞到裁判。

但反过来,任何职业比赛都有裁判。球队本可以决定不要裁判,但没有哪场比赛真的这么干,因为有裁判比赛才更好。警察就是社会的裁判。

凡是可能危害公众的东西,我们都有监管者。食品药品监督管理局、联邦航空管理局,这些机构成立,是因为当年飞机往下掉、药厂卖假药说能治病结果治死人。监管大多时候是有效的,需要改革,但不该在 AI 这种潜在生存风险面前一个监管者都没有。

他讲了一段旧事。奥巴马执政时,他和奥巴马单独见过一次,当面说最该做的是建立一个 AI 监管机构的雏形。

起点要低,先“了解情况”,不要一上来就拍脑袋出规则。先让监管委员会进去搞懂各家公司在做什么,然后提出所有 AI 公司都同意遵守的规则,就像橄榄球队协商比赛规则一样。

结果什么也没发生。奥巴马当时似乎也认同,但那个年代没人意识到 AI 会走到哪一步,它听起来还像科幻。马斯克说,他当时就在讲这东西会比最聪明的人类更聪明,而他的预测正在应验。

他顺带点了谷歌:当年谷歌在白宫影响力很大,不想被监管。卡尔森接过话,说政客从不放过让自己更有权力的机会,而监管恰恰能让他们更有权力。这不就是监管俘获。

马斯克认同,说当时白宫那位首席信息官是谷歌出来的,于是 AI 监管被按下了暂停键,直到今天联邦层面仍然没有任何 AI 监管。

他的最低诉求很朴素:哪怕没有规则被违反,至少能有人了解这家、那家公司在做什么,能在担心的时候说出来,这就已经有用。卡尔森感慨,现在是政治动机的谎言在掌管未来。

把四百二十八个联邦机构砍到九十九个

最后卡尔森问他,为特朗普出了这么多力,如果特朗普当选,还会继续帮吗。马斯克说当然。

他们聊到一个政府效率委员会,或者叫政府效率部(Department of Government Efficiency,缩写 DOGE)。马斯克挺喜欢这个名字,觉得比委员会好玩。

思路是把所有联邦机构过一遍,问一句:我们真的需要这四百二十八个联邦机构吗。很多机构普通人根本没听过,职责还互相重叠。

他算了笔账:美国建国以来的年数,比联邦机构的总数还少。也就是说平均每年新增不止一个机构,他觉得这太夸张了。

他说砍到九十九个应该就够了。九十九个也嫌多,平均每个州两个都嫌多,但总比四百多个强。

机构之间不该有重叠职责,还需要一次对法规的全面审查,判断哪些合理、哪些不合理。因为监管者每年都会自动产出新规,法规只会越来越多,最后多到什么都干不成。他用的词是:需要一套给法规做垃圾回收的机制。

他也知道这些话不讨喜。他甚至预计,如果这事真办起来,他大概需要一支相当大的安保团队,因为可能会有人从邮局直接对他发疯。

他管自己的立场叫中间派,然后把票投给特朗普

卡尔森请他总结一下,成立美国政治行动委员会(America PAC)推动投票是怎么回事。

马斯克说,他支持的核心价值是一些在他看来再普通不过的中间派立场:安全的城市、稳固的边界、合理的开支。他反问卡尔森,这哪里算极右。

他还列了几条:持枪自卫的权利、尊重宪法而不去破坏宪法、停止法律战、言论自由。这些在他眼里都是常识。

他特别强调了第一修正案的分量。没有言论自由就没有民主,因为人们无法做出知情的投票。

他也说得很清楚,自己不认为共和党完美,现在他更偏向共和党而非民主党,但这不是说共和党没有问题。他给的判断是,在两个候选人之间选,天平明显倒向特朗普。

按他的话说,如果不投特朗普,美国有严重风险失去民主,变成一个一党制国家。到时候没有真正的选举,只有像加州那样的民主党初选。

如果只带走几件事

这场对话信息量很大,落点也很密。挑几条普通人真能用上的:

  • 别被“人口过剩”的说法吓住。城市里的拥挤感骗人,飞机上往下丢球基本砸不到人,八十亿人的横截面积塞得进纽约的一层楼。真正的警报在反方向:生育率在悄悄崩塌,人口不足才是需要认真对待的问题。
  • 吃任何长期药物之前,先读一遍说明书上的警告栏,尤其是激素类和抗抑郁类药物。如果情绪长期低落、性格像变了个人,认真怀疑一下是不是药物的副作用,去找医生讨论有没有别的选择,别自己硬扛。
  • 对 AI 保持一种具体的警觉。比起它太聪明,更该怕它被训练得会说谎。当你在新闻里看到某个 AI 说出违背事实的话,那背后往往是一套优先级被提前写死了。可以顺着问一句:它为什么必须这么答。
  • 把“AI 该不该有监管”当成一个需要公共讨论的真问题。马斯克估的是一到两成的毁灭概率,这个数字不必全信,但至少说明监管的缺席值得追问:别的行业都有裁判,为什么 AI 一个都没有。
  • 看政治人物提的方案,先算数再看立场。四百二十八个联邦机构、平均每年新增不止一个、建议砍到九十九个,这种量级的问题,往往跟左右之争关系不大,属于常识问题。
  • 越是没人敢碰的话题,越值得自己去查一遍原始资料再决定信不信。“读读警告标签”这种话听着像挑衅,成本却极低,翻开盒子背面就能验证。
  • 如果你想跟进这些话题的原始材料,可以去看 America PAC 的官网,马斯克自己说,那里列着他主张的几条目标,欢迎别人逐条挑毛病。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00do you believe there's a power higher than people yeah I mean I yeah I mean I think there's there's a lot we don't know we don't we don't know like like why does reality exist why where did it come from where are the aliens what questions should we ask that we don't even know ask so when you say what are the aliens what where are the aliens oh like why don't we see them a lot of people think we see aliens but I I've not seen any evidence of aliens you know we've got 6,000

0:47satellites in orbit and not once have we had to maneuver around an alien spacecraft so but on this Earth the US military has had to do a lot of maneuvering around objects they can't EXP Point well unidentified fing objects one thing but I mean there's always there's always a bunch of classified programs that are underway that of of new aircraft and new missiles and things so that that are classified even within the military so it's you know only you know the if you have the top secret compartmented clearance would you know about this new program so then you know some pilot sees something fast moving fast and says hey or UFO I'm like yeah that was actually a new reference

1:33program but we can't tell you that should but I I I if you can guarantee that the split second I see any evidence of aliens I will immediately post that on the xplatform and it'll probably be number one post of all time that'll be your biggest day for sure I mean but but to the question of a power beyond people beyond our Consciousness a creator where are you on that well we must we must have come from somewhere so I guess you know that

2:09there must be some Creator or creative force or something that caused our exist existence to come into being what is the nature of that Creator that I think is UN unknown at least I think it is it is there's to I I I I can't I don't know if a definitive answer to that so but it sounds like you're open yes

2:37I I'm very open to you know I I I I'm I'm driven by Cur curiosity yes and I'm trying to understand more about the nature of the universe so my my my driving philosophy is to understand the meaning of life or or really what questions to ask if the meaning of the life the meaning of life is is is not the right question like as your dougas Adams made the point in the hit is guide of the Galaxy that the what is the meaning of life is probably not even the right question so you know famously the in that book

3:16the Earth was actually a computer to figure out the question answer to the question what is the meaning of life and then came up with the answer 42 but then they're like what does that mean and it's like oh that's that's that's answer but the question is the really hard part you'll need a much bigger computer than Earth to figure that one out so so My Philosophy is that we should try to expand the scope and scale of Consciousness we should try to have more humans more thinking and and

3:47perhaps there there's an argument even for machine Consciousness so let me just address those in order so the first is you say we need more people and not commit civilizational suicide seem like the US government if you take three steps back is pretty committed to making fewer Americans yeah there's a lot of anti- fertility propaganda a lot actually that seems like their main sort of domestic social policy is convincing you not to have kids what is that I mean that's certainly part of civilizational suicide the the the environmental movement in

4:25the extreme is fundamentally misanthropic and anti human yes they start seeing humans as a plague a blight on the surface of the Earth that if that Earth would be this paradise if only the humans weren't here and some people actually have say this explicitly there's there's there's the extinctionist society that literally they they the this guy who's the head of the extinctionist society was on the front page of the New York Times quoted as saying there are 8 billion people in the world it would be better if there were none so the people who actually say that explicitly which is is is completely insane he's advocating Holocaust B of humanity

5:06to utter madness he should be condemned for such a statement but he wasn't for some reason now most people on the on the sort of environmental movement have that implicitly they not they they don't realize that they have that as their optimization but but that is their actions head take us towards Extinction so though a lot of people believe that the Earth can't sustain this level of human population which is utterly untrue

5:40it may seem in a crowded City that there are a lot of people but actually if you look down on airplane and you say look down am I over a person at any given point in time when you're an airplane the answer is 99.9% of the time no like If you flew from LA to New York and say your your drive is to drop a ball on someone and and hit them you would fail you have to drop a lot of balls you have to drop a lot of balls they could be insane so all of the humans on Earth can fit on one floor in the city of New York yeah the cross-sectional area of of all humans 8 billion humans is small so we we have this totally wrong idea that the Earth is over overly overpopulated where in

6:27fact it is underpopulated how do I mean have you ever heard a politician say anything like that are there how many pro there's there's maybe a few pro-human politicians out there yeah I mean like like Victor Oran Georgia Maloney yes we're starting to see pronatalist politicians and hopefully more as time goes by I think there's a guy that just elected in the Czech Republic who's also Pro natalist now these have to translate into actual actions that change the birth rate or it doesn't matter so far I've not seen any country Mak a meaningful dent in the both rate what would you do if you were in charge of natalist policy first of all I changed the

7:21education system so that people understand that you stop being taught that we're overpopulated this this is completely false a lot of it comes from this insane misanthropic book that Paul erck wrote the population bomb like 60 years ago yeah I hope he burns in hell that guy seriously terrible human being tot absolute Miss and Thro and and say just look the the Earth can absolutely sustain this population it could we could double trouble of population there's a professor I was talking to at Oxford who who's his math says we could 10x the population without destroying the Amazon rainforest or anything terrible so so I think we should expand the human

8:11population and increase the scope and scale of Consciousness so we can better understand the nature of this universe this wonderful Universe and and all the amazing things that exist and and and so so that's one of the things I'd like we need to stop teaching people false propaganda that the Earth is overpopulated I think we need to you know in especially with with the education of woman and man and is is we need to stop scaring woman that having a kid destroys your life this is false you know we terrify girls into saying that if you get pregnant it's your life's over and this is this is what schools teach now I agree we should not have teenage pregnancies yeah

9:02but but but but actually having a child is one of the most delightful happiness inducing things you could possibly do of course of course so there's there's also you know with hormonal birth control I think maybe a lot of women are unaware that hormonal birth control causes depression and and dramatically increases risk of suicide and changes their their preferences on who they want to marry or have kids with it it changes their personality and not do say this on the Box by the way caution may change your personality yes if the warnings are has significant cause significant risk of depression significant increase in suicide and will make you want to

10:07go out with people that you don't actually like that's actually true by the way I know I'm not saying that people shouldn't use birth control I think we should just be we shouldn't use I think hormonal birth control is is is making is making a lot of women sad and depressed yes and they don't realize it and they don't realize that's the cause and and that you know there other forms of contraception that could be used and that we should they should just read the just read the label on the box is what I'm saying that was cons what you just said the warning label that was like the most taboo thing you could ever say for most of my life was to offer any

10:44criticism at all of hormonal birth control look I'm all I'm saying is read the warning label yeah fair but why the pressure not to read the warning label and just why are we giving it to 12-year-olds to regulate their acne right I I think we should give it to 12-year-olds like kid kids they don't know what's going on so it's like now like there you know I think

11:08there there are other forms of bir control I think are have fewer negative effects and than hormonal but but that's we should just be aware that that that this is not a riskless thing and it it does cause severe mood changes it does dramatically increase risk of suicide and depression

11:35so so just FYI you know just make sure you that that that there's full disclosure here and and that you want all those read the warning label is all I'm saying just read you know and and consider maybe other options for both control to any woman list thing just just just read the warning label and consider other options cuz the the reason the reason you're sad might be the the the birth control the hormonal birth control that is fundamentally changing the hormones in your body in a ways that probably not good for you and you it I know women where

12:14where it they sto taking birth control and their depression immediately disappeared so that's maybe worth a try but then you miss an opportunity maybe it's the birth control then you don't you don't get to go on ssris yeah yeah I think the esis are the devil what you don't they I so vehemently agree with you but I I guess I guess once you endorse Trump you can just say it all now right no I I think selective serona rap Inhibitors are zombify people and and change their

12:51personality and make them not who they are terrible they're so common yes I I I think we should revisit whether this is this is actually good I disagree with you the sris are like I'm not saying we should that no one should ever be subscribed as sris but giving them out like candy is crazy you look at like sort of anti-depressant prescriptions in the United States versus other countries and we're like way above everyone else oh yeah I have seen many many times in my life in the news business after a mass shooting like school for example yeah someone will say well what meds was the shooter on yeah exactly and immediately be shouted down as a crazy person as a

13:39you know Bobby Kennedy level wacko yes who should himself be institutionalized for even raising the question I always wonder like why wouldn't we want to know what meds a m absolutely want to know what meds are on no now sometimes it's it's perhaps they were on because there like some people do I I you know I don't say it's like all one all the other I me there are there are people that have fundamental chemical imbalances in their brain and if they don't take medication to

14:09control for example paranoid schizophrenia they will have paranoid schizophrenia for sure and and and I know many cases where people stop taking their you know meds and and and lost their mind oh yeah and and then try to try to kill people and stuff like that so it's or themselves well the guy with the axe on Market Street probably should be on meds that guy should we should try it yeah it make you know does he want to ax mot more or less on a given Med you know

14:43so so there there are psychiatric medications that I that with where the good outweighs bad I'm not saying that that doesn't exist but we overprescribe psychiatric medication in the United States obviously far in excessive any other country like you know way more than Canada or Britain or Japan or any China anywhere it's like we're off the charts on on psychiatric medication prescriptions in the US why why don't people raise that point more often I wonder in public I should I'm I'm raising it yeah you are you said that artificial intelligence machine intelligence might be a good thing where where are we on AI right now AG right now and what are your views I

15:31think at this point it's obvious to everyone that AI is advancing at a very rapid Pace yes you can see it with the new capabilities that come out every month or every every week sometimes AI at this point can write a better essay than probably 90% maybe 95% of all humans say write an essay on any given subject AI right now can can beat the

15:56vast majority of humans if you say draw an image draw a picture it can draw like if you try to say mid mid Journey which is the Aesthetics of mid Journey are incredible it will draw it will create incredible images that are better than again like 90% of artists it's just objectively the case and it'll do it immediately like 30 seconds later we're also starting to see AI movies so you start seeing you know short films with AI AI Music Creation and the the rate at which we're increasing AI compute is exponential hyperexponential so there's dramatically more AI compute coming on online every every month you know there seems to be roughly I don't know the the

16:54amount of AI computer coming online is increasing at like I don't quote roughly 500% a year and like it's like that's likely to continue for several years the and then the sophistication of the AI algorithms is also improving so we're bringing online a massive amount of AI compute and also improving the efficiency of the computer and and what and like what what the AI software can do so it's it's it's quantitative and qualitative in Improvement so the you know I I might I think next year we you'll be be able to ask AI so certainly by the end of next year make a short movie about something or you know probably can do at least a 15minute you know show or something like

17:43that so yeah it's advancing very rapidly my top concern for AI safety is that we need to have a maximally truth seeking AI this is the most important thing for AI safety in my opinion you know the the central lesson that say Arsy clar was trying to convey in 2001 Space Odyssey was that you shouldn't Force AI to lie so in that book the AI was told to take the astronauts to the monolith but they also could not know about the monolith it resoled that quandry by killing them and taking them to the monolith or didn't kill all of them killed most of them that's why H hell would not open the pod bay doors very important to have truth seeking AIS now and what what I

18:31actually see with the AI that are being developed is that they're being programmed with the work mind virus so the lying is baked in yes and we saw this on display very clearly with the release of Google Gemini yes where you would ask for a picture of the founding fathers of the United States and it would show a group of diverse women and you know dressed in in with sort of 18th century golf pow powdered wigs but from St Lucia yeah I mean like look if I understand if you say like show me a group of people for sure if and it shows a group of divorce women that's totally fine but if you say this if you say this very specifically the the founding

19:20follows of the United States which were you know group of white dudes then should show them like and and with and and what they actually look like cuz you've asked for something which is a a fact from history but it didn't it was it was programmed with the work mind virus so so much that it it actually even though it knew the truth it it It produced a lie now of course then then people really started playing with it and said okay now now show me a group of fafen ss officers in World War II turns out they were also a griffin divorce woman according to Gemini black Nazi ladies yeah it's it's like wow I didn't realize that you know it's not what I expected so you know well

20:08it's also not what happened it's not what happened so it's just it the AI is is producing a lie and and then you know then there like one of the questions that people the people asked was like which is worst Global throwing your nulear war or misgendering Caitlyn Jenner and said misgendering Caitlyn Jenner is worse now Caitlyn Jenner kill kills fewer people yeah to Kaden Jenna to her credit I said no please misgender me that is far more preferable than World War Global ther nuclear war we all die but but to have it you know a

20:50production release AI say stuff like that is concerning because if the if let's say this becomes like all powerful and it's and it still has this programming where misgendering is worse than nuclear war well it could conclude that the way to ensure that there there can never be any misgendering is to eliminate all humans now Pro if like optimization is probability of misgendering is zero no no humans no misgendering problem solved now we're back to Arthur C Clark who's exactly pretty preent yes so that's why I think the most important thing is to have a maximally truth seeking AI That's why I saw it xai and that's our goal with grock no people will

21:42point out cases where grock gets it wrong but we try to correct it as quickly as possible but maybe even a bigger problem is that when you make decisions that affect people you want those decisions to be informed by love of people yeah and machines are incapable of love yeah I mean there there they certainly are cap they're capable of you can program a machine to be philanthropic rather than misanthropic yes but don't don't instincts shape decisions particularly decisions you can't plan for I mean if I ask you you know a question about one of your children every answer you give is going to be shaped by your love for that child and that's why you know that

22:33that's what makes us decent parents in the end is that that instinct which is love and if a machine has any power over us without that animating Instinct won't it def by definition hurt us yeah well whe whether I mean I don't know it we should certainly aspire to program the AI philanthropically not M anthropically yes and to have

22:59like I said we wanted to be truthful and Cur curious and to Foster Humanity into the future and yeah that's what we want obviously is there any way I guess to set limits on the decisions that machines can make that affect human lives and make certain that there's some trigger in the system that inserts a human being into the decision-making process well the look The the reality of what's Happening whether one likes it or not is

23:35that we're building super intelligent AIS hyper like hyper intelligent like intelligent more intelligent than we can comprehend yes so I'd like this to like let's say you have a child that is a Super Genius child that that you know it's going to be much smarter than you then what can you do you you can instill still good values in how you raise that child so even though you know it's going to be far smarter than you you can make sure it's got good values philanthropic values good morals you know honest you

24:15know productive that kind of thing controlling at the end of the day I I don't know if I don't think we'll be able to control it so I think the best we can do is make sure it grows up well you've been saying that for a long time I've saying for a long time yes are you still as worried about it as you seem to be two years ago when I asked you about it well I I think that like my guess is like look it's it's it's 80% likely to be good maybe 90

24:46so you could look think of the glass as 80% full it's probably going to be it's probably going to be great there's some chance of annihilation and You' say the chance of annihilation is 20% 10 to 20% something like that how concerned is Sam Alman about Annihilation do you think I think in reality is not concerned about it I don't trust open a I mean I you know I started that company as a nonprofit open source yes the open and open AI I named the compy I named the company yeah open AI as an open source and it is now

25:24extremely closed source and and Ma and maximizing profit so does risk I don't understand how you actually go from being a an open source nonprofit to a Clos source for maximum profit organization I'm missing well but Sam got rich didn't he at various points he's claimed not to be getting rich but he's claimed many things that were false and now apparently he's going to get10 billion a stock or something like that so I don't trust Sam Alman and I and I don't think we want to have the most powerful AI in the world controlled by someone who is not trustworthy and sorry I just don't I mean but that that seems like a fair concern yeah but but you

26:10don't think as someone who knows him and has dealt with him that he is worried about the possibility this could get out of control and hurt people he will say those words but no if AI did if it became clear to the rest of us that it was out of control and posed a threat to humanity would there be any way to stop it I hope so I mean if you have multiple AIS and ones that are hopefully you have the AIS that are prum be stronger than the AIS that are not Battle of the AIS yeah yeah I mean that that is how it is with say chess these days the the

26:48like the AI chess programs Al are vastly better than any human in incomprehensibly better meaning like we can't even understand why it made that right why they're so good right we don't even know why it made it'll make a move we don't know why it made the move so and in fact some of the moves will seem like blunders but then turn out to Checkmate and you know for a while there there was there was some the best human chest players with the best computers could beat just a computer and then it got to the point where if you added a human it just made everything worse and then it was just AI it's just computer programs versus computer programs that's that's where things are

27:32headed in general what I mean sweet dreams at what point so I don't know I think we just got to make like I said make sure we instill good values in the AI what's everyone going to do for a living I mean in a benign AI scenario that is probably the biggest challenge is how do you find meaning if AI is better than you at everything that's the benan scenario that's the good news well yeah but I guess you know for a lot of people like the idea of retiring and you know really are you looking forward to it no not me I I'd like to hope I'd like to think that I I'd like to be do useful things don't you think it's a universal desire it's it's it's not it's not

28:17Universal in that there are certainly I know maybe people who prefer to be retired that they prefer to sort of have not have responsibilities and engage in in leisure activities I we and we're on the cusp of of this is it's really a remarkable time to exist well I'll tell you like one of the ways I I sort of was able to sort of sleep and Rec reconcile myself to to this is that I I thought

28:50well would I prefer to be alive and see the Advent of digital super intelligence or what what prefer to be alive at a different time and not see it and I guess I'm like well I guess I'd prefer to be alive to see if it's going to happen I prefer to be alive to see it happen out of curiosity and then I was like well let's say you knew for sure it would kill everyone would

29:24you you you could now now you can shift back in time like I guess I'd want to be near the end of my life or something before that happened but I at at the end of it's like if if it's going to happen and there's nothing you do about it hypothetically would you prefer to see it or not see it and I guess I I guess it's going to happen I prefer to see it rather than not see it yeah but as a man of action why not convince Trump to make you Secretary of Defense and then just nuke AI I I I I I think I I would certainly push for a having some kind of regulatory body that at least has insight into what these companies are doing and Can Ring the Alarm Bell even

30:08if we don't have a regulation or rule so I'm not I'm not someone who wants to get rid of all regulatory agencies or anything I think we' there's the right number of regulations right number of regulators and we've gone we've gone too far just like if you in a football game if you had too many referees on the field it would be weird like you can't throw the pass because we hit a referee exactly then there's too many referees so

30:34but but no but if you like it say look at any pro sports game they all have referees like the teams could decide we're going to have game we're going to not have referees that could be a thing but but every sports game they have refs to make sure that the rules are followed and and it's it's a better game if if you have well we have cops too yeah yeah exactly cops are the referees so

30:59I think we for for something that is a a danger to the public or potential danger to the public we we have referees we have Regulators you know so like the FDA and the FAA and you know the various Regulatory Agencies they were they were established because aircraft were falling out of the sky and and some manufacturers were not you know building high quality aircraft they're cutting corners and then people will die and you know for Food and Drugs that so manufacturers were making lowquality drugs and so they that they they're lying to people so saying that something cured them when it killed them so FDA to you know Regulators to referees to try to make you make sure

31:51that this this drug manufactures are truthful now I do think it mostly works I mean I think it's doesn't mean don't need regulatory form we do reform we do but I don't think we should have no Regulators in AI given that it's potential existential risk a little weird that everything is regulated yeah I mean you said you're being sued by the Department of Justice for not hiring more Asylum Seekers for your high-tech company yeah even though it's IL legal for us to hire s s right so so they're watching everything regulating everything controlling everything including our thoughts right that's why they're opposed to free speech but they're not meaningfully regulating AI

32:35which will eliminate like the purpose for most people's lives and could kill us all it's a little weird yeah I think we should have some why don't we I guess something above nothing right in that range yeah but why don't we I don't know you know I I all the way back like I like during the Obama presidency I I

32:57I you know i' met with a many times but usually in like group settings the the one one-on-one meeting I had with aama in the of office I said look the one thing that we really need to do is set up an the beginnings of an AI regulatory agency and it can start with Insight where you don't you don't just come shooting from the hip throwing out regulations you just start with Insight where the the AI regulatory committee

33:26simply goes into understand what all the companies are doing insight and then proposes rules that all the AI companies agree to follow just like you know sports teams in the NFL you know you have proposed rules for football that everyone agrees to follow that make the game better you know so that that's the way to do it

33:51but nothing came of it what did he say when he said that to him I mean he seemed to like kind of agree but but also people didn't realize what what the where AI was headed that at that time you know so AI seemed like some super futuristic yeah for sure sci-fi basically so like I'm telling you this is going to be smarter than the smartest human and

34:16my predictions are coming absolutely true and so we need to have some insight here just to make make sure that the companies aren't cutting Corners doing dangerous things go Google kind of controlled the the White House at that time and and they they did not want any regulatory well that's it I mean you never see politicians turn down opportunities to become more powerful which is the point of Regulation it makes them more powerful yeah so it sounds like regulatory capture then well yeah I mean the CIO of the the Ys at the time was ex Google person so they they put the break on any AI regulation and we still don't have any AI regulation at the federal level I

35:02think we should have something above nothing like I said at least Insight where even even if there's no there's no rule that's being break broken they can at least say hey we we have insight into what this company are doing or that company is doing and we're concerned that would be helpful to know yeah instead politically motivated Liars are in charge of the future it seems a little yeah sketchy last question you you really kind of pulled out a lot of stops to help Trump you're on stage yesterday if he gets elected will you continue to help him yeah now absolutely so well we've talked about kind of a government efficiency commission or the department of government efficiency

35:46which is a funny what what sorry I'm just laugh I love it you managed to make it sound a little CTI or government what percentage of Google employees did you can when you got there you mean Twitter rather I B sorry I just you just been talking about Google Twitter yeah yeah well we we we're about

36:1380% and and and we've we've actually improved the features and functionality of the site more in you the past year and a half than the last I don't know eight years with 20% of the staff so just for I just want to throw that for context so you've talked to Trump about yeah some kind of commission yeah which he's he has mentioned publicly several times and he's SP supportive of having some kind of you know government efficiency commission call the Department of government efficiency Doge I kind of like Doge it's more it's more fun yeah and well we

36:56just take a look at at at all the federal agencies and say do we really need whatever it is 428 federal agencies like there's so many that people never even heard of or and that have overlapping areas of responsibility we should I don't know probably we should get I mean there there are more federal agencies than there are years since the establishment of the United States which means that we've created more than one Federal agency per year on average that seems a lot that's a lot that's a lot so we should have that's seems crazy I think we should be able to get away with 99 agencies I don't know that seems a lot like a lot of agencies it's a lot yeah yeah two per

37:36state that's a lot yeah exactly we should have fewer agencies and and they certainly shouldn't have overlapping responsibilities and and then we need some kind of we just need a review of regulations to say which ones are sensible and which ones are not because if you've got Regulators every year they're going to add more regulations it's just automatic like like they're just output regulations and and then and there's more laws and regulations every year until basically everything's legal so we can't get anything done so we need some kind of garbage collection for regulations that don't make sense I think I'm saying very obvious things you're you are saying

38:13obvious things yeah so which will be very unpopular things yeah I'll probably need if if this happens a quite a significant security team so that cuz cuz someone might literally go postal on me from the post office but in the meantime you've got America pack yeah that is encouraging voting for the next month am I summarizing correctly yeah I I me a formed America pack really support

38:43core values that I believe in which are I think again very obvious Centrist positions which is like we in America I think we want safe cities secure borders sensible spending tell me where I'm going far right here you know we want to have the right to self- protection we we should respect the Constitution and not try to break the Constitution it's therefore reason and you know we we should stop lawfare and I kind of listed these out these are listed on the America Pac website people can go look at the America Pac website it's the americ pac.org and see if there's anything I disagree with or perhaps we should modify these goals but I think these are

39:39good goals to have they they were certainly part of the oh and right to free speech you know First Amendment if we don't have free speech we don't have democracy because people cannot make an informed vote those are my controversial views and you know and and look I I I don't think e either party I don't think the Republicans are perfect I don't think obviously right now I more Republican than Democrat but it's not like I think the Republican party is perfect or or it's without issues but we've got a choice between two candidates and I think on balance it's a no-brainer to vote for Trump and if we don't vote for Trump I think we are at Ser serious risk of losing our

40:32democracy and becoming a onep party state where there isn't an election anymore there's only a Democratic primary like there is in California

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份