2008年11月,通用、福特、克莱斯勒的三位CEO坐着各自的私人飞机飞到华盛顿,在国会听证会上请求250亿美元紧急贷款。有议员问他们为什么不坐商业航班来,他们答不上来。
同一周,旧金山,Web 2.0峰会。台上坐着埃隆·马斯克(Elon Musk),37岁,特斯拉(Tesla Motors)董事长,一个月前刚接下CEO的头衔。
他在介绍一辆车。售价10.9万美元,年产1200辆,零个气缸。
主持人John Battelle把这组对比摆得很直接:底特律的人前一天还在南希·佩洛西的办公室里,端着要饭的杯子,那杯子特别大,因为25亿已经花完了,他们要的是另外25亿,好撑到明年再拿25亿。
这个对照在2008年11月格外刺眼。一个百年行业集体断粮,一家六岁的创业公司在卖10万美元的跑车,价格还被人嫌不够贵。
五十多分钟的对话里,最值得读的部分不是跑车的加速数据,是马斯克怎么解释他为什么造车、为什么造火箭,以及为什么在全行业最坏的时机选择不拿那笔钱。
一辆没有气缸的车,和一堆没人相信的前提
先说车本身。
Tesla Roadster,标价10.9万美元。主持人提醒他,明年有税收抵免,能降到10万左右。马斯克纠正:是"10万出头",还是六位数。
产量每年1200到1500辆。主持人问,这个量能赚钱吗。马斯克说,绝对能。
参数摊开:没有气缸。0到60英里加速3.9秒,明年升级电池包后能压到3.6到3.7秒。能效折算成"每加仑英里数"(MPGe)约130,是普锐斯的两倍。除了法拉利Enzo,它比所有法拉利都快。
这个130 MPGe的算法值得停一下,因为它常被误读。
算法是这样的:一加仑石油,提炼成汽油,运到加油站,加进车里,能跑多少英里。换一条路径,同样一加仑石油拿去发电,扣除输电损耗,充进电池,能跑多少英里。两个数字相除,得到等效值。
所以130不是一个"电动车自己跟自己的比较",是把油井到车轮(well-to-wheel)的整条链路都算进去之后的结果。这是2008年,电动车还被视为高尔夫球车同类的年代。
续航接近250英里,高速和城市综合路况,空调开着。充电器集成在车里,插任何插座都能充,功率和吹风机差不多。
Battelle的接话很妙:一台带轮子和座椅的笔记本电脑。它有导航。
"那我就上车了。"
十万美金的富人玩具,是通往大众市场的必经台阶
Battelle替在场所有人问出了那个尖锐的问题:这车只有极少数人买得起,明显改变不了气候,几个富人开上节能车,又能怎样。
马斯克的回答是整场对话里最系统的一段。他说,特斯拉存在的意义就是走到大众市场电动车,但要去那里,必须从某个地方出发。
他给了三个类比。
手机。笔记本电脑。还有更贴切的一个:早期内燃机汽车。
汽油车刚出现的时候,被当成富人的玩具,因为其他人还在骑马。任何新技术的成本曲线都是这样,第一阶段是让技术跑通,第二阶段才是把成本压下来。顺序不能反。
于是特斯拉的产品路线是倒着走的。
第一步,Roadster,10万美元级,年产千余辆,验证电池、电机、整车集成能不能成立。
第二步,Model S。五座豪华运动轿车,价格是Roadster的一半,明年一季度发布,年产量1.5万到2万辆,是Roadster的十倍以上。
第三步,3万美元以下的车,年产量几十万辆。
这条路后来被几乎所有新造车公司复制,但在2008年它很不主流。当时的行业常识是从低端切入,用便宜车走量摊薄成本。
马斯克反过来的理由不难推:电池贵,短期内降不下来,那就先卖给对价格不敏感、又愿意为"更快"付钱的人。跑车用户本来就在为性能付溢价,他们对早期产品的粗糙容忍度最高。
这条路的问题也明显:十年才能走到第三步,中间任何一次融资断档都会前功尽弃。2008年11月,他正好撞上了这个断档。
市场崩盘那周,他把融资目标砍掉了六成
Battelle问他,为什么要融更多钱,为什么要推迟Model S。
马斯克的回答从一组数据开始:上一次有主流汽车创业公司成功,是1941年的Jeep。中间六十多年,没有第二家。
原本的计划是融1亿美元,全力推进Model S开发。他打了个比方:汽车开发的成本曲线像一座山,前面是很长的缓坡,等到了买工厂设备那一段,几百亿美元会一次性砸下去。他本来打算在市场崩盘前翻过那道坡。
然后市场崩了。
Battelle追问:你其实融得到钱,只是不想按那个价格融,对吧。
马斯克承认。条款太差,各种棘轮条款堆在一起,"基本上等于放弃公司控制权"。
Battelle半开玩笑:你创办特斯拉之前赚了不少,是不是照镜子给自己写了张支票。
马斯克:我确实这么做过。人的容忍度总有个界限。
最后的结果是从现有投资人那里拿到4000万美元的承诺,马斯克自己出大约一半。这笔钱够Roadster业务和动力总成供应业务正常运转。
顺便说一句动力总成业务。特斯拉当时已经在给别的车厂供应电池包和电机系统,这块是赚钱的,它后来成了撑到Model S量产的关键现金流。
主持人还问了一个定价问题:既然有人愿意排队,为什么不直接标20万美元。
马斯克的回答是关于参照系:特斯拉想对标的是保时捷911 Turbo(约12.5万美元)和911 S(9万多美元)这个区间,不是超级跑车。定价要让人觉得"跟普通跑车差不多",而不是"贵得离谱"。
这个回答里藏着一条产品逻辑:价格不只是收入工具,还是心智定位工具。定到20万,Roadster就变成收藏品,它就失去了为Model S铺路的功能。
裁员的标准,最低及格线是优秀
Battelle问裁员是怎么做的,用了"特种部队"这个词。
马斯克分两部分讲。
第一部分是Model S团队。原来一大组人在做,钱不够了,缩到公司总人数的10%左右。
第二部分是全公司。他把所有岗位重新审了一遍,标准是他在创业公司一贯的那条线。
最低及格线是优秀。(马斯克)
他特意补了一句:按这个标准被裁的人,不能算差。这是特种部队和常规军的区别。
这段话在2008年11月的语境里分量很重。同一场峰会上,红杉资本那份"好日子结束了"的备忘录被反复提起,所有人都在讨论怎么在削减成本的同时保住前进能力。马斯克给的答案是把标准往上调,不是往下调。
他的理由也很直接:一家创业公司要想穿过真正恶劣的环境、最终长成有规模的公司,组织里的人才密度和投入度必须维持在很高水平。标准一旦松,后面所有事都会跟着松。
底特律的病,他只肯说两句
Battelle问了一个很大的问题:汽车行业怎么走到今天这步,底特律到底发生了什么。
马斯克说自己也没有好答案。他给了三条,说得很克制。
组织劳工的问题。管理层的问题。管理层还想按1955年的方式经营一家2008年的公司,"太多乡村俱乐部会员资格",注意力放错了地方。
然后话题转到通用的Volt。Battelle说通用的Volt项目搞了至少五年,为什么特斯拉几年就把整车和传动做出来了。
马斯克说Volt其实挺新,而且Volt是受特斯拉启发的,通用副董事长Bob Lutz公开承认过。
这句话后面跟着一个数字。Battelle说:通用汽车现在的市值是28亿美元,比汉堡王还低。
马斯克补了一句:汉堡王的市值也被砸得很惨。
这场对话里最锋利的时刻就在这里。一个刚裁完员、刚推迟产品、靠创始人自己掏钱续命的创业公司CEO,在评论一家百年车企的估值,态度还挺客气。
十六年后再看这一段,那个"受特斯拉启发"的说法被验证了。2010年之后,几乎每家主流车厂都上了电动车项目。马斯克当年希望看到的事,确实发生了,只是比他预想的慢很多。
他图什么
Battelle问了一个更根本的问题:你做这些到底为了什么。
马斯克的回答很像他后来一贯的说法,但在2008年听,还没那么像模板。
我想买的东西都买得起。我也不喜欢游艇。我的兴趣在环境,在国家安全,再往长了看,在整个经济结构。你手上是一种不可再生的燃料,那就最好找到一个可再生的替代,否则经济早晚会塌。(马斯克)
他把动因拆成三层。环境是一层,国家安全是一层,还有一个更长的经济考量:整个体系建立在一种会耗尽、而且主要靠进口的燃料上,这不是一个能长期成立的安排。
他还讲了对特斯拉的另一层期待,这层期待比卖车重要得多。
当时行业里有两个被广泛接受的前提。第一,电动车技术做不成。第二,就算做成了,也没人愿意买。
特斯拉要做的事,是把这两个前提证伪。只要有一家公司把车造出来、卖出去、有人在路上开,这两个前提就站不住了,大车厂就得重新算一遍账。
这不是在抢市场份额,这是在改写对手的假设。两件事的难度差一个数量级,杠杆也差一个数量级。后来的事实是,这条路走通了。
太阳能:一门在衰退里更好卖的生意
Battelle让马斯克给SolarCity做个电梯陈述,马斯克先做了一段免责声明。
他说自己的时间大致平均分给特斯拉和SpaceX,SolarCity几乎不花时间,功劳全是团队的,"他们让我惊叹"。
SolarCity的价值主张是:住宅和小企业层面效率最高的太阳能系统供应商,领先幅度很大。另有一个独特的融资产品,零首付签约,装完之后电费反而下降。
马斯克的原话是,这种事怎么拒绝得了。
更反常识的一句在后面:他预计SolarCity的销售会在衰退中加速,因为省钱的生意在衰退里更好卖。刚完成的一轮融资规模是一年前的三倍,2009年业务预计至少翻一番。
Battelle顺势开玩笑:要是把SolarCity和特斯拉合并,那1亿美元不就融到了。
这个玩笑其实点到了一个真问题。2008年底,一家做高端电动车的公司在资本市场上几乎融不到钱,一家做屋顶太阳能、主打"帮你省钱"的公司在同一时间拿到了三倍于去年的融资。差别不在技术难度,在商业模型离现金有多近。
大学时列的三件事,他做了两件半
Battelle问他为什么选太空。
马斯克说,大学时他想过哪些事最能改变人类的未来,最后剩下三件:互联网、向可持续能源经济转型、太空探索,特别是把生命扩展到多个行星。
他当时的判断是:第三件几乎肯定轮不到自己,第二件也悬,第一件相对可行,因为互联网创业需要的启动资金很少。
于是他先做互联网。1995年创业,Zip2,后来是X.com,也就是PayPal的前身。卖掉公司拿到的钱,投进了清洁能源和太空。
1995年那会儿的硅谷是什么样,他讲得很具体。风险投资人听到"互联网"这个词的反应是往后退,大部分人自己都不用。就算互联网普及了,也没人相信能赚到钱。直到网景上市,大家的心智才变:哪怕互联网公司赚不到钱,至少有大傻子愿意在公开市场接盘。
马斯克当时的打算很朴素:希望能赚够付房租和买饭的钱,不然就得去斯坦福读研究生。
Battelle插了一句:斯坦福的研究生院好像是很多事的发射台。马斯克回:现在有点老套了。
Battelle接着问了一个他问过兰斯·阿姆斯特朗的问题:这里面有多少是自我。
马斯克说,大概有一部分吧。
然后他讲了那套关于太空的理由,分成防御性和进攻性两套。
防御性的:生命有可能在地球上终结,应该给生物圈做个备份。
就像你备份硬盘一样,也许你该备份生命。(马斯克)
进攻性的那套才是他真正兴奋的部分:一个永远困在地球的生命,和一个扩散到多个行星的生命,是两种完全不同量级的未来。范围、规模、丰富度,都差得很远。
他说防御性的论点成立,但真正驱动他的是正面那一套。
第四次发射才进轨道,因为招不到首席设计师
SpaceX在2008年9月完成了猎鹰1号的第四次发射,第一次成功入轨。前三次全失败。
马斯克讲起这件事的时候很平。公司六年前从零开始,他没造过任何硬件,物理背景,从小在工程氛围浓的家庭长大,"算是工程师"。
创办SpaceX时他不懂火箭工程。本来想招一个首席设计师,没招到。
如果当时能招到人,我们大概会更早入轨。(马斯克)
这句话是整场对话里最像马斯克的一句。它把一个通常被讲成英雄叙事的故事,还原成了一次招聘失败之后的被动自学。
Battelle的反应是"我有点说不出话"。他接着问:你进轨道有多难。马斯克说,说难也难,说不难也不难,反正我们试了四次。
Battelle还问了一个更实际的问题:怎么通过一家私营公司把人类送上太空。
马斯克说,SpaceX的客户既有商业卫星公司,也有政府客户。商业公司在太空这件事上能做的事,比大多数人想的多。
这里值得补一句背景。2008年12月,也就是这场对话之后一个月,NASA给了SpaceX一份16亿美元的国际空间站补给合同。那笔钱基本决定了这家公司能活下来。马斯克在台上没提这件事,因为当时还没签。
换电和充电不是二选一
Battelle提到了Shai Agassi和Better Place。那个模式是把电池从车里分离出来,建换电站和快充网络,车厂只管造车,基础设施由另一家公司做。
马斯克的回答很干脆:这个方向跟特斯拉基本正交。
Better Place不造车,它在帮别的车厂造电动车,同时建基础设施。两家公司更像共生关系,谈不上谁吃掉谁。
至于这个模式能不能成:能,问题是时机。不能本末倒置,先把马放到车前面。
他没说"这是竞争对手"。
顺便说一句后来发生的事。Better Place在2013年破产清算,换电模式在乘用车领域失败了。但换电这个思路在中国被几家车企重新捡起来,走通了。马斯克当年的判断是对的:方向没错,时机才是问题。
他评价同行骗局时没有留情面
现场提问环节,一位《圣罗莎新闻民主党报》的记者问了一个不太好答的问题。
圣罗莎是ZAP电动车公司的所在地,ZAP最近被《连线》杂志的一篇报道批成"拉高出货"式的骗局。那篇文章同时批评整个电动车行业没有人站出来说话,大家都在装看不见。
记者问:你会公开点名ZAP吗。
马斯克的回答只有一句:ZAP没有兑现承诺的记录。
然后他补了一句:《连线》那篇文章基本准确。
接着他讲了一段特斯拉自己的麻烦,这段比点名更值得读。
特斯拉早期面对的一个大问题是,在它之前,很多电动车公司是骗局,或者只有PPT和渲染图,业内叫"vaporware"。加上特斯拉自己也有一堆交付延迟,声誉被连累得很厉害。
用他的说法,一个真做事的公司,被前面的骗子拖累了信誉。
他给了一组当下的数字:现在每周产10辆车,明年初提到每周30辆。路上很快就能看到这些车。
认识我的人知道,我在时间表上可能有点乐观,但我说的事一定会交付。(马斯克)
这句话他在后面很多年里重复过很多次,每次都是同一个意思。时间表乐观,交付兑现。2008年说这句话的时候,特斯拉账上的钱只够撑几个月。
还有一件事他没主动说
现场有人问,为什么别的车厂不直接跟特斯拉合作,把技术授权出去。
马斯克的回答里藏了一条没被充分展开的信息:特斯拉已经跟一家主要车厂签了协议,不是美国公司。他不肯说是谁,只说"谷歌一下很容易找出来"。
Battelle猜本田。马斯克说:半球错了。
暗示的是欧洲厂商。后来公开的信息是戴姆勒,2009年入股特斯拉约10%,双方在电池包和动力总成上有合作。
马斯克对这件事的评价是:这个合作有可能做出一辆2万美元级别的可行电动车。
这句话在2008年听起来像远景。十六年后回头看,2万美元级别的电动车成了全球汽车行业竞争最激烈的那一档,而且主导者不在底特律。
这场对话里最有用的东西
把整场对话拆开,能拿走的不是产品参数,是几条判断方式。
第一条,技术普及的成本曲线是有顺序的。先让技术跑通,再让成本下来。反过来做,通常两头都做不到。
第二条,融资条款的价格和估值是两回事。市场最差的时候,钱不是拿不到,是拿到的代价会改变公司归属。这个判断在2008年11月很少有人做,因为当时所有人都在抢现金。
第三条,组织的标准只能往上调。裁员的时候把及格线下调,短期省了钱,长期把公司变成一个平庸组织。
第四条,改变行业最快的方式是证伪对手的假设,不是抢对手的份额。特斯拉当年做的事,是把"技术做不成"和"做成了也没人买"这两个前提同时打掉。
第五条,商业模型离现金越近,在衰退里越抗打。同一时间,同一批资本,屋顶太阳能拿到三倍融资,高端电动车差点断粮。
这些都是2008年11月在一个会议台上说出来的。十六年后,它们大部分被验证了,一部分被证明过于乐观,还有一部分直到今天仍然没人做到。
这场对话最后,Battelle开玩笑说再不结束,后台的小猫要被杀了。马斯克下台,掌声,音乐。
一个月后,NASA的16亿美元合同落地。再一个月,戴姆勒入股谈判开始。特斯拉账上的钱,勉强撑到了那两件事发生。
给读者的几条具体建议
这场对话值得反复读的地方,在于它记录了一个人在最坏时点做决策的全过程。下面几条可以直接拿去用。
- 创业早期做产品定价时,先想清楚价格在对标谁。对标超级跑车,产品就变成收藏品;对标保时捷911,产品才有机会走向大众。定价是定位工具,不只是收入工具。
- 融资条款太苛刻的时候,砍规模比砍控制权划算。目标从1亿砍到4000万,产品推迟一年,公司还在自己手里。这个账要算清楚。
- 裁员不要下调标准。把"最低及格线"维持在优秀,短期更痛,长期组织不会烂掉。标准一旦松动,后面所有事都会跟着松。
- 进入一个成熟行业,先找出这个行业最流行的两个"做不到"的判断,把它们当成首要目标。抢份额是第二层的事。
- 判断一个新技术的商业化路径,先看成本曲线现在在哪一段。在成本还没降下来的时候推大众产品,通常两头落空。
- 经济下行期,优先做能直接帮客户省钱的生意。同一批资本,会更快流向离现金近的模型。
- 如果你在一个骗子扎堆的赛道里做事,主动跟骗子划清界限。行业信誉是公共品,沉默的代价由认真做事的人承担。
0:01[Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] why don't we just bring up Elon Musk and we'll have a conversation about it welcome to web to Elon let H right here so I I think I just want to start with with sort of the ultimate Gadget like the the dream Gadget the six figure Gadget with lots of scarcity so can we bring that picture up we cue the red sort of gadget porn
0:41there it is that's a Tesla Road Roadster it costs $14,000 109 oh yeah although there is a tax credit that'll take effect next year bring it down to about 100 all right so we're still into six figures range you're making how many of them we'll make about 1,200 a year maybe, 1500 a year and and when you do make 1,500 a year are you going to make a profit on that yeah yeah absolutely so tell me a little bit about this car give me the sort of Gadget rundown like the the specs the stats how many cylinders does it have it has no cylinders so the the car was joking I was joking John I mean really so the car is is
1:34really I mean the the I the the elevator phrase is it's faster than a Ferrari more efficient than a Prius it's the 0 to 60 time is 3.9 seconds and we actually working on a on a power pack upgrade that'll take that down to about 3.6 to 3.7 next year the Energy Efficiency in terms of miles per gallon equivalent is is about 130
2:02so that's if you took a gallon of oil and you refined that to gasoline transported to a gas station and and how many miles do you get in a car versus you took that gallon of oil generate electricity took the the transmission losses into account and then said how many miles do you get out of the car that's how you get the equivalency so it's about twice the Energy Efficiency of a Prius and and faster than than any Ferrari except the Enzo so it's it's really pretty unique proposition but but we can't really get one I mean not only because it's 100 Grand which not everybody's got but you can only make
2:43so many of them yeah absolutely in fact one thing important thing I forgot to mention is that the range is almost 250 miles and that's a combined Highway city with the air conditioning on so and you and the charge is built into the car so you can just plug it into any Outlet like it's a hairdryer it's a it's a hell of a yeah hair dryer or laptop you know it's a laptop with wheels and seats does it have nav it does okay well then I'm in you know CU otherwise so yeah yeah so you know common thing we he is well gez this is available to a very small number of people it's clearly not going to change the climate and you know so what if a few rich people get energy efficient
3:27cars you just took my next question away right and it's important to emphasize that the the point of Tesla the reason I I funded it and put so much time and effort into it is is really to get to mass Market electric cars but to get to get there you need to start with something and if you look at any new technology development I think in almost any sphere you you start with something which is expensive because it's first the first thing is about making making the technology work and then you work then you go from there optimizing the technology I'm sure everybody remembers the early days of cell phones or laptops or or even more directly if if people are aware of
4:08the history of internal combustion engine cars you you would know that in the early days of of of gasoline cars they were considered toys for rich people because everybody else was driving was riding a horse and and so you you need to go through this phase of having an expensive car that is a available to a few in order to get to the lowcost car that is available to many so if you look at our next the next product we're coming out with which is the sedan and that's a five passenger luxury sports sedan it's half the price of this of of the Roadster it's called the model S we'll be unveiling it the first quarter next year and that you know that cars are going to
4:53be produced at more than 10 times the volume of of the Roadster so we're aiming to make about 15 to 20,000 cars a year and and and it doesn't stop there our third model will be a lowcost car that will be I think under $330,000 and and and that call be the hundreds of thousands of of units per year so let's talk a little bit about that because you've had some news in the last couple of weeks and it has been news consistent with pretty much all the rest of the news in the last couple of weeks some layoffs some delays in the s model as I
5:31understand it you you've sort of Taken officially the title of CEO you've had a number of CEOs over the last couple of years I imagine it's not easy to birth an entirely new car company it's been tried many times before and most times it doesn't work and they weren't trying to necessarily invent this at the same time absolutely so talk to me about why it was that you needed to raise more funds and why it is that you had to delay the s yeah AB absolutely and it's true the the last time there was a successful mainstream car startup was was Jeep in 1941 so it's been a while but
6:13so it's it's definitely it's a hard task and certainly I I didn't actually I didn't think that this would be easy or or or anything like that but it seemed as though if if action wasn't taken then it was simply left up to Detroit I mean I think we'd be waiting for a very long time well Detroit was in the offices of Nancy Pelosi last night or yesterday
6:40with their Tin Cups out I mean they were really big cups right because because apparently it's about $25 billion that they want well they already have that but they want another 25 billion just so they can keep in business to get the 25 billion that they're going to get next year I'm curious I mean you just had a round of layoffs the way you did it was interesting sort of as I understand it a special forces approach like you sort of only the the seals get through but the Marines and the Green Berets don't in terms of the staff that you kept we've had a discussion over the last two days that certainly included the discussion of entrepreneurs and
7:15startups and the the Sequoia memo and you know how do we cut but still go forward and so on how did you get through that is you know and and and tell us a little bit about that process and and what again why did you have to do it yeah well before the market Armageddon occurred the plan for Tesla was to raise about $100 million and Go full force into the model S development really into the expensive part of the model S development if you look at the development costs for something like like a like a car where you've got a lot of Capital Equipment it sort of looks like a like a hill you know you've got a long sort of tail and then when it comes time
7:52to build buy all the factory equipment all that sort of stuff you that's where youve got to spend you know a couple hundred million dollars and so we intended to sort of get going with that at full force prior prior to the market collapse and then the market collapsed and clearly that was that would have been a very difficult strategy to execute and and and so you my gut tells me you could have probably raised the money but you didn't want to give away the equity is that what it came down to the pricing was too bad I I think we the the I think we could have raised the the the money at at very difficult terms essentially giving up control of the company
8:30and just with you know very difficult ratchets and all sorts of things involved you did pretty well before you started Tesla maybe you sure looked in the mirror and written yourself a check well I actually have done that so there's a certain point where your tolerance gets yeah it's but it's tough to carry it all drop the picture now cuz we got other things to talk about thanks you can go to imag Johnny cuz I know you like you know sorry yeah well in effect that's what what what we've we've done is rather
9:06than raise 100 million we we're raising well have have reach have commitments for for 40 million from the existing set of investors which is a bunch of people apart from me right you know I'll be providing about you know sort of half that but the other half is coming from from the other investors so and
9:25that that's that's enough to certainly get the the roader business and our power train supply business right so you have an outs a business where you're you're supplying two other yes absolutely in fact that power train supply business is is part of what will allow us to get to mass Market affordable cars because that business is profitable right it is yes and expect the roader business to be profitable in the second quarter next year so did you ever consider if they can afford 109 Grand why not just price it at 200 because anyone can I mean you have a waiting list of how long 1,200 yeah no it's it's it's always tough figuring out pricing some people
10:05are are relatively insensitive to pricing some people are extremely sensitive to pricing we wanted the price of our car to be something that was comparable to a gasoline sports car like a Ferrari well it's we're actually cheaper than a Ferrari but but comparable to say a Porsche M you know if you look at a Porsche turbo it's about $125,000 or so or Porsche 911 S is is
10:29you know High 90s so it we wanted to be something where it's in the in the realm of a comparable price to it to other sort of normal sports cars apart from the super Exotics I want to move on because we got a lot to talk about very quickly let me just ask you again about sort of your philosophy around you couldn't raise that money you needed to lay off staff H what was your approach to that so there were two parts to it one was sort of a reduction in force for people that were on the working on the model S because we just could afford to sustain you know a large group working on the model S so we we we knocked that down to about 10% of the company working on the model
11:09S and then we did an overall review of the company and I said look let's just let's approach this from a standpoint of I want to sort of accentuate the the philosophy that I have with companies in the startup phase which is which is a sort of Special Forces approach you know the minimum passing grade is excellent and that's that's you know it's just that's the way I believe s companies need to be if they're ultimately going to be large and successful companies and you know
11:41I think we' we'd adhere to that to some degree but would' straight from that path in in a few places and that that doesn't mean the people that we let go on that basis were would be considered bad you know just it's just difference between sort of Special Forces and regular army and if you're going to get through a really tough environment and and ultimately grow the company to something significant you have to have a very high level of dedication and talent throughout the organization let's I want to move on because we've got a lot to cover I want to talk a bit about solar solar City so give us the sort of elevator pitch as to what what what that company
12:21does yeah absolutely and and actually before I do that it's worth noting you know from a business standpoint my time is split roughly evenly between Tesla and SpaceX right so Solar City I spend hardly any time on and deserve really hardly any credit for the the guys there are just phenomenally good I they actually blow my mind so Solar City the value proposition that they have that they're the most efficient provider of solar systems for at at the residential and and small business level by long shot and they also have a unique financing product which allows people to sign up for solar with no money down and your cost of electricity decreases so it's a
13:09no-brainer how do you say no to something like that in fact we're expecting Solar City sales to actually accelerate within the recession because you save money mhh so how you know the solo city just did a financing round that was about about 3x the round it did a year ago that makes it unusual yeah and we're expecting business to at least double in 2009 over 2008 so I mean what do you say to that you sound that sounds great too sounds like if you could merge Solar City and Tesla you could have raised that 100 so actually I had one last
13:51question about Tesla that I didn't get to which is maybe unfair but what's how did we get here not not the Tesla piece but how did the automobile industry end up where it is like help help us understand what happened in Detroit such that we got to the point where the industry literally is not viable you know I I don't think I have a really great answer for that I think there's there's issues with with organized labor and there are issues with entr management that you know still wants to run a company like it's 1955 so you know there's too many country club memberships and and then and I think the and the you know management sort of focused on the wrong things
14:40but GM has this Vault project how is it that you could get the Tesla up and running and and and the the transmission and the drive train done and they've been working on the Vault project seemingly for well at least for five years or something and actually the the vault is relatively new I think so the vault is actually inspired by Tesla and and Bob blutz has gone on record as oh that's right yeah that's right yeah so if that was one of the positive effects that I'd hope Tesla would why don't they just buy Tesla I'm not sure they could afford Tesla right now their market
15:17cap did you guys get that did you get because the market cap of GM right now is less than Burger King right it's 2.8 billion is that low well actually Michael pollen this morning probably that's probably a good thing that Burger King is market cap has been hammered as well but yeah they're not they're 2.8 billion or something like that so everyone's madly doing calculations right now on Tesla's value but yeah so the do you think the vault's going to work do you hope it's going to work or you I hope it's going to work absolutely yeah you my motive you think I'm a volunteer at this point there's nothing I I want to buy personally that that I can't buy and
15:58I don't really like Yachts or anything like that and so my interest is is really from an environmental standpoint to some degree from a national security standpoint and then and then longer term from an overall economic situation standpoint which is if you've got a non-renewable fuel you better find a renewable source or the econom is going to collapse down the road so my interest is like what can we do to
16:28get as many you know renewable energy cars on the road as possible you know my personal belief and in the in the right solution is electric cars and primarily solar power although wind and geothermal are also good good options and and so one of the things I was hoping would occur would would be that the larger car companies would look at what Tesla's done and and establish electric car programs sooner than they might otherwise do so mhm I mean they would eventually do so but if we could sort of show them that the technology is possible to make the technology work and that and that people want to buy electric cars when you when you make them because previously the car industry
17:08had thought you can't make technology work and even if you did people wouldn't buy it right so if we can prove those those those those premises false then then that would get the car industry moving in the direction of electric and that has had some positive effect with which directly credits Tesla to you know so yeah now one one last question on the cars and then we're going to go to space Shay aesy has is coming later and and he's got another sort of an alternative approach to to this particular sea simmering which is he he he you know the battery pack per se is distinct from the car and you there's service stations and a whole grid Network and and and what do
17:50you make of that model and and you know do you think the two can coexist or is it one's going to win and the other's not well I think you know know what he's doing is somewhat orthogonal to us or perhaps rather in terms of being a competitor it's I think it's more of a a sort of symbiotic thing that that you know we're making electric cars he's not making electric cars he's helping wants to help build the infrastructure to swap out battery packs and have fast charge stations and that sort of thing he does have a model though right no he doesn't make cars yeah you know he he's he's working with some of the other car makers to encourage them to make
18:27electric cars but but he's not him s an electric car maker so do you think it's going to work his model yeah I think yes eventually the question is one of timing you know you know we don't want to have the cart before the horse and so I think what he's doing is right really it's just time will tell whether this is It's a thing to do now or a thing to do later so so let's swap to another really big or potentially really big industry I mean it is a very big industry but it's a mostly a government at least industry which is using lots and lots and lots of gas to hurdle things into space right Rockets Rockets right so
19:14why did you decide that this was an interesting industry to try to reinvent well so you know when I was in college there were sort of I try to think of what what are the things that would most change the future of of humanity and the the three things I came up with were the internet transitioning to a sustainable energy economy and and space exploration in particular the extension of life to multiple planets I didn't really think I'd be involved in the third one I wasn't even sure about the second one but the first one fortunately the internet you you can get something started with very little Capital so you did a couple interet companies and that that gave me
19:59the capital to to to work on the the clean energy stuff which is where Solar City and Tesla come in and then the third element was space and you I just think it's it's important that we we make progress in in space and that we're you know ultimately that we're on a path so if you sort of put put sort of project outwards and extrapolate forward you could see that one day we would be a space buring civilization that there would be life on one many planets Life as we know it at least on on many planets I think that's just a very exciting future compared to one where life never gets beyond Earth and and there were all the defensive Arguments for that of course of like
20:45well you know is life going to end on Earth and maybe we should sort of back up the biosphere like sometimes call it you know if you back up your hard drive maybe you should back up life too so and I think those defensive aru arguments are are good I mean they're they're they're valid and and all that but I I'm much more the thing that sort of gets gets me excited is really the the positive side of it of the the much greater richness in in the scope and scale of life and and you know by by being out there and and being a space making life multiple planets so space faing going be a little styed here but I mean usually when we imagine what you're
21:28talking about we then write a series like Star Trek or we you know we have you know almost every popular culture projection of what you're discussing has men and women in government uniforms right you know out there exploring on behalf of civilization back home but you're you're trying to do this as a private Enterprise well we have we have lots of government customers although we have both you know commercial and govern customers so tell me practically you know get us to space through spaic like how does this happen and you're in the early phase I understand and you just had a first launch right well actually we our fourth launch but our first time to orbit so
22:18SpaceX is about 6 years old started from scratch never I never built any physical Hardware myself and you know just although I do have a physics background and and grew up in a very engineering Centric household so you know more an engineer than anything else I guess but you starting starting
22:41spaceex I didn't really know know that much about Space Engineering or rocket engineering but I learned quite a lot and as it turns out I wasn't able to hire anyone to be the chief designer of the rocket so I ended up being that myself so like a kid in the backyard playing with yeah we probably would have gotten to obit sooner if I'd been able to hire someone but I wasn't able to so we got to overit on a four fourth attempt you say it's it's hard to get to orbit by the way this is the first well I I haven't tried but I at least not in a rocket but right I hear you but I I I just I I'm I'm a little bit speechless the idea that you know I mean it's rather audacious and and I
23:26asked Lance Armstrong this question but I'll ask you as well I mean how much of this is ego you know I don't know I mean it's probably some some meaningful amount as ego I suppose but you know you just want to go to college and you're smoking a joint at like midnight and you're like I think I'll reinvent space first the internet then then I'll do the energy economy then I'll deal with interplanetary travel I I'm pretty sure all of us had that moment in college but you're the only guy I know who's actually trying to do it well yeah well actually when when I thought about it in college it wasn't from the standpoint of I'm going to go get these things done it was it was
24:12really these are just these are what I think are the most important things it's almost certain I will not be involved in at least the space part of it probably not the renewable energy part of it and hopefully the internet and if I do the internet thing hopefully I can make enough money to pay the rent that was actually that was the my frame of mind to be clear was well the internet thing worked out pretty well it did it but you know I started in 95 and and nobody had made any money on the internet and even in Silicon Valley you know we went to bench capitalists in in '95 and they sort of HED the internet most of them weren't even using it and and even if the internet did
24:51become widespread nobody make any money on it and then the net skap went public and that kind of changed people mindset and they think at Le at least from the standpoint of the greater fool Theory like even if there internets can't internet companies can't make money at least some fools willing to pay a lot you know if they go public and and so that that got things more more interested but really my perspective was starting my first company was hopefully I can make enough money to pay the rent and buy food otherwise I would have to go and go to my graduate program at Stanford which is fine it's not a fine fine option the graduate program at Stanford seems to be the
25:31Launchpad for an awful lot of things yeah it's somewhat cliche at this point yeah you know we're actually we're running out of time but and and you still haven't told us exactly how we're going to get to space but I know that well at least somebody's going to be able to get that tour of SpaceX Factory which is part of the auction thank you very much for that I I know I'm being told but it's my show so let's have a couple questions and then and and then we'll let Elon go over here jate from Le I tried testify way
26:03spectacular car I have to nitp when you're going 60 70 miles an hour on the highway and you want to pass that car in front of you you can't just downshift it but it's okay I'm the question is I'm not sure I yeah I I would love to see your technology in pretty much all the cars manufactured in us and I don't think selling to GM is the right solution but but you have the technology they they hopefully know have to know how to mass produce cars so is licensing an option maybe combined with some not not just GM you know for Chrysler every car company combin why aren't they have electric cars with I'm sure you'd love to do a deal with all of them
26:46right so yeah sure absolutely why aren't well are they in there is it are they they tend to have sort of an ni you know non invented here thing I don't know we you know we actually I should say we do have a deal with a major car company it's not a US Car Company I I can't say who it is but it's pretty if you Google around you'll it's easy to figure it out to no
27:15Honda wrong hemisphere you go but I'm very excited by that that relationship because it has potential to provide a a viable electric car for around $20,000 smart Okay I'm going to stop we have a question over here yeah hi my name is Nathan hon I'm the reporter with the Santa Rose pressed Democrat Santa Rosa is home to zap electric cars which got blasted in a recent story in Wired Magazine but essentially for being a pump and dump kind of scam operation but the the magazine was the article was actually a little critical too of the whole electric car industry for not calling these guys out so my question to you is will you call zap out well yeah I
28:00mean z zap is not is does not have a a track record of delivering what they say you know yeah I mean I would that's about as much calling out as you're going to need Elon Musk to do that's my guess that is a call out in this guy's book yeah I mean they're look good I mean if anyone's curious I mean I think the wired article is reasonbly accurate so yeah it's unfortunate
28:33we did face the problem with Tesla in the beginning of of having to deal with the fact that that many prior electric car companies had been sort of scams or a a lot of vaporware and stuff and and that you know with with with Tesla having had a bunch of delays and and and all that it it did hurt us perceptually but fortunately we're now in production at 10 cars a week and that'll be ramping up to 30 cars a week by early next year and so you're going to see start seeing a lot of these cars on the road yeah so at least it's you know it's real and all that I think the people that that know me know that you know I might be a little optimistic on schedules but I always deliver right I'm
29:14sorry we can't take any more questions but I'm I'm kittens are being threatened to be killed back there if I don't if I don't wrap this up so thank you very much Elon for for coming here [Music] [Applause]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版