2008年底,洛杉矶一场聚会上,马斯克被请上台讲两件事:SpaceX和Tesla。台下坐的多是编剧、导演、制片人,没几个人看过火箭发射直播。主持人开场就自嘲:我们这儿是好莱坞,不是硅谷,不太懂技术,但慢慢会跟上。
马斯克先讲了一段Tesla,然后放了一段火箭升空的视频。屏幕上那枚细长的白色火箭是他公司的产品,名字来自《星球大战》里的千年隼。他讲到一个数字:要把东西送上轨道,火箭起飞重量的3%是有效载荷,剩下97%全是燃料和结构。换句话说,入轨是一门在3%里抠出一切的生意。
这句话背后藏着整场演讲的主线。他反复绕回同一个问题:为什么火箭只能用一次,而汽车、飞机、自行车都能反复用?这个问题听起来幼稚,却是他创业的全部理由。
250亿美元的贷款,最后拿去造油老虎
演讲前半段,马斯克先聊了Tesla。
2008年是汽车行业的多事之秋。美国国会批了一笔250亿美元的贷款项目,本意是资助车企研发节能车辆,帮国家摆脱石油依赖。结果三大车企跑到华盛顿,要求把这笔钱拿去做日常运营,继续造油老虎。马斯克的原话是,这跟立法的初衷正好相反。
国会现在把250亿里的150亿给了三大车企,用来填日常运营的窟窿。我算了一下,这笔钱大概能撑到明年二月。这不是夸张。(马斯克)
他补了一句,等奥巴马政府上台,这笔钱会补回来,应该问题不大。但他还是提醒在场的人:如果有机会跟华盛顿或者媒体表达意见,请替清洁能源车辆说句话。
Tesla的处境和三大车企不一样。马斯克强调,Tesla没有申请救助资金,申请的是研发低成本大众车型的经费,正好符合那笔贷款的立法本意。媒体有时把两件事混为一谈,他说这是误会。
那辆两人座跑车Roadster,售价10万美元。马斯克自己的那辆是量产第一台,就停在门外。圣莫尼卡大道上还有一家Tesla的销售和服务中心,感兴趣的可以去看看。他提到一个细节:下周要交付第100辆量产车,第100位车主是Sam Perry。
这个名字马斯克特意点了出来。奥巴马胜选那晚,电视镜头里有个男人靠在别人肩上哭,那个人就是Sam Perry。马斯克说他是个很好的人,住在湾区,周二会亲自把钥匙交到他手上。
先造贵的车,才可能造出便宜的车
总有人问马斯克:造这种富人玩具一样的贵车,对环境到底有什么好处?
他的回答是,任何新技术早期都贵。回头看看最早的手机、笔记本电脑,几乎所有新东西刚出来时都不便宜。原因很简单:新技术的第一要务是先让它跑起来,先小批量做出来卖掉。规模上去了,成本才会下来。
你没法直接造出便宜的车,除非从贵的车开始做起。(马斯克)
他还强调了一件事:Tesla卖Roadster赚的每一分钱,都投进了低成本大众车型的研发。公司不分红,以后也不会。他自己的工资是最低工资标准,基本上算个志愿者。
这段话放在2008年听,分量不太一样。那一年Tesla资金吃紧,马斯克个人也在往里垫钱。他在台上说得轻描淡写,但台下的听众未必知道这家公司当时离悬崖有多近。
第四次发射:第一枚私人研制的火箭入轨
讲完Tesla,马斯克切到正题。屏幕上放的是Falcon 1(猎鹰一号)的发射录像,地点在赤道附近一座偏远的热带小岛,夸贾林环礁。
他开了个玩笑:在偏远小岛上发射火箭,感觉有点不正经,像007电影里的反派基地。这次发的是个假卫星,纯粹是测试飞行,目标是入轨。
这是Falcon 1的第四次飞行。第二次和第三次都到了太空,但没能入轨。马斯克说,到太空和入轨是两码事,很多人分不清。
他用数字解释:到太空,速度到3马赫就够了。入轨,最低要25马赫。但这还没说清难度,因为能量随速度的平方增长。到太空大约需要9个单位的能量,入轨需要625个单位,差不多难70倍。
这也是为什么全世界只有五六个国家真正把东西送进过轨道。
这次飞行创造了两个第一:第一枚完全由私人研制的火箭入轨,第一枚私人研制的液体燃料火箭入轨。马斯克说,这枚火箭叫Falcon,名字来自《星球大战》的千年隼,虽然长得一点都不像。
录像的背景音乐是Crystal Method的《High Roller》。这类细节是马斯克式的趣味,他把一场技术验证做成了有配乐的发布会。
火箭为什么只能用一次
放完视频,马斯克聊起火箭回收。
全世界唯一勉强算可复用的火箭是航天飞机,但他说这只算“半可复用”,因为主燃料箱每次都要扔掉。其他火箭更彻底:要么再入时烧毁,要么掉进海里沉底。火箭基本是一次性用品。
Falcon 1的设计里,第一级本来就打算回收。这次没成功。传回来的遥测显示,第一级再入时隔热不够,烧掉了。下次要加厚热防护。
燃料是高纯度煤油,马斯克形容它像一种很干净的喷气燃料,不含硫。他说这玩意儿不算最环保的东西,但公司买了不少碳抵消额度。
发射场选在北纬9度,是为了借地球自转帮一把入轨速度。这是火箭发射的常识:越靠近赤道,地球自转给的初速度越大,越省燃料。
有人问太空垃圾怎么办。马斯克说目前没遇到这个问题。轨道上确实飘着不少东西,包括中国打卫星留下的碎片,但太空太大,被撞的概率极小。载人的航天器和SpaceX的龙飞船(Dragon)都装了微流星体防护罩,能扛住高速子弹一样的撞击。
可复用是通往廉价太空的唯一钥匙
终于讲到重点。有人问,这件事的更大图景是什么?
马斯克说,他创办SpaceX,是因为入轨的成本和可靠性从1960年代以来就没怎么改善,甚至更糟。如果把这条曲线往未来延伸,总有一天人类会连一次发射都负担不起。
他想扭转这个趋势,让进入轨道和更远的地方变得便宜。而这里最大的技术突破,是造出完全可复用的轨道运载火箭。
Falcon 1的第一级打算复用,Falcon 9的两级都打算复用。他承认这需要很多次发射才能摸清楚,要把级体安全收回来,要优化翻修流程,要确保可靠性。但这就是他在等的那件事。
他打了个比方:任何交通工具,可复用和一次性之间都是天壤之别。
如果车是一次性的,今天还有多少人会开车过来?(马斯克)
这句话把全场逗笑了。但笑完之后,逻辑很清楚:自行车、马、飞机,几乎所有交通工具都靠反复使用摊薄成本。唯独太空是个怪地方,飞行器只能用一次,想要返程还得再拖一个在后面。
难度在哪?马斯克解释,一枚入轨火箭在把重量优化到极致、用上最先进材料、发动机效率推到极限之后,通常只有3%的起飞重量能变成有效载荷。设计上稍有闪失,比如损耗3%,就什么都送不上去。
这还是针对一次性火箭说的。一次性火箭不用考虑复用,不用做得很结实,不用扛再入,不用装隔热罩。要把这些东西全加上,重量还会往上走。一旦超过那3%,有效载荷就归零。
所以造一枚既能复用、又能送出有用载荷的火箭,极其困难。马斯克说,到目前为止没人做到过。
让生命成为多行星物种
有人追问,为什么要做这件事,图什么?
马斯克说,他相信把生命延伸到地球之外,让生命成为多行星物种,是人类能做的最重要的事情之一。
他怎么判断“重要”?方法是把时间尺度拉长。历史拉得越远,重要的事越留在画面里,不重要的事早就看不见了。
看地球几十亿年的生命演化史,能数出大约六七个关键节点:单细胞生命、多细胞生命、动植物分化、生命从海洋登上陆地、哺乳动物、意识。这些是留在画面里的东西。
按同样的尺度,生命扩展到多个行星,至少和生命从海洋登上陆地一样重要,甚至更重要。
他补了一句比较:从海洋到陆地,不舒服了还能跳回海里。去另一个行星,要先跨过几十亿英里的敌意太空,降落在一个和地球完全不同的地方,再试着造出一个生态系统。难度不是一个量级。
也有人提醒他:现在的地球,可能正在变得越来越像那些行星。马斯克没回避,说这正是要小心的原因。
既然这件事重要,就该分到一些资源。分多少?
大概比我们在口红上花的少,比在联邦医保上花的多。顺便说,我们在口红上花了很多钱,我觉得挺好。(马斯克)
这句是全场最好笑的段落,也是他真正想说的比例问题。他给了一个具体数字:拿出经济产出的0.25%用于让生命多行星化,是个合理的量级,算下来是几百亿美元。他说这点钱可能还不够,但关键前提是先有可复用的轨道飞行器,否则一切免谈。
燃料的终极答案,可能在聚变
最后有人问,他对燃料有什么最狂野的想法。
马斯克的回答是聚变。如果能造出紧凑的聚变反应堆,那就是最好的能源。然后你需要从尾部喷出点什么,本质上就是一台由聚变反应堆驱动的高能离子发动机。他说,从物理角度看,这差不多是人类能做到的极限了。
至于引力弹弓、太阳帆,他也提了。太阳帆是个选项,但太阳的光压很小,站在户外你并不会觉得自己被太阳推倒。所以帆要做得很大,在太空里才有效。如果是不赶时间的货运飞船,比如从地球到火星,太阳帆其实是个不错的选择。
这一段问答透露出马斯克的思考习惯:他先问物理允许的极限在哪,再倒推工程上怎么逼近。聚变、离子推进、太阳帆,都是在这个框架里被拿出来比较的。
回到那3%
整场演讲,马斯克其实一直在讲同一件事的两面。
一面是现实:一枚火箭97%的重量是燃料和结构,只有3%能变成有效载荷。另一面是愿景:如果这枚火箭能反复用,那3%的账就能重算,太空运输的成本会掉到另一个数量级。
Tesla的故事是同一个逻辑的另一种版本。先造10万美元的跑车,把技术跑通,再往下做便宜的车。新技术从贵到便宜,中间没有捷径。
他在2008年底说这些话的时候,两家公司都还在悬崖边上。Falcon 1刚刚第四次发射成功,Tesla刚交付第100辆车。台下的人喝着酒,听完鼓掌。没人知道接下来两年会发生什么。
但演讲里那个判断一直没变:一件事重不重要,把时间尺度拉长就能看出来。生命从海洋登上陆地,留在了画面里。生命走向多行星,会不会也留在画面里,取决于那3%能不能被重新算一遍。
- 判断一件事值不值得做,把时间尺度拉长十年、一百年再看。留在画面里的才重要,其余的会自己消失。
- 新技术早期一定贵。想做出便宜的产品,路径通常是从贵的产品开始,把技术和供应链跑通,再往下压成本,而不是一上来就做低价。
- 遇到“为什么这东西只能用一次”这类看起来幼稚的问题,别放过。很多行业的成本结构,就卡在这个没人追问的常识上。
- 评估一个宏大目标时,先问物理允许的极限在哪,再倒推工程怎么逼近。先算上限,再谈路线。
- 给重要但不紧急的事定一个具体比例,比如经济产出的0.25%。模糊的“应该多投入”不会变成行动,一个数字才会。
0:01all right one more second for people to grab a drink walski let's go sit all right we good all right do you have the key nearby for the side gate okay sorry all right how's everybody doing with my about my away is everybody ready to end this [Music] year let's just end it today we've got more booze in the back and I'm sure we can finish ourselves off at least all right so it's been an incredibly long year it's been what two or three years since we started the Hollywood Hill and we're winding down the second major Year I'll give you a few announcements why a few great people are strolling in so the event facility first announcement most of you know we took over an event center
1:38property in Hollywood earlier in the year and we it's it's basically a piece of junk that we were going to renovate so what's happened now we were in a pretty flexible relationship with the landlord and because the marketplace now with real estate is dropping so significantly and the space was not amazing I mean we were going to have to totally you know gut in and rebuild it and spend a lot of money doing that we're now going to hold off from doing that at the moment and we've got a broker out there who is keeping an you know very fast eye on what properties are opening up around town because we have a feeling there's going to be some really exciting you
2:14know properties that we could instead take over and have to do less work in renovation so that being said our current landlord because the market for contractors is also so good has decided he wants to bring in a contractor to kind of do a base renovation of the building we're in right now so we're going to move out of there in about 2 weeks and be out of there from January through March and there's a very good you know chance that we're not going to go back there that we will find a space between that period and then move into it so in the meantime those first three months we're going to be launching armchair revolutionary which obviously we've been
2:47working on for about two years but I can tell you it's looking really good and it's going to you know be in beta in about two weeks and then and then we'll open it up to the public and so we'll be working on that and doing media projects finally for the first time so you guys are going to start seeing a lot of internal media projects go up on seed grid and we'll be asking a lot of you who are writers and directors to come in and start working on media for armchair etc etc and that'll be really exciting that's about probably all the announcements I want to give so this event is a really fun topic obviously when I went to Ean original happy talking about filming in space but
3:27the inspiration for it was you know you'll see today he he got into film making himself and and put some cameras on his Rockets and we got to watch it live how many of you actually watched the live webcast of his Rockets going up into space like four people five people all right so it's this isn't silon Valley it's Hollywood we're not very techsavvy but we'll catch up eventually but a lot of you obviously are going to see this for the first time which is really actually really exciting so that'll be great and then our other guest speaker is standing right behind me Steve Squires so give a round of applause for both of
4:10them and elon's going to go first with a presentation for about half an hour on SpaceX and what he's been doing he's also going to give us an update at some point on the Auto industry as it relates to Tesla right now because I'm sure we're all fascinated to find out what his yeah perspective is on that and and then we'll do the the two half hour presentations then we'll have Q&A with both of them for another half an hour and then we have our real party in the back so we've got you know drinks and food and everything from 5: to like 6:30 whatever and we can all party and have a good time so one last thank you to our host who is probably outside
4:46Victoria are you back all right well we're going to wait for our host to get back because that would be the appropriate thing to do
5:12I think I'll take this opportunity to have our photographer come over and photograph me with the speakers you you guys have to you know stand below me though because you're so tall I have to look somewhat more important [Music] excellent all right well actually why don't we take this this time yeah all right Orie the other co-founder of the Hollywood Hill would also like a photo with them it's photo time everybody step
5:49up why don't you can take a quick photo all right there's Victoria Victoria come front and center so Victoria Hopper walking towards us our wonderful host for today give her a huge the second year we're doing this it's so fantastic to end the year with you and this is fantastic house and obviously your hospitality and obviously you know I love you dearly she's been very involved in the Obama campaign and obviously from very early on so from very very early on when there's a split in town here you know who's you know backing Hillary wor Obama she decided to go with Obama and so you have a lot you know you owe to her to getting him in the office of the
6:49White House thank you all right so thank you and please yes yes I just want to say thank you for coming back it's nice to see so many familiar faces and welcome and the art has changed a lot of it is on tour so if anyone has any questions later I'd be happy to tell you what's what so I'll see you after all right and then we should get you you need a photo with the speakers so why don't you step
7:22up all right Ian I think you why don't you give us a quick thing on Tesla and then we'll leave that behind we can move into space sure okay all right so quick update on on Tesla hold on one sec hello yeah so I'm sure people have been reading about the auto loan bailout and all that sort of stuff so it's it's kind of a travesty what's going on although hope I don't think it's going to last too long into the Obama Administration there was a $25 billion Loan program that Congress approved to fund energy the development of energy efficient vehicles essentially to wean ourselves off off of oil and ironically the the big three then came to to Washington and said now give us
8:11that money for our day-to-day operations building gas guzzlers which is is obviously a somewhat of a version of the intent and unfortunately with with the job situation being being the way it is Congress has acceded to that demand and is my understanding currently giving 15 of 25 billion to to to the big three to fund their day-to-day operations which I believe gets them to about February I'm not kidding it's not even an exaggeration although the the speaker speaker closy has also said that as soon as the new Administration come comes in they're going to replenish that fund so I think it'll be I think it'll be okay but certainly if you have the opportunity to
8:56to express to anyone in DC or in the Press the importance of developing clean energy vehicles please take the opportunity to do so in the case of Tesla you Tesla actually is not applying for any bailout funds although some of the press have mistaken that what what Tesla has done is applied for funding to develop lower cost Mass Market vehicles and essentially the exact intent of the legislation and so hopefully there's little of money left over to do to actually do that after the big three have taken what they what what they will take so and the the Tesla Roadster I
9:40think a lot of people are familiar with that that's the two-seater sports car in fact my my car which is production unit one is is parked outside if anyone's curious to see it there's there's also Tesla sales and service center on Santa Monica Boulevard so if you want to pop in and take a look at the car at that time you're also welcome to do so and we're about to deliver our 100th production Tesla next week and that's interestingly enough the our 100th customer is Sam Perry if if anybody watched the the
10:13when Obama won and an opro was crying on some guy's shoulder that same guy is 100th customer so he's B like zelic I mean he's sort of everywhere so anyway he's he's a really great guy and lives in in the Bay Area he's going to take delivery of his car on Tuesday so I'm going to hand him the keys personally and U thank for being a customer so and you know there's an important point about Tesla which is whenever somebody buys the the Tesla Roadster even though it's a $100,000 $19,000 sports car and it's kind of a fancy sports car every penny that Tesla makes goes into development of lower cost Mass Mar Vehicles so the company doesn't issue any dividends nor will it
11:01ever you my my salary is minimum wage you know so I'm a volunteer basically so and you know it's it's it's just an important point because sometimes people think well gee what's the point of making these these expensive cars which are sort of toys for rich people how's that really helping the environment the the important point to bear in mind is that when you have new technology it takes time to optimize that technology if you think back to the early days of cell phones or laptops or or pretty much anything new it's expensive in the early days because the first job with a new technology is you got to make it work and and you make it at small volume you
11:41sell those cars but if you critical point is that you can't get to the lowcost cars unless you start with the expensive cars and and that's that's a point that sometimes Li anyway that's enough on Tesla I'll jump into the space stuff and I'll kick it off with our last flight video fuel valve set got
12:09[Music] it triggered water system so this is actually on a remote tropical island we launched our small rocket the Falcon 1 from an island in the quadrine atle so it feels a bit nefarious to be launching rockets for remote cocel Islands yeah feel a bit like a Vine Bon in this case it's basically just a dummy satellite so this was basically the test flight to get to orbit so this is actually our fourth flight so the flight's two and three made it to space but they didn't make it all the way to orbit and it's actually a lot harder to get to orbit than it is to get to space you can get the space just by getting going up to Mark 3 but to get to orbit you get to you have to have
13:04a minimum of Mark 25 and that doesn't actually explain the full difficulty because the the energy scales with the square of the Velocity so getting Space 9 units of energy getting to orbit 625 units of energy it's about 70 times harder to get to orbit than to get to space and that's why there's only been about half a dozen countries in the world that have actually reached over it so this is actually the first completely privately developed rocket to to reach orbit and also the first privately developed liquid fuel rocket to reach orbit oh this is it's named this is the Falcon one it's named Falcon after the Millennium Falcon from Star Wars looks nothing like it
13:56but you got it so the music in the background is a high roller from The Crystal Method separation actually with with rockets the only semi- reusable rocket in the world right now is the space shuttle and I say semi reusable because the main tank is actually thrown away every time so typically well really almost in all cases Rockets are not covered they basically re-enter and kind of either burn up or or crash into the ocean and sink to the bottom type of thing now with Falcon 1 our intent is to recover the first stage which unfortunately we weren't able to do in this fight the the the cemetry coming down showed that that the it didn't have enough
14:48thermal protection so it actually ended up burning up we need to increase the the thermal protection the the field is is a high Pur kerosene so it's like sort of a very clean form of jet fuel basically with with no Sul content it's not the greenest thing in the world but we do buy lots of carbon oxide
15:18so it's 9 degrees north latitude yeah exactly we're making use of the the earth rotation to help with the insertion velocity well the only way to go up and stay up is is to reach orbit the the gravity is actually almost the same Force at say 200 mil above Earth's surface as it is on the on the surface of the Earth the the only reason people seem to be sort of floating around but actually what's happening is they're zooming around the Earth Earth super fast and the the the outward acceleration is equal to the inward acceleration of gravity and so when that's neutralized you have what appears to be zero gravity but you're actually just sort of falling around the
16:10earth do you want space junk all the to we've not encountered any any space junk issue the it's although there's been a lot of launches up there and and been issues like the where the Chinese blow uper satellite and Scattered bits all over the place it's so big up there that the statistical chance of of being hit is Tiny but but for things which are which carry people like the space station and our and our Dragon spacecraft they actually have micr meteorite Shields so they can take a high impact which essentially a high-speed bullet coming at it I know this is a pretty big picture but what's the bigger picture that this ah the bigger picture very good
16:54question so the reason I started SpaceX was because the the cost and reliability of getting to getting to orbit and and Beyond is not really improved since the' 60s in fact it's gotten worse so and if you look at the trajectory over time it's not an improving trajectory if you would extrapolate that the cost directory and Steve could tell could could affirm that if if you would extrapolate to the Future you would basically be able to afford no launches at some point because it just it's actually was getting more and more expensive so I I started SpaceX to to Really reverse that Trend and make make it affordable to get to to over it and Beyond the the
17:37huge breakthrough that SpaceX aspires to to to achieve and this is a very difficult thing is to make a fully reusable orbital launch vehicle so with Falcon 1 the first stage is intended to be reusable with Falcon 9 both stages are are intended to be reusable now it's going to take us many launches to figure that out and get the stages back safely and optimize the refurbishment for flight and make sure they're reliable and all that but that's that's the that's sort of the big tech tech technal breakthrough waiting for and you can imagine in any mode of Transport if you had a reusable vehicle or an Expendable vehicle it it would be a night and day difference I mean how
18:16many people would would have driven here if their car was single use yeah or or or even and that applies to any M of Transport bicycles horses planes you know really pretty much anything so we've got this weird situation in space where Vehicles can only be used once in fact you want to return Journey you got to like tow one behind you so that's
18:39what we're aspiring to it's it's a tough goal we're not saying we we can achieve it but we're we're aspiring to achieve that and I I think we will but to explain why that's so difficult when when an orbital rocket is after they they've really optimized the the the weight of the rocket and used the most advanced materials and the engines are incredibly efficient and you've pushed everything to the maximum you typically get about 3% of the liftoff weight to orbit so if you make even a small mistake in the design you know if you give 3% off you you know got nothing so and that's for for expandable single use Rockets where they're not trying to make the the the rocket robust
19:29enough to have multiple flights they're not trying to make it robust enough to re-enter safely it doesn't have to have heat shields and all all that that other stuff so when you add in all those things if that exceeds 3% well you're getting nothing to Orit so so to make it reusable and
19:46still deliver a useful payload is extraordinarily difficult and and no one has ever succeeded in doing that so once you streamline application what does that for right so I'm getting I'll get so the the why essentially sorry I should I should I actually you're right I should perceive this with the why and then and then the how
20:14no I I take things for granted being in a space business but so I'm a huge believer in the extension of life beyond Earth so making life multiplanetary I think is is one of the most important things we could do so why why is that important well how do you how do you say that anything is important how do you judge importance well if you look at things on an historical time scale and the further you zoom out more the important stuff stays behind and the unimportant stuff you can't see it anymore and if you look at the the span of of life's Evolution on Earth you know the multi-billion year history of Earth itself of life on Earth itself you can really point to
20:57about about half a dozen major steps on on the evolution of life there's obviously single cell life multicellular life differentiation to plants and animals life moving from the oceans to land mammals Consciousness you know those are sort of like the big ones and that's why we're here talking and on that scale also
21:28would fit I think the extension of life to multiple planets so life becoming multiplanetary it would be at least as important if not more important than life going from the oceans to land you at least oceans to land you could jump back in the ocean if you got uncomfortable but going to another planet you've got to go of a you know billions of miles of of hostile space and then land and try to create an ecology on a planet that is nothing like the planet that that we live on on today well it might current Planet may become more like that planet we not careful but you know that's so so if you have something which arguably could fit on the important scale of the
22:12evolution of life itself then it's it's reasonable to say it's important and should get some of our resources and they say well what is some of our resources well probably like you know less than what we spend on Medicare and more than what we spend on lipstick you know you can sort of bracket it so we
22:33spent a lot on lipstick by the way which I think is great but if you said well maybe we should spend a quarter of a percent of our of our economic product on the extension of life to another planet making life Planet I think that would be like a reasonable number and you know that's you know several tens of billions so we I don't think it could be done for that and but but a critical element is making having that reusable orbital craft so that's the that's the fundamental breakthrough that's necessary for us to be able to afford to do it at a price that is going to be palatable to the
23:23generalu proba look wildest ideas about the fuels that using well my wildest idea about fuels I think longterm you know once we or if we I suppose figure out fusion you're having a fusion if you can have a compact Fusion reactor and that that would be the best energy source and then you need to sort of shoot something out of the back end you know which is basically high energy ion engine powered by a fusion reactor but that's I think that's pretty much about as good as you're going to get I mean theoretically from a physics standpoint sorry gravity a gravity s maybe a solar sale solar yeah solar sale is an option now now the sun doesn't have a lot of
24:16force because if if you stand outside you don't feel yourself getting knocked down by the sun but but so you need a big sale in space and it it can work and it's an option and particularly you know if you had like say a cargo ship going from Earth to Mars where the time of the journey wasn't that big of a deal then that could be actually a good option
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频在 B 站收看UP 主「SpaceX小工」搬运,标题注明带中文字幕
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版