2008年,NASA 想送一名宇航员上国际空间站,得向俄罗斯买一张联盟号(Soyuz)的船票,价格超过 7000 万美元。同一年,马斯克在一场小范围分享会上给出了 SpaceX 的账:假设火箭完全不回收、一次性用完,送一个人上轨道的成本大约是 1500 万美元。
这两个数字摆在一起,差的不只是钱。差的是「美国还有没有能力把人送上天」这件事,究竟由谁来做。
这场分享会放在好莱坞山的一栋房子里,台下坐着投资人、制片人,还有一些想把摄影机送上太空的人。马斯克讲完 Falcon 9 的点火视频,开始回答问题。问题很杂,从太空电梯到绿色燃料,从国会拨款到卫星频谱,回答里藏着的判断比发布会上的 PPT 有意思得多。
一枚火箭点火,推力是一架 747 的四倍
他先放的是几周前刚做完的测试:猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)一级火箭全时长点火。
推力数据是这样的:真空状态接近 100 万磅,大约是波音 747 最大推力的四倍。画面里火焰把整个试车台吞掉,马斯克顺口说了一句,那底下就跟电影《绝世天劫》(Armageddon)里的场景差不多,没人愿意站在试车台底座那儿。
有人问试车台多高,他给了个参照:试车台本身三十英尺,上面架着的箭体一百多英尺,加起来到顶大约 230 到 240 英尺。换算过来七十多米,一栋二十多层的楼。
播放第二段动画时,画面里出现了倒计时音效,他特意打断:这段是给国会看的,所以配了音乐,火箭是模拟的,不是真飞。这种坦白挺有意思,他在推销,但不愿意让人误会。
发射台 40 号,泰坦导弹的老窝
猎鹰9号将从卡纳维拉尔角的 40 号发射台升空。这个台子以前是泰坦(Titan)系列火箭用的。
运力数据:到近地轨道 11 到 12 吨。加上龙飞船(Dragon),一次能坐七个人,和航天飞机一样多。区别在货舱,航天飞机有个巨大的货舱门,龙飞船没有。
七个人这个数字不是随便定的。它意味着美国在航天飞机退役之后,只要 SpaceX 跑通,载人运力不会归零。
现在只运货,载人那一栏还空着
SpaceX 手上这份 NASA 合同的内容是:演示向空间站运送货物,再把实验样品带回地球。
载人是一个选项,写在合同里,但还没被激活。
有人追问这个选项什么时候生效。马斯克的回答很直接:NASA 现在没有这笔钱。这部分属于 COTS 计划(Commercial Orbital Transportation Services,商业轨道运输服务)里的载人选项,拨款还没下来。他把希望寄托在当时正在起草的经济刺激法案上,如果刺激法案里没写进去,那就看 2010 财年的预算案,一般二三月份过。
这里有一个他反复强调的时间差:航天飞机 2010 年退役,NASA 自己的「星座计划」(Ares/Constellation)要到 2015 或 2016 年才可能成型。中间那五六年,如果 SpaceX 不成,美国就没有把人送上轨道的能力。
六百人,三个律师
有人问他法务团队多大。三个律师。
整个 SpaceX 六百人。他补了一句,真正的麻烦不是律师造成的,是监管。工程师得自己去满足那些合规要求,因为要去空间站,SpaceX 必须达到和航天飞机同等的监管标准,某些方面比俄罗斯人自己的规矩还严。
问到技术传承,他说公司里不少人来自 NASA 和 JPL(喷气推进实验室),大概占工程师总数的 5% 到 10%。其余的招聘来自大型航空航天企业,也来自航天圈外的公司。
这个构成值得留意。一支六成以上来自圈外的队伍,做出了一个推力四倍于 747 的火箭。航天这件事的门槛,可能没行业内部以为的那么高。
他买了维珍银河的票,但两家不在一个量级
有听众问起维珍银河(Virgin Galactic)。马斯克说布兰森(Richard Branson)是他朋友,他自己也买了一张票。外界总以为两家在竞争,其实不是一回事。
维珍做的是亚轨道飞行,飞船的能量不到 SpaceX 火箭的 2%。
这个 2% 是关键。亚轨道是「上去一下、马上掉下来」,几十分钟的失重体验,垂直高度刚过一百公里。轨道是「横向速度足够快,快到永远掉不到地面」。两者需要的能量差了一个数量级还多,技术难度也不在同一个维度。
把这两件事放在一起比较,就像把跳伞和登月放在一起比较。
太空电梯:先造一座碳纳米管天桥再说
有人问太空电梯靠不靠谱。马斯克先开了个玩笑,说他脑子里浮现的总是《查理和巧克力工厂》里那部电梯。
然后他认真解释了这个设想:一根四万到六万英里长的缆绳,一端固定在赤道地面,另一端甩到太空深处。地球在自转,缆绳被离心力绷直,你就顺着它往上爬。
问题一箩筐。最硬的那个是材料,需要碳纳米管级别的超高强度材料。
在我们造出一座碳纳米管人行天桥之前,我觉得不该花太多心思去想怎么建一座六万英里高的电梯。(马斯克)
他给的判断是:这件事本世纪内看不到。
还有一层他顺带点出来的逻辑,很多人忽略:就算电梯建成了,你到了缆绳顶端,还是得换一艘飞船去别的地方。电梯只负责把你送出重力井最费劲的那一段,剩下的路,火箭照样得造。
而且,太空电梯要成立,前提是天上已经有海量的商业活动在跑。需求先到,基建才可能跟。反过来的顺序在工程史上没几次成功过。
火箭烧的煤油,和一架客机差不多
有听众问有没有更环保的燃料方案。
马斯克说液氢液氧是个不错的选择,但有个前提问题:制氢消耗的能量,通常比提炼煤油消耗的能量更多。如果这些电来自太阳能,那确实更干净。
接着他抛了个反直觉的数字,用来缓解「火箭是环境杀手」的印象:猎鹰9号的煤油装载量,和一架客机差不多。
原因在配比。火箭里三分之二的重量是氧化剂,也就是液氧,只有剩下的部分才是燃料。因为太空里没有空气,氧化剂得自己带。
所以「火箭喷那么多火」的观感,跟它实际烧掉的碳氢燃料量是两回事。你在机场看到的那架飞机,燃料舱里的煤油可能还更多。
他自己是 SolarCity 董事长,还是不看好太空太阳能
这个问题是冲着他来的:你既搞太阳能又搞火箭,为什么不做一个太空太阳能电站?
如果这世界上有人应该热爱太空太阳能,那个人就是我。我是 SolarCity 的董事长和最大股东,我还有一家火箭公司,这组合简直完美。(马斯克)
然后他说,可惜这事不成立。
他的推演是这样的:先做一个极端假设,把太阳能板送上太空的运费算成零,一分钱不收。即便这样,账还是算不过来。
因为天上得有一套设备把电能转成微波或者其他形式的能量束,地面上还得有一套设备把微波转回电。这两套设备的资本开支一算进来,成本立刻被甩出竞争圈,完全打不过地面光伏。
所以他给了一句很干脆的评语:连想都不用想。
这段值得多停一下。一个人同时握着光伏公司和火箭公司,理论上最有条件把这条产业链打通,他给出的结论却是「不划算」。判断的落脚点是转换设备的资本成本,不是发射成本。很多人讨论太空太阳能时盯着发射价格,方向从一开始就偏了。
2010 年之后的五年空窗
有人问美国在载人航天上落后多少。
马斯克的回答把范围收窄了:目前能把人送上轨道的,只有中国、俄罗斯、美国三家。中国有自己的载人计划,值得关注。
美国的问题在时间表上。航天飞机 2010 年退役,星座计划要到 2015 到 2016 年。中间有五六年,如果 SpaceX 没跑出来,美国本土没有任何把人送上轨道的手段。
那段空窗期里,唯一能去空间站的方式,是买俄罗斯的座位。
一年五亿美元,买六七张船票
说到这儿他的语气变了。
俄罗斯人现在收我们每人七千多万美元。我们被卡住了脖子,他们下手不轻。(马斯克)
他算了一笔年度账:每年送六到七名宇航员上空间站,光买票就要花掉五亿美元左右。
然后是他真正的诉求:让载人能力落地,SpaceX 需要的是 3 亿美元,一次性投入。
一年五亿,对一次性三亿。
他当然知道这个对比不足以说服人。原话大意是:我以为这是明摆着的选择,但华盛顿那些明摆着的事,不一定能走通。
这里能看出 2008 年的 SpaceX 处在什么位置。技术验证在推进,商业合同在手里,但载人那一栏的钱卡在国会。一家公司能不能活下来,取决于一份刺激法案里有没有一行字。
从机库到升空,目标是六十分钟
有人问技术之外还有什麼障碍。
马斯克提到的是发射频率。火箭行业的常态是一年飞几十次就算多,他想要的是一天飞十次。
猎鹰9号的一个设计指标:从机库里推出来到升空,60 分钟以内。
这个数字放在当时的火箭行业里近乎荒谬。常规流程是几周的准备、几天的加注、几个小时的倒计时,任何一步出问题就整体推倒重来。
他也承认,要达到这个节奏得飞很多次。但设计阶段就必须把地基打好,让结构上有可能做到一小时一发。
发射频率是所有成本问题的总开关。一枚火箭如果一年只能飞一次,它的制造成本、人工成本、地面设施成本全都要摊在那一次任务上。一天飞十次,单次成本才可能接近燃料钱。可复用、快速周转,是马斯克从 2008 年就在算的同一笔账。
两万两千英里外的那颗英国广播卫星
业务结构他讲得很清楚,分两条线。
给 NASA 的那条线:猎鹰9号加龙飞船,送货去空间站,再把实验样品带回来。
商业那条线:猎鹰9号单独当运载火箭,送对地观测卫星、通信卫星、广播卫星。
具体订单也有了:次年底要发一颗英国的广播卫星,目的地是地球同步轨道,高度两万两千英里。
这个高度意味深长。近地轨道是几百公里,两万两千英里是它的几十倍。能把卫星送到那儿并精确入轨,说明火箭的上面级能力和入轨精度都经得住考验。对一个还在做首次发射的公司来说,这是相当激进的排期。
谁在管太空
有人问卫星由谁控制。这个问题其实混了三件事。
频谱归国际电信联盟(ITU)管,这是联合国的机构。想广播、想占带宽,得从 ITU 拿许可。
只是想把东西送上去,不需要 ITU,向本国政府申请就行。在美国,商业或非政府任务由联邦航空管理局(FAA)管。
至于军方任务,军方自己想怎么干就怎么干。NASA 的任务,NASA 自己想怎么干就怎么干。
他补了一句关键的:全球层面并没有一个统一的航天监管机构,ITU 只管频谱这一件事。
这句话在 2008 年听起来像吐槽,十几年后回头看更像预言。轨道资源、频段资源、太空碎片,这些都缺一个真正有执行力的规则制定者。
推进剂的成本低到可以忽略
最后一个问题问的是燃料价格对发射成本的影响,他借机算了笔账。
如果假设火箭能完美翻修、运营成本归零,那么一次发射的底线成本就是推进剂本身。猎鹰9号的燃料加氧化剂,总共二十万美元上下。小火箭猎鹰1号,三到四万美元。
这一点很值得记住。一枚几千万美元的火箭,烧掉的燃料钱只有二十万美元。剩下的钱全在硬件、人工、测试、地面设施、保险和利润里。
所以「油价上涨会不会推高发射成本」这个问题,答案几乎是不会。煤油长期看会涨,但在发射成本结构里占比小到可以忽略。液氧更便宜,它的成本基本就是电费,因为空气压缩液化就完事了。
换句话说,火箭发射贵,贵在一次性把几千万美元的精密 hardware 扔进海里。这就是可复用要解决的事。
回到那笔账
整场问答里,被反复提到的数字只有几个:7070 万美元一张联盟号船票,五亿美元一年,三亿美元一次性投入,1500 万美元一个人的 SpaceX 成本估算,二十万美元的推进剂。
这些数字拼起来是一幅很清晰的图:航天贵,贵在一次性消耗硬件,贵在极低的发射频率,贵在没有第二条路可走。
2008 年的 SpaceX 还没把猎鹰9号送上天,龙飞船还在图纸和车间里。马斯克在好莱坞山的一间房子里,对着几十个人讲一天飞十次、一小时周转、1500 万美元一个人。这些话在当时听上去像许愿。
十六年后再看,猎鹰9号的单枚火箭已经飞过二十多次,周转时间压缩到几周,龙飞船成了美国往返空间站的唯一载具。当年那些「荒谬」的数字,大部分兑现了。
但有些判断没变。太空太阳能至今不成立,太空电梯连一座碳纳米管人行天桥都还没造出来。他的预测不是全对,只是每次都会把账算给你看。
如果你想把这些判断用起来
这场问答的信息密度不在结论,在推演方式。有几件事可以直接搬到自己的工作里。
- 碰到「某件事太贵所以做不了」的结论,先把成本拆开看结构。火箭的例子摆在这儿:燃料只占千分之几,钱全在一次性硬件上。拆对了结构,才知道该攻哪一环。
- 看到「把 X 搬到太空就解决了」这类设想,先补上转换和接收两端的资本开支。马斯克否掉太空太阳能,不是因为发射贵,是因为天上地下的转换设备太贵。很多方案死在没人算的第二个环节。
- 评估一个新方案时,先问「前提条件成立了没有」。太空电梯的大前提是天上有海量商业活动,没有这个需求密度,六万英里的缆绳建了也是白建。
- 面对「长期主义」式的宏大项目,找那个可以当下验证的最小指标。他没有去论证电梯能不能造,他问的是:你造得出碳纳米管人行天桥吗。
- 跟体制打交道时,把一次性投入和每年的持续性支出摆在一起比。三亿对一年五亿,这个对比方式比任何技术论证都好懂。说服人靠换算,不靠参数。
- 如果你在做一件「行业里没人相信能成」的事,注意 SpaceX 的人员构成:六成以上来自圈外。行业共识往往是被外来者打破的,因为外来者不知道哪些规矩是不能碰的。
0:00can you talk about the camera yeah it's it's I mean it's it's pretty simple I mean I feel hold on all the F questions do the combined Q&A because I think that's what we should do if you want to ask in general you know questions about the company about space travel whatever let's get those out of the way and then you know we'll do his presentation then Steve and then we can get them both on and talk about filming in space and that topic absolutely and let me jump to some some new additional videos that I've got
0:35so this is our this is our big rocket the Falcon 9 that I was talking about that we aspired to make fully reusable this is the first stage firing of the [Music] [Applause] Falcon full duration yeah just like a few few weeks ago yeah so this is almost a million pounds of thrust in vacuum which is about four times the maximum thrust of a 747 and U it's pretty much all the it's Armageddon down there you don't want to be standing at the base of that test stand tell them how tall the test stand is give them scale sure the test stand is couple hundred ft well the test stand itself is like 30 ft tall and then there's about 100t tall stage on top of
1:33it so it's like 230 or 240 ft approximately to the top and now jump into so this is like intended for congress that's why it's got this music 9 8 7 [Music] so Falcon 9 will launch from out pad at Cape Canaveral that's a Launchpad 40 at Cape canaval which used to house the Titan for this is not real by the way this is
2:21simulation so the contract SpaceX has right now is to demonstrate cargo transfer to the space station and return of experiments to Earth and what we're hoping NASA will exercise is an option on that contract to also carry astronauts and I think they will exercise that option fairly soon
2:57you mean people or [Music] yeah well Falcon 9 can carry about roughly 11 to 12 tons to Orit and then with in our Dragon spacecraft we can carry seven people so we the same number of people as the space shuttle carries but of course we don't have the giant C Bay when will when will that option become valid for the the man portion yeah it's it's it's n going to exercise it right now there isn't currently funds there aren currently funds appropriated for what's called cart D which carts is commercial orbital transportation services option D which is B but in the stimulus bill that's been crafted we're hopeful that there will be a portion of the stimulus bill that will
3:56include money for cutd how big is your legal team like three lawyers SpaceX as a whole is 600 people a legal red tape dating or there's quite a lot of Regal yeah a lot of legal red tape there's also a lot of regulatory stuff that has which isn't done by the lawyers it's just it's done by the engineers who have to comply with the the regulations because in order for us to go to the space station we have to meet the same regulatory requirements that the space shuttle does or that the Europeans or or or actually more than the Russians do the Russians are they have their own rules what how much did you draw upon the existing retired
4:44engine we have actually a lot of people at space Tex that that used to work at NASA or JPL so I'm not sure the exact percentage but it's you know maybe 5 to 10% of our Engineers we also hire a lot of people our school and from also from you know the big aerospace companies and from companies that are not in the space
5:08Arena yeah virgin Fran is a friend of mine and I've actually bought a ticket on Virgin Galactic people often think we're competing but but that's not the case because virgin is really just going to space they're doing subal flights so the energy of the Virgin ship is only it's less than 2% of the energy of our vehicle your opinion on elevator space is that realistic you know I always lik Charlie in the Chocolate Factory I think that's where the idea comes from I do yeah no
5:48[Music] basically yeah so the space elevator the idea is you have this really long cable like really long I mean it's sort of like anywhere from 40 to 60,000 Mi long and and it's with the ends way out in space and the bases on the earth and you can imagine like the Earth is this ball rotating and you've got this like cable trailing you know out and it's sort of you know the there are a lot of issues with the space elevator
6:23and this like issues and I mean this is H it it also does rely on on super strong materials carbon Nano tubes and you know until we build say a carbon anit tube foot Bridge then I think we should not really be thinking too much about building a 60,000 M elevator and it's possible that somebody May figure out how to how to do it a space elevator and make it workable at some point in the future but there's got to be a huge amount of business going to space before that's that's feasible and then of course you get to the end of the elevator but then that's then you got to go somewhere from there so there's got to be a spacecraft that picks you up at
7:06the end of at the end of the elevator anyway so the elevator is just sort of getting you out of that that initial portion of the gravity well it's not you know not this Century are there any fuel options that are Greener well the you know you could use hydrogen and oxygen that's that's not a bad choice although you know typically the energy required to create the hydrogen is is more energy than was used to get the the kerosene so but
7:39if you in principle if you were to make hydrogen with solar panels that would be a Greener way to do it but it's it's although we you know rock the rocket is pretty big and and what not it's it's actually good about the kosene load of of an airliner because 2/3 of the rocket is actually oxidizer oxygen so that's it's you know think of it like it's an airline flight do you have any plans to create something that combines your interest in solar energy and collection of solar energy on the rockets and orbits you mean like space solar power you know if there's anyone in the world who should love space space solar power it's me because I'm chairman
8:27and the largest shareholder of a of a Solar called Solar City and I've a rocket company so it's going to be like perfect that's unfortunately I think don't think space solar power is makes sense I wish it did because that'd be awesome but the you know even if you assume it costs zero to transport the solar panels to space when you take into account the equipment that's necessary to convert the the the energy to say microwaves or some other Beam Beam form of energy and then you got to have equipment on the ground that converts the microwaves back to electricity just when you take that Capital cost into account you're immediately blown out of the water and
9:09it's not competitive with with terrestrial solar power so there's no point in even thinking about it how far behind are we from other countries is anybody else doing any place on the planet with with with SPX well the the Chinese are have a pretty interesting manspace program I mean right now there's there's really just the the Chinese the Russians and the US that send people to over and the the space shutt is retiring in 2010 so unless unless ourcraft is active the US will not have the ability to send people to orbit there is a longer term program that NASA's got called Aries Ryan project which is due to be finished around 2015 or 2016 and that's intended to be part of a system
9:58that takes us back to the Moon but for about five or six years there unless SpaceX is successful there will be no American man space capability so there'll just be the Russians who are charging us C right now that you see the this is this is really awful the Russians are charging us over $70 million per seat to go to after after the shuttle retires I mean they like they got us over battle R and they're doing us hard I mean it's really rough I mean we'll spend half a billion dollars per year on on the Russians just buying tickets for Six astronauts six or seven astronauts to go to the space station per year but if if we're you know if we're ready in time and I think
10:38we can be then U you know that that won't happen out cost per per person even with assuming no reusability assuming that every bit of it is expended and no refurbishment or reusability is about 15 million per per person and it's us and you know the jobs are here and all that sort of stuff so I think it's kind of Nob brainer but no-brainers in Washington DC don't always you so what has been the response from Congress the generally generally enthusiastic but well there's yeah I mean I don't know Hollywood have amazing saying no money there's like so many different words but really they haven't given you any money well we've been given money for for the cargo portion but not the
11:30not the not for the man portion and but I I you know I'm hopeful like said that the stimulus bill will actually include the funds for the man space light activity if it's not in this in the stimulus bill I think it's quite likely that'll be in the financial year f 10 Bill which is will get approved around the February or March time frame so the government financial year starts in October so so I'm optimistic it's
12:00going to happen it's just question of what time scale and for every year that we're dependent on the Russians we we have to send them half billion dollars so and and the amount that we're asking for to get this done is $300 million so I know just it seems kind of ludicrous but anyway that's DC yeah so you you you've never
12:21you've never had a mission go off is what you're saying you have we've done Falcon one which is our small our small rocket we'll be doing our first launch of our big rocket with our Dragon spacecraft next year and that there'll be two flights next year one's demonstration flight and one one's a NASA flight and then there are two more NASA flights after that and then there's people in those or no no because we've not had the the the the crew portion of our contract has not been turned on okay so you're saying you're hoping to get the 300 million to be able to yeah to basically add the incremental crew capability and most of that money is for demonstrating the system reliability
12:59once have the technology what prevents launes well 10 launches a day would be super fast for rockers we need we do need to get to the point where we can do 10 launches a day and one of the design goals for Falcon 9 is that it can go from in the hanger to in the air in under 60 minutes which would be super super fast for a rocket particularly a big rocket now it's going to take several flights before before we get there but as long as we lay lay the the the foundation make sure that the design is capable of that then we can at least have the the possibility of getting to you know a flight an hour or or so in future is your cargo telecomunication
13:45satellites or deliver theace station well for for NASA our current NASA missions are just for delivery of cargo the space station return of experiments to Earth for Falcon 9 just so Falcon booster and then there's Dragon spacecraft Dragon spacecraft goes to the space station a falconite booster Carri satellites and it'll do Earth observation satellites and it'll do communication satellites forecast satellites that kind of thing so we're launching a UK broadcast satellite towards the end of next year a geostationary satellite so that that really goes pretty far out there 22,000 miles altitude are there sort of developing
14:38control yeah so there's few questions bound up there like who who controls the satellites the satellites generally are if a satellite is broadcasting then that broadcast spectrum is controlled by the international T Communications unit so that's kind of a un body I think yeah you have to get permission from the itu to get broadcast to get bandwidth to just go up there all you need is permission from your national government and in the US if it's a commercial or non-government Mission the fa the FAA governs it if it's a military Mission the military does what they whatever they want and then if it's NASA NASA does whatever they want so who regulates all
15:23that there really isn't a global the only Global regulatory Authority is the international te Communications Union and that just governs Spectrum how much itel seever yeah well that's a good question because that sets the minimum cost of of a mission if you had perfect refurbishment and had no operations cost the the the the the fuel and and oxidizer cost is is is really super low it's for our big rocket it's only a couple hundred, for our small rocket it's about $3 or $40,000 so it's if you just look at the propellent cost it's very very
16:14cheap I wouldn't say going down but yeah I think the the cost of kerosene which is you know jet fuel is going to go up over time but I think it's not going to be a big factor for rocket launch costs and the cost of liquid oxygen is just really the cost of electricity because you can just compress and liquefy air
16:37all right well good yeah I think that's it so thank you very [Applause] much all right so we're going to have a quick quick quick break and if anybody if you guys want to try and find seats now would be a good [Music] time all right for bathrooms if anybody needs a restroom there's one in the poolhouse so you go outside this glass door and then into the back and it's right there and then there's one in the front if you need it
17:39[Music] gotop my [Music] so much [Music] here make oh my God [Music]
19:28all [Music] h [Music] I [Music] per so [Music] guys [Music]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版