访谈·中文精读

马斯克 2021 WSJ 访谈:Tesla、Neuralink、Starship、中国与政府角色

Elon Musk 2021 WSJ Interview - Tesla, Neuralink, Starship, China, Government's Role

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2021 年 WSJ CEO 峰会上,主持人抛出一个假设:如果拜登明天给马斯克打电话,说「我最近很少提特斯拉,你需要这项基建法案给你什么」,你怎么回答。

马斯克的回答是,说实话,特斯拉可能压根没人讨论过这事。

这项法案通过还是不通过,我们可能完全不在意。(马斯克)

他紧接着补了一句更狠的:坦率讲,它不通过可能更好。

理由是几个数字。美国联邦支出大约 7 万亿美元,联邦收入大约 4 万亿,中间差 3 万亿。

如果这是一家公司,那就是每年亏 3 万亿美元。我们该往这个亏损上再加钱吗?这看起来相当疯狂。(马斯克)

他说,不能每年花掉比收入多 3 万亿的钱,还指望不出事。「总有一方要让步。」

主持人提到,麦康奈尔说过类似的话,语气没这么极端。那如果总统接着问:美国基础设施最该改的是什么?

马斯克的答案是机场、高速公路,以及城市拥堵。他的方案挺具体:双层高架,加上挖隧道。他明确表示不看好飞行汽车。

飞行汽车本质上就是带轮子的直升机,人们不希望天上挤满直升机。(马斯克)

这里面有一条他反复强调的因果链。自动驾驶会普及,开车变得不痛苦,于是路上车会更多,拥堵会更严重。所以得提前动手挖隧道、修双层路。

自动驾驶汽车上路,会是人类文明有史以来最大的转变之一。到时候路上的车会更多,交通会糟糕得多。(马斯克)

他还顺手给了个判断:郊区没有交通问题,问题都在高速公路上,因为路修得太窄,当年设计的人没预料到今天的车流规模。

补贴这件事,他的立场比很多人想的更彻底

主持人把话题引到电动车补贴。这项法案里有大量支持电动车的条款,可能帮到特斯拉。

马斯克先纠正了一个流传很广的说法。7500 美元的购车税收抵免,特斯拉两年前就拿不到了,因为销量超过门槛。今年和去年的销售跟这笔抵免没关系。除了通用汽车,其他厂商还在拿。

然后他给了一个数据:特斯拉造了美国大约三分之二的电动车,差不多是其余所有厂商加起来的两倍。

我不确定大多数人知道这一点。(马斯克)

他还还原了这笔补贴的来源。特斯拉创业早期,市场上根本没有电动车补贴,汽油也便宜得很。那笔 7500 美元抵免不是特斯拉争取来的,是通用汽车游说的结果。

所以他的建议是:

老实说,把整个法案砍掉,别通过,这是我的建议。(马斯克)

主持人追问,那充电网络的补贴呢?法案里有一部分钱是给充电桩的。

马斯克:不需要。加油站需要补贴吗?不需要。充电网络也不需要,删掉。

他补了一句,如果要删,就连石油和天然气的补贴一起删。主持人问这样会不会影响竞争对手,他说也许对手需要,但总体上他支持删除所有补贴。

主持人又试了一次,说法案里还有很多研发经费,要不要把这部分留下。马斯克回答就一个字:不。

政府是家没有对手、也不会破产的公司

主持人问起他一年前在同一场合说过的话:政府该对创新放手。那政府到底该扮演什么角色。

马斯克给了一个比喻。

政府应该当裁判,不是上场的球员。(马斯克)

他真正想讲的,是监管的累积效应。规则和法规每年都在增加,但几乎不会消失。

法规是不死的。除了极少数带日落条款的法律,绝大多数规则会永远存在。(马斯克)

他的推理是这样的:每年新增一批规则,旧的又不清理,日积月累,做事越来越慢、越来越难。他用了一个生物学比喻,说这会让「文明的动脉硬化」,时间越久,能做的事情越少。

他还说,这套系统缺一个有效的「垃圾回收机制」,专门用来删掉那些曾经有道理、现在没道理的规则。他看不到有人在往这个方向努力。

不过他没有走到极端。他承认有些事只能政府做。比如往火星发射探测器,全体公民各出 10 美元来凑钱,收钱本身就不划算,这种事交给政府更合理。大型科研项目属于这一类。

所以他的定位是:把政府该做的事压到最少,因为政府花钱的效率比竞争性商业公司低,而且低很多。

他举了两个例子:东德和西德,朝鲜和韩国。同一条线,被红军和盟军的位置随手划开,几十年后人均 GDP 差距巨大。东德的生产率至少比西德差五倍。而西德本身也不算资本主义堡垒,相当偏社会主义。

竞争性私营公司和政府之间的效率差距,可能有一个数量级。(马斯克)

主持人换了个角度,假设他被选进国会,负责税收政策,他会怎么给亿万富翁征税。

马斯克先报了自己的情况:边际税率大约 53%,不算低。然后他提到遗产税,说这是一项好税。

他的论证是:超过某个量级的资产,早就超出了个人消费能力,那些钱实际在做资本配置。把资本配置的职责,从已经被证明擅长这件事的人手里拿走,交给一个被证明很不擅长这件事的机构,说不通。

政府可以理解成一家公司,在极限情况下它就是最大的那家公司,垄断暴力,而且你没法退货。(马斯克)

主持人让他解释「没法退货」是什么意思,他接着往下说:政府是终极形态的公司,是垄断的,还是唯一被法律允许使用暴力的机构。一家没有竞争、也不会破产的公司,你为什么想给它更多钱。

他补了一句,这不是说政府不该存在。有些事必须由政府做。他只是主张把政府的规模压到最小。

CEO 是编出来的头衔,他把自己改成了 Techno King

主持人问,特斯拉的工作量一直很大,他有没有想过重新拿回董事长位置,或者调整自己的头衔。

马斯克的回答绕到了公司法。

一家公司里法律上有意义的头衔只有三个:总裁、秘书、财务主管。技术上,这三个可以是同一个人。其他头衔基本都是编的。CEO 是编的,CFO 是编的,总法律顾问也是编的。(马斯克)

他说自己把正式头衔改成了「Techno King」,还强调这是正式的 SEC 文件,法律上他就是这个名字。改这个纯粹是开玩笑,想说明头衔没什么意义。

他给了一个验证方法:去填一份创建 C 类公司的表格,你会看到只需要总裁、财务主管、秘书,再加一个董事。就这些。

主持人问,那特斯拉机器人有没有可能在未来拿到某个头衔。马斯克说,也许未来。

特斯拉本质上是家机器人公司,车只是四个轮子的那一个

聊到特斯拉机器人(Tesla Bot),马斯克先纠正了外界对特斯拉的定位。

你可以把特斯拉看成世界上最大的机器人公司,或者说半感知机器人公司。车就是四个轮子上的机器人。(马斯克)

他的逻辑是:全自动驾驶在做的事情,本质上是在真实世界里导航的高级实用 AI。把这套技术挪到人形机器人上,机器人就能有用。人形那部分需要自研执行器和传感器,导航那部分直接复用。

这可能会相当深刻。我不确定什么时候能做成,但我们一定会做成。(马斯克)

主持人问这机器人能干什么。马斯克说,长期看,它有可能成为人类劳动的通用替代品。

接下来这段是他整场访谈里最不受欢迎的观点之一。

经济的基础是劳动。资本设备本质上是被蒸馏过的劳动。(马斯克)

他提到一位朋友给他的建议:要优化的指标是每位员工的毛利润,而且要把整条供应链算进去。

然后他把话题拉到人口。

根本的约束是人。人不够。我怎么强调这一点都不为过。(马斯克)
我认为文明面临的最大风险之一,是低生育率,而且是快速下降的生育率。(马斯克)

他特意点出了一个反差:很多聪明人也认为世界上人太多、人口增长失控。他的说法完全相反,请去看数字。

如果人们不多生孩子,文明会崩塌。记住我的话。(马斯克)

主持人顺势问:所以你才生那么多孩子?马斯克:我在努力做个好榜样,言行得一致。

12 月 9 日什么都不会发生

访谈中间有个插曲。主持人在 Twitter 上看到有人在猜 12 月 9 日会有什么大事,问马斯克能不能透露。

马斯克说:据我所知什么都不会发生。他不知道这个消息从哪来,猜测是那种凭空冒出来的梗。也许会发生点他不知道的事。

Cybertruck:可能是特斯拉做过最好的产品

接下来是一段 60 秒快问快答,主持人点名项目,马斯克用一分钟说清 2022 年的计划。

Cybertruck 的回答是:

它会是一款了不起的产品,可能是我们做过最好的产品,我认为很可能是。它用了很多新技术,所以是辆难造的车。(马斯克)

量产目标是 2023 年。更详细的产品更新会放在明年年初的特斯拉财报电话会上。他的形容是:那种偶尔才出现一次的稀有产品。

Neuralink:一只看起来完全正常的猴子,用意念打 Pong

Neuralink 的进展,马斯克说得比较具体。设备在猴子身上运行良好,团队做了大量测试,确认安全可靠,也确认设备可以被安全取出。

他提到那年早些时候公布的演示视频:一只猴子用意念玩 Pong。设备完全无线,靠感应充电,猴子看起来完全正常。

一只看起来完全正常的猴子,在用意念打电子游戏。我觉得这相当深刻。(马斯克)

下一步是人体。目标对象是严重脊髓损伤患者,比如四肢瘫痪的人,时间点是次年,同时在准备 FDA 的审批。

这里他加了一句:

我们对植入设备设定的安全标准,明显高于 FDA 的要求。就像特斯拉的安全标准明显高于美国政府的要求一样。(马斯克)

然后他说了那段让主持人放弃掐表的话。

我认为 Neuralink 有机会让脊髓损伤患者恢复全身功能。也就是说,让一个不能走路、不能用手臂的人重新走路。不是自然的方式。(马斯克)

他补了一句限定:不想不合理地抬高期望,但越来越确信这件事能做到。

Starship:把入轨成本砍掉一百倍

最后一个项目是星舰(Starship)。马斯克的语气明显变了。

星舰是一个非常非常难的项目。人类造过的最大火箭,推力和质量是土星五号的两倍。目标是完全、快速可复用。(马斯克)
从来没有完全可复用的入轨运载器。这是太空技术的圣杯。(马斯克)

他还说了一句挺少见的话:这件事消耗他的脑力比任何其他单一项目都多,难到离谱,有时候他会怀疑人类到底能不能做成。

主持人追问,对普通人来说,难在哪。马斯克的解释从物理开始。

地球的引力在太阳系里算强的,大气又厚。一枚典型的入轨火箭,能把大约 2% 的起飞质量送进轨道。聪明人拼命优化,能做到 2% 到 2.5%。历史上从来没有火箭超过 4%。

要做到完全可复用,你得做到 4% 甚至更多。这意味着每个环节都得是 A+:效率极高的发动机,极轻的结构,极轻的隔热罩,助推器和上面级都要能回收。

规模本身带来效率,星舰造这么大就是这个原因。他举了个例子:火箭的「大脑」,也就是航电系统,质量跟火箭大小关系不大。火箭越大,航电占总质量的比例就越接近零。

他还给了一个类比,解释可复用的意义。

如果飞机每次飞完就扔掉,机票会贵得离谱。如果车每开一次就换新的,开车会贵得难以想象。火箭必须走到加注燃料就能再飞。(马斯克)

猎鹰 9 做到了助推器和整流罩复用,上面级没有。星舰希望整支火箭都能复用。如果成功,入轨成本能降 100 倍以上。

这是人类成为单行星物种和多行星物种之间的区别。就这么重大。(马斯克)

他也承认,很多非常聪明的人试过完全复用,没人成功,大多数人在半路就放弃了。

他不希望人类活得太久

主持人聊到幽默,问他上《周六夜现场》的经历有没有影响管理风格。马斯克说自己觉得挺搞笑,讲很多笑话,不是每个都响,但一直在努力。

话题转到年龄。主持人在 Twitter 上看到马斯克经常拿别人的年龄开玩笑,问他有没有对抗衰老的秘密技术。

马斯克的回答很直接:没听说过什么抗衰老的秘密技术,而且他也不确定人类真该活那么久。

人是要死的,这一点很重要。大多数时候,人不会改变想法,他们只是死去。如果我们永生,社会会变得非常僵化,新想法没法胜出。(马斯克)

他解释,自己不是在嘲讽衰老。他的意思是,如果有些人在极关键的岗位上,要做关系到国家安全的决定,他们需要有足够的清醒和认知能力,因为整个国家都靠这些人。

主持人开玩笑,以为他会说迷幻药是抗衰老的办法。马斯克回了一句:我不觉得 LSD 能让人老得慢,可能老得更快。

中国会成为街区里最大的那个孩子

现场观众提了一个问题:怎么看中国和美国。

马斯克先给了一个历史坐标。美国成为世界最大经济体,大概在 120 到 130 年前。今天活着的人,没有谁记得美国不是最大经济体的时代。

我们正在走向一个局面:中国的经济规模可能是美国的两到三倍。那会是一个不同的世界。(马斯克)

他接着讲了一个心态问题。中国政府里有很多人成长于中国还是小经济体的年代,那个年代中国常觉得被推来推去。这批人还没有完全意识到,中国真的会成为街区里最大的那个孩子。

如果你是街区里最大的孩子,你其实可以很淡定。其他国家对你来说不构成真正的威胁。(马斯克)

他的建议是换位思考:如果你将成为最大的那个孩子,你希望最大的孩子怎么表现?那就按那个方式去表现。这是一种重要的心态转变。

谈到特斯拉,他说公司和中国的关系总体不错。他也补了一句边界:

我不打算为中国的每一件事背书,就像我不会为美国的每一件事背书一样。(马斯克)

结尾他说,我们都是人类,尽量保持积极的关系,为全人类的共同繁荣努力。

这场访谈真正在讲什么

把三十分钟拆开看,马斯克其实在讲同一件事的四个版本。

讲监管,他说规则只增不减,文明会动脉硬化。讲财政,他说支出远超收入,总有一方要让步。讲补贴,他说连自己的行业也该一起删。讲政府角色,他说当裁判,别上场。

这四条指向同一个判断:系统的摩擦在变大,而清理摩擦的机制不存在。

另一半内容是关于规模和技术极限的。星舰要突破 4% 这个人类从未越过的门槛,靠的是把每个环节做到 A+,再用规模把边缘成本压到接近零。人形机器人复用的是同一套导航 AI,换的只是执行器。Neuralink 的野心是让瘫痪者重新走路。

还有一条容易被忽略的线索:他不止一次提到「人不够」。劳动力是经济的基础,出生率在快速下降,这是他给文明排的最大风险之一。特斯拉机器人之所以重要,前提就在这里。

至于他自己,头衔改成 Techno King 是玩笑,但他想说的那句不是玩笑:法律上真正有意义的头衔只有三个,其余都是包装。他把时间花在离产线最近的地方,一周七天,哪边有危机就去哪边。这个选择比任何头衔都更能说明他在做什么。

可以带走的几件事

  • 评估任何一项政策或补贴时,先问它在总量上是减少摩擦还是增加摩擦。马斯克反对自家行业拿补贴,理由不是姿态,是他认为这套账长期算不平。
  • 做长周期硬项目,先把物理极限算清楚。星舰的所有设计决策都来自「4% 入轨质量」这个硬约束,不是来自审美偏好。先找到你所在领域的那个 4%,再倒推资源。
  • 组织设计上,把管理和工程放到离产线最近的地方。他在工厂里办公不是作秀,是为了让决策者每天看见真实约束。
  • 面对反直觉的结论,先查数字再下判断。人口问题是最好的例子,主流直觉和统计事实相反,多数人没去核对。
  • 别把头衔当能力证明。真正决定你价值的是你解决了哪个具体的、别人绕不过去的问题。
  • 如果你所在的系统里有大量过时规则,主动做一个「垃圾回收」的动作:每个季度列一遍流程,问它当初为什么存在,现在还成不成立。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01hi hi elon how are you good how are you pretty good pretty good thank you so much for being here and by here i mean electronically and where are you right now i'm at i'm at the tesla gigatexas factory that we're about to complete so yeah what you see behind me is the factory basically we have the office space and the factory kind of together so i think this is kind of important that we don't have ivory tower management or engineering and that the management engineering is as close to the factory as possible so yeah so you can see what's going on in the factory and and stay grounded all right well i'm in the ivory tower here in front of a lot

0:59of ceos and a live audience here in washington dc and we are also joined by lots of people all over the internet we are streaming this wsj.com twitter and youtube so we have a very brief amount of time only 30 minutes but i'm very excited to talk about a wide range of things i want to start with talking about our world the world we currently live in we currently live in then i want to move to the future of the world and then talk a little bit about your world and so we'll start right here in washington dc where everyone is talking about the infrastructure plan and the bill and i wanted to ask you you say tomorrow you get a phone call from joe biden and he

1:39says i think that's unlikely but sure you know he he just gives you a call and he says you know i haven't been talking a lot about tesla lately but you know what do you what do you need from this bill what are your needs what do you answer him well i i i mean to be totally frank i'm i i i don't know if we at least no one at tesla is actually just brought up whether they they care about this will or not i i think if this bill happened or didn't happen i i don't know we don't think about it at all really okay it might be better honestly it might be better if the bill doesn't pass because we've spent so much money you know it's like the the the federal budget deficit is

2:26insane you know it's like three trillion dollar the federal expenditures are seven trillion federal revenue is four trillion that's a three trillion dollar difference in if this was a company it'd be a three trillion dollar loss so i don't know if we should be adding to that loss that seems pretty crazy something's gotta give you can't just spend three trillion dollars more than your own every year and expect you know don't expect something bad to happen i i think you know this is not good well mitch mcconnell is actually saying in fact if i may elaborate on that the the deficit is more than three trillion when you look at the future obligations so it's seven trillion of

3:08current expenditures but the it's much more than that if you look at future obligations for social security medicare and so forth so we're running this incredible deficit someone's got to give i i don't know let's just can't keep going well mitch mcconnell said something similar that it wasn't too not as extreme as you but it just okay so let's say his follow-up question is okay elon you don't think we need to spend anything on the infrastructure if he says to you what is the biggest improvement we can make to the u.s infrastructure what do you what do you what do you what do you say

3:48i i think we generally could have better airports better highways and you know i think that that especially in in cities that are congested we've got to do something to deal with the extreme traffic which i think is some combination of double decorating freeways and building tunnels but if we're going to do something we will be stuck in traffic for forever and as autonomy vehicle autonomous vehicles come to the floor and it's it's easier to drive without going through the pain of of having to ride to drive yourself which which is absolutely coming and will be one of the biggest transformations ever in human civilization there will be more cars on the road

4:46and the traffic will get much worse and so we really need to do some combination of tunnels and or like it's a double decker ring freeways i'm not a big believer in flying cars that they're basically helicopters with wheels and people don't want the eye the skies to be swimming with helicopters so it's it's tunnels and double decorating freeways we don't have a traffic problem in suburbs we have a traffic problem on freeways because they're they were just too small and did not anticipate the size of the open environments they would currently experience so

5:23yeah but i i don't see a strong effort in this direction well i want to come back to autonomous vehicles but i want to just stay a little bit more on the role of government you said at this conference actually a year ago that you think government should really just be hands off when it comes to innovation though with this bill there is a lot of support for evs and it could be the biggest change that we've seen throughout the country in terms of the infrastructure of evs and it helps tesla what do you think the role of government should be i i think the role of government should be that of like a referee and you know like and and but not a player on the

6:07field so generally you know government should i think just try to get out of the way and and not impede progress i think there's a general problem not just in the us but in most countries where the rules and regulations keep increasing every year rules and regulations are immortal they don't die there's not a natural occasionally you see some law with a sunset provision but but really otherwise the vast majority of rules and regulations live forever and so if moral rules and regulations are applied every year and it just keeps growing and growing eventually it just takes longer and longer and it's harder to do things and there's there's not really

6:55an effective garbage collection system for removing rules and regulations and so the gradually the the this hardens the arteries of civilization where you're able to do less and less over time so i think government should be really trying hard to get rid of rules and regulations that perhaps had some merit at some point but don't have merit currently but there's very little effort in this direction this this is a big problem and we i also want to come back to you later i know that you do have some other stance on sort of ai and what the rules and regulations we should have on on that but you're right now you're sitting in a tesla factory where how are you spending your time

7:37these days between the split between spacex and tesla yeah it's about even between spacex and tesla it depends on you know what is the kind of crisis of the moment so some weeks will be more tesla more spacex but i mean i work a lot i work seven days a week and putting put in some pretty crazy hours so but it really depends on on where the where i'm needed most i like basically just i triage the tasks and try to do the things that are most useful or where i'm most needed you know and it varies from from from one week to the next but you know just going back to that infrastructure bill for a second the because sometimes the criticism of tesla is like hey tesla gets all these

8:31subsidies but it's worth noting that for the the vehicle purchase tax credit the 7 500 tesla stopped getting that like two years ago so we've whereas everyone else i think except for gm still gets the 7 500 tax credit so all of our you know sales this year and last year were i had nothing to do with the the the tax credit because we were no longer eligible because we'd made so many electric cars tesla has made roughly two-thirds of all the electric cars in the united states you know i'm not sure most people are aware of that so yeah so tesla's made basically twice as many electric vehicles as the rest of industry combined and we don't need the 7 500 tax credit

9:20i would say honestly i would just can this whole bill don't pass it that's my recommendation what about what about the the support though for the charging network i mean there are there are parts of this bill no no i mean you know do we need support for gas stations but we don't so there's no there's no need for this for support for a charging network i would delete it

9:48okay all right i'm literally saying get rid of all subsidies and but also for oil and gas if you think about also how this affects your competitors is that is that impact how some of your view on this i mean maybe they need it i don't know but i i think just generally i'm in favor of deleting subsidies i mean when we started tesla there were there were no ev subsidies at all and gasoline was super cheap we did not anticipate any subsidies that that came later and and that came the the 7500 tax credit came as a result not a tesla activity but of general motors lobbying for it so you know i would just say just just delete them all all right but there are some other

10:40good things in this bill that some would argue i mean a lot of money earmarked for r d would you want to put that towards something no okay all right all right we're going to move on from the bill because i think we get what you seriously say in general we should just we if we don't cut govern spending something really bad is going to happen this is crazy our spending is so far in excess of revenue it's insane like you could zero out all billionaires in the country this is almost like anti-billionaire bs well if you zeroed out all the billionaires you still wouldn't solve the deficit all right i'll ask you another question around the billionaire

11:19bs say tomorrow we've talked you get the phone call from for president biden next day actually we decide we elect you to congress somehow this happens you're now working on tax bills you're you're working on tax policy what what is how do you tax someone like you how do you tax billionaires i mean first of all i pay a lot of tax i mean my marginal tax rate is like 53 so that's not trivial and you know and then obviously there's like you know asset-based taxes the sales tax and everything else there's also the estate tax and generally i i think i think the the estate tax is is a good tax like if you think of assets beyond a certain level that

12:09that are far beyond let's say somebody's ability to consume then you know at some point really what you're doing is capital allocation so you're not it's not money for personal expenditures it's what you're doing is capital allocation and it does not make sense to take the the job of capital allocation away from people who have demonstrated great skill in capital allocation and give it to you know an entity that has demonstrated very poor skill in in capital allocation which is the government i mean you can think of the government essentially as a corporation in the limit it is it is a the government is simply the biggest corporation with a monopoly

12:49on violence and with and where you have no recoils so how much more you want to give that entity can you explain the last part quickly and then i want to move on to some product stuff sure i mean i can talk for a bit longer if you'd like than the half an hour if you're worried about getting through other questions i hear we have nobody else joining us at this conference yeah i mean government is a corporation in the limit so if you it is the most corporate thing is that it is maximum corporation and it but it's also a monopoly and and also is the only one that's allowed legally to do violence so why why would you want to give a corporation with no

13:41competition that that can't even really go bankrupt more money now it's not as though i think the government shouldn't exist or that they're not good things that the government can do or things that are necessary for the government to do you know for example a you know science programs where you know we send a probe to to mars and the value of that is it's a it's sort of a it's a small amount of value for for all citizens but it would be inefficient to sort of go and collect you know ten dollars from from every citizen for a mars probe and so that therefore it's better to have the government do something like that you know like a heavy science program

14:25rather than try to collect small amounts of money from everyone so so i want somebody who is sort of an extreme libertarian and thinks the government should not do anything i just think we should minimize what the government does because the government's efficiency at spending is is just going to be lower than a a competitive commercial company but by a lot if you look at say east germany versus west germany or north korea vs south korea and you look at the gdp per capita of east and west germany or north and south korea the the difference is gigantic and that's just the difference between east west germany you know it's like a random line was

15:06drawn basically depending on where the the the red army was and where the allied troops were and east germany's productivity was like at least five times worse than west germany and it's not like west germany was like some bastion of capitalism they were quite socialist really so there may be as much as an order of magnitude difference between a the efficiency of of a competitive private company versus the government i'm going to shift away from government come back to your world just just thinking about sort of how you juggle tesla and spacex and you've said along the way that you know the workload at tesla is is quite a lot have you and and i know now you can you could regain

15:50the the chairman position have you thought about that have you thought about that have you thought about your sort of your your title and your and your position there right now i i mean it's interesting that these titles you know that there's there's actually only three legal three titles that actually mean anything for a corporation it's pr president secretary and treasurer and technically they can be the same person and all these other titles are just basically made up so ceo is a made-up title cfo is made up title general counsel made-up title don't mean anything i think a room of ceos are how do we feel about that yep yeah it was like obviously just

16:34somebody's marketing experiment so so i guess i'll be more direct i mean are you considering stepping down as ceo would you would you transfer be chairman and think about being chief product officer i mean since ceo title doesn't matter and i'm like i i changed my title to to techno king and by the way this is a formal sec filing it's i'm legally whatever techno king i just did that as kind of like a joke because just just to show that these titles don't don't mean a lot you can see what what is actually legally necessary if you fill out the form for creating a c portal and then you'll see as president treasurer and secretary they need a director too but that's that's

17:19basically it and then all these other you know chief whatever officer are basically just made up is a tesla bot in the running for any of these titles no yes maybe in the future but but speaking of the tesla bot i i know you've talked about the importance of creating this bot for the future of ai tell me a little bit about where you're at with this project and what we can expect in the next coming months

17:50[Music] well with the tesla autopilot of full self driving we're effectively i think creating the most advanced practical ai for navigating the real world and you can always think of tesla as like the world's biggest robot company or semi-sentient robot company so then you know so the car is kind of a robot on four wheels and and so then well you know we could probably take that same technology and and put it in a humanoid robot and have that rope be useful and you know so essentially for to have the humanoid part we we need to develop some custom actuators and sensors and then essentially use the tesla full self driving or autopilot or just

18:52generally speaking real world navigation ai in in the humanoid robot and i think this could be quite profound i don't know exactly when we'll get we will get this right but we will get it right and you've said also that it will solve some labor issues what are some things that you envision this bot doing well it has the potential to be a generalized substitute for human labor over time and the economy the foundation of the economy is labor i mean capital equipment is essentially distilled labor so i was talking to a friend of mine actually to say you know just like what what what should we optimize for and he what he said was gross profit per employee

19:45full fully considered so you've got to include the supply chain in that the fundamental constraint is labor there are not enough people i can't emphasize this enough there are not enough people and i think one of the biggest risks to civilization is the low birth rate and the rapidly declining birth rate it is and yet so many people including smart people think that there are too many people in the world and think that the population is growing out of control it's completely the opposite please look at the numbers if people don't have more children civilization is going to crumble mark my words is this why you have so many children i'm trying to set a good example

20:29yeah you know gotta practice what i preach i won't ask you to predict how many more children you're going to have tonight but we're i i want to move on to some future talk that's part of where i'm going with this tesla bot i i'm not as good at twitter as you are but people on twitter are asking me what's going to happen on 12 9 can you tell me what's going to happen on 12 9 nothing as far as i know i i don't know where this came from i think this is just one of those memes that i don't know it came out of nowhere but as far as i know nothing but maybe something will happen that i'm not aware of all right so i want to ask now a little bit farther out in the

21:08future into into 2022 and we can't get to all your future projects but i thought a fun way to do this might be i'm going to name some of the projects i'm going to give you 60 seconds and you tell me what your plan is in 2022 to move that project along and what we can expect from it but 60 seconds you only get 60 seconds okay you going to do it all right here we go so the first one is hold on i think i know how to work this apple watch all right 60 seconds and cyber truck cyber truck star truck's gonna be an incredible product i think it's it may it may it may be our our best product ever and i think it probably will be

21:51it has a lot of new technology so it's it's a hard car to make i bet it will be awesome and i think i've said before that you know we're aiming for volume production in 2023 and i will provide a more detailed product update at the tesla earnings call that you know early next year so i wish you could be sooner but that's that's most likely when it happens it'll be something really special you know like just one of those kind of rare product that happens once in a while that's that's really special okay that was about 60 seconds i don't know what's going on with my watch but we're we're on cybertron now we're on to neural link okay okay yeah so no the big question is

22:42in 2022 how are you pushing that project along what happens so neuralink we we have neural links working well in in monkeys and we were actually doing just a lot of testing and and just confirming that it's it's very safe and reliable and and that the neural link device can be removed safely people may have seen the demo that we we published earlier this year with video of a monkey playing the video game pong telepathically using the neural link in its in its in its in its brain and it's completely wireless charges inductively but basically monkey looks completely normal and yet is playing a video game telepathically which is i think quite profound

23:37we will have we hope to have this in our first humans which will be people that have severe spinal cord injuries like tetraplegic quadriplegics next year preparing fda approval and and i should say our standards for implying the device are substantially higher than what the fda requires just as our standards for safety with tesla are much higher than what the us government requires and i'll take a little more than 60 seconds yes i'm about to cut you off because i i think this there's something that's that's i think pretty cool and i i do want to say that i'm i'm very you know emphasis on cautiously optimistic about this i think i think we have a chance with neural

24:28link of being able to restore full body functionality to someone who has a spinal cord injury meaning i think i think we have a chance i have size a chance of being able to allow someone who cannot walk or use their arms to be able to to walk again not natural okay i'm not going to cut that i can't really cut you off when you're talking about that so it's a super big deal and i don't want to raise hopes unreasonably but but i'm increasingly convinced that this can be done all right so the the last one is starship sure because there's a lot happening in 2022 on starship right yes man starship is a hard hard hard hard project this is the the biggest rocket

25:26ever made it will have a thrust and mass of double that of a saturn v which is the largest rocket to reach a little bit and is intended to be fully and rapidly reusable this is a profound if we are successful with this which i i think we will be but i don't know if we'll be either in 2022 i hope so that this is a profound revolution in access to orbit there has never been a fully reusable orbital launch vehicle this is this is this is the holy grail of of space technology it is the fundamental breakthrough that is necessary for humanity to become a space faring to civilization

26:15you know this this absorbs more of my mental energy than probably any other single thing but but it is it is so preposterous it's so preposterously difficult that there are times where i wonder whether we can actually do this if you had to summarize very quickly what is so hard about it for just a normal person to understand what is so hard about it well this will take a lot more than 60 seconds but but now i'm so interested okay well oh no okay okay yeah i i am overdue for for doing a starship update so we live on a planet where the gravity is actually very strong we actually live on the dances planet in the solar system our atmosphere is very thick

27:15and what this comes down to is that you know a typical orbital rod rocket might be able to put about two percent of its left off mass into orbit and then this is with smart people trying hard maybe two two and a half percent then and no rocket investment knowledge has ever gotten about four percent of its liftoff mass to orbit so now in order to make a rocket fully fully reusable you've got to

27:50basically create a rocket that can do about four percent if not more than four percent of its little mass to orbit which hasn't happened before so that means you have to have the basically a pluses across the board incredibly efficient engines incredibly efficient structure you do need scale because there are some efficiencies of scale that's why part y starship is so gigantic because for example the the brain of the rocket really weighs about the same if it's a small rocket or a big bracket so with a big rocket you get to have the avionics be basically we round down to zero percent or will be inconsequential in the mass of the vehicle

28:48yeah then you need to make an incredibly light heat shield and and just there's so many things that need to be done to have both the booster and the the upper stage or should it be be reusable insanely difficult it's not like like many super smart people have tried to do this before and and no one has succeeded and most of the time they've just given up part way through but but if full and rapid reusability can be achieved it reduces the cost of access to orbit by a factor of 100 or more

29:33so before eventually it's like like an aircraft imagine if if an aircraft or a car or any any form of transport was not reusable imagine if you had to buy a new plane every time you flew that would be make airplane insanely expensive or a car if you had to get a new car every time you drove somewhere that would be unbelievably expensive as opposed to simply refueling it so we've got to get rocked to the point where we simply refuel the rocket and we don't throw it away and with the falcon 9 we managed to make the booster reusable and the fairing the nosecone reusable but not the upper stage so so we made the i think the most progressive usability that has ever been

30:17done but with starship we're hoping to make the whole thing reusable this is this is profound like i said it's different it is the difference between humanity being a single planet species and a multi-planet species it's it's really that big of a deal all right well ian they're they're running the clock down on me so i want to ask you one last question we'll try to go to at least one or two audience questions i wanted to ask you a little bit about humor you you're a pretty funny funny guy you show it on twitter a lot you've hosted snl and i'm wondering how that plays into your management style i mean would your co-workers say you're funny is this

30:52something you're sort of bringing to the office now is it is it helped with managing your teams i mean i think i'm funny i find my jokes about funny i i don't know i guess i yeah i i do i mean i do crack a lot of jokes they don't all land but i i am aspirationally you know aspirationally funny so

31:26yeah i mean we try to have a good sense of humor at the office too okay you know i think you know yeah you know i also wanted to ask that lately on twitter and you you've been poking fun at people for their age quite a bit and i wanted to have a sense of do you not plan to age and what is what is your you know how how are you combating aging is there some secret technology we don't know about that you are that you've got i'm not aware of any secret technology to combat aging and i mean i don't i don't know that we should really try to live for a super long time i think there is some it is important for us to die because you know most of the times people don't change

32:17their mind they just die and so if they if we live forever then we might become a very ossified society where new ideas cannot succeed so but i'm not poking fun at aging i'm just saying you know if we've got people in very important positions that have to make decisions that are critical to the security of the country then they need to have sufficient presence of mind and cognitive ability to to make those decisions well because the whole country is depending on them well i thought you might say psychedelics where your your your way of of not aging but i would like to just go if there's any anyone's got one or two questions for this guy i don't think propping acid

33:06makes you age less i think directly make you age more not less all right any okay well elon thank you so much for being with us here tonight oh there is a question sorry i did not see any hands up ah thank you baldass from bgd holdings i'd be very interested first let me thank you for what you're doing in terms of your breakthrough for humanity but i am curious about your views on china and the united states just on a free-flowing basis if you want to share a few thoughts yeah i mean i think we're we're at an interesting point in history where

33:55the united states has been the world's largest economy for as long as anyone can remember you know and i think the u.s became largest economy i don't know probably 120 130 years ago and there's nobody that old really anymore who can remember a time when the united states is not the world's biggest economy now we're we're heading towards a situation where china is going to be probably have an economy two to three times the size of the united states and so that that's just a different different world

34:30i i do think there's you know there's there there are a lot of people in the government in china who who kind of grew up with china not being it was china being a small economy and maybe who feel like china was pushed around a lot and but that but they haven't fully appreciated the fact that that china really is going to be the big hit on the block and and so like if you're going to be the big hit on the block then you you can really be pretty chill about things you know you don't have to worry about like other countries are not really a threat to you if you're by far the biggest kid on the block and you know so i would say it's that that's kind of an important

35:17mindset change hopefully that that you know china goes through is just you know to think like if you're the biggest kid like how would you want the biggest to kid on the block to behave and now if you are ever going to be the biggest kid on the block then wouldn't you want to behave like you'd want like you would have wanted the biggest kid on the block to behave i think that's that's pretty important

35:45i mean overall you know i think like tesla has has a good relationship with with china and i don't mean to endorse everything that china does any more than i would say endorse everything the united states does or any country but you know overall i i think yeah we are headed to to an interesting and different world and i hope that we can remember that you know we're all human beings and you know let's just try to have as positive a relationship as possible and you know and work towards mutual prosperity of humanity as a whole well elon thank you so much for being here tonight or where you are and thank you everybody and i hope to see you next year back to tarot

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份