访谈·中文精读

马斯克 2022 收购期间答 Twitter 员工问

Elon Musk addresses Twitter Employees Q&A amidst Twitter Acquisition in 2022

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

如果要问马斯克,五年后怎么判断收购 Twitter 这件事成没成,他给的答案简单到有点粗暴:日活用户超过 10 亿。

当时 Twitter 的日活大约 2 亿。地球上有 80 亿人,也就是说,78 亿人不在这上面。

这个数字他在整场问答里反复提起,几乎是他所有判断的起点。产品为什么要改,机器人账号为什么必须清,内容创作者为什么得能赚到钱,答案都绕回到那 78 亿人身上。

这是 2022 年的那场全员问答。马斯克还没完成收购,Twitter 员工提问相当直接,裁员、远程办公、言论审核、政治立场,一个都没绕开。他的回答也很少含糊,有些地方甚至过于坦白。

他要求所有人按字面读他的话

有位员工问:Twitter 有很多聪明有才华的人,我们怎么赢得你的信任,你又怎么赢得我们的信任。

他的回答值得单独拎出来。

我说话极其字面化。你不需要读弦外之音,直接读字面的那一行就行。(马斯克)

他还补了一句,信任由行为定义。有人把事情做成了,那很好;没做成,那就要问,为什么他还在公司。

这个标准硬得有点刺人。但放在后面的所有回答里看,他确实按这个逻辑走:看产出,不看过程;看结果,不看解释。

这也解释了他后面谈裁员时为什么那么平静。

78 亿人不在 Twitter 上

他给出的用户画像是这样的:全球 80 亿人,Twitter 日活算 2 亿,剩下 78 亿人不在上面。

在他看来这是巨大的空白。Twitter 当时只服务了全世界大约 4% 到 5% 的人,而他判断 50% 的人本来可以从中得到价值。

要让这个比例涨上去,前提是「人们得喜欢待在平台上」。他的说法很朴素:如果用户在上面被骚扰、感到不舒服,他们就不会用了,产品就会变成一个很小众的东西。

所以他反复强调一种平衡:让人能说自己想说的话,同时让人待得舒服。这两件事在他那里并不冲突,它们指向同一个目标。不舒服的人会走,走了用户数就上不去。

这套逻辑贯穿全场。他谈内容审核、谈机器人、谈支付、谈广告,最终都回到同一个指标:有多少真实的人愿意留在这个平台上。

人可以在时代广场喊,但没有资格要求被推送

这是整场问答里最有信息量的一段。

他把言论拆成两种东西:说话的 freedom of speech,和被放大的 freedom of reach。

他的例子很极端。任何人都可以现在走到时代广场中间,否认大屠杀,没人能拦住。这句话却没有任何理由该被推送到几百万人面前。

人们应该被允许说相当出格的话,只要法律允许。但这些话不应该被放大,不应该获得大量曝光。(马斯克)

这个区分很重要,因为大多数关于平台审核的争论都卡在这里。反对者说你在限制言论,支持者说你在纵容仇恨。马斯克给出的是第三个答案:话可以留着,放大器可以关掉。

他接着谈那些「合法但恶劣」的内容,比如虐童片段、人肉搜索、性暴力视频。这些东西在美国是合法的。他的处理方式是保留内容,但取消推荐。

他自己的解释是:这类内容让人反感,那些人会直接不用 Twitter。平台要做的是尽可能有吸引力,也就是不把让人反感的东西推给他们。

他还加了一条更狠的:连无聊的内容也不该推。他定的门槛远远高于「不冒犯人」,他要的是「让人觉得有趣、被启发」。

这个标准比大多数平台写得都高。

创作者把视频放 YouTube,再回 Twitter 贴个链接,这很荒谬

他花了不少时间讲这个具体问题。

一个内容创作者拍了视频,会先传到 YouTube,然后回 Twitter 发一条带链接的推文。原因很直白:YouTube 能给他分成,Twitter 不能。

他的原话是,创作者用 Twitter 给自己的 YouTube 视频导流,因为那是他们谋生的方式,这个现状很荒唐。这些内容本该留在 Twitter 上。

他在会上把这类现象归成一个问题:为什么更多人不用 Twitter,为什么用户会点开链接离开 Twitter。把这两个问题解决了,用户自然会多用,也会得到更多价值。

这种提问方式很工程师。他不谈愿景,先谈流失点在哪里,然后把流失点一个个堵上。

微信是他心里唯一跑通的样本

他主动提到了微信。

微信是个很棒的 app。中国以外没有微信的对等物,我认为这里有一个真正的机会做出这样的东西。(马斯克)

他的观察是,中国人基本「生活在微信里」,因为这个工具对日常生活太有用了。他希望 Twitter 能接近那个状态,哪怕只是靠近一点,也算成功。

这个类比背后藏着他的产品路线图。微信能做成,是因为它把消息、支付、服务、内容全塞进一个入口。而 Twitter 当时只是一个信息流。

所以他后面才会专门讲支付:把新闻、娱乐、支付这三块拼起来,是他心里 Twitter 该有的样子。他的目标说得很直白,要让使用 Twitter 这件事变得「离了它就活不了」。

治机器人:开源算法,蓝色认证,按认证排序

机器人、垃圾账号、加密货币诈骗,他承认这些问题一直存在,虽然有改善但还有不少。

更麻烦的是另一类账号:不是机器人,但一个人操作几百个账户,装成不同的人。

他的方案有三层。

第一层是开源推荐算法。他把理由放在信任上,技术上没做更多展开。算法透明了,人们才能批评它、改进它、找出 bug 或偏见。他还加了一条:如果 Twitter 内部有人对某条推文做了降权处理,这个动作必须明确标在那条推文上,让人看得见。

当一切不可解释的时候,人们不知道该怎么想,就会往最坏的方向猜,哪怕那并不是真的。(马斯克)

第二层是蓝色认证挂上支付。当时 Twitter Blue 有个问题:付了钱,你在系统里的身份标识完全没变,看起来还是普通用户。他想的改法是,用一个每月三美元左右的订阅,在名字旁边打个标记,表示这个人大概率不是机器人,也不是一个人管着一百个号。

第三层是按认证状态排序。评论、提及这些互动,优先展示已认证用户的内容。他强调,未认证用户仍然有完整的读写权限,只是排序靠后。

他的原话是,要让养一支水军的成本变得高得多。当时开十万个假账号几乎不花钱,这个局面必须改。

远程办公:倾向线下,但不会开除一个远程的卓越员工

这是他回答得最反复的一段,主持人追问了一次,员工也在实时反馈里继续追问。

他先讲特斯拉。造车这件事没法远程,供应链、零件、组装、把车运到车主手里,全部得到现场,物理上不可能远程完成。

然后他区分了软件和设计这类可以远程的岗位。他的态度是:默认倾向线下办公,但卓越的人可以例外。

特斯拉的做法是让管理者提交一份名单,确认这个人是优秀贡献者,确认了才允许远程。

他也承认远程有代价,会削弱即时沟通的效率。同事就在几张桌子之外,沟通是实时的;隔了物理距离,就难得多。

他还提了一个细节:就算远程,也得偶尔来办公室,至少得认得自己的同事。否则走在街上遇到同事都认不出来,那很不合适。

被追问之后,他把结论收得更紧:

如果一个员工做得非常出色,只是只能远程工作,就把他开除,那明显是疯了。我支持任何能把生意做得更好的事。(马斯克)

裁员:成本超过收入,这话他说得很直

有员工直接问特斯拉最近的裁员,想知道 Twitter 会怎么样。

他的回答没有任何缓冲:公司需要恢复健康,现在的成本超过收入,这个状态很糟糕。必须对人员规模和开支做某种合理化调整,让收入大于成本,否则 Twitter 根本不可持续,也谈不上增长。

接着他给了一句安抚:明显的核心贡献者没什么可担心的。他强调自己不会做损害公司健康的事。

这两句话放在一起看,逻辑一致。他判断人的标准是产出,裁员的标准是成本结构。谁在这两条线之上,谁就安全。

他还坦白了自己最不了解的部分。产品他很熟,几乎每天用。但他对机器人、垃圾账号、一人多号这些影响「可变现日活」的东西了解不够。而这个数字直接决定广告收入和订阅收入。

他把这称为自己最大的担忧。这也和他在公开场合说过的一致,他特意强调自己说话尽量字面化,不玩暗示。

合法但恶劣的内容,办法是不放大

前面提过这个立场,但值得再展开一层,因为他在这里谈到了全球差异。

有些国家的法律限制言论,有时这些法律被用来压制对政府的批评。主持人问他怎么处理这种冲突。

他的回答是:在法律允许的范围内做到最远。如果员工会因为不遵守当地法律而被逮捕,那就必须遵守,或者退出那个国家。

这个答案不漂亮,但很实际。它承认了平台在主权国家面前的边界,也保留了「退出」这个选项。

他还谈到一件更长期的事:同一个问题如果有两个侧面,就该把两个侧面都呈现出来。多数议题是复杂的,没法压成「这边百分之百好,那边百分之百坏」。公众看到多方观点,才会更知情。

这句话在当时的语境里有点讽刺,因为他正在买的这个平台,长期被批评在推动某种叙事。

TikTok 让他不无聊,Twitter 该在严肃议题上做得更好

他主动拿 TikTok 做了对比。

他说 TikTok 的算法做得非常好,能确保你不无聊,好到有点「下一个层级」的意思。他也承认自己觉得里面有些视频令人反感,但那些视频不无聊。

他给 Twitter 定的标准是:内容得让人娱乐、被启发、获得信息。不冒犯人只是底线,让人无聊一样会流失用户。

但他不想照抄 TikTok。他的说法是,TikTok 在娱乐上很强,Twitter 应该在严肃议题上做得更好,帮人们理解世界上正在发生的事。

这两种能力的来源完全不同。娱乐靠刺激,理解靠结构。他想要的是一个能同时做到这两件事的信息流。

政治立场:一直投民主党,这次投了个共和党市长

他把自己定位成中间派,说如果画一条美国政治观点的正态分布曲线,他大概在中心附近。

然后他给了一个具体的事实:过去每一场选举他都投民主党,只有最近这一次不是。他投了市长 Flores,一位共和党人,墨西哥裔美国人,他认为这是个不错的候选人,值得投。

他给 Twitter 定的一个衡量标准挺有意思:如果极左的 10% 和极右的 10% 同样对 Twitter 感到不满,那大概就是个好结果。

这句话可以当成他理解「中立」的操作化定义。目标并非让所有人满意,他要的是两端的抱怨量大致相等。

广告是需求发生器,特斯拉不需要它

他解释了一个很多人好奇的问题:为什么特斯拉和 SpaceX 几乎不打广告。

答案是需求已经超过产能。广告本质上是需求发生器,需求不缺的时候,它就没有意义。

但他不反对广告,还提了三个具体要求。

第一,广告要有趣。娱乐性强的广告效果更好,不要搞得刺耳或者像在刷屏。

第二,别给烂产品打广告。他讲了个亲身经历:在 YouTube 广告里买了个东西,不能用,去谷歌一查,翻到搜索结果的第二页才发现,这产品评价一片差,就是个垃圾。他当时的反应是,YouTube 为什么要允许这种骗子产品投广告,完全不像话。

第三,广告要对用户真的有用。如果广告本身就是用户可能想要的东西,那这就是好广告。

这三条合起来,其实在说同一件事:广告的问题不在数量,在质量。

钱本质上是信息,支付该进 Twitter

他谈支付的角度很像在讲物理。

钱本质上是一种信息。它使人们不必以物易物就能交换产品和服务,也让人能把义务在时间上挪动。(马斯克)

既然钱已经是数字的,那把支付嵌进 Twitter 就很自然。他的设想是让人在平台上方便地转账,法币和加密货币都支持。

他提到 PayPal 在支付上做得很好,Twitter 可以做类似的事。

他也说清了这件事的优先级:一切以提高「有用性」为准。新闻、娱乐、支付是他眼里的三个关键领域,但真正的目标只有一个,让使用 Twitter 这件事变得不可或缺。

匿名和认证,他给了个折中方案

有人问,如果要求所有人认证,那些人权活动者、边缘群体怎么办,他们需要匿名保护。

他的回答很清楚:不需要用真名。

支付认证的意思是,Twitter 后台知道你是谁,但你不必在资料里写真实姓名。他还举了个具体场景:如果一个员工的政治观点和老板不同,他当然不想在公开场合撞上,用假名发推更安全。

他强调自己从未说过「必须认证才能用 Twitter」。认证只影响优先级,已认证的评论和动作排前面,未认证的排后面。目的就一个,把水军的价格抬上去。

头衔叫 Technoking,他真正想干的是产品

关于他会不会当 CEO,他的回答是把头衔这件事看得很淡。

他提到自己在特斯拉把职位名改成了「Technoking」,还走了 SEC 的正式备案。CFO 改成了「Master of Coin」,他觉得这个比 CFO 酷。

他真正想要的是驱动产品,具体说是软件和产品设计。CEO 这个岗位有很多杂事,他不太感兴趣。但他也承认,自己说「产品要往这个方向改」,人们就得听。

他还顺手澄清了一个印象:外界觉得他天天在外面发声,其实他接受的采访很少,只是随便发一条推文,媒体就能写出两页长的文章。

他把自己的日常描述成:在 SpaceX 和特斯拉内部,非常聚焦。一个在推进火箭技术和星链的全球互联网,一个在加速可持续能源,电动车、储能电池、太阳能。

他给所有事找的答案:延长意识的寿命

主持人问,怎么衡量特斯拉和 SpaceX 的根本价值。

他的回答是两句话。特斯拉的价值,看它把可持续能源的到来加快了多少年。SpaceX 的价值,看人类能不能成为多行星物种,从而提高意识存续的概率。

然后他把这套标准上升成了一个统一哲学:

我们应该采取那组最可能扩展意识的范围、规模和寿命的行动。文明终有一天会结束,但我们要尽力让它持续得尽可能久。(马斯克)

他给了个时间尺度做对比。人类从发明文字到现在大约五千年,地球年龄约四十五亿年。五千年在四十五亿年里只是一瞬。

他想做的,是把这一瞬变成一团烧得久一点的火。

顺带说一句外星人。他明确表示自己没看到任何证据,被问过很多次,到目前为止什么都没有。他还开玩笑说自己要开始拿外星人话题钓鱼了,因为真有人信。

成功的定义

回到最初那个问题。五年到十年后,怎么算成功。

他给了两个层次。

具体的那个:日活大幅上升,如果能超过 10 亿就是巨大进步。虽然那仍然只是全球人口的八分之一。

抽象的那个:Twitter 有没有让文明更强、更长久,有没有让人更好地理解现实的本质。

他补了一句自己的立场:他的哲学是好奇,是尽最大可能去理解宇宙的本质。而要理解宇宙,就必须扩展意识的规模和寿命。

整场问答到这里收尾。一个关于收购社交公司的会,最后落在了宇宙和文明寿命上。但你回看他前面所有的具体判断,用户数、机器人、支付、广告、远程办公,其实都在为这个抽象目标服务。

他判断一件事值不值得做,问的是它能不能让「意识」这件事延续得更久一点。这个标准听起来很大,用起来却省事,因为它足够单一,不需要为每个决策单独找理由。

读者可以直接拿走用的,有下面几条。

  • 分清「能说」和「被放大」。评估任何平台的规则时,先问它是否在放大,而不是它是否允许。这两个问题的答案往往完全相反。
  • 判断产品机会,先看缺口不看满意度。现有用户的反馈会告诉你哪里难用,非用户的数量才会告诉你天花板在哪里。
  • 远程办公政策可以这样写:线下为默认,卓越输出为例外,管理者确认做闸门。三个条件缺一个,政策就会失控。
  • 看一家公司裁员合不合理,先看成本结构和收入结构,再看被裁的人。顺序反了,判断就会变成情绪。
  • 广告的有效性来自娱乐性,不来自曝光量。让用户主动想看,比让他被迫看到更省钱。
  • 认证机制的价值在于提高作恶成本。设计任何身份系统时,先算一遍坏人批量复制的成本是多少。
  • 读创始人的公开表态,按字面读。马斯克特意说了自己说话字面化,不需要读弦外之音。这条对判断其他创始人同样适用,猜动机的成本远高于读原文。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00everyone thanks for joining this special Q&A session with Elon Elon thank you so much for joining us the company has been so eager to hear from you live and direct and we all appreciate you joining us today absolutely thanks for having me glad to be a to speak J and since we started late I'm going to go right right ahead hand it over to Leslie so that she can moderate this Q&A session for us okay sounds good amazing thanks brog hi Elon we have a lot to cover a ton to cover so I am going to ask you a question that usually gets asked at the end which is will you come back for a part two at some point if there are things that we don't cover oh yeah

0:42absolutely okay great okay so you have some breathing room so I really do see this as the beginning of a conversation obviously with the company at large and then also with teams and leaders over the next coming weeks and months and Beyond so we're just getting started okay so I'm going to zoom all the way out to the reason that we're actually here together today and that is because you love Twitter I do love Twitter yes I want to be clear about that I love Twitter in fact I literally have tweeted I love Twitter you have so tell us say more why do you love Twitter and also why did you and do you want to buy Twitter well let's

1:26see I mean I I find like I learn a lot from what I read on Twitter and what I see and the the pictures videos text and memes that people create I also find it's a great way to get a message out if I want to if I want to say something make an announcement I think Twitter is the the best way to do that it just goes out mediately to everyone and you

2:04know I I sort of made this joke already but you know some people use their hair to express themselves I use Twitter so you know I I find it's yeah the best for for communicating with a lot of people some ously and getting that message directly to people you know in the past you'd have to in order in order for somebody to to read read about something you'd have to issue a press release or and then youd hope that the the regular media would write about the press release and then they wouldn't write about it in quite the way you'd like to write about it I always find those like old style press releases kind of OB like really quite strange because you're

2:59like writing a press released about yourself which is sort of a something that the media it's like it's over some overly flattering it's like vaguely sort of you know propagandist in fact quite propagandist and hope that the media writes something favorable which they usually do not and you know I think that that actually is maybe one of the biggest reasons for me using Twitter is so I can talk I can communicate directly to people and not through the lens of the media and you know I think there's obviously an important role for the media to play but as anyone knows who reads the newspaper it's coming through quite a negative lens so you know here have to say how many newspaper

3:41articles do you read that are positive and how many news articles do you read that are negative what percentage are positive what percentage negative and then when you read about it's you know it's obviously overwhelmingly negative and then when you when you read about something in in newspaper a data term in the news that you where you actually personally understand the situation how many times has have the media gotten it right I would say almost never not not never but almost never so you know this is a way to

4:17for for people to communicate directly with each other and not through a negative lens and I think that's extremely important for the world so I'm I'm sort of going waxing on about this but I think pretty important and you know the the some of my some of my comments about Twitter being sort of like a digital Town Square but really much more than that because you know you can't put that many people in Town Square but you can have to communicate with millions of people on Twitter that that's just an incredibly important thing and I think it's it's essential for a functioning democracy or to to to function well I think it's essential to have a a free

5:06speech and for and to be able to communicate yeah just communicate freely now the you know the PRI speech stff there need to be you know it's it's free speech within within the context of the law so it's not I'm not definitely not suggesting that we you know just flout the law because we'll get shut down in that case and and I think there's all so there's freedom of speech and freedom of reach and you know freedom of speech is one thing because you like anyone could just go into the middle of of Time Square right now and say anything they want they just walk into the middle of of Time Square and deny the Holocaust okay can't off them they will just do that but that

5:47doesn't mean you have to that needs to be promoted to millions of people so so I think people should be allowed to say you know pretty outrageous things that are within the bounds of the law but but then they don't you know the doesn't get Amplified it doesn't get you know a ton of reach and and I

6:05think an important goal for Twitter would be to try to include as as much of the country as much of the world as possible So currently you know it's a it's a relatively small percentage of of the world that is it is a small percentage of the world that is on Twitter if you say like daily active users you assume that that's say 200 million you've got you know 8 billion people on on Earth that's that's 7.8 billion who are not on Twitter so that's a pretty big number and really I think you want as many as much of the world as possible on Twitter you want to be as as inclusive as possible the broadest demographic and for that to happen people must like being on Twitter

6:45so if they're being like harassed or that they're uncomfortable they're just not going to use Twitter and they're you know so you know we we have to sort of strike this balance of you know allowing people to say what they want to say but but but also making people comfortable on on Twitter or they simply won't use it it it it will be you know it it'll be sort of quite Niche I think there's also a lot a lot that should be done in terms of enhancing the core technology and and offerings of of Twitter like right now if somebody does say a video like let's say a content creator does a video then they're going to put that video on on YouTube and and just link put a link to

7:29it from Twitter because they're able to monetize their content on YouTube but not on on Twitter and I think it's going to be really important for if you want people put put the content on on Twitter which we do then there has to be a mechanism for Content creators to monetize that that content and so they could they do post they could post it to YouTube and and to Twitter but I think it's crazy right now that you know content creators will will use Twitter to to drive traffic to their YouTube video of because you know that's how they make a living and and that really should be on on Twitter like this we want to basically address the reasons that

8:09people like why why aren't more people using Twitter and why do people click away from Twitter and if we can address those reasons then then they there will be they'll use Twitter more and they'll get greater value from the you know from the service and and and and and you know if if I if I you

8:33know think of like like WeChat in China which is actually a great great app but there's no WeChat equivalent in outside of China and I think that there's a real opportunity to create that sort of you know you basically live on weat in China so because it's so useful and and you know so so helpful to your daily life and I think if we we achieve that or even get close to that with qu be an event's success hopefully that that is that's you know really went I really went on there but and we have to elaborate on any of those points yeah no it's great and we're gonna get a little bit deeper on free speech and policy a little bit later so I do want to come back to this

9:14actually but in terms of you you clearly have a lot of thoughts around sort of the problems with Twitter the things that aren't working well or sort of the barriers to what's possible how do you see your buying the company is that was that sort of feed your desire to buy the company or how do you see these things s together and what like how what's your thought process around that well there's there's definitely an ongoing challenge with Twitter with with bot bot accounts and spam accounts you know there's still quite a lot of crypto scams on Twitter it's got It's got better but there's still still a fair bit of that there are also people where they're not necessarily

10:01Bots but they might be operating you know one person's operating hundreds of accounts and trying to make try trying to make them look like individuals but they're not so you know I think it's and I a lot of this time kind of reiterating stuff that I said publicly but in fact on Twitter the in order for people to have trust in Twitter I think it's extremely important that there be transparency so that that's why I advocate of say having the algorithm be open source so that people can critique it improve it identify bugs potentially or bias but when is transparent transparency obviously increases trust so I think it's just very important like that any anything

10:51that's happening on an automated basis be open source and be you know clear and that if there is any action taken by someone within Twitter to you know de boost or Deb boost or or something with a tweet that that is just very clearly identified on the Tweet so people aren't you know ascribing to malice that which is not the way where there's no malice so but but when

11:20when when when it's inscrutable then people don't know what to think and they will sometimes think the worst when when that's actually not true so I think that trust is extremely important and and then just for the usefulness of the system get getting rid of of sort of troll farms and and and and Bot and spam is incredibly important I'm G I have a thought in this regard which I think is is might work which

11:46is to you know there's currently this Twitter blue but if you get Twitter blue it doesn't your your identification in the system does not change at all like you still look like a normal user ID but I think if there was like a little you know Twitter blue authenticated not like authenticated like a celebrity but authenticated at least by Twitter blue payments is using the pay piggy backing on the payment system to your authentication that I think a lot of people be like okay that's that's that's pretty helpful to have some designation that respects my name that indicates I'm I'm probably not a bot or spam or one of one person is operating 100 accounts and you

12:30know that's like three bucks a month I believe I think that would be pretty helpful and then and then also prioritizing comments and you know mentions and whatnot by who is verified in this broader sense the word of verification in the sense of you know the put a blue verified and just prioritize yeah like that above

12:57someone who's not not verified so there will still be full read access to the system still be full write access to the system but but in but you essentially any any tweets or or actions would be prioritized according to who who's verified and then and then a very large number of people can be verified I'm gonna have a couple of followup questions on this specifically but given you mentioned trust I wanted to ask one of the employee questions around trust they said Twitter has a lot of incredible smart talented people what can we do to earn your trust and what are you going to do to earn our ours you know I think I know trust is as trust does so

13:47you know the I I tend to be extremely literal in what I say so you know aspirationally one does not need to read between the lines one can simply read the lines and so the things that I've said about Twitter I think are need to happen in order for it to be you know to really go go to the next level I mean I think like the potential is there for Twitter to have an you know be accessible to an order of back to more people and for a lot more people to find it useful not you know currently I guess would be four 4% of the world or something like that I don't know four or five% of the world optimistically is finding Twitter useful and like maybe 50% of the world

14:37could find Twitter useful so I want to take whatever actions would would lead to that and you know the you know I'm very much like a it's it's I would say it's a trust thing it's like if somebody's getting useful things done then that's great and but if if they're not getting these whole things done then like okay why are they at the company so it's it's really just like we need to improve the core technology improve the the design [Music] and you know so trust emerges from that yeah I mean trust yes it's not like i' say trust is it's not the it's not exactly the it's it's like you know if somebody's getting stuff done great I love them and if they're not I don't

15:32like then I do not love me it's pretty straightforward can we I would love to say on this topic of employees and how we work so distributed work is something that has been core to our strategy most of our people work in a hybrid Viet model about 1500 people work remote fulltime we know that you recently made you know sent a communication to Tesla Executives about remote work can you share what your point of view is on remote work and specifically for Twitter yeah so now now Tesla makes cars

16:05and you cannot make cars in roly obviously there there you have to make cars in a big Factory and the supply chain and and you know and you have to bring in the parts and you know assemble them and then transport the car to the owner all of these things must be done in person because they're just it's physically impossible to do them remotely now there are some roles at T where what can be can be done remotely like say software or design and

16:39so that you know I think that's still a case where you want to Aspire to do things in person but if somebody is exceptional at their job then it's possible for them to be effective even working remotely so the with with Tesla I simply have asked for a a list you know of that the manager has to confirm that that they're they're they're an excellent contributor and if they do they're allowed to work remotely so it's pretty basic I think there is there is a a hit one takes remotely because the it does reduce a spre of core and you know it's like it's hard to you know like like if if you just there's there's really it really it kind of matters to be in puss at least

17:27some of the time so like one of the things to said even if somebody's working remotely they got to show up at the office occasionally so that they recognize their colleagues and don't have you know you don't walk down the street and pass your colleague and and they're you don't recognize them that that would not be good yeah no I think this this is super clarifying and resonates with us and entirely in terms of how we work so thank you for for clarifying that topic it's it's really important to us i' would like to keep on the topic of employees and some of the questions that have come through this one's on on compensation and benefits most people especially

18:03obviously here are used to working for a public company can you talk a little bit about how you compensate Folks at SpaceX as a private company how does it work and what approach you plan to take at U at Twitter as a private company yeah so SpaceX I think operates in The Best of Both Worlds where stock and options are issued to everyone but but we don't all the the challenges being publicly traded company where the stock can be up and down from one day to the next and be quite a distraction and where one is at the most you of short Sellers and class action lawsuits and just generally it's like being in The Stockade public Stockade and they throw tomato at you

18:45all there so but but SpaceX still allows liquidity and and so every every six months this liquidity event at SpaceX and people have the opportunity to sell their shares and that's worked very well for the the whole life of the company so I think something like that would make sense at Twitter so it still be stock and options and everything and it just be liquidity events twice a year great and thanks we are getting some realtime feedback on the remote work question so I just want to make sure I follow up sure your approach to remote work and distributive work at Twitter you are that what I'm hearing from you is that you are supportive of of remote and distributed work as as a

19:28is productive and meaningful and people show up when it's important and depending on their jobs is that an accurate reflection yeah I the bias definitely needs to be strongly towards working in person but but if somebody is exceptional then remote work can be okay but then basically if their if their work output is exceptional then remote work is is fine there is some communication you know impact that one takes when working remotely because if you're with people you know and they're just you know a few desks away it's very easy to communicate in real time but it's much harder to do that if you're in different physical locations so I do want to emphasize that

20:13that the bias is very much towards impers work it's it's just that it would obviously be insane if someone is excellent what they do but can only work remotely to then fire them even though they're doing excellent work would be insane so I'm definitely in favor of like things that are like Mad I'm in favor of things that that build the business and make it better thank you question about layoffs we've received several questions from employees on this point obviously they WR about the recent layoffs at Tesla can you speak to how you're thinking about layoffs at Twitter well I think it depends on you know the the company does need to be to get healthy so the I mean right

21:00now the the costs exceed the revenue so that's just that's not that's not a great situation to be in and so there would have to be some rationalization of of the of head count and expenses to have Revenue be greater than than cost otherwise Twitter is simply not not viable or you know can't grow

21:22so you know I think it would just be dependent on you know but like said anyone who's like obviously like a significant contributor should have nothing to worry about like I'm I I I'm not you know I do not take actions which are destructive to the health of the company so you know yeah El a question connected to that as you're obviously learning and gaining information as we get closer to this deal being closed what do you feel that you have sort of a deep understanding and grasp of and what are areas that you feel you want to dive much more deeper on to understand and learn well I certainly I mean I have a strong a great understanding of the the

22:07product because I I I use Twitter every day practically and you know I think I've got a a really good understanding of of you know how Twitter works from a product standpoint what I have less an understanding of is you know you know like like this this this sort of Bot spam or or you know multi-user account basically anything that that affects the the monetizable daily user number is that that's probably my my biggest concern because that's really what drives advertising Revenue as well as subscription Revenue so and really

22:50Twitter's re revenue is is going to be subscription advertising I think payments would be an interesting thing to do as well but but all of those things are are only relevant for as as a function of how many unique humans are on the system so it's that's that's the that's the most that's my that's my biggest concern and that's what's you know what I said publicly as well like I said I try to be as literal as possible so and you know

23:26yeah and as we think about OB a product and the service and serving customers all around the world clearly it's critical and exential existential for us to serve diverse communities and all people as you said as you said earlier so inclusion diversity is obviously core essential to our work at Twitter both our employees and and the customers that we serve you've been vocal on a variety of different topics and issues that relate to inclusion and diversity can you talk about your both your views and also your commitment to creating a diverse and inclusive workplace and also Al a service where everyone can feel included and safe yeah I mean well to be clear

24:07you know ifone talks about the TW you know I said about Twitter as a whole like there's eight billion people in the world there's sort of I'm told there's 200 million you know daily users of Twitter that's a 7.8 billion person Gap so I think we really want to have you know I don't know at least a billion people on Twitter maybe more as many people as we can possibly get on Twitter so that I think is is the most inclusive definition of inclusiveness is like all humans so

24:43you know that's that's important you know from a company standpoint you know I believe in in a sort of strict meritocracy so whatever you know whoever's doing great work great you know they they they get more responsibility and Authority and that's that and I know we you mentioned in in some of our conversations about your IND team at Tesla we have an amazing indd team here here at Twitter as well so continue on the journey on the journey together I wanted to talk about content mation go back to a number of the things that you said earlier so this one I'll take I'll take verbatim so you've spoken a lot about the importance of free speech let's start

25:26with the us where we have a strong tradition around this and you talk you touched on this earlier a lot of what's called lawful but awful speech is allowed here in the United States right animal abuse footage doxing videos of sexual violence Etc so all allowing this kind this type of content obviously could cause harm and make you know Twitter unusable for for the broad audience that that you're trying to reach what is your approach to this type of content that's sort of legal but problematic as it relates to people actually using the service how do you think about this tension as I said earlier really it's I I think people we should allow people

26:08to say what they want post what they want within the bounds of the law but that that that's different from them being able to reach people who don't want to be reached with that content so if that content is offensive then to to people they will those people will not will simply stop using Twitter so it's important to U make Twitter as attractive as possible and and really that that means not showing people content that they would find hateful or offensive or or even frankly content they would find boring is not good so we don't even want them to see boring content unless we were talking about Tik Tok last night and Tik Tok obviously does like

26:57like a great job of making sure you are not bored I mean it does get it does like feel like add but like next level but but but Tik Tok does does a great job of of making our board I mean I do find some of the videos offensive I think but they're not boring so the the folks we are like how do we ensure people have content that is that they find entertaining and engaging and interesting such that they want to keep using Twitter and use it more so that's you know that's that That's essential to the growth of the of the service and one of our employees asked about sort of people who use Twitter having the right and the ability to filter out content that they don't want

27:48to see I think this gets to exactly what you're what you're pointing to yeah yeah I mean to be clear it's like like the the standard is much more than not offending people the standard is should be that they're they're very entertained and informed like because like said like you could not offend someone but you go Bor them and show them a bunch of content that they don't find interesting and then they will not use the service or they will use it less so that's why I use the example of Tik Tok where they they just H the algorithm to be as engaging as possible and I think we want to also H it to be as engaging as possible in a different way I think

28:26you know way that's that's like Tik Tok is interesting but like you want to be informed about like serious issues as well and I think Twitter in terms of like serious issues can be a lot better in informing informing people about serious issues I I do think it's important that that there there be you know if if there are two sides to an issue it's important to represent you know if there are mult multiple opinions but you know and and just make sure that we're not sort of driving a narrative but that we give people an opportunity to understand the various sides of issues most issues in the world are are complex they they they're not they don't well down to a simple this is

29:11this is 100% good and this is 100% bad so I think it would be it it would have a more informed public if if people were presented with multiple sites to an issue one point I just want to go back to on sort of the law and sort of how that how that impacts impacts content moderation as as we think globally around the world there are some countries right that limit that have laws that limit speech and sometimes actually use these laws to silence disagreement with the government Etc you were talking about different points of view so Twitter is historically focused on doing what we can do to enable people everywhere to have their voices how do you think about that as a Rel to

29:52again like the local laws and what that means well I mean I'm in favor of doing you know of going as far as the law will allow us if the law you know if if say twiter employees would get arrested in the country if we if we didn't adhere to the law then we we OB must adhere to the law or exit the country or something so but I mean as much as we can enable people to have a voice and and to speak our mind I think we want to we want to do that yeah yeah and I

30:29know we talked about this as well last night about the teams doing this work and sort of your desire to connect with those teams and and sort of understand of where we've been where we are where we're going and I think that would be hugely productive across the board both ways can we talk briefly about your political views how if all if at all do your political views play into the leadership of the companies that you currently run how would it affect Twitter if that all well my my political views I think are U moderate at least as would be you know as if you said like what is the center of the normal distribution of political views in the country I think I'd be

31:12pretty close to the center you know I've voted the Democrat every election until this recent one this week and you and I voted for mayor Flores who who was a republican but she was Mexican-American and I thought I thought a good candidate and and worth worth voting for so but I you know I I'm in favor of the of of modern politics but but you know allowing people who have like you know

31:48relatively extreme views to to express those views with within the BS of the law so that's you know you know as I said publicly like the I think if the let's say the far left 10% and Far Right 10% will equally upset on Twitter then that would probably be a good outcome I want to just talk about our business for a minute you've spoken about incentives that the ad business creates for services like Twitter what role does advertising play in the future of your business plan for the company I think advertising is is very important for Twitter so in the case of say Tesla SpaceX there is there's no need for advertising because the demand exceeds our production so I mean

32:38advertising is fundamentally a a demand generator and occasionally you want to get some other message out there but it's it's it's fundamentally a demand generator so given that that Tesla demand as far in excess of of production there's no need Tesla to advertise but you know I'm not not against advertising I I would I would probably I don't know want to talk to the advertisers and say like hey let's let's make sure the ads are as entertaining as possible that I think they're more effective if they're entertaining like you want sort of you don't want to be strident or spamming in the ad and then of course I don't think it's good to allow advertising of any products which are

33:25you know bad products you know like like like I was literally scammed on I I bought this thing off of a YouTube ad and it didn't work and then I I Googled it and it's like oh yeah once you click on the second page of Google starch results it's like yeah this this product totally doesn't work and it's trash and I'm like well what the hell is you YouTube allowing advertising of the of of scammy products that's totally not cool so you know like and I just I think if if you if advertising is entertaining interesting something you might actually want and the product would be you know fulfilling to the you know to the Twitter user then I think that's great

34:14advertising so yeah so El we're gonna go over is that okay awesome thank you can you talk a little bit about Twitter and payments you mentioned a few times in different settings let to understand your thinking there yeah I think you money is essentially a form of information so you know it's information that allows us to exchange products and services without having to to barer and and and allows people to shift obligations in time but but money is fundamentally digital at this point and has been for a while and you know PayPal you know I think is done done a great job from on the payments front I think it's it's it would make sense to integrate payments into Twitter so

35:11it's easy to send money back and forth you know and and fiat currency as well as crypto you know essentially what somebody would find useful so like said the goal my my goal would be to to maximize the usefulness of the of the service the more useful it is the better and if one can use it to make convenient payments that that's an increase in usefulness you know sort

35:47of sort of news entertainment and and payments I think are like three critical areas but really it's just about sort of thinking about how how we make this how do we make using Twitter so compelling that you can't live without it and and that and that everyone wants to use it I wanted to stay the product I know again you did touch up on this earlier but it's a recurring question around the authentication piece you know in terms of your saying you you want to authenticate All Humans so so just to sort of double click into that you know balancing this with those who benefit from imity right from a safety perspective especially for example human

36:30rights activists and marginalized communities so it's sort of can you just clarify again and speak to that sort of that tension and and how you think about about those groups specifically is sort of core to how the service yeah yeah I I don't think it's necessary for someone to use their real name so if if one say does a a payment based authentication I think it should be okay to not use your real name on Twitter if but so Twitter would would know who who would know who you are at least from a payment standpoint but but you would not have to State your real name or anything that's obviously important where if if someone has different political views from their

37:15manager let's say then they they they don't really want to you know get crosswise there and so that it would be better for them to you know have a student them on Twitter but but it still be backand authenticated and like said at no point would I suggest that you have to be authenticated in order to use Twitter it's just that it would just be a PRI prioritizing of authenticated comments and and actions on Twitter over unauthenticated in order to combat the sort of bots and trolls

37:53and essentially like it needs to be much more expensive to to have a Troll Army whereas right now it's it's basically very inexpensive to have 100,000 fake Twitter accounts and you have you have certainly been very vocal on Twitter you are very vocal on Twitter and often your tweets and even emojis create new Cycles you know you have been also critical of the company on Twitter which obviously impacts lots of discussions conversations and perceptions from whether it be partners or even our employees how do you think about these tweets do you look at the reaction think about the reaction of those these tweets I'm just curious s of the thinking behind the Tweet if you

38:36will well I think it would be helpful you know one thing about words is that it's hard to convey tone and so it's it's possible for essentially people will sometimes like take take the words and then assume they were said in maybe an angry way or you know a vindictive way or something like that but I mean hopefully you can tell like my my normal tone is not I'm not I'm not an angry person I almost never raised my voice so like in a year I might not have raised my voice literally so this is not you know so sometimes people may think oh wow he's he's sort of yelling screaming or something but I'm really not so maybe some way to indicate how I mean

39:27emojis sort of do that but I don't know maybe they could be like a where you have like a I don't know irony flag or something this is like this is an ironic you know this is an ironic tweets and something like that listen I think I think spaces is a great product for you as well we also also voice tweets which I don't think I've seen you use before but I think that would add sort of your your literal voice over and color to some of the things that you tweet so maybe you can sort of oh sure that's I should I should yeah maybe I could just say it yeah exactly exactly or you

40:12could you could read it but then you can also see how I would have said it like then you you know if you're like I wonder if you said that in an angry way and then you can see how I actually said it yes absolutely absolutely that'd be amazing on your I know we have I'm gonna only push you about what 10 more minutes at up at the hour so I'm holding you until then your your role at the company you know there's been some discussion about will you be CEO will you not be CEO how what can you speak to this and how do you anticipate Your Role sort of influencing strategy day-to-day the vision well I guess I'm not that hung up on titles but I I do want to Drive

40:58the product in a particular direction so you know it's it could be like I don't really care what you know about being CEO in fact I I I renamed myself techn King at at Tesla with an official SEC filing so yes we saw yeah and and then our CFO was renamed master of coin which I think is a cooler thing than CFO so the I mean the what I really just want to do is is like Drive the product improve the product and and it's like basically software and product design you know so you know I don't mind doing other things you know related to operating a company but there are kind of chores there's a lot of chores you're the CEO and I I really just want to make

41:58sure that the that the product evolves rapidly and in a good way and I don't really care what title is but but I do obviously people do need to listen to me U if I say like hey we need to make product improve the product in in the following weight make the following changes add add these features then you know like I you expect that that that people listen to me in in this regard I mean that's how that's how what I do at SpaceX and Tesla so you know I I'm really just

42:35working with really engineering and production and like it sometimes may seem like wow he's you's really out there a lot but actually I'm not if you see how many actual interviews do I do it's quite a small number but when if I do a tweet they'll like make an entire like two-page article about it you know so I'm like like basically get far few I'm like actually quite internally focused at SpaceX and Tesla even though it may not seem that way and it's really just you know evolving the rocket technology SpaceX and providing Global Internet with Starling and then Tesla it's about accelerating sustainable energy and you know with with electric cars and stationary

43:22battery packs and solar power and you know the fundamental good good of Tesla I would say is measured by how many years did we accelerate the Advent of sustainable energy and then the fundamental good of of SpaceX is you know are we able to make life multiplanetary and thus improve the probable lifespan of of Consciousness like you always say like what what is a unifying philosophy for me it is

43:53we should take the set of actions most likely to extend and the scope scale and lifespan of Consciousness as we know it and you know so that's like like what what set of actions improve things at a civilizational level and improve the probable lifespan of civilization like our civilization will come to an end at some point but let's try to make it last as long as possible and it would be great to understand more about the nature of the universe why we're here the meaning of life where are things going where do we come from from can we travel to

44:30other star systems and see if there are alien civilizations there might be there might be a whole bunch of long Dead one planet civilizations out there that that existed you know 500 million years ago if you think about the span of human civilization from the Advent of the first writing it's only about 5,000 years which is nothing you know Earth is roughly 4 and a half billion years old so all of civilization as measured from the Advent writing is a flash in the pan and I think we want to take whatever actions we can to extend that flash in the pan to hopefully be be a

45:13flame that last a long time I can't believe that's the transition from Aliens away away from this conversation back to to Twitter what what do you I'm not saying it's aliens but it's alien what does Twitter look like to you I got to startop trolling people about the alien stuff because people really think I I to be clear I I've seen no evidence what I've seen no actual evidence for aliens I get asked that a lot and I think I know and I've not seen anything yet

45:48okay you've heard it here everybody question about Twitter when you look five to 10 years from now what do you consider successful for yourself in in acquiring the company and for all of us in the work that we do what does success look look like yeah so I think success would be a a substantial increase in daily active users you know I don't know like said if you know can can can we get daily active users over a billion that would be you know it's still only 1/8 of us but that would be a huge improvement from where things are today and

46:34you know and and I guess broadly speaking like is Twitter helping further civilization and Consciousness you know like are we it's tter I'm not I'm transactions AR complete so I shouldn't say we but but like is is Twitter contributing to a a a stronger longer lasting civilization where we're better better able to understand the nature of reality I would say like my My Philosophy is one of curiosity of trying to understand the nature of the universe in as much as is possible to understand so in order to understand the nature of the universe you must expand the scope and scale of Consciousness that extend the life of Consciousness so I guess broadly speaking would be has

47:34Twitter U meaningfully improved this the strength and longevity of civilization and I know that we have gone meaningfully over so first of all thank you so much for the time thank you for coming back for a part two thank you for continuing the conversation with all of us oh you're welcome pleas thank you so much we'll talk very soon all right thanks bye thanks you good bye everybody

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份