2022 年 11 月,马斯克接手推特大约三周,给全员发了一封信,要大家承诺进入“硬核”工作状态。几百名员工选择拿钱走人,没有签。
同一套剧本,十三年前在特斯拉演过一遍。2012 年,Model S 准备提产,马斯克给团队发的邮件主题行写着“ultra-hardcore”(超级硬核),提醒大家准备迎接一种多数人从未经历过的强度。
华尔街日报采访了几位特斯拉(Tesla)和 SpaceX 的前员工,拼出了一套从来没写进员工手册的用人逻辑。这套逻辑可以拆成六个能辨认的动作,每个动作都有它成立的代价,也有它失效的边界。搞清楚这些边界,比记住“马斯克很狠”有用得多。
你只有 30 秒:一场没有明说的效率测试
访谈一开头,一位前员工给出的建议最实用:跟马斯克说话,必须简洁、快。
“他从没这么说过,但我观察到了:你有 30 秒讲完你的观点。”(前特斯拉员工)
这句话的分量在于它是一套隐性筛选,没有写在任何制度文件里。你不知道自己在被考核,但你每一次汇报的表现都在累积一个人的判断:这个人值得留,还是可以走。
有人进会议室之前会先去公司吧台要两杯浓缩咖啡,一口气灌下去,然后才推门。这个细节解释了为什么“跟马斯克开会”本身是体力活。还有那种作息:凌晨两点的短信,早上六点的电话会议。前员工说起这些语气很平,没有控诉感,因为在那家公司这就是默认设置,没人觉得需要特别说明。
先给一个值得熬夜的理由
马斯克管理动作的第一步,是围绕一个宏大目标把人聚起来。这一点几乎被所有受访者提到,而且位置都排得很靠前。
卡尔·梅德洛克(Carl Medlock)2009 年加入特斯拉,如今在西雅图经营自己的电动车维修店。他描述当年的状态:
“我们当时特别兴奋,我们一星期干 80 到 100 个小时。家人、爱好、激情这些,基本都顾不上了,但我们热爱自己做的事。”(梅德洛克)
加勒特·赖斯曼(Garrett Reisman)2011 年加入 SpaceX,2018 年离开,去南加州大学教航天工程。他说在 SpaceX 待了七年后,想找个强度低一点的地方。他描述那里的氛围:
“那是个要求极高的环境。但大体上说,他并没有在后面抽鞭子。让人类成为多行星物种、去火星、在火星上建殖民地,这些东西几乎激励着 SpaceX 的每一个人。”(赖斯曼)
两位都提到一个反直觉的点:马斯克本人不做那种热血动员式的演讲。梅德洛克说他一次都没见过。所以这套激励的驱动力来自目标本身的当量,煽动在这里是缺席的。目标一旦成立,加班就不需要强迫,员工自己会把账算平。
这也解释了一个常见误读。外界看 SpaceX 和特斯拉,容易觉得那是被老板逼出来的强度。内部人的说法恰好相反:压力确实高,但压力的源头写在墙上那张使命宣言里。老板要做的事情,是保证那个使命足够可信,而不是每天站在台上喊。
推特缺的正是那个“足够大的目标”
这是马斯克在推特遇到的第一道坎。华尔街日报科技与汽车记者蒂姆·希金斯(Tim Higgins)写过一本追踪特斯拉崛起的书《权力游戏》(Powerplay),他的判断很直接:
“埃隆在推特要面对的挑战是,赌注是什么?”(希金斯)
去火星,输了是人类层面的损失。保护言论自由当然重要,但它在情绪上的当量比火星差着好几个数量级。希金斯补了一句:推特谈的是保护言论自由,这和“去火星”的戏剧性完全不在一个量级。
人愿意为一件事把自己榨干,前提是这件事在他的价值排序里足够高。梅德洛克们当年自愿,赖斯曼们当年也自愿,而这份自愿的底座,推特暂时给不出来。
“硬核”是一份明码标价的合同
马斯克有个词:hardcore,硬核。他用它描述高强度、长时间的工作状态。
“你每周就得投入 80 小时,80 到 100 个小时,每周如此。”(马斯克)
他还补过一句,说有时候凌晨两点大家还很有精神,因为刚做完一场活动,玩得很开心。这话听着像鸡汤,但它透露的是一种自我认知:他真心觉得自己在做的事很好玩。这种人当老板,下属很难用“太累了”去讨价还价,因为老板本人不觉得累。
2012 年那封“ultra-hardcore”邮件,把这种期待写成了文字。2022 年 11 月接手推特后,他发了类似的一封信。结果前面说过,几百人选择离开,没有签“推特 2.0”的协议。
希金斯对这一段的概括很到位:马斯克继承了一支庞大的队伍,他必须说服这些人加入“埃隆队”。他正在做的,是在这一大堆人里筛出他真正需要的那部分,好把公司转成一家私有化的推特。整个过程很难看。
“难看的”三个字值得停一下。它描述的是一种公开的、带创伤的组织改造:邮件发出去,一批人走,留下来的人看着昨天的同事被清空工位。这种改造在危机中的创业公司还能用“共渡难关”包装,在一家成熟的上市公司里,它首先摧毁的是信任存量。
他自己先跪进泥里
要别人硬核,自己就不能软。这一条马斯克做到了近乎夸张的程度。
“我睡那边那张沙发。上次来的时候,我实际上是直接躺在地板上的,因为沙发太窄了。”(马斯克)
一位前员工讲过另一件事。某天他很早到工厂,整个 5.5 万平米的厂区只有他、马斯克和一个保安。他很意外马斯克在,就在厂区的通道和安全区骑着自行车转,然后看到马斯克在一张工程师的办公桌上睡着了。
2022 年 11 月,马斯克自己发推说睡在旧金山的推特办公室。
他投进去的不只是时间。有人在访谈里问他给公司投了多少钱,他答大约 5500 万美元。2008 年特斯拉最黑暗的时候,他把个人最后几百万美元砸了进去。梅德洛克提到,那会儿马斯克在门洛帕克蹭沙发睡,用个人信用卡的负债垫付公司的经营开支。
“他的做法是,为了保持公司竞争力,什么都可以做。我给他工作的时候,他每一天都在这么做。”(梅德洛克)
这一段是理解整套体系的钥匙。当老板本人在用个人信用卡给公司续命、睡在工厂地板上时,他要求员工每周干 80 小时,这件事的性质就变了,变成一种“我跟你一起扛”的默契。这种默契没法靠制度设计出来,只能靠示范一点一点积累。反过来说,如果老板只在嘴上要求硬核,同样的加班要求立刻会变成压榨,员工的抵触情绪会成倍放大。
灵感与消耗出自同一套系统
示范是有代价的。受访者的评价几乎都成对出现:一只手是极强的激励,另一只手是消耗和反复无常。
“跟他聊过的人都说,他一方面极具感召力。另一方面,很多人也会说他让人精疲力竭、喜怒无常,过一阵子就真的跟不上了。”(前特斯拉员工)
这里还有一个绕不开的背景:特斯拉和 SpaceX 历史上都面对过员工针对工作环境和相关行为的指控。访谈没有展开,它提示了一件事,这套体系的账并非所有人都算得过来,也并非所有账都被看见了。
“跟不上”这三个字很关键。它说明这套体系的淘汰机制主要靠自然损耗来完成:不需要谁下命令,跟不上的人自己会走。组织由此保持精简,代价是持续的人心磨损。对一个上升期的公司,这种磨损可以用增长来对冲;对一个正在收缩的公司,磨损会直接转成士气的下坠。
裁员属于常规操作
马斯克让公司变瘦的速度同样惊人。他当上特斯拉 CEO 的时候,砍掉了大约 20% 的员工。
接手推特大约一周后,他裁掉了约一半员工。华尔街日报看到的文件显示,加上知情人士的估计,可能有一千多人主动辞职。
这种刀法在内部留下了一种奇怪的荣誉感。前员工说,这套做法让留下来的人相信:给马斯克干活的人都是最好的那批。当年在特斯拉,马斯克经常说给他干活的人是“特种部队”(special forces)。
他的用人算盘非常清楚:一个关键工程师在他眼里的价值,抵得上一百个普通工程师。把这样的人放到最难的问题上,速度快,而且不用背着层层审批的官僚包袱。
“特种部队”这个比喻值得展开。它隐含的资源分配方式是极端倾斜:组织不追求平均水平整体抬升,而把最好的资源、最难的任务、最高的曝光度集中给少数几个人。好处是决策快、突破快;坏处是绝大多数人在这套评价体系里注定是背景板,他们贡献稳定,但拿不到那种被点名的认可。一家公司长期靠这种结构运转,中间层会持续失血。
扁平是物理事实
“扁平化”在多数公司是 PPT 上的词,在这里是能摸到的现实。
“如果埃隆对你正在做的事感兴趣,他会直接来找你谈。他不会穿过一堆管理层级,让信息一层层往上过滤。”(前特斯拉员工)
这条规则的作用是双向的。好消息能直达,坏消息也藏不住。你在马斯克面前的价值,取决于你本人能不能把事情讲清楚,而不是你的汇报线有多漂亮。这也解释了“30 秒讲完观点”为什么那么要命:中层缓冲被抽掉之后,每个人都得自己面对老板。
它对员工的能力结构提出了一种特殊要求。在这种组织里,写一份漂亮周报的价值远低于当面把问题讲明白;擅长协调各方的人不如擅长直接给出方案的人吃香。这套偏好放在硬件工程里极其有效,因为问题边界清楚,答案能被验证。放到内容平台、广告系统这类边界模糊的业务上,同一套偏好就可能让复杂问题被过度简化。
用财务压力当发动机
除了目标、示范和扁平,马斯克还有一个常见动作:抬高财务上的赌注。
他接任特斯拉 CEO 的时候,经济一片狼藉,正撞上大衰退。当时最大的疑问是,人们还愿不愿意买豪华车,而且是电动的豪华车。
把镜头切到 2022 年的推特,结构惊人地像:经济前景不确定,公司需要开始赚钱,背着巨额债务,还得在一个广告市场收缩、竞争压力巨大的社交媒体行业里找到自己的位置。
2022 年 11 月,马斯克在给推特员工的邮件里写得很明白:如果没有可观的订阅收入,推特在接下来的经济下行中活下来的可能性不大。
这句话的作用是把外部压力原封不动地灌进组织内部。危机感一旦变成共识,裁员的阻力、加班的抵触都会小很多。2008 年的特斯拉就是这么走过来的:所有人知道自己随时可能拿不到下一张工资单,于是没人计较工位和工时。
但同样的手法在推特会遇到一个新的问题。特斯拉当年是在造一辆还没造出来的车,失败意味着归零,员工的个人命运和公司的存亡完全绑定。推特的员工面对的是一个已经在运行的产品,公司倒下他们还能去别处写代码,绑定关系天然弱一些。危机感的效力,取决于员工信不信自己也在船上。
推特这一局的变量在哪
希金斯提醒,马斯克在推特仍处于搭建策略的早期阶段,还在找人,找那些他信得过、能帮他改造公司的人。
推特和 SpaceX 最大的差别,在于“证明自己”的通道不同。SpaceX 前员工说得很清楚:如果你证明了自己有能力、有创新,尤其是在技术层面,那你在公司里的晋升会非常非常快。
火箭不会说谎。工程结果就是硬通货,行与不行,一次发射就能判定。而推特的核心业务是内容审核、广告系统、产品体验,这些领域的“好”很难像火箭回收那样一眼看清。评价标准一模糊,“谁行谁上”的机制就容易滑向印象政治:谁在老板面前表现得更果断、更笃定,谁就更容易被看见,而这跟谁真正解决了问题可能关系不大。
再加上他本人对推特的期待夹杂着太多非商业因素。赌注的性质一旦从“公司能不能活”变成“某种公共讨论的形态能不能成”,员工对目标的理解就会分化,而目标一旦分化,前面那套靠共同使命感支撑的加班逻辑就会松动。
访谈结尾,一位前员工给了一条极其冷静的建议:如果他现在是推特的员工,他会先把本职工作做好,然后,别让他们知道你的名字。
这话听着心酸,但它点破了整套体系的筛选机制。在这套体系里,被看见并不等于安全,被需要才等于安全。能否被需要,取决于你手上那个问题是不是老板眼里最难的那个。至于名字被记住,有时候只是意味着下次裁员你会被更早想起。
给普通从业者的几条可操作结论
多数人不会去马斯克的公司,这套东西依然有可迁移的部分。要学的部分是如何配置注意力和资源,至于压榨人那一套,看看就行。
- 给自己准备一个 30 秒版本。无论汇报对象是谁,先练会一句话讲清你在做什么、为什么重要、需要什么资源。这种表达能力在任何组织里都稀缺,在层级越少的公司越值钱。
- 判断一家公司值不值得投入,先看它的目标能不能让你自愿加班。如果答案是不能,就别指望靠意志力硬扛,那撑不过三个月。马斯克的公司靠的从来是目标本身的吸引力,员工的意志力只是燃料。
- 留意行业特性和公司文化的错配。火箭工程有清晰的物理判据,社交产品没有。如果你所在领域的好坏难以验证,那“谁行谁上”的扁平结构很可能变成印象政治,评估自己处境时把这一点算进去。
- 把“被看见”和“被需要”分开算。前者靠表达和站位,后者靠你解决的问题难度。在高压组织里,后者决定你能留多久,前者决定你留得体不体面。
- 看老板是否真的下场。光喊硬核的老板和睡在工厂地板上的老板,是两种完全不同的生物。判断标准很简单:他为这件事付出了什么不可回收的东西,钱、时间,还是声誉。
- 把强度当成一段经历,不要当成身份。赖斯曼在 SpaceX 待了七年后去教书,梅德洛克回西雅图开了自己的维修店。能进能出,才算真的清醒。
0:00If you're talking to Elon or you want to have a conversation with Elon and you get that opportunity to talk to Elon, you need to be concise, quick. There's definitely 2 AM, texts and 6 AM conference calls. When I used to go into meetings with him, I used to always stop by our barista and I would get a couple of espresso and chug that down and then go into the meetings.
0:17He's never said this, but I've watched it. You have 30 seconds to make your point. Elon Musk is known by his employees to be intense. When he took over Tesla in 2008, he sent the company into Crisis Mode to jumpstart his vision. of how to reinvent the auto industry. Now he appears to be using a similar management playbook to remake Twitter.
0:37We spoke with former Tesla and SpaceX employees to better understand how Musk became known for his cutthroat and tireless management style, and what that may mean for his future employees. Step one for Musk is to rally employees around a lofty company mission. It's exactly what inspired Carl Medlock to join Tesla in 2009.
0:59We were also excited about the brand. I mean, we all work in 80, 100 hours a week. We kind of lost track of our families, our passions, our hobbies and all that stuff, but we love what we were doing. I never once had Elon or saw Elon do a rah-rah meeting like that. Medlock now runs his own electric vehicle repair shop in Seattle.
1:16He said he was terminated from Tesla in 2013 over a misunderstanding with his direct manager. Garrett Reisman was similarly inspired by the mission of SpaceX and joined in 2011. It's a very demanding environment. But by and large, it's not because of him cracking the whip, you know, making human life multi-planetary, getting to Mars, having a colony of Mars, is something that motivates pretty much everybody there at SpaceX.
1:40Reisman left SpaceX in 2018 to teach astronomical engineering at the University of Southern California. He said that after seven years at SpaceX, he wanted to work somewhere less intense. Yet at Twitter, the mission isn't exactly saving the world. They are talking about protecting free speech, which of course is important, but it is not as dramatic as trying to go to Mars.
2:02Tim Higgins is a tech and automotive reporter for The Wall Street Journal and author of Powerplay, a book that traces the rise of Tesla at Elon Musk. Well, the challenge that Elon has going to have at Twitter is what are the stakes? Neither Elon Musk nor Twitter responded to requests for comment.
2:19The company's mission is what Musk hopes will drive people to be hardcore, a term he uses to describe working long hours at high intensity. You just have to put in, you know, 80 hour, 80 to 100 hour weeks every week. Obviously people at two o'clock in the morning because we finished up an event and we were all still energized because we're having such a good time.
2:38And Musk has used this idea of hardcore to rally his team over the years as they approach hard challenges. For example, in 2012, when Tesla was preparing to ramp up production of the Model S Luxury sedan, Musk sent his team an email with a subject line ultra-hardcore, telling them to
2:53prepare for a level of intensity that most of them had never experienced before. About three weeks after taking over at Twitter, Musk sent a similar email. But hundreds of employees opted to leave the company rather than sign up for Musk's vision of Twitter 2.0. The challenge here is Elon has inherited a huge workforce and he has to convince them to be on Team Elon.
3:17And we're seeing him try to go through those ranks of people to find the talent that he's going to need, to pivot the company to a private Twitter, and it's messy. Musk himself leads by hardcore example. I sleep on the couch over there. Last time I was here I actually stepped literally on the floor because the couch was too narrow.
3:34I showed up at work early one day, and it was just me and him and one security guy, the entire 5.5 million square feet. And I didn't know he was there, right? And at the factory when you, there's walkways and safety areas and stuff like that, when nobody's there, I just got on a bicycle riding around.
3:48And here Elon is asleep on this engineer's desk. In November, Musk tweeted that he was sleeping at Twitter's offices in San Francisco. And it's not just his time, but his money. How much did you put into this company? Oh man, about $55 million. In 2008, when Tesla was at its darkest moment and he put in his personal last millions of dollars to fund it,
4:13He was even couch surfing in Menlo Park and paying my business expenses with personal credit card debt, right? His approach is to do anything required to keep his businesses competitive. And he lived that every single day when I worked for him. Conrad left Tesla in 2011 for a no Nissan Mitsubishi.
4:37They, people that I've talked to with Elon talk about how he in one hand is incredibly inspiring. But on the other hand, a lot of people will say he was also exhausting and mercurial and after a while they just couldn't keep up with him. There is also a history of employees at Tesla and SpaceX alleging this conduct at the companies.
4:57Musk is also known to quickly make his company's leaner. When he became CEO of Tesla, he cut about 20% of the workforce. About a week after he took over Twitter, Musk laid off roughly 50% of the staff according to a document seen by the journal, and people familiar with the matter, estimated that likely
5:14over 1,000 have resigned. Former employees have said that this cut-throat approach instills in them this feeling that anyone working for Musk is the best of the best. Back in the day at Tesla, Elon would often say that people who work for him are special forces. He wants to hire a key engineer who in his mind has way more value than, say, a hundred
5:35engineers and to deploy those top talent on the hardest problems and be able to move faster and not have the same kind of level of bureaucracy. Former employees have said that Musk avoids traditional corporate hierarchy. If Elon was interested in something you were doing, he would come and talk directly to you.
5:53He's not going to go through a bunch of different layers of management and have the information filter up. Musk also motivates employees to work harder by raising the financial stakes. And Elon became CEO of Tesla. The economy was in shambles. It was the great recession. And there was huge questions about whether people were going to want to buy a luxury car
6:12and not just a luxury car, a luxury car that was electric. Similarities to Twitter today, we've got an uncertain economy. The company needs to start generating more money. It has a huge debt load. It has to find its place in this social media world that's under a lot of pressure.
6:31as the ad market kind of contracts. In November, Musk wrote in an email to Twitter employees that without significant subscription revenue, there is a good chance Twitter will not survive the upcoming economic downturn. Musk is still in the early stages of setting up his strategy for Twitter and finding people he trusts to help him transform the company.
6:52That's SpaceX. If you proved yourself to be capable, innovative, especially on a technical level, then that led to very, very rapid advancement throughout the company. If I were an employee at Twitter right now, I'd probably just do your job. Don't let them know your name.
你只有30秒时间把观点说清楚。
You have 30 seconds to make your point.
你每周就得投入,你知道,80小时、80到100小时。
You just have to put in, you know, 80 hour, 80 to 100 hour weeks every week.
例如,2012年,特斯拉准备提高Model S豪华轿车产量时,马斯克给团队发了一封主题为 ultra-hardcore 的邮件,让他们准备好面对大多数人此前从未经历过的强度。
For example, in 2012, when Tesla was preparing to ramp up production of the Model S Luxury sedan, Musk sent his team an email with a subject line ultra-hardcore, telling them to prepare for a level of intensity that most of them had never experienced before.
马斯克本人就是以硬核方式以身作则。
Musk himself leads by hardcore example.
马斯克也以迅速精简公司而闻名。他出任特斯拉CEO时,裁掉了约20%的员工。
Musk is also known to quickly make his company's leaner. When he became CEO of Tesla, he cut about 20% of the workforce.
当年在特斯拉,埃隆经常说为他工作的人是特种部队。
Back in the day at Tesla, Elon would often say that people who work for him are special forces.
如果埃隆对你正在做的事感兴趣,他会直接过来跟你谈。他不会经过一层又一层管理层,让信息逐级过滤上来。
If Elon was interested in something you were doing, he would come and talk directly to you. He's not going to go through a bunch of different layers of management and have the information filter up.
如果你证明自己有能力、有创新精神,尤其是在技术层面,那就会在整个公司里获得非常、非常快的晋升。
If you proved yourself to be capable, innovative, especially on a technical level, then that led to very, very rapid advancement throughout the company.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频原始视频文件
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版