大会演讲·中文精读

2014年马斯克出席能源创新峰会

Elon Musk at the energy innovation Summit (2014)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2014年,华盛顿,ARPA-E能源创新峰会的台上坐着两个人:即将卸任的美国能源部长朱棣文(Steven Chu),诺贝尔物理学奖得主;和马斯克。

主持人抛出的第一个问题带着点挑衅味道:如果奥巴马打电话请你当能源部长,你去不去?

马斯克的回答很干脆,不去。

理由也不客气。他说当部长这种活儿,不管干得多好,收到的批评永远比赞扬多。原话是:这不是我向往的那条路(马斯克)。

这场对话持续了将近一个小时,主持人最后自己都说超时了两分四十七秒。但聊出来的东西密度很高。从政府为什么创新慢,聊到2008年三家公司差点同时死掉,再聊到怎么判断一条技术曲线正在变陡。

政府就是一家巨型公司,而巨型公司天生做不了激进创新

主持人问的第二个问题本来是冲着朱棣文去的,但马斯克接了话。

他说,理解政府最好的方式,是把它当成一家巨型公司,地球上最大的那家。而大公司在激进创新这件事上,天生吃亏。

原因不复杂。大公司要养现有的业务,要应付股东,要让每个季度的数字好看。任何可能推翻现有产品线的想法,在会议室里都活不过三轮。规模越大,这套免疫系统越强。

马斯克承认有例外。苹果在乔布斯手里就是个反例,一个偏执到极点的人,硬推着整个组织往前做激进创新。另一条路是收购,大公司花钱买下那些真正在做激进创新小团队,把小公司的胆量装进自己的报表。

但这两条路都依赖偶然。前者依赖世界上恰好出现一个乔布斯,后者依赖市场上恰好有值得买的小公司。剩下的大多数情况,就是马斯克那句话:实体越大,越难做激进创新。

朱棣文接过了这个类比,而且接得很漂亮。他说,按公司来算,总统是CEO,国会是董事会,这个董事会有535个人,所以这位CEO有时候会觉得有点无聊。

在这个框架里,一个机构能做的事情其实有限。ARPA-E这个项目是总统提的,国会投票通过的,两党都支持。但资金一旦批下来,真正的变化发生在机构内部。

朱棣文在能源部推的那套东西,核心叫"建设性对抗"(constructive confrontation)。听着文绉绉,实际做法很粗暴:开项目会的时候,不要礼貌地念完自己的PPT然后等别人鼓掌。有人讲完,其他人直接说我不信这个,那这个数据怎么解释。吵起来,当场吵。

这套文化的源头是贝尔实验室。朱棣文说,那里的传统是你不用老老实实排队等发言,大家都把智力扔到桌上,想法在碰撞里长出来。

ARPA-E另一条设计是明确接受失败。立项的时候就写清楚,这些项目里大部分会失败,我们赌的是少数几个能跑出来。而且周期短,三年就得看出苗头。朱棣文自己评价这三年的成绩:全垒打可能还没出现,但已经有人跑到二三垒了。

主持人顺势问了个更狠的问题:贝尔实验室已经不存在了,这对美国经济是不是一个伤害?ARPA-E是不是在补这个洞?

朱棣文的回答很清醒。贝尔实验室当年做研发,最终目的是服务母公司,有明确的财务底线。ARPA-E不做出资方,只出钱赞助别人创新,等着私营部门把成果接走。他说两者最像的地方是人的质量,那批进项目的项目经理,水平是真的顶。

大学时代他认定三件事会决定人类未来

主持人提到马斯克几年前在圣地亚哥一个论坛上说过的话:有三件事驱动他,互联网、可持续能源、让生命成为多行星物种。

马斯克解释了这三件事怎么来的。

他在大学时想的问题是:哪些东西最可能影响人类的未来?筛到最后剩下三个。互联网。可持续能源,包括用可持续的方式生产能源、用可持续的方式消费能源。以及把生命延伸到地球之外,长期地、稳定地,让人类成为真正的太空文明、多行星物种。

逻辑很朴素。如果人类解决不了可持续能源,经济会先崩,这跟环不环保没关系。如果不能成为太空文明,那么地球上早晚会发生某件事,把我们所知的文明抹掉。

他说自己当年并没指望真的去做这些事,只是觉得这几件事必须有人做,如果哪天有了机会,他愿意下场。

关于互联网,马斯克用了一个很妙的比喻。他说互联网让人类更像一个超级有机体,给了人类一套神经系统。以前人体里的细胞只能靠渗透作用慢悠悠地感知彼此,现在不一样了,你坐在巴西雨林正中间,掏出卫星电话,就能连上全人类的知识库。相当于你的脚趾知道的事情,你的大脑立刻也能知道。

能源问题不解决,环境还没恶化经济就先崩了

这个判断值得单独拎出来说。

很多环保议题的讨论,起手式都是气候变化、海平面、物种灭绝。马斯克绕开了这一整套论证。他说的是,哪怕你完全不关心环境,哪怕你觉得碳排放是个骗局,你也得解决可持续能源。

因为化石能源是有限的,开采成本会越来越高,价格会越来越贵。一个建立在不断上涨的能源成本上的经济体,最后一定会撞墙。他用了一个词:经济崩溃。

这个角度解释了特斯拉为什么存在。它不太像一家"环保公司",它在解决一个成本曲线问题。电池成本往下降,太阳能发电成本往下降,整个经济体的能源底座才稳得住。

也解释了为什么马斯克说,这三件事(互联网、能源、太空)之间没有别的联系。它们唯一的共同点,是他判断它们决定人类未来的走向。剩下的都是执行细节。

那笔著名的政府贷款,来龙去脉要讲清楚

主持人提到特斯拉拿了能源部一笔大额贷款,开玩笑说"贷款不是补助",还打趣说在后台休息室可以重新谈谈条款。

马斯克借这个机会把事情的来龙去脉讲了一遍,因为外界一直搞混。

这个项目叫"先进技术车辆制造计划"(Advanced Technology Vehicle Manufacturing Program)。签它成为法律的是小布什总统,不是奥巴马。很多人记错了。

申请筛选很严格,其中一条硬性要求是:申请公司必须是能活下去的公司。结果通用汽车和克莱斯勒当时正在走破产程序,直接不符合资格。

问题就出在这儿。通用和克莱斯勒的救助,跟先进技术车辆制造计划的公告,时间上撞在了一起。公众把两件事混成了一件,以为特斯拉拿的是救助款。马斯克说这两件事完全不同。

还有一层:这笔贷款是按里程碑发放的。你必须完成既定目标,才能拿到下一笔钱。项目里确实有一家参与方,因为没完成里程碑,拨款就停在那儿了。马斯克说这个结构设计得很合理。

主持人追问:你们的里程碑完成了吗?

马斯克回答:全部完成。

朱棣文补充了几笔。福特申请了最大的一笔贷款,日产要在田纳西造车,包括聆风(Leaf),也拿了一笔。这两笔是给车企的最大两笔,能源部认为都会还上。剩下的有些可能有风险。

他特别讲了福特那笔贷款的价值。那笔钱保住了三万五千个工作岗位,还让福特把产线改造成了高度机器人化的产线。区别在哪?以前的产线只能造一种车,改造后的产线几周、几个月就能切换成另一种车。这让福特在美国保住了制造能力,而不是把工厂搬走。

然后朱棣文罕见地替一家公司说了段好话。他说特斯拉是一家垂直整合到极致的公司,不只设计了整个平台和动力总成,连验收零件用的测试设备都是自己设计的,还深度参与供应商的开发。他说这是美国创新里最好的那一类,路子完全不同,如果成了,就是未来的方向。

他还特意说明,自己不是在给特斯拉做广告。

制造业和餐馆端盘子,到底是不是一回事

主持人问了个美国政策圈争论了很多年的问题:把制造业岗位换成服务业岗位,到底亏不亏?

朱棣文的回答很硬。他说有些人的说法是"工作就是工作,服务业岗位和制造业岗位一样",他强烈不同意。

他先讲了一个常识层面的道理。你在美国发明、在美国制造、在美国生产的岗位,会带动一大堆配套的服务业岗位。杠杆效应完全不是一个量级。

然后是数据。他提到了诺贝尔经济学奖得主迈克尔·斯宾塞(Michael Spence)的一篇论文,斯宾塞是他朋友,也是斯坦福的同事。那篇论文研究了二十年里美国新增就业的分布,把所有岗位分成两类:可贸易的,和不可贸易的。

什么叫可贸易?你种的小麦、玉米,可以装船卖到国外。汽车可以出口。这些都是可贸易的。

什么叫不可贸易?美国能源部长这个岗位不可贸易。餐馆服务员不可贸易。医院里的护士,绝大多数也不可贸易。

结论是:1980年之后的那二十年,美国新增的就业几乎全部集中在不可贸易部门。可贸易部门的就业增长,基本是平的。

朱棣文把这个结论推到极限:在一个美国必须跟全世界竞争的领域里,美国没有增长。这个状态没法长期维持。你总得从外面买东西进来,可你卖不出去东西。我卖你披萨,你卖我牛仔裤,这没问题,但总有一天你需要从外面拿到别的东西,那时候你拿什么换?

所以他说,认为可以放弃制造业这个根基的想法,是深层错误的。美国今天的岗位大部分是服务业,这话没错。但制造业是根,因为那些是可贸易的东西。

还有一层他没明说但意思到了:美国公众的天赋和兴趣是多样的,每个人都去当股票经纪人不现实。制造业提供了另一条路。

马斯克顺着这个话题补了特斯拉的数据。特斯拉给奔驰和丰田供应电动动力总成,其中很大一部分是出口的。Roadster这款车已经出口到31个国家。长期看,他们预计生产出来的车里,60%到65%会卖到欧洲、亚洲和其他地方。

他反问了一句:如果别的国家能把车出口到美国,为什么美国造不出足够好的车出口给他们?

一条排放法规,意外让美国车变得能出口了

朱棣文在这时候插了个观察,很有意思。

他说,美国环保署和交通部提高了燃油经济性标准,这件事刺激了一个谁都没预料到的结果:在美国造的车,突然变得能出口了。

逻辑是这样的。如果一辆车只能跑每加仑15到20英里,它在国际市场上根本没有竞争力,那点油耗在欧洲和亚洲卖不动。但如果一辆车能跑35、40、45英里每加仑,它就是全球市场能接受的产品。

所以一项看起来是"政府教我们怎么做生意"的监管,实际上悄悄打开了出口通道。

朱棣文说,汽车厂商已经开始意识到这一点,开始想"我们可以在美国造车然后卖出去",而不是继续守着老路子。

这段对话里藏着一个更大的判断:政策的真正作用,有时候跟它字面上要求的东西关系不大。它改变了整个行业的成本结构,逼着所有玩家往同一个方向挪。挪完之后,竞争力自己就长出来了。

第一性原理不用来装聪明,用来找别人漏掉的位置

主持人提到马斯克在圣地亚哥说过的一句话:限制你的只有物理。马斯克笑了笑,把这句话解释了一遍。

他没说自己什么都能干。他的意思是,物理定律划出来的边界绕不过去:物理学说这件事不行,那你大概真的不行。要尊重热力学定律,尊重能量和动量守恒。

顺着这个,他讲了那套被引用过无数次的方法论,但讲得比平时更细。

日常思考用的是类比推理。你参照别人做过的、过去发生过的事情,稍作调整,这叫因循。这条路省脑子,人类绝大部分时间都这么活着,也必须这么活着,不然一天下来脑子就烧了。

但如果你真想做出新东西,就得切到另一套模式。找到这个领域里最基础、几乎无可争议的事实,从这些事实往上推,一直推到一个结论。

真正值钱的是下一步。如果推出来的结论跟行业共识不一样,那你的机会就来了。因为共识是类比推理的产物,它继承了过去所有的错误假设。

他特别强调,这种模式不能整天开着。太耗脑力。生活里绝大多数决策还是靠类比,靠经验,靠别人踩过的坑。只有当你真的想创新的时候,才切过去。

朱棣文接了一段,讲的是同一件事的另一个侧面。他说看一项新技术,先别管别人吹得多响,先问:理论极限在哪里?注意,是物理意义上的极限,不是海森堡不确定性原理那种听着唬人的东西,是真正的下界。过了这条线,这事就没戏。

然后问第二个问题:从今天出发,五年之内,现实中最远能走到哪?

这两个数字之间,就是你能折腾的空间。想清楚这个区间,脑子会自动聚焦,该想什么、不该想什么,一目了然。

他说成功的创新者一直在做这件事。

主动去找人骂你,是最划算的反馈机制

马斯克给的第三条建议,是主动去寻求负面反馈。

他自己的说法是:这听起来有点怪,但你得从懂行的人、从朋友那里,主动去要批评。

原因很人性。人不会主动给你负面反馈,因为怕伤感情。他们看着你做的事情,心里清楚这不对,但他们不说。等你撞了墙回来,他们才说"我早就觉得有问题"。

所以你得自己去问,而且要问得足够具体,让对方没法用客套话糊弄过去。你需要知道的是自己错在哪里,这跟面子没关系。

朱棣文把这一点接回了ARPA-E。他说这套东西正是他们在能源部建立的文化:听到一个不认同的想法,不要礼貌地坐着点头,直接说我不认为这是对的,理由是这个那个。然后大家坐下来吵,吵完之后,要么你发现自己错了,要么对方发现了自己的盲区,双方对问题的理解都深了一层。

他说这种文化从ARPA-E开始,现在正在往能源部其他部门扩散。

朱棣文的补充:去找那条斜率正在变的曲线

主持人问,给在场三千个正在挣扎的创业者两三条最重要的建议。

朱棣文的回答是一套寻找方向的方法。

他说,你得四处看,找三种信号。第一种,某个领域出现了突破性思维的微光。第二种,某项技术一直存在,但从来没被用到这个行业里。第三种,一个正在兴起市场,摆明了有需求没人满足。这三种信号,都是真正能驱动成功的入口。

然后他讲了自己年轻时的例子。

他读研究生的时候,激光在1960年代初就已经被演示出来了。可调谐激光是1970年发明的。到1972年,他的导师其实并不在激光领域,连激光的名字都不太熟。朱棣文跟导师说,我们得进这个技术。

怎么进?他的答案很具体。别去买一台现成的激光器,要去造出下一代更好的东西,让自己跑在整个领域的前面。只有这样,你才能做别人做不了的实验。

他还提到,八九年前他就在关注储能和超级电容,那时候电池技术的进步曲线几乎是平的,慢得让人着急。但你能感觉到,某些东西正在积累,那条曲线随时可能换一个斜率。感觉到这一点之后,要做的就是扑上去,把技术做出来,并且把能帮你做这件事的人聚在身边。

他用了"身后的浪"这个说法。你得站在一个正在形成的浪前面,而不是浪过去之后追着跑。

2008年,三家公司同时站在悬崖边上

主持人问马斯克,同时当两家公司的CEO是什么体验。

马斯克说,他不推荐。

然后他补了一句更实在的:我做这些,是因为我觉得自己必须做,跟我愿不愿意做没关系(马斯克)。

这句话放在2014年说,分量不轻。他接着说,事情从来不像看上去那么好。外面的人觉得这几年挺顺,实际有很多年非常痛苦。2008年,他这三家公司差点全部死掉。特斯拉、SpaceX、SolarCity,同时走到悬崖边。

那一年特斯拉的融资差点断掉,SpaceX的猎鹰一号连续三次发射失败,第四次才成功。任何一家倒下,另外两家大概率跟着完。

所以当主持人问他"你觉得现在一切都很顺利吗",他的回答是:从来没有看起来那么好。

一个被忽略的收尾:他当场宣布提前还贷

对话快结束的时候,马斯克做了一件很少见的事。

他说,既然今天聊到这儿,他想做个公开承诺:特斯拉要把这笔贷款的还款时间缩短一半。原本还有十年,现在打算用一半或更短的时间还完。

他还顺带讲了讲特斯拉当时的成绩。车出口到多个国家,给奔驰和丰田这两家全球最受尊敬的品牌供应动力总成,拿了年度电动车奖。

然后他说了句带情绪的话:如果能源部出了问题时大家都来骂,那么成功的时候,也该有人夸一句。

这句话背后是一段真实的处境。那些年,围绕这笔贷款的质疑一直没停过,特斯拉被当成政府乱花钱的典型。而事实是,这笔钱是带利息的贷款,按里程碑发放,全额偿还。公众记住的却只有"政府给了特斯拉钱"。

主持人在最后开了个玩笑,说马斯克早年第一家公司Zip2,投资人里就有纽约时报,后来那笔投资还帮纽约时报做起了线上业务。所以纽约时报后来写特斯拉的那些尖锐报道,算不算自己打自己。

现场笑成一片。

这场对话里最值钱的,是那些不带修饰的判断

回头看这一个小时,马斯克讲的东西没有一句是漂亮话。

他说大机构做不了激进创新,这是结构性的,跟里面的人聪不聪明没关系。他说自己同时管两家公司是被迫的,不是选择。他说2008年差点全盘皆输。他说人不会主动告诉你错在哪,你得自己去要。

朱棣文讲的则是另一面。他在体制内待了几年,讲的是怎么在一个535人的董事会眼皮底下,硬生生造出一小块能吵架、能失败、能快速迭代的地方。

两个人讲的东西拼在一起,其实是一件事的两个面。创新的底子从来都是那套能容纳失败、能容纳冲突、能快速验证的结构,灵光一现只是它的副产品。这个结构可以是一家公司,也可以是一个政府项目。

区别只在于,公司可以自己决定要不要建这套结构,政府得先说服535个人。

  • 挑一个你手上正在推进的方案,找张纸写下这个领域里几乎无可争议的三条事实,从这三条往上推,看看结论和行业通用做法差在哪。差的地方,就是你还没被别人占掉的位置。
  • 找一两个会当面说你错的人,定期问同一个问题:你觉得我这个方案哪里有问题。问完之后,先别解释,把话听完再回应。
  • 判断一个新方向,先查理论极限,再估五年内现实能走到哪。两个数字之间的空间太小就别进去,空间够大就值得全力押注,而且要造出比现有最好的东西更好一档的版本,别只是买一台现成的设备。
  • 审视你所在业务的收入结构,把可贸易和不可贸易的部分分开算。可贸易那部分才是长期竞争力所在,别让它在你手上慢慢萎缩。
  • 如果你在大组织里推新东西,先接受规模带来的创新折损,然后用三件事对冲:小团队、独立预算、按里程碑放款。做不到这三条,激进创新基本没戏。
  • 同时扛多个高风险项目之前,先问自己一句:这是我觉得必须做的事,还是我想做的事。前者可以撑过2008年,后者撑不过。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00now we have the Secretary of Energy Steven Chu and innovator galore CEO and product architect at Tesla CEO of SpaceX in creator of paypal Elon Musk LM thank you for joining us to join us putting on here and Steven there would be great so we're going to have again have some fun have a bit of a an informal chat with with two giants and I thought I was started off a little bit fun maybe a little bit risque that I understand Steven that you have a Nobel Prize on your wall and that some people have said hey when you're dealing with Congress and talking about sequestered maybe you should take it on off the wall and when you're having a meeting with that Center

0:47and say hey here's what I've got what do you have bad idea bad idea hasn't worked for you I also heard at the end one of the inaugural dinners will.i.am came up to you and said you know Steven you're really really cool but one way to get even cooler is to change your name to MC energy taking it upset you yeah

1:11that's true and you did go around that night and end up well we have I thought where we'd start a longe great to have you with us out from California I thought we'd start the conversation in an interesting way because Steven you're known for investing and thinking about the transition from non-fossil fuel energy to renewable energy trying to think about how you systematically do that bring science and innovators and government resources to get together to do it you're going to be leaving fairly shortly I assume you've announced that you're going to be leaving your post a lon musk is here he's quite an innovative guy he's gotten a lot of awards and I'm just sort of interested

1:48in starting off conversation by asking you should you President Obama call you and say would you like his job how would you do it differently Wow well I think Steve's done a pretty awesome job actually I think I bought out of a hard time doing a better job so and I think being Secretary of anything is a really tough tough role to hold and one way you tend to get I think a lot more criticism than praise no matter what job you do so weõll it is not a

2:23road to which I would aspire you're a young man you've revolutionised payments you've done a lot of revolution in cars and batteries you're now revolutionising our access to space and you're doing this in part on on the the backs of scientists and other innovators and some government investments but you're outpacing what government has been able to do and so my question was not a facetious one it was if you were able to not have the the environment if you were able to basically jump ahead and you know steven is is also a brilliant innovator and nobel laureate of course in physics but what makes you who you are how do you how are you able to do

3:02these things which government has found itself less able to accomplish as quickly well i mean i think one way to think of government is is to think of it as essentially a large corporation or the largest corporation and generally large corporations have a harder time with radical innovation than been small comfort smaller companies that there are some exceptions that rule like Apple but it's generally true that the larger company is the hot the harder it is to to execute innovation now there are ways to get around that by in the private sector by acquiring smaller companies that that that do do the radical innovation or by having someone like say

3:47Steve Jobs who is just relentlessly hardcore about pushing radical innovation but a bit but I think it is just generally true that the larger the corporation or large the entity the the harder it is to to engage radical innovation Oh Steven it seems to me sitting here at an arpa-e conference that arpa-e is a very innovative notion of how do you move from their very large maybe I would argue risk avoiding of our environment of government and here you've got rpe which really is about encouraging you know maybe not risk but investment innovate and would love you to reflect for a moment on on how you think this experiment is going and what more needs

4:30to be done particularly in the in the air energy area of next generation and right well you know going to the corporation analogy I've got a CEO the president I got a very diverse Board of Directors 565 is this little bit bored in Congress but but within that you there's many things you can do within the agency certainly getting our PE going that was of course voted on by congress proposed by the president you know lots of bipartisan support but once you have the funding say let's get started within the agency you can then say how can it be different and so we went in there thinking this could be a new example of how we want to get a lot of department of energy programs and

5:21it's yes you're going to have to take risks i was designed into the program it was written into the American competes act that philosophy was written into rising above the Gathering Storm that it's ripped its research its development and it's very intimate we didn't we don't expect all those things to work but they're short hits it is not a long-term thing this is a short hit get in there see if it's going to work it's going to be a home run is it we wanted home runs now after three years is a argument home runs well maybe not but there's a people rounding second and third base so it's looking good and so and then the culture in our PE is something else that was very different

6:05you had a bunch of program managers who sit around and instead of politely presenting their program and advocate for their program they would listen to what everyone else said and they would start to say well I'm not so sure that I believe that what about this what about that and was described as constructive confrontation that was exactly the thing we got it Bell Laboratories that you know you're not completely wait your turn you're going to old discusses the divine intellect of the group would develop those ideas and that is very different and of course then there's their spirit that oh my gosh this is going to be something special and so far it has been very

6:42special so much grew out of Bell Labs and and of course you were at Bell Labs is arpa-e essentially taking that there is no bell labs today so is and I'm interested in whether that is a very harmful thing for the US economy is that what r PE is now replicating and what do you think is important to sort of institutionalize that sort of constructive confrontation how do you look at the future of that kind of big investment in basic research that they would drive the country forward well to be fair at the very very different bell labs research and development ultimately was to serve the company and they had a financial bottom line RPE is we are

7:19funders of other innovators and but the Bell Labs beer I was talking about can be exactly the same the quality of the people we got into the program were truly outstanding and so that part of the bell lap spirit was there but but you know we're not we're not there in business to to do something we're there to sponsor very sponsor innovation that

7:46the private sector will pick up and run with elan to think a little bit about the agenda for today which is essentially about innovation you shared a while back actually in a forum that was organized by the Atlantic this was done in San Diego at a forum we call the Atlantic meet specific and you spoke there and said you had three wheels spheres that drove your interest one was the internet the other was sustainable energy and the other was making life multiplanetary all right would you should like to share a little bit about the making life multiplanetary bit it might be slightly off topic but but I guess I can talk about a little bit not necessary not about getting there on you

8:26know here's about innovation with rockets of space with batteries and cars which I assume ur are somehow in your mind integrated as component pieces of changing the way we live creating sustainability and thinking about moving you know moving into the other spheres well the thing that really i mean when i was in in university I think about what were the things that would most likely affect the future of humanity in least as far as I could see and the three things seem to be the internet sustainable energy which which requires with producing it in a sustainable manner and consuming it in a sustainable manner and and then the third being extending life beyond Earth on a

9:06permanent basis who have become a true spacefaring civilization of multi-planet species I thought as one sort of thinks about the future history of humanity those if we don't take those paths then it will be really very different if there was no internet if there was if we were unable to solve sustainable energy obviously they'll be economic collapse if we were unable to become a spacefaring civilization that eventually something would happen on earth that would eliminate civilization as we know it so I thought those those three things needed to be addressed and not that I

9:42expected actually in college that I would address them or have but I hadn't things as soon as though I thought this would I'd have a dive at I have an option you to do it but but that that's essentially what connects them there's not there's not any other connection with respect to it obviously the Internet has happened and it's amazing it's transformed my life and I think it's actually made humanity a much more of a superorganism than we have a word before and it's like it's given humanity and nervous system so it's like every cell in the body can notice what the rest of the cells are doing essentially whereas previously they would occur buy

10:20us some sort of process more like more like osmosis as opposed to you know your your brain knowing what your toe knows right where you can be in the middle bit of a Brazilian jungle give a satellite phone connection you're connected to all of humanity's knowledge which is pretty amazing so but I think as far as Earth

10:42is concerned I think the biggest problem that humanity faces is one of sustainable energy we don't solve that problem the century independent of any environmental concerns we will face economic collapse this is obvious it's too logical really you know if do the sustainable and it's not part of what you brought into Tesla that you're concerned about energy batteries and it brings this you know really did to secretary Chu you have a robust array you're one of the recipients of large grant from the department energy nor gratis or grin not not a grant alone yes and if if we'd like to change those terms of course there's a be a good opportunity you know we're back in the

11:22green room in here I can tell a deal had just been done it's with interest Johnson with interested in DC everything's a grant good job good try but in sustainable energy i assume that the the loan that you have with interest is really built around a partnership and looking at you know next-generation batteries and opportunity creating this and so I'm interested in how you see your own product in this Steven love they draw your thought and why this investment or that investment yeah own makes sense I'm sure well first of all I

12:00think it's worth just talking about about the book the program under which we received the ballon it's called the advanced technology vehicle manufacturing program it was actually signed into law by president bush although people will think of signed by Obama no it was actually signed by President Bush the and then there was a quite a careful consideration of the

12:29applications that came in and and one of the requirements actually of that loan was that you had to be a viable company and as a result General Motors and Chrysler were ineligible at the time because they were going through bankruptcy proceedings unfortunately that so stay back the viability now in terms of the grant makers or then on yeah I think they're more respect tubing Bible that through quite obviously dramatic restructuring but because the the bailout of GM and Chrysler occurred roughly the same time as the announcements for the advanced technology vehicle manufacturing program were announced people conflated those two and thought they were the same thing

13:16there are very different things and in fact in order for us to be the program is milestone based as well so in order for us to receive portions of the loan we must make progress along along with concrete milestones and that's I think that's a very sensible way to structure a program and that's that's why for example one of the participants in the program that the disbursement stopped what when that that participant was unable to complete the milestones so I think that's a very sensible way I think it's I think it's really structured very well are you are you hitting your milestones we've hit all of our milestones yeah and Steven how do you feel about this program are are the

14:02other car companies going to apply and try and move this forward is this something that Tesla's the the the single loan recipient of right now or no first first they're not we've as Leon said GM caught a GM and Chrysler were not eligible Ford was for applied for long our largest loan we think that that

14:28long will be repaid we have confidence full conference board Nissan makes cars and Tennessee including nissan leaf and they wanted a loan to start you know making cars in Tennessee like the week we think that loan is going to be repaid those are the two biggest loans to car companies there are others which may be a risk but but i would say in you know any new car company even but in those days even even a ford nissan was

14:59accessary risk but even for was considered risky but but but what it did is it preserved over 35,000 jobs just for that one lone ward and and allowed them to retool to go to higher stage robotic automation so they can program on the line instead of program to generate just one type of car the line could be reprogrammed very very quickly you know in months weeks so that they can produce something else so it gave them a manufacturing capability in the u.s. that would keep the jobs in the US so so there were so now with Tesla you

15:38know this is a very innovative camera any new company bear some risk but on the other hand its way of innovation the way it's pushing this it's a totally different approach to an electric vehicle they're incredibly vertically integrated company a meaning that they not only designed the entire platform the drive the motor chain electrons they designed their test equipment for the acceptance of the of the parts and they work with the suppliers I don't want to sound like an ad for because I know but but I'm just saying this going but this is but this is the innovative the most is the best of American innovation in the sense that it's it's a totally

16:23different approach it's a radical approach and if successful it's it's going to be the wave of the future and you know one of the reasons why i like arpa-e so much and I've met many of the people who attend this this this meeting from last year in this year is that there are real innovators and business people out there struggling trying to kind of you know fix whatever puzzle they're dealing with they're not only dealing with it within the u.s. context they're dealing it with it with the realities of a globalized world and you know when you think about the kinds of you're from South Africa your your your whether it's SpaceX or you're dealing

17:01with you know technology you're now dealing with a global format you were emphasizing us jobs us technology which i think is also important because there's a sense that stewardship here is something we need to get back to thinking about we may have lost that track you get a sense I let me ask you as a businessman you get a sense that the United States you've cited Bush administration for science but do you think we're beginning to shift i remember a mckinsey report saying you know that America benefited tremendously from every offshore job i remember in earlier presidential administrations advisor to the president didn't matter what we made in the United

17:36States a potato chip and a semiconductor chip or the are the same and and you get a sense that they're you know some people call it industrial policy but let's just call it you know a sense that manufacturing and that creating things in the US economy is back and that takes smart policy and I'd love to get your thoughts on this even just in your leaving your job soon but you've been at this yeah and it's a hard nut to get people to believe that the government can really make a positive impact well it is smart policy but let me you know it's a great question here's here's the thing there are some who say it as a job as a job and service jobs are the same

18:17as manufacturing jobs I strongly disagree if you look at how the haces is embedded and how we got to where we are and this is looking back we're also looking forward there the jobs in manufacturing that you invent in America you manufacture America you produce here have all the other secondary service jobs associated with so this greatly leveraged the other more important thing to realize is if you'd looked over there's a Michael Spence a Nobel prize-winning economists a friend of mine happens to be from Stanford Ian a colleague if his published a paper about six months eight months ago that looked at jobs and all the new jobs were recreating the odd states over twenty

19:06year period and they divided it into service jobs into manufacturing of tier 10 22 through all these things and but he really divided between what would be called things that you do that are tradable and things that are not tradable let me give you an example if you're a farmer and you go a wheat or corn that's tradable you can ship it abroad cars are tradable you know things of that nature are tradable what's not tradable the US Secretary of Energy is not tradable it's the US sector of energy restaurant jobs are not tradable all right it's serving that most hospital job not tradable okay the job growth in yon stays remarkably grew a lot very healthy

19:50time imperion since nineteen eighty to ninety two 2020 years only in the non-tradable sector think about that all the jobs were in the non-tradable sector the job growth in the tradable sector was flat right so now think about this in areas where the United States has to compete globally we didn't grow now what

20:20you take that to its natural limit you're in a very bad place because you still need to import things into the US but we're not exporting things you get to a very bad place if I sell you pizza and you sell me blue jeans that's okay but eventually we're going to need something else from outside the US and so on this larger context this notion

20:43that you can give up manufacturer as a root foundation of yon States wealth is I think deeply flawed it is part of you know yes most of our jobs are today's service jobs but manufacturing is a root foundation because those are tradable things and not only that in terms of the wide diversity and talents in the American public you want you know not everyone's going to be a stockbroker or something like that and so so that's another thing where yes good sensible policy to actually get horses back to look at in the long term what will be good for our citizens actually if I may be coming on that with respect to Tesla we have as customers Mercedes and Toyota

21:32so we supply electric powertrains to them much of that being exported and we have a tesla roadster have been exported nap to 31 different countries long term we expect probably something in the order of sixty to sixty-five percent of the cars that we manufacture will be exported to europe asia and then other parts the world as well so do you think that that keeps king of your point that that isn't it if if other countries can export their cars to us why can't we make cars that are good enough to export to them mm yes can I add to that and what I'm seeing the first time it's actually stimulated by the higher mileage standards that EPA and transportation put out all of a

22:19sudden cars being manufactured in the united states are now exportable because there's their smartly alarm limo fuel-efficient and so what you think would be a quote regulation telling us how to do our business is actually stimulating this thing in a very subtle way where if you know if you know except from a few exceptions if you're only making cars to get 15 20 miles to a gallon that's not mass-market exportable if you're making cars to get 35 40 45 miles a gallon that is and so that's another thing that's you see beginning happen the car manufacturers are beginning to say you know what we can build me on states and export rather than you know building another kind well

23:04I remember I worked for Senator Bingaman in the 1990s I remember at that time in this arena we had Sandia National Laboratories there and they had cooperative research and development agreements with very large firms like Intel General Motors and others and the guys that were running the GM greata were very explicit in over that they have the agreement to try and take all the dual use or you know non national security technology they could get out of the agreement and to apply it to their facilities in China and they said if we didn't do that we won't be there in 30 years so this was raised interesting ethical questions for me as a you know taxpayer-supported down

23:39security research but it's hard to get these equations right because technology flows PhDs flow and you have it but while we have just a few minutes left I'd like to ask you you're both such giants in in the world of innovation and a lon youyou've not just done I mean it's ironic because you've had some tough media recently in the New York Times I was just reminded that this was

24:01entirely your fault not because of bad right Elon's first foray into business was a company called zip to which the New York Times was an investor in and you actually help take the New York Times Online so any that was years ago I right I think that's called being cold hoist on your own petard yeah so but from that and and paypal and Tesla of course Solar City where I've interviewed a number of the your friends and colleagues that have helped put that together and Steven with you and your in your research work at Berkeley and others you know forget yourself as a powerful secretary of energy but just in terms of innovating thinking out of the box and doing things

24:42that no other people have done before we have three thousand people in the room who are struggling to find that kind of those what are the right ingredients to make innovation work not just innovation but then disrupting incumbents getting financed and capital partnering in the right ways and I'd love to just get two or three important lessons from you that this crowd should hear as they struggle with their own aspirations okay yeah

25:14well I think so you leave for suggestions that people vote for executing on everyone in my 0 1 million we do what you've done but maybe in different area I think I'm not worth they really knew what they would want that actually yeah it's never as good as it seems they think things are better these days but but for many years there was it was very painful and we

25:43almost lost everything back in two thousand eight so at Tesla yeah it worked all three companies almost died in 2008 because that SpaceX when you're still running to the company's full time right as CEO right how's that going for you I don't recommend it yeah yeah it's it's not i I'm doing this

26:09because I think I have to not because I want to okay so that's it's maybe an important consideration so doing what you have to do I also remember in san diego meeting was fascinating you conveyed that the only limits on you and your aspirations were physics well i was a really great line that's that's yeah well i'm not saying that i can do anything within limits of physics but i'm saying if if physics says you can't do it that you probably can't boy you should get a she gonna rip a really big nobel prize yeah what are the two yeah yeah you know certainly important to serve the laws of thermodynamics and conservation of energy momentum and that

26:53kind of thing I see and Steven yes I would agree and I ok we're straight on loss of fizzy what thoughts for innovators in the in the room I think when I look at both what I've done certain Sam would be long has done with number of people then you cast around and you look for areas that you begin to see either a glimmer of a new breakthrough type of thinking or the

27:27some technology in this sector has been left alone not applied to that sector and or there's a just a need based on an emerging market and those are the things that actually are can be real drivers for success innovation when you see a glimmer of a breakthrough I mean he'll I was telling me when he was a graduate student he was into energy storage and supercapacitors things like that and I think many of us saw eight ten years ago battery technology before that was crawling along crawling along quantal and also in you sleep wait a minute there's beginning to see something that will take a different slope and if you think that it could take a different

28:10slope do those things that develop that technology and surround you with people that help you develop that technology so you become the leader okay but but but there's something behind you that's building wave that you're going to ride and so that's very important and and so in the things I did my research career when I was a graduate student lasers had been demonstrated in the early 60s the tunable laser was invented by nineteen seventy by 1972 even though my thesis advisor had not been in lasers didn't know lasers name I told them you know what we got to get it into this technology but you get into it not by purchasing a laser you get into it by

28:54building the next best thing that keeps you ahead of the pack and then you can do signs no one else could do yeah I can't 22 recommendations which actually do slightly kilo physics which is I think a lot of times if you want to do something really innovative you have to apply it as sort of first principles analysis not and don't own reason by analogy analogies are referencing the past it so your first principles means you look at the most fundamental truths in a particular arena and the things

29:27that really are almost in disputed Lee corrected and you reason up from there to a conclusion and if you if you see that that conclusion is that is at odds with with what people generally believe then you have an opportunity now you can't operate like that on all things because it takes too much mental horsepower so mostly life you have to operate by reasoning by analogy but if you really want to invite you must reason for his first principles to identify the problem and then you also should seek negative feedback hopefully this sounds like a strange thing and proceed from from from your friends and from people who are knowledgeable people will not give you the negative feedback

30:07cruel to be kind no sir it's a agent you just want you need to understand where you're wrong it's good it's got nothing and put feelings aside and a lot of times people can look at what you're doing and they know that's wrong but you had but but they don't wanna hurt your feelings and that's why they don't tell you so yeah Stephen yeah we're right at the end but go ahead I lost I agree with any more days it'll be longer than that but

30:34but i think i agree with everything Leon said when you look at new technologies and you look at that there could be you know sinkhole a wild claims but you what is the quote theoretical limitations but not theoretical Allah the Heisenberg uncertainty principle you know there's a lower theory this is beyond this it's just you know it's not going to make it and then you swear is the technology and then you say how much space is there between that that realistically you can get there in five years okay and and that actually helps define things and and focuses the mind and what you should be thinking about what you shouldn't be thinking about so there are many things

31:12like that I think successful innovators do all the time the constructive feedback that honest feedback is exactly what we were establishing an r PE that's now being infecting the rest of the departments or energy you know if you hear an idea that you don't really agree with instead of politely sitting there and being polite you say no I you know that I don't think that's right you know this is why you know you're wrong and then and then you sit at a table and you talk about it and that's where you figure out are you right are you wrong and then you have a deeper understanding of what's going on and that's the type of culture that we want to that started

31:58in RPE which certainly has to be continued in RP but to the inside the rest of the Department of Energy ladies and gentlemen we've come a last last word I can make meal an announcement that maybe oh yeah it's interesting so everybody get Twitter out exactly so I really think that that the day we learn to to Teslas should be viewed as as a pretty significant success I mean we're exporting cars which were selling power trains to two of the most respected brands in the world mercedes and toyota we want electric oven car of the year last year I mean this is pretty good stuff I mean so if people are going to you know attack the deer we for bloody cylindrical a dick honestly I'm

32:50sure you know then there should be some praise for the DOA when there is a success I think you just help do a stock go up yeah and and and and to actually want to make a public commitment and we're going to codify it that Tesla is going to cut the payment time in half of the loan so we have ten years ahead of us will earn half or less great well we

33:20are we are two minutes and 47 seconds over but I think when you're sitting with two of the most brilliant innovators in the United States they can lend us that that little extra time I want to thank you both for for sharing your insights and how I make this work I know I tease you a little bit about the government private sector thing but what we're doing here and I think what arpa-e is doing is so important of essentially creating a platform raising aspirationally where we need to go as a nation bringing participants into this so that they can get constructive feedback negative and positive and that they've got real world examples to see what you've done over and over and over

33:55again if we had another hour or two you know it's interesting I've had an opportunity in my position to interview a lot of geniuses and when you're around genius it gives you an opportunity because people organize the way they see the world these guys are slowing down a little bit for us right now but when you're having a beer with them late at night you can sort of see how they see that the future and how they're operating and it is really incredibly valuable to all of us into people in room that you take the time to share with us and give us some on-ramps into how you see innovation and how it works so thank you so much

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份