股东会·中文精读

Tesla 财报电话会上的马斯克 Bingo | Elon, Inc.

Elon Musk Bingo on Tesla’s Earnings Call | Elon, Inc.

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2024 年 1 月的一个周三,几十万人同时在线,听一个 52 岁的男人讲他明年打算卖多少辆车。这些人里有华尔街分析师,有特斯拉员工,有纯粹来看热闹的粉丝。他们真正想知道的事情只有一件:他今天心情怎么样。

心情值多少钱?几千亿美元市值,几十万个工作岗位。

Bloomberg 播客《Elon, Inc.》在特斯拉财报电话会前一天做了这期节目。主持人 Joel Weber 代班 David Papadopoulos,请来三位嘉宾:从 2009 年就开始跑特斯拉、开过四十多场财报会的 Dana Hull,Bloomberg News 大科技团队负责人 Sarah Frier,以及《商业周刊》资深记者 Max Chafkin。

他们聊了两件事:马斯克最近那些让人皱眉的动作,以及怎么像内行一样听一场特斯拉财报会。

节目组还搞了个小发明,一张宾果卡(bingo card)。24 个格子,每个格子写一句马斯克的名言或者惯用套路。电话会一开始,你就盯着听,听到哪句划掉哪一格。

一次飞往奥斯维辛的公关行程

2023 年 11 月,马斯克在 X 上回复一条反犹帖子,说那是"事实真相"。广告主成批撤离。到了 2024 年 1 月,他还在想办法把他们请回来。

周一,他飞到波兰南部,参观了奥斯维辛集中营。私人行程,没有记者随行。之后他参加了媒体人 Ben Shapiro 主持的一场对谈。

Sarah Frier 用的词是"cringe",尴尬到脚趾抠地。她的原话大意是:跑去集中营洗白形象,然后宣称自己"向往成为犹太人",仿佛这场灾难跟你"沾亲带故"就成立了。她说自己作为美国犹太人,实在很难消化这套表演。

Max Chafkin 复述了他编辑 Naomi 的一个玩笑。普通人说了反犹的话,去华盛顿的大屠杀纪念馆走一圈也就算了。你要是犯了世界历史级别的反犹错误,放任成百上千个疯狂的反犹账号,还真心相信那些阴谋论,那你就得亲自飞一趟奥斯维辛。

现场照片把事情说得更清楚。马斯克神情肃穆,肩上扛着三岁的孩子,旁边站着一位奥斯维辛幸存者。这画面像极了政治竞选的一站。他当然不竞选任何职位,但舞台调度是政治级别的。更要命的是时间点:这一站正好卡在特斯拉财报周。

为什么非得现在飞波兰再飞回来?因为 X 的广告。

Sarah 说得很直白,马斯克和 X 的 CEO Linda Yaccarino 公开讲话时只有这一个主题,两人反复强调"你怎么能认为我们反犹"。与此同时,马斯克自己的推文涵盖各种反移民情绪和种族煽动内容,还在转发那些平台上最糟糕的账号。这不只是反犹的问题,这是一场以言论自由为名的全面拥抱,把以前被封禁、被认定危险的人全部请回来。

整件事里最荒诞的一幕出现在活动开场。主办方欧洲犹太协会(European Jewish Association)做了个思想实验:假如 1930 年代末的德国就有 X,也许大屠杀根本不会发生。

马斯克基本上认了这个假设。

Sarah 的吐槽是:那就拜托各位订阅 Grok 吧。

"我有两倍于非犹太朋友的犹太朋友"

在那场对谈里,马斯克说了这么一句:

我有两倍于非犹太朋友的犹太朋友。我是通过关联成为犹太人,我是向往成为犹太人。(马斯克)

这句话在节目里被反复回放。Max 说,问题不在于他说错了什么,问题在于他压根没打算回应任何实质质疑。整趟行程没有解释那些账号为什么被恢复,没有解释那条"事实真相"的回复,没有解释广告主为什么要回来。它只提供了一个画面:一个神情凝重的首富,站在人类历史上最沉重的地点之一。

Sarah 补了一刀:这是纯光学(optics),是公关,不是认错。

德桑蒂斯退选,马斯克的押注落空

同一周,佛罗里达州长 Ron DeSantis 在新罕布什尔初选前宣布退出共和党总统竞选。

2023 年 5 月,他选在 X 上宣布参选,和马斯克一起做音频直播。开场就崩了,服务器过载,二十多分钟只有杂音和音乐。马斯克当时的解释是:

在线人数实在太多了,服务器有点吃紧。(马斯克)

Sarah 的判断是,历史会记住这是一次糟糕的押注。而且押的不止一个。马斯克还给 RFK Jr. 办过类似活动,那人是知名的反疫苗阴谋论者。他也和 Vivek Ramaswamy 在 X Spaces 上聊过。

这些人有一个共同点:都不是特朗普,也都不是拜登。Sarah 说,马斯克在一厢情愿。他真希望自己不必贴着这两位中的任何一位。可看起来他必须选一个。他已经公开说过不会投拜登。

于是 X 上的修辞开始移动。投票阴谋论的内容多了起来。

特朗普不需要 X,但马斯克可能需要特朗普

Max Chafkin 那天早上翻了马斯克的 X 主页。他在发 2020 年大选的内容。

播客里之前就讨论过,马斯克对"选举被偷"这套说法好奇了很久,节目里用的词是"steal curious"。现在他在重述、转发特朗普及其支持者对 2020 年计票结果的有意误读。

Max 认为马斯克支持特朗普基本是板上钉钉的事,甚至可以说已经发生了。

背景是这样的:2020 年之后冒出一批右倾社交平台,Parler、Gettr,还有特朗普自己的 Truth Social。现在 X 有机会把整个市场收进来。反过来看,那些右翼媒体生意存在的理由,正因为 X 转向同一片市场而变得不那么成立。对马斯克来说,这是纯赚。

但特朗普不需要 X。

2020 年他需要 Twitter,2016 年更需要。现在平台完全变了。特朗普建立了自己的网络:一堆电子邮件地址,一堆电话号码,发一条足够吓人的消息,5 美元捐款就进来了。Sarah 说,政治募捐正在这样演化。政客必须靠 X 动员基本盘的观念,可能还留在马斯克脑子里,所以他奖励了那个愿意认真玩 X 的候选人。结果没成。

特朗普在这平台上看到的,和所有人看到的一样:它不再那么有效地驱动结果。显示给你的粉丝数,不等于真的有人在看。

所以结论有点刺:现在可能马斯克需要特朗普,多过特朗普需要马斯克。

Max 同意,还往前推了一步。特朗普是否曾经"需要"Twitter,本身也存疑。媒体有高估社交媒体影响力的习惯,更多时候是媒体追着大众关注的东西跑,而不是反过来设定议程。特朗普缺席这个平台很久了,似乎也没造成多大差别。

和克鲁格曼的恩怨,降级成热带低压

DeSantis 退选之后,克鲁格曼(Paul Krugman)在 X 上嘲讽他,说别忘了此人在新冠上错得多离谱。这指向左派长期以来的批评:德桑蒂斯无视 CDC 的基本指南。

马斯克回了一句:你是经济学这个职业的耻辱。

Max 自称"埃隆恩怨鉴赏家",很遗憾地报告:克鲁格曼没接招。所以这是一场假恩怨。

他顺手吐槽,想到马斯克像学术经济学鉴赏家一样点评,就觉得好笑。马斯克根本不知道克鲁格曼是否给这个职业带来耻辱,他只是凭感觉回复。他确实有沃顿的商学位,也确实说过要办大学,可这不等于他懂学术经济学里的门道。他回的是"感觉",不是论证。

如果恩怨按飓风分级,这一场连热带风暴都算不上,最多算热带低压。

一场财报会,四十多次,一次没落下

Dana Hull 从 2009 年开始跑特斯拉,公司 2010 年 6 月上市。她开过四十多场财报会,可能接近五十场,一场没落下。

她先解释这玩意儿本来该长什么样。大多数公司的财报会极其无聊。CEO 念稿,CFO 念稿,内容基本是把股东信重复一遍。然后分析师提问:"恭喜好季度,Bob,能不能就某某方面多给点色彩?"

特斯拉完全不是这样。

马斯克不念稿。他会对分析师发火,会当场表示无聊。2018 年,Bernstein 的明星分析师 Toni Sacconaghi 提问,马斯克不回答问题,直接说这个问题"无聊且愚蠢"。还有一次,他干脆切到 YouTube,跟一个有频道的小伙子聊了 25 分钟。

所以每场财报会的头号悬念是:这位"亲爱的领袖"今天心情如何。

Dana 的解释是,股价反应很大程度取决于马斯克说了什么。财报本身的数字反而次要。1 月这场尤其重要,因为它设定全年的预期。明天的问题就一个:我们会看到一个亢奋、满口宏伟计划的马斯克,还是一个阴郁、念叨"我们给自己挖了坟"的马斯克。

马斯克只缺席过一次。

几年前他大张旗鼓地宣布,除非有大事要宣布,否则不再参加财报会。有一次真没参加,CFO 主持,Dana 说效果很好。然后他回来了。他离不开聚光灯,必须当主角。所以几乎每一场他都在。

2024 年交付多少辆,特斯拉不说

特斯拉没有给 2024 年的交付指引。2023 年卖了大约 180 万辆。今年说 200 万还是 250 万?增长曲线是什么形状?

整个电动车行业在放缓。电动车在整体车市里的份额还在涨,但不再是那种 50% 同比的爆发式增长。

还有一个问题:马斯克会花多少时间谈别的业务。我们是 AI 公司?能源?保险?Optimus 机器人?每一条线都有人想听。

历史上特斯拉的承诺多于兑现。他们会给一个区间,然后马斯克补一句:也可能有不可抗力,地震、疫情、海啸,我也说不准。

他确实爱把锅甩给宏观环境。前几场财报会上他猛批美联储和高利率,逻辑很直白:利率低我们就能卖更多车,利率高车对普通人就太贵了。

以价换量,可能再来一遍

2023 年特斯拉做了一个大赌:牺牲利润率换销量。2024 年这一手可能重演。

Dana 说,特斯拉还有毛利空间可以玩,代价是利润率会薄很多。马斯克完全可以在电话会上说:我们会继续主导市场,我们会继续降价。这是一条策略,只是财务报表会难看。

另一类指引则完全脱离单位数和利润率,比如全自动驾驶、Robotaxi。

Dana 转给主持人一份分析师笔记,里面给出的 Robotaxi 落地时间区间是 3 年到 10 年。区间大得离谱,但这份离谱本身就是信息。马斯克几乎每年都说 Robotaxi 就在拐角,说了快十年。分析师已经学会打折,或者干脆学会忽略。

一张 24 格的宾果卡

Bloomberg 做了一张卡,在 bloomberg.com/eloninc 或者《商业周刊》的社交账号上能下载。24 格,外加一个免费格。

Max 特意强调,这不是他们发明的。Twitter 上的马斯克粉丝、马斯克批评者、特斯拉"Q 军团",凡是相对这个人有意见的,做这玩意儿做了好多年。

他挑了几个格子出来讲。

G4 格是 Cybertruck。白送的,属于必中项。

B1 格是"听得见的抽大麻烟声"。B2 格是"抽大麻烟",光抽不够,声音得被听见。这两格概率很低。Max 开玩笑说,他现在的部分工作就是戴着耳机,专门等这一声。

Dana 最爱的是"相当乐观(reasonably optimistic)"这一格。

马斯克有一种非常独特的说话方式,说出来粉丝立刻学。我相当乐观年底之前能实现全自动驾驶。我相当乐观 2024 年能卖出 5 万辆 Cybertruck。这个句式本身就是一种承诺,同时又留好了退路。

宾果卡真正在追踪的,是语言。

Gigafactory 不是个真词。马斯克管自己的电池厂叫 Gigafactory,现在全球所有车企和电池公司都在说自己的 Gigafactory。Megapack 又是什么鬼东西,那是特斯拉对公用事业级储能产品的命名。Dana 说她想找个语言学家来专门聊聊这件事,聊聊一个人怎么把自造词塞进全行业的词典。

还有一点容易被忽略:听财报会的人有几十万。员工在听,粉丝在听,不只是华尔街分析师。

Max 把它比作口传诗人。语言学家认为荷马史诗是这么传下来的,一堆小对句,每次演出重新排列组合。马斯克的财报会也这样,一堆口头禅往上一扔,成了粉丝文化的一部分,粉丝既重复它们,也在搜寻它们。

听一场马斯克财报会,体验接近看一场泰勒·斯威夫特的演唱会。大屏幕上出现蛇,全场沸腾:蛇来了。这里换成 Optimus、Dojo、"我们给自己挖了坟"。

"没多少人理解这一点"

Max 最爱的另一格是"没多少人理解这一点(not many people understand this)"。

这句话他老说,它精准对应马斯克粉丝圈的某种许诺:你被授予了一套别人不懂的真理,你懂了,你就能致富,就能站进这个圈子。它同时提供文化归属和财富预期。

还有一格是"把地球称作一个市场"。

Dana 的解释很有意思。他什么事都这么讲:你要么和我们站一起,要么反对我们;我们在为意识而战,为地球的未来而战。把地球叫"市场",暗含的意思是未来还会有行星际市场。这是他的世界观,随口就漏出来了。

焦点宿醉

因为这些套路用得太密,记者和分析师在电话会上的真实状态是"焦点宿醉"。

你必须逐字听,捕捉任何细微变化,因为新闻就藏在那里:他是不是稍微调整了某句口头禅,方向对公司是好是坏?他是不是在疏远 Dojo?是不是在给 Cybertruck 泼冷水?

上一次电话会就是个例子。他说 Cybertruck 是"我们给自己挖了个坟"。原话更狠一点:

没人比我们自己更会给自己挖坟。(马斯克)

Dana 通常一边听一边写博客,手边放着宾果卡,同时给员工、分析师、粉丝发消息,互相问:你听到他刚才那句了吗?

她说这游戏只有一张卡,所以要么所有人都赢,要么所有人都输。

几千亿美元取决于一个人的语气

Max 说,宾果卡听起来像玩票,但 Dana 一开场问的"我们会看到阴郁的马斯克还是开心的马斯克",其实极其严肃。

这家公司几千亿美元的市值、几十万个岗位,取决于马斯克在那两个小时里投射出什么状态,取决于他听起来是否沮丧。他在对一群分析师和粉丝说话,可这句话的重量超过任何一份季报。

Dana 给了个实用技巧。手上有彭博终端的话,边听边看盘后交易。他一阴郁,股价直接塌;他一自信,股价往上冲。这是行业里的老把戏。

批评也来了。有人在社交平台上说,这张卡缺了两格:"限制因素(the limiting factor)",以及"人口崩溃(population collapse)"。Dana 辩解,他财报会上不太讲人口崩溃,别的时候才讲。

节目组干脆邀请听众提意见:我们的卡缺什么?自己做一张。

反正三个月后又一场。

怎么玩这张卡

把一场财报会当成语言现象来听,能听出财报数字里没有的东西。下面是几条能立刻上手的做法。

  • 去 bloomberg.com/eloninc 下载那张 24 格卡,或者自己做一张,把马斯克的口头禅填进去。"相当乐观""没多少人理解这一点""把地球称作市场""给自己挖坟",这几个都是高频格。
  • 盯住三件事:2024 年交付指引给不给具体数字、给多少;毛利率和降价口风有没有变化;FSD 和 Robotaxi 的时间表是否又往后挪了。
  • 听他"相当乐观"后面接什么。马斯克用这个词的时候,通常意味着这件事还没有确定的时间表。把它翻译成"我很想做,但别指望按期"。
  • 听他抱怨宏观环境和利率的强度。抱怨越重,说明短期销量压力越大,也说明降价的可能性越高。
  • 有终端就看盘后走势,没有就看电话会结束后一小时的股价。市场对语气的定价比对数字快。
  • 与其听结论,不如听语气的变化。"挖坟"这类负面比喻再次出现,是比任何财报数字都早的信号。
  • 下一季度电话会前把这张卡翻出来,补上你上次没听到的格子。听三次以上,你会开始在他开口之前就知道下一句是什么。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:03well Elon Musk is now the richest person on the planet more than half the satellites in space are owned and controlled by one man starting his own artificial intelligence company well he's a legitimate Super Genius I mean legitimate he says he's always voted for Democrats but this year it will be different he'll vote Republican there is a reason the US government is so reliant on him Alan musk is a scam artist and he's done nothing anything he does is fascinating to [Music]

0:41people welcome to Elon Inc where we discuss Elon musk's vast corporate Empire his latest gambits and Antics and how to make sense of it all I'm Joel Weber sitting in for David papadopolis for the first time on elanic we're going to get you ready for Tesla's earnings call this Wednesday and we have a little surprise to take the fun factor to ludicrous mode to help us prep the popcorn we'll convene Dana hle who's covered more Tesla earnings call than any other reporter I know hi Dana good morning Sarah frier who leads the big Tech Team here at Bloomberg News hello and Max chafkin senior reporter at Bloomberg Business Week hey but first some recent topics we've discussed on

1:24Elon Inc have been back in the news a big one anti-Semitism both X and mus had been accused of amplifying hate speech on the platform on Monday musk got a private tour of the oswit concentration camp in southern Poland later he participated in a discussion hosted by Ben Shapiro a controversial media pundit let's listen twice as many Jewish friends as non-jewish friends I'm like Jewish by association I'm aspirationally Jewish Sarah what do you make of this visit to ashz and and sort of this musk non-apology apology it's extremely crank eny to go to a concentration camp to try

2:03to launder your image and say that you are aspirationally Jewish basically like this happened to your people by association I mean I can't believe it happened just welcome to the tribe brother thank you as one as a Jewish American I'm just so happy to have encountered another Jewish American Elon Musk I also agree why is doing this Max cringe so our editor Naomi joked yesterday that you know normally if you committed anti-semitic FAA you have to go to the Holocaust museum in Washington DC if you commit a world historical anti-semitic FAA if you allow hundreds or maybe even thousands of crazy anti-semitic accounts if you buy into crazy conspiracy theories if you as

2:55the world's richest man promote all this nonsense then you have to actually go to aitz and and so yeah I mean he's like attempting to make things right I guess but of course doesn't seem to be really addressing any of the normal stuff and is is claiming Jewish identity and an extremely depressing and cringeworthy way in my opinion just struck me as like a very political it's like all Optics it's like there is there is Elon Musk looking somber with let us note his three-year-old toddler on his shoulders and an oswit Survivor standing next to him too and ASA Survivor standing next to him and and then like the images that were released it very much struck me it

3:36looked like a a political campaign stop obviously musk is not running for any kind of office but it had all of the stage craft of a political moment during the week when Tesla is reporting earnings and so for him to sort of take the time to fly to Poland and fly back why now it's all because of X and advertising right Sarah I mean this is still sort of an effort to lure the advertisers back it's wild because this is the only thing that Elon Musk and Linda yako are talking about Linda's the the CEO when they speak publicly like they're just doubling down on the how could you think we were ever anti-semitic meanwhile if you look at what Elon Musk is tweeting there's there

4:16it runs the gamut there's there's all sorts of anti-immigrant sentiment all sorts of of you know other race CH stuff and and he's promoting a lot of these accounts that are the worst of the worst it is not just anti-semitism it is a wholesale Embrace of people who were banned before were considered

4:36dangerous to have on the platform in the name of his his Free Speech initiative and so the funniest thing about this about this event was that Elon Musk and the European Jewish Association which hosted it started with this kind of thought experiment like what if we had X during the late Yar period in Germany maybe we would never have had the Holocaust and Elon Musk claimed essentially that yes if if we'd only had Twitter you know back in the late 30s early 1940s the Holocaust never would have happened which like I guess you know pay sign up for grock guys okay elsewhere in current events Florida Governor Ronda santis dropped out of the Republican presidential race ahead of

5:16the New Hampshire primary one of our mini Elon Inc Pilots was all about DeSantis announcing his campaign on X with Elon which was glitchy shall we say yeah I think we got a just a massive number of people online so it's servers are straining somewhat so very glitchy Sarah frier how will history remember that musk to santis embrace just a you know a Bad Bet right

5:47but you know it wasn't the only candidate that he has aligned himself with he also did one of those for RFK Jr the known antia conspiracy theorist he's also been in X spaces with the vake ramaswami this is is all kind of wishful thinking on his part because he would really like it if he didn't have to Cozy up to either Trump or Biden but sounds like that's what he's going to have to do and he's already we've already discussed on this podcast that he he has said he will not vote Biden and so we do see a lot more Trump aligned rhetoric these days on X including voting conspiracy theories max if Ronda santis is out of the race who is elon's horse now I

6:37mean we've we're already seeing I I looked at elon's X page earlier today and you know he's he's tweeting about 2020 election stuff we've talked about this on the podcast before he's been sto the steal curious you know for some time and he is you know reiterating those concerns sort of rebroadcasting or or promoting would essentially amount to like willful misreading by Donald Trump

7:01and and Donald Trump type supporters of the 2020 voting results among many other things I mean he is essentially you know moving towards Trump as Sarah said I mean I think I think we're we're already seeing it I'm guessing we'll see it more like like frankly like many billionaires who affiliate with the right right where like there were other candidates that they might have preferred we have a New Hampshire primary today it doesn't look great for Nikki Haley and I think we're going to see this same Evolution playing Out Among other people not just Elon Musk Max any musk Trump predictions obviously Trump was a prolific Tweeter before musk

7:39purchased the platform Trump obviously has not been active on X but there sets up this Dynamic where you've got musk and Trump perhaps needing one another first of all to me musk supporting Trump is like a foron conclusion basically I think it's it's going to happen I think you could argue it is it has already happened the real question to me is like what happens you know after 2020 there were all of these right-leaning social networks that launched you know one of which was truth social Donald Trump's company and and then one another one of them is X essentially and it it does seem like X has a chance of like claiming that market you do sort of

8:14Wonder you know this is kind of a deep cut I mean you really have to be in the interested in sort of right-wing media and media landscape to care like what happens to Tru social parlor get her what's the right-wing dating site the right stuff like they're all these sort of media Business Media businesses that seem like their reason for being doesn't quite doesn't exist as much now that now that Elon Musk has so firmly turned X to that market so in that sense you know I I it's like all gravy for Elon I think I think the consolidation of the Republican Party probably allows you know X honestly to consolidate this sort of ecosystem but let's be clear Trump

8:51does not need X the way he needed Twitter in 2020 or 2016 it is a completely different plat platform now and Trump has managed to build up his own network that he has control over of email addresses of phone numbers of people who will hand him those $5 donations when he sends a scary thought I think that that's really how we are seeing political fundraising evolve and the idea that you know a politician needs to use x in order to to Rally their base may still be in musk's mind which is why he he rewarded the candidate that we leaning into it but as we've seen that hasn't been successful for them and I think that what Trump is is seeing with the platform is the same

9:37thing we're all seeing it is not as effective anymore for driving results with an audience the followers that it shows you you have are not all visiting the platform anymore so so I think in that sense maybe musk needs Trump more than Trump needs musk at this point I I 100% agree with that and I do think there's some question about about whether Trump Ever Needed Twitter like we I think there was a there has been a tendency to kind of like overstate the impact of social media and a lot of times media kind of chases like whatever

10:12people are into rather than like setting the agenda but with trump it it definitely is kind of has reached a different Dynamic where he's basically been absent from this platform for a really long time and it hasn't seemed to make a huge difference one more Fallout of DeSantis exiting the race there was a potential Feud of the week Max from Elon Musk trolling Economist Paul Krugman who's a columnist at the New York Times what what happened well I mean I'm a little as a Elon Feud connoisseur I am sad to report that Paul Krugman the Nobel prize winning economists princet University New York Times columnist well-known Progressive liberal commentator did not take the

10:53bait so it's kind of a fake Feud Krugman trolled D santis essentially saying like let's not forget how wrong Ron DeSantis was on Co pointing to long-standing criticisms among the left that DeSantis kind of ignored you know basic CDC guidelines and so on and Elon Musk responded like you are a disgrace to the economics profession which Krugman sadly did not take the bait and I'm mostly sad because it was sort of amusing to think of Elon as a connoisseur of like academic economics like he's like oh man you know you're just like disgracing canes or like like Elon has no idea who like it does not follow the the Deep nuances of Economics like he follows the

11:34wait he's starting a university and he has an economics degree from or business degree from Wharton come on he has like some grounding in business as a but that doesn't mean he's like some kind of connoisseur of who you know like academic economics State Academia yeah he doesn't know what whether krugman's are disgrace to anything he's just responded The Vibes if it's not a feud if it's what what's below a feud is it like a schoolyard scrap it's like a it's like a we have I think it's a big nothing Burger it's like it's like on the hurric you have the one to five on the hurricane scale but below that it's like a tropical storm this is like a a

12:10tropical depression maybe I guess as far as feuds go maybe watch yeah winry [Music] mix and now for our main event earnings okay publicly traded companies like Tesla get to do these quarter meetings where they reveal how much money they made or lost it's a face the music moment that gives investors analysts and journalists a better look at what's happening in a given company's business Dana you are the Tesla Pro here

12:43how many earnings have you done and can you give us a short history of Tesla's earnings calls so I've covered Tesla since 2009 they went public in June of 2010 and I I don't think I've ever missed an earnings call so that's what 10 years four times a year I don't know I've done like over 40 maybe 50 in my life and they're pretty wild because if you so like most corporate earnings calls are pretty boring frankly like the CEO reads scripted remarks the

13:15CFO reads scripted remarks that basically repeat what they've just put out in the shareholder letter and then they take questions from analysts that are like congratulations on a good quarter Bob like can you give us some color about the yada yada and it's just like very frankly it's very boring like Tesla learnings calls are not like that at all like Elon is not scripted he gets really pissed off at the analysts he gets bored and like a big question like when this call starts is like o what kind of mood is dear leader in and we've had some really wild earnings calls over the years I mean at one point in 2018 he called Tony Sagi who's like an great

13:52Analyst at Burnstein like you know that his question he like didn't answer his question he was like this is boring and boneheaded at one point he went to YouTube and took 20 spent 25 minutes talking to like a millennial who has like a YouTube channel and they're just really un they're very interesting calls and so much of like how stock reacts is to what does Elon say and then like what's the actual news from the call because it's all about like what does he say about you know things going forward and the January call is always really important because it kind of sets out the expectations for the year so tomorrow the question is like are we going to get ulent expand ensive like

14:29wonderful Elon or is he going to be like morose Elon talking about how they're digging their own grave like that's the big question on everybody's mind Elon is such a fixture here right like how many of these has he missed in your time covering the company he he's only missed one he made this big show a couple of years ago about how he's like not going to be in the earnings calls unless he has big news to announce and then there was one call that he missed that the CFO LED that was great and then Elon was back and he just can't stay out of the Limelight like he's got to be the main character like so he's only he's been on every single call okay so because this

15:07is a January call this one is more year ahead leaning than a typical one which would typically look back at the previous quarter is that right yeah yeah especially because Tesla has not given guidance for 2024 they have not said publicly how many vehicles they expect to deliver in 2024 we know that they roughly 1.8 million cars in 2023 so like

15:32what is the forecast like we're seeing kind of slowing growth in the EV sector like EVS are still growing as part of the overall auto market but it's not this like Blockbuster 50% year-over-year growth so that's a big question for investors are they going to say that they're going to deliver 2 million or 2.5 like what is the growth trajectory and then how much does musk talk about all the other aspects of the business is he going to be like we're an AI company or is he going to talk talk about energy or insurance or you know opt The Optimist robot I mean there's all these different sort of aspects of the business that that people are curious

16:07about and and what do everybody who's watching the company what what do we think about what the 2024 numbers could look like especially after all the price cuts of of last year but also POS possibly the slowing demand well do they tend to to overpromise you know cuz I know like a lot of companies have the opposite strategy where they under promise and then they try to beat that but historically Tesla has said more good things are going to happen than actually end up happening so what do we think it's kind of weird they'll give like a range where and musk will be like well like there could be a force majour and things that I can't control like

16:45earthquakes and pandemics and tsunamis and like I don't really know how things are going to go but he actually tends to blame the macroeconomic environment quite a bit like you know on previous earings calls he's he's really bashed the fed and high interest rat and been like look we could sell more cars if interest rates were lower the fact that interest rates are high is making the cars too expensive for people which is why they made this big Gambit to chase volume over profit margins and they could do that again he could say we're going to continue to dominate and we're going to cut prices and I mean that would be one strategy it's just that

17:18then then the margins are are much smaller but you know Tesla has room to play with their margins and we could see that again in 2024 it also seems like there's like a real guidance and then any mus guidance Elon will throw in hey like anything's possible like full self Drive there's this whole other category of stuff that doesn't relate to like number of units sold or like margins where the guidance is is whacked out and kind of everyone agree everyone understands that this is like these are not real timelines these are Elon Musk timelines you know I was reading an analyst note that Dana sent me just before we went on and they're talking about the question of Robo taxis

17:54is anywhere from 3 years to a decade out like that's the that's the time timeline that this analyst was suggesting which is like a huge range and it reflects the fact that Elon Musk has essentially said robotaxis are just around the corner basically every year for almost a decade so it's like very confusing and analysts have just learned to I think just kind of ignore SL discount some of those Wilder [Music]

18:23promises and now for the really fun part the brains behind Elon Inc have created a special bingo card which you can download at bloomberg.com Elon in or on the mini Business Week social media accounts Max what is earnings Bingo and how do I play along okay so earnings Bingo is this is a thing that exists we did not invent this you know all credit to the Elon stands out there on Twitter as well as the Elon critics the Tesla Q Army basically anyone who has an opinion about this guy has been making these Bingo cars cards for years and the idea is you have a card the one that we have which you can go to bloomberg.com Elon Inc and download and it it's 24

19:09squares I love it plus the free space I I'll just tell you so some of these are are ones that I think are definitely going to happen like these are this is like easy money some of these so so for instance yeah walk through some of the highlights Okay so we've got b i n g G4 that's cybertruck that's come on that's a gimme that's practically a free space now B1 is definitely less likely I

19:34would say and that one's what audibly Puffs joint so as I understand it like my job at Bloomberg now at least part of my job anyway is I'm going to be listening to that podcast as the you know person who has to listen for the audible joint puffing by the way that B2 sorry B2 because it's not enough to just puff a joint it has to be it has to be audible Dana do you have a favorite on here that you're going to hopefully get to scratch out yeah so I think what's really interesting is you know Elon just has this very peculiar way of speaking that all of his fans then adopt and I am a big fan I forget what the square is but reasonably optimistic because you

20:11know Elon will say I'm reasonably optimistic that we'll have full self driving by the end of the year or I'm reasonably optimistic that we will you know sell 50,000 cyber trucks in 2024 and so the bingo card is really about musk and his language and his very unique use of language and how he invents all these words that then enter the Lexicon like gigafactory is not a real word but Elon started calling his battery plan a gigafactory and now every automaker and every battery company on the planet talks about how they have a gigafactory similarly mega pack like what the hell is a mega pack it's Tesla's name for their like utility scale battery product so I mean I would

20:52love to get a like linguist on the phone someday to talk to us all about this but his use of language is very unique and it it is adopted by his Legions of fans and the other thing about the earnings calls is that like tens of thousands of people listen to them like employees listen to them fans listen to them like a lot of people dial in and and listen and it's not just like Wall Street analysts it's like hundreds of thousands of people we talk a lot about on this podcast about like how to think about Elon and I think on the last episode Dave Alba compared him to Donald Trump right as a as sort of a political influencer and and so on but I was

21:27thinking like with the looking at this bingo card and thinking about the way as Dana says that Elon sort of remixes himself like he has these tropes that he repeats and reuses and you know I I think the the the sort of great oral poets right like the the way that I think linguists believe that oral poetry Homer and so on was consumed was you'd have these like little like couplets or little bits of language that would then be arranged in order and it's almost like that with Elon where he's got these like catchphrases that just get get tossed in and it becomes like a part of the fandom as Dana said it's something that the that his fans repeat and also

22:02that they look for right and it's it is like the experience of like one of these Elon Musk earnings calls it's like not all that different from the Taylor Swift con concert right where you see the snake and you're like oh the snake like here it is and except here it's like it's like Optimus or Dojo or the phrase you know digging our own grave or whatever my other favorite Square here is not many people understand this which is just like a thing that he says all the time and just really speaks to like this sense of in Elon fandom of that you're given access to this truth or really it's like a set of truths that are not well understood and if you

22:40understand them you are going to have you're going to get rich you're going to you're going to be a part of this it's not only going to be a source of cultural meaning but it's going to be a source of wealth well no I was just going to say like I love 03 refers to Earth as a market because that is just so how he talks about everything like are you with it or against it we're fighting for our Consciousness we're fighting for the future of Earth and referring to Earth as a market implies that there will be future planetary markets which is of course his his worldview and because he uses these tropes so often part of the challenge of listening to a Tesla earnings call as a

23:18journalist or an analyst is that you almost get like a focus hangover because you have to listen very carefully for any change and Nuance because that's what the news is like is he slightly altering these tropes in a way that's either positive or negative for the future of the company and is he backing away from you know Dojo or is he talking

23:38down cybertruck I mean on the last call he very famously said that with the Cyber truck we dug our own grave and it was like ooh like what is that about man so you have to listen very very carefully for any kind of change in Nuance or tone we dug our own grave with CER sber truck nobody Dr exort gr better than themselves and it's kind of it's it's just really wild and usually when I'm on the calls I'm like blogging and I'm listening and I've got my bingo card but I'm also like texting like employees and analysts and like fans and everyone's like you know did you catch when he said this did you catch when he said that and you if you've never listened to an earnings call we really

24:13encourage you to join along and play and go to bloomberg.com Elon in to download our first bingo card I think we'll do this again will we okay you have to this the great thing about the bingo card is that everybody wins we only made one card so or everyone loses see or everyone yeah yeah what how what happens if I win do I get all that money that you were talking about Max well I just want to say like it sounds kind of superficial to be Dana opened this conversation talking about do we get dow Elon do we get happy Elon but like that actually matters and like that's what what Dan's kind of saying is that because he repeats these phrases like it

24:54sounds like we're just we're doing like theater crism or something but like the fortunes of this company hundreds of billions of dollars you know hundreds of thousands of jobs sort of depend on like what Elon projects and like does he sound depressed you know when he's talking to this audience of analysts and fans and like it's such a weird it's just such a weird world we live in and like you can kind of understand I I doubt this is a cause for Elon to believe in the simulation but it kind of makes me like question our reality when

25:25so much depends on you know basically how Wall Street interprets Elon musk's mood yeah the other thing that's really fun fun to do if you have a terminal is while he's talking watch Gip post and you can see the stock trade after hours in real time and if he gets like dark and if we get like dark Elon you will just see the stock completely tank and then if he's like ulent and like very confident you'll see the stock go up so that's like another trick of the trade that a lot of people do you all just learned a terminal function yeah I love that Dan and I are going to be live blogging on the terminal as well so you know get ready people are also already

26:03criticizing our bingo card we don't have a square that says the limiting factor we don't have a square that says you know talks about population collapse but to be fair like he doesn't really talk about population collapse on the earnings calls he talks about them like all the rest of the time you know what listeners tell us what's wrong with our our bingo card tell us what's missing make your own Bingo cards we you know yeah we'll be back in q is is only three months away yeah yeah exactly all right not enough let's call it thanks for listening to Elon Inc and thanks to our panel Dana Sarah and Max thank you thank you always a

26:46[Music] pleasure this episode was produced by Stacy Wong Naomi shaven and rahan hermani are our senior editors the idea for this very show came from rahon Lake Maples handles engineering and we get special editing assistance from Jeff grocott our supervising producer is Magnus Hendrickson the Elon Inc theme is written and performed by taka yazza zawa and Alex sigura Sage bomman is the head of Bloomberg podcast and our executive producer I'm Joel Weber covering for David popis if you have a minute please rate and review our show it'll help other listeners find us also let us know what you think of Tesla bingo see you next [Music] week

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份