X Spaces·中文精读

马斯克谈丰裕、AGI 与 2024 媒体 | EP #79(X Spaces)

Elon Musk on Abundance, AGI, and The Media in 2024 | EP #79 (X Spaces)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2024 年新年,马斯克在 X Spaces 上跟彼得·戴曼迪斯(Peter Diamandis)聊了两个多小时。中间他提到一件事:偶尔不小心读到新闻,他整个人会变丧。

他补了一句:“他们出多少钱我都不看。”(马斯克)

这场对话挂的标题叫“即将到来的丰裕时代”,但马斯克花了大量时间解释另一件事:为什么人类明明活在历史上条件最好的时候,却普遍感觉世界正在塌方。

答案一半在进化,一半在生意。

新闻只回答一个问题:今天地球上发生的最坏的事是什么

戴曼迪斯把日播新闻的逻辑拆得很直白:它每天只回答一个问题,今天地球上最糟糕的事情是什么,然后每隔五分钟在你家客厅里重播一遍。

地球上有 80 亿人。这么大一个系统,每天必然有人遭遇不幸。头条每天只挑那一件播,观众就会得出一个结论:世界每天都在变糟。

马斯克的说法更刻薄,他给 CNN 起了个外号,叫“危机新闻网络”,或者“持续负面新闻网络”。他谈新闻业的商业模式时没留情面:媒体的工作只有一个,把你的眼球交给广告主。人类对负面信息的关注度是正面信息的十倍左右,供给端当然只生产负面。

“如果新闻真的说,今天总体还不错,暴力事件处于历史最低,食物、能源、水、医疗、教育的可及性比以往任何时候都高,那观众大概会转台去看恐怖片。”(马斯克)

大脑是在草原上被筛选出来的,怕比馋更保命

戴曼迪斯提了一个角度:风险与回报的进化不对称。

草丛那边有头狮子,你走过去,游戏结束,你的基因从池子里出局。草丛那边有丛浆果,你走过去,是加分项,不是必须项。死亡比饥饿更糟,所以任何对危险不够敏感的先祖,都没能把基因传下来。

马斯克接过这个话说得很干脆:那些对负面消息反应不够强烈的人,早就被淘汰了。他还加了一句调侃,说谨慎的基因被狮子吃掉了,剩下的都是听见风吹草动就跑的那批。

这套神经回路在十万年前是对的。放在一个 80 亿人的信息网络里,它出了故障:媒体系统会持续把全世界最坏的那 0.0001% 喂给你,而你的杏仁核以为那头狮子就在家门口。

他给的建议很实用:你在 X 上可以自己选信息源,能看到世界上正在发生的好事;看电视和读报纸的时候,是某个编辑或制片人在决定什么内容进入你的大脑。这两件事的差别,比很多人以为的大。

把数字摊开:极端贫困、儿童死亡、预期寿命

这场对话里最扎实的部分是数据。戴曼迪斯摆出来的几条,值得单独记住。

全球极端贫困人口比例,1800 年是 90%,1981 年是 42%,今天低于 10%。

五岁以下儿童死亡率,两百年前是 42%,差不多是抛硬币决定孩子能不能活下来,现在低于 5%,并且过去三十年里又降了一半。孕产妇死亡同样大幅下降。

全球预期寿命从 30 岁左右涨到 75 岁以上。

这些数字放在一起,指向一个不太符合直觉的结论:人类历史上最大规模的福祉改善,发生在最近两三代人身上,而且发生的时候没上过几次头条。

戴曼迪斯反复强调一个观察:正面消息是慢性积累的,负面消息是瞬时爆发的。前者不构成新闻,后者构成新闻。而人对世界的判断,几乎完全由后者塑造。

铝曾经比黄金贵,稀缺很少是存量问题

马斯克讲了一段材料史,用来解释技术到底在干什么。

19 世纪,地球上最贵重的金属是铝。它比黄金、比铂金都贵。可铝是地壳里含量最高的金属元素之一,占比接近 8%。问题不在储量,在于它处在一种极难提取的低能量状态,氧化铝极其稳定,要把它还原成金属铝,需要砸进去大量能量。

他顺手举了个例子解释这个能量差有多大:铝热剂就是氧化铁加纯铝,两者的能量差大到反应时能烧穿钢板。

二战时铝严重短缺,英国人造“蚊”式战斗轰炸机时,机体大量用木头,外层是硬木,中间夹轻木,做成早期的复合材料夹层结构。这是能量约束逼出来的工程方案,跟美学没关系。

后来电解铝工艺成熟,铝变成了最廉价的金属之一。

这个故事的落点很清晰:技术做的事,就是把处于不可用状态的丰裕资源,变成可用状态。稀缺通常是能量问题和工艺问题,存量问题反而少见。

电网是按“最热的那一天”设计的,所以大部分时间在浪费

话题转到能源,马斯克给了一个非常特斯拉式的判断。

特斯拉做过两份演示,一份极简版,一份极其详细版,论证地球完全可以靠太阳能加锂电池实现能源自给。拆解下来,锂离子电池和太阳能所需的材料里,没有任何一种会接近耗尽地球储量。工作量大,但没有卡脖子的元素。

更关键的是电网逻辑。几乎所有电网都按峰值功率设计,也就是最热的那个夏天下午。到了夜里,输出可能掉到一半,悲观一点掉到十分之一。大量发电能力在大部分时间里是闲置的。

他的结论:如果加上电池缓冲,同样的电网可以把输出提高两到三倍。不需要新建电厂,只需要把浪费掉的时间和容量存起来。

他还提到 2023 年(或 2022 年)新增发电量里,太阳能超过了其他任何单一能源形式。电池产量增速是整车产量的数倍,某些口径下接近十倍。

戴曼迪斯补充了一个数字:太阳照到地球表面的能量,是人类总消耗量的八千倍左右。马斯克没有对这个数量级提异议,他关心的是另一个相关性:国家 GDP 与能源产量高度相关,健康、教育、几乎所有指标都随人均能源上升而改善。

能源放在丰裕议题的核心,因为它本身就是所有问题的分母。

直连手机要和光速赛跑

通信这块,戴曼迪斯给的数字是 2023 年全球约 69 亿智能手机用户,占人口 85% 左右。从零到覆盖绝大多数人类,用了不到一百年。

马斯克提到一件刚发生的事:Starlink 的直连手机卫星已经发射了。

技术难点他讲得很清楚。卫星必须模拟地面基站,手机才肯接受信号。要做多普勒补偿和其他一系列修正,因为卫星在天上跑得很快,频率会漂移。还有光速的硬约束。

他给了一个很好用的物理直觉:光在太空里大约每毫秒走 300 公里,在光纤里只有 200 公里出头。

这句话解释了为什么卫星通信在长距离上能赢光纤。赢的地方在路径,不在带宽。纽约到伦敦走光纤要贴着地球曲面绕,走卫星是直线。物理站在卫星这边。

他也承认,如果这件事容易,早就有人做成了。

星舰上有几千个传感器,你身上一个也没有

戴曼迪斯问马斯克,星舰发射时上面有多少传感器。马斯克说,把所有子系统算上,几千个。33 台发动机每一台都有,还有结构应力传感器、航电传感器、通信传感器,覆盖整个飞行器。

戴曼迪斯顺势把话题拐到健康。他说了一句我觉得整场对话里最有杀伤力的话:你的身体是藏病的高手。

在他们检查过的一批“看起来健康”的成年人里,2% 的人身上有自己不知道的癌症,2.5% 有未发现的动脉瘤,14.4% 有代谢疾病、冠状动脉疾病或神经退行性疾病。

70% 的心脏病发作没有任何前置症状。身体一直在代偿,等你感觉到疼,通常已经是三期四期。

“我们对汽车的内部状态了解得比对自己的身体还多。”(戴曼迪斯)

这段论述的价值在于它把问题定义清楚了。医疗能力不是瓶颈,检测缺位才是。人体没有仪表盘,而现代医学已经能装一个了,只是绝大部分人没去装。

他给的建议也很直接:现在就去查,别等有症状。知道得早,可选的疗法完全不一样。

你的左臂和右臂为什么不分开变老

长寿那段对话很有意思,因为马斯克给的是结构性论证,没有堆数据。

他说:我没见过哪个人左臂老了、右臂还年轻。一次都没见过。

人体有 30 到 40 万亿个细胞,它们的衰老速度几乎完全同步。那么问题来了:这几十万亿个细胞是通过什么机制保持同步的?

他的推论是,既然存在一个非常明确的同步机制,那它就可能有开关。衰老如果是同步的,它更像一个可调的参数,不像三十万亿个独立的磨损过程。

他补了两个反例:弓头鲸能活到 200 岁,格陵兰鲨能活到 500 岁,200 岁还能生育。同一个生物学底层,寿命差了十倍以上。

戴曼迪斯从医学角度补了一刀:一个单细胞能展开成一个成年人,成年人又能把信息压缩回一个单细胞传给下一代。这个压缩解压过程本身说明,生物系统里有远超我们理解的机制存在。

马斯克对长寿的立场比外界印象中克制。他明确说不想让人活几千年,理由是会导致社会僵化。他用了一个很马斯克的例子:你愿意让金正恩活一千年吗?

他自己的目标是把四五十岁的活力和认知保持到一百岁。治愈痴呆、治愈癌症,这些是明确的好事。他承认在“解决衰老”这件事上,跟戴曼迪斯的分歧没有外界想的那么大。

学校是最后一个相信自己不需要改变的系统

戴曼迪斯问,今天有多少中学在教孩子应对未来的能力。

马斯克的回答是:据我所知没有,可能有个别例外,但 99% 的学校不是。学校的变化速度极慢,而且在往远离基础训练的方向走,写作、数学、历史这些基本功在退,同时各种工作观念和意识形态在渗透进教育,对教育本身是破坏性的。

他的判断很直接:最好的医疗和最好的老师都会是 AI。AI 知道你孩子最喜欢的颜色、最喜欢的球星、最喜欢的电影,知道他会哪几门语言,知道今天发生了什么。这意味着地球上每一个孩子都能拿到当前最好的教育,这件事在人类历史上从未发生过。

他提到戴曼迪斯早年做的全球学习 XPRIZE,在坦桑尼亚用平板电脑做无人教学实验,只靠软件教孩子读写和算术,效果很好。那个项目的获奖者之一埃马德·穆斯塔克(Emad Mostaque)后来创办了 Stability AI。

但他不看好体制会主动让位:教育系统不会很快交出控制权。

戴曼迪斯补了个现成的观察:他自己的孩子在很大程度上是被 YouTube、Reddit、X 教育大的,当然还有 TikTok。马斯克承认教育状况有问题,但坦白说不知道该怎么办,可汗学院算是往对的方向走了一步。

戴曼迪斯在这里提了一句关于线性思维的批评:人们习惯把今天的状态往未来推四五年,然后以为那就是未来。他自己的判断是,没人准备好迎接 2030 年的世界,包括马斯克。马斯克的回应是,他也不知道 2030 年会是什么样,所以不敢说自己准备好了。

韩国和意大利每一代人减少一半

人口是马斯克反复回到的话题,这次他给的数据密度很高。

人口替代率是每对夫妇 2.1 个孩子。欧洲现在 1.5。北美从 3 左右掉到 1.6,美国已经低于替代水平。亚洲从 1950 年代的 5.7 掉到今天的 1.9。

韩国和意大利的情况更极端:每一代人损失大约一半人口。三代之后,剩下的人口规模是现在的八分之一,而且结构极度老龄化。

他把这称作当前最被低估的风险之一,并且点了保罗·埃尔利希(Paul Ehrlich)的名,说《人口炸弹》可能是人类写过的最反人类的书。这本书在 1960 到 70 年代塑造了整整一代人对人口的认知,而现实走向了反面。

他特别批评了一种心态:有些人认为不生孩子是在为地球做贡献,是在做自我牺牲。他的回应是,这种观念和事实完全相反,保持人口不崩塌是一种公民责任。

戴曼迪斯问了一句很关键的话:为什么人们不想生孩子?

他给出的原因是恐惧。怕 AI 毁灭人类,怕环境崩溃,怕把孩子带到一个糟糕的世界。所以乐观不只是情绪问题,它直接决定了人类是否继续复制自己。

戴曼迪斯在这里的态度很鲜明:他一直在解决自己这一侧的变量,也就是通过长寿让人活得更久,同时反复劝马斯克多生孩子。马斯克的说法是,机器人加 AI 能补一部分,但根本上还是得有人。

法律是不死的,人是要死的

这一段是整场对话里最尖锐的现实批评。

马斯克提了一个结构性矛盾:法律和监管会不断累积,因为它们是永生的;而人是会死的。结果是每年都有一层新规叠上去,永不删除。叠加到某个临界点,一切都非法,因为法规之间存在重叠甚至互相矛盾,往左走违规,往右走也违规。

他给了一个正在发生的例子。美国司法部起诉 SpaceX 只招永久居民和美国公民。而 SpaceX 这么做的原因,是政府非常明确地告诉过他们:如果不招永久居民,就违反《国际武器贸易条例》(ITAR),整个高管团队和董事会要去坐牢。

现在司法部又因为不招“已获庇护者”起诉他们。马斯克特意区分了这两个概念,寻求庇护的人和已经获准庇护的人是两回事。

他的总结很干:招了违法,不招也违法。(马斯克)这套逻辑还有个副作用,让美国公司在国际上跟别国对手竞争时处于劣势。

苏联捕鲸船长的奖章,比十九世纪捕鲸船更致命

这段讲的是激励结构如何杀死一个物种。

很多人以为鲸鱼数量的最低点出现在 19 世纪,因为那时捕鲸业最繁荣。实际的最低点在 20 世纪中期,主要推手是苏联。

机制是这样:苏联实行五年计划,每个行业都有配额,鲸鱼捕捞量也有吨位配额。而配额制度的特点是,每隔五年就要比上一个五年更高。于是鲸鱼吨位目标年年加码。

对船长来说,吨位高就有奖章和晋升,吨位低就被送去古拉格。激励一旦这样设定,行为就注定了。

结果就是苏联捕鲸船跑到美国和澳大利亚海域,拼命找鲸鱼,捕上来称重,记进配额,然后把尸体扔回海里,因为压根没打算用。这个计划从头到尾都不关心鲸鱼肉有没有用处,只关心吨位数字。

马斯克讲完这段,落点在于:这就是中央计划的失效方式,也是把早已无用的法律一直留在纸面上的代价。

地堡逻辑不成立:文明崩了,你也活不了

戴曼迪斯问了一个挺直接的问题:地球上有那么多身家几十亿上百亿的人,钱就放在那儿,除了让它继续生钱,什么也不做。怎么看?

马斯克的回答绕开了道德劝说,用一个纯自利的论证:你无法在文明之外存在。

对那些在新西兰或者夏威夷修地堡的人,他的评价是:真到了末日情境,别人会找到你的地堡,把你撬出来,拿走你的东西。你的私人武装挡不住有组织的人。

他还给了一个很土但有效的思想实验:去森林里裸着活一天,你很快就会明白文明有多好。你得吃虫子,还会被虫子吃。

所以他的结论是,即便你完全不关心他人,只关心自己,也应该为文明投入资源。你的财富、你的安全、你能否活到明天,全部寄生在这套复杂的分工系统上。拥有一点长期视角,完全是自利行为。

他顺带提了一句他对财富的看法:世界上自由流动的财富和能量越多,能做成的事就越多。这个角度跟“富人囤钱”的道德批评不太一样,他关心的是钱有没有进入生产循环。

Optimus 不能有总开关

聊到人形机器人,马斯克的态度比很多人想的更谨慎。他主动提了一句,他得确保 Optimus 不会增加文明层面的风险。

他的具体要求是:不能有集中控制。如果十亿台机器人能被某一个人或者某一个系统一键接管,那就是灾难剧本。他直接点名了《终结者》:失控 AI 拿到了母舰控制权,接管所有机器人。

他说这在架构上必须是不可能的,控制权必须是去中心化的,必须做到本地控制。

这个观点值得单独看,因为它是从造机器人的人嘴里说出来的,不是从批评者嘴里说出来的。做这项技术的人自己认为最大的风险在于控制权的拓扑结构,不在单台机器的能力。

Neuralink 的第一个产品,叫心灵感应

戴曼迪斯问了一个玩笑式的问题:什么时候能用 Neuralink 直接连上 Optimus。马斯克的回答给了具体进度。

首例人类植入“可能就在这个月或下个月”。第一个产品面向四肢瘫痪者,让他们用思维控制手机和电脑。他给这个产品起的名字叫 Telepathy(心灵感应)。第二个产品叫 Blindsight(盲视),即使双眼和视神经全部损坏,也能通过直接刺激视觉皮层恢复视觉。

他强调了两件事:这些功能在猴子身上已经跑通;没有任何一只猴子因为 Neuralink 死亡,公司对实验动物的待遇非常好。

被问到那只玩 Pong 的猴子时,他描述了现场:猴子 Pager 没有任何束缚,坐在树枝上喝着奶昔,用思维打游戏。把游戏机关掉,它会不高兴,跟人类小孩一样。

算力每六个月十倍,人类数据快被吃完了

进入 AI 部分,马斯克给的第一个数字是增长速度:投入 AI 的算力大约每六个月增长十倍。他说这比年增长快得多,而且他没见过任何一项技术以这个速度推进。

他举的例子是规模:一个千兆瓦级的 AI 算力集群正在建设,里面是几十万块 GPU,而且是两代之前的型号。这只是他听说过的最大的一个。此外还有 500 兆瓦级的装置,以及多个 100 兆瓦级的项目在推进中。

他自己都承认不确定这么多算力拿来干什么。原因是数据侧很快就撞墙了:把人类有史以来创造的所有数据都算上,包括全部视频,用不到十万块 H100 就能训练完。再往上走,只能靠合成数据。

这个判断的分量在于,它把 AI 竞赛的瓶颈从算力挪到了别处。资本、创业者数量、可用数据,都在同步膨胀,互相喂养。这也解释了为什么他反复用“令人眩晕”这个词来形容当前节奏。

把道德写进 AI,你会得到一个 Waluigi

戴曼迪斯问,怎么让公众对 AI 少一点恐惧。

马斯克给的方法论从一个反例开始:如果你给 AI 写一套明确的道德程序,你会同时得到一个反向版本。他管这叫 Waluigi 问题。创造一个路易吉,就自动创造了瓦路易吉,把路易吉反转一下就出来了。

他的替代方案是两条:最大程度的求真,并且始终承认存在错误;最大程度的好奇心。

第二条尤其重要。他的论证是,一个有人的地球,对一个高级 AI 来说比没有人的地球有趣得多。人类是宇宙里目前已知的唯一观众,把我们抹掉,等于关掉唯一一台正在播放内容的电视。

他举了个类比:人类完全有能力把黑猩猩全部猎杀,但我们没有,反而在保护它们的栖息地。智力足够高的存在,对低一级的生命未必是威胁。

戴曼迪斯在这里追问了一句:智力极高是否必然带来共情和对生命的尊重。马斯克的回答是,这就是彩虹尽头的那份希望。

如果 AI 学到“人类是地球的瘟疫”

接下来这一段,马斯克的语气明显沉了下去。

他说 AI 出问题的一种具体路径,是灭绝主义哲学被写进去,不一定是显式写进去,更可能是隐式渗透。他举了个例子:一年多以前《纽约时报》头版报道过一个人,是某个灭绝主义组织的负责人,他在采访里说,地球上有 80 亿人,最好是零个。

如果这种观念以某种形式进入 AI 的优化目标,后果不堪设想。

他特别点了极端环保主义里的隐含推论:人类是地球表面的瘟疫。这个前提一旦被 AI 当作优化方向吸收进去,再配上最强的能力,就是最坏的组合。

他也承认这个观念有现实土壤。很多人相信资源在耗尽、人口太多,唯一出路是减少人口。这套叙事从 1960 年代《人口炸弹》开始流行,至今影响着大量受过教育的人。

戴曼迪斯的补充很到位:人类习惯浪漫化过去,但过去的生活是短、粗野、四十岁就死的。今天的一切来自技术。他在这里引了一句霍布斯的话,说那是“肮脏、粗野而短暂”的生活。马斯克接了个段子,说他养过一只约克夏梗,又脏又野又短命,还老咬人,所以他给狗起名叫霍布斯。

最有趣的结局,最可能是真的结局

对话末尾有一段关于模拟假说的讨论。

戴曼迪斯回忆,多年前在洛杉矶的一场派对上,他跟拉里·佩奇、谢尔盖·布林聊过这个话题。当时的判断是:我们活在模拟里的概率很高,因为你怎么可能正好活在人类历史上最有趣的这个时间点。有人说了句:别去戳那个模拟,会被关掉。

马斯克接这个话,给出了一个自己的推论:人类跑模拟的规律是,结果越不可预测,就越会继续跑;一旦结果变得完全可预测和无聊,就停止模拟。SpaceX 跑火箭飞行模拟是这个逻辑,撞机模拟也是这个逻辑。

所以如果真的有一个外星计算机在跑我们这个世界,那我们保持有趣,就是维持模拟运行的方式。

他由此推出一个更实用的判断标准:最有趣的结局,往往是最可能的结局,前提是站在第三方视角看。就像看一部一战纪录片,屏幕里的人在被炸飞,屏幕外的人在吃爆米花。区别在于,我们在这部电影里面。

这段话听着像玩笑,用起来其实是一种预测方法。当一个系统里存在多个参与者,最有戏剧张力的路径往往会被选中,因为它最可能被继续观察下去。

乐观不只是情绪,它是有生理回报的选择

戴曼迪斯在对话里引了一项研究:14000 名女性和 1500 名男性的样本显示,持乐观心态的人比悲观者平均多活 14% 到 15%。

马斯克的说法更土:幸福在大多数情况下是一个决定。他承认存在化学失衡的情况,但对多数人来说,快乐和不快乐的差别就在于决定要快乐。

他还提了一条生活原则:宁可乐观而错,不要悲观而对。理由是期望值问题,乐观带来的生活质量提升是确定的,而悲观带来的“我早就说过”的快感几乎一文不值。

更实际的一层是自证预言。如果你相信未来是反乌托邦,你的行为就会变成防守:不投资未来,不建东西,不生孩子,缩起来保护自己。然后那个悲观的结果就真的来了。反过来,相信未来更好的人会下注、会建设、会承担风险。

马斯克在这里还说了句自己的心理变化。他一度因为 AI 而感到压抑,后来转成了宿命式的态度:就算 AI 真的终结人类,他还是想活着看到那一天,纯粹出于好奇。这种好奇心,某种程度上就是他自己说的那条“站在乐观一边”的具体形态。

戴曼迪斯补了一个他认为被严重低估的事实:今天一个普通个体拥有的能力,超过几十年前大多数国王、女王和国家元首。不需要政府,不需要大公司,一个创业者加几块 H100,就能做出上一代人无法想象的事。

马斯克对这场对话的收尾是这样:站到乐观那一边,你会更快乐,大概也会活得更久;顺便,多生孩子。他还开了个谐音玩笑,说犯错是人性(to err is human),繁衍也是人性(to reproduce is human),两个词根一样。

把它落到你自己身上

这场对话信息量很大,能拿走的部分不多,但都很实。以下是几条可以立刻执行的动作。

  • 重做你的信息源。关掉日播新闻和算法推荐流,改成主动订阅。你选择看什么,比看了什么更重要。马斯克的原话是他不看网络新闻、不读报纸,出多少钱都不看。
  • 用能量视角重估所有“稀缺”说法。看到任何“资源要耗尽”的论断,先问一句:这是存量不够,还是提取成本太高?铝从贵过黄金到最廉价金属,靠的是电和工艺。
  • 给自己装一个仪表盘。2% 的健康人有未知癌症,2.5% 有未知动脉瘤,14.4% 有未发现的代谢、冠脉或神经退行性疾病,70% 的心脏病发作没有前兆。做一次全身深度筛查,成本远低于晚期治疗。
  • 把 AI 安全的理解从“对齐道德”换成“求真加好奇”。写死一套道德程序,会反向生成它的对立面。评估任何 AI 产品时,看它是否承认自己可能出错,比看它宣称价值观正确更有意义。
  • 在小团队里试一次 AI 原生创业。算力每六个月十倍,人类数据在十万块 H100 的量级上就被吃干。窗口还开着,但不会一直开着。
  • 想生孩子就去生,别被“世界要完了”的叙事劝退。替代率是 2.1,美国 1.6,欧洲 1.5,韩国和意大利每一代人减半。这个数字背后是养老金、创新能力和文明延续。
  • 把长期主义当成自利行为来做。地堡逻辑不成立,文明崩了你也活不下去。投资那些让文明继续运转的东西,回报会以你意想不到的方式回到你身上。
  • 每年主动删掉一条你已经不信的旧观点。物理学的进步有时一次葬礼一次葬礼地完成,创业不该这么慢。改主意的成本,远低于抱着过时判断跑五年。

马斯克在那场对话里提了很多次一个词:最有趣的时代。他没把它当作祝福,也没当作诅咒,更像是一种物理条件。而我们恰好赶上了。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00following is a Year's conversation I had with Elon Musk arguably the greatest entrepreneur of our time perhaps the greatest entrepreneur ever during this conversation which is called the coming age of abundance we talk about how Technologies including Ai and humanoid Robotics are creating a world of abundance uplifting Humanity across Food Water Energy Healthcare education we'll be talking about longevity we'll be talking about AI we'll be talking about the decreasing global population and what are the reasons that you should have for being optimistic about the future join me happy New Year Yan happy New Year 2024 I love Yeah it feels like

0:41the future it is the future it is the future it's going to be awesome you know I'm hoping we get a little bit of conversation on some hope and good news for folks on this on this spaces I think people can use it you are the most optimistic person that I know of by far and I mean I guess it is a refreshing to to hear such

1:12optimism I I think people need I think people need a positive mindset I think it's self-fulfilling prophecy to a large degree you know if you're pessimistic and we can talk about how the news media just decimates our minds constantly yeah the news is so negative I mean it makes me sad to read the news frankly I I well let me ask you a question I don't watch I don't watch Network news and I don't read any newspapers they couldn't pay me enough money yeah to do that time I I'll accidentally read the news and I'll just be sad it's insane well I mean as you as you know the the news The Daily News really

1:58really attempts to answer the question what is the worst thing that happened on Earth today it is and and and and let me show let me show it to you every 5 minutes in your living room over and over and over again yeah and it's a big world there's eight billion people on Earth so you know somewhere on Earth something horrible is happening every single day but there's also great things happening every single day you know what I call CNN the crisis News Network or the constantly negative newth Network and the problem is if they've got to scare you otherwi yeah you know if they say hey it's been a pretty good day overall you know violence is an alltime

2:40low yeah we've got more access to food energy water healthc care education on the pl than ever before I mean people would just start watching horror movies I think instead yeah yeah the challenge is it's it's our neural Nets the wiring of our brains you know evolved in a world of constant danger and so we're sort of just wired for fear and scarcity constantly Yeah well yeah I think You' made this point maybe others have which it it sort of makes sense as a as an evolutionary asymmetry that we would respond more to

3:22Danger than to reward in that like the consequences of danger could be fatal like it could be like well if you go over there there's a lion that's going to eat you or some neighboring tribe that's going to kill you and it's game over yeah your jeans are out of the Jean Pool yeah you're you're out whereas say like

3:44news that there there's a there's a a nice bush with berries over there it's it's nice to have it's it's optional but it's the in one case you die in other case you're you're hungry but death is worse than hunger so so that's is B basically we're any anyone who did not respond more to negative news than positive news didn't make it they were they were select they were selected against for sure that sucks yes I mean anyone who was complacent about where the lion was e by L and and you know the reality is you know the news media has one job to deliver your eyeballs to their advertisers and when we pay 10 times more attention to negative news and

4:28positive news that's all we get 24/7 so I mean listen I I it's yeah it is I mean I do get my my news invariably you know on my on my feed on X but I also get all the great things happening in the world because I can selectively choose to watch that but when you're watching TV or you know in the newspaper some editor someplace or some producers deciding what gets fed into your mind and it can really with your mindset yes exactly so I mean this

5:05this space is called it the coming age of abundance and you know you were really when my first book came out abundance the future is better than you think you were super supportive and I and I appreciate that was 12 years ago and I think the story whoa 12 years amazing yeah and it's gotten so much better so I it is in so many ways not not every

5:28way I mean I mean obviously we go back ways the the I I I remember when we were at Ado's party in Brazil yeah how Longo he was it was his 40th or was it his 30th I don't no was it was this was just when SpaceX was just when I was forming space yeah it was it was 2003 there about it just before the X prise Was Won right I was trying to convince you not to build Rockets 21 years ago could like like you

6:06could have a kid that that has could legally or legally up kids yeah yeah so 21 years ago yeah so and you know things things are mostly better most you I want to give everybody listening a dose of Hope and optimism on the abundance inside because the world has gone better in so many ways all you hear about is the negative constantly and I think that's going back to our sort of core dystopian mindsets from you know evolving 100,000 years ago but if we just look at some of the look at some of the areas right so like Global extreme poverty right I mean what's more what's what's a more important metric you know here are the numbers 90% of the world was in global extreme poverty in

6:57in the 1800s in 1981 it was 42% today it's under 10% of the world right yeah hunger Hunger is actually rare and it used to be common exactly and another one is obviously one har that you're leading the charge on is energy you know we used to kill whales to get whale oil to light our nights and we ravaged mountainsides and we drilled kilometers under the ground and what's the figure it's like 8,000 times more energy hits the surface of the Sun surface of the Earth from the Sun than we consume as a species what's the rate at which batteries and solar is increasing it's it must be massive yes I mean I mean Tesla we we've made a couple of presentations what one sort of

7:45simplistic and then one in extreme detail on how to make Earth completely self- sustaining from an energy standpoint and demonstrating that there that there is no that if you break down all of the materials for lithium ion battery and for solar you can easily make earth not I mean there there's no shortage material it's easy it's a lot of work obviously but but but

8:13there's not like some critical material that we don't have enough of in order to make earth fully self- sustaining even if the only way that you powered all of Industry on Earth and and all power including heating and transport electrically you could do that with solar and leine batteries and and not

8:34not come anywhere close to depleting the resources of Earth yeah my favorite my favorite example there was back in the 1800s the most precious metal on the planet was aluminum it was more precious than gold and and platinum and even though the Earth's crust is you know 8% boxy you know basically aluminum it was just so energetically difficult it wasn't that it was scarce it just wasn't in usable form yet and that's what technology does it takes something which is scarce and not usable and makes it usable right so

9:11yeah yeah ex aluminum oxide is extremely common and but but it is it is a low energy state in fact thermite thermite thermite is just iron oxide rust and and and pure aluminum and the the energy difference between iron oxide and aluminum oxide is so great that it generates incredible enough heat to melt through steel so that's what thermite is so yeah you do need a lot of energy to turn aluminum oxide into aluminum but but yeah it in World War II there was a massive scarcity of aluminum for aircraft sure and that in fact in

9:57Britain the the mosquito sort of fighter bomber was U made of mostly of wood and but it was it was done with it was basically an early form of of of composits but using stiff wood on the on the outside and and Lightwood and like Balsa on as a sandwich structure it's pretty clever and the whole thing was intended to to address the shortage of and that and then then we get technology we get better better mechanisms of extracting the aluminum from the from the aluminum oxide from the boxy and this happens over and over again in fact that's just what we do I mean I think the number was last year in 2023 or maybe in 22 we had more new electricity production from solar than

10:46from any other form and and and you've done an extraordinary job on battery production yeah and the battery production is growing actually almost at well at several times the rate of vehicle production so you know in some cases almost 10x the rate of vehicle production so so yes

11:12the there's a massive demand for batteries and you know as as the world uses more electricity there's actually a lot more capability that the grid has if you can buffer the energy then without it because the vast majority of electrical sure it's wasted assume no they assume no buffering so they have to size the power plants for for Peak output Peak power output which is typically a hot summer day and and and then for at night you can

11:46have anywhere from half optimistically half power output to sometimes one/ tenth of the power output so so so basically the the grid almost everywhere the grid is sized for excess electrical power output and if you just buffer it with batteries you can in increase the output of the grid by you know two or three times I mean to make to make the point here on the abundance theme there is no limitation on energy right we are increasing the amount of energy per capita and there's a direct correlation between the GDP of a nation and its energy production right and the direct correlation between health and education and energy everything scales as you

12:35increase the energy per capita of a Nation yeah yeah I talk about another category Communications another area that you're revolutionizing I think the number right now I just was checking it earlier it's like 6.9 billion smartphone users in 2023 like 8 86% and that's what I got when I when I Googled it I don't know what 6.9 you know what to say yeah 6,900 million 6,900

13:08million let go there that my my my 12-y olds would say the same it's like 85 85% of the planets got a smartphone and and well I mean if if you add up the total number of smartphones made ever made it exceeds oh I think it so it's it's amazing so we've gone from like zero telepan to the majority vast majority of the planet in under a century you know global internet as well the same thing and did I your your next

13:47iteration of starlink spacecraft have gone up the direct to cell phone okay yes that just went up so you know we still have to prove that it works and all but we're confident that even if the if these early satellites don't work we're confident from from a physics standpoint that it can work it it's it is h a challenge

14:13because we have to emulate a cells celf tower on the ground in order for the phones to accept the signal so we have to do do compensation for example and and and and do some sort of because because you've got a speed of light limitations pal if if it were easy it would have been done already yeah yeah some speed of light limitations so you know this this like light is is so fast and yet so slow

14:47so you know I I yeah a good way to think about light at least in the space context or for the low or context is is it travels about 300 km every millisecond in in air or in in space and and then and then around just over 200 kilm per per millisecond in fiber hey everyone I want to take a quick break from this episode to tell you about a health product that I love and that I use every day in fact I use it twice a day it seeds ds01 daily symbiotic hopefully by now you understand that your microbiome and your gut are one of the most important modifiable parts of your health you know your gut microbiome is connected to everything your brain health your cardiac health your

15:37metabolic health so the question is what are you doing to optimize your gut let me take a moment to tell you about what I'm doing every day I take two capsules of seeds ds01 daily symbiotic it's a two-in-one probiotic and Prebiotic formulation that supports digested Health gut health skin Health heart health and more it contains 24 clinically and scientifically proven probiotic strains that are delivered in a patented capsule that actually protects the contents from your stomach acid and ensures that 100% of it is survivable reaching your colon now if you want to try seed ds01 daily symbiotic for yourself you can get 25% off your first month supply by using the

16:20code Peter 25 at checkout just go to seed.com moonshots and enter the code Peter 25 at checkout that that's seed.com moonshots and use the code Peter 25 to get your 25% off the first month of seeds daily symbiotic trust me your gut will thank you all right let's go back to the episode you know another abundance area is Health I hear some some kids in the background there so interestingly enough you know child mortality I mean probably I mean this is one that hits me the most in terms of increasing abundance child mortality under the age of five was 42% a couple hundred years ago it was a coin flip of whether your kid survived and it's decreased now to

17:08under 5% and it's gone down by 50% in the last 30 years so just childhood mortality and women dying in child birth all of these things people don't think about when they're listening to all in news on and all the issues and then life expectancy my favorite subject has gone up from you know 30 years old to to 75 plus I still disagree with you on longevity though that that we should solve it or not like we should you think we should solve well I I listen I'm not necessarily saying live forever but I'd like to make it to 120 I yeah I I sort of wonder if we should not Sol it too

17:56soon just presidential elections expect first and and do you really want them to get that life expectancy first well you know you know I I I think we I think being able to have the Vitality the cognition the physical prowess you know that you have when you're in your 40s or 50s through the age of 100 that's my goal I mean you don't want to you don't want to you know you want to make it to at least 100 don't you well I guess it does depend on

18:39whether I'm you know have dementia I I don't think I'd want to be a burden on society or have dementia not know what's going on i' prefer it to be dead well yeah I think that's that's for sure but let's assume that you had you know all the cognitive power you have today your physical strength is there any reason why you wouldn't want to you know have an extended lifespan or health span yeah sure I I guess I I think we are end up there's such a strong forcing function for Life Extension or health span extension that I think we will see advancers in that area whether I want them to be there or not and actually my opinion on the subject is that it's I I think it's actually not

19:34that hard to solve because the if you just consider arguments of symmetry it's are quite helpful the the the cells in our body all age age at basic almost exactly the same speed like what like I've not seen anyone who has an old left arm and a young right arm I've never seen that not even once yes so how how are the cells communicating and how what is keeping them what is synchronizing their behavior something there's there's a very clear mechanism for synchronizing aging among the 30 to 40 trillion cells in your body like depending on your body mass you're typically going to have 30 to 40 trillion cells that's correct you know keep you know in sync I mean the

20:27other the other the other reference proof point is you know boohead whales one the largest mammals can make it to 200 years repeatedly Greenland sharks can make it to 500 years and have babies at 200 years old I remember when I was in medical school hearing that I said you know why can they why can't we I said it's either an engineering problem or software problem a hardware problem or software problem and I think I think this is one of the biggest areas AI is going to give us is a real understanding and then to your other point about your left arm arm and right arm you know when you have a baby woman's 30 35 you're

21:0440 45 your baby starts out at zero yeah I I do find it remarkable that we decompress from a single cell to an adult human and then and then we you know to procreate compressed back down to a single cell that is fascinating you know I mean you look you sort of look look at yourself as a sort of you know Blas assist and say like I haven't changed a bit here we go again let's recycle it's like it's like the big bang it's like right the Big Crunch you know one of the things people argue about on extended Health span and you know increasing the population getting to 100 120 150 and there's a concept called Longevity Escape velosophy right that there's going to be a point at which for

21:58every year you're alive science is extending your life for more than a year and that's an interesting idea to think about in which case you know accidents become really a thing to be concerned about they concern about overpopulation and and you've you've hit this multiple times right the and I saw you Tweeting about it or sorry you're Xing about it today sorry but it's

22:26you know overpopulation is one of the biggest myths and biggest false over population is outer BS yeah you know and and you know it's it's such nonsense Earth is UN underpopulated not overpopulated with under look out the window when you're flying across the country it's empty absolutely exactly it's like if you say like if your goal was to like flying from aliot to New York to drop a bowling ball on a human you would

23:04fail you know I think one of one of my goal I think the greatest gift we can give people in this abundance world is increased Health span I mean when you think about what people want they want happiness and they want Health right no one wants to die in a painful cancer or or dementia so yeah and you know I

23:28I have extended to you many times my friend come down to Fountain Health let me put you through our our program the world needs you around for another 30 30 years okay well what do you have any what should I do let's say well I mean so there two what actions can be taken two this could be helpful for listeners two on on this discussion yeah so they're two there are three things you need to know number one is there anything going on inside your body that you don't know about so the body is amazingly good at hiding disease so we found in our seemingly healthy adults 2% have a cancer they don't know about two and a half% 2% 2 and a half% have an aneurysm 14.4% either have

24:15metabolic disease coronary disease neurogenerative disease and okay and so your body is incredibly good at hiding disease all right so you don't actually feel any cancer until stage three or stage four 70% of all heart attacks have no precedence your body is compensating constantly and you know for most of us we know more about what's going inside our cars or airplanes than we do our bodies yeah I had a question for you how many how many sensors are going up on on Starship when you're launching how many Star sensors are going are on board that vehicle rough order magnitude getting back data well I guess there's when you count everything up there's several thousand

25:02sensors and if I were I mean there are 33 engin so they they count from the bul of sure and but you also have stress sensors and looking what's going on in in the structures and avionics and Communications across all the subsystems and if I ask you how 39 engines including the uper stage so so there's several thousand sensors and way more sensors than than yeah I was going to say if you if ask you how many sensors do you have in your body and so we don't look which is insane because we do have the technology now to look to determine is there anything going on I need to know about and when's a good time to find out about like now or what's likely

25:41to break what's likely to undergo failure cycles and then what's the most extraordinary Therapeutics available to extend the human lifespan so I mean for me that's that's that's a that's a big one let me ask you another another abundance theme which is education do you think any of our

26:06schools today middle schools or high schools are preparing any of our kids for the future well none that I know of well there might I mean there might probably are a few schools that are doing it but probably 99% of schools are not yeah schools are very slow slow to change and and I think that there there

26:34there there is do seem to move away from teaching the fundamentals you know of writing well and math and history you know I'm concerned about the whole work agenda and ideology perating through education agreed and actually being destructive to education agreed I mean you know how do you think do you have these thoughts I mean so at the end of the day I think our best our best healthc care and our best teachers are going to be AIS right that understand

27:13everything and they demonetize and they democratize every aspect mean the AI knows your your kids favorite color sports star movie star what they know the languages they know what they did today I mean it's a way of giv every child on the planet the best education I mean you you funded back years ago if you remember the Global Learning X prise that we did we did a that we we demoed in Tanzania with AIS on tablets it was the earliest days of of AI imod mustak who you know was one of the winners of that competition who went on now to create stability I mean the the challenge is I don't think the Educational Systems are going to give up that control anytime

28:00soon true well if I mean if I look at how my kids were educated they seem to be mostly educated by YouTube and Reddit yeah and X as well I suppose but they're constantly on the internet that that seems to be and I guess a lot of cases these days Tik Tok unfortunately yeah yeah so I think yeah the education situation is is problematic not sure what to do about it I

28:37think I think ultimately you know KH Academy is one step in the right direction but I think part of it is getting our educational institutions to First realize they're not preparing kids for the world that's coming I mean this hits another point we are such linear thinkers right we're projecting what we have and putting it out four or five years I don't think people let me ask you do you think people are ready for what the world's going to be like in

29:122030 no I I don't know what the world's going to be like in 2030 so probably I wouldn't say that I'm necessarily the the we definitely live in the most interesting of times you know like this legally this Chinese saying that may you live in interesting times is is is a not a good thing but I mean I I I think

29:39personally I would like to live in the most interesting of times and this is the most interesting of times I also think it's is the best time to be alive ever the only time more exciting than today is tomorrow I mean you know by what measure yeah we have environmental issues but I think we have the best chance of solving those environmental issues with the technology we have now versus the technology we had 10 years ago yeah I well I generally think it's as as a as a general sort of rule of living it is it is better to ear on the side of being optimistic and wrong than pessimistic and right if you're going to make if you're going to ear one side

30:19of the other better it's just a higher quality of life to ear on the side of being optimistic and risk being wrong than than than pessimistic you know and you know and right I mean it's it's better to be you'll just have a just enjoy life yeah what optimism is is is is gonna make you happy there was a study of 14,000 people for it was 14,000 women and 1500 guys and it showed that opt those who had an optimistic mindset lived 14 to 15% longer than those who with a pessimistic mindset I mean mindsets a powerful thing

31:01and I think undervalued by almost everybody one my one of my favorite examples of This was do you know what the environmental disaster of the 1880s and 1890s was I'm sure you know of the is this is this back to whal no no it's it's it's another form of life it's a the HSE Manor disaster the the hored problem yes yeah

31:28what what is this hor well yeah no no you're right the I mean New York was was basically a a hor manure and and and urine and carcass it was it was terrible people brought their Motive Power I mean basically like if you think if you think you think New York subways are stinky right now wait I mean try when it's just everywhere everywhere you know people everywhere people people moved from people moved into downtown New York Detroit Chicago they brought their Motive Power with them and and the articles in the 1880s and 90s and into the 1900s as you as you read this the projection was disaster it was going to be a disaster because hor horse horse

32:20manure was like grow they had like special parking lots for horeshit at the corner of every street well well I it seems like there's also a challenge because I think if a horse lives you know for on the order of 15 years that means 1/5th of all horses are kicking the bucket every year

32:43so you just got and so so if you if you got like 300,000 horses it means you got 20,000 horses dropping dead every year and then you need a horse to move the horse the dead horse or just or just cover it with Horseman or let it decompose yeah I mean it's going to be like decomposing horse caucuses throughout major cities then and then and then like it's like well whose whose dead horse is this are people are probably quick to claim a live not rushing to claim a but then and then Innovation came along and here comes the car and solves the problem and I think that's the problem that we keep on forgetting we we forget that we are incredibly Innovative

33:33at solving problems that's what humans are amazing at yeah yeah true true actually on the whale front I don't if you know back to the whales it's a whale of a tail whale Tales okay the the so a lot of people think that the the the low point on whale population was was in the 1800s

34:04because you know whales were being hunted for for whale and whale oil yeah but but actually the the low Point by far was in fact in the mid 20th century because of a bureaucratic error in the Soviet Union okay this I have to year they they can't so they would always have these five-year plans and quotas for for how for whale tonnage now it didn't they didn't actually have even a whether the whale tonnage was usable tonnage in anyway they just had a quota for whale tonnage and what they would do in the sovi union they would just keep increasing the quota of everything every year every five years so the so the whale tonnage just got Higher and Higher and Higher and and if you if

35:04you were a captain and you and you and you had a high whale tonnage you'd get a metal and a raise and if your whale tonnage was low you'd be sent to the G you get you get what you incentivized baby yes incentives matter and and so it it got to it to it just got to absurd levels and you had Soviet whaling ships like going into you know us and Australian Waters to desperately trying to find whales and and they they would catch the whale weigh the whale and then dump the cus over I mean there there's there's a whole AET rabbit hole that you can go down on this and which is basically a lesson in the the folies of central planning so and this is the problem of

35:49keeping laws on the books way way after they're useful to society well we do have actually have a fundamental issue with the accumulation of laws and regulations because they are Immortal and humans are mortal as we were just discussing you know with life extension so so naturally every year you're going to have this accumulation of laws and regulations until eventually everything is legal I mean everything is illegal everything is illegal yes nothing is allowed because you have overlapping laws regulations and and some of which are in fact contradict each other that whether you go left or right they're both left and right [Laughter] are my God you know it like SpaceX

36:44is I mean sham you know the doj in this respect in this particular case with it doj as you may know is suing SpaceX for hiring only a permanent residents and and citizens of the US the reason that we did this was because we were told very clearly that if we did not hire permanent residents of the United States that that would con constitute a violation of international trade tra traffic and arms regulations itar and the entire executive team of SpaceX and the board would go to prison sounds like a good motivation yes and so we we were literally told us by the government in very clear terms and and you mean you're well aware of it I well aware yes it's it's a nightmare and

37:33we would like to which which by the way puts us in a non-competitive world against other nations yes it it's it's it's it's it's pretty bad so but but then then then the doj you know is suing SpaceX for not hiring Asylum Seekers now important Point here not Asylum those who have been granted Asylum those who are seeking Asylum there's a lot of those there's a lot of people seeking Asylum yes so we're damned if we do and damned if we don't so if if we hire someone who's not a perent residence we're breaking the law and if we don't hire someone who who's not a permanent resident we're breaking the law so what this is this is an example of the madness that we're facing

38:28buddy I I want to compliment you on something which and I've seen I've known you for long enough to have seen you gone through this where you have bet everything over and over again you've bet your entire Fortune gone into debt to do the things that you believe in and I I I have a question to ask you which I've been dying to ask and I'm going to start making this this known there are so many billionaires on the planet who have tens of billions and hundreds of billions of dollars who are effectively sitting on it and not changing the world not putting it in you know

39:08other than for increasing its return which is not a bad thing I think the more wealth and free energy there is out there to do things but can you speak to that I don't know if you're willing to but there are a few people like Mark Benny off and and Eric Schmid and your yourself top of the list who invest on making the world a better place solving Global Grand challenges thoughts on

39:41that sorry I just have some some kids and stuff right problem sort of family noises in the background so let's see yeah well yeah I mean I do think that smart people with resources should care about the the good of civilization the future of civilization even if there is not even if they're not particularly altruistic because you can't really can you cannot exist absent civilization you you know if civilization collapses it's all over you know there's like people who've got like these sort of bunkers and

40:35you like other countries or Hawaii or whatever I'm like listen do you really think that you're going to make it in in an apocalyptic situation like they'll they'll they'll come and find you in that bunker and they pry they'll pry you out and get your stuff and and and and it's it's going to anyway so really smart people with resources any smart person with resources they just have some long-term perspective I mean listen it's it's you and it's you and and Jeff Bezos right now who've got the biggest long-term perspective and I see I you know

41:16I'm just curious about how do you incentivize other people to really help the world accelerate you know and and make the world a more productive place right the best way to become a billionaire is help a billion people the world's biggest problems the world's biggest business opportunities do you believe that well I guess maybe we should just talk to people more I guess just talking to them and you

41:52know I think it's perhaps just raising conscious awareness the fact that there is no living without civilization when when you like one doesn't actually have to make an altruistic argument you can actually you know make a even it's a purely self-seeking argument say like life would be miserable without civilization and if you want to know what life is like without civilization just go try living in the forest naked for a day and you will be naked and afraid and and quickly realize civilization is

42:34awesome have to eat bugs and get eaten by bugs and and and we're so interdependent upon each other to enable the state of technology and capability we have today you know I'm curious is there anything that you think that isn't becoming more abundant out there or anything we have an abundance constraint on you know I'll just mention well answer that first then I want to come and talk about the carbon removal ex prise that you funded one

43:10second you know we're we're creating abundance of food energy water Health Care education are we constrained in any way no not really no I mean no I I think I I agree with you that the future most likely has abundance we shouldn't be complacent about the future you know complacency and entitlement are not a recipe for success but the most likely outcome is one of abundance of goods and services that is certainly where we're headed yeah yeah when I when I saw you lasty likely where we're at very likely yeah when when I saw you last you said you know definitely a bunch after AGI and I saw you know when you were talking about Optimus which is Awesome by the way let's just start

44:05with that congratulations well thanks mean Optimus I need to make sure the Optimus is you know doesn't cause it doesn't add to civilizational risk you know because you don't want like a billion of these things or with centralized control unless unless what could go wrong has anyone made a movie about that unless they obey

44:36you well I don't think they should any any one personation yeah like I think you have to have Lo local control but it has to be decentralized because and any Central control is going to be problematic CU you just can't be like it could be the a rogue AI takes I mean let's literally movie a rogue AI you know Terminator takes over somehow gains control of the mothership of that controls all the you know the Optimus robots or something like that that is you basically it needs to be DEC it needs to be impossible for that to occur let me ask you I always love combining your companies because it's like you know you know it's like a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup you know

45:32sterlink and and and and and Starship together how about Optimus and neuralink when can I plug into an Optimus with my neuralink connection well hopefully the first neural links will the First new link in a human will hopefully be soon with from the next maybe this month or or next now this is really just at first

46:05just trying to give you know quadr quadriplegics and tetraplegics the ability to control their phone and computer it's it's basically like the first the first product is TE telepathy essentially or telekinesis and and then the second product sort of tentatively called Blind sight where we can restore sight even if somebody is has lost both eyes and their optic nove amazing go straight to the visual cortex yeah yeah exactly now these things all already work in monkeys and i' just like to reemphasize no no monkey has ever died because of a neuralink and we treat our monkeys extremely well last time last time I spoke to you about this you were playing you were playing

47:01pong against pager I think that's right actually it turns out monkeys love playing video games they they're they're really just like us I mean they they they love eating eating snacks and playing video games I'll tell my 12-year-old boys about that yeah I mean you you see the video of Pedro playing you know monkey mind

47:27you know telepathic playing pong telepathically he's not restrained in any way he's just sitting on on the the sort of tree branch drinking smoothies and drinking smoothies drinking a smoothie and playing pong yeah he's not held down you know in fact he's he gets upset when we take his video game away just like like hum just like our kids that's that's awesome and and this I mean giving sight to the blind I mean it's biblical stuff and and this is again coming back to the original you know kicking off the new year with a positive mindset with an abundance mindset with an exponential mindset with a moonshot mindset right which I and I think I hope you agree like I think for

48:13entrepreneurs and people listening like the single most important thing we have is our mindset how we see the world I mean would you agree with that yeah yeah I mean you can choose to be I mean happiness is I think is a decision I mean Lely I mean there's obviously people that have chemical imbalances but for most people the difference between being happy and unhappy is deciding to be happy over the years I've experimented with many intermittent fasting programs the truth is I've given up on intermittent fasting as I've seen no real benefit when it comes to longevity but this changed when I discovered something called prolon 5day fasting nutrition

49:01program it harnesses the process of autophagy this is a cellular recycling process that revitalizes your body at a molecular level and just one cycle of the 5-day prolon fasting nutrition program can support healthy aging fat focused weight loss improved energy levels and more it's a painless process and I've been doing it twice a year for the last year you can get a 15% off on your order when you go to my special URL go to prolon life.com p r o l n

49:34l.com back slm moonshot get started on your longevity Journey with prolong today now back to the episode I want to take a second for everybody listening to point something out you know Elon it was 2021 I was texting with you and I said you should fund an another exerprise you funded an exerprise years AO go on teaching kids in the middle of Tanzania Reading Writing and arithmetic without any adults no schools around just on a tablet they were handed and the software had to teach them and it was an amazing success and then in 21 I asked you if you'd do an exerprise on carbon removal and you said yes almost instantly and we launched it three months later it was like the

50:21fastest yes to an xprize launch ever so thank you for that I want to give you a quick up on it if I could you're welcome absolutely well I hope the the education ex prise and the the Caron removal ex prise are result in you good out they I'm sure we had 6,000 teams enter the carbon removal prize we have 1300 active teams in the competition right now as we down select about 36% 460 are focused on

50:53carbon air capture 4 30 are land related capture 240 are ocean related capture and the we've given away 20 million of your money already five million to students and 15 million to the a million to the top 15 teams and the finals are coming up in two years in Earth Day of 2025 and interestingly enough you know the winning team needs to demonstrate Megaton level capture that can scale to G level capture and so just the final competition is going to capture four megatons of carbon which is twice what's being done on an annual basis today so good progress so far great that's that's good to hear well as we as we as we begin to wrap up what other thoughts for people on

51:50abundance what other mindset thoughts do you have for folks here is H well I I I I do think that the birth rate is too low for humans as I I'm always going on about that just a longevity baby I'm solving it with longevity I'm G to keep people alive longer okay well and robots and AI sure but

52:27I mean it just the current situation is is grim Dr yeah yeah yeah yeah I mean a lot of countries are you know if you look at say say Korea Italy yeah they're they're losing roughly half their population per generation yeah that means three generations they're on10th of their current size and and and with the one1 that remains being very old yeah the

52:55the numbers folks the replacement number is 2.1 children per family on the average and Europe is at 1.5 Asia dropped from 5.7 in the 1950s to 1.9 today which is crazy North America dropped from about 3 to 1.6 were below the replacement level in the United States and it's an it is an issue I mean we we need smart people

53:27on the planet yeah well I mean know if we don't make new humans we won't have Humanity and and even with longevity we'll live longer but we're not live forever so I think we just need it's it's you know I'm concerned that like a lot of people think that the plan planet is overpopulated and that's one of the things contributing to a low birth rate in fact some people I've encountered think they're basically being Martyrs for not having kids and that's just it's just not true I think we should take the position that we we we actually have a civic responsibility to have kids to at least keep the

54:13human population constant ideally we should grow it but we should at least not have population collapse which is what we currently have I I think people people fear the future and I mean the ations I've heard is I don't want to bring children into this world it's too dangerous AI is going to destroy Humanity the environment you know we're destroying the environment and so forth so I think part of it is getting people to be optimistic about the future versus pessimistic which is one of as you said in the beginning of this of this space is one of my one of my missions if people think the world is getting better and they have a hand in making it a better place you most

54:55definitely do yeah I I think people should be optimistic about the future they still Earth can handle Far More Humans than currently exist and the danger is not a population explosion but population collapse so I would just encourage as many people as possible to have kids and ideally have a lot of kids because they they're going to make up for those who whatever reason don't buy an extra bottle of wine tonight folks yeah it's a big deal

55:32so would you would you let's let's close out on the conversation of AI and AGI which I know a lot of people are always interested in and and and there's a real fear about AI what would you say to dissuade people I mean it's you you've you I've heard you say 80% probability we make it through and we need to protect it downside can you speak to that what how do how can people walk away more optimistic than pessimistic on on this front and how do you how do you think about you know is is it containment is it shaping

56:13how we train our AI systems how do you think we navigate super digital super intelligence well the the rate which AI is growing is it really boggles the mind yeah so it currently seems as though the amount of compute dedicated to artificial intelligence is increasing by a factor of 10 roughly every six months it's it's faster than annual that's for sure so I mean I've I recently heard today

56:55about a gigawatt class AI compute cluster wow that's I think it's being being built in Kuwait or something to that effect and it's a like 700,000 v100s which is a couple Generations above two generations Beyond that's Curr in production so this is staggering amount of compute and and there are many such such things that's just the biggest one I've heard of so far but there are there's a 500 megawatt installation happening there's and there's there's there's multiple 100 100 megawatt installations in the works I I I don't even clear to me what what you do with that much compute because when you when you actually add up all human data ever created you really just run out of

57:54things to train on very quite quickly like you you know if you've got maybe I don't know 20 or 30,000 h100s you can train on synthetic data almost yeah yeah you basically you have to have have synthetic data because forly well under 100,000 h100s you can train on all human data ever created including video and it's not and it's not just the compute which is the major scarce resource but it's also the number of of entrepreneurs focusing this area the amount of capital that's going into this area the amount of data Avail I mean it's all increasing and it's all feeding on itself and so it's just you know hitting your point about the speed at which it's progressing is is I think the

58:43word awesome is is comes to mind or staggering yeah it's it's really staggering and and for sure so I'm just trying to give a tense of scale it's I've never seen anything move this fast any of any technology this is the fastest moving thing so in terms of aiming for AI safety my my best guess of my sort of primitive

59:12biological NE man is is that we should aim for maximum truth seeking and and curiosity that that's that's that's my gutfield for this for how to make AI as safe as possible if the the danger with programming morality and explicit with an explicit morality program is what is sometimes referred to as the Waluigi problem if you create Luigi you automatically create Waluigi by inverting Luigi sure so so I think we we have to be

59:54careful about programming and you know sort of an arbitrary morality but but if if we focus on maximizing truth with acknowledged error that's that's probably I think that's the the way to maximize safety and and also to have the AI be curious because I think that you know Earth is much more interesting to an advanced AI with humans on it than without humans I have a I agree with you now a interesting

1:00:31question of do you think vast intellig with vast intelligence comes significant empathy and respect for Life yeah I think so because that's the that's the hope at the end of the rainbow here that I don't want to use the word AGI I'll use a super digital super intelligence as a as a term with a dig super intelligence that is able to be more benevolent and support us because sometimes I'm not sure us squishy meat sacks can make it through our own our own horseshit problems that we put together so maybe there's a value there my

1:01:18you know I think on the whole AI is the single most important technology we ever invented and it is going to uplift all of human I think it's what you said you know post AGI comes abundance I think it's the interim issues in the next one to four years right it's it's not artificial intelligence it's human stupidity yeah well I mean one way that AI could go wrong is if the extinctionist philosophy is programmed into the AI whe

1:01:52whether implicitly or explicitly I mean probably not explicitly but there's a strong danger of of an implicit extinctionist philosophy being programmed into AI you know and and what would that look like what would that look like well like there's this guy on the front page of New York Times think about a year ago he's head of the extinctionist society and he was literally quoted as there are 8 billion people on on Earth it would be better if there were none oh my God and yeah so

1:02:26and if you if you take the extreme environmentalist argument especially like the implicit extreme environmentalist argument they they there's an imp implicit conclusion that humans are a plague on the surface of the Earth so we I think we have to be quite careful about an an implicit like like if the extinctionist movement was somehow programmed into AI as as the optimization that would be extremely dangerous yeah to say say the least

1:03:04yeah and but you know there there there are people quite a few people actually who who view Humanity as as a blight on the surface of the oan yeah and there we're we are coming down to there is the you know accelerationist movement the deceleration movement the Boomers and the doomers but I think people forget to realize or don't realize forget the fact that you know we romanticize the past and the past life was short brutish and you were dead by 40 you know the life that we enjoy today is a result of the extraordinary technology that we brought to bear yeah the like you know Hobs life

1:03:49is nasty brsh and I I actually I I had a little Yorkshire terer once who was nasty brutish and short and kept kept biting people so I called him hob perfect I would tell friends that that that came over watch out for the dog and and they'd look at this miniature York ter and laugh and then then bite them on the ankle and I said watch I said watch out for the you know that extinctionist Meme is the same sort of you know you discount it until it starts

1:04:32being a mind virus in part as you've called it and it starts disrupting us yeah if you convince people that you know we're running out of resources on Earth that there are too many people in the world and the only way to survive is to have fewer people which a lot of people are believe to be the case and like I said if that if that somehow gets programmed into Ai and that AI becomes the most powerful AI then we're in deep trouble yeah we need to counterforce the population bomb I mean what an extraordinary disservice to humanity yeah er's book was terrible nightmare maybe the most Anti anti-human book ever written yeah for sure for sure the but get people Hope on the flip side

1:05:32here those who are saying again going back to I don't want to bring up my children because I hear this all the time and I'm sure you do too in an age where AI is going to destroy us so short-term problems long-term problems short-term Solutions long-term Solutions you said make it curious make it maximum truth seeking 100%

1:05:56is it okay to say that we're going to have issues in the short term and we're going to have to deal with them or do you there won't be there will be there will be some issues I mean essentially at this point no way to stop AI it it's it is accelerating whether people like it or not I mean that's that's that's why together with a number of really smart people we created xai and you know hopefully you

1:06:33know some really small humans will continue to join xai and and build what is intended to be a maximally truth seeking and maximally curious AI anyway I think that's that's really important so listen on behalf of of those of us and I think everybody here listening who are pro- humanity and pro uplifting Humanity and making us a multiplanetary species and living a longer healthier life and I the one place I disagreed with you on on on X is on you know having people live longer you don't people don't need to die for there to be new ideas you know that the CEO of Ford and GM didn't have to die for Tesla to come into existence so we're yeah you know I'm I want

1:07:34to just say thank you for all that you're doing and and setting a model for other other in industrialists and entrepreneurs out there to take on and solve the big huge problems well thank you I would encourage people to be optimistic about the future like or on the side of optimism you will be happier for it and and as you pointed out probably live longer so and I'm not I'm not totally against life extension I I think we did we you know we want to be I'm I don't think we want to necessar have people live forever that's or live for a very long like thousands of years that I think that would potentially lead to OIC of society it it it would I think lead to

1:08:23oif of society but but I mean solving de dementia and you know curing cancer I think are good things obviously so so I'm not sure we're actually that far apart on the life extension thing I think we're prob probably mostly in agreement I yeah we just don't want to have like you know can you live for like do you want Kim Jong Un living for a thousand years no but I I'd like I'd like Elon Musk and Peter D mandis living for 150 years and a few other thousand amazing entrepreneurs out there sure so it's it's a you know there there

1:09:09is a a challenge that like a lot of people they really never change their mind they just die and this this is actually I'm not sure who originally said this but even in physics where which is extremely rigorous that you know that that you know physics in a lot of cases has advanced one Death at a time yeah my my friend Brian keading who's a a astrophysicist reminded me of that and and maybe it was true but in

1:09:42this world of Entrepreneurship I think we do live with meritocracy to a large degree and the best ideas can bubble up to the top faster than ever before especially with with AI now where you can build companies you know extraordinary companies with a couple of people and a lot of tech so yeah I have one last question and then it's I know it's dinner time there the future of X

1:10:16xai what's your vision there pal well as I was saying I think the the path to AI safety is to BU an AI that is maximally truth seeking with acknowledged error that is maximally curious and I think that I think that that is most likely to lead to a good outcome for Humanity because we are we are much more interesting than than than not Humanity like like obviously you know I'm a big fan of Ms but m is much less interesting because there is no human civilization there and

1:11:03you take humans for example we we we could hunt down all of the chimpanzees and kill them but we don't and in fact we make efforts to preserve their habitats we so anyway I think that that's that is a path to a great future and and a a maximally positive AI to be rigorously truth seeking always acknowledging some amount of error and and maximally curious

1:11:41that's and that's that's the the goal of XI is and you know the company MTO is understand the universe and that's a it's a it's a good Mission and and one that's going to take a bit of time I can't wait till the first AI is able to come up with new theories of physics and new Innovations that's going to be I mean I don't think that's far away and I think that's gonna be one of the most awesome times ever to be alive true like we we definitely live in the most interesting times and actually for a while I was kind of depressed about AI but then I I kind of got fatalistic about it and said like well even if even if AI was going to you know end all all

1:12:37Humanity would I prefer to be around to see it or not I I guess I would prefer to be around to see it just out of curiosity but I obviously hopefully AI is extremely beneficial to humanity but but the thing that sort of reconciled me to be less anxious about it was to say well I guess even if it was apocalyptic I'd still be curious to see the it's like you know I be curious to see it I remember I was at your birthday party at one of your homes here in La before you sold them and Larry Page was there and Sergey was there and we were having a conversation about living in a simulation and the notion was this is we're in the 99th level of the game play

1:13:23and this has got to be a simulation because you couldn't why would be why would be alive right now in this single most interesting time and then the only comment was don't poke the simulation or will end yeah yeah well if we are in a simulation the the the way to keep the simulation going is to keep being interesting so like humans run lots of computer simulations because we we we don't know what the outcome's going to be and we're curious to see we'll run lots of simulations like in like will run crash simulations and SpaceX will run you know rocket flight simulations and we only stop doing the simulations when the when the outcome is extremely predictable and

1:14:16boring yes so if we're in some alien Compu that's a great argument that is perfect right when it's absolutely known if we're if we're not if we're not entertaining enough to the the digital gods or the universe Gods they'll Land The Sim yeah we just need to make sure we keep the ratings [Laughter] up but but this why also why I think like one of the ways to predict the

1:14:46future is that the most entertaining outcome is the most likely as seen by a third party as seen by as though we were an alien soap opera I love that yeah like so it's not necessarily good for those in the soap opera like you could be watching a World War I movie and seeing you know people get blown up and and you're just eating popcorn and drinking of soda but we're we're we're in the movie yeah well let's not get let's not get dystopian here because I think we can have a we can have a we can have a really positive outcome of a lot of other cool stuff yeah for sure I think the most likely outcome is positive and and I think if you you know and I think that's partly a

1:15:36self-fulfilling prophecy if you don't believe so if you believe it's going to be a distopian outcome then you're going to be back on your heels protecting yourself not investing in the future and it unravels and this yeah and and so you know I think the the message of this entire space is is this is the most extraordinary time to be alive the most exciting time to be alive a time where you know a lot a lot of individuals listening on the spaces has more power than Kings or queens or heads of Nations had just a few decades ago and it doesn't take a government or a large corporation to solve a problem anymore you know an entrepreneur with you some a few h100s can do a good

1:16:21job yeah I I think we should ear on the side of optimism we should we should ear on the side of optimism and we should have kids like you know to to to air is human and h e i r and to reproduce is human all right buddy listen thank you so much for your time thanks for sharing you're welcome all right thanks Peter take care buddy [Music] bye n

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份