大会演讲·中文精读

马斯克对话托德·霍华德 | E3 Coliseum 2019 座谈

Elon Musk in conversation with Todd Howard | E3 Coliseum 2019 Panel

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2019 年的 E3 游戏展,马斯克和 Bethesda(贝塞斯达)的设计总监托德·霍华德(Todd Howard)坐到了同一张台上。台下坐着几万名游戏开发者,马斯克开口讲的却是自己十岁那年写的一个游戏。

玩家开飞船打外星人。画面、音效、代码,全是他一个人弄的。四十年后,他在这群人面前说了一句很认真的话:

我进入科技行业,原因就是电子游戏。(马斯克)

这话搁在别人嘴里是客套。搁在他嘴里,接下来两个小时他聊火箭、聊自动驾驶、聊模拟世界,几乎每个话题最后都绕回了游戏。

两个老玩家是怎么认识的

主持人上来先问了一个所有人都好奇的问题:你们俩到底认识吗?

托德说,这些年一直有人在撮合他们认识,没成。最后把两个人连起来的是一件很日常的事,马斯克买特斯拉。托德说特斯拉没法到店直接开走,得先在网上下单,“我点下那个按钮的时候,我们才算真正连上了”。

马斯克说自己早就是托德游戏的老玩家。《辐射3》(Fallout 3)他玩了很久,把每个角落都探过一遍,只是没打通《上古卷轴:天际》(Skyrim)。他还专门要了一个等身大小的人偶,就是游戏里那个穿 50 年代连体工装、长得有点怪的家伙,摆在家里。开派对的时候他承认有点怪,“每个人都得问一句,那是什么”。

全场最松弛的一段就在这里。两个人聊的无关产业、无关趋势,是那种在游戏里翻箱倒柜、把整张地图跑遍的体验。

十岁写太空游戏,在“火箭科学”打过工

主持人问他,小时候写游戏是真的吗?

马斯克说,十岁或者十一岁,写了个很简单的游戏,你开飞船打外星人,就这样。画面、声音、代码都是他自己写的。他补了一句,“写得很原始”。

后来聊到他还在游戏行业打过工。那家公司叫 Rocket Science,火箭科学。他自嘲了一下:一个做游戏的公司叫这个名字,后来真去造火箭的人也是他。他在那边待过一阵,大概是 1993、1994 年。那段经历他形容成“有点难办”,没细说。

他真正想做的三件事,AI 是那个不安分项

主持人顺势问,那你为什么没进游戏行业?

马斯克的回答很直接。他原本的计划是读研究生,研究电动车。他一直想做的就是电动车和可持续能源。他把未来压缩成几件必须解决的事:

  1. 能源的生产和消费得可持续,太阳能板要便宜,电动车要有吸引力。
  2. 人类得成为多行星物种,所以必须搞定火箭。
  3. 还有人工智能。说到这一条,他语气变了,“这件事让我不安”。

台下笑了。托德接了一句:按他的记忆,那个 AI 基本上引发了第三次世界大战。他指的是《辐射》里的设定,战前世界毁于 AI 和核战。

玩笑归玩笑,马斯克对 AI 的担忧在这段对话里一直没散。他说这就是让他操心的那一件事。

招程序员,先问“你是怎么开始编程的”

主持人问,游戏和技术之间有没有联系?游戏有没有推动过技术?

马斯克的回答很具体。他说,游戏是让孩子对技术产生兴趣的一股强大力量,作用比大多数人意识到的大。

他招人的时候常常问一个问题:你是怎么开始编程的?很多人的回答是:电子游戏。

他说,世界上最好的软件工程师,很多都在游戏公司待过,或者职业生涯的大部分时间都在那里。道理很朴素。要在很有限的算力下做出逼真的画面,这件事本身就难,工程师不得不把代码写得很紧,不得不琢磨各种巧妙的办法。

他说,这种经历本质上就是解决问题。一个优秀的软件工程师,或者一个优秀的航天工程师,体现的是同一种能力,这种能力可以迁移到别的领域。

托德补了一个他最喜欢的段子。游戏 AI 比火箭 AI 难多了。游戏崩了,按个重启就行;火箭崩了,残骸得散出去好几英里。

马斯克接了句茬:如果现实是一场电子游戏,那它的画面很棒,剧情很烂,时间还特别长。

把游戏搬进特斯拉

主持人问,游戏和特斯拉现在到底怎么结合。

马斯克说,他们已经在合作了,先从小的开始。《辐射:避难所》(Fallout Shelter)会上车,免费,你养的那些小居民就住在车里。

主持人问,那得停着玩吧。马斯克说,对,得停。“乐趣警察”要求停车才能玩。他们本来还打算,车停着的时候能用浏览器看 Netflix、YouTube。总的原则是,怎么让车尽可能好玩,怎么做出别的车没有的东西。

车上已经能玩雅达利(Atari)的老游戏,能接 Xbox 或 PlayStation 手柄,操控反馈还不差。车上还埋了个彩蛋叫 Genius Moves,能让放屁声从任何一个座位冒出来。放屁声的命名里有一个叫 Falcon Heavy。

屏幕本来没有为游戏设计,存储空间不大,一次放不了几款。他们考虑的是:哪些游戏好玩、能用来打发时间,就放进下载列表。

现场放了两段视频。一段是车机上跑《辐射:避难所》,另一段是赛车游戏,支持单人和双人。

台下欢呼。主持人最惊讶的是方向盘。马斯克说,既然有赛车游戏,方向盘就在手边,那就用它。刹车是连线的。油门打算用滚轮控制,免得车停着的时候误踩。

创新和失败,SpaceX 连炸了三枚火箭

主持人把话题引到失败。他说,你们俩都经历过很多次失败,创新就是这样,你得准备好失败。

托德说,他们做游戏,能走到今天靠的是尝试大的新东西,以后还会这么干。他提到《辐射76》(Fallout 76)的起起伏伏,说粉丝很棒,一直跟着他们,那款游戏后来成了他们见过的最好的在线社区之一。

马斯克说,做创新的东西就是在未被探索的区域,出错概率很高。只有做已经清楚的事,失败率才低,但那也没意思。

后来有人问,你们各自最大的失败是什么。

马斯克说,他一开始炸了三枚火箭。他原本打算把 PayPal 赚的钱分成两半,一半留着,一半投进 SpaceX 和特斯拉这些很可能失败的项目。结果这些项目把钱全要走了。他连房子都没有,没钱租,那是 2008 年。最后他们凑齐零件做了第四次发射,成了。如果那次没成,SpaceX 就死了,也筹不到后面给特斯拉的钱,“今天我们就不会坐在这儿”。

托德说的是另一件事。他们有一段时间做的游戏都没成,公司差点倒闭,后来靠一个项目活了下来。

去火星要飞多久,光速都嫌慢

话题转到《星空》(Starfield)。托德说,今天没有片段可放,请大家耐心。但他可以讲讲思路:游戏里的事有可能发生,飞船用什么燃料,物理怎么运作,怎么在好玩和真实之间找平衡。

马斯克插了进来:太空非常远。四光年,就算以光速飞,也很远。如果你想要正常物理,反物质推进是最好的,但它也会把你限制在光速,要飞很久。否则你就会被困在一个恒星系里。

他说了一句,“老实讲,我觉得我们活在一个相当不错的电子游戏里”。为什么去火星可能,恒星为什么那么远?“那些星星就是些小光点,别担心”。

他接着聊曲速。他说,科幻电影和电子游戏可以很有启发性,讨论我们想要什么样的未来,哪些听起来不可能的技术也许真能实现。曲速引擎从原理上讲有办法,但它属于非常深、非常边缘的物理。技术上你不能超过光速,空间本身却可以以超过光速的速度膨胀,这就是曲速的意思。你需要大到难以想象的能量,不是“每秒把一颗木星转化成能量”就能解决的,木星没那么多颗。而且那附近可能有不少辐射。

他说,宇宙确实以超过光速的速度在膨胀,所以我们才能看到那些极远恒星的光。要搞清楚这些东西,还得更好地理解暗物质,那里总觉得有点不对劲。

托德说:暗物质这名字取得不好。

马斯克说:按现在的物理学,宇宙里大部分是暗能量和暗物质,你把它们代进方程,它们就管用。他的猜测是,如果这是一场电子游戏,模拟器有个 bug,只好加一个补丁,“不行,得让这些小兵相信自己在现实里,那就插一段暗物质进去”。

自动驾驶,难在现实世界的 bug

主持人问,游戏可以当模拟器来测试想法,这有价值吗?

马斯克的回答绕回了自动驾驶。他说,他们有一整个团队在做逼真的世界,想做到照片级。但自动驾驶难,难在各种奇怪的边缘情况。路本该是某个样子,偏偏不是;车道线本来画得好好的,被人涂掉了;标线和画出的线错开了,车要是只看线,就会撞上东西。如果每条线都清清楚楚,自动驾驶就是件小事。现实里到处是不按规矩来的东西。

他说,自动驾驶 AI 真正的难点是判断:在一条没有标线、或者线画错的路,我该在哪儿?地上的刹车痕、刮痕、施工,全是想不到的情况。这才是最难的部分。

他们做了很多相关性测试:车会不会冲下悬崖?会。现实中会不会冲下悬崖?接近。

主持人提起,马斯克以前讲过一句话,他关心的从来是哪里真能开过去,车道线只是参考,因为人脑就是这么运作的。

马斯克说,他们识别标线和技术上的可行驶空间已经不错了,但还要分清“路”相对于“可行驶空间”是什么,尤其在弯道上,现在他们特别看重这个。有的弯很微妙,有的该在意,有的不该。车开进别人家的车道,那里有个弯,车就会觉得“过不去”。经过邻居家,每家车道都是可行驶空间,技术上没错,但你不该开进每家车道,那不行。

托德说,很多这类东西是从游戏来的,图像处理和 AI。人们总是低估技术发展的速度。自动驾驶会从根本上改变世界,我们的孩子可能不用学开车,车会自己开。它会影响城市的样子、停车场、喝酒这件事。他还提了一个有意思的研究:押注自动驾驶,最好的标的之一是酒类公司。

马斯克补了一句:还有更多游戏可以玩。

他说,GPU 一开始是为了让游戏画面更好看,后来这些 GPU 变得非常有用,对 AI 是巨大的提升。更好的画面和 AI,是同一套东西,对自动驾驶也关键。

游戏的下一站:从“看起来真”到“反应真”

主持人问游戏未来五到十年会怎么走。

托德说,这是游戏最可能发生大跳跃的地方。现在大部分人判断一款游戏,第一反应是看截图和视频。截图能看出画面,看不出手感。怎么让玩家觉得那个世界是真的,包括 Bethesda 在内的很多团队都在这上面挣扎过。

他的判断是,把一部分运算搬到云端,下一代会明显变好。周围的东西对你的动作反应得更真实、更即时,这种“活”的感觉会大幅提升。

模拟套模拟,你是谁的头像

主持人顺着这个往下推:游戏越来越像真的,会不会有一天,世界和游戏就是一回事?

马斯克没绕弯。他说,真到了那一步,事情就疯了。游戏里的角色会站在那儿感慨,也许我们就在一场模拟里。而发出这句感慨的角色,自己就在模拟里。

他说,模拟是一层套一层的。模拟里有模拟,模拟里还有模拟,一路往下套。他觉得这个可能性不小。

接着他给了一个二选一的推演:要么文明先完蛋,要么游戏真实到人分不出真假。他自己押后者。然后他补了一句更狠的:我们现在可能就在别人的游戏里。

主持人问,那你是谁的头像?

这个问题没人接。台上的两个人笑了一下,就滑过去了。

他想要的游戏,尺度再大一点

主持人把话头转向马斯克:你玩现在的游戏,有没有什么是你觉得“要是能这样就好了”?你对游戏满意吗?有什么让你沮丧的?你希望未来游戏做成什么样?

马斯克说,我不知道该不该说。

主持人追问,你也在做游戏?

他说,没有。就是,尺度可以更大一点,更成人一点。我也不知道。我尽量诚实。

台下欢呼。托德在旁边说,我不知道怎么接这个。

整场最马斯克的一刻就在这里。他语气平平,没有开玩笑的意思,也没有往下展开,说完就把话题交回去了。一个管着火箭公司和汽车公司的人,对游戏最大的私人期待,是希望它更放得开。

赛博朋克皮卡,看着就不该上路

主持人换了个角度:你孩子玩游戏,你自己也玩,什么东西让你兴奋?最近玩过什么?一款游戏要吸引你,需要做到什么?

马斯克说,他玩得不多。这几年工作强度太大,睡得不够,就这个状态持续了两年。上一次玩得比较多的是《辐射4》(Fallout 4),那款不错。

主持人调侃了一句:然后他就说“我玩够了,挺好”。

马斯克说,他喜欢《赛博朋克》的主题。

这个主题恰好和特斯拉要做的一辆皮卡对上了。他说那辆车就是赛博朋克风格,希望夏末发布。他的描述很直接:看起来怪,不像一辆正常的车,看着就不该出现在路上。不会讨所有人喜欢,但会与众不同。他说自己会买。

主持人问,是直接受那款游戏启发吗?

马斯克说,他是后来才注意到这款游戏的,人家已经做了很久。他喜欢的是那个整体概念,有点《银翼杀手》(Blade Runner)的味道。他补了一句:如果你在做一件事,却要琢磨别人喜欢什么而你自己不喜欢,那很难做好。你爱上了它,是个好兆头。别管别人喜不喜欢,你喜欢,别人多半也会喜欢。

托德接得很顺:完全同意。而且不只我一个人,是整个团队。这些东西是我们会半夜排队去买、去玩的。热情就从这儿来。你得天天跟有品味的人待在一起,而且经常打不中目标。

Starlink 想让地球上任何角落都能玩

主持人问起 Starlink(星链)。最近关于卫星和全球互联网的新闻不少,低延迟,游戏可能是受益者之一。

马斯克说,Starlink 的一个设计标准就是低延迟,这对实时游戏很重要。第二代的星座会瞄准更低的延迟,对任何实时游戏都会很好。

主持人问,全球任何地方都能接?

马斯克说,地球上任何角落。

主持人说,从设计师的角度看,云平台和串流会打开很多可能。

托德把话题拉回到人。他说,这件事的关键,是让“谁能玩”这件事变得更公平。现在门槛很多:我想玩那款游戏,得先买设备,得人正好在某个地方。游戏应该像别的娱乐一样,你根本不用想这件事。它应该无处不在,不只在我们这种网络条件好的地方,还有世界上正在增长、几十亿新玩家正在进场、却没有我们习以为常那些条件的地方。

台上那几个提问

主持人开放现场提问。

一个正在 Twitch 直播的年轻人问模拟论。他的说法是:如果去考虑每个人的性格、细胞层面的运作、宇宙里的一切,这么复杂这么精致,模拟论是不是反而显得更牵强?

马斯克说了一句“好的,这个想法”,然后道谢,直接跳到下一个问题。这个质疑他等于没答。没听清,还是不想在游戏展上展开,没人知道。

第二个问题很欢乐。有人冲台上喊,查尔斯,你的獠牙呢。马斯克说,这问题他以前听过。

第三个问题问去火星。宇航员路上要飞很久,你有什么娱乐计划?会不会让他们在路上玩游戏?

马斯克说,当然,绝对。太空派对。

第四个问题问,我得恳求多久才能跟你拍张自拍?他说,现在就可以。

第五个问题问怎么报名参加 Neuralink(神经连接)的测试。马斯克说,把这个 USB-C 接口装进脑袋就行,会没事的,可能有点刺痛。

第六个问题问托德招不招实习生。托德说,去官网,上面有很多职位。

第七个问题来自一个正在给玩家做代币化游戏经济的年轻人。他问,能不能用两点 karma 积分换马斯克在他的赛博朋克帽子上签名。马斯克还了个价:两点半。旁边有人补了一句,karma 看起来是真的。

第八个问题问的是专注。你每天面对那么多噪音和疯狂,怎么保持专注?我实在没法体会那种状态。

马斯克说,确实疯了。他打了个比方:感觉难度一直在往上调,能不能调低一档?这会很有帮助。它一直在加难度,噩梦难度。

最后一个问题来自一个开车的人。他说,你火箭发射那天我正往西开在 Burbank 大道上,所有人都靠边停车了。下一次发射是什么时候?

马斯克说,我们一直在发射,一年 20 到 30 次,大部分从卡纳维拉尔角,有些就在加州。那种特别显眼的发射,看着像朝鲜的核入侵。YouTube 上有些视频很好笑,911 被打爆了。对我们来说,我们知道那是什么,所以就是“哦,一次发射”。下一次大概是月底从卡纳维拉尔角,那次会推一点边界,侧载荷更大,动压更高,气压也更高。如果你正好在大角,会是一场好看的发射。

主持人说时间到了,谢谢两位。台下鼓掌,两个人下台。

这场对话里真正值得带走的

整场聊下来,最有信息量的部分藏在几句随口说的话里。

一句是招人。马斯克说他面试软件工程师,经常问对方是怎么开始编程的,很多人的答案是电子游戏。他由此得出一个判断:世界上最好的工程师里,相当一部分在游戏公司待过,因为要在有限算力下做出逼真画面,逼着人把代码写紧、想巧办法。这种能力会迁移到别的领域。

一句是创新和失败的关系。他说,做没被探索过的事,出错概率本来就高。只有做已经弄清楚的事,失败率才低,但那也没意思。他自己炸过三枚火箭,2008 年连房租都拿不出来,第四次发射成了才活下来。托德那边是公司差点倒闭,靠一个项目续命。两个人的故事结构一模一样:先差点死掉,再活过来。

一句是做产品。你得自己先爱上它。如果一件事你自己不喜欢,只因为猜别人会喜欢才去做,很难做好。这话放在游戏、车、火箭上都成立。

还有一句是关于自动驾驶的,很多人没注意。他说自动驾驶难,难在现实世界的 bug:标线被涂掉、标线和实际路错开、地上的刹车痕、施工。他们把问题重新定义成“哪里是路”和“哪里是可行驶空间”,车开进邻居家车道,技术上可行驶,但你不该去。这段话其实在讲一件更大的事:真实世界充满不按规矩来的东西,规则写得再清楚也不够用。

最后,那个问模拟论的年轻人被略过了。这个细节比任何回答都说明问题:在一场游戏展上,最哲学的问题反而最没人接。

给读者的几条具体建议

  • 面试工程师时加一个问题:你是怎么开始编程的?答案里出现“游戏”的人,往往在资源受限、要求极限优化的环境里练过,这种经验比刷题更能说明动手能力。
  • 想判断一个人能不能真的做出东西,看他对自己在做的事有没有爱。自己都不喜欢、只靠猜市场喜好硬做的项目,成功率低得多。
  • 做创新项目之前,先把失败预算算清楚。与其问“会不会失败”,不如问“失败几次之后我还活着”。马斯克的做法是把钱分两半,留一半兜底,结果两半都投进去了,靠第四次发射翻盘。教训是:兜底的钱要真的留得住。
  • 如果你在做自动驾驶、机器人或任何和物理世界打交道的产品,别把精力全放在规则内的场景。真正难的是标线错了、路面脏了、路上有人乱停车。先把边缘案例的收集机制建起来。
  • 给孩子的屏幕时间做减法之前,先看看他在玩什么。如果他在玩能造东西、能写逻辑、能改规则的游戏,那可能是他接触技术最自然的入口。
  • 关注低延迟网络的进展。Starlink 这类项目要解决的是全球任何角落都能实时联网,一旦成本降下来,云游戏、远程协作、远程医疗的场景会重新洗一遍。
  • 看访谈时,注意那些被跳过的问题。谁被略过、什么话题被岔开,往往比台上说了什么更能看出一个人的真实边界。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:01AND NOW, ELON MUSK IN CONVERSATION WITH TODD HOWARD! PLEASE WELCOME YOUR MODERATOR!

0:12THIS IS GOING TO BE REALLY SPECIAL. E3 I THINK IS A SHOW ABOUT CELEBRATING GAMES BUT IT'S ALSO ABOUT TALKING ABOUT THE IMPACT GAMES HAVE ON THE WORLD AND PEOPLE FROM ALL WALKS OF LIFE TALKING ABOUT WHAT GAMES MEAN TO THEM. TODAY IT'S MY HONOR TO INTRODUCE ONE OF OUR INDUSTRY'S MOST RENOWNED DESIGNERS WITH AN INDIVIDUAL WHO IS CHARTING THE FUTURE OF THE WORLD IN SO MANY INCREDIBLE WAYS WHO ALSO HAPPENS TO BE A BIG GAMER.

0:44PLEASE WELCOME TODD HOWARD AND ELON MUSK! WELCOME TO E3! THANK YOU.

1:07WHEN WE ANNOUNCE THIS, THE BIGGEST QUESTION EVERYONE HAD WAS TO THESE GUYS KNOW EACH OTHER? YOU GUYS ARE FRIENDS, RIGHT? YEAH.

1:18HOW DID YOU GET TO KNOW EACH OTHER?

1:22PEOPLE TRIED TO CONNECT US OVER SEVERAL YEARS, WE FINALLY CONNECTED I THINK WHEN I BOUGHT MY TESLA. AND SOMEBODY -- I WENT INTO THE STORE, YOU DON'T BUY TESLA, YOU ORDER THEM ONLINE. I CLICK THAT BUTTON WHEN ORDERING OUR TESLA AND THEN WE CONNECTED.

1:48I'VE BEEN A BIG FAN OF YOUR GAMES FOR A LONG TIME AND I PLAYED "FALL OUT 3," I PLAYED THAT GAME A LOT. I EXPLORED EVERY CORNER OF THAT GAME. I DID NOT COMPLETE "SKY ROOM." AND THEN, I ASKED FOR THE DASH CAN I HAVE THAT STATUE OF THAT WEIRD LOOKING GUY WITH THE 1950s GUY? THAT GUY.

2:36LIFE-SIZED STATUE OF THIS 1950s JUMPSUIT. DO YOU HAVE THIS AT HOME? IT WAS SO WEIRD HAVING THAT WITH PARTY. TO PARTNER TO MAKE EVERYONE ELSE IS LIKE, THAT'S WEIRD. ROLLING BACK IN TIME, WHEN YOU WERE A KID, YOU PROGRAMMED A GAME, IS THAT TRUE?

3:11PRIMITIVE. IT I THINK I WAS PROBABLY TEN OR 11 WHEN I PROGRAMMED THAT GAME, IT'S A SIMPLE GAME. YOU ARE A SPACE FIGHTER, YOU FIGHT ALIENS. YEAH. I WROTE THAT GAME, THE GRAPHICS AND THE SOUND AND EVERYTHING. IT'S A VERY SIMPLE GAME.

3:38DID YOU EVER ASPIRE TO MAKE GAMES OR GET INTO MAKING GAMES? THAT WILL BE FUN.

3:51THERE WERE A FEW PLACES WHERE YOU KEPT DOING A LITTLE BIT OF GAMING STUFF.

3:54I WORKED AT A GAMING START UP WHICH WARILY WAS CALLED ROCKET SCIENCE. FADE TO LOVE'S IRONY. I WORKED AT ROCKET SCIENCE, IT WAS LONG TIME AGO. IT MUST HAVE BEEN '93, '94. IT WAS TRICKY.

4:21YOU NEVER APPLY TO BETHESDA, THOUGH?

4:26HE WAS DOING OTHER THINGS.

4:29MY ORIGINAL PLAN WAS TO GO TO GRAD SCHOOL AND DO STUDY FOR ELECTRIC VEHICLES, I ALWAYS WANTED TO DO ELECTRIC CARS AND WORK ON SUSTAINABLE ENERGY, I CAN SORT OF TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT IT. BASICALLY, WHAT OF THE THINGS I THINK ARE IMPORTANT FOR THE FUTURE, WE HAD TO HAVE SUSTAINABLE ENERGY, SUSTAINABLE CONSUMPTION OF ENERGY.

5:02SO THAT MEANS MAKING SOLAR PANELS LOW-COST AND ELECTRIC ELECTRIC CARS APPEALING. AND THEN WE WANT TO BE, MULTI-PLANET SPECIES, ROCKETS, AND THEN -- THERE IS A SOME THINGS I THOUGHT WOULD AFFECT THE FUTURE BUT I'M NOT SURE IF IT'S GOOD OR BAD, LIKE A I. THAT WORRIES ME, THAT ONE. [LAUGHTER]

5:32I JUST MADE A VIDEO GAMES. I WAS GOING TO DO ALL THAT. BUT I ACTUALLY DON'T KNOW HOW TO DO THAT.

5:46THAT AI BASICALLY CAUSED WORLD WAR III, AS I RECALL.

5:53IS THERE A LINK THERE, YOU TALK ABOUT AI AND VIDEO GAMES AND THE TECHNOLOGY AND VIDEO GAMES, IS THERE ANYTHING THERE THAT SORT OF HELPS PUSH TECHNOLOGY THAT YOU THINK? YOU LOOK AT SELF-DRIVING CARS OR OTHER THINGS, ARE THERE THINGS FROM VIDEO GAMES YOU THINK HELP PUSH TECHNOLOGY FORWARD?

6:13PART OF THE REASON I GOT INTERESTED IN TECHNOLOGY, THE REASON WAS VIDEO GAMES.

6:33VIDEO GAMES ARE A POWERFUL FORCE FOR GETTING KIDS INTERESTED IN TECHNOLOGY, IT HAS A BIGGER EFFECT THAN PEOPLE REALIZE. IF WE ARE INTERVIEWING SOMEBODY FOR SOFTWARE ENGINEERING, MANY TIMES, HOW DID YOU START PROGRAMMING? "VIDEO GAMES." I THINK MANY OF THE BEST SOFTWARE ENGINEERS IN THE WORLD ARE AT OR SPENT MUCH OF THEIR CAREER AT VIDEO GAMES HOUSES AND

7:03ESPECIALLY IF PEOPLE HAD TO TRY TO CREATE REALISTIC GRAPHICS USING VERY LITTLE COMPUTE POWER, THAT'S A HARD PROBLEM AND SO A LOT OF PEOPLE HAD TO WRITE REALLY TIGHT CODE AND COME UP WITH REALLY CLEVER IDEAS TO DO THAT. IF YOU LOOK AT SOMEONE, AND AMAZING SOFTWARE ENGINEER AND A REALLY GOOD AEROSPACE ENGINEER, IT SHOWS PROBLEM SOLVING, FIGURE

7:32OUT SOFTWARE ENGINEERING, PROBLEM-SOLVING, IT TRANSFERS TO OTHER THINGS.

7:37THE BEST ANECDOTE BETWEEN VIDEO GAMES AND ROCKETS, GAMING AI IS SO MUCH HARDER. WHEN THE GAME CRASHES, HE PRICES REBOOT AND WHEN THE ROCKET CRASHES, A GIANT MASS SPREAD OVER SEVERAL MILES.

7:52THERE'S A JOKE ABOUT, IF REALITY WAS A VIDEO GAME THE GRAPHICS ARE GREAT BUT THE PLOT IS TERRIBLE. AND THE TIME IS REALLY LONG.

8:10HOW HAS THE STUFF ELON'S DONE INSPIRED OR AFFECTED WHAT YOU DO, TODD, IN YOUR WORLD?

8:16I MEAN, THE SPACE STUFF, AS WE LOOK AT STARFIELD'S, THAT'S REALLY KIND OF LOOK, OKAY, HOW ARE THESE THINGS GOING TO WORK IN THE FUTURE? GOT TO GO TO SPACE X LAST YEAR, THAT PLACE IS LIKE THE AVENGERS MEETS NASSAU. WHAT DO THOSE THINGS LOOK LIKE AS WE DO A SCIENCE-FICTION GAME? BUT THE OTHER STUFF, IN THE CARS AND SELF-DRIVING IS SOMETHING I'M PASSIONATE ABOUT BUT THAT DOESN'T AFFECT THE GAME STUFF.

8:49AND I KNOW THAT NOW YOU ARE PUTTING GAMES ON THE TESLA SO THAT'S DIFFERENT.

8:55YEAH. ACTUALLY, THANKS FOR HELPING OUT ON THAT, I APPRECIATE IT.

9:03WE TALKED ABOUT THAT, WOULDN'T IT BE PRETTY COOL? SO WE ARE WORKING TOGETHER. "SKYRIM" ON IT? WE ARE GOING TO START A LITTLE SMALLER. WE ARE WORKING ON "FALLOUT SHELTER" FOR THE CARS. IT WILL BE FREE, YOUR LITTLE DWELLERS ON THE SCREEN, THEY LIVE IN THE CAR IN SOME WAY. IT'S A GREAT STARTING POINT.

9:30HOW IS THIS GOING TO WORK WITH GAMES, YOU'VE TALKED ABOUT UNITY AND PORTING IT ALL, YOU HAVE TO BE PARKED WHEN YOU PLAY THESE? HOW DOES THIS WORK?

9:41YEAH, YOU HAVE TO PARK THE CAR. [LAUGHS]

9:49THE FUN POLICE MAKE US PARK THE CAR. WE WERE ALSO GOING TO ENABLE PEOPLE TO WATCH VIDEOS, STREAMING. THROUGH THE BROWSER, TO WATCH NETFLIX OR WHATEVER. YOUTUBE, IF THE CAR IS PARKED. A CHARGING STATION IF YOU WANT TO WATCH SOMETHING, WATCH IT ON THE SCREEN IN THE CAR. BUT THE GENERAL PRINCIPLE, WHAT CAN WE DO TO MAKE THE CAR THE MOST FUN POSSIBLE?

10:24AND WHAT DO OTHER CARS NOT HAVE? SO IT SEEMS LIKE, WELL, YOU KNOW, IF YOU ARE JUST PARKED SOMEWHERE WAITING FOR SOMEBODY, FINISH AN APPOINTMENT, ON A ROAD TRIP IT WOULD BE PRETTY COOL IF YOU JUST GO TO THE CAR SCREEN AND PLAY SOME FUN GAME. AND WE ARE EXPLORING, HOW DO WE MAKE IT AS MUCH FUN AS POSSIBLE?

10:48YOU CAN ALREADY PLAY ALL OF THE OLD ATARI GAMES IN THE CAR, YOU CAN CONNECT AN XBOX OR PS FOR CONTROLLER AND HAVE A PRETTY GOOD CONTROL FEEDBACK. AND WE HAVE GENIUS MOVES AND -- YOU CAN MAKE THE FART SOUND LIKE IT'S COMING FROM ANY SEAT.

11:24THAT ACTUALLY IS THE FUNNIEST EASTER EGG. AND THE NAMES OF THE FART. THE FALCON HEAVY IS ONE OF THEM, I BELIEVE. EXACTLY.

11:41WE'VE GOT SOME CLIPS, RIGHT?

11:43I CAN SHOW YOU SOME CLIPS OF SOME UPCOMING GAMES IN THE CAR, IT'S MEANT TO BE, WHAT ARE SOME COOL GAMES PEOPLE MIGHT LIKE TO PLAY, HOW MUCH PEOPLE PLAY THEM, ADD THEM TO -- HIGHER ON THE LIST OR MAYBE PUT IT INTO AN ARCHIVE YOU CAN TAP TO DOWNLOAD. THE SCREEN WAS NOT ORIGINALLY MEANT AS A GAME PLAYER, DOESN'T HAVE THAT MUCH STORAGE.

12:09SO IT WOULDN'T HAVE THAT MANY GAMES ON IT AT ONE TIME BUT IT WOULD BE LIKE -- WHAT DO PEOPLE ENJOY PLAYING, A GOOD WAY TO PASS TIME.

12:18LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT GAMES ON TESLA. ♪ ♪ [APPLAUSE]

12:58WE'VE GOT A SECOND ONE, TOO?

13:02WE GOT A RACING GAME, SINGLE PLAYER OR TWO PLAYER.

13:07GAME TWO, CHECK IT OUT. ♪ ♪ [APPLAUSE]

14:16THE STEERING WHEEL, I WASN'T PREPARED FOR THAT, THAT'S PRETTY .

14:21IF YOU HAVE A RACING GAME AND YOU HAVE A STEERING WHEEL SITTING RIGHT THERE, WAITING TO BE STEERED.

14:28TO GAS AND BRAKE, WILL THAT WORK, TOO?

14:32YEAH. THE BREAK IS WIRED IN AND I THINK WE WILL PROBABLY HAVE MAYBE THE SCROLL WHEEL FOR THE GAS PEDAL SO WE DON'T ACCIDENTALLY -- STEPPING ON THE BREAK IF YOU ARE STATIONARY IS NOT A PROBLEM.

14:49THE GAS COULD BE. THAT'S AMAZING. THAT'S SO COOL THAT YOU'RE DOING THAT INSIDE THE CAUSE. I WANT TO ASK YOU THE IDEA, YOU ARE BOTH CERTAINLY KNOWN FOR A TON OF INCREDIBLE SUCCESSES IN YOUR CAREERS. HE SAID BEFORE, SOMETIMES YOU'RE REALLY ONLY INNOVATING IF YOU'RE READY TO FAIL OR HAVE FAILURE

15:11ALONG THE WAY, SHOWS THAT YOU ARE PUSHING RENOVATION. TODD, YOU'VE BEEN THROUGH QUITE A YEAR, CAN YOU GUYS MAY BE RARE LITTLE BIT ON SWORD OUT OF THE FOR INNOVATION AND HOW SOMETIMES FAILURE IS PART OF THAT JOURNEY?

15:30USUALLY WHEN YOU GET TO GAMING, THE FIRST TIME YOU SEE IT, YOU'VE GOT SUCCESSFUL AND YOU GOT THERE BY TRYING BIG NEW THINGS AND WE ARE GOING TO KEEP DOING THAT, OTHER GAME MAKERS DO THAT AND I THINK IT'S GOOD THAT THE AUDIENCES ARE WELCOMING TO THAT. THEY ARE GOING TO TRY IT OUT AND SUPPORT US AS WE GO THROUGH THAT PROCESS TO FIGURE OUT, HEY, WHAT'S GOING TO MAKE THIS TAX?

15:52WE HAD OUR UPS AND DOWNS WITH "FALLOUT 76" BUT OUR FANS ARE INCREDIBLE AND HAVE REALLY STUCK WITH US AND IT'S TURNED INTO ONE OF THE BEST ONLINE COMMUNITIES WE'VE EVER SEEN, IT'S FANTASTIC.

16:05THROUGH YOUR CAREER I'M SURE YOU'VE SEEN THAT, TOO, THE PROJECTS THAT TAKE TIME TO EVOLVE BUT THAT'S PART OF WHAT IT TAKES, I GUESS, HAVING THAT VISION AND PUSHING FOR IT.

16:16SURE, IF YOU'RE GOING TO TRY SOMETHING INNOVATIVE, YOU ARE IN UNEXPLORED TERRITORY SO THE ODDS THAT SOMETHING WILL GO WRONG ARE PRETTY HIGH. IT'S ONLY IF YOU TRY TO DO SOMETHING THAT'S WELL UNDERSTOOD THAT THERE IS A LITTLE CHANCE OF FAILURE BUT THERE WILL NOT BE INTERESTING OR INNOVATIVE.

16:39FOR SURE, UNCHARTED TERRITORY WILL RESULT IN FAILURES NECESSARILY. OR YOU'RE NOT TRYING HARD ENOUG ENOUGH.

16:52SPEAKING OF UNCHARTED TERRITORY, YOU MENTIONED "STARFIELD" BUT OBVIOUSLY SPACE IS GOING TO BE A PART OF THAT. I'M CURIOUS, I DON'T KNOW HOW MUCH YOU CAN TELL US ABOUT THE GAME -- I SHOULD ASK, WHAT CAN YOU TELL US?

17:08I DO NOT HAVE A CLIP. EVERYONE NEEDS TO BE PATIENT ON THAT BUT WHAT I CAN SAY IS HOW WE APPROACH IT. THIS COULD HAPPEN. WHAT KIND OF FUEL DO THE SHIPS USE? USING HELIUM THREE, WE CAN DEBATE WHETHER THAT IS A GOOD POWER SOURCE FOR SPACESHIPS, HOW DO THE PHYSICS WORK IN SPACE AND GRAVITY AND THOSE KIND OF THING THINGS.

17:37WE HAVE TWO A GAME IF I IT SO IT'S NOT AS PUNISHING AS ACTUAL SPACE TRAVEL BUT THAT IT FEELS LIKE TRAVELING IN SPACE IN OUR GAME IS STILL -- AND IT'S DANGEROUS, IT'S STILL DANGEROUS TO GO AND EXPLORE. EVEN THOUGH LOTS OF PEOPLE DO I IT.

18:01SPACE IS FAR, IS THE THING. YOU HAVE TO DEFINITELY CUT THAT SHORT. FOUR LIGHT YEARS, MAN. EVEN AT LIGHT SPEED THAT'S PRETTY FAR. I MEAN, IF YOU WANT NORMAL PHYSICS, AND ANTIMATTER DRIVE WOULD BE THE BEST BUT THAT'S GOING TO LIMIT YOU TO LIGHT SPEED WHICH IS A LONG TIME. YEAH. OTHERWISE YOU'RE GOING TO BE STUCK IN ONE STAR SYSTEM.

18:34SO -- JUST HONESTLY, I FEEL LIKE WE'RE IN A PRETTY GOOD VIDEO GAME. WHY IS IT JUST POSSIBLE TO GET TO MARS? WHY ARE THE STARS OF SO FAR AWA AWAY? PUT THOSE STARS, LITTLE POINTS OF LIGHT, DON'T WORRY ABOUT IT.

19:01ARE YOU LOOKING AT THAT WHEN YOU ARE BUILDING "STARFIELD"? I DON'T KNOW HOW FAR IN THE FUTURE IT'S SET.

19:07GOING BACK TO THAT, RISKING FAILURE AND STUFF, HONESTLY, THE WORLD NEEDS MORE PEOPLE LIKE ELON WHO SAY, I'M NOT SURE HOW THAT WORKS, I'M GOING TO TRY THAT A DIFFERENT WAY. A LOT OF PEOPLE WILL DOUBT THAT. WHETHER IT'S GOING TO SPACE, SELF-DRIVING CARS, I AM VERY PASSIONATE ABOUT THOSE THINGS AND AS IT COMES TO WHAT'S HAPPENING AT SPACE X, WHAT ARE THE LIMITS OF THE PHYSICS OF THE NEW ENGINES OR THINGS LIKE THAT?

19:38TALKING TO ELON, HOW FAR COULD THIS GO IN CURRENT REALITY, HOW WOULD WE MOVE BEYOND THAT IN A FICTIONAL WAY? YEAH.

19:49OBVIOUSLY YOU ARE YOU DOING WITH THE REALITY OF TODAY BUT SOMETHING FUTURISTIC LIKE TODD IS DOING, DOES THAT GET YOU EXCITED ABOUT WHERE IT SPACE TRAVEL CAN GO, CAN TODD'S WORLD EXPLORE THAT EVEN FURTHER ON?

20:04I THINK SCI-FI MOVIES AND VIDEO GAMES, REALLY I THINK IN VIDEO GAMES AND MOVIES THESE DAYS, IT CAN BE PRETTY INSPIRING, TALKING ABOUT THE FUTURE WE WANT, WHAT ARE SOME IMPOSSIBLE SOUNDING TECHNOLOGIES THAT MAY BE COULD WORK SOMEHOW? THIS CONCEIVABLY THERE IS A WAY TO DO WORK DRIVE BUT IT'S SUCH

20:32ESOTERIC, SUPER OUT ON THE EDGE PHYSICS BECAUSE TECHNICALLY YOU CANNOT GO FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT BUT SPACE CAN TRAVEL FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT. THAT'S WHAT'S MEANT BY WARP DRIVE. THE AMOUNT OF ENERGY YOU NEED TO WARP SPACES UNBELIEVABLY GIGANTIC. YOU'D HAVE TO BE CONVERTING MATTER AND ENERGY AT A RATE THAT

21:00WE CAN'T CONCEIVE, REALLY. IT CAN'T BE LIKE SOMETHING WHERE IF WE JUST CONVERT ONE JUPITER PER SECOND TO ENERGY, PROBLEM SOLVED. THERE IS A LOT, THERE'S NOT MANY JUPITER'S. YOU KNOW. SO -- THERE MIGHT BE A BIT OF RADIATION AROUND THAT. THERE ARE THINGS, TECHNICALLY THE UNIVERSE DID EXPAND FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT, THAT'S WHY WE CAN SEE LIGHT FROM ALL THESE SUPER DISTANT STARS.

21:37YEAH. IT'S A PRETTY WILD THAT SPACE EXPANDED FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT. FIGURE OUT SOME STRANGE BREAKTHROUGHS AND COME TO GRIPS BETTER WITH DARK MATTER ESPECIALLY WHICH SEEMS LIKE SOMETHING FISHY IS GOING ON THERE. AND -- IT HAS BAD BRANDING.

22:02YEAH. EXACTLY. THE UNIVERSE IS MOSTLY DARK ENERGY AND DARK MATTER ACCORDING TO CURRENT PHYSICS BUT YOU KIND OF PLUG THEM IN THE EQUATIONS AND THEY SORT OF WORK. I SORT OF FIGURE, HEY, IF THIS IS A VIDEO GAME AND HAD A BUG IN THEIR SIMULATOR, OH, NO, WE HAVE TO FIGURE OUT A WAY FOR THESE MINIONS TO BELIEVE THEY ARE IN REALITY, INSERT DARK MATTER.

22:38THE IDEA OF A GAME AS A SIMULATION PREDICTING THINGS, OBVIOUSLY IT'S ENTERTAINMENT ON SOME LEVEL BUT THERE ARE GAMES WHERE IT'S MORE SIMULATION. OR MAYBE NOT. IS THERE VALUE IN THAT? IN TESTING THINGS AND EXPLORING IDEAS INSIDE THE GAME WORLD?

23:01YEAH, AT BEST SO WE HAVE A WHOLE TEAM THAT CREATES PHOTOREALISTIC WORLD, TRYING TO BE PHOTOREALISTIC. CONCRETE CURBS, SHADOWS, FADED LINES, THE REASON SELF-DRIVING IS HARD IS BECAUSE YOU HAVE ALL THESE CORNER CASES AND THINGS WHERE THE ROAD SHOULD BE A CERTAIN WAY ABOUT IT ISN'T, THERE SHOULD BE CERTAIN LINES BUT THERE ARE INTO PAINTED LINES, THEY TOOK THE PAINTED LINES AWAY, MARK THAT'S OFFSET FROM THE PAINTED LINES THAT IF IT JUST LISTENS TO THE LINE AND IT CRASHES INTO STUFF.

23:47IF YOU HAD CLEARLY PAINTED LINE LINES, SELF-DRIVING WOULD BE TRIVIAL. THE WORLD IS FULL OF THINGS THAT ARE NOT THE WAY THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO BE IN THE REAL TRICK WITH SELF-DRIVING AI IS TO FIGURE OUT, WHERE SHOULD I BE ON THIS ROAD THAT HAS NO PAINTED LINES OR THE LINES HAVE BEEN PAINTED WRONG.

24:10SKID MARKS AND SCRATCHES AND ROADWORK, ALL SORTS OF THINGS THAT ARE UNEXPECTED. THAT'S THE REALLY HARD PART, OTHERWISE IT WOULD BE CHILD'S PLAY. WE DO A LOT OF -- GOOD CORRELATIONS, DOES THE CAR DRIVE OFF THE CLIFF? YES. DOES IT DRIVE OFF THE CLIFF IN REALITY? CLOSE.

24:40I THINK YOU SAID IT ONCE, IT'S NOT THE LINES, IT'S LOOKING FOR DRIVABLE SPACE BECAUSE THAT'S HOW YOUR MIND IS ACTUALLY WORKING EVEN IF THERE'S A LANE. DRIVABLE SPACE IS THE PROBLEM.

24:57WE HAVE A PRETTY GOOD RECOGNITION OF LINES AND WANTS TECHNICALLY DRIVABLE SPACE BUT WE NEED, WHAT IS THE ROAD AS OPPOSED TO -- WHAT IS THE MOST PROBABLY THE ROAD AS OPPOSED TO DRIVABLE SPACE AND A WHOLE SUBSET ON CURVES. WE ARE REALLY INTO CURVES RIGHT NOW. SOME CURVES ARE REALLY SUBTLE.

25:25SOME YOU SHOULD CARE ABOUT, SOME YOU SHOULDN'T CARE ABOUT, SOMETIMES YOU GO TO A DRIVEWAY AND THERE IS A CURVE, AND THE CAR IS LIKE, CAN'T GO OVER THAT. GOING THROUGH HER NEIGHBORHOOD AND EVERYONE'S DRIVEWAY IS DRIVE SPACE. TECHNICALLY TRUE BUT YOU DON'T WANT TO GO THROUGH EVERYONE'S DRIVEWAY, IT'S NOT GOOD.

25:46THINK ABOUT, A LOT OF THAT STUFF STARTED VIDEO GAME WISE, IMAGE PROCESSING AND AI AND WHAT THEY'RE DOING THERE, PEOPLE LOOK AT TECHNOLOGY NOW, THEY ALWAYS UNDERESTIMATE HOW FAST TECHNOLOGY MOVES. IN THE PRESENT DAY, I THINK THE SELF-DRIVING AND WHAT'S HAPPENING NOW IS GOING TO FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGE THE WORLD IN WAYS PEOPLE CAN'T EVEN EXPECT AND -- OUR CHILDREN MIGHT NOT EVEN LEARN TO DRIVE BECAUSE THE CARS WILL ALL BE DRIVING THEMSELVES AROUND OR HOW IT AFFECTS CITYSCAPES, PARKING LOTS, ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION, ALL THESE STUDIES ARE FASCINATING.

26:30THE BEST SELF-DRIVING STOCKS, ALCOHOL COMPANIES. MORE GAMES TO PLAY, TOO.

26:40VIDEO GAMES, ALL YOU NEED A GPU FOR IS TO HELP THE GAME LOOK BETTER. THOSE SAME GPUs ENDED UP BEING VERY USEFUL, HUGE BOOST TO AI. BETTER GRAPHICS TO AI, THE SAME THING IS QUITE KEY TO SELF-DRIVING.

27:14I KNOW YOU HAVE OPEN AI, WHERE GAMES ARE GOING. IT YOU HAVE RPGs, SIMULATED WORLDS, EMERGENT BEHAVIOR, THINGS LIKE THAT. CAN YOU TALK ABOUT WHERE GAMES ARE GOING IN THE NEXT FIVE, TEN, PLUS YEARS, WHAT SORT OF HAPPENED THERE.

27:40I THINK THAT'S THE PART OF GAMING THAT'S GOING TO MAKE THE BIGGEST JUMP. MOST PEOPLE REACT TO INSTANTLY YOU ARE LOOKING AT A SCREENSHOT OR VIDEO. AS FAR AS HOW A GAME FEELS, A LOT OF PEOPLE, INCLUDING US HAVE STRUGGLED WITH HOW YOU MAKE THAT FEEL REAL. YOU CAN MOVE SOME OF THE PROCESSING TO THE CLOUD, THAT'S THE PART WHERE IT'S GOING TO GET SIGNIFICANTLY BETTER OVER THE NEXT GENERATION.

28:14REACTING TO THINGS YOU DID IN MORE REALISTIC MANNER, THE MORE REACTIVE TO WHAT YOU ARE DOING OR THE SITUATION AROUND THEM IS THAT YOU CAN GET THAT IN A VIDEO GAME ALL THE TIME.

28:29YOU GET TO A POINT WHERE THESE GAMES BECOME MORE INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM REALITY. WHAT DO YOU THINK, WHERE DO YOU THINK THIS GOES AS THESE GAMES CONTINUE TO IMPROVE, GRAPHICS GET BETTER, SIMULATION GETS BETTER, DO WE REACH THIS POINT WHERE THE WORLD IS THE SAME THING?

28:50IMAGINE IF WE WERE TO REACH SUCH A SITUATION, THAT WOULD BE CRAZY. WE SEE THOSE CREATURES IN THE GAME SAYING WOW, IMAGINE, CAN YOU IMAGINE IF THERE IS A SIMULATION? YOU ARE IN A SIMULATION. [LAUGHS] THE SIMULATION IS ALL THE WAY DOWN. A SIMULATION IN SIMULATION, IN A SIMULATION.

29:20SEEMS LIKELY. ONE OR TWO THINGS ARE GOING TO HAPPEN, CIVILIZATION WILL END OUR GAMES WILL BE SO REALISTIC THAT YOU CAN'T TELL THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THEM AND REALITY. I POSTULATE. IS -- DOES THIS SOUND CORRECT OR -- DOESN'T SOUND CORRECT? WE COULD BE SOMEBODY'S VIDEO GAME RIGHT NOW. WHOSE AVATAR ARE YOU?

29:57WHEN YOU THINK OF, KIND OF, YOU KNOW, WHEN YOU LOOK AT GAMES AND OF THE YOU PLAY NOW, WHATEVER THINGS YOU WANT TO SEE IN GAMES? IS THERE ANYTHING WHEN YOU PLAY A GAME YOU ARE LIKE -- I WISH IT DID THIS? YOU ARE OBVIOUSLY THINKING ABOUT LOTS OF THINGS BUT ARE YOU SATISFIED, ARE THERE THINGS THAT FRUSTRATE YOU ABOUT GAMES?

30:22WHAT DO YOU WANT TO SEE GAMES DO IN THE FUTURE?

30:26I DON'T KNOW IF I SHOULD SAY.

30:29YOU WORKING ON A GAME, TOO?

30:34NO. I DON'T KNOW. A BIT MORE R-RATED, I DON'T KNOW. TRYING TO BE HONEST HERE. [CHEERS AND APPLAUSE] A POPULAR THEME. TODD?

30:54I DON'T KNOW THAT I CAN FOLLOW THAT UP. I MEAN, WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE STUFF YOU PLAY NOW, YOU TALK ABOUT TODD, YOUR KIDS PLAY GAMES, YOU PLAY GAMES, WHAT EXCITES YOU? WHAT WHAT IF YOU PLAYED RECENT? THERE ARE A LOT OF GAMES OUT THERE, WHAT DOES IT TAKE FOR A GAME TO ATTRACT YOUR INTEREST?

31:22I HAVEN'T PLAYED A LOT OF GAMES, IT'S BEEN SUPER INTENSE, WORK, GET NOT ENOUGH SLEEP, THAT'S BEEN THE SITUATION FOR A COUPLE YEARS. SO -- JUST HAVEN'T HAD MUCH TIME. YOU KNOW, THE LAST GAME I PLAYED A LOT WAS PROBABLY "FALLOUT 4". THAT WAS A GOOD ONE.

31:58AND THAT HE WAS LIKE I'M DONE, I'M GOOD.

32:05"CYBERPUNK," I LIKE THE THEM THEME. THAT WEIRDLY WAS WHAT WE DECIDED TO HAVE OUR PICKUP TRUCK AS CYBERPUNK THEMED PICKUP TRUCK THAT WE WILL BE UNVEILING HOPEFULLY END OF SUMMER. YEAH, YEAH. IT LOOKS WEIRD, IT DOESN'T LOOK NORMAL.

32:26INSPIRED DIRECTLY BY THE THEME -- THE GAME A LITTLE BIT?

32:29I NOTICED ABOUT THE GAME AFTERWARDS, THIS IS SOMETHING OF THEM WORKING ON FOR A WHILE. I LIKE THE GENERAL IDEA. AND YEAH, SO IT'S SORT OF -- YEAH, SORT OF, SORT OF A SLIGHT RUNNER FEEL TO IT. IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE A NORMAL CAR, LOOKS LIKE IT SHOULD NOT BE ON THE ROADS. BUT -- YOU KNOW, IT WON'T APPEAL TO EVERYONE BUT IT WILL BE SOMETHING THAT'S DIFFERENT AND YOU KNOW, IT WILL BE COMING YOU KNOW, PROBABLY APPEAL TO -- I THINK I WOULD BUY IT.

33:10YOU KNOW, IF YOU'RE TRYING TO WORK ON SOMETHING, IT'S REALLY HARD TO -- TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT OTHERS LOVE BUT YOU DON'T LOVE IT, IT'S REALLY HARD TO MAKE THAT GREAT. WHEN YOU'RE WORKING ON SOMETHING, IF YOU FALL IN LOVE WITH IT, THAT'S A GOOD SIGN. DON'T WORRY ABOUT IF OTHERS DO, IF YOU DO OTHERS WELL. ABSOLUTELY TRUE.

33:40PROBABLY HOW YOU FEEL ABOUT MAKING GAMES, YOU HAVE TO LOVE TO PLAY A?

33:45ABSOLUTELY AND IT'S NOT JUST ME, THE WHOLE TEAM. THESE ARE THE KIND OF THINGS WE WOULD LINE UP AT MIDNIGHT TO GO PLAY AND BUY. AND THAT'S WHAT DRIVES YOUR PASSION TO DO IT. YOU HAVE TO BE AROUND TASTE MAKER DAY IN AND DAY OUT, YOU OFTEN MISS THE MARK.

34:04ONE THING I WANT TO TALK ABOUT HIS ONLINE PLAY, A LOT IN THE NEWS RECENTLY ABOUT THE SATELLITES AND THE INTERNET AROUND THE WORLD, LOW LATENCY AND GAMING COULD BE ONE OF THE BENEFICIARIES OF THIS. CAN WE TALK A BIT ABOUT THAT PROJECT AND HOW IT WILL TIE AND POTENTIALLY TO GAMING?

34:24SURE. ONE OF THE CRITERIA FOR STARLIN STARLINK, IMPORTANT FOR REAL-TIME GAMING AND LATER, SORT OF SECOND-GENERATION CONSTELLATIONS ARE AIMING FOR -- THIS WOULD BE REALLY GREAT FOR ANY KIND OF REAL-TIME GAMING, YEAH.

34:51ACROSS THE WORLD YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO ACCESS THAT?

34:54ANYWHERE ON EARTH. I SPEAK ARE PRETTY AMAZING. THAT'S EXCITING, WE LOOK AT THESE CLOUD PLATFORMS, STREAMING, FROM A DESIGNER PERSPECTIVE THAT MUCH OPEN UP SO MANY POSSIBILITIES. WHERE GAMES ARE GOING TO GET IN THE FUTURE.

35:12I THINK IT'S ABOUT DEMOCRATIZING WHO CAN PLAY, THERE'S A LOT OF BARRIERS TO I WANT TO PLAY THAT GAME, I HAVE TO BUY THIS, BE SOMEWHERE. HAVING THAT WHERE YOU CAN APPROACH IT LIKE ANY OTHER ENTERTAINMENT, YOU DON'T THINK ABOUT IT AND THAT'S WHERE GAMES NEED TO BE, WHERE IT'S UBIQUITOUS, NOT JUST IN OUR PART OF THE WORLD WHERE PEOPLE ARE CONNECTED WELL, OTHER PARTS OF THE WORLD THAT ARE GROWING AND THESE BILLIONS OF GAMERS COMING INTO THE SCENE WHO DON'T HAVE THE ACCESS WE TAKE FOR GRANTED.

35:46MAYBE A COUPLE AUDIENCE Q&A, MAYBE RAISE YOUR HAND, COUPLE QUESTIONS FOR THESE GUYS. A RARE OPPORTUNITY.

35:54HELLO, HOW ARE YOU DOING? WE ARE STREAMING ON TWITCH RIGHT NOW, BY THE WAY. I HAD A QUESTION ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF LIVING IN A SIMULATION. WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT ALL THE QUIRKS, EVERY INDIVIDUAL PERSONALITY, HOW THINGS WORK ON A CELLULAR LEVEL LIKE THE UNIVERSE, EVERYTHING, DOESN'T IT START TO SEE MORE FAR-FETCHED WHEN YOU SEE HOW INTRICATE AND INDIVIDUAL THINGS ARE?

36:21OKAY, THE IDEA THAT -- [APPLAUSE] THANK YOU, APPRECIATE IT. NEXT QUESTION, LET'S MAYBE GO OVER HERE.

36:40HI. BIG FAN. THAT'S LOUD. CHARLES. WHERE ARE YOUR TUSKS? I'VE HEARD THAT BEFORE.

37:09THANKS FOR COMING, THANKS, GUYS. ELON, IF YOU WANT TO GET TO MARS, THAT'S GOING TO TAKE A LONG TIME TO GET ASTRONAUTS OUT THERE. WHAT KIND OF ENTERTAINMENT PLAN DO YOU HAVE? HOPEFULLY VOTED TO PLAY GAMES ON THEIR WAY TO MARS, WHAT YOU THINK ABOUT THAT.

37:25ABSOLUTELY, SURE. AWESOME. PARTY IN SPACE. LET'S DO IT.

37:37MINE IS SIMPLE, HOW MUCH DO I HAVE TO BEG TO GET A SELFIE WITH YOU?

37:45SURE, I'LL DO A SELFIE. SURE. ALL RIGHT. NEXT QUESTION. BACK THERE IN THE RED SHIRT.

37:58IT'S FOR ELON, HOW DO I SIGN UP TO TEST OUT YOUR NEURAL MAP PROGRAM?

38:08YOU PUT THIS U.S. BC REPORT IN YOUR HEAD. IT WILL BE FINE, MIGHT STING A LITTLE.

38:19ANOTHER ONE, SURE, RIGHT OVER THERE.

38:22QUESTION FOR TODD HOWARD. I LIVE IN ROCKFORD MARYLAND, ARE YOU LOOKING FOR ANY INTERNS BY CHANCE?

38:29GO TO OUR WEB SITE, THERE'S A LOT OF JOB POSTINGS THERE.

38:34A COUPLE MORE. SURE, RIGHT OVER THERE.

38:37HEY, WOW, THIS IS CRAZY. SO RIGHT NOW, I'M TRYING TO BUILD A TOKENIZED GAME ECONOMY FOR GAMERS, MY QUESTION IS, FOR TWO KARMA POINTS, CAN YOU SIGN MY CYBERPUNK HAT?

38:56WE WILL GET IT UP HERE FOR HIM.

38:58TWO AND A HALF KARMA POINTS. ANOTHER ONE RIGHT HERE. KARMA DOES SEEM REAL.

39:11ELON, I'M JUST WONDERING, WITH ALL THE NOISE YOU DEAL WITH, LOTS OF CRAZINESS, HOW DO YOU STAY FOCUSED? I CAN'T IMAGINE. YEAH, IT'S INSANE.

39:27HIS PROMISE WAS YOU DO STAY FOCUSED. SO MANY THINGS.

39:33I FEEL LIKE THE LEVELS, THE LEVEL KEEPS RATCHETING UP, CAN WE TURN THE DIFFICULTY DOWN ONE NOTCH? THAT WOULD BE REALLY HELPFUL. IT KEEPS DIALING UP THE DIFFICULTY. NIGHTMARE LEVEL. [LAUGHS]

39:54THIS IS A QUESTION FOR BOTH OF YOU, WHAT'S THE ACTUAL BIGGEST FAILURE YOU'VE GONE THROUGH TO GET TO WHERE YOU ARE? [APPLAUSE] WHO GOES FIRST?

40:14THAT'S A TRICKY QUESTION, IT'S FUNNY, IT'S AN INTERVIEW QUESTION I ASK PEOPLE AND I DON'T --

40:22YOU DON'T KNOW YOUR RESPONSE.

40:25PEOPLE IN THE MILITARY HAVE THE BEST FAILURES, THEY CRASH SATELLITES AND TANKS AND THINGS LIKE THAT. I DO NOT HAVE A GOOD ANSWER FOR THAT.

40:40I BLEW UP THREE ROCKETS IN THE BEGINNING. [APPLAUSE] SO THAT WAS, THAT WAS BAD. I ONLY HAD ENOUGH MONEY -- ORIGINALLY, I BASICALLY TOOK ALL THE MONEY I MADE FROM PAYPAL AND PUT IT INTO SPACE X, CREATING SPACE X, TESLA, I FIGURED I'D JUST KEEP HALF OF IT AND SPEND THE OTHER HALF ON THESE CRAZY VENTURES THAT WOULD PROBABLY FAIL AND THEY UNFORTUNATELY NEEDED ALL THE MONEY.

41:14SO I HAD TO GIVE THEM ALL THE MONEY. AND THAT I DIDN'T HAVE A HOUSE OR MONEY FOR RENT, THAT WAS PRETTY DIFFICULT. THAT WAS BACK IN 2008. WE MANAGED TO SCRAPE ENOUGH SPARE PARTS TOGETHER TO A FOURTH LAUNCH AT SPACE X AND THAT WORKED. IF IT HAD NOT WORKED, SPACE X WOULD'VE DIED, PROBABLY WOULD'VE LOCKED THE CREDIBILITY TO RAISE THE REMAINING MONEY FOR TESLA, WE WOULDN'T BE HERE TODAY.

41:43NOT THIS ENDING. [APPLAUSE]

41:51FOR ME IT WOULD HAD TO BE SIMILAR, THE GAMES WE MADE IN THE PERIOD AFTER -- WE MADE A BUNCH OF GAMES THAT DIDN'T LAND AND THE COMPANY WAS GOING TO GO OUT OF BUSINESS. WE GOT A LIFELINE AND -- LET'S DO THIS GAME, THAT'S WHAT WE SHOULD DO AND THAT SAVED THE COMPANY. [APPLAUSE]

42:13ONE MORE QUESTION, LAST QUESTION. YOU WANT TO PICK? ELON, TODD?

42:23EVERYONE UP THERE. I CAN'T SEE THROUGH THE LIGHTS. THE HAND WAY UP THERE, YEAH. YELL OUT YOUR QUESTION.

42:36I WAS DRIVING WEST ON BURBANK BOULEVARD THE DAY YOUR ROCKET LAUNCHED, EVERYBODY PULLED OVER. WHEN IS YOUR NEXT LAUNCH? [INAUDIBLE]

42:58WE LAUNCH ALL THE TIME, WE DO 20-30 LAUNCHES A YEAR, MOST OF THEM ARE FROM CAPE CANAVERAL, SOME OF THEM ARE HERE IN CALIFORNIA. FOR PEOPLE TO REALLY SEE A LAUNCH LIKE THAT SUPER CRAZY VISIBLE, LOOKS LIKE NUCLEAR ALIEN INVASION FROM NORTH KOREA. SOME OF THE YOUTUBE VIDEOS WERE PRETTY FUNNY.

43:29YEAH, 911 LINES WENT BALLISTIC, BURPED ON THE 911 SYSTEM. FOR US, WE KNEW WHAT WAS HAPPENING SO IT WAS LIKE -- THIS LAUNCH. THE NEXT THING IS PROBABLY THE DOG AND HAVING LUNCH AT THE END OF THIS MONTH OUT OF CAPE CANAVERAL, THIS WILL BE THE MOST -- WE ARE PUSHING THE ENVELOPE A LITTLE BIT, SO IT'S MORE SIDE LOAD, HIGHER DYNAMIC

44:06PRESSURE. THE AIR PRESSURE WILL BE HIGHER. THAT WILL BE AN EXCITING LAUNCH TO SEE IF YOU ARE AT THE CAPE.

44:31AMAZING. ALL RIGHT, I THINK WE ARE UNFORTUNATELY OUT OF TIME. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR COMING TO E3 AND BEING A PART OF THIS, THIS IS SO COOL TO HAVE YOU HERE. TODD HOWARD. THANKS, EVERYONE. APPRECIATE IT, GUYS. ♪ ♪

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份