大会演讲·中文精读

2014年挪威油气峰会专访马斯克

Elon Musk Interviewed at Norwegian Oil and Gas Summit - 2014

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

一个造电动车的人,站在挪威石油天然气大会的主讲台上,主持人开场第一个问题就是:你到底来这儿干什么?

马斯克(Elon Musk)的回答很直接:挪威对电动车非常支持,我是来表达感谢的。

台下坐的全是油气行业的人。主持人之前介绍他时,把话说得很满:PayPal 的联合创始人之一,本可以在加勒比海的躺椅上花掉那笔钱,结果他把三份财富投进了三家听起来都不太靠谱的公司。特斯拉(Tesla),做电动车;SolarCity,给全世界阳光充足的地方铺太阳能板;SpaceX,目标是把人送上火星。

这场对话没有演讲稿,全程问答。也正因为没有稿子,马斯克讲出了不少平时不太会主动讲的数字和判断。

挪威能成为特斯拉的大市场,靠的不只是补贴

主持人问他,挪威到底特殊在哪里。毕竟这是特斯拉的第二大市场。

马斯克先纠正了一个细节:中国其实已经排在前面了。然后他给了自己的解释。

挪威政府对电动车有一整套激励政策,这当然是基础。可同样是高补贴,丹麦的电动车销量就远不如挪威。马斯克认为差别在别的地方:挪威有一群电动车的死忠,他们自发地去推广,做得非常出色,效果直接体现在销量上。

他举了一个具体的人。挪威北部的纳尔维克(Narvik),在北极圈以北,有位车主一个人拥有的特斯拉比全世界任何一位客户都多。

我不知道现在是12辆还是14辆了。他人非常好。(马斯克)

这个细节值得多想一层。政策能降低购买门槛,但决定一个新技术能不能在一个市场扎根的,往往是早期那批愿意替它说话的普通用户。补贴可以被别的国家照抄,这批人抄不走。

Model 3 要等三年,卡点是一座电池工厂

现场有人问:你们的下一款大众市场车型什么时候能出来?现在这款太贵了。

当时 Model S 在美国的售价大约是7万美元,按马斯克自己的定义,这是一款高端车。2015年要推出的是 SUV 版本 Model X,但它和 Model S 共用平台,成本差不多,谈不上便宜。

真正被寄予厚望的是 Model 3。

这是一款我一开始就想做的车,但要先把技术迭代到位,需要一点时间。(马斯克)

时间表是两年到三年,而且有一个前置条件:超级电池工厂(Gigafactory)必须建成。

为什么电池厂会卡住一款车的上市?马斯克的逻辑很简单。要造大量的电动车,就需要大量的电池。而当时全世界的电池产能根本不够,也没人生产长续航电动车真正需要的那种电池。

既然市场上没有,就只能自己建。这座工厂的命名来自它的目标产能:500亿瓦时。

放在2014年,这个数字大得不寻常。马斯克说得很直白,对电池储能这个领域,这是非常大的规模。

更关键的是产能分配。工厂大约三分之一的产出,规划给固定式储能,主要用来和可再生能源配套。剩下的部分里,还有一块用途常被忽略:给电网做缓冲。

这一点他解释得很清楚。哪怕是烧碳氢化合物的电厂,你也可以让它稳定运行在最佳工况上,不用为了应付用电高峰反复调节负荷。储能在这里起到的是削峰填谷的作用,让整个系统的效率更高。

这段信息其实比"电动车什么时候降价"更重要。马斯克在2014年就把电池厂定义成了能源基础设施,顺带才是汽车零部件供应商。

一个核电站,和它围墙里的太阳能板

主持人问电池技术和可再生能源有没有关联,马斯克的回答是绝对有,然后给了一组算术。

太阳照到地球上的能量,是人类总用量的很多倍。只要配上足够的电池容量,太阳能可以供全世界用很多次,这句话在物理上成立。

他给了一个让人一下就能记住的对比。

核电站周围通常有一大片禁区,半径大概五公里左右,因为没人愿意在核电站旁边盖密集的住宅和写字楼。如果把太阳能板铺在这片禁区里,同样的土地面积,太阳能板的发电量通常会超过核电站本身。

他的计算过程是这样的:一平方公里等于一百万平方米,太阳能的功率密度大约每平方米1千瓦,所以一平方公里接收到的太阳能就是1吉瓦。核电站的装机容量没法和这个数字比。

顺着这个思路,他给了一个更大的数:给整个美国供电,大约需要150到200平方公里的太阳能板。

相当于犹他州的一个角落。那地方没什么产业,我去了,连个广播电台都没有。(马斯克)

这话听起来像玩笑,但它指出的是能源讨论里一个常被忽略的量级问题。人们直觉上觉得可再生能源占地太大,实际上被太阳照亮的土地接收到的能量,比我们想象的密集得多。真正的瓶颈落在转换效率、储能和输电上,地皮本身够用。

油气行业头上的威胁,来自资源本身

主持人问得直接:特斯拉加太阳能,对油气行业到底构成多大的威胁?

马斯克的回答先给了个台阶:目前算不上什么威胁,还早。

然后他补了半句:更明显的威胁是,碳氢化合物总有一天会被挖完、烧完。

当天上午,会场里的人还在说储量充足。马斯克不绕弯子,把争论的焦点落回时间上:什么时候用完,什么时候变得贵到用不起。开采难度在上升,成本已经涨了两到三倍,有些地方甚至更多。

主持人换了角度反驳:你是搞技术的,你是物理学家、工程师,技术一直在突破边界,页岩气革命就是例子,那些资源以前被认为根本采不出来。技术进步不会让化石燃料继续保持充裕吗?

马斯克的回应同样干脆。

延长赛肯定会有,但比赛总会结束。可再生这个词本身就是同义反复,不可再生的东西,就是不可再生。

他给了一个比喻:你被困在一个氧气正在慢慢耗尽的房间里,门外就是充足的空气。你想不想早点出去?早点出去的人处境更好。

主持人接着问了一个更尖锐的问题:那你的火星计划呢?火箭不是也要烧碳氢化合物吗?这里面是不是有矛盾?

马斯克说自己对碳氢化合物没有根本性的反感。他只是看未来,问一件事:什么才是真正可行的。用不可再生的资源,显然不可行,所以必须找到替代方案。

然后他给了一个重要的限定。

如果现在有一个按钮,按下去就能让全世界立刻停止使用碳氢化合物,我不会按。因为那会让文明停摆,医院也没法运转,这是不负责任的做法。(马斯克)

这句话值得单独拎出来。它划清了两种立场的界限:一种是立刻切断,一种是有序加速转型。马斯克站在后者,他想要的是让转型来得更快一些。

至于时间尺度,他给了一个判断:不用等到遥远的未来,本世纪末,人们回头看汽油车,会像今天看煤一样,觉得那是一种古老的、该放进博物馆的东西。

他还点了沙特阿美的名字。沙特有极其丰富的阳光,这份资源能持续几十亿年。

至少还有10亿年,直到太阳把地球吞掉。10亿年是个很扎实的数字。(马斯克)

专利是彩票,中奖是一次官司

主持人做了点功课,把一个跨行业的问题抛了出来:不久前特斯拉把专利开放了,这背后的考虑是什么?油气行业在做碳捕集封存这类高难度新项目时,是不是也该考虑联合起来,把专利放掉?

马斯克说他不喜欢专利。

刚创业的时候他申请了一大堆,觉得这是好事。后来发现,专利更像是一张买来的彩票,中奖的奖品是一场官司。

他举了苹果和三星的诉讼战。那场仗谁赢了?律师赢了,两家公司都没赢。

回到特斯拉,他的推演只有两步。如果别的车企用我们的专利造电动车,我们会起诉他们、逼他们停产吗?不会。既然不会,为什么要假装会?

主持人追问:那你们不只把它当作内部默认立场,而是直接公开告诉全世界,随便用?马斯克说是的,这是又往前走了一步。主持人接着问,这么做是不是有什么商业上的好处?

马斯克的回答出人意料地诚实。

我真的不知道。如果有什么好处,你告诉我,我洗耳恭听。也许它最后会带来好处,我不确定。(马斯克)

主持人帮他找理由:市场做大了,充电桩变多,大家都受益,水涨船高。

马斯克承认这个说法有道理,特斯拉确实希望整个行业做大。开放专利也许会积攒一些善意,善意什么时候能派上用场,谁也说不准。

这里有个反常识的地方。他并没有一套精巧的战略推演,他知道自己在赌,也承认不知道结果。一家公司愿意在核心资产上做这种事,前提是它认定真正的护城河是执行速度和迭代能力,专利文件算不上。专利保护的是已有设计,特斯拉赌的是自己跑得比别人快。

火星票价的临界点:50万美元

现场有个37岁的挪威人,收入中等偏上,正在攒钱去火星。他想知道要攒多久。

马斯克的回答从一个经济学概念开始:临界票价。

关键问题是,票价要低到什么程度,火星上才可能出现一个能自我维持的殖民地。他猜这个数字在50万美元左右。当然他希望更低。

顺带还提了一点:票里应该包含返程票。万一去了不喜欢,可以回来,不至于被困在那儿。

50万美元是什么概念?在美国很多地方,这是一套中产住宅的价格。也就是说,想去火星,大概要拿一套房子去换。

时间表同样给得很具体。第一批人上火星,他希望是12年左右。要把成本压到50万美元这个量级,大概还要再翻一倍时间,也就是25年左右。

12年这个数字后来被人反复引用。需要留意的是它的条件:这个数字建立在当时技术演进速度的估算上,算不上一张已经排好的工程进度表,也从来没有变成过承诺。

火箭卖到波音四分之一的价钱,靠什么

SpaceX 已经多次给国际空间站送货,核心卖点是把发射成本砍下来。砍到什么程度?

马斯克给了对比:大约是波音(Boeing)和洛克希德(Lockheed)的三分之一到四分之一,这两家是美国本土的竞争对手。相比俄罗斯和中国,大概便宜了40%。

主持人敏锐地抓住了矛盾:这些火箭是在洛杉矶县从头造出来的,加州的人工成本全美最高,那成本优势从哪来?

这就引出了马斯克关于创新的最实质的一段论述。

第一个机制是空间上的。SpaceX 把工程团队和生产团队放在同一个厂区里,双方沟通是双向的、即时的。工程师设计的零件不好制造,他们能立刻知道,然后马上改设计。这个反馈闭环越短,浪费越少。

第二个机制是节奏。新版本火箭的迭代速度比传统承包商快得多。

第三个机制容易被忽略:制度设计。

主持人把话挑明了,大意是,光讲创新没用,你得在公司里建立起对创新的预期,薪酬结构必须反映这一点,等于用钱去激励创新和降本。

马斯克同意,并且补了后半句,这半句的分量更重。

必须为失败留出空间。如果你尝试新东西,它总有一定概率不成功。如果你对失败的惩罚过重,人们的反应是可预期的,你得到的创新会变得非常保守、非常渐进。没人敢做大胆的尝试,因为怕被开除。(马斯克)

风险和回报必须平衡,并且要偏向于鼓励大胆的动作,否则大胆的动作根本不会发生。

这段话解释了为什么一家在加州造火箭的公司能做到对手四分之一的成本。工资单解释不了这件事,答案落在一套组织机制上:让人敢改设计、敢试错,并且知道试错不会被惩罚。反过来看,如果一家公司嘴上说要创新,考核上却在惩罚任何一次失败,那它得到的必然是渐进式的改良。

如果我是油气公司的 CEO

主持人最后问了一个假设题:如果你是一家大型油气公司的 CEO,你会做什么改变?

马斯克的回答只有一句话:大举投资可再生能源。

他补了两个细节。

第一,已经有人这么做了。道达尔(Total)对 SunPower 做了一笔巨额投资,他认为这笔投资未来会带来可观的回报。

第二句话更直接:要认真对待,别把 C 队或者 D 队派上去,要派 A 队。

这背后的判断很清楚。传统能源公司进入新能源,最常见的失败方式,钱投了,事情却当副业来做,派二线团队去试水,结果自然试不出东西。资源配置的诚意,体现在派谁去。

他还给了挪威一个建议。挪威有大量水电,也有风能和地热潜力,把这些可再生能源扩大,向欧洲其他地区输出电力,是一个明智的方向。

这个建议和电动车直接相关。马斯克说得很清楚:电动车要真正干净,前提是电本身干净。如果电还是烧煤发出来的,电动车的环保账最终算不过来。

这句话在2014年说出来,很多人当宣传听。放到今天看,它其实是整个电动车行业最硬的一条约束条件,也是各国电网改造的真实压力来源。

火箭为什么不能电动

现场从推特(Twitter)来了一个问题,问 SpaceX 和油气行业在太空探索上有什么合作空间,比如小行星采矿,或者在火星上钻井。

马斯克的回答先纠正了一个直觉。

火箭烧碳氢化合物,或者烧氢,但最有可能的火星方案是甲烷加氧气。甲烷是地球上成本最低的燃料之一。

至于为什么不把火箭做成电动的,答案很物理:火箭在真空里没有空气、没有地面、没有水可以反作用,它必须自己带东西烧,才能获得推力。

到了火星,会有一部分钻探活动,主要是找地下水。如果火星地核加热的地下水能以液态存在,制造推进剂会容易得多。

真正要紧的,是能不能在火星上就地生产燃料。火星有二氧化碳大气,表面有大量冰冻的水,这两样加起来就能合成甲烷和氧气。马斯克把这件事定义成了火星殖民的硬性前提:燃料工厂的效率,直接决定殖民地能不能活下来。

这也是整场对话里少数几个把"太空"和"油气"真正接上的地方。钻井技术、化工合成、地质勘探,这些能力在火星上全部用得上。

给一个14岁孩子的答案

最后一个问题来自主持人的儿子,14岁,想知道大学该学什么,才能成为未来的汽车工程师。

马斯克的回答是物理。

理由是物理提供了一套最好的思考框架,尤其是在发现反直觉的结论上。然后再学一点工程。

主持人追问:那是不是就不要碰人文学科了?马斯克说不是,历史很重要,所有人都应该学一点历史。

主持人笑着说,他儿子就一个人,只能给一个答案。马斯克坚持:物理是最佳选择。

这段对话很短,但它和前面讲成本、讲创新、讲火星的部分是同一套逻辑。物理训练的核心是从基本原理往前推,而不是从现有做法往后修补。他把这套方法用在了火箭成本上,用在了电池产能上,也用在了判断碳氢化合物什么时候会用完上。

这场对话真正给出的东西

四十分钟的问答,信息量集中在这几处:一座500亿瓦时的电池厂,一个把核电站禁区铺满太阳能板的对比,一个50万美元的火星票价临界点,一条为失败留出空间的薪酬原则,以及一句"如果有个按钮能停掉所有化石燃料,我不会按"。

把这几件事放在一起看,会发现一条共同的方法线:先算终局,再倒推现在该做什么。碳氢化合物不可再生,所以终局是必须换掉;电池产能不够,所以终局是自己建厂;火星票价要降到中产房子的水平,所以终局是25年;发射成本要做到对手的四分之一,所以终局是把工程和生产放进同一栋楼,并且允许失败。

2014年说这些话的人不多。当时特斯拉年销几万辆,SpaceX 还在为商业载人努力,超级电池工厂刚动工。三年后 Model 3 开始交付,那座工厂成了全球最大的电池产能之一。

至于那些数字和判断,有多少兑现,有多少被低估或者高估,读的人自己会算。

如果要把这场对话里能直接拿来用的东西列出来,大概是这些:

  • 评估一个行业的前景,先问它依赖的资源是不是可再生的,再问开采成本最近十年是涨了还是跌了。成本和储量两个数一起看,比任何预测都可靠。
  • 做长期项目规划时,先算出一个临界值,比如"成本降到多少,这件事才能自己转起来",再倒推时间表。50万美元这个数字本身不重要,重要的是它给所有中间目标提供了一个锚点。
  • 把专利当成一项成本来算,而不是资产。问自己一个问题:如果竞争对手用了我的技术,我真的会起诉吗?如果答案是不会,这项专利在账上就应该是负的。
  • 检查你的考核制度到底在奖励什么。如果失败会被重罚,你得到的创新一定是渐进式的,哪怕口号喊得再响。想让人做大胆的尝试,薪酬结构里必须写进对失败的容忍额度。
  • 要推一件新业务,看派了谁去。派 C 队去做的业务,等于宣布这件事不重要。
  • 做技术转型时,先看配套的上游。电动车要真正干净,前提是电网干净;一项技术要真正普及,卡点往往落在它依赖的那一环,而非它本身。
  • 如果一个行业在靠"还能找到更多"来回应资源枯竭的质疑,去查一下开采成本曲线。延长赛和改变比赛是两回事。
  • 学一门能让你从基本原理往前推的学科,物理是其中最典型的一个,但别只读它,历史也得读。前者给你算力,后者给你判断力。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00good morning so far thank you for your questions and I want a whole lot more because our next speaker has decided that he doesn't want to give a presentation at all he would like to just answer your questions and perhaps a few pesky journalistic ones from me can we have chairs brought up yes so that we can sit comfortably for the next half hour sir who is our next speaker or we've been dropping tantalizing hints haven't we he's a Titan of Technology I understand he's something of a rock star here in Norway because yes I think so because he

0:35has plowed in his initial fortunes from the sale of for instance PayPal did you know this this gentleman was behind PayPal one of the co-founders and instead of retiring to a comfortable lounger in the Caribbean and spending money on wonderful yachts or perhaps he does that too he's also spent three fortunes in three audacious businesses Tesla needs no introduction to you space city app Tory Solar City is trying to

1:07put solar panels around the world or at any rate in all the hot and sunny parts of the world and then we have SpaceX which has the truly jaw-dropping mission of one day transporting us all to Mars how is this man real well we're going to find out for ourselves his initials are e M please do send in your questions thick and fast a big warm welcome to Elon Musk

1:43make yourself comfortable Ilan oh my gosh we've got so many questions here already where do we start shall we start with Tesla should we do a bunch of Tesla questions is that good audience well I thought it's thorough for the song well now maybe I'll ask you this question rather than Tesla I'm gonna ask you this question which is from me not the audience what exactly are you doing here you know this is an oil and gas conference why why are you here well Norway has been very supportive of electric vehicles and so I'm here in gratitude and appreciation for what no he's done for electric vehicles okay so it's thank you to Norway I think exactly so what is it

2:29about Norway then it's your second biggest market I understood actually someone knows snuck in there China all right there's some Democrats yeah so what is it about Norway is it the government support putting in all our stations what is it I think it's a number of factors certainly and Norway has a lot of incentives for electric vehicles which are great but it's worth noting that say Denmark also has very strong incentives for electric vehicles but I sales a much greater in no way than in Denmark and I think in Norway there's a core group of electric vehicle enthusiasts who have really taken it upon themselves to promote electric vehicles and have done an amazing job

3:15and and as a result that that has made Tesla sales in Norway really really great I mean there's one gentleman yeah who owns more no more EVs than any kind of your customers around the world yeah that's right no way yes yes he's in Norvik Narvik yeah how many does he owe do you remember that's above the protest above the Arctic Circle by the way and he Oblivion's I don't know 12 or maybe 14 now so his name Sanskrit Homa and he he's

3:52very nice guy very nice person so we have a we have a question here from the audience which is when is your next mass-market car going to be ready because your current one is a roughly but in price well our current one is in in US dollars it's about seventy thousand dollars so it is a premium car and then we're we're coming out with an SUV version called the X that's coming

4:21out next year but also that's on the same platform so it's about the same cost the the car that we we're really looking forward to bringing to market is called the the model 3 and that's intended to be a mass-market long range electric vehicle it's the car that I wanted to bring out from the very beginning but it just takes a bit of time to iterate the technology and computer how long because I think the launch date has been pushed back and back a bit well it's we're hoping for about two two and a half to three years contingent upon that is completion of this very big battery factory called the Giga factory that we're building so tell us about that sure so the in order to

5:01make a lot of electric cars you need a lot of batteries and that the the I'm looking my own battery capacity of the world I thought in terms of production capacity is really not big enough yet nor does that make the most advanced type of batteries that that we really need for long range electric cars so in order to solve that problem we that have found there was really no choice but to build a really enormous factory called the Giga factory so named because we're targeting about 50 gigawatt hours of output which for battery energy storage is quite a big huge yeah and it sounds cool as well yeah so are there any links

5:44do you think between the battery technology that you're investing in at the moment and renewables I mean would there be yes absolutely the stuff that you're developing is not just for cars and in fact it more about that sure so about a third of the out of the gigafactory is intended as stationary storage primarily to be paired with renewables but also to do grid buffering in non renewable situations so you can operate the plants even if it's a hydrocarbon energy plant you can operate it close to its optimum and avoid having to sort of peak the yeah so I think we'll see really a very huge demand for Sage stationary storage and this this is really going to help

6:30out some of the more intimate and sources like wind and solar and you know it's worth noting I'm not sure if people are aware of this but the world could be powered many times over by solar if you had enough battery capacity to pair with it many times like the world I mean California where you're based but in Europe time you're a thousand it's literally true the amount of energy that reaches the Earth from the Sun is staggeringly high we have this enormous fusion generator in the sky that that is logging out vast amounts of energy and I'm talking about just using land area I mean it's it's really amazing in fact here's a little tidbit if you take a

7:17nuclear plant and you took its current output and compared that to just taking solar panels and putting solar panels on the land on the area used by the nuclear power plant because these typically have a big keep out zone you know about maybe five kilometers or thereabouts where building houses you know and dense you know any kind of dense office or a housing space usually people don't want to do that near a nuclear power plant so

7:47that there's this quite a bit keep out zone and when you factor the keep out zone into into account the solar panels put on that area will typically generate more power than the nuclear power plant yes and that's not competition just done by you I know you can just very easy to do it so here's my tomato just do just a tidbit

8:13of math the collective max mental so one square kilometer is a million square meters and there's one kilowatt per square meter of solar energy so on one square kilometer there is a gigawatt of solar energy so I mean if you wanted I mean you can get the nuclear power station doesn't give you the same as that the calculation yeah but like you

8:55could power the entire United States with about let's say 150 to 200 square kilometres of solar panels which are United States take a corner of Utah not much going on there I've been there there's not even radio stations okay so the question from the audience then is seeing that you're your big thrust into Tesla cars which has taken off ten years in your big ambitions for solar power what kind of a threat do you think you are to the oil and gas industry well I don't think we're a bunch of a threat I mean yet you know yet but I mean the the more obvious threat

9:41is that we're gonna run out of hydrocarbons to mine and burn that that's rather obvious I mean it's not no time soon judging from the comments we've had this morning what means what soon means I mean there's it's clearly getting harder and harder my ascending is that the cost of extraction is is doubled true and in some cases tripled so it's it's getting harder and harder to find hydrocarbons and it's getting much more expensive to extract them and really we're just arguing about the when hydrocarbons run out or become prohibitively expensive not if I mean because there's anyone here who would say there's it's an if not a win they will run out for sure

10:28so that you don't think I mean you are you know a tech guy right you're a physicist and an engineer you call yourself the chief architect of yeah ingenuity and technology and resourceful nurse will mean that we will still have abundant fossil fuels no available I mean this has been going on they think you've reached the boundaries and yet they find more and you know look at the whole shale gas revolution that was stuff that people said would never be able to be extracted that there are there are x time extensions on the game but the game is going to come to an end that should be absolutely certain obviously frankly I mean the I mean to

11:13be and non-renewables and it's tautological either renewable it's not renewable so if you're not in non-renewables it's like me you're stuck in a room where the oxygen is gradually depleting and then outside it's not so you want to get out that room and I think the ones that get out of the room sooner will be better off if you is that

11:38where the mission to Mars comes in no ironically the rockets will use hydrocarbons quite a bit isn't there an inherent contradiction here no presence I'm I don't have any I don't have any fundamental dislike of hydrocarbons I simply look at the future and say what is the thing that will actually work it and using a non-renewable resource obviously will not work so we must find an alternative but if I if there was a button I could press to stop all hydrocarbon usage today I would not press it you would not press it course not okay did you expect him to say that you would not be recorded civilization to come to a halt every hospital would have to be

12:24ridiculous so there would be irresponsible to press that button but what does need to happen is to if we can accelerate the transition towards renewables it's the sensible thing to do and you know if you take a say I mean used maybe two examples Saudi Arabia since the Saudi Aramco president spoke here the set Arabia has an enormous amount of sunlight and that that that will be there for billions of years well at least 1 billion years until eventually engulfs us but a billion is solid bit more maths fair got a soft

13:04solid billion years there so it seems that you know in investing in the the solar resource is the thing that that's really going to preserve the the long-term future not not so much the oil and gas I mean that's that's a temporary thing in the future will look back and buy future I'm not talking about super far in the future I'm talking about towards the end of the century we will look back on gasoline-powered cars the same way look we look back on coal as sort of a quaint anachronism that's in a museum that's the quote for you members of the press at the back of the hall but it's true I think there are some business models that we could perhaps all learn

13:44from and I've been trying to do some boning up thinking what is it that Elon is doing in his Tesla cars for instance and his Solar City ventures which seems so very different from the oil and gas sector but which perhaps there is some commonality some points of learning and the thing that I want to ask you about is patents patents as you call them now a few months ago you decided to open them up make them open source some key areas of Tesla Cardinal oh all of them okay what is the thinking behind them and it's that's something that pops the oil and gas industry should consider when developing things like say carbon storage and things like that very very

14:24difficult new project should they get together and just junk the patterns yeah I think patents or I don't like patents personally you know when I was first starting out developing technology I got lots of patents and thought this was a good thing and then I sort of discovered that a patent was really like buying a lottery ticket to a lawsuit looks like I'd rather not by asthma those tickets and you look at sort of the battle between Apple and Samsung and me who's really winning there you know the lawyers are winning certainly but not but neither of those two companies and in in the case of of Tesla I thought

15:04well would Tesla ever sue some other car company if they were using our patents to try to make them stop making electric cars we would never do such a thing so why why pretend that we would but and you're not just saying recognising that internally as a de facto position you're saying to the world here have them go for it yeah yes which is a different thing that's going one stage further yeah yes and that's not just because you think we're never gonna sue them it's presumably because you think there is some business advantage to it no I really don't know I mean if there is let

15:42me know what it is I'm not sure you know I'm all ears maybe it will somehow turn out to be good I don't know you boost the market there's more charging stations you know everybody benefits rising tide lifts all the boat it's that argument there is every nice I mean we're really trying to get relevant vanish but maybe it can help lift the industry as a whole and I think yeah generated some goodwill and I think maybe that goodwill is helpful you never know where that pays off okay so there's an idea for all of you here at ons you know think about patterns do we have to be quite so possessive about them so it's a kind of secretive it's an idea yeah I want to throw

16:21another thing at you we haven't really spoken about space or exploration very much yet and we have a question from a young man called let me see if I've got his name right go to mugs and I hope I've pronounced his name right he's 37 years old and he's saving up to go to Mars okay yes and he says he isn't he's on average earnings and which is probably quite high here in Norway and he says how long is it going to take him before he'll be able to make this mission a reality well I think the the critical threshold is what's the cost of moving to Mars what's the ticket of moving to Mars and I which what's the threshold ticket price below which a self-sustaining Martian

17:06colony would be established and I suspect that is somewhere on the half-a-million dollar level you know so obviously we'd like to have it be lower but III do see a path to being able to offer tickets for someone to move to Mars or also they get a free return ticket they don't like it so it's so

17:27trapped there and I think if we can get that threshold back below half a million dollars you know which is the price of a sort middle-class home in many parts of the US then you have to trade in your home yeah what are you moving tomorrow certification and what's the time span on this two three four decades yeah I think I think we should be able to hopefully send the first people to Mars in about 12 years and then it's going to view what that forward from your previous no is it always been okay 12 years Wow roughly and and then probably double

18:08that to get again to get to where the cost is reduced to the half-million dollar levels there's probably 25 years this obviously technological advantage advances and cost-effectiveness are you've already been able to put a number of vehicles into space supplying the supplying the International Space Station with cargo and your main bid was bringing down costs dramatically yes slashing costs by what a factor of what is compared to we're about we're about a third to a quarter the price of Boeing and Lockheed which are our domestic quarter competitors in the US and probably I don't know sixty percent

18:55of the price of the Russians or the Chinese California not exactly a low-cost Rockets manufactured from scratch in LA in Los Angeles County so necessarily is this cannot be a function of labor cost because the labor cost is very high so facing an audience of people who are grappling with costs we heard Karl Adele Fowler talking about how cost of exploration is doubled in the last decade we've been it's something that's bubbling along here what advice can you give them how does one go about really reducing the costs of a venture well you have to innovate you have to do different things and it has to be a tight feedback loop on innovation and one of the things I think that

19:38advantageous the way the SpaceX operates is that the engineering team and the production team are in the same facility and there is good communication back and forth so as the engineers see that they've designed something that is difficult to manufacture they can adjust their design quickly to make it easier to vote and and at the pace at which we're able to do new versions of the rocket is also much faster so innovation just improving things is is key you know that's that's actually it sounds lovely and everyone talks a lot about innovation there's been a take away from that has been expected stablish an expectation of innovation and the compensation structure must reflect that

20:20AHA so yeah you're basically incentivizing innovation and cost reduction you have to insert it yes you have to do the Henry Ford thing which is every year you just expect the price to come to happen and of course to come to Hanna that's just something I kind of directive from above no it's so there

20:40needs to be an expectation of an innovation like the compensation structure must reflect that there must also be an allowance for failure because if you are trying something new necessarily that there's some chance it will not work so if if you punish people too much for failure then they will respond accordingly and the innovation you will get will be very incrementalist nobody's going to try anything bold for fear of getting fired or being you know punished in some way so that there must be a real that the risk reward must be balanced and and in favor taking bold

21:18moves otherwise it will not happen it's your door open to members of the oil and gas industry to come and see what you've done to really sure sort of out of SpaceX yeah I mean there's some limitations of SpaceX because it's considered an advanced weapons technology but the but within within the

21:42route balance of what the US government will let us do more than happy to show people around but I I forgot I was gonna give two about it two examples one was Saudi Arabia and another knows was no way because team said that's appropriate for given the venue they in Norway has tremendous natural resources in terms of hydropower also I think wind and potentially geothermal and I really don't think there's a huge opportunity that to expand those those renewable sources and provide that power to the rest of Europe so I think I mean that that really I think would be a wise thing to do and you need it really don't you because we need to clear clean up

22:25power generation yeah evie cars to be truly clean right if they're still being powered from coal-fired power stations then you're evey product is not ultimately that clean is it yeah no way of course or it already has a lot of hydropower but I would but I think expanding expanding upon that would be would be wise going back to SpaceX we have a question here from Christian Ronan who sent it in on Twitter what collaboration do you see between SpaceX and the current oil industry in space exploration for instance asteroid mining that's really drilling on Mars there are commonalities

23:04yeah well the as I said loot earlier but I mean rockets do do burn hydrocarbons or if they convert just hydrogen as well but the the most likely Mars architecture that I think makes sense is a methane oxygen system methane is the lowest cost sauce fuel on earth and with rockets you can't really make a rocket electric because it's got react against something once it gets to vacuum there's no air or land or water to react against so you have to you have to burn something really so the I think a methane methane based system is gonna be what makes the most sense once you get to Mars I think there will be some drilling activity particularly if it to

23:58find out if we can get to underground Lakes like if it to find liquid water but you know water that sort of heated by the Mars central core that would make it a lot easier to build to develop propellants online so it was critical to any any Mars colonization is the ability to generate fuel on Mars you need generate methane on Mars which you can do because Mars has a co2 atmosphere and there is a lot of frozen h2o around so you got your ch4 gyro - and and having

24:41that propellant plant on Mars be efficient is critical to a Mars colony so perhaps collaborations ahead I've got one last question which I'm gonna sneak and brief me and that is what changes would you make if you were the CEO of an oil and gas major I would I would invest heavily in renewables no that may sound like an obvious thing to do and and there are some companies that are doing it at total made a huge

25:10investment in Sun power and I think that that investment will pay big dividends in the future but I think it's important to look at renewables and take it really seriously you know just don't don't just put like the the C or D team on it put put the a-team on it are you listening a team yeah I want to ask you a personal question actually it's from my son he's 14 and his question to you is what should he study in university to become a car engineer of the future should he do physics like you like those like physics and engineering are I mean if physics provides a good framework for thinking it has the best framework for thinking I believe particularly for discovering things that

25:57are counterintuitive and but then I think also studying a little bit of engineering and also evident completely neglect the humanities well I think history history is important I think history is something everybody should study for one I think there's only one boy one boy my son one of him yes

26:21physics for you to go for one answer yes he's 14 he wants us it's probably the best choice is physics okay yeah pretty fast a physicist shouldn't just read physics no there's other things too you know must have been such a pleasure having you yeah I swore wide-ranging view of the world

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份