2013 年秋天,三辆特斯拉 Model S 在几周内先后起火,没有一个人受伤。同一时期,美国记录在案的汽油车火灾大约 25 万起,造成约 400 人死亡、约 1200 人重伤。
前者上了全球头条,后者没上。
马斯克在 CNN 的采访里被问到这件事,用了一个很重的比喻。
我像是被人拿枪托砸了一顿。(马斯克)
这场采访放在 SpaceX 工厂的阳台上,脚下是正在为周一发射做准备的车间,工人来回穿梭。扎卡利亚(Fareed Zakaria)和他聊了很久,从火星聊到电池,从阿波罗聊到空客和波音,中间还聊了那个当时没几个人相信的管道列车。
十多年过去,这段对话里的很多判断可以拿出来对照了。
他去 NASA 网站查"什么时候去火星",什么也没找到
故事的起点在 PayPal 卖掉之后。马斯克手里有钱,有时间,需要决定下一件事做什么。
他一直对太空感兴趣,但他当时的判断是:这件事跟个人无关。发射火箭、把人送出地球轨道,那是大国的领地,需要国家意志、国家预算、国家实验室。一个从南非来的创业者,能在这件事上做什么?
他没有直接下结论,而是去查了资料。他打开 NASA 的网站,想找到人类去火星的时间表。按照当时的常识,登月之后下一步就该是火星,路线图上写得明明白白。
他什么也没找到。
我当时的印象是,我们失去了做这件事的意愿。后来我意识到这个判断错得很离谱。我认为美国尤其是一个由探险者构成的国家。(马斯克)
这个细节值得停一下。他最初的解释落在心理层面:意志衰退,雄心消退。后来他把解释换到了结构层面:意愿还在,只是没有一条可行的路径。一个国家的航天体系里,如果没有哪个环节在认真计算"怎么把成本降下来",那么"什么时候去火星"这个问题就永远不会有答案,不管多少人心里想去。
这也解释了他为什么从运输切入。火箭、飞船、发射场,这些看着最不性感的部分,恰好是卡住整条路的那一段。
到火星这件事,卡住的是运输
扎卡利亚问了一个很自然的问题:你为什么认为运输最重要?在火星上怎么活、怎么种地、怎么造氧气,这些不才是难点吗?
马斯克的回答把问题倒了过来。
在火星上生活是相对容易的部分。现在根本到不了火星,所以到了之后干什么其实无所谓。第一件事是想清楚怎么过去,而且必须是能运送大量人口和货物过去的方式。(马斯克)
他补了一句关键的限定:不能只是几个人。
几个人建立一个科考站,可以。建立一个能自我维持的文明,不行。人数太少,基因多样性不够,工业链条不完整,任何一次设备故障都可能是终局。所以运输系统的设计目标从一开始就是量,只问"一次能送多少"。
他用阿波罗做了对照。阿波罗是人类历史上最激励人心的事业之一,这一点他明确承认。但最后一次登月是 1973 年或者 1974 年,此后五十年,再没有人回去过。
我们不想要只有旗帜和脚印,然后再也不去火星。(马斯克)
这句话里有一个判断:一次性任务的激励效果会衰减。1969 年全世界盯着电视看的那一代人,他们的孩子对登月已经没什么感觉,因为那是一件"发生过的事",不再"正在发生"。要真正改变人类未来的走向,得让这件事持续下去,而持续的前提是成本降到能反复支付的水平。
6000 万美元的火箭,20 万美元的燃料
车间里那枚叫 Grasshopper 的火箭,是这段话的技术注脚。普通火箭是一次性的,点火、上天、坠落、沉海底。Grasshopper 试的是另一条路:垂直起飞,悬停,然后自己降落回来,像一支铅笔立在桌上。
为什么非要做可重复使用?马斯克给了一组数字。
猎鹰 9 号(Falcon 9)的造价大约 6000 万美元,而推进剂的成本只有大约 20 万美元。(马斯克)
比例是 300 比 1。
他接着打了个比方:如果每次飞行都要买一架新飞机,能坐得起飞机的人会少得可怜。给一架飞机加满油很便宜,所以航空才能成为大众交通。
这个类比看着简单,实际指向一个常被忽略的思维习惯:看一个行业的成本结构,先分清哪些部分是一次性投入(可以摊薄),哪些部分是每次都要重付(无法摊薄)。火箭的问题在于,那个本该被摊薄的东西,被设计成了每次都要重付。一枚 6000 万美元的运载器,用完就扔,等于每一趟航班都烧掉一架 747。
这里还有一个延伸出来的判断:进入太空的门槛由会计学决定,物理学早就让路了。化学能提供的能量密度几十年前就够用,缺的是把硬件从消耗品变成耐用品的工程能力。而这件事在过去几十年里没人真正去攻,因为客户是国家,国家不按商业逻辑算账。
747 之后,民航再没快过
扎卡利亚提了一个自己也想不通的问题:过去三四十年,芯片、通信、医疗全都在突飞猛进,唯一没有明显进步的领域是民航。纽约到伦敦的飞行时间,和四五十年前一样,甚至更长。
马斯克同意,而且更具体。
确实更长了。我最喜欢的客机是 747,因为它飞得相当快。第一版 747 是 60 年代设计的,从那以后我不认为我们超越过它,这太荒唐了。(马斯克)
然后他给出了解释,这个解释跟技术无关。
商用飞机领域基本是空客和波音的双寡头。这类大飞机项目周期特别长,投入特别大。如果你在这两家公司的高层,瞄准一点点渐进改良,比瞄准激进改良要安全得多。因为一般来说,你瞄准激进改良,一旦赌错了,你会被解雇。(马斯克)
这段话值得反复看。它跟工程师是否变懒、技术是否停滞都无关,它指向决策者的风险收益结构发生了变化。
在成熟的双寡头市场里,份额稳定,监管成本高企,一款新机型从立项到交付要十年。这个时间尺度下,激进方案的失败概率被放大,失败的代价由个人承担,成功的收益由股东分享。理性选择就是小步改良,一轮一轮往下走。每一家企业都做了对自己最优的选择,整个行业因此停在原地。
把这段和 SpaceX 放在一起看,逻辑就完整了。马斯克为什么能做出可重复使用火箭?一部分原因是技术,另一部分原因是他是老板。赌错了他不会被解雇,公司会死。风险和收益在同一个决策者身上重合,激进方案才有机会被选中。
扎卡利亚顺势问:那 SpaceX 为什么不造世界上最快的喷气机?
马斯克的回答只有一句:我们得专注在火箭上。
十二年后,第一个上火星的人
扎卡利亚问他,什么时候能真正把人送到火星。
大概十二年后能送出第一个人。(马斯克)
从 2013 年往后数十二年,是 2025 年。
扎卡利亚追问:那个人会是你吗?
这个问题的回答,是整场采访里最不像企业家标准答案的一段。
只有在我确信,即使我死了,SpaceX 也能继续走下去的情况下,我才会去。如果我对任务能在我不在的情况下继续推进有信心,那我就去。(马斯克)
他没有说"当然,那是我的梦想",也没有说"不,我要留在公司"。他给了一个条件句,而这个条件句本身就是一个组织设计问题:一家高度依赖创始人的公司,能不能在创始人缺席时继续运转。这个问题他在 2008 年差点用现实回答过一次,SpaceX 和特斯拉同时濒临破产,他两边分钱。
顺便说,2013 年他说两年后 Dragon 二代具备载人能力。这个时间表后来推迟了很多次,直到 2020 年才实现首次载人飞行。他在这个访谈里给出的大多数时间估计都偏乐观,这是他的老毛病,但方向判断很少出错。
三起火灾和一顶激光
回到开头那组数字。
三起没有造成任何伤害的特斯拉火灾,获得的全国性和国际性头条,比全美国所有汽油车火灾加起来还多。(马斯克)
他抱怨完,又给了一句更有用的表述。
新技术应该被聚光灯照着,但不该被激光照着。(马斯克)
这个区分很精确。聚光灯意味着更多人看见、更多讨论、更多监督,新技术应该承受这些。激光意味着能量集中在一点,持续加热,直到烧穿。媒体做的工作跟风险评估没关系,它在寻找叙事。
扎卡利亚把话题引向规模:特斯拉一年生产约 3 万辆,丰田一年生产几百万辆。市值却一度接近一些老牌车企。
马斯克没辩护,反而主动压低预期。
我不止一次说过,我们的估值超出了我们应得的程度。我们会尽力去兑现这些价值预期。我认为长期看,特斯拉的价值会显著超过今天,甚至超过几周前的高点。但如果说特斯拉板上钉钉值 220 亿美元,而我们今年销售额只有 20 多亿美元,那就是对未来执行的巨大信用透支。(马斯克)
这段话在 2013 年说出来需要一点定力。股价正在高位,媒体正在追捧,他却在电视上说"我们不值这么多"。原因可能是他真心这么认为,也可能因为他被 2008 年的现金流危机教过一次,知道过度承诺的代价。
顺便说,220 亿美元市值配 20 多亿美元营收,市销率大约 10 倍。今天回看这场"高估"的争论,结论有点滑稽:批评者和马斯克都算错了一头。批评者低估了增长曲线的陡峭程度,马斯克低估了自己的执行速度。
混合动力是两栖动物
扎卡利亚提了一个当时很流行的质疑:电池不够强,进步不够快,一个靠电池驱动的世界不现实。
马斯克没有辩护电池。他直接给出终局判断。
我的看法是,除了火箭这个讽刺的例外,所有交通方式都会变成全电动。包括飞机。飞机、火车、汽车,全部。(马斯克)
为什么火箭是例外?火箭要在大气层内用极短时间释放巨大能量,化学燃料的能量密度目前没有电池能接近。地面交通工具不需要背着全部能量飞起来,重量约束宽松得多。
至于混合动力,他用了一个生物学的比喻。
混合动力像两栖动物。生命从海洋走向陆地的时候,两栖动物有它的位置。但到最后,留下来的两栖动物非常少。(马斯克)
这个比喻的价值在于它给了一把尺子,用来判断一项过渡技术能活多久:看它解决的是路径问题,还是终局问题。混合动力解决的是续航焦虑和充电基础设施不足,这两样都属路径问题。电池成本下降、充电网络铺开之后,这两个痛点会一起消失。到那时混合动力就失去了存在理由,它身上背着两套系统,重量、成本、复杂度全是负担。
他对汽油时代的判断用的是同一个结构。
未来的人回望汽油时代,会像我们今天回望蒸汽时代一样。转化不会百分之百,今天还有蒸汽机在跑,还有人骑马,但比例非常小。(马斯克)
没有太阳,地球是个接近绝对零度的冰球
扎卡利亚问太阳能。马斯克绕开了"太阳能好不好"这一层,直接讲了一个物理事实。
世界几乎已经完全由太阳能驱动了。如果没有太阳,地球会是一个 3 到 4 开尔文的冰球,接近绝对零度。太阳驱动着我们整个降水系统、整个生态系统。除了极少数例外,几乎所有生命都是太阳能驱动的。(马斯克)
这段话的作用是把争论的框架换掉。反对太阳能的人通常会说,太阳能占比太低,替代不了化石能源。马斯克的回答是:占比低属于转换效率的问题,能量来源本身没有争议。太阳每年送到地表的能量,是人类全部能源消耗的几千倍,连化石能源本身也是几亿年前存下来的太阳能。
所以真正要回答的问题变成了:我们能不能把接收和储存的效率提上去。这两件事都在沿着学习曲线下降,光伏组件的成本从 1970 年代到现在掉了差不多三个数量级。
Hyperloop 比 Space Mountain 还温和
采访里还聊到了那个管道列车。2013 年 8 月,马斯克发布了 Hyperloop 的 alpha 设计文档,从洛杉矶到旧金山,30 多分钟。
扎卡利亚让他描述一下乘坐体验。
你会把自己绑在座位上,感觉大概像迪士尼的太空山(Space Mountain)。过载比太空山还小。所以如果你能坐太空山,你就能坐 Hyperloop。它会非常平顺,因为它用的是气垫,像空气曲棍球台,只不过气垫喷嘴在舱体上,不在管道上。(马斯克)
这个细节值得注意:气垫放在舱体,管道就不必做成精密的连续喷嘴阵列,造价大幅下降。取舍的思路很马斯克,把复杂度从"需要重复上万次的基础设施"转移到"只需要造几十个的运载舱"上。
顺便说,这个项目后来基本没按原方案推进。2016 年成立的两家创业公司改了技术路线,一家做真空管道加磁悬浮,一家做低压管道加气垫。马斯克本人把精力转到了隧道公司 Boring Company,思路也变了,从真空管道转向直径小得多的汽车隧道。
十年后的美国公路
采访接近尾声,扎卡利亚问:十年后,美国的汽车出行会是什么样?
路上会有很多电动车,比现在多得多。我认为十年后,我们会处在电动车普及曲线的陡峭段。(马斯克)
2013 年加十年是 2023 年。回头看,美国 2023 年纯电动车占新车销量大约 8% 到 9%,加上插电混动能再高一点。这个数字算不上陡峭,但确实进入了一个加速阶段,全球范围看中国和欧洲的曲线更陡。
他的判断在方向上没错,在斜率上乐观了。这个偏差在他的预测里反复出现:火星时间表、完全自动驾驶、Model 3 产能,无一例外。有意思的是偏差的方向每次都是同一个。他低估了制造和供应链的摩擦力,高估了组织执行的速度。
这场访谈里可以拿走的东西
把整段对话拆开,马斯克反复在用同一套方法。
第一步,找到那个被所有人默认"只能这样"的约束。火箭是一次性的,所以太空很贵;飞机由寡头造,所以五十年没快过;汽油车会起火,所以电动车起火是新闻。这些约束单独看都很合理,放在一起看就发现它们互相支撑,谁都不去碰。
第二步,算清楚这个约束的成本结构。6000 万美元对 20 万美元,300 比 1。这个数字一摆出来,可重复使用就从理想主义变成了唯一合理的选项。
第三步,检查激励。空客和波音不造更快的飞机,能力从来够用,问题出在激励上:高管赌错了会被解雇。这一层想通了,就知道为什么改变往往来自行业外部。
这套方法谈不上天才,门槛只有一个:愿意在别人都往前赶路的时候停下来问一句,这条路为什么要这么修。
- 看一个行业的技术进步速度,先看它的激励结构。决策者的失败成本远大于成功收益时,这个行业就会长期停在渐进改良上,不管工程师多聪明。判断一个赛道有没有突变机会,查一查过去二十年有没有人被激进方案毁掉过职业生涯。
- 分析成本时,先把一次性投入和每次重付的部分分开。火箭 6000 万对燃料 20 万,300 比 1,可重复使用立刻只剩一个答案。你的业务里哪些成本每做一次就重付一次?那通常就是最大的改造空间。
- 面对负面事件,先算基数和伤亡率。3 起无伤亡对 25 万起 400 人死亡,比例差在十万分之一量级。新技术出问题时,把它放回同类技术的基线里比一比,结论会完全不同。这个动作能帮你避开被放大的恐慌,也能帮你识别被掩盖的真实风险。
- 判断一个过渡方案会不会死,看它解决的是路径问题还是终局问题。混合动力解决的是充电桩不够和续航焦虑,这两样都会消失。凡是"因为现在条件不成熟所以需要"的技术,都该给它设一个退出时间表。
- 把宏大目标拆成第一件必须解决的事。火星计划的第一个问题不在怎么生存,而在怎么到那儿,并且便宜到能运送大量人口。想清楚"这件事解决不了,后面全都白搭",资源分配会立刻清晰。
- 对时间表打折,对方向下注。马斯克的预测几乎每次在时间上都过于乐观,方向判断的命中率却很高。听这类人的话,把年份往后推,把方向当参考。
- 专注有代价。被问到为什么不造世界最快的喷气机,马斯克的回答只有一句"我们得专注在火箭上"。机会摆在面前不等于该接,判断标准是这件事会不会分散你解决核心约束的能力。
- 创始人的风险结构决定公司敢不敢赌。如果一家公司的关键决策者赌错就会被解雇,它必然走向渐进改良。想在自己的组织里做成激进的事,先想办法让决策者的风险收益重新对齐。
0:01Elon Musk is a billionaire, an inventor, a scientist, a designer, and one of the world's most innovative minds. He runs two companies that are trying to disrupt major industries that have been doing things the same way for decades. Aerospace with SpaceX and automobiles with Tesla.
0:22Tesla is making luxury all-electric cars, cars that have had a bit of controversy of late. Currently, SpaceX is essentially an intergalactic trucking company, taking loads back and forth from the International Space Station and bringing satellites up to orbit. In the future, it hopes to carry humans too.
0:44We met on a balcony overlooking the SpaceX factory floor. It was buzzing, literally and figuratively. The workers were preparing for an important launch on Monday. Elon Musk, pleasure to have you on. Thanks for having me. So this is the dragon that goes up in this space and is going to go up on Monday, correct?
1:06Yeah, that's our dragon spacecraft of version one, which is capable of taking cargo to and from the space station, including biological cargo, like fish and mice and that kind of thing. So when do when do human beings start going up and if you think? So we expect to complete version two of dragon which will have astronaut transport capability in about two years.
1:25And most of what you do now is send satellites up into space. That's how you pay the bills. Exactly. But you want to do something much more ambitious with space apps. Yeah. I mean, the long-term aspiration is to develop the technologies necessary to transport a large number of people in Chicago to Mars in order to create a self-sustaining civilization there.
1:49And that's really why I started the company, was because it seemed to create the possibility for life on other planets? Yeah, exactly. I mean, it sort of started off when I was thinking about what to do after PayPal. And I'd always been interested in space, but I didn't think there was anything that an individual could do in space.
2:08I mean, it seemed like the province of large governments. But I sort of started looking into it, and I went to the NASA website to find out when we're going to Mars. It seems like, obviously, that is the next thing out of the moon. And I couldn't find anything. So I was like, wow, this seems very strange.
2:29Initially I was under the impression that it was, that we'd lost the will to do that. And I later came to the conclusion that I was quite wrong about that, I think the United States in particular is a nation of explorers. So you decide you want to try and do this? And do you look at it as, why did you decide transport was the most important thing?
2:51I mean, I think we would regard living on Mars as, no, that's the relatively easier thing. Yes, yes, absolutely. So we could live on Mars just getting there is the problem. Yes, but getting, I mean, right now getting to Mars is impossible, so it's kind of doesn't matter what you do when you get there if you can't get there.
3:13So the first order of business is to figure out how to get there, and it needs to be in a way that enables large numbers of people and cargo. Can't just be like a handful of people because that's obviously not gonna create a self-sustaining civilization. And Apollo was an amazing, inspiring thing for all of humanity, but the last time we went to the moon was like 1973 or four, I believe.
3:37So we don't want to just have flags and footprints for, and then never go to Mars again. If we just have one mission, that will also be a super inspiring thing, but it's not gonna fundamentally change the future of humanity. So you have this Grasshopper rocket, which unlike most rockets, which can't, you know, which are not reusable, this one gently comes back down in a kind of vertical lamp.
4:05Yeah, absolutely. You can see the videos of this on the SpaceX website. The fundamental breakthrough, going back to the point of, that developing a Mars transportation system, it has to be affordable to go. Like it can't just be like billions of dollars per person to go to Mars, then you'd snow where you could establish a base on Mars at that cost.
4:32So we have to develop rockets that are rapidly and as close to completely reusable as possible. As an example, the Falcon 9 costs about $60 million It's sort of like a jet, but the cost of the propellant is only about $200,000. So it's just like you can imagine how expensive it would be if you had to buy a new plane every
4:58time you went somewhere. A very few people would fly. But refueling a plane is pretty easy. We once talked about airplane travel, and I asked you why it is that with all this technological improvement over the last 30 or 40 years, the one thing that doesn't seem to have improved,
5:14and it is in the domain of the private sector sort off. Is Jeff trouble, I mean if you're flying from New York to London, it takes about as long as it took 40 or 50 years ago. In fact, it takes long ago. It actually does take longer because, the 70s, my favorite sort of commercial airliner
5:33is the 747, because it actually goes quite fast. And it's actually incredible that that thing was, I mean the first iteration of it was designed in the 60s. I mean, since then I don't think we've exceeded the 747, which is nutty. I think, well, for the commercial airline or business, you essentially have a duopoly
5:57between Airbus and Boeing. And these big airplane programs are really long-term and they're quite expensive. And I think if you're in the senior management of one of those companies, it's a safer bet to take it to just aim for a little incremental improvement, then to try to aim for a radical improvement.
6:17Because generally, if you aim for a radical improvement and you're wrong, you'll get fired. Why don't SpaceX create the fastest jet plane in the world? We've got to focus on rockets. When do you think you'll be able to achieve the aspiration of SpaceX on actually moving people to a place like Mars?
6:37Well, I think we could probably send the first person in about 12 years. Wow. Will you be that person? Only if I'm confident that SpaceX will be fine if I die. That's... you know, if I was... maybe if I was confident that the mission would continue if I wasn't around, then I would do it.
7:02Elon Musk on his program to Mars. Lots more ahead from him, including his response to all the headlines about Tesla's cars catching fire. New technology should have a spotlight on it, but it should have a laser on it. Elon Musk says he doesn't get a lot of sleep these days. He's not only CEO and
7:23chief designer at SpaceX, he's also CEO and product architect at Tesla. Tesla produces luxury all-electric vehicles and the company's cars have been in the news after some Model S sedans caught fire. Earlier in the week but after our interview the National Highway Transportation Safety Board announced an investigation into two of the incidents. The board had previously given the
7:47more or less a five-star safety rating, it's highest. Listen in to more of my interview with Elon Musk. You've heard all the press about Tesla, so let me first give you a chance to get it off your chest. I was really like pistol whipped. Three cars gone on fire. What's your response?
8:06So the amount of national and international news headlines dedicated to three Tesla fires that caused no injury is greater than all of the gasoline fires that occurred in the United States. And with all the other cars. Yeah. Which from mid last year to today is about a quarter million
8:34gasoline car fires, which caused about 400 deaths, something like 1,200 serious injuries. Our three non-injurious fires got more national headlines been a quarter million deadly gasoline car fires. That's mad. What the heck is going on? When I realized like a new technology should, it should have a spotlight on it, but it shouldn't have a laser on it.
9:01So when you look at Tesla, the big concern many people have is scale. You're producing about 30,000 cars a year, but Toyota is producing. Oh yeah, we're, we're, we're millions. You're millions. So, yeah, it's like way too much attention. And your market cap is almost as high as some of these guccos.
9:19Well, yeah. It's got more than recent weeks. But yeah. Do you think it's crazy or do you think it's an appropriate indication of future growth? Yeah. I mean, what I've actually said on more than one occasion is that I thought our valuation was more than we had any right to deserve.
9:38That we would do our best to fulfill those value expectations. that I thought over time the value of Tesla would probably significantly exceed where it is today or even where it was at the relatively high point a few weeks ago. But it would be, I think silly for me to assert that Tesla is unequivocally worth, at one
10:03point we're like worth $22 billion and we'll have somewhere over $2 billion in sales this here. That is an enormous amount of credit for future execution. The heart of what interests you about Tesla, at least as I recall when we've talked, is that it's not a compromise. That a hybrid is something of a compromise between an internal
10:23combustion engine and a battery powered engine. And here you can do it cleanly. But batteries just aren't that powerful enough. And they don't seem to improve enough to imagine a a world powered by batteries, right? I certainly can see that. And in fact, my opinion is that all transportation
10:45with the ironic exception of rockets will be fully electric. Even planes. Yes, everything. Planes trains. By wind. Everything. It'll never be like a 100% conversion. Like, we still have some steam engines running around. And some people still ride horses. But it's a pretty tiny percentage.
11:03So I think it'll be the same with gasoline. I think in the future people will look back on the gasoline era The way we look back on the steam era today. So you're using battery technology your dear You're doing Tesla, which is an electric car you have solar panel You have an interest in business and solar panels. Yeah, do you think solar energy is the future? I think it's super obvious in the future
11:25absolutely in fact If you think about it, the world is almost entirely solar powered already in that we would be a frozen ice ball at about three or four degrees Kelvin, close to absolute zero without the sun. And the sun powers our entire system of precipitation, the ecosystem, apart from a tiny number of
11:51exceptions, almost all life is solar powered. All right, another great technology you've talked about that most people think of is out of a movie. Explain how it would work. Let's say it's New York or Boston or LA to San Francisco. I get into a tube and it's almost like air hockey.
12:11The way it works is I strap myself into a seat and... Well, it would actually feel maybe like the Space Mountain ride at Disney World. And the G-learning would actually be less than what people experience at Space Mountain. So if you can handle Space Mountain at Disneyland, you can handle the hyperloop.
12:32It'll feel super smooth because, as you mentioned, it would use air skis like an air hockey table, but with the air jets on the pod side as opposed to the tube side. So it would just be, I mean, it would be smoothest glass. Ten years from now, what would car travel look like in America?
12:52Ten years from now. I think there's going to be a lot of electric cars in the road. We're certainly faster than there are now. I think we'll be in the steep portion of the adoption of electric cars in ten years. You think hybrids are a transition that will fade away? Yeah, they're like sort of an amphibian.
13:14There was a role for amphibians when life was moving from the oceans to land, but it would in the end very few amphibians remain. It's a good point to your hand now. Thank you. Thank you.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 视频原始视频文件
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版