2015年9月29日,加州弗里蒙特工厂。马斯克上台发布Model X,一辆0到60英里加速3.2秒的七座SUV。他开口讲的第一个数字,是6.5%。
这是Model X在高速事故中造成严重伤害的预期概率。美国政府的五星安全评级里,五星对应10%,四星对应15%。6.5%意味着,如果这套评级体系里真有第六颗星(5%),Model X已经站在六星之上。
一辆以鹰翼门和狂暴加速为卖点的车,发布会的前二十分钟全在讲碰撞、翻滚、滤芯和细菌。这个顺序本身就是马斯克的态度:先证明它撞不坏,再证明它很酷。
先讲使命,再讲车
马斯克照例从特斯拉的使命讲起。
特斯拉的使命是加速可持续交通的到来。我们越早完成这件事越好。(马斯克)
他把这条路拆成三段。Roadster证明跑车可以电动,Model S证明轿车可以电动,Model X要证明SUV也可以电动。三类车,三种最难说服的人群,一个一个拆掉"电动车只能是小众玩具"的偏见。
然后他话锋一转,说对一辆车来说最重要的东西是安全。理由很朴素:你开车时载着朋友和家人,没有什么比这更要紧。车企发布会上讲安全通常是一页PPT带过,马斯克把它做成了整场的第一幕。
五星不是分数,是一个概率
很多人对五星评级的理解是错的,马斯克专门花时间纠正这一点。五星并不是某种统计意义上的精确数值,它更像一个粗略的参考坐标,背后描述的是高速碰撞中严重受伤的概率。
这套坐标的刻度是这样的:从两星、三星、四星到五星,每一档之间相差5个百分点。四星对应15%的受伤概率,五星对应10%。如果存在六星,对应的就是5%。
Model X的实测预期值落在6.5%附近。这个数字不是靠加厚钢板堆出来的,马斯克把原因归到整车的基础架构上,然后逐项拆解。
汽油车最危险的东西,是那个发动机
正面碰撞是伤亡最集中的场景。传统汽油车在车头放着一大块钢制发动机,高速撞击时,这块发动机被推着往乘员舱里挤,人坐在后面承受全部后果。
Model X没有这个东西。它的电机体积很小,位置压得很低,紧贴着电池包。结果是车头空出了一大段距离,溃缩区变得非常长。
溃缩区的原理不复杂:碰撞能量需要在某段距离上被吸收掉。距离越长,同样的能量分摊到每一厘米上的冲击就越小,减速度曲线越平缓,传递到座舱的力道越弱,人也越安全。车头短、发动机硬的车,等于把这段缓冲距离压缩到极限。
马斯克打了个比方,说这就像从高楼上往泳池里跳。你当然希望池子里是水,不希望池子里有一块大石头。汽油车的发动机,就是那块石头。
215毫米,和"生与死的差别"
侧面碰撞是另一条主线。马斯克给出一个对比:Model S和Model X的侧柱侵入量,大约是同级最佳车型的一半。
具体到Model X,侧柱侵入只有215毫米,而全世界排在它后面的那台SUV,这个数字差不多翻倍。侧面是车门,是人肩、胸、髋的位置,侵入量每多一厘米,伤害就往上跳一档。
现场放了两段侧柱碰撞的对比影像,一台是Model X,一台是当时世界上最好的SUV。看完之后马斯克只说了两句:
这是生与死的差别。这个差距真的非常大。(马斯克)
翻滚是第三个指标。SUV和MPV的重心普遍偏高,翻滚概率天然吃亏。Model X把沉重的电池包平铺在底盘上,重心被压得很低,翻滚倾向只有普通SUV或MPV的一半,翻滚致伤的概率随之大幅下降。
马斯克在现场把车身结构一层层拆开给观众看。电池包在这里不承担储能之外的另一个角色:它是整车刚性的支撑件,是底板的基础,还是把冲击载荷传导到车身各处的介质。
对比之下,汽油车底部只有一层薄薄的波纹钢板。侧面被撞时,这层钢板没有能力把力分散出去,撞击能量只能就地消化,车门就往里凹。
最好的保护是别撞上
被动安全讲完,马斯克转向主动安全。Model X全系标配自动紧急制动和侧撞避让,靠的是车上的摄像头、雷达和环绕车身的超声波传感器。
系统会在碰撞发生前自动刹车,也会在侧向有碰撞风险时主动打方向把车带开。这些功能不用选装,不用订阅,全天候处于激活状态。2015年这个时间点,AEB还没成为欧美市场的强制配置,特斯拉把它做成了标配。
一个滤芯,和那个真的按钮
第三个话题是空气。马斯克说这辆车的设计早在最近那些事情发生之前就完成了,只是那些事情恰好说明了车内空气质量有多重要。
Model X装的是汽车上第一个真正意义上的HEPA滤清器。为什么要在车里放这个东西,马斯克的回答落在预期寿命上。他引用了一组数据,说这是他们能在互联网上找到的最保守的数字,真实情况比这糟糕得多,这组数字基本等于"你住在那座城市里会发生的最不坏的情况"。
为了让人直观感受到差距,他把三个滤芯摆在台上。最左边是Model X的主滤芯,右边是副滤芯,中间那个小得多的,是普通汽车的空调滤芯。
普通车的滤芯只有巴掌大一块。Model X的副滤芯,尺寸就已经超过普通车的主滤芯。面积大了十倍,滤材本身的等级也更高,两个因素叠起来,过滤能力提升了几百倍。
具体数字是这样的:过滤细菌的能力强300倍,过滤过敏原强50倍,过滤烟雾强700倍,过滤病毒强800倍。而且这组成绩是在"最差的一天"测出来的,也就是系统状态最差时的下限,正常工作状态下只会更好。
颗粒物过滤之外还有三层活性炭。第一层是通用吸附层,第二层针对酸性气体,第三层针对碱性气体。整套系统跑起来,车内的洁净度接近医院手术室。
如果按下最大净化档位,车内已经检测不到任何病毒、细菌或孢子。马斯克顺手开了个玩笑,说如果哪天真出现某种末日场景,你只要按下那个按钮就行。
这个按钮是真的。(马斯克)
它叫"生物武器防御模式",在中控屏上,不是贴纸,不是概念图,按下之后空调会以最高功率和最高正压运行。马斯克补了一句:
我们想在这类末日防御场景里当个领导者。(马斯克)
鹰翼门最开始不是为了帅
讲完安全,车才真正开始变得好玩。马斯克先讲车门和车窗。
自动前门是第一个。车会三角定位车主的位置,判断出你正在朝车门走,门自己打开,你坐下,门自己关上。整个过程不用碰任何东西,像有个隐形司机在服务。
全景挡风玻璃是第二个。玻璃从车头一直延伸到头顶,坐进去像直升机的驾驶舱,视野大到不太像一台SUV。马斯克说这个设计会改变驾驶体验,试驾的时候就能感受到差别。
还有一个很小的功能,手机盲插。不需要低头找线、对接口,从口袋里掏出来直接放进去,支架会自动对准。各种主流手机都有对应的转接件。功能不大,但每天都要用。
然后是鹰翼门。马斯克讲了它的来历,这个故事比门本身有意思。
他当年买第一台SUV的时候,双胞胎刚出生。儿童安全座椅一装进第二排,第三排就彻底进不去了。人得从两个安全座椅之间的缝隙里挤过去,或者干脆放弃第三排。他觉得这个设计不讲道理,于是给团队提了一个要求:开门之后,要留出足够大的开口,让人能直接走进去。
现场演示很直白。按一下按钮,第二排座椅自动前移,人从开口处一步跨进第三排。如果第二排已经装了儿童座椅,家长可以站在车外,直着腰把孩子放进座椅,不用弯腰、不用扭身、不用把孩子从一个小洞里塞进去。马斯克说这对腰背的负担差别很大。
所以鹰翼门的两个真实理由都是功能性的:让第三排真正可用,让放孩子这件事不伤腰。好看排在第三位。
两个铰链,让它能在夹缝里开门
鹰翼门最常见的质疑是:这玩意儿停进窄车位怎么办。
现场直接演示。两台车并排停着,中间只留了几英寸,人侧着身都很难挤过去。鹰翼门打开,向上翻,人可以从门下的空间走过去。
能做成这样,关键在铰链数量。传统鸥翼门只有一个铰链,门只能先向外、再向上,动作轨迹向外扩张,窄车位上根本打不开。Model X的鹰翼门有两个铰链,门可以一边向上、一边向内收,先抬高再折进来,横向占用的空间极小。
现场还拉来一台MPV做对比。侧滑门完全打开之后,那条缝隙人还是过不去。马斯克的意思是,他们想要的是比侧滑门更好用的开口,结果是做到了。
第二个质疑是低矮车库。这是马斯克被问得最多的问题之一。
解决办法是传感器。车门内侧装了超声波传感器,实时测出车顶高度和两侧障碍物的位置,再据此算出一条新的开门弧线。车库矮,门就开得低一点;旁边有柱子,门就避开那个方向。
这里有个工程细节值得说。超声波传感器通常需要在车身上开孔,还得在外面留一个圆形的凸起,装在车门正中央会很难看。特斯拉的团队为此重新开发了一款能穿透金属的超声波传感器,把它藏在门板内侧,外观上完全看不到。
被亏待的第二排,和一块平地板
马斯克说,汽车的第二排座椅长期得不到重视,大多数车的第二排长得就像凑数的。
Model X的情况不一样。鹰翼门打开之后,门洞非常高,座椅会整个暴露在外,像被打了光。这种暴露放大了设计的缺陷,也放大了优点。团队于是在座椅造型上花了很大力气,马斯克说这大概是世界上最好看的第二排座椅,这个说法有点自夸,但他紧接着讲了实用性。
地板是平的,座椅下方有空间。背包、笔记本电脑、手提袋可以塞到座椅底下,不用堆在脚边占地方。好看和好用在这里同时成立。
拖5000磅,坐7个人,还要塞下婴儿车
接下来是载物能力,这一段是现场效果最好的部分。
Model X的拖拽能力是5000磅。同时车里坐满7个人,后备箱还能装不少行李。前备箱也没浪费,现场直接把一辆婴儿车放了进去。
装载演示一个接一个往上堆:7个人、一台5000磅的拖车、一堆包、一辆婴儿车。马斯克自己数到后面也数不清装了多少件。
还有一个配件值得一提。特斯拉做了一个快拆拖车钩,一个小孩子大约10秒就能装上。现场那位小朋友用了差不多5秒。这个钩子可以挂4辆自行车,或者6副滑雪板,挂上之后后备箱照常开关,车的其他功能完全不受影响。
一台快得不太合理的SUV
最后是性能。
标准版Model X 90D,续航257英里,四驱,0到60英里加速4.8秒。这个成绩放在2015年的SUV里已经很快。
然后是P90D的狂暴模式(Ludicrous Mode)。0到60英里,3.2秒。
这车快得不太对劲。一台SUV,3.2秒。(马斯克)
他说这话的时候语气里带着一点自己也觉得过分的笑意。台下在笑,他接着把钥匙交给车主。
交付的那几分钟
发布会的尾声没有煽情演讲。马斯克一个个念车主名字,请他们上台,把钥匙递过去。有人带着家人来,有人举着手机拍自己的车牌。他站在台侧,跟每个人握手,说恭喜,说谢谢。
他最后提到自己的那台车马上就到,会留在台上,散场之后大家可以围过来看、可以摸。然后他感谢了团队,说这群人为了这个晚上拼了很久。
整场发布会到这里结束。回头看,它的结构其实非常清楚:先用碰撞数据建立信任,再用滤芯和车门建立差异,最后用3.2秒建立欲望。三件事按这个顺序排,缺一件都不成立。
这场发布会真正在争什么
2015年,电动车面对的核心质疑有三个:不安全、不实用、不好开。Model X的发布会对准的就是这三条。
安全这条线,马斯克没有停留在"我们通过了五星测试",他把五星拆成一个概率,再把概率拆成溃缩距离、侧柱侵入毫米数、翻滚倾向和电池包的结构作用。这些是可验证的物理量,不是营销话术。
实用这条线,他没有回避鹰翼门的争议,反而把最尖锐的两个问题(窄车位、矮车库)摆到台上当场演示。这种做法有风险,演示失败就是灾难,但演示成功的说服力远超任何参数表。
性能这条线,3.2秒是一个不需要解释的数字。它和"SUV"这个车型放在一起,本身就构成一个话题。
值得多想一层的是空气过滤那一段。它和车的动力、操控、空间都没有关系,却被放在发布会的前半段,占了相当长的时间。马斯克给出的理由是预期寿命,这个理由把一台车的价值从"出行工具"扩展到了"长期健康暴露"。这个角度在2015年很超前,放到今天看反而更容易理解。
还有一点容易被忽略:整场发布会里,马斯克几乎没有提竞品的名字,唯一一次对比是那台"世界上最好的SUV"和那台MPV,都没点名。对比的对象是物理量,是碰撞后的车身形态,不是某个品牌。这种对比方式很难反驳,因为它不依赖观点。
给读者的几条实用建议
- 看安全评级别只看星级。问清楚星级背后对应的受伤概率,四星和五星之间差5个百分点,这5个百分点在真实事故里可能就是轻伤和重伤的距离。
- 判断一台电动车安全不安全,先看电池包是不是结构件。平铺在底盘、参与整车刚性、承担载荷传递的电池包,和只是挂在底盘下面的电池包,侧撞表现完全不是一个量级。
- 关注侧柱侵入量的实测毫米数。这个数字比"高强度钢占比"之类的宣传语有用得多,它直接对应侧面碰撞时车门离你身体还有多远。
- 买车时看一眼空调滤芯的尺寸和层数。滤芯面积、滤材等级、活性炭层数,这三项决定了车内空气的真实水平,尤其在空气质量差的城市,这是每天都在生效的配置。
- 试驾鹰翼门这类结构复杂的车门,别在空旷的4S店院子里试。找一个最窄的车位、一个最低的地下车库,实地开一次,看传感器算出来的开门弧线是否真的可用。
- 把儿童座椅装进第二排,再试着进一次第三排。这个动作能立刻暴露一台七座SUV的空间设计是真做了功课,还是只在参数表上凑了七个座位。
- 看发布会时留意讲者把什么放在最前面。先讲加速的车,通常安全底子一般;先讲碰撞概率的车,后面的加速数字才值得信。
0:00I reminding people like what the you know the mission of Tesla is to accelerate the advent of sustainable transport and as I think you guys know it's incredibly important that we move to a sustainable world sooner rather than later the sooner we do it the better the better it is and and it's
0:25important to to show that that any any type of car can go electric we showed that you could make a compelling sports car with the roadster and that could go electric and we showed that you could do it with a sedan and now we're going to show that you can do it with an SUV so we're going to start off with being what's actually most important for it for a car which is safety so the if you
1:04if you're driving you're carrying your friends and family around there's really nothing is more important than safety so first and foremost the car is going to go to keep you and and the ones you love safe and and protection or any circumstance you can imagine so
2:15so the they have the model x don't talk a lot of more about the details of the car but I was start off with safety so that with the Model X we've created the safest SUV ever it's the first SUV that's five stars in every category and I thought I'd just to explain what does five stars mean as five star is not technically a statistical number it's sort of a you know a rough reference point it's and what it actually means is it describes the probability of a serious injury in a high-speed accident so you start off with sort of 2 star 3 star force are five star and they go down in in five percent increments a four star would be a fifteen percent probability of injury in a high-speed
3:16accident five star would be ten percent hypothetically if there was a sixth star it would be at five percent and we've been able to get with the Model X or an expected rating of about six and a half percent so and so let me explain to how we how we get to such a low probability of injury and it goes to the design of the car and the fundamental architecture so starting off with the frontal eye if so for what
3:53happens in a frontal crash this is where most high most injuries and deaths occur is in a frontal frontal crash and normally with with a gasoline car you've got a large steel engine block in front and so in a high-speed impact that engine block compresses it into the passenger compartment and obviously causes damage to the people that are sitting there with the Model X there is no such there's no such thing so we have
4:24a small electric motor that's down low by the battery pack and the net effect is that you've got a much larger distance for the crumple zone so it it's really taking impact energy is about for server distance and if you go to longer distance you can actually distribute that force over that longer distance and have a better deceleration and not impact the cabin so in the case of the frontal a frontal zone you've got it's not something it's the equivalent of like if you want to jump out of a tall building into a pool it's demonstrate jumping into a pool or a pool with a rock in it so the you don't want the pool with the rock in it so then going
5:06on to a side a side impact the the model s and the Model X are about half of the next best in the SP class so the X is a so the side pole intrusion is only two hundred fifteen millimeters in the in the Model X and that's compared to the next best of SUV which is about double that number and let's see what that looks like in pictures so this is what
5:42it looks like with a site this is the actual side pole test for the Model X compared to the next best SUV in the world this is the difference between life and death this is a really big difference so and then look now now let's look at the role of numbers so the Model X because it has a low center of mass with the battery pack in the flow pan has half the role of a propensity of any SUV or minivan so the probability of a rollover injury is substantially reduced and you can see this in the architecture we start with the pack and that that pack for what it provides a stiffening member for the whole car prevent provides a very strong foundation for the whole car
6:34lowering the center of mass and serving as a load transfer medium to the rest of the vehicle so whereas a gasoline car really just has thin corrugated sheet metal at the base and can't transfer the load in a side-impact so we'll just show you the rest of the car building up you see the motors and the chassis it gives you a sense for the core architecture of the car now of course the best protection is not to get into an accident at all so the Model X comes standard with active safety which includes automatic emergency braking and
7:13add side collision of a cyclisation avoidance so the column will actually use the camera on the radar to automatically break before there's an accident and it will use the ultrasonic sensors around the side of the car to steer you away from a side collision and these are active all the time and it's just a standard feature in the car
7:40now the third thing which is sort of topical is is the air safety now we designed the car well before recent events 7 so just happens just happens to you know this recent events have illustrated the importance of a bear safety and we have with the Model X the first the first true HEPA filter in a car so and wide why it is important to have a particular full so why is important to have a gas filter in the car it's because the this translates to
8:24a real real change in life expectancy so these these are the most conservative numbers we could find on the internet like the most conservative they go way worse than this this is basically the least bad thing that would happen if you lived in these cities so and I'll just take a look at the functions themselves you can i want to show you just how much of a difference this is that the top the
8:51top one is our primary Ethel to the the one on the left in the bottom is our secondary Ethel to the one on the right is a normal car air filter I think we've got some of those here so this is this is what a normal car filter looks like it's really really quite small this is the this is the primary air filter of the model x and this is the second this is the secondary air filter our secondary air filter is bigger than the primary air filter of a typical car so the and not
9:31only is it 10 times larger area but the the quality the culture is greater so that translates to several hundred fold improvements in the filtration capability it is three hundred times better at filtering bacteria 50 times better at allergens seven hundred times better at source mog and eight hundred times better at filtering viruses and and this is on a bad day so this is the minimum passing grade winners just operating at its worst sit and yeah so
10:04that in addition to to the the particle filters we have three layers of active carbon so we've got one universal adsorbent layer that's the initial layer then we've got another activated carbon layer that's meant for acid gases and another one for alkaline gases the the net effect of the air filtration system is that you have our cleanliness levels which comparable to a hospital operating room in the car and
10:41and in fact when the car is operating when the car is operating at its at maximum capability so if you sort of press max Mac capability in the car we can't even detect any viruses or bacteria or spores so it's like zero come through so if there's ever if it is ever sort of a apocalyptic scenario of
11:07some kind hypothetically you just press the bioweapon defense mode button this is a real button
11:34so what yeah we're trying to be a leader in apocalyptic defense scenarios now so let's move on to the car itself like what's cool and fun about the car doors and windows okay so that you obviously familiar with the Falcon wing door what we also have is an auto presenting front door so what it will do is it'll triangulate my position and detect that i am moving towards the front door it will open the front door without me touching anything I will sit down and it will close the door like an invisible chauffeur
12:39and there are a few other features that are hard to the hard to demo in this exact scenario but it's something that we work very hard on is a windshield that's a panoramic windshield so it comes up and over and feels like a helicopter cockpit when you're driving so it gives you unbelievable visibility and its really it's transformative in
13:04the driving experience so you really when you do the test test drives latest night you'll see what I mean it's really really makes the difference and then in addition to that we also have a it's a small feature but an important one is the ability to blind holster your phone so this this is like one of those things where you it's small but it's important instead of having to fiddle with a bunch of wires to plug in your phone you can basically take it out of your pocket and blind holster it it'll automatically fit and there are adapters for every variant of popular phone so it's open these
13:54doors so that the reason we created these doors I was originally we're trying to solve a problem which is how do you access the third row if you have child seats in the second row and I encountered this problem when it when I first got to a gassing SUV and I had had twins and once you put them in the second row you couldn't access the third row so we wanted to have an opening that was big enough so that you could do that so you can have real utility of the third row while even if you have kids he's in the second rope so you basically just press the button this used to go forward and I can step directly in
15:09it's also important that if you have say a child seat here that instead of having to cantilever your kid out in front to sort of put them basically into a small hole you you can actually just stand right here you can actually step into the car if you want you can just put your child down in the child seat it makes a huge difference in terms of a back strain and comfort so those those
15:37are two functional reasons and and it also looks cool so yeah so that's a that's the Falcon wing doors and now obviously a question with the doors is so how do they fit in tight spaces well we'll show you let's bring out the cars
16:29mhm so so the scenario we're going to show you here is if you've ever been in a parking lot and someone parked real close so that it's I don't you can see
17:10well here but there's only about a few inches separating the side murs on each side of the car so we're going to open the Falcon wing doors whether it's barely enough room to squeeze between the two cars
17:51so the reason it's able to do that is because unlike a traditional Gullwing door which is only actuator on a single hinge the demonics Falcon wing doors are actuated on two hinges so it's able to move up and over instead of simply moving out in a bra dark and moreover if you're compared to say a minivan door let's open the minivan door here you can
18:23see that it when the minivan door opens I can't even get through that space so let's close the minivan door now the Falcon wing door is open
18:44so I go ago was to create some an aperture that was more functional than a mini van door and I think I think the team is as exceeded so i think is this semester aperture out there
19:26and just illustrates what it's like in a garage so you saw what it's like if it's tight from a science standpoint well what if you have a low garage that's one of the most common questions I get about the Model X the car actually automatically senses what the roof height is so there are ultrasonic sensors in the inner of the car that calculate the roof height and automatically compute a new opening arc depending upon what the higher ceiling is and what the side obstacles are we
20:01actually developed a new ultrasonic sensor that's able to do so north through metal so in order to avoid having a puck which is ordinarily needed for ultrasonic sensors we thought the aesthetics the park would not be good to be in because it would have to be in the center of the door so we actually developed an ultrasonic sensor that can literally see through metal alright so
20:29let's maybe talk a bit more about the second row seats so only second row seats in a car don't get a lot of love so let's let's see show you what connect northeast typically look like in a car so that's sort of what that what second row seats and only look like but when we're typically when you open something and it's so silhouette it as it does with the bell cooing door it tends to create a halo around the seat so we put a lot of effort into creating a beautiful seat and not only is the seats I think I
21:17probably the best-looking second seat that's a superlative and ever but it's actually provides full functionality because you you have a flat floor and you can stow if something so if you've got a backpack or a laptop or a handbag you can still you can stow that under the seat instead of having it at your feet so it actually provides utility as well as aesthetics all right
21:50and speaking of utility let's see what the market what the Model X can really carry
22:17so more likes is capable of towing 5,000 pounds so 55 thousand pounds while carrying seven people and quite a lot of luggage
22:52and of course let's not forget about the front yes we need the stroller
23:15there you go to put them in I was gonna hurt them out all right all right
23:39alright so there you have it 1likes carrying 77 people a 5,000 pound trailer and I lost count of how many bags and a stroller
24:11alright so something we developed with for the Model X is like let's say you want to carry skis bikes and you want to do that quickly and easily we made an accessories hitch that can be put on by a kid in approximately 10 seconds thank you I think that was one like five seconds so the accessories hitch can
24:43carry up to four bikes or up to six sets of skis and you can close the trunk and have full functionality of the rest of the car
25:04skis and snowboards indeed and then the final element of course is performance so that even the standard version of the model x has quite high performance so it's got the standard version 9 tds got 250 seven mile range or wheel drive a course and it gets to 60 miles an hour in 4.8 seconds and then the p90 d ludicrous mode I mean this goes so fast
25:37is wrong do zero to 60 ad this is an SUV I don't know too soon to 60 in 3.2 seconds alright alright so with that let me let's hand over the post production cars all right
26:13alright so let's see if insects hey Kara what's up man okay amazing hey congratulations such an awesome job hey nice license plates
26:45all right it's a fen five guys coming soon all right c is okay hopefully the call goosey here soon
27:22alright thanks all right then bin for Saturn for Sergei oh the old city then three alright good save that's really should Thanks hey thank you all right and then too
28:27all right yeah man all right and then let's see the final one is my car which is going to be up in a moment and i will leave up i'll leave that my power on stage when it arrives so that you can all you can come and take a close look at it and pull around it and that kind of thing and and that's that really i hope you have a great night i enjoy the test drives and like thank you
29:08and I think that has the team who work super hard to make this night work alright thanks have a good night
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版