如果人类明天彻底治愈癌症,平均寿命能延长多少?
两年。
这个数字是马斯克给的。2022年,他做客雷恩·威尔逊(Rainn Wilson)的节目,整场访谈在一辆面包车的后座上进行。主持人端着汉堡问他要不要来一口,他说不用。
为什么先提这个数字?因为它解释了马斯克后来所有的精力分配。在他看来,把资源砸进单一疾病的治疗,收益比大多数人以为的小得多。
治愈所有癌症,只多活两年
他的推理不复杂。人的身体在基因层面被设定在大约八十岁左右关机,死因可以换,器官衰竭、免疫系统失灵、痴呆,总有一个先到。癌症被消灭了,其他器官衰竭的队伍还排在那里。
他说所有生物都有写进DNA里的自然寿命。果蝇只有几个星期,人类是八十年上下,也许能慢慢挪到八十五。这个上限不因为某项医学突破而改变。
所以医疗领域真正的突破口不在某一种病,在DNA本身。要让人健康地活到一百二、一百五,得重写那套程序,而且必须是健康的那种延长。他顺带描述了自己不想要的结果:躺在生命维持系统上,不能动,只有一个神经元还在工作。
这条路他判断会有突破,但会很慢,因为拿DNA做实验太敏感。
访谈里他加了一个限定:这类进展对个体的意义,大于对整个人类文明的意义。这句话很关键,它划出了他的兴趣边界。
大学时他挑了三件事,一直做到现在
马斯克说,大学时期他认为有三件事最影响人类的未来:互联网、可持续能源、太空探索。前两个他已经下场,第三个是SpaceX。
主持人追问,为什么是这三件,不是医疗、教育、环境。他的回答很干脆:可持续能源就是环境问题,而且是我们面对的最大的环境问题。教育这一项他没有展开。
这个选择的逻辑在整场访谈里反复出现。他关心的不是人类某个具体的苦难,是人类这个物种的底层条件。底层条件决定了其他一切能走多远。
太空探索那一项,他给的定义更具体:把生命延伸到地球之外。
去火星的账,他算得很细
主持人问他想去哪儿,他说火星。主持人开玩笑说这辆面包车就能到。
去火星的理由他讲过很多遍,这次讲得比较完整。那是人类成为多行星物种最合适的地方,也是太阳系里最让人兴奋的目的地。
具体怎么去,他给了时间表。最初单程六个月,他认为能压到三个月以内,最终可能压到一个月以内。到了之后先建基地,人住在加压穹顶里。
再往后是改造整颗行星。办法听起来有点讽刺:往火星大气里排温室气体,把星球加热。这件事人类在地球上正在干,也正在为此吵架,而同样的物理规律在火星上可以反向使用。加热之后大气变厚,火星大气主要是二氧化碳,植物长起来就能把二氧化碳转成氧气。
第一棵植物怎么活?一个透明的加压穹顶,加一个从火星稀薄大气里抽气加压的泵,就够了。主持人问火星土壤能不能种地球植物,他说可以。
火星很冷,这个前提没变。温室本身就有温室效应,穹顶里还得有加热装置。主持人开玩笑说需要很多羽绒被,他接着往下讲,说温室配上空间加热器就行。
飞船会回来。他算过账:不回来太贵。人去火星是搬家,船是资产,资产必须复用。人可以回地球探亲,也可以选择不回来。
主持人问,第一个在火星出生的婴儿怎么办。马斯克说那会很了不得,也很吓人,那孩子压力太大了。第一个火星人。
他自己也想去。
关于SpaceX的定位,他专门强调过:这是一家商业公司,目标是推进火箭技术,让任何想去火星的人都能去,而不是只让马斯克去。谁掏钱?他提到政府,或者联合国这样的机构,为移民买单。
他把"多行星"排进了进化史的大事年表
为什么非要去火星?他给的理由跟浪漫无关,是概率。
他把人类成为多行星物种放进进化史的大事年表里比较:单细胞生命的出现、多细胞生命的出现、植物和动物的分化、生命从海洋登上陆地、哺乳动物、意识的诞生。他说,第一次有生命离开地球去另一颗行星,在这张表上的分量,至少和"从海洋到陆地"相当。
分量来自哪里?来自意识存续的概率。如果生命只在一个星球上,一次足够大的灾难就能把它清零。他列的清单:小行星撞击、超级火山、大规模核战争、超级病毒。
他补了一个更现实的判断。这类灾难未必一次性摧毁文明,更可能把文明打回低技术状态,然后在几代人的时间里慢慢衰退到灭绝。这比瞬间毁灭更难防,因为没人会为"缓慢下滑"拉警报。
两个星球,等于给意识上了个备份。
亿万富翁为什么支持遗产税
访谈里有一段讨论,放在今天看仍然少见。主持人夸他白手起家,说那些继承亿万家产的人让人想揍一拳。马斯克的回应是,从税收的角度,他确实认为税应该更多地向遗产税倾斜,而不是向活着的人收。
他的推理是这样的:一定量的税必须收,那么收在死亡那一刻,比收在生前更合理。一个人活着的时候已经证明了自己是资本的好管家,给他更多资本,他会拿去做更多有价值的事。继承人没有证明过任何东西,钱到他手上,效率就下降了。
他还提了一个附带效果:遗产税会推着人别光囤钱,去捐、去建基金会、去支持艺术,在生前把资产安排掉。钱最后是要给出去的,烂在地里没有意义。
更根本的担心是财富贵族化。他用的词是"aristocracy of wealth",财富的世袭贵族。
如果规则让资源锁在少数人手里,然后这些人确保资源只流向自己的孩子,那本质上就是封建制度。(马斯克)
他举了海地:六个家族掌握全国99%的财富,钱不往下流,也不往外走。在这种结构里,努力工作、创造伟大的东西都没有回报,因为回报通道被堵住了。
他对美国的评价是,在提供机会这件事上,美国是全世界做得最好的,但这种状态需要自觉维护,不会自动续期。
顺便说一句他的财富观。成为亿万富翁那天,并没有什么仪式。他开玩笑说,自己银行账户里并没有十亿美元躺着,所谓身家,是把各家公司的持股加总算出来的数字。
访谈开头还有一小段值得记下来。主持人问他在南非的军队经历,他纠正说没有,17岁就离开了,部分原因是为了避开种族隔离政权的征兵。
花两年时间去压制黑人,看起来不是个好的人生用途。我认为那可能是任何人一生中最糟糕的用法。(马斯克)
他说完,主持人接了一句"逃避兵役者",两个人都笑了。
这两段隔得很远,判断标准却是同一个:一件事值不值得占用一个人的时间,看它是在创造还是在压制。
气候争论,他说问题问反了
主持人提到气候变化的否认者。马斯克罕见地把话说得比较重。
他的观察是,很多人不信科学报告,信的是保守派电台主持人和某些电视台的评论员。
他认为争论被问错了方向。人们常问:我们怎么确定二氧化碳会导致全球变暖?而科学家面对"你确定吗"这类问题,通常会说没有什么是确定的,我们知道的确定的事很少。这个诚实的回答被拿去当成证据,证明科学界心虚。
正确的问法反过来了:我们怎么确定它不会导致全球变暖?
我们完全无法确定它不会。事实上科学界的压倒性共识是,二氧化碳正在导致全球变暖。考虑到石油迟早会用完,我们无论如何都必须找到可持续的能源生产和消费方式,跑这个实验没有任何意义。(马斯克)
他用的词是"愚蠢的实验"。往大气里灌几万亿吨二氧化碳,然后看会发生什么,而替代方案本来就非找不可。石油和煤炭是有限资源,这一点跟气候争论无关,是账本问题。
他甚至提了一个加分项:如果早一点转向可持续能源,我们有可能以快得多的速度修复大气。
喷气背包造得出来,但不会出现在洛杉矶上空
主持人问,说好的喷气背包呢。
马斯克说喷气背包和火箭背包其实已经有人做出来了,YouTube上就能看到,问题是它们老摔。他给了一个很具体的画面:如果洛杉矶上空全是喷气背包,天空会像一群小飞虫互相撞,还要互相加塞。而且人得不停抬头看天,防止有人从上面掉到你头上。
技术可行不等于能普及。真正的门槛在配套系统:空域怎么管,事故怎么处理,密度上去之后怎么保证安全。这类问题不是工程问题,是系统问题。这段话可以用来校准很多技术乐观主义的判断。
关于"现实版钢铁侠"这个称号,他的回应是,托尼·斯塔克没有五个孩子。他大部分空闲时间在加州的迪士尼乐园,而不是在开派对。飞行服他大概能造,造出来之后要干什么,他没想明白。
奇点之后的事,没人知道
主持人问奇点。马斯克先解释定义:人工智能超过人类智能的那个点。之所以叫奇点,是因为过了那个点之后会发生什么,没人能预测。
他描述的场景是:一台超级聪明的计算机,智能以一种失控的方式自我增长。
说完这句他就停了。访谈没有继续追问,他也没有展开风险论述。这一点要如实说清楚,否则容易把别处的观点移植过来。术语不是他造的,他也强调过。
他不太相信有个超级意识在给你打分
主持人问,你有精神生活吗。马斯克的第一个反应是反问,这个词指什么。
他自己给了分类。有人指宗教,一套很具体的东西;有人指瑜伽、水晶、冥想课,很模糊的一套;对他来说,指的是人身上超出物理和物质的那部分,而且比单纯的思想要多一点。
然后他把自己这个定义拆了。思想是物理的,是神经元在放电。至于思想究竟是什么,他说不确定。有没有某个维度是思想存在的形式,他不知道。
他不太相信的版本是:有一个超级意识,盯着我们的一举一动,拿一套标准打分,然后决定我们死后去哪儿。
那不太可能。我认为这非常不可能。(马斯克)
他倾向的解释是复杂性从简单性演化而来。简单的元素在时间里组合成更复杂的东西,最后成了我们。他甚至追问了一句:如果真有个超级意识,那个超级意识又是从哪来的。
另一个可能性他也没排除:我们在一个模拟里。
他给的论证不是哲学,是技术趋势。想想现在最先进的电子游戏已经逼真到什么程度,戴上头显就是另一个世界。我们完全可能是某个更高级存在游戏里的角色。
他拿暗物质和暗能量当论据,虽然带着点玩笑的味道。人类至今不知道这两个东西究竟是什么。而在一个模拟里,最底层的单位必须保持自洽,其他层可以随便设定,出现"我们算不出来但确实存在"的东西并不违和。
主持人接了一句,这也可以是天堂和地狱的另一种说法。马斯克顺着讲完:物理层面就像一个电子游戏,我们在里面觉得一切真实,就像我们在《使命召唤》里的那个角色,然后在八十岁那年被拔掉插头,进入另一个层面,回头一看,哦,那原来只是个游戏,我还以为是真的。
前三次火箭全炸了
主持人问他,给想改变世界的年轻人什么建议。
他的回答只有一句半:去干,直接去干。
他说人最常犯的错误是太害怕尝试,怕失败。其实不该怕。
主持人追问,你试过的事里有失败的吗。他说战争没输过,输过很多战役。猎鹰1号(Falcon 1)前三次发射,全部坠毁。
主持人问,那你哭了吗。他说没有。
这段对话很短,信息量在于时间线。三次连续失败,公司还能不能活下去,是SpaceX早期真实面对的问题。他没在访谈里展开,但"前三次都失败"这个事实本身,比任何励志话都有说服力。
快问快答里的几句真话
最后一段是快问快答,几个回答比长篇论述更能看出人。
他崇拜什么?他说不崇拜任何东西,但把自己投入到用技术推进人类这件事上。
技术永远无法替代什么?人的感受。
他是工作狂吗?他自己承认是,工作很多。
创造力从哪来?压力和必要性。
怎么放松?看电影、去派对、和朋友吃饭。他去过火人节(Burning Man),形容那是《疯狂的麦克斯》遇上拉斯维加斯,再遇上《爱丽丝梦游仙境》。他通常会搞装扮,穿达斯·维达(Darth Vader)的连体服。
外星有生命吗?他认为简单生命在别的星球上概率不小,复杂的、有意识的生命是另一回事。银河系里恒星数量以千亿计,这个数字摆在那里,他依然认为意识的概率低得多。他反问了一句:如果有意识,它在哪儿。
科学和宗教能共存吗?大概不能。
他祈祷吗?不祈祷。他得过疟疾,差点死掉,那时候也没祈祷。
你人生中最大的问题是什么?他绕回了《银河系漫游指南》:那本书给出的答案是42,但没人知道问题是什么。他纠结的是问题本身。
整场访谈看下来,他的答案有个统一的形状。把人类当成一个物种来看,把时间拉到几百万年,把问题反过来问,然后把手弄脏。面包车后座上的那两个小时,讲的其实是同一件事。
如果你只带走几件事
- 换一个问法。面对有争议的判断,把"我怎么确定它会发生"换成"我怎么确定它不会发生"。马斯克用这个句式处理气候争论,同样的句式可以用在你的技术选型、投资决策和风险评估上。
- 把失败次数写进计划。猎鹰1号前三次发射全部坠毁,公司还在。做长期项目时,先算清楚自己能承受几次失败,而不是默认一次成功。
- 判断技术能不能普及,去看配套系统。喷气背包造得出来,空域管理和事故处理跟不上,它就只能是YouTube视频。评估一个新技术,问的是周边的规则、基础设施和成本结构能不能承载它。
- 把时间投在改变底层条件的地方。互联网、能源、太空,这三件事他大学时就选定,然后用二十年去做。选方向时看它是否改变别人做事的前提,别只看当下的热度。
- 主动安排恢复时间。他自己承认是工作狂,但放松方式是看电影、和朋友吃饭、去火人节,而不是继续开会。压力和必要性给他创造力,恢复时间给他续航。
- 定期回头确认题目。《银河系漫游指南》给了答案42,没人记得问题是什么。手上有答案的时候,先确认一下题目有没有搞错。
0:14well well well welcome to my talk show [Music] tasty chicken burger sure you may be a billionaire yeah entrepreneur inventor man extraordinaire you're not getting any of my chicken burger all right nope no problem i can i can do without the chicken burger that's so good elon musk yeah what is it like to be named after the scent of a of a of an animal it certainly led to a lot of marking in in junior high i know what that feels like my name is ryan right can you imagine if you were named rain musk right it's raining musk i mean you grew up in south africa yeah you you were in the army there no no i left at 17.
1:39well in in part in order to avoid conscription into these selections so that you didn't have to do the army you know spending two years suppressing black people didn't seem to be a great use of time i think that's probably the worst use of any human being's time right so good for you right right on elon musk draft dodger i guess the first question is you're the founder of tesla motors right can i have a car yes for free no what if i told you that i will not let you out of the van unless you give me a car for free next question now what was that like when all of a sudden like you're a millionaire you're a millionaire you're working your butt off you're creating
2:26these software companies you're developing paypal and then all of a sudden like that needle goes blank and you're a billionaire did you ever go like did you have like a party did you blow a party favor like when you became a billion did your accountant call you and like guess what elon you went from millionaire to billionaire not really no no i i mean it's not as though i've got like a billion dollars just sitting in a bank account or something it just means that that my ownership of the companies if you add them up you know it's a couple billion dollars right it's pretty awesome in that you earned it and you made it yourself right i didn't i did
3:04not inheritance yeah i did not and that's so cool because people that inherit their billions i just want to punch them in the thing right right i mean actually i do i do think that from taxation standpoint it's better if taxes are focused on it's on estate taxes when somebody dies as opposed to taxes when somebody's living ah okay so you're in favor of a high estate tax i mean given that there's a certain amount of tax that must be raised it's i think it's better to obtain that tax upon death than right during during life you know if if somebody's demonstrated that they are a good steward of capital then they you know they want to have more capital
3:46in order to do more good things with the economy but if somebody's inherited money then they have not demonstrated that they are a good steward of capital and so it's it's less it makes less sense that they inherit money also it i always think that then it urges them to not just stockpile their money but to give it away charitable foundations or or art or or gifts or there's a whole manner of things that you can do foundations in your estate planning you know if you've stockpiled all that all that money yeah absolutely you know it's it's really there to give it away what good is it when you're rotting in the ground yeah absolutely and and also i
4:20think we want to avoid creating aristocracy of wealth you know that's where this you want to avoid having entrenchment of wealth and i think that leads to stagnation of society and why is that well if if the rules are set up such that you know somebody can't make headway you know because the resources are constrained to a small number of people and and then they ensure that it only goes to their kids which is essentially the feudal system right then you know there's not much point in working hard or or trying to create great things because you know there's no reward for that and there's a lot of countries that are like that some say the united states
5:03is like that but in a lot of ways it's not really there are a lot of countries where it's just it's locked up by like in haiti there's six families right that own 99 of the wealth right right and the wealth is not trickling down it's not going anywhere it's just staying in those families right and the united states i think is actually the the best in the world in terms of enabling opportunity but but we need to be conscious of retaining that that status right on where you want to go anywhere anywhere in the universe mars mars
5:41wow we're there and you didn't even need a spaceship you just needed a van yeah why did you want to go to mars well the reason i want to go to mars is because i think that's the best place where humanity can can become a multi-planet species and a space breaking civilization and i think it's it's the most exciting place that we could go in the solar system now how would that work for people to go to mars like what would happen what happened you mean once we were there well like like describe to me that process so a bunch of people to get on a spaceship what happened talk me through mars travel well we you need to have a big spaceship that takes you awhile
6:18it'll take initially six months to get there although i think we can bring that down under to under three months and maybe eventually under a month and then you have to land on mars and establish a base there and initially people would have to live in pressurized domes but over time you could you could tear from the planet and make it like earth so you could do how would you terraform mars you'd actually heat the planet up by emitting greenhouse gases kind of the what we're doing on earth we're learning a lot about that here on earth so we would just do that on mars and that would warm the planet up it would thicken the atmosphere and then the atmosphere in mars is carbon dioxide
6:56so as you grow plants the plants would convert the carbon dioxide into oxygen how could you plant the first plant on mars how would that work well you'd have to initially have plants in a pressurized transparent dome but all you need is a transparent dominar and a pump to to pressurize it from the mars atmosphere so you can grow you can grow earth plants in water soil you can grow earth plants in mars soil that's correct but it's cold over there on mars isn't it right so you have to warm it up you need a lot of down comforters over there yeah you need to but if you have a a greenhouse sort of a space heaters well the greenhouse is a greenhouse effect
7:34right so it's like it's just like greenhouses that's fantastic and then what do the humans do when they're there well i think initially all or what initially people would would work on creating a mars base and and creating the infrastructure necessary sport life on on mars so that would take a lot of effort just just as it took a lot of effort to establish the american colonies now does the ship come back yeah when you go to mars are you gonna go like i'm gonna die on mars so you take healthy people that are just gonna plan on living the rest of their 30 or 40 years on mars or something like that well most most people would actually i think most people would go to mars to
8:11move to mars but the space ships would come back because otherwise would be way too expensive to travel to mars so people could choose to come back to if they want or come back to earth for for a visit or something like that would you imagine the first baby born on mars right that would be huge that would be freaky right a lot of pressure for that poor kid right the first martial the first martian that's right would you go to mars yeah yeah i would like to go to mars but but the reason for spacex is to enable anyone who goes to mars or anyone who wants to to go to mars so we want to enable people to go to mars you know governments or the world government
8:46would you know united nations or something like that would would pay to get the people over there because spacex is a for-profit company obviously so spacex is with the goal of advancing rocket technologies so that eventually we could travel to mars and and and establish a base on mars and make life multi-planetary because i think that's one of the most important things that we could accomplish in fact i think it's important enough that would actually fit on the scale of evolution itself if you consider the the major elements on the scale of evolution past being the advent of single-celled life multicellular life differentiation of plants and animals
9:23life going from the oceans to land mammals and consciousness those are probably the big ones but i think on that on that scale would also fit life becoming multi-planetary for the first time you know i think it's perhaps at least as important as lacrosse from the oceans to land and it would i think preserve the light of consciousness you know the consciousness the probability of consciousness existing for a long time would be much greater if we're on two planets if something catastrophic would have happened to earth then it would you know life would still exist on another planet i mean let's say there was a a giant meteor impact or a super volcano or
10:01you know we had sort of a massive nuclear war on earth or right some super virus right you know i mean there could be something that that doesn't necessarily initially destroy human civilization but knocks it back to a much lower technology technology level right and and and then there's sort of a decline to eventual extinction so i i totally believe in science i mean science isn't something you believe in it's something that just is but it just you had referenced kind of the reverse climate change but what drives me crazy is the climate change deniers and what what is up with that is it just becomes so politicized that they just have stopped believing scientists that's
10:42what drives me crazy is that people don't believe scientific reports they believe conservative am radio disc jockeys and certain you know fox news reporters instead of scientists right i mean it's it's it's i think it's it's problematic and i think often that the rate is is phrased in the wrong way because they'll often say well how do we know for certain that co2 emissions cause global warming and if you ask a scientist do you know anything for certain they will generally say well no we don't know if we're certain or we don't know we know hardly anything for certain right but but that's that's not the right question the question is really do we know that it won't cause global
11:24warming and and we absolutely do not know it won't cause global warming in fact it's quite the overwhelming opinion among the scientific community is that co2 is causing global warming and given that we will run out of oil anyway and must find a sustainable means of generating energy and and consuming energy it it makes no sense to run this experiment you know wow it's we're going to run out of oil and coal these these are finite resources sure so why not look for those alternate resources and right and and also potentially heal the planet's atmosphere at a much faster rate yeah it just doesn't make yeah it doesn't make any sense to to consume to
12:15to put trillions and tons of co2 in atmosphere and see what happens which could be catastrophic when we have to find a non- hydrocarbon based way of generating and consuming energy anyway so it's just a dumb experiment now you have said that there are three main problems that you are focused on the most what are those three right so well there were three winners in college i thought there were three things that most affect the future of humanity and those were the internet sustainable energy and space exploration so those three things would they're not problems per se but they're the three things that will affect humanity the most right exactly the things that that would
12:59and in in a good way if they're so right yeah internet energy and space exploration yeah and specifically extending life beyond earth now why did you choose those three things and not health care education and the environment sustainable energy is about the environment it's the biggest environmental issue that we face and so with respect to healthcare the real problem is not it's not curing any any one particular disease it's actually that we have a natural kind of age limit if you will which is around 80.
13:33that that's that's the the a human being is essentially genetically programmed to die around age 80. and the cause of death will will vary but it's it's just because you're having multiple organ failure your immune system isn't working well anymore and you're suffering from dementia you're just going to die around around 80 on average maybe 80 you know maybe that'll creep up to the sort of 85 sure level but that's that's really it in fact if we cured all cancer the average lifespan would only increase by like two years did you just i have heart disease or right over any number of yeah exactly you just start falling apart in your 70s and things just start falling apart
14:13right i mean all creatures have a natural lifespan that is built into their dna so you know for instance fruit flies live live i think a few weeks right and it really doesn't matter can you reprogram the dna well then you get in there and do that and reprogram human beings to live 250. we'll see that that's essentially what would have to happen is is in order to live longer and particularly live longer in in a sort of good way a healthy way healthy healthy way and not you know not just decrepid living in an old food right i mean you could be on like life support you know where you can't move and you've got one functioning neuron that's that's not fun
14:48right but but but so we'd have to reprogram the dna in order to live longer in a healthy way and so that's that's probably the that that that that's an area where i think there's likely to be breakthroughs but it's going to take a while because of the sensitivity of experimenting with dna right and so i do think that that's also an area that that'll have a big effect but it'll have more effect on individual lives than on humanity collectively gotcha now you have been called real life tony stark you're inventing lots of cool new stuff what does that feel like well i guess elements of it are true although i mean tony stark doesn't have five kids so i get you know
15:34most i spend more time at like disney world than or disneyland really in california that than i do you know having parties and stuff you know i like having parties i could probably make a flying suit but you know i think you could make a flying suit and you're making solar power sure what are you thinking i think i mean there's no strange i mean what would i do with the flying suits i mean i could tell you a thousand things to do with the flying suit you fly around in it it would look awesome it would look awesome you could blow up things i i i'd probably be locked up hey listen i thought that we were going to be flying around in jet packs now right can
16:14you be the guy can you make the jet packs please i mean people actually have made jack jet packs and rocket packs i've seen them on youtube but they crash all the time that's the problem see it's like you can't have random people flying around with jet packs because they'll crash like crash on you but could you imagine the air in los angeles if there were jet packs right it would just be like it would be swarms of gnats bumping into each other and people going right i mean people cutting each other off it would be awful if if somebody crashes you know that you know you have to be constantly looking up in case somebody's with a jet pack lands on you that's true
16:48yeah okay have a dodgy situation yeah so what do you think about the singularity well so the singularity is is what singularity that that's that's the point where artificial intelligence exceeds human intelligence and the reason it's called singularity and i think greco as well coined that term is because after that we don't know what's going to happen you know we'll what will happen you know if you've got some sort of super smart computer that's increasing into intelligence in kind of a runaway fashion do you have a spiritual life well it sort of depends on what spiritual means but what do you think spiritual means i mean it is one of those words that kind of needs to be
17:34defined for everyone some people it's like they're religion and it's a very specific kind of thing for some people it's a very vague kind of yoga and crystals and meditation classes and stuff like that and for me it is the life of the human being that's beyond the physical and the material that also is a little bit more than just thought cause we have thoughts right but those are physical because there's neurons that are bouncing around right so i mean i mean maybe there's some some dimension where thoughts exist or something because i don't you know what is a thought and what is it i mean is it i mean i'm not sure what what thoughts are you know whether there's
18:16some some manifestation of thought in in a way that you know it's different from the physical dimensions we're aware we're aware of and there's certainly things that we don't understand about the universe but you know i'm i'm less convinced that there's say some some super consciousness watching over our every movement and kind of evaluating it against some criteria you know and deciding whether we're going to go to one place or another when we die that's unlikely right i i think that's very unlikely right too that's i i personally do believe in god but i don't define god in that way i would define god as closer to being like science right or the energy of the
19:02laws that propel science because science really quantifies so what is it quantifying yeah yeah exactly i mean and and it does beg the question if there is some super consciousness of consciousness where did the super consciousness come from and so i think the most likely explanation is that complexity evolved from simplicity you know that the simple elements over time combine to become more complex and arrive to what we are it's also possible though that we're in a simulation yeah we're in a simulation like the matrix yeah well different from the matrix but a simulation of sorts yeah well this whole world could be a dream it could be a dream yeah
19:51yeah but i mean it could be a simulation i mean have you ever ever played like these foot like the most the advanced video games and how how realistic they were getting i know there it's it is like a whole nother it is like a whole nother life right with the goggles and everything 3d and every yeah all that stuff it could be that you know that's that's that's what we know to be with maybe we're some some of the creatures avatar you're blowing my mind you deal with so much stuff i mean you deal with space travel and energy and the source of consciousness and you're thinking about all of these giant life's big questions what blows your mind what gives you awe
20:32well i think that i mean the the nature of the universe gives me more and and just the huge expanse of the universe and here's how far away things are and how big they are and the fact that there are things like supermassive black holes that are equal to a billion suns what about dark matter doesn't that freak you out too yeah and dark matter is also i mean i don't matter dog energy are are kind of interesting because mean i'm not sure what those actually are you know people don't know what those actually are and it's particularly dark energy in fact this is why you know that may be an argument for this being a simulation because in a simulation
21:15you wouldn't you know you could just make things be however you want the the lowest unit will have to be consistent but that could be a great argument for heaven and earth and it's another way of looking at it is that this physical plane is like a video game and we're down here thinking it's very real just like our avatars do in you know call of duty or whatever game we're we're playing and then we get unplugged in our 80s and then we're onto some other plane or some other reality right where we go oh that was just a video game right that whole time and i thought it was real yeah what would you say to young people that want to change the world that have big
21:54ideas what advice could you give i would say you know go do it just just go out there and and and do it the i mean the biggest thing i think people fail to do is that they're they're too afraid to try things that they shouldn't be afraid of of failing and and they should just go and do it did you fail at anything that you tried i i've lost i mean i've not lost a war but i've lost battle certainly yeah i mean the first three flights of of the falcon 1 rocket that crashed wow that must have been a big bummer there was big brother did you cry no i'll make you cry with the new lightning round from soul pancake do you own my book no i don't you suck okay what do you worship
22:43well i don't really worship anything but i do devote myself to the advancement of humanity using technology what can technology never replace i think human feeling are you a workaholic i suppose i am i work a lot what fuels your creativity pressure necessity what do you do to unplug and relax well i like doing like going to the movies i like going to parties having dinner with friends i get a bunny man that's pretty fun did you go to burning man sure what do you do there just it's just like a crazy sort of mad max meets vegas meets us in wonderland do you put on a hippie wig no i usually have some kind of costume i wear a soft vader ones do you believe there's life
23:27on other planets i think there's a good chance that this simple life on other planets it's much more of a question as to whether there's complex life like consciousness with all the trillions of stars and all those trillions of planets you don't think that isn't that an arrogant statement to say we're probably the most evolved in all of the universe well no i'm not saying that we probably are just i think that the chances of of consciousness are much much lower particularly in our galaxy you know because we have to ask the question if there's consciousness where is it can science and religion coexist probably not do you pray i don't i didn't even pray when i when i
24:05almost died of malaria wow that's really not praying right so you put your money where your bug spray was yeah what's your life's big question what's the big question you personally wrestle with well i mean i i guess i i i wrestled with the the question of of what is the question you know like from the hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy the answer is the universe what's the question one of the world's greatest entrepreneurs is here in the back of my van what's your big ideas what how do you want to be an entrepreneur what kind of passion or dream do you want to pursue to make the world a better place to take humanity to the next level can you upload it on a video or write it down in
24:49the comments below i'll tell you what i'll give you a bite if you give me a tesla sounds like a good deal [Laughter] subscribe
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版