2016年2月,巴黎。马斯克上台做的第一件事是道谢,第二件事是报数字:特斯拉去年一共造了5万辆车。
这个数字放在汽车工业里是什么分量?丰田、通用、大众,随便哪一家的年产量都是它的二十倍上下。换算下来,特斯拉的产能只有它们的5%。
他说媒体给了特斯拉很多注意力,可公司规模还很小,能一路走过来,靠的是台下这批人。
特斯拉能成功,唯一的理由是有像你们这样的人在支持。(马斯克)
这场问答持续了一个多小时。他两天只睡了一个小时,讲话时不时卡壳,麦克风换了三次才调好。内容密度却很高:Model 3 的时间表、自动驾驶的两年之约、充电功率的天花板在哪、欧洲工厂的选址逻辑、和法国财长聊了什么、怎么看待苹果造车。下面按主题拆开讲。
5万辆车,5%的产量
开场他先聊了和法国的缘分。高中在南非读的,外语课选的是法语,学得一般,现在只能慢慢想起来。巴黎是他离开南非后去的第一个外国城市,父亲带他来的,那年他6岁。
那是他第十五次左右来巴黎。他对这座城市的好感持续了三十年,讲话里也没藏着。
然后进入正题。Model S 当时的生产节奏是每周1000辆,Model X 正在往同样的水平爬坡,目标是2016年第二季度达到每周1000辆。欧洲的 Model X 交付定在当年夏天,已经下单的客户最晚等到夏天。
顺手报了一句 Powerwall 和 Powerpack 的进度:全球有很多试点在跑,数据不错,第二代 Powerwall 大概在七八月发布,能力会有一次台阶式的提升。
Model X:一辆"不该被设计出来"的车
说到 Model X,他的原话很不客气。
我不确定这辆车该不该被设计出来,因为它太难造了。但你拿到手之后,会真的喜欢它,我觉得它很特别。(马斯克)
这句话听起来像自嘲,实际是在承认一个工程事实:Model X 把太多新东西塞进了同一代产品里。鹰翼门、电动座椅、超大挡风玻璃,每一样单独看都是加分项,叠在一起就变成了产线噩梦。交付延迟、供应商掉链子,2016年上半年的产能爬坡被拖得很辛苦。
他还是给了一个明确的判断:Model X 作为一台 SUV,相对同级别对手的领先幅度,比 Model S 作为一台轿车相对同级别对手的领先幅度更大。他在现场演示过两辆车并排停得很近,鹰翼门照样能打开。
台下有人问法国停车场的层高只有1.9米,门打不开怎么办。他说车门设计时就是按极窄车位算的,横向和顶部需要的空间比看上去小很多。不想自己停,还有召唤功能,让车自己停进去。
Model 3 学乖了:功能一年加一点
Model X 的教训,马斯克当场承认了,并且给出了具体做法。
我们会刻意限制 Model 3 的新功能数量,跟 Model X 相比,这样是为了避免重复同样的错误。之后每一年我们都会往 Model 3 里加东西,而不是把所有的东西都塞进第一年。(马斯克)
这段话背后的逻辑值得所有做硬件的人抄下来。新功能不是免费的,每一个都要走完设计、验证、供应链、产线工艺、售后这几道关。一次上十个,出问题的概率按乘法叠加,交期就崩了。一年上两个,产线熟练度还能跟着涨。
Model 3 的量产启动时间点,他说会尽力贴近2017年底。他自己对这台车的评价是"我非常满意,人们会爱上这台车"。
至于外观,3月底会放出第一批照片。他特意补了一句:不会一次性展示全部,真要看清这台车,得等到接近量产的时候。
自动驾驶:两年后不用碰方向盘,最坏三年
他问台下有多少人经常用 Autopilot,举手的人不少。接着问,升级到7.1之后有没有感觉变好,回答也是肯定的。
然后是他给出的能力边界,说得很具体:现有的硬件套件,就能做到高速公路上的近乎完美控制,即使前方没有车可以参考;在有前车可跟的任何路况里,也能做到近乎完美。团队同时在补地图方案,这块是短板。
真正的时间表出现在后面。他说大约两年内,Model 3 会配上完全自动驾驶。台下有人追问"完全"是什么意思,他的定义很干脆:不需要任何人工干预。
大概两年,最坏情况三年。技术层面是这个时间,监管批准是另一条独立的轨道。(马斯克)
这个区分很重要。技术成熟和合法上路是两件事,前者由工程师决定,后者由监管机构决定。工程师给不出监管的时间表,谁也给不出。
他也承认现阶段的短板:乡下的弯道,Autopilot 表现不好。
充电时间的物理天花板:锂离子在找车位
有人问充电速度还能不能更快。他先报了功率的演进:最早的超级充电桩是90千瓦,后来120千瓦,当时是135千瓦,未来可能往180到200千瓦走。
但功率不是唯一的瓶颈。他列了三个变量:电芯化学、车内部的线束、充电桩的实际输出功率。其中电芯化学是最难啃的。
把充电时间往下压,难度几乎是指数级上升的。你可以把它想成一队锂离子在找停车位,电池空的时候到处都是空位,越满空位越少。你要是硬塞,它们就会撞在一起出事。(马斯克)
这个比喻把电化学讲得比任何图表都清楚。所以从20分钟压到15分钟,看起来只省了5分钟,工程难度是一次跃迁。
他给出的现实目标:15到20分钟充完,续航够你开4个小时。后面还补了一句大实话:开4个小时,你本来也该下车了。
续航500公里以上,多出来的电池是负担
台下有人喊700、800公里。他的回应是反问:"你想要多少续航?"
接着讲了物理约束:电池包越大,平时不开长途的时候,你就在天天拖着一坨没用的重量跑。真正要找的是一个平衡点,够应付日常通勤和偶尔的长途,又不至于把一半容量永远闲置。
团队试过一些偏门方案,比如挂一个带辅助电池包的拖车,像小房车那样。他自己的判断是,直接扩大电池包容量更实际。至于上限,超过500到550公里,基本上就不需要更多了。他也不认为会看到每一代产品续航都稳步上涨这种局面。
有人问能不能在车顶铺太阳能板补电。他算了笔账:车顶可用面积2到3平方米,峰值功率大概600瓦,前提还得是停在户外、没有遮挡、阳光直射。这个量级对给车充电来说太慢,意义不大。
还有人问能不能把车当家庭备用电源。早期的 Roadster 原型车确实做过这个功能,后来放弃了。原因很实在:家里那侧的电路会变得很复杂,电工不知道车什么时候会往电网里灌电,这有安全隐患;车主要出门的时候,家里的灯就得灭。他的结论是,固定式储能电池包和电动车各司其职,才是正确做法。
超级充电桩对所有人开放,除了那个插头
第一个问题是充电网络覆盖。他给的答案是:2016年6月之前,法国境内任意两点之间都能靠超级充电桩跑通,整个西欧也差不多。
然后有人问,会不会对其它车厂开放。他的回答很直接:
超级充电网络的目标从来就不是建一座围墙,也不是要拿它当对付其它公司的竞争优势。特斯拉的使命是推动可持续交通的到来,所以只要别的厂商想用,我们的网络就对他们开放。(马斯克)
他还说会加装欧洲标准插头,别的品牌来充电不用带特斯拉转接头,站里两种接口并存。
紧接着他抱怨了一句欧标插头:太大了,插拔手感不好。他说自己亲自去找过欧盟专员反映这件事,最后也没改成。
欧洲工厂:阿尔萨斯是玩笑,欧洲工厂不是
法国听众最关心的当然是工厂。有人问,法国有优秀的工程师,巴黎北边有大片现成的厂房,为什么不在这儿造车,听说你要去德国、去荷兰?
他的回答从全局开始。当时特斯拉只有一座整车工厂(加州的弗里蒙特),荷兰那座规模很小。要扩产,逻辑上应该在中国建一座、欧洲建一座。百万辆级别的工厂需要大片土地和足够大的劳动力池,这两样在欧洲不是随便哪里都能凑齐。
然后他开了个玩笑:为了让欧洲尽可能多的国家高兴,也许可以把工厂放在阿尔萨斯,一半在德国一半在法国。他特意声明这不是预测,只是现场瞎想。
玩笑之后是正题。
欧洲在汽车制造、工程和设计上的人才储备非常深厚。老实说,我觉得比美国更深、更丰富。所以我们一定会做这件事,只是时间和细节的问题。(马斯克)
长期来看,欧洲同时会有工程团队和生产基地。这一点他说得很死。至于为什么要把车造在加州再运到欧洲,他的原话是"这太疯狂了"。
油价跌了,受伤最重的不是特斯拉
2014年底开始油价腰斩,2016年初还在低位。有人问他怎么看对电动车的影响。
他没有回避:油价大幅下跌,对所有类型的电动车销量都会有负面影响。但影响程度不一样。特斯拉的产品差异化足够大,受冲击最小。日产和雪佛兰那些电动车型,外观和驾驶感受跟自家汽油版几乎没差别,消费者买的理由就是省钱。油价一便宜,经济账算不过来,产品本身又没有不可替代的地方,销量自然顶不住。
这段话其实给出了一个判断产品抗周期能力的框架:如果你的产品存在的唯一理由是"更便宜",那你的护城河就是价格差,价格差一消失,客户就散了。
投屏、召唤、法语口音:三件软件小事
手机投屏这件事,他说大概年中能上。难点不在投屏本身,在于 iPhone 和 Android 的接口没有想象中好用,能投画面,但投不了触控,用户看得见摸不着。
他给的理由很有说服力:指望第三方开发者为只有几十万用户的车上系统写应用,不现实;手机上有几亿用户,那才是开发者愿意去的地方。所以车机必须接手机,不能跟手机对着干。
召唤功能在欧洲卡在监管上。他解释,即使是在私人用地上使用,欧洲也要求监管机构明确批准。特斯拉在跟荷兰 RDW 这个主管机构沟通,一起把可接受的边界划出来。按现行条文,召唤在技术上是不被允许的,所以只能想办法去满足监管的本意。他估计两到三周能推下去,但这不取决于特斯拉。
最后一个问题很扎心:语音控制非要美国口音才认,法国人用不了。他愣了一下,承认根本不知道有这个问题,然后说这个很好修,下周就跟团队提。
和法国财长聊的:汽油车一直在拿隐形补贴
他前一天见了法国财政部长米歇尔·萨潘(Michel Sapin)。评价相当高,说对方非常聪明、阅读广、思考深入,是他见过的政治家里面排得上号的。
聊的核心是一笔账。
每一辆汽油车,实际上都在接受补贴。因为它没有为排放的二氧化碳、硫氧化物、氮氧化物付钱。这笔污染成本由公众承担了。(马斯克)
所以他给政府提了两条路。上策是征碳税,经济学界研究这个题目的人基本都同意碳税是合理的做法。碳税推不动,退而求其次,给电动车的补贴至少要跟汽油车隐形成本打平,否则这是一场起跑线完全不同的比赛。政府在这件事里的角色是规则制定者和裁判员,规则歪了,比赛就没法看。
他说财长听进去了。至于会不会真做,还得看。
财长还问了一件很实际的事:特斯拉的工厂到底可能放在哪,在法国建厂有什么障碍。马斯克说他给了坦率的反馈,具体内容属于私下对话。
苹果造车与四个中国背景的对手
有人问怎么看苹果进入电动车领域。他的态度是欢迎:苹果有钱,有很强的电子工程能力,这是好事。但他判断苹果要拿出量产车还得等一段时间,原因在制造方式上。
苹果习惯把生产外包出去,但汽车这个行业,没有一种好的外包方式。(马斯克)
这句话点出了消费电子和汽车之间最难跨越的一条沟。手机代工的良率和节拍可以靠人力堆,汽车的冲压、焊装、涂装、总装是一条以百亿计的产线,供应商体系、质量体系、召回责任,全都不可能像组装耳机那样切出去。
至于竞争对手,他点了几家:在美国,有四个资金规模在十亿美元以上的中国背景电动车创业公司,Faraday、Atieva、NextEV,还有原名叫 Fisker 后来改名的 Karma。竞争确实不少。
他的应对方式是不看别人。
我基本上不关注竞争对手在干什么。我关注的是,我们得做什么才能让车足够有吸引力。把车做好,别的都是结果。(马斯克)
AI 会不会让他睡不着
有人问得很直接:你怕人工智能怕到晚上睡不着觉吗?
偶尔会因为人工智能失眠。但大多数睡不着的时候,是因为工作压力。(马斯克)
他接着说了立场:需要对 AI 保持警惕,不能默认它一定会往好的方向走。可以想象出它很好的未来,也可以想象出它很糟的未来。所以态度应该是谨慎,别假设太多。
这段回答没有展开论证,2016年他还没有把这个问题讲成后来那套完整框架。但这个判断在当年已经成型了。
顺便说一句,有人问火星上有没有超级充电桩。他的回答是希望有,然后自己笑了。也有人问怎么才能去现场看火箭发射,他说不需要 SpaceX 的任何许可,上官网查时间,自己去卡纳维拉尔角的堤坝上找个位置就行。任务控制室进不去,那里连内部员工都限制得很严。
写在最后
把这场问答重新读一遍,会有一种时间错位感。2016年他说的很多时间表,事后看都推后了:Model 3 量产比2017年底晚了将近一年,完全自动驾驶的两年之约变成了一个至今还在讨论的问题,欧洲工厂最终落在德国勃兰登堡,是2020年才宣布的事。
但那些关于"怎么做"的判断,反而经得起时间。功能要一代一代加,别一次堆完;产品必须有不可替代的理由,不能只靠便宜;产能布局要看人才密度和供应链深度,不看哪个政府给的笑脸多;技术上能做到、法规上被允许,是两条独立的线。
这些东西比时间表有用得多。时间表会滑,方法论不会。
对做技术和产品的人来说,这场问答里能直接拿走的东西有这几条:
- 做硬件路线图时,把新功能拆到多代产品里。Model X 的教训是每多一个未验证的新部件,交期风险按乘法放大,加法在这里不成立。第一代先保证能稳定量产,功能留给后续年度改款。
- 评估任何产品,先问它存在的理由是不是只有"更便宜"。油价一跌就卖不动的电动车,和补贴一退就消失的生意,属于同一个问题。去找那个不随外部价格波动的价值点。
- 看性能指标要找边际收益递减点。续航超过500到550公里,多出来的电池变成日常负担;充电从20分钟压到15分钟,成本指数级上升。做取舍时先算这条曲线在哪拐弯。
- 面对生态问题,别跟平台对抗。特斯拉做手机投屏,理由是开发者的时间在手机上,不可能为小用户量平台单独写应用。你的产品要长在用户已经待着的地方。
- 区分技术可行和合规可行。召唤功能在技术上早就跑通了,卡在欧洲的监管条文上。排期时把监管审批当成一条独立的关键路径,别混进工程进度里。
- 算成本时把外部性算进去。汽油车没有为污染付费,这笔账由公众承担了。用同样的方法审视自己的行业,你会找到很多别人没算进报表的成本,那往往是机会。
- 别假设新技术天然向善。对 AI 这类能力,把"它大概会没事"当成默认选项,是一种偷懒。具体做法是提前把失效模式想清楚,等它发生就晚了。
- 调低竞争分析的时间配比。马斯克说他不看对手在干什么,只看自己的车够不够好。可以不完全照做,但至少把八成精力放在产品本身,两成放在对手身上。
0:14[Music] super [Applause] welome to friends welcome to friend [Applause] want to say first of all thank you very much for coming out tonight and and for your support of Tesla the only reason Tesla is successful as is successful at all is because of people like you so yeah you know tends like
1:25it's a lot of attention in the press and everything but as you guys know we're a small company we made 50,000 cars last year that's 5% as many cars as say toyoto General Motors or VW and yeah so so really the reason we are able to make progress and keep growing is with the support of people like so you guys are really Inc difficult to makeing it happen and I just want to say thank you from thank you [Applause]
2:07your isn't working is my that's better yes much better few in fres got well in in high school I mean I I was is a big kind of friends actually the why because it's great but in high school you have to pick a a foreign language in in sou Africa where I was growing up and my choice was French so a high school French which comes back to me slowly but you know it's usually being able to say things like
2:58better in Spanish true I do and actually France was Paris was the first place I visited outside of South Africa my father brought me here when I was 6 years old so I've love Paris for a long time probably this is probably my 50th 15th and yeah so it's been been a lot and yeah so like I said thanks for all your support I I can give you sort of a general update on the company and and kind of where things ahead it and then I'd love to just hear get into a dialogue you know just back and forth get me with questions whatever questions you have on your mind and I'll try to answer them to the best of my ability with without hopefully creating some silly news
3:55headline yeah something quite a lot so yeah so where we are right [Music] now microphone so we've got the model S in production at about 1,000 units a week and we're trying to ramp up the model X to roughly a comparable number of a th000 units a week and hopefully we should be at that at that production level around well close maybe sometime coming Q2 of this year so for those of you who have a model exent order I've expected you may wondering where's my car coming I think it's probably the summer is the most likely
4:45I'm yeah so I think the mod x the model X is much better this better much better thank you I'm not sure that anyone should have built or designed this car because it's so difficult to make but I think if you do get it you're really going to love it it's it's I mean it's I think it's something
5:24special [Music] well the honest answer is I think the the x is a better SUV than the S is a sedan yeah so it's it's quite remarkable if you've seen if you saw the model X demo we drove two cars really close together and you can open the Valk doors yeah I have seen that was just question of you know how tall have you seen the French parking lots 1 M 90 Li minut yeah but it's it
5:58it's designed to work in very very tight spots so I think I think it should work pretty well and then of course there's the summon and unsummon capability so if you don't want to park the car yourself you can basically have Park yourself you can just have the car park yeah sorry and I'll get bug down in
6:19questions but let's see so anyway just going over the big picture U Model X production in terms of significant deliveries this summer in in Europe then the model 3 is under development I'm pretty happy with how that's turning out which we're we're going to constrain the the number of new features in the model 3
6:51compared to say the X in order to avoid repeating the same mistake so we'll have you know with each success of year we'll introduce more things into the model 3 as opposed to trying to file it all in in one year we trying to stay stay as close as possible to our end 2017 St production but based on where and I
7:11feel really good about the model 3 I think it's I think people are going to love that car and then another big push is towards autonomy making the water pilot features more and more capable mic oh sorry so making the the the autopilot features more and more capable I'm not sure how many people how many people hear viewed s pilot all the time okay great great and yeah so did you notice improvements going to 7.1 yes yeah okay great yeah so
7:53I think the even with the the current Hardware Suites I think we will see significant improvements to the autopilot basically what it'll be capable of doing is near perfect control on freeways even where there's no cars and near propriate control in any traffic situation where it's tracking a vehicle so that's
8:25hello yeah so that's going to get better one of the things we also working on is the mapping solution and if I seem a little ragged by the way it's I literally had 1 hour of sleep in the last 48 hours so sorry so the I think that result is you know basically in about 2 years we should have model 3 plus full autonomy yeah quite transformative so three have yeah doesn't work so well in the country it it's the current water pilot does not work on windy roads in the countryside L what do you mean by full autonomy yeah full autonomy no here intervention require okay
9:38option probably two years worst case 3 years that's a differ regulatory approval is is a separate track but in terms of if it being technologically done it's in the two to two to three year time and then we've got the the the power wall and power pack we have a lot of Trials underway right now around the world seeing very good results and then we're expecting to come up with a verion to you got to keep it close Okay like feels like eat the mic the the we'll be coming out with version two of the power wall probably around July August this year which we'll see further step change in
10:34capabilities yeah at a high level that's kind of where where things are I'm happy to answer questions s in Rapid Fire [Music] sucession thank youan we are really honored to have you there we have honor from all across France as you can see and I'm sure most of them would like to ask you a few questions I have team members in the room with some microphones so I'm just going to call the team members with the microphones because you are lots of people tonight so if we can start with Mya please for the first question and let me let me anticipate at least one of the questions will be is when will will there be super charg of coverage completely around France yeah
11:25that that is stated for no later than J so by by June of this year you should be able to travel anywhere in France anywhere within France and really any almost anywhere in Wern Europe using the Tesla supercharge Network great thank you just other question
12:09the island of Napoleon the island of Napoleon yeah yeah when sorry napole next time so it's over there please goe my good evening first of all thanks for having us and for sharing your vision my question is about mirroring of smartphone in the car you talked about that a while ago and then you talk about it again a few days ago so could you elaborate a bit on your vision on that and when can we expect to have it
13:02so I think sometime later this year like maybe middle of this year is when I would so when when can we have phone mirroring on the screen I think around the middle of this year it's harder than it seems like the interfaces to the iPhone and Android are not as good as as we'd like they can project a screen but not not they're not so good at projecting a touch interface as well so you able to see it but not touch it but but I do think that's the logical way to go CU otherwise to expect an app developer Community to develop for a few hundred, customers is that when there's hundreds of Millions on iPhone and Android is online just not going to happen think it's going to be okay
13:57yeah I do think that the the honest answer is that the dramatic drop in oil prices will have some negative effect on electric vehicle sales of of all types I think it it'll have the smallest effect on Tesla because we have think a highly differentiated product whereas what say Nissan and Chevy do is they they have an electric product that's pretty hard to tell the difference between the electric and the gasoline or petral product so if the economics don't favor the Electric in that case and the product and there's no product differentiation they're unlikely to buy the electric when will we see pictures of model 3 the first pictures of model 3 will
14:44be end of March yeah but I'm being a little quiet here we're not going to show everything about model 3 until a lot closer to production time can you give us some I got three fre question so welcome in France we got a saying in France impossible is not French so three impossible question to you one first question when the supercharger will be accessible to every car manufacturer will you open the access of superer to other car manufacturer first question second question everybody in France know J Jerome we are very proud of them very proud of when what will be the key factor for you to to create an n and Design Center in France and why not a factory
15:45such as Freo in France so three impossible question sorry unfor I was adjusting my mic so I missed a second so just first supercharger open to every manufacturer Char open to everyone this is something that we stated publicly the goal the goal of the Tesla Supercharger system is definitely not to create some special World Garden or to have a sort of a Competitive Edge against other companies you know the velocity of Tesla is I think is is very consistent we want to do anything we can to help the Advent of sustainable transport so our network is open to any other manufacturers that want to use it okay yeah and and yeah and we will be adding the the European Standard plug as
16:33well so they don't have to have a Tesla adapter so we'll have a mixture of Tes adapters and and and the EU standard plug I don't love the plug honestly I went to the EU commissioner myself and said like this plug is enormous and does not PL good not change so the two question all French question is what what will be or convince you what the key factors of the policy of t to create a second R&D and Design Center here in France because we have very good engineer and second we got a huge Factory North of par in center of the the Europe why not produce car in France I I heard you want to produce car in Germany Holland what are the problem in your
17:17mind about France why not producing France sure so let me just speak in general terms because let me tell you what happens is you know I engage in sort of [Music] the why why not put a factory in France yes okay so well right now we only have one Factory so then question is where do we put our next factories for expansion the the logical thing to do you know this is I I don't think any any new information that I'm was saying there'll probably still be some new newspaper headline about it the obest thing to do is to establish a factory in China and a factory in Europe now we have a sort of smallest Factory in the Netherlands but to do large scale
18:14manufacturing like on the order of a million units a year type of factory we'll need a much bigger area of land access to a large employee base and I don't know try try to make as many make as many countries in Europe happi as possible so like this is Idle speculation I was like well maybe we could put it put a factory on like in elas and you know it's like half in Germany and half in France or something like that this is not a prediction thank you very much it's just SP Bing here so but but the bottom line is it totally it makes total sense to to like I mean there's an incredible Talent po of of production expertise and Engineering expertise and design expertise in Europe
19:12in automotive actually I think it's it's a deeper and Rich pool than in the United States so so why not so we are going to do it thank you imposs is not French come to French no we're definitely definitely going to have both engineering and production in Europe long term it's just a question of when so and how yeah how and the details and what not but I think it's a
19:42natural thing it's crazy to make tons of cars in California and Sh them all the way over to you to Europe okay yeah question up upside thank you very much to improve the charging time to show is Charing yeah so charging time is limited by a number of variables the there's the cell chemistry there's the internal wiring of the car and then there's the actual power output of the supercharger so when the the first supercharges that we started out with were 90 KW hour then we went to 120 KW hour and now they're 135 I I think I think we'll probably see
20:27them going to towards maybe 10080 to 200 but what what tends to happen with battery chemistry is is that you exponent micro trans the bottom German microphone once again should just go with the Lael mic yeah so the cell chemistry gets incrementally harder it almost becomes exponential as you decrease the charge time like the way to think of it is like you have these little lithium ions looking for a parking spot that's basically what's happening and so they're like zooming around and looking for a parking spot when when when the battery is empty it's easy to find a spot and as the gets full there's few and fewer spots but if you keep jamming them in real hard then
21:34they smash into each other and have accidents basically what happens so so the like going from say a 20 minute charge time to a 15minute charge time is is actually a huge difference so I I I I think we'll be we'll really be aiming for charge times that are in the 15 to 20 minute time frame but with enough range that You' be driving for 4
22:03hours or something like that before you need to stop for 15 20 minutes which I think is like you you want this you're torturing yourself you really want to get out of the car after 4 hours [Music] to what do you think to use the battery as a power oh yes so you you certainly could in principle turn your car into kind of an emergency power source for your house the very early prototype versions of Roadster actually did did allow that capability what we found though was that it it created quite a lot of complexity on the house side and if you didn't know when the car was going to be pumping energy into the house it could be dangerous for electricians and potentially pump too
23:04much energy it it really wasn't designed for being a backup hous it it and then of course if somebody wants to drive the car then all the lights would go out in the house so I think the right com the right thing to do is actually have station battery packs in conjunction with electric car
23:28what what can we expect in term of range for the the model S for example within 2 years I I mean for the existing now are you how much range do you want February that's question how much R do you want 700m 800 800 km lot optional battery extra ready to play yeah the challenge is like if as you have a bigger and bigger battery pack then when you're not doing the long distance trip you're puling around all that mass for no reason so so we want to
24:20find a happy medium between what you really need for convenience of recharging and for doing long distance TR but not have so much battery capacity that it's almost never used I we Ted around with certain ideas like for example having a trailer with an auxiliary battery pack like like a little camper trailer with an auxilary battery P something like that might work but I think just naturally expanding the the models battery pack size and once you start getting up above 500 km 55 I mean it's really do need more than more than that pretty unlikely so you can't expect to see steady increases in battery capacity every time did you think about putting a
25:18a solar p panel on the top of the of the roof in order to recharge the the car better yeah we about the solar panels in the roof the actual area of the roof would really be quite a small amount so it would take a long time to recharge the car if you if you just had solar panels in the roof but it would help to go further no it would not no it's
25:50the if you look at the square you said like what is the area and and then how much direct sunlight does the car get so has you park outside in an nonshaded situation and then you might get 2 to Three Square met which would be maybe 600 wats of charging at Peak time nothing yeah let's see so so Summit in Europe whereas in the US we can pretty much like roll out summit and so long as it's it's not done on public property it's it's there's no it it can be done in Europe even if it's a private property it requires explicit approval from The Regulators so we're working with RDW which is the main regulatory agency we work with and to define the
26:44precise limitations of summon that they will find acceptable currently the way the law is written or the regulations are written summon isn't technically allowed so we we we've got to figure out ways to meet the the intent of the regulations so one way of saying I think sumone will roll out in about 2 or 3 weeks but that's that time frame is not within our control it's up to The
27:18Regulators I know you're a great interpreter and we appreciate that we do appreciate the fact that you invited here it's it's amazing what you do we are as well we here and we work for start and we our just fun about space I'm sorry and we would love you to inv us in your so if you can do that you will be the greatest although anyone that's interested in seeing a rocket launch it's actually pretty easy to [Music]
27:53see come to you the there will actually there will be a lot of rocket launchers is here sorry yeah hopefully the anyone you don't need any permission from SpaceX or anything just look at SpaceX website and head there whenever you want the best best place to look at it is on the cause waves at Capal
28:21just oh I yeah no we can't you can't come in the mission patol room no even within space 6 it's very limited I'll take maybe maybe three three more questions and not about I'm not answering SpaceX questions so much afraid of artificial intelligence that you come sleep at night or say that somewhere or it's more just a warning about well I have had occasional sleep nights worrying about artificial intelligence but most of the time if I have a sleepless night it's because of work related stress but yeah I just think we need to be careful about artificial intelligence and not assume it's going to be good you know we can certain The Envision Futures
29:22where it's good but also on where it is not so really it's just about being cautious and not not assuming too much are you running away okay last impossible it's not French oh Mar the supercharg on Mars I hope we have supercharges class problem all right Tesla related questions three more and then
30:10U question and please I ask a question you think that really people a lot of people want to know about you met with our you met with our Ministry of Finance yesterday or today I'm sure he asked you for pieces of advice anything you could share with us on what you told him yeah like I said actually I think he's very smart guy and very well read the thoughtful like I would say one of the best politicians I've met anywhere yeah so for M the Finance Minister what what did I have to say to the Finance Minister when I met with him today so I think first of all I think he's really I was very impressed he's really smart well red guy and really cares about U about Brands
31:03like a lot so the I mean we talked about the the fact that there's effectively every gasoline car is subsidized by the fact that it it is not paying for the carbon dioxide and sulfur oxide nitrous oxide pollution that it creates so so every gas car is effectively subsidized by the public good so then one of the two things need to need to happen because the fundamentally the role of government is that of rulemaker of reg they're the they're the referee and and the and they set the rules of the game so
31:47the best thing would be to put a tax on carbon and everyone in the economics indust profession I think who WR about the subject would agree that that c tax is a sensible thing to do or if you can't get that then to to match the subsidy that gasoline cars get match that on electric cars otherwise it's a very uneven playing field he seems to take that to heart what I can tell and yeah we'll see
32:23what happens he was also very keen to understand where exactly Tesla might be placing a Factory yes and and if if there were any obstacles to establishing a factory in in France you know so yeah I gave him some candid feedback but I that was that's part of a private conversation question can can you comment Apple strategy on the EV what's your view on Apple coming in because you you've been the first one we know that somebody else is going to come in how is it yeah yeah I think it's I think it's great that Apple's doing an electric car they have a lot of money they' got a lot of electronics expertise I think it will be a while before they can bring something to Market because
33:18they they're used to Outsourcing production and there was no good way to Outsource production to it for cars and what about future you think it's Apple no parad future is not Apple in the US there are four China funed EV startups at the Billion Dollar Plus level so it's farad ativa next CV and Karma
33:46formerly called FIS so it's definitely quite a lot of competition but I mean I focus a l on like you know what a comp is doing really what do we need to do to make our cars as compelling as possible so that that's really what matters if we make great cars that people love then things will be fine and if other car companies make great cars that people love they'll be fine too M to come back on Tesla would you redesign models like front design of modic now one comment on future anything
34:28like that sorry the very last question and then go the car the voice control doesn't work for us unless we speak with American accent wa seriously good question oh okay that that's very fixable I didn't even realize that was an issue what's an issue okay voice being able to issue voice commands in French yeah I think that's probably something we can fix fairly quickly I'll I'll take not of that and talk to the team next week
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版