纽约被几公里厚的冰盖压着的时候,全球平均气温比今天低 5 摄氏度。纽约被海水淹没的时候,比今天高 5 摄氏度。
两者的差距只有 10 度。
换成物理学计算温度用的绝对温标,这 10 度的落差还不到 2%。马斯克在巴黎索邦大学(Sorbonne)的一场演讲里,把这个换算摆到台面上,想说明一件事:气候系统对温度极其敏感,只是我们习惯了用摄氏度的相对刻度看问题,感觉不到那个量级。
这场演讲发生在巴黎气候大会(COP 21)期间。他开场先讲了点私人话题,说巴黎是他人生第一次走出南非去的地方,六岁那年父母带他来的。寒暄完,直接进正题:人类要走出化石燃料时代,需要做什么。
碳循环运转了几亿年,我们往里面扔了新东西
地球本来有一套碳循环。碳进入大气,被植物吸收,被动物吃掉,再通过呼吸和腐烂回到空气里,还有一部分溶进海水,过一阵再回到大气。这套系统转了几亿年,一直相对稳定。
循环本身没有问题。问题是我们往里面加了原本不属于它的东西。
马斯克在这里用了句很难听但很好记的话。
这就好比往潘趣酒碗里扔了一坨东西。(马斯克)
潘趣酒(punch)是派对上那种一大碗的混合饮料,一坨东西掉进去,整碗都废了。
我们扔进去的是什么?是几亿年前被埋进地下的碳。煤炭、石油、天然气,这些东西原本被封存在岩层里,跟地表的碳循环完全隔绝。人类把它们挖出来,烧掉,把碳释放到空气和海洋里。
每年大概 350 亿吨。
这个量远超生态系统能吸收的上限。结果就是大气和海洋里的碳浓度一路往上走。马斯克放了一张图,说单看这条曲线,涨幅好像没什么了不起。放到历史尺度上看,就不是那么回事了。
过去 1000 万年,大气里的二氧化碳浓度一直在 300 ppm(百万分之一)上下小幅波动,涨一点跌一点,从没破过圈。最近几百年,这条线直接变成了垂直攀升。
他把这个叫问题的本质。不是缓慢漂移,是近乎垂直的爬升。这个增长速度在地球历史上相当罕见。
气候的敏感度,被我们自己的城市放大了
碳浓度上去,温度跟着上去,符合预期。人们常讨论升温 2 度还是 3 度,马斯克提醒,这个数字必须在绝对温标里理解。
绝对零度是零下 273.15 摄氏度,地球的平均温度大约 288 开尔文。所以 5 度的变化,换算成绝对温度只有 1.7% 左右。
这个比例听起来微不足道,后果却是天壤之别。
冰封的纽约和沉入水下的纽约,中间只隔着 2% 的绝对温度。宇宙是用绝对温标来思考温度的,物理学家也是。我们习惯用摄氏度,是因为水在零度结冰,方便日常生活,但它同时遮住了系统真实的敏感度。
更麻烦的地方在于,人类自己把这种敏感度又放大了一层。
看看地图就明白。全世界的大城市几乎都贴着海岸线建,贸易靠港口,港口靠海,几百年来人口自然往海边聚集。还有一批国家地势极低,海平面上升几米,国土就没了。
所以马斯克的说法是:我们把整个人类文明,设计成了对气候变化极度敏感的样子。
他演讲时还有一句自我调侃,说如果这些内容在座有人早就知道,先道个歉。他讲这些基础原理,是因为很多在气候圈内属于常识的东西,放到公众面前并没有那么显而易见。
退出化石燃料,不是要不要的问题
接下来是整场演讲里最硬的判断。
我们会走出化石燃料时代,这件事件一定会发生。原因简单到有点粗暴:煤、石油、天然气埋在地下的总量是有限的,迟早有一天会挖完、烧完。
所以真正的问题从来不是会不会退出,是什么时候退出。
如果目标是把退出时间尽可能提前,那么思考框架就得换一套。马斯克把人类能源史分成三段。
前工业时代,人类的能源策略是砍树和捕鲸。森林砍光了,鲸鱼快杀绝了,这条路走不下去。
然后转向化石燃料。放在当时的语境里,这是一件好事,它确实让人类从对森林和鲸鱼的血腥依赖里解脱出来了。
现在的目标,是从化石燃料转向可持续能源。
可用的清单不复杂:水电、太阳能、风能、地热,还有核能。核能在某些地方是好选项,他点名的例子就是法国,因为法国不像某些地区那样容易遇到地震、海啸这类自然灾害。
他给了一个判断标准,很值得记住:我们要用的是那些在十亿年尺度上依然靠得住的能源。
这句话有意思的地方在于,太阳能、风能、水电本质上都是太阳能的变体,太阳还能稳定燃烧几十亿年。化石燃料相反,它是几亿年积累下来的一次性存款,花完就没了。
拖延的代价:最好的情况和最坏的情况
如果不加速,会发生什么?马斯克给了两个剧本。
最好的情况是,我们只是把那次不可避免的转型往后推了几年。多烧了几年煤,多排了几年碳,最后还是得转向可持续能源,中间白折腾一圈。
换句话说,拖延不会让转型消失,只会让它变慢。这是乐观版本。
悲观版本就没那么客气了。
最坏的情况是,造成的流离失所和破坏,超过人类历史上所有战争的总和。(马斯克)
他补了一个数据:大约 3% 的科学家认为会发生最好的情况,97% 认为会发生最坏的情况。
基于这个分布,他给这场博弈下了个定义。
这是人类历史上最蠢的实验。你为什么要做这种事?(马斯克)
这句话背后的逻辑是这样的:一个实验,如果结果有 97% 的概率指向灾难,只有 3% 概率指向无事发生,而且实验的收益仅仅是「晚几年再转型」,那这个实验的风险收益比糟糕到无法解释。
但人类正在做,而且做了两百年。
转型为什么这么慢:一张 5.3 万亿美元的隐形账单
答案藏在经济学最基础的那一页里。
在一个健康的市场里,假设某项活动给社会带来 10 个单位的收益,同时造成 4 个单位的损害,那么真实利润是 6。算得清清楚楚,激励机制和社会的长远利益是对齐的。这种对齐一旦成立,推动社会往好方向走的力就非常强大。
现实不是这样。
现实中,那 4 个单位的损害没有被征税。它是免费的。
这就是经济学入门第一课讲的负外部性(negative externality)。成本由全社会承担,收益由排放者独享。结果是排放者拿到了不合理的超额利润,而整个市场的激励方向被扭曲成了鼓励排碳。
马斯克举了个生活化的对照:垃圾清运。
没人会主张要一个完全没有垃圾的社会,那不现实。但所有人都认可一件事,扔垃圾的人得为收垃圾付钱。这个道理谁都懂。
碳排放现在的问题就是,全世界都在往大气这个公共垃圾桶里扔东西,没人付清运费。
这份没付的账单有多大?按国际货币基金组织(IMF)的估算,每年 5.3 万亿美元。
这是人类历史上规模最大的一笔隐性补贴,而且它补贴的恰恰是我们最该减少的那件事。
烟草公司用过的剧本,正在被重复使用
既然解决方案这么清楚,为什么推不动?
马斯克说,因为化石燃料产业的抵抗非常激烈,而且他们用的手法,和烟草行业几十年前用的一模一样。
当年关于吸烟是否有害,科学界的共识早就非常明确。烟草行业的应对策略是:找几个持不同意见的科学家,然后对外宣称「科学家们对此有分歧」。
公众听到「有分歧」三个字,就以为这事还没定论,于是监管推不动,销量继续走。
这套手法今天被原封不动搬到了气候议题上。
识破它的方式很简单:看共识的分布,不要看有没有反对的声音。97% 对 3%,那 3% 不是「另一种观点」,那是统计噪声。
碳税怎么收,才不会被当成左派或右派的战争
解决方案只有一句话:把那笔补贴拿掉。
具体做法是征收碳税。但怎么收,设计很讲究,马斯克给了一个相当务实的方案。
第一,让它收入中性(revenue neutral)。
提高碳税的同时,在其他地方减税。比如降低销售税或增值税(VAT),用碳税的收入补上。这样总税负没有明显增加,只有那些生活方式高度依赖化石燃料的人和公司,才会真正多掏钱。
这个设计的政治意义很大。碳税长期被贴上「左派议题」的标签,一提高税收,右派选民立刻反对。收入中性的设计绕开了这个陷阱,它不再是「加税」,而是「换一种方式收税」,征的是你排了多少碳,减的是你买东西时的普遍税负。
第二,分阶段推进,给工业留出反应时间。
他建议用五年左右逐步抬到位。这样五年之后会难受的,只有那些今天什么都不做的公司。提前布局的企业反而会占便宜。
第三,政府必须释放极其明确的信号。
这一条最重要。
今天的问题不是企业不愿意转型,是企业算不出转型的经济账。规则奖励排碳,企业就排碳,这符合商业理性。政府的职责是把规则改掉,然后用足够清晰的方式告诉所有人:方向定了,不会反复。
马斯克的原话逻辑非常朴素:你激励什么,就会得到什么。
现在的规则在激励人类往大气里倒碳,所以我们就看到了倒碳的结果。这不是道德问题,是设计问题。
2 度升温已经锁定了
演讲快结束时,他给了一个不太乐观的判断。
升温 2 摄氏度这件事,基本已经是既定事实,没什么悬念。
真正的问题变成了:会超出 2 度多少。
这个措辞值得注意。它把讨论从「能不能阻止」切换到了「能控制到什么程度」,后面那个问题才是各国政策真正要回答的。
普通人能做的三件事
演讲最后的行动建议非常具体,没有停留在呼吁层面。马斯克把它们压缩成了三条,每条都能当天执行。
- 见到政治人物的机会别浪费,直接要求他们推动碳税。理由就一句话:那笔没被定价的外部性必须被修正。议员听多了,议题才会进入议程。
- 跟身边的人聊这件事,把「科学家还有分歧」这个假象戳破。97% 对 3% 不是观点之争,是常识。身边人的认知变化,是最便宜的舆论改造。
- 对化石燃料行业的宣传保持警惕。看到「气候科学有争议」这类说法,先问一句:这个说法的资金来自哪里,用的是不是烟草行业那套「找几个反对者充当分歧」的老办法。
他在这三条之外还留了一句话,值得单独拿出来:我们今天做的选择,会把碳排放曲线推向两个完全不同的极端,或者被压到可控水平,或者一路冲高。中间地带很窄。
而所有选择的起点,都是那 4 个单位的成本,究竟由谁来付。
0:01All right. Well, it's thank you for having me. It's great to be here. Paris is one of my favorite places in the world. And it's actually the, on the first trip that I went out of South Africa, Paris that that was where I went when I when I was a young little kid. Well, my my parents brought me when I was like six years old. so I've left Paris ever since. so thank you for having me. What I'm going to talk about today is just in general terms what is needed to address the the climate crisis. and this is a thing that if if if we if we do what actions can we take that that will accelerate the transition out of the fossil fuel era.
0:45so where we are today is let's see if this thing's working. Maybe not. Okay. All right, we have the we have the present era where we have the the car carbon cycle. And my apologies if if some of you already know all about this, but I think some of these things are maybe not as obvious as they may seem.
1:06So there's a certain amount of carbon that is circulating through the environment. So it's going into the air, being absorbed by and then getting absorbed by plants and animals and then going back into the air. And this this carbon is just circulating on the surface. U and this this is fine and it's been doing that for millions hundreds of millions of years. the the thing that's changed is that we've added something to the mix. So this is what I would call the the sort of the turd in the punch bowl. so the we added all this extra carbon to to the carbon cycle and the net result is that the the carbon in the ocean's atmosphere is growing over time.
1:49It's much more than can be absorbed by the ecosystem. It's it's really it's really quite simple. We're taking billions of tons of carbon that's been buried for hundreds of millions of years and is not part of the carbon cycle. Taking from deep underground and adding it to the carbon cycle.
2:08The result is that a steady increase in the the carbon in the atmosphere and in the ocean oceans which doesn't look like much if you look at it on this chart but when looked at in the context of of history it actually looks like this. So the the carbon parts per million has really been bouncing around the 300 level for around 10 million years.
2:34and then the last few hundred years it went into a vertical climb. This this is the the essence of the problem. This is very unusual. and and a and a very very extreme threat as you can see from from this rate of growth. Then this is accompanied by a temperature increase as one would expect and and and this and this temperature increase you people talk about 2 degrees or or 3° it's important to appreciate just how sensitive the the climate actually is to to temperature and it's important to look at it in terms of absolute temperature not in degrees Celsius relative to zero. We need to say what is the temperature change relative to absolute zero. That's how the
3:20universe thinks about temperature. It's how physics thinks about temperature. It's it's relative to absolute zero. So for small changes result in in huge effects. so New York City under ice would be minus 5 degrees. New York City underwater would be plus 5°. But looked at in in a as a percentage relative to absolute zero. it's only a plus minus 2% change.
3:51So the the sensitivity of the climate is extremely extremely high. we've amplified this sensitivity by building our cities right on the on the coastline and most most people live very close to to the ocean and some countries of course that are that are very lowlying and would be completely underwater in in a in a
4:15climate crisis. So then the the the we've essentially designed civilization to be super sensitive to climate change. and the the the important thing to appreciate is that we are going to exit the fossil fuels era. So it is it is it is inevitable that we will exit the fossil era because at a certain point we will simply run out of carbon to mine and burn. So the question is really when when do we exit the era not not if
4:52the goal is to exit the era as quickly as possible. That means we need to move from from the old goal with the pre-industrial grow goal which was to move from chopping down forests and killing lots of whales. that the old goal was to move from from chopping wood and and killing whales to fossil fuels which is actually in that context was a good thing but the new goal is to move to a
5:24sustainable energy future and we want to use things like hydro solar wind geothermal nuclear is also a good option in places like France which don't aren't subject to natural disasters. and and we want to use energy sources that will be good for for a billion years. So, how do we accelerate this transition away from fossil fuels to a sustainable era?
5:57And and and and what happens if we don't? So if we if we wait and if we delay the change the best case the best case is is is simply delaying that inevitable transition to sustainable energy. So this is the this is the best case if we don't take action now. at the risk of being repetitive it's there's going to be no choice in the long term to move to sustainable energy.
6:26It's it's total logical. we have to have sustainable energy or we'll simply run out of the other one. So the the only thing we gain by slowing down the transition is is is just slowing it down. It doesn't doesn't make it not occur. It just slows it down. The worst case, however, is more displacement and destruction than all the wars in history combined. Okay, this is these are these are the best worst case scenarios. So then we have you know about 3% of scientists that believe in the best case and about 97% that believe in the worst case.
7:01This is why I call it the dumbest experiment in history ever. Like why would you do this? So the the the reason that the the the transition is delayed or or or is happening slowly is because there is a hidden subsidy on all carbon producing activity. In a healthy market, if you have say€ 10 of benefit and 4 of harm to society, the profit would be €6. The sort of you know makes obvious sense. This is where the incentives are aligned with a good future.
7:39This is not this is not the case today. but if you have the incentives aligned then the forcing function towards a a good future towards a sustainable energy future will be powerful. In an unhealthy market you have your 10 years of benefit. You have your four years but the four years doesn't isn't taxed. So you have an untaxed negative externality. This is basically economics 101.
8:06So you have basically unreasonable profit and a forcing function to to do carbon emitting activity because this this this cost to society is not being paid. The net result is 35 gatons of carbon per year into the atmosphere. So this is analogous to not paying for garbage collection. and it's it's not as though we should we should say in the case of garbage have a garbage free society. It's very difficult to have a garbage free society but it's just important that people pay for garbage collection.
8:52So we need to go from having an untaxed negative externality and which is effectively a hidden carbon subsidy of enormous size 5.3 trillion a year according to the IMF every year. we need to move away from this and and and and have a carbon tax. So, but this is being this is being fought quite hard by the the carbon
9:24producers. and they're using tactics that are very similar to what the cigarette industry or the tobacco industry used for many years. they would they would take the approach of having of of even though the overwhelming scientific consensus was that smoking cigarettes was bad for you. they would find a few scientists that would disagree and then they would say look scientists disagree. So that that that's essentially how they would try to trick the public into thinking that smoking is not that bad.
9:59The solution obviously is to remove the subsidy. so that means we need to have a re a carbon tax and to make it sort of something which is neither a left nor a right issue we should make it probably a revenue neutral carbon tax. So this would be a case of increasing taxes on carbon but then reducing taxes in in other places. So maybe there would be a reduction in sales tax or VAT and an increase in carbon tax. So that only those using high levels of carbon would pay an increased tax.
10:40And moreover this I mean in order to give industry time to react this could be a phased in approach so that maybe it takes five years before the the carbon taxes are very high. So that means that only companies that don't take action today will suffer in 5 years. But there needs to be a clear message from from government in this regard. The the because the fundamental problem is the rules today incent people to create carbon and this is madness and whatever you incent will happen. That that's why you know we're we're seeing little very little effect thus far.
11:21And depending upon how what what action we take, we'll we'll will will drive the the carbon number to either extreme or or moderate levels. I I think it's pretty much a given that that the two degree C increase will occur. The question is whether it's going to be much more than that, not if there will be a twoderee increase.
11:44so the then the question is so so what can you do? I would say whenever you have the opportunity, talk to your politicians, ask them to enact a carbon tax. We we have to fix the unpriced externality. I would talk to your friends about it and fight the propaganda from the carbon industry.
12:04So that that's the basic message I have and I'm happy to take questions. Thank you.
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版