访谈·中文精读

马斯克在巴黎索邦大学COP 21发表演讲并问答

Elon Musk gives a talk at the Sorbonne, Paris - COP 21 (Q&A session)

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2015年12月,巴黎气候大会(COP 21)期间,马斯克出现在索邦大学的一间报告厅里。台下坐满了学生,问题一个接一个抛上来,有些尖锐,有些天真,有些带着明显的敌意。

主持人提醒大家每人只能问一个问题,但没人真的在意这条规则。

这场问答持续了将近一个小时。马斯克谈到了碳税、锂矿、核聚变、火星殖民,还罕见地聊了聊特斯拉差点死掉的往事。下面这些内容,值得逐条拆开看。

“还有比气候变化更重要的事吗?”

第一个提问的学生很直接:世界上有那么多紧迫的问题,凭什么把气候放在最前面?

马斯克的回答没有绕弯子。他承认世界上确实有很多重要议题,气候不是唯一一个。但他给出了一条判断标准:哪件事如果放着不管,对人类的负面影响最大。

他的答案是气候变化。

他引用的数据是当时最乐观的预测模型:如果什么都不做,5%到10%的陆地面积会被海水吞没。这个数字乍一听不算吓人,毕竟地球那么大。

但接下来这句话才是关键:

“大约三分之一的人类住在海岸线上或者低洼国家。所以这意味着可能有二十亿人流离失所,他们的家被毁掉,他们的国家消失。”(马斯克)

百分之五的陆地,对应的是二十亿人的住所。这个换算方式比任何抽象的温度曲线都更有说服力。

钱不是激励,钱是信息

一位营销学博士生问了一个很有意思的问题:激励人们去解决世界级难题,金钱是不是最好的手段?还是说,人们可以纯粹出于善意去行动?

马斯克的回答把问题拆成了两层。

第一层,他相信大多数人本质上想做好事。这一点他不怀疑。

第二层才是问题所在:当前的规则体系在系统性地奖励坏结果。好人想做好事,得逆着水流游泳,速度自然就慢。

然后他说了一句容易被忽略但非常重要的话:

“金钱和价格本质上只是一种信息机制。它告诉企业该做什么,是劳动力分配的信号。”(马斯克)

这个定义把经济学课本里的概念还原成了最朴素的样子。价格不是道德判断,不是价值衡量,它只是一套信号系统。信号错了,企业的行为就会跟着错。

所以问题不在于人好不好,而在于信号准不准。而发出信号的那个人,是政府。

碳税:修复一个定价错误

整场问答里,马斯克反复回到同一个主张:给碳定价。

他用了一个很妙的类比。政府干预市场,大多数时候会把价格信号弄得更扭曲。但碳排放是个例外,它是一个典型的“公地悲剧”,因为没有人拥有大气层,所以往里面排放二氧化碳的成本是零。

零,就是那个定价错误。

“任何你加上去的价格,都比接近于零更正确。”(马斯克)

他特别提到,中国在那年早些时候宣布要建立碳交易体系,他表示非常兴奋。这句话放在2015年的语境里,分量不小。

有人追问:给碳加税,会不会伤害那些依赖化石燃料的国家?

马斯克的回答又用了一个生活化的类比。他说,我们对酒和烟草征的税远高于水果蔬菜。没有人会跳出来说“我们国家产烟草,所以要求降低烟草税”,因为这个辩论本身就很荒谬。

碳税的逻辑是一样的。不需要额外多收税,只需要把同样的税负结构,从“好东西”挪到“坏东西”上。而且可以设计成逐年递增的渐进方案,一开始幅度很小,给经济留出调整时间。

这样一来,哪怕今天高度依赖煤炭的国家,也能看到五年、十年后的方向,企业会提前调整投资。

太阳:天上那个巨型聚变反应堆

一位学生问核聚变什么时候能用上。

马斯克的回答分成了两半。

先说现实。他提醒在场的人,全球在路上的汽油车和柴油车大约有二十亿辆,化石燃料发电厂有几十万座。这个存量太庞大了,哪怕今天立刻全力转向可再生能源,也需要很长时间才能替换完。

他给的时间表是十到二十年才能看到显著变化。

然后是核聚变本身。他觉得技术可行,但离商业化太远:

“要让聚变在发电厂层面真正运转起来,大概还要三十年。而且要投入巨大的努力。”(马斯克)

所以他给出了那个后来被反复引用的说法:他更支持使用“天上那个巨大的聚变发电厂”,也就是太阳。

接着他算了一笔账。太阳每小时照射到地球的能量,远超人类一年的消耗。具体到数字:每平方公里接收到的太阳能功率是一吉瓦。按20%的光电转换效率计算,一平方公里的太阳能板可以发出两百兆瓦的电。

他还给了一个地理参照:如果只铺满西班牙的一小块区域,就能供整个欧洲用电。换作美国,内华达州或者犹他州的一个角就够了。

这个比喻的妙处在于,它把“能源不够”的焦虑直接消解掉了。能源总量从来不是问题,问题是我们有没有把它收集起来、存起来、送出去。

锂不够用?元素周期表第三号

一位管理学学生问,特斯拉打算用锂离子电池用到什么时候,毕竟锂是有限资源。

马斯克直接纠正了这个前提。

“地球上其实不缺锂。锂是元素周期表上的第三号元素,极其常见。任何含盐的水里都有锂。”(马斯克)

换句话说,制约电池产能的从来不是锂的储量。他明确表态,至少在储能这件事上,锂离子电池会长期是主流,而且现有的资源足够造出储存全世界所需能源的电池。

关于电池的环保问题,另一位学生追问了锂离子电池生产过程中的碳足迹和废弃物处理。

马斯克的回答聚焦在“生命周期”上。电池和化石燃料的根本区别在于:电池里的锂、镍、钴可以被回收,循环使用,而石油烧掉就没了。

他把两者放在一起比较:一边是可以反复回收的金属材料,另一边是每年挖出来、烧掉、进入大气和海洋的几十亿吨碳。他用了“数量级差异”这个词,意思是两者根本不在同一个尺度上。

电网里藏着的秘密:全球电厂多建了一到两倍

这场问答里信息密度最高的部分,是马斯克谈储能的那一段。

他说,哪怕完全不考虑可再生能源,光是储能本身就能带来巨大收益。原因在于用电负荷的波动。一天之内的用电量通常会有两倍以上的起伏,而除了水电,电几乎是无法储存的,必须实时供需匹配。

结果就是,全世界的发电装机容量是实际峰值需求的两到三倍。

这个数字很多人不知道。也就是说,大量发电厂只是为了应对用电高峰而存在,平时在低效运转甚至闲置。

“如果你能用大型固定式电池组把电力缓冲下来,你实际上可以关掉全世界最糟糕的那一半发电厂。”(马斯克)

关掉一半,而且关的是污染最严重的那一半。这笔账算下来,储能的价值远远不止“配合光伏”这么简单,它本身就是电网效率的一次大修。

他提到特斯拉当时已经在和全球多家公用事业公司推进大型储能项目,美国国内和海外都有。

碳封存:往海里灌,等于制造酸化

一位经济学本科生问,把二氧化碳从大气中捕集、压缩、注入深海,这套方案可不可持续。

马斯克的回答很干脆:他没见过任何一个能经济可行的碳封存系统。而且他明确反对往海洋里注碳。

原因讲得很清楚。二氧化碳溶入海水会生成碳酸,海水酸化。而贝类这类生物对pH值的变化极其敏感。

至于地下岩洞储存,他觉得理论上可行,但量级对不上。人类每年排放的碳太多了,地球上找不到足够大的地方来装。

这段回答背后的思路,和他整场问答的一贯立场一致:与其想办法处理排放出来的碳,不如一开始就不排。

火星和地球,不是二选一

有人问了一个很典型的问题:与其费劲救地球,为什么不直接去殖民别的星球?

马斯克说,两件事都要做。

他坦白自己个人的精力就是分裂的:一半在可持续能源上,一半在推进太空技术上,目标是让火星上有一座自给自足的城市。

然后他给出了一个统一的框架,用来衡量这两件事的共同意义:降低存在性风险。

可持续能源让未来变好,而且越快越好。多行星物种则让人类在面对灭绝级事件时更有韧性,用他的原话说,是“给我们更多的回旋余地”。

最后他补了一句很马斯克的话:这也会是一场非常棒的冒险。

法国核电:位置对了,就是好事

一位可持续发展专业的女生问了两个问题,其中一个关于核能。

马斯克顺势把前一个没答完的核聚变问题一起回答了。

他对核裂变的态度相当务实:如果在不遭受自然灾害的地方建核电站,这是好事。他直接点名法国,说法国核电占比很高,这其实是好事。反过来,在地震带或者海啸风险区建核电站,显然会出问题。

核聚变他也看好,提到了法国正在建设的ITER项目。但他重申了那个判断:聚变离真正发电还有三十年。

所以短期到中期,他的答案还是光伏加储能加高压输电的组合。

特斯拉差点在圣诞夜死掉

问答的后半段,有人问融资。特斯拉早期最难的是什么?

马斯克的回答揭开了一段很少被完整讲述的往事。

他说,在特斯拉和Solar City刚起步的时候,他认为成功的概率太低,低到不好意思去问别人要钱。所以他投进去的全部资金,都是自己从PayPal套现得来的。

“我把从PayPal拿到的所有钱都投进了特斯拉、Solar City和SpaceX。即便这样,我们也只是勉强活了下来。”(马斯克)

然后他讲了一个具体到日期的细节。2008年,特斯拉的融资轮在平安夜那天关闭,那是“最后一天最后一个小时”才谈成的。

为什么这么难?他解释了汽车行业的残酷之处:汽车制造有周期,经济好的时候还行,经济一转差,制造业最先受冲击。

他给了一个残酷的数据:美国历史上没有破产过的汽车公司,只有两家,福特和特斯拉。通用汽车破产过,克莱斯勒破产过,其他的也都破产过。

他还提到,直到2013年初,特斯拉账上的现金只够支撑一到两周。而在他看来,直到最近两年,特斯拉才算摆脱了随时可能死掉的处境。

这段话值得所有想创业的人反复读。不是因为它励志,是因为它把一个被神化的故事还原成了真实的时间线:从2003年成立到2015年,十几年里,这家公司有相当长的时间在生死线上。

节俭救不了未来

一位提问者提出了一个尖锐的反问:我们讨论的都是效率和技术方案,但有没有可能,真正需要的是改变社会运行的方式,减少消费?

马斯克部分同意。他说确实不该浪费,应该关注消费。

但他紧接着给出了一个逻辑上的硬边界:

“哪怕我们在能源使用上极度保守,在回收利用上做到极致,那也只是推迟了转向可持续未来的必要性,并没有消除它。如果我们没有可持续的能源生产方式,光靠节约是走不到好未来的。”(马斯克)

这个论证很干净:节约可以减少需求,但需求不可能降到零。而供给端如果是化石燃料,那么无论需求多低,碳排放都在继续。所以必须解决供给侧。

埃克森美孚一年的利润,超过全美光伏产业的总值

有一位学生提到,科学界内部意见分歧,部分原因是研究经费来自不同的企业。她问,环保一方是不是也应该组织自己的游说力量?

马斯克对这个提议泼了冷水,但泼得有理有据。

“我们绝对在游说上打不过石油和天然气行业。这是一场必输的仗。埃克森美孚一年的利润,超过美国整个太阳能行业的价值总和。”(马斯克)

他的意思是,把美国的太阳能公司全加起来,还不如埃克森美孚一年的利润。在钱的层面上,这场竞争没有胜算。

那什么有胜算?他给出了另一条路径:选票。

“如果每一个筹款晚宴、每一场私人饭局上,都有人问政客一句,你在气候问题上做了什么,他们就会行动。你手上有巨大的力量。”(马斯克)

这段话是整场问答里最具体的一条行动建议。它不要求你懂技术,不要求你有钱,只要求你在合适的场合问出那个问题。

关于AI,他只说了几句

有人把话题从气候拉到了人工智能,提到马斯克和比尔·盖茨、彼得·蒂尔都曾公开表达过对超级智能的担忧。

马斯克显得不太愿意展开,说自己想专注于可持续能源这个主题,免得跑题太远。但他还是说了几句。

核心意思是:对AI的到来应该保持谨慎。他认识很多正在开发AI的人,这些人太确信结果一定是好的。

“我们需要考虑那些可能不那么好的结果,需要小心,需要真正去监控正在发生的事,并确保公众知情。”(马斯克)

这段话在2015年说出来,当时听起来还有点杞人忧天。放到今天回看,分量完全不同。

COP 21 会成功吗

最后一个问题很简单:你觉得巴黎气候大会会成功吗?

马斯克的回答很诚实,他说自己没有任何依据,但感觉不错。

然后他做了一个对比。哥本哈根那次气候大会是失败的,几乎什么都没谈成。他希望巴黎能有实质性的进展,但成功也有程度之分。

他想传递的信息是:这一次,必须要有显著的变化。

整场问答里,马斯克没有一次把希望寄托在某个技术突破上。他反复说的是同一件事:改变规则,让正确的行为在商业上划算。

这可能是这场一个多小时对话里,最容易被忽略也最重要的一条判断。

普通人能做什么

把这场问答里的建议抽出来,能落地的其实是这么几条:

  • 把气候议题带进每一次和政客的对话里。马斯克的原话是,不用试图在游说经费上赢过石油行业,那场仗必输。但选票和持续的公开质询是有效的,尤其是在筹款场合。
  • 支持碳定价,哪怕起步幅度很小。渐进式的碳税不会立刻冲击经济,但它给出的长期信号会改变企业的投资决策。五年后建成的工厂,取决于今天定下的规则。
  • 如果要创业或择业,优先看可持续能源领域。风能、光伏、地热、潮汐、储能,选择加入或者自己开一家。马斯克提醒过这条路很难,特斯拉当年的成功概率他自己估的是10%。但他也说过,这是值得做的事。
  • 不要指望靠节约解决问题。减少浪费是对的,但供给端的能源结构不改变,节约只能推迟问题,不能解决它。把注意力放在能源生产方式的替换上。
  • 对AI保持一份警觉,并推动信息公开。开发AI的人往往对结果过于乐观,公众需要知道正在发生什么。这件事在2015年听起来遥远,今天已经不是了。
  • 记住那个换算:5%的陆地,二十亿人的家。当你听到有人用抽象的百分比讨论气候变化时,把这个换算讲出来。

马斯克在那场问答里说过一句话,现在读起来依然成立:政府制定规则,规则决定企业的行为,而企业决定了五年后世界的样子。如果你希望五年后的世界是另一个样子,那么现在就该去问那个问题。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00Hi sir, I'm hon from the master of inter innovation and technology man management and my question is what do you say to those who think there are more important concerns right now than climate change and global warming. Sure. I mean there's definitely there are many important issues in the world. this is not the only important issue. but it is I think the thing that will have the biggest negative effect on humanity if we do not address it. I mean based on on the the projections that we're seeing right now and these are like I'd say arguably best case projections. We're going to see significant rises in temperature and sea level. the the net result is if if we

0:44don't take action we could see you know anywhere from 5 to 10% maybe maybe more of the land mass absorbed by water which would which is maybe not doesn't sound like that much but about a third of humanity lives right on the on the coastline or in low-lying countries. So we'd be talking about maybe two billion people being displaced and and their homes being destroyed and their countries being gone.

1:12So I think we should take action. Hello sir, thank you for coming here. my question is I'm PhD student in marketing and what I study is what motivates people to participate in challenges. Now you have created a company which creates challenges which brought which brought a rocket to moon and back if I if I'm not wrong. My question would be do you think a challenge maybe not moon and back right? Yeah.

1:39We're getting there. Getting there. My question to you would be, do you think that incentives, which is the biggest incentive to use, monetary incentives, are the best possible incentive to get people to participate and solve the world's biggest problems, or do you think people can do it in order to just help everyone on the planet and make it better? So, is money the only way to ask people to get in and solve challenges, or do you have other ways to actually motivate people to participate?

2:05I I I think there's there's definitely a philanthropic element. and there's the you know I think there's I think in general people want to do the right thing and they want to do what's good. the the issue we have right now is that the the rules fundamentally favor the bad outcome. So when you're fighting for the good outcome and it's an uphill battle it it it's just it's just slower. so with respect to to climate change it's just critical that the government and the government is the set of rules. The government decides what rules companies will will play by and if if we currently have a system which massively insense bad behavior. So even if most people

2:47don't do the bad behavior some people will still do the bad behavior. Yeah. I mean money and prices are prices are basically just an information mechanism. They're just they're just basically they tell you that it's it I mean money's mostly an information mechanism for labor labor allocation and for you know to and sort of tells companies what to do. So it's just critical. This is why it's so critical to be that action be taken at a government level because the government is the one they're setting the rules of the game and and it's just crazy to have the rules of the game favor a bad outcome.

3:24A question up top there. There's a question here. hi Musk. my name is Michelle. I'm an undergrad in economics here at Paris Pont. my question is there are some new studies on removing carbon dioxide dioxide from the atmosphere and buring deep in the ocean. Do you think it's a sustainable solution and why? Thank you.

3:56you know, I I'm I'm not aware of any carbon sequestration or carbon storage system that is that that that works and works economically. and and I definitely wouldn't want to I would be wouldn't want to store the carbon in the ocean because of possible acidification. you know, as the as the carbon as the CO2 levels rise in the atmosphere, some of that is absorbed into the ocean becomes carbonic acid. and a lot of the shellfish in particular are super sensitive to changes in in pH level. so I I definitely are against trying to store in the ocean. There potentially you could try to store some of it in giant underground caverns, but the the sheer quantity we're talking

4:38about I I don't think can be stored anywhere. there's just there's just no nowhere to store it. Yeah. Question up front. Thank you. Hello sir. I'm studying management at Parion and I would know how long do you do Tesla Motors intend to use lithium batteries knowing that it is not a limited resource?

5:01well actually I think so so lithium in terms of energy storage lithium I think is is definitely the future and will be for a long time. there's actually not a shortage of lithium on earth. so lithium is you number three on the periodic table. It's actually extremely common. any salty water has has lithium. so the there definitely won't be a lithium constraint on energy storage for batteries. so I feel pretty confident that one one could make enough batteries to store all the energy that the world needs with the current resources that are that are available.

5:42Yeah. Hello. my name is Idin Vad. I am a PhD student in project and infrastructure finance in Sorbon. First of all, I would like to thank you for your latest product power wall which to me it gives to the citizens to have the power to select the way they can consume energy. I can spend few,000 to buy some solar panel and the power wall and to be free of any

6:13offer in the market. My question is about the the large scale storage systems you have designed. Have you received any serious involvement from governments and large companies to develop such such infrastructure or do you have any serious plans within within the United States or maybe in other countries for for large energy storage? Yeah, we do actually. We've got a number of very very big storage

6:48projects underway with utilities around the world. so both in the US and outside. the the the thing that's interesting about the energy storage situation is that even even without renewables, there's a there's a huge potential to make the energy grid more efficient and to be able to shut down the the the heaviest polluting power plants. because the the energy consumption through the day usually changes by a factor of two or more. So and since with the exception of of hydroelect electric you can't store the power. It has to be available in real time the world has somewhere between two to three times as many power plants as it actually needs. So if you can buffer

7:32the power with big big stationary battery packs then you can actually shut down the the the worst half of the power plants in the world. So I think that's that's sort of a very exciting thing that I think a lot of people don't appreciate. and I think it's it's gonna make make a big difference.

7:54Hi sir, I'm Kami from the master degree innovation and technology man management and my question is do you believe that in the ability of government international government to prevent climate change and what would you suggest? yeah absolutely I think I this fundamentally is a government issue. so it's it's it's the as as mentioned the government is the one that sets the rules of the game that they set you know how companies are rewarded financially and so in the absence of government actually establishing some kind of a carbon tax or potentially a cap and trade on carbon which I was very excited to see that China announced earlier this year that they

8:37were going to do that unless the government does something to fix the market mechanism the it it's it's we're fundamentally going to have a very slow transition out of the fossil fuel era. So it's it's critical that government action change the incentive structure. yeah and and that that be very clear and so it's like I think hopefully what comes out of this out of these the climate talks in Paris is that that the governments of the world say that you know they put their foot down and they say 5 years from now let's say there has to be a huge change and and and that companies know for sure that this is going to happen. and if they if they do then that the the investment

9:23decisions they make today will will will bear fruit in five years. So the for for heavy industrial applications or or for heavy industry you you you kind of know what the world's going to look like in 5 years if you know what pl what what what factories are being built today because if you build a really big factory to get to full production takes about 5 years from from start. And so since we know that today there are very few sustainable energy projects at large scale that are that are being built we know that unless something changes very quickly the sustainable energy will still be in a bad situation 5 years from now. So

10:07you know I mean there there are companies like you know at Tesla and Solar City we're quite ideologically motivated but but that's that's relatively unusual. So hi my name is Thomas. what do you think about people who are saying then rather than trying to save the earth we should try to colonize other planets?

10:31Well I think we should do both. Yeah. Yeah, I think we you know the I mean my sort of personal ideology is is kind of split right now between trying to be helpful on earth related stuff which is sustainable energy and then trying to you know advance space technology so we can establish a self-sustaining city on Mars. But I do think it's important to be a multilanet not just one planet but another planet.

11:01so the and and the overarching goal is to minimize existential risk, you know. So if we look at look out into the future and say what are the things that pose a risk to to humanity to what what what is going to make the future good versus bad. and I think if obviously if we have a sustainable energy future that's good. and the faster that comes the better. And then if we're a multilanet species, that gives us much more resilience against an extinction event. and also would be a really great and fun adventure.

11:37Hi, my name is Jeda and u I wanted to know in your opinion what would the future will look like in ter energy sources and how soon could we use nuclear fusion efficiently? Thank you. Sure. well the the thing to appreciate about the industri the sort of installed industrial base is that it's it's really enormous like the number of petrol and diesel cars on the road and trucks is about 2 billion you know there are sort of hundreds of thousands of of of power plants using fossil fuels. So the the even if we if today we went super hard in the direction of renewables, it would still take a long time. so I think we we it's before we see significant

12:30change, it's probably 10 or 20 years. and and that's there's a lot that can happen in 10 or 20 years, of course. so the the faster we can bring that date forward, the better. Yeah. hi. my name is Natasha. I'm from the master program of sustainable development. I have two questions. First one, because I want to be optimistic that we are going to switch at some point to be completely sustainable and to use renewable energies. do you think that there are going to be a gap between developing and developed countries that and when developing countries will be able to reach developed ones switching into sustainable and renewable energies? Then second one would be sustainability of

13:20nuclear energy in your opinion. Thank you. Sure. and I actually I should answer the nuclear question because that was posed just just before this. I actually think that like nuclear fision if it's in a location that is not subject to natural disasters like like in in the case of France there's a very high percentage of nuclear I think that's actually a good thing obviously you don't want to have nuclear fision power plants in places that are subject to natural disasters because that obviously can go wrong so and so I think fision is a good is a good approach fusion is also So interesting. and it's exciting to see what's happening with the iter project

14:03which is a a fusion plant that's being built in France. I I I I do think fusion is is a is a feasible technology. I think we can definitely make fusion work. the but but it is it is a it is kind of a faroff technology. So to to make fusion at the power plant level work is probably I don't know 30 years away. and and

14:27and and a lot of lot of effort. so the that's why in in at least you know for now and I think maybe even in the long term I'm a proponent of using the big fusion power plant in the sky called the sun. So that the sun is a giant fusion explosion and it it shows up every day and if we have photovoltaics for solar panels we can capture that fusion energy. it also needs to be stored in batteries so we can use it at night. and then we we want to have high power lines to transfer solar energy from one place to another. So but the important thing to appreciate is like if if let's say the only thing we had was was solar energy that that was the only

15:10power source you could if you just took a small section of of Spain you could power all of Europe. It's it's a very small amount of area that's actually needed to generate the electricity we need to power civilization or in the case of the US like a little corner of Nevada or Utah power the entire United States. So

15:33good evening. you you do have a very impressive and stimulating career. you succeeded in business while staying true to yourself and beliefs. So I would like to know what advice you would give to a young entrepreneur who is aware of climate change issues and maybe what was the best and the worst advice you were given about that. Thank you.

15:58Okay. well I think if somebody's wants to do something entrepreneurial in energy I mean either either you want to start a company or you want to join a company that's doing something sustainable. and it could be, you know, there's there's obviously wind, solar, and, the geothermal, there's tidal power. so I would just say look at companies that are trying to do sustainable energy and decide if you want to join them or or if you want to start one. so, I I generally wouldn't, you know, starting companies in in either the automotive arena or the energ like energy arena is a like quite a tricky business. I mean when when when we first started Tesla and Solar City

16:41we we thought they would fail. We thought and Tesla in particular we thought probably with maybe 10% chance of success. So it's you know particularly particularly cars the you know it's it's hard it's hard to stay alive as a car company. Honestly like it must be one of the worst riskadjusted returns.

17:04yeah. Hi my name is Benjamin and I was wondering what do you wish for in terms of international rules and politics to facilitate the implementation of your power wall battery? Well the it's really that the what I've been saying here is that that that the governments of the world need to price the the externality. they need to put put a proper price on carbon and then automatically the right behavior will occur. So this is by by putting a price on carbon we essentially fixing a pricing error in the markets market system. So I mean most of the times when government governments intervene in markets it's usually increases the pricing error but in but when when

17:56the pricing error is a huge tragedy the commons issue like we have with carbon capacity it's critical that the government put a price on it because you just can't go wrong by put it by you know and any price you put on it will be more right than than close to zero which it is right now. so this is this is by far the most important thing if we want to accelerate the transition to sustainable energy. the there are other less effective ways by providing incentives and and subsidies to say electric cars or or solar. that that is that is a sometimes a more politically expedient way to do it. But the best way is just to directly fix the pricing error by taxing

18:36carbon. and and this is I like if you ask most economists they would say the same thing. So this is sort of well well known in obviously the e economics world. Elen could you say a few words on artificial intelligence because you know I think I I read or you you you know you were quoted among with others Bill Gates and Peter Thiel and so forth saying that you know you were afraid of the that one day an hyper you know intelligent machine would destroy humanity and you know are you investing a lot into artificial intelligence with you know because are we wasting a lot of energy because we're using you know we're not being smart or with not having smart

19:18objects and so forth and how do you reconcile the two if you know there's a there's a long time you know long-term major risk for us yeah I mean I definitely want to stay stay on the you know sustainable energy topic because it's it's easy to get get derailed on too many other things but yeah I mean I think I just think we should be cautious about the advent of AI and a lot of the people that I

19:44know that are developing AI are too convinced that that the only outcome is good. and we need to consider potentially less good outcomes. and to, you know, to be careful and and and and really to monitor what's happening and make sure the public is aware of what's happening. I'm Gabriel Rondon from we I stood innovation here in Serbon. I have a question about fundraising specifically about the fundraising process regarding what Tesla does.

20:16what is the most difficult thing to raise funds in the beginning not now because now you you have a welldeveloped project and the worldwide knows you and knows Tesla also but in the beginning about the the the industry that you are working about the this kind of energy what is the most difficult thing to find investors and also to convince investors and keep what you thought in the beginning throughout the development of the company.

20:48sure. well, in in the beginning, I in the beginning of Tesla and and Solar City, I mean, I thought the the probability of success was was so low that I I provided all of the money. So, all of the money was just came from me personally. cuz I didn't want to ask people, other investors for money if I thought we were going to die because I thought I thought we would. So so I invested you know entirely the the money that I got from PayPal all of all of that got invested into Tesla Solar City and and SpaceX. and and even then we we only narrowly survived.

21:29So you know in 2000 2008 for Tesla we actually closed the financing round on Christmas Eve 2008. it was the last hour of the last day that it was possible. and you know this is one of the tricky things with with something like a car company is like there there there are good times and bad times and in and when the economy goes south then that's when things get really really tricky for a manufacturing company. so yeah I mean

21:59in in the US for example like the only two car companies that haven't gone bankrupt in history are Ford and Tesla. That's it. everybody else is bankrupt or went bankrupt at some point. You know, General Motors, Chrysler, and and others. So, so I think we we just made it by the skin of our teeth.

22:19The these days, the last few years, it's really I'd say the last two years is is when Tesla's achieved a level where it's not facing imminent death. I mean even as recently as as early 2013 we were operating with maybe one to two weeks of money. hi my name is Pascal and I would like to ask you don't you think that we need a deeper reflection about our dynamic of society because

22:54all the solutions that you are talking talking about is about efficiency but don't you think that we need to think differently and consume less because right now our is about confronting problems and going always in the same direction and trying to find the technological innovation to save us.

23:22Yeah. I mean I I do think we we should be watch our consumption. We shouldn't be wasteful. but but but even if we're re really conservative in our use of energy and are very effective with recycling and all sorts of things that that that delays the the need to move to a sustainable future but it doesn't eliminate it. like if if we don't have sustainable energy generation that that there's no way that we can conserve our way to to a good future.

23:57we we have to fundamentally make sustainable energy available. I mean on the on the plus side that that there's actually an enormous amount of sun of sustainable energy. I the the energy from the sun per square kilometer is a gawatt. So if you just had a 1 km by 1 km array of solar panels, it would be generating well it would be receiving a gigawatt of solar energy. then at at a 20% efficiency you'd be generating 200 megawws. so we can actually generate way more energy like probably I don't know 100 times more energy than we actually need to operate civilization just with solar panels. So we just we just need to fix the incentive structure of the world to

24:43make sure that that that that companies are are incented towards sustainable versus unsustainable technology. This is fundamentally the problem. Hello, my name is Lily and I'm a PhD physics students at Yale University, but I graduated here. So, I have three questions. So, the first one is sort of political because because you mentioned it, you said that scientists sometimes they diverge. They have a different opinions and it's probably Yes. on anything. Yeah. And that's also probably because sometimes they are financed by different corporations.

25:20Sure. And so you said we should stop the propaganda. We should try to ask the politicians to set the rules so that we will go in a better direction you know not climate you know global warming. but so that probably goes against the interest of oil companies but as well probably the governments themselves when they have a financial interest. So I was thinking perhaps your own I mean perhaps we could have lobbyists ourselves. So that would be perhaps an efficient way to to have those rules put into you know so

26:02so the these rules the carbon tax would be applied. So that's my first question. because also you know France is one of the u main importer of nuclear energy. So, you know, trying to ask them for a tax carbon tax when themselves are the the people who are making the most money from importing, you know, nuclear energy from power plants that are in France. We'll limit it to one question per person for now, I think.

26:32Thank you so much. Yeah. So, go ahead. The other question was, you know, renewable energy, that'd be great, but it's kind kind of intermittent, you know, like solar solar energy. Okay, that's great. But perhaps we need to store it with perhaps with lithium batteries, but we we want we want to use like Sure. Yeah, I see. The last one was the f fossil fuel area.

26:58I mean, yeah. I mean, is it not going to go to an end on its own because it's not an unlimited resource? Right. Maybe pick one out of the three questions, Elon. Sure. yeah. I mean I I I I think it's you each government should just that they they should do the right thing without waiting for without depending upon what other governments are doing. Like the I think that's you there's too much in these cl climate talks of of countries like trying to only do things if another country does it. I mean, if some if it's if it's the right if it's the right thing for the future, a country should just do it and don't worry about what other countries are doing. Just do the

27:47right thing. and many of the countries are. So, it's it's really just, you know, we just want to encourage as many governments as possible to change the rules to incent this is fundamentally what what what has to happen or we will substantially delay the transition away from carbon. So and and yeah,

28:11so that that's that's what it has to happen. and and and you know Tesla and Solar City that my companies are very tiny like we're tiny tiny companies. So the in order for there to be a big move towards sustainability the the the giant companies have to know that that that that is what the governments are demanding for the future and that's what the people are demanding for the future. So at the end of the day, if you know the governments respond to to polit to to to popular pressure, like if if you tell politicians that that your vote depends on them doing the right thing with climate change, that that makes a difference. So if if they're having sort of a a fundraising

28:54event or a dinner party or whatever, and at every fundraising event and every dinner party, somebody's asking them, hey, what are you doing about the climate? Then they will take action. So I think you have tremendous power. You you have the power to make the change. We can't we we can't let me tell you we definitely can't beat the oil and gas industry on lobbyists. Okay, this is that that would be a losing battle.

29:19you know the you know Exxon makes more profit in a year than the value of the entire solar industry in the United States. So it's like if you take every solar company in the United States, it's less than Exxon's profit in one year. There's no way you can win on money. It's impossible.

29:38Good evening, sir. I have just one small question, but very actual. do you think the COP 21 will be a success? You know, I I am I I have I don't have any real basis for this, but I have a good feeling about it. I I do have a good feeling about it. So I I think Well, it's going to be degrees of success. So it's sort of like like for example like the Copenhagen was was terrible like nothing nothing came out of Copenhagen the Copenhagen climate talks. I mean it was basically I think there was a net increase in global warming as a result of that one.

30:10unfortunately in the case of the Paris talks I I think there will be some positive movement and it's a question of what degree. and I think we need to send a clear message to the the negotiating teams and to to the politicians that this time there needs to be significant change. this time it which then something needs to happen.

30:29There's a question all the way up on the top. Hello and thank you for coming. My name is Maria and I'm a student of international relations here. My question to you is this. We know that climate is a global common good. So, how do we get countries with economies relying heavily on fossil fuels on board with climate change, which like how do we get those who have the most to lose on board? Thank you.

30:59I I think I think we just need to turn that argument around and say like look this this is a common good. and if if if we if if countries don't take action that they all will share in in a bad future. So they they need that everyone needs to take action and and care about what what the future's going to hold and lead by example.

31:28so even countries that that are quite dependent on on fossil fuels if they just change their tax structure they can they can move away from that in in a in a way that's not super disruptive to the economy. they it's really just a question of collecting like the same amount of taxes but but weighted towards things that we that's people believe are most likely to be bad instead of things that are most likely to be good. and we do this already in you know in in in our tax code. We we tax alcohol and cigarettes much more than we tax fruits and vegetables. It's just sort of the sensible things sensible thing to do.

32:08And nobody, you know, you don't and you don't hear, you know, countries saying, well, we make lots of fruit and you know, we make lots of fruits and vegetables, so like we we want low taxes or we make lots of alcohol and tobacco and we want, you know, lower taxes. Like that's a silly debate that it's gone.

32:23and I think the same thing applies to to carbon emissions. Just just adjust the tax code and the right thing will happen over time. And if you if it's graduated over time and you know it starts off small and becomes significant in the future then even if you're heavily dependent on carbon today the that that that message of of seeing what's going to happen in the future will have a huge impact on on the way that that any given country's economy works. So so so they will then become

32:54not dependent on carbon because of the incentive structure. So, I really don't think they have anything to lose here and anything to lose by taking action and a lot to lose by not taking action. We have time for maybe two or three more questions. So, there's one right here. Hi. my question is about batteries.

33:13So, electric batteries today, especially lithium ion, have a significant carbon footprint and potential impacts on both the environment and our health. and the environmental impact moves away from consumables and to how the way how we produce and how we store the waste that comes from it. So the gap with fossil fuels might not be as wide as we think. So my question is how do you respond to this and how do you see this evolving in the next years?

33:43so I'm not sure I totally understand that question. Could you say that again? Yeah. basically the the impact on the environment of today our ways of electrical batteries lithiumion the production of lithium ion batteries and how do you equate this with fossil fuel and its impact as it's more about the production and how we use the waste and how we store the waste and so how do you see this how is this going to be optimized in the next years or is this going to change? Yeah. Well, the important one thing is like once you've once you've built a battery, then at the end of life of the battery, you can recycle those components. So, it's it's a it's something that you know has no

34:23long-term or negligible long-term impact on the carbon cycle. because you you essentially you get the sort of the lithium and nickel, cobalt and and you create create the battery, you create you essentially get those materials once and then you recycle them forever. so I I think that the

34:45it's really a negligible impact for for for batteries on the environment. and yeah and and as compared to carbon producing mining and burning billions of tons of carbon every year which which effectively permanently from from a human standpoint affects the carbon the carbon content of the oceans and atmosphere. So yeah, it's

35:16it's really we're talking orders of magnitude difference between fossil fuels and batteries like not not even on the same scale. Okay, then the last one. hello. So my question is taking into consideration the technology now is at some of a breaking point it is advanced but not so advanced to pass to the sustainable clean energy. How do you see this integration of clean energy in for long term in the future step by step maybe? How do I see the integration? How do I see us getting to a sustainable energy future? Yes. Yes.

35:55How will will the clean energy integrate into the society taking into the consideration that technology isn't advanced? sure. Well, I mean I I I expect you know all transport to go fully electric over time with the ironic exception of rockets. and and then all energy production to go sustainable over time. this will take this will take a long time many decades.

36:25but you know the way it'll manifest itself is by people having batteries in their homes or at the utility substation and by driving you know electric vehicles and having electric planes. But as I said that this is this is going to be quite a very slow transition because the incentive structure is so biased against sustainable energy. So in fact even I

36:54think even if there's quite a strong action by government as a result of of the the climate talks in Paris, I think it's still going to be a transition that's measured in decades. So it will be it will be a slow a slow transition. and and and the fundamental question is how how do we accelerate that transition? That that's the real question here. what actions can we take that would accelerate a transition to a good future? and that's why I'm so so harping on this notion of a a revenue neutral carbon tax. I think that's something that that every country can implement.

37:36and it can be graduated and phased in over time and this is this will be by far the most effective thing for accelerating that transition to a good future. Okay. All right. Well, thank you everyone. [Applause]

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份