2008年圣诞节前两天,马斯克的钱快见底了。
特斯拉那一轮融资在经济危机里散架,SpaceX 的第三次发射又失败,他同时在办离婚。后来他承认,那段时间得跟朋友借钱付日常开销,住的房子也不在自己名下。
两年后,2010年,他把这段经历原样搬到一群创业者面前。这场对谈的主办方是 TheFunded,一家让创业者给风投打分的网站。坐在对面提问的是他宾大的室友 Adeo Ressi,两人当年合住过一栋十居室的房子,还一起折腾过类似夜店的派对生意。马斯克自称是那摊生意里"清醒的那一个",大学时期滴酒不沾,理由很朴素,受不了酒精的味道。
整场对话从"硅谷的创业者还敢不敢冒险"开始,中间经过给风投打分、特斯拉差点关门、火箭的成本账,最后落在一句关于创业的名言上。
他先在纸上列了三个领域
一切要从宾大说起。
读书时他反复琢磨一个问题:哪三个领域对人类未来的影响最大。他给出的答案是互联网,向可持续能源的转型(生产端和消费端都算),还有太空探索,尤其是让生命成为多行星物种。
注意他的措辞。他没说"我以后要做这三件事",他说的是这三件事做成了,人类的未来会好很多,所以如果有机会,他愿意参与进去。
1995年他跑到硅谷,连续两个夏天待在一家研究机构,那里在做高能量密度的超级电容器(ultracapacitor)。他原本要去斯坦福读高能物理和计算机的博士,真实目的很朴素:搞清楚超级电容器能不能量产,成本能不能压到足够低、能量密度能不能提到足够高,高到可以当电动车的储能方案。
这类研究有个残酷之处。你可能投入好几年,最后的结论只有三个字,不可能。他当时的说法是,至少能给知识树添点东西。
同一个夏天,他还在摆弄互联网软件。他有个感觉很强烈:世界正在长出一套神经系统。以前的人类社会像多细胞生物,没有神经,现在有了。你能在非洲的丛林里,实时知道地球上另一个角落发生了什么。
后面的事大家都知道了。互联网这条线先跑通,Zip2 和 PayPal 都出自这里。另外两条线,要等 PayPal 卖掉之后才真正开始。
如果这是最好的投资机会,他反而不做
Ressi 开场就抛出一个判断:硅谷的创业者比十年前更不敢冒险了。
他拿马斯克当反例。PayPal 那批人当年重新押注互联网,做 LinkedIn、投 Facebook、做 Slide,在当时被看作一群疯子。马斯克比他们还疯。刚卖完 PayPal,转身去做太阳能公司、火箭公司、电动车公司,很难凑出比这更离谱的组合。
结果呢,他的公司比那批人更早上市,NASA 的合同一笔接一笔。Ressi 问他从 NASA 拿到的钱是不是以十亿美元计,马斯克给的数字是"大约二十亿"这个量级。
Ressi 说,那现在谁才是疯子。
马斯克以前被问过同样的问题,他的回答很干脆:如果他当时认为这是排序最好的投资机会,他根本不会去做,那才叫疯。
如果我当时认为这是最好的投资排序,我就不会做这些事,因为那才是疯了。(马斯克)
这句话给整场对话定了底色。他做火箭、做电动车、做太阳能,出发点跟回报率关系不大,他在意的是这些事对人类未来的分量。钱是结果,不构成理由。
2007年,特斯拉差一步关门
Ressi 问他,为什么把那么多自己的钱压进去,是不是筹不到外部资金。
真正的转折点出现在2007年。那年特斯拉的处境已经很清楚,必须重新融资,把公司的资金规模翻一倍,否则只能关门。
为什么会走到这一步。他的解释是管理层犯了一连串错误,而且这些错误直到最后一刻才暴露。公司把大量资本压在生产和库存上,结果发现很多零件是错的、不工作的、规格不对的。库存做了大额减记,一批零件要重新设计,还有不少供应商要换掉。
那轮融资走的是一笔过桥贷款,没有做下调估值的 down round。
为什么不去找风投。他的回答很直白:以公司当时的状态,过不了任何一家机构的尽职调查。
于是他只剩两个选项。把手里的储备资本全部投进特斯拉,或者让公司死。
Ressi 提到一组数字,他在特斯拉和 SolarCity 上自掏腰包大约1.8亿美元,SpaceX 那边大概1亿美元。马斯克没有否认。2009年底他还向朋友借过钱,用来付日常开销。
那几年他把 PayPal 赚到的钱几乎全部重新押回牌桌,而且押在三个当时看起来最不可能成的方向上。
给风投打分,他给了一堆3分
TheFunded 是个给风投打分的网站,Ressi 顺势让他给自己的风投体验打分,1分最差,5分最好。
马斯克说,大概是中等,一堆3分。
有一些好的风投,但大多数不是。(马斯克)
他补了一句平衡的话:风投圈有不少坏行为,创业者圈也一样。就像最后能成功的创业公司只是少数,能做好的风投大概也是这个比例。他甚至开玩笑说,数量上谁更糟还不一定分得出胜负。
他自己的经历还算体面,早期那几家机构和红杉资本的合作体验不错。但整体判断就是三个字,及格线。
宁可估值低一点,也要选对人
他给台下创业者最实用的一条建议,是关于怎么选投资人。
接受一个你喜欢的、聊得来的风投给出的低估值,好过接受一个你合不来的风投给出的高估值。
Ressi 追问,这说的是具体的合伙人,还是机构。马斯克说两个都重要,合伙人稍微更重要一点。
理由很现实。你签下的是机构,打交道的是人。合伙人会离开,人一走,董事会里换进来一个你从没见过的董事,之前谈好的默契全部作废。他说自己就碰上过一回,领投的合伙人走了,留给他的是一堆麻烦。
这条建议背后是个更朴素的判断:创业是长期关系,估值是一时的数字,跟谁共事却是好几年的事。
钱不少,全挤在同一条赛道上
话题转到行业结构。Ressi 说大量资金涌进风投这个资产类别,1999到2000年那一波基金的回报会等于或低于标普500,这在历史上从来没发生过。他问,这个行业还有救吗,是不是钱太多了。
马斯克的回答换了角度。问题出在资本的流向,总量倒是其次。
太多钱在追显而易见的东西。大家盯着 IT,盯着社交,因为过去这些年成功案例都出自那里。资本的惯性把所有人挤上同一条赛道。
他的建议是范围放宽一点,多看几个不同的行业,硅谷得有人愿意去看那些不好懂、周期长、必须动手做硬件的地方。
清洁技术的盘子可能比互联网更大
Ressi 提到奥巴马在总统辩论里说,清洁技术是美国的"新 PC",能创造公司和就业。同时也有另一种声音,说基础科学的投入在减少,早期互联网和计算机那种由大学和政府打底的研发没人做了。
马斯克站在乐观那一边。他认为清洁技术是新方向,潜在的价值创造可能比互联网更大。理由很简单,能源在整个经济里占的份额太大了。
他还加了一层判断:能源的生产和消费必须转向可持续,这件事往后拖不了。需求摆在那里,机会就摆在那里。
Ressi 追问,那谁来写大支票。特斯拉这种公司,投5万美元出不了产品,只靠有钱的创业者自己掏钱,这个行业起不来。
PayPal 上市前烧的钱,比特斯拉还多
马斯克说,这里有个普遍误解。
很多人以为互联网创业资本效率高,其实 PayPal 在上市之前花了大约2.5亿美元,可能比特斯拉到现在花的还多。
物理硬件确实更难做演示。网站可以快速搭个 demo,汽车不行,得把真车造出来、跑起来、通过碰撞测试。但资本需求的差距,没有大家想得那么夸张。
他还举了一个反例。资本效率表现最好的公司,恰恰是很多人以为最重的 SolarCity。
SolarCity 是他回报倍数最高的一笔
那笔投资是他个人回报倍数最高的一笔,绝对金额排不上最大,倍数是他所有投资里最高的。到2010年,那笔钱大约涨了10倍,用了三四年时间。
然后他主动澄清了一件事:他不认为自己是 SolarCity 的联合创始人。他只是把想法提给了 Lyndon 和 Peter Rive 兄弟,建议他们做完手上的公司之后去做这个方向。他没有投入足够的汗水,所以不配这个头衔。
这个细节挺能说明他的标准。名声归名声,功劳归功劳,没干活就不挂名。
创始人要不要一直当 CEO
Ressi 提到一个硅谷的老问题。红杉这类机构习惯从外面找职业经理人来当 CEO,但统计上看,做得最大的公司往往是创始人一路带到最后的,苹果、甲骨文都是例子,盖茨离开微软是后来的事。
马斯克同意这个观察。最成功的那些公司,通常是创始人一直在场的公司。他当时仍然是 SpaceX 和特斯拉两家公司的 CEO。
他留了余地。他不确定一个人该永远当 CEO,未来某个时点应该换人,只是那一天离现在还很远。
那段纽约时报的公案
中间插了段轻松的对话。Ressi 说上次采访马斯克,马斯克管某个人叫 douchebag(混蛋),他在旁边笑了,结果被纽约的媒体写成坏人。
马斯克说,《纽约时报》后来发了更正,但没人读更正。那篇文章的前提本身就是误导的,作者该被形容成不负责任、误导,而且是故意的,绕一圈还是那个词。他还提到,《纽约时报》那位商业编辑和《纽约邮报》的一位作者配合,做了一次隔山打牛式的报复报道。
这段对话的价值不在八卦。它展示了马斯克面对媒体的方式:不绕弯,不装客气,也不指望更正能改变什么。
下一个想法:超音速电动飞机
有人问接下来要做什么。马斯克说得很明确,接下来一段时间专注 SpaceX 和特斯拉,暂时不会再创办新公司。
但他脑子里已经有一个设计:电动超音速垂直起降飞机。
他的判断是飞机行业创新太慢。波音777这一类机型,比上一代只好10%到15%,全是一点点挤出来的改进。他想做的是比现有技术水平领先几代的东西。
难点他也清楚。让它飞起来不算最难的部分,真正难的是航程,以及航空业要求的那种可靠性。民航乘客对安全的要求,实验室里凑合不出来。
把高速公路做成预制件
另一个想法更接地气:用航空航天的高强度轻重量结构技术,做预制好的双层高速公路段。
逻辑是把路段的金属结构在工厂里造好,运到现场直接吊装就位,对现有交通的影响降到最小。
这套方案在美国和欧洲算得过来账。人工贵,封路修车道的代价高,交通延误的成本是天文数字。在新兴市场不一定成立,要看材料成本和人工成本的对比。
他说这个想法如果做成,影响可能是最大的几个之一。印度那种堵车程度他自己领教过,不到5%的汽车保有量就能堵成那样,一段路能堵七个小时。
送宇航员上空间站,最终送人上火星
观众问 SpaceX 会不会像维珍银河那样做太空旅游。
马斯克的回答保持了他一贯的顺序:先接航天飞机的班。
SpaceX 打算把宇航员送到空间站,承担航天飞机的载人运输职能。国会为这件事打过一场大仗,争论点是空间运输由政府自己运营,还是外包给商业公司。他的判断是商业路线正在赢。
如果能送 NASA 的宇航员,当然也愿意送私人宇航员。
长期目标不在旅游上。SpaceX 的长期目标是让人类成为多行星物种。这句话在2010年听起来像口号,他说得很平静,就像在陈述一份工程计划。
他也承认工作量已经超过"有趣"的临界点。一个人同时管两家公司,还兼着火箭的首席设计师,这个节奏对身体和精神都是硬考验。
火星殖民地会是个工程殖民地
有人问他是不是真的打算在火星退休。
他的回答很谨慎:不能保证,因为中间要发生的事太多。但他觉得那样很酷,所以那算一个愿望,谈不上预测。
接着他描绘了那个殖民地会是什么样。
那不会是一群日结工待的地方,整天问"我该干什么"。那会是人类最优秀的大脑聚在一起。(马斯克)
他还加了一句判断:出于必要,那会是一个工程殖民地。要建的东西太多,要设计的东西太多,第一批过去的人必须会动手。
从"最大的书呆子"到"去书呆子化一百倍"
有观众问性格。Ressi 抢答,说他以前是我见过最大的书呆子,这二十年去书呆子化了一百倍。
细节很生动。马斯克大学时不喝酒,理由是不喜欢酒精的味道。他是那个直肠子,朋友遇到麻烦会喊他:Elon,警察来了,你去处理一下。
这跟他在台上的形象差别其实不大。一个把精力全部投进工程问题的人,社交上通常显得钝一点。区别只在于,成名之后他学会了怎么在公开场合把话说得不那么钝。
幸福曲线:2007年下滑,2009年最糟
一位观众问了个很好的问题。做那些真正激励自己的事,对个人幸福有多大帮助。
马斯克的回答没有粉饰。
2007年特斯拉的困境显形,他不得不把大量时间投进去,个人幸福大幅下滑。2008年更糟,2009年还要更糟。
最低点在2008年末。特斯拉那一轮融资因为经济崩盘而散架,SpaceX 第三次发射失败,他同时在办离婚。
三件事同时塌下来,任何一件单独拿出来都够呛。
转折来得也很戏剧。第四次发射成功,SpaceX 拿到了合同,圣诞节前夕完成了一轮内部融资。他后来说,那是他人生里最接近悬崖的一次。
火箭首席设计师,同时是 CEO
Ressi 在台上感叹了一句:他既是火箭的首席设计师,又是汽车的主要工程师之一,还是 CEO。
马斯克接过话,说自己对第三次发射失败负有部分责任,因为他就是那枚火箭的首席设计师。
Falcon 1 在第四次发射中成功入轨。Falcon 9 被 NASA 选中,接替航天飞机的货运职能。航天飞机第二年退役,Falcon 9 顶上。载人运输也越来越可能交给它。
接下来的成本对比,是整场对谈里信息密度最高的一段。
Ares I 火箭和 Orion 飞船,到2010年已经花掉100亿美元,能送到空间站的人数还不如 Falcon 9 加 Dragon。按当时的估算,把这两个项目做完还要再花200到300亿美元。
SpaceX 这边,Falcon 1、Falcon 9、Dragon 三个项目加起来花了大约5亿美元。要演示载人能力,可能再花5到10亿美元。
算下来,大概相当于对方成本的5%。
汽车那边的对比也类似。特斯拉的研发花了约1.5亿美元,通用的 EV1 花了超过10亿美元。比例没有火箭那么夸张,差距仍然显著。
他顺手给了一个判断公司价值的标准:一家公司的价值,等于它产生的自由现金流,除以产生这些现金流所需要的资本。任何行业都适用。想建一家值钱的公司,就要想办法用更少的资本撬出更多的现金流。
为什么不去海底
最后一个问题很尖锐。有观众问,海底有大量未知物种,探索成本只有太空的几百分之一,能带来新药和新知识,为什么 NASA 和私人公司都往天上跑,不往水下走。
马斯克的回答围绕"隔离"这个词。
如果地表发生毁灭文明的事件,退到海底算不上可行方案。水下的生态系统和陆地连在一起,一边出事,另一边跑不掉。
不同行星之间隔着几亿英里,这种距离才构成真正的隔离。地球上出了再大的事,另一个星球上的文明还能继续。
这是他全部太空热情的底层逻辑。他真正在意的是文明有没有备份。
嚼着玻璃,凝视深渊
活动最后要颁一个奖,Ressi 让他给台下的创业者留一句话。
他引用了一个朋友的说法,关于创办公司到底是什么体验。
创业就像嚼着玻璃,同时凝视深渊。(马斯克)
台下笑了。这句话之所以传得开,因为里面没有任何励志包装。它说的是真实体感:每天都在处理让你难受的事,同时看着一个可能吞掉你的深渊。
而讲这句话的人,刚刚用一小时讲完自己怎么在2008年从深渊边上爬回来。他给出的路径不带浪漫色彩:把钱全部压进去,承认过不了尽职调查的现实,然后等第四次发射。
给创业者的几条可操作建议
这场2010年的对话,能拎出来用的东西不少,大部分今天依然成立。
- 先想清楚哪几个领域对未来影响最大,再想自己能做什么。顺序反了,容易做成一家回报还行、你自己却不在乎的公司。
- 选投资人时把"聊得来"排在估值前面。合伙人比机构重要,人会走,董事会会换人,默契带不走。
- 融资之前先把公司状态修到能过尽职调查。状态不行的时候去融资,等于把命交给运气。
- 别默认互联网创业省钱。PayPal 上市前烧掉约2.5亿美元,不比造车便宜。判断资本需求要看行业的物理本质,看它需要多少真实世界的投入。
- 把资本效率当成设计指标。公司价值等于自由现金流除以产生它所需的资本,火箭上省下的每一块钱,最后都会体现在估值里。
- 做硬件创业,提前把"演示件"的成本和周期算进去。软件一周能出 demo,硬件不行,融资节奏必须按硬件的节奏排。
- 挑赛道时看它占整个经济的比重。能源占的份额极大,所以清洁技术的价值创造空间可能超过互联网。天花板由赛道决定。
- 别都挤在同一个方向。资本过剩往往体现在流向,而不是总量。所有人盯着 IT 和社交,意味着别处的钱和人才都不够。
- 想清楚自己做这件事的理由。只靠回报排序撑着的项目,遇到2008年那种局面很容易放弃。活下来的人通常有一个跟钱无关的理由。
- 长期目标可以定得大,短期执行要具体到零件。马斯克一边说让人类成为多行星物种,一边在算某个零件要不要换供应商,这两件事同时成立。
- 准备好同时处理多件坏事。2008年他同时面对融资崩盘、发射失败和离婚,抗压能力最终会落到一个具体问题上:那种状态下你还能不能做出正确决策。
- 对媒体叙事保持清醒。更正没人读,前提被扭曲的报道会长期存在。把精力放在做出东西上,比纠缠叙事划算得多。
- 验证需求的方式得靠真东西。汽车造出来才算数,火箭飞上去才算数,PPT 阶段的自信心不可靠。
- 最后一条来自"嚼着玻璃,凝视深渊"。听完这句话你还想做,那就去做。听完觉得这活儿不值得,那大概率是真的不值得,早点换一件事同样是好的判断。
0:01[Music] all right so the first thing i mean we're going to talk about obviously a lot of things you've learned from starting companies and there's a lot of first-time entrepreneurs in the crowd so advice you would give them like like jason did earlier but you got to one-up him really tell the truth and like give people you know the absolute pitfalls here which i know you'll do because you got me in trouble thank you for checking two months so first of all i want you about risk because i'm of the belief and i've written about this why wildly i think entrepreneurs i think entrepreneurs are really taking less risk in silicon valley than they were 10 years ago
0:41and i think you're interesting because you know your other paypal co-founders were considered really risky for getting back into the web as early as they were you know whether it was linkedin whether it was funding facebook whether it was slide a lot of these are they were really the pioneers and believing in the web again which was considered crazy at the time but you were considered crazier i mean you got done with bay found and you wouldn't have started a solar company a rocket company an electric car company like it would be hard to come up with a crazier combination and yet you've had a quicker ipo than those guys you have how many billions of dollars
1:15you're getting from nasa from spacex well we're about two yeah so who's the crazy one now i mean exactly i mean you told me before that like i asked you if you're crazy in an interview before and you said well look if i if i if i were thinking this is the best rank order investment i would not have done these because it would have been crazy yes absolutely what made you take your tell us about how you come up with an idea well a day i you know we were housemates in college and that would have been actually one really our first adventure together was running a kind of a nightclub yeah
2:04no it's really a nightclub that's how we first met we were actually just transfer students to japan and staying in like this the storm storm situation which was not not a lot of fun and and so we're just talking in the cafeteria like we really want to get out of this dorm situation so then we'll find a house that was this huge house that hadn't been rented and there were there so it was like 10 bedroom house and there were just two of us and we met to get this like this freshman to join us in the house dude chase's life forever
2:54he took a different path after after that year can you tell the most outrageous thing that happened tonight club don't worry yeah you know what's the amendment you plead at the foot [Music] but i did have my mom there one night
3:31the decoration in the house it was sort of like like a new york nightclub basically what was your role i was kind of the the sober one no yeah wow yeah anyway so it's back to taking risks yeah so that that was actually quite risky by the way if we've been blasted we've been defaulted but so let's see so in college i i try to think you know what are the three areas that would most affect the future of humanity at least in my opinion and the three areas that i that i could come up with were the internet the transition to sustainable energy both production consumption and space exploration particularly making life multi-planetary so it was it wasn't from the perspective
4:23of those were the things that i would expect to be involved in but rather those were things that i thought in the absolute most effective future of the magic so those were the things that if i had the opportunity i would like to get involved and my initial thought was was that i was to actually do something in electric vehicles and so i actually came out silicon valley spent a couple summers at a place called clinical research which developed the high energy test the ultra fasteners they're super expensive so the i said i was going to come to to stanford do a phd in high physics computer science and just kind of try to figure out if there was a
5:03way to to mass produce super capacitors while capacitors at low enough price and high enough energy density for them to be a energy storage solution for electric vehicles and that's what actually what originally pulled me out here and that was in 95 and so i was trying to figure out you know would this work or wouldn't it work this is one of those problems where you're not entirely sure whether success is one of the possible outcomes right well that's one thing that species don't want to fund that's really changed in silicon valley there's this stigma associated with like so-called science fair projects right so so like an an energy an ultra
5:44capacitor with that blown up costs and high enough energy so you compete with with batteries yes that's one of those things where the the you you could spend several years and then the conclusion would be this is not possible right and so okay well that's that's that was the path that i was involved upon you know you at least add something to the tree of knowledge yeah people notice the tree knowledge and then and there's a but that summer i was kind of just experimenting with some internet software and and i thought well you know i think there is going to be something that really fundamentally changes the world just seemed like the world was acquiring a nervous system
6:27you know like previously we were like this multi-cellular creature without a nervous system and now we we are we have acquired no system you could be in you know the jungles of africa or right now no i'm the biggest loser i went just before the world cup speaking of conference and then left unfortunately did you go back to that i know i just think says last year
7:01so do you think that people are taking efforts do you see people coming out of school and like i mean there's a lot of people who've said that america has lost its fascination with science i mean we don't have kids anymore growing up and wanting to be an astronaut we don't have kids you know in getting chemical sets for christmas i mean you obviously were one of those kids who was very interested liability issues well yeah like so my father was an engineer and so i grew up in an engineering situation mechanical engineering and but i think if that hadn't been the situation that i would have had a little exposure to it even in south africa you know so i think
7:37the you know one of the things maybe that engineers should have more kids whether it's their nature or nurture they're more likely to become engineers and you're you're doing that you have like yeah i'm doing my civic journey i've got makeup for lost ground with some okay so this is all this whole event is put on by the funded so let's talk about funding you've started several companies several companies in very wildly different spaces yeah you've done quite well yourself from what i unless the numbers have changed last i heard you i think put either it was 180 million between tesla and the basics of your own money but yeah and and a solar system yeah
8:22really but it's around 100 million from spacex yeah that was oldest really yeah i mean all the skin you had meaning you were eating raw noodles meaning you also had a million dollar house like how do you quantify that like it was it was all the best all liquid assets were sold i i don't actually own my house
9:04so wow yeah and actually as was publicized i had to borrow some money from friends last late last year to you know find fun looking expenses so let's talk about this whole idea of like having that degree of skin in the game i mean there's a lot of people who make a lot of money and invested in their friends companies and become angels i mean you didn't you didn't go that route there's also a lot of people who just want to keep that money and want to raise a lot of venture capital i mean you had crazy ideas but you also had already had a success you probably could have raised venture capital why put that much of your own was it out of need was no one gonna find a rocket
9:41company yeah well the the sort of surprise thing came really in 2007 when it was clear that tesla was in in a very difficult position and we need to recapitalize the the company essentially double funded the company so just to sort of it was either that or all that has to die and why was it in that position that is a long answer
10:15just the that there'd been a number of mistakes made by the management team there that just were very extensive mistakes and a lot of them and and and they've not been brought to light until really the 13th hour so we had sort of scaled up our production inventory so we spent a lot of capital on production inventory but there were a lot of parts that ignored that were wrong that didn't work that were out of spare that just didn't you know just problematic so i went to we had huge write-offs on inventory and we have to redesign a whole bunch of parts and and resource change change suppliers in number cases did you do a recap yeah it wasn't actually
11:14well it was it was kind of a bridge load so it was it wasn't a crown down or anything like that so how close were you two dying well it would have yeah so that that was the funny issue either i took you know i have a choice of either taking all my reserve capital and applying it to tesla based on all all free capital or tesla those are the two choices and finding funding for investors when the company is is was in the state was and that was it was just there was no chance we would not survive any diligence process so across your companies on a scale of of one to five would have been your experiences with venture capital one being i guess we'll go with the
12:05voting rights tonight one being the worst and five being the best i mean people you know the species get a lot of but they are to some degree the lifeblood of this industry i mean where do you fall in that have you had good experiences or mostly bad experiences probably medium george zachary's pink of threes well i think it varies considerably based on on which french capitalist is doing a deal i think that probably varies maybe as white as wildly as they are things which are entrepreneurs i think there are some some good venture capitalists and and but most are not go on you know yeah there's there's some i mean you know just like there are some only only a few companies
13:00ultimately succeed i think the same is probably true but are there more successful venture capitalists who aren't very nice to startups than there are not very good entrepreneurs who succeed there's a lot of votes i i'm not sure if we could win the numbers contest there i i i do think there's i mean this you know there's been a a lot of bad behavior by venture capitalists and you know probably a lot about the hero by five entrepreneurs so i think my experiences were actually pretty good you know with the mdd and then with sequoia
13:44yeah if i give my experiences out of five is the best rating what's one of the toughest lessons that you learn that might be applicable to this audience in terms of raising outside money i mean what are the big pitfalls you don't want to fall into whether it's angel or venture capital well i think it's better to take a lower evaluation from a venture capitalist that that you really like to get along with and feel that you're sort of the same wavelength it's better to take a lower evaluation from that person there's been a higher evaluation from someone who you think you may not get along with so yeah and so that sounds like it's more about the individual partner versus
14:41the firm i mean there's a lot of entrepreneurs who come to silicon valley and are dying to get an investment from sequoia you know not necessarily an investment from roll up or from mike or you know i think partners were smart they both both matter you're both both the individual partner and the firm i think probably the partner matters slightly more than the firm but they both matter because that partner could leave that firm and then do something by yourself with a new board member that you've been anticipating that that actually happened to me in one one case that i i went to about there that was the the lead partner that phone sucks
15:29[Laughter] so obviously a lot of your success particularly none it's not dfj it's not i'm trying to remember who else you mentioned refresh the ones it's not it's not found or something yeah
16:06so the way venture capital has changed in the time you've been out here i mean a lot of money has flowed into the asset class the bus novel standing more money was blowing into the asset class the returns of you know 199 and 2000 fall off will be at or below the s p 500 which has never happened in the industry before is this industry viable do you think it's broken do you think there's just too much money it needs to get out
16:49well i i do think that probably there should be a broader scope of investments that venture capitalists consider in silicon valley you know i think there's there's a little too much of people kind of focusing on on i.t or focusing on selecting because that's kind of the stuff that's gone before i think there needs to be kind of a broader you know i look at multiple different industries and and then i think there's there's probably not just not too much capital i think there's probably too much capital chasing the obvious stuff so how would how do you think we're doing on cleantech there was a lot of hype several years ago between technically this big wave of
17:34silicon valley and if you look at it as we started with semiconductors that went computers went to software and priced off and sort of everything spiraled up to the web there's a lot of people arguing that's kind of the logical conclusion of that wave and we need a new way a lot of people wanted that to be cleantech during the presidential debates barack obama said clean tech is are the new pc for america in terms of creating companies and creating jobs but you know there's a lot of people who feel that that basic investment of science is sort of not being done the stuff that was done in the early days of the internet that in computer that drove a lot of that
18:04do you think that we're all talk when it comes to cleantech or do you think that you know people are taking risk and really building that foundation well i do think that cleantech is is the kind of new way and yeah and and the the potential value creation there i think is probably greater than on the internet just if you think of just look at the size of the economy that energy that constitutes it's it's huge what way where are we going so you know and we are you know sort of almost topological that we're going to need to we're going to have to move to sustainable production and consumption of energy it's not sustainable it's you know relator yeah
18:54so i do think there's there's there's actually a a lot of opportunity there and and we will see a lot of value creation in the cleantech space you know tesla's done pretty well you know i think i think one of the i'm not sure how we rank but i think we're one of the better ideas this year but that's sort of the question is when it comes to people who want to invest in clean tech like who's willing to write the chat i mean you would put a lot of your own money into tesla yeah so does that mean only wealthy entrepreneurs start cleaning companies i mean do you think there's the willingness for people to write the big checks to really develop this space i mean tesla was not
19:40a web company where you can invest fifty thousand dollars and get a product out no but you know if you look at something like paypal people might assume that hey paypal was not a high capital endeavor but we spent about the same actually maybe more on on paypal before going public than we've been on tesla so paypal was like maybe 250 200 billion dollars that other investments before being public so it wasn't a small change and it is a little harder to get it like a demonstration article when you talk about physical hardware then they took a it's a website you can do some quick demo or whatnot but but i think in terms of capital i think that there
20:27is i think there's actually sort of a misapprehension about the capital needs of a internet startup versus say a car company or a solar company or something like that the most the most capital efficient company so far which will be my and it is actually my highest return on investment is solar station by far you'll never hear about solar city tell us about it how much did you put in how much is it doing what is that statement yeah well it's just it's just factually true it's not it's not the largest it's it's not the largest returning absolute dollars but it's the largest retinal investment it's yeah it's at this point 10 10 at twitter connects
21:16with my original investment that's looking like a portion of the company it can be more than that and that's in the course of three or three years four years yeah
21:43i should be clear in case of of solar city i don't consider myself a co-founder of solar city well i i did actually suggest the the idea to leonard and peter ryan that this was an area that that that they should pursue once they're done with their other company but i didn't put enough i'd say perspiration into solar city to really work the co-founders i have two quick questions and then i think maybe we're gonna open up the audience we'll pick a couple questions okay so just real quick so you know i'm interested because i think there's a lot of founders in this room there's a lot of people with good ideas and there's this issue in silicon valley
22:22whether you can be a founder but have to stay the ceo a lot of people like sequoia who you mentioned tend to bring in a lot of other people to be ceos founders fun was started with the idea of no you know in statistically the people who build the biggest companies or when the founder stays involved the whole way you know you kind of step away from the tesla okay back right i think are you still the ceo of both businesses yeah yeah so i mean what is your view on this does the founder need to stay the ceo well i think i think what founders one says it's true i mean if you look at say apple or oracle or you know microsoft report gates left you know it's it's true you know
23:07the biggest companies most successful companies we want is run by their founder as well wait one more question i want more questions oh oh you're fine i'm done okay so last time i interviewed elon i asked him a question and he called someone a douchebag and i laughed because i thought it was funny i got written up in new york media as like a horrible person for laughing that someone was [Music] i called want to get into your personal issues at all but i just want to give you this form if there's anyone else you'd like to call a douchebag
23:51yeah i mean yeah new york times did print a correction but you know the thing with corrections on that article the guy left was a douchebag because [Music] he wrote but nobody reads corrections so it was the fundamental premise of the article it was yeah i mean it was just incredibly misleading i mean i should have said it was irresponsible and misleading and intentionally so ergo he is a
24:57that would just be repetitive there's i mean there was recently an article in new york times that was the same editor who who wrote the attack piece on you he did basically a bank shot with his buddy in your post yeah that's the guy the guy did the bank shot on you in new york post that the study times business editor you know sort of wrote a payback article well how to pay back like working on a couple weeks ago in the new york times which obviously that that was not a great
25:40thing [Applause] time but people seem to be enjoying i was transfixed so three questions answer honestly whoa there's a lot of hands so all the questions what do we have on here these people have come in all right two and a half questions no okay what's your next what are you doing next
26:18well i i i'm definitely focused on spacex and tesla and and and donated tanks to start any companies for for a while i need to get a few things done with spacex and tesla at some point i i have a design in mind for electric supersonic vertical technology [Applause] don't think there's been that much innovation in in airplanes
26:56we've just traveled oh you're not at all especially coach right yeah you've got the triple seven and the these things are very very incremental like they're like 10 15 percent better than the last version so i think it'd just be worth trying to do something that's several generations beyond the current state-of-the-art and i decided i'm very confident with work it's just a question of like the what sort of range can you achieve and and how difficult would be to achieve the level of reliability that people come to expect in aviation those are really the tough parts it's not we'll look let's make it work so just that and and i have to say for using aerospace construction
27:51techniques as you know spaceflix the high strength low low weight design techniques used in space industry to create prefabricated metal sections of a double decker highway system so you can sort of drop them in place with minimal effect on the existing traffic pattern does that be affordable for emerging markets i mean like you can't even get through intersection it took me seven hours to get your medium and buy less than five percent of india's cars i mean this is a massive meeting yeah i do think this this actually would be yes this would probably have the bigger you know one of the biggest impacts if if this can be done right i i'm not sure
28:42how well it would work in emerging markets it kind of depends on sort of like materials cost versus labor cradle i'm confident that it would work in you know like in the u.s or in europe or something like that where labor is kind of expensive and and the cost of traffic delays of like you know adding a lane to a highway and having that temporarily reduce the amount of traffic that's incredibly expensive so i'm confident of that that it would work economically in the us and it might work it might work in emerging markets maybe for like you know certain big big studies here exactly elon's factory by the way in los angeles is incredible all right
29:25my name is casey leon with papi tv one question do you have a space x have you thought about evolving it into space tourism similar to virgin galactica well we with spacex we do intend to carry astronauts to the space station essentially take over the crew transport role of the the space shuttle and this big battle that's been fought recently in congress over this as to whether it's going to be kind of a government-run system or whether it makes sense to outsource national transport therapies that the commercial route is winning and so if we're carrying us astronauts i think we certainly also want to carry private private astronauts and and then ultimately the long-term goals
30:18of spacex is to try to i'm moving us in the direction of becoming a multi-planet species and staying lucky under that that's sort of obviously that involves a lot of firing of people on fire [Music] no the workload is beyond the fun point so yeah i mean and i you know i'm not sure that somebody should be ceo coming forever either yeah so i think that at some point in the future not in the near term but something in the future
31:20this is so this is your first public experience yeah in silicon valley speaking right since you want to call it the password yeah that's awesome all right let's take a few more questions aj thomas with romantic seed as a gen y blogger i wanted to ask you do you really plan on retiring on mars well i can't say it's like i'm certain that i work our laws because that requires a lot of things have to happen between here and there i think it's just i think it would be cool to do that
31:57so that is not predictive it is is just saying that like you know yeah aspirationally first of all possible situations then yeah it would be great to ultimately prepare and wise it's not going to be filled with a bunch of day laborers who are like what do i do it's going to be like the great minds of humanity it kind of it kind of would be sort of i mean i think of necessity it would be somewhat of an engineering colony just because you got to build a lot of stuff and design a lot of stuff so
32:35hi my name is buday i'm the founder of live on campus i wanted to ask you we hear a lot about the personalities of a founder or ceo both both you and jason are obviously very successful but slightly different personalities i'd say i'm curious do you feel i mean did you were you always this way as being more low-key or did you sort of mellow into kind of the personality you have now well you know there's probably answers yeah that's a question he was the biggest dork i've ever met
33:11he's actually de-dorkified a hundredfold between over 20 years you're much cooler i mean i remember but back then it was kind of painful he'd be like he literally was the straight man didn't drink i'd always be like elon i think the police are here can you deal with it sure i'm fine
33:37yeah i didn't i didn't drink in college actually i mean i'm not for about it not bro i wasn't i just didn't like to use alcohol really and then it's a flavor issue [Laughter] thank you your work is just impressive sincerely impressive part of one of the catalysts i think with being an entrepreneur is is trying to do things that motivate you things that you love but money always comes second usually so how how much has focusing on humanity actually improved your own personal happiness that's a great question you have been successful there so yeah with some ideas that were pretty far out
34:26yeah that's true well my personal happiness took a took a big dive when you know around 2007 when when you know that when tesla's difficult situation became apparent and i had to substantially increase my time in palpation that that that clues top and in 2008 was worse in 2009 it was even
35:00worse [Music] the cars and like salt a lot of this props really was worse in 2008 and worse in 2009 well okay so probably the lowest point was late 2008 when the tesla financing round fell apart because the economy went into a tailspin the third spacex rocket launch failed and i was getting divorced
35:46yeah that sucks and then unfortunately the fourth launch worked and i spoke for spacex and we were able to close a financing kind of internal financing round basically yeah late christmas eve on in 2008 [Music]
36:25sure so so falcon one is a floor rocket that's the one that's secured on fourth launch and i i'm certainly partly to blame there because i was the chief designer of the rocket so this is crazy like he's the chief designer of the rocket and one of the lead engineers in the car on top of the ceo yeah
37:11[Music] we we succeeded on the first flight in railroad kids orbit and falcon 9 is is what nasa has chosen to replace the cargo transport function of the space shuttle so space shuttle retires early next year and and falcon 9 will be work to replace the cargo transport that's that's a given and then it's looking increasingly likely that it will face the space shuttle as far as crude transport as well so let me help you phrase the question better like give give perspective like how long did it take to develop a comparable payload rocket and how much money and how long did it take for you to develop the nine and how much money just put by orders magnitude
38:05well if you were to compare say the the 59 to the the aries one vehicle and there's actually two password there's there's talking in our dragon spacecraft right and then there's ares one and the orion spacecraft so so far 10 billion has been spent on aries one orion and it carries fewer people to the space station than falcon 9 dragon between falcon 1 falcon knight and dragon we've spent about half a play there will be more spent between now and then because you know more test flights would probably they will spend more too yeah yeah true so the estimated cost for completing ares one orion would be another 20 to 30 billion for us it would be probably
39:04to demonstrate crude get to all that maybe it's another billion or 500 million something like that so we're somewhere in the maybe five percent of the cost is that comparable to tesla with electric car versus what's been on the eb1 i mean what is the delta is it similar yeah so just in r d cost on the tesla so we spent yeah about maybe 150 million thereabouts and the eb1 i think they spent over a billion so it's maybe not as significant a ratio but it's still still very significant and you know the the value of any company is the free cash flow that it generates versus the capital required to generate that free cash flow that's really what defines the market
39:56capital of any company in any industry so you know so if you want to build a valuable company that's what you're gonna do you're gonna figure out how do you make the capital generate a lot of free cash flow robert clegg founder of novers creating educational video games you discover more life going underwater more species we have no idea about you know on a cost savings of hundreds of times any disasters in the relatively near future are not going to send our civilization into space we're probably going to go underwater to what's why aren't we exploring more underwater for cures science all these undiscovered species and new life forms in your in your estimation why aren't we
40:46going underwater with nasa instead of out everywhere well i i think that that's that's not quite the right you know if something were to happen that that destroyed civilization on on the surface i i don't think that retreating underwater is is really a you know viable option it's difficult to say what what is that thing you know the civilization is not going to last forever forever so if you you know some point in the future something but bad will happen or maybe some set of bad things will happen probably not there's probably a series of things that would happen that way just racialization
41:32and you know just i just i don't think there's enough separation like let's say we underwood colonies or something i don't think you really have enough separation between land what's going on land what's going on in the water to really not have the what what effects won't affect the other but if you're at different planets that are separated by hundreds of millions of miles then even if something really terrible happened on earth i think you'd probably be okay on the other planet
42:02yeah so that's that's my theory right now so one we gotta get back to the the business of awarding a winner and a cheesy trophy is one last five we got probably most of the houses entrepreneurs judges if you want to get ready because we're going to speed through this one parting thought for them inspiration comment anything
42:32well actually i i i kind of like a quick for a friend of mine bully about starting companies which is it's like eating glass and staring into the abuse of death
42:54eating glasses [Music] [Applause]
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版