访谈·中文精读

马斯克 SEC“资金已到位”证词视频 第4部分

Elon Musk SEC "Funding Secured" Deposition Video Part 4

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2018年那场会开了大约40分钟。两年后坐在SEC律师对面,马斯克能回忆起来的细节只剩三样:有人递给他一罐红牛,一位沙特来客坐在桌子对面,以及一句被反复重复的话,“你定条款,我们照做”。

监管要查的是“资金已到位”这五个字有没有事实基础。马斯克给出的说明带着浓重的商业味,跟法律答辩的腔调相去甚远。他讲的是一笔生意为什么在他看来已经谈成了。

这份证词耐读的地方在过程。一个记忆模糊到需要律师反复提醒日期的人,凭什么笃定那笔钱一定在。他的论证链条拆开看,其实相当清晰。

一罐红牛,四十分钟,一张没递出去的名片

证词开头散得很。律师在确认会议细节:有没有单独相处,有没有人递东西,名片有没有交换,会议开了多久。

马斯克的回答是:整场会大约40分钟。他只在与亚西尔·鲁马扬(Yasir Al-Rumayyan,沙特公共投资基金负责人)离开会议室时单独相处了“大概10秒钟”。他没注意到有人做会议记录。名片确实拿到了,但会议期间没有发生任何文件交换。

那罐红牛是别人给的。他补了一句,自己平时也会收到各种东西,通常往桌上一放就不看,因为大多是通用模板类的文件。他很确定对方没有给他任何“高度敏感”的东西。

这些细节看着琐碎,实际在回答一个核心问题:这场会到底谈成了什么,有没有留下书面痕迹。答案是:没有意向书,没有备忘录,连一封确认邮件都没有。

马斯克在证词里反复回到这一点,并且把它当成论据来用:一家管理着数千亿美元的基金,在没有要求任何书面保障的前提下,先掏钱买了几十亿美元的特斯拉股票。这种行为的可信度,高于任何一纸协议。

沙特人带来的新信息:5%是被规则卡住的

那场会上,对方披露的信息让马斯克感到意外。

他们告诉马斯克,已经在公开市场买入了价值数十亿美元的特斯拉股票,持股接近5%。没能继续买下去的唯一原因,是美国的披露规则:跨过5%这条线,就必须公开申报。

马斯克在证词里强调,这件事他们此前从未明说。更早的某次会面中,对方只说过“会投资特斯拉”,后来真的投了。他的评价很直白:这些人说话算话,说要做的事就会做。

他还做了个推算:如果美国的披露门槛是10%,他们就会买到10%。门槛划在哪里,他们的买入就停在哪里。卡住他们的只有这一条规则,跟意愿无关,跟对公司前景的犹豫也无关。

这就构成了整份证词最结实的一层逻辑:他们已经投了钱,而且明确表示想投更多。

他当场纠正了自己的一个误解

证词里有一段很容易被忽略,却对理解整件事很关键。

马斯克原本以为,沙特方面对特斯拉私有化的兴趣,已经被委托给另一家机构去处理了。会上对方当场纠正了他。

这件事没有被委托出去。我们想私有化特斯拉,已经想了两年。(马斯克复述沙特方面在会上的表态)

“两年”这个时间跨度,在他的判断里分量很重。它代表一个持续了两年、反复被提起的意图,跟临时起意的随口一提完全不同。

对方的表态还包括:马斯克可以设定任何合理的条款;如果需要的资金规模更大,他们希望获得与之匹配的战略参与度,比如建厂这类安排。

马斯克把这场会的性质总结得很干脆:

告诉我你想怎么做,我们就照做。我们想做成这件事,那就做吧。(马斯克在证词中复述对方的原话)

“合理”到底划在哪条线上

律师在这里追问得很细:对方说的“任何条款”,字面上能走多远?

马斯克举了个例子。如果有人提出以每股8000美元的价格把公司买下来,那显然不合理,这种要求超出了正常私有化交易的范围。只要落在正常私有化交易的框架内,对方的立场就是“这单已经成交”。

他进一步解释了自己理解的边界:

  • 价格溢价在正常区间内,比如20%左右,没问题
  • 溢价高到200%,那就属于离谱
  • 要求把巨额资金直接支付给马斯克个人,属于离谱
  • 要求马斯克拿到全部投票权,对方可能会有异议,虽然他从没提过这种要求

他特意强调,对方嘴里的“合理”没有精雕细琢的法律定义,更接近“只要不觉得自己被宰了就行”。

只要条款不宰人、在正常私有化框架下是公平的,这单就成交了。(马斯克描述对方的态度)

这个区分很重要。SEC关心的是那句公开声明有没有事实基础,而马斯克给出的答案是:基础存在于对方的资金行为和历史一致性里,纸面上你找不到。

发推前的那个周末:三通电话

证词后半段进入时间线梳理。律师显然希望把发推前的每一步都钉在具体日期上,马斯克的记忆明显跟不上这个精度。

他能确认的几件事排下来是这样的。

周六,他和史蒂夫·罗森布鲁姆(Steve Rosenbloom)通过电话。罗森布鲁姆来自银湖资本(Silver Lake),曾在迈克尔·戴尔(Michael Dell)的私有化交易中担任法律顾问。更早的时候,也就是当年年初,马斯克在SpaceX和他见过一面。当时马斯克说自己一直想考虑把特斯拉私有化,对方回应说,如果哪天认真考虑这件事,给他打个电话。

周六,他还和迈克尔·戴尔本人聊过。这通电话的用途是取经:私有化之后感觉怎么样,后不后悔,觉得这个决定对不对。他没有提沙特的任何具体信息。

周一晚上,也就是发推前一晚,他和埃贡·杜尔班(Egon Durban,银湖资本联席CEO)通了电话。

此外还有一些更简短的交流,对象包括“山姆”和另一位他记不清名字的人,内容无非是私有化的利弊、更大规模的沙特投资等等。他说自己“很可能聊过”,但“想不起任何实质内容”。

律师追问有没有和某位特定人物通过电话。马斯克的回答是:可能有短信,但他不认为有通话,也不记得任何实质内容。他甚至直接说,有些人的电话他根本不接。

他想要的投资人结构,和罗森布鲁姆的意外

和罗森布鲁姆的沟通里,有一段关于股权结构的讨论值得单独拎出来。

马斯克告诉对方,沙特的意愿很明确,支持力度很大,条款基本可以由他来定。但他自己的偏好是更分散的投资者基础,不希望单一股东持股过多。他给出的数字是15%,最多到20%。他特意说明这只是他个人的看法,不代表对方开出的条件。

他关心的另一点是现有股东的去留。他判断大部分投资人会继续留在公司里,于是问罗森布鲁姆:引入更多投资人、把股东结构做得更分散,让任何单一投资方都无法施加过度影响,这条路可行吗?

罗森布鲁姆的回答是“绝对可行”,说市场上兴趣很大,他确信会有很多人愿意参与。后来那些投资人被逐一问到时,据说每一个都答应了。

这里有个细节。罗森布鲁姆最初的假设,是按戴尔那笔交易的标准模板走的,也就是除马斯克之外,几乎所有股东都会被买断出局。马斯克花了些力气纠正他。

我不想挤出小股东。我不想任何人被迫卖出。我要的只是找到一个能更好执行的办法。(马斯克在证词中复述自己的原话)

他补充说,这件事跟提高自己的持股比例无关,他不在乎自己的持股有没有变化。他需要的是造车,把公司规模做起来,而且要尽可能少受干扰。

罗森布鲁姆听完的反应是“这是个高尚的原则”。马斯克回了一句:“我只是想在这里把事做成,想有点用。”

他真正想摆脱的东西:集体诉讼和季度边界

这段证词解释了他为什么对私有化如此执着。他能给出的理由跟融资无关,指向的是运营环境。

他拿SpaceX做对照。SpaceX的间接费用很低,没有密集的短期业绩优化压力,也不会出现那种“股价一动就有人假定相关即因果、然后递上诉状”的集体诉讼。

火箭炸了,我们不会收到一堆人说我们本该知道火箭会炸的集体诉讼。你觉得我们是想让它炸吗?(马斯克在证词中的表述)

特斯拉面对的是另一套逻辑。股价波动会立刻转化为法律风险,管理层的注意力被迫分配到解释和应诉上。他想把特斯拉搬进SpaceX那种环境:目标清晰,评价周期长,不必为每个季度的边界做短期优化。

他也说清楚了特斯拉存在的意义:推动可持续交通和可持续能源。私有化是手段,目的始终落在前面那句话上。他甚至说,如果自己的持股比例一点变化都没有,他也无所谓。

Zip2的阴影:他不想再要一个动机不纯的董事会

证词里有一段离题的自嘲,信息量不小。

马斯克提到自己创办的第一家公司Zip2。投资方包括赫斯特(Hearst)、纽约时报公司,还有一家叫Nightrider的机构。他顺口吐槽了这个名字:

这名字糟透了,史上最差的名字。这就是把命名权交给广告公司的下场。(马斯克谈Zip2的命名)

他记得Zip2做过互联网上第一批地图和导航服务,也做过第一批白页和黄页,还帮一批中小报纸把内容搬上网,帮大报改进过网站。这些成绩他讲得挺高兴。

但他同样记得另一件事:那些战略投资人有自己的非财务目标,跟公司本身的利益并不完全一致。

我们有一项很好的技术,却没有被有效应用。(马斯克谈Zip2的经历)

这段回忆解释了他对私有化之后董事会构成的担忧。就算交易条款干净,如果董事会里坐着动机不纯粹的战略投资者,公司还是会被拖住。他不想再进一次那个局。

一个他亲口承认的根本性误解

证词里有一处马斯克主动承认的认知错误,值得单独看。

他原本以为,私有化之后有办法让大量小股东继续留在公司里。他在证词里说得很直接:这是他理解上的一个根本性错误。

这个误解直接影响了他对交易复杂度的估计。他告诉罗森布鲁姆,大部分现有投资人,包括大股东和散户,都会保留持股。罗森布鲁姆的反应是:如果真是这样,需要的资金会比戴尔那笔交易少得多,尽管特斯拉的估值更高。

换句话说,马斯克当时对私有化的想象,是一笔“名义金额巨大、实际动用资金相对有限”的交易。这个判断建立在“股东会留下来”这个前提上,而他自己后来承认,这个前提站不住。

“痛苦的最小面积”

律师问他是怎么做出最终决定的。马斯克的回答方式,更像在描述一个优化问题。

他说,管理两家公司本来就非常吃力。私有化意味着接下来几个月到一年里痛苦显著上升,之后四年大概会舒服一些。他需要判断的是这段时间里“痛苦曲线下的面积”,或者换个说法,痛苦的净现值。

我们要算的是痛苦的最小面积。(马斯克在证词中的表述)

他承认这个计算充满不确定性,也承认这是一片他没走过的地图。SpaceX的私有状态是已知的,问题是怎么从特斯拉走到那个状态,以及走过去的代价有多大。

他还提到一个现实约束。特斯拉当时正处在关键节点上,目标是第三、第四季度实现现金流转正和微幅盈利。私有化必然带来一段管理开销的短期激增,这个风险必须算进去,所以决定要么快做,要么推到几个季度之后再谈。

股价涨50%,这事就做不成

证词里有一段关于市场反应的推演,逻辑很干脆。

马斯克说,影响他决策的一个重要变量,是财报电话会之后市场的反应。如果股价涨到离谱的程度,私有化就不具备可行性,因为没有人知道这波涨幅会在哪里停下来。

他给了具体的界限:如果股价涨了50%而不是15%,在当时那个时点,私有化基本不可行。他并没有说永远不做,只是得等这波涨势退下去。

他解释了原因。如果在股价高点之上再加一层私有化溢价,总价会超出合理性的边界。他还提到,特斯拉历史上出现过几次股价被他本人公开认为“明显过高”的情况,他担心这次可能又是一次。

实际结果是,财报后股价确实涨了不少,但没有涨到让交易无法成立的地步。

记忆的缝隙:周三、周五还是周六

这份证词最真实的部分,是马斯克对自己记忆的反复修正。

他记不清决定发出收购意向的那封邮件是周五写的还是周三写的,只能说“我印象里是周五,但可能是周三”。他记不清和罗森布鲁姆的通话是周六还是别的日子,只能说“如果我没记错的话”。他记不清某次会面是几个月前还是年初,只能给个大概区间。

律师几次要求他用文件来锚定日期,他的回应是:如果有文件能帮忙确认具体时间,那会有帮助。

这些空白不能证明撒谎。一个人在两年后被问到某次电话的具体日期,记忆出现偏差是常态。但这也解释了为什么SEC会盯着那句“资金已到位”不放:一句几秒钟内发出的推文,需要在几年后用大量模糊的记忆去支撑。

马斯克在证词里给出的支撑,最终落回两件事。几十亿美元的真金白银已经到账,这一点有交易记录。对方在会上明确说过“条款你定,我们照做”,这一点只有记忆。

他为什么最终接受了“继续上市”这个结果

证词快结束时,马斯克说了一段话,语气比前面松弛。

他提到,最终如果不私有化,算不上理想,但权衡下来大概也是正确的选择。他还半开玩笑地对律师说,希望你们别把我折腾得太狠。

这句话背后是一个没被追问下去的转折:从“这单已经成交”,到“继续上市”。中间发生了什么,这份文字稿没有展开。能看到的只有他对私有化价值的判断,以及他对公开市场环境的疲惫。

把整份证词串起来看,他的核心主张其实只有一句:判断一笔钱会不会到位,要看对方已经付出了什么代价,而不是听承诺包装得多么漂亮。一个已经用几十亿美元投票、并且明确表示想投更多的资金方,在他眼里就是“资金已到位”。至于这个判断在法律上是否成立,那是另一个问题。

这份证词能给普通人什么

它讨论的是几百亿美元的交易,但里面有几个判断方法,放在日常合作里同样成立。

  • 先看对方已经投入了什么,再听对方承诺了什么。沙特基金在没有任何书面协议的情况下先买了几十亿美元,这种“先付钱再谈”的行为,比任何口头保证都更能说明意图。
  • 把“合理”的边界提前说清楚。马斯克举的例子很实用:20%溢价属于正常,200%就是离谱,给创始人个人塞一笔巨款也是离谱。谈判前先划定“什么算宰人”,比事后争论条款更容易达成一致。
  • 重要沟通留痕。这份证词里最耗时的部分,是所有人都在猜某个电话发生在周几。一封确认邮件能省掉几年后的这场拉锯。
  • 警惕战略投资人的非财务目标。Zip2的经历让马斯克对董事会构成格外敏感,这个教训不分行业:给钱的人如果另有所图,钱越多,麻烦越大。
  • 算“痛苦曲线下的面积”,别只盯着收益。马斯克评估私有化时,把未来一年的管理开销激增和之后四年的顺畅放在同一个坐标里权衡。做重大决定时,把时间维度拉长,很多看起来划算的选择会露出另一面。
  • 承认自己的认知盲区。他主动说出“我以为小股东能留下来,这是我理解上的根本错误”。早点承认这一点,比在交易推进到一半时才发现要好得多。
YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:09No, I mean I was given a Red Bull. All right. No. Yes. I think maybe a third to half the way through or something like that. I'm not certain exactly. no, I can't pin the exact timing of I I suspect he would be able to answer that more precisely, but I cannot recall the exact point at which he it wasn't towards the very end and it wasn't towards the very beginning.

1:38I don't recall though. I'm not sure. I might have. I'm not sure. I don't recall doing so, but it's possible. Well, I think I don't I'm not sure if I if I asked that he join or not as as the reason that he joined, but I would have certainly at some point asked that he join once the subject of investment came up.

2:27Sorry. I think that would have probably been that if he wasn't there already, I would have requested that he join upon learning that the PAF had made a multi-million dollar investment into Tesla already. That's correct.

3:09I don't think he he would have perhaps had his phone, but I don't think anything else.

3:33I think I was briefly with Yesir alone. I just as as he was like leaving the conference room I think but just for like 10 seconds or something like that. I did not notice it. Yeah. No. Oh, I didn't I don't know if they did.

4:08I did not notice them doing it. They did.

4:18I think about 40 minutesish. No, I don't. Wait, I don't think so. I don't think so. I don't recall getting anything.

4:44Well, every now and again people give me things, but I don't I usually just put them on my desk and don't read them. I mean, usually cuz it's like some sort of like generic document. It was He didn't give me anything that was like I I don't think he gave me anything and I'm but I'm quite sure he did not give me anything that was highly sensitive.

5:09No, I have a business card. So, I don't I don't know during the meeting. No.

5:42During the meeting, no, I don't think so. Not during that sure. the you know what I mean the the the article essentially as mentioned was that they disclosed that they had made a multi-billion dollar investment in Tesla up to the limit of 5%. this was new information to me and that the only reason they had not gone above 5% was the disclosure constraint. and they'd obviously done this without any written agreement or without any requirements or anything at all. and they had done this. They they had at one point, I think in prior meetings said that they would invest in Tesla and and I I was like, okay. And they said, okay, they did what they said they would do. Okay.

7:31okay. These are people where you can take their word. If they say they're going to do something, they're going to do it. So, they were extremely clear that they wanted to take Tesla private. that I could set the terms essentially any reasonable terms I could set. that they had been interested in taking Tesla private for two years. They corrected my misunderstanding that this had been delegated to MASA and said for two years they wanted to take Tesla private. they they had invested

8:08billions of dollars on was not written agreement no agreement of any kind just as a good paid gesture to show that they are serious. and if I would just say what I wanted to do they would do it. so there was no question in my mind whatsoever that the funding was secure for this deal.

8:40Right. That's that was the closing sentiment. I recall that they wanted they were unequivocal in their desire to take Tesla private. that they were willing to take essentially

9:07whatever terms I asked for within the bounds of reason. that a larger investment would require a larger strategic involvement, meaning factories and that kind of thing. and so it was really just a question of what do you want to what they're just saying like how do you want us to proceed? We want to do it. Let's do it.

9:40Yes. That's correct. He said, "Just tell it." He He said, "Tell me how you want to do it and we'll do it."

10:01So, not not whatever terms, but tell me how you want to do it. I think had some language and like provided they're reasonable, we will be fine with it. So there's no, you know, obviously it can't be like, let's go public at $8,000 a share. Okay, not reasonable. This would not be reasonable. But within the bounds of a reasonable take private transaction, they were extremely certain they wanted to do it and moreover had been certain for two years.

10:32this was no question. Sorry. Take take pride. so you know obviously here you have an extremely wealthy fund arguably the wealthiest fund in the world. they had with no conditions no effort at all made a multi-billion dollar investment up to the 5% point. explicitly constrained only by the reporting requirement. That was there was nothing else holding them back from investing more. to you.

11:10so this was really it was up to me. Do I want to do this take private or not? If I want to do it, they will support it.

11:31they the onus was on me to say how I wanted to to do this deal. So I just needed to tell them what what they needed to do and they would do it. that is almost explicit I would say I mean meaning it's like I don't know the that I can say the exact words but that is the that is the exact meaning

12:16I believe so it was something like that Yes, it just just that it's not it can't be like $8,000 a share. It can't be, you know, something completely crazy and outside of the bounds of of a of a take normal take private.

12:45he said like tell me how you want to do it and we'll do it and and and and there was like just some like I think it was reasonable but may have been some it may have been a synonym of reasonable but like tell me how you want to do it as long as the terms are reasonable. I don't know if it was exactly the word reasonable, but it was if not something it was something of equivalent meaning.

13:11and we'll do it. No, no. I I know. The next step would be for me to tell them what terms I wanted. No, but they were very clear that it was up to me to I I it was very clear to me this deal is done. Tell us what terms you want and this deal is done on your terms. provided those terms are not outrageous in another another way to say like they didn't use the word not outrageous, but essentially provided those terms are not completely out of bed with how what an all tape private would be. This is a done deal.

14:25Yes, but they were pretty clear that this was not like some narrow definition of reasonable. Essentially, like as long as they don't feel like they're getting ripped off, they would be fine with it. No, no. would just be unless these terms are unreasonable, there's not like some fancy definition of reasonable, unless unless as long as the terms are not a ripoff and are fair under the normal, you know, structure of as long as they're not out of bounds of a normal take private, this is a done deal.

15:10No, they were telling me explicitly in the meeting that the terms will I could have whatever terms I wanted provided they're not crazy

15:28no they're very clear that they wanted this to happen the only thing that would inhibit this is if I had demanded crazy terms or unreasonable terms otherwise Hey, it's a done deal. Case closed. No, no. Wait. It's important to bear in mind that they had already invested billions of dollars. They they they spoke with their money. Okay? And if somebody invests billions of dollars up to the 5% point and that the only thing stopping them is the reporting number, not anything else. and obviously there wasn't even a verbal or written deal.

16:19They just did it. These people mean what they say. They have the resources. You can take them at their word. They're going to do it. They really wanted to increase their investment in Tesla by whatever means necessary.

17:41I mean, I think the the the the right way to view this is that this was unequivocally a done deal. provided I did not come back with outrageous terms. Yes.

17:59Yes. So, as long as I didn't demand like something egregious, this is a done deal. Well, I presumably they they would decide, but I mean there is a there's a natural framework for whether a take private is egregious in for in the in the price premium or not. I mean really it's just if if I say for example demanded all shares must I must vote all shares. They they may may have objected to that. That is not a not something I would have required but that could have been an inhibitor. if I just if I if

18:37I had said that that's you know there must be like some huge sum of money that comes to me personally as a result of that that would be egregious. If id said instead of a of a of a sort of typical premium on a take private acquisition that instead of a 20% it was 200% that would be egregious.

19:00but anything within the framework of a normal tape private would not be considered egregious. No.

19:38No. they would have been fine with that and they already have 5%. So they have five they have 5% of public markets with no terms and conditions at all. and they were explicit that that 5% limit was just due to reporting requirements not due anything else. So let's say if reporting requirements in the US started at probably

20:0010% they would have acquired 10% in the public markets something on that order. Yeah.

20:20I did not believe there was any any minimum. They already had spoken with their funds and bested 5%. I

20:40I think no because they already had a smaller stake in Tesla and and and they were clear that the only thing that inhibited their stake from being more than 5% was the reporting requirement. So, they're clearly more than happy to have a larger stake in in the company, but and it just happens that US recording climate started 5%. So, that's what they would they were clearly happy to have 5% with no terms and conditions, no requirements, nothing.

21:27Yes. No. as I said, I spoke I I think I spoke to Yir for maybe 10 seconds as he was leaving the conference room. and the substance of that conver substance of that conversation was just him repeating, "Let us know how you want to do this. We want to do this." Or something to that effect.

22:19Yes. I said, "I'll get back to you. there. Yeah. I think I think you did I don't think so.

23:05No. Yeah. I I heard they saw heard I heard that Yeah. that that that like at some point that they had he'd give them a tour. Yeah. No. I think council council to

23:50Jennifer Cole discussion. That I don't recall. I think I may have had some brief conversations. I don't recall right now what those conversations were. I might I might have had some, but I probably had some, but I do not recall the subset of them. Yeah, of course.

24:45Yeah, I mean I do not recall anything substantive. I think we almost certainly had conversations of some sort, but I don't call anything substantive apart from the obvious.

25:07I think something to that effect. Yes. with Ego and Durban on Monday night, I think it would have been before the before the Tuesday tweet.

26:20I recall having some brief conversations with with Sam, maybe Deepo briefly, that pretty brief, just, you know, I think both of them. Not sure.

26:48No. On that night. Well, there was a call with Steve Rosen Bloom and he's over like at any point subsequent sorry what what to precise what data are you referring

27:40I don't think so. It's possible, but I ignore her calls. I don't recall that All right. Sorry, which state?

28:56That' be helpful if if there's some documents that would be that help would help anchor specific dates that would be helpful.

29:42my recollections are a conversation with Steve Roben Bloom. a conversation with which is on the Saturday I believe a conversation with the Egon Durban on the Monday before the tweet. I think I talked to Michael Dell on a Saturday as well, but did not mention anything specific about the Saudi I was just really asking him about did he find that the that being private was good?

30:07like that did he think that that does he did he regret going private? Did he think it was a good idea? yeah.

30:53he was the legal counsel that Michael Dell used in the tape private.

31:09Yes. Silver Lake. just a conversation. Yes. I probably had a few conversations with Sam discussing the pros and cons of a take privates and a a larger Saudi investment. I don't recall having any conversations, but I probably there might have been there might have been a few. I don't recall anything substantive. in there.

32:52No. It's possible that there was some text that he sent me a text or something, but I don't think I had a phone call. I don't recall certainly anything substantive. It's possible he may have, but I do not think you're self. I don't think so.

34:05No. Sorry. At what fair is No. Yes. Sorry. Sorry. Second show.

37:29yeah, I've not seen in this format before, but yes. Yes. Yes.

38:08Yes, it is. Yes. pardon the what? Sorry.

38:58Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes. This was some months earlier this year, I think, where we met at SpaceX and I said, you know, I've always wanted to consider taking Tesla private. they that was it pretty much. and he said, "Well, if you're ever thinking about doing that seriously, you should give me a call."

39:55Yeah. I mean, he said a bunch of nice things about me and the companies and that's it. And he talked a little bit about his prior experience with take private soon. It's like I should give him a call if I ever think about this seriously.

40:23I think in that meeting, that first meeting that I had with him earlier this year, he gave me some kind of like document that was like these are people who would be interested in I think in a take private, but it's somewhat generic, you know, like here are a bunch of people with money that he knows that would be interested in potential take privates and something that he'd be happy to support if we wanted to go in that direction.

40:54No, specific to Tesla. Yes. I mean, I didn't consider it to be especially I mean, it's like here are a bunch of people I know that have tons of money and would be interested in helping Tesla. he he thinks would be interested in a take private situation. I'm like, but I don't consider that to be of like particular note because sure, you know, I I kind of already knew that.

41:34No, that was his opinion. No in person meetings. I don't think there were any calls. It's possible that there were kind of like a some touch base texts or emails sent, but nothing substantive. Yeah.

42:46Yeah, that's about right. I did. I told him about the that the Saudis wanted to take Tesla private. that they were super supportive like they wanted to do this deal. that I could pretty much dictate the terms and but I I did say that my preference would be to have a broader investor base and not have

43:27too much of a not have that size be too too large of a shareholder. you know and I I think I actually did say like I think you know maybe something on the order of 15%, maybe up to 20% would be okay but from my standpoint not from this is from just purely from my standpoint and that but I told you I think look I think most of our investors are going to remain in the company and so

44:02but what does he think about bringing other investors was in that to have a more diversified investor base

44:11so that there wouldn't be excessive influence from any one investor.

44:19He said absolutely there's a lot of interest and he's confident that there many others that would step up and join this take private I don't I don't think so. But he did not mention it. so this he was going I I think he was going entirely on the basis of the people that he knew and that had been say part of the Dell Tech Privates and and other transactions that he had been involved in. So he I don't know if he had conversations with them about it but he did not convey that he had he did convey that that he was confident that there would be many other investors who would be interested in in participating in a take private and then that was later borne out when they

45:14were asked when those investors were asked they I I believe every one of them said No, he was just very supportive and it's like I said, if you want this like this is up to me. If I want this done, it'll be done. No, it's possible he signed something before the meeting that we had at SpaceX, but I did not know there was no I I don't I didn't personally sign anything with him, but but obviously he's someone who is confidence can be trusted.

46:12Yeah. I actually I I did it's a good question because his initial assumption was more along the lines of the the Dell deal which is like essentially his his assumption was more along the standard template of a of a take private where all of the investors besides me or almost all would be bought out. and and I took

46:41pains to emphasize that this is not the which is not what I wanted. In fact, he I think he said something to the extent of like you know well there will you know be a squeeze out of small investors like I do not want a squeeze out. This is I don't want anyone being forced to sell. This is not what I want. I'm just trying to execute find a way to execute better. That's this is not about trying to increase my ownership in the company.

47:04I don't care if there's zero change in my ownership. but I need to build cars. I need to scale this company. I need to do so with the minimum distraction. and this seems like it might be a good way to do that. And so he was he was a bit, I think, taken aback by that. sort of surprising. I think he said, "Well, that's a noble that's a noble principle." I was like, "Well, I'm just trying to get things done here. I'm trying to be useful." and and I said like I've got this situation at SpaceX which is very little overhead

47:41does not involve lots of difficult short-term optimization pressure and that kind of thing. and you know, we're not we don't have all these like class action lawsuits like every time the stock moves they they'll assume correlation is causation and then file a bloody lawsuit.

48:35no. No, he he actually it was like he said well as I recall he said well that's going to make it a lot easier if lots of investors remain that's going to be a lot easier than what was done with Dell. and and he said it actually means that you may actually need less capital than Dell ironically despite being a more valuable company than was required in the Dell Dell transaction if if because I told him I believe most if not all of our

49:23major investors would would retain their ownership. and I and I thought that most most investors not not even the large ones but but the small ones too would retain their ownership. and so you said like well in that case this is really going to be even though it is nominally a a a very large take private on a on a dollar value. The actual amount of capital needed to take it private may be relatively small compared to other deals.

50:03lodge and and well shareholders in general. he he the the the the concern of the the concern of like can can can non-h high netw worth small retail investors remain with the company was not raised. This was so this was you know in in in terms of mis you know and my councils advised me like don't get into mistakes and everything but like a fundamental misunderstanding that I had was that there'd be some means of retaining the the small shareholders that was a fundamental misunderstanding on my

51:03No, no. I don't want to misremember this, but I think it was the Saturday before the Tuesday tweets. If I am not mis I'm Is that correct? I'm not sure exactly.

52:16Yes. For for as a as a lead or co-lead councel on a potential tech issue on the advice of Michael Dell. I had actually talked to Steve Rose I think almost two years ago as I had had a brief conversation with them then he

53:42I'm sorry. The first part of this exc on Friday when I wrote the email. I think it was a Friday. I'm not sure what I Oh, actually, maybe it was a Wednesday instead. yeah, essentially the point at which I decided to make the offer was when I sent the I'm make a decision and then I take action I believe so.

55:06Yes. No. Yeah. Oh, can I mean I I the the part of what would inform my decision for any potential take private would be the result of how the market would react to the earnings call. if if the price went stratospheric then a take private would not be feasible. yeah and did increase quite a lot but not to a degree that would make a type take private you know impossible or on at too high at like some crazy price.

56:34Well, if if the if if if there was a very big spike in the stock, I don't know, like let's say the stock went to $500 or something crazy, or or or went into like just a a a very steep day of a day change, then it's it's there's just not realistic to do any kind of take private transaction because people would want to see is this when where does the steep increase level off? Where does it stop? how you know like we couldn't be a we couldn't be if if if there were times in Tesla's history where we've had these quite big spikes in the the value of the company including times when I thought the value of the company was really the sale price was way too high and I've said that

57:29publicly and I thought this could have been one of those times and it's it it wouldn't be reasonable to expect a take private take to take place. If there was a premium on a spike, like if you if if if the stock spiked and on top of that you had a premium, then you've got like that that wouldn't be feasible

57:57or anyone really like no I it would it would it would exceed the bounds of reasonability. So you know if the stock had spiked say 50% instead of 15% then it would not have been I think viable to consider take private. Yes. there.

58:58Correct. That's correct. That was the biggest factor. I I mean I mean there's just generally I think it's good to sort of sleep on these decisions. you know and and it's hard to say like you know like the sort of like au in our minds kind of the the kind of neural network that is our brain what that feels like the right decision what seems like the right judgment. and there are many often many small factors that weigh into ultimately a decision. and it's difficult to say exactly what led to that decision. there in lies judgement.

1:00:17Yes. Yes, definitely. I mean like as I said if there wasn't if if there had been some massive jump it would have been not been real realistic or at least at that time it would have at least that's not to say that they wouldn't that that a take private was off the table but we would have to wait for the spike to subside. Right.

1:01:21well I mean I think certainly like what level of just since I had not done a take private before I mean it's sort of I I knew there would be some overhead like there would be a necessarily a short-term spike in overhead of managing a a take private. wait and and that that was a factor

1:01:51in like how risky is this is it going to how much is it going to affect our short-term performance and will it be create too much of a distraction such such that you know we we would not achieve our our targets of being cash flow positive and and at least slightly profitable in Q3 and Q4. that was a big concern.

1:02:16so the I I certainly thought that this is something we need to decide quickly or not at all or quickly or postpone to some point past the next few quarters which are of pivotal which are of pivotal importance. I had that red wall. So I am I've got a lot of energy. Yeah. Yeah, sure.

1:02:56no, I think those are I mean I'm really trying to think hard about and make sure I give you as accurate an answer as possible. the the I mean I think it's very important to emphasize that the like the I mean I described this in my in in the blog pieces. It's like really there's like the point of Tesla is to advance the advance sustainable transport and energy. and and so the my mental

1:03:23framework was you know it was very arduous running two companies. and so what is the area under the curve of the least pain? Because there would certainly be something on the order of months to maybe a year of significantly increased pain but then presumably decreased for the following four years.

1:03:52So you know what's the net present value of pain if you will and overhead and obviously that was like very difficult to know so tried to put some uncertainty bounds around that and but this is definitely uncharted territory for me so well it's charted in the sense of obviously I know what SpaceX is like but it's charted in the like how do we get from Tesla to a SpaceX scenario? How feasible is that?

1:04:28you know will the will will a will a a set of private investors even post deal make ownorous demands? You know like even if your deal is clean but you've got a board that maybe is has strategic has like motivations that are non-financial. This I had this experience with my first company and it was a difficult situation.

1:04:59we had a night rider host we had as investors for my first company too. Terrible name worst name ever. but we did do the first maps and directions on the internet among other things. Oh sorry we did we did do the first maps and directions on the internet. Oh, so my my my first company that I created was Zip 2. Such a bad mayor.

1:05:27This is what happens when you let advertising agencies choose your name. It's brutal.

1:05:36Does sound like Nightrider totally, but with two DS.

1:05:41Yeah. and Hurst and the New York Times company. And we did do the first maps and directions in the internet which was cool. first white pages, first yellow pages and we helped bring a bunch of the newspapers, the smaller newspapers online. We helped enhance the websites of the major newspapers. but we had did have those we had Nightrider Hurst and Hurst

1:06:09and New York Times company were board members. So they did have these strategic objectives which were not necessarily aligned with Zip 2 and I felt that you know we have this incredible technology that wasn't effectively applied. So I had some concern like I did not want to be in that situation again. and although SpaceX is private, we Google's an

1:06:42investor in SpaceX rockets and spacecraft and make them better. And we don't really worry whether something's on one side or another of a quarterly boundary. and or like a rocket blows up. Thought word may that not happen again. we don't have like some class action lawsuit from a bunch of people that said we somehow should have known that a rocket would blow up. Like no one do you think we have launched the thing? I was like this is crazy. so okay

1:07:15there's like much less headache. Can we get there with Tesla? didn't know you know so lot of uncertainty. thought it was worth investigating. So, the calculus changed and it was like, okay, they were going to stay public. This is not an ideal, but nonetheless, on balance, probably the right move.

1:07:49Let's hope you hopefully you guys don't torture me too much.

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份