猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)的直径是 13 英尺,约合 4 米。这个数字跟气动外形关系不大,也不是运力需求倒推出来的。
2013 年 3 月 8 日,马斯克在德州议会大厦的一场听证会上讲了这个尺寸的来历:他把火箭设计成公路可以运输的最大物体,前提是不用抬升高压电线,也不用为运输专门改造道路。第一级长度大约 140 英尺,40 多米。
一枚火箭的体型,被高速公路的通行条件限死了。
这听上去像个工程趣闻。放在当天的场合里,它是整场问答的底层逻辑。几位德州议员反复追问的是同一件事:能不能把加州那两三千个岗位搬到德州来。马斯克没有直接答应,他先讲了这 13 英尺。
先参观工厂,再提要求
这场听证会属于德州众议院拨款委员会(House Appropriations)的公开问答环节。开场发言的是经济和中小企业委员会主席戴维斯(Davis)。他三周前刚带人参观过 SpaceX 在麦格雷戈(McGregor)的测试场,那里有 220 名员工,做发动机试车。他用“非常专业”“了不起的运作”来形容那次的见闻。
夸完之后,要求就来了。他希望商业发射场建在布朗斯维尔(Brownsville)的博卡奇卡大道(Boca Chica Boulevard)一带。
我们不喜欢那 2000 个岗位留在加州,我们需要你把火箭放在这边造。如果这件事能成,那真是太好了。(戴维斯)
马斯克的接话很顺:“这点很重要,我本该提到这个。”
注意这个顺序。议员先讲自己的选区焦虑,企业家先认可这个焦虑,然后才拿出准备好的技术解释。整套动作没有任何停顿,看得出来是排练过的,只不过排练的内容不是话术,是物理。
火箭多大,取决于公路多宽
猎鹰9号可以在加州工厂造好,用公路运到发射场。马斯克在设计之初就把直径和尺寸定在公路可运输的上限,这样运输时不需要抬电线、不需要封路改造、不需要一整套特殊许可流程。
我按公路可运输的最大物体来定火箭的直径和尺寸,这样就不必抬升电力线或者做类似的事情。(马斯克)
这个尺寸会长期保留。马斯克说,猎鹰9号大概会永远保持这个规格,因为这一档运力的市场需求足够稳定。
再往上就走不通了。更大的火箭,公路运输的物流成本会高到无法承受,出路只剩两条:装船海运,或者在发射场附近造。
这句话在议员耳朵里的分量,比字面重得多。德州想要的不只是一个发射台,他们要的是总装线、供应商、几千个岗位。马斯克把物理约束摊在桌上:未来的大火箭只能在发射场旁边造,发射场定在哪里,制造厂就跟着定在哪里。
他没有说“你给我建发射场,我就给你建工厂”。他只是让在座的人自己去算这道题。
这套说法的妙处在于,它把一笔招商引资的谈判,改写成了一道工程题。补贴可以讨价还价,公路宽度不能。当一件事被说成物理定律,对方能争的空间就只剩下“我们这里到底能不能满足条件”。
一场没有人反对的环评听证会
接下来的一段问答,把整场听证会的调子定住了。
SpaceX 要在布朗斯维尔建发射场,必须先过环境评估这一关。环评(EIS,Environmental Impact Statement)的牵头机构是联邦航空管理局(FAA),流程里有一个环节叫公开范围界定会议(public scoping meeting),在项目早期召开,专门听取当地社区意见。
SpaceX 的立法事务总监蕾妮(Renée)解释得很清楚:这个会不是公司办的,是 FAA 办的,公告由 FAA 发布。目的就是给反对者一个正式的、不受公司影响的表达渠道。
结果反过来了。
会议到场 500 多人。现场发言的 70 多个人,全部支持这个项目。没有一个人发言反对。到场的人里有学生,有多个学区的总监,有各级民选官员,州参议员也发来了支持信。
FAA 的人对 SpaceX 说了一句话:在他们的环评公开听证历史上,从来没有见过这么多人到场、却一个反对者都没有的场面。他们被到场人群的规模和构成惊到了。
更麻烦的是后续。会开完之后,当地居民还在不断联系 FAA,问的都是同一个问题:你们什么时候告诉我们这事成了。FAA 不得不反复说明,公开意见征集是有明确时间窗口的,不是宣布结果的场合。
蕾妮还补了一个更早的细节。第一次社区会议,大约 7800 人到场,南德州没有一个人反对 SpaceX 进来。会上有四个年轻人主动上台发言,是德州大学布朗斯维尔分校(UT Brownsville)物理专业的学生,事先没人知道他们会来。他们讲的是同一件事:终于可以在本地把物理学到的东西用上了。
这段陈述的价值在于,它把“社区支持”从一句公关话术变成了可核查的程序记录。听证会是政府办的,反对意见是被主动邀请的,公告是公开发布的。结果是没人来反对。这种证据,比任何一份新闻稿都硬。
招人优先本地,UT 的人最多
众议员佩里(Perry)来自西德州。他开场先开了个玩笑,说自己一听就知道马斯克不是西德州人。
他问的问题很实在。全国上下都在说数理教育不行、工程人才不够,那 SpaceX 到底是从世界各地搬人过来,还是在本州招人?公司有没有参与公立教育和大学层面的合作?
马斯克的回答短得有点出人意料:招聘优先本地。公司在德州大学(University of Texas)招得很多,在德州的发射场里,来自德州大学的人比来自任何其他大学的都多。和学校的合作一直在做。
蕾妮补充说,SpaceX 在历史上对本地中小学和大学一直有投入,未来还会大量依赖全州各地的大学。
这段回答里没有一句“我们重视人才培养”之类的漂亮话。马斯克给的是一个可验证的事实:哪个学校的人最多。这种答法在议会场合特别有效,因为它可以被查证,而承诺不能。
140 天的会期,和一场还没结束的竞标
众议员邦嫩(Bonnen)问了两个问题:选址决策有时间表吗?正在审议的立法,能满足公司的需求吗?
第一个问题,马斯克答得明确:希望今年内做出决定。
第二个问题,他答了三个字:“大概可以。”
真正的解释由蕾妮给出,这段话说清了德州立法者面对的结构性难题。
德州议会每届会期只有 140 天。用她的话说,开国先贤只给了他们 140 天,而很多事情会在休会之后发生。所以立法只能写成附条件的形式:如果最后选的是我们,则如何如何。
麻烦在于,其他州这会儿还在会期里。它们正在做自己的竞标方案,方案里有数字,有土地,有条件。
她说,拨款委员会主席皮茨(Pitts)也在担心这件事。航天港的专项资金正在讨论中。盯着德州海岸线的不止 SpaceX 一家,还有好几家公司。德州有海岸线、有空域、有相对宽松的监管环境,有些州则有自己的麻烦,这些麻烦德州没有。
邦嫩追问:那具体需要多少拨款?
蕾妮的回答很谨慎。她说团队正在研究其他州开出的条件,那些数字相当可观,而且不光是钱,还有直接送地。地方层面已经很拼了,正在想办法把水电接到那片偏远区域,因为发射场必须在偏远地区。至于具体金额,她现在不愿意给。
我们可能拼不过他们,这是风险。但州长对这件事有承诺,德州企业基金(Texas Enterprise Fund)能做什么也在讨论中。(蕾妮)
提问的议员在这里插了一句自嘲,说自己有外科医生的习惯,讲话直接,不想绕圈子。
这个细节值得留意。整场听证会里,唯一没有被回答的问题就是钱。公司方给了一堆约束条件、时间压力、竞争格局,就是不给数字。这套打法在谈判里很常见:先让对方相信“不投钱就会失去”,再让对方自己开口报价。
邦嫩还顺便介绍了一下马斯克的履历:南非出生、南非长大,现在是洛杉矶居民,五个孩子的父亲。议会在审法案的间隙插播企业家小传,说明这场听证会的性质,一半是立法程序,一半是招商引资的路演。
顺带被问到的特斯拉
众议员贝尔(Cecil Bell Jr.)刚参观完麦格雷戈,站在龙飞船(Dragon)旁边拍了照,情绪还没退。他说麦格雷戈正好符合“偏远”这个条件,然后话锋一转,问起了另一家公司。
马斯克先开了个玩笑:同时管两家公司,是有点勉强。
特斯拉(Tesla)做电动车,四门轿车 Model S 已经量产,性能很高。他重点讲的是两个奖:Motor Trend 年度车,Automobile Magazine 年度车。这两个奖的意义不在奖本身,在于评委的结论是“所有车里最好的”,而不只是“电动车里最好的”。
这是电动车的一个关键里程碑,被认可的维度不再局限于电动车这个类别,而是跨所有车型比较。(马斯克)
产能是每周 400 辆左右。德州是特斯拉的第二或第三大市场。
然后他提到了麻烦。特斯拉走直销,不经过传统的特许经销商体系,这在德州有法律障碍。他说希望能对法律做一点小修改,但“今天不是来提这个要求的”。
这句话的位置很讲究。先讲德州是第二或第三大市场,再讲直销受限,最后说今天不提要求。信息全给了,姿态放得很低。奥斯汀 Domain 商区的特斯拉展厅刚开,他顺口邀请在场的人去看看。
贝尔回应说自己开过这车,体验很带劲。
祖父靠牛仔竞技读完了大学
听证会快结束时,马斯克说了两件跟政策无关的事。
一件是邀请。麦格雷戈测试场随时欢迎议员们去,公司每年还会办一次大型烧烤。
另一件是家事。他的祖父是美国人,当年靠表演牛仔竞技(rodeo)挣学费读完了大学。他说,这里的人可能会喜欢这个故事。
一个南非出生、洛杉矶定居、有五个孩子的企业家,在德州议会用祖父的美国人身份和一场烧烤收尾。这不属于政策论证,属于政治。而政治在这种场合从来不是多余的。
整场问答不到一个小时。它没有敲定任何条款,没有承诺任何金额。但它把三件事说清楚了:产品怎么运出去,人从哪里招,社区会不会反对。剩下的只有钱。
2014 年 8 月,SpaceX 宣布把商业发射场定在布朗斯维尔。
回头看 2013 年这场问答,有意思的地方不在结论,在论证方式。一个企业家要在别人的地盘上拿到政策支持,他没有讲情怀,没有讲就业数字,他讲了公路宽度、大学名字和一场没人反对的听证会。三样东西都可以被查证。
如果你以后要在类似的场合做判断或者做陈述,这几条可以直接拿走用:
- 判断一个重资产项目会不会来,先问三个问题:产品能不能运出去,人能不能招到,社区会不会反对。这三件事有了答案,剩下的才是补贴金额。顺序反了,谈的都是空中楼阁。
- 听企业高管在议会上的发言,留意他怎么把“要政策”翻译成“讲约束”。火箭直径被公路限死,这句话既是工程事实,也是谈判筹码。能分清哪部分是物理、哪部分是姿态,就不会被带着走。
- 被问“你要多少钱”时,不一定要立刻报数字。把竞争格局摆出来:其他州还在会期、还在做方案、还给地。让时间压力替你说话,比让财务模型替你说话管用。
- 查一个项目的民意基础,看环评听证会的原始记录,别只看新闻稿。谁办的会、谁有发言权、多少人到场、多少人反对,这些是政府程序留下的数据,改不了。
- 看到“如果选中我们,则……”这种附条件立法,别当成敷衍。会期只有 140 天,跨州竞标不会等议会散会,条款只能这么写。这种措辞出现,说明事情在动。
- 想验证一家公司对某个地方的承诺是真是假,看它在本地哪所学校招的人最多,比看它捐了多少钱准得多。招聘数据骗不了人,捐款数字可以。
0:08representive Davis you know I first of all I want to thank you for letting me sit in on your on your committee Mr chairman and and Mr musk I chair the economic and small business committee and with Cil B represent the Cil Bell Jr down there we went out to your site in McGregor about three weeks ago where you have like 220 employees and very professional I was just very impressed it's you're you test the engines it's just an amazing operation seeing that take place I guess what would be would be ideal is is if we can have that take place where we can launch the commercial site there off boach Chica Boulevard there in Brownsville and and ideally we
0:49we don't we don't like those 2,000 jobs being in California we need you to manufacture those Rockets over here that would be a really a cool thing if that could take place you know that's a very important Point and I should have mentioned that which is the the current the Falcon 9 rocket is something that can be manufactured in California transport Road Transport in fact I set the design diameter and dimensions of the rocket to be the maximum road transportable object without requiring lifting of power lines and that kind of thing so it's it's roughly 13 ft in diameter and about 140t
1:27long on the for the first stage but and we'll keep we we'll keep doing the falcon9 I think for forever in in that size but as we go to future rockets that are bigger than that we would actually do the manufacturing at the launch site or near the launch site because the otherwise the road Transportation Logistics become prohibitive essentially you have put on a big ship or or build it near the launch sight the logical thing is to BU new launch light so that that is something that would occur wherever this launch light occurs and it needs to be a b CH come so that'd be great we would love to see that happen so very good thank you again for what you do thank
2:04you CH repr Perry just real quickly U I detect you're not from West Texas not originally no I I would ask it this way you got 2,000 employes I think you said almost 3,000 actually but prospectively you know we always are hearing about our math and science and how deficient it is in our education and stuff but do you do you see that you know with our commitment in your place do you see helping our kid and our public Ed and our employee Workforce are most of you guys transplants from around the world or do you find a a Workforce here and are you engaged at the public education level and the college level and the in those processes actually I I'll
2:44prefer to rout for recruiting is is local so we do a lot of recruiting at the University of Texas and I'd say we have more representation from the University of Texas than any other University at our Texas lach site and and we work withs and whatnot so so we graduate high level scientist there's an outlet through your place and you is grou and encourage that and are active in that Pursuit we we are absolutely yeah thanks and if I can add Rene Leda I guess for the record represent Perry our University when we had the first meeting I think about 7800 people showed up
3:34and there was not a single person against having SpaceX in South Texas and four young people came up that were in the physics program at UT brownzville unsolicited nobody knew they were going to be there and they talked about how exciting it was for them and that they could be applying their efforts in higher education in physics and be part of this so there's no doubt in my mind the history of SpaceX is they've been very philanthropic they have been very supportive of local schools and universities they will rely heavily on all our universities all around the the state and we can be launching Rockets again in in Texas if we can do this yeah it's actually maybe worth the
4:26and you may want to add add a bit to that but so this was a review that a public hearing that we held in the Brownsville area to where essentially we it's for an environmental view where you invite people normally to raise objections I don't know if there were people that wanted to object but they didn't get a chance to to object because people kept coming up to the mic and and voting their support in fact I I don't think they've ever seen an environmental hearing like that before certainly I mean you want to elaborate on that that's that's correct the the your name Karen shanor counil just counsel I don't want to take over my boss's job as general counsel to to
5:11SpaceX and and director of legislative affairs so when we when we had these Federal scoping meeting so the the environmental impact statement process that we're undertaking under the FAA because they are the lead agency part of that involvement involves a public hearing early in the process where they take input from the local community they post notice of those hear of that hearing and give people the opportunity SpaceX doesn't run the hearing the FAA runs it so it's to make it an objective opportunity for people to present their concerns over over 500 people and as the Congress stated it seemed to be a lot more to those of us who were there in attendance
5:50attended the event and over 70 people spoke up in in favor of the project no one actually spoke in opposition at the event we had students young students we had a number of superintendents from the local schools we had elected officials at all levels up to our state senators who sent letters of support for the project involved in that in that Community Support and statements of support and what the FAA did say to us at that event was they had never seen a turnout of so many people with no opposition before in the history of their experience with an Eis public scoping hearing they were incredibly impressed by the community support and by the the wealth and
6:33breath of folks that showed up to voice their support for the for the project and who they continue to hear from in support of the project they actually told us that they had to make it clear to people that the public the public scoping area time was a specific time frame because they kept hearing from people asking when are you going to tell us that this is happening because they you know they had to give their information to the folks there and they kept trying to contact them to tell them how much they want this project in Brownville so I have to say from from my perspective it has just been absolutely abolutely amazing to see the support that we've received
7:01from the local community Karen before you leave will you fill out a witness affirmation plan that's on each side of these gentlemen rep representative Bond thank you Mr chairman is there a a timeline or a decision point that we're looking at with respect to your choice of where you want to put this facility yeah we're hoping to make that decision this year and if I may ask because I haven't been involved in the proposed legislation do does that legislation address the the needs or the concerns that the the company would have to allow you to make that decision I I I think it it probably does yeah Renee again for the record represent bonon yeah we have tried to
7:52foresee everything because you know our founding fathers say we only get to meet 140 days because a lot may happen after we're gone and we have a pretty good working group you know I again TimeWise we're hoping that we get the the draft study from the feds soon that says what the potential problems might be in terms of environmental concerns us
8:24parks and wild wildlife Texas but you know a lot of this may happen while we're gone so we're in a position of having to do things contingent upon us being the final place to go and it is a strange deal because those other states will still be in sessions and and they're coming up with their own competitive packages to you know out there so I know chairman pittz is concerned about this as well and we've talked about u a space port funding and and again I think Mr musk would would say and I'll take the liberty of speaking on his behalf that you know we're looking at more than space sex potentially there are several other companies that are looking at Texas
9:23and our Coastline and our advantages are are great and are problems in some of those other states that we don't have and I'm doing everything I can to convince particularly Council here how great it is to be in Texas and by the way for the record Mr musk I think you were raised in South Africa was born born and raised in born and raised in South Africa and he is now a proud residents of Los Angeles with five five children and he's done a lot if you I could brag about him a long time but I know you have a lot his history is incredible in what he's done I just want to is there a specific contingency Appropriations request associated with the legislation I think we're trying to look
10:18at what other states are doing and see how competitive we can be you know we've heard some numbers from the other states that are pretty impressive and they're not just talking about money they're talking about donating land we at the local level are being very aggressive and and trying to be part of the package in terms of U assistance and because it is a remote area of of the county it needs to be a remote area obviously so we're trying to work on getting power and water to this area that doesn't have it but in terms of a specific number I'm I'm guess I'm not prepared to say but we're we're we need to be competitive is is how I'd leave it for now I wish I could say x
11:03will do it but I I appreciate your your comments and I'm not trying to be abrupt but perhaps with the surgeons mentality I tend to be very to the point and yeah no that's a good question I just with the action items are I just don't have unfortunately a number yet that I would even want to suggest right now
11:23we're we're trying to see what the other states are doing and we may not be able to to match them that's that's a risk but the governor's committed to this and there are discussions about what tech doot can do and discussions about what the Enterprise fund might do and and and other things so that we can be competitive and and bring them
11:48here thank you represent Bell I just wanted to say having toured the McGregor side as chairman Davis said earlier I was very impressed and if you're looking for remote McGregor by the way fits the category I like McGregor but it is it certainly is remote but to and be able to be standing next to the dragon space
12:12craft it's it is it is great to know that there is a private sector desire to make certain that we maintain our our our presence as the leading entity in the world and and I I think you guys do a great job of what you do I for one want to see you expand in Texas so anyway just we appreciate you from from
12:40here can you just briefly tell us about the vehicle that you have created the Tesla oh oh sure okay Tesla yeah absolutely so you we can probably help the 41 guys out on the sustainability and green initiatives as you as you mentioned so the Tesla is an I I run two companies it's a bit of a stretch but Tesla makes electric cars and is now production with a four-door sedan which is a a real high performance sedan it actually won a car of the year motor train car of the year last year it One Automobile Magazine Auto automobile of the year and it's so essentially saying it's the best car of any kind not merely the best electric car which I think is a was a key
13:27milestone for electric vehicles to be recognized not just within an electric vehicle category but with across all vehicles and we're in production of that about doing about 400 cars a week just going throughout the United States Texas is actually one of our biggest I think maybe second or third in terms of States in terms of the number of customers in Texas and it is a bit of a challenge actually operating in Texas because our approach is to do direct sales rather than than go through the traditional franchise system so just just present some challenges in Texas and we obious would would would love a slight modification of the law not here today to to ask for that but
14:11just managing just [Music] saying thank you I I drove your car and it's a very exciting experience thank you is there any other questions oh oh actually I should mention we we're just opening our the the Tesla Gallery in in Austin at the Domain so if you want to go check it out please please do oh and and yes and and anyone who
14:37wants is invited to our test site at McGregor anytime you'd like we be happy to host you and we also have these these big barbecues once a year that maybe you want to want to go to and then like one little bit of trivia my grandfather was actually American and he paid his way through college by doing Rodeo tricks people might appreciate that so well thank you for coming here today it was a real honor for this committee to have you all right well thanks very much for having me thank you thank you thank you
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版