访谈·中文精读

马斯克在斯坦福谈商业(2013)

Elon Musk talks business at Stanford 2013

中文精读由 AI 基于原始视频与文稿改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;表述以原视频为准。说明

2008年12月24日下午6点,马斯克拿到了特斯拉的救命融资。再晚几个小时,这家公司就会在圣诞节后几天内破产。

他后来说,那天他把账户里剩下的钱几乎全押了进去,因为没有任何其他人愿意再掏一分。特斯拉当时负毛利,金融危机正在最深处,高盛的私募发行刚刚失败,戴姆勒的交易还没影。用他自己的话说,那个圣诞节一点都不好看。

把时间快进到2013年,斯坦福商学院的这场对话里,马斯克坐在台上,身后是一群想搞清楚“这一切到底怎么运转”的学生和校友。台下有人举手问:硅谷路上跑的Model S越来越多了,你当年说想看到一辆不是员工测试车的特斯拉,现在实现了,感觉怎么样?

他的回答没有停在情怀上,而是把话题拉回到一个更本质的东西:他到底在赌什么,为什么赌,以及怎么把一个成功率不到一半的赌局,一步步做成今天这个样子。这篇文章把这期访谈里的核心论点和细节整理出来,信息量很大,值得慢慢读。

大学时代列过一张清单,五个领域能改变人类未来

主持人一开始问了一个设计层面的问题:你做特斯拉、做SpaceX,是先有一个具体的产品,比如Model S、猎鹰9号(Falcon 9),再倒推怎么实现;还是先认定世界上有某件事坏了,必须修,哪怕不知道怎么修也要上?

马斯克的回答很干脆:具体产品只是结果,起点在更早的地方。大学时代他就在想一个问题,什么东西最可能影响人类的未来,而且往好的方向影响。

他当时列出了一张清单,一共五个领域。

前三个他非常确定会带来正向影响:可持续能源、互联网、让生命成为多行星物种。

后两个他画了问号:人工智能和基因编辑。这两件事大概率也会发生,影响巨大,结果可能很好,也可能出大问题。访谈里他顺口说了一句“改写基因”(rewriting genetics),语气里带着不确定。

所以严格说,这张清单先于任何生意。他先有一份关于人类未来的判断表,再在表上逐项下注。特斯拉对应可持续能源,SpaceX对应多行星,PayPal和更早的Zip2对应互联网。后两项他到现在也没有真正下场,但一直在公开场合提醒风险。

主持人追问:这个顿悟你持有很久,为什么没有马上去做?马斯克承认,大学时他只是想清楚了方向,真正能执行是很多年后的事。

互联网是给人类装了一套神经系统

1995年马斯克来斯坦福,原本想读博,研究方向是先进储能技术,具体说是超级电容。他在硅谷做暑期实习时就在做这个。

但那个夏天他读了一些互联网软件的书,想法变了。他意识到,互联网会像给人类整体装上一套神经系统。

他打了个比方:以前信息只能靠渗透传播,一个人传给另一个人,靠电话、靠邮件,很慢。有了互联网,人类集体的任何一部分都能瞬间知道另一部分在发生什么。哪怕你身处南美丛林,只要有一根网线,就能接入全人类的信息库。

用他的话说,互联网实际上创造了一个超级有机体,从根本上改变了人类的性质。他想成为这件事的一部分。

于是他退学,和弟弟一起创办了Zip2。

这段创业的开局被他讲得很朴素:公司只有一台电脑,白天当服务器,晚上他用来写代码。办公室在帕洛阿尔托,月租450美元,比公寓还便宜,所以他们睡在办公室,走路去El Camino上的YMCA洗澡。

我们当时真的没想过要发财。我只是想参与互联网这件事,能赚够生活费就行。(马斯克)

这里有个细节。主持人提到,1996年1月他和马斯克一起去向一位投资人介绍Zip2的商业计划,对方是少数真正读完计划书的人。当时他们见的大多数投资机构甚至不知道互联网是什么,也没人靠互联网赚过钱。所以那时候并没有清晰证据证明这是一门生意。

特斯拉真正的产品,是让整个行业相信电动车可行

很多人以为特斯拉的使命是卖车,马斯克的表述不是这样。

他讲得很清楚:特斯拉存在的意义,是加速电动交通这个必然趋势的到来,把环境和经济损失压到最低。如果整个行业能早十年、二十年完成切换,这就是特斯拉创造的最大价值。

而且他反复强调一个反直觉的判断:特斯拉对行业的催化作用,比它自己造的车影响更大。

他给了一个具体例子。特斯拉Roadster发布后,时任通用汽车副总裁鲍勃·卢茨(Bob Lutz)看到新闻稿,说如果加州一家小公司能做到,通用也能。他拿着这个去问自己的工程师,工程师们此前一直说电动车造不出来,这下只好承认得赶紧动手。通用的行动又带动了日产做Leaf。

换句话说,特斯拉最早那款车卖了多少辆并不重要,重要的是它让传统巨头相信“这事能成”。这就是马斯克说的“催化”。

为了证明这个逻辑,特斯拉甚至向丰田和奔驰供应动力总成。主持人问他,这些可能是你未来最大的竞争对手,你为什么要帮?马斯克的回答是:加速这件事本身就值,帮对手也是在加速。

Model S的安全和性能,来自一个底层的架构选择

访谈里主持人列了一串评价:Consumer Reports说Model S是他们测试过最好的车,Road & Track说它是美国历史上最重要的车,安全测试显示它是有史以来最安全的车,连货车和SUV都算上。

马斯克没有把功劳全揽在自己身上。他把原因归结为一个物理层面的架构优势。

核心点是:电动车如果从一张白纸开始设计,电池包可以平铺在整个底盘上,重心极低。电机和逆变器、变速箱可以做得很紧凑,同样外形尺寸下,车内可用空间比燃油车大得多。

再加上铝制车身和底盘,单位质量能吸收的碰撞能量更多,溃缩区更有效。这些优势里,一部分来自电动架构本身,一部分来自其他工程决策,两者叠加,才有了那个安全评级。

主持人追问:这些设计是你一开始就想好的,还是边做边发现的?马斯克的回答是,很多是提前想清楚的,因为物理规律摆在那里,第一性原理推一遍就知道哪些方向值得走。

顺便说一句,他在访谈里承认,早在22年前,也就是读物理的时候,他就认定所有车最终都会是电动的。主持人问当时你身边有人同意吗,他说几乎没有,跟约会对象聊电动车也不受欢迎。

2008年,差几个小时就破产

这是整场访谈里信息密度最高的一段。

马斯克说,做SpaceX和特斯拉,他一开始判断的成功率都不到50%。他没在谦虚,他真的这么算的。

SpaceX他预留了足够三次发射失败的资金。结果真的三次都失败,三次全砸。他们硬是凑出第四次发射的钱,2008年第四次成功,公司才活下来。

特斯拉这边更惊险。2008年12月24日下午6点,融资在最后一刻完成。如果那天没成,圣诞节过后几天公司就破产了。当时的情形是:高盛的私募刚失败,金融危机正烈,没有能源部贷款,没有戴姆勒交易,车是负毛利,大股东气得失联。

马斯克说那段时间根本谈不上“利润还是非利润”的选择,问题是“怎么活下去”。

这段经历解释了他后来在股东信里写“利润不是首要目标”时为什么底气那么足。他没在讲漂亮话。他从死亡线上爬过来。主持人补了一句:那封股东信发出去,董事会有成员质疑这个表述,马斯克的回应是“它就是真的”。

成功率不到一半,为什么还要做

主持人问了一个很关键的问题:你选行业的标准到底是什么?你进的这几个领域,商业银行、军工、汽车,全是重监管、投资人躲着走、创业公司成批死掉的地方,几十年没什么变化。这不像经过风险调整后收益最高的选择。

马斯克的回答很朴素:他选赛道的标准是“这件事需不需要发生”,风险调整后的回报率排在后面。

他的原话大意是,如果这件事必须做成,哪怕钱全赔了,也值得试。Solar City那边他判断成功率超过50%,但不确定能做多大,可能只是个小生意,那也要做,因为这件事本身该做。

这就解释了一个很多人想不通的点:为什么一个连续创业者会反复跳进最难、最不赚钱、最容易被监管拖死的行业。他并不喜欢难。他把“必要性”排在了“回报率”前面。

当然,这不代表他不在乎钱。他后面专门澄清:他要利润,只是不要短期利润最大化。他算过账,如果现在就把研发停下来,特斯拉立刻就能做出漂亮利润,但那样会牺牲未来的产品线,牺牲整个转型目标。从净现值角度看,短期的利润最大化反而不聪明。

一个人管两家公司,80到90小时的账怎么算

主持人用了一个带玩笑的问题开场:你成功的秘诀是不是同时当两家公司的CEO?

马斯克的回答是:这从来不在他的计划里。他之所以要当特斯拉的CEO,是因为当时的老牌车企(incumbent)都认定电动车不可能做得好、也不可能卖得动,他必须亲自证明这件事能成。Solar City他不是联合创始人,特斯拉才是他联合创办并设计了核心架构的。

关于时间分配,他给了一个很具体的账:同时管两家公司,最多只能给每家一半时间。这逼着他做极致的取舍,每天想的就是“我在每家公司能做的最有用的一件事是什么”。有一段时间他每周工作100小时,现在降到80到90小时,分到每家公司也就45小时左右,还是不够用。

主持人追问:这种被迫的分权,是不是反而帮你建立了更强的授权(delegation)文化?马斯克承认,确实有这个效果,代价是很多细节他没法亲自盯。

造火箭之前,他跑了三趟俄罗斯想买洲际导弹

SpaceX的起源很能说明马斯克的思维方式。

2001年,他和朋友聊起接下来要做什么。他最初的想法是让NASA的预算增加,自己没打算造火箭。他很好奇NASA什么时候会送人上火星,因为登月之后按逻辑接下来就该去火星了。他跑到NASA网站上找计划,结果什么都没找到。

后来他才知道,NASA做过一份载人火星任务的成本研究,报价5000亿美元。小布什政府一看这个数字,直接把计划搁置了,甚至规定NASA内部不许再谈载人火星任务。

马斯克当时想的是:如果我能做一件足够吸引公众注意力的事,公众的兴趣会转化成国会的额外拨款,NASA就有钱去火星了。

他的方案是在火星表面放一个小温室,里面装脱水凝胶和种子,着陆后加水,让植物长出来。他算过传播效果:这将是生命到达过的最远距离,是火星上的第一株生命,画面是一株绿植衬在红色背景上。他说这会是“money shot”,也就是能上头版的那张照片。

他把航天器、通信、温室这些成本都压下来了,唯独发射成本压不下去。美国这边的发射选项太贵,他只好去俄罗斯,想买退役的洲际弹道导弹(ICBM)。他一共去了三次。

第三次去的时候他意识到,自己最初的假设错了。他原以为问题是公众没有意愿,实际上美国民众的探索意愿很强,问题在于这件事看起来太贵,贵到没人相信能做成。

于是他换了个问题:火箭的成本里,到底有没有本质性的、无法压缩的部分?他和一群人利用几个周末做了一系列头脑风暴,结论是看不到任何根本性障碍。那就自己造。

这就是SpaceX的起点。

把火箭当成软件来设计

主持人注意到一个模式:猎鹰9号的设计看起来像软件工程师的产物。只造一种发动机,然后重复堆叠(step-and-repeat),用系统设计的优雅去抽象掉硬件的复杂度。

这个观察很准。马斯克做火箭的方式,确实带着强烈的软件工程色彩:先定义通用模块,再通过组合和复用把成本压下来。传统航天是每个任务定制一套,成本自然下不来。

同样的逻辑在特斯拉上也成立。Model S从一张白纸重新设计,不从燃油车改起,所以能拿到前面说的那些架构优势。主持人问,是不是因为老牌公司不会用这种白纸思维,所以你才有机会?马斯克的回答没有直接下结论,但他的整套方法论确实指向这个方向:不从过去迭代,从第一性原理重新推一遍。

电动超音速垂直起降飞机,可能是最优解

观众提问环节有人问:你研究过超音速飞机,SpaceX也做过很漂亮的工作,特斯拉专注电动,电动加垂直起降(VTOL)的飞机能不能用来解决405号公路的堵车?

马斯克的回答很干脆:他认为电动超音速垂直起降飞机,很可能是空中交通的最优解。

他给了几个理由,逻辑很清晰。

第一,飞得越高,电动飞机效率越高,燃油飞机正好相反。燃油发动机的进气口是固定尺寸的,你只能在某个巡航高度做最优设计,从海平面到高空都得将就。电动不存在这个问题。

第二,电动电机的功率重量比高于内燃机,所以垂直起降需要的动力,用较小的电机就能实现。

第三,如果用电动机做推力矢量,可以取消升降舵和方向舵,去掉尾部控制面,整个飞行器的结构会简单很多。

他也承认难点在哪:怎么做到真正的长航程,以及怎么做到至少和现有飞机一样安全。他说这两个问题很难,但也就这两个问题。

中国占全球豪华轿车一半,Model E的彩蛋

有观众问特斯拉的全球扩张计划,尤其是中国市场,以及当年对中国市场抄袭风险的担忧。

马斯克的回答分两层。

第一层是市场数据:Roadster当时已经在31个国家销售,Model S计划2014年进入中国、日本、香港、新加坡、澳大利亚等地。中国是全球豪华轿车最重要的市场,约占全球销量的一半。奔驰S级去年有54%卖到了中国。所以特斯拉会专门为中国市场做适配,不会把美国车原样搬过去。

第二层是知识产权:他承认抄袭是风险,但认为中国这几年在变好,新政府对知识产权更认真,他的信心在增强。真正需要小心的是未来在当地建厂时,怎么设计激励机制,避免工厂团队出去另起炉灶。他说这个担忧还是几年后的事。

访谈里还有一个被主持人挖出来的彩蛋。特斯拉的产品线是Model S、Model X,刚注册了Model E,还有Model Y。主持人说没人注意到这个命名拼起来是什么。马斯克笑着说,他们确实注册了,福特那边一开始还没反应过来,看到Model Y才问:你们是打算用Y代替E吗?他的回答是:不,那只是个玩笑。

这个细节看起来是闲笔,其实说明了一件事:马斯克在产品命名上也在玩长期叙事,哪怕是个梗,也要埋进去。

利润和使命:短期的账和长期的账

整场访谈里,主持人反复回到一个张力:你既说利润不是首要目标,又说公司必须赚钱,这两件事怎么统一?

马斯克的回答可以概括成一句话:他要处理的分歧,在短期利润和长期价值之间。

他承认,任何时刻都可以选择停下来不研发,公司立刻就能盈利。但他选择把现金流重新投进去,投Model X、投工厂产能、投第三代大众车型。从净现值看,这才是更聪明的做法。

主持人补了一个观察:在他自己的投资组合里,那些把使命写进公司第一性原则的企业,长期反而比不这么做的公司赚得更多、增长更快。样本不大,但方向一致。

这其实回应了很多商学院学生的困惑。大家默认“做正确的事”和“赚钱”是矛盾的,马斯克给的答案不谈道德,谈时间尺度:把时间拉长到十年、二十年,做正确的事往往也是回报最高的事。

给今天想做事的人,六条能执行的建议

这场访谈是2013年的,但里面关于判断、取舍和执行的方法,放到今天依然成立。下面几条是从马斯克的表述里提炼出来的,可以直接用。

  • 先列一张“人类未来清单”,再在清单上选赛道。选赛道的时候,可以问“哪些事必须发生”,别急着问“哪个行业赚钱”。马斯克大学时列的五项里,三项确定、两项存疑,他后来做的公司全落在那三项上。这个方法能帮你过滤掉大量看起来热闹、没有长期价值的机会。
  • 用第一性原理重推一遍,别从现有方案迭代。火箭贵不贵、电动车能不能好看又好卖,这些问题如果只参考行业惯例,答案永远是“不行”。把成本拆到物理层面,问一句“到底有没有本质障碍”,往往能发现障碍来自组织惯性和假设,跟物理规律无关。
  • 接受成功率不到一半,把失败预算算清楚。SpaceX预留了三次发射失败的钱。他没在盲目乐观,他提前把最坏情况纳入了计划。做难事之前,先算清楚自己能承受几次失败,比喊口号有用得多。
  • 同时管多件事时,逼自己做极致的取舍。马斯克给每家公司的上限是一半时间,倒推下来每天只能做最有用的那一件事。如果你手上事情太多,先问:今天只能做一件,是哪件?
  • 把利润当成长期变量,别当成短期目标。能立刻盈利却选择再投入,前提是你算得清未来的账。做产品、做公司都一样,先想清楚“现在停下来能赚多少”和“继续投入能换来什么”,再决定节奏。
  • 使命要能对应到具体产品上,否则只是口号。特斯拉的使命是加速电动化,执行路径是先做Roadster证明可行,再做Model S证明能卖,再做第三代车证明能普及。每一阶段都有可验证的产品,使命才执行得下去。

最后说一个细节。访谈快结束时,主持人提到当年在谷歌的一次午餐上,拉里·佩奇(Larry Page)半开玩笑地说,如果自己被车撞了,要把钱全留给马斯克。理由是:把钱捐给慈善机构,能做成的事远不如交给一家以“让人类离开石油、殖民其他星球”为使命的公司。

这个玩笑背后藏着一个严肃的判断:真正稀缺的从来都是钱之外的东西,是把钱变成长期价值的组织能力。马斯克这场访谈真正在讲的,也是这件事。

YouTube 平台字幕(自动或人工),可能有识别错误,人名与数字请以视频为准。已按语句合并成段落,并去掉 um、uh 等口头填充词。 文稿来源:YouTube(自动/人工字幕)。

0:00about a year and a half ago before model s shipped I remember him saying with sort of a gleam in his eye that he relishes the day that he'll be driving around somewhere in Silicon Valley and see a Model S on the road that's not like an employee car that's in testing but like a real customer like that he doesn't know and so there's a quick survey of hands how many people here today saw Tesla driving around Silicon Valley and I don't mean the one out there because that means you've all seen multiple Tesla's right I saw ten I counted today just then I have a short commute so you know that dream has become reality and wild what Tesla's done has been a marvel to watch so I

0:34think a lot of folks here you know business students students you know friends of the firm are really curious on how this all works and so if we could start with some design questions and then some organizational and people kinds of questions but starting with design you know as you think about the big problems in the world that you are addressing do you start with a particular product in mind like there could be this Model S there could be this Falcon 9 and then think how do I get there or do you start with saying there's something broken in the world and I'm gonna fix it and I'm gonna commit to do it even if I don't know how I get there so let's see yeah it seems

1:09to be good in a case of Tesla SpaceX and Solar City and actual so the PayPal and the zip2 before that it really stemmed from when I was in college just trying to think what would most affect the future and you know and it very likely to be a positive way so that the three areas where I was quite sure we were positive were sustainable energy internet and making life multiplanetary and then there were a couple other areas where it's maybe a question walk like AI and writing genetics yeah rewriting

1:48rewriting denies oh this is happening big impact good the door for three and four Michael yeah you know potentially negative consequences hopefully positive but something could go wrong like the top three and a couple contenders or were they all is kind of jumbling around when you know you know if you look if you look ahead and say what's what's really gonna have a an important effect on the future of humanity as a whole those were the five areas that that I could come up with standing in the shower basically you know so there's this moment of Epiphany but that you held for a while because you didn't pursue those right away right these were this was sort of a really

2:29vision that you then got opportunities to execute on yeah so when you maybe if we pick an example like Tesla going towards the Model S or SpaceX pointing towards the Falcon nine do you commit the team yourself your resources to that endeavor you know now a little farther along when you have the endpoint in line or just let's say the the cost of goods analysis for the rocket or the cash evie should be better than internal combustion engines just in general I'll commit I'll believe that that should be done yeah I didn't I mean I didn't really get it to any of us with with the expectation of success or at least yeah

3:08I mean I started out we're thinking okay when I do something in the electric vehicle space and that's why I originally came to Stanford was to work on advanced energy storage technologies in particular ultra capacitors so that was continuing on research that I've done as an intern in Silicon Valley and summer prior so that so that's that's why I originally came out of 95 and then during that summer I read some internet software and I thought okay I can either work on electric vehicle technology or or I could just sort of work on internet stuff try to try to do something with the Internet I thought the internet would be something that would dramatically affect the future of

3:48humanity would be like like acquiring a nervous system and whereas previously communication would have to occur almost by osmosis therefore one person to another slowly through telephone or mail or something I got but now if you have a nervous system any part of the human collective no can know about any other part incidentally and you're previously you'd have to be at the sort of Library of Congress even to have the Library of Congress as sort of information but with everything digitized and access anywhere you could be in a jungle in South America and and if you had just an internet link somehow you could you'd have access to all of humanity's information so it actually

4:32effectively created a super organism and and fundamentally change the nature of humanity itself so I was kind of just want to be kind of part of that is that the panel AI that you might see it's it's actually not exactly AI it's some sort of human machine collective intelligence so different different from AI although AI may not turn out to be exactly what hopefully not it's not exactly what's you know like describing terminator or some things no quick pause for those that haven't been to space X the data center has got to be the coolest thing you've ever seen it's you know Skynet on the door Cyberdyne systems branding and satellites coming from a leaking server

5:12so these are exactly our FB and CFD clusters it's called Cyberdyne systems welcome back to influences later on but I'm gonna try to see if I understand what you were saying about this this you see the long arc of and what's important to humanity not little problems but huge problems that could be solved a lot of us go around and we see something frustrating like traffic on the 405 we just take it as well crap government screwed you all right you have this incredible sort of scope of ambition right planetary scope interplanetary scope right a little more than just changing the world let's change some other worlds too right then this is big stuff is that always in your mind or

5:52that that you become more emboldened over time that this is available we can do these things it definitely emboldened over time I mean at the you know when I started the first Internet companies up to with my brother and another question a great curry the it wasn't really with the thought of being wealthy it you know nothing against being wealthy but

6:17but it's just it was just from the standpoint I've been wanting to be part of the internet and I figured if we could make enough money to just get by or people that'll be okay and when we started off with we literally only had like one computer and so it would be our web server during the day and I'd code at night and we just got a small office in Palo Alto back

6:44when rent was not insane and it cost us like four fifty dollars a month it was cheaper than an apartment so we actually just slept in the office and then and then shower at the YMCA a page from El Camino so we'd walk her over there and and shower and and that was actually I think it was when I first I first met you by the way and so I don't know how many people know but probably people knows but we actually pitched Steve in like January 96 on the zip-t business plan and actually I thought he was actually one of the most up to speed on on what actually was in our business plan most most the people we met did not actually read our business plan in fact

7:31a lot of people were a lot of bench capsules we met at the time didn't even know what the internet was Nevernever youth they never used yeah you know sort of well-known people intent he was like wow okay but but at the time nobody made any any money on the internet so I guess that's you know did then it wasn't really clear evidence that there was was a business and yeah sometimes I remember

7:59Kimball and you coming in right very young-looking guys I think I was in my first four months on the job - yeah exactly so so for a sec I also had the great honor to work with Steve Jobs briefly but enough and as a business school student to study him with as much scrutiny as I could during that period and there's some obvious parallels and so let's start with the most obvious but just must be like elephant the room is the secret to your success to be the CEO of two companies at the same time no I think it's look at the

8:35correlation yeah struggling companies everything's in the craft can and December 2008 so let's take on a new CEO gig yeah and same for Steve coming back to have no it definitely it was not my intention to be CEO of two companies the you know after I mean there are certain things that I kind of wanted to throw important to happen and I thought it was important that that there was that that an electric vehicle happened that there was a success in the electric vehicle arena because the the incumbent companies were convinced that it was not possible to create a an electric car that looked good had rained a good range performance and so forth and that even

9:16if you did make such a car it would not sell yeah because people had this love of gasoline and so we had to show that it was possible to create a compelling electric car long range good-looking you know all those things that was a Tesla Roadster and if you created if you made such a thing people would buy it and so

9:39that that's that's what we would try to do with other actually I should say like one way to sort of correction on the on the introduction I I'm not a not a co-founder of Solar City by I'm a co-founder of Tesla okay so and architected yeah many of its key features so very much like jobs both a hand at some of the detail as well as the long arc of what's important all right for the company the the quick though about being co-ceos is more than just a joke in that I wonder if in ways that are hard to predict and you wouldn't set out for this amount of work seems insane but inevitably both companies cannot expect more than half your time at most it sort of it

10:20naturally forces a delegation upon you and an expectation they have to rise up for partial awareness at best rent and I just wonder if that helps drive prioritization and really focusing on what's important a bit more than you otherwise might have to it probably does yeah I think I probably do yeah I mean it accepted triage that the things that I do at each company and consciously think about what is the most useful thing that I could that I could do but even with that it's that it still actually just take it an almost amount of time and for a while they I was just doing constant hundred hour weeks and that's that's definitely wearing and and you know now I'm kind of

11:00in the 80 to 90 which is well manageable but but you know that if you divide that by two it's only like you know maybe 45 hours but for a company which is not not much if there's a lot of things going on like a slacker I mean yeah you know it is interesting also how you have a love for certain aspects of the product so its basics you you know the whole concept and the vision of going to Mars back into features and stuff it's it's a wonderful thing to see I think what what obviously should strike folks in the room as remarkable is the diversity of industries that you've tackled right from commercial banking to the military-industrial complex to the

11:42automotive industry these are heavily regulated industries the generally investors flee from and startups routinely failing and they haven't seen much change for a good reason over decades so there might not be an obvious pattern in which industry you tend to thrive in but I wonder if there's a pattern perhaps in process like do you approach each of these perhaps the way Software Architect might to think of a different way to bring innovation a different way to reset you know from first principles perhaps instead of iterating from the past a breakthrough and is the reason you end up in these otherwise really tough industries I mean I don't know if that's ever occurred to

12:18you that you don't even with SolarCity going up against the regulated utilities these are places that you would normally find entrepreneurs yeah it like said if it was not from the standpoint of like what's the best risk adjusted rate of return or you know where I think things could be successful is just like I think these things need to happen try to make them happen and certainly when we started SpaceX or Tesla I thought the probability of success was less than 50% you know probably fair but less than 50% in the case of Solar City I thought the probability of success was probably greater than 50% but it wasn't there what the magnitude of success

12:58would be it could just be small and yeah but if it was I just thought these four things that needed to get done and even if the money's lost okay it's still worth trying seed conviction but it didn't mean certainty right you knew that all vehicles will be electric in your heart but ultimately I mean I think the sort of fundamental good that has the can accomplish is acceleration of the inevitable which is electric transportation I think there's a lot of value to accelerating even though I think it's somewhat of in Ewa table it's about this value to accelerating it to minimize the the environmental and economic damage that would otherwise occur so you know it's better if

13:46if we transition to sustainable transport ten years or what maybe twenty years sooner than might otherwise be the case and I think the Tesla's effect has been much greater than the cars have made that it's made internally because when we announced the Tesla Roadster then Bob Lutz who was by she ordered GM at the time saw a press release and said if if a small company in California can do it then then so can jam he took it to his engineers who told him that that you couldn't build an electric car and told him that they needed to get going and that's what got the ball rolling and that in tune got Nissan to do the leaf and sort of it's kind of got the got

14:27things going so now and ultimately it's like it's what we induce other companies to do that will have a greater impact than the cars we make ourselves and it's an interesting point I'm going to come back to you later this idea that Tesla's founding mission is as Ilana is articulated from the very beginning through the most recent reports to the public is to catalyze an industry shift that Tesla will be some part of but to help others in that shift as well which is remarkable realm so we supply power trains to Toyota and to Mercedes exams to help what could be viewed as your biggest competitors one day you know absolutely accelerate that but before we

15:03get to that sort of Purpose Driven mission I do want ask one or at least maybe make sure the ideas how cool this car is and in case you haven't been as much of a fan as the two of us it's a bit unprecedented the reviews it's received consumer reports saying is the best car they've ever tested Road and track saying it's the most important car in America's history the safety testing show is the most safe car ever manufactured by far including vans and SUVs and so it's pretty markable to peg performance desirability safety and all these parameters so is it luck or is there something particularly unique about the evey design space that let it be possible to build the best car well I

15:47you know like just play some role here but I think we I think electric vehicles have a fundamental architectural advantage if if one designs an electric vehicle from the ground up and takes advantage of of what's possible like if you just were to convert a gasoline car you would not you would not achieve these advantages but if it's probably done and you can actually package the battery pack in the full pan and achieve a low center of mass and and have a very compact motor and an inverter and gearbox so that the actual usable space in the car is significantly greater than a gasoline car of the same overall extent accel dimensions and and then if you do a few

16:32other things which ones necessarily specifically related to an electric car like using an aluminum body and chassis is is helpful because you can absorb more energy per unit mass essentially in a crash i crumple zone yeah exactly well it's so that yeah but part of its related to electric vehicle architecture and part of it is related to other technical decisions that that were made in the design of the Model S and so yeah

16:59that's that's what leads to sort of having a high safety is I mean I were sort of going into too much detail might take up too much time but like a road you did you know some of those things at the get-go or did they unveil themselves as you went along curious how the vision materializes before long either the product dimensions like it will have all these great features like I got the get go did it all gel and ii also curious when did you first know that all vehicles would be electric like was that early probably 22 years ago

17:37something like that before you met desolate before wait before there was definite before there was a way for there's Tesla oh yeah well like said it you know when I originally came out when if I mean when I was studying physics and that's probably when I thought it was the case and maybe you know it's more than that probably when I was in my sophomore year do you give certainty in your heart yeah absolutely it's super obvious yes yes now yes now it is any old there are obvious then but that this is a because even like three years ago most people probably didn't agree with this point of view and if I could be confident of any prediction I could make

18:15it's that within ten years all people will let me have this point of view you know we want to make the transition yet but we'll realize that there's a ridiculous debate to be having okay you were a lone voice of sorts back then probably amongst your cohort and friends and you know social yes actually I used to talk to like dates about electric cars how they go it wasn't it wasn't helpful Pizza yeah so actually I ran

18:43into Cole I did briefly in Canada Kristen Nicholson she's now a writer for Scientific American and and she mentioned yeah when we were in on a date I asked her do you ever think about electric cars and she said no I don't so yeah while back I mean it's pretty I mean almost everything's electric that we have in our daily lives from the physics of it yeah internal combustion engines just yeah pretty amazing pretty amazing so I'm gonna I want to share a little story that leads to a question along a different angle I don't think you've heard us before so but I find it fascinating I was at a lunch at a Google event and out of the blue with no expectation this would be a topic Larry

19:28Page turned to me knowing a little bit about our connection said you know how much money do I have any mention a number I thought that was cute he was trying to recall that he goes you know if I were to get hit by a bus today I should leave all of it to you on musk really yeah he said that and and so I'm

19:48like paper pen yes he like zingers so he was so context is important but I said you know I mean I mean I met Larry before he got venture funding yeah I was like 90 Wow well he's a remarkable guy obviously also an underachiever and you know has a company that wants to do good in the world right and I think he looks at you with a bit of end because what he then proceeded to say was you know I could give my money thrown a profit and a lot less would get done than a corporation that's pursuing things that are directly aligned with things I care about like getting off of oil and colonizing other planets he believes in those missions and thinks that a corporation if endowed

20:35with the right to do that as his business purpose is the best vehicle out there and wishes he could do more of that in his own life he compared plainly I think to some other software companies in the Pacific Northwest who might have executives who do evil good for the second half and then the sad story of others who'd never get to the second half of their life like Steve Jobs I mean not in a jokey might mean I mean seriously and and and it was a very moment so it raises the question of a Purpose Driven business so you've heard already that Tesla's not just trying to make money it's not the parody guys you read the most recent show holder letter

21:11yes in fact I started off the the shareholder letter saying that the profits are not our primary goal and then I got a little bit of some of the board members to question that statement and I was like well it's true you know and like you like like for now or like justjust what we're growing but no it's just not the priority and which I think in a business school is a really good point that dwell in for a moment yes nothing but I think they're unimportant or anything it's just not the primary goal and I actually told people that a ninth year as well and so it's not like new information but these you know people that watch the IPO not in your information and yeah actually

21:56amazing the stock went up after that I think there's a profound reason I mean you you see the benefits of being focused on something that's a higher calling as your primary motivation your employees love it the customers love it yeah there's then you feel better about your job the interesting thing the irony perhaps is that at least within our portfolio the companies that have that kind of a founding principle actually make more profit and grow their revenue more quickly than the ones that don't announce this low sample set but the handful that have taken this bold of a step to say no no that we will not make that our number one priority actually do

22:29a great job and it occurred to me and I don't know if this was conscious in your head of it at some point that if you weren't wildly profitable the auto industry wouldn't follow you in other words this whole mission of catalyzing a shift to new electric vehicle isn't gonna work if the business model is worse than a current business model and so yeah you know it's the obvious byproduct of what you're focusing on not obvious but it occurs to me that it's a byproduct wasn't obvious at first at all but I'm curious if that thought occurred to you that only other profits will come or yeah well we have to generate positive cash flow or we have to generate enough cash flow to fund

23:04future developments which requires having a good gross margin and and so I guess one could just say okay well we're gonna stop developing your products and then you would be really profitable so at any given point you could sort of say well we could be possible you know at this point in a significant way but but we've got these great things that we want to develop for the future and they're a good investment and that's what we're doing and similarly at SpaceX the you know the founding vision was to colonize Mars indirectly again interestingly catalyzing others well to move yeah and then you realized hey I got to actually lead this charge yeah well I

23:40mean with SpaceX I originally I started off just thinking well how do I increase NASA's budget action that was my goal so it was like 2001 with just destroyed a friend of mine and you asked me yes what I was gonna do have to PayPal and I thought well you know I was wondering like I'd like to get involved in space but I just didn't think there was anything I could do as an individual and but I was curious as to win we win would NASA would be sanding a team to Mars

24:11because that was always gonna be the thing to do after the moon I figured that there be some plan and I just go to websites and I could read the you know the schedule then Mars oh yeah it's like okay 2017 good okay but actually it wasn't anything on on the website and or at least I thought like am I can and I'll find it like what's going on right here and is it secret I don't know I said but it turned out that that NASA had done a study on what it would cost to send to do a manned Mars mission and I this was under Bush the first and I suppose he asked for a 90-day study short laughed at taking office and NASA came back with a 500 billion dollar price tag and he said

24:58okay maybe not bill you know be that's been 500 billion dollars was serious money here for the government so I so then that got totally shelf and it was like you were not allowed to talk about any kind of crude mission to Mars at NASA anyway so I but I thought well if I could do something that would galvanize public interest that and and then that public interest would translate to additional appropriations for NASA increased that their budget then then maybe they could do it so the foot so actually what I sort of thinking I would do is stand as a small greenhouse the surface of Mars there were seeds in dehydrator gel and then upon landing hydrate the jelly roll ants and the

25:44public has to respond to precedents and superlatives so this would be the farthest that life's ever traveled the first life on and you have this great shot of green plants on a red background and I thought okay maybe that would get some money shot you gotta be don't be the money shot yeah I never quite sure whether that's the sort of a word you can use or not I don't know its origins until

26:12somebody pointed it out to me but green house on Mars and and I thought okay we could make this happens to be cool and NASA would get the money and they could do though they could sort of send a team to Mars and be great so I tried to figure out how to do this with the proceeds that I had from from PayPal and I was able to figure out how to get the cost of the spacecraft down and the communications and the little greenhouse and everything but the one thing I couldn't compress was the cost launch it was there only a few options and the us options were way too expensive and I ended up going to Russia three times to try to buy the biggest ICBM and the

27:02Russian nuclear fleet that's where I'd start yeah yeah go back I mean okay but they it was so there was some strange trips that's for sure but you know it's like virtually like you can buy any it's a very capitalist society some ways so I actually didn't ago she had a deal to bet to buy two of the ICBMs minus the nukes but I can't think inclusion after that third trip that it wouldn't really matter like you four before I actually came inclusion that my initial premise was was was wrong because I actually think there's there's tremendous amount of will in the American population particularly to to explore the United

27:52States you know maybe more than any other country is a distillation of the human spirit of exploration and it's really fundamental to psyche so if people think there's a way I think it actually get a lot of support no but but then it can't be just banging your head against the wall I gotta believe that this can be done without breaking the federal budget so that's when I said okay well is there some way to affect the cost of space transport and and is and so I got

28:24together with a group of people over series of Saturday's just to just try it outside is there something super expand 'mentally super expensive about rockets or can the cost be substantially improved and act we had a bunch of those kind of brainstorming sessions and I couldn't see I couldn't see any fundamental obstacle to improving the cost of rockets so that's when I started SpaceX I'll just build them myself yeah and then but I said at that point I would say the probability of success was definitely less than 50% I thought it would most likely not succeed but we're a try it's fascinating so but the parallels are so many between these companies again probability is low

29:08certainty that it needs to be done yeah certainly that it could be done by for physics and first principles that it's the success is an option right it's one of the possibilities and interestingly starting with a roadster and a one as a proof point to a larger design you know as I look at the Falcon 9 and it looks like the product of a software engineer model reuse like let's build one engine and step-and-repeat and building all kinds of elegance into the system design to abstract away almost from the hardware into the software into the design the beauty of the system and and I wonder if that's why incumbents don't see this sort of range hearing of the other car or the rocket

29:46or the what-have-you the Hyperloop is this they don't approach it in that kind of blank sheet of paper how would you do this if you didn't have to create jobs across distance or you didn't have some other I'll turn your motor interesting interesting looking at the time I want to give an ask one last question better give a heads up on there's mics to start getting them ready for the audience because I don't want him in Oppel eyes people's time here actually there's so many questions on ask but but I'll start with moving beyond the old right and here for at least some of the quirky one about influences so you've we've heard about the the Iron Man reference

30:18in your childhood interest in comic books and Hitchhiker's Guide to the galaxy and azimoff it but there's all kinds of things woven into like Cyberdyne systems that its basics that we heard and then some Easter eggs so some of us noticed that the stereo goes to 11 all right on the Tesla's a spinal tap reference for those who know that this one goes to 11 and they just just one was louder than loud that's right exactly that's right but no one seems to have noticed the product lineup so you got the model s you got the model X oh yeah you've just trademarked the model e yeah no one's better what do you got and the model and the model Y yeah no I know

30:57exactly oh this is I guess there's not a lot of humor in trademark that pretty well off you know because yeah obviously we just trademarked sexy so and and they were having this discussion with the like forward because they the force council did they also didn't get it like because because they're sort of slightly opposing us using model II mmm and then they saw that we registered model Y and they say oh are you planning to use model Y instead of model e like no it was just a joke like we don't do that what is this fellow come on fantastic well do we I'll

31:42keep going if we don't but do we have microphones for folks if they want ask questions okay let's do a quick see if anyone oh my gosh yes we have some why don't we do that let's take a couple questions in the audience and I'll let you guys figure out how to do the allocations thank you very much I heard you talk about supersonic aircraft you guys have done some beautiful work at SpaceX on beat all

32:09clearly Tesla is is focused on electric have you thought about the synergies of electric and VTOL and aircraft for solving the 405 okay for solving the 405 pelham well I mean I do think there's there's a there's a reason vertical takeoff and landing yeah is it right sorry vertical take for landing is VTOL and yeah I do think there's there's a really likely I think the optimal sort of air transport solution is Vito electric supersonic plane and it

32:44actually works together quite well for a bunch of reasons you take a look at the higher you go the the better of the electric the more efficient the electric aircraft is whereas if you have a combustion aircraft as you as you get higher it gets a tends to get worse because you have a kind of a fixed aperture and air scoop yes like the engine is the hole in a part of the engine his is a fixed size and so you have to pick a particular cruising altitude and so you've got to figure out how do you get the right amount of air at sea level all the way through really high altitude and then you've got this issue of super because the supersonic combustion but you know you see you know

33:24having to slow the air down and it ends up being not that efficient but an electric after aircraft would just get better and better as as it got higher and then electric motors have a higher power to weight ratio than a combustion engine so you're gonna have you could actually have the power to do the vertical takeoff and landing part with a fairly small motor compared to combustion and you could get rid of the elevator

33:51and and rudder so you don't need the rear control surfaces if you gimbal the end that you forgettable the motor gosh it starts to look like a pod craft like and yeah oblivion or something right it's so it's it's yeah something not quite that the real trick of it is like how do you make it really long range and at least as safe as existing aircraft but those are really the only two questions on that front I think but

34:22they're tricky they're certainly true don't underestimate those new questions great let's go to the next one or whoever has a mic however we're doing the allocation fairly and efficiently let me give my hand okay know that we have someone great younggu ESB 94 hey Steve long time no see a one question are you as Tesla going to expand the worldwide and I think GSB is going to help host China 2.0 tomorrow and do you

34:57have any plans to go into the biggest car market today but I know you're a little concerned for another friend of mine actually asked you indirectly a few years ago that you were concerned about the secret and the parroting in the Chinese market are you still concerned about that or you have a strategy yes is

35:22definitely gonna ship worldwide in fact the Tesla Roadster is in 31 countries right now and we expect to ship the model s2 to China starting next year as well as to Japan and Hong Kong and you know singapura marilah in Australia and so really it's gonna be quite widely distributed next year certainly China is an extremely important market in fact for premium sedans in China is about half the world market for for premium sedans so if you take some growing okay yeah take some elective Mercedes s-class last year of 54 percent of Mercedes s-class this was sold in China so a pretty important market and yes so we're

36:09gonna definitely do a major push in China and actually some of the most enthusiastic potential customers we've seen are people from China so we actually want to make sure that the car actually has features which are specific to the Chinese market and make sure that it's not just you know taking an American product and you know just sort of sending it to China without any any changes so we want to make sure it's tailored to the market and at Japan as

36:39well I don't want to you know a lot of its but not for any American cause sell in Japan but I think that would be symbolism yeah I mean like I think we should take the Japanese market seriously and and and I think if we do things right we should have reasonable sales there so yeah so that that's gonna

37:01be next year I mean as far as copying stuff I think that that's certainly a risk I think China is actually getting a lot better these days and and I think the the new government is taking taking intellectual property a lot more seriously so I'm actually starting to feel more and more confident about that the technology not actually not being copied in in China or at least you know it getting much better and I don't think it's gonna be too much of an issue until we want to establish local production and that that's that's where you know we need to make sure that we do it riot and there's not an incentive for the factory team that we established there it's to

37:42sort of go across the world and create a competing factory but but that'll depth concern is a few years away another one oh yeah up here and the students are largely upstairs yes MBA student first of all thank you it's very inspiring to hear an experience about actually you know changing the world using our organizations that you created

38:09hopefully we will inspire an array Iron Man movie as well and I was wondering if you can tell us more about the experience about like you know how to balance you know those trade-off between your profits and you know following purpose that goes further than just make money you know you are trying to change the world you know what for the humanity rather than just make profits in the short term what was the question okay had it bounced oh yeah that's right well yeah well I mean first of all I

38:44should say you know with with with with all of the companies but but I think particularly SpaceX and Tesla although there's in a good position today they went through some super tough times and and in fact for SpaceX I reserved a capital to to do three tap three launch failures okay to twist and to launch failures and have the third one be success sort of three strikes and actually we had three launch failures we're just able to scrape enough money together for a fourth flight that succeeded in 2008 and also in 2008 as

39:25Steve knows we we we got the Tesla financing around done on the last hour of the last day it was like 6 p.m. December 24th 2008 and if we hadn't gotten it done then the company would have gone bankrupt a few days after Christmas so that but he's not mention there are only reason that happened is he wrote a check for the remainder of his wealth to save the company during payroll and Christmas when no one else would and Goldman had just failed the private offering and the financial collapse was amongst us there was no do a loan there was no Daimler deal the car had a negative gross margin it was not pretty oh and you had you know your larger shareholder just completely

40:04pissed off and you know going AWOL yeah yeah it was ugly yep yeah cuz a stressful period and that was just at work yeah so for a while it really wasn't a question of profit or non profit is it was like we need to live how do we live so that was the main challenge and and and now I mean now we're at the sort of the stage where we can say okay we can shift the dial between the wicked we could make let's say at this point a medium amount of profit or a small amount which sort of chosen to make a small amount because we can reinvest the cash flow into future products so now we're you know right now we're reinvested in cash flow into developing the the model X which is an

40:54SUV and to increasing the production capacity of the factory and doing a little bit of advance planning on the third-generation vehicle that'll be a mass market a sort of affordable compelling electric car so so that's really I guess what what's meant by in this case no pursuing we're not trying to maximize profit at this point because it would constrain the business the growth of the business and constrain the overall objective of transitioning the world towards electric cars so I got nothing against profit in general but it's just it's just it's not I mean I actually don't think it's the smart move I mean if one were to take the net present value of future cash flows i I

41:40think max logic proffer at the stage is actually not the smart move you know an interesting cuz earlier I said we get back to it you mentioned that your goal was not to start a company that has the you know the chance of making the most money for you the quickest yeah and that the wealth personally is almost a byproduct of these activities of passion and by analogy like an investment fail to mention capital you know you could look for the thing that make the most money the quickest right like a new ad network for social media but who cares I think it's really just doesn't help the world in any meaningful way and and there are much over longer if you take a

42:15longer-term perspective there are things you could do that don't answer the short-term question of what's gonna make me the most money this year or this five year period but Lord 20 years focusing on those ironically he may make the most money right of any entrepreneur or these companies might be more profitable than their cohort that doesn't follow that same purpose-driven kind of almost messianic zeal yeah so

42:37there was the balance question almost implies a dichotomy that may not be opposed but maybe aligned if you orchestrate it right yeah maybe more of a short-term versus long-term approach yeah exactly great another one will be the last question oh is this the last question okay yes from your current carb

42:58marketing strategy you could say that your car is directed towards the luxury car market place so that's a fairly well defined market do you have any plans for expanding it to the general marketplace to say make a car for the masses which might be maybe in the twenty five to thirty five thousand dollar range for

43:23the first blog piece I wrote for Tesla was Tesla master plan which is to start off with an expensive low volume vehicle then go to a mid price mid volume and then sort of low at low price high volume so we're kind of in Phase two and without third generation vehicle we expect to be somewhere in the thirty to thirty five thousand dollar range for the car which when you take into account the savings from the use of electricity instead of gasoline is more like comparing it in the u.s. to about a twenty-eight thousand dollar car or in Europe to a twenty twenty two thousand dollar car and the maintenance is much less the fuel cost too much yeah absolutely

44:06that's right well great well I want to thank you very much for this and transition to the closing segment

44:26well Elon congratulations on behalf of the Stanford Graduate School of Business and the Stanford Alumni Association Business School Alumni Association dean saloner would like to present you with this year's entrepreneurial company of the year

资源与出处

相关视频

同频道、同主题或相邻年份