一枚火箭能做多粗,答案写在公路的限宽和沿途电线的高度上。
2013年,马斯克在德州议会做了一场作证,之后回答了议员们的提问。整场问答里最硬的一个细节,出现在开头几分钟。他解释猎鹰9号(Falcon 9)为什么长成现在这个样子:箭体的直径和长度,是照着"能从加州用卡车拖到德州"这个前提定的。
我把火箭的直径和外形尺寸,设定成不需要吊起电线、不需要特殊许可就能上路运输的最大物体。所以它大概是13英尺粗,一级大约140英尺长。(马斯克)
13英尺,约合4米。140英尺,约43米。这两个数字背后没有气动优化的影子,只有美国州际公路的物理条件。
这条约束解释了很多事。猎鹰9看起来又细又长,运力不足的时候靠三根箭体并联成猎鹰重型,而不是把箭体吹粗一圈。直径一旦被公路锁死,增加运力的路径就只剩加长和加数量。
它还解释了另一件事:为什么当年在加州造、运到德州发射,账是算得过来的。跨州公路运输的成本,比在海边重建一条总装线便宜得多。
但这个前提会变。马斯克在同一场听证会上,把这个变化说出来了。
更大的火箭,只能长在发射台旁边
他的原话分两段。第一段是猎鹰9这个尺寸会一直做下去,"可能永远"。第二段是如果你要做比它更大的火箭,制造就必须放在发射场或者发射场附近。
理由是物流。箭体一旦超过公路能承受的尺寸,运输只剩两种选择:专门造一条船,或者封路、拆电杆、临时架线。这两种做法的时间和钱都不成比例。他在现场用的词是,道路运输的后勤会变得"很原始"。
于是因果关系倒过来了。过去是造好了再想办法运到发射场,未来是发射场定在哪,工厂就建在哪,生产线跟着发射台走。
当时有位议员代表德州东南部提出了一个具体的期待:不希望那2000个岗位留在加州,希望火箭在德州本地制造。马斯克的回应是,那种更大的火箭的总装,会发生在任何"较小的那一类"的发射所在地,希望那个地方是博卡奇卡(Boca Chica)。
2013年听这句话,像是一句争取投资的场面话。今天回头看,它是一份施工图。
星舰(Starship)的直径是9米,比猎鹰9粗一倍多,靠平板车跨州运输没有任何可能。它最终在博卡奇卡的海边直接焊起来,箭体在离发射台几百米的地方完成总装,然后被推到发射架上。马斯克当年描述的那种"工厂跟着发射台走"的形态,十几年后真的出现了。
会场里的人当时听到的是招商承诺,实际上听到的是技术路线。
麦格雷戈的220人,和那句"我们不想要加州那2000个岗位"
提问的议员开场先讲了实地探访的感受:三周前去了SpaceX在麦格雷戈(McGregor)的试验场,那里有220名员工,在做发动机试车,评价是"非常专业"、"令人印象深刻"。
220这个数字值得停一下。2013年的SpaceX,整个公司在德州的核心资产就是这么一个试验场,两百多人,主要工作是试车。猎鹰9还没进入稳定量产,龙飞船(Dragon)在2012年5月刚成为第一艘造访国际空间站的商业飞船。整场听证会上,议员们反复提到的公司总人数是2000到3000人。
马斯克没有反驳这个量级。他还顺便交代了另一层现实:公司的注册地和主要居住地都在洛杉矶,本人在南加州生活,有五个孩子。
这就是2013年的对比。一家两千多人的公司,被一个州用立法程序请到议会大厦,讨论要不要为它专门立一部法、修一条路、通一趟水电。
议员们的诉求具体到有点朴素:把发射放在布朗斯维尔,把制造也搬过来,让这2000个岗位落在德州而不是加州。
招人先看本地,物理系学生自己跑来了
有位议员问了一个更实际的问题:你们那两三千人,是从世界各地搬来的,还是从本地招的?公司在公立教育和大学层面有没有参与?
马斯克的回答是,招聘的首选路径是本地化,公司在德克萨斯大学系统做了大量招聘,技术支持团队里来自德州大学的人越来越多。他还提到和本地物理项目的互动。
现场补充的一段细节更能说明当时的气氛。有人在听证会上作证说,之前在第一场社区会议上,大概来了七八百人,没有一个人反对SpaceX进入南德州。中途有几个年轻人主动站起来发言,他们是德州大学布朗斯维尔分校物理项目的学生,没有人提前安排他们到场,他们讲的是自己能留在本地读物理、并且参与这个项目有多兴奋。
那位作证者还提到,SpaceX对本地中小学和大学一直有支持,如果发射能落地,公司会大量依赖全州的大学系统。这话由公司方说出来,可信度要打折,但七八百人的社区会议和那几个自己站起来的学生,是当场可以被核实的部分。
一场零反对的环保听证会
整场问答里最有信息量的一段,是关于环境影响的公开听证。
流程是这样的:联邦航空管理局(FAA)是牵头机构,SpaceX要做的发射场项目必须走环境影响报告书(EIS)程序。这个程序早期有一场公开听证,用来收集社区意见。听证会由FAA主办,SpaceX只是被审查的一方,连会都不是自己开的。
这种会的常规剧情是有人举牌抗议。这次没有。
按现场作证者的说法,到场超过500人,70多人上台发言,全部支持这个项目,没有一个人发言反对。发言的人里有中小学生、有当地学区的学监、有各级民选官员,州参议员则发来了支持信。FAA的人当场说了一句被反复引用的话:在他们主持公开环评听证的历史上,从没见过这么高的到场率,而且是零反对。
还有一个细节挺有意思。听证会的时间段结束后,FAA的工作人员不得不反复向人解释"公众意见征集期"是有明确时间范围的,因为不断有人过来问,你们什么时候能告诉我们这个项目确定落地,他们想把这个消息传给更多人。
一个联邦机构在自己的程序会上被当地居民追着问"什么时候开工",这个场面不太常见。它说明布朗斯维尔那边对这个项目的期待,远比一般招商引资的热度要高。
德州只有140天,别的州正在送地
有位议员把立法层面的困境讲得很透。
德州议会每届会期只有140天。这一届讨论的法案,很多效果要等议员们休会回家之后才显现。也就是说,这届议会必须提前把一家公司未来可能提出的所有诉求都想到,然后写进法条里。用他自己的说法,开国先贤只给了他们140天。
更麻烦的是竞争节奏。德州休会的时候,其他几个州还在开会,还在不断推出自己的招商方案。那些州的报价单里不只有现金,还有土地。
他提到,主席皮茨(Pitts)对这个时间差也很担心,议会内部已经在讨论太空港的专项资金。而在地方层面,县里的做法更接地气:那个区域必须偏远,这是发射场的硬性要求,但偏远就意味着没有基础设施,所以县里正在想办法把电和水通到那片地方去。
被追问具体的拨款请求数字时,回答是:还没准备好说一个数,正在看其他州出什么价,可能匹配不上,这是个风险。但州长已经表态支持,州交通厅(TxDOT)能做什么、州企业基金(Enterprise Fund)能做什么,都在谈。
有意思的是这个回答方式。一位议员说,他欣赏这种直接,因为自己是外科医生出身,习惯直奔主题。对方答,问题问得好,但手上确实还没有一个愿意说出口的数字。
从这段能看出2013年那场选址竞争的真实形态。一家两千多人的公司,同时在几个州之间被竞价,条件是现金、土地、通电、通水和立法。而SpaceX要的东西很明确:一块足够偏远、能听见爆炸声也没人投诉的海边土地。
讲到特斯拉,和一条让直销违法的法律
听证会快结束时,有位议员忍不住问了另一家公司:你造的那台车,能不能简单讲讲。
马斯克的回答带着明显的推销口吻,但里面的数据是真的。特斯拉当时在生产一款四门轿车,性能很高,刚拿了《Motor Trend》的年度车,还有一本汽车杂志的年度汽车奖。他强调的重点是:这个奖评的是所有车型里的最佳,不限于电动车类别。
它拿的不是最佳电动车,是任何类别里的最佳汽车。我认为这对电动车是个关键节点,电动车第一次被放在所有车里一起比,然后赢了。(马斯克)
产量是每周400辆左右,正在向全美交付。德州是最大的市场之一,按客户数量排,大概是第二或者第三。
然后是那段有点尴尬的部分。他说在德州做生意有点挑战,因为特斯拉走的是直营,不经过传统的经销商加盟体系,而德州的现行法律不允许这么卖。他希望法律能有一点微调,但也明确表示,今天来这里不是为了游说这件事。
一位议员接过话说,自己开过那台车,"是非常令人兴奋的体验"。
这段插曲和太空港那条线摆在一起看,能看出同一家公司面对的两套规则。发射场这边,州议会愿意为它写法案、通水电、抢时间窗口;卖车这边,一条几十年前为保护经销商写的法律,让它在德州连直接卖车都不行。
这个矛盾后来拖了很多年,成了特斯拉在美国多个州反复碰壁的老问题。
会议结束前的两句闲话
马斯克顺手做了两个邀请。一个是特斯拉在奥斯汀Domain商场的展厅刚开,欢迎去看看。另一个是麦格雷戈的试车场随时可以安排试驾,公司每年还会办一场大型烧烤,欢迎大家来。
最后他补了一个冷知识:他的外祖父是美国人,当年是靠在学校里表演牛仔竞技特技读完的大学。他说这话的时候,语气大概是觉得德州议员会喜欢这个细节。
一个在南非出生、住在洛杉矶、正在向德州议会要一块海边土地的人,用这种方式把自己的家族史和德州接上了线。政治场合的这类小动作,往往比前面半小时的政策讨论更能拉近距离。
整场问答停下来看,最有价值的部分还是开头那几分钟。一家火箭公司的选址、产能、招聘、甚至未来十年的产品形态,被一条公路的宽度从源头决定了。而当这家公司决定突破那条公路的时候,它就必须搬到一个足够偏远、能承受这种突破的地方去。
所以2013年那场听证会的真正主题,其实不是招商。是一家公司造出了超出交通基础设施承载能力的想法,然后不得不去找一个能容纳它的地方。
- 看一家制造业公司的选址逻辑时,先问它运的是什么、怎么运。运输约束经常比成本、税收、政策更能决定工厂落在哪,火箭是这样,电池、风机叶片、大型铸件也是这样。
- 读企业高管在立法机构的说辞时,把他讲的"未来会做什么"单独拎出来记一笔,过几年再回来核对。马斯克这次讲的"更大的火箭必须在发射场旁边造",后来在星舰上完整兑现了,这类话的预测价值高于任何当场的财务承诺。
- 判断一个招商项目能不能落地,看社区会议的到场率和反对率,比看新闻稿里的投资额更有用。500人到场、70人发言、零反对,这种数字装不出来。
- 评估政策风险时,注意同一家公司在不同业务线上面对的是完全不同的规则体系。SpaceX在德州被追着送水电,特斯拉在同一个州连直营卖车都违规,两件事发生在同一年。
- 如果你在做需要跨区域运输的硬件产品,把运输尺寸当成设计输入放进第一版方案里。等结构定型之后再发现运不出去,代价会比一开始就让出一部分性能高得多。
0:07every day of Davis you know I'm first of all I wanna thank you for living sitting on your on your committee mr. chairman and mr. musket I share the economic and Small Business Committee and with Cecil Vale represent to Cecil Bell Jr down there we went out to your site in McGregor about three weeks ago where you'd like 220 employees and very professional but I was just very impressed it's your retesting engines there's just an amazing operations in that take place and I guess what would be on going to be ideal is if we can have that take place where we can launch the commercial side Boca Chica Boulevard there in Brown's villain and ideally we
0:49we don't we don't like those 2,000 jobs being in California we need you to manufacture those Rockets over here that would be a really a cool thing effect that take place you know that that's very important point and I should have mentioned that which is the current route the Falcon 9 rocket is something that can be manufactured in California and transport Road transporter in fact that i set the design diameter and dimensions of the rocket to be the maximum road transportable object without requiring lifting and power lines and that kind of thing so it's roughly 13 feet in diameter and about 140 foot long went on the foot for the first stage but and we'll keep we'll
1:31keep doing the Falcon I and I think for forever it didn't in that size but as we go to future rockets that are bigger than that we would actually do the manufacturing at the launch site or near the launch site because of the otherwise the road transportation logistics become primitive essentially that put on a big ship or overly needle or psychological thing is to vote news website so that that is something that would occur wherever the smaller side occurs and it needs to be a Boca Chica so they'll be great we would love to see that happens pretty good thank you game as you do thank you child ever seen Perry is real quickly detect you're not from West
2:09Texas not originally know I i would ask it this way you got 2,000 employees I think you said it was 3,000 actually but prospectively you know we always are hearing about our math and science and how efficient it is in their education stuff but do you do you see that you know with their commitment in your place do you see helping our kiddos and republic add in our employee workforce are most of you guys transplants from around the world or do you find a workforce here and are you engaged at the public education level in the college level nuh in those processes actually I preferred route for recruiting is is local so we do a lot of recruiting at the university of texas
2:51and i said with more representation from university text at the University and our tech support site and if we work with Franson but not so I graduate high level scientists there's an outlet through your place and you risk group and encourage that interactive in that pursuit we are absolutely yeah thanks and if i can add renovated guest for the record mmm rubs and perry our university
3:27when we had the first meeting I think about seven eight hundred people showed up and there was not a single person against having SpaceX in South Texas and for young people came up that were in the physics program at UT Brownsville unsolicited nobody knew they were going to be there and they talked about how exciting it was for them and that they could be applying their efforts in higher education in physics and be part of this so there's no doubt in my mind
4:06the history of SpaceX is they've been very philanthropic they have been very supportive of local schools and universities they will rely heavily on all our universities all around the state and we can be launching rockets again and in Texas if we can do this it's actually maybe with the county maybe when i add out of it to that but so this was a review that the public hearing that we held in the Brownsville two were essentially weird but and it's
4:38for an environmental view where you invite people normally to raise objections I don't know if there were people that wanted to object but they didn't get a chance to object because people kept coming up to the mic and poisoning their support in fact I don't think I've ever seen it environmental sharing like that before this is late I mean wanna elaborate on that expect correct on the beach yeah Karen schnoor council just Council and I want to take over my boss's job as general counsel to SpaceX and director of legislative affairs so when we when we have these federal scoping meeting so the the environmental impact statement process that we're
5:22undertaking under the fa because they're the lead agency part of that involvement involves a public hearing early in the process where they take input from the local community they post notice of those hear of that hearing and give people the opportunity SpaceX doesn't run the hearing the FAA runs it so it's to make it an objective opportunity for people to present their concerns over 500 people and the congressman stated it seems to be a lot more to those of us who are there in attendance attended the event and over 70 people spoke up in in favor of the project no one actually spoke in opposition at the event we had students young students we had a number
6:01of superintendents from the local schools we had elected officials at all levels up to our state senators who sent letters of support for the project involved in that in that community support and statements of support and what the FAA did say to us at that event was they had never seen a turnout of so many people with no opposition before in the history of their experience with annie is public scoping hearing they were incredibly impressed by the community support and by the the wealth and breadth of folks that showed up to voice their support for the for the project and who they continued to hear from in support of the project they actually told us that they had to make
6:41it clear to people that the public the public scoping area of time was a specific time frame because they kept hearing from people asking when are you going to tell us that this is happening because you know they had to give their information to the folks there and they kept trying to contact them to tell them how much they want this project in Brownsville so i have to say from my perspective it has just been absolutely amazing to see the support that we've received from the local community caring
7:06before you late will you fill out a witness have formation I mean side of these gentlemen arrested in Baden Thank You mr. chairman is there a timeline or a decision point that we're looking at with respect to your choice of where you want to put this facility yeah we're hoping to make that decision this year and if i may ask because i haven't been involved in the proposed legislation did does that legislation address the needs for the concerns that the company would have to allow you to make that decision i think it probably does yeah Renee again for the record of reps and banana yeah we have tried to foresee everything because you know our founding fathers say we
7:56only get to meet 140 days because a lot it may happen after we're gone and we have a pretty good working group you know I again time-wise we're hoping that we get the draft study from the feds soon says what the potential problems might be in terms of environmental concerns us Parks and Wildlife text
8:32but you know a lot of this may happen while we're gone so we're in a position of having to do things contingent upon us being the final place to go and it is a strange deal because those other states will still be in sessions and and they're coming up with their own competitive packages to you know out there so I know chairman Pitts is concerned about this as well and we've talked about a spaceport funding and and again I think mr. musk would would say and I'll take the liberty of speaking on his behalf that you know we're looking at more than SpaceX potentially there are several other companies that are looking at Texas and our coastline and
9:25our advantages are great and there are problems in some of those other states that we don't have and I'm doing everything I can to convince particularly counsel here how great it is to be in Texas and by the way for the record mr. musk I think you were raised in south africa was born 14 races on raised in south africa and he is now a proud resident of Los Angeles with five five children and he's done a lot if you
10:03I could brag about him a long time but I know you have a lot his history is incredible and what he's done I disorder is there a specific contingency appropriations request associated with the legislation I think the writers I think we're trying to look at what other states are doing and see how competitive we can be you know we've heard some numbers from the other states that are pretty impressive and they're not just talking about money they're talking about donating land we at the local level are being very aggressive and trying to be part of the package in terms of assistance and because it is a remote area of the county it needs to be a remote area
10:45obviously so we're trying to work on getting power and water to this area that doesn't have it but in terms of a specific number I'm guess I'm not prepared to say but we're we need to be competitive is how I'd leave it for now i wish i could say x will do it but I appreciate your your comments and I'm not trying to be a breath but perhaps with the surgeons mentality I tend to be ready to the point and no no it's a good question i just the action items are I just don't have unfortunately a number yet that I would even want to suggest right now we're trying to see what the other states are doing and we may not be
11:29able to to match them that's that's a risk but the governor is committed to this and there are discussions about what TxDOT can do and discussions about what the Enterprise Fund might do and and and other things so that we can be competitive and and bring them here thank you everything about I just wanted
11:53to say having curved the McGregor side as chairman Davis said earlier that was very impressed and if you look for remote McGregor by the way pissed again her life I like McGregor that is expressed certainly is remote but in be able to be standing next to the Dragon spacecraft I it is it is great to know
12:16that there is a private sector desire to make certain that we maintain our our presence enemy in the world and and I think you guys do a great job watching I for one want to see you expand in Texas so anyway just a week from from here can you just briefly tell us about the vehicle that you have created the Tesla
12:47oh sure okay Tesla yeah absolutely so you can probably help with pointy one guys that on the sustainability and green initiatives as you mentioned so that the Tesla is and i went to companies bit of a stretch but Tesla makes electric cars and is now in production with 4-door sedan which is a real high performance and I'd actually one car of the year motor trend car of the year last year at one automobile magazine automated or nabil of the year and it's essentially saying it's the best car of any kind but merely the best electric car which i think is it was a key milestone for electric vehicles to be recognized much as we know electrical category with whip across all vehicles
13:33and reproduction of that about doing about 400 cars week just going throughout the United States Texas is actually one of our biggest moving grip I think maybe the second or third in terms of states in terms of the number of customers in Texas and it is a bit of a challenge actually operating in Texas because I approaches to do direct sales rather than can go through the traditional franchise system so it just presents some challenges in texas and what Oscar quick would love a slight modification of the law in order not here today to task that but just managing just named psyche I drove your
14:18car and it's a very exciting experience thank you has any other questions Oh actually should mention we're just opening out the Tesla gallery in Austin at the domain so if you want to go check it out please please do oh and yes and in whatever anyone who wants is invited to our test i turn my Gregor anytime you'd like with really happy to host you and we also have these
14:45these big barbecues once a years I didn't maybe want to go to and then like one little bit of trivia my grandfather was actually American and he played his way through college by doing rodeo tricks that I hope you might appreciate that so well thank you for coming here and say it was a real honor for this committee to have you all right that well thanks very much for having a nike time
资源与出处
- 视频在 YouTube 收看
- 档案silicon-valley.tech 档案页本页视频与文稿数据来自 Elon Musk Archive
- 精读本篇精读 Markdown 版